Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1001–1010 ENTRIES
1001
MAY 15, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting – May 15, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 15, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Myrna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and President Aaron Peskin. The committee acted on one landmark designation, a commemorative plaque for disability rights leader Judith Heumann, and an ordinance expanding small business fee waivers. Public Comments & Testimony - On the Westwood Park landmark item, Kathleen Baitix (Westwood Park Association) expressed support and presented the neighborhood’s history. Pauline Ju, board president of the Westwood Park Homeowners Association, said she does not see the gates as exclusionary and guessed the neighborhood is 30–40 percent Asian. David Pilpel supported the designation. A remote caller voiced concern that gates are inherently exclusionary and classist. - On the Judith Heumann plaque item, many speakers supported the resolution, including Nicole Bond (Mayor’s Office on Disability), Deborah Kaplan (Mayor’s Office on Disability), 504 sit-in participant Dennis Bullets (as transcribed), Emily Badics (Longmore Institute on Disability), Tiana Hinsey (Independent Living Resource Center SF), Ted Jackson, John Skolnick, Annette Williams (SFMTA), Georgia Connor (Creativity Explored), and others. A letter from Sasha Bittner was read by staff. Callers highlighted Heumann’s mentorship and the significance of the 1977 Section 504 sit-in. - On the small business fee waiver item, one remote caller, speaking as Disability Activism SF, expressed support for helping small businesses recover from the pandemic. Discussion Items - Westwood Park Entrance Gates and Pillars: Supervisor Melgar introduced the resolution to initiate landmark designation for the original gates at Miramar Avenue/Monterey Boulevard and pillars at Miramar Avenue/Ocean Avenue. Melgar noted the neighborhood’s 1916 origin, the loss of most original pillars, and the Westwood Park Association’s restoration work in 2003. She also acknowledged the historic use of racial covenants. Kathleen Baitix described the development’s roughly 700 lots and 650-plus bungalows, the architect Louis Christian Mulgart, and the original 128 street lamps; only four original freestanding pillars survive. Supervisor Preston said the gate form raised concerns about exclusionary symbolism and asked that the landmark report grapple directly with that history. - Judith Heumann Commemorative Plaque: Supervisor Melgar presented the resolution authorizing a plaque or commemorative artwork at United Nations Plaza and directing Public Works to install it. She described Heumann’s life, including her disability-rights work, the 1977 Section 504 sit-in at 50 United Nations Plaza — which lasted 25 days and involved more than 150 people — and her federal appointments. Nicole Bond and Deborah Kaplan spoke in support, as did a participant in the original sit-in. Supervisor Peskin asked to be added as a co-sponsor. Melgar read non-substantive amendments suggested by the disability community. - Small Business Month Fee Waivers: Supervisor Joel Engardio presented the ordinance to add new awning installations to the existing May fee-waiver program for storefront improvements, and to codify existing waivers for replacement awnings, awning signs, and pedestrian lighting. He noted only 60 applications had been processed under the program in eight years. Amendments included refund-processing language and a Chan amendment limiting new awning waivers to fiscal years 2023 and 2024. Engardio accepted both, requested a duplicate file to explore expanding the waiver to all signs, and cited 325 sign permits issued in May from 2015 to 2022. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Westwood Park): Motion to recommend the landmark designation resolution to the full board as a committee report passed 3–0. - Item 2 (Judith Heumann plaque): Motion to adopt non-substantive amendments and recommend the resolution as amended to the full board as a committee report passed 3–0. - Item 3 (Small business fee waivers): Motion to amend and recommend the original file as amended to the full board as a committee report passed 3–0. The duplicated file was continued to the call of the chair.

DISABILITY RIGHTS 31% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 27% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT 13%
1002
MAY 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - May 11, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee convened on May 11, 2023, to consider five items: two liquor license transfers, an ordinance amending health code massage permit requirements, a resolution to rename Stowe Lake in Golden Gate Park, and a resolution on police recruitment bonuses and staffing. The committee voted on all items, with one continued to a future date. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Liquor License Transfer – 1336 Grant Avenue): Santino DeRose, a nearby business owner, spoke in opposition, stating the new owner had reduced grocery offerings, increased alcohol displays, and that the area already has nine other liquor stores within four blocks. He noted over 30 letters of opposition were submitted. - Item 4 (Renaming Stowe Lake): Multiple speakers supported the resolution. Henry McCulski, a Holocaust survivor’s child, emphasized the need to reject anti-Semitism. Angus McFarland proposed naming the lake after Patrick Quigley, a former park foreman. Representatives from the Jewish Community Relations Council and the California Legislative Jewish Caucus cited rising anti-Semitism: a 41% increase in anti-Semitic incidents in California in 2022 and a 91% increase in white supremacist propaganda. All encouraged the name change. - Item 5 (Police Recruitment Bonuses): David Pilpel spoke in support but cautioned against the word “automatically” in the resolution title and suggested civilianizing some sworn positions to improve efficiency. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Liquor License Transfer (The Nature Stop): Officer Salmonson reported the Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval, but the acting captain of Central Station opposed. Applicant’s attorney argued for approval based on a clean operation and security measures. Committee members noted 29 letters of opposition, oversaturation in the area, and opposition from District 3 Supervisor Peskin. The committee voted to prepare a resolution finding that the transfer would not serve public convenience or necessity. - Item 2 – Liquor License Transfer (Casa Lucaz 3): Officer Salmonson reported no opposition from Ingleside Station and ALU recommended approval with conditions. Applicant’s representative confirmed that all conditions (graffiti removal, lighting, window clearing) were met within 24 hours. The committee voted to prepare a resolution finding that the transfer would serve public convenience or necessity. - Item 3 – Health Code Massage Permit Requirements: This ordinance, previously amended on April 27, was heard again. No public comment. The committee voted to recommend approval to the full board. - Item 4 – Renaming Stowe Lake: Supervisor Melgar presented the resolution, detailing William Stowe’s anti-Semitic record as a 19th-century California Assembly Speaker. The committee expressed support, and Chair Stephanie, Supervisor Dorsey, and Vice Chair Engardio added their names as co-sponsors. The committee voted to send the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 5 – Police Recruitment and Staffing: Supervisor Dorsey introduced the resolution, noting that the City of Alameda now offers a $75,000 recruiting bonus. He proposed amendments to include parallel provisions for the Sheriff’s Department and to remove the word “automatically” from the text. After public comment, the committee voted to adopt the amendment and then continued the item to the call of the chair. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion passed (3-0) to send a resolution to the Board of Supervisors recommending that the liquor license transfer not serve public convenience or necessity. - Item 2: Motion passed (3-0) to recommend approval of the liquor license transfer. - Item 3: Motion passed (3-0) to recommend the ordinance to the full board. - Item 4: Motion passed (3-0) to send the resolution as a committee report to the full board. - Item 5: Motion to amend (including parallel provisions for Sheriff’s Department and removing “automatically”) passed (3-0). Motion to continue to the call of the chair passed (3-0).

PUBLIC COMMENT 34% · LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 19% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 16% · PROCEDURAL 10%
1003
MAY 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
Special Joint Health and Planning Commission Meeting – May 11, 2023: CPMC Annual Compliance Review

This informational hearing was held jointly by the San Francisco Health Commission and Planning Commission on Thursday, May 11, 2023, at 10:15 AM. The sole agenda item was the review of California Pacific Medical Center’s (CPMC) Annual Compliance Statement for the 2021 reporting period, the ninth year of the development agreement (DA). City staff from Planning, the Health Service System, the Mayor’s Office of Economic and Workforce Development, and the Department of Public Health presented findings, and public comment was heard. The meeting concluded with a staff recommendation to find CPMC in compliance for 2021, though several commissioners raised concerns about ongoing obligations and community needs. Public Comments & Testimony - Billie Jean Wall (representing former CPMC warm‑water pool users): Described the long‑standing community aquatics exercise program at Davies and Pacific campuses, which she said was structured (not drop‑in) and provided critical therapy. She requested the program be restored. - Dr. Teresa Palmer (former St. Luke’s physician): Urged a 10‑year extension of the monitoring agreement, stated that CPMC has a pattern of maximizing profitable short‑stay acute care while reducing less lucrative services for underserved populations. She cited the closure of labor and delivery at St. Luke’s without notice, discontinuation of the Davies warm‑pool low‑cost use, and lack of support for subacute beds. She argued the commission has stretched to find CPMC compliant. - Gloria Rivera Since (community advocate): Highlighted the lack of hospital‑based subacute beds in San Francisco, forcing families to send loved ones out of county. She asked what steps the health commission is taking to ensure this care remains available. - Melanie Grossman: Noted a pattern of service closures (Alzheimer’s unit, skilled nursing facility beds, warm‑water pool) and asked when the closure trend will stop. - Tony Oriera: Supported Dr. Palmer’s call for a 10‑year extension, argued that CPMC should be found non‑compliant for the labor and delivery reduction without notice, and questioned the point of a development agreement with no penalties for non‑compliance. Discussion Items - Staff Presentation: Elizabeth Pearl (Planning) introduced the review. Key updates: CPMC completed construction of the Mission Bernal and Van Ness hospitals, made over $73 million in payments, and met most hiring and healthcare commitments. The City’s Health Service System reported CPMC in compliance on fee‑increase limits. Lowell Rice (OEWD) noted that 47% of entry‑level positions (48 hires out of 102 referrals) came from the First Source network, with 67% from priority neighborhoods and a 91% retention rate. Max Scarrow (DPH) reviewed healthcare provisions: CPMC exceeded charity care/Medi‑Cal patient counts (30,779) and community benefits ($16.5 million), continued participation in Medi‑Cal Managed Care, and maintained a partnership with NEMS for Tenderloin patients. However, labor and delivery services at Mission Bernal remained closed under a COVID waiver (without prior notice, found non‑compliant in 2020, but for 2021 DPH did not issue a new finding because the action occurred earlier). The Center for Excellence in Community Health (Health First) served 652 patients in 2021, below the target of 800; the pandemic was cited. The Center for Excellence in Senior Health (ACE unit) exceeded its goal. CPMC reported that the warm‑water pool at Davies closed due to a broken pump and lift and is expected to reopen by end of August/early September 2023. On subacute beds, CPMC has not committed to financial support for new units but is open to discussions. - Commissioner Questions and Comments: - Commissioner Bernal (Health): Asked about the 1,500 new Medi‑Cal enrollees in the Tenderloin. CPMC’s Kate Wyland explained that no new Managed Service Organization (MSO) was created before 2015, so the obligation lapsed; they continue to work with NEMS and St. Anthony’s. Only about 8% of the 4,593 NEMS patients were new in 2020. Commissioner Bernal urged CPMC to do more to serve the Tenderloin. - Commissioner Christian (Health): Questioned the lack of documentation for new Tenderloin patients and encouraged CPMC to increase services. On the warm‑water pool, CPMC’s Melissa White clarified it is a therapy pool (requires doctor’s order) and will reopen after repairs. Commissioner Christian urged CPMC to proactively address the subacute bed crisis. - Commissioner Gamero (Planning): Asked about the timeline for restoring labor and delivery at Mission Bernal. CPMC’s interim CEO stated they intend to reopen and will meet with DPH to plan a safe return, but no specific timeline was given. On the Center for Excellence, he noted the community advisory board is meeting again in person. Language services are currently only Spanish and English; he encouraged proactive expansion. - Commissioner Koppel (Planning): Praised construction compliance and the success of City Build and First Source programs in hiring from disadvantaged neighborhoods. - Commissioner Braun (Planning): Asked about the Guerrero Plaza improvements (part of the DA). Staff reported that the plaza design and permitting have been lengthy, but a substitution agreement has increased funding, and a permit application is in process with construction expected this year. On transportation demand management (TDM), she noted that only 18% of employees were enrolled in the transit subsidy in 2021; CPMC said they plan to hold transit fairs in November 2023 and are working to improve commute options. Commissioner Braun encouraged robust implementation. - Commissioner Diamond (Planning): Questioned the legal obligation to restore labor and delivery services. Staff noted that CPMC can reduce services with proper notice and meet‑and‑confer, but they did not provide notice in 2020. The city attorney said the health commission’s Prop Q authority is advisory only. Commissioner Diamond also raised concerns about the TDM goal (15% reduction in single‑occupancy vehicle trips by 2024) and whether the pandemic justifies an extension. She asked what happens if the goal is not met; staff said further measures would be required, but amendment would need Board of Supervisors approval. - Commissioner Chow (Health): Reflected on the history of the DA and the complexity of reopening OB services, noting patient safety, staffing, and declining birth rates. She commended CPMC for the improved cultural competency report (class standards) but urged more active engagement on subacute beds and a clearer process for the labor and delivery closure. She questioned why the 2021 compliance finding did not reflect the ongoing closure, since no change had occurred since the 2020 non‑compliance. - Commissioner Moore (Planning): Emphasized that the TDM plan is a continuous obligation and that the Cathedral Hill neighborhood has raised concerns about Clipper Card usage and transit mode share. She noted that the DA’s obligation to serve low‑income communities, especially in the Tenderloin, has consistently fallen short, and urged CPMC to embrace the spirit of the agreement as a nonprofit receiving tax relief. - Commissioner Imperial (Planning): Stressed the need for better data on barriers to community partnerships and asked whether SFMTA could impose additional fees if TDM goals are not met by 2024. SFMTA staff (Forest Chamberlain) said they will follow up but that no such fees have been discussed. - Commissioner Christian (Health): Requested a breakdown of construction hires by neighborhood (staff agreed to provide). She also urged CPMC to find temporary alternatives for the warm‑water pool users and to provide advance notice of service changes. Key Outcomes - Staff Recommendation: The directors of Planning and Public Health will determine compliance based on the hearing. Staff recommended finding CPMC in compliance for the 2021 reporting year, noting that most obligations were met or exceeded, but highlighting ongoing areas of concern: labor and delivery services at Mission Bernal, patient enrollment in Health First, culturally and linguistically appropriate services, and CPMC’s rate increases as a city health service provider. - No Formal Vote: The hearing was informational; no motion or vote was taken by either commission. - Next Steps: CPMC will meet with DPH to discuss safely reopening labor and delivery at Mission Bernal. The 2022 compliance report will be due soon, and at least one more joint hearing is expected before the DA expires in August 2023. Commissioners requested follow‑up on several issues: the legal basis for the 2021 compliance finding on labor and delivery, the status of TDM measures and the 2024 goal, data on new Medi‑Cal enrollees in the Tenderloin, and progress on subacute bed partnerships.

HEALTH SERVICES 31% · PUBLIC HEALTH 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 11%
1004
MAY 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
Special Joint Building Inspection and Planning Commission: Site Permit Reform Project - May 11, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission and Building Inspection Commission held a special joint hearing on Thursday, May 11, 2023, to receive an informational presentation on the proposed Site Permit Reform Project. The project aims to replace the current site permit process with a new 'development review permit' that would streamline review, consolidate agency comments into a single 30-day cycle, and provide a clear implementation roadmap for applicants. The hearing featured extensive public comment from architects, developers, and community members, followed by detailed commissioner discussion on project management, interagency coordination, staffing, and accountability. Public Comments & Testimony - Charlie Chen (architect): Expressed support for the reform but urged the Planning Department to better control input by, for example, eliminating unnecessary reviews for in-law units, raising the historical preservation threshold from 50 to 100 years, and allowing straightforward projects to bypass neighbor notifications. - Christopher Roach (architect, AIA Public Policy & Advocacy Committee) : Expressed strong support for the reforms, calling it a historic opportunity to improve permitting. Noted that the 'devil is in the details' and asked for continued collaboration with architects. - David Gast (architect): Broadly supportive, highlighting the need for concurrent review, digital tools, and clear checklists. Urged bringing the Department of Public Works (DPW) and Fire Department fully on board. - Serena Calhoun (architect): Supported the reforms but stated she generally does not advise clients to use the current site permit process due to two-to-five-year timelines. Requested eliminating separate site permit/full permit paths, publishing unwritten planning policies, limiting design reviews to objective code terms, and improving the Accela interface. - Lev Weisbach (architect): Supported the reforms as a top priority from the AIA small firms committee. Expressed concern about DPW delays (citing a 7.5-year project) and the difficulty of working with PG&E on transformer vaults. - Mark Loper (entitlements lawyer): Welcomed planning handling minor projects without other departments. Supported advanced interagency review and urged faster DPW processes. - Jerry Dratler: Urged expediting site permits to help housing production, noting San Francisco is the only major California city that processes site permits with building permits, causing 4-18 month delays. - Georgia Shudish (building code expert): Called for changes to slope protection requirements, egress issues, and demolition thresholds. Noted that demo counts must be provided at intake, not later. - Sean Keegrin (Residential Builders Association) : Urged a pause on moving the site permit process to the Planning Department, arguing other broken pieces (backlogs, planner responsiveness, 311 notice delays) must be fixed first. Said concurrent plan checking is unrealistic when projects go through many revisions. - Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition) : Expressed gratitude for the reform and support for using digital tools from start to finish. Said they will continue to solicit feedback from members. - Kevin (architect, no last name given) : Emphasized the need for accountability, noting that planners often do not respond to emails or phone calls in a timely manner. - Anonymous resident (name not stated) : Described a 1.5-year process to legalize an unpermitted unit, asking for shorter timelines and separate pathways for ADU legalization. - Dennis Richards (former commissioner) : Enthusiastically supported the reform, calling it 'allelujah' and a '10 out of 10.' Noted that similar improvements were called for 20 years ago. - Instavantis (architect) : Stressed that interdepartmental communication must include PG&E and DPW. Suggested contracting out DPW services to speed up small projects. - Sue Esther: Urged Planning and DBI to use the same computer system for transparency, noting past manipulation issues. Called for a report from DBI on their plans. - Carrie Green (architect, AIA San Francisco) : Supported reforms but added two points: ensure applicants are qualified per state law (Business and Professions Code) and be aware of new state law on architectural copyright protection. Discussion Items - Presentation by Michael Christensen (Principal Planner, Permit Center) : Reviewed the current site permit process (a uniquely San Francisco concept) and proposed a new development review permit. Key changes include: single online intake via Planning's Accela system; concurrent 30-day plan check by Planning, DBI, Public Works, and Fire with consolidated comments; checklists to define review scope; a roadmap of all needed permits; and issuance directly from Planning. The new process mirrors what other California cities do. Statistics: 96% of new building projects currently use site permits (only 7 small sheds do not). For alterations, the mix varies. - Commissioner questions and staff responses: - President Tanner emphasized the value of legislated timelines (citing Prop H success). Asked about ideal total timelines and number of review cycles. Liz Wadi (Director of Current Planning) said the 30-day completeness check and 30-day plan check are already being implemented starting July 1, 2023, as part of Permit Streamlining Act compliance. Michael Christensen noted that tools like Airtable have worked for Prop H and could be scaled. Neville Pereira (Deputy Director, DBI) reported DBI already limits to two revisions before supervisor escalation. - Commissioner Diamond raised concerns about geotechnical reviews (neighbors often worry about undermining). Staff said triggers for geotechs (slope, excavation) are defined and will be flagged early via checklists, but two versions (preliminary vs. final) may still exist. She also noted architect Calhoun's reluctance to use site permits—staff replied the new process will make site permits more attractive. - Commissioner Braun asked about staffing capacity and budget. Wadi acknowledged challenges but said new management dashboards (showing planner workloads in real time) and a recent re-org have improved efficiency. She also noted the department is fee-for-service and will need to set rates appropriately. Regarding the impact of commission changes on interagency-reviewed projects, she said the checklists will help planners understand which changes affect other agencies. - Commissioner Koppel praised the collaboration and stressed the need for a bulletproof system to prevent abuse (referencing past corruption scandals). He also urged not to neglect downtown commercial building permits in the reform. - Vice President Moore cautioned that management alone cannot solve all problems; leadership and human capital are essential. She emphasized that checklists must be co-created with architects to avoid omissions. She also highlighted the need for clear plan submittal guidelines. - Commissioner Imperial asked for case studies to be presented to the commissions during the summer to see how the new process works in practice. - BIC Commissioner Shaddox echoed the need to involve PG&E early. - BIC Commissioner Alexander Toot inquired about long-term data collection and interdepartmental management. Christensen said they will use Accela to track tasks and due dates, enabling proactive management. - BIC Commissioner Tam asked if applicants could log in to see comments in real time. Staff confirmed that Accela's Property Information Map shows workflow status and documents post overnight, but the official consolidated letter will still be issued. - Public Works (Deborah Lutzky) confirmed 100% commitment to the project, stating they are working on checklists for early input on transformer vaults, tree removals, right-of-way changes, and street improvement permits. She noted that PG&E has been asked to provide transparent materials on vault requirements. - Fire Department was not present but staff said they are engaged. Key Outcomes - No formal vote was taken; this was an informational presentation. - Commissioners and staff agreed to continue outreach, including smaller working sessions with stakeholders to walk through example projects. - The project will proceed with developing checklists, case studies, and a legislative package targeted for summer 2023. Concurrently, Planning is implementing 30-day completeness and plan check timelines starting July 1, 2023, as part of Permit Streamlining Act compliance. - Direction was given to involve all relevant agencies (DPW, Fire, PUC, SFMTA, PG&E) and to address specific concerns: integration of DPW's 'Clarity' system, resolution of conflicting comments between agencies, and creation of submittal guidelines in consultation with architects. - President Tanner and President Beto committed to continued joint work and annual reviews to hold staff accountable to metrics. - The meeting adjourned with a note that the road to success is always under construction.

PERMIT PROCESS 51% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 13% · TECHNOLOGY AND INFRASTRUCTURE 11% · PUBLIC SAFETY 6%
1005
MAY 10, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
Police Commission Meeting on Juvenile Diversion, Crime Statistics, and Policy Revisions - May 10, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission convened on May 10, 2023 to address juvenile diversion initiatives, crime trends, the Early Intervention System (EIS), the Collaborative Reform Initiative (CRI), and revisions to Department General Order (DGO) 2.01. The meeting opened with the recognition of Officer Yuka Nagamine and featured significant public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Betrellis objected to the meeting beginning with officer recognition, stating that unsolved cases should take priority. He also criticized the commission for eliminating remote public comment, forcing the public to appear in person. - Mattie Brown, mother of Arbre Abercassa (murdered in 2006), pleaded for the resolution of her son's unsolved case and urged the hiring of investigators to solve cold cases. - A third speaker referenced an unspecified personal ordeal involving a crime, questioning its ethical handling and impact. - During the juvenile diversion discussion, multiple speakers supported the concept but emphasized the need to include youth voices and families. Don Stickle (Sunset Youth Services) noted that all necessary community resources exist but require appetite from SFPD and the District Attorney. Molly Brown (Juvenile Justice Providers Association) echoed that San Francisco has robust services ready to be leveraged for pre-arrest diversion. Dan Macallair (Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice) stated that implementation only requires a decision and action from the city. Hilary, director of CARC, added that the agency has run post-arrest diversion for 20 years and is now working on a pre-arrest model to avoid trauma to youth. Discussion Items 1. Weekly Officer Recognition – Captain Derek Jackson honored Officer Yuka Nagamine for her exemplary service including work in Japantown and her role in solving a homicide. Commissioners commended her community policing and bilingual skills. Public commenters criticized the practice of beginning meetings with praise for police. 2. Juvenile Diversion Best Practices – The commission heard presentations from David Mohammed (National Institute for Criminal Justice Reform) on Oakland's Neighborhood Opportunity and Accountability Board and Jessica Ellis (Centinela Youth Services) on Los Angeles's pre-booking diversion model. Both emphasized that early diversion reduces recidivism and trauma. Chief Scott expressed support, stating all necessary ingredients are in place. Gabe Calvillo (Juvenile Probation) confirmed active discussions. Commissioner Benedicto noted ongoing efforts over two years. The commission committed to a follow-up in two months. 3. Chief’s Report – Chief Scott reported a 7% overall reduction in Part I serious crimes (1,300 fewer than prior year) but a 27% increase in homicides (19 total, 13 firearm-related). Shootings were down 8%. Specific incidents included the fatal shooting of a 15-year-old on Eddy Street (May 4), a stabbing homicide with an arrest, and a shooting on a Muni bus (May 5) with no arrest. Nine bank robberies were solved with an arrest. The chief updated on stun driving enforcement (three vehicle seizures) and the Banco Brown Walgreens shooting, stating the investigation remains open and video will not be released until closed. Commissioner Walker expressed concern about transparency and the proposed MOU with the DA on video release. The chief clarified that video release would occur after case closure. 4. DPA Director’s Report – Acting Director Sarah Hawkins noted cases pending beyond 270 days decreased from 34 to 26 (20 stayed). DPA received 14 new complaints; top allegations were failure to investigate (19%) and inappropriate behavior (11%). A key issue report on officer discipline was issued, and DPA won an award for audit work. 5. Commission Reports – Brief updates from commissioners; no action taken. 6. Early Intervention System (EIS) – Commander Paul Yep and Sergeant Darwin Naval presented Q3 and Q4 2022 data. Alerts decreased 19.6% from Q3 (864) to Q4 (695), mostly due to use-of-force policy changes. One new intervention was opened. Transition to Benchmark Analytics continues with technical issues; go-live expected Q4 2023. 7. Collaborative Reform Initiative (CRI) – 245 of 272 recommendations are in substantial compliance; 27 remain. Work is organized into five project plans covering use-of-force data, demographic capture, community policing, bias-free policing, and internal discipline. Phase three is on schedule for completion by April 2024. 8. Revision of DGO 2.01 (General Rules of Conduct) – The commission debated amendments. Changes included adding the phrase "or impaired by" to align with other DGOs and striking a redundant sentence on insubordination. Commissioner Benedicto moved to approve the revised order for use in meet-and-confer negotiations. The motion passed unanimously (7-0). Key Outcomes - Approved amended DGO 2.01 for negotiation with bargaining units (7-0). - Juvenile diversion program development to continue; progress update requested in two months. - Chief Scott will provide updates on the Banco Brown investigation as appropriate. - EIS transition to Benchmark continues; target go-live Q4 2023. - CRI remains on track for April 2024 completion. Adjournment - The meeting was adjourned.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 34% · JUVENILE JUSTICE 29% · PUBLIC SAFETY 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11%
1006
MAY 10, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - May 10, 2023: COPs, Airport Leases, and Grant Approvals

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, May 10, 2023, at 10:00 AM. Chair Connie Chan presided, joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and later Supervisor Ahsha Safaí. The committee approved several routine lease amendments, tax credit extensions, and grant applications, and held extended discussion on two major certificate of participation (COP) ordinances, including implementation delays for public housing and SRO elevator repairs. Consent Calendar - Items 1 & 2 (Airport Leases): Approved resolutions amending the Smarte Carte luggage cart lease agreement (modifying flat service fee methodology) and exercising the final one-year extension for the off-airport reprographics lease (837 Malcolm Road, Burlingame; annual rent $150,450). Both forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0, Safaí excused). - Item 3 (Child Care Tax Credit): Approved ordinance extending the early care and education commercial rents tax credit for qualifying child care facilities through December 31, 2028. Added Vice Chair Mandelman as co-sponsor. Forwarded 2-0. - Item 4 (Housing Trust Fund Grant): Authorized MOHCD to apply for up to $5 million in matching funds from the California Department of Housing and Community Development’s Local Housing Trust Fund Program. Added Mandelman as co-sponsor. Forwarded 2-0. - Item 5 (Abandoned Vehicle Fee): Extended the $1 abandoned vehicle abatement fee on all vehicles registered to city residents for ten years (June 1, 2023, through May 31, 2033). Chair Chan noted the full board will need a two-thirds vote. Forwarded 2-0. Discussion Items - Item 6 (Pit Stop Program Grant): Resolution to retroactively accept and expend a $250,000 grant from BART for the Pit Stop Public Toilet Program at three locations (24th & Mission, 16th & Mission, Hallidie Plaza). Public Works presented usage data: over 30,000 uses at 16th & Mission, over 27,000 at 24th & Mission, and 15,000 at Hallidie Plaza in calendar year 2022; also collected 500+ needles and 2,000+ waste bags. Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) Nick Minard reported that the nonprofit operating these sites (Hunters Point Family) has financial distress: net assets declined from $1.8 million to $750,000, cash at 2% of operating expenses. BLA recommended approval but noted Public Works plans to reprocure the contract. Supervisor Ronen’s office requested a continuance. The committee voted to continue the item to the call of the chair (3-0). - Items 7, 8, 9 (Certificates of Participation): Three ordinances authorizing: (7) appropriation of $275 million for refunding COPs; (8) refunding up to $260 million of existing COPs, estimated to save $7.9 million in net present value debt service; (9) new COPs not to exceed $146.8 million for affordable housing, community facilities, and financing costs. The new COP funding plan includes: $40M for site acquisition, $20M for public housing/HUD co-op repairs, $12M for educator housing, $10M for SRO elevator repairs, $30M for nonprofit community facility acquisitions, and $34.8M for financing costs. Key Debate: Supervisor Dean Preston expressed strong frustration that two components—public housing repairs ($20M) and SRO elevator repairs ($10M)—still lacked a timeline for issuing NOFAs or RFPs nearly a year after the spending plan was agreed (June 2022). MOHCD Deputy Director Benjamin McCloskey cited staff capacity and vacancy issues (30% staff loss over three years). HSH’s Emily Cohen later clarified that a solicitation for elevator repairs would go out this summer. MOHCD Director Eric Shaw stated the public housing/co-op piece is delayed due to governance and capacity concerns among co-op boards and the need for alignment with redevelopment plans for Plaza East and North Beach. Chair Chan noted the committee would have a deeper housing discussion later that day. Modification: The BLA’s recommendation for a report back by November 1, 2023, was revised to a quarterly report starting in September 2023, as proposed by Chair Chan and accepted by MOHCD. Public Comments & Testimony - Francisco De Costa (speaking on items 7-9) accused presenters of being “full of BS” and demanded accountability for federal funds, including a need assessment. - Greg Hardeman (Elevator Constructors Union, Local 8) supported item 9, emphasizing safety risks from broken elevators in SROs and urging fast track of the $10 million allocation. - Additional speaker (name not given) urged the committee to dedicate $85 million in new revenue to land acquisition and housing, citing the Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board’s recommendation. Key Outcomes - Items 1-5 approved and forwarded to full board with positive recommendations (unanimous). - Item 6 continued to the call of the chair for further discussion with Supervisor Ronen’s office and to allow Public Works to provide information on the nonprofit’s financial health and the new RFP process. - Items 7-9 approved and forwarded to full board with positive recommendations (unanimous). The committee requested MOHCD provide a quarterly report back by September 2023, including timelines for remaining NOFAs on public housing repairs and SRO elevator repairs.

PUBLIC HOUSING 35% · PROCEDURAL 13% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 10% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 10%
1007
MAY 10, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Budget and Appropriations Committee Hearing on Affordable and Supportive Housing Spending - May 10, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a hearing on May 10, 2023, to discuss affordable and supportive housing spending, revenue sources, and recommendations from the Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board. The hearing featured presentations from the Department of Disability and Aging Services (DAS), Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH), Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD), and the Council of Community Housing Organizations (CCHO) along with the Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board (HSFOB). Public comment was limited to one minute per speaker. The committee continued the item to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - Grace Can (retired senior): Stated monthly income of $1,500, cannot afford $1,000 rent, appealed for low-income senior housing. - Anonymous senior: Monthly retirement of $1,100, after Medicare only $800-$900, cannot pay more than $700 rent; urged government help. - Manson (Self-Help for the Elderly): Highlighted critical need for senior operating subsidies to prevent seniors from becoming homeless; noted income changes and family composition reductions. - Nick McCoy (formerly homeless): Advocated for community-based solutions and criticized harsh treatment of Supervisor Ronan; suggested involving existing street workers in clean-up jobs. - Stephen Spano (AIDS Legal Referral Panel): Urged continued funding for rental subsidies, calling them the fastest, most effective, and cheapest way to keep people housed (approx. $1,500/month vs. many thousands for project-based). - Ms. Colorado (senior, disabled): Facing eviction for two years; noted only 40% of past housing goals met for low-income units; asked for $82 million in new Prop I funds for affordable housing. - Stephanie Gott (Catholic Charities): Described a housing subsidy program for HIV-positive individuals (90 to 160 clients); paused new enrollments due to uncertain funding; subsidies are life-changing and quick to implement. - Caroline Fang (MEDA): Emphasized that affordable housing funding creates healthy community outcomes and supports small businesses; asked for funding for both production and preservation. - Peter Papadopoulos (MEDA): Noted 55% spike in Latino homelessness during COVID; stressed the need to fund frontline community organizations. - Fernando Marti (HSFOB Vice Chair): Highlighted unmet needs including elevator repairs, HUD-funded co-ops, and new housing innovations like social housing; urged preservation funding. - Julian Johnson (SF Community Health Center): Supported housing subsidies for people living with HIV; requested $3.6 million to house 200 individuals per year. - Kristin Nation (SF Community Land Trust): Requested $300,000 general operating capacity grant for FY24-25 to ramp up capacity for small sites program and support BIPOC CBOs. - Rosheen Eisner (SF Tenants Union): Urged dedicating new Prop I revenue to affordable housing as voters intended; noted it's only 0.5% of the budget. - Teresa Imperial (Bill Sorrow Housing Program): Urged adoption of HSFOB and CCHO budget recommendations; emphasized need for bilingual tenant services and capacity building for preservation in SOMA. - Mayra Ordonnez (client of Bill Sorrow): Expressed gratitude for help obtaining permanent housing after living in shelter with children; asked for continued support. - Julian Ball (Bill Sorrow): Noted that affordable housing lottery process is challenging; tenants need dedicated support to navigate document requests and language barriers. - Mia Laktibi (Bill Sorrow): Shared personal story as DV survivor and formerly homeless; with help from Bill Sorrow secured affordable housing and now helps Arabic-speaking community. - Dana (DV survivor, single mom): Lost job but with Bill Sorrow's help avoided homelessness; asked for continued support. - Peer advisor (Brave Button program): Described peer-led overdose response button in Minna Lee building; saved lives; asked to expand to more buildings. - Yasmin Kuchosfahani (Legal Assistance to the Elderly): Thanked supervisors for no proposed cuts to Tenant Right to Counsel (TRC); noted 90% of clients stay housed; TRC costs $5,500 per eviction vs. $30,000 for homeless services. - Kim Cruz (LAE): TRC saved 455 tenancies in 2022 (90%); 22% of clients in subsidized housing, 60% below poverty; urged continued subsidies. - Jessica Juarez (TRC lawyer): Provided examples of clients helped in Districts 9 and 11; asked for increased subsidies for seniors, disabled, and people with HIV/AIDS. - Maria Samudio (SF Anti-Displacement Coalition): Urged full funding of HSFOB recommendations; said funds raised by Prop I should be spent; outreach served 11,000 tenants last year. - Cody Keene (DISH): On behalf of Supportive Housing Providers Network, requested funds for peer-led overdose response, safety/security, food security, and capital improvements in permanent supportive housing (PSH). - Jeff Dolgar (AIDS Legal Referral Panel): Warned that $3.7 million cuts to nonprofit grants would severely impact ability to represent tenants; employment and immigration services tied to housing stability. - Tramisia Garner (Swords to Plowshares): Requested $205,000 from MOHCD for legal representation for veterans; would leverage $4 million in VA benefits. - Gabriel Medina (La Raza Community Resource Center): Asked for continuity of rental assistance programs; noted 55% increase in Latino homelessness since pandemic. - Evan Amos (La Raza): Helped 2,000 families with $10 million in rental assistance; personal recipient of ERA program; urged continued support. - Ustakia (La Raza): Described emergency help for a family with a newborn; many families need financial assistance. - Zabrina Olivaris (La Raza): Works with families with children under 5; provides strollers, cribs, utility bill help; hears heartbreaking stories daily. - Meg Heisler (TNDC): Stressed need for capital improvements in legacy buildings and programs for food security and overdose prevention; urged preservation of affordable units. - Anya Worley Zygman (DISH): Read letter from peer responder Susan; peer responders have saved multiple lives; requested funding for peer overdose prevention programs. - Adrian Mendel (Eviction Defense Collaborative): TRC prevents homelessness; 88% of tenants with full representation remain housed; program on track to serve 2,400 tenants this year; urged full funding. - Lisa Kim (Bay Area Legal Aid): In 2022, over 60% of TRC clients had disabilities, 33% were Black; TRC is vital for racial and disability equity. - Hope Williams (SF Community Land Trust): Requested $300,000 operating grant for stability of services. - Emily Van Loon (TNDC): Urged funds for housing preservation program; many multifamily buildings coming to market at good prices; now is time to buy and preserve. - Mitch Mankin (SF Housing Development Corp.): Supported $45 million for small sites program; 53 families would stay in SF; urged maintaining current funding for CBOs. - Tanis Canallen (Safe & Sound): On behalf of Family Resource Center Alliance, requested $13.9 million additional for emergency rental assistance. - Anonymous caller: Criticized one-minute public comment limit as undemocratic. - Stacy (D5 resident): Rent-controlled building at risk due to seismic retrofit; urged full $85 million funding for small sites; said voters will lose faith if Prop I funds not spent as intended. - Marnie Regan (Arkin Street Youth Services): Requested no cuts to MOHCD nonprofit contracts; use unspent funds from DLA audit to keep contracts whole. - Zach Weisenberger (Young Community Developers): Urged city not to balance budget on backs of communities; support Black-led organizations to stabilize Black residents overrepresented in precarious housing. - Lupe and Jamie Aguilar: Resident in small sites building purchased by MEDA in 2018; asked for more funds to preserve buildings for families. - Reina Fayo (FLID): Supported HSFOB and CCHO budget recommendations; need subsidies for low-income under 30% AMI; prevent homelessness. - Anastasia Yolinopolis (SF Tenants Union): Urged full funding of HSFOB recommendations; tenants at greater risk as eviction moratorium ends; tenant counseling and legal services critical. - ECS representative: Supported capital improvements and tenant services investments for PSH sites. - Saki Daly (SF Community Land Trust): Requested $45 million for small sites program and $300,000 operating grant for SFCLT; supports BIPOC CBO capacity. - Lucia Aragon (SF Latino Parity & Equity Coalition): Asked to keep all CBO budgets whole; Latinos now 30% of homeless population (55% increase); called for continued services. - Cheron Nerrera Licona (Latino Task Force): Supported housing stability; senior subsidies from MOHCD crucial; COVID funding critical for stabilizing households. - Athena Caldus (La Raza): Urged continued funding for emergency rental assistance program; Latina community at high risk of homelessness. - Ivan Crado (Latino Task Force): Asked to preserve $3.7 million MOHCD cuts; Latino safety net at risk; homelessness increased 55%. - Eliana Bender (GLIDE): Supported HESPA budget request; urged expansion of rental assistance for seniors, disabled, and people with HIV; 11% of disabled adults in SF homeless. - SRO resident: Participated in Narcan training pilot; asked for funding to expand overdose prevention across city; Narcan costs $20 vs. ambulance $3,000. - Teresa Flandric (North Beach Tenants Committee): Urged full adoption of HSFOB and CCHO recommendations; voters intended Prop I funds for affordable housing. - Anonymous caller: Noted city promised 46,000 new affordable units but only built 8,000; urged right investment. Discussion Items - Department of Disability and Aging Services (DAS) – Susie Smith: DAS oversees approximately $10.2 million in housing programs (9% of its community-based services budget). Programs include a rental subsidy program ($4.8 million serving 380 seniors/disabled adults at risk of eviction), a bridge housing program ($3.2 million for 110 people leaving institutional care), senior operating subsidy program ($3.2 million), supportive services at 20 older adult housing sites ($1.7 million), veterans housing services ($400,000), and housing advocacy ($174,000). All are general fund programs. The need for senior subsidies far exceeds current capacity. - Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) – Gigi Whitley: HSH's adopted FY23 budget is $672 million, with 42% from general fund, 10% federal, 7% state, and the rest from other local sources. 58% ($489.8 million) goes to housing, but 90% of that sustains existing housing for 11,000 households already housed. Permanent Supportive Housing (PSH) totals 11,000 units (9,500 site-based, 1,500 scattered site). Rapid rehousing is 6% of budget ($24 million, serving 1,600 households). Shelter budget is $154 million for 2,700 shelter beds plus crisis intervention and transitional housing. The five-year strategic plan aims for 50% reduction in unsheltered homelessness, 15% total reduction, with 85% of those exiting homelessness not experiencing it again. Goals include 3,250 new permanent housing units (not all PSH) and 1,075 new shelter beds (additive). - Pier 94 closure (HSH) – Emily Cohen: Approximately 116 people at Pier 94 trailer site; 70 determined eligible for housing, 24 not eligible. All will be offered alternative shelter or housing; no one will be asked to leave without an offer. HSH requested extension from Port Commission to end of year to wind down. Supervisor Walton criticized lack of a concrete plan and expressed doubt about housing placements. Supervisor Ronan raised concerns about good neighbor policy around shelters, especially in the Mission District, and asked HSH to take ownership of coordinating cleanliness and safety. HSH noted they are hiring a community engagement manager. - Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) – Benjamin McCloskey: MOHCD's FY23 budget is $210 million, but 60% does not go through annual appropriation. Proposed FY23-24 budget is $183 million (eliminating one-time items). Budget instruction targets: $3.1 million reduction in Year 1, $4.9 million in Year 2, with all cuts proposed from CBO grants. Multifamily housing development: approximately $700 million in anticipated funding (including GO bonds), with $306 million in anticipated loans for FY23-24 ($46 million capital maintenance, $77 million Hope SF infrastructure, $43 million pre-development). Small sites program: $91 million available, $45 million programmed for next fiscal year. Senior operating subsidies: $9.2 million general fund carried forward, plus $52 million state funding through 2028. Tenant-based senior subsidies: $2.7 million through Catholic Charities. Tenant Right to Counsel: $18 million proposed. Supervisor Preston pressed on land acquisition strategy and use of Prop I revenue; MOHCD stated they have an open NOFA for land acquisition ($40 million) but need a strategy to actually build units. Deputy Director Lydia Ely noted the funding gap for RHNA goals is $19 billion in local funds and $30 billion in state/federal funds. - Council of Community Housing Organizations and Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board – Lee Levitt and Shanti Singh: Prop I has generated over a quarter billion dollars since November 2020. HSFOB recommended $85 million in new spending: $30 million for land acquisition, $30 million for capital funding for new affordable/social housing (prioritizing essential workers), $18 million for building upgrades and repairs (including elevators in SROs), $5 million for affordability for seniors and people with disabilities ($4.5M senior operating subsidies, $500K pilot for accessible housing), and $2 million for housing innovation. CCHO added a joint ask of $90 million, including at least $45 million for small sites preservation, plus asset management, PSH services, and tenant support. They emphasized the gap between past RHNA (8,000 affordable units built) and new RHNA (46,000 units needed). Key Outcomes - The committee voted 3-0 to continue the hearing to the call of the chair (Supervisors Chan, Mandelman, Walton, and Ronan absent for the vote? Actually transcript says: Vice Chairman Mandelman, member Safai absent, member Ronin absent? Wait:

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 47% · HOMELESSNESS 24% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 10% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 4%
1008
MAY 9, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - May 9, 2023

Introductory Paragraph The San Francisco Port Commission held a regular meeting on May 9, 2023, chaired by President Kimberly Brandon. The meeting covered a wide range of topics including the executive director's report, consent calendar approvals, a proposed sole-source grant to the Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefits District, strategies to address food and beverage and retail vacancies, the Port's 10-year capital plan, and a proposed public art program. Commissioners also discussed the departure of a key staff member, Rebecca Benissini. Consent Calendar - Item 7A: Approved Resolution 2323 authorizing an interagency cooperation agreement with the Transbay Joint Powers Authority (TJPA) for port staff work and reimbursement related to Phase 2 of the Transbay Program. Unanimous. - Item 7B: Approved Resolution 2324 granting License 17036 to GSW Arena LLC for 624 linear feet of white zone, 337 linear feet of yellow zone, and 80 metered parking spaces on game and special event dates around Chase Center for a 10-year term with two five-year options to extend, subject to Board of Supervisors approval. Unanimous. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 8A (Sole Source Grant): Tom Creedon, owner of Scoma's restaurant, expressed skepticism about the Fisherman's Wharf CBD as the grant administrator, noting that some port-side tenants voted out the CBD in 2020 due to dissatisfaction with services. He described the wharf as "a war zone" and said his business is "hanging on by our fingernails." No other public comments were made on any agenda items. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Elaine Forbes): Forbes provided updates on the Fisherman's Wharf sole source proposal, noting that after the April 25 hearing, staff decided to issue a Request for Interest (RFI) for 30 days to gauge other interest before proceeding. She reported that SailGP attracted an estimated 15,000 spectators over the weekend and nearly 1,000 people daily at Pier 80. Building 12 at Pier 70 is being activated with new local businesses. Juneteenth on the Waterfront will expand this year with a parade down Market Street. The Port is a leader in resilience, having secured $425 million through Prop A for the seawall. The Pier 30-32 legislation is moving through the Senate, and the Port will delay action on the Pier 94 COVID emergency trailers to work with HSH on relocation. Forbes then acknowledged the departure of Rebecca Benissini, Deputy Director of Real Estate and Development, with numerous staff and commissioners expressing gratitude for her leadership. Commissioners Gilman and Harrington emphasized the need for nimble activation and cooperation on homelessness. - Item 8A (Sole Source Grant to Fisherman's Wharf CBD): Megan Wallace (Economic Recovery Manager) and Amy Cohen (Business Generation Manager) presented a proposal to award a $2,188,446 sole-source grant to the Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefits District (CBD) for a two-year public space activation program using federal stimulus funds. The program includes cleaning, safety ambassadors, beautification, and pop-up events at vacant sites like the former Alioto's. The Port would waive license fees for related events. Commissioners expressed broad support but raised concerns about past tenant dissatisfaction, perception of safety, and the need to target local visitors. Commissioner Lee and Vice President Adams highlighted the importance of local marketing and younger audience engagement. Commissioner Harrington suggested flexibility in the budget. The item will return as an action item on June 13, 2023, with a six-month progress report requested. - Item 8B (Strategies to Address Vacancies): Rebecca Benissini presented strategies to fill food & beverage and retail vacancies. The Port faces up to seven potential solicitations in 2023, compared to six during 2012-2021. Strategies include using brokers from a pre-qualified city pool, short-term activations through pop-ups, reducing barriers (e.g., Chapter 6 exemption), and adopting flexible criteria for tenant selection. Commissioners recommended short-term broker agreements, focusing on local equity criteria, and accelerating short-term activations. Commissioner Lee emphasized the need for speed and avoiding tenant displacement later due to infrastructure repairs. Commissioner Gilman urged giving more weight to equity in scoring. - Item 9A (10-Year Capital Plan FY2024-2033): Nate Cruz (Acting Deputy Director of Finance) presented the capital plan. The total need over 10 years is $4.2 billion ($2.24 billion for state of good repair and $1.9 billion for enhancements). Identified funding totals $590 million for state of good repair and $1.2 billion for enhancements, leaving a combined gap of about $2.36 billion. Funding sources include port net revenue ($386 million), external grants, infrastructure financing districts (IFD), community facilities districts (CFD), and developer investments. The plan does not yet include the full cost of sea-level rise resilience. Commissioners noted the large funding gap and requested a future informational item on the city's approach to sea-level rise. Commissioner Lee questioned priorities regarding vacant restaurant spaces and underlying pier infrastructure. - Item 10A (Public Art Program): Ryan Wassom presented a draft public art program to guide selection and placement of public art along the waterfront. The program establishes three selection processes: open call (for funded projects), direct selection (for projects under $129,000), and artist-sponsored proposals (unsolicited). Maintenance and ownership vary depending on funding source. The program aims to increase transparency and diversity. Commissioners Harrington and Adams emphasized prioritizing local artists. The program will be put on the Port website and reviewed after one year. - New Business: President Brandon noted that a six-month progress report on the CBD grant will be brought to the commission, and a one-year informational item will be scheduled. Commissioner Lee requested updates on linking cruise ship passengers to Port tenants, an update on Pier 70 developments, and an update on illegal vending on the waterfront. Executive Director Forbes agreed to follow up. Key Outcomes - Unanimous approvals on Consent Calendar Items 7A and 7B. - No formal votes on informational items (8A, 8B, 9A, 10A); decisions deferred to future meetings. - Action expected June 13, 2023: Commission to vote on the sole-source grant to Fisherman's Wharf CBD (Item 8A). - Next steps: Staff will issue an RFI for Fisherman's Wharf development, bring back findings in July; return with action on the grant in June; continue working with HSH on Pier 94 relocation; schedule a future informational item on sea-level rise with city partners; and provide updates on cruise ship connections, Pier 70, and vending issues.

PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 15% · CAPITAL PLANNING 13% · PUBLIC ART 12% · FISHERMAN'S WHARF 10%
1009
MAY 9, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
SFPUC Commission Meeting: May 9, 2023 – Rates, Contracts, and Community Updates

Date: May 9, 2023, 9:30 AM (Pacific) The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on May 9, 2023. The meeting included approval of minutes, recognition of a retiring employee, reports from the General Manager, adoption of wholesale water and CleanPowerSF rates, amendments to contracts for the Balboa Reservoir and Transbay Joint Powers Authority projects, and general public comment. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously approved the consent calendar (4-0), which included several routine contracts and agreements for sewer, water, and power infrastructure projects. Specific items included awards for sewer rehabilitation (Items 6F and 6G) and other minor contracts. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 7 (Wholesale Water Rates): Nicole Sancula (representing Boska CEO) spoke in support of the proposed staff action. - Item 7: Peter Dreckmark (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust) commented that water demand projections are lower than the Urban Water Management Plan and urged the commission to adjust demand projections and the design drought length to avoid unnecessary investments and impacts on the Tuolumne River. - General Public Comment: Teresa Wallace (creator/founder of I Am That I Am Bereavement Trauma and Crisis Center) advocated for a trauma center in San Francisco, noting the lack of mental health resources and requesting SFPUC sponsorship of a space in Bayview Hunters Point. She also inquired about any SFPUC connection to a property at 4101 3rd Street. - No other members of the public spoke during the meeting. Discussion Items - Item 4: Employee Retirement Recognition – The commission recognized Constance “Connie” Smith for 32 years and 9 months of service. Ms. Smith worked in the Business Services Division, processed invoices, and served as a union representative (SEIU Local 1021). Commissioners and staff praised her dedication and customer service. - Item 5a: Quarterly Audit and Performance Review Report – Irella Blackwood (Audit Director) reported that as of March 31, 2023, 15 audits (52% of the planned portfolio) were complete, 8 (27%) were in progress, and 6 (21%) had commenced in the third quarter. Key completions included an Enterprise Risk Management Cyber Risk Assessment and clean financial statement audits for all three enterprises. The audit bureau is monitoring recommendations from eight public integrity reports. Five audits are anticipated in the fourth quarter, and six more audits are planned to launch. Commissioner Rivera asked about “Super Green and Super Green Saver” programs; staff agreed to provide follow-up information. - Item 5b: Community Contractor Update – Ben Poole and Steve Robinson presented data on LBE (Local Business Enterprise) participation, focusing on micro-LBEs. On the Biosolids Digester Facilities Project (worth $1.78 billion), 77 micro-LBEs have been awarded 186 contracts worth $194 million. From District 10 (Bayview Hunters Point), 55 micro-LBEs have been awarded 120 contracts worth $112 million. The project exceeds the 12% LBE goal, currently at 17%. Staff acknowledged concerns from community contractors and are working to strengthen the liaison role and develop a plan for future projects. Commissioners commended the progress and stressed continued improvement. - Item 5c: Report on Recent SFPUC Activities – General Manager Herrera celebrated the 100th anniversary of the O’Shaughnessy Dam/Hetch Hetchy system, describing it as a testament to San Francisco’s ingenuity and stewardship. Commissioners expressed appreciation. - Item 7: Wholesale Water Rates FY 2023-2024 – Aaron Kurbanova (Financial Planning Director) presented a proposed 9.7% rate increase for wholesale customers, bringing the rate to $5.21 per CCF (100 cubic feet, equivalent to 748 gallons). Drivers include low water sales volumes and the depletion of the balancing account. The increase is lower than the earlier estimate due to expected recovery in water usage. The commission voted 4-0 to adopt the rates. - Item 8: Balboa Reservoir Purchase Price Amendments – Ron Flynn (Deputy General Manager) explained amendments to loan documents for the sale of Balboa Reservoir. The original payment schedule is revised due to changed market conditions; the next payment is due by December 31, 2026, but the purchase price, interest (3%), and ultimate maturity (December 2028) remain unchanged. This allows for development of 290 affordable housing units in Phase 1. The commission approved the resolution 4-0, recommending Board of Supervisors approval. - Item 9: Interagency Cooperation Agreement with Transbay Joint Powers Authority (TJPA) – The commission authorized the General Manager to consent to an agreement for coordination of utility relocations for the downtown rail extension (Phase 2 of the Salesforce Transit Center project). The agreement ensures reimbursement for SFPUC work. Commissioner Rivera asked about lessons learned from the Van Ness project regarding asset management and digital mapping; Mr. Flynn agreed to follow up. Approved 4-0. - Item 10: Public Hearing on CleanPowerSF Rates FY 2023-2024 – Mayi Yap (Principal Revenue and Rates Analyst) proposed a 15% increase in CleanPowerSF generation rates, driven by a 60% increase in power supply costs. The total bill increases for residential customers will be 4-7%, but CleanPowerSF rates remain 0.5-3% lower than comparable PG&E rates. The commission also approved a mechanism to set temporary rates for new rate schedules using a formulaic approach, allowing the General Manager to implement companion rates when PG&E introduces new schedules. Commissioner Maxwell inquired about the default rate schedule and competitive dynamics; staff explained the default is the most common schedule and that the temporary rate formula ensures competitiveness. The proposal passed 4-0. - Item 11: Contract Amendments with Western Area Power Administration – The commission approved amendments to two contracts (Full Load Service and Scheduling Coordinator) for power service to Treasure and Yerba Buena Islands. The contracts are extended by five years (to December 31, 2029) with an increased not-to-exceed amount of $41.5 million. The action requires Board of Supervisors approval. Passed 4-0. - Item 12: Communications – Informational items only, including an annual CleanPowerSF SuperGreen update and water supply conditions. Key Outcomes - Approved minutes of April 25, 2023 (4-0). - Retired employee Connie Smith recognized with a resolution. - Noted quarterly audit status and community contractor progress. - Adopted wholesale water rates for FY 2023-2024 with a 9.7% increase (4-0). - Approved amendments to Balboa Reservoir loan documents (4-0). - Authorized interagency cooperation agreement with TJPA (4-0). - Adopted CleanPowerSF rates for FY 2023-2024 (15% generation increase) and approved temporary rate-setting mechanism (4-0). - Approved contract amendments with Western Area Power Administration (4-0). - Heard general public comment from Teresa Wallace regarding a trauma center; no action taken. - Meeting adjourned.

PUBLIC UTILITIES 17% · PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · PUBLIC WORKS 12%
1010
MAY 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
Rules Committee Meeting: Ethics Commission, Military Service Credit, PROSAC Membership - May 8, 2023

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, met on Monday, May 8, 2023, at 10:00 AM. The committee considered three agenda items: an appointment to the Ethics Commission, an ordinance expanding retirement service credit for military service, and amendments to the Park Code concerning the Park Recreation and Open Space Advisory Committee (PROSAC). The meeting included public testimony and unanimous votes on all actions. Appointment to the Ethics Commission (Item 1) The committee considered two applicants for a seat on the Ethics Commission (term ending February 1, 2029): Larry Bush (incumbent interim appointee) and Yaman Salahi. Applicant David Sai withdrew prior to the meeting. - Larry Bush spoke in support of his reappointment, citing his experience as a founding member of Friends of Ethics, his two years of service on the commission, and his concerns about declining public participation, the lack of a commission secretary, and the need for an advisory panel. He also highlighted the upcoming appointment of a new executive director. - Yaman Salahi presented his legal background, including work with the Asian Law Caucus, representation of Yemeni and LGBT communities, and a judicial clerkship. He emphasized his commitment to addressing the complaint investigation backlog, audit delays, and root causes of noncompliance. He noted that he would likely be the first Arab American appointee to the commission. - Public comment: Speakers Miriam (community member) and Abdu Hadwan (Yemeni Association) supported Salahi, citing his work during the Muslim ban and civil rights advocacy. Paul Melbastad (former Ethics Commissioner), Charles Head (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods), and David Pilpel supported Bush, emphasizing his institutional memory and experience. - Supervisor Safai expressed support for Salahi, praising his work with immigrant communities and the historic nature of the appointment. He noted the importance of integrity in the commission given recent corruption concerns. - Motion: Supervisor Dorsey moved to recommend Yaman Salahi to the full board. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). Administrative Code – Including Military Service in Definition of 'Public Service' for Retirement Service Credit Purchases (Item 2) Dominica Donovan from Supervisor Stefani's office presented the ordinance, which expands the definition of "public service" to allow members of the San Francisco Employees' Retirement System to purchase service credit for time served in the military before city employment. The change corrects a 1970s exclusion believed to stem from anti-war sentiment. - Amendments: Non-substantive amendments to use gender-neutral pronouns were adopted without objection, as described by Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson. - Public comment: Veterans Affairs Commissioners Hanlin Chan and David DeCoolant spoke in support, noting that federal employees already have a similar buyback option. - Motion: Chair Dorsey moved to recommend the ordinance as amended. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). Park Code – PROSAC Membership (Item 3) President Aaron Peskin introduced an ordinance to reduce the number of seats on the Park Recreation and Open Space Advisory Committee (PROSAC) from 23 (two per supervisor district plus one mayoral appointment) to one voting member per district with an alternate, and to allow members to serve more than four consecutive terms. The goal is to address quorum issues and improve efficiency. - Amendments: Supervisor Chan’s office (Kelly Growth) proposed adding an additional seat appointed by the Board President representing an environmental justice organization, and adding disability as relevant experience. President Peskin proposed requiring meetings at City Hall. All amendments were adopted unanimously. - Public comment: Stephen DePont Colani (PROSAC member, District 11) opposed the single-voting-member model, suggesting an at-large structure instead, and supported meeting at City Hall. Lady Aragon (PROSAC chair) thanked the committee for continuing the item and emphasized the need for meaningful reform, including addressing long-standing vacancies. - Motion: Supervisor Safai moved to adopt the amendments, and then Chair Dorsey moved to continue the item as amended to June 12, 2023. Both motions passed unanimously (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Ethics Commission): Yaman Salahi recommended to the full Board of Supervisors for appointment to Seat 1, term ending February 1, 2029. - Item 2 (Military Service Credit): Ordinance amended and recommended to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 (PROSAC Membership): Amendments adopted, and the item continued to the June 12, 2023 Rules Committee meeting for further discussion after PROSAC’s June 6 meeting.

ETHICS COMMISSION 37% · PARKS AND RECREATION 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · PROCEDURAL 12%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com