Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 951–960 ENTRIES
951
JUL 17, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - July 17, 2023

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, July 17, 2023, at 11:00 AM (remote and in-person) to consider eight items including campaign finance updates, surveillance technology policy, multiple commission appointments, and amendments to the Parks, Recreation, and Open Space Advisory Committee (PROSAC). The committee, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shamann Walton and Supervisor Ahsha Safai (arriving later), voted unanimously to advance most items to the full Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Ordinance - Campaign Advertisement Disclaimer Requirements): Unanimously approved as a committee report. The ordinance modifies campaign and governmental conduct code to conform to a court order (Judge Breyer, February 2020) regarding Proposition F (Sunlight on Dark Money), which requires disclosure of top contributors for independent expenditure committees. Sponsored by Supervisor Connie Chan, the ordinance codifies the exception for very small print ads or short audio/video ads. The Ethics Commission voted 4-0 to approve. - Item 2 (Ordinance - Surveillance Technology Policy for Social Media Management Software): Unanimously approved. The Human Services Agency (HSA) presented its policy for using social media management software (currently Hootsuite, moving to Sprout Social). The policy was discussed at two COIT meetings and recommended for adoption. No public comments. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 7 (Homelessness Oversight Commission Appointment - Dena Aslanian-Williams): Multiple public speakers expressed both support and opposition. Jordan (she/her/they) strongly opposed, citing Aslanian-Williams' former role as Governmental Affairs Chair of the SF Association of Realtors, which Jordan argued contributed to homelessness through opposition to tenant protections and harm reduction. Jordan also criticized the appointment as rushed. In support, Jack Shea, Gabe Schreyer, Stephen Martin Pinto, Mike Noorr, and Kimberly Wong praised Aslanian-Williams' community leadership, open-mindedness, and ability to represent neighborhood perspectives. Sarah Short (HomeRise) expressed concern about lack of homelessness experience and potential conflicts of interest. - Item 8 (Park Code - PROSAC Membership Amendments): Public comment included Richard Rossman (District 1 PROSAC) supporting amendments but urging flexibility to meet outside City Hall. Wendy Aragon (PROSAC Chair) thanked supervisors for collaborative amendments. David Pilpel requested careful language on meeting locations. Stephen DuPont Kalani (District 11 PROSAC) expressed support. Discussion Items - Items 3 & 4 (Mayoral Reappointments, Entertainment Commission): Ben Bleiman (representing entertainment associations) and Cynthia Wang (representing urban planning) were reappointed. Bleiman highlighted his six years of service and the importance of nightlife in San Francisco's recovery. Wang noted her work on the 'Just Add Music' permits and pandemic transition. No opposition. Supervisor Dorsey commended Bleiman for inspiring a drug checking service grant. - Item 5 (Appointment, Entertainment Commission - Dory Camino): Appointed to seat representing neighborhood associations. Camino, Vice President of the Entertainment Commission, shared her background and cited pre-pandemic nightlife statistics: $6 billion in economic impact, 3,600 businesses, 62,000 employees, $80 million in tax revenue, and 1.6 billion in local supplies. She emphasized the resilience of San Francisco's nightlife. - Item 6 (Mayoral Appointment, Building Inspection Commission - Earl Shaddix): Shaddix, previously appointed to fill a vacancy, highlighted his work on ADA compliance (deadline October 1, 2023) and the importance of the SRO Collaborative. He opposed budget cuts to the SRO Collaborative. Public comment: Jordan raised concerns about conflicts of interest in SRO Collaboratives. - Item 7 (Mayoral Appointment, Homelessness Oversight Commission - Dena Aslanian-Williams): Aslanian-Williams, an immigrant from Iran, real estate professional, and neighborhood association leader, acknowledged her lack of direct homelessness experience but expressed willingness to learn. She mentioned her work with the Welcome Home Project (furnishing homes for formerly homeless) and her perspective as a small business owner and neighborhood delegate. In response to questions from Vice Chair Walton and Supervisor Safai, she emphasized accountability, data, and communication. She also addressed systemic inequities affecting African Americans, noting her personal family connections. Supervisor Safai noted the seat was designed for a neighborhood/small business perspective, and that the earlier nominee had been withdrawn. - Item 8 (Park Code - PROSAC Membership): Supervisor Safai introduced amendments to the previously heard file: allow at-large board president appointee from multiple impacted communities (including disability), allow alternates to vote when primary recuses, and set a process for board president to appoint if a district supervisor does not fill a vacant seat within 30 days. The committee voted to adopt the amendments and continue the item to July 24, 2023. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Passed unanimously (3-0, Supervisor Safai absent) to full board as a committee report with positive recommendation. - Item 2: Passed unanimously (3-0) to full board as a committee report. - Items 3 & 4: Passed unanimously (3-0) after motion to strike 'reject' and send as amended to full board. - Item 5: Passed unanimously (3-0) to appoint Dory Camino and send to full board. - Item 6: Passed unanimously (3-0) after motion to strike 'reject' and send as amended to full board. - Item 7: Passed unanimously (3-0) after motion to strike 'reject' and send as amended to full board, despite public opposition. - Item 8: Motion to adopt amendments and continue item to July 24, 2023, passed unanimously (3-0).

HOMELESSNESS 26% · PROCEDURAL 20% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · ENTERTAINMENT POLICY 14%
952
JUL 17, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting – July 17, 2023

Chair Supervisor Mirna Melgar called the meeting to order at 9:45 AM, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered six agenda items, including amendments to existing legislation and new proposals. Several items were continued from prior meetings. The meeting included extensive public comment, particularly on rent control protections and a proposed family housing special use district. Item 1: Rent Control Protections for Subsidized Housing (File 230770) Supervisor Preston introduced an ordinance closing a loophole that allowed certain units receiving multifamily revenue bonds to lose rent control protections. He highlighted the case of Frederick Douglass Haynes Garden Apartments, where long-term tenants face rent increases of $500+ per year. One tenant reported rent jumping from $1,408 to $1,921 in July 2023, with projected increases to $3,973 by 2026 – a 182% rise. He offered a non-substantive amendment (replacing IRS Section 103 with Section 142D). Public comment: several tenants (Stephanie Brandon, Gabriel Tacle, Henry Anderson, Leroy Beagley, Patricia Beasley, Michael Mahari) and organizers (Maria Samudio of Housing Rights Committee) expressed urgent support, detailing displacement fears. One caller (David Pilpel) suggested a technical amendment. The committee unanimously (3-0) approved the amendment, then voted to send the file to the full Board with a positive recommendation. A duplicate file was continued to the call of the chair. Item 2: Parkside Branch Library Landmark Designation (File 230690) Planning Department staff presented the proposal to designate the library (built 1951) as a historic landmark, citing architectural and cultural significance. The Historic Preservation Commission had unanimously recommended designation. Public comment: one caller (David Pilpel) spoke in support. The committee unanimously (3-0) voted to send the item to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 3: Commercial to Residential Adaptive Reuse and Downtown Revitalization (File 230732) President Peskin presented trailing amendments previously reviewed in committee, including raising the threshold for commercial-to-residential ratios from 15,000 to 20,000 square feet. He proposed deleting two lines in Planning Code sections. Public comment: one caller expressed general support. The committee unanimously (3-0) approved the amendments and voted to send the item to the full Board with a positive recommendation, adding Supervisor Safai as co-sponsor. Item 4: Awning Amnesty Program (File 230745) President Peskin described two remaining substantive amendments (changing the definition of existing signs and removing a five-year lookback for business signs) that had been previously debated. No public comment. The committee unanimously (3-0) voted to send the item to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 5: Streamlining Site Permit Review (File 230374) Supervisor Safai explained that the legislation codifies existing practices into a simplified one- or two-page checklist. Public comment: George Shudish requested adding explicit demolition calculation requirements. Jake Price of Housing Action Coalition reiterated support. The committee unanimously (3-0) voted to send the item to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 6: Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District (File 230026) Chair Melgar introduced the ordinance to allow up to four units or one unit per 1,000 square feet in single-family zones, exempting certain height, open space, and rear yard requirements. She offered several amendments (neighborhood notification pre-application meeting, clerical fixes, rent control consolidation). Supervisor Mandelman's staff proposed amendments to retain existing special use district protections (e.g., anti-monster home rules). President Peskin read a list of additional amendments (not yet approved as to form), including longer lookback periods for multi-unit buildings, restrictions on demolishing rent-controlled units, and limits on short-term rentals. Supervisor Preston raised concerns about impacts on Haight-Ashbury and North of Panhandle neighborhoods and suggested banning short-term rentals. Public comment: many speakers opposed the ordinance, citing potential demolition of rent-controlled housing, displacement, and lack of affordability. Supporters (e.g., Jake Price) appreciated the neighborhood notification addition. The committee unanimously (3-0) voted to adopt the amendments from Chair Melgar and Supervisor Mandelman, then continued the item to the following week for further amendment integration. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Rent control): Passed to full board (3-0), duplicate continued. - Item 2 (Library landmark): Passed to full board (3-0). - Item 3 (Adaptive reuse): Passed to full board (3-0) with amendments. - Item 4 (Awning amnesty): Passed to full board (3-0). - Item 5 (Site permit review): Passed to full board (3-0). - Item 6 (Family housing SUD): Amendments approved, item continued to next meeting. The meeting adjourned at approximately 12:00 PM.

PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · HOUSING 17% · LAND USE 16% · PROCEDURAL 12%
953
JUL 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting – July 13, 2023

This regular meeting of the Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stephanie, was held on July 13, 2023, with Vice Chair Engardio and Supervisor Dorsey present. The committee considered three agenda items: two liquor license transfers (type 20 and type 42) and an ordinance to expand prohibited places for firearms. Both liquor license transfers received unanimous approval, while the firearm ordinance was continued to the call of the chair due to pending state legislation. Consent Calendar - No items were designated as consent calendar; all agenda items were considered individually. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were received in person or remotely on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Liquor License Transfer (Type 20) – Blue Stream Gallery and Gifts Officer Salmonson (SFPD ABC liaison) reported zero letters of protest or support. The location (census tract 117) is a high saturation area and high crime area (plot 160). Central Station had no opposition, and the Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval. The applicant, a co-founder of Blue Stream Gallery, explained that the business is an art gallery in Chinatown, and the license would allow off-sale beer and wine to promote Asian-owned Napa wineries. No public comment was received. The committee voted unanimously to recommend approval. - Item 2 – Liquor License Transfer (Type 42) – Ales Unlimited Officer Salmonson reported zero letters of protest or support. The location (census tract 135) is a high saturation area but low crime area (plot 525). Northern Station had no opposition, and the Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval. The applicant, Steve Smith (owner of Ales Unlimited), stated that the business had a small downtown bar that was evicted during COVID. They now have a location in Pacific Heights after a seismic retrofit and wish to transfer the license to offer tastings and generate sales. Vice Chair Engardio noted the business is popular in District 2. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously to recommend approval. - Item 3 – Ordinance Amending Administrative Code – Firearms Prohibited Places Chair Stephanie introduced the ordinance to expand prohibited firearms places (including childcare facilities, city property, election facilities, medical facilities, private parks/playgrounds, places of worship, and private commercial establishments without express consent), in response to the Supreme Court’s Bruen decision and over 200 CCW applications pending. She noted that state Senate Bill 2 (SB2) addresses similar issues and is moving forward; therefore, she proposed continuing the item to the call of the chair to avoid conflict with state law. No public comment was received. The committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the call of the chair. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Blue Stream Gallery and Gifts): Unanimous motion (3-0) to prepare a resolution supporting the license transfer and send to the full Board with a positive recommendation. (Vice Chair Engardio aye, Member Dorsey aye, Chair Stephanie aye) - Item 2 (Ales Unlimited): Unanimous motion (3-0) to prepare a resolution supporting the license transfer and send to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 (Firearms Prohibited Places Ordinance): Unanimous motion (3-0) to continue the item to the call of the chair, pending developments with state legislation (SB2).

LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 60% · PROCEDURAL 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · GUN CONTROL 7%
954
JUL 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Special Meeting – July 13, 2023

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a special meeting on July 13, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan. The committee considered two items: a development agreement for 98 Franklin Street and a motion to audit the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission's (SFPUC) water and wastewater rate setting and oversight processes. Discussion Items Item 1: Development Agreement – 98 Franklin Street - Chair Preston, sponsor, presented the agreement, which involves a 400-foot building with a five-story campus for the French American International High School and 385 housing units. The developer will dedicate a parcel at 600 McAllister Street (already entitled for 196 affordable units) to the city at no cost to fulfill inclusionary housing requirements. Additionally, $1 million in fees will go to pre-development costs for Parcel K in Hayes Valley, a long-promised affordable housing project. Chair Preston characterized the package as a "rare quadruple win" for a new high school, affordable housing sites, investment in Parcel K, and good jobs. - Lee Lutensky, Deputy Director of Joint Development at OEWD, presented key terms: the agreement vests entitlements and requires land dedication before construction. - Public comment: No in-person or remote speakers offered comments. - Motion by Chair Preston to send item 1 to the full board with a positive recommendation as a committee report. Unanimous vote (3 ayes). Item 2: Audit of SFPUC Water and Wastewater Enterprises - Supervisor Safai, sponsor, requested a one-week continuance to allow further conversations with the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) and SFPUC leadership. He explained the impetus: concerns about water rate increases without adequate ratepayer participation, vacant commissioner seats, a large contract without performance standards since 2018, and a vacant assistant GM position. He cited an example from DPH where similar scrutiny saved costs. He emphasized the goal is to find efficiencies to reduce ratepayer costs. - Supervisor Chan expressed support, noting her own concerns about utility rate increases and ongoing studies at LAFCO. She supported audits to ensure good governance. - Chair Preston thanked Supervisor Safai and noted the need to coordinate with existing audits and capacity. - Public comment included several speakers: - David Hooper (Outer Mission) raised sewer flooding issues, stating the SFPUC had long denied the problem, leading to higher costs. He supported the audit to compel forthright engagement. - A caller (name not provided) criticized the SFPUC's debt growth from $0 in 2002 to $6 billion in 2022, alleged capital project cost overruns and pay-to-play contracting, and mentioned possible legal issues with Prop 218. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) supported the audit and advocated for a joint study session on the "design drought," claiming it contributes to ecological collapse and excessive costs. He said the SFPUC failed to deliberate on the design drought's prudence. - Molly (Sierra Club California) urged a full external audit, noting rate increases disproportionately impact low-income communities and the SFPUC's internal audits are insufficient. - Dave Warner expressed concern that rates could rise further due to declining demand and fixed costs, and that the SFPUC's risk discussions were inadequate. - Motion to continue item 2 to the July 20, 2023 GAO hearing. Unanimous vote (3 ayes). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (98 Franklin Street Development Agreement) was approved as a committee report and will appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on July 18, 2023. - Item 2 (Audit of SFPUC) was continued to the next Government Audit and Oversight Committee meeting on July 20, 2023.

PROCEDURAL 23% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 21% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 18% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 15%
955
JUL 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Hearing - July 13, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, July 13, 2023, at 1:15 PM UTC. The meeting covered a wide range of items including a consent calendar, commission matters, department announcements, general public comment, regular calendar items on adaptive reuse, inclusionary housing and fee reductions, development impact fee reforms, and two discretionary review items. The commission voted on all items, with most passing unanimously except for two items that passed 5-1. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (1240 Stanyan Street): Continued to October 5, 2023, unanimously (6-0). - Items 2-8 (Consent Calendar): Approved unanimously (6-0). Items included modifications to conditions of approval, conditional use authorizations for ILO units, vertical addition, automotive service use, formula retail, and a community recycling center. Public Comments & Testimony - Mauricio Chavez (Carpenters Local 22): Introduced himself and emphasized the importance of labor standards such as apprenticeship, health care, retirement, and living wages. - Georgia Shutish: Commented on a John King article about a Sunset District design contest and raised concerns about a specific project at 1647 Sanchez. - Anastasia Yobinopoulos (SF Tenant Union): Criticized the inclusionary housing formula as inadequate and urged the commission to balance developer incentives with affordable housing production. - Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition): Supported the commercial-to-residential adaptive reuse legislation, noting office-to-housing conversions as part of the solution. - Natalie Natoli (SF YIMBY): Expressed support for the adaptive reuse legislation. - Mark Babson (Emerald Fund): Supported the inclusionary housing fee reduction and urged inclusion of small projects (10-24 units). - John Avalos (CCHO): Acknowledged the need for changes but stressed the importance of parallel investment in affordable housing and equity considerations. - Lorraine Petty: Urged the commission to continue the fee reduction package indefinitely, arguing it would harm affordable housing production. - Several speakers (IATSE Local 16, Global Gourmet Catering, Knob Hill Association, neighbors): Spoke in support or opposition to the Masonic Center's request for additional events. - Discretionary Review Speakers: For 50 28th Street (DR requesters argued light loss; project sponsor supported by staff) and 900 Chenery Street (DR requester raised privacy concerns; project sponsor and staff supported the project). Discussion Items - Item 9 (Land Acknowledgement): Commissioner Ruiz delivered the acknowledgement. - Item 10 (Minutes): Approved unanimously. - Item 11 (Commission Comments): Commissioner Diamond raised concerns about property maintenance during extension periods; Director Hillis agreed to consider standard conditions. - Item 12 (Director's Announcements): Recognized planning interns and Claudia Flores for her 17 years of service on racial equity. - Item 13 (Review of Past Events): Dan Sider reported on Board of Supervisors actions including waterfront plan updates, 98 Franklin tower, Polk Street health services, and Supervisor Melgar's family housing opportunity SUD. - Item 14 (Commercial to Residential Adaptive Reuse): Staff presented four amendments; approved unanimously with modifications. - Item 15 (Inclusionary Housing and Fee Reduction): Extensive presentations from Ted Conrad, President Peskin, Ted Egan, and Kate Connor. The ordinance reduces inclusionary rates and impact fees for pipeline and interim projects. Staff made nine recommendations including extending reductions to small projects, standardizing deadlines, and simplifying the program. Commissioners debated feasibility, equity, and AMI concerns. Approved 5-1 (Commissioner Imperial opposed). - Item 16 (Development Impact Fee Indexing, Deferral, and Waivers): Dan Sider presented changes including annual indexing cap at 2%, fee lock-in at approval, fee deferral program, and exemptions for hospitality and industrial uses. Katie Tang proposed additional amendments to eliminate change-of-use impact fees. Approved 5-1 (Commissioner Imperial opposed). - Item 17 (4199 Mission Street – HOME-SF Authorization): Project to demolish gas station and build 40 residential units (12 affordable). Staff and project sponsor presented; approved unanimously. - Item 18 (1111 California Street – Masonic Center): Request to increase large live events from 79 to 91 (non-music). Strong public support and opposition from neighbors. The project sponsor committed to address concerns about trash, traffic, and noise. Approved unanimously. - Item 19 (50 28th Street – Discretionary Review): DR requesters argued loss of light; staff found no extraordinary circumstances. Commission denied DR and approved the project unanimously. - Item 20 (900 Chenery Street – Discretionary Review): DR requester cited privacy concerns; staff noted windows were designed to minimize impact. Commission denied DR and approved the project unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Continued to October 5, 2023 (6-0). - Consent Calendar: Approved (6-0). - Item 14: Approved with staff modifications (6-0). - Item 15: Approved with staff recommendations and delegation of authority (5-1; Imperial opposed). - Item 16: Approved with substitute amendments and small business changes (5-1; Imperial opposed). - Item 17: Approved with conditions (6-0). - Item 18: Approved with conditions (6-0). - Item 19: DR not taken; project approved (6-0). - Item 20: DR not taken; project approved (6-0). Next Steps - The commission will reconvene in August with noon start times. - The TAC will reconvene by January 2026 to reassess inclusionary rates. - The Board of Supervisors will consider the recommended legislation from items 14, 15, and 16. - The building inspection commission will vote on fee deferral code changes.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · HOUSING 13% · PROCEDURAL 8%
956
JUL 12, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Rescheduled Meeting - July 12, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Supervisors Asha Safai and Shaman Walton, convened a special meeting on July 12, 2023, at 6:15 PM to hear two final budget trailer legislation items. Supervisors Rafael Mandelman and Hillary Ronan were excused prior to the meeting. The committee reviewed previously amended items, heard public comment on one, and voted to forward both to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Gross Receipts Tax Rate Increase Postponement and Credits for Opening City Location): Eileen Bogan, speaking on behalf of the Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods, opposed the legislation unless amended. She urged the committee to delete the tax credits for opening a city location, particularly for the tech sector and AI, arguing that similar tax breaks for Twitter had not accounted for negative impacts such as rising income inequality, displacement, and gentrification. She expressed concern that the mayor's goal of making San Francisco the "AI capital of the world" would repeat past mistakes. - Item 2 (Funding Reallocation - Our City, Our Home Homelessness Gross Receipts Tax): No public comments were made. Discussion Items - Item 1 (File No. 230155): The committee discussed an ordinance to extend through December 31, 2024, the gross receipts tax rates in effect on January 1, 2022, for retail trade, certain services, manufacturing, food services, accommodations, arts, entertainment, and recreation. It also postpones to January 1, 2025, the imposition of higher rates previously set. Additionally, it provides a tax credit for businesses that open a physical location in specific downtown zip codes between January 1, 2023, and December 31, 2027, with a maximum credit of $1 million per tax year for up to three years. No new presentation was given; the committee had previously made substantive amendments narrowing the eligible zip codes. - Item 2 (File No. 230657): The committee considered an ordinance reallocating approximately $16.36 million in unappropriated earned interest revenues from the Our City, Our Home Fund (derived from the homelessness gross receipts tax) to fund services preventing homelessness. The amendments, championed by Supervisor Ronan, allow the use of accrued interest from the Prop C fund for transitional-age youth housing, family housing, and temporary shelter for adults. No presentation was given; the committee had already made substantive amendments. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee voted 3-0 (Supervisors Safai, Walton, Chan in favor) to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The motion was made by Chair Chan and seconded by Supervisor Safai. - Item 2: The committee voted 3-0 (Supervisors Safai, Walton, Chan in favor) to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The motion was made by Chair Chan and seconded by Supervisor Safai. - Both items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on July 18, 2023.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 57% · PROCEDURAL 35% · TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION 8%
957
JUL 12, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – July 12, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, July 12, 2023, at 1:45 PM. The meeting began with a warning about maintaining orderly conduct, then proceeded through officer recognition, extensive public comment on the July 8 Dolores Park Hillbomb incident, the Chief’s Report, updates on juvenile diversion and disciplinary review, approval of revised departmental general orders, and closed session. Commissioners emphasized that the Dolores Park matter would be agendized for the next meeting and called for an internal affairs investigation. Consent Calendar - The Commission unanimously (5–0) received and filed the Police Commission report of disciplinary action for Q2 2023, SFPD’s SB 1421 and SB16 monthly report, and DPA’s SB 1421 and SB16 monthly report. Public Comments & Testimony General Public Comment (Item 2) – Dolores Park Hillbomb Incident - Dozens of community members, parents, youth, educators, and advocates spoke for two minutes each, expressing outrage over the mass arrest of approximately 113 people (81 minors) during the unsanctioned Dolores Park Hillbomb event on Saturday, July 8, 2023. Speakers described police in riot gear, kettling, indiscriminate arrests, denial of bathroom breaks, zip‑tying of children, and prolonged detention without parental notification. Many called for an independent investigation, dropping of charges, defunding the police, and community‑led solutions. Several speakers demanded accountability from Chief Scott and the department, citing a pattern of excessive force against Black and Brown youth. Commissioner Benedicto noted the incident would be agendized for the next meeting. - Additional public comments on other items (Chief’s Report, DPA Report, Consent Calendar, etc.) included criticism of arrest metrics, requests for youth‑friendly complaint procedures, and concerns about the city’s budget priorities. Discussion Items Chief’s Report (Item 5) - Chief William Scott reported on crime trends: homicides up 8% (28 vs. 26 year‑to‑date), shooting victims up 12% (101 vs. 90), and total gun violence victims up 11% (120 vs. 108). Gun seizures decreased 13% (86 ghost guns vs. 99). Narcotics enforcement in the Tenderloin saw 3,519 gross grams of fentanyl seized in the past week and 72,036 grams year‑to‑date – a 200% increase – with 463 arrests for drug dealing. Chief Scott stated that despite increased enforcement, a visible difference on the streets remains the ultimate measure. He also reported two homicides and two non‑fatal shootings during the reporting period, and a significant narcotics bust on June 28. - Commissioners asked about foot patrols, overtime staffing, the LEAD program, and treatment referrals. Chief Scott noted that none of the more than 100 arrested drug sellers had accepted treatment. Commissioner Walker stressed the need for alternative infrastructure and case management. DPA Director’s Report (Item 6) - Chief of Staff Sarah Hawkins reported a 36‑case increase in DPA cases from last year (390 vs. 354) and 57 more pending cases. Only 19 cases are past the 270‑day marker. Four investigators have left, raising resource concerns for the upcoming Dolores Park investigation. The full misconduct audit draft has been sent to the Controller’s Office. Commission Reports (Item 7) - Commissioner Benedicto updated on the body‑worn camera working group and the principal policy analyst search. Commissioner Yanez reported progress on the investigative social media DGO and the juvenile diversion program. Commissioner Yi described a visit to a safe injection site in New York and suggested exploring similar options. Juvenile Diversion Program Update (Item 8) - Kara Lacy presented an update on moving from a post‑arrest to a pre‑arrest diversion model for youth. An internal working group has consulted with LAPD and Oakland. Meetings with CARC, the DA’s office, and other partners are ongoing. The revised DGO 7.01 is near completion. Commissioners emphasized the need for adequate case management and wraparound services. Disciplinary Review Board (DRB) Findings – Q4 2022 (Item 9) - The DRB identified trends: theft of department‑issued firearms, failure to thoroughly investigate, failure to activate body‑worn cameras, prolonged holding cell detentions, and issues with language access equipment. Seven recommendations were made, including updating property processing, auditing LEP equipment, and improving training. Chief Scott raised questions about defining “trends” and ensuring equity in discipline. Quarterly Activity and Data Report – Q4 2022 / Q1 2023 (Item 10) - Jason Cunningham presented the Racial Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA) 2023 annual report and a sneak peek of the SFPD’s first quarter 2023 data. Key findings: perceived Black individuals account for 24.7% of SFPD stops (vs. 15% statewide). Search rates and discovery rates vary by race, but SFPD’s 2021 use‑of‑force disparities were not statistically significant. Since 2016, per‑capita disparities in stops and force for Black and Hispanic/Latinx individuals have declined but persist. Arrests per capita for Black individuals have also declined. The report noted a decrease in total stops since 2019. Revised DGO 7.03 – Megan’s Law (Item 11) - Deputy Chief Vaswani and Captain Perdomo presented a revised departmental general order on dissemination of registered sex offender information. The DGO adopts California Penal Code sections 290 and 290.45, clarifies hierarchy for disclosure, and incorporates DPA recommendations. Unanimously approved for meet‑and‑confer. Revised DGO 11.13 – Behavioral Science Unit Referrals (Item 12) - The DGO on directed and recommended referrals to the SFPD Behavioral Science Unit was adopted unanimously (5–0). Commissioner Benedicto thanked the bargaining units for expeditious negotiation. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar and Minutes approved 5–0. - DGO 7.03 approved unanimously for meet‑and‑confer. - DGO 11.13 adopted unanimously. - Closed Session (Item 15) voted to enter closed session and subsequently voted not to disclose any items discussed. - Dolores Park Incident: Commissioners announced the matter will be agendized for the July 19, 2023 meeting. Commissioner Yanez called for an internal affairs investigation and encouraged community members to file complaints with DPA. Chief Scott stated he would present a detailed report including body‑worn camera footage at the next meeting. - The DPA director noted resource constraints for the investigation but affirmed commitment to thorough review. - The Juvenile Diversion Program will continue to be developed with partner agencies; the DGO 7.01 revision will be posted for public comment soon.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 35% · PUBLIC SAFETY 27% · PROCEDURAL 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11%
958
JUL 12, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Meeting on Seal Rock Inn, Health Plans, and Telecom Agreements - July 12, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 12, 2023, at 10:30 AM, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with members Supervisor Asha Safaí and Supervisor Joel Engardio (sitting in for Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman). The committee unanimously approved all 14 agenda items, including waiving fees for the historic Seal Rock Inn, adjusting the Budget and Legislative Analyst's contract, allocating SoMa stabilization funds, approving health plan rates for 2024, contracting for Microsoft products, designating advertising periodicals, authorizing emergency road repairs at Hetch Hetchy, and entering into wireless telecom license agreements. Call to Order Chair Chan called the meeting to order. The committee excused Vice Chair Mandelman. Clerk Brent Haliba reviewed public comment procedures. Item 1: Seal Rock Inn – Waiver of Annual Occupancy Assessment Fee - Discussion: Supervisor Chan introduced an ordinance to waive the annual public right-of-way occupancy fee for the Seal Rock Inn's major encroachment permit, which was originally granted in 1961. The fee was assessed only after the restaurant closed during the pandemic. The ordinance also removes the prohibition of commercialization of encroachments. Bobby and Barbara Elam, the family owners, spoke in support, noting the inn's 60-year history and the need to reopen the restaurant to support the community and local jobs. - Public Comments: Tom Kuhn (Friends of Sutro Heights Park) supported the waiver, highlighting the restaurant's role as a gathering place for park visitors and VA patients. Stefano Casolado, Gary Gardner, and Rob Howe all expressed support for the legacy business and the need for dining in the underserved area. - Outcome: Motion to forward to full board with positive recommendation. Unanimous (3 ayes). Item 2: Cost of Living Adjustment for Budget and Legislative Analyst Services - Discussion: Edward Deasis (Deputy Director of Administration for the Board) requested a 4.75% cost-of-living adjustment to the Harvey M. Rose contract, increasing the FY2023-2024 amount by $142,000 to $3,121,318. The adjustment matches the COLA granted to city employees and elected officials. The Controller certified the contract saves the city money. - Outcome: No public comment. Approved unanimously. Item 3: SoMa Community Stabilization Fund Expenditure - Discussion: Claudine Del Rosario (MOHCD) requested authorization to expend $800,000 from the SoMa Community Stabilization Fund, but amended the request to $600,000 because only Soma Pilipinas submitted a responsive proposal. The funds will support Filipino mental health services, capacity building, and a cultural gateway. The remaining $200,000 will be re-bid later. - Outcome: Amended to $600,000 and forwarded to full board. Unanimous. Item 4: Medi-Cal County Inmate Program Agreements - Discussion: Matthew Sir (Reimbursement Director, San Francisco Health Network) presented retroactive participation and administrative services agreements with the California Department of Health Care Services, not to exceed $24,443.73, for reimbursement of inpatient hospital services for Medi-Cal eligible inmates. The program offsets General Fund costs. Supervisor Safaí asked about alignment with CalAIM and Care Court; staff committed to follow up. - Outcome: Approved unanimously. Item 5: Health Service System Plans and Contribution Rates for Calendar Year 2024 - Discussion: Executive Director Abby Yant presented the proposed rates, reflecting an aggregate cost increase of 10.38% (city-only: 10.27%; medical only: 11.19%). Drivers include higher healthcare wages, increased mental health/substance use demand, and prescription drug costs. Mitigating factors include $14.7 million from a Sutter legal settlement and $1.9 million from rate stabilization. No plan design changes. Yant noted the national health cost trend. Supervisor Safaí requested a detailed breakdown of employee impacts by category. Chair Chan asked for a hearing in November on cost containment strategies and future projections. - Outcome: Approved unanimously with understanding that a follow-up hearing will be scheduled after open enrollment. Item 6: Microsoft Products Enterprise Agreement with Zones LLC - Discussion: Hao Sieu (Strategic Sourcing Manager, Department of Technology) presented a new citywide agreement with Zones LLC, not to exceed $55 million for three years (base $46 million plus $9 million for upgrades). The contract covers all Microsoft products except for SFMTA (which procures separately). DT negotiated free licenses for 28,000 enterprise mobility and security seats ($1.5M savings) and Teams conferencing ($2.3M savings), and upgraded O365 to M365 without cost increase. - Outcome: Approved unanimously. Items 7 & 8: Outreach Community Advertising and Official Newspaper Designations for FY2023–2024 - Discussion: Selaida Umala and Will Alderman (Office of Contract Administration) explained the solicitation process. For the official newspaper, only the San Francisco Examiner met qualifications (San Francisco Chronicle did not print locally). For outreach periodicals, recommendations included Bay Area Reporter (LGBTQ+ community), Wind Newspaper (Chinese community), El Tecolote (Mission neighborhood), and others. The African American and Hispanic communities received no responsive bidders. Supervisor Safaí moved to add El Reportero (Spanish language) and Sing Tao Daily (Chinese language) as neighborhood periodicals to serve underserved areas, including Excelsior, Outer Mission, and other neighborhoods. OCA also requested adding additional neighborhoods for Wind Newspaper (Richmond, Sunset, Portola, etc.). The committee discussed the challenge of outdated printing requirements (Proposition J) and the need for a future ballot measure to update the code. - Outcome: Motion to amend with additions passed unanimously. Items 7 and 8 forwarded to full board as amended. Item 9: Emergency Declaration for Repair of Hetch Hetchy Water and Power Roads - Discussion: Margaret Hennefer and Jeremy Spitz (SFPUC) presented the emergency declaration to repair road failures caused by unprecedented precipitation (over 20 inches in January and March 2023). The total cost is estimated at $20 million ($11.5M for an emergency contract with Sierra Mountain Construction, plus $8.5M for additional repairs and pavement). The SFPUC already used $8.4M in existing contracts, bringing total emergency spending to $28.4M. FEMA reimbursement is expected at 60–75%. Funding comes from ratepayer capital projects, which will be reprioritized. Minor clarifying amendments were offered by the city attorney. Supervisor Safaí requested a list of deferred projects. - Outcome: Amendments accepted; forwarded to full board unanimously. Items 10–14: Wireless Telecommunications Master License Agreements - Discussion: Jeremy Spitz (SFPUC) presented five master license agreements with Verizon, AT&T, Mobilitie, ExtNet, and Crown Castle for installing wireless antennas on city poles. The agreements comply with a 2018 FCC order limiting fees. The annual license revenue will decrease by $3.2 million from previous agreements, but one-time fees increase. SFMTA projects net negative income through FY2029; SFPUC is net positive. By federal law, the city must provide pole access. Chair Chan and Supervisor Safaí proposed an amendment directing that revenues be used for the SFPUC streetlight program and SFMTA transit operations. One public commenter (Eileen Bulk) opposed the agreements as corporate welfare. Staff agreed to the amendment. - Outcome: Amended and approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - All 14 agenda items were approved unanimously, many with amendments. - The committee requested a November hearing on health plan cost management. - The city will seek a future ballot measure to update printing requirements for official advertising. - SFPUC will provide a list of capital projects deferred due to emergency road repairs.

PUBLIC COMMENT 27% · PUBLIC HEALTH 14% · TECHNOLOGY AND INFRASTRUCTURE 10% · PUBLIC OUTREACH 9%
959
JUL 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - July 11, 2023

The San Francisco Port Commission convened on Tuesday, July 11, 2023, at 10:45 a.m. and adjourned at 5:02 p.m. Commissioners Kimberly Brandon (President), Gail Gilman, Ed Harrington, and Stephen Lee were present; Vice President Willie Adams was absent. The commission voted on executive session actions, approved a consent calendar, adopted the FY 2023-24 rental rate schedule, advanced an unsolicited Fisherman’s Wharf development proposal to the Board of Supervisors, and reviewed finalists for Pier 27 public art. Consent Calendar The commission unanimously adopted Resolutions 2332–2335: - Resolution 2332: Approved a cooperative agreement with BART for the repair and replacement of a fire water line and fire hydrant, and delegated authority for future similar agreements. - Resolution 2333: Approved a consent to sublease between Blue and Gold Fleet, L.P. and Worldwide Foods LLC (dba Cousins Maine Lobster) for approximately 1,824 square feet at Pier 41. - Resolution 2334: Authorized advertising for competitive bids for Construction Contract No. 2788, Hyde Street Harbor Repairs. - Resolution 2335: Authorized advertising for competitive bids for Construction Contract No. 2796, South Beach Marina Repairs. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comment was offered on items not listed on the agenda or on the consent calendar. - Extensive public comment was heard on the Fisherman’s Wharf proposal (Item 11B). - John Barnett, President of the Crab Boat Owners Association, said the proposal would use space currently rented to fishermen for gear storage and that Pier 45 is not vacant; he supported keeping Pier 45 for fishing and urged using currently empty buildings instead. - Sarah Bates (Crab Boat Owners Association) said Pier 45 is not vacant and there is a waiting list for storage; she called the storage spaces essential working space, not just storage, and warned that fishers might relocate to Half Moon Bay if displaced. - Larry Collins, a longtime port lessee and co-op member, said the fishing fleet needs storage, a working fuel dock, and ice machine; he argued that losing Pier 45 sheds would take the fleet’s future and that the proposal ignores immediate infrastructure needs. - Matt Wannis, a commercial fisherman, said without Pier 45 storage he would have to look at other harbors; he asked not to lose the storage space. - Sean Filanding, a commercial fisherman, emphasized that Sheds A and C are the heart of the fishing business and critical for staging crab gear; displacing them would be catastrophic and would remove the "fishermen" from Fisherman’s Wharf. - Michael Racino, a fourth-generation fisherman and charter boat owner, opposed eliminating or using the shed space, saying it would force fishermen out and hurt his business; he also cited safety and congestion concerns. - No other public comments were received. Discussion Items Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A) Elaine Forbes reported: - The Ferry Building will celebrate its 125th anniversary on July 13, with events including free ice cream, performances, a time capsule sealed until 2048, and afternoon happy hour. - The California State Transportation Agency (CalSTA) awarded the Port $21 million to modernize Pier 80 maritime terminals, rebuild Amador Street, and study a 100-vehicle electric truck fleet at Pier 96—the first state supply-chain funding the Port has received. - Cruise traffic hit a record: 110 cruise calls and 390,967 passengers, 100,000 more than the previous record. - The "Pier Party at the Wharf" summer concert series launches July 14, funded by a $2 million Sol Source Award. - All three bond rating agencies affirmed the Port’s rating; two upgraded the outlook from negative to stable (ratings: A, A, AA3). - The Board of Supervisors approved a $1 million supplemental appropriation for Mission Bay Parks, with a transfer event scheduled for July 20. - The proposed seawall bond includes a $400 million investment with amenities such as public walkways, swimming areas, and an Olympic-sized pool. Commissioners congratulated staff and asked questions about specific projects. FY 2023-24 Rental Rate Schedule (Item 11A) Kimberly Beale presented the proposed rate schedule, based on consultant analysis (Heiser Marston Economics and Maven Retail). Key points: - Office vacancy on Port property is 17.2%, vs. 16.8% (Class B) and 15.3% (Class C) citywide. - Industrial vacancy is 11.9%, vs. 5% citywide; other properties have 6% vacancy. - Of the 115 existing rates, 40% would remain unchanged, 10% would decrease, and the rest increase slightly. - Proposed incentives include: office/shed rent ramp-ups (e.g., 70/80/100% for 3-year leases), half-month free rent, termination rights, excess rent sharing (≥50% to Port), a maritime "triple threat" discount, and continued fee waivers/reductions for nonprofits and Port-sponsored events. - The nonprofit annual budget threshold for a 50% fee reduction would increase from $2 million to $3 million. Commissioner Lee requested more retail incentives; Commissioner Harrington asked for revenue impact data to be provided in writing; Commissioner Gilman questioned the half-month free rent rationale. The commission adopted Resolution 2336. Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized LLC Proposal (Item 11B) Michael Martin presented the unsolicited proposal from Lou Gerardo, Seth Himilian, and Chris McGarry, covering the triangle parking lot, Little Embarcadero, and Pier 45 Sheds A and C. The proposal includes a visitor center, winery/brewery/distillery, short-term rentals, waterfront walk, plaza, museum, food hall, and event space. Port staff conducted outreach (three March meetings) and issued an RFI on May 19; two responses were received by June 21: a follow-up from Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized and a letter from Dan Gerardo (Boudin Bakery) opposing the proposal and advocating for current needs over long-term development. Public comment (detailed above) was strongly opposed by the fishing community. Commissioners responded that this action only starts a two-year exclusive negotiation process, that the fishing industry remains a priority, and that community input will shape the final plan. They approved amendments to the resolution: - Adding two "whereas" clauses about the RFI results and the impracticality of a competitive process. - Deleting "now, therefore be it" from one clause. The commission adopted Resolution 2337, recommending the Board of Supervisors waive competitive bidding to allow exclusive negotiations. Pier 27 Cruise Terminal Plaza Art (Item 12A) Ryan Walsham and Marcus Davies presented three artist finalists selected by the San Francisco Arts Commission: Ana Teresa Fernandez, James Shen, and David Brooks. The project has a total budget of $330,000 (from a 2012 GO bond), with $136,000 for the artist contract and $83,700 for site work. The RFQ drew 144 applications (91 California, 58 Bay Area, 34 San Francisco, 57 BIPOC). Finalists will receive $2,000 each to develop proposals, with public comment and a final panel review. The commission received this as information; no vote was taken. Commissioners praised the outreach and asked about budget constraints and site-specific design. New Business - Commissioner Gilman requested a future briefing from staff and Hudson Pacific on plans to refresh the Ferry Building. Key Outcomes - Approved appointment of Nate Cruz as CFO (closed session). - Adopted consent resolutions 2332–2335. - Adopted Resolution 2336 (FY 2023-24 rates and incentives). - Adopted Resolution 2337 (Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized proposal) with amendments, forwarding to the Board of Supervisors. - Received informational presentation on Pier 27 art finalists. - Directed staff to schedule a Ferry Building briefing.

PROCEDURAL 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · FISHERIES MANAGEMENT 14% · LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 12%
960
JUL 10, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Hearing on Appointments and Sentencing Commission – July 10, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on Monday, July 10, 2023, at approximately 11:00 AM PDT, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, joined by Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai. The packed agenda included an ordinance to extend the sunset date of the San Francisco Sentencing Commission, and numerous mayoral and presidential appointments to the Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) Board, the Sanitation and Streets Commission (item withdrawn), the Building Inspection Commission (BIC), and the Civil Service Commission. Public comment was taken on each item. Public Comments & Testimony - Sentencing Commission (Item 1): Three members of the public spoke in support of extending the sunset date. Speakers included Steve Adami (former director of reentry division, adult probation), Destiny Pletch, and Sheila McCarthy. No opposition was voiced. - Lydia So appointment (Item 2): Speakers included Forrest (Stop Asian Hate activist) in support, Slo Kelly (Coalition on Homelessness) urging awareness of impacts on unhoused people living in vehicles, Barry Toronto (San Francisco Taxi Workers Alliance) urging questions about taxi industry, David Pilpel urging independence from MTA management, and Mike Chen (former SFMTA CAC chair) and Kevin Ortiz (SF Latinx Democratic Club president) in support. - BIC Mayoral Appointments (Items 4-6): Several speakers opposed the appointments of Raquel Bito and Bianca Newman due to their alleged lack of engagement with SRO families and support for budget cuts to the SRO Collaborative and code enforcement. Speakers included Juan Alejandro Garcia (SRO Families United Collaborative), Sonica Mahan (District 5 resident, SRO Families United Collaborative), and Becky Holland (Causa Justa). No public comment supported these two nominees. - BIC Presidential Appointments (Items 7-9): Speakers supported all three nominees. Wendy Aragon (Urban Habitat), Molly Goldberg (San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition), and attorneys Jason Hain and Jacqueline Patton (Eviction Defense Collaborative) praised the qualifications of Elizabeth Alexander-Tutt, Evita Chavez, and Kevin Williams. - Civil Service Commission Reappointments (Items 10-11): One speaker, David Pilpel, strongly supported both Kate Favetti and Jacqueline Minor, praising their expertise. Discussion Items Item 1 – Sentencing Commission Sunset Extension: Edward McCaffrey, Chief of Policy and Communications for the District Attorney’s Office, presented the ordinance to extend the commission’s sunset from June 30, 2023 to June 30, 2026. He described the commission’s role in developing data-informed sentencing strategies and cited recent work on jail population analysis, CalAIM preparation, and a MacArthur Foundation grant ($6 million). Allie Riker from the Sheriff’s Office expressed support. Supervisor Safai questioned the commission’s tangible policy achievements over 10 years; McCaffrey acknowledged the need for further policy work. The item was moved to the full board with a positive recommendation unanimously. Item 2 – Lydia So Appointment to SFMTA Board: Supervisor Chan introduced So, praising her expertise as an architect and her ties to the AAPI community. So emphasized her focus on public safety, community outreach, and bridging diverse communities. Supervisor Safai urged her to champion small business and neighborhood voices. Public comment included concerns about taxi industry and homeless residents. The committee voted unanimously to approve. Item 3 – Vincent Yuen Appointment (Withdrawn): The mayor’s nomination was withdrawn. The item was tabled unanimously after no public comment. Items 4-6 – BIC Mayoral Appointments (Newman, Sommer, Bito): Bianca Newman, Angie Sommer (appearing online, nine months pregnant), and Raquel Bito (current Commission President) each described their backgrounds. Bito highlighted her work on permit streamlining and the housing element. Supervisor Safai pressed Bito on the BIC’s budget proposal that eliminated the SRO Collaborative and code enforcement funding; Bito stated she opposed raising fees but supported the SRO program. Public comment opposed Newman and Bito, citing ignored invitations to visit SROs. The committee approved Newman and Sommer (2-1, Walton dissenting on Sommer? Actually Walton voted no on the motion for Newman and Sommer? Let's check: On the motion to approve Newman and Sommer, Walton voted no. So 2-1. Then on motion to reject Bito, Walton and Safai voted aye, Dorsey no – 2-1. Items 7-9 – BIC Presidential Appointments (Alexander-Tutt, Chavez, Williams): Nominees spoke: Elizabeth Alexander-Tutt highlighted tenant rights and housing code enforcement; Evita Chavez emphasized equity and policy experience; Kevin Williams, an eviction defense attorney, stressed improving housing habitability. All three were supported by public comment. The committee voted unanimously to approve. Items 10-11 – Civil Service Commission Reappointments (Favetti, Minor): Kate Favetti and Jacqueline Minor discussed efforts to address hiring delays, referencing a recent civil grand jury report and a listening campaign with HR departments. Supervisor Safai raised concerns about vacancies in 911 dispatch, fire, nursing, and public works, and asked about the mayor’s salary. Minor and Favetti explained the commission’s role in setting elected official salaries and ongoing reforms. The committee approved both reappointments unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1 – Sentencing Commission: Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2 – Lydia So Appointment: Motion to approve (striking “reject”) passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 3 – Vincent Yuen Appointment: Motion to table passed unanimously (3-0). - Items 4 & 5 – Bianca Newman and Angie Sommer Appointments: Motion to approve (striking “reject”) passed 2-1 (Vice Chair Walton opposed). - Item 6 – Raquel Bito Appointment: Motion to reject (striking “approve”) passed 2-1 (Chair Dorsey opposed). - Items 7, 8, 9 – Alexander-Tutt, Chavez, Williams Appointments: Motion to approve (striking “reject”) passed unanimously (3-0). - Items 10 & 11 – Favetti and Minor Reappointments: Motion to approve (striking “reject”) passed unanimously (3-0).

BUILDING INSPECTION 20% · PROCEDURAL 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · JUSTICE AND CORRECTIONS 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com