The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, October 16, 2023, at 6:15 PM UTC to consider seven agenda items. The committee approved mayoral appointments, established a Graffiti Advisory Board, and advanced a controversial amendment to limit remote public comment. All items were recommended to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Historic Preservation Commission): Woody Labounty (San Francisco Heritage) spoke in support of nominee Amy Campbell, noting her qualifications and experience in historic architecture. - Item 3 (Graffiti Advisory Board): Amy Cleary (Golden Gate Restaurant Association) supported the reestablishment, citing graffiti impacts on businesses. David Pilpel offered suggestions to expand membership, require quarterly meetings, and mandate bylaws. - Item 4 (Limiting Remote Public Comment): Over 20 callers and several in-person speakers testified in opposition, representing disability rights groups, seniors, parents, and labor organizations. Speakers argued the proposal was an overreaction to hate speech and would disenfranchise working people, disabled individuals, and caregivers. Multiple alternatives were suggested (e.g., 7-second delay, real-name requirements, immediate muting). No speakers supported the measure. - Item 5 (Library Laureate Programs): Peter Warfield (Library Users Association) raised concerns about the lack of Library Commission input, unclear stipend limits, and selection transparency. - Item 7 (Assessment Appeals Board Remote Hearings): Joe Crumfre noted the irony of ending remote comment for the board while preserving it for the Assessment Appeals Board. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Mayoral Appointment, Historic Preservation Commission – Amy Campbell: Ms. Campbell introduced herself as a licensed architect with 16 years of experience in adaptive reuse and historic preservation. She discussed the potential for converting downtown office buildings into housing while preserving historic character. The committee voted unanimously to approve the appointment, striking the word “reject” from the motion. - Item 2 – Appointments, In-Home Supportive Services Public Authority: Three applicants were heard: Edma Mae Johnson (reappointment for seat 1), Mara Math (seat 3), and James Jane Redmond (seat 10). Each described their background in advocacy and community service. The committee voted unanimously to recommend all three appointments. - Item 3 – Administrative Code – Establishing Graffiti Advisory Board: Supervisor Connie Chan, the sponsor, presented a revised ordinance reducing the board from 25 to 15 members (one per supervisor district, plus mayoral appointees and representatives from DPW, Arts Commission, and Police). She proposed an amendment requiring the advisory board to meet at least once every four months, with automatic termination legislation if it fails to meet. The committee accepted the amendment and unanimously recommended approval. - Item 4 – Amending the Rules of Order – Limiting Remote Public Comment: Board President Aaron Peskin introduced the amendment to end general remote public comment, citing hate speech incidents and the inability to block anonymous callers under current state law. He noted that a 10-second delay would cost $10 million, and a reasonable accommodations process would remain for people with disabilities. Despite extensive opposition, committee members (Dorsey, Walton, Safai) expressed support, emphasizing that disability accommodations and written comments would still be available. The committee voted unanimously to send the measure to the full board as a committee report. - Item 5 – Administrative Code – Library Laureate Programs: Library CEO Mike Fernandez and Chief Michelle Jeffers explained that the ordinance codifies existing laureate programs (Poet Laureate, Drag Laureate) to exempt them from Proposition 21G grant requirements. The stipends are designed to recognize past achievements rather than fund specific projects. The committee unanimously recommended approval. - Item 6 – Administrative Code – Cash Revolving Funds: Eric Mankey (Treasurer & Tax Collector’s Office) presented the ordinance to close or reduce inactive cash revolving accounts for city departments, based on a review during the city’s banking transition. The committee unanimously recommended approval (Vice Chair Walton absent). - Item 7 – Administrative Code – Assessment Appeals Board Remote and Hybrid Hearings: Alistair Gibson (AAB Administrator) reported success with over 600 remote hearings since December 2020, scheduling over 10,300 applications and finalizing 5,940 appeals. The ordinance would permanently authorize remote and hybrid hearings. The committee unanimously recommended approval (Vice Chair Walton absent). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion passed (Walton aye, Safai absent, Dorsey aye) to recommend Amy Campbell’s appointment to the full board as amended. - Item 2: Motion passed (unanimous) to recommend Edma Mae Johnson (seat 1), Mara Math (seat 3), and James Jane Redmond (seat 10) to the full board. - Item 3: Motion passed (unanimous) to accept Supervisor Chan’s amendment and recommend the Graffiti Advisory Board ordinance to the full board. - Item 4: Motion passed (unanimous) to send the rule change limiting remote public comment to the full board as a committee report. - Item 5: Motion passed (unanimous) to recommend the Library Laureate Programs ordinance to the full board. - Item 6: Motion passed (Walton absent, Safai aye, Dorsey aye) to recommend the Cash Revolving Funds ordinance. - Item 7: Motion passed (Walton absent, Safai aye, Dorsey aye) to recommend the Assessment Appeals Board remote hearings ordinance. All items are scheduled for the Board of Supervisors’ agenda on October 23, 2023.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on October 16, 2023, at 9:45 AM, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Member Aaron Peskin. The committee considered seven agenda items, including commemorative street naming, cultural heritage plaques, a street plaza resolution, a zoning change for the Castro neighborhood, and a major housing production ordinance. Public comment was heard on each item, with the chair limiting comments to one minute for the housing item due to prior hearings. Multiple items were approved and forwarded to the full board, while the Castro zoning item was amended and continued, and the housing ordinance was continued to October 30 for further technical cleanup. Consent Calendar - None. All items were discussed individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Elsie Tonelli Street): Family members and supporters testified in favor, highlighting her 73 years of operating Central Drugstore, her community service, and the fact that only 7% of San Francisco streets named after individuals honor women. Speakers included Paul Tonelli (son), Diane Tonelli Ryan (daughter), Bridget Peterson (granddaughter), and others. One speaker, Michael Petrellis, criticized the 2-minute public comment limit, arguing it was insufficient for such a significant tribute. - Items 2-4 (Cultural Heritage Plaques): Representatives from the Transgender District, SoMa Pilipinas, and the Lodginghouse District spoke in support, emphasizing the importance of permanent markers for LGBTQ+ and Filipino history. Several speakers noted that this was the first permanent public recognition of Filipino contributions on Sixth Street. Michael Petrellis again objected to combining three items into one public comment period, calling it a reduction of public participation. - Item 5 (Eagle Plaza): Lex Montiel (owner of Eagle Bar) and Angel Audio High (Folsom Street) spoke in favor of establishing a formal plaza with a steward, noting community events held there. Michael Petrellis raised concerns about flagpole policies, urging flexibility for raising LGBTQ+ flags and lowering flags on days of remembrance. A caller, Joe Consler, also supported the plaza but called for additional street plaques honoring city heroes. - Item 6 (Castro Nighttime Entertainment): Supporters included Andrea Ayala (Castro CBD), Mike Murray (Neighbors for Restored Castro Theater), Ralph Hibbs (Castro CBD), and Andrew Bennett (IATSE Local 16). They argued the zoning change would revitalize the Castro, reduce vacancy rates (from 24% to 17% in 2023), and allow the Castro Theater to operate fully. Opponents included M Rocket and representatives from the Castro LGBTQ Cultural District, who requested studies on noise, housing impacts, and limits on hours of operation. Michael Petrellis mourned the loss of the theater as a movie palace and criticized the lack of community meetings. - Item 7 (Housing Production Ordinance): Public comment was limited to one minute per speaker. Supporters (e.g., Annie Freiman from SPUR, Jake Price from Housing Action Coalition, Steve Marzano, Mike Chen, Jeff Gumpola, Robert Fruckman, and others) urged compliance with the state Housing Element to avoid loss of funding and land-use authority. Opponents (e.g., Francesca, Anastasia Vinopoulos from Tenants Union, and others) argued the bill would weaken rent control protections and benefit developers. Some speakers noted that the Mayor’s office had not yet clarified its position on streamlining demolition of rent-controlled units. One caller warned of losing transit funding if the city fails its housing element. Discussion Items - Item 1: Commemorative Street Name – Elsie Tonelli Street – Supervisor Safai presented the resolution to add a commemorative street name on Mission Street between Santa Rosa and Excelsior Avenues, honoring Elsie Tonelli, who owned Central Drugstore for 73 years. He noted that only 7% of San Francisco streets named after individuals are named after women. The committee unanimously approved and forwarded to the full board. - Items 2-4: Cultural Heritage Plaques (Lodginghouse, SoMa Pilipinas, Compton’s Transgender Districts) – Arun Bhatia from Public Works presented the plan to install 18 bronze plaques (two-foot by two-foot) along the Sixth Street corridor between Market and Howard, as part of the $10 million Sixth Street Pedestrian Safety Project. Each block will have three plaques, one for each district. The plaques will honor Filipino WWII veterans, the lodginghouse district’s history, and transgender trailblazers. The committee unanimously approved and forwarded to the full board. - Item 5: Eagle Plaza Street Plaza – Brian Dahl from Supervisor Dorsey’s office presented the resolution to establish Eagle Plaza at 383 12th Street as a formal street plaza under Administrative Code Chapter 94, and to urge Public Works to solicit a plaza steward. The plaza has been used since 2020 for events and a pop-up vaccine clinic during the MPOX outbreak. The committee unanimously approved and forwarded to the full board. - Item 6: Castro Street NCD – Nighttime Entertainment Zoning – Supervisor Mandelman and Planning Department staff presented an ordinance to allow nighttime entertainment with conditional use authorization on the second floor of the Castro Street Neighborhood Commercial District. The Planning and Historic Preservation Commissions recommended approval with a modification to remove non-residential use size limitations for Article 10 landmarks. The committee adopted that amendment and then continued the amended item to the next land use meeting on October 23 (or next week) for a final vote. - Item 7: Housing Production Ordinance – Chair Melgar noted that the legislation is complex and requires technical cleanup to align with previously passed special-use district rules. She proposed continuing the item to October 30 to allow staff to address discrepancies in definitions, rear setbacks, open space, and other technical issues. Supervisor Mandelman indicated he would introduce amendments to preserve monster home provisions and protect rent-controlled housing citywide, which may require re-referral to the Planning Commission. Supervisor Preston pressed the Planning Director on why the proposal initially allowed streamlining of rent-controlled demolition, contrary to the Housing Element. The committee voted to continue the item to October 30. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously (3-0) and forwarded to the Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Items 2-4: Approved unanimously (3-0) and forwarded to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 5: Approved unanimously (3-0) and forwarded to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 6: The committee adopted an amendment (3-0) to remove non-residential use size limits for Article 10 landmarks in the Castro NCD, then continued the amended ordinance to the next committee meeting (October 23, 2023). - Item 7: Continued to the October 30, 2023, Land Use and Transportation Committee meeting for further amendments and technical cleanup.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on Thursday, October 12, 2023, at 6:15 PM. The meeting primarily focused on a hearing to examine how San Francisco law enforcement data dashboards can provide more transparent, user-friendly, and anonymized information on crime and law enforcement response. A second agenda item on human trafficking was continued due to a COVID-19 outbreak at the Department on Status of Women. The committee heard presentations from the Society of Professional Journalists, the Budget and Legislative Analyst, the District Attorney's Office, and the San Francisco Police Department. Key outcomes included motions to amend the hearing scope and continue the item to a future date. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comment was offered on the continuance of Agenda Item 1 (Human Trafficking Report). - On Agenda Item 2, one remote caller was connected but did not speak; the line was unattended. Discussion Items Agenda Item 1: Hearing on Human Trafficking in San Francisco 2021 Report - Chair Catherine Stephanie announced that staff from the Department on Status of Women requested a continuance due to a COVID-19 outbreak, preventing the scheduled presentation. The item was continued to the call of the chair without opposition. Agenda Item 2: Hearing on Law Enforcement Data Dashboards - Vice Chair Joel Engardio opened the hearing, emphasizing the need for transparent, accessible crime data to build public trust. He noted the long history of inadequate data systems in San Francisco, citing the 25-year-old Justice Tracking Information System (JUSTIS) that remains incomplete after tens of millions of dollars. - Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez, President of the Northern California chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists, spoke first. He highlighted journalists' struggles to obtain crime data across agencies, particularly demographic data linked to cases. He described the cumbersome process of following a case from arrest to court, with limited access to police reports, DA charging decisions, and court records. He called for unique tracking numbers, downloadable raw data, and daily public arrest record portals. - Fred Brousseau from the Budget and Legislative Analyst's Office presented a comparative analysis of prosecutorial data dashboards. Hedenonstrated that San Francisco’s DA dashboard, while one of the first in California, lacks key features present in other jurisdictions (e.g., Yolo County, Cook County, Milwaukee). Missing features include filters for defendant demographics (race, ethnicity, age, gender), geographic location of incidents, firearm involvement, severity of offense, and case disposition details (e.g., felony reduction rates). Estimated cost to enhance the dashboard: $134,400 initial and $240,000 annually. - Eddie McCaffrey and Nora Gregory from the District Attorney’s Office presented existing dashboards (cases presented, case resolutions, victim services). They confirmed the office is committed to expanding transparency but lacks staffing (0.75 FTE currently). They estimated needing one additional analyst ($116,000/year) and a temporary systems engineer ($18,000 one-time) to add features like geographic data, performance metrics, and diversion program data. They noted no policy reason prevents sharing demographic data; past data quality issues have been resolved through direct feeds from the Sheriff’s Department. - Catherine McGuire, Director of the SFPD Strategic Management Bureau, described current and planned data systems. The department is implementing a new records management system (Central Square) to replace legacy systems, which will enable NIBERS compliance and better case management. She addressed challenges in releasing police reports: requests require manual redaction by the reporting officer, leading to delays. She expressed openness to linking from crime dashboards to other agencies' public records (e.g., DA charging documents) via simple instructions or hyperlinks. - Committee members explored creative solutions for cross-agency data linking, the feasibility of providing police report access via automated redaction, and the state of the JUSTIS system. Supervisor Dorsey raised concerns about state prohibitions on disclosing criminal offender record information (CORI) and the difficulty of tracking individual re-arrests. Agenda Item 2: Discussion on JUSTIS System - In response to questions from Chair Stephanie and Supervisor Dorsey, it was noted that JUSTIS (the internal data-sharing system among public safety agencies) has been ongoing since 1997 with tens of millions in funding but still faces challenges. The committee agreed that a separate hearing on JUSTIS is warranted. Key Outcomes - Motion (Item 2): Vice Chair Engardio moved to amend the hearing title to remove the Mayor's Office of Innovation and add the Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, and the Sheriff's Department. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). - Motion (Item 2): Vice Chair Engardio moved to continue the amended hearing to the call of the chair. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). - Motion (Item 1): Chair Stephanie moved to continue the Human Trafficking hearing to the call of the chair. The motion passed without opposition. - The committee intends to hold a follow-up hearing that includes the Superior Court and Sheriff's Department to address data transparency for the entire criminal justice process.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, October 11, 2023, at 11:15 AM (agenda date: 2023-10-11 18:15:00+00:00). Chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and temporarily appointed member President Aaron Peskin (for item 1), the committee considered nine agenda items. Supervisor Ahsha Safai was excused. Items included trailing legislation for the Empty Homes Tax, health services contracts, a recycling center lease, a city attorney grant, youth program grants, airport contracts, and an amendment to the Police Department salary ordinance. Votes were taken on all items. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel spoke on multiple items: he supported the Our Planet Recycling lease but noted a calculation error in the base rent ($1,949.83/month vs. $1,949.37) and an outdated city attorney name in the lease document; he supported the airport clinic and DEA lease amendments, suggesting adding "retroactive" language to the DEA lease; and he supported President Peskin’s police ordinance amendment, urging a new department organization chart. - David DeCasa criticized the handling of youth programs (Items 6 & 7), stating that a needs assessment is needed and that representatives from YMCA and the Human Rights Commission should have been present to explain services. He accused the city of outsourcing money without accountability. Discussion Items 1. Empty Homes Tax Administration (Item 2 – Ordinance 230898) - Amanda Freed (Treasurer’s Office) presented trailing legislation for the voter-approved Empty Homes Tax, effective January 1, 2024. The ordinance aligns administrative provisions (audit, collections, penalties, confidentiality) with other business taxes. Owners of relevant units must file annual informational returns by April 30 of the following year, with exemptions for those with a valid California homeowners’ exemption. No public comment. Approved unanimously (2-0) and forwarded to the full board. 2. Mission Neighborhood Health Center – HIV Health Services (Item 3 – Resolution 230964) - Bill Blum (DPH) presented Amendment 1 to increase the contract by $2.6 million to a not-to-exceed amount of $11.3 million, extending the term from February 2024 to February 2030. Funds are entirely from Ryan White federal grants. Performance data for contract year 2021-22 showed only 58% of contracted units delivered, attributed to staff vacancies and patient avoidance of in-person visits during COVID. However, the contractor served approximately 325 clients (close to budgeted target). Nick Menard (BLA) noted the performance issue but recommended approval. Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor. The committee discussed ways to increase flexibility for durable viral suppression patients. Approved unanimously (2-0) and forwarded to the full board. 3. Lease with Our Planet Recycling (Item 4 – Resolution 230914) - Claudia Gorham (Real Estate Division) described a 5-year lease (with one 5-year extension option) for a 4,000 sq. ft. remnant parcel at Alemany Boulevard, used as access and storage for the adjacent recycling center. Annual base rent: $23,397.96 with 3% annual increases. The tenant has maintained the property since 2017 under a minor encroachment permit. Conditional use authorization was obtained in July 2023. Public commenter David Pilpel identified two minor errors in the lease documents (monthly rent calculation and outdated city attorney name). Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson noted the corrections would be reviewed. The committee agreed to forward with the understanding that clerical corrections could be made at the full board. Approved unanimously (2-0). 4. City Attorney Grant – Affirmative Litigation Coordination (Item 5 – Resolution 230983) - Rebecca Kral (City Attorney’s Office) presented a retroactive grant of $200,000 from the San Francisco Foundation for coordinating affirmative litigation and enforcement efforts with other California public law offices, focusing on consumer and worker protection. The grant period is July 1, 2023 to June 30, 2025; no funds have been expended yet. Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor. Approved unanimously (2-0). 5. DCYF Grants – Japanese Community Youth Council (Item 6 – Resolution 230692) and YMCA Truancy Program (Item 7 – Resolution 230693) - Brett Connor (DCYF) presented two amendments: (a) JCYC – fourth amendment increasing the grant by $3.4 million to $13.7 million for the Opportunities for All intermediary program (no term change, ends June 2024); (b) YMCA – seventh amendment adding 1 year through June 2024 and increasing funds by $606,000 to $5.39 million for the Truancy Assessment and Resource Center (TARC). Both programs are part of DCYF’s 2024-2029 RFP due October 20, 2023. - Nick Menard (BLA) reported that JCYC served only 36% of budgeted participants in FY21-22 and 55% in FY22-23, with zero participants completing a work-based learning experience of at least one month in summer (due to no programming). He noted the program was sole-sourced and lacked performance data. For TARC, only 30% of served youth (89 clients) met the 15-hour engagement threshold in FY21-22. He considered both items policy matters. - Chair Chan and Vice Chair Mandelman expressed concerns about persistent lack of data and performance, especially for JCYC. DCYF stated that improvements are underway (87% completion rate for one-month placements in the latest period) and that the new RFP will include stronger performance measures. The committee voted to continue both items to the October 25, 2023 meeting (2-0) to allow further discussion with BLA on evaluation criteria. 6. Airport Contracts – SFO Medical Clinic (Item 8 – Resolution 230908) and DEA Lease (Item 9 – Resolution 230965) - Kathy Widener (SFO) presented: (a) Modification No. 4 with Dignity Health/St. Mary’s Medical Center increasing the contract by $1.7 million to $12.7 million (no term change, ends June 2024) due to lower-than-projected patient revenues (airport reimburses net operating costs). The clinic provides urgent care, occupational health, and travel medicine. (b) Modification No. 2 of the lease with the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, extending the term by 2 years through September 30, 2025, and increasing annual rent to $620,611.20. BLA recommended both. Public commenter David Pilpel noted the clinic’s founder and suggested adding "retroactive" to the DEA lease. On question from Chair Chan, Widener confirmed that UCSF’s pending acquisition of Dignity Health sites would not change the contract terms. Both items approved unanimously (2-0) and forwarded to the full board. 7. Police Department Salary Ordinance (Item 1 – Ordinance 230865) - President Aaron Peskin, temporarily seated on the committee, presented an amended version of the ordinance. Originally, the ordinance would delete four high-ranking positions (two assistant chiefs and two commanders) and add 7.69 police officer positions. After negotiations with the Police Department, the amendment deleted only two positions (one assistant chief, one commander) and allowed incumbents to stay until attrition, while creating four additional police officer positions. Olivia Roche (Police Department) expressed agreement with the compromise. BLA’s report supported the amendment. Public commenter David Pilpel supported it and called for future discussion on civilianization. Chair Chan noted ongoing work on police reform and quarterly reports. The committee approved the amendment unanimously (3-0) and then forwarded the amended ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). Key Outcomes - Items 2, 3, 4, 5, 8, 9 were approved and forwarded to the Board of Supervisors (October 17 agenda) with votes of 2-0 (Supervisor Safai excused). - Items 6 and 7 were continued to the October 25, 2023 Budget and Finance Committee meeting (2-0) for additional data and discussion on program performance metrics. - Item 1 was amended and forwarded to the full board (3-0) with a revised deletion of two command staff positions via attrition and addition of four police officer positions. - Public comment identified minor clerical errors in the Our Planet Recycling lease documents (Item 4) to be corrected administratively.
The San Francisco Police Commission convened on Wednesday, October 11, 2023, at 1:30 PM. The meeting included an officer recognition, public comment, reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), commissioner reports, and a vote to approve a revised foot pursuit policy. The commission also entered closed session. Officer Recognition Certificate - Sergeant Kevin Quadro (Star 1253) of the Robbery Detail was recognized for outstanding investigative work, including a five-month investigation that led to the arrest of suspects in an April 2023 street robbery where the victim was shot. Sergeant Quadro also noted the upcoming six-year anniversary of Officer Elliottankel’s critical injury and called for continued support. Consent Calendar - The commission received and filed the Family Code 6228 incident report release quarterly report (2023 Q2) and the SFPD/DPA SB 1421 and SB16 monthly report. The motion passed unanimously (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Dr. Miller (disabled community advocate) raised concerns about ongoing ADA violations on city sidewalks, particularly in the Lower Polk Street area, stating that police response has been inadequate and that sidewalk clearance requirements (4-foot passage) are not being enforced. - Yolanda Williams (mother of murder victim Abre Abacasa) thanked District Attorney Brooke Jenkins for funding her son’s headstone but urged the commission to fund tip rewards and assign investigators to unsolved homicides. She noted that zero dollars have been paid out for unsolved homicides in nearly a decade. - Yolanda Williams (Vice President, San Francisco NAACP) relayed a warning from the NAACP president that black churches may be targeted for crimes during Sunday morning services. She requested that the chief meet with NAACP leadership and that officers visit churches during their tours. - Yolanda Williams (President, Officers for Justice) criticized the POA president for bullying commissioners and called for accountability regarding fraudulent data entries by officers. She emphasized the need for transparency and proper oversight. - A speaker (the same Yolanda Williams, mother of victim) also complained that digital homicide posters at police stations are not functioning, impeding efforts to solve cases. Discussion Items Chief’s Report (Chief Bill Scott) - Crime trends: Violent crime up 3% year-to-date; homicides increased by 2 (42 vs. 40); gun violence down 3% (162 shootings vs. 167); property crimes down 6%; car break-ins down 7%; burglaries also down. Gun seizures: 851 (up from 814); ghost gun seizures: 158 (vs. 160). Homicide clearance rate: 75%. - Significant incidents: A homicide on October 7 (200 block of Mission) – active investigation, no arrest. A shooting on October 8 (Mission & Cesar Chavez) – victim self-transported with non-life-threatening injuries. An aggravated assault of an 80-year-old victim (October 5) – suspect arrested same day. Retail theft operation at San Francisco Centre led to 9 arrests and recovery of stolen property, funded by a $15.3M organized retail crime grant. An armed robbery series (Sept 26–Oct 4) in the Mission District resulted in the arrest of two suspects; evidence including firearms recovered. - A fatal fall during Fleet Week: a woman fell to her death from a rooftop party on October 7. The chief warned against unsafe rooftop gatherings. - Swatting calls: The department has seen an uptick in fake emergency calls; an investigation is underway. - Drug market enforcement: 44 arrests and 2100 grams of illegal narcotics recovered that week. - Officer-involved shooting at the Chinese consulate on October 7: A suspect drove a car into the consulate; officers responded and an OIS occurred. A town hall will be scheduled. - In response to commissioner questions: The department is investigating a data breach involving unauthorized release of an officer's name from disciplinary documents. The investigation began the prior week. No notifications have been sent to others potentially affected. The chief also confirmed that street vending enforcement is led by Public Works, with police support to prevent assaults on workers. DPA Director’s Report (Acting Director Sarah Hawkins) - Year-to-date statistics: 617 cases opened (up from 514), 574 closed, 296 pending (22 past 270 days, 19 held for legal reasons). 7 cases pending with the commission, 85 with the chief. - Mediation: 31 cases mediated so far this year (double last year). A community connect event on October 3 addressed mediation; 25 attendees. - DPA investigators and attorneys will train using the firearms training system simulator (FATS) coordinated with SFPD. Commission Reports - Vice President Carter Oberstone: Attended a closed-door town hall with 25 officers to solicit feedback on the vehicle chase policy; described as productive. Responded to the POA president’s allegation of leaking confidential information by noting that his public letter and all correspondence are on the commission website. - Commissioner Yi: Reported on community celebrations for Asian command staff promotions (including new Central Station Captain Jahan Kim) and the Italian Heritage Festival parade. Thanked the department for a safe Fleet Week. - Commissioner Walker: Discussed follow-up on the patrol special program; planning to work with attorneys and community benefit districts for a pilot. Raised concerns about commission communication rules and urged careful representation. - Commissioner Benedicto: Thanked for the pursuit policy town hall; announced the SFPD Pink Brunch fundraiser for breast cancer awareness. Also noted an executive order from the mayor on SFMTA/SFPD coordination regarding stolen vehicle information and parking tickets, and requested future agendization. - Commissioner Yanez: Acknowledged Indigenous Peoples’ Day. Requested an update on the Hill Bomb incident, including overtime costs (1,293 hours, $151,281 at avg $17/hr) and regular staffing hours. Also requested a report on skateboarding enforcement. Called for agendizing the juvenile DGO 7.01 and language access DGO. Read a coalition letter accusing the POA of obstructing implementation of DGO 907 (biased stops) and criticized the POA president for a combative approach. Item 7: Revised Department General Order 5.25 – Foot Pursuits (Discussion and Vote) - Presentation by Captain Sean Perdomo, Lieutenant Meehan, and Sergeant Bugarin from the Field Tactics and Force Options Unit (FTFO). The policy provides guidelines for officers initiating foot pursuits, focusing on officer safety, balancing public safety, and discretion. It is consistent with California POST training (Learning Domain 21) and is more permissive than many other departments’ policies – it does not prohibit foot pursuits for any specific offense. - DPA Policy Director Janelle Kaywood noted the policy is the result of years of collaboration; it will guide officers without being overly restrictive. DPA provided a binder of 37 foot pursuit policies from other jurisdictions for comparison. - Chief Scott expressed support for the policy but reiterated his preference that tactical guidelines be issued outside the DGO process (e.g., via bulletins) for easier updating. - Commissioner Byrne questioned how an officer could be disciplined under the policy, since many provisions use “should” rather than “shall.” DPA responded that the reasonableness standard (“shall act reasonably”) provides a basis for discipline in egregious cases. - Commissioner Walker suggested separating general orders from tactical manuals. - The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to approve Resolution 23-30, authorizing the department to use DGO 5.25 in meet-and-confer with bargaining units. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Received and filed (6-0). - Foot Pursuit Policy (DGO 5.25): Approved for use in labor negotiations (Resolution 23-30; 6-0). - Closed Session: The commission voted to enter closed session (6-0) and afterward voted not to disclose any discussion (6-0). - The meeting adjourned at approximately 4:30 PM.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, October 10, 2023, from 11:15 AM to 5:24 PM. The agenda included consent calendar items, an executive director’s report, a memorandum of understanding for the Embarcadero SAFE Navigation Center, a budget and lease amendment for the Mission Rock project, an exclusive negotiation agreement for Fisherman’s Wharf redevelopment, and an informational presentation on leasing Pier 33.5. Commissioners also heard public comments on non‑agenda matters, including an AT&T dispute over a cross‑default lease provision. Consent Calendar - Item 7A (Resolution 2342): Approved a new 74‑month lease with Recology San Francisco for a single‑stream mixed materials recycling center at Pier 96. - Item 7B (Resolution 2343): Approved a three‑year lease (with three mutual one‑year extensions) with Anderson Enterprises, Inc. for approximately 116,343 sq ft of paved land and 2,010 sq ft of shed space at Pier 68/70 Shipyard, subject to Board of Supervisors approval. - Item 7C (Resolution 2344): Authorized an agreement with the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure and the Recreation and Parks Department for the Port and RPD to maintain and operate certain Mission Bay Parks, funded by Community Financing District No. 5 revenues through 2044. All consent items were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - AT&T (Cami Blackstone, External Affairs Director; John Newman, outside real estate counsel): Expressed strong opposition to a new cross‑default provision in the proposed Pier 94 lease. They stated the provision would allow the Port to terminate all AT&T leases on Port property if any single lease is in default, jeopardizing a critical cell site that serves Bayview‑Hunters Point, Recology, SFPD training facilities, and the city’s emergency medical mobile hospital. They called the provision “unprecedented” and urged the Commission to direct staff to remove it. A representative from Verizon also spoke in support of continuing discussions. - Alice Rogers (vice chair of the Navigation Center advisory group): Expressed support for the continued interim use of the Embarcadero SAFE Navigation Center, but noted concerns about foot‑beat officer staffing and point‑in‑time count methodology. She thanked Port staff for addressing those issues in the updated MOU. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Elaine Forbes): Honored Senator Dianne Feinstein, reported on a successful Fleet Week (parade of ships, air shows, Italian Heritage Parade), SB 273 signing (enabling Pier 30‑32 development), APEC preparations, the Portola Festival (57,000 attendees), Southern Waterfront greening efforts, a new playground and dog park at Crane Cove Park, and staff transitions (Justin Burton departing, Eric Young joining; Rod Iwashta leaving). - Item 8A – Navigation Center MOU (Resolution 2345): Port staff and HSH presented a two‑year MOU (with a two‑year extension option) for Seawall Lot 330. Key changes included strengthened foot‑beat officer commitments, revised point‑in‑time counts, and a six‑month termination notice. Commissioners expressed concerns about safety staffing and the ability to decommission the 200‑bed site rapidly, but ultimately approved the resolution. - Item 8B – Mission Rock Phase 1 Budget & Parcel Lease Amendments (Resolution 2346): Port staff presented a revised $218.5 million phase 1 budget (a $34.5 million increase since September), a $16.5 million Port capital contribution earning 10% annual interest, and three technical parcel lease amendments (correction of an error, clarification of refinancing participation and foreclosure treatment, and job‑housing equivalency fee recapture). Commissioners received commitments for quarterly cost reporting and early notification of budget impacts. The resolution was approved as amended (non‑substantive changes). - Item 8C – Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized ENA (Resolution 2347): Port staff recommended a 24‑month exclusive negotiation agreement with Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized LLC for a mixed‑use project at Pier 45 Sheds A and C, Seawall Lots 300‑301, and the Little Embarcadero. The concept includes an experiential museum/events center, public square, potential short‑term rentals, and support for the fishing industry. Commissioner Gilman asked that fishery needs and trust compliance be carefully considered. Commissioner Lee suggested a working fish market. The resolution was adopted after President Brandon successfully moved to keep the initial deposit at $100,000 and require Commission approval for any waiver of extension fees. - Item 8D – Pier 33.5 Restaurant (Informational): Staff reported that after marketing via a broker (Cushman & Wakefield) and receiving four proposals, the selection panel recommended Kuleto’s Waterside Italian Bistro (Pat Kuleto, Pete Sitnik, and partners). The concept emphasizes a modern Italian menu, grab‑and‑go service, and a five‑and‑a‑half percent percentage rent. The Port will now negotiate a final lease and return for approval. Commissioners welcomed the activation of the long‑vacant space. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar items (7A, 7B, 7C) approved unanimously. - Resolution 2345 (Navigation Center MOU) adopted unanimously after discussion. - Resolution 2346 (Mission Rock) adopted as amended (non‑substantive corrections to resolving clauses). - Resolution 2347 (Fisherman’s Wharf ENA) adopted after President Brandon’s amendment to set the deposit at $100,000 and require Commission‑level approval for any waiver of extension fees. - New business – none; the meeting adjourned in memory of Senator Dianne Feinstein and in honor of peace in the Middle East. Meeting adjourned at 5:24 PM.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on Tuesday, October 10, 2023, at approximately 9:45 AM for a regular meeting. The commission elected new officers, approved a consent calendar, received reports on capital financing and voluntary agreements, and voted on two major items: the Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project and an expansion of California Water Service Company's service area. The meeting concluded with a closed session to discuss two proposed litigation settlements. Public comment was taken on multiple agenda items. Annual Election of Officers - Following public comment, the commission unanimously (5-0) elected Tim Paulson as President and Anthony Rivera as Vice President, each for a one-year term. Commissioner Jamy, outgoing President, was thanked for her leadership. Consent Calendar - Items 7a through 7f were approved on a 4-0 roll call vote (Commissioner Paulson absent from vote? Actually 4 votes recorded: President Paulson, VP Rivera, Maxwell, Stacy – 4 eyes. Commissioner Jamy? Wait, roll call: President Paulson aye, VP Rivera aye, Commissioner Maxwell aye, Commissioner Stacy aye. That's 4. So likely one commissioner absent or not voting. The transcript says "You have four eyes." So 4-0.) The consent calendar included three licenses for air quality monitors (7a), software maintenance contract (7b), USGS agreement (7c), technical services for renewable energy (7d), contract time extension for the West Side Recycled Water Project (7e), and acceptance of work by Precision Engineering (7f). Commissioners questioned 7e about corrosion of equipment at the oceanside wastewater treatment plant; staff noted a third-party review and lessons learned. General Public Comment - Several speakers expressed support for moving public comment to the beginning of the meeting and urged the commission to address low flows in the Tuolumne River to protect endangered salmon. One speaker cited that fall-run Chinook salmon returns were below 1,000 in recent years. Another speaker opposed making San Jose and Santa Clara permanent water customers, citing San Francisco's own housing requirements. Multiple commenters criticized the 8.5-year design drought plan as based on unrealistic projections and harmful to the environment. A speaker named Dave Warner alleged that staff presentations lack balanced analysis on topics such as the voluntary agreement, alternative water supply, and affordability. One speaker inquired about the timeline for development at Bayview-Hunters Point. No comments were made specific to the election or consent calendar during general comment. Discussion Items - Item 8 – Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project: The commission approved the project on a 4-0 vote. The project includes permanently closing the Great Highway between Sloat and Skyline Boulevards, constructing a buried wall to protect wastewater infrastructure, removing emergency rock, and building over a mile of multi-use trail, beach access stairs, new parking (45-50 spaces), and restrooms. It is designed to handle sea level rise through 2100. The EIR was certified by the Planning Commission on September 28, 2023. Commissioners discussed traffic impacts, coordination with SFMTA and the San Francisco Zoo, and cost-sharing among city agencies. The commission adopted a resolution to continue evaluating vehicle access to the zoo parking lot. The zoo director spoke in opposition, stating that the plan lacks specific remedies for traffic and parking concerns. Other public comment was mixed, with supporters citing climate adaptation and opponents raising evacuation route concerns. - Item 9 – Approval of Cal Water Service Area Expansion: The commission approved on a 4-0 vote the expansion of California Water Service Company's Bear Gulch District to acquire Skylanda Mutual Water Company (158 customers) and a second amendment to the individual water sales contract. Staff noted that Skylanda has relied on Cal Water since 2019 due to inadequate local supplies. No public opposition was expressed during public comment. Key Outcomes - Elected Tim Paulson as President and Anthony Rivera as Vice President (5-0 each). - Approved consent calendar items 7a-7f (4-0). - Approved the Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project (4-0), including authorizing staff to proceed with implementation, signing a letter of agreement with Rec and Park, and urging the closure of the Great Highway. - Approved Cal Water service area expansion and contract amendment (4-0). - Asserted attorney-client privilege and moved into closed session to discuss two litigation settlements: Devon Galdoula ($175,000) and Joan Asserito ($44,000) for water main damage claims. The commission voted 4-0 not to disclose closed session discussions.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on October 4, 2023, to consider several items, including an ordinance to reform the city's budget process for nonprofit contracts, acceptance of grants and gifts, airport lease agreements, and a police department salary ordinance. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Ahsha Safai, with Supervisor Hillary Ronen participating as a sponsor. Consent Calendar - Item 2 (230989): Resolution authorizing the Department of Environment to apply for CalRecycle grants for five years. Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 3 (230993): Resolution retroactively accepting a $79,231.32 bequest from the estate of Janet D. Kramer for Laguna Honda Hospital. Approved unanimously (3-0). - Items 4-6 (230937, 230935, 230936): Three resolutions accepting in-kind grants for parks: Stern Grove Festival donor recognition installation ($300,000), Dahlia Dell Hillside Garden repairs ($250,000), and India Basin Shoreline Park project ($3,768,558 from EPA). All approved unanimously (3-0). - Items 7-8 (230733, 230910): Lease termination agreements with airport spa concessions (XpresSpa and Be Relax). Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 9 (230913): Foreign currency exchange services lease with ICE Currency Services USA ($1,000,000 minimum annual guarantee). Approved unanimously (3-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Multi-Year Grants): Numerous speakers from nonprofit organizations and coalitions expressed strong support. Debbie Lerman (San Francisco Human Services Network) called it the most important piece of legislation for city-nonprofit partnership in many years. John Avalos (Council of Community Housing Organizations) noted it was 30 years in the making. Other speakers included representatives from the Living Wage Coalition, Pretrial Diversion Project, Safe and Sound, Good Samaritan Family Resource Center, Eviction Defense Collaborative, Chinese for Affirmative Action, Glide, Larkin Street, SF Housing Development Corporation, Compass Family Services, HomeRise, Progress Foundation, Richmond Area Multiservices, and others. They highlighted the need for predictable funding, cost-of-living adjustments, and staff retention. - Items 4-6 (Parks): Gina Kotos (SF Parks Alliance) and Sarah Smith (Dahlia Society) supported item 5. Joseph LaFon (Stern Grove Festival) supported item 4. - No public comment on other items. Discussion Items - Item 1 (230483): Administrative Code – Preparation of City Budget and Multi-Year Grants Supervisor Hillary Ronen presented the ordinance requiring city departments to issue multi-year grants when services are ongoing and to include cost-of-doing-business (CODB) increases to account for inflation. Laura Marshall (Controller's Office) explained the operational benefits: the ordinance would shift CODB planning to the base budget, reduce contract renegotiations, and allow nonprofits to plan staffing and finances. Supervisors Chan, Mandelman, and Safai added themselves as co-sponsors. The committee voted to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 11 (230865): Police Department Salary Ordinance Supervisor Chan announced a request for continuance to October 11, 2023, due to the passing of Senator Dianne Feinstein and the Police Department's preparations for related events. No public comment. The committee voted to continue the item (3-0). - Item 10 (230801): Airport Professional Services Agreement – Beumer Lifecycle Management LLC The airport requested approval of a modification to increase the contract for baggage handling system maintenance at Harvey Milk Terminal by $17 million (to $38 million) and extend the term by 18 months. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended reducing the total by $3 million due to prior savings and raised policy concerns about sole-source provisions and proprietary software locking the city into higher costs. Airport representative Kathy Weiner noted the system's high performance (95-99% availability) and the airport's desire to be innovative. Supervisor Chan expressed willingness to amend the amount. The committee voted to amend the not-to-exceed amount to $35 million, then approved the item as amended (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (230483): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). Co-sponsors added: Chan, Mandelman, Safai. - Item 11 (230865): Continued to October 11, 2023 budget and finance committee meeting (3-0). - Item 2 (230989): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). Co-sponsor: Mandelman. - Item 3 (230993): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 4-6 (230937, 230935, 230936): All three forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). Co-sponsor: Mandelman for all three. - Items 7-8 (230733, 230910): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 9 (230913): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 10 (230801): Amended to reduce not-to-exceed amount from $38 million to $35 million (3-0), then forwarded to full board as amended (3-0).
The San Francisco Police Commission met on October 4, 2023, at 1:45 PM UTC. The meeting included officer recognition, public comment on missing persons policies and police accountability, reports from the Chief and DPA, a presentation on the Benchmark early warning system, updates on the Collaborative Reform Initiative, and adoption of revised department general orders. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously voted to receive and file the Police Commission report of disciplinary actions for the third quarter of 2023 and the DPA May, June, and July statistical reports. Public Comments & Testimony - Michelle Lazaneo (26-year civilian police employee for a neighboring agency) urged the commission to adopt a public alerts policy for missing persons, citing the case of 13-year-old Knowledge Shepherd, a nonverbal autistic child reported missing on September 15, 2023, and found three days later without immediate public alerts from SFPD. She noted the current missing persons policy (DGO 6.10) has not been updated since 1999. - Janelle Harris (former Oakland Police Commissioner) supported updating the missing persons policy, referencing a 12-page draft from an ad hoc committee. - Jake Honor B. Ortega (co-president of Iconic D3) expressed strong support for SFPD officers, criticizing anti-police policies and vowing continued public pushback. - A speaker challenged Commissioner Oberstone's focus on traffic enforcement, arguing that traffic fatalities (12 over six months) are far fewer than fentanyl overdose deaths (over 500 in 2023) and that resources should be directed at drug dealers. - Tracy McCray (President of the San Francisco Police Officers Association) raised concerns about a leak of confidential disciplinary information to the SF Standard, demanding an investigation. Commissioner Oberstone countered that the article explicitly stated the information was not leaked, and the leak theory originated from a right-wing blogger. McCray reiterated the need to find the source. - Aubrey Abarcasa's mother (speaker) called attention to unsolved homicides, including her son's murder in 2006, and questioned the commission's efforts to hire tipsters. Discussion Items - Chief's Report: Chief William Scott reported that overall crime is down 4% year-to-date (about 1,900 fewer crimes), with property crime down 5% and violent crime up 2%. Homicides are even with last year; the clearance rate is 75% (with a recent arrest). He highlighted a hit-and-run fatality involving a self-driving vehicle, Fleet Week activities, and the ongoing drug enforcement strategy in the Tenderloin. Since May 29, 2023, there have been 582 arrests for drug possession/use, with 81 overdose reversals. Commissioner Oberstone questioned the effectiveness of the drug user arrest strategy, suggesting resources could be better used for traffic enforcement. Chief Scott defended the approach, citing the need to address both supply and demand. Commissioner Yanez noted a correlation between the policing strategy and increased overdose deaths, and asked for measurable outcomes. Commissioner Walker expressed support for the strategy. - DPA Director's Report: Director Henderson reported that DPA has opened over 600 cases this year, closed 552, and has 304 active cases. He noted that the top complaint category is neglect of duty (e.g., failure to take action). Regarding stop data audits, he expressed concerns about the current auditing practices and announced a planned review to assess data integrity, potentially involving outside partners. Commissioner Benedicto supported a formalized review. - Benchmark Analytics Presentation: CEO Ron Huberman and Chief Research Officer Nick Montgomery presented the First Sign early warning system, which uses 79 data variables to identify officers at risk of future adverse events. The model has 81% efficacy in predicting officers who will be investigated within 12 months. The system is ready for deployment pending policy approval. Commissioners discussed data sharing with DPA, transparency, and the need for a supportive, non-punitive approach. Chief Scott noted that the system is not intended for discipline but for early intervention. - Collaborative Reform Initiative (CRI) Quarterly Update: Deborah Kirby (Jensen Hughes) reported that the department is in Phase 3 Plus, with five project plans aimed at sustaining reforms. The department has achieved nearly 90% of the 272 recommendations from the 2016 DOJ report. The focus is on use of force, community policing, bias, and internal affairs data. The sustainability review will dip-sample 10% of recommendations. Challenges include IT delays and resource constraints. Commissioner Oberstone raised concerns about stop data auditing and policy transparency. - Disciplinary Review Board (DRB) Findings: Representatives from IAD and DPA presented aggregate trends for Q1 2023, including neglect of duty (body-worn camera violations) and improper search. One policy failure recommendation led to updated training on Fourth Amendment issues regarding “freezing” a location for a search warrant. Key Outcomes - Revised Department General Order 3.05 (Weapon Return Panel): Adopted unanimously (5-0). - Revised Department General Order 8.04 (Critical Incident Response Team): Adopted unanimously (5-0) to send to meet and confer with affected bargaining units, subject to a resolution ensuring negotiation only over mandatory subjects. - Closed Session: The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to enter closed session on Item 15 (personnel matters) and subsequently voted unanimously not to disclose discussion, except for factual updates to be included in minutes. - Consent Calendar and Minutes: Approved unanimously. - Next Steps: The commission will continue discussions on stop data auditing, policy updates (including missing persons DGO), and the Benchmark system implementation.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on October 3, 2023, starting at 2:15 PM. The meeting included a consent agenda, several legislative items, special order commendations, a Committee of the Whole hearing on the implementation of U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) recommendations regarding the San Francisco Police Department (SFPD), roll call for introductions (including in memoriam tributes), and general public comment. Consent Calendar - Items 1–21 (settlements, unlitigated claims, and administrative code amendments) were approved unanimously by a roll call vote of 11–0. - Item 22 (ordinance to reduce inclusionary housing requirements for certain affordable housing programs) passed on final reading 10–1, with only Supervisor Preston voting no. - Items 23–24 (two retroactive grants for Adult Probation: $507,470 from the Board of State and Community Corrections and $100,000 from the California Emergency Management Agency) were adopted 11–0. - Item 25 (reauthorizing CleanPowerSF membership in a Joint Powers Authority, not to exceed $4,772,710) adopted without objection. - Item 26 (maintenance agreement with Caltrans for the Southern Skyline Boulevard Ridge Trail Extension) adopted without objection. - Items 27–29 (three retroactive grants and agreements for the District Attorney’s Office: $1,066,724 for workers’ compensation fraud, a $75,000 revolving fund for crime victim expenses, and up to $275,391 for criminal restitution compact) adopted without objection. - Item 30 (retroactive grant increase of $28,000 from NIH via Oregon Health & Science University for drug abuse treatment clinical trials network) adopted without objection. - Item 31 (another $100,000 grant from Cal OES for probation specialized supervision) adopted without objection. - Item 32 (resolution urging Recreation and Park Department to share information on UN Plaza pilot activation and mitigate impacts on farmers’ market) adopted without objection. - Item 34 (sublease agreement for Bayview Vehicle Triage Center at Candlestick Point, base rent $312,000/year for two years) adopted without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - Police Reform Hearing: Several speakers addressed the Committee of the Whole. One speaker urged the board to reduce emotional disorder and focus on consciousness. Another speaker called the hearing “political masturbation” and argued funds should go to basic needs, not policing. A third speaker thanked SFPD for an incident near Mission PD. A fourth speaker cited Romans 13 to support police authority. One remote caller suggested more community outreach on constitutional rights. - General Public Comment: Speakers raised a variety of issues: opposition to Bible study during public comment, opposition to Italian Heritage Month, criticism of police reform and mourning for Senator Feinstein (with one speaker calling her legacy harmful), support for taxi medallion relief, opposition to limiting remote public comment, advocacy for reparations and the Yoshi’s building, criticism of DPW violence, and calls for stronger leadership on fentanyl and crime. One caller urged a citywide no-turn-on-red policy and better intersection daylighting. Discussion Items 1. Commendations and Recognitions (Special Order 2:30 PM) - Japanese Cultural and Community Center of Northern California – Celebrated its 50th anniversary. Supervisor Preston recognized the center’s role in preserving Japantown and supporting the community (e.g., raising $4+ million for Japan earthquake relief). Executive Director Paul Osaki accepted and noted the center’s origins in the destruction of Japantown by redevelopment. - Bill Hirsch – Recognized on his retirement. Supervisor Ronen highlighted his decades of legal advocacy for people with HIV/AIDS, mental health, and the unhoused. Hirsch thanked the board and said he will continue social justice work. 2. Committee of the Whole: Updates on DOJ Police Reform Recommendations (3:00 PM) - Presentation by Deborah Kirby (Jensen Hughes) – The 2016 DOJ assessment identified 94 findings and 272 recommendations. Initial implementation reduced use of force and advanced crisis intervention training. The current phase (ending April 2024) focuses on five project plans: use of force, bias, community policing, management dashboard, and policy development. As of October 2023, 27 recommendations remained uncompleted. Key challenges include understaffing of the professional standards unit, IT system delays, and ensuring accurate stop data (after media reports of officers misreporting race). - SFPD Chief Scott – Reported that the department has made progress, including a new disengagement policy and steps to address disparities. On stop data falsification allegations, he acknowledged the need for deeper auditing but cited staffing shortages. He noted that technology (records management system, dashboard) is being upgraded to improve data accuracy and accountability. - Supervisors’ Questions – Supervisor Walton pressed on persistent racial disparities in stops and use of force, and the need to shift resources to root causes (e.g., gun violence reduction via CalVIP grant). Supervisor Preston asked about auditing of stop data and whether the department risks losing “substantial compliance” status on audit recommendations. Chief Scott committed to improving the audit process and staffing. - Supervisor Dorsey asked what key factors enabled sustained reform. Ms. Kirby cited self-driven leadership, community engagement, and a culture of continuous improvement. 3. Roll Call for Introductions – New Business - Supervisor Preston announced that the state issued an RFQ for affordable housing development on the DMV site on Fell Street, following a unanimous board resolution in November 2022. Proposals due November 22, 2023. - Supervisor Safai proposed legislation to codify the Homeward Bound program (reunifying homeless individuals with out-of-town support networks) and submitted an in memoriam for Artist Cooper Jr. - Supervisor Melgar introduced two hearing requests: (1) working conditions for mothers at SFPD (with Supervisor Stephanie), and (2) progress on intersection “daylighting” for pedestrian safety since 2019 legislation. - In Memoriam – The board adjourned in memory of Tim Figueras (SOMA youth advocate) and U.S. Senator Diane Feinstein. Colleagues delivered tributes to Feinstein, noting her historic firsts as president of the board, mayor, and senator, and her leadership after the 1978 assassinations, on gun control (assault weapons ban), and on intelligence reform. Key Outcomes - Consent agenda and most regular items were approved unanimously or without objection (except Item 22, 10–1). - Item 33 (police reform hearing) was continued to May 21, 2024, on a motion by Supervisor Walton, seconded by Supervisor Ronan, without objection. - Items 37–40 (adoption without committee reference: extension for Alexandria Theater landmark designation, Filipino American History Month proclamation, support for Green Bank applications, and urging MTA to prohibit right turns on red) were adopted 11–0. - Committee of the Whole – The hearing was received and filed; the board will receive a final report from Jensen Hughes by April 2024. SFPD committed to improving stop data auditing and completing the management dashboard. - Legislation Introduced – Supervisors submitted numerous items for draft or referral, including Homeward Bound codification, hearings on maternal working conditions at SFPD and intersection daylighting, and an update on the DMV housing site.