Public Meetings - Detroit, Michigan

The Detroit Elected Officials Compensation Commission convened its initial meeting on October 22, 2025, to establish leadership, adopt procedural rules, and set the schedule for salary determinations. Commissioner Erica Heel was elected Chairperson and Commissioner Tiffany Jackson elected Vice Chairperson. The commission was reminded of its 45-day mandate to finalize salary recommendations for the Mayor, City Council, and City Clerk by December 6, 2025, subject to a two-thirds City Council rejection. The meeting concluded with public testimony and the adoption of a four-meeting schedule. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Agenda: Unanimously adopted with no objections. - Adoption of Rules of Procedure: Unanimously adopted with no objections. - Election of Chairperson: Commissioner Erica Heel was elected Chairperson by voice vote (4 votes). - Election of Vice Chairperson: Commissioner Tiffany Jackson was elected Vice Chairperson by voice vote (4 votes). - Quorum Confirmation: It was noted that a majority (4 of 7) is required for a quorum, and currently 5 members are serving. Public Comments & Testimony - Shadante Smith (Public Member): Expressed strong opposition to salary adjustments for elected officials. Smith argued that with a projected billion-dollar shortfall and the impending loss of ARPA funding, the city should cut budgets and salaries rather than increase them. Smith specifically suggested cutting the Mayor's salary and noted the irony of sitting City Council members attending a meeting to potentially approve their own raises. Smith advocated for preserving the residents' quality of life over executive compensation. - Councilman Scott Benson (City Council): Expressed full support for a salary adjustment for the Mayor, City Council, and City Clerk. Benson stated that current compensation does not reflect the responsibility and successes of the last decade. He argued that competitive salaries are a critical investment to attract and retain high-caliber leadership. Benson emphasized that the city budget already includes recurring funds to support these salaries. Discussion Items - Commission Ethics and Open Meetings Act: Chair Erica Hill briefed members on ethics ordinances and the Open Meetings Act. She advised against using email threads or group chats for deliberations to ensure compliance, suggesting all communication be public if possible. Hill agreed to investigate the feasibility of creating dedicated commission email addresses to prevent personal email exposure to Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests. - Vacancy Management: It was noted there are two open positions. Chair Hill stated that filling vacancies is the Mayor's office's responsibility, but the current five members (including Commissioner Rhonda Willis) would constitute the active commission for the year. - Resolution on Information Requests: The commission discussed and approved a resolution requesting data from City Council, the Mayor, and the City Clerk regarding salaries, as well as reports from Human Resources on comparable city salaries and historical wage obligations. - Fiscal Impact Analysis: A resolution was adopted to request a fiscal impact statement and budget report from the Office of the Chief Financial Officer to ensure any salary adjustments align with the city's budget and four-year plan. - Meeting Schedule Adoption: Members deliberated on the dates for the upcoming meetings to meet the December 6 deadline. The following schedule was agreed upon: - October 22, 2025 (Today) at 4:00 PM - October 28, 2025 at 4:00 PM - November 7, 2025 at 4:00 PM - November 13, 2025 at 4:00 PM - November 17, 2025 at 4:00 PM (Tentative, subject to availability) - All meetings to be held in person at the Coleman A. Young Municipal Center, 13th Floor. Key Outcomes - Leadership Appointed: Erica Heel (Chair) and Tiffany Jackson (Vice Chair) were elected to lead the commission. - Mandate Established: The commission has a 45-day window (until December 6, 2025) to issue final salary determinations, utilizing no more than 15 session days. - Resolutions Adopted: - Resolution requesting input and recommendations from the Mayor, City Council, and City Clerk. - Resolution requesting reports from the Human Resources Department regarding salary history and comparable positions. - Resolution requesting a fiscal impact analysis from the Office of the Chief Financial Officer. - Resolution establishing the formal meeting schedule and meeting location for October through November 2025. - Meeting Adjourned: The meeting was adjourned with a scheduled reconvening date of October 28, 2025.

The Budget Finance and Audit Standing Committee convened on October 22, 2025, to review financial reports, property tax exemptions, public safety funding, and neighborhood development initiatives. The committee received updates on the city's fiscal health, including a discussion of revenue shortfalls and the establishment of a corporate income tax reserve fund. Public commenters addressed retirement benefits, transparency regarding zoning changes, and the operations of the Land Bank board. Key outcomes included the approval of resolutions to send items to formal for public hearings, the authorization of additional funding for Community Violence Intervention (CVI) groups, and the scheduling of a hearing for the Bagley Neighborhood Enterprise Zone expansion. Consent Calendar - Minutes from the previous meeting were approved without objection. - The committee moved directly to public comment after confirming a quorum. Public Comments & Testimony - William M. Davis expressed a desire for greater efforts to ensure city retirees are eligible for all available programs and requested extra allowances for retirees living within Detroit regarding property taxes. He also emphasized the need for greater awareness regarding HOPE exemptions. - Tara Warwick (representing "Transparency Matters") raised concerns about the lack of transparency, questioning if council members or staff had personally read massive zoning change proposals before presenting them. She argued against rushing these changes before the election and requested that Land Board Zoom meetings be recorded and made available publicly. She noted that allowing the Land Bank to operate under current rules may be shifting decision-making power back to the mayor. - Betty A. Barner (President of the Soda Ells World Block Association) shared information about a caregiver response program (RE:SPOND) offering services like house tours, food prep, and light construction, noting that it serves various income levels and requires a call to the executive director. - Steve Wasco (calling from Chicago) criticized public officials for not answering previous questions. He mentioned the opening of a veterans housing facility housing 25 veterans and accused the board of police commissioners, mayor, city council, and school board of cheating. He threatened a significant increase in public noise and activity. Discussion Items Corporate Income Tax Reserve Fund & Financial Report (Line Item 6.4) - Donnie Johnson (Acting Deputy CFO) and Valerie Agoli (Acting Treasurer) presented the financial report for the two months ended August 31, 2025. They clarified that the new corporate income tax reserve fund ($42 million) was funded strictly from the unassigned fund balance of the general fund, not from the retiree protection fund. - Speaker Position (Committee Members): Councilmember Corley and Vice Chair Young expressed concern regarding a potential $500,000 shortfall in state revenue sharing due to the passed state budget. They questioned if austerity measures, layoffs, or service reductions would be necessary given economic pressures and unemployment trends. - Donnie Johnson's Response: Johnson stated that while they expect reductions in statutory revenue sharing, they do not foresee a need for extreme austerity measures, layoffs, or service reductions. He emphasized that reserves and safeguards built over the last decade protect the city. He also noted that the city is on track to spend all ARPA funds by the December 31, 2026 deadline. - Revenue Projections: The committee discussed a projected $61.1 million shortfall in municipal income tax, which the team expects to be partially offset by overperformance in wagering taxes. Treasurer Agoli cautioned that wagering taxes are volatile and cannot be relied upon to fill the entire income tax gap. Property Tax Exemptions (Lines 6.2 & 6.3) - Willie Donwell (Director, Property Assessment Board of Review) explained amendments to the 2025 and 2026 homeowner property exemption processes. The changes allow for the review of prior-year applications for homeowners who missed the original deadline, provided they did not previously file and were denied. This is to accommodate the new state statute (Public Act 191). - Committee Action: Vice Chair Young requested clarifications on grammatical errors (scrivener's errors) to be corrected before the items were sent to formal. Public Safety Funding & CVI (Line Item 6.6) - Donnie Johnson introduced a resolution to authorize supplemental public safety funding for Community Violence Intervention (CVI). The state has allocated approximately $10.6 million, with 25% ($2.6 million) earmarked for non-law enforcement public safety expenditures like CVI. - Committee Position (Member Santiago Romero): Expressed concern that 75% of the funds might be restricted to law enforcement. She asked if the city could use the remaining 75% to free up general fund dollars for community investments or shelters, rather than simply adding to the police budget. - Committee Position (Vice Chair Young): Questioned whether analysis exists regarding the cost savings or lives saved by CVI programs. He suggested a study on economic impacts like property value increases in intervention areas. Johnson agreed to explore this analysis. - Donnie Johnson's Clarification: The 25% is specifically for non-law enforcement (CVI). The remaining 75% is for public safety purposes (primarily law enforcement), though the exact boundaries are still being analyzed. He noted the funding is largely one-time and emphasized the need to avoid creating recurring expenses that cannot be sustained if state funding stops. Neighborhood Enterprise Zone Expansion (Line Item 6.5) - Alvin Horn (Deputy CFO and Assessor) discussed a request to expand the Bagley Neighborhood Enterprise Zone (NEZ). The expansion would add 499 parcels, bringing the total to 1,412 parcels and a new potential qualifying area of 255 homestead exemptions. - Committee Position (Vice Chair Young): Expressed satisfaction that the expansion would not exceed the 15% state limit (currently at 13.78%) and noted Bagley is a smaller zone compared to others. - Committee Action: The committee moved to set a public hearing for the expansion on November 5th (the day after the election) to accommodate the legislative calendar before the end of the fiscal year. Willis Street Apartments PILOT Program (Line Item 6.7) - Michelle Oberholser Zimmerman (Housing and Revitalization Department) presented a pilot program for the Willis Street Apartments to replace an existing NEZ abatement. Under the pilot, all 10 units will be rent-restricted (80% AMI), compared to the current abatement where 8 units are market rate. - Committee Position (Member Corley): Asked if the Wayne County Treasurer has opted out of the pilot. The department confirmed that the county has not yet decided, though they expect to opt out based on past precedents. Key Outcomes - Line Item 6.1: Sent to formal for the introduction of an ordinance to reserve budget allocations for incoming elected officials. - Line Item 6.2: Sent to formal with a recommendation to approve the 2025 property exemption amendment (pending scrivener's corrections). - Line Item 6.3: Sent to formal with a recommendation to approve the 2026 property exemption guidelines. - Line Item 6.4: Received and filed; the committee noted the financial outlook and confirmed the city is managing revenue shortfalls without austerity. - Line Item 6.5: Approved to send the Bagley NEZ expansion request to formal and set a public hearing for November 5th. - Line Item 6.6: Sent to formal with a recommendation to approve supplemental public safety funding for CVI, with instructions to continue analyzing the usage of the remaining 75% of the state allocation. - Line Item 6.7: Sent to formal with a recommendation to approve the Willis Street Apartments PILOT program. - Public Notices: The committee scheduled virtual meetings and policy sessions regarding the HOPE program and voting education for the upcoming election period.

This meeting of the Detroit City Council covered general public comments addressing concerns regarding environmental health, municipal corruption, voter integrity, and police accountability, followed by deliberation on pending litigation settlements, legal representation for city employees, and the scheduling of a special session for a public appeal. Consent Calendar - Members of the public expressed a range of positions: Mr. Holloway sought clarification on the status of an East Side crisis and home improvement grants; Mr. Davis expressed full support for a domestic violence task force and advocated for stricter alcohol testing for police, while opposing the city's indemnification policies; "Owner Papa" expressed strong opposition to the use of county jail addresses for voting, alleged misappropriation of ARPA funds, and criticized the direction of city spending; "Caller ending in 482" accused specific council members of election theft and "televen" (likely "teaming up") for years; "You Matter" expressed sadness that public comments about fumes from the Stellantis plant are ignored and stated full support for investigating the Land Bank for failing to record Zoom meetings, while expressing shame toward council members who voted for solar takings; Mr. Grady expressed support for the minority business Gyanga Company; Ms. Love demanded representation and improved safety on the people mover; "Not That Karen" disputed claims regarding a 13th check for general retirees, noting they received no such payment, and requested an investigation. - The Chair responded to several public points: confirming a neighborhood beautification grant for the Stellantis impact area is open until October 24th; confirming a second $10 million allotment for retirees is in motion; clarifying that MCL 168.758B and MCL 168.492A allow absentee voting for individuals detained in the county jail; and reaffirming a commitment to addressing Land Bank board residency and recording issues via an upcoming intergovernmental agreement. Discussion Items - Voting Rights (Line Item 5.1): The Council discussed a memorandum regarding the voting rights of individuals in county jail. Councilmember Waters sought clarification on whether the law specifically requires a 30-day detention period. City Attorney Anderson agreed to locate and highlight the specific statutory language regarding the address requirement for absentee ballots. - Legal Indemnification (Line Item 5.4): Councilmember Callaway raised concerns regarding a data analyst, John Grover, who allegedly lives in Novi and drives a city-leased vehicle to his home, characterizing this as an unjustified perk where the city pays insurance for a Detroit address. He moved for a closed session to investigate the facts of the accident and whether the employee was on city business. - Appeal of Suspension (Line Item 6.1): Council discussed an appeal by Gyanga Company LLC regarding an interim suspension related to a complaint about "Dirty Dirt." Due to the need to schedule a hearing before the November 24th deadline, the Council agreed to refer the item to the Council President's office to schedule a special session for both the hearing and the vote. - Risk Management Funding (Line Item 6.2): A request to extend time and increase funds for legal services regarding MGM Grand Casino tax disputes was tabled pending the acquisition of proper tax clearances. Councilmember Callaway criticized the procurement process for allowing contracts to reach the Council without clearances. The item was moved back in one week. - Settlement Discrepancies (Line Item 6.4): A motion was made to bring this item back after Councilmember Callaway questioned whether a sidewalk accident fell under the Police Department (DPD) or the Department of Public Works (DPW). A scrivener's error was acknowledged, and the item was moved back in one week to correct the department attribution and verify repair status. - Body Cam Ordinance (Line Item 6.17): Councilmember Letitia Johnson requested a two-week bring-back regarding questions on the fiscal impact and liability of a proposed body cam ordinance. The Office of the City Chief Financial Officer (OCFO) confirmed a fiscal impact statement could be prepared by Friday. The item was moved back in one week, contingent on the response arriving before the public hearing on Monday, October 27th. Key Outcomes - Line Item 5.1: Motion carried to receive and file the memorandum on voting rights of individuals in county jail. City Attorney Anderson to highlight specific statutory language. - Line Item 5.2: Motion carried to send the settlement request (Donovan Courtney vs. City of Detroit, $99,500) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Item 5.3: Motion carried to send the settlement request (Chineta Yarber vs. City of Detroit, $118,535.61) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Item 5.4: Motion carried to bring the legal representation request (John Grover) back to a date to be determined (TBD). - Line Item 6.1: Motion carried to refer the appeal of Gyanga Company LLC to the Council President's office for scheduling a special session. - Line Item 6.2: Motion carried to bring the contract amendment (MGM Grand tax dispute) back in one week pending tax clearances. - Line Item 6.3: Motion carried to send the settlement request (Advanced Physician Group vs. City of Detroit, $15,000) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Item 6.4: Motion carried to bring the settlement request (Carolyn Taylor vs. City of Detroit, $25,000) back in one week for department correction and clarification. - Line Item 6.5: Motion carried to send the settlement request (Daniel Katzman vs. City of Detroit Fire, $55,000) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Items 6.6 & 6.8: Motion carried to send the combined settlement requests (DeAndre Hayes vs. City of Detroit, $15,000 and Joey Hunter vs. City of Detroit, $10,000) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Item 6.7: Motion carried to send the settlement request (Delbert Relliford vs. City of Detroit Fire, $15,000) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Item 6.9: Motion carried to send the settlement request (Arnisha Taylor vs. City of Detroit, $15,000) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Item 6.10: Motion carried to bring the settlement request (Northland Radiology vs. City of Detroit, $16,500) back in two weeks. - Line Item 6.11: Motion carried to bring the settlement request (Shant and Montgomery vs. City of Detroit, $50,000) back in two weeks. - Line Item 6.12: Motion carried to receive and file the report on unresolved matters. - Line Item 6.13: Motion carried to send the case evaluation award (Lenise Frazier vs. Caymans, $20,000) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Item 6.14: Motion carried to receive and file the OIG quarterly report. - Line Item 6.15: Motion carried to receive and file the report on exploring a domestic violence task force. - Line Item 6.16: Motion carried to send the resolution (cancelling Nov 4 formal, scheduling Nov 14) to formal with a recommendation to approve. - Line Item 6.17: Motion carried to bring the body cam ordinance report back in one week, pending the OCFO fiscal impact statement by Friday.

The Detroit City Council convened on October 21, 2025, led by Council President Mary Sheffield, to address a comprehensive agenda including the awarding of the Spirit of Detroit Award to First Lady Monica Anthony, a detailed update on the City's 20-Year Master Plan, and several zoning and policy amendments. The session was marked by extensive public testimony regarding neighborhood development, concerns over displacement, and calls for accountability. Key legislative actions included the approval of a stadium tobacco ban, the continuation of community violence intervention contracts, and referrals of various reports to standing committees. Consent Calendar - Journal Approval: The journal of the previous session (October 7th) was approved without reconsideration or unfinished business. - Committee Referrals: Multiple reports were referred to the Budget Finance and Audit, Internal Operations, Neighborhood and Community Services, Planning and Economic Development, and Public Health and Safety standing committees as routine administrative actions. - Resolutions: The following line items were approved via motion and vote without objection: 17.1 (Auditor General services), 18.1–18.8 (Lawsuit settlements), 19.1 (Zoning map revision for Rosa Parks Blvd area), 19.5–19.13 (Brownfield plan terminations), 19.14–19.15 (Rehabilitation certificates), 19.21 (Tobacco ban at stadiums), and various contracting resolutions (21.2–21.4, 21.5–21.7, 21.8–21.10 [partial], 21.11–21.13, 21.14–21.19, 21.20). Public Comments & Testimony - Monica Anthony: Received the Spirit of Detroit Award for over 30 years of service and community activism. Councilmember Young expressed full gratitude for her support of her husband and the community. - Betty Lyons: Expressed strong opposition to Councilmember Santiago Romero's presentation of the award to the First Lady, labeling him a "liar" and "thief" and accusing him of supporting "perversion," while demanding justice regarding an alleged $600 million overpayment by residents. - Dale Young: Expressed frustration regarding the proposed billing/development on Van Dyke and Ketchua, citing severe congestion, lack of parking, and a history of property damage. The speaker advocated for resident rights over development interests. - Annette L. Simpson: Expressed intent to sue Council President Sheffield regarding election discrepancies and requested an official audit of the August 25, 2025 election. - Joyce Jennings Phil's: Spoke in honor of her husband, Cleveland Fells Jr., expressing strong opposition to the displacement and development of the Mount Elliott area to build apartments, citing the area's historical significance. - Teresa Davis: Expressed strong opposition to the planning and development for Chapter 50 Section 19 and zoning amendments, advocating for an anti-displacement clause to protect long-term residents from tax-driven displacement. Also expressed opposition to a proposed apartment building on the Butzel Family Center parking lot. - Letitia McCall: Expressed opposition to Chapter 50 Section 19 zoning amendments in R1 and R2 districts, arguing that allowing four unrelated roommates threatens the stability of single-family residential cores. - Denise Copeland: Opposed the proposed development and zoning changes, proposing a "clean clause" to guarantee increased city-funded lawn mowing and sidewalk repairs in residential blocks. - Kenneth Halloway: Expressed opposition to the extension of both bus platforms, arguing they slow down traffic and create congestion without providing adequate seating for waiting residents. - Marcia Kimball: Expressed strong opposition to the proposed development on Van Dyke and Kirchhoff, citing safety concerns due to lack of street lights and the congested nature of the area. Expressed skepticism that the affordable housing is truly affordable for residents. - Toya Watts: Expressed strong opposition to the Request for Proposal (RFP) to build an apartment building on the Fred M. Butzel Family Center parking lot, viewing it as an attack on a community hub used for generations. - Vincent DePaul: Expressed a desire to partner with the city to deliver services through Community Sherry Temple 7 to address unemployment. - Joshua Lemire: Expressed a desire for access to United Sound Studios for young musicians and opposition to the development on Van Dyke and Kirchhoff due to congestion. - Tanya Wells: Expressed concern that the proposed apartment development on the Butzel parking lot is being pushed without proper council initiation and demanded the city address the displacement of a community hub. - Martin White: Expressed strong and vigorous opposition to the planning and economic development standing committee amendments (19.2, 19.1), specifically the revision of the definition of family to include unrelated persons, arguing it does not mean quality and threatens neighborhood character. - Renard Manchunski: Expressed concern that the Detroit Football Club soccer stadium project lacks sufficient transit considerations, specifically calling for increased bus frequency and bus lanes on Michigan Avenue rather than specialized private transit. - Cristana Anderson: Expressed strong opposition to the public comment process, questioning the use of Community Violence Intervention (CVI) funds and requesting an explanation regarding election ballot practices. - Riley: Expressed dissatisfaction with the performance of District 3 leadership and called for a new face on the Council. - Miko A. Williams: Expressed concern for the health of Malik Shabbaz and warned council members against voting for candidate Renata Miller based on campaign conduct and tax issues. - Cindy Dara: Expressed strong opposition to the current property tax strategy, predicting widespread gentrification and displacement if tax laws are not changed to protect current residents. - Ryan: Expressed strong opposition to the current leadership and the University of Michigan alumni network, urging support for Ken Locke over Mary Sheffield. Discussion Items - Spirit of Detroit Award: Councilmember Young presented the award to First Lady Monica Anthony, citing her extensive service as a faith-based activist, founder of the Gladys M. Rice Health Center, and NAACP member. - City Master Plan Update: Planning Director Alexa Bush and Deputy Director Darrow Byrne presented the 20-year Master Plan update. They outlined the vision "Detroit will be a city of choice and opportunity" and established four primary goals: improve quality of life, grow the economy, focus density to support services, and make it safer and easier to get around. The team emphasized the next phase involves community engagement on land use and place types. - Councilmember Santiago Ramiro requested the planning team visit District 6 to address local needs and plan investments. - Councilmember Johnson emphasized the need to integrate Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) into plans for neighborhood commercial corridors and expressed hope that "Complete Streets" would be part of the agenda. - Chapter 50 Zoning Amendments (Line Item 19.2): Council President Pro Tem Tim Tate James moved to postpone this item for one week to address public confusion and misinformation. Director Ty Todd clarified that the amendments include provisions for utilizing municipal parking for commercial corridors and allowing conditional lofts in non-residential structures in R1/R2 districts, explicitly stating these were not intended to allow short-term rentals in private residential garages. Councilmember Benson requested further education on why a motion to remove a specific parking credit provision was not enacted, while Councilmember Young questioned the high cost of parking construction. - Stadium Tobacco Ban (Line Item 22/21.1): Councilmember Durhaw introduced an ordinance prohibiting smokeless tobacco, alternative nicotine products, and other tobacco products at stadiums or sports arenas. Councilmember Young expressed opposition, arguing that adults should have the right to chew tobacco in private or public spaces, while Councilmember Callaway and Councilmember Durhaw countered that the behavior directly impacts youth who mimic what they see, citing the link between chewing tobacco and mouth cancer. - Community Violence Intervention (CVI) Contracts (Line Items 21.8–21.10): Councilmember Santiago Romero moved to approve contracts for Detroit People's Community (21.9) and Force Detroit Incorporated (21.10) and requested a one-week postponement for the contract with Detroit Friends and Family (21.8) due to outstanding questions. - Estate Planning: Councilmember Benson introduced a resolution recognizing National Estate Planning Awareness Month. Darcia Darkell Love from the Housing and Revitalization Department explained the program's goal to build generational wealth and rectify historical injustices by providing free estate planning services, noting that 76% of African Americans lack wills. Key Outcomes - Line Item 19.1 (Zoning Map Revision): Reconsidered and approved by a roll call vote of 9 yes, 0 no, revising zoning classifications in the Rosa Parks Blvd area. - Line Item 19.2 (General Zoning Text Amendment): Postponed by one week to allow for further public education and clarification regarding parking credits and loft definitions. - Line Item 19.1 (Reconsideration): Reconsidered and approved by a roll call vote of 9 yes, 0 no. - Line Item 19.21 (Stadium Tobacco Ban): Approved by a roll call vote of 7 yes, 2 no (Councilmember Young and Santiago Romero voted no). - Line Item 21.8 (CVI Contract Extension): Postponed by one week for further discussion; Lines 21.9 and 21.10 approved. - Line Item 21.20 (Estate Planning Resolution): Approved with a request for a waiver. - Line 21.14 (Freeway Trash Pickup): Approved with a request for a waiver. - Line 21.18–21.19 (Sign Permits): Approved with requests for waivers. - Line 21.21 (Resolutions 32.1–32.6): All approved. - Directives/Next Steps: - The Law Department and Lincoln Place Development (LPD) were directed to provide a report on whether ordinances exist to prohibit vaping and marijuana use on city property (specifically precincts and fire departments). - The Planning Department was instructed to appear at the postponed hearing next week with staff to clarify the Chapter 50 text amendments. - The CVI contract with Detroit Friends and Family (21.8) was delayed for one week. - The 13th check controversy regarding general retirees was raised by public commenters during the session, with Councilmember Waters clarifying that only Police and Fire received the 13th check, not general retirees. - Public records were requested regarding the relationship between Council President Sheffield and Mark Sever, and the influence of the University of Michigan alumni network. - Council President Sheffield announced a virtual meeting for the HOPE Program for November 7th deadline preparation scheduled for October 22nd.

The Detroit City Council convened on October 21, 2025, presided over by Council President Mary Sheffield. The session featured the presentation of the Spirit of Detroit Award to Monica Anthony, an update on the city's 20-year Master Plan, extensive public testimony regarding development and zoning, and several legislative actions including the approval of a smokeless tobacco ban at stadiums and resolutions related to estate planning and community contracts. Consent Calendar - Approval of the Journal of the session from Tuesday, October 7th. - Approval of resolutions for contract amendments related to auditing services (Line 17.1), NEZ certificates (Line 17.2), lawsuit settlements (Lines 18.1-18.8), community violence intervention contracts (Lines 21.9, 21.10), and various other service contracts (Lines 21.2-21.4, 21.5-21.7, etc.). - Approval of routine departmental reports referred to their respective standing committees. Public Comments & Testimony - Betty Lyons: Spoke in support of Monica Anthony's recognition but launched a severe attack on Mayor Duggan, accusing him of theft and favoritism toward Dan Gilbert, while condemning the LGBTQ+ community and labeling the Spirit of Detroit Award as "evil" when given to LGBTQ+ leaders. Council President Sheffield noted that Councilmember Santiago Romero would defend the award to LGBTQ+ leaders. - Rose Lyons: Questioned who would act as a "hero" to recover alleged misappropriated funds related to a $600 million over-assessment. - Dale Young: Opposed a proposed building on Van Dyke and Ketchum streets, citing congestion and a lack of required parking. expressed frustration with how the development process was handled previously. - Annette Simpson: Stated she is suing Council President Mary Sheffield regarding discrepancies in the August 2025 election and requested an audit. - Teresa Davis: Advocated for an anti-displacement clause to stabilize property taxes for long-term residents and opposed the "Arrival" development on Fred M. Butzel Family Center parking lot, citing 271 petitioners against it. - Letitia McCall: Opposed Chapter 50, Section 19 zoning amendments in R1 and R2 districts, arguing they threaten single-family stability. - Denise Copeland: Proposed a "clean clause" to increase city-funded lawn mowing on vacant lots and opposed the Arrival development. - Ann Goulet: Requested a charter amendment requiring all elected and appointed officials to take an oath of office supporting the City Charter. - Walker Brown: Opposed new bus platforms, arguing they slow traffic; suggested adding benches for waiting riders instead. - Kenneth Holloway: Requested the placement of Black vendors at downtown events and criticized Mayor Duggan's handling of Eastside projects. - Fidel L.: Accused the City Council of being "corrupt and moral" (corrupted), criticized the three women-led planning committee, and demanded accountability regarding the "butzel" issue and property tax restitution. - Marcia Kimball: Opposed the Arrival development due to traffic congestion in the Kirchhoff/Ketchum area and lack of street lights; criticized the unsanitary conditions of a local restaurant. - Cynthia Perry: Opposed the development on "Bustle" (Butzel) parking lot, citing rising taxes and questioning the intent to dictate neighborhood changes. - Toya Watts: Strongly opposed the RFP for an apartment building on the Fred M. Butzel Family Center lot, emphasizing the center's generational use as a community hub. - Martin White: Vigorously protested zoning amendments regarding the definition of family, warning that increasing the number of unrelated persons per household (to four) effectively legalizes boarding houses. - Vincent DePaul: Requested partnership opportunities for his unemployment training organization, Community Shelter Temple 7. - Joshua Lamir: Expressed a desire for youth access to the George Clinton Wade (Second Avenue) recording studio, which he noted is underutilized. - Renard Boshanski: Advocated for increased bus frequency and dedicated bus lanes on Michigan Avenue to support the Detroit FC soccer stadium project, rather than specialized private transit. - Cristana Anderson: Demanded answers regarding funding sources for community intervention groups and voter suppression on ballots; expressed support for officials taking an oath to the Charter. - Cindy Dara: Predicted gentrification if property tax reforms are not implemented; promoted the concept of rank-choice voting. - Riley: Criticized Councilmember Benson's staff for an empty campaign bag and called for new leadership in District 3, endorsing Crassina Anderson. - Miko A. Williams: Clarified that Reverend Kenlock did not endorse martial law and warned neighbors against voting for Renata Miller. Discussion Items - Spirit of Detroit Award: Councilmember Colt Young presented the award to First Lady Monica Anthony. In her acceptance speech, Anthony expressed gratitude for her 40+ years in Detroit, noting the city's transformation into a "renaissance city" and a "haven for black people." - Master Plan Update: Planning Director Alexa Bush and Deputy Director Darrow Byrne presented a status report on the city's 20-year Master Plan. - Status: The plan is currently in the draft policy phase, targeting a draft release by Q4 2026. - Engagement: Over 2,500 residents were reached via 60+ pop-ups; 500 residents attended policy workshops; 141 youth attended a summit. - Vision: "Detroit will be a city of choice and opportunity," centered on values of resilience, equity, innovation, collaboration, and legacy. - Goals: The plan consolidated to four main goals: (1) Improve quality of life in every neighborhood, (2) Grow and strengthen the economy, (3) Focus density to support services, and (4) Make it safer and easier to get around. - Council Feedback: Councilmember Santiago Ramos requested a meeting in District 6 to discuss local needs. Councilmember Johnson requested specific information on Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) to protect neighborhood commercial corridors and the inclusion of a Complete Streets ordinance. - Zoning Amendments (General Text Amendment / Line Item 19.2): - Council President Pro Tem Tim James Tate requested a one-week postponement for this item to allow for further clarification. - Councilmember Johnson questioned why a provision regarding parking credits for municipal lots (using ARPA funds) was not removed from the agenda despite a prior committee motion, prompting Director Todd to explain it allows businesses to utilize the seven municipal lots developed in traditional Main Street areas to meet parking requirements. - Councilmember Benson expressed concern that the text amendment might allow residents in R1/R2 districts to build "lofts" in garages for short-term rentals. Director Todd clarified the intent is to convert non-residential structures (like vacant industrial buildings) into lofts, not to authorize conversions of accessory residential structures like garages, citing existing protections against unauthorized short-term rentals. - Tobacco Ban at Stadiums (Line Item 22.01): - Councilmember Durhaw introduced an ordinance prohibiting smokeless tobacco, vaping, and other nicotine products at Detroit sports arenas to protect youth role models (chewing tobacco is a leading cause of mouth cancer). - Councilmember Young voted in opposition, arguing it infringes on personal freedoms for adults when only chewing tobacco (not smoking) is banned, though acknowledged the health risks. - Councilmember Callaway and Councilmember Ramos spoke in support, highlighting the direct impact of adult behavior on youth vaping and the support of Major League Baseball. - Councilmember Benson requested a memo from the Law Department to research prohibiting vaping and alcohol use by city employees (police/fire) on city property. Key Outcomes - Approval: Ordinance passed to prohibit smokeless tobacco and alternative nicotine products at stadiums and sports arenas (7 Yes, 2 No: Young and Ramos). - Approval: Ordinance Line 19.1 (Zoning Map amendment for 11534 Woodrow Wilson St. to SD1 district) passed on reconsideration with a unanimous vote (9 Yes). - Postponement: Item 19.2 (General Text Amendment) postponed for one week to address public concerns and provide further clarification on parking credits and loft definitions. - Postponement: Item 21.8 (Community Violence Intervention contract) postponed for one week pending further review from colleagues. - Postponement: Item 20.1 (Request to speak) postponed for one week. - Referrals: Multiple reports referred to standing committees (Budget Finance, Internal Operations, Neighborhood Services, Planning, Public Health). - Public Health: Resolution approved to recognize National Estate Planning Awareness Month, highlighting the program's free services to close generational wealth gaps (76% of African Americans lack wills). - Contract Approvals: Various contracts for HIV/AIDS services, trash pickup, and community violence intervention amendments approved. - Administrative: Hearing regarding the appeal of the interim suspension of Ganga Company LLC and Brian McKinley scheduled within 45 days (by Nov 24, 2025).

The Public Health and Safety Standing Committee convened to review approximately 70 properties on the dangerous buildings list. The session featured testimony from property owners regarding the status of their properties, discussions with Building and Construction (B-Seed) inspectors about required repairs, and legal inquiries regarding property ownership. The committee focused on verifying compliance with safety codes, determining whether properties could be salvaged, and directing owners to appropriate city departments for assistance with repairs, demolition, or ownership clarification. Consent Calendar - Approved the withdrawal of properties from the dangerous buildings list where owners demonstrated compliance with repair requirements or where items were already resolved (e.g., 7591 Santa Rosa, 2063 Taylor, 13320 Wilshire, 7629 Dexter, 13763 Sparling, 7411 Central). - Approved the removal of properties from the list where the structural issues were mitigated or the property had already been demolished by the owner (e.g., 14219 Elmdale, 17601 Chester). - Approved recommendations for the 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 12th, 13th, 14th, and 15th blocks to either order demolition, withdraw from the list, or return jurisdiction to B-Seed for further inspection based on the specific hearing discussions. Public Comments & Testimony - Danielle Wandsley (5937 Cooper Street): Expressed concern regarding a previous hearing; staff confirmed her property was not on today's list and was being reviewed separately. - Camila Wallet (4900 South Martindale): Stated she secured the roof with tarps but requires further repairs; committee directed her to continue working one-on-one with B-Seed. - Mr. Amir (7591 Santa Rosa): Announced that repairs were completed and the property was ready to be removed from the list; stated intent to pull permits within the next month. - Jacqueline Turner (2063 Taylor Street): Confirmed permits to repair were in place and the property was resolved. - Tiffany (6043 Beagle Street): Expressed that while the roof is tarped and secured, she cannot immediately afford full roof repairs; suggested certification of vacancy to the committee as a temporary measure. - Lynn Marie Adams (13320 Wilshire): Via attorney Anthony Adams, confirmed that permits would be pulled within the week following consultation with an insurance company. - Shahida Mohammed (3295 Glendale Street): Expressed a desire to keep the property following a house fire on July 9, 2025; disclosed she is currently homeless but returns to the site 2-3 times weekly to manage belongings; disputed the classification of the property as unoccupied. - Sean (14321 Ardmore Street): Stated he is marketing the vacant property for sale to an investor but acknowledged the property has received numerous blight tickets; expressed willingness to secure openings and remove overgrowth by the next hearing. - Yvonne Murray Madden (17601 Chester Street): On behalf of Strategic Alliance Development Corporation, expressed intent to purchase the property confirmed the listing had been withdrawn. - Maximilian Schuford (7629 Dexter): Representing property owner Alma Richard; confirmed renovation plans are moving forward and the property was withdrawn. - Angela (2943 South Bassett): Stated she is looking to sell the property; admitted that while some sections are tarped, a recent inspection on October 16th failed due to backyard overgrowth; agreed to email photos of completed work. - Hisham (13769 Sparling): Stated he boarded up windows and cleaned debris for this property (distinct from 13763 Sparling) and intended to sell it; agreed to email photos for verification. - Mona Walker (14219 Elmdale): Clarified that the structure had already been demolished by the owner and agreed to send photos of the cleared lot to finalize the process. - Wanda Fenderson (716 Green Street): Expressed confusion and hesitation due to a discrepancy in property ownership correspondence following her husband's death; she is the second wife and has not finalized the deed; sought legal guidance before proceeding with demolition or repair plans. Discussion Items - Occupancy Clarification (3295 Glendale Street): Councilmember Benson and the Vice Chair disputed the classification of Shahida Mohammed's fire-damaged property as "vacant" despite her homelessness, noting she retains personal belongings and visits frequently. The committee decided to connect the owner with the Housing and Revitalization Department (HRD) to determine eligibility for assistance, rather than proceeding with immediate demolition. - Maintenance and Blight Standards (14321 Ardmore Street): Councilmember Benson noted that bi-weekly landscaping does not justify the presence of leaves and debris lasting over a season; warned that if the property is not improved by the next hearing, the committee would be less supportive of retention. - Ownership Ambiguity (716 Green Street): After identifying that Wanda Fenderson is not the current legal owner (her late husband Joe is on the record, with a discrepancy in the mailing name), the committee discussed the risks of a lien if the city demolishes a structure the owner does not control. The decision was made to halt proceedings and refer the owner to the Detroit Immigrant Center for free legal consultation regarding probate and ownership rights. - Deferral Requirements: The Administration outlined six mandatory steps for property owners seeking deferral or demolition orders: proof of ownership, payment of inspection fees, securing openings (boarding), removal of debris/abandoned vehicles, payment of delinquent taxes, obtaining permits, and submitting a deferral application. Key Outcomes - Withdrawn from Dangerous Buildings List: 5937 Cooper St, 7591 Santa Rosa, 2063 Taylor St, 13320 Wilshire, 7629 Dexter St, 13763 Sparling St, 7411 Central Ave, 3771 24th St, 4860 25th St, 1954 Covert St, 18636 Hays Ave, 19531 Ashton Ave, 1268 West Graham Blvd, 13831 Pinewood Dr, 18826 Fleming Ave (partial list based on specific caller confirmations and block motions). - Demolition Ordered: Properties including 19531 Anvil, 19935 Ashton, 5503 Barham, 5590 Beaconsfield, 14635 Bentler, 15751 Burt, 14801 Chicago, 632 Claremont, 19410 Dunberry, 2449 Elmhurst, 10090 Elmira, 8068 Emily, 14330 Evergreen, 18108 Fairport, 15757 Fielding, 18826 Filler, 11106 Findlay, 18901 Fleming, 80324 Slawn, 15504, 14764 (partial list based on block motions), 11407 Hartwell, 9018 Keller, 8833 Manor, 5525 Pacific, 15747 Piercing (partial list based on block motions). - Returned to B-Seed for Further Review: - 3295 Glendale St: To assess housing resources and occupancy status (Nov 17 hearing deferred pending HRD contact). - 14321 Ardmore St: To verify overgrowth removal and securing of openings prior to the Nov 17 hearing. - 2943 South Bassett: To verify photos of repairs (wall patches, overgrowth) and structural defects. - 13769 Sparling St: To verify evidence of boarded-up windows and roof repairs. - 716 Green St: To await legal resolution regarding ownership status before proceeding with demolition or repair directives. - Directives: - Property owners of withdrawn properties must still maintain vacant property registration if they intend to keep the site empty. - Owners sending photo evidence must include all four sides and the backyard. - Wanda Fenderson directed to call the Detroit Immigrant Center at 313-288-9904 for legal aid regarding property ownership and potential liens. - Shahida Mohammed directed to contact HRD for assistance with housing and revitalization resources.

The Detroit Public Health and Safety Standing Committee convened on Monday, October 20, 2025, under the presiding of Councilmember Gabriela Santiago Romero, with Councilmember Scott Benson present and Councilmember Mary Waters absent. The committee addressed a comprehensive agenda including unfinished business on memos, multiple construction and health department contracts, significant public health discussions, and two public hearings focused on a new smokeless tobacco ordinance and dangerous buildings. Public comments covered a wide range of grievances including city services, affordable water programs, and specific concerns regarding the proposed tobacco restrictions. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: Minutes from the October 6th session were approved without objection. - Routine Receipts: Several memos and resolutions (Items 6.5, 6.7, 6.8, 6.9, 6.11, 7.34, 7.35, 7.36, 7.42) were received and filed or approved for new business without discussion. - Deferrals: Recommendations to defer specific dangerous building cases (Items 7.27, 7.28, 7.29) were concurred with by the committee. Public Comments & Testimony - Mr. Foster (General Comment): Expressed strong support for free speech but voiced opposition to government "strong-arming," specifically criticizing the surveillance ordinance and accusing the committee of being "corrupt" and favoring special interests over the community. - Mr. Cunningham (General Comment): Shared details about an upcoming ride-along and a portrait of former Councilwoman Carolyn Cheeks Kilpatrick; advocated for the respect of city leadership and the community's need for support items like hand warmers. - William Davis (General Comment): Advocated for increased health department transparency regarding child poverty and expressed concern regarding the high number of gas stations and liquor stores selling cigarettes; later in the hearing, he expressed support for stricter enforcement of no-smoking policies in public buildings to ensure the majority's health rights. - Owner Papa (General Comment): Criticized the committee as the "most corrupt" for failing to address child poverty despite billions in funding; opposed the focus on tobacco restrictions while other issues like speed humps (generating particulate matter) were ignored; advocated for crime solutions like jobs and recreation centers. - Galaxy S22 (General Comment): Complained about DPW service failures, home tax overtaxation, and lack of representation regarding industrial fumes (Christ); expressed disappointment that city leaders prioritized corporate interests over residents. - Betty A. Verner (General Comment): Provided information regarding a new Medicaid-based program for caregivers and those needing home assistance. - Karen Winston (General Comment): Stated that the Fast Track Resolution for retirees did not help general retirees who were hit harder than police/fire retirees; raised a safety concern regarding a fallen cable wire near a school. - Miko A. Williams (General Comment): Asked for a plan regarding rat infestations in downtown restaurants; accused the city government of corruption and demanded accountability from the mayor's office; stated that public officials should provide resources like bus tickets and water to demonstrators. - Caller 1 (General Comment): Expressed disappointment with Sheckfield and city staff regarding the inability to answer questions about DOT bus shelters; raised a concern about unlicensed individuals poisoning apartments. - Cecily McClellan (General Comment): Expressed concern regarding the termination of the Detroit Lifeline program; advocated for the Affordable Water Now bill, debt forgiveness, and shut-off protection. - Cindy Dara (General Comment): Advocated for approval voting over ranked choice voting; opposed restrictive ordinances that dictate what residents cannot do; noted that while tobacco chewers spit, it doesn't damage lungs like smoke. - Karen (Public Hearing Comment): Concerned that the ordinance penalizes smokeless tobacco users without providing designated spitting areas, unlike the designated smoking areas allowed for cigarettes and vapes; suggested a fair alternative would be designated zones. - Miko A. Williams (Public Hearing Comment): Argued that the ordinance should prioritize vaping and smoking over chewing tobacco; stated that current laws are not being enforced regarding weed and vapes at stadiums; advocated for stricter regulation of gas stations and liquor stores selling vaping products. - Owner Papa (Public Hearing Comment): Disagreed with the ordinance, calling it "not on the people's agenda" and called out hypocrisy regarding the Vice Chair's support for health measures while ignoring speed hump pollution; stated tax revenue should be used to fix larger health issues rather than this ordinance. - Cindy Dara (Public Hearing Comment): Agreed with Owner Papa, opposing the ordinance as another restrictive rule; stated that the city should focus on what can be done together rather than what cannot. Discussion Items - Smokeless Tobacco Ordinance (Chapter 31, Article 5): - Context: The ordinance, co-sponsored by Councilmember Durhall and introduced by the Law Department, prohibits the use of smokeless tobacco, alternative nicotine products, and other tobacco products within stadiums and sports arenas (semi-open or closed areas). It requires sign posting at entrances and defines smokeless products as those chewed, absorbed, dissolved, or ingested other than smoking. - Definitions: Defined "alternative nicotine product" as non-combustible nicotine intended for consumption. Excludes vaping, which is already addressed by other ordinances. Does not impact designated outdoor smoking areas. - Enforcement: Includes warnings, potential tickets, and a misdemeanor charge with a potential $100 fine. - Key Questions: Councilmember Benson questioned the grandfathering of baseball players who used chewing tobacco before the 2016 MLB ban; the chair noted these players would likely still be subject to the blanket prohibition but acknowledged the complexity. - Procedural Note: A request to allow Councilmember Durhall to speak as a subject matter expert was denied by the Law Department due to quorum rules; he instead submitted a letter supporting the ordinance. - Construction and Demolition Contracts: - Items 7.1-7.3: Approved extensions for maintenance repairs (W3 JJ Barney, Angeles Diamond Construction, Gandalf). Funds not increasing for 7.1 and 7.2; 7.3 increased by $500,000 for unplanned new repairs, bringing the total to $2 million. - Items 7.4-7.6: Approved for emergency demolition (SC Environmental Services) at three locations totaling approx. $62,885. - Item 7.7: Approved for Class A CDL training (Michigan Truck Driving School) for $100,000. - Item 7.8 ($15.9M): A contract for sewer condition assessments, hydraulic modeling, and CIP design (DLZ Michigan Inc.). Councilmember Benson questioned the cost ($389k/mile) and lack of cleaning mention in the TEDA report. The Detroit Water and Sewerage Department clarified the work includes cleaning sewer lines, flow monitoring, camera inspections, and resident notification for private line issues. DLZ is a Detroit certified business with a commitment to hire 30% Detroiters. - Health Department Contracts (Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program): - Items 7.9-7.13: Amendments for various contractors to increase funds for HIV epidemic services. - Specific Concerns: Councilmember Benson questioned 7.9 and 7.13 because the contractors (Oakland Livingston Human Service Agency and Wayne State University) are located in Oakland County/Southville. Deputy Director Christina Floyd explained that the federal Ryan White grant covers metropolitan Detroit and funds transportation/services for Detroit residents to access these providers, confirming Detroit residents are the primary beneficiaries. - CVI (Violence Intervention) Contracts: - Items 7.14-7.16: Approved extensions and funding increases (approx. $1M total) for Detroit Friends and Family, Detroit People's Community, and Force Detroit. Correction letters were required to clarify funding sources as ARPA grants must be encumbered by June 2026, but contracts run to Sept 2026; the committee received and walked on four correction letters to align funding sources. - Item 7.17: New Era Community contract held for one week due to pending questions regarding funding clarification (State Budget vs. Grant). - Other Contracts & Resolutions: - 7.18: HIV program admin services (Neighborhood Legal Services) extended. - 7.19-7.23: Various public works extensions and bus wrap repairs approved. - 7.24: OEM transit fleet cameras held for one week to provide a COGS report. - 7.30-7.32: Opioid settlement and transit grant appropriations approved. - 7.37: Resolution regarding Aviated Specialty Services Corporation approved. - 7.39-7.40: Resolutions permitting banner installations by West Werner/Springwells BID and Downtown Detroit Partnership approved. Key Outcomes - Vote: Smokeless tobacco ordinance was sent to the formal session with a recommendation to approve (Item 6.13 and Public Hearing). - Vote: Item 6.13 (Hamelhook encroachment petition) was approved and sent to formal with recommendation to approve. - Vote: Contracts 6.12, 7.1-7.8, 7.10-7.12, 7.14-7.16, and 7.18-7.23 were approved and sent to formal or new business. - Vote: Contracts 7.9 and 7.13 were approved and sent to new business. - Hold/Deferred: - Items 6.1, 6.2, 6.3, 6.4, 6.6, and 6.10 (memos on trash, stormwater, code red, flood, walking mileage, DPD training) were returned in two weeks. - Item 7.17 (CVI contract) and 7.24 (Transit cameras) were brought back in one week. - Item 7.41 (Legal opinion on closing Cronos Concrete) was referred to the Law Department and returned in three weeks. - Item 7.43 (Travel in report) was returned in three weeks. - Directives: Councilmember Benson requested quarterly reports from the Health Department regarding specific HIV service contracts; the committee noted this request for future discussions. - Procedural: The committee recessed at the conclusion of the morning session and reconvened at 1:30 PM for dangerous buildings hearings.

This committee meeting convened to review public comments, approve several parade permits, discuss funding amendments for freeway maintenance, and consider petitions regarding city songs and monuments. The session included significant controversy regarding election integrity and the death of Charmaine McCloud, alongside public service announcements and community event planning. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes of the previous meeting were moved and approved without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - Mr. Rue (Individual Speaker): Expressed strong opposition to current public officials, specifically accusing Councilmember Kenisha Coleman of ballot fraud since 2020. Mr. Rue stated she "cheated in" and possesses the most votes illicitly. He positioned himself as a witness claiming Charmaine McCloud committed homicide and was not a suicide, asserting the homicide unit's initial determination was amended four and a half months later to suicide due to the involvement of Jeffrey Hudson. He further argued that the homicide unit and investigators were misleading the public. - Betty A. Varner (President, DeSoda Elsburn Black Association): Expressed support for residents needing home assistance, advocating for community service programs offered by Deborah A. Royal. She provided contact information and highlighted programs for caregivers, including house cleaning, food prep, and digital thermostat installation, noting eligibility varies (some requiring Medicaid, some income-based). - Unnamed Caller (Resident): Expressed strong opposition to the rapid processing of the Department of Buildings' (COO) massive zoning ordinance changes. The speaker argued this process was disrespectful to residents, questioning if Councilmembers James Roberson and Keith Butler had even read the proposal. They accused officials of manufacturing false narratives and criticized the legal team's advice to ignore constitutional rights to petition. The speaker demanded a 60-day review period for proposals to ensure meaningful public participation. - Unnamed Caller (Aviation Subdivision Resident): Expressed opposition to the "freeway pickup" funding item (6.4) and the general agenda process. The speaker argued that voting on illegal contracts is unconstitutional and claimed the agenda prioritizes parades over neighborhood concerns regarding zoning. The speaker expressed concern over demographic changes in their neighborhood, noting an influx of individuals with different cultural and religious backgrounds, while criticizing funding for English services in areas like Dearborn. - Norel Hempfield (Legal and Policy Manager, We the People of Detroit): Expressed concern regarding the lack of accuracy in official communications about the Detroit Lifeline Plan. The speaker clarified that as of October 1st, the original Lifeline program has been terminated and replaced by a "Lifeline H2O" program (starting date and enrollment process undefined) to be conducted by Promise Network. The speaker noted the new program has only one tier at $34, requires no arrears, and is funded by a $3.5 million allocation. Discussion Items - Line Item 6.4: Freeway Rubbish Removal Amendment: - Proposal: Amendment to increase funding by $750,000 for Motor City Preservation LLC to perform freeway trash pickup, bringing the total contract value to $2,255,000. The original contract is city-funded; the amendment is entirely state-funded (MDOT grant). - Councilmember Callaway's Position: Expressed support for the program's success in transforming commuter views but raised concerns about the $140 million general fund reduction next year. Questioned the funding mechanism, noting the state's responsibility for freeway maintenance and whether the current funding is commensurate with services provided under the principle of devolution. - Alex Weatherup (General Services Assistant Director): Clarified that the additional $750,000 is an increase in service frequency (50% more often) funded by a state grant, not the general fund. Confirmed the city cleans the "Lodge" (I-375) weekly, while the state clears the inside shoulder monthly. Admitted uncertainty regarding the specific historical division of responsibility between state and city for the cleanup and promised to investigate. - Legal Department Position: Councillegal counsel (Graham Anderson and Philip Keller) declined to immediately rule on the constitutionality of the funding relationship, requesting one week to conduct a comprehensive historical and legal analysis of the state's obligation versus the city's duties. - Line Item 6.5: "Detroit Better Than Ever" Song Petition: - Proposal: Petition by Thelma Stubbs Mitchell to adopt the song "Detroit Better Than Ever" by The Four Tops as a city anthem. - Councilmember's Position: Expressed opposition and bias against the adoption due to the personal connection of the speaker (whose father wrote the original song "Hello Detroit" commissioned by the late Mayor Coleman Young). However, the speaker expressed willingness to listen to the petitioner's arguments in a formal session. - Outcome: The item was moved to TBD (To Be Determined) for a later date. - Line Item 6.6: Gateway to Freedom Monument Petition: - Proposal: Petition by Sharon East Sexton to discuss the status of the Gateway to Freedom monument, specifically regarding reports of it being used as a children's jungle gym and the need for renovations. - Outcome: The item was moved to TBD for future discussion. - Line Items 6.1, 6.2, 6.3: - Various parade petitions (America's Thanksgiving Parade, Halloween at the Station, Turkey Trot) were discussed and moved to formal session for approval. Key Outcomes - Parade Approvals: Line items 6.1 (America's Thanksgiving Parade), 6.2 (Halloween at the Station), and 6.3 (Turkey Trot) were approved for formal session with recognition. - Funding Vote: Line item 6.4 (Freeway trash pickup increase) was approved to move to formal session with recognition for approval, pending legal review on the state vs. city obligation. - TBD Items: Line items 6.5 (Song adoption) and 6.6 (Monument discussion) were postponed to TBD. - Community Events: Vice Chairman McCalloway announced a District 2 community cleanup (Oct 18, 1:30 PM), a virtual webinar on property tax exemptions (Oct 22, 5-6 PM), and a Domestic Violence survivor walk (Oct 25, Palmer Park Barneshell). - Adjournment: The Neighborhood and Community Services standard committee was adjourned without objection.

The Planning and Economic Development Committee convened on October 16, 2025, to address a full agenda featuring multiple public hearings on zoning amendments, development exemptions, and property rehabilitation projects. The session was marked by significant public concern regarding the complexity and timing of proposed zoning text amendments, with many residents expressing distrust in the rushed process and demand for greater community engagement. The committee approved several projects, including a community farm redevelopment and a major office building conversion, while deferring the controversial "Housing and Parking" ordinance to allow for additional consultation and the scheduling of a dedicated public hearing. Consent Calendar - No routine consent calendar items were explicitly listed or acted upon distinct from formal hearing recommendations in this session. Public Comments & Testimony - Community Concerns on Zoning & Process: Multiple speakers, including Carolyn Hughes (Caller ID: Owner Papa) and William M. Davis, expressed strong opposition to the consolidation of multiple text amendments, calling the process "fraudulent," "rushed," and lacking transparency. They argued that the committee was prioritizing corporate interests over residents by removing public notice requirements and reducing parking standards. - Opposition to Specific Amendments: Residents from historic districts (e.g., Lynette Roberson of the North End Association) and Indian Village (Ara) expressed fear that allowing "lofts" by-right in R1/R2 zones and expanding "microbreweries" would erode neighborhood character and safety. Caller "Don't Rush Massive Zoning Changes" reiterated the need to separate amendments rather than bundling them. - Support for Specific Projects: Reverend Cheryl Clark and residents of the Broader Tower supported the proposed renovation and tax abatement for Broderick Tower. Martin White, President of the Indian Village Association, opposed the R1/R2 loft amendments in historic areas but admitted confusion as they may have been conflating items. - Specific Project Concerns: Michelle Matthews supported the inclusion of miniature golf as a tool for community connection. Conversely, Tyson Gersh and others opposed the amendment granting credit for public parking up to a quarter-mile away in Traditional Main Street Overlay areas, citing concerns about neighborhood parking congestion. - Calls for Fairness: Speakers demanded that residents be able to meaningfully study the 192-page ordinance texts and requested that the city stop "fast talk" and "fast track" approaches, specifically regarding retiree benefits and the city's financial health. Discussion Items - 10:15 AM Public Hearing (Rezoning for Detroit Farm and Cider & Jehovah Shalom Church): Leandra King and Woodrow Hankins presented a request to rezone seven parcels from R2/R5/R6 to SD1 (Special Development Small Scale Mixed Use) to allow for a youth equestrian farm, cider pressing, retail sales, and a church expansion including child care and event hosting. The City Planning Commission recommended approval. - Public Questions: Concerns were raised regarding water runoff, fertilizer use, smells, and parking. The presenters confirmed the use of no-till methods to reduce runoff, the absence of animal smells due to pasture feeding, and the commitment to ADA-compliant parking and local hiring. - Outcome: The committee voted to send the item to formal session with a recommendation to approve. - 10:35 AM Public Hearing (Sixth General Text Amendment): Staff presented 17 substantive and non-substantive changes to the zoning code, including conditional allowances for lofts in R1/R2, by-right lofts in B2/B3/B4 districts, expanded allowances for tattoo parlors and brew pubs, removal of 500-foot spacing for miniature golf, and changes to the definition of "family" (increasing unrelated occupancy from 2 to 4). - Deliberation: Member Letitia Johnson raised concerns about the complexity of the bill, the removal of public notice for planned developments, and the quarter-mile parking credit provision. She specifically requested the removal of the parking amendment pending further community discussion on walkability and transit. Member Vice Chair Fred Durha supported the changes as a necessary step toward a more walkable city and vibrant commercial corridors, noting the current lack of sufficient parking structures. - Outcome: The committee voted to remove the quarter-mile parking credit provision as requested by Member Johnson. The amended text was then sent to formal session with a recommendation to approve. - 10:55 AM Public Hearing (PA 146 Certificate for Wayne Tower LLC): Representatives from Black Acre Management requested an Obsolete Property Rehabilitation (OPR) certificate to redevelop the vacant 1200 Sixth Street office towers into 354 residential units (71 affordable), a 114-room hotel, and commercial space. The project promises a $71.9 million investment and 333 construction jobs. - Deliberation: Public commenters inquired about environmental remediation (asbestos/lead), traffic congestion near the bus station, and community benefits. Developers confirmed full abatement of hazardous materials and minimal exterior site work due to the nature of the conversion. They clarified that the tax abatement does not replace existing tax revenue but freezes the current tax level during the 12-year term. - Outcome: The committee voted to send the item to formal session with a recommendation to approve. - 8.1, 8.4, and 8.7 (Screening and Buffering Amendment Updates): Director Marcel Todd clarified that most changes to the screening ordinance no longer require public hearings, with only one item requiring future review. The items were initially approved but required reconsideration to ensure the correct procedural action (Receive and File vs. Introduction). - Outcome: The committee voted to reconsider and receive and file line item 8.1, as well as file the responses to 8.4 and 8.7. - 8.2 (Broderick Tower PA 210 Commercial Rehabilitation District): Councilmember Johnson confirmed she had met with the developer and addressed constituent concerns. The item was moved for approval. - Outcome: The committee voted to send the item to formal session with a recommendation to approve. - 8.5 (Housing and Parking Ordinance - COO Proposal): This item, proposed to increase housing capacity by modifying zoning in R2-R6 districts, became the primary discussion point. Director Schneider and COO team acknowledged community confusion, particularly regarding historic districts and the North End. They proposed adding explicit exemptions for historic districts and committing to further engagement in the Lower North End (R3 zones). - Deliberation: Significant discussion ensued regarding the timeline before the election and the inability to secure a public hearing slot on the current agenda due to scheduling conflicts. Member Johnson requested the item be brought back in one week to allow for more comprehensive community engagement and clarification of the amendments. Member Vice Chair argued that postponing by one week would still allow for a hearing in November, whereas immediate introduction was urgent to meet statutory timelines. - Outcome: The committee voted to bring back line item 8.5 in one week to facilitate additional engagement and finalization of the text, specifically regarding historic district exemptions and North End concerns. - 9.16 (Miscellaneous Council President Pro Tem): Request for LPD assignment clarification was brought back in one week pending resolution. - Other Dispositions: - Line items 9.2 through 9.10 (Termination of Brownfield plans): Approved to be sent to formal session with recommendation to approve. - Line item 9.11 (Payment in Lieu of Taxes): Removed from the agenda and referred to the President's office/BFA. - Line items 9.12, 9.13, 9.15: Received and Filed or brought back in one week. Key Outcomes - Approved for Formal Session (with amendments): - Line Item 5 (Rezoning for Detroit Farm & Cider): Recommendation to approve. - Line Item 6 (Sixth General Text Amendment): Recommendation to approve with the specific removal of the quarter-mile public parking credit provision. - Line Item 7 (PA 146 Certificate for 1200 Sixth Street): Recommendation to approve. - Line Item 8.2 (Broderick Tower PA 210): Recommendation to approve. - Line Items 8.4 & 8.7 (Screening amendments responses): Received and Filed. - Line Items 9.2–9.10 (Brownfield terminations): Recommendation to approve. - Deferral/Postponement: - Line Item 8.5 (Housing and Parking Ordinance): The item was not moved to formal session. The committee voted to bring back the item in one week to allow for further community engagement, finalization of historic district exemptions, and negotiation of a dedicated public hearing slot. - Line Items 8.8, 8.11, 8.12: Brought back in two weeks/one week respectively pending responses from law departments and auditors. - Line Item 8.1: Reconsidered and received and filed after clarification. - Removal/Referral: - Line Item 9.11 was removed from the agenda and referred to the Budget and Finance Committee (BFA). - Procedural Clarifications: - Director Marcel Todd and Attorney Anderson clarified that items not acted upon before the end of the legislative term (2025) will fall to the floor. However, if the 120-day viability period remains active, items can be resubmitted to the next council without restarting the planning commission public hearing process, provided they were not voted down. - Public Engagement Commitment: - The Housing and Revitalization Department and COO office committed to holding additional meetings (16 already held, 8+ scheduled) and specifically targeting the Lower North End and historic districts to clarify the impacts of the proposed housing and parking ordinances before the next hearing.