The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular meeting on Wednesday, April 12, 2023, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included officer recognition, a presentation by the San Francisco Police Activities League (SFPAL), reports from the Chief of Police and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), a quarterly policy update (Sparks Report), and approval of a revised general order. A significant portion of the meeting was devoted to a debate over the department's use of bureau orders versus the formal DGO process, with commissioners expressing concerns about transparency and circumvention of the commission's policy-making authority. Consent Calendar - The commission received and filed the Police Commission report of disciplinary actions for the first quarter of 2023 (Agenda Item 4). The motion passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 3): Several members of the public spoke: - A mother of a homicide victim urged the commission to help solve unsolved homicides, showing a photo of her son at autopsy and describing her ongoing grief. - Paul Allen criticized the lack of transparency regarding a three-commissioner meeting with command staff, noting that the commission's annual statement of purpose required by the city charter was not on the website. - A resident living near the meeting location reported persistent loud traffic, modified cars, and stop-sign violations over 13 years, requesting the commission investigate. - Public comment during later items: - Paul Allen again raised concerns about the lack of disclosure of any three-commissioner advisory committees and the missing annual statement of purpose. Discussion Items - Weekly Officer Recognition Certificate (Item 1): Captain Martin from Southern Station recognized Officers Pete Impson and John Tynes for a March 14, 2023 incident on Treasure Island in which they coordinated to safely apprehend three suspects and recover two loaded handguns. The suspects were linked to a separate shooting in the Northern District. Commissioners praised the officers' strategic use of backup and critical mindset. - SFPAL Presentation (Item 2): Acting Commander Aaron Perra and retired Captain Rick Bruce presented certificates to PAL members, including the first PAL Boy of the Year in many years (Malachi Hightower) and the championship-winning 4th and 5th grade boys basketball teams. The presentation highlighted the PAL program's history since 1959 and its role in building police-youth relationships. - Chief’s Report (Item 5): Chief William Scott reported: - Crime statistics: 0% change in homicides, 0% change in shooting victims, violent crime up 3%, property crime down 11%, total serious crime down 10%. - A homicide on Main Street (Mr. Robert Lee) is under active investigation; a second homicide in the Tenderloin also ongoing. - Three shootings during the reporting period: one in Bayview (two suspects detained), one in Ingleside (victim shot, no arrests), one on Kiska Road (details not repeated). - Notable arrests: a hot prowl residential burglary suspect arrested on 44th Avenue; an assault with deadly weapon suspect arrested at Lombard and Laguna; enforcement at sideshows resulting in four court orders for vehicle seizures. - Tenderloin drug enforcement: 1,303 grams of fentanyl seized in the past week, over 30,000 grams year to date (141% increase), 231 arrests for possession/sales. - In response to Commissioner Byrne’s question, Chief Scott confirmed SFPD was working with Whole Foods prior to its store closure to address shoplifting, including making arrests. - Regarding the social media investigative use bureau order, the Chief stated the order was issued because there was no existing policy and the DGO process was too slow; he welcomed a separate DGO but argued bureau orders are permissible under DGO 3.01 for operational needs. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 6): Chief of Staff Diana Rosenstein reported DPA case statistics: 206 cases opened (vs. 184 in 2022), 210 closed (vs. 184), 16 sustained (vs. 10), 5 mediated (vs. 4). Weekly allegation categories: 32% failure to properly investigate, 13% failure to take required action, 8% biased policing, 8% inappropriate behavior/language. DPA conducted outreach on March 23rd. - Commission Reports (Item 7): - Commissioner Benedicto: Reported initial working group session for DGO 10.11 (body-worn cameras); attended the annual remembrance for Officer Isaac Espinoza (19th anniversary) at Bayview Station. - Commissioner Byrne: Noted that DGO 5.18 is being sent to concurrence; requested agendizing an item on the existence and purpose of any three-commissioner committees for transparency. - Commissioner Yee: Mentioned DGOs 2.02 (alcohol use), 2.03 (drug use) due soon; expressed interest in DGO 6.14 (psychological evaluations); attended a stop crime event. - Commissioner Yanez: Announced a joint presentation with Juvenile Probation Commission postponed to May 10; will be away for three weeks; requested to agendize an update on community policing plans and expressed concern over the department's recent issuance of a bureau order on investigative use of social media without commission input, despite an existing DGO working group. Chief Scott responded that the order was necessary due to lack of policy and risk management, and he supports a DGO but needed immediate guidance. - Sparks Report (1st Quarter 2023) (Item 8): - Captain Toomer reported 48 DGOs in process, 9 in public comment, 12 in meet and confer, and that department bulletins are being phased out. Commissioners pressed on the number of bureau orders issued; Captain Toomer said seven department notices were issued in Q1. - DPA Director of Policy Janelle Kaywood presented DPA's Q1 policy work, including 39 recommendations on eight existing general orders, a recommendation to require cameras for plainclothes officers, and a critique of SFPD's use of bureau orders as a workaround to the DGO process, citing lack of transparency and undermining commission authority. She also recommended changes to DGO 2.07 to address the backlog of 65 officers awaiting chief's hearings. - Extended discussion ensued about the department's use of bureau orders. Commissioners (particularly Elias, Carter Oberstone, Yanez, and Benedicto) argued that bureau orders covering the same subject matter as existing or planned DGOs (plain clothes, body-worn cameras, social media) circumvent the commission's charter authority and the intent of DGO 3.01. Chief Scott maintained that bureau orders are necessary for urgent operational needs and do not amend DGOs, but he agreed to post future bureau orders on the commission's website and provide them to the commission for transparency. The commission expressed intent to formalize this via a resolution. - DGO 6.02 (Item 9): The commission voted unanimously to approve revised Department General Order 6.02, "Physical Evidence and Crime Scenes," sending it to meet and confer with bargaining units. Key Outcomes - Votes and decisions: - Consent calendar (disciplinary report) – received and filed unanimously. - DGO 6.02 approved unanimously (motion by Commissioner Byrne, second by Commissioner Benedicto) to proceed to meet and confer. - The commission directed the SFPD to post all bureau orders on the commission website and provide copies to the commission; a formal resolution will be drafted. - Directives and future items: - Commissioner Yanez requested agendizing the social media DGO and the related bureau order for a future meeting. - Commissioner Byrne requested agendizing an item on the existence of any three-commissioner committees and their purposes. - Commissioner Elias noted that staff will draft a resolution reiterating support for CART (Community Alternative Response Team). - Next steps: The department will provide an ETA for reissuance of the expired department bulletin 21062 (stop data collection system) as a department notice. The chief agreed to include the bureau order posting practice in his next chief's report. DGO 5.18 is expected to come before the commission in about one month. The meeting adjourned at approximately 9:10 PM.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 12, 2023, at 11:45 AM (delayed due to a fiber optic cable issue). Chair Connie Chan presided, joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Member Asha Safai. The committee considered 11 agenda items, including grant approvals, contract amendments, and public restroom projects. Several items were amended or continued for further review. Consent Calendar - None (all items received individual discussion) Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (Stop School Violence Grant): Francisco De Costa expressed concern that violence prevention in elementary schools is neglected and that $1 million is insufficient. He criticized supervisors for side conversations during public comment. - Item 5 (Bridge Navigator Program): A speaker (Ephraim, self-identified as having no contact with others for 15 years) supported the grant but lamented the lack of help for people like him. He pleaded for recognition and support. - Item 8/9 (UCSF and North Valley Grants): Ephraim spoke again, praising the grants for providing job opportunities in the Southeast and asked for help finding work. - Item 10/11 (Noe Valley Restroom): Rudy Gonzalez (San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council) opposed accepting an out-of-state modular restroom, arguing it undermines local workers and contractors. He urged the city to build restrooms locally. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Children’s Council Grant ($164,346,004): The Department of Early Childhood (Ingrid Mezquita) presented a retroactive grant agreement for early care workforce compensation, funded by Proposition C (2018). The Budget Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended adding a report requirement to reconcile stipends and wage enhancements, and a Controller's Office review of internal controls. The department accepted the amendments. Supervisors Safai and Mandelman praised the community engagement and asked to be co-sponsors. The committee voted unanimously to amend and forward the item. - Item 2 – Airport Terminal 1 Contract Extension: SFO staff (Kathy Warner, Kristen Allen) requested approval of modification 18 to extend the contract with T1 Partners through July 2025 at no cost increase. The project is on schedule. No public comment. Unanimously approved. - Item 3 – Stop School Violence Grant ($1,000,000): DCYF (Jasmine Dawson) presented an ordinance to accept a DOJ grant for school violence prevention. Chair Chan and Supervisor Safai questioned metrics, sustainability, and specific uses (multidisciplinary teams, training, violence interrupters). The BLA noted the grant's narrative provides more detail. Supervisor Safai expressed concern about ongoing funding after grant expiration. The committee voted to forward with positive recommendation, with co-sponsors added. - Item 4 – Library Infrastructure Grant ($13,210,129): SFPL (Mike Fernandez) presented a state grant for Mission and Chinatown branch renovations. The grant requires a dollar-for-dollar match from the Library Preservation Fund (LPF). Supervisor Safai asked about freeing LPF funds for the Ocean View Library. Maureen Singleton stated that cost changes will determine reallocation, and $32 million has been allocated for Ocean View through FY24, with an additional $4.8 million proposed for FY25, still short of the estimated $9.7 million need. The committee voted to forward. - Item 5 – Bridge Navigator Program Grant ($120,000): DPH (Jenna Balinski) presented a grant for substance use navigation services at Zuckerberg SF General Hospital's ED. Supervisor Mandelman supported the program and noted the hospital's improved behavioral health response. Unanimously approved. - Item 6 – California Arrearage Payment Program ($1,244,798.66 & $103,243.80): SFPUC (Christina Venice) requested retroactive approval to accept state funds for customer utility debt relief from the pandemic. Funds were disbursed before formal authorization. Supervisor Safai added as co-sponsor. Unanimously approved. - Item 7 – Michelin Tire Lease Contract ($18,900,000): OCA (Serena Corolla) and SFMTA (Ashish Patel, Lewis Guzzo) presented a seven-year tire lease contract for 860 buses, with a 5.5% cost increase. The BLA noted no performance metrics were included. Supervisor Safai questioned the lack of tracking data, such as tire lifespan and staff availability. Chair Chan proposed a one-week continuance to allow BLA and departments to develop a performance tracking framework. The committee voted to amend to include retroactive start date and continue to April 19. - Item 8 & 9 – Economic Development Grants ($150,000 and $350,000): OEWD (Ken Nim and Orion Willis) presented two grants: UCSF Construction Community Outreach Program (supporting local hire on UCSF projects) and the Regional Equity and Recovery Partnerships (supporting cybersecurity training at City College). Supervisor Mandelman asked about the delay in processing retroactive grants. OEWD explained the internal review process. The committee voted to forward with positive recommendation. - Item 10 & 11 – Noe Valley Town Square Restroom Grants ($425,000 in-kind + $1,700,000 state): Rec & Park (Tony Morin) presented an in-kind modular restroom from a Nevada company and a state grant to fund site work and future projects. The Rec & Park Commission approved 5-2, with concerns about the out-of-state build and worker conditions. Under city law, the unit cannot be purchased but can be accepted as a gift. Supervisor Mandelman thanked community advocates. Chair Chan noted the commission's split vote. The committee voted 2-0 (Safai absent) to forward the items without recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved as amended (add reconciliation report requirement) and forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 4: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 7: Amended to include retroactive start date (April 1, 2023) and continued to the April 19, 2023 meeting (3-0). - Item 8: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 9: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 10: Forwarded to full board without recommendation (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 11: Forwarded to full board without recommendation (2-0, Safai absent).
The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on April 12, 2023, at 10:45 AM to discuss the March update to the City and County of San Francisco's Five-Year Financial Plan. The meeting featured presentations from Anna Dunning, Budget Director from the Mayor's Office, and Michelle Alersma from the Controller's Office. Public Comments & Testimony - David Philpel spoke during public comment. He characterized the report as "sobering," noted the large deficit numbers, and suggested several policy ideas, including: standardizing language in charter set-asides and MOUs regarding deficit projections, a charter amendment to reorganize city agencies, examining classification creep, downgrading vacant positions, and encouraging use of Proposition F retirees. He also expressed concern about the city's dependence on volatile revenue sources and thanked the staff for their work. Discussion Items - Presentation of the March Update: Anna Dunning reviewed the January report, which projected a $728 million deficit over two years ($200 million in fiscal year 2023-24 and $528 million in 2024-25). The March update showed that the first-year deficit increased by $90 million to $273.8 million, while the second-year deficit decreased by $38 million to $354.4 million, for a total updated deficit of $780 million. Key assumptions remained largely unchanged: very slow or no growth in major tax revenues, loss of federal and one-time revenues (including FEMA), and cost pressures from salary and benefits. Revenue updates included modest increases in property and business taxes, but lower sales tax and transfer tax forecasts, and a significant push-out of FEMA revenue expectations due to delayed reimbursements. Expenditure changes included increased reserve deposit requirements ($50 million in year one), higher health care and retirement costs, and modest adjustments in citywide costs. - Recession Scenario Discussion: Chair Chan asked about the recession scenario presented in the report. Michelle Alersma explained that the base case does not assume a recession. The scenario projects a $950 million revenue loss over the forecast period if a recession began in mid-2023, partially offset by lower baseline expenditures and reduced reserve deposits, and the ability to draw $380 million from economic stabilization reserves. However, the trigger for drawing those reserves requires a year-over-year decline in total revenues, which is not occurring (revenues are still growing, albeit slowly). Chair Chan clarified that even with deficits in some tax categories, overall revenue growth prevents access to those reserves. - Pending Policy Decisions: Dunning listed major cost pressures not included in the deficit projection, including annualizing police and public works supplements, downtown ambassador programs, maintaining shelter capacity (potentially losing state grants), and various tax change proposals and pending supplementals exceeding $60 million. She emphasized that these decisions could significantly impact the budget. - ERAF (Educational Revenue Augmentation Fund): Chair Chan asked about the potential state change to ERAF allocation, which is approximately $300 million. Dunning stated that no changes are yet proposed, but given the state's own deficit, it remains a risk. The governor's May revise may provide clarity. Key Outcomes - The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. The motion was made by Chair Chan, seconded by Supervisor Walton, and passed unanimously with 5 ayes (Vice Chair Mandelman, Members Safai, Ronen, Walton, and Chair Chan). The meeting was then adjourned.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on April 11, 2023, to address routine approvals, receive updates on port operations and environmental initiatives, and take key actions including the adoption of the final Waterfront Plan. Highlights included the approval of a construction contract for the Roundhouse building, a contract for marsh revegetation and youth training, an informational presentation on the demobilization of a homeless shelter site, and a presentation on the Pier 50 Earthquake Improvement Project. Consent Calendar - Resolution 23-13: Approved License No. 17025 with Pacific Cruise Ship Terminals LLC for terminal operations parking at Pier 29 during cruise operations at Pier 27. Passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Waterfront Plan (Item 9A): Three members of the public spoke in strong support of the plan. Alice Rogers praised the collaborative process and the dedication of staff. Linda Richardson expressed full support, stating the plan positions the port to lead San Francisco's economic recovery. Rudy Nothenberg, co-chair of the working group, emphasized the importance of procedural safeguards to reduce contention in future projects and urged the commission to follow them. - MOU with HSH (Item 10A): Alice Rogers spoke in support, commending the partnership between HSH and the port and noting the success of the shelter site. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 6A): Executive Director Elaine Forbes reported on the port's climate leadership, including removal of dilapidated piers, zero-emission hydropower for cruise ships, and a one-stop eco-industrial center reducing 35,000 truck trips annually. She noted the 2023 commercial salmon season cancellation due to low Chinook salmon numbers and a $450 million emergency proposal to support fishers. Deputy Director Rebecca Benissini provided an update on the port’s real estate portfolio, highlighting vacancies in shed and storage spaces, deferred maintenance issues, and efforts to improve leasing through competitive solicitations and marketing. - Roundhouse Building Contract (Item 8A): Project manager Erica Peterson presented a request to award a $4,586,900 construction contract to Roebuck Construction (an LBE) for roof, solarium, and window replacement at Roundhouse 2. A bid protest from Ingadium Riley was denied after CMD confirmed Roebuck met LBE requirements. The project aims to address water intrusion issues and make the fourth floor leasable. Commissioner Lee raised concerns about contractor performance and on-time completion. The contract was approved unanimously. - Waterfront Plan Adoption (Item 9A): Diane Oshima presented the final Waterfront Plan, summarizing revisions to transportation policies per commission and SFMTA comments. The Planning Commission certified the Final EIR on March 16, 2023. The plan contains 161 policy recommendations (160 unanimously endorsed) developed over three years with extensive public engagement. Commissioners and speakers lauded the process. Commissioner Gilman requested a future briefing on the plan’s procedural recommendations. The plan was adopted unanimously. - Literacy for Environmental Justice Contract (Item 9B): Elizabeth Alexander Toots presented a request to award a $987,000 contract to Literacy for Environmental Justice (LEJ) for marsh revegetation and a transitional-age youth work training program. Only one bidder met minimum qualifications. The contract includes a DEI scoring element and aims to provide internships and employment readiness. Approved unanimously. - MOU with HSH – Shelter Demobilization (Item 10A): Kim Deal (port) and Emily Cohen (HSH) presented an informational report on a proposed MOU to demobilize the shelter-in-place trailer site at Seawall Lot 344. The site opened in April 2020, served 303 guests, and currently houses 118. The MOU would run from March 1 to December 31, 2023, with no new placements after October 2 and full demobilization by December 1. Commissioners questioned the housing placement rate (11% to permanent housing so far) and expressed concern about displacement. Emily Cohen noted a 65% placement rate in similar wind-downs and committed to working with guests. The item will return for approval on April 25. - Pier 50 Earthquake Improvement Project (Item 11A): Chris Foriucci (new project manager) presented an informational overview of an RFP for initial study and pre-design services. The project aims to retrofit Pier 50 (built 1920s-1940s) due to its importance for disaster response. The contract is not to exceed $2.7 million, funded by ARPA. The RFP will be issued to a pre-qualified pool of seven engineering firms, with a panel review in May and a request for award in June. Commissioners supported the approach. Key Outcomes - Resolutions Adopted: 23-13 (Cruise Terminal License), 23-14 (Roundhouse contract), 23-15 (Waterfront Plan and CEQA findings), 23-16 (Literacy for Environmental Justice contract) – all passed unanimously. - New Business: President Brandon recorded items for future discussion: a tour of the living seawall, a report on contract closeout and performance metrics, and a briefing on real estate vacancies. Commissioner Gilman requested a mid‑six‑month check-in on demobilization of the shelter site, focusing on housing placements and equity. The meeting was adjourned in solidarity with the Tennessee Three.
On April 11, 2023, the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting. Commissioners voted to rescind the local water shortage emergency, adopt a new customer assistance program, approve rules for the Social Impact Partnership Program, approve a $791 million WIFIA loan agreement, award a $90 million wastewater program management contract, and terminate the Alameda Creek Recapture Project contract. The meeting also featured a water supply update, public comments from community members and contractors, and discussions on equity and small business inclusion. Consent Calendar - Items 5A-5F (approved unanimously): Included a $5 million job order contract, amendments for security consulting, Treasure Island wastewater engineering, Folsom stormwater tunnel engineering, Stern Grove emergency restoration cost increase, and a lease with SPRO LLC. Commissioner Stacy requested item 5G be severed. - Item 5G (approved unanimously): Authorized an amended MOU with Recreation and Parks to use electrical facilities at McLaren Park for the Sunnydale Hope SF project. Commissioner Stacy disclosed her firm's work with Mercy Housing on the site. Public Comments & Testimony - Water Supply Update (Item 4A): Peter Drekmeier (Tuolumne River Trust) urged the Commission to consider taking a year off the "design drought" to reduce alternative water supply needs, citing the SFPUC's entitlement to over 1 million acre-feet from the Tuolumne River this year and a 2.7 million acre-foot snowpack. - Consent Calendar (Item 5): James Mabry (Construction Site Services) requested that micro LBE goals be implemented on the Treasure Island Wastewater Treatment Plant contract (Item 5C). A caller raised concerns about Merced Manor Reservoir repairs. - Customer Assistance Program (Item 7): A public commenter praised the program and requested that micro LBE goals be included in PUC contracts to help underserved communities. - Social Impact Partnership Program (Item 8): No public comments. - WIFIA Loan (Item 9): A caller questioned whether the additional debt would increase rates, noting that the total borrowing (bonds plus EPA loan) could increase PUC debt by 37%. - Contract Award (Item 10): James Mabry and others asked for higher micro LBE goals on the Biosolids Headworks project, arguing that current goals do not reach the smallest businesses. - Alameda Creek Termination (Item 11): A caller from BAWSCA expressed support for the termination and noted the project's challenges. Another caller commended staff transparency. Peter Drekmeier cautioned against over-investing in alternative water supplies. - General Public Comment (Item 13): Several micro LBE contractors from the Bayview neighborhood spoke about the Biosolids Headworks project, asserting that larger contractors do not subcontract to local micro businesses. They requested the Commission mandate inclusion of micro LBE goals on the project. Commissioners acknowledged the comments and committed to a future agenda item on micro LBE programs. Discussion Items - Item 4A – Water Supply Update: Steve Ritchie reported that reservoir storage is healthy, snowpack is above 250% of normal, and year-to-date precipitation is 160% of average at Hetch Hetchy (185% in Bay Area). The Governor's March 24 executive order removed the directive for Stage 2 conservation, and the State Water Board rescinded curtailment orders on April 4. The SFPUC recommends rescinding the local drought emergency and surcharge. Commissioner Maxwell discussed flood control, groundwater recharge, and hydropower optimization. - Item 6 – Rescind Water Shortage Emergency: The Commission voted to rescind the November 2021 emergency declaration and drought surcharge (effective May 1, 2023) while continuing a voluntary 11% reduction until state board regulations expire. The item passed unanimously. - Item 7 – Customer Assistance Program: Michael Perlstein presented a program that expands discounts from 200% of federal poverty level to 50% of area median income (AMI), with two tiers: 25% discount for very low income (50-80% AMI) and 40% discount for extremely low income (0-30% AMI). The program eliminates late payment charges for single-family residential customers and exempts low-income customers from shutoffs/liens for one year. $8 million annual funding was approved. Commissioners expressed support and requested future data on expanding eligibility above 80% AMI. The resolution passed unanimously. - Item 8 – Social Impact Partnership Program: Valerie Toulier Lewa presented rules and regulations for the SIP program, which allows contractors to voluntarily commit to community benefits. The program includes a public dashboard, performance benchmarks, and enforcement mechanisms. Exemptions are limited and require GM approval. The Commission approved the rules unanimously. - Item 9 – WIFIA Loan Agreement: Alexandra Gannell and Nikolai Sklarov presented a master loan agreement with the EPA for up to $791 million, with an initial $369 million sub-loan for six wastewater projects. The interest rate is tied to U.S. Treasury rates (currently 3.61%). The loan allows a one-time adjustment before drawdown. The Commission approved the agreement unanimously. - Item 10 – Wastewater Program Management Contract: Stephen Robinson presented the award of a $90 million, 10-year contract to AECOM for program management of the entire wastewater capital plan. The contract includes a 20.25% LBE commitment and a racial equity component. Commissioners discussed the need for innovation and flexibility. The item passed unanimously. - Item 11 – Terminate Alameda Creek Recapture Contract: Katie Miller recommended terminating the contract with Anvil Builders due to site erosion, cost overruns, and operational concerns. Termination costs are estimated at $13-16 million, versus $30.8 million to continue. The project will be redesigned after bank stabilization. The Commission approved termination unanimously. Key Outcomes - Votes: All action items were approved unanimously (4-0). - Rescission of Drought Emergency: Effective May 1, 2023, the local water shortage emergency and drought surcharge are rescinded; voluntary 11% reduction continues. - Customer Assistance Program: New discount tiers and protections take effect July 1, 2023. Staff will report back after one year. - Social Impact Partnership Program: Rules adopted effective April 22, 2023. - WIFIA Loan: Master and sub-loan agreements approved; closing expected soon. - Wastewater Program Management Contract: Awarded to AECOM; subject to Board of Supervisors approval. - Contract Termination: Alameda Creek Recapture Project contract terminated; staff will conduct lessons-learned review and report back. - Future Agenda Item: Commission directed staff to present an educational item on micro LBE programs and inclusion in upcoming meetings. - Closed Session: The Commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and went into closed session on the Yosemite Slough sediment contamination claim. After reconvening, they recommended additional funding to the Board of Supervisors for the settlement.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, April 10, 2023, at 10:15 AM. Chair Matt Dorsey presided, joined by Vice Chair Shimon Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai. The committee considered three items: an ordinance revising duties of the Small Business Commission, an ordinance amending public works contracting procedures, and appointments to the Assessment Appeals Board No. 3. All items were advanced to the full Board with positive recommendations. Discussion Items - Item 1 (230135): Administrative Code - Small Business Commission Duties – Board President Aaron Peskin presented an ordinance to replace the Small Business Commission's duty to coordinate an application and selection process for honoring small businesses with a broader duty to coordinate activities encouraging public support for small businesses during Small Business Month. The change was made in coordination with Office of Small Business Director Katie Tang. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the item to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (221268): Administrative Code - Public Works Contracting and Contractor Performance Evaluations – Supervisor Raphael Mandelman introduced an ordinance responding to two civil grand jury reports (June 2021 and April 2022). The original ordinance would: (1) remove the mandatory cost criterion in awarding construction manager/general contractor (CMGC) contracts, allowing departmental discretion to weigh cost and non-cost criteria case-by-case; and (2) require departments to consider contractor past performance evaluations when awarding construction contracts. After discussion, the committee agreed to separate the two provisions. They unanimously (3-0) duplicated the file, amended the duplicated version to remove the second provision (contractor performance database requirement), and forwarded the amended version to the full Board with a positive recommendation. The original file was continued to the call of the chair (unanimous). The committee expressed gratitude to the civil grand juries and city staff. - Item 3 (230243): Appointment, Assessment Appeals Board No. 3 – The committee heard from two applicants: Mark Dickau (applying for seat 5, term ending September 4, 2023) and John Sue (applying for seat 6, term ending September 4, 2025). Mr. Dickau is a San Francisco real estate broker and former president of the San Francisco Association of Realtors. Mr. Sue is a real estate broker and licensed insurance agent with a law degree, residing in Albany, California. Both expressed interest in serving to help property owners with assessment appeals. Supervisor Asha Safai was excused from this item due to a scheduling conflict (motion passed 2-0 with Safai excused). The committee then voted 2-0 (Safai excused) to recommend both appointments to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Small Business Commission duties) passed unanimously (3-0) to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (Public Works Contracting) was split: the amended version (removing contractor performance evaluation requirement) passed unanimously (3-0) to the full Board; the original version was continued to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 3 (Appointments to Assessment Appeals Board No. 3) – Mark Dickau and John Sue were recommended unanimously (2-0, Safai excused) to the full Board. - The committee adjourned after completing the agenda.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, met on April 6, 2023, to discuss two major items: the long-awaited neighborhood grocery store at 555 Fulton Street in Hayes Valley and a multi-year Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the San Francisco Police Officers Association (POA). The grocery store hearing was continued pending contract developments, and the POA MOU was approved with a 2–1 vote, sending it to the full Board of Supervisors with a recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Grocery Store): A long-term Hayes Valley resident, Mr. Warshell, expressed support for the continuance and thanked the supervisor for diligent work, noting the neighborhood's strong desire for resolution and the broader issue of vacant commercial spaces. - Item 2 (POA MOU): Numerous callers and speakers supported the MOU, including: Randall Scott (Executive Director, Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefit District), who called the MOU a "band-aid" to stop losing officers and emphasized the need to make officers feel appreciated; Alex Bastion (President/CEO, Hotel Council of San Francisco), who shared his experience as a former prosecutor losing staff to higher-paying jurisdictions; Tracy McCray (President, San Francisco Police Officers Association), who detailed specific officers lost to other cities (e.g., Grand Prairie, TX, Daly City, San Ramon) and argued that morale and fair compensation are essential; Stephanie Lehman (caller), who urged supporting the MOU and criticized policies she said undermine officers; Julia Rome (San Francisco Travel Association), who highlighted public safety concerns for visitors; Marie Raviel (caller), who described the staffing level as a crisis; Jan Diamond (caller), who expressed full support; David Pilpel (caller), who leaned toward support but noted procedural timing concerns; and Jennifer Yen (resident of District 2), who supported the MOU. No public comments opposed the MOU. Discussion Items - Item 1: Hearing on 555 Fulton Street Grocery Store - Chair Preston announced that on April 5, 2023, the property owner ZNL Properties had entered a contract to sell the site to a buyer eager to facilitate Trader Joe's opening a neighborhood grocery store. He provided background: the site was purchased in 2015 and developed into 139 residential units with a 16,686 sq ft retail space; Trader Joe's was conditionally authorized in July 2021 but faced delays due to ZNL not completing tenant improvements. The potential buyer requested anonymity until closing. Trader Joe's confirmed eagerness to open. Chair Preston proposed continuing the item to the call of the chair to monitor progress. - Vice Chair Stephanie recognized the work of former Supervisor Malia Cohen and Mayor Breed (as former supervisor) on earlier attempts. No other committee discussion occurred. - Item 2: Ordinance Adopting POA MOU (July 1, 2023 – June 30, 2026) - Presentation: Carol Eisen (Director, Department of Human Resources) and Artis Graham (Employee Relations Director) presented the MOU. They highlighted charter factors, recruitment/retention challenges (SFPD declined from 2,065 to 1,906 officers in 2022, a 7.7% loss, with unusual resignation spikes at years 5 and 7), and the competitive regional landscape. Key provisions: 10.75% wage increase over three years (with delayed increases if a joint report shows a $300M+ deficit); retention pay of 9% at years 5, 7, and 8; and making San Francisco the highest entry-level payer in the region. Costs: $25.7M in Year 1, $56.3M in Year 2, and $84.7M in Year 3 (cumulative $166.7M over three years). The one percent of total compensation is $4.7M. - Discussion: Chair Preston questioned whether the data supports the costly retention strategy, noting no exit interviews or tracking of destinations for departing officers. Director Eisen and Mr. Graham acknowledged anecdotal evidence (e.g., background checks showing transfers) and argued that compensation matters for morale and recruitment. Supervisor Chan expressed support but emphasized the need for broader conversations on recruitment, reform training, and mental health services. Vice Chair Stephanie strongly supported the MOU, asserting that the cost of not acting is worse and that the city faces a genuine public safety crisis; she cited a recent violent attack on a friend in her district and described being 500–600 officers short. Chair Preston opposed the recommendation, questioning the lack of data and missed opportunities for reforms (e.g., pretext stop policies) and noting that the $166M cost comes amid cuts to other programs. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee voted unanimously (3 ayes) to continue the hearing to the call of the chair, keeping the file open to monitor progress on the property sale and Trader Joe's opening. - Item 2: The committee voted 2–1 (Vice Chair Stephanie and Supervisor Chan in favor; Chair Preston opposed) to recommend the MOU to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The item is expected on the Board's April 18 agenda. Chair Preston noted no committee report was requested for the earlier April 11 date, but DHR clarified that a report was submitted.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, April 5, 2023, at 1:45 PM UTC. The meeting included a new weekly officer recognition segment, consent calendar items, reports from the Chief and DPA Director, commission reports, a discussion on the Compassionate Alternative Response Team (CART), and votes on several resolutions and department general orders. All votes were unanimous unless otherwise noted. Consent Calendar - Item 3: SFPD Collaborative Reform Initiative Quarterly Update – Received and filed unanimously. - Item 4: Adoption of Minutes – Minutes from the previous meeting were adopted unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Yolanda Katsalko expressed concern about the implementation of no-knock warrants without public comment and urged that any funding for a compassionate alternative response team be used to work with the homeless. - Paulette Brown spoke about the unsolved homicide of her son Arbor Abercasa, requested more resources for solving such cases, and called for improved public comment access for mentally disabled individuals. - Vaughn Foster described a negative encounter with police and alleged that his complaint to the Office of Citizen Complaints was not properly addressed. - Jennifer Friedenbach (League of Women Voters/SF) supported the CART program, noting it arose from a robust public process and urged the commission to support city funding. - Jennifer Friedenbach (Coalition on Homelessness) highlighted the CART program's commitment to hiring peers with lived experience of homelessness and emphasized the importance of extensive training and clinical supervision. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 5): Chief Scott reported 13 homicides year-to-date (8 by firearm), overall Part I crimes down 10%, and notable arrests including a homicide suspect and an invasion of privacy case. Fentanyl seizures increased 169% year-to-date. The Chief provided data on pending Chief's hearings (103 total) and BIBUS arrests (22 year-to-date plus 18 from Tenderloin officers). Discussion included the backlog of discipline cases, narcotics enforcement strategies, and the need for updated tactics. - DPA Director's Report (Item 6): Director Henderson reported 22 cases over nine months old (17 tolled), 91 cases pending with the Chief. DPA's audit of DGO 8.10 won the Knighton Award. He also mentioned a key issue report on monitoring communications for bias. - Commission Reports (Item 7): Commissioners reported on attendance at recruitment events, a mission town hall meeting, working group progress on DGO 7.01 (juvenile interactions) and DGO 10.11 (body worn cameras), and meetings with command staff. A procedural debate occurred regarding the formation of a committee to hire a police commission analyst. - CART Presentation (Item 8): Chris Herring (UCLA) presented on the Compassionate Alternative Response Team, aimed at eliminating police as first responders to homeless-related calls. He cited research showing 90,000+ such calls annually, the ineffectiveness of policing, and negative impacts on unhoused individuals. The CART model uses community-based teams, a hotline, and a budget of $6.8 million. Discussion included coordination with existing programs (SCRT, SWERT, HOT) and the need for data collection. - Naloxone Gift (Item 9): The commission approved a resolution to retroactively authorize acceptance of 900 units of naloxone valued at $48,750 from the state's Naloxone Distribution Project. - Labor Relations Resolution (Item 10): The commission adopted a resolution providing labor negotiation instructions for the department when meeting and conferring on DGOs, consistent with prior practices. - DGO 6.02 (Physical Evidence and Crime Scenes) (Item 11): Discussion focused on clarifying responsibility for evidence collection at crime scenes. The commission voted to continue the item to the next meeting to allow for amendments on gunshot residue warrant language and minor typographical fixes. - DGO 9.07 (Restricting Pretext Stops) (Item 12): After prior revisions, the commission unanimously approved the revised DGO. Key changes included deprioritization language and clarifying exceptions for enforcement. The Chief expressed support, and Vice President Carter Overstone noted collaboration with the Mayor's office on disability and aging concerns. - Closed Session Items (Items 13-15): Public comment was invited; none offered. The commission voted to hold Item 15 in closed session and to assert attorney-client privilege (7-0). Key Outcomes - Unanimous approval of consent calendar, minutes, naloxone resolution, and labor relations resolution. - Unanimous approval of DGO 9.07 (Restricting Pretext Stops). - DGO 6.02 (Physical Evidence) continued to the next meeting for amendments. - No formal action on CART, but the commission expressed support for continued exploration and coordination. - The commission voted to proceed to closed session (7-0).
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Asar Shafay, met on April 5, 2023 at 10:15 AM. The committee considered nine agenda items, including grants, appropriations, lease agreements, and bond financing. Several items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors, while two were continued for further review. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel spoke in support of the SFPUC energy efficiency program (Item 5), encouraging collaboration with the Department of the Environment. He also expressed support for the SFO lease (Item 6), noting the unique annual payment to the general fund, and praised the late Airport Commission President Eleanor Johns. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Grant to Planned Parenthood Northern California ($400,000, Security Services): The committee heard from Dominica Donovan (Legislative Aide to Supervisor Stefani) and DPH staff. The grant would fund armed security (S2 Security) at the Planned Parenthood clinic, replacing unarmed Allied Universal. The BLA originally recommended quarterly reporting, but after discussion, DPH agreed to an annual report to the Board. The committee amended the ordinance to include that reporting requirement and forwarded it with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2 – Grant to Children’s Council of San Francisco ($164,346,004): The city attorney had not completed review of the contract. The committee voted to continue the item to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 3 – Future of Public Health Funding ($3,639,888): Daisy Guero (DPH) presented a grant to fund 17 FTE positions. Supervisor Chan expressed concern about grant-funded positions lacking a backup plan if grants expire. The committee forwarded the ordinance with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 4 – Joint Exercise of Powers Agreement (Assessor Tech Improvements): Holly Long (Assessor-Recorder’s Office) explained the resolution, which authorizes San Francisco to join a statewide IT authority at no cost. The committee forwarded it with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5 – SFPUC Energy Efficiency Program ($4,579,056): Mike Himes (CleanPowerSF) described a program providing free energy assessments and equipment for food service businesses, funded by CPUC ratepayer funds. An RFP will select an energy services company; the business pays nothing upfront. The committee forwarded the ordinance with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6 – SFO 2023 Lease and Use Agreement (10-year, 29 airlines): Chair Chan noted the importance of the lease but requested more time to review details and to consider 11 additional airlines. The item was continued to April 19, 2023 (3-0). The committee also paid tribute to the late Airport Commission President Eleanor Johns. - Items 7 & 8 – Public Defender Immigration Legal Defense ($1,051,298 and Salary Ordinance Amendment): Francisco Ugarte and Mano Raju presented the appropriation of settlement funds from a class action lawsuit against ICE. The funds will add one attorney and one paralegal. The BLA recommended amending the FTE count for FY 2022-23 to 0.17. The committee first moved the items, then rescinded the vote on Item 8 to accept the BLA amendment. After amending, both items were forwarded with positive recommendations (3-0). - Item 9 – Hunters Point Shipyard Affordable Housing Revenue Note (up to $63,000,000): Jasmine Ku (OCII) presented a 112-unit affordable housing project (110 units for 30-50% AMI, plus 2 manager units). Construction is set to begin May 2023. Supervisor Safai noted the inclusion of a 5-bedroom unit as unusual. The committee forwarded the resolution with a positive recommendation (3-0). Key Outcomes - Action Taken: - Item 1 (Planned Parenthood grant) amended to require annual report and forwarded (3-0). - Item 2 (Children’s Council grant) continued to call of chair (3-0). - Item 3 (Public Health grant) forwarded (3-0). - Item 4 (Assessor JPA) forwarded (3-0). - Item 5 (SFPUC energy program) forwarded (3-0). - Item 6 (SFO lease) continued to April 19, 2023 (3-0). - Item 7 (PD appropriation) forwarded (3-0). - Item 8 (PD salary ordinance) initially forwarded, then vote rescinded, amended per BLA, and re-forwarded (3-0). - Item 9 (Hunters Point bonds) forwarded (3-0). - Additional Notes: Committee members added themselves as co-sponsors to several items. All items that passed are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on April 11, 2023, unless continued.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, April 3, 2023, at 10:15 AM, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai. The committee considered several mayoral appointments and a rule amendment to formalize remote public comment. All appointments were approved unanimously with positive recommendations to the full Board, except for the Ethics Commission appointment which was continued due to the nominee's inability to connect remotely. The rule amendment was also approved with a minor typographical correction. Consent Calendar - No items were designated as consent; all items were discussed individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Treasure Island Development Authority): James Tallis and Sean McGarry, both from Carpenters Local 22, spoke in support of nominee Timothy Reyff, praising his work ethic and dedication to community interests. - Item 3 (MTA Board – Steve Heminger): Multiple speakers supported Heminger. Eileen Boken (Sunset Parkside Education and Action Committee) urged the Board to consider MTA governance reform, citing concerns about MTA's priorities and policies. Jody Majaris (Walk San Francisco) endorsed Heminger for his experience and Vision Zero commitment. David Pilpel supported Heminger but noted an outdated Form 700 in the packet. - Item 4 (MTA Board – Amanda Eaken): Supporters included Michael Chen (MTA Citizens Advisory Council chair), Stephanie Cajina (MTA board colleague), Jody Majaris (Walk San Francisco), Cyrus Hall, and Lan Chang. David Pilpel expressed a dissenting view, stating he had not always felt heard or respected by Eaken, and also noted the missing current Form 700. - Item 5 (Port Commission): David Pilpel spoke in support of Ed Harrington, praising his qualifications and service. - Item 6 (Rules Amendment): A caller noted the city's three-tier system for remote comment accommodations and argued it was discriminatory, urging the Board to work with the city administrator. David Pilpel supported the amendment but pointed out a typo and suggested further work on standardizing remote comment rules. - Item 1 (Ethics Commission): Two callers, including David Pilpel, supported Larry Bush's reappointment and urged the committee to resolve the matter promptly. Discussion Items - Item 2 – Timothy Reyff (Treasure Island Development Authority): The nominee, a field representative for Carpenters Local 22, described his interest in the position after attending a community meeting on Treasure Island where residents raised concerns about power outages and utility issues. He emphasized his construction experience and commitment to equitably serving existing and future residents. Chair Dorsey noted the district's housing element goals and the importance of treating Treasure Island as a full neighborhood. The committee voted unanimously to send the appointment to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 – Steve Heminger (MTA Board): Heminger, current MTA board member, reviewed his tenure, including navigating the pandemic, implementing slow streets, shared spaces, and red carpet lanes. He noted Muni ridership is at two-thirds of pre-pandemic levels, and that $1 billion in federal emergency aid is nearly exhausted. He highlighted Vision Zero challenges, noting 2022 was one of the worst years for traffic fatalities. In response to Vice Chair Walton's question on the fiscal cliff, Heminger said local revenue measures may be needed. Supervisor Safai asked about MTA's organizational structure and community outreach; Heminger acknowledged the need for a possible audit and pledged to improve engagement. The committee voted unanimously to recommend reappointment to the full Board. - Item 4 – Amanda Eaken (MTA Board): Eaken, current chair of the MTA board, spoke about her priorities: addressing the fiscal cliff (projected $130 million deficit in FY25, rising to $214 million in FY26), Vision Zero (37 fatalities in 2022, commitment to improve all 130 miles of the high-injury network by 2024), and building trust in government through a "culture of caring." In response to Vice Chair Walton's concerns about responsiveness, she described efforts to strengthen the Citizens Advisory Council's role. Supervisor Safai asked about a potential management audit; Eaken noted that MTA is 1,200 staff short and everyone is overworked, but she would be open to reviewing the top-heavy criticism. The committee voted unanimously to recommend reappointment to the full Board. - Item 5 – Ed Harrington (Port Commission): Harrington, former city controller and former general manager of the SFPUC, highlighted his background in government finance, environmental work, and nonprofit board service. He identified key port issues: revitalizing the Northern Waterfront and Fisherman's Wharf, development for affordable housing and jobs, and climate change impacts such as sea level rise. Supervisor Safai spoke about the need for a visionary public-private partnership approach, citing the Fisherman's Wharf and Pier 30-32 proposals. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the appointment to the full Board as a committee report. - Item 6 – Amending Rules of Order for Remote Public Comment: The motion codifies the Board's recent decision to allow unlimited remote public comment within parameters. Chair Dorsey noted it was a housekeeping step. Public comment included a suggestion to eliminate the three-tier accommodation system. The committee adopted an amendment to correct a typo (changing "rules" to "rule" on page 2, line 10) and then voted unanimously to send the amended motion to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 1 – Larry Bush (Ethics Commission): Bush was unable to connect remotely. The committee heard public comment supporting his reappointment. After determining he could not be reached, Chair Dorsey moved to continue the item to the call of the chair. The motion passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 2 (230186): Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 3 (230254): Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 4 (230255): Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 5 (230284): Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full Board as a committee report. - Item 6 (230306): Approved with an amendment (typo correction) and sent to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 1 (230053): Continued to the call of the chair (unanimous 3-0).