The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on Friday, June 16, 2023, to review the proposed budgets for fiscal years 2023-2024 and 2024-2025 for multiple city departments. The meeting included presentations from the Fire Department, City Attorney, Superior Court, Department of the Environment, Law Library, Public Library, Civil Service Commission, Rent Board, Department of Emergency Management, Juvenile Probation, Adult Probation, Sheriff's Office, Office of Police Accountability, Sheriff's Office Inspector General, Public Defender, District Attorney, and Police Department. Public comment was heard on the overall budget and salary ordinances. Consent Calendar - Items 3 and 4 were moved to the full Board of Supervisors with recommendations. Item 3 (Resolution to accept a grant from Friends of the San Francisco Public Library up to $1,030,400 for FY2023-2024) passed unanimously. Item 4 (Ordinance amending EMS fees and health codes) passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers urged the committee to reject the proposed $62 million increase for the Police Department, arguing that funds should be redirected to housing, food security, youth programs, and other community services. Several speakers referenced the death of Banco Brown and called for divestment from policing. - Speakers supported funding for the Department of Environment's climate equity hub, the City Attorney's gun violence restraining order work, and the Sheriff's Department's longevity pay for deputies. - A representative from the Deputy Sheriff's Association requested retention incentives similar to those given to the Police Department. - Community members expressed frustration with the budget process and the perceived lack of attention from committee members during public comment. Discussion Items - Fire Department (Chief Jeanine Nicholson): Presented a budget of $511.8 million for FY23-24 and $526.7 million for FY24-25. Noted 90% of the budget is for salaries and benefits. Discussed increasing call volume (16% above pre-pandemic levels), street crisis teams, overtime management, and challenges with equipment costs (e.g., fire engines now $900,000 vs. $500,000 pre-COVID). Chief Pang noted that street crisis teams have only one shelter bed available after 5 p.m. and highlighted the need for same-day treatment placements. - City Attorney (David Chiu): Presented a budget request including four new positions for CARE Court implementation (a state mandate). Requested an add-back of $500,000 to make a temporary gun violence restraining order position permanent. Noted that the office has seized firearms from dangerous individuals, including one case involving a mentally ill person with bomb-making materials. - Superior Court (Brandon Riley): Presented a budget of $9.9 million for indigent defense administration. Supervisor Ronan raised concerns about court delays and violations of defendants' due process rights. The court executive officer declined to comment due to pending litigation. - Department of the Environment (Tyrone Jue): Presented a balanced budget, noting that grants make up 27% of funding. Highlighted climate action plan goals and recent audit compliance. - Public Library (Michael Lambert): Presented a budget that includes $19.8 million for the Ocean View Branch Library project and $3 million for the Mission Branch renovation. Supervisor Safai expressed concern about continued spending on alternative sites for the Ocean View Library and requested that the project balance be placed on reserve. - Civil Service Commission (Sandra Ng): Presented a budget with a 5% reduction, including a freeze on a vacant senior clerk typist position, reducing the team from six to five. The department cited challenges in meeting hiring demands and technology needs. - Rent Board (Christina Varner): Presented a budget of $17.7 million for FY23-24, noting that all 50 budgeted positions are filled or in active recruitment. Highlighted language access services and the role of rent control in preserving affordable housing. - Department of Emergency Management (Mary Ellen Carroll): Presented a budget of $139 million, with 70% from the general fund. Discussed the 911 center's staffing challenges (only 70% of calls answered within 10 seconds) and the coordination of street crisis teams. Introduced the Drug Market Agency Coordination Center (DMAC) with a proposed budget of $5.5 million. - Juvenile Probation (Director Miller): Presented a budget reflecting a 32% reduction in probation division staff and a 22% reduction in juvenile hall staff over the past four years. Noted increased referrals and admissions since 2021, and that 52% of youth on probation do not have a San Francisco address. Discussed the impact of the state's closure of DJJ and the need for alternative facility plans. - Adult Probation (Chief Christelle Tulach): Presented a budget of $58.5 million for FY24, with $15 million in grants to community-based organizations. Noted that 73% of the 5,000 probation cases are in suspended status, and the department is working to fill 23 vacancies. - Sheriff's Office (Undersheriff Catherine Johnson): Presented a budget of $289 million from the general fund. Stated the department is 185 deputies short and is deploying an Emergency Services Unit to the Tenderloin and SoMa areas to address drug sales and use. Requested an add-back of $457,000 for pretrial services. Discussed the impact of the lack of longevity pay for deputies. - Office of Police Accountability (Director Paul Henderson): Presented a budget just under $10 million, with 80% for salaries. Requested support for an admin code change to allow pursuit of grant funds. Highlighted the department's language access improvements and the need for additional resources as police and sheriff operations increase. - Sheriff's Office Inspector General (Dan Leo): Presented a budget with a $552,000 reduction in salary and benefits. Noted that all positions are vacant except the executive secretary, and requested restoration of funds to allow the new inspector general to begin operations. - Public Defender (Mano Rajun): Presented a budget of $49 million, noting that the office is 57% of the District Attorney's budget. Highlighted rising caseloads, trial delays, and the need for additional staff for clean slate and immigration work. Discussed the structural inequity in funding within the criminal legal system. - District Attorney (Brooke Jenkins): Presented a budget of $89.8 million for FY24, with 89% from the general fund. Noted caseloads of 110 cases per attorney in preliminary hearings and 70 in general felonies. Discussed the Crankstart Foundation grant for the Healing Justice Initiative and the need for a dedicated attorney for retail theft. - Police Department (Chief Bill Scott): Presented a budget of $661 million for FY24, up from $606 million. Stated the department is short-staffed and relying on overtime. Outlined recruitment goals (100 officers in FY24) and plans for civilianization, fleet modernization, and equipment like license plate readers and TrueNarc analyzers. President Peskin questioned the size of the command staff, and Chief Scott defended the structure. Key Outcomes - Items 1 and 2 (Budget and Salary Ordinances) were continued to the June 21, 2023, special meeting for further review. - Item 3 (Friends of the Library grant) was recommended to the full Board of Supervisors (passed 5-0). - Item 4 (EMS fees ordinance) was recommended to the full Board of Supervisors (passed 5-0). - Multiple departments were asked to provide additional information before their second appearances, including breakdowns of overtime spending, staffing structures, and program details.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a special meeting on June 15, 2023, to consider the proposed two-year budget for fiscal years 2023-2024 and 2024-2025, along with several trailing ordinances. Chair Connie Chan presided, joined by Supervisors Hillary Ronen, Shamann Walton, Rafael Mandelman, and Ahsha Safaï. The meeting included presentations from multiple city departments, public testimony, and votes on various items. Consent Calendar - Items 1 & 2 (Budget and Appropriation Ordinance & Annual Salary Ordinance): Heard together with department presentations. No separate vote; public comment taken later. Public Comments & Testimony - Minimum Compensation Ordinance (Item 3): Multiple speakers, including Debbie Lerman (Human Services Network), supported raising non-profit wages but urged the city to fully fund the mandate. Aliana Bender (Glide) emphasized the need for expanded food funding. One speaker called for more training on pandemic issues. - Film Fees & Sublessor Deduction (Items 4 & 5): Over 30 speakers, mostly from early childhood education advocacy groups, urged rejection of the sublessor tax deduction, arguing it would divert $17 million annually from early care and education programs. Many speakers noted the ordinance would undermine voter-approved Proposition C. Film industry representative Joanne Desmond supported the film fee increases. - OCO Fund Reallocation (Items 12 & 13): A large number of speakers, including families, service providers, and coalition members, opposed the mayor's proposal to reallocate $60 million from the Our City, Our Home fund away from transitional age youth and family housing to adult shelter and prevention. They argued it contradicts voter intent and would harm vulnerable populations. - Early Childhood Baseline Reduction (Item 14): Many speakers, including parents and educators, opposed reducing the general fund baseline for early care and education, stating it would set back progress toward universal child care. - General Budget (Items 1 & 2): Sean Brooks (SF-Marin Food Bank) warned that cuts to food programs would force service reductions. MCCLA supporters urged continued funding for the Mission Cultural Center. Discussion Items - Human Services Agency (HSA) Presentation: Director Trent Rhorer and staff reviewed HSA’s $350 million general fund budget, highlighting challenges from federal debt ceiling changes (CalFresh work requirements) and state budget uncertainty. Supervisor Ronen expressed frustration with the policy changes and asked about local food aid reductions. The agency reported no service cuts and planned to use attrition savings. - Minimum Compensation Ordinance (Item 3): The committee approved the ordinance to incrementally raise minimum pay for non-profit and public entity contractors, with a goal of $23/hour by 2026 and $25.50/hour by 2027. The motion passed 4-0 (Safaï absent). - Human Rights Commission: Director Dr. Sheryl Davis presented the $34 million budget, emphasizing equity-focused programs. Key challenges included staffing (18 vacancies) and pay equity. - Fine Arts Museums: Jason Sefer (CFO) reported a city-funded budget of $27 million, with 75% for payroll and benefits. No service cuts; the museums saw 1.5 million visitors in FY23. - Academy of Sciences: Matthew Lao (interim CFO) presented a $7.46 million city budget, slightly higher than FY23. Two additional building engineer positions were requested to improve maintenance and morale. - Arts Commission: Director Ralph Remington highlighted $16.5 million in grants to 94 organizations, with 70% awarded to BIPOC-led groups. The department is fully staffed after filling 12 positions. - War Memorial: Donna De Cruz reported a $37.7 million FY24 budget, with 12 vacancies. The department plans to hold 5 positions in attrition. - Department of Children, Youth and Their Families (DCYF): Director Maria Su presented a $224 million operating budget, with no service cuts in FY24. A new five-year services allocation plan was outlined. - Child Support Services: Karen Roy noted the department relies solely on federal/state funds and has no service cuts. Caseload declined 21% since 2017. - Department on Status of Women: Kimberly Ellis presented a $15 million budget, with 83% for grants. The department is shifting from grant-making to advocacy and accountability roles. - Recreation and Parks: Antonio Guerra presented a $267 million budget, with challenges including escalating utility costs (projected to hit $24 million by 2030) and staffing at new facilities. - Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD): New director Sarah Dennis Phillips and staff presented the budget and two ordinances (Items 4 & 5). Debate centered on the sublessor tax deduction, with City Economist Ted Egan estimating minimal economic benefit ($3.8 million in new rent) compared to $17 million annual revenue loss. Supervisor Ronen and others opposed the measure. The committee voted to advance the film fee ordinance and continue the sublessor item. - Department of Public Health (DPH): Director Dr. Grant Colfax presented a $3.2 billion budget with no service cuts. Key investments included $14 million for wellness hubs and $5 million for naloxone distribution. Supervisors Mendelman and Ronen pressed for more acute mental health beds and faster progress on the crisis diversion facility. - Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH): Director Shireen McSpadden presented a $690 million budget, with a proposed reallocation of $60 million from OCO fund. The BLA noted $478 million in unspent OCO funds. Public comment was strongly opposed to the reallocation. The committee continued both items to June 21. - Department of Early Childhood (DEC): Director Ingrid Mejía presented the budget and a proposed ordinance to reduce the general fund baseline by $30 million over two years to fund food programs. The BLA reported the savings would transfer to HSA food programs. Supervisor Safaï questioned the sustainability of using child care reserves for food aid. The item was continued. Key Outcomes - Item 3 – Minimum Compensation Ordinance: Approved (4-0) to advance to the full board. - Item 4 – Film Commission Fees: Approved to forward to the full board. - Item 5 – Sublessor Tax Deduction: Continued to June 21. - Items 6, 8, 9, 10, 11 – DPH Managed Care, Patient Rates, Grants, MOUs: Approved to forward to full board (4-0) after a minor amendment to Item 7 (added interactive complexity and sign language rates). Item 7 was continued. - Items 12 & 13 – OCO Fund Reallocation & HSH Expenditure Plan: Continued to June 21. - Item 14 – Early Childhood Baseline Reduction: Continued to June 21. - General Budget (Items 1 & 2): Public comment taken; no vote on these items at this meeting.
This joint hearing of the San Francisco Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) and Planning Commission (PC) considered a series of items related to the Castro Theater and the Castro Street Neighborhood Commercial District (NCD). The meeting began at 11:15 am and lasted over seven hours. The HPC first voted on a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) and a Planning Code Amendment, then adjourned. The PC then separately considered a Planning Code Amendment and a Conditional Use Authorization (CUA) for the same project. A total of 1,580 public comment letters were received in support of the project, 704 in opposition, and approximately 80 neutral submissions. Consent Calendar - The HPC and PC approved a consent calendar containing several routine items, including continuances of 10 items (e.g., 51 Prosper Street, 372 Dolores Street, 900 Chenery Street) to later dates (June 29, July 13, July 20, July 27, 2023). - The PC also approved a consent calendar for items 14–17 (e.g., 1615 Polk Street, 555 Fulton Street 307 and 405, 667 Folsom Street) without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - Supporters (over 1,500 letters and dozens of speakers): Representatives from IATSE Local 16, the Castro Merchants Association, the Eureka Valley Neighborhood Association, Frameline, the Gay Men’s Chorus, and many local residents and business owners expressed strong support. They argued that the theater’s financial viability requires a flexible, multi-use venue; that the $15 million investment by Another Planet Entertainment (APE) will restore the historic fabric and bring ADA accessibility; and that the current 2001‑era seats are not historic and can be replaced with a reversible system. Speakers emphasized that the neighborhood is in decline and needs the theater to thrive. - Opponents (704 letters and many speakers): Members of the Castro Theater Conservancy, the Castro LGBTQ Cultural District, the Harvey Milk LGBTQ Democratic Club, and other community members argued that the proposed removal of the orchestra‑level fixed seats and the raked floor would destroy the character‑defining features of a movie palace. They contended that the theater can be profitable with the existing seating, that APE has a poor track record of honoring promises (e.g., at Bill Graham Civic Auditorium), and that the plan would turn the theater into a concert venue open only 180 days a year, reducing community access. They requested enforceable conditions including community oversight, a minimum of 25% LGBTQ+ programming, and a default seating arrangement. Discussion Items - Planning Code Amendment (Nighttime Entertainment in Castro Street NCD): Staff recommended approval with a modification to remove non‑residential use size limitations for Article 10 landmarks in the district. The HPC and PC both approved this amendment. - Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for Castro Theater: The HPC reviewed the proposed interior and exterior alterations, including restoration of historic features, installation of a flexible tiered seating system, new HVAC, and a rear addition. Commissioners questioned the reversibility of the seating changes, the treatment of the blade sign, and the security gate. The HPC voted 5‑0 to approve the COA with conditions requiring completion of all preservation work (including ceiling, murals, proscenium, and blade sign) within five years, administrative review of finishes, and compliance with Secretary of the Interior Standards. - Conditional Use Authorization (CUA) for Nighttime Entertainment and Bar: The PC discussed extensive conditions proposed by Commissioner Braun and President Tanner, including a minimum of 90 days of public events (reduced from 135), annual meetings with the Castro LGBTQ Cultural District (twice yearly for the first three years, then annually), a good‑faith effort to source local food and beverage concessions, and annual reporting to the PC and HPC. The project sponsor, APE, objected to some requirements, but the PC adopted the modifications after debate. Key Outcomes - Historic Preservation Commission (HPC): Approved the COA and Planning Code Amendment (5‑0) with conditions: full preservation scope to be completed within five years, administrative review of architectural finishes, and restoration of the blade sign prior to temporary certificate of occupancy. - Planning Commission (PC): Approved the Planning Code Amendment (5‑1, Commissioner Diamond dissenting) with staff modifications. Approved the CUA (4‑2, Commissioners Imperial and Moore dissenting) with modified conditions: at least 90 days of public events per year; at least 25% of programming committed to LGBTQ+ arts and culture (as stated in the online community benefits package); semi‑annual meetings with the Castro LGBTQ Cultural District for the first three years, then annual; an annual meeting with other interested organizations; good‑faith efforts to source a portion of concessions from local businesses; annual reporting to the PC and HPC; and a requirement that the CUA report be forwarded to the HPC. - Continuances: All 10 proposed continuances were granted. - Consent Calendar: Items 14–17 were approved without discussion. Note: The meeting also included a land acknowledgement, roll call, and disclosures by commissioners. The HPC adjourned after its vote; the PC remained in session to complete its agenda.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee met on June 14, 2023, to review the Mayor's proposed FY2023-2024 and FY2024-2025 budget, hear from city departments, and consider related legislation. The meeting featured the Controller's revenue letter, presentations from numerous departments, and substantial public comment. The committee continued many items to subsequent meetings, approved several ordinances, and forwarded others to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Numerous members of the public spoke in support of restoring funding for the SRO Families United Collaborative and the Code Enforcement Outreach Program (COP) under the Department of Building Inspection (DBI), emphasizing the critical role these programs play in providing language access, tenant rights education, and direct assistance to immigrant and low-income residents in SRO hotels. Speakers also opposed cuts to the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) community building grants and the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (OLSE) worker outreach contracts. Discussion Items - Controller's Revenue Letter (Item 1): Controller Ben Rosenfield presented the revenue outlook, noting slow economic recovery, a heavy reliance on one-time solutions (including $1 billion in federal funds and reserve draws), and a projected $500 million structural deficit in FY2025-2026. The committee filed the hearing. - First Year Free Program (Item 4): Ordinance to extend fee waivers for small businesses through June 2028. Supervisor Ronin expressed concern that the second year of the budget did not fund the program, contradicting the eight-year extension. The item was continued to June 21, 2023. - Administrative Code Changes (Items 5-7): Items to reduce reporting burdens. Chair Chan voiced concern about eliminating proactive reports to the Board of Supervisors. Item 5 was continued to June 21, 2023; Items 6 and 7 were forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Department of Building Inspection (DBI) Budget & Fee Increase (Item 15): DBI proposed a 15% fee increase to address a structural deficit, but eliminated the $5.2 million in grants for the SRO Collaborative and COP programs. Many public commenters urged restoration. The item was continued to June 21, 2023. - Ethics Commission Budget: Acting Executive Director Guy Tri Thekendil warned that the proposed budget would cut the commission's staff by 40% and severely impact campaign finance enforcement, transparency, and ethics training. Supervisor Ronan called the cuts "a disgrace" and stated she would not support any budget that guts the ethics department. The item was continued to June 21, 2023. - Airport (SFO) Position Requests (Item 24): The airport requested 128 new positions due to rapid traffic recovery. The Budget and Legislative Analyst recommended deleting 34 positions, but the committee, after discussion, approved the full request, noting the airport is an enterprise fund and the positions are needed for operational safety and cleanliness. - San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) Capital Budget (Items 16-22): The SFPUC presented a $1.4 billion capital budget for FY2023-2024, including bond authorizations. The committee approved all items with amendments requiring reporting on key projects in the legislative file. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Controller's Revenue Letter): Hearing filed. - Item 4 (First Year Free Program): Continued to June 21, 2023. - Item 5 (Administrative Code - Reporting Burdens): Continued to June 21, 2023. - Items 6 & 7 (Administrative Code - Fundraising Drive and Tech Procurement): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 8 (Municipal Elections Code - Opt out of AB 1416): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 11 (Prop J Contract Certification): Continued to June 21, 2023. - Items 9,10,12,13 (Hearings, Access Line Tax, Graffiti Fund): Heard and filed or forwarded as appropriate. - Items 16-22 (SFPUC Capital Budget and Bonds): Approved as amended (reporting requirements added). - Items 23 & 24 (SFPUC/Port/Airport Budget Amendments): Approved as amended. The airport's full request for 128 positions was approved; the port's $500,000 general fund reduction was accepted. - Item 15 (DBI Fee Increase): Continued to June 21, 2023. - Items 2 & 3 (Main Budget Ordinances): Continued to June 15, 2023, after public comment.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on June 14, 2023, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included consent calendar approvals, reports from the DPA Director and Police Chief, recognition of an officer, a unanimous vote to support the CART model, a lengthy discussion on enforcement strategies in the Tenderloin, and adoption of four revised Department General Orders. Public comment was heard on several items. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously voted to receive and file the Internal Affairs Division quarterly case update (first quarter 2023), SFPD's 1421 and SB16 monthly reports, and DPA's 1421 and SB16 monthly reports. (Vote: 6-0) Public Comments & Testimony - Zach Dillon (Public Defender's Office) requested a status update on DGO 9.07 (pretext stops) which has been in the meet-and-confer process for weeks, urging expedited final approval. - Ms. Brown, mother of a murder victim, advocated for paid tipsters to solve cold cases, stating no rewards have been paid out for homicides. - Jennifer Wagner (League of Women Voters) and Jennifer Friedenbach (Coalition on Homelessness) expressed support for the CART resolution, emphasizing the need for a public health response. - Nicholas Diaz supported CART, stating that police lack training for homelessness and that the program prioritizes peers with lived experience. - Joel Haile (ACLU of Northern California) supported CART, citing the killing of Banko Brown and noting that nearly a third of people in county jail are unhoused. - Teresa Roman (UC Law SF student) supported CART, arguing that law enforcement is not equipped to address root causes of homelessness. - Francisco Herrera (Latino Task Force) urged commissioners to act as a choir to those resisting CART, calling compassion effective, courageous, and intelligent. - Laura Guzmán (National Harm Reduction Action Coalition) opposed the plan to arrest drug users, stating that incarceration has failed for 50 years and increases overdose deaths, especially among Black and Brown communities. - Starchild (Libertarian Party of SF) opposed drug arrests, calling the war on drugs unconstitutional and arguing that housing shortages drive open-air use. - Lady Branson (Gubio Project) advocated for supervised consumption sites, stating that arrests drive people into alleys where they die. - Sheba (District 6 resident) urged opposition to forced treatment, noting that 37% of SF's unhoused population is Black despite being 6% of the overall population. - Brian Cox (Deputy Public Defender) argued that the plan is a rerun of the war on drugs that will increase arrests and incarceration without evidence, and questioned whether other agencies might circumvent commission authority. - Rihanna Baylord (COO, UC Law San Francisco) implored the commission to address violence in the Tenderloin, citing three shootings in three days and the need for enforcement alongside services. - Paul Allen urged support for policing to shut down open-air drug markets, calling the situation an embarrassment. - Unnamed service provider accused the city of using the crisis to clear the area for the APEC conference, calling the city's approach anti-homeless. Discussion Items - DPA Director’s Report: Executive Director Henderson announced that DPA won a national award for audit presentations (second consecutive year). He reported that DPA has opened over 300 cases this year, closed 344 cases, has 261 pending investigations, 28 sustained cases, and 22 cases exceeding nine months (20 tolled due to litigation). Six cases are pending commission decisions, 88 pending chief decisions. Top allegations were failure to promptly respond (20%) and failure to take required action (20%). The highest number of allegations came from Southern, Mission, and Ingleside stations. DPA is seeking public input on DGO 3.05 (weapon return panel). - Chief’s Report: Chief William Scott reported that over the previous weekend, 16 people were shot, one fatally, in separate incidents (Mission, Ingleside, Tenderloin). He stated that the Mission shooting was not connected to other incidents and that a rumor linking it to Carnival was false. Crime statistics: violent crime up 4% year-to-date, property crime down 8% (driven by reductions in burglaries and thefts). Firearm-related homicides increased from 12 to 15 (25% increase), total gun violence victims up by 6 (100 vs. 94). Fentanyl seizures: 61,449 grams seized this year, compared to 23,801 grams at this time last year. Arrests for possession/sales: 378 as of June 11. Stunt driving events occurred over the weekend; 70 cars have been impounded since the program began. A hate crime arrest was made on June 5 after a suspect shouted anti-LGBTQ+ slurs and threw a glass object. The department did not use live surveillance footage during protests after the Tyree Nichols incident, as the city remained peaceful. - Officer Recognition: Lieutenant Kevin Noble presented Officer Susie Dare (Ingleside Station, 15-year veteran, native San Franciscan) with the Weekly Officer Recognition Certificate for her teamwork, community policing, and investigative excellence. - CART Resolution: Commissioner Benedicto introduced a resolution urging the Board of Supervisors and Mayor’s Office to fully fund and implement the Compassionate Alternative Response Team (CART) model, which was developed over two years and endorsed by dozens of community stakeholders. The resolution passed unanimously (7-0). Commissioners expressed that police should not be the primary response to homelessness and that CART provides a public health alternative. - Tenderloin Narcotics Enforcement: Chief Scott presented a detailed overview of the unified command strategy involving SFPD, California Highway Patrol (CHP), National Guard, Sheriff's Department, Department of Emergency Management, Department of Public Health, and other agencies. Objectives include increasing enforcement, disrupting open-air drug markets, reducing overdose deaths, and collaborating with community partners. The SFPD has deployed a sergeant and 8 officers specifically for public drug use arrests, with 45 arrests made so far (only 3 San Francisco residents). Of those arrested, none accepted treatment. The CHP has 6 units deployed 7 days a week, and the National Guard is providing analytical support. The Sheriff's Department will deploy its Emergency Services Unit to patrol city/county buildings. The department plans to expand the program to overnight hours. Discussion included concerns about evidence-based approaches, the impact on vulnerable populations, and the need for transparency and data tracking. Commissioner Yanyez cited a study showing that opioid overdose deaths double within a six-minute walk of each drug arrest. Chief Scott defended enforcement as a necessary part of a broader strategy, stating that the public demands action on street conditions. - Adoption of Department General Orders: The commission adopted four revised DGOs with a 60-day implementation delay: DGO 6.02 (Physical Evidence and Scene Preservation), DGO 6.04 (Assaults on Police Officers), DGO 6.05 (Death Cases), and DGO 11.08 (Grooming Standards). All were approved unanimously (7-0). Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Unanimously received and filed. - CART Resolution: Passed unanimously (7-0) to urge full funding and implementation of the CART model. - Tenderloin Strategy: The commission noted the chief's presentation and deferred further discussion to future meetings. Commissioners requested regular data reporting and transparency, including a dashboard. The unified command center opened on Monday, June 12, and will operate for the foreseeable future. - DGOs Adopted: DGO 6.02, 6.04, 6.05, and 11.08 adopted unanimously, all with a 60-day implementation delay. - Closed Session: The commission voted (7-0) to go into closed session and subsequently voted not to disclose the discussion, except for factual updates to be included in the minutes.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee met on June 14, 2023, to consider three resolutions related to San Francisco International Airport: two approving a 10-year Lease and Use Agreement with 40 airlines, and one authorizing up to $6.06 billion in revenue bonds and other financing. The committee heard presentations, public comment, and voted to forward all items to the full board with a positive recommendation. Discussion Items - The committee received a presentation from airport staff on items 1 and 2 (lease agreements) and item 3 (bond authorizations). The new lease replaces the 2011 agreement starting July 1, 2023, through June 30, 2033, and is expected to generate $6 billion in airline revenue over 10 years, consisting of $3.4 billion in terminal rental rates and $2.6 billion in landing fees. - A key feature is the Operating Reserve and Capital Investment Fund, which will receive an initial $250 million deposit from airlines on July 1, 2023, and total over $800 million over the lease term. The fund can be used for capital projects with shorter useful lives, cash funding of small items, stabilizing rates during economic downturns, and other lawful airport purposes. - Chair Chan questioned whether the fund could be used for labor disputes involving airport contractors. Airport staff responded that it could be used for contracts directly with the airport but not for third-party contractor wages, and they would follow up. - Chair Chan also raised recent incidents at SFO—a power outage on June 13 and two go-around incidents involving Southwest and United airlines. Airport staff explained the power outage was caused by a cable failure scheduled for replacement, and the go-arounds were routine safety measures reviewed by the FAA. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel spoke in support of all three items, noting the bond refunding would save $81 million in net present value (1.27% savings), exceeding the airport's minimum policy threshold. He urged quick approval to meet the July 1 deadline. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (2-0, with Supervisor Safayi excused) to forward all three resolutions to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The items are expected to appear on the Board's agenda on June 27, 2023.
This meeting of the Port Commission on Tuesday, June 13, 2023, began with a land acknowledgment and approval of prior minutes. The agenda included consent calendar items, an executive director's report, an engineering item on underground utility locating, an informational update on the mobile vending program, and a report on Local Business Enterprise (LBE) contracting activity. Public comment focused on labor negotiations with Alcatraz Cruises. Consent Calendar - 7A: Approved a Memorandum of Agreement with the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure for temporary maintenance and operation of Mission Bay Parks (July 1, 2023, up to six months, reimbursement up to $510,028). Resolution 23-25. - 7B: Approved the Port’s 10-Year Capital Plan for FY 2024-2033. Resolution 23-26. - 7C: Approved a sole source grant to the Fisherman’s Wharf Association (Community Benefits District) and waived port license fees and the sugar-sweetened beverage prohibition. Resolution 23-27. - 7D: Approved strategies to address food/beverage and retail vacancies, including a new broker policy, competitive leasing criteria, and rent abatement terms for short-term activations. Resolutions 23-28 and 23-29. - 7E: Retroactively authorized modification to Construction Contract No. 2843 (Pier 70 Shipyard Grading and Abatement) to extend substantial completion date. Resolution 23-30. All consent items passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Evan McLaughlin (International Longshore and Warehouse Union, Northern California) and workers from Alcatraz City Cruises (Jack Calvin, Parker) spoke about ongoing union contract negotiations. They reported that the company is not bargaining in good faith, citing long gaps between sessions (52 days), low wages (as low as $19.50/hour), scheduling issues, and refusal to include captains in the bargaining unit. They requested the Port Commission’s continued support for a fair contract. - Councilor Moore (via phone) thanked Marcia Matham for her service on the Waterfront Design Advisory Committee. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 6): Elaine Forbes reported on economic recovery, noting revenues rebounding faster than expected and reaching pre-pandemic levels in key business lines. Megan Wallace, Economic Recovery Manager, presented the Economic Recovery and Growth Plan, which focuses on three pillars: administrative improvements (lease administration, grant-seeking, technology), activation and business development (pop-ups, Fisherman’s Wharf, maritime growth), and public-private partnerships. A detailed expenditure plan for $10 million in economic recovery funds (from FY 2021-22 budget) was shared. Forbes also highlighted a successful Juneteenth event at the Ferry Building, resilience work with the Army Corps of Engineers, an updated MOU with HSH for Pier 94 shelter (month-to-month), and the sale of two dry docks (minimum bid $2.5 million). She also acknowledged retiring staff (Carol Bach, 27 years) and departing advisory committee members Marcia Matham and Roscoe Maps. - Commissioner Comments: Commissioners praised the economic plan, requested metrics, and emphasized activation across the full waterfront (not just northern). Commissioner Gilman expressed support for the Inland Boatman’s Union and concern over low wages. Commissioner Harrington asked about the $10 million tenant improvement fund—none has been spent yet; staff will bring individual deals to the Commission. - Engineering (Item 8A): Paul Chazon presented a request to issue an RFP for underground utility location and marking services, with a proposed $250,000 contract over four years. This aligns with state law (California 811). Commissioners approved the RFP (Resolution 23-31) unanimously. - Mobile Vending Program (Item 9A): Mike Martin provided an update on the Port’s mobile vending program and enforcement challenges. Since SB 946 (2019) decriminalized street vending, unpermitted vending has increased, concentrated at Fisherman’s Wharf, Alcatraz Landing, and Oracle Park. The Port’s pilot program (with 50+ permitted vendors) uses a lottery system for high-demand spots. Enforcement has been difficult due to state limits (administrative citations only, no requirement for ID). The Port now uses deterrence operations (confiscation) and coordinates with police, ABC, and other agencies. Commissioners discussed escalating illegal vending (alcohol, cannabis, potential human trafficking) and the need for stronger law enforcement partnerships. New security manager Kyle Thomas (former SFPD Marine Unit) onboarded. No vote; informational. - LBE Contracting Report (Item 10A): Elizabeth Alexander Tooth reported on contracting activity from July 1, 2022, to March 31, 2023. Total payments of nearly $14.5 million, with $6.4 million (44%) going to LBEs. Of five eligible contracts, all were awarded to LBE primes or joint ventures. Private developments (Pier 70, Mission Rock) awarded $103.4 million to LBEs. Improvements in outreach, simplified RFP forms, and pre-qualified pools were highlighted. Informational. Key Outcomes - Votes: All consent calendar items (Resolutions 23-25 through 23-30) and Resolution 23-31 (RFP for utility locating) passed unanimously (President Brandon, Commissioners Harrington, Lee, Gilman; Vice President Adams absent). - Directives: Staff to return with qualitative and quantitative metrics for the economic recovery plan, and a report on how the plan reaches partners port-wide. Commissioner Gilman requested an informational report on wayfinding/signage grants by September. - New Business Discussion: Commissioner Lee inquired about the Ferry Building kitchen (former Opera Trust space). Staff will report back after broker tours; Commissioner Harrington suggested a cost-benefit analysis of demolition as an option. - Meeting Adjourned at 5:09 p.m.
On June 13, 2023, the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) convened a regular meeting, with President Ajami presiding and Commissioners Paulson and Stacy present. Vice President Maxwell and Commissioner Rivera were excused. The commission discussed and voted on several capital improvement projects, contracts, grants, and financial reports. The meeting included a consent calendar, regular calendar items, and a closed session for legal matters. This summary captures the key decisions, reports, and public comment themes from the session. Consent Calendar - Approved the consent calendar (excluding item 5J) with a unanimous vote (3-0). Items included contract amendments, new contract awards, and extensions. - Approved item 5J (as amended) with a unanimous vote (3-0). The amendment increases the contract cost contingency by $5,000,000 and adds 228 calendar days to Contract WW-639, bringing the total contract amount to $47,293,000 and total duration to up to 1,997 calendar days. Staff clarified a typo in the agenda, noting the correct increase is $5,000,000 (not $5,000 as originally printed). - No public comments were made on the consent calendar items except for one caller on 5J, who expressed concerns about the lack of public meetings on the clean drinking water upgrade progress. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4D (Water CIP Report): A caller asserted that Hetch Hetchy water was stolen from Indigenous peoples, emphasized that water is life, expressed opposition against mixing groundwater that could contaminate water quality, and urged the Commission to collaborate with Indigenous communities. - Item 5J: A caller referenced the $2.6 billion infrastructure upgrade from 2002, urging the need for public meetings to report on the percentage of pipes replaced, and questioned the purpose of the additional $5 million while old pipes leak. - Item 6 (John O'Connell Grant): A caller accused the Commission of not listening to Indigenous statements, urged learning from empirical data, and criticized the lack of people of color in presentation materials. - Item 8 (Parsons Contract): A caller asked what the presenter was doing to stop contamination in the Bay and bring attention to new viruses found, and stressed the need for environmental orientations for contractors. - General Public Comment: Dave Warner voiced concerns about the 92 MGD water supply shortfall cited in the Alternative Water Supply Program Quarterly Report, arguing it was disingenuous without considering population decline, demand trends, and high costs. He suggested a more balanced presentation and caution on capital expenditures. - Item 16 (Closed Session): No public comments were made on closed session matters. Discussion Items - Report of the General Manager: - HR Update (4a): Wendy Macy presented quarterly hiring statistics. Vacancies are decreasing, with 282 hires in FY 2022-23, exceeding exits. Infrastructure had the highest vacancy rate, followed by HRS, though recent efforts have improved. The presentation highlighted collaboration with communications to enhance recruitment through job fairs, website improvements, and social media. Commissioner Stacy praised the website improvements; Commissioner Paulson asked about the composition of infrastructure vacancies, and Commissioner Stacy requested a breakdown by education level for future reports. - Bond and Loan Financing (4b): Nikolai Skarloff reported that on April 5, 2023, the PUC issued $974 million in bonds for the Wastewater Enterprise, including $750 million in new revenue bonds and refunding of prior bonds. The all-in interest rate was 3.08%, lower than the good faith estimate of 3.35-3.77%. Green bonds (CBI-certified) attracted significant ESG investor interest, and all bonds were rated double-A. Additionally, a WIFIA loan closed on April 26, 2023, locking in a 3.65% rate versus the estimate of 4.046%. The loan's optionality allows drawing at favorable times, as demonstrated by borrowing at 1.45% earlier this year. - Quarterly Budget Report (4c): Laura Bush presented Q3 FY 2022-23 results. All enterprises (Water, Wastewater, Power, CleanPowerSF) project positive net operating results: Water +$27.8M, Wastewater +$19.7M, Power +$49.6M, CleanPowerSF +$14.3M. Higher power prices boosted wholesale revenues, while drought surcharge removal reduced retail sales. Budget adjustments were made for increased power purchase costs, and all financial ratios are on target. - Water CIP Report (4d): Stephen Robinson reported 36 projects in the Water Enterprise CIP with a total budget of $3.3 billion, 33% complete, with $1 billion expended and $30 million spent in Q3. Key updates included the Sunol ozone project reaching 95% design, Harry Tracy filter underdrain construction nearing halfway, and the San Francisco Recycled Water Project facing a 3-year delay due to PG&E requiring primary power for the Golden Gate Park pump station (originally approved for secondary power). Commissioner Stacy asked about the regional groundwater treatment program's alignment with the well findings, and about the Eflocculant polymer feed optimization at Sunol; staff confirmed linkages and optimization efforts. - Water System Improvement Program (WSIP) Quarterly Report (4e): Brian DeSora reported two active projects and one in closeout. The Alameda Creek Recapture Project faced increased costs ($10.2M in anticipated change orders) and significant erosion issues, prompting staff to recommend terminating the construction contract. The project will be re-evaluated and redesigned, with a new contract issued only after pond banks are stabilized. The Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery Project completed Contract A, with ongoing work at wells. Commissioner Stacy asked about interaction between groundwater well findings and the treatment program; staff noted new contaminants (e.g., perchlorate) have influenced treatment needs. - Activities & Events (4f): General Manager mentioned that EPA Assistant Administrator for Water visited to announce WIFIA loans for the North Side Treatment Plant, highlighting the PUC's status as a major WIFIA user. - Item 6 (Grant to John O'Connell High School): Blair Randall and Carmen Ayton presented a request for $375,000 over two years to continue a career exposure and environmental education grant with John O'Connell High School. The program includes externships for teachers, field trips to Hetch Hetchy, and career panels. Commissioners praised the program for its alignment with workforce development and environmental stewardship. Commissioner Stacy asked about measurable outcomes; staff noted tracking is difficult due to privacy but they’ve seen increased awareness and some students moving into SFPUC training programs. - Item 7 (Folsom Stormwater Contract Modification): Derek Adams presented a request to modify Contract PRO.0101 (tunnel design for the Folsom Area Stormwater Improvement Project) by $7.5 million and 48 months (new total: $17.2M, 9 years 1 month). The modification funds engineering support during construction and additional modeling required by Caltrans for relocating the launch shaft under I-80 and for the US-101 foundation. Commissioner Stacy asked about the foundation modification; staff explained piling removal and replacement. President Ajami raised concerns about lack of prior awareness of underground structures, emphasizing the need for better data digitization. - Item 8 (Parsons CM Contract Modification): Stephen Robinson requested a $12 million increase (new total: $47M) with no time extension for Contract PRO.0104, providing program construction management services for the Southeast Treatment Plant. The increase is needed due to increased utilization, including electrical inspection support, safety management, and COVID-related efforts. Staff noted they will use time to consider bringing work in-house. Commissioner Stacy and President Ajami probed the necessity and future direction. - Item 9 (Sewer Inspection Contract): John Wong presented a request to award Contract WW-735 to Pipe and Plant Solutions for $1,998,888, with a 330-day duration, for main sewer inspection. The contract will support asset management by feeding data into the system. Commissioner Stacy asked about how locations are selected (geographic grouping) and inspection frequency (typically every 5-10 years). - Item 10 (Airport MOU Extension): Danny Fung presented a request to extend the MOU with the Airport Commission for two years (through June 30, 2025) with no change to the $3.8M amount, for design work on electric capacity upgrades. - Item 11 (Commercial Clothes Washer Rebate Program): Steve Ritchie presented a proposal to adopt a rebate program for commercial clothes washers, providing up to $5,000 per machine to promote water and energy conservation. The program dates back to 2004, and funding is targeted to neighborhoods with limited access to laundromats. Julie Ortiz noted outreach will include flyers, site visits, and community groups. There are estimated under 300 laundromats in the city. - Item 12 (Zoo Recycled Water Grant): Steve Ritchie requested authorization to accept a $538,051 grant from the California Department of Water Resources for construction of pipeline to the San Francisco Zoo as part of the West Side Recycled Water Project. The grant covers a portion of the $2.3M construction cost. The project will supply an annual average of 100 million gallons of recycled water (307 acre-feet) Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (excluding 5J): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 5J as amended: Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 6 (Grant to John O'Connell High School): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 7 (Folsom Contract Modification): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 8 (Parsons Contract Increase): Approved unanimously (3-0), with direction for staff to explore in-house capabilities. - Item 9 (Sewer Inspection Contract Award): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 10 (Airport MOU Extension): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 11 (Commercial Clothes Washer Rebate Program): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 12 (Zoo Recycled Water Grant): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Closed Session: Commission voted not to disclose discussions (3-0). - Minutes of May 23, 2023: Approved unanimously (3-0). No reportable actions were taken during closed session. Note: The agenda listed item 5j as a consent item, but it was pulled for discussion and amended. The minutes for this meeting were not available; this summary is based solely on the transcript.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on June 12, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shimon Walton and Supervisor Asha Safai. The committee considered several appointments and two ordinances, all of which were passed unanimously with positive recommendations to the full Board. Discussion Items Item 1: Appointment to Sheriff's Department Oversight Board - Proposal: Reappointment of William Monroe Palmer II to Seat 3, term ending March 1, 2027. Palmer, who is system-impacted and on parole, emphasized his perspective on procedural justice. Public commenters Julie Sue (fellow commissioner) and Linda Parker Pennington supported his reappointment, citing his dedication and community work. - Outcome: Motion to recommend unanimously passed (Walton aye, Safai aye, Dorsey aye). Items 2-4: Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD) Public Financing Authority Appointments - Background: The Petrero Power Station project (2,600 residential units, 30% affordable, 7 acres green space) is supported by an EIFD. Appointments: Catherine Dumani (Seat 4), Keith Goldstein (Seat 5), and Supervisor Aaron Peskin (alternate). Both nominees called in from overseas to express support. Walton praised their community leadership. - Outcome: Motion to amend (strike "reject" from the motions) and recommend unanimously passed (Walton aye, Safai aye, Dorsey aye). Item 5: Commission of Animal Control and Welfare Appointments - Proposal: Five appointees: Michael Reed (Seat 1), Michaela Garfinkel (Seat 3), Lisa Irene Fagundes (Seat 4), Jane Tobin (Seat 5), and Michael Torres (Seat 6). Each applicant described their animal welfare experience. Public comment from Vice Chair Ivan Algernoi supported all. - Outcome: Motion to recommend unanimously passed (Walton aye, Safai aye, Dorsey aye). Item 6: Nonprofit Reporting Requirements Ordinance (File 230165) - Proposal: Sponsored by Supervisor Safai, the ordinance limits reporting to nonprofits receiving over $100,000 annually, requires tax and governance documents, and centralizes reporting with the City Administrator. Amendments included publishing information publicly and controller compliance reviews. Controller Ben Rosenfield supported the measure. Public comment: Debbie Lerman (Human Services Network) expressed support but concerns about burden; David Philpell noted threshold differences with existing law. - Outcome: Motion to accept amendments and recommend as amended unanimously passed (Walton aye, Safai aye, Dorsey aye). Item 7: PROSAC Membership Ordinance (File 230482) - Proposal: Sponsored by President Peskin, reduces PROSAC from 23 to 13 members, adds alternate members, allows up to four consecutive terms, and requires experience in environmental justice, disability, and racial equity. Amendments added racial equity (from Supervisor Chan) and encouraged alternate attendance. Public comment: Chair Wendy Aragon requested a continuance; Nick Belani echoed; David Philpell supported the reduction. The committee declined to continue. - Outcome: Motion to amend and recommend as amended unanimously passed (Walton aye, Safai aye, Dorsey aye). Key Outcomes - All five items (appointments and ordinances) were approved unanimously and sent to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. The EIFD appointments and PROSAC ordinance included amendments. No consent calendar was used; all items received individual discussion and public comment.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Land Use and Transportation Committee met on June 12, 2023, at 1:45 PM, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered six items, including adaptive reuse ordinances, park code amendments, awning amnesty, small business fee waivers, and a family housing special district. Several items were amended and continued to future meetings due to substantive changes and the upcoming holiday schedule. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 3 (Park Code amendment): David Pilpel requested that the Recreation and Park Department post a list and map of additional properties subject to the park code on their website, and urged greater transparency regarding rules and regulations. - On Item 4 (Awning amnesty): A caller (name not given) expressed concern about the cumulative economic impact of fee waivers on city departments, suggesting that the committee should include standard economic impact analysis for such legislation. - On Item 6 (Family Housing Opportunity District): Eileen Bogan spoke in opposition unless amended, arguing that the legislation may be a result of redistricting and criticized the process, stating that the Housing Element and this legislation send a message that "the problem is too much democracy." Discussion Items Item 1 – Commercial to Residential Adaptive Reuse (230371) President Peskin presented amendments. Non-substantive amendments included: (1) in Section 102 definitions, adding "other than hotel use" to commercial-to-residential adaptive reuse; (2) in Section 210.5, mirroring the hotel exclusion; (3) removing the word "non-conforming" from neon sign language on page 39. Substantive amendments (increasing thresholds for large projects in C3O, adding portions of C2 zoning for sign permitting, and off-street loading curb cuts) were deemed substantive. The committee voted to amend the original file with the non-substantive changes, duplicate the file with the substantive amendments, continue the duplicated file to the call of the chair, and forward the original file to the full board with a positive recommendation. All votes were 3-0. Item 2 – Development Impact Fees for Adaptive Reuse (230372) Madison Tam from Supervisor Dorsey's office presented an amendment to add a sunset date of December 31, 2028, for the fee waiver. The committee adopted the amendment and continued the item to the call of the chair. Vote: 3-0. Item 3 – Park Code Authorization (230522) Tom Paulino from the mayor's office and Stacey Bradley from Rec and Park presented the ordinance to authorize the Recreation and Park Commission to apply the park code to properties they operate and maintain, including DPW-owned community gardens and mini parks. Supervisor Preston and Chair Melgar raised questions about the impact on DPW properties and the need for transparency. The committee continued the item to July 10, 2023, for further discussion. Vote: 3-0. Item 4 – Existing Awning Amnesty Program (230447) President Peskin, co-sponsor, presented amendments after discussion with the planning department. Non-substantive amendments adopted: (1) limiting the program to "business signs" (a defined term in Planning Code Article 6); (2) requiring signs to comply with illumination provisions of Article 6; (3) allowing applicants to use plans prepared by a state-licensed contractor, architect, or registered engineer (removing "professionally"); (4) adding "physically existing on or serving a non-residential business on the effective date"; (5) deleting lines about existing size and methodology. The substantive amendment (five-year lookback to the introduction date) was placed in a duplicated file. The committee voted to amend the original file with the non-substantive changes, duplicate the file with the substantive amendment, continue the duplicated file to the call of the chair, and forward the original file to the full board. Votes: 3-0. Item 5 – Small Business Month Fee Waivers (230559) Tita Bell from Supervisor Engardio's office proposed amendments to expand the annual May fee waiver program to include business signs for a two-year period (2023–2024). The committee adopted the amendments and continued the item to the call of the chair for further economic impact analysis. Vote: 3-0. Item 6 – Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District (230026) Chair Melgar presented the legislation to create a special district allowing up to 4 units on individual lots and 12 units on merged lots in RH1 districts on the west side, along with group housing. She noted ongoing work with stakeholders and planning commission recommendations. The committee continued the item to July 10, 2023. Vote: 3-0. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (230371): Original file amended and forwarded to full board; duplicated file continued to call of chair. - Item 2 (230372): Amended with sunset date and continued to call of chair. - Item 3 (230522): Continued to July 10, 2023. - Item 4 (230447): Original file amended and forwarded to full board; duplicated file continued to call of chair. - Item 5 (230559): Amended and continued to call of chair. - Item 6 (230026): Continued to July 10, 2023. All recorded votes were unanimous (3-0). The next committee meeting is scheduled for July 10, 2023, due to Juneteenth and Fourth of July holidays.