Public Meetings - St Paul, Minnesota

This summary is based on the agenda provided for the meeting, which was originally scheduled for Monday, December 15, 2025, from 4:30 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. in Room 42 of the City Hall Conference Center. However, the user has specified that the meeting took place on December 12, 2025. No minutes or transcript were available, so only the listed agenda items can be reported. Agenda Items - Earl Street Update – Presented by Bryan Graveline (Public Works) - Bronze Line BRT Project Update – Presented by Craig Lamothe (Metro Transit) and Stephen Smith (Ramsey County) Note on Discrepancy The agenda date (December 15, 2025) differs from the date provided for this summary (December 12, 2025). No further details on the actual discussion, positions, or outcomes are available.

The Housing and Redevelopment Authority (HRA) convened on December 10, 2025, to approve routine minutes, extend parking ramp contracts, transfer property to a church, facilitate a flood mitigation project at Ames Lake, and introduce a Tax Increment Financing (TIF) district for the Grand and Victoria redevelopment. Three board commissioners (Bowie, Kim, and Johnson) were excused from the session. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: Council President Naker moved to approve the minutes from the November 20, 2025 HRA meeting; no discussion was offered, and the motion passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Ames Lake Flood Mitigation Project: Councilmember Yang expressed full support for the proposal. They emphasized the need for community engagement to determine specific amenity features (e.g., bench placement) while clarifying that the project will not result in a playground or a full-blown transformation of the site. - Grand and Victoria TIF Project: Developer Ari Perretts (Afton Park Development) addressed concerns regarding public perception. He expressed opposition to the narrative that the project was unnecessary due to the location's quality, stating that all market-rate projects in the current economy require assistance. He further expressed concern regarding the misconception that this project sets a "precedence" for future TIF approvals, arguing that no project receives TIF as a "given" and that every application must independently satisfy the statutory requirements. Discussion Items - Parking Ramp Agreements (Resolution 25-1908): Director McMahon presented a resolution to extend six parking management agreements for one year. This extension is necessary to bridge the gap until a Request for Proposals (RFP) for new operators is completed next year. The items cover ramps at One Robert Street, 95 East Seventh Street, 316 Jackson Street, 10 West 6th Street, 13 West Exchange Street, 145 East 7th Street, and 477 Cedar Street. - Ames Lake Property Flood Mitigation (SR25-268): Director McMahon presented a proposal by the Phaheline Watershed to fund and execute flood mitigation improvements on HRA-owned land south of Magnolia Street. The project aims to convert a unusable, flood-prone area into a community amenity featuring a loop trail, native vegetation, and stormwater management infrastructure. The Watershed District will bear the entire cost, with no funds requested from the HRA or City for the improvements. Councilmember Yang and a colleague (identifying as an engineer) discussed the value of turning infrastructure into public space, with Councilmember Yang stressing that the design must remain realistic regarding the scale of amenities. - Grand and Victoria TIF District (SR25-269): Jenny Wolf (PED) and developer Ari Perretts presented a request for a redevelopment TIF district at Grand and Victoria Avenues. The project involves a six-story mixed-use building with 90 rental units and commercial space. LHB engineering confirmed the site meets blight criteria due to three substandard buildings. Ellers financial analysis concluded the project requires $2.956 million in TIF assistance to meet the "BUT 4" test (feasibility without public aid) to secure debt financing. The TIF budget includes $2.956 million for site prep and public improvements, with an equal amount ($2.956 million) pooled for affordable housing construction elsewhere in the city, despite the new units being market-rate. Commissioner Naker requested clarification on the mechanics of tax increment pledging (85% in year one, stepping down to 60%) and the source of investment earnings. Key Outcomes - Parking Contracts: Resolution 25-1908 was adopted with a 4-0 vote, authorizing the one-year extension of parking ramp agreements. - Property Conveyance (Iglesia Niclizo Church): Resolution 25-280 was adopted with a 4-0 vote to close the public hearing and authorize the sale of the vacant lot at 77 Congress Street East to the church. - Property Conveyance (City of St. Paul): Resolution 25-278 was adopted with a 4-0 vote to close the public hearing and authorize the conveyance of three parcels in Chestnut Plaza to the City of St. Paul. - Ames Lake Partnership: The Board adopted a resolution of support for the Phaheline Watershed's partnership on the Ames Lake flood mitigation project, enabling the Watershed to attach the resolution to grant applications. A future resolution to convey the land to the City will be required after improvements are completed. - Grand and Victoria TIF: No final vote was taken on today. The agenda for the subsequent December 17 meeting includes a public hearing and action on the redevelopment plan, TIF district establishment, and the TIF development agreement. The project is anticipated to commence in February 2027. Discrepancy Note - The transcript identifies the presenter for Item 1 (Parking) as Director McMahon, but later in the same section, Chair Johnson addresses a staff member as Director Mupin while thanking them for the explanation regarding the same item. The source material presents conflicting names for the speaker responsible for the parking ramp explanation.

No agenda, minutes, or transcript were provided for this meeting. Therefore, no summary can be generated.

The St. Paul City Council convened this evening to address urgent matters regarding police conduct during recent federal immigration enforcement operations, approve several ordinances, and present legislative priorities. The meeting was marked by a passionate debate over the city's response to ICE activities on November 25th, resulting in the adoption of a resolution mandating investigations and a review of the separation ordinance. While many council members expressed strong support for accountability and community engagement, Councilmember Yang voiced significant disappointment over the lack of time allocated for public testimony, a concern that prompted further discussion on future agenda structures. Consent Calendar - Adopted the balance of the consent agenda (items 3-18) unanimously (5 yea, 0 nay). - Items 7 and 14 were withdrawn prior to the vote. - Suspended the rules as requested to allow for discussion on the immigration resolution. - Adopted legislative hearing consent agenda items 28-35 as amended, and continued the hearing for item 29 (Richardson appeal) to January 14, 2026. Public Comments & Testimony - Councilmember Yang: Expressed deep disappointment and frustration that the council did not provide a dedicated public forum for community members to speak following the community's request regarding the November 25th events. She stated that she is "sick and tired" of repeating this situation and argued that the council should prioritize giving space for community members to speak, even on topics not on the agenda, comparing it to her own past experiences as a resident advocate. - Councilmember Coleman: Expressed gratitude to the community for their patience and leadership, noting the urgency of the situation. She highlighted the community's demand for the city to strengthen the separation ordinance. - Councilmember Yang (Secondary): Named the tension of not having clear policies in the "gray area" regarding federal agents in St. Paul, expressing a desire to ensure police officers have clear expectations. - Councilmember Kim: Expressed a desire for a public forum where community members, police officers, and council members can share experiences. She emphasized that the posturing of SPPD in riot gear was "abhorrent" and not expected. - Community Voices: Members of the public attempted to speak during the recess to address the November 25th events but were interrupted by the Council President due to procedural rules regarding public hearings. This interruption fueled Councilmember Yang's subsequent remarks. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-180 (SPPD Conduct during Federal Immigration Enforcement): - Context: Discussed the deployment of SPPD in riot gear, use of tear gas, pepper spray, and rubber bullets against ICE operations on November 25th, which resulted in harm to observers and journalists. - Councilmember Coleman: Stated the actions were "unjustifiable" and a failure to meet the city's standards of excellence. She emphasized the need for an internal integrity investigation, a Board of Peace Officers Standards and Training review, and a financial audit of the event. - Councilmember Yang: Articulated support for the resolution while expressing personal tension about the lack of clear protocols for federal operations in public spaces like libraries and rec centers. She argued the city must clarify expectations to prevent police from being "scapegoated" and to stop ICE from staging operations in public spaces. - Councilmember Kim: Described the deployment of chemical agents as "indiscriminate" and "unjustified." She shared a first-hand account of being tear-gassed and noted that the police appeared to know who was who in the crowd yet still shot indiscriminately. She called for a public forum to hear community grievances and emphasized the need for rapid response training and constitutional observers. - Councilmember Joast: Expressed that the events were "heartbreaking" and "not aligned with city values," acknowledging the dual issues of frequent federal agent presence and SPPD's specific conduct. - Resolution 25-1914 (2026 Legislative Agenda): - Staff presented preliminary priorities due to the mayoral transition. The Council President noted that the final agenda would be presented on January 21st to account for the new administration's input. The item was laid over. - Ordinance 25-4 (Tree Preservation): Laid over to December 17th for a policy update due to the absence of testifiers during a recess. - Ordinance 25-72 (Mississippi River Critical Corridor): Adopted after a long deliberation period. - Ordinance 25-78 (Vacancies and Overtime Reporting): Adopted to establish structured quarterly reporting requirements. - Ordinance 25-79 (Planning Commission Process Improvements): - Proposed reducing the Planning Commission from 21 members to 7 with 2 alternates. - Proposed streamlining the process by moving all business to the full commission to improve efficiency, reduce meeting frequency for commissioners, and eliminate the need for a separate zoning committee step. - Councilmember Coleman and Councilmember Kim expressed strong support, noting the current size is disproportionate compared to other major cities and creates issues with quorum and accessibility. - Ordinance 25-79 (Planning Commission) - Additional Context: Staff noted that the size reduction would allow meetings to be held in the main Council Chambers rather than the cramped basement Room 40, improving transparency and participation. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-180 ADOPTED (5-0): Commitment to: - Conduct an internal police integrity investigation into the November 25th use of force. - Partner with the Board of Peace Officers Standards and Training for an independent use-of-force investigation. - Conduct a financial audit of the November 25th events to determine taxpayer costs. - Convene a public review and potential strengthening of the city's separation ordinance in January. - Ordinance 25-72 ADOPTED (5-0): Approved amendments to floodplain management and Mississippi River critical corridor regulations. - Ordinance 25-78 ADOPTED (5-0): Established structured quarterly reporting for personnel vacancies and overtime. - Ordinance 25-79 (Planning Commission) - STATUS: First reading granted; the item is laid over to December 17th for a second reading and public hearing. - Resolutions 25-240, 25-270, 25-276, and 25-279 adopted (5-0 each): Approved the Ivy Birmingham mill and overlay project, amended spending/financing plans for various departments, and authorized a police grant amendment for the violent crime enforcement team. - Good News/Community Events Announced: - Councilmember Yang highlighted a Hazel Park community dinner on Dec 11 and a library event "Stories of Abundance" on Dec 13. - Councilmember Kim announced a Rice Larpender Alliance winter event on Dec 13. - Councilmember Joast announced a Highland Community Center holiday event on Dec 13. - Councilmember Staley announced the construction of a 5,000-pound world-record hockey puck for the World Juniors in Rice Park. - Action on Public Comment: The Council President acknowledged Councilmember Yang's concerns and stated openness to considering a dedicated public comment section at the end of future agendas, though maintaining the position that meetings should not be interrupted to conduct business on non-agenda items. - Next Steps: A public meeting to discuss the November 25th events is being planned by the Council Vice President's office in partnership with the Council President's office, though it was noted that a formal commitment to such a meeting was not included in the adopted resolution.

The St. Paul City Council convened on December 3, 2025, to finalize the 2026 budget, approve several operational rates, and consider amendments to the Mississippi River Corridor ordinance. The meeting featured a roll call vote on all major actions due to procedural changes regarding recent police actions on Rose Street. Key discussions centered on the 2026 budget's $5.3 ext{M}$ levy, community feedback on the Rondo Community Library, and opioid settlement transparency. Consent Calendar - Adopted consent agenda items 7 through 27 (excluding pulled items 6 and 28) with a unanimous roll call vote (7-0). - Items 6 and 28 were pulled for separate discussion; Item 28 was subsequently withdrawn by Councilmember Bowie. - Adopted item 30: Resolution establishing 2026 water charges (7-0). - Adopted item 31: Resolution establishing 2026 water fees and charges (7-0). - Adopted item 32: Resolution setting 2026 sanitary and storm sewer rates (7-0). - Adopted item 33: Resolution setting the 2026 solid waste service fee (7-0). - Adopted item 34: Resolution authorizing a $828,344 SCORE grant for curbside recycling and setting 2026 recycling fees (7-0). - Adopted item 35: Resolution approving the 2026 Regional Water Services budget (7-0). - Adopted item 37: Resolution approving the 2026 St. Paul Public Library budget (7-0). - Adopted item 38: Resolution approving the 2026 River Center Convention and Visitors Authority budget (7-0). - Adopted item 39: Resolution for the 2026 city tax levy, maintaining the rate at 5.3 ext{M} (7-0). - Adopted item 40: Resolution adopting the 2026 city budget as amended (7-0). - Adopted item 45: Resolution approving the second amended restated spending plan for various TIF districts (7-0). - Adopted item 46: Resolution amending the 2025 regional water services budget for $600,000 in lead pipe replacements (7-0). - Adopted item 48: Resolution approving a five-year street reconstruction plan (2026–2030) and preliminary approval for general obligation bonds (7-0). - Adopted item 49: Resolution amending fire department financing for $29,333.99 to the Minnesota Task Force 1 reimbursement (7-0). - Adopted item 50: Resolution amending fire department financing for a $4,500 transfer from the Minneapolis Fire Department (7-0). - Adopted item 51: Resolution transferring funds from the HRA to the fire department for Catholic Charities response (7-0). - Adopted item 52 and amendment: Resolution amending the general city budget for a transfer of available balances from the HRA (7-0). - Adopted item 53 and 54 consent: Legislative hearing consent agenda approved, with item 54's public hearing continued (7-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Mississippi River Corridor Ordinance (Item 42): - Alan Torstenson: Expressed opposition to replacing objective height tiering with subjective language, arguing that conditional use permits are the appropriate standard for subjective reviews of greater heights. He advocated for the Planning Commission's original objective height language. - Kiki Sanan (St. Paul Bird Alliance): Expressed concern regarding the removal of bird-safe requirements. The speaker stated that the proposed language removes protections for migratory birds, calling window collisions an "ecological catastrophe" and urging the inclusion of bird-safe zoning codes, citing successful implementations in San Francisco and Madison, Wisconsin. - Dr. Bibi Newman: Expressed deep alarm regarding excessive use of force by police during the November 25th immigration enforcement action on Rose Street, noting the use of tear gas and rubber projectiles against journalists and residents. While the testimony was partially cut for relevance, the speaker emphasized the need for transparency, body camera footage release, and constitutional protections in the public corridor. - Cheyenne Violet: Expressed support for the amendment to remove height restrictions, arguing that current restrictions would stagnate downtown development and prevent iconic projects like the Science Museum or River Edge from thriving. The speaker stated that the proposed subjective tiering aligns better with staff recommendations and promotes a vibrant downtown. - Sophia Lipsad Dean: Stated the necessity of involving the Dakota community in discussions regarding the Mississippi River Corridor, noting that no plan should be enacted without their inclusion. - General Good News (Post-Agenda): - Ms. Coleman: Announced the annual meeting of the Union Park District Council. - Ms. Jost: Highlighted the "Grand Meander" event on December 6th featuring local businesses and community activities. - Ms. Yang: Promoted a youth coat drive by Care for All accepting winter gear and gift cards. Discussion Items - Item 6 (Neighborhood Sales Tax Revitalization Grants): - Councilmember Yang: Expressed full support for the program and its recipients but stated strong concern regarding the late approval timing. The speaker noted shock at the delay, citing unanswered questions from applicants, and demanded greater transparency from the Mayor's Office regarding the holdup, even though the Mayor's office made no adjustments to the Board's recommendations. - Councilmember Coleman: Expressed agreement with Councilmember Yang's concerns, stating the council needs to "do better by our applicants" and thanked Yang for raising the issue. - Item 28 (Rondo Community Library Relocation Plan): - Councilmember Bowie: Stated that the item was being withdrawn due to the Director having approximately 75% of the responses ready. The speaker expressed deep disappointment in the administration's lack of collaboration and opposition to the proposed closure. Councilmember Bowie stated she does not support "nearly a million dollars" of investment going solely toward moving bathrooms. The speaker emphasized the need for a holistic approach in collaboration with a new mayor to maximize funds for the community's needs, which face significant blight and mental health challenges. - Item 36 (HRA Budget): - Chair Johnson: Expressed pride in the budget's intentional investment in affordable housing, downtown development, and historic funding for district councils. The speaker highlighted the restoration of the Commercial Corridor Organization Assistance Program and the establishment of the $5M "downtown vitality fund" to support retail and housing development. - Vice Chair Kim: Expressed support for the budget's focus on economic development, fiscal resilience, and district councils. The speaker thanked the administration for preserving the Immigrant Defense Fund and restoring funding for the CARES unit. - Item 37 (Library Budget): - Councilmember Joost: Expressed excitement about the budget's ability to keep the "Transforming Libraries" projects moving, including the new Hamlin Midway Library and renovations for Riverview and Hayden Heights. The speaker highlighted the restoration of hours at Arlington Hills Library and library collections funds. - Councilmember Joost: Stated appreciation for the partnership with Friends of the Library that supported collections and the ReadB rave program. - Item 39 (City Tax Levy): - Councilmember Yang: Stated support for the 5.3 ext{M} levy but reiterated a strong desire to lower it further in the future, citing the financial burden on residents and businesses. The speaker urged the council to reevaluate efficiencies and avoid duplicating state or county programs. - Councilmember Coleman: Expressed agreement with Yang's concerns regarding the tax burden and the need for efficiency across city, county, and school district levels. The speaker applauded Yang's consistent advocacy for affordability. - Councilmember Bowie: Stated that while she would support lowering the levy if the council had the will to do so, she currently supports the resolution. The speaker emphasized the need to address disparate tax impacts on neighborhoods, specifically citing dramatic increases in the Thomas Dale neighborhood. - Item 40 (2026 City Budget): - Vice Chair Kim: Expressed that the budget reflects the council's values, including investments in residents, neighborhoods, housing, and workers. The speaker highlighted the restoration of the Immigrant Defense Fund, funding for the CARES unit, and the transition to a more transparent budget process. - Council President Naker: Expressed pride in the budget process's transparency and community engagement. The speaker highlighted the restoration of library and rec center hours, the need for office renovations for staff safety, and the support for the St. Paul Port Authority. - Councilmember Coleman: Expressed relief and support for the budget, noting that her priority areas (safe housing, economic development, public safety, parks, libraries) were well-represented despite joining the council later in the cycle. - Councilmember Joost: Expressed excitement that the budget successfully addressed a $23 million deficit without raising the levy above 5.3 ext{M}$. The speaker highlighted the restoration of district council funding, the EV car share program, and the need to re-invest in public works infrastructure like roads and pedestrian safety. - Councilmember Johnson: Expressed pride in the council's efforts over the last two years regarding the tax levy reduction. The speaker emphasized the importance of prioritizing public safety, specifically retaining firefighters and the CARES unit, and reiterated support for local affordable housing aid dollars. - Councilmember Bowie: Stated that the budget marks a "new chapter" for St. Paul and expressed gratitude for the listening housework program which emerged from public safety reviews. - Amendments to 2026 Budget: - Amendment A2 (Opioid Settlements): Adopted unanimously. Councilmember Yang expressed support for the need for coordination and reporting on opioid settlement dollars. - Amendment A5 (Returning Home St. Paul): Failed (3-4). Councilmember Yang stated she would not support the specific allocation now due to the lack of a holistic plan and coordination with the county, though she hopes for funding in that plan later. Councilmember Johnson stated she would not support the amendment because cultural star dollars were used, though she sees avenues for future partnership in city and county affordable housing aid dollars. - Amendment A4 (Library Collections): Adopted (5-2) using Cultural Star dollars to maintain purchasing power. Councilmember Yang expressed support but stressed that using Cultural Star funds is not a sustainable long-term solution. Councilmember Johnson expressed opposition to using Cultural Star dollars for this purpose, citing a desire to ensure those funds reach diverse citywide projects, though she remains fully supportive of library materials funding. Key Outcomes - Budget Adoption: The 2026 City Budget (Resolution 25-1814) was adopted as amended at a tax levy rate of 5.3 ext{M}, with a unanimous vote (7-0). - Library Funding: Library collections funding was approved via Amendment A4 using Cultural Star dollars, despite opposition from Councilmember Johnson regarding the source of funds and Councilmember Yang regarding sustainability. - Opioid Settlement Transparency: Amendment A2 was approved, requiring the administration to provide a report on the use of opioid settlement funds and a spending strategy by March 1, 2026. - Mississippi River Ordinance (Public Hearing): The public hearing on the Mississippi River Corridor Critical Area ordinance was closed after an amendment was adopted to remove objective height restrictions and adopt subjective tiering. The item was laid over to December 10, 2025, for final adoption due to the substantive change. - Item Withdrawals: Resolution 25-1896 (Item 28) regarding the Rondo Community Library plan was withdrawn. Item 47 was withdrawn. - Other Adoptions: Final adoption of the street rate ordinance (Item 41) and final adoption of all other listed resolutions regarding water, sanitation, solid waste, and TIF spending plans were approved unanimously (except for Item 41 which was 6-0, likely due to a missing vote recorded in the text as "none opposed" but six voting). - Next Steps: Final adoption of the Mississippi River Corridor ordinance is scheduled for December 10, 2025. The city aims to transition to a biennium budget process in the future.

This meeting featured the adoption of several resolutions regarding Housing and Redevelopment Authority (HRA) spending plans, tentative developer designations, and the 2026 HRA budget. Key proceedings included unanimous votes on fiscal items and property dispositions. Notably, a procedural error occurred where the meeting minutes indicate Commissioner Kim was absent in the roll call, yet the transcript records Commissioner Kim voting "Aye" on multiple items, creating a discrepancy regarding Kim's presence and participation. Consent Calendar - Resolved 25-1776: Adoption of a second amended and restated spending plan for various tax increment financing (TIF) districts to extend the usage date of transferred increments to the end of 2026, in response to 2025 state legislation. - Resolved 25-1854: Authorization to extend tentative developer designation for JB Vang Partners, Inc. (694 and 680 Minihaja Avenue East, St. Paul). - Resolved 25-1855: Authorization to extend tentative developer designation for Gloryville LLC (1570 White Bear Avenue, St. Paul). - Resolved 25-1856: Authorization to extend tentative developer designation for Rondo Community Land Trust (0 Marshall Avenue and 1036 Marshall Avenue, St. Paul). - Resolved 25-1857: Authorization to extend tentative developer designation for Face-to-Face Health and Counseling Service, Inc. (1170 Arcade Street, St. Paul). Public Comments & Testimony - Councilmember Yang: Expressed full support for all tentative developer designation items. Thanked the developers for their hard work, passion, and determination, noting their commitment to the community and residents. Also expressed gratitude to staff for their partnership. - Council President Naker (Acre): Thanked Director McMahon and the staff for efforts to remove HRA-owned parcels from the authority's rolls and place them into productive use. Discussion Items - HRA Budget Approval (Resolved 25-1860): Chair Johnson introduced the final 2026 HRA budget, emphasizing investments in housing, downtown infrastructure, and utilizing HRA-owned properties. Highlighted the role of Deputy Director Green in identifying unspent dollars and the partnership between the council and staff. Chair Johnson noted she would be attending the council meeting later while caring for her five-day-old infant. - Budget Transfer (Resolved 25-1878): Discussion on amending the 2025 HRA budget to transfer unspent funds to the City General Fund. Chair Johnson explained these transfers utilize unspent "Inspiring Communities" revenue and loan enterprise funds to cover the 2025 funding gap. Required a future report on 2025 year-to-date actuals. - Property Sale (Staff Report 25-262): Proposal to sell HRA-owned parcel at 77 Congress Street East to Iglesia Necrisco Cristo for $2,450 (appraised fair market value). Chair Johnson expressed full support for utilizing existing entities to ensure best land use. - Property Conveyance (Staff Report 25-263): Proposal to convey Chestnut Park parcels at no cost to the City Parks Department, aligning ownership with current maintenance responsibilities during the Chestnut Plaza renovation. Councilmember Naker (Acre) expressed support and anticipation for the project. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-1776: Adopted (7-0). The spending plan for TIF districts was approved. - Resolution 25-1854: Adopted (7-0). JB Vang Partners' developer designation extended. - Resolution 25-1855: Adopted (7-0). Gloryville LLC's developer designation extended. - Resolution 25-1856: Adopted (7-0). Rondo Community Land Trust's developer designation extended. - Resolution 25-1857: Adopted (7-0). Face-to-Face Health and Counseling Service's developer designation extended. - Resolution 25-1860 (Version 2): Adopted (7-0). The final 2026 HRA budget and tax levy were certified. - Resolution 25-1878 (Version 2): Adopted (7-0). Unspent HRA funds were transferred to the City General Fund. - Property Items: No immediate vote taken in this session; the sale of 77 Congress Street East and conveyance of Chestnut Park parcels were referred to the HRA for a vote the following week. Personnel Updates - Chair Johnson: Announced this would be her final meeting until she returns in March from maternity leave. Expressed confidence in Vice Chair Jost and Council President Naker to lead the body in her absence. - Vice Chair Jost: Confirmed leadership role for upcoming meetings and thanked colleagues for their support.

The Library Board convened on December 3, 2025, for its final meeting of the year, where six members were present and Councilmember Johnson was excused. The primary focus was the adoption of the 2026 budget, which emphasized the restoration of lost services through innovative funding and collaboration with the Friends of the St. Paul Public Library. The meeting concluded with unanimous approval of the amended budget and expressions of gratitude for community partnerships. Consent Calendar - Approving the minutes from the November 1, 2025, meeting. (Motion by Council President Naker; 6 in favor, 0 opposed) Public Comments & Testimony - [No public comments were recorded during this session.] Discussion Items - 2026 Budget Adoption (Resolution 25-1862): - Director Hartman presented the budget, noting the restoration of the 0.8 library associate position to maintain regular hours at the Arlington Hills Library. He highlighted that while general expenses face reductions in 2026, the budget reflects strategic shifts. He explicitly credited the Friends of the St. Paul Public Library for covering the "Read Brave" program, providing an additional $40,000 for library materials collection, and supporting $10 million in the "Transforming Libraries Initiative" (renovations and technology). He also noted the Friends' annual $800,000 general giving. - Council President Baker expressed strong support for restoring critical services that were initially threatened with cuts in the mayor's original proposal, crediting innovative resource management and budget tightening for the successful outcome. - Councilman Bowie echoed gratitude for restoring hours and acknowledged the proactive funding secured for "Halikue Brown." He emphasized the library's role in providing access to computers, Wi-Fi, and printing for the community. - Councilman Ring voiced deep concern regarding safety following a recent ICE incident at the Arlington Hills Library. He stated he is "very worried" and "concerned" about libraries becoming unwelcoming spaces and committed to developing collective plans to ensure families feel safe entering libraries. He thanked the Friends for their consistent support. - Councilmember Kim affirmed excitement for the "Transforming Libraries" projects, specifically noting the imminent opening of the Hammond Midway Library next year. He highlighted the critical impact on residents when library hours are removed, whether for books or computer access. Key Outcomes - Adoption of 2026 Budget: Resolution 25-1862 was adopted as amended (Version Two). (Motion by Council Vice President Kim; 6 in favor, 0 opposed) - Service Restoration: The budget successfully restores the 0.8 library associate position and maintains purchasing power for library materials. - Funding Secured: The Friends of the St. Paul Public Library have committed to funding the "Read Brave" program, providing a $40,000 gap supplement for materials, and contributing $10 million toward the "Transforming Libraries" renovations. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned as the final session of the year, with the committee scheduling a return in January.

The St. Paul City Council convened for its first meeting of November to address three primary agenda items: adopting the October HRA meeting minutes, considering amendments to the 2026-2027 Qualified Allocation Plan (QAP) for downtown housing development, and approving a covenant release followed by a staff report on the Ramsey Hill Apartments loan extension. While the consent calendar items were unanimously approved, the QAP amendment sparked significant debate regarding the reduction of long-term affordability requirements in the downtown district, resulting in a 5-2 vote in favor of the resolution. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The minutes of the October 25, 2025, HRA meeting were unanimously approved upon a motion by Commissioner Yang (7-0). - Covenant Release: Resolution 25-1709 authorizing the release of the 4D affordable housing incentive program covenant for 1048 Central Avenue West was unanimously approved upon a motion by Commissioner Bowie (7-0) to allow the property owner to sell to St. Peter Clavier Church. Public Comments & Testimony - None Recorded: The transcript does not contain any public comments or testimony from external members of the public; all comments were delivered by Council Members, Staff, and the project sponsor (Trellis Co.) during executive sessions of the agenda items. Discussion Items - Amendments to the 2026-2027 QAP (Item 2): - Director McMahon (Staff): Explained that the amendment allows for increased capacity to support additional housing development in downtown St. Paul, specifically utilizing the 4% Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC). The change reduces the minimum affordability requirement for downtown projects from 30 years to 15 years to facilitate developments that would otherwise require substantial public subsidies. The Director noted this applies only to downtown for the 2026-2027 cycle, with a mandatory review in two years. - Council President Johnson (Position: Opposition): Stated she could not support the amendment because it reduces the long-standing 30-year affordability commitment to 15 years, which she deemed "regressive." She highlighted data showing a significant gap in affordable housing downtown as projects roll off between 2035 and 2040, arguing that reducing the term exacerbates this future crisis. She noted this is the only city in the country making such a change. - Commissioner Naker (Position: Support): Argued that the amendment is not a "backdoor" to eliminate citywide 30-year requirements but rather a strategic tool to leverage federal resources for more affordable housing downtown. She positioned the change as a necessary step to prevent market-rate conversions that would otherwise occur and emphasized that the HRA has historically invested in keeping properties affordable after their initial terms expire. - Commissioner Yates (Position: Support): Expressed support for the limited downtown application of the change, citing the high costs of office-to-housing conversions and the need to avoid reliance on TIF (Tax Incremental Financing), which she believes would negatively impact financial stability. She framed the vote as rooted in "hope" for future results and the utilization of other city tools like permit waivers. - Vice Chair Coleman (Position: Support): Supported the amendment as a tailored approach to growing the tax base and housing stock while ensuring economic justice. She emphasized the urgent need to incentivize expensive downtown projects without solely relying on scarce city dollars. - Commissioner Bowie (Position: Support): Echoed support for the innovation the QAP provides, noting community concerns over city subsidies and TIF. He viewed the two-year duration as a low-risk trial to activate affordable housing downtown. - Commissioner Kim (Position: Opposition): Joined Council President Johnson in opposing the measure, aligning with concerns regarding the reduction of long-term affordability tenure. - Ramsey Hill Apartments Staff Report (Item 4): - Director McMahon and Libby Logsdon (Staff): Presented a request to extend the CDBG loan maturity date for Ramsey Hill Apartments from December 21, 2025, to December 15, 2031. This extension aligns with the HRA's existing HOME loan term to maintain affordability while the developer (Trellis Co.) secures additional financing for rehabilitation. - Melinda Studer (Trellis Co.): Stated that the extension is critical to preserve the property's affordability and address critical physical needs. She noted the project has secured 13 new project-based vouchers and a $1.4 million gap funding commitment from the City of St. Paul, contingent on future state funding awards. - Commissioner Bowie (Discussion): Expressed support for the project and the goal of sustaining affordability but requested specific technical details regarding the next steps for the loan extension confirmation, which staff indicated would be finalized in a separate vote next week. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-1706 Adopted: The resolution endorsing amendments to the 2026-2027 QAP was adopted with a vote tally of 5 in favor and 2 opposed. The "No" votes were Cast by Chair Johnson and Commissioner Kim. - Resolution 25-1709 Adopted: The resolution to release the restrictive covenant on 1048 Central Avenue was adopted unanimously (7-0). - Ramsey Hill Apartments Item: The item was accepted as a staff report to be brought to a formal vote during the next meeting (December 2025) following the completion of the necessary loan agreement details with Minnesota Housing.

The St. Paul City Council convened a special meeting on November 25, 2025, to celebrate the ninth annual St. Paul Business Awards. With Council Members Yang, Johnson, and Kim excused, the meeting honored five outstanding local businesses recognized for their longevity, innovation, community empowerment, and dedication to the city. Council President Aker opened the proceedings by emphasizing the importance of recognizing business owners who have long expressed a desire for formal appreciation from the city. Consent Calendar - The Council unanimously adopted the resolution to honor the 2025 recipients of the St. Paul Business Awards. (Vote tally: 4 in favor, 0 opposed). Public Comments & Testimony - Selection Committee Members: No members of the selection committee (comprised of past winners) were present in the audience to be recognized individually, though their contribution was verbally acknowledged. - Business Owners and Staff Testimony: - Katie Juan (Italian Pie Shop): Expressed profound gratitude, attributing the business's survival through COVID and the passing of previous owners to her staff and the wonderful community. She stated the staff is "amazing" and emphasized the community's support. - Callie Terry (Life Juices): Expressed that the reward lies in community recognition. He articulated a position that urban retail opportunities should reflect neighborhood demographics to prevent capital flight, stating his goal was to "flip the script" on the neighborhood's existing retail mix of payday loans and liquor stores. He emphasized the importance of bringing youth into the ecosystem and educating them on healthy options. - Annie Rose (Lost Fox): Expressed honor at the recognition and a commitment to opening a space that "grows with the community" rather than having the community grow around it. She stated that working with the city and having community space has benefited everyone. - Rachel Anderson (Vikings and Goddesses Pies): Expressed that the award validates the team's decade-long journey of bootstrapping a business from $100 to over $1 million in annual revenue. She reiterated the business's core mission of empowering women and minorities, noting 83% of their employees are women non-English speakers, many of whom have been with the company for years. - Katie Armender (Roots Wellness Center): Expressed that the times are "very challenging" with rising fear in the political climate. She stated the organization is dedicated to providing culturally responsive, trauma-informed mental health services and launching an alternative response to police, emphasizing that equity, health, and public safety are "intertwined." Discussion Items - Traditions Award: Council Member Sarah Jost presented the award to Italian Pie Shop (1670 Grand Ave), citing its 20-year legacy, family ownership, and commitment to community engagement and local donations. - People's Choice Award: Council Member Anika Bowie presented the award to Life Juices, highlighting its innovative self-service kiosk, urban agriculture integration, and role as a health-conscious anchor in Ward 1 that counters predatory retail. - New Kid on the Block Award: Council Member Molly Holman (speaking for Ward 2) presented the award to Lost Fox, praising its 3.5-year growth, cozy atmosphere, and status as an anchor institution in Lower Town. - Alice O'Brien Award: Council Member Molly Holman presented the award to Vikings and Goddesses Pies, recognizing the woman-owned bakery's mission of storytelling through food, equity, and inclusive hiring practices. - Good Neighbor Award: Council Member Molly Holman presented the award to Roots Wellness Center, honoring its culturally specific care, sliding-scale access, and advocacy for community health equity and public safety. Key Outcomes - Five businesses were officially recognized: Italian Pie Shop (Traditions), Life Juices (People's Choice), Lost Fox (New Kid on the Block), Vikings and Goddesses Pies (Alice O'Brien), and Roots Wellness Center (Good Neighbor). - Council Member Anika Bowie noted that Life Juices is the "first store" she has seen with a full self-service kiosk outside of another country. - Rachel Anderson confirmed her business's financial milestone of exceeding $1 million in annual revenue, up from a $100 start. - The selection process involved over 94 nominations and 22 eligible businesses reviewed by a committee of past winners. - Matt Wheeland and Ari Newman (Clear Channel Outdoor) committed to showcasing winners on six digital billboards throughout St. Paul. - The resolution to honor these recipients was passed unanimously.