Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1021–1030 ENTRIES
1021
APR 25, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - April 25, 2023

The Port Commission met on April 25, 2023, from 11:15 AM to 5:53 PM. The meeting included approval of consent items, public comments on Alcatraz Cruises labor issues, informational updates on offshore wind development and the Fisherman's Wharf unsolicited proposal, and a discussion on the future of competitive solicitations. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2317: Approved mutual termination agreement with D&G Company dba Lou’s Pier 47 (Lease L-14630 and License 14651) at 300 Jefferson Street. - Resolution 2318: Approved mutual termination agreement with 340 Jefferson, LLC dba Pompei’s Grotto (Lease L-8986 and License E-13772) at 340 Jefferson Street. - Resolution 2319: Approved second lease amendment with Andre-Boudin Bakeries, Inc. for the Chowder Hut Restaurant to extend construction deadlines and revise patio improvements. - Resolution 2320: Approved a development and multi-use lease of Building 49 at 701 Illinois Street (Crane Cove Park) with the YMCA of San Francisco for an initial 10-year term plus options (total up to 34 years), including a fee waiver for a companion license. All consent items were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Marina Saccatano (Inlandboatmen's Union): Stated that Alcatraz Cruises is not bargaining in good faith, citing 52 days between negotiation sessions. She asked the Commission to demand fair scheduling and good-faith bargaining. Mentioned a rally on May 1. - Evan McLaughlin (ILWU): Supported the Alcatraz workers, emphasizing that consistent schedules, fair wages, and safe conditions are standard elsewhere. Asked for port support to bring Alcatraz Cruises to the table. - Tristan Senift (Alcatraz Cruises deckhand): Described deteriorating management-worker relations, lack of on-site managers, and slow negotiations since January 2023. Asked for continued port assistance. - Francisca DeCosta (Environmental Justice Advocacy): Criticized the port’s focus on development over public trust obligations, maritime users, and pollution remediation. Called for funding for the seawall and cleanup of coal tar contamination. - Paul Kapuro (Alioto’s restaurant family): Expressed dire conditions at Fisherman’s Wharf (street crime, illegal vending, vacancies) and urged expediting the unsolicited proposal from the “dream team” (Lou Girado, Seth Hamilian, Chris McGarry), stating businesses are “bleeding to death.” Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (6A): Director Forbes welcomed Commissioner Ed Harrington. Reported on offshore wind opportunities at Piers 80-96, short-term activations for Fisherman’s Wharf (paint, flower baskets, pop-ups), and progress on Piers 30-32 legislation (SB 47). Josh Keene gave a development update: Mission Rock Phase 1 buildings near completion (40% affordable housing, 537 units), Pier 70 in down-market delay but with tenant interest, and pending term sheets for Piers 30-32 and 38-40. Mentioned closing the fire training facility relocation this fiscal year and a $2.8M grant from Speaker Pelosi for YMCA gap funding. - License with GSW Arena (8A - Informational): Presentation on a proposed 10-year (plus two 5-year options) license for curb spaces and 80 metered parking spaces near Chase Center ($1.5M revenue over initial term, up to $3.5M total). Scheduled for approval on May 9. - MOU with SF Environment (8B): Approved a 5-year MOU for a building material reuse facility at Seawall Lot 344 (27,502 sq ft paved, 5,766 sq ft unpaved, 3,615 sq ft shed). 6.5% of revenues ($80,000) set aside for community benefits. Operator selection underway. - Interagency Cooperation Agreement - TJPA (8C - Informational): Presentation on the Downtown Rail Extension Phase 2. The port will sign the ICA to be reimbursed for staff costs. Approval scheduled for May 9. - Offshore Wind Update (9A - Informational): Report on AB 525 and California’s goal of 25 GW floating offshore wind by 2045. Port staff identified Pier 96 (25 acres), Pier 80, and Pier 68 as possible support sites. Early engagements with developers (Cadmus) underway. - Fisherman’s Wharf Unsolicited Proposal (10A - Informational): Presentation on a proposal from Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized (led by Lou Girado, Seth Hamilian, Chris McGarry) to lease Triangle Lot and Pier 45 Sheds A and C. Three community meetings were held (avg. 30 people each). Key public input: prioritize fishing industry, protect the valley, concerns about short-term residential (Prop H), and need for revitalization. Commission discussion centered on the sole-source process. Commissioner Harrington questioned the lack of a competitive process; Commissioners Gilman, Lee, and President Brandon expressed openness to the proposal given the wharf’s crisis and the team’s track record. Staff will present to the Board of Supervisors for a sole-source determination before any exclusive negotiation agreement (ENA). Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar Items (Resolutions 2317-2320): Unanimously adopted. - Item 8B (Resolution 2322): Unanimously adopted; MOU with SF Environment approved. - Items 8A, 8C, 9A, 10A: No action taken; informational items to return for future decisions (May 9 for 8A and 8C). - New Business: Commission directed staff to return with an informational session after the building reuse operator selection and after the Board of Supervisors acts on the Fisherman’s Wharf sole-source request. Also discussed reviewing delegation authority for interdepartmental agreements and revenue thresholds.

FISHERMAN'S WHARF 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · MARITIME OPERATIONS 10% · PROCEDURAL 7%
1022
APR 25, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Regular Meeting: April 25, 2023

At its April 25, 2023 regular meeting, the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) had a quorum with President Ajami, Vice President Maxwell, and Commissioners Paulson, Rivera, and Stacy. The Commission approved the previous meeting minutes, the consent calendar, several contract and budget items, and an MOU with the Local Agency Formation Commission, and then held a closed session. The General Manager reported no current update. Consent Calendar - Approved the consent calendar unanimously, which included: (7a) Award of Job Order Contract No. JOC-94 for general engineering construction in San Joaquin, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne Counties; (7b) Acceptance of work by Pipe and Plant Solutions, Inc. under Contract No. WW-695, As-Needed Sewer Cleaning and Inspection; and (7c) Approval of a 110-calendar-day increase to the duration contingency for Contract No. WW-715. Reports - Revenue Bond Oversight Committee Annual Report: Committee Chair Theodosia presented the annual report for the period July 2021 to June 2022. It led an audit of six revenue bonds representing approximately $2 billion in expenditures, with the audit report released in January 2022. Two audit findings were identified; the reporting finding was fully addressed, and the SFPUC is following up on quality assurance issues. The committee is now beginning a second audit covering a new selected group of approximately $2 billion in bond expenditures. - Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Update: BAWSCA reported on historical and projected regional water use. Since 1986, per-capita residential water use has declined 42% while population rose 33%, groundwater use fell 61%, and recycled water use is now about 8 million gallons per day as of fiscal year 2021-22. Looking toward 2045-46, BAWSCA projects population growth of 30%, a 109% increase in recycled water use, and a broader planning update called Strategy 2045. Staff discussed the difficulty of tracking onsite recycling and the need for regional coordination. Discussion Items - FY 2023-24 Overtime Supplemental Budget: SFPUC Budget Director Laura Bush requested that the Commission approve an increase of $1.5 million in 2023-24 overtime budget, offset by a $1.5 million reduction in the regular salary budget. The increase is needed because of winter storm response and vacant positions; $800,000 is for wastewater, $450,000 for water, and $250,000 for Hetch Hetchy. Commission members voiced appreciation for the staff working overtime and reiterated the need to fill vacancies. - Helicopter Services Contract Amendment: SFPUC sought approval for Amendment No. 3 to Contract PRO.0089 with A&P Helicopters, Inc., increasing the contract by $240,000 and extending it by two years, bringing the total contract value to $990,000, for aerial survey, patrol, transmission system maintenance, and occasional emergency response. The Commission approved the amendment. - As-Needed Spot Sewer Replacement Contract: The Commission approved $9,796,468 contract award for Contract No. WW-000T, As-Needed Spot Sewer Replacement No. 44, to Jackob Flor Construction Company for 400 consecutive calendar days. Staff noted the contract was a sole bid because one other prospective contractor declined due to resource issues. - CleanPowerSF MOU with LAFCO: Staff requested approval of a revised memorandum of understanding with the San Francisco Local Agency Formation Commission (SFOLACF) to perform CleanPowerSF-related work. The $129,000 in remaining funds from an older MOU will be used first, with up to a possible additional $600,000 in new funds, and the agreement term is three years and two months starting May 1, 2023. The study topics include energy storage barriers, natural gas infrastructure decommissioning, electric vehicle charging access, financing through a Green Link connected to the federal Inflation Reduction Act, and other emerging technologies. Public Comments & Testimony - A public speaker said that bond oversight as presented was too general and called for clarity on how much of the bond funding is green bonds, including a line item for green bonds, and for an accounting of the $6 billion bond program. - Another public speaker on the sewer contract, said the public needs to know how many miles of sewer pipe have been replaced, noting there are over 1,100 miles of sewer pipe in San Francisco, and called for replacement work to be done before the next major earthquake. - During general public comment, a speaker requested an accounting of the Ocean Beach Climate Adaptation Project status and urged the Commission to be transparent about related capital planning. - Another speaker asked for updates on municipal pump stations and seawall studies, warning that these facilities could be vulnerable if not properly addressed. - Peter Drekmeier, Policy Director for the Tuolumne River Trust, thanked the Commission for keeping remote access, noted that the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear a case, and requested a future workshop on the Tuolumne voluntary agreement and the 2022 Bay-Delta Plan amendments. Key Outcomes - Minutes of April 11, 2023 were approved by a 5-0 vote. - Consent calendar items 7a through 7c were approved unanimously. - The overtime budget transfer for FY 2022-23 was approved unanimously. - Amendment No. 3 to the helicopter services contract was approved unanimously. - Contract No. WW-716 for as-needed spot sewer replacement was approved unanimously. - The revised CleanPowerSF MOU with LAFCO was approved unanimously. - Following closed session and the necessary motion, the commission voted not to disclose closed-session discussions. Next Steps - Staff will begin the second Revenue Bond Oversight Committee audit and expect that a Ombudsman will continue its public protection work. - BAWSCA’s strategy update under long-term water supply planning will be reported to the Commission as it progresses. - Commission initiated a future request to compile a table of which SFPUC bonds are identified as green bonds and to explore how more bonds could qualify as green. - The commissioners praised visits to the Mountain Tunnel and saw a desire for expanded tours of ongoing utilities projects.

PROCEDURAL 42% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 18% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 13% · PUBLIC WORKS 6%
1023
APR 24, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - April 24, 2023

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, April 24, 2023, at 10:15 AM. Chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, the committee considered two items: a mayoral appointment to the Successor Agency Commission (OCII) and an ordinance to regulate the Sheriff's Department's use of certain equipment under Assembly Bill 481. Both items were unanimously approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for consideration on May 2, 2023. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Appointment of Vanessa Aquino): No public comment was offered. - Item 2 (Sheriff’s Equipment Policy): One in-person speaker thanked the sheriff’s office for a community event. Two callers from the American Friends Service Committee (AFSC) – Jennifer Two and John Lindy Colland – spoke in support of the policy, noting that it is more compliant with state law and incorporates better practices after multiple iterations. They recommended forwarding the ordinance to the full board and suggested further improvements, such as phasing out submachine guns not authorized for deployment and ensuring consideration of vulnerable populations (e.g., children, non-English speakers, people in mental health crisis) in deployment decisions. Discussion Items - Item 1: Mayoral Appointment of Vanessa Aquino to the Successor Agency Commission (OCII) – Vanessa Aquino, a native San Franciscan and Dogpatch resident, introduced herself, highlighting her community involvement and commitment to smart, sustainable development that benefits local communities through small business contracting, local hiring, and neighborhood preference for affordable housing. Supervisors Walton and Dorsey expressed support, noting the importance of OCII to their districts and praising her community outreach experience. The committee voted unanimously to recommend her appointment to the full board. - Item 2: Ordinance Amending Administrative Code – Sheriff’s Department Equipment Policy (AB 481) – Ronnie Singh from the Sheriff’s Office presented the ordinance, detailing extensive collaboration with the American Friends Service Committee and other stakeholders, including over 17 meetings and a dozen edits. The policy was initially heard in January 2023 and passed unanimously by the previous committee, but a 30-day waiting period was required after a substantive amendment (deleting a sentence on chemical agent use for crowd control). The committee heard public comment and then voted unanimously to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to strike “reject” from the motion and recommend Vanessa Aquino’s appointment passed unanimously (Vice Chair Walton, Supervisor Safai, Chair Dorsey all aye). The appointment will be considered by the full Board of Supervisors on May 2, 2023. - Item 2: Motion to recommend the ordinance to the full board passed unanimously (all aye). The ordinance will appear on the Board of Supervisors’ agenda on May 2, 2023.

PROCEDURAL 57% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 43%
1024
APR 24, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - April 24, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 24, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered eight items, including HOME-SF amendments, a hotel rezoning, delegation of affordable housing lease amendments, facade inspections, environmental justice framework, Castro Theatre landmark designation, and a study of Midtown Park Apartments. Multiple items were continued to future meetings due to substantive amendments or the need for additional information. Public Comments & Testimony Items 1 & 2 (HOME-SF): No public comments were offered. Item 3 (Hotel Rezoning): No public comments. Item 4 (Delegation of Lease Amendment Authority): - David Pilpel opposed delegation, arguing Charter Section 9.118 powers cannot be delegated and that the board should retain authority. - Yelena Bulbasain (Mercy Housing) supported delegation, citing the need to address unpaid rent and rising costs post-COVID. Item 5 (Facade Inspections): No public comments on the item (only regarding the continuance). Item 6 (Environmental Justice Framework): - Karen Pierce (former DPH EJ director, Bayview resident) supported adoption, emphasizing community-led process and the importance of lived experience. - Julie Lindo applauded the plan and urged funding for a climate bond. - Antonio Diaz (PODER) supported adoption and commitment to continued engagement. - Maggie Dog (Chinatown Community Development Center) supported, noting the value of local data. - Chester Williams (Community Living Campaign) supported adoption and requested continuation of phases 2 and 3. Item 7 (Castro Theatre Landmark Designation): - Steven Torres (Castro LGBTQ Cultural District) requested a two-week continuance to allow further negotiations. - Gerard Koskevich supported the amended landmark designation, arguing it respects LGBTQ heritage. - Ralph Hibbs opposed fixing the orchestra seating, citing ventilation concerns. - Jared Goldfine raised concerns about protocol regarding last week's meeting. - Several callers supported the fixed seating as essential for historic integrity and film screenings; others argued for flexibility to modernize. Item 8 (Midtown Park Apartments LAFCO Study): - Alan Buradell urged that language should focus on ownership, not just management. Discussion Items Items 1 & 2 – HOME-SF Amendments: Supervisor Peskin introduced amendments to Item 2 (including eliminating parking exemptions, revising unit sizes, etc.). After public comment, the committee voted to amend Item 2 as presented and continued both items to the next meeting. The Historic Preservation Commission and Planning Commission had recommended approval with modifications. Item 3 – Rezoning for Hotel Use (RM-2 to allow up to 47 tourist hotel rooms): The proposal was part of a litigation settlement requiring payments to support the Veterans Academy permanent supportive housing program. Planning Commission approved on March 23. The committee voted to recommend approval to the full board. Item 4 – Delegation of Authority to Amend Leases for 100% Affordable Housing: MOHCD presented a proposal to streamline amendments to ground leases and loan agreements to align with current residual receipts policy. Supervisors Peskin and Preston expressed concerns about delegation of charter authority, transparency, potential politicization, and lack of oversight at the affordable housing loan committee. Supervisor Melgar echoed concerns about precedent. The committee voted to continue the item to May 1, requesting information on how many projects were originally from redevelopment and an analysis of the full universe of applicable leases. Item 5 – Facade Inspections for Tall Buildings: Supervisor Peskin explained the history of window failures in downtown buildings, noting that seven buildings lost windows in March 2023. The legislation would require post-1998 buildings over 15 stories to submit inspection reports by November 1 (later suggested December). DBI supported the concept but recommended timeline adjustments and an independent study. The committee continued the item one week. Item 6 – Environmental Justice Framework and General Plan Update: Planning staff presented the EJ Framework, including a community-developed map identifying areas facing the top 30% of environmental and health burdens. The framework covers six topics (healthy environments, physical activity, food access, housing, green jobs, empowered neighborhoods). Supervisors discussed implementation and integration into city decision-making. The committee voted to recommend adoption to the full board. Item 7 – Castro Theatre Landmark Designation Amendment: The ordinance would expand the landmark designation to include interior features and capture full historical significance. Supervisor Preston suggested a two-week continuance to allow further negotiations between stakeholders. The committee voted to continue to May 9, 2023. Item 8 – LAFCO Study for Midtown Park Apartments: Supervisor Preston introduced a motion requesting LAFCO to study future management/ownership options and conduct a resident engagement process. The committee adopted non-substantive amendments (changing from motion to resolution) and recommended approval to the full board. Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2: Continued to May 1, 2023 (after amendment of Item 2). - Item 3: Recommended approval to full board. - Item 4: Continued to May 1, 2023, with requests for additional data. - Item 5: Continued to May 1, 2023. - Item 6: Recommended adoption to full board. - Item 7: Continued to May 9, 2023. - Item 8: Recommended approval (as amended) to full board.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 29% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE 16% · BUILDING INSPECTION 6%
1025
APR 20, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
GAO Committee Advances Excelsior CBD and Approves Litigation Settlements - April 20, 2023

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee (GAO) of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, April 20, 2023, to consider a resolution of intention to form the Excelsior Community Benefit District (CBD) and to discuss and vote on a closed session litigation agenda involving multiple settlements, a tolling agreement, and unlitigated claims. The committee voted unanimously to forward the CBD resolution to the full board and to recommend the entire litigation agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - William Ortiz Cartagena, founder of the nonprofit Glecha, provided brief comments but did not state a position on the CBD item. - David Pilpel, a remote caller, commented on the closed session litigation agenda. He noted that item 3 (plaintiffs Doe 1 and Doe 2) involved an employment dispute with the police department and suggested that future agendas include the specific department in the long title of such cases. He expressed no opinion on the underlying issues. Discussion Items - Resolution of Intention – Excelsior Community Benefit District (File 230386): - Bill Barnes, chief of staff for Supervisor Asha Safai, presented the item, noting that the effort began in 2017 with an economic strategy for the Excelsior neighborhood. The CBD aims to improve street cleanliness, business attraction and retention, and corridor activation. Property owners representing 30% of the assessment had subscribed by March 2023, meeting the threshold to call an election. He thanked the Jewish Home and other supporters. - Diana Ponce de Leon, from the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD), presented the resolution and outlined the community engagement process. The timeline includes ballots going out in May 2023, ending in July, and if passed, services commencing in the first quarter of 2024. - Supervisor Dean Preston asked whether the Excelsior Library, located within the proposed boundaries, was included in the management plan. Steve Gibson, president of Urban Place Consulting, confirmed that the library is within the boundaries and would be assessed and receive services. Bill Barnes added that the library recently underwent renovations through the Library Preservation Fund. - The committee then voted unanimously to send the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors with a recommendation. Closed Session Litigation Agenda - The committee convened in closed session to discuss 17 items, including settlements of lawsuits, a tolling agreement, and unlitigated claims. The total settlement amounts included: - Christopher Wirowek: $436,000 - Plaintiffs Doe 1 and Doe 2: $120,000 - Justin Tsai: $185,000 - Robert Burchell et al.: $100,000 - Lyn Rawles: $200,000 - Alexis Krup: $3,325,000 - M. Hernandez Construction, Inc.: $137,000 - San Francisco Care Center, L.P.: $825,000 - Ronnie Jones: $149,000 - Treasure Island Series 1, LLC: Tolling agreement (real property transfer tax dispute) - KHP III SF Sutter LLC: $3,750,000 (unlitigated) - Joseph Goldmark: $35,000 (unlitigated) - Chinatown Community Development Center: $70,000 (unlitigated) - Michael Gwilliam: $38,350 (unlitigated) - BRIDGE Housing Corporation: $100,000 (unlitigated) - Executive Hotel Vintage Court, LLC: $762,965 (unlitigated) - SF Americania LLC: $4,692,008 (unlitigated) - After reconvening in open session, the committee reported unanimous action to recommend the entire litigation agenda to the Board of Supervisors for consideration on May 2, 2023. Supervisor Connie Chan disclosed a professional relationship with plaintiff Christopher Wirowek from her prior positions at the District Attorney's Office and City College of San Francisco, noting the relationship was limited to professional. - The committee then voted unanimously not to disclose the closed session discussions. Key Outcomes - Excelsior CBD Resolution: Passed committee (3-0) and sent to the full Board of Supervisors with recommendation. - Litigation Agenda: All 17 items recommended to the full Board of Supervisors (unanimous). - Non-Disclosure of Closed Session: Approved unanimously (3-0).

PROCEDURAL 43% · PENDING LITIGATION 35% · COMMUNITY BENEFIT DISTRICTS 14% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 8%
1026
APR 19, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – April 19, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular meeting on Wednesday, April 19, 2023, at City Hall. The meeting included an officer recognition, public comment on unsolved homicides and police conduct, reports from the Chief of Police and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), commission reports, and a detailed update on the SFPD's 30x30 initiative to increase the representation of women in law enforcement. The commission also voted to enter closed session for pending litigation and to assert attorney-client privilege. Consent Calendar - SFPD and DPA SB 1421 and SB 16 Monthly Reports: The commission unanimously voted (7-0) to receive and file the monthly reports for March 31, 2023. No public comment was offered. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 2): A mother of Aubrey Abacasa, murdered in 2006, pleaded for help solving her son's case and questioned where reward money is going. She stated that cases of white victims (e.g., Kate Steinle, Cash App stabbing victim) get solved while African American cases do not. - Item 4 (Chief’s Report) commenters: A French artist urged city agencies to unite; a speaker alleged unequal treatment of homicides based on race; another speaker alleged an officer harassed and threatened him after he filed a complaint. - Item 5 (DPA Report) commenter: A member of the public claimed an officer planted drugs on him, threatened to kill him, and that no investigation occurred. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report (Item 4): Chief Scott reported overall crime down 10% year-to-date (≈1,500 fewer serious crimes). Violent crime up 4%; homicides even; gun violence victims down by 3 (5% reduction). Homicide clearance rate at 85%. Announced an arrest in the Robert Lee murder and solving a 1994 cold case. Significant narcotics seizure: 4.6 kg (10 lbs) of fentanyl (≈2 million lethal doses). Reported a hate crime at Loris Park (anti-LGBTQ+ assault) and stunt driving events over the weekend that were disrupted with help from CHP and San Mateo PD. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 5): Director Henderson reported 286 pending cases (23 older than 9 months, of which 19 are tolled). Top allegation trend: officers failing to properly investigate. DPA won a Knighton Award for its audit on electronic monitoring for bias. DPA is collaborating with SF Safe to host community events. Commissioner Benedicto asked about the new complainant portal; Henderson said feedback has been positive. - Commission Reports (Item 6): President Elias attended the SFPD women’s luncheon and discussed patrol specials. Vice President Carter-Oberstone expressed concern that Bureau Orders are being used to issue new policy without authority and requested a future resolution to rescind them when underlying Department General Orders (DGOs) become effective. Commissioner Byrne asked for committees to be formalized. Commissioner Benedicto noted progress on body-worn camera DGO. - SFPD 30x30 Initiative Update (Item 7): Commander Nicole Jones presented the six-month update. SFPD signed the 30x30 pledge in October 2022. Current sworn women representation: 14.4% (up from 14.3%). Academy recruit demographics: 33% women in 2023 (one class of 12, including 4 women). Key actions: anonymous survey distributed (107 of 274 sworn women responded); lactation facilities; mentorship program launched (86 members); uniform and equipment fit improvements; planned transition to a smaller service firearm (pending funding). Upcoming steps: form a 30x30 committee and develop a strategic plan by November 2024. Commissioners discussed expanding recruitment pools, childcare support, and exit interview data for women. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved 7-0. - Closed Session Vote (Item 9): Unanimously voted (6-0) to hold Item 10 in closed session and assert attorney-client privilege on Items 10C and 10D. - Closed Session Disclosure Vote (Item 11): Unanimously voted (6-0) to not disclose the closed session discussion and to assert attorney-client privilege; the commission will finalize language for the minutes. - Future Action: The commission will agendize a resolution in May to establish a process for Bureau Orders and to ensure they are rescinded upon the effective date of underlying DGOs.

PROCEDURAL 61% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 27% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7% · PUBLIC SAFETY 3%
1027
APR 19, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Budget Committee Discusses 10-Year Capital Plan, Amends Bond Schedule - April 19, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee met on April 19, 2023, to consider the proposed Ten-Year Capital Expenditure Plan for fiscal years 2024–2033. The committee heard presentations from Brian Strong (Office of Resilience and Capital Planning), department heads, and extensive public testimony. After debate, the committee voted to amend the bond schedule, swapping the March 2024 public health bond with the November 2024 affordable housing/shelter bond, and continued the item to the April 26 meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers from the Climate Emergency Coalition and 350 San Francisco urged the committee to include a dedicated climate mitigation bond in 2024, arguing the current plan underfunds emission reductions and defers critical projects. They called for a vote against the plan until a climate bond is scheduled. - Joyce Calagos, Susan Green, Nancy Haber, Elena Engel, Corey Monteith, Sarah Greenwald, Joni Eisen, Paul Wormer, and Lawrence Baskett all expressed support for bold climate action, with some citing the UC Berkeley CLEAR report and the need for a multi-billion dollar measure. - Charlie Shamus (Council of Community Housing Organizations) stressed the need for accelerated affordable housing funding, noting the 23.6 billion estimated need and the recent board resolution on regional housing bonds. - Eileen Bogan criticized the plan for allowing enterprise departments (MTA, PUC) to receive general obligation bond funds despite governance and project concerns. - David Pilpel supported the plan as written, noting minor typos, and suggested duplicating the file to allow further amendment. - Francisco DeCosta called for attention to climate justice and indigenous land. Discussion Items - Presentation of the 10-Year Capital Plan: Brian Strong outlined the $41 billion plan, including $5.7 billion for general fund departments, and highlighted accomplishments since 2020 (e.g., 2,600 affordable housing units, seismic retrofits, new fire station). He explained the constrained bond program, policy of retiring debt before issuing new bonds, and proposed schedule: March 2024 public health bond ($200M for clinics and shelter at 1001 Polk St.), November 2024 affordable housing/shelter bond ($200M for 260 Golden Gate and other housing), and later bonds for transportation, parks, etc. - Board President Peskin’s framing: He noted the elimination of odd-year elections, the regional housing bond (BAFA) potentially on November 2024, and the need to decide whether to swap the two 2024 bonds to avoid voter confusion. He suggested hearing from DPH, HSH, and MOHCD about fiscal impacts of a swap. - Supervisor Safai’s concerns: He questioned the 1001 Polk Street shelter plan ($100M for 200 beds = $500k/bed) and the location in a drug-ridden area. He proposed moving the shelter conversation to November and using March for housing. He also noted the need for more general fund pay-as-you-go funding to reduce backlog. - Supervisor Mandelman’s comments: He emphasized climate, public health, and affordable housing. He expressed frustration with DPH’s lack of plan for severe mental illness facilities and opposition to a March 2024 public health bond without addressing those needs. He supported a transportation bond for climate and noted the need for a decarb bond. - Supervisor Ronan: She requested that future capital plans include estimated emissions reductions for each project to link to climate action goals. She supported exploring a regional transportation bond and noted the importance of timing relative to BAFA. - Supervisor Walton: He underscored the challenge of timing bonds with regional measures and the need for affordable housing investment. - Chair Chan: She questioned the split of shelter projects between March and November, and asked about the clarity of the affordable housing bond’s scope. She stressed maintaining the city’s AAA bond rating by adhering to the debt-retirement policy. - Fiscal Impacts of a Swap: DPH’s Greg Wagner estimated $9.9M escalation and $2.5M design costs if the public health bond were delayed to November. HSH’s Gigi Whitley estimated $5M escalation for the shelter project. Douglas Sleg (Deputy City Administrator) noted total escalation of $16M if both are delayed. MOHCD’s Lydia Ely stated that the affordable housing bond funds are needed by mid-2025, so an earlier bond would save escalation costs. Key Outcomes - Motion to Amend: Supervisor Safai moved to amend the resolution to revise the bond schedule so that the affordable housing and shelter bond appears on the March 2024 ballot and the public health and shelter bond appears on the November 2024 ballot. The motion was seconded by Supervisor Ronan and passed 4-0 (Vice Chair Mandelman absent). - Continuance: The committee voted 4-0 to continue the item to the April 26, 2023 meeting for further consideration, as the amendment is substantive and requires additional time. - Next Steps: The amended resolution will be considered at the April 26 committee meeting, with a final deadline of May 1 for administrative code compliance.

CAPITAL PLANNING 27% · PUBLIC HEALTH 22% · CLIMATE ADAPTATION 12% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 11%
1028
APR 19, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - April 19, 2023

The San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on April 19, 2023, from approximately 10:00 AM to 1:50 PM to consider 17 items. The committee approved several grant acceptances, contract amendments, affordable housing financings, and a collection transfer, while continuing a major overtime supplemental and two airport lease agreements to future meetings. Key discussions centered on overtime staffing, PG&E delays affecting affordable housing, and performance metrics for a tire lease contract. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (230221): Accepted a $70,000 retroactive grant from the California Coastal Conservancy for the Islais Creek Interpretive Program. Approved unanimously (Vice Chair Mandelman and Chair Chan voting aye, Member Safai absent). - Item 3 (230344): Authorized the gift of the Debenham Comedy Recording Collection to Emerson College. Approved unanimously (3-0). - Items 6-8 (230169, 230170, 230171): Accepted grants for Rec and Park: $500,000 from Bay Area Young Survivors for a memorial seating area in Golden Gate Park, $6,000,000 for Portsmouth Square renovation, and $2,300,000 for South Sunset Clubhouse and Playground renovation. All approved unanimously (3-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Overtime Supplemental): A single public speaker supported the overtime appropriation, suggesting creation of a volunteer force. - Items 11-15 (Hope SF Housing): A speaker expressed support for the housing projects but raised concerns about tenant representation and displacement of Black residents. Another speaker urged attention to PG&E delays. - Items 16-17 (PG&E Loan Amendments): Multiple speakers, including representatives from Bridge Housing, Mission Housing, and the Council of Community Housing Organizations, supported the loan increases, attributing cost overruns to PG&E delays and opposing cost-sharing with developers. Some speakers echoed frustration with PG&E and called for state legislation (SB 83). - Items 9-10 (Airport Leases): A speaker supported the lease agreements and urged the committee to take time to get them right. Discussion Items - Item 2 (230257): Overtime Supplemental – The committee discussed a $63.7 million appropriation to shift salary funds across six departments (Fire, Emergency Management, Public Health, Public Works, SFPUC, Sheriff) to cover overtime, with an amendment adding Recreation and Park ($1,050,000) and increasing amounts for DPH ($1.5M), PUC ($100,000), and DPW ($232,409). The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) noted DPH overtime was 24% higher than last year. Supervisor Safai expressed concern about chronic staffing shortages, particularly in emergency services. The item was continued to April 26, 2023, after the amendment was approved. - Item 4 (230207): Michelin Tire Lease – After a previous continuance, the committee reviewed performance data: 60-minute response time for road calls (generally met) and a mean distance between tire failure improving toward 12,000 miles. The BLA recommended approval. The contract, not to exceed $18.9 million over seven years, was approved (3-0). - Item 5 (230337): Bay Cities Produce Contract – The committee approved an amendment to increase the contract to $11.1 million (reduced from $12 million per BLA recommendation) for fresh and frozen produce for ZSFGH and Laguna Honda Hospital. The BLA received a 100% timely delivery audit for ZSFGH. Approved as amended (3-0). - Items 11-15 (230376-230380): Affordable Housing Financing – The committee approved financing for Sunnydale HOPE SF Block 3A (80 units, $68.8M in bonds, $27.3M city loan, $21.2M state grant) and Hunters View Phase 3 Vertical (118 units, $76M in bonds, $50.5M city loan). These projects represent the fourth and final affordable housing phases at their respective sites. The Hunters View project includes a right-to-return preference for former residents. Approved unanimously (3-0). - Items 16-17 (230319, 230318): Loan Amendments for PG&E Delays – The committee considered $4.2 million for 555 Larkin Street (108 units) and $8.9 million for 4840 Mission Street (137 units) to cover cost overruns from PG&E delays in power infrastructure. The BLA noted these costs are systematic and may set a precedent. Supervisor Safai expressed frustration with PG&E and the lack of SFPUC cost-sharing. The committee approved the items without recommendation to the full board (3-0), after removing language about a pending easement. Key Outcomes - Item 2 (Overtime Supplemental): Continued to the April 26, 2023 Budget and Finance Committee meeting, with an amended total of approximately $65 million and the addition of Recreation and Park. - Items 9-10 (Airport Leases): Continued to the call of the chair. - Items 16-17 (Loan Amendments): Approved without recommendation to the full board, as amended (striking easement language). - All other items (1, 3-8, 11-15): Approved with positive recommendation to the full Board of Supervisors, with the exception of Item 5 (amended) and Items 6-8 (co-sponsors added). - Votes: All approvals were unanimous (3-0) when votes were taken, except where noted (Item 1 had 2 votes with Safai absent).

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 31% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · PROCEDURAL 10% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 7%
1029
APR 17, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - April 17, 2023: Repeal of Travel Ban, Reparations Appointment, Surveillance Report, Ethics Appointment Continued

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, April 17, 2023, at approximately 10:15 AM under Chair Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shamann Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai. The committee considered four agenda items: the repeal of Chapter 12X (city travel and contracting bans), an appointment to the African American Reparations Advisory Committee, acceptance of the annual surveillance report, and a continued appointment to the Ethics Commission. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel (multiple items): Supported the repeal of Chapter 12X, stating the ban was not changing laws in other states and was costing the city. On the surveillance report, he noted two minor errors (page 19 date and PUC job classifications) but supported the resolution. On the Ethics Commission appointment, he urged the board to fill the seat quickly, noting that the vacancy had caused a lack of quorum at a recent commission meeting. - Unnamed caller on Item 2 (Reparations Committee): Emphasized the historical contributions of African Americans in San Francisco and criticized the lack of progress on reparations. Discussion Items Item 3: Repeal of Chapter 12X – Prohibitions on City Travel and Contracting Related to Discriminatory States Supervisor Raphael Mandelman, the sponsor, presented the ordinance to repeal Chapter 12X. He argued that the ban was ineffective: no other jurisdictions joined San Francisco's boycott, and the banned states had not changed their laws. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) found poor compliance: between 2017 and 2020, six departments were granted 47 waivers worth over $75 million; between July 2021 and July 2022, 35 departments approved 538 waivers worth $791 million. The BLA estimated staff costs of processing waivers at nearly $500,000, and procurement cost increases up to 20% (tens of millions of dollars). Mandelman noted unintended consequences, such as the Human Rights Commission being unable to visit HBCUs or civil rights landmarks, and disaster relief complications. He argued that repealing the ban would save money and allow the city to focus on local vulnerable populations. Vice Chair Walton opposed the repeal, stating that it had not been analyzed for impacts on small businesses and protected communities. He called for a more methodical approach with a plan before repeal. Supervisor Safai supported the repeal, noting that the ban had not achieved its intended effect, had increased costs, and had been expanded to 30 states. He committed to working on local business enterprise (LBE) opportunities. Chair Dorsey supported the repeal, adding himself as a co-sponsor, citing inefficiencies in city contracting. The motion passed 2-1 (Walton dissenting) and was sent to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Appointment to the African American Reparations Advisory Committee (Seat C15) The committee considered nine applicants for one seat expiring January 2024. Vice Chair Walton led the discussion, thanking applicants and encouraging continued engagement. Applicants spoke about their backgrounds, lived experiences, and ideas for reparations. Notably, Frederick Martin attended multiple committee meetings and highlighted his housing justice work; other applicants included Fatima Abdul Khalik, Larry Martin, Shakama Stoney, Tiana Danielle Blunt, Tatiana White, and others. Three applicants did not appear. Vice Chair Walton nominated Frederick Martin. The motion passed unanimously and was sent to the full board. Item 4: Acceptance of Annual Surveillance Report (Administrative Code Section 19B) Julian Johnson, Director of the Committee on Information Technology (COIT), presented the inaugural annual surveillance report covering 31 reports from 21 city departments. Technologies included audio recorders, automated license plate readers, drones, RFID systems, security cameras, and face recognition (with an addendum from the police). Most departments reported no proposed changes or violations. Some reported changes in authorized job titles or equipment. The police department disclosed four incidents where officers requested face recognition data from external agencies, but no matches were received. Johnson noted two corrections to the summary memo. Chair Dorsey asked about resources for COIT; Johnson indicated the office could use additional support. The motion to accept the report passed unanimously. Item 1: Appointment to the Ethics Commission This item was continued to the call of the chair. Chair Dorsey noted that a new applicant had appeared and another was considering applying. Public commenter David Pilpel highlighted the urgency of filling the seat, as the commission had lacked a quorum. The motion to continue passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 3: Passed 2-1 (Walton dissenting) to repeal Chapter 12X, sending to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 2: Unanimous appointment of Frederick Martin to the African American Reparations Advisory Committee. - Item 4: Unanimous acceptance of the annual surveillance report. - Item 1: Unanimous continuation of the Ethics Commission appointment to the call of the chair.

PROCEDURAL 21% · LGBTQ+ HISTORY 18% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 13% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
1030
APR 17, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use Committee Meeting: April 17, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 17, 2023, from approximately 1:45 PM to 5:00 PM (actual start/end not specified). The committee, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar and joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin, considered six agenda items. The most contentious item was the landmark designation of the Castro Theater's interior, which drew extensive public comment and resulted in a split vote on an amendment to specify fixed theatrical seating. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was used; all items were considered individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Eviction protections): No public comment was offered. - Items 2 & 3 (Home SF programs): No public comment was offered. - Item 4 (Planning code reorganization): No public comment was offered. - Item 5 (Gates and railings for small businesses): No public comment was offered. - Item 6 (Castro Theater landmark designation): Over 90 speakers testified in person and by phone, with one minute per speaker due to high turnout. The public was deeply divided: - Supporters of the amendment (fixed seating): Included Castro LGBTQ Cultural District Director Tina Valentina Aguirre, who stated APE had not engaged with her organization; representatives from San Francisco Heritage, Art Deco Society, Castro Theater Conservancy, and many residents. They argued that the phrase "presence of seating" was vague and that fixed theatrical seating configured in a movie palace style is essential to preserve the theater's historic character as a cinema and LGBTQ cultural landmark. Speaker George Koskevich noted that the seating configuration is "intrinsically linked to the place of the Castro Theater in LGBT community building culture." Several speakers cited APE's record at the Fox Theater in Oakland, where they promised films but now show none. A petition with 11,991 signatures supporting seat preservation was mentioned. - Opponents of the amendment (flexible seating): Included many Castro merchants (over 100 businesses signed a petition), representatives of the Eureka Valley Neighborhood Association, Castro Community Benefit District, and residents. They argued that flexible seating is necessary for economic viability, that the theater has struggled with low attendance (e.g., 17 people for a Lion King sing-along on June 5, 2022), and that APE's $15 million investment will revitalize the neighborhood. Speaker David Goldman noted only 200 of 1,400 seats would be removed. Several speakers emphasized that the theater has been dark for months and that fixed seating would prevent diverse programming, including standing-room events for queer artists. Attorney Andrew Junius submitted a letter from 26 Hartford Street neighbors supporting APE's plan. Discussion Items - Item 1: Ordinance extending eviction protections for 60 days (Supervisor Preston): The committee had previously approved amendments at a prior meeting. Supervisor Preston moved to send the amended file to the full board with a positive recommendation. The motion passed unanimously (3-0) after no public comment. - Items 2 & 3: Home SF program amendments (Supervisor Peskin): Supervisor Peskin requested a one-week continuance to April 24, 2023, citing pending city attorney documentation. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue both items. - Item 4: Planning code reorganization (from Supervisor Dorsey's office): Presented by Madison Tam. The ordinance updates neighborhood commercial and mixed-use zoning controls, including amendments to align with recently passed nighttime entertainment legislation. Supervisor Peskin's previous questions about adult entertainment buffers were addressed. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send it to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 5: Ordinance exempting gates, railings, and grill work from transparency requirements for small businesses (Supervisor Safai): The ordinance reduces transparency requirements from 75% to 20% for non-residential uses, exempts cannabis retail uses, and requires artwork on new gates. It includes a three-year grace period for existing non-conforming gates. The planning department confirmed they will begin working on objective design standards after the mayor signs the legislation. Supervisor Preston expressed support for updating codes that penalize small businesses. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send it to the full board as a committee report. - Item 6: Castro Theater landmark designation amendment (Supervisor Mandelman): Supervisor Mandelman reported that negotiations between APE and the Castro Conservancy failed to reach an agreement. He recommended accepting the Historic Preservation Commission's recommendation without adding

PUBLIC COMMENT 38% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 24% · LAND USE 8% · ARTS AND CULTURE 6%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com