Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 961–970 ENTRIES
961
JUL 10, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - July 10, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 10, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Myrna Melgar, along with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin (standing in for Supervisor Melgar due to her chair role). The Committee Clerk was Erica Major. The meeting covered eight agenda items, including updates to the Port Waterfront Plan, a major housing development at 98 Franklin Street, building permit streamlining, and a new Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District ("Domicity") for the West Side. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 1 (Park Code), a speaker expressed confusion about the park code application and ramp slopes at parks; another speaker, David Pilpel, supported the continuance. - On Items 2-4 (Port Waterfront Plan), a caller raised concerns about Navy contamination, unmitigated ammonia spills, coal tar, and sea level rise at Pier 70 and the waterfront. - On Item 5 (98 Franklin Street), callers from the Housing Action Coalition and a community member (Shirley Thaum Box) spoke in support, citing community ties of Related California CEO Bill Witt. - On Item 6 (Polk/Haight NCD), Chris Shulman from the Lower Polk CBD supported the ordinance; a speaker expressed concern about discrimination against Middle Eastern tobacco shop owners. - On Item 7 (Site Permit Streamlining), numerous builders, architects, and trades representatives spoke in support, describing years-long delays (e.g., two-year average wait for a building permit, six-year project timeline). Some requested further reforms such as third-party review. A building trade union representative supported the legislation as an important step. - On Item 8 (Family Housing SUD), extensive public comment (both support and opposition) included: Eric Brooks (Our City SF) opposed the legislation, citing lack of outreach and risk of speculative investment; Lori Lederman (Sunset resident) expressed concerns about condo conversions, removal of demolition controls, and elimination of notifications; Dennis Moscovi questioned the need given vacancies; Sally Tobin (West Side) warned of economic bias from shortened input periods; Teresa Flanders (North Beach Tenants Committee) worried about condo conversions displacing tenants; George Clothing (friend of architect Eugene Liu) suggested longer occupancy requirements and stronger CEQA notices; Tanya Rendell (Louis Harrison Foundation) called for 100% affordable housing and protested removal of notices; Howard Waugh (SF Tomorrow) urged robust public process; Robert Falkman supported the legislation to meet state housing goals; others requested more time to review amendments. Discussion Items Item 1: Park Code - Authorization for Recreation and Park Commission (Continued) - Supervisor Melgar moved to continue this item to the call of the chair due to outstanding questions from the community (e.g., relationship between Hummingbird Farm and RPD). The motion passed unanimously (3-0). Items 2-4: Port Waterfront Plan Update (Zoning Map, General Plan, Planning Code Amendments) - Matt Snyder (Planning) presented the three ordinances: updates to the Northeastern and Central Waterfront Area Plans and the Recreation and Open Space Element; amendments to Planning Code Section 240 (waterfront special use districts) creating a new SUD 4 for southern waterfront properties; and a zoning map correction for a parcel at Mission Rock to correct an inadvertent rezoning. The amendments include administrative cleanups and removal of a conditional use requirement for unscreened uses. - No questions from committee. Public comment: one caller raised environmental concerns about past Navy use and sea level rise. The committee voted to approve all three items with a positive recommendation (3-0), after confirming an amendment to the EIR addendum recitals. Item 5: 98 Franklin Street / Van Ness & Market Residential SUD - Supervisor Preston, the sponsor, described the package as a "quadruple win" that would unstick the 98 Franklin Street project (38-story mixed-use with a new high school and 385 units), enable a land dedication for 100% affordable housing at 600 McAllister Street (up to 196 units, increased from 168 at a previous site), and jumpstart affordable housing at Parcel K in Hayes Valley. - Christy Alexander (Planning) summarized the project: 400-foot tower, five-story podium for the French American International High School, ground-floor retail, 385 units (275 studio/one-bedroom, 72 two-bedroom, 38 three-bedroom). Inclusionary obligation to be met via land dedication for at least 135 affordable units. Planning Commission unanimously recommended approval. - Public comments: Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition) and Shirley Thaum Box (community member) supported. - Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation passed unanimously (3-0). Item 6: Polk Street and Haight Street Neighborhood Commercial District Amendments - President Peskin introduced: permits health services on ground floor in specified Polk Street NCD areas (to fill vacancies), and makes permanent tobacco paraphernalia restrictions in both Polk and Haight NCDs (previously set to expire). Supervisor Preston added himself as co-sponsor and noted future separate legislation for other neighborhoods. - Public comment: Chris Shulman (Lower Polk CBD) supported; one speaker expressed concern about discrimination against Middle Eastern tobacco sellers. - Motion to send as a committee report for hearing on July 11 passed unanimously (3-0). Item 7: Building Code - Streamlining Site Permit Review - Supervisor Safai presented: the ordinance would define and limit the scope of site permit review to what is in the code (to prevent scope creep), require simultaneous interdepartmental review, and codify requirements. He noted the Building Inspection Commission (BIC) recommended approval with modifications, including requiring concurrent review with planning entitlements, removing the codified list of site permit contents (since DBI already achieved its intent via director's memo), adding fire department access, and incorporating slope protection. Chair Melgar offered a friendly amendment to apply simultaneous review only to electronically submitted applications (currently 70% of site permits). - DBI's Carl Nacita requested a one-week continuance to address the amendments and BIC's concerns. - Public comments: Overwhelmingly supportive from builders, architects, and trade unions (e.g., Gary G. Architects, Sean Keegan, Cyrus Sanadet, Rudy Gonzalez of Building Trades Council) citing extreme delays (e.g., 21 months for site permit, two-year wait for building permits). Some advocated for further reforms. - The committee adopted the amendments by supervisor Safai (slope protection) and Melgar (electronic submissions), then continued the item for one week (to July 17) by unanimous vote (3-0). Item 8: Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District (Domicity) - Supervisor Melgar presented: this legislation creates a new SUD for RH1 zones in high-resource neighborhoods (per HCD opportunity map), allowing up to four units on a single lot or up to 12 units on merged lots, with a minimum of two- and three-bedroom units. It includes tenant protections (five-year look-back for no-fault evictions and buyouts, deed restrictions for rent control on new units, conditional use for two-unit buildings). Read multiple amendments: density exceptions (up to 1 unit per 1,000 sq ft), unit mix requirements, tenant displacement protections (mirroring SB 330), and clerical clarifications. She also agreed to an amendment from Supervisor Mandelman to respect the existing Central Neighborhood SUD (monster home controls). - Supervisor Engardio proposed additional amendments for corner lot projects: up to 65 feet height, 25% rear yard (min 15 ft), 100 sq ft private or 133 sq ft common open space, no group housing, and no rear yard units. These would be added to a duplicate file that would be re-referred to the Planning Commission. - President Peskin offered amendments to protect Article 10 historic districts and National Register properties from demolition under the ordinance. - Supervisor Preston noted that while he supports increasing density, the legislation primarily creates market-rate units and should not be conflated with affordable housing production; he urged continued focus on truly affordable housing. - Public comment: mixed; many speakers appreciated the anti-displacement amendments but expressed concern about reduced public notification, environmental review waivers, potential for speculation, and lack of community outreach. Some requested more time (longer than one week). - The committee adopted the amendments by Melgar and Peskin, then continued the original file to next week (July 17) by unanimous vote. The committee also created a duplicate file incorporating Engardio's corner lot amendments and Melgar's lot merger language (to prevent through-lots from street to street), and continued that duplicate to the call of the chair with a planned re-referral to the Planning Commission. Both motions passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Continued to call of chair (3-0). - Items 2-4 (Port Waterfront Plan): Approved with positive recommendation to full board (3-0). - Item 5 (98 Franklin Street): Approved with positive recommendation to full board (3-0). - Item 6 (Polk/Haight NCD): Approved as a committee report for July 11 (3-0). - Item 7 (Site Permit Streamlining): Amended to include slope protection and electronic submission provisions, then continued one week to July 17 (3-0). - Item 8 (Family Housing SUD): Original file amended with Melgar and Peskin amendments and continued one week to July 17 (3-0). Duplicate file created with Engardio and Melgar corner lot/lot merger amendments and continued to call of chair for re-referral to the Planning Commission (3-0).

PUBLIC COMMENT 24% · LAND USE 19% · HOUSING 16% · PERMIT PROCESS 11%
962
JUN 29, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - June 29, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, June 29, 2023, at 1:15 PM. The meeting was chaired by President Tanner, with Vice President Moore and Commissioners Braun, Diamond, Imperial, and Coppel present. Commissioner Ruiz was absent. The commission considered a range of items, including continuances, consent calendar items, a major ordinance on constraints reduction, several conditional use authorizations for cannabis retail and housing projects, and discretionary reviews. Consent Calendar - Items 4 (580 Minna Street – State Density Bonus findings) and 5 (11 Franklin Street, Unit 304 – ILO conditional use) were approved unanimously (6-0) on consent. - Item 3 (51 Prosper Street – unit merger) was pulled off consent and later continued to September 7, 2023. - Items 6 and 7 were continued (indefinitely and to September 28, 2023, respectively). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Several speakers addressed the commission on topics including illegal subdivisions, the proposed constraints reduction ordinance, tenant protections, and the need for affordable housing. Jerry Dratler criticized weak internal controls on illegal construction. Eric Brooks and others opposed the constraints reduction ordinance, arguing it would harm the environment and displace tenants. Lawrence Hollins advocated for converting abandoned buildings into SROs for homeless individuals. A speaker from the San Francisco Land Use Coalition highlighted that demolition data shows losses of five-plus unit buildings, not just single-family homes. - Item 13 (Constraints Reduction): Over two dozen public speakers commented. Many supported the legislation, citing the need to streamline approvals to meet state housing mandates and to allow families, teachers, and seniors to remain in the city. Opponents, including representatives from the San Francisco Tenants Union, Rep SF, and the Anti-Displacement Coalition, argued the ordinance would accelerate displacement, eliminate public notice, and fail to produce genuinely affordable housing. Some speakers questioned the accuracy of vacancy statistics and highlighted the risk to rent-controlled units. - Item 18 (1541 Polk Street – Cannabis Retail): Several local cannabis equity operators opposed the project, alleging the applicant understated its number of stores and would undercut local businesses. The community meeting had strong opposition. The project sponsor stated they were a small, ambitious company and that they would be a good neighbor. - Item 19 (1 Sansome Street – DR for atrium events): Speakers from BOMA, San Francisco Travel, and others supported the proposal to allow private events in the atrium to revitalize downtown. One letter opposed, citing concerns that the space had been rendered more like a private lobby. - Item 20 (939 Lombard Street – DR for new dwelling): Parents from Yick Wo Elementary School and neighbors opposed the project, raising concerns about shadow on the schoolyard, construction noise, soil contamination, and traffic impacts. The DR requesters argued the building would block light and air and was out of character. The project sponsor noted the site is code-compliant and the building has been modified to reduce impacts. - Item 21 (372 Dolores Street – ADU): No public comments. Discussion Items - Item 13 – Constraints Reduction Ordinance (Housing Production Ordinance): The commission heard a detailed presentation from staff, the Mayor's Office, and Supervisor Engardio. The ordinance (2023-003676 PCA/MAP) proposes numerous changes to streamline housing approvals, modify zoning standards (e.g., front setbacks reduced to 10 feet, rear yard standardizations), remove conditional use requirements for certain projects, and amend demolition controls. Commissioners debated amendments: Commissioner Diamond proposed a modification to require a 15-foot front setback when 75% of block faces and adjacent neighbors have 15-foot setbacks, which was accepted. The commission also added a condition to Section 317 to include a five-year history of tenant buyouts. After discussion, the ordinance passed 4-2, with Commissioners Imperial and Moore voting against. Commissioner Imperial expressed concerns about impacts on priority equity geographies and the elimination of public process; Commissioner Moore cited insufficient focus on affordable housing and community participation. - Item 14 – 952 and 960 Howard Street (Informational Presentation): The project proposes a nine-story mass timber addition above an existing three-story building, with 113 units (16 affordable). Commissioners commented positively, but Commissioner Moore raised concerns about vinyl windows and mass timber construction. No action taken. - Items 16A/B – 395 Third Street (Large Project Authorization and Variance): The project is a 35-story, 524-unit mixed-use building with 84 affordable units. Commissioners supported the design but debated the dwelling unit mix variance. The applicant committed to providing 40% two-bedroom units in the affordable portion. The commission approved the large project authorization with conditions, including a finding that 25% two-bedroom mix was acceptable for market-rate units, subject to the variance outcome. Vote: unanimous. - Item 17 – 372 Ritch Street (Cannabis Retail): Approved unanimously. - Item 18 – 1541 Polk Street (Cannabis Retail): Heard strong opposition from existing operators. The commission voted to continue to September 14, 2023, to allow further review of formula retail concerns and applicant transparency. - Item 19 – 1 Sansome Street (Mandatory DR for atrium events): The commission approved the modification allowing up to 12 full-day and 24 partial closures per year for private events, with biannual reporting. Commissioners encouraged the sponsor to return if more days were needed and emphasized maintaining a welcoming public space. Vote: unanimous. - Item 20 – 939 Lombard Street (DR for new single-family dwelling): After hearing public testimony, the commission voted 4-2 (Commissioners Imperial and Moore against) not to take DR and approve the project, finding no extraordinary circumstances. - Item 21 – 372 Dolores Street (DR for ADU): No opposition present; commission voted 6-0 not to take DR and approve. Key Outcomes - Item 13 – Constraints Reduction Ordinance: Approved with amendments (front setback change and tenant buyout inclusion) on a 4-2 vote (Commissioners Imperial and Moore dissenting) to recommend to the Board of Supervisors. - Items 4 and 5 (Consent Calendar): Approved 6-0. - Item 3 (51 Prosper Street): Continued to September 7, 2023. - Items 16A/B (395 Third Street): Large Project Authorization approved 6-0 with conditions on affordable unit mix and findings. - Item 17 (372 Ritch Street): Approved 6-0. - Item 18 (1541 Polk Street): Continued to September 14, 2023, for further review. - Item 19 (1 Sansome Street): DR approved 6-0, authorizing conditions for private events. - Item 20 (939 Lombard Street): DR not taken; project approved 4-2. - Item 21 (372 Dolores Street): DR not taken; project approved 6-0.

HOUSING 25% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 11% · LAND USE 9% · CANNABIS REGULATION 9%
963
JUN 28, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Finalizes FY 2023-2025 Budget on June 28, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman, Supervisor Hillary Ronen, Supervisor Shamann Walton, and Supervisor Ahsha Safaí, convened a series of recessed meetings on June 28, 2023, to finalize the Fiscal Years 2023-2024 and 2024-2025 budget and related trailing legislation. The meeting spanned from 6:15 PM through late evening, with multiple recesses for negotiations. The committee successfully approved a $60 million reallocation from the Our City, Our Home fund, passed several business fee waivers, and forwarded a balanced budget package to the full Board of Supervisors. Discussion Items - Our City, Our Home Fund Reallocation (Items 6 & 7): Supervisor Ronen introduced amendments to preserve $60 million originally diverted from TAY and family homelessness for adult homeless services, instead keeping the funds for youth and family prevention. The $60 million will remain for TAY/family housing, and $4 million in accrued interest from Prop C lawsuits will fund other priorities from the Mayor's budget. The amendments were substantive, requiring continuation to the next meeting; Item 7 (expenditure plan) was sent to the full board with positive recommendation. - Small Business Fee Waiver (Item 5): Supervisor Ronen amended the ordinance to limit the first-year permit/license/business registration fee waiver to one year (FY 2023-2024) instead of multiple years, aligning with the Mayor's funded budget. The amendment was adopted, and the item was forwarded to the full board. - Curbside Shared Spaces Permit Fee Waiver (Item 3): Supervisor Safaí proposed an amendment to reduce the fee waiver period from two years to one year (ending June 30, 2024). The amendment passed, and the item was sent to the full board. - Gross Receipts Tax Rate Postponement and Credit (Item 10): Chair Chan proposed amendments to limit the tax credit to downtown zip codes, exclude home-based businesses, and require the credit be taken on original returns. The substantive amendments were adopted, and the item was continued to the July 12 committee meeting. - Early Care and Education Commercial Rents Tax Sublessor Deduction (Item 11): Chair Chan moved to table the item; the motion passed. - Building Code Fee Increase (Item 4): The committee discussed a 15% increase in Department of Building Inspection fees, temporary until a comprehensive fee study is completed in fall 2023. The item was forwarded to the full board without amendment. - Ambassador Programs (Items 8 & 9): Grant amendments for the Downtown Welcome Ambassador Program ($21.4 million total) and Mid-Market/Tenderloin Safety Program ($61.09 million total) were approved and sent to the full board. - Early Care and Education Baseline Funding (Item 12): Amended on June 26, the ordinance was sent to the full board with positive recommendation. - Final Budget Approval (Items 1 & 2): After multiple recesses, the committee reached an agreement with the Mayor's office. Chair Chan made a motion to adopt the spending plan, authorize the Controller to make adjustments, and forward the budget and salary ordinances to the July 11 full board meeting with a positive recommendation. The motion passed 5-0. Key Outcomes - Budget Approved: The committee forwarded the FY 2023-2024 and FY 2024-2025 budget to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (5-0). - Prop C Reallocation Preserved: $60 million in Our City, Our Home funds was preserved for TAY and family homelessness prevention, with $4 million in accrued interest redirected to other priorities. - Small Business Relief: First-year fee waiver program reduced to one year and forwarded; shared spaces permit fee waiver also reduced to one year. - Downtown Business Tax Incentive: Gross receipts tax credit limited to downtown zip codes, continued for further consideration. - Building Code Fees: Temporary 15% fee increase for DBI forwarded. - Ambassador Grants: Both grant amendments approved. - Early Care and Education: Sublessor deduction tabled; baseline funding ordinance forwarded. - All votes were 5-0 unless otherwise noted.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 10% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 9% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 8% · ENTERTAINMENT POLICY 7%
964
JUN 28, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting - June 28, 2023: Reparations Office Funding

On June 28, 2023, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a special rescheduled meeting to consider an ordinance appropriating $50,000,000 from the General Reserve to the Human Rights Commission to establish the Office of Reparations and implement approved recommendations for fiscal year 2022-2023. The committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - Bobby Jones (native San Franciscan, financial district worker) expressed strong support for the task force, stating that racism in housing persists, and urged the committee to move forward. He noted that money is not an issue and called for unity with other communities. - Leah McGeever submitted a written comment and read an account from a formerly enslaved person, arguing that the magnitude of reparations requires dedicated staff. She stated that non-Black people should not vote on the issue. - Beverly Upton (Domestic Violence Consortium) expressed full support, noting that Black families have suffered from family violence, loss of homes, land, and culture, and looked forward to working with leaders. - Charles James Riggs expressed gratitude for Proposition 13 (no further context provided). - Bill Tamayo (native San Franciscan, attorney, former Asian Law Caucus member) supported the office, citing his work overturning Fred Korematsu's conviction and the 1988 Civil Rights Act granting reparations to Japanese Americans. He questioned why San Francisco is taking so long to act. - Jennifer Friedenbach (Coalition on Homelessness) registered support, highlighting the impact of slavery and institutional racism on homelessness, evictions, gentrification, and disinvestment. She expressed deep appreciation for Supervisor Walton. Discussion Items - Item 230313: Ordinance appropriating $50,000,000 from the General Reserve to the Human Rights Commission to establish the Office of Reparations and implement approved recommendations. The committee heard opening remarks from Supervisor Walton, who emphasized the Board's unanimous March 14, 2023 resolution accepting the Reparations Task Force report and committing to reparations. He stated the funding would fully staff the office, provide administrative support, research eligible individuals, and fund approved recommendations. He moved to continue the item to the call of the chair. - Supervisor Chan praised Supervisor Walton's leadership, noting the emotional and intellectual burden of being the only Black elected member on the Board. She seconded the motion. - Supervisor Safai expressed appreciation for Supervisor Walton's work, acknowledged the discomfort of conversations about institutional racism, and noted the real impact of historical injustices. He said he was happy to be part of the effort. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3 ayes: Chan, Safai, Walton; Vice Chairman Mandelman and Member Ronen absent) to continue the ordinance to the call of the chair. The motion passed without further action on the appropriation itself. - The meeting was adjourned, with the committee reconvening later that day for a recessed budget meeting.

REPARATIONS 59% · PUBLIC COMMENT 35% · PROCEDURAL 6%
965
JUN 27, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco PUC Meeting - June 27, 2023: Alternative Water Supply, Bonds, and Wildfire Mitigation

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on June 27, 2023, at 9:45 AM to discuss a wide range of items including the Alternative Water Supply Plan, Hetch Hetchy Capital Improvement Program, wildfire mitigation, bond authorizations up to $450 million for the Water Enterprise, and a resolution on labor and environmental standards for the California Community Power Agency. The meeting included extensive public comment, particularly on water supply planning and the design drought. Consent Calendar - Approved items 5a–5e (contract awards and work acceptance) unanimously (4-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4A (Alternative Water Supply Plan): Numerous callers and in-person speakers criticized the SFPUC's use of an 8.5-year design drought, calling it overly conservative and a "manufactured crisis." Speakers urged reducing the design drought by one year and using more realistic demand projections to avoid unnecessary rate hikes and environmental harm. Several speakers noted that the SFPUC has ample storage (e.g., four years' worth) and that demand projections are inflated. Peter Drekmeier (Tuolumne River Trust) and others called for a sensitivity analysis. Bosca (represented by Tom Francis) expressed support for the plan and commitment to collaboration. - Item 4B & 4C (Hetch Hetchy CIP & Wastewater): No public comments. - Item 4D (GM Report): No public comments. - Item 10 (Transparency Resolution): Several speakers, including Moises Garcia (CAC Chair) and Alex Lantsberg (Restore Hetch Hetchy), praised the commission for adopting CAC recommendations and for its collaborative approach. Peter Drekmeier urged a similar resolution for the water enterprise. - General Public Comment: Speakers raised concerns about public access at Hetch Hetchy, the civil grand jury report on the water system, and urged financial oversight improvements. Discussion Items - Alternative Water Supply Plan (Item 4A): Manisha Kothari presented the plan, noting an average gap of 92 million gallons per day (MGD) between supply and projected 2045 demands under a dry-year scenario, with a maximum obligation gap of 122 MGD. Six regional projects could fill 22–48 MGD. The plan recommends moving forward with Los Vaqueros Reservoir Expansion and Daly City Recycled Water Expansion (approx. 4.6 MGD combined) and adding staff. Commissioners Stacy, Paulson, and President Ajami questioned demand projections, on-site reuse potential, and affordability. President Ajami stressed the need to consider demand-side strategies and avoid overbuilding. - Wildfire Mitigation Plan (Item 6): Staff presented the 2023 comprehensive revision and independent evaluator report. The plan includes a new Techno Silva wildfire analyst tool (first public utility to use it). The independent evaluator found the plan fully comprehensive and recommended approval. Commissioners Stacy and Ajami emphasized the need to adopt the independent evaluator's recommendations and to build in-house model capability. The item was approved 4-0 with an amendment to direct implementation of those recommendations. - Bond Authorizations (Items 7, 8, 9): Staff presented three related items: approval of commercial paper dealer agreements, issuance of up to $450 million in Water Revenue Bonds (Series A & B), and issuance of refunding bonds (Series C & D) to take advantage of tax-exempt market conditions. The refunding will use a tender process to repurchase existing bonds at a discount, potentially saving 8% or more. The commission approved all three items (each 4-0). - Resolution on Transparency and Labor Standards (Item 10): The commission adopted a resolution supporting transparency, environmental accountability, and labor standards for the California Community Power Agency (CC Power). The resolution builds on CAC recommendations and commits staff to advocate for comparable commitments in CC Power procurements. Approved 4-0. - CleanPowerSF CC Power Cost Share (Item 11): Approved an annual payment of up to $100,000 (with 5% escalator) for 25 years to cover CleanPowerSF's share of CC Power's general and administrative costs. Commissioner Stacy was absent; approved 3-0. - Redwood City & Cal Water Contract Amendment (Item 12): Approved minor map corrections and transfer of seven residences from Redwood City to Cal Water service area. Commissioner Stacy absent; approved 3-0. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar approved 4-0. - Alternative Water Supply Plan received as information; final plan to be released publicly later that week, with a return to commission in fall for further action. - Wildfire Mitigation Plan adopted 4-0 with amendment to implement independent evaluator recommendations. - Commercial paper dealer agreements (Item 7) approved 4-0. - Water Revenue Bond issuances (Items 8 & 9) approved 4-0 for up to $450 million in new money and refunding bonds; pricing expected in mid-July. - Transparency/labor standards resolution (Item 10) adopted 4-0. - CleanPowerSF CC Power fees (Item 11) approved 3-0 (Commissioner Stacy absent). - Redwood City/Cal Water contract amendment (Item 12) approved 3-0. - Commissioner-initiated items: none; next meetings (July 11 and 25) canceled, next meeting in August.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 33% · FINANCE AND DEBT 18% · WILDFIRE MITIGATION 16% · ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 10%
966
JUN 26, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Recessed Meeting - June 26, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, held a recessed meeting on June 26, 2023, to take public comment on the City's Annual Budget for FYs 2023-2024 and 2024-2025, including the Budget and Appropriation Ordinance (File 230644), the Annual Salary Ordinance (File 230645), and related budget items. Committee members present were Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisors Ahsha Safai, Hillary Ronen, and Shamann Walton; President Aaron Peskin joined later in the meeting. The committee heard hours of public testimony from residents, service providers, and advocates, and then voted to continue the agenda to Wednesday, June 28, 2023. Public Comments & Testimony - Women's services: Multiple speakers from Community Forward SF, the San Francisco Women's Housing Coalition, and allied organizations urged the committee to invest $2.2 million in women's services. They cited 2,600 women turned away from victim services and shelter each year, 3,000 unhoused women/transgender/gender nonconforming individuals on the streets each night, 99 women's shelter beds, 157 housing units for female-identified clients, and 80% of unhoused women reporting severe trauma. They argued that low-barrier services should not mean low-quality care and asked the city to make ending homelessness for women a priority. - SRO families and housing rights: Tenants and organizers from SRO Families United Collaborative, Chinese Progressive Association, Mission SRO Collaborative, and Just Cause urged restoration of $5.2 million for SRO collaboratives and the Code Enforcement Outreach Program. Many described unsafe conditions—broken stoves, leaky bathrooms, fire hazards—and said language-accessible organizers were essential to getting repairs and protecting tenants. - Worker rights outreach: Workers and organizers from the Workers' Rights Community Collaborative, Chinese Progressive Association, Filipino Community Center, and Trabajadores Unidos requested $400,000 in restored funding for worker outreach and education. They said wage theft and labor violations are widespread, and education in workers' languages is necessary to enforce rights. - Homelessness and Proposition C reallocation: The Homeless Prenatal Program, Larkin Street Youth Services, HESPA, the Coalition on Homelessness, and many families and youth opposed the Mayor's proposal to reallocate $60 million in Our City, Our Home (Proposition C) funds from families and transitional-age youth to adult shelter expansion. Speakers said children who experience homelessness are five times more likely to become homeless adults and argued the money is for future family and youth housing, not one-time savings. - Food security: Representatives of the SF-Marin Food Bank, Booker T. Washington Community Service Center, Farming Hope, Filipino Community Center, the FACTS Coalition, and recipients opposed cuts to food programs. They noted pop-up pantries serve nearly 20,000 households weekly, 44% of surveyed SNAP recipients reported skipping meals in May 2023, the food bank's hotline saw a 64% increase in calls from January to March, and proposed food funding represents a 40% cut next fiscal year and 70% in FY 2024-25. They called food a human right and asked for continued funding. - LGBTQ history and services: The GLBT Historical Society, historians, educators, and community members requested ad-back funding to restore previous cuts and prevent service reductions, citing more than 500 anti-LGBTQ bills nationwide, the museum's reach of 25,000 people annually, and the archives' importance to students and researchers. - Immigrant legal services: The San Francisco Immigrant Legal Defense Collaborative, Justice and Diversity Center, Dolores Street Community Services, CARECEN, La Raza Centro Legal, and others asked for expanded funding. They reported more than 1,600 San Francisco residents represented, over 525 people on waitlists including 200 children, asylum seekers 2.5 times more likely to win with counsel, and only 8 out of 1,000 immigration court respondents obtaining pro bono representation between October 2022 and April 2023. - Child care / Baby Prop C: Dozens of parents, educators, and providers urged the committee to reject proposals to change voter-approved Baby Prop C and to maintain child care funding. Speakers highlighted the need for special-needs child care support, paid living wages for teachers, and the Family Childcare Small Business Program's $200,000 request. Some referenced 700 ECE community members turning out during budget season and opposed using child care funds to close budget gaps. - Public safety and policing: Speakers were divided. Several residents and business advocates supported Mayor Breed's proposed increases for SFPD, the District Attorney, drug market enforcement, ambassador programs, and treatment on demand. They cited about 1,500 police officers versus 2,001 authorized, open-air drug markets, retail theft, and public safety concerns. Other speakers—including law students, the San Francisco Public Defender supporters, Coleman Advocates, Anakbayan, and others—urged diverting police funding to housing, food access, mental health, and community services. They noted the public defender's office receives roughly half the District Attorney's funding ($50.2 million vs $84 million) and that the DA budget is set to increase 6.9% while the PD budget increases 1.3%. Some opposed $20 million in APEC-related spending and increased police overtime. - Other requests: Speakers asked for CART (Compassionate Alternative Response Team) funding of $6.8 million placed in the Department of Public Health, disability housing subsidies and senior services, an SRO elevator replacement fund, human trafficking hotline funding, library safety officers, street showers, Great Highway sand management option three, and various community garden and arts funding. Key Outcomes - The committee did not make substantive amendments or vote on the budget itself during this recessed meeting. - After public comment closed, Chair Chan moved to continue the remaining agenda items to Wednesday, June 28, 2023. The motion was seconded by Vice Chair Mandelman and passed 4-0 (Supervisor Safai absent). - The committee then voted to recess until 10:00 a.m. on Wednesday, June 28, 2023. The motion was seconded by Supervisor Walton and passed 4-0 (Supervisor Safai absent).

PUBLIC SAFETY 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · HOMELESSNESS 12% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 10%
967
JUN 23, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Recessed Meeting - June 23, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, convened on June 23, 2023, at approximately 10:00 AM to review department budgets for FY 2023-2024 and FY 2024-2025. The meeting focused on proposed reductions from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) and policy disagreements. No public comment was taken; it was deferred to the recessed meeting on Monday, June 26, 2023. The meeting recessed at approximately 1:45 PM after approving a motion to carry over remaining agenda items. Consent Calendar - San Francisco Public Library: Agreed to BLA reductions totaling $485,000 per year (ongoing) from materials/supplies and salary attrition savings. Disagreed on three upward substitutions (chief information officer, fleet logistics supervisor, city archivist) costing $240,241 total, arguing they are necessary for recruitment and capacity. The committee expressed skepticism but will continue discussion. - City Attorney: Agreed to BLA reductions: $363,183 in FY23-24 ($163,183 ongoing, $200,000 one-time) and $170,377 in FY24-25 (ongoing). - Department of Emergency Management (DEM): Agreed to BLA reductions: $359,172 in FY23-24 ($156,224 ongoing, $202,948 one-time) plus $68,144 in encumbrance closures. Disagreed on two policy recommendations: (1) $1.277 million for DMAC operations (part of $5.5 million initiative) and (2) a reserve recommendation for $4 million in work orders for the Drug Market Agency Coordination Center. DEM argued the DMAC is still being stood up and asked for flexibility. The committee leaned toward placing the $4 million on reserve. - Superior Court: Agreed to BLA reductions of $75,000 ongoing per year. - Fire Department: Agreed to BLA reductions of $484,210 in FY23-24 ($421,194 ongoing, $63,016 one-time) and $197,260 in FY24-25. - Juvenile Probation: Agreed to BLA reductions of $295,081 in FY23-24 ($243,924 ongoing, $51,157 one-time) plus $104,592 in encumbrance closures; $246,005 in FY24-25. - Adult Probation: Agreed to BLA reductions of $396,399 in FY23-24 ($65,000 ongoing, $331,399 one-time) plus $32,326 in encumbrance closures; $65,000 in FY24-25. - Department of Police Accountability: Agreed to BLA reduction of $20,000 (one-time) in FY23-24 only. - Office of the Inspector General (Sheriff): Agreed to BLA reductions of $467,360 in FY23-24 ($42,826 ongoing, $424,534 one-time) and $33,420 in FY24-25 (corrected from initially stated $42,826). - Sheriff's Department: Agreed to BLA reductions of $627,551 in FY23-24 ($70,551 ongoing, $557,000 one-time) plus $95,102 in encumbrance closures; $70,551 in FY24-25. Disagreed on an upward substitution for a strategic planning position ($33,184), arguing it was justified by a DHR analysis. - Public Defender: Agreed to BLA reduction of $15,873 (one-time) in FY23-24 plus $9,358 in encumbrance closures. Disagreed on a policy recommendation regarding a chief of confront and advocacy position ($15,996 in FY23-24, $16,331 ongoing in FY24-25), noting it was already approved in a prior budget cycle. Supervisor Walton supported the department; the committee indicated willingness to approve. - District Attorney: Agreed to BLA reductions of $253,761 in FY23-24 ($13,000 ongoing, $240,761 one-time) plus $1,000 in encumbrance closures; $13,000 in FY24-25. Discussion Items - San Francisco Public Library Upward Substitutions: The library requested three position upgrades: CIO (deputy director 2 to manager 3, cost $16,130), fleet/logistics supervisor (senior materials supervisor to manager 1), and city archivist (page to manager 1). Total cost $240,241. BLA flagged this as a policy matter given the city's structural deficit. The committee leaned against approval, with Chair Chan and Supervisors Safai and Walton expressing concern about cumulative costs. The library offered to increase salary savings to account for delayed hiring. Discussion included the Ocean View branch feasibility study; Supervisor Safai proposed reserving remaining funds for the Orizaba site, which the library accepted. - DEM Drug Market Agency Coordination Center (DMAC): DEM presented the $5.5 million initiative to coordinate drug enforcement. BLA recommended placing $4 million on reserve for work orders still being finalized, and considered the remaining $1.277 million a policy decision. DEM agreed to the reserve but asked for quick action. Supervisors debated the long-term sustainability and mission clarity. Supervisor Ronan criticized the approach as a short-term "gimmick" and called for systemic changes. Vice Chair Mandelman supported the DMAC as necessary to address street conditions. Chair Chan requested a detailed breakdown of all street response programs (FTEs and costs) and updates on DEM's capital project at 1101 Turk Street. - Police Department Overtime and TrueNARC: The police department disagreed with two BLA recommendations: (1) a $1.4 million cut to overtime (reduced from $2.7 million after discussions) and (2) a policy recommendation not to fund $200,000 for 10 TrueNARC devices. Chief Redmond argued both are critical given staffing shortages (84 civilian vacancies, ongoing sworn attrition) and the need for efficiency in drug enforcement. BLA countered that the department already budgets $81 million in overtime for FY23-24 (quadruple historical levels) and that TrueNARC devices are redundant with existing lab testing. The committee requested data on drug arrests per district and discussed command staff structure. Chair Chan noted the police budget has increased 12.2% since FY2019-20 to $692 million. The committee will continue discussion. Key Outcomes - Motions Passed: The committee voted unanimously to carry over the balance of today's agenda items to the recessed meeting on Monday, June 26, 2023, and to recess this meeting until that time. - Next Steps: The recessed meeting on June 26 will include public comment on the budget (agenda items 1 and 2) and further deliberation on outstanding policy disagreements. Departments are to provide requested documents (e.g., DEM street response details, police arrest data, library Ocean View project information) to the committee and BLA. - Reserve Items: The committee indicated willingness to place DEM's DMAC work orders ($4 million) on reserve pending a finalized plan. The police overtime reduction and TrueNARC funding will be revisited.

PROCEDURAL 28% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 24% · PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 12%
968
JUN 22, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Budget and Appropriations Committee Recessed Meeting - June 22, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on June 22, 2023, to review departmental budgets, policy recommendations, and several legislative items tied to the FY 2023-24 and FY 2024-25 budget. The committee heard from department heads, the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA), and the public. Many departments accepted BLA-recommended reductions, but several policy disagreements emerged, particularly around park rangers, homelessness funding, ambassador programs, and child care tax policies. The meeting recessed to continue on June 23, 2023, with final action expected on June 26, 2023, after public comment. Consent Calendar - Multiple departments (Asian Art Museum, Fine Arts Museums, War Memorial, DCYF, Status of Women, Human Rights Commission, Arts Commission, DPH, OEWD) accepted BLA-recommended budget reductions. Specific savings included: - Asian Art Museum: $69,839 in FY 23-24 (one-time) plus $36,450 from encumbrances. - Fine Arts Museums: $48,980 in FY 23-24 (one-time) plus $92,531 from encumbrances. - War Memorial: $95,870 in FY 23-24 (one-time) plus $76,024 from encumbrances. - Status of Women: $110,000 in FY 23-24 ($10,000 ongoing, $100,000 one-time) plus $13,122 from encumbrances. - Human Rights Commission: $154,958 in FY 23-24 (ongoing) plus $1,046 from encumbrances. - Arts Commission: $39,335 in FY 23-24 (ongoing) and $36,705 in FY 24-25 (ongoing). - Department of Public Health: $4,508,461 in FY 23-24 ($1,796,603 ongoing, $2,711,858 one-time) plus $785,140 from encumbrances. - OEWD: $1,959,753 in FY 23-24 plus $210,914 from encumbrances. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 6 (Our City, Our Home reallocation): Many speakers opposed the mayor's proposal to reallocate $60 million from transitional age youth (TAY) and family homelessness programs to adult shelter beds. Speakers argued this would increase youth and family homelessness, undermine prevention, and violate the will of voters who passed Proposition C. Over a dozen individuals testified, including representatives from Larkin Street Youth Services, Compass Family Services, Homeless Prenatal Program, and Coalition on Homelessness. - Items 8 & 9 (Ambassador programs): Several speakers supported the downtown welcome and mid-market/Tenderloin safety ambassador programs, citing improved safety, tourism support, and workforce development for formerly incarcerated individuals. A few speakers raised concerns about inconsistent treatment and accountability. - Items 11 & 12 (Child care tax policies): Many early childhood educators and parents urged the committee to reject the sublessor deduction (Item 11) and protect the Prop C baseline (Item 12). They argued that cutting child care funding would harm families and long-term economic recovery. Discussion Items - Department of Children, Youth and Their Families (DCYF): Director Sue requested $2 million from the Free City College reserve to pay off outstanding student fees for up to 13,500 students. BLA considered this a policy matter. Committee members expressed support, noting the program's success in reducing barriers. Supervisor Safai raised concerns about declining enrollment and future reserves. The item was continued. - Recreation and Park Department: The department proposed adding 8 new park rangers and upgrading two manager positions. BLA flagged these as policy matters due to citywide growth in managerial roles. Committee members debated the need, with Supervisor Chan noting other public safety investments. The item was continued. - Department of Public Health (DPH): DPH agreed to BLA reductions but flagged four new manager positions (Office of Victims and Witness Rights, behavioral health coordination, Laguna Honda recertification, equity deputy director) as policy choices. Supervisors Safai and Mandelman supported funding the victim services office per Prop D. Chair Chan requested more detail on sustainability. Continued. - Human Services Agency (HSA): Director Rohr disagreed with six of 21 BLA recommendations, including positions for a stationary engineer, bilingual clerk, HR analysts, and $9.6 million for relocating from 170 Otis Street. The committee agreed to place relocation funds on reserve and to reduce funding for unfilled positions to 0.75 FTE to account for hiring delays. Three manager upward substitutions (chief IT security officer, foster parent recruitment manager, outreach manager for benefits) were supported by the committee. The BLA's revenue recommendation (HSA-21) to increase fee revenue was accepted, pending a technical adjustment. - Treasurer and Tax Collector: The department accepted all BLA reductions but disagreed with policy flags on two upward substitutions (Bureau of Delinquent Revenue director and compliance director). Committee supported the department, citing increased tax complexity. - Department of Building Inspection (DBI): The department accepted BLA reductions but sought an upward substitution for a permit technician to manager. Committee approved, noting the union issue if unfilled. - Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH): BLA recommended a $2 million reduction to a $3 million program for transgender and gender non-conforming homelessness prevention. Director Whitley argued funds were needed for capacity building and safety. Supervisor Ronin supported restoration. Committee continued the item. - Department of Early Childhood: Director Mesquit disagreed with most BLA recommendations, arguing that cuts to public information officers, evaluation contracts, and facility cost transfers would hinder the new department. Committee expressed skepticism about the need for additional communications spending and continued the conversation. - Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD): The department presented downtown recovery spending ($6.3 million) and ambassador programs. Chair Chan questioned the return on investment for activations and business attraction, noting the city's deficit. Supervisor Safai supported the concept but questioned specific spending. Supervisor Mandelman expressed ambivalence about public dollars for private market activation. The ambassador program contracts (Items 8 & 9) were discussed extensively, with Supervisor Walton and Preston strongly supporting the Tenderloin/mid-market safety ambassadors. Chair Chan proposed a timeline for DEM to develop a citywide plan and consider transitioning contracts to a sustainable model. - Item 10 (Gross receipts tax postponement and credit): OEWD presented the mayor's proposal to delay rate increases for certain sectors and offer a tax credit for new office-based businesses. Chair Chan proposed limiting the credit to downtown zip codes and possibly expanding eligibility to existing businesses opening a new location downtown. The committee discussed the need to balance incentives with budget constraints. Continued. - Items 11 & 12 (Child care tax policies): Supervisor Melgar proposed an amendment to Item 12 to use interest earned on Prop C funds (up to $20 million in FY 23-24 and $10 million in FY 24-25) instead of reducing the baseline. The amendment also included a provision to restore the baseline if the deficit is less than $200 million in March 2024. The committee approved the amendment. Item 11 (sublessor deduction) was not supported by the chair due to minimal economic impact and negative effects on child care funding. Key Outcomes - Department budgets: The committee recessed with most departments' technical reductions accepted, but many policy disagreements continued to Wednesday, June 26, 2023. - Recreation and Park rangers: Committee did not reach consensus; item continued. - HSH transgender program: $2 million reduction not accepted; item continued. - OEWD ambassador contracts: Committee did not vote; Chair Chan proposed a plan for DEM to develop a citywide ambassador strategy by early 2024, with quarterly updates. The contracts were continued. - Item 10 (Gross receipts tax): Amendment to limit tax credit to downtown zip codes was introduced but not finalized; item continued to Wednesday. - Item 12 (Prop C baseline): Amendment to use interest earnings (up to $30 million over two years) passed unanimously (4-0, with Vice Chair Mandelman absent). The baseline for future years remains protected, with a provision to restore if deficit conditions improve. - Item 11 (Sublessor deduction): No motion made; effectively rejected. The committee signaled opposition. - All remaining legislation (Items 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12) were continued to the recessed meeting on June 23, 2023, for final action after public comment on June 26, 2023.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 27% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 11% · PROCEDURAL 10% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 10%
969
JUN 21, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Reviews FY2023-2025 Budgets and Policy Items – June 21, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on June 21, 2023, to consider the proposed FY2023-2024 and FY2024-2025 budgets, along with related policy items. Chair Connie Chan presided, joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisors Hillary Ronen, Shamann Walton, and Ahsha Safai. The meeting focused on departmental budget presentations and responses to the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommendations, with public comment on the main budget items scheduled for June 26, 2023. The committee voted on several items and set the agenda for the next day. Consent Calendar - Items 6 and 7 (HIV Grant and Patient Rates): The committee approved a resolution retroactively accepting a $1.2 million increase (total $2.2 million) from the CDC for HIV behavioral surveillance, and an ordinance setting patient rates for the Department of Public Health for FY2023-2025. Both were forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation (5-0 vote). - Item 4 (Contract Certification): A resolution concurring with the controller's certification that certain services could be performed by private contractors was approved and forwarded (5-0 vote). - Item 5 (SB1 Road Project List): A resolution approving the list of projects funded by Senate Bill 1 (Road Repair and Accountability Act) for FY2023-2024 was approved and forwarded (5-0 vote). - Item 3 (Reporting Burdens Ordinance): An ordinance amending administrative and environment codes to reduce reporting burdens was amended by the committee (adding annual list of reports to the board) and then forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation (5-0 vote on amendment, then 5-0 on final passage). Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4 (Contract Certification): One member of the public spoke, expressing confusion about the item and alleging that their rights were being violated. No other public comments were submitted. - Item 5 (SB1 Project List): One speaker again expressed confusion and frustration, claiming their rights were being lost. No other comments. - No public comments were taken on the main budget items (1 and 2) as per the chair's announcement; those will be heard on June 26, 2023. Discussion Items - Department of Human Resources (DHR): Director Eisen agreed to BLA reductions totaling $85,491 in FY23-24 and $446,587 in FY24-25. Vice Chair Mandelman expressed concern about impacts on hiring improvements, but the BLA and director stated the cuts would not affect core hiring initiatives. The committee approved the reductions. - Department of Technology: Director Jarrell agreed to BLA reductions of $446,956 in FY23-24 and $226,857 in FY24-25. Approved. - Assessor-Recorder: Director Torres agreed to all BLA recommendations except one policy recommendation to upgrade a manager position (from 0923 to 0931) at an added cost of $16,008. The committee rejected the policy recommendation, aligning with the chair's focus on controlling manager-to-staff ratios. Revised BLA reductions: $236,250 in FY23-24 and $104,304 in FY24-25. - Planning Department: Director Hillis disagreed with a BLA policy recommendation to cut a vacant manager 2 position (0923) used for racial and social equity work. The committee sided with the department, retaining the position. BLA reductions: $572,863 in FY23-24 and $545,903 in FY24-25. - Department of Elections: Director John Arntz agreed to BLA reductions of $70,763 in FY23-24 and $60,337 in FY24-25. Approved. - Retirement Board: The board agreed to BLA reductions but disagreed with three policy recommendations to delete or reclassify manager positions (cybersecurity and investment roles, totaling $634,307 in FY23-24). The committee noted these positions do not affect the general fund and left the decision to the board. BLA reductions: $499,110 in FY23-24 and $693,982 in FY24-25, plus encumbrances. - General City Responsibility: The committee agreed to $500,000 in reductions and placed $10 million in reserve for the APEC conference, consistent with the mayor's request. - Controller's Office: Controller Ben Rosenfield opposed a BLA policy recommendation to delete a new manager 3 position ($199,480) for a budget academy training program. The committee supported the controller, citing the need for training given high staff turnover. BLA reductions: $195,917 in FY23-24 and $176,748 in FY24-25. - City Administrator's Office: Director Katie Petruccioni agreed to BLA reductions of $1,067,000 in FY23-24 and $872,528 in FY24-25. Approved. - Public Works: Director Carla Short disagreed with a BLA policy recommendation to convert a park area supervisor position (3464) to a manager 1 (0922) for $41,024 savings. The committee upheld the department's position, noting the conversion would change applicant qualifications. BLA reductions: $1,230,120 in FY23-24 and $863,127 in FY24-25 (non-general fund). - Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development: Director Benjamin McCloskey agreed to BLA reductions of $634,109 in FY23-24 and $204,323 in FY24-25. Approved. - Board of Supervisors: The committee rejected the BLA's recommended $6,000 reduction, with Chair Chan noting the board's lean operations. The BLA had also recommended closing encumbrances. Key Outcomes - Votes and Forwarding: Items 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 were forwarded to the full board (July 11, 2023) with positive recommendations. All votes were 5-0. - Technical Adjustments: Director of Budget Dumene announced technical adjustments to be submitted, including shifting $500,000 for the board's legislative management system to FY23-24. - Continuation: The committee recessed at the end of the meeting and will reconvene on June 22, 2023, at 10:00 AM to consider items 1, 2, and 8-17 (remaining budget and policy items). The motion to recess passed 5-0. - Public Comment Schedule: Public comment on the main budget (items 1 and 2) will be held on Monday, June 26, 2023, at 10:00 AM in the chamber.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 62% · PROCEDURAL 11% · PUBLIC WORKS 8% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 5%
970
JUN 21, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - June 21, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular meeting on Wednesday, June 21, 2023, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included officer recognition, public comment, approval of the consent calendar, the Chief's report on crime trends and significant incidents, the DPA Director's report, commission reports, and a discussion with the SFPD Officers' Pride Alliance regarding the Pride patch program. The commission also voted to hold a closed session item. Consent Calendar - The commission voted 5-0 to receive and file the DPA monthly statistical report for March and April 2023. Public Comments & Testimony - Officer Recognition (Item 1): No public comment. - General Public Comment (Item 2): Multiple speakers addressed the commission. One individual reported feeling unsafe due to cars speeding past a stop sign and being touched on the street, claiming a crime was being committed against them. Paulette Brown spoke about her son's unsolved 2006 murder, urging the department to find ways to pay tipsters to solve cold cases, noting a $250,000 reward. A speaker criticized the fentanyl crisis, comparing it to the Jonestown tragedy, stating that San Francisco is approaching 800 overdose deaths this year and that drug dealers may skew data. Another speaker expressed concerns about blurring the lines of police roles, urging a redefinition of an officer's duties. - Chief's Report (Item 4): No public comment. - DPA Director's Report (Item 5): A speaker briefly commented, reiterating the need to redefine police roles and avoid confusion. - Commission Reports (Item 6): No public comment. - Pride Patch Discussion (Item 7): No public comment. - Closed Session Vote (Item 8): No public comment. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 4): Chief William Scott presented an overview of crime trends and major incidents from the past week. He described a car-to-car shooting on June 18th at approximately 6:53 PM near Pier 39 that resulted in two gunshot victims, three injured by shattered glass, and a 10-year-old struck by a vehicle (the 16-year-old sister was also struck but not hospitalized). Officers responded within four minutes; one suspect has been arrested. Other shootings included a homicide in the Tenderloin on June 13th and an incident on the 500 block of Turk. Chief Scott reported that year-to-date homicides are at 23 (one above last year), violent crime is up 3%, property crime down 6%, and overall part one crime down 5%. Homicide clearance rate is 91%. For the Tenderloin enforcement pilot (8 officers and 1 sergeant), the department seized 341 grams of fentanyl that week; year-to-date fentanyl seizures total 61,790 grams (a 159% increase). Total narcotics seized: 95,426 grams (148% increase). Arrests for possession/sales: 390 individuals so far in 2023 (compared to 566 in all of 2022). Of those arrested for public consumption, 62 arrests were made; only 4 were San Francisco residents. The California Highway Patrol (CHP) statistics were also released, including 92 total arrests, 625 citations, and 4,228 grams of fentanyl recovered. Commissioners questioned whether the shootings were gang-related (Chief Scott said most were not) and about the CHP's use of pretext stops (Chief Scott said CHP denies that practice). A commissioner noted that no one arrested in the Tenderloin pilot has accepted treatment yet; the chief confirmed and said the strategy will continue. The Lead program is not in the budget for this year, but the chief is open to revisiting it. Commissioner Yanez requested a future presentation on the Community Engagement Division’s work on relationships and services. - DPA Director's Report (Item 5): Executive Director Paul Henderson reported that DPA has opened 346 cases this year, 265 pending, 29 sustained, 14 mediated, and 21 cases beyond the nine-month investigation period (19 of those are tolled with criminal/civil cases). 6 cases await commission decisions, 88 await chief decisions. The top allegation (21%) was failure to take required action. He also mentioned working on a summary of last week's discussion items and will share with the chief first. - Commission Reports (Item 6): Vice President Carter Oberstone updated that the working group on DGO 810 (First Amendment surveillance) will need one more meeting. Commissioner Walker reported on discussions about the patrol specials program and a tour of the crime lab; she suggested exploring a different type of reward for incidental information in investigations. Commissioner Yanez thanked the chief for the prompt turnaround on the investigative social media DGO draft; he requested that the public comment period be extended to start July 1st to compensate for the lost week due to July 4th. He also confirmed with Chief Scott that the department is prepared to allocate resources for a pre-booking juvenile diversion program, and that a presentation on the program is expected by mid-July. - Pride Patch Discussion (Item 7): Sergeant Winters of the SFPD Officers' Pride Alliance presented the history and impact of the Pride patch, first approved in 2019. The patch is worn during Pride Month and has raised over $30,000 for local LGBTQ organizations (Larkin Street Youth, Castro Country Club). The program has become a model nationally. Winters highlighted that the Pride Alliance also works on policies (e.g., transgender interactions) and collaborates with other employee groups. Commissioners thanked the group and requested donation links for posting on the commission site. Commissioner Walker noted she was the only current commissioner from 2019 and appreciated the uniform DGO modification. The commission unanimously expressed support for the program. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (Item 3): Approved 5-0. - Closed Session Vote (Item 8): The commission voted 5-0 to hold Item 10 in closed session. - Closed Session Non-Disclosure (Item 11): The commission voted 5-0 not to disclose the closed session items. - Future Items: The working group on DGO 810 will continue. A presentation on the juvenile diversion program is scheduled for mid-July. The commission will explore a new reward system for investigative information. The investigative social media DGO draft will be posted for public comment starting July 1st.

PROCEDURAL 56% · PUBLIC SAFETY 16% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 13% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com