Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1011–1020 ENTRIES
1011
MAY 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - May 8, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on Monday, May 8, 2023, to consider three agenda items: acceptance of avigation easements for SFO noise insulation, a hearing on below-market-rate (BMR) homeownership program challenges, and an ordinance amending the landmark designation for the Castro Theatre. The committee voted unanimously on the first two items and passed the third on a 2-1 vote. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (230401): Acceptance and Recording of Avigation Easements – The committee approved a resolution authorizing acceptance and recording of 124 avigation easements from property owners in San Mateo County for the San Francisco International Airport’s Noise Insulation Program. The easements are required for properties within 65-decibel noise equivalent levels. No public comment was offered. The motion passed 3-0 (Melgar, Preston, Peskin) with a positive recommendation to the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony Item 2 – BMR Housing Program Hearing: - Amy and Simon Jansuk, BMR homeowners, testified that they have been unable to sell their unit since September 2022. They stated the city’s “affordable resale price” ($386,000) is $152,000 below the maximum resale price ($538,000), which would result in a loss of $25,000 after paying off their mortgage and a loss of $90,000 in equity. They said the affordable price policy was implemented after their purchase in 2018 and was not disclosed to them. They requested the city remove the affordable price and allow them to sell at the maximum price. - Jennifer Rosdale, a realtor with 20 years of experience, spoke about the program’s processing times (6–8 months) and restrictions (no rental option) and argued the program is failing its mission. - A remote caller urged the committee to address the situation. Item 3 – Castro Theatre Landmarking: - Steven Torres of the Castro LGBTQ Cultural District spoke in support of moving the amended landmark designation forward, stating 1,000 signatures had been collected in support. - Rob Byrne of the Castro Theater Conservancy also supported the amendment, stating 12,000 people had signed a petition and that a viable alternative plan exists that does not require destruction of the theater interior. - Remote speaker Michael Petrellis criticized both the Conservancy and Cultural District for lack of transparency and financial planning. - Remote speaker Mike Murray argued the Conservancy’s plan lacks funding and a realistic operational model, and noted that at a previous hearing, 85 speakers supported the owner’s plan (Another Planet Entertainment) while 58 opposed it. Discussion Items Item 2 – Hearing on Impact of Housing Market on Below Market Rate (BMR) Units: - Chair Melgar introduced the hearing, prompted by reports of BMR homeowners feeling trapped. Sheila Nicolopoulos and Maria Benjamin from the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) presented an overview: the BMR program includes 2,200+ units across three program categories. Since 1988, 688 units have been resold with an average ownership of 9 years and average equity gain of $96,000 for recent sales. However, average applications per resale fell from 26 (2019) to 5 (2023). Of 64 units with a gap between maximum resale price and affordable price, 46 have sold, 28 at the maximum price. 14 active resale units are above the affordable price, with 10 having no buyers. MOHCD attributed challenges to market conditions, competing new construction, and high interest rates, and noted plans for community engagement in summer 2023. - Chief Economist Ted Egan noted declining housing demand and slowing price growth post-pandemic. - Supervisors Melgar and Preston questioned the policy gap between maximum and affordable prices, the impact of HOA fees, and the need for legislative fixes. Chair Melgar expressed commitment to working with MOHCD and the city attorney to provide more flexibility. Item 3 – Landmark Designation Amendment for Castro Theatre: - The committee considered an ordinance to amend the landmark designation (No. 100) for 429–431 Castro Street (the Castro Theatre) to include interior features (e.g., seating, raked floor) and capture full historical significance. Supervisor Preston noted that no deal had been struck and moved to send the item to the full board as previously amended. Supervisor Melgar expressed concerns about precedent and voted against, while Supervisors Peskin and Preston voted in favor. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously (3-0) to forward to full Board. - Item 2: The hearing was filed (motion passed 3-0). The committee committed to exploring legislative fixes. - Item 3: Passed on a 2-1 vote (Peskin and Preston in favor, Melgar opposed) with a positive recommendation to the full Board.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 58% · PUBLIC COMMENT 17% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 9% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 7%
1012
MAY 4, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting - May 4, 2023

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on May 4, 2023 at 6:15 PM to consider three agenda items: ordinances adopting memoranda of understanding with San Francisco Firefighters Union Local 798 (Units 1 and 2), a resolution selecting independent auditors, and a hearing on a City Services Auditor report regarding United Council of Human Services (UCHS). All items were approved or filed with unanimous votes. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - For items 1 and 2, one in-person speaker made comments about firefighters as "intruders" and one remote speaker (union representative Adam Wood) spoke about the difficulties of mandatory overtime and understaffing. Union President Floyd Rollins also spoke in support of the MOU and highlighted mental health needs. - For item 3, one in-person speaker made personal comments about the audit firm. - For item 4, one in-person speaker questioned the decision to cease funding UCHS. Agenda Items 1 & 2: Memoranda of Understanding with San Francisco Firefighters Union Local 798 (Units 1 and 2) Discussion - DHR Director Art Graham presented: fire department staff increased by 3.5%, but still understaffed due to pandemic; 73 retirees and 7 resignations; wage pattern same as police contract; 2% retention pay at year 21; 2% additional holiday pay; Mother's Day and Halloween added as holidays with sick-call restrictions; emergency childcare pilot; total three-year cost $103.7 million. Average overtime per firefighter was $47,000/year. - Supervisor Chin stated his partner is a firefighter but confirmed no recusal. - Chair Preston questioned the basis for retention pay and requested overtime data; DHR noted the data. - Vice Chair Stephanie praised the childcare pilot. - Supervisor Chan supported the MOU and emphasized mental health. - Union representatives Adam Wood and Floyd Rollins spoke: contract ratified with some frustration due to mandatory overtime; described ongoing understaffing and need for future support. Key Outcome - Motion to forward both items to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendation passed 3-0 (Stephanie, Chan, Preston). Agenda Item 3: Selection of Independent Auditors – Macias Gini & O’Connell LLP Discussion - Controller's Office Financial Reporting Manager Carmen LaFranc presented: resolution to select MGO as independent auditor for the controller's office and separately audited departments; not-to-exceed amount $6.8 million over four years (first year $1.7 million), rate locked. - BLA analyst Nick Menard recommended approval. - No questions from committee. Key Outcome - Motion to forward the resolution to the full Board with recommendation passed 3-0. Agenda Item 4: Hearing on City Services Auditor Report – United Council of Human Services (UCHS) Discussion - Vice Chair Stephanie introduced the hearing, citing concerns about nonprofit contract management and noting $1.4 billion in city social services contracts. - Controller's Office Director of Audits Mark De La Rosa and Project Manager Amanda Sobrepena presented: audit requested by HSH; found 83% of sampled tenants (24 of 29) not properly prioritized; 66% (19 of 29) had incorrect income calculations; three employees improperly enrolled; $108,000 in tenant rent collected without approval; $30,000 not turned over to fiscal sponsor; backlog of unpaid expenditures. 14 recommendations made to HSH. - HSH Chief Deputy Director Noelle Simmons presented: UCHS has had multiple fiscal sponsors since 2009; current sponsor Felton Institute took over in October 2022; in March 2023, UCHS lost state charitable registry status, leading HSH to remove UCHS as subcontractor and transfer all services to Felton. Of the 14 recommendations, 5 are no longer applicable, 6 implemented, 3 in process. - Committee members questioned the long pattern of noncompliance, the selection process for Felton Institute, and the impact on services. HSH noted that two programs are ending soon and federal grants will be reprocured competitively. - Chair Preston asked about whistleblower complaints (not disclosed) and requested quantification of service delivery impact. Key Outcome - Motion to file the hearing passed 3-0. Vice Chair Stephanie indicated she will continue work on legislation to improve nonprofit contract oversight. Key Outcomes - The firefighters MOU (items 1 and 2) were forwarded to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - The auditor selection resolution (item 3) was forwarded to the full Board with a recommendation. - The hearing on UCHS (item 4) was filed. HSH will continue to support Felton Institute in delivering services and will reprocure federal grants competitively. Vice Chair Stephanie plans to introduce legislation for better contract monitoring.

AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE 47% · HOMELESSNESS 21% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 9%
1013
MAY 3, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting on May 3, 2023: Recognitions, Reports, and Policy Approvals

The San Francisco Police Commission convened on Wednesday, May 3, 2023, at approximately 1:45 PM UTC (6:45 AM PT) for a regular meeting. The agenda included officer recognition, public comments, consent calendar, chief and DPA director reports, commission reports, a DPA audit presentation, and votes on several revised Department General Orders (DGOs). The meeting also included a closed session. All votes during open session were unanimous except where noted. Consent Calendar - Collaborative Reform Initiative Monthly Update and SFPD First Quarter 2023 Audit of Electronic Communication Devices for Bias were received and filed. The consent calendar passed with 5 yes votes (Commissioners Walker, Benedicto, Byrne, Carter Oberstone, Elias). Adoption of Minutes - Minutes for the meetings of April 5 and April 12, 2023, were adopted with 5 yes votes. Chief’s Report - Chief William Scott reported: - Violent crime up 4%, property crime down 9%, total serious crime down 8% year-to-date (approximately 1,300 fewer crimes). - Homicides: 17 year-to-date vs. 15 last year (one counted case was a 2004 incident where the victim died from complications). - Gun violence victims down 3% (65 vs. 67) and weapon seizures up by 23. Ghost guns: 39 of 336 weapons seized were ghost guns (about 11.6%). - Two homicides reported: an April 27 shooting on Market Street (security guard shot suspected shoplifter; DA declined charges but police investigation continues) and an April 30 shooting on Folsom Street (victim shot in car, no arrests). - Two non-fatal shootings and a stabbing; a battery with serious injuries/elder abuse was also noted. - Tenderloin: 8,058 grams of fentanyl seized last week; over 47,125 grams seized in 17 weeks; 284 arrests year-to-date. - California Highway Patrol (CHP) deployment: 6 officers focused on traffic enforcement in the Tenderloin/SOMA area; no MOU with SFPD. National Guard role is administrative/analytical support only, not boots on the ground. - Commissioner Carter Oberstone and others raised questions about the security guard shooting, the former fire commissioner case, and the CHP deployment. Commissioner Carter Oberstone expressed concern about pretext stops; Chief Scott clarified CHP was not asked to perform pretext stops. DPA Director’s Report - Director Paul Henderson reported: - 270 pending cases; 26 cases over 9 months old; 19 of those on hold; 7 pending with the Police Commission; 83 pending with the Chief for termination decisions. - Joint discipline tracker proposal submitted to COIT for funding. - DPA seeking public comment on policy revisions (critical incidents, foot pursuits, training plans). - Issued a key issue report on SFPD's handling of officer discipline (holding discipline in abeyance and timeliness of chief’s hearings); SFPD did not dispute the report. - Provided updates on audits, including the 2020 use of force audit with 10 of 37 recommendations still open. Commission Reports - Commissioner Benedicto noted attendance at events for National Crime Victim Week and the SFPD fallen officers memorial; the body-worn camera working group is meeting; DGO 2.01 expected to return. - Commissioner Walker mentioned the memorial for fallen officers and ongoing work on patrol specials, recruiting women, and coordinating with community groups. - Vice President Carter Oberstone announced the first working group meeting for DGO 8.10 (First Amendment surveillance) and plans to introduce a resolution rescinding bureau orders he deems illegal. DPA Presentation: Audit of Department Communications for Bias - Steve Flaherty, DPA Director of Audits, presented the key issue report issued March 20, 2023. - Key findings: - Most communication hits are false positives (99.7% false positive for one period), causing alert fatigue and wasted time. - SFPD did not consistently review or update the bias word list as required (only memos from May 2019, May 2020, Aug 2021). - Not all department-issued cell phones were enrolled in the monitoring system; the vendor was enrolling them on its own, and SFPD had no confirmation process. - Quarterly reports lacked disciplinary outcome details; year-end reports were not issued. - Commissioners discussed solutions; Commissioner Benedicto announced forming a working group with SFPD, DPA, and the tech division to address the issues. Discussion and Possible Action on Revised DGOs - DGO 2.02 “Alcohol Use by Sworn Department Members” – Approved for meet and confer with bargaining units. Passed 6-0. - DGO 2.03 “Use of Intoxicants or Drugs by Sworn Department Members” – Approved with an amendment to strike “may diminish” and replace with “diminishes” (effective immediately). Passed 5-1 (Vice President Carter Oberstone voted no). - DGO 5.24 “Disengagement Procedures” – Adopted for final adoption. Passed 6-0. Recognized as one of the first such policies in the country. - DGO 2.08 “Peace Officer Rights in Disciplinary Investigations” – Adopted. Passed 6-0. - DGO 8.01 “Major and Critical Incident Evaluation and Notification” – Adopted. Passed 6-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Officer Recognition (Item 1): No public comment. - General Public Comment (Item 2): - A speaker (Francisco Naccha) commented on the difficulty of virtual public comment and appreciated the officer recognition. - Paulette Brown, mother of murder victim Arboria Casa, pleaded for justice for her son, whose case remains cold (murdered August 14, 2006). She urged anyone with information to call the tip line. - A caller commented on youth safety, referencing a recent Board of Supervisors meeting, and expressed concern that the district attorney was asked to review a video of an incident involving a young person. Key Outcomes - Votes on DGOs: - DGO 2.02 approved (6-0) to proceed to meet and confer. - DGO 2.03 approved with amendment (5-1). - DGO 5.24 adopted (6-0). - DGO 2.08 adopted (6-0). - DGO 8.01 adopted (6-0). - Closed Session: The commission voted to enter closed session on Item 16 and to assert attorney-client privilege. Upon return, voted not to disclose any discussion. - Next Steps: - DGO 2.02 and 2.03 (after amendment) to be sent to bargaining units. - Commissioner Benedicto to convene working group on bias audit fixes. - DPA to publish additional key issue report publicly and provide full audit draft to SFPD in June. - Commission to agendize updates on Article 25 security guard regulation, CHP deployment, and chief’s hearing backlog.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 35% · PUBLIC SAFETY 34% · PROCEDURAL 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
1014
MAY 3, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - May 3, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 3, 2023, at 10:15 AM. Chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, the committee considered six agenda items, including an electricity procurement ordinance, a contract amendment for tax filing software, an emergency declaration for library repairs, a cannabis equity grant, and two airport lease agreements. The committee voted to forward four items to the full board with positive recommendations and continued two airport lease items to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Electricity Procurement): One member of the public spoke, expressing concern about the increase in the annual expenditure limit from $150 million to $200 million, describing it as "an intrusive amount of money." - Item 2 (21 Tech Contract): A member of the public argued that tax filings should be done in person, not online, and opposed the 10-year contract extension. - Item 3 (Library Emergency): David Pilpel supported the resolution but requested a follow-up report with details and photos of the remediation, and noted potential interjurisdictional issues with the emergency declaration process. - Item 5 & 6 (Airport Leases): David Pilpel expressed support for the resolutions, acknowledging they would be continued. Discussion Items - Item 1 (230281) - Electricity Procurement: The committee heard no new presentations as the item was continued from the previous week due to substantive amendments. Public comment was taken, and Vice Chair Mandelman moved to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. The motion passed 3-0. - Item 2 (230405) - 21 Tech Contract Amendment: Amanda Freed from the Treasurer & Tax Collector's office presented the proposed 10-year extension and $10 million increase (total not to exceed $18.2 million) for the service and support agreement enabling online tax filings. The BLA recommended amending the resolution to correct the not-to-exceed amount to $18.2 million, noting actual spending averaged $815,000 per year against a $1 million budget. The committee unanimously approved the amendment and then forwarded the amended resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 (230315) - Library Emergency Declaration: John Kuha, Director of Facilities, described a January 20 sewage stoppage at the Main Library that caused overflow on three floors. Remediation by Belfour cost an estimated $550,000, with most costs covered by insurance (a $10,000 deductible). The BLA recommended approval. The committee voted 3-0 to forward the resolution to the full board. - Item 4 (230453) - Cannabis Equity Grant: Jeremy Schwartz, Deputy Director of the Office of Cannabis, presented a $1,511,791.11 grant from the Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development for social equity businesses. He noted that over $7 million had been previously disbursed to 60+ equity businesses, with 95% of recipients satisfied and 98% finding the office responsive. Up to 10% of the grant can be used for administrative overhead. Vice Chair Mandelman added himself as a co-sponsor. The committee voted 3-0 to forward the resolution to the full board. - Items 5 & 6 (230204/230342) - Airport Lease Agreements: Chair Chan called these items out of order. The managing director of finance was absent, and Chair Chan had questions about the $800 million operating reserve and capital improvements. She moved to continue both items to the call of the chair. The motion passed 3-0. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Amended to correct not-to-exceed amount to $18.2 million, then forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 4: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 5 & 6: Continued to the call of the chair (3-0). No other business was discussed, and the meeting adjourned.

PUBLIC COMMENT 34% · PROCEDURAL 25% · CANNABIS REGULATION 18% · ELECTRIC SERVICE REGULATION 15%
1015
MAY 3, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - May 3, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on May 3, 2023, to consider two items: the Ten-Year Capital Expenditure Plan for FY 2024-2033 and a resolution calling on the Mayor to fund 2,000 new shelter or temporary housing placements. Both items were forwarded to the full Board with positive recommendations after public testimony and committee discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 1 (Capital Plan): Multiple speakers from climate and housing advocacy groups expressed support for including climate-focused actions and using funds to retrofit existing affordable housing. Speakers urged the committee to allocate newly identified $150 million capacity for decarbonization and preservation of existing buildings. Representatives from housing development organizations (e.g., Chinatown Community Development Center, Mission Economic Development Agency, Young Community Developers) voiced strong support for the March 2024 affordable housing bond, noting the enormous local funding gap of $1.3–$2.4 billion per year and the need to complement potential regional bonds. - On Item 2 (Shelter/Housing Placements): Many speakers representing Rescue SF, neighborhood associations, and business districts urged rapid expansion of shelter and housing. They highlighted the urgency of the crisis, with over 4,000 unsheltered people, hundreds of overdose deaths, and the inadequacy of current approaches. Rescue SF presented a detailed proposal to lease hotels and apartments at lower cost. A formerly homeless speaker shared personal experience and supported the resolution. Some speakers criticized the city's lack of urgency and called on the mayor to act. Discussion Items Item 1: Resolution adopting the Ten-Year Capital Expenditure Plan for FY 2024-2033 The committee heard the item for the third time. Chair Chan noted previous amendments: rescheduling general obligation bonds so that the affordable housing and shelter bond would be on the March 2024 ballot ($340 million) and the public health and shelter bond on November 2024 ($320 million). An additional $150 million in capacity was identified. Committee discussion included: - President Peskin endorsed the plan, emphasizing the importance of adaptive reuse of existing buildings for climate goals and noting that delaying the public health bond made policy sense. He also linked this to the work of the Technical Advisory Committee on inclusionary housing. - Supervisor Ronan, who had previously dissented, stated she would now support the plan but emphasized the need for more information about the regional bond and expressed excitement about using bond funds to decarbonize homes. - Vice Chair Mandelman supported the delay of the public health bond and urged exploring a transportation/climate bond. He called for MOHCD to study the cost of retrofitting all city affordable units to all-electric, noting evidence of asthma impacts from gas stoves. Lydia Ely of MOHCD responded that they recently received overwhelming demand for a $20 million NOFA for repairs, far exceeding available funds, and that IRA guidelines are not yet clear. - Supervisor Safai highlighted the opportunity to combine affordable housing rehabilitation with climate goals and to address homelessness through renovation of existing buildings (citing $500,000 per bed at one Polk Street project). The committee voted unanimously (5-0) to forward the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Resolution calling on the Mayor to fund 2,000 new shelter or temporary housing placements over the next two fiscal years Vice Chair Mandelman introduced the resolution, stating that the city desperately needs more immediate exits from the street for unsheltered people. He noted that the Department of Emergency Management confirmed that the main barrier to encampment resolution is lack of placements. He cited examples of vacant beds and units (e.g., 80 empty beds at Embarcadero Safe Navigation Center due to missing mattresses). Committee discussion: - Supervisor Safai strongly supported the resolution, pointing out hundreds of vacant permanent supportive housing units and below-market-rate units. He called for better management of existing resources and expansion of options like leased hotels, tiny homes, and triage spaces. He noted a successful Homekey project in his district. Emily Cohen of HSH reported that mattresses for the Embarcadero beds are arriving that week. - Chair Chan noted the need for honest conversation about resources, including the $600 million annual HSH budget (62% for housing) and leveraging state/federal funds, given the city's $190 million deficit. Vice Chair Mandelman moved to forward the resolution to the full board. The motion passed 4-0-1 (Supervisor Ronan absent). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Capital Plan): Resolution adopted amended capital expenditure schedule with March 2024 affordable housing bond ($340M) and November 2024 public health bond ($320M). Forwarded to full board on a 5-0 vote. - Item 2 (Shelter/Housing Placements): Resolution calling on Mayor to fund 2,000 new shelter or temporary housing placements over two fiscal years forwarded to full board on a 4-0-1 vote (Ronan absent). - Next steps: Both items expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on May 9, 2023.

HOMELESSNESS 37% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 30% · PUBLIC HEALTH 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11%
1016
MAY 1, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting: May 1, 2023

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on Monday, May 1, 2023, at 10:15 AM. Chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, the committee addressed four agenda items. Key actions included continuing a Ethics Commission appointment hearing, advancing an ordinance to create a permit prioritization task force, approving the dissolution of the Youth, Young Adult, and Families Committee, and approving the use of the city seal on District 6 office jackets. All decisions were unanimous, with one member absent on the final vote. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was presented. Public Comments & Testimony - Joe Kelly (small businessman): Expressed frustration with the city's inefficiency, particularly regarding the permit process and the continuation of the Ethics Commission appointment. He stated the process is "not serving the public's interest." - David Pelpel (public commenter): Supported the use of the city seal on Supervisor Dorsey's office jackets, suggesting it would positively increase visibility of city officials in communities like the Tenderloin. He proposed two amendments: replacing "termination" with "separation" and changing the end date from election-related to the end of the term (January 8, 2027). - In-person speaker (name not captured): Expressed strong support for the city seal item, sharing personal pride in wearing a city uniform and urging the committee to pass the item with a positive recommendation. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Ethics Commission Appointment (Continued): Chair Dorsey apologized for a version control error that agendized the item contrary to his commitments. He emphasized the importance of the Ethics Commission and the need for a thorough, participatory process. The committee voted to continue the item to May 8, 2023, without objection. - Item 2 – Permit Prioritization Task Force: Supervisor Safai presented the ordinance, explaining its origin from Home SF program projects facing inconsistent prioritization across departments. He highlighted that DPW had not updated priority processing since 2014, and emphasized the need for a data-driven, transparent, and corruption-resistant approach. Amendments were adopted to clarify that the task force's list is advisory only, and the task force has a sunset date. The ordinance was approved with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 – Dissolving Youth, Young Adult, and Families Committee: Supervisor Ronan's remarks were read, affirming that dissolving the committee would not deprioritize youth issues. Chair Dorsey and Supervisor Safai expressed appreciation for the committee's work, with Safai citing Prop G and the Student Success Fund as lasting outcomes. The motion to approve passed unanimously. - Item 4 – Use of City Corporate Seal: Chair Dorsey requested approval for District 6 office jackets with the city seal, citing visibility at community events. Clerk of the Board, Angela Calvio, explained her role as custodian of the seal and raised considerations such as liability and proper handling of jackets upon staff separation. Public comment supported the use with amendments. The committee adopted amendments to change "termination" to "separation" and set the end date to January 8, 2027. The item was recommended as amended. Key Outcomes - Ethics Commission Appointment: Continued to May 8, 2023, by unanimous vote. - Permit Prioritization Task Force: Ordinance amended and passed with positive recommendation to the full board (3-0). - Dissolution of Youth Committee: Approved with positive recommendation (3-0). - Corporate Seal Use: Approved with amendments (2-0, Supervisor Safai absent) and recommended to the full board as amended. All votes were unanimous among present members, with no objections.

PROCEDURAL 81% · PERMIT PROCESS 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 2%
1017
MAY 1, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - May 1, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 1, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered eight agenda items, including resolutions, ordinances on street naming, displaced tenant preference, facade inspections, lease delegation, and HOME-SF program amendments. Public comment was taken on several items. Consent Calendar - Item 1: Resolution recognizing decommissioning of Congregation B'nai Emunah – Unanimously approved (3-0) and forwarded to the full board. - Items 2 & 3: Street naming – Mayor Edwin M. Lee Avenue and Balboa Reservoir streets (Diego Lane, Loquat Lane, Mayor Lane, Westeria Lane) – Unanimously approved (3-0) and forwarded. The project will add 1,100 housing units (50% affordable) on the west side, including an educators' building. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1: David Pilpel and Val Langmuir spoke in support, sharing personal memories and gratitude for recognizing the congregation's history. - Item 4: Alicia Sandoval (Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco) supported the legislation, describing the dire situation of tenants at the 2861-2899 St. Bruno Avenue project—20 illegally built units displacing working-class families, majority monolingual Spanish speakers. - Item 5: A member of the public thanked President Peskin for introducing the facade inspection legislation, noting the severity of window failures during March windstorms with winds up to 80 mph. - Item 6: David Pilpel opposed delegation of board authority under Charter Section 9.118, calling it a bad precedent, and supported the continuance. - Items 7 & 8: Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition) supported item 8 (density bonus) and opposed item 7 (excluding historic districts from HOME-SF). Discussion Items - Item 4: Displaced Tenant Preference Expansion – Legislation to expand the displaced tenant preference program to tenants in unlawful units that the Planning Commission orders removed or denies legalization. Motivated by the St. Bruno project where 20 illegal units were built. An amendment was adopted to clarify documentation requirements (notice to vacate or tenant intent to relinquish). The committee forwarded the amended ordinance with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Existing Building Code – Facade Inspections for Tall Buildings – President Peskin's legislation, amended to remove the November 1, 2023 deadline after the Department of Building Inspection contracted WJE for a three-month study of window failures in seven high-rises. The amended ordinance requires inspections within six months of DBI notification. Forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6: Administrative Code – Delegation of Authority to Amend Leases for 100% Affordable Housing – MOHCD requested delegation for 14 ground leases to save staff time (estimated 700 hours, 0.3 FTE). The Council of Community Housing Organizations (CCHO) stated the existing process is not onerous. MOHCD offered to limit delegation to the 14 projects. The committee continued the item to the call of the chair (3-0) for further amendments. - Items 7 & 8: Planning Code – HOME-SF program amendments – Without further discussion, the committee voted to forward both items with a positive recommendation (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved (3-0), forwarded to full board. - Items 2 & 3: Approved (3-0), forwarded. - Item 4: Amendment adopted (3-0); forwarded as amended (3-0). - Item 5: Amendment adopted (3-0); forwarded as amended (3-0). - Item 6: Continued to the call of the chair (3-0) to revise the ordinance limiting delegation to 14 projects. - Items 7 & 8: Both forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0) to the Board of Supervisors.

PUBLIC COMMENT 23% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 22% · PROCEDURAL 13% · REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 12%
1018
APR 27, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Regular Meeting – April 27, 2023

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on Thursday, April 27, 2023, at 6:15 PM UTC (11:15 AM PT). Chair Catherine Stefani presided, joined by Supervisor Dorsey (Vice Chair Engardio was excused). The committee addressed six agenda items, including two liquor license transfers, amendments to the Health Code on massage permits, a Police Code change for live performance hours in the Polk Street NCD, a hearing on the Recovery Summit Working Group's recommendations and housing needs of justice-involved adults, and a hearing on the 2022 Aging and Disability Affordable Housing Needs Assessment. All votes were unanimous unless noted. Agenda Item 1 – Liquor License Transfer for Rye Bar (140 10th Street) - Discussion: Police Department representative reported zero letters of protest and two letters of support. The location is in a low-crime area but a high-saturation census tract. Southern Station had no opposition. ALU recommended approval with conditions: monitoring to prevent loitering and ensuring entertainment noise is inaudible at residences. Applicant Greg Lindgren spoke, expressing intent to be a neighborhood asset. Supervisor Dorsey voiced support, noting he lives nearby. - Key Outcomes: Motion to prepare a resolution finding the transfer serves public convenience/necessity carried unanimously. Motion to send resolution to full board as a committee report passed without opposition. Agenda Item 2 – Liquor License Transfer for The Gifted Basket (72 Dorman Avenue) - Discussion: The Police Department reported the application had been withdrawn. The item was tabled by motion. - Key Outcomes: Motion to table passed unanimously. Agenda Item 3 – Health Code Amendments – Massage Permit Requirements (Ordinance 221160) - Discussion: Adam Tongsfit (Supervisor Mandelman’s office) presented cleanup legislation to reduce red tape for massage businesses while enhancing enforcement against illicit activity. Amendments were introduced to clarify prohibitions on lewd conduct and solicitation, and to allow nuisance enforcement. Deputy City Attorney confirmed amendments were substantive. No public comment. - Key Outcomes: Motion to adopt amendments passed unanimously. Motion to continue the ordinance as amended to the next meeting passed unanimously. Agenda Item 4 – Police Code – Limited Live Performance Permit in Polk Street NCD (Ordinance 230309) - Discussion: Melody Shoe (President Peskin’s office) explained the change from 10 p.m. to 11 p.m. performance curfew to align with other districts and support economic recovery. Public comment: Kevin Thomason (patron) and Chris Shulman (Lower Polk Community Benefit District) spoke in favor, citing business and cultural benefits. - Key Outcomes: Motion to pass the ordinance out of committee with positive recommendation to the full board passed unanimously. Agenda Item 5 – Hearing – Implementation of Recovery Summit Working Group Recommendations & Housing Needs of Justice-Involved Adults - Discussion: Steve Adami (Re-entry Division, Adult Probation) introduced four programs launched since a 2021 hearing: - Her House (women/children, capacity 10 women + 4 children): served 40 participants, 19 completed, with 1% recidivism. - Positive Directions TRP Academy (abstinence-based therapeutic community, capacity 65): served 208 individuals, 59 completed. - Billy Holiday Center (stabilization center, capacity 30): served 606 people, 321 completed. - Minna Project (behavioral health, capacity 75): served 139, 17 moved to permanent housing. All programs at over 90% capacity with waiting lists; combined recidivism rate for three programs was 1%. - A two-year mixed-methods research project surveyed 284 justice-involved adults and held 12 focus groups. Findings highlighted addiction, financial instability, and re-entry barriers. Recommendations included a citywide goal for housing, expanding beyond housing-first/harm reduction, creating a recovery system of care, building stabilization centers in high-need neighborhoods, increasing financial literacy, expanding transitional housing, and expanding Her House to serve 40 women. - Public Comment: Over 20 speakers, mostly program participants and graduates, shared powerful personal stories of recovery. Common themes: need for more space (especially for women), lower barriers to entry, and abstinence-based options. Many emphasized that these programs save lives and create taxpayers. - Supervisor Statements: Chair Stefani and Supervisor Dorsey expressed strong support, noting the programs are evidence-based and deserve robust funding. Supervisor Safai joined to show support and commit to budget advocacy. Supervisor Dorsey called for clarifying that abstinence-based recovery should be the primary aspiration of public policy. - Key Outcomes: Hearing filed by unanimous motion. Agenda Item 6 – Hearing – 2022 Aging and Disability Affordable Housing Needs Assessment Report - Discussion: Cindy Kaufman (Deputy Director, Department of Disability and Aging Services) presented the first comprehensive report, based on over 1,200 survey responses, focus groups, and community forums. Key findings: 1. Tenant/project-based subsidies are critical but insufficient. 2. Inadequate accessibility features in affordable housing. 3. Siloed resources across city departments. - Recommendations: invest in operating subsidies (including a new disability operating subsidy program), improve the reasonable modification process, and strengthen interdepartmental coordination. The Planning Department has hired a senior and disability housing implementation planner to lead implementation. - Public Comment: Speakers from Senior and Disability Action (SDA) and community members highlighted: - Only 27 of 10,000 planned affordable housing units are designated for people with disabilities. - Broken elevators in SROs trap residents; a $500,000 ask for elevator repairs was noted. - Need for simplified application processes and expanded rental subsidies. - Call for prioritizing disability operating subsidies and senior operating subsidies in the upcoming budget. - Supervisor Questions: Chair Stefani asked about cost of inaction; planning staff acknowledged that some recommendations require significant investment but interagency coordination is underway. Supervisor Dorsey requested a cost estimate for elevator repairs citywide. - Key Outcomes: Hearing filed by unanimous motion. Adjournment - The meeting adjourned after completing all agenda items.

PUBLIC COMMENT 31% · REENTRY SERVICES 13% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 10% · DISABILITY RIGHTS 10%
1019
APR 26, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Meeting on 10-Year Capital Plan - April 26, 2023

Date: April 26, 2023 The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met to consider the proposed Ten-Year Capital Expenditure Plan for fiscal years 2024-2033. The item was continued from the previous week due to amendments. The committee debated the allocation of an additional $150 million in bond capacity, bond scheduling for 2024, and the integration of climate action goals. Public comment included strong calls for a dedicated climate bond. After discussion, the committee voted 3-2 to amend the capital plan, increasing the affordable housing bond to $340 million and the public health bond to $320 million, then voted unanimously to continue the item to the May 3, 2023 meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Elena Engel (District 9) criticized the lack of a climate bond, noting the board had previously urged capital planning to include one but saw no follow-up. She asked for labeling on all bonds to show their climate impact. - Sarah Greenwald (District 2) urged a climate bond in 2024 and questioned how the city would fund its climate action plan without one. - Ronnie Diamont Wilson (1000 Grandmothers) called for a climate bond on the 2024 ballot, emphasizing the urgency of reducing emissions from buildings and transportation. - Judy Rosenfeld (1000 Grandmothers) acknowledged the difficulty of balancing priorities but urged the committee to coordinate climate action across agencies. - Joyce Calagos (District 11) spoke as a homeowner unable to afford electrification, suggesting bonds support programs like BayREN or Rebuilding Together for low-income home repairs, linking climate and health. - David Pilpel supported the capital plan as comprehensive and urged using the additional $150 million for general fund capital needs rather than specific bonds. - Eileen Booken opposed the proposed earthquake safety bond unless amended, criticizing PUC's use of previous bond funds for cisterns and flexible water supply systems, which she deemed ineffective. - Susan Green (Climate Emergency Committee) argued the capital plan fails to incorporate the city's climate action plan and lacks a champion for carbon tracking on the Capital Planning Committee. She urged allocating bond capacity to building and transit decarbonization. - Francisco DeCaster criticized the city for not acting on mental health needs, specifically at Laguna Honda, and urged action over talk. - Charlie Summer (Council of Community Housing Organizations) urged the committee to keep open the possibility of a local affordable housing bond in 2024, warning that reliance on a regional bond alone (potentially $10-20 billion) could leave San Francisco without resources if it fails. Discussion Items - Presentation and Amendment: Brian Strong (Office of Resilience and Capital Planning) confirmed that climate mitigation (decarbonization, water conservation) is already incorporated into project scoping and code requirements, with lead gold standards and Chapter 7 reforms (requiring electric replacements for failed gas appliances). Charles Sheehan (Environment Department) noted that new buildings are all-electric, but existing buildings need to be retrofitted to reduce emissions. - Supervisor Mandelman expressed dissatisfaction with the capital plan, calling it a "work in progress." He opposed waiting until 2026 for a transportation bond (reduced by $100 million from earlier plans), noting transportation accounts for 40% of greenhouse gas emissions and is critical for accommodating 80,000 new housing units. He also raised concerns about the public health bond without clear planning for severe mental illness capital needs. - Supervisor Walton emphasized the need to incorporate climate goals into all projects with real resources, but acknowledged difficult trade-offs given budget constraints. He noted the importance of being thoughtful about competing priorities. - Supervisor Safai agreed more capacity was needed for affordable housing, expressed reservations about shelter investments per bed, and called for more consideration of environmental goals. He supported President Peskin's proposal to increase the affordable housing bond. - Supervisor Ronan (arriving late) agreed she was not ready to commit to specific bonds for 2024, noting strategic concerns: a large March 2024 local housing bond might dampen voter support for a much larger regional housing bond in November 2024. She instead favored using the $150 million for behavioral health capital needs, citing a successful cooperative housing model for people with severe mental illness that lacks capital expansion funding. - Board President Peskin proposed amending the capital plan to use the $150 million in new bond capacity: $140 million for affordable housing and shelter bond (increasing it to $340 million) and $10 million for the public health bond (increasing it to $320 million). He argued the affordable housing need was more clearly documented with identified projects, while a climate bond lacked specific planning and CEQA analysis. - Technical Clarifications: City Attorney Ann Pearson and Anna Van Dagna (Controller's Office of Public Finance) confirmed the capital plan is a guide and does not bind future bond amounts. The board retains flexibility to adjust amounts when actual bonds are placed on the ballot. Brian Strong noted capacity can be left unallocated. Key Outcomes - Motion to Amend: Supervisor Safai moved to adopt President Peskin's proposal: increase the 2024 affordable housing and shelter general obligation bond from $200 million to $340 million, and the public health and shelter bond from $310 million to $320 million. The motion passed 3-2 (Chair Chan, Vice Chair Mandelman, and Supervisor Walton in favor; Supervisors Ronan and Safai opposed – note: transcript shows Mandelman voted aye but the roll call listed Mandelman as aye, so the two nos were Ronan and possibly a transcription error – the chair announced "three ayes with two no's with Vice Chair Mandelman and Member Ronin in dissent" which is contradictory; based on the roll call: Mandelman aye, Safai aye, Ronan no, Walton aye, Chan aye = 4-1? Let's re-check the transcript: "Vice Chair Mandelman. Aye. Safai aye, member Ronin. No. Ronan, no, member Walton. Walton I, Chair Chan. Aye. Chan I. Uh we have three ayes with two no's with Vice Chair Mandelman and Member Ronin in dissent." This is confusing: Mandelman is listed as aye but then included in the two dissenting? Most likely a transcription error. The chair states "three ayes with two no's" and names Mandelman and Ronan as dissenting. But earlier Mandelman said aye. Possibly the clerk mis-called or the transcript has an error. For accuracy, note the discrepancy: the motion passed with three in favor and two against, but the exact alignment is unclear from the transcript. The final vote was 3-2, with Chair Chan, Supervisor Walton, and (likely) Supervisor Safai in favor, and Vice Chair Mandelman and Supervisor Ronan opposed, based on the chair's summary. - Continuance: The committee voted unanimously (5-0) to continue the amended item to the May 3, 2023 meeting of the Budget and Appropriations Committee.

CLIMATE ADAPTATION 29% · CAPITAL PLANNING 22% · PUBLIC HEALTH 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
1020
APR 26, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - April 26, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee (Chair Chan, Vice Chair Mandelman, and Supervisor Safai) met on April 26, 2023, to consider several fiscal items, including appropriation amendments, grant acceptances, contract amendments, and policy waivers. The committee forwarded most items to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, continued one item to the following week, and heard public testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - A recurring public commenter expressed general grievances about city governance, personal hardship, and feelings of exclusion. He did not take specific positions on most items but voiced confusion and opposition to the processes. On items related to the PUC and port, he questioned the motives behind waivers and large expenditures. On the HUD grants, he supported housing but criticized the system for not helping him. - Another speaker (remote) on item 2 (in-kind gifts) called the city “the most corrupt city in America” and requested the item be tabled for review by the ethics commission and budget analyst before supervisor action. On item 5 (port waivers), a speaker (remote) supported the legislation and noted that it does not waive Charter Section 9.118 powers. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Overtime Appropriation – Various Departments): Director Anna Duning explained the amended ordinance shifts permanent salary to overtime funds for multiple departments, adding Recreation and Parks. The BLA report noted DPH overtime increased to $30.7 million. Chair Chan questioned park ranger overtime at Union Square (holiday season, Oct 27–Jan 1) and UN Plaza (since March 8, two shifts daily, 55% filled). Parks finance director Antonio Ferrari confirmed the amounts. The committee forwarded the item 3-0. - Item 2 (In-Kind Gift – Civic Bridge Program): Sophia Kittler (Mayor’s Office of Innovation) presented five pro bono consulting projects (with firms like Accenture, Zendesk, Slalom). A key discussion centered on whether consultants could later bid on resulting RFPs; the city attorney and office stated their agreements prohibit that. Vice Chair Mandelman praised the program and added as co-sponsor. Forwarded 3-0. - Item 3 (Title X Family Planning Grant – Retroactive): Jenny Lopez (DPH) requested retroactive acceptance of a $221,725 grant increase (total $301,725). Chair Chan noted 50% vacancy rate; currently serving 500–800 clients. Forwarded 2-0 (Safai absent). - Item 4 (HIV Services Contract Amendment): Beth Neary and Bill Blum (DPH) presented the amendment for Asian and Pacific Islander Wellness Center, increasing the contract by $5.5 million to a total not-to-exceed $15.2 million, extending to 2027. BLA found no major performance issues but noted late financial statements. Forwarded 3-0. - Item 5 (Port Tenant Improvement Waiver): Rebecca Benassini (Port) requested a waiver from Admin Code Chapter 6 for tenant improvement allowances up to $20 million (using ARPA and port funds) to recruit tenants. Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor. Chair Chan clarified the waiver is tied to the $20 million cap. Forwarded 3-0. - Item 6 (PUC Electricity Purchase Authority): Barbara Hale (SFPUC) requested increasing the annual expenditure limit from $150M to $200M, adding waivers for labor ordinances and binding arbitration. BLA called it a policy matter. Chair Chan expressed reluctance about waiving Minimum Compensation, Healthcare Accountability, and Sweat-free Contracting, asking for quarterly reports on any such waivers. Supervisor Safai asked about competition benefits. The committee approved the amendments (adding renewable portfolio standard) and continued the item to May 3, 2023, by a 3-0 vote. - Item 7 (SFPUC–Caltrans Agreement Waiver): Suzanne Huang (SFPUC) requested exempting two cooperative agreements for stormwater projects from certain municipal code requirements. Forwarded 3-0. - Items 8 & 9 (Airport Grants and Lease Amendment): Kathy Widener (SFO) presented a $31 million FAA grant for terminal roof replacement (with solar panels) and a lease amendment reducing Tastes on the Fly’s space by 43% while maintaining $1.1 million minimum annual guarantee. Chair Chan expressed hope for recovery. Forwarded 3-0. - Items 10–13 (HUD Formula Grants for Housing): Brian Chu (MOHCD) presented applications for FY2023-2024: HOPWA ($10.1M), ESG ($1.6M), CDBG ($25M), HOME ($7.3M). All are formula grants with known amounts. Forwarded 3-0. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 4: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6: Amended as read (3-0), then continued to the May 3, 2023 budget committee meeting (3-0). - Item 7: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 8–9: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 10–13: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0).

PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · ELECTRIC SERVICE REGULATION 20% · PUBLIC HEALTH 11% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 8%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com