The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 3, 2023, at 1:45 PM (UTC) under Chair Mirna Melgar, Vice Chair Dean Preston, and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered seven items, including tenant protections, street naming, shared spaces, drug disposal, security gates, commercial-to-residential conversion, and the Castro Theatre landmark designation. Extensive public comment was heard on multiple items. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (COVID Tenant Protections): A speaker expressed full support for extending protections, noting that COVID is not over and many tenants remain at risk. - Item 3 (Safe Drug Disposal): A speaker raised concerns about using police stations for drug drop-offs and suggested recycling unused medicines instead of incineration. - Item 4 (Gates & Railings): Multiple small business owners and cannabis retailers spoke in support of allowing solid roll-down gates, citing repeated break-ins and security needs. Some emphasized requiring artwork on gates. - Item 5 (Commercial-to-Residential Conversion): Extensive public comment included calls for a comprehensive downtown vision, affordable housing, inclusion of artists and ground-floor uses, and frustration with slow pipeline projects. - Item 6 (Castro Theatre): Over 50 public commenters spoke. Supporters of the landmark amendment argued that fixed theatrical seating (movie palace style) is a character-defining feature and must be preserved. Opponents (including many business owners and residents) supported flexible seating to allow diverse programming and argued the theater is in decline without renovation. Former Supervisor Tom Ammiano urged decisive action. Discussion Items - Item 1 – COVID-19 Tenant Protections (File 230311): Supervisor Preston moved to amend the ordinance to include city-regulated housing units (e.g., MOHCD and HSH portfolios) that were inadvertently omitted. The amendments were substantive, requiring a continuance. The committee voted unanimously to amend and continue to April 17, 2023. - Item 7 – Emperor Norton Commemorative Street Naming (File 230230): Supervisor Peskin presented the resolution to add “Emperor Norton Place” to the 600 block of Commercial Street. The emperor impersonator, Joseph Amster, spoke in support. Public comment was unanimously in favor. The committee voted 3-0 to send to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 – Shared Spaces Program Extension (File 230124): The committee voted unanimously to send the ordinance (extending the grace period for pandemic shared spaces permits by 120 days) to the full board without further discussion. - Item 3 – Safe Drug Disposal (File 230156): Staff from the Department of the Environment presented technical changes to require disposal at permitted facilities and annual reporting. Supervisor Preston raised equity concerns about drop-off locations in low-income areas. The committee voted 3-0 to approve and forward to the full board. - Item 4 – Gates, Railings, and Grillwork Exceptions (File 220971): Supervisor Safai introduced amendments to reduce transparency requirements from 75% to 20%, exempt cannabis retail uses, and legalize existing non-compliant gates. The Planning Department noted the Planning Commission’s recommendations. The committee voted 3-0 to adopt the amendments and continue to April 17, 2023. - Item 5 – Repurposing Commercial Real Estate for Residential Use (File 230147): A hearing was held with presentations from the Budget and Legislative Analyst, SPUR, Gensler, ULI, and the Office of Economic and Workforce Development. Discussions focused on vacancy rates (24.1% downtown, 20.7 million sq ft vacant), conversion feasibility (Class B/C buildings could yield up to 4,200 units), regulatory barriers, and needed financial incentives (e.g., property tax abatements). Supervisor Preston questioned the lack of affordable housing analysis. The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. - Item 6 – Landmark Designation Amendment for Castro Theatre (File 230192): Supervisor Mandelman recommended updating the landmark designation to include interior features. The Historic Preservation Commission’s fact sheet identifies two periods of significance (1922–1937 and 1976–2004). Public comment strongly urged replacing “presence of seating” with “fixed theatrical seating configured in movie palace style” to protect the orchestra seating. Supervisor Preston indicated support for that amendment. Supervisor Peskin urged Another Planet Entertainment (APE) to negotiate with the community. The committee voted 3-0 to continue to April 17, 2023, to allow the city attorney to draft the amendment and for further talks. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Amended and continued to April 17, 2023 (3-0). - Item 7: Approved and forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 2: Approved and forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 3: Approved and forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 4: Amended and continued to April 17, 2023 (3-0). - Item 5: Continued to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 6: Continued to April 17, 2023 (3-0); city attorney to draft amendment regarding fixed theatrical seating.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held its regular meeting on March 28, 2023, to discuss water supply conditions, capital improvement programs, bond issuance, cooperative agreements, and other business. Commissioners voted unanimously on all consent and regular calendar items. The meeting included updates on the end of the drought emergency, notable progress on the Mountain Tunnel Improvement Project, and a presentation on the upcoming $865 million wastewater bond issuance. Consent Calendar - Item 6: Consent calendar approved unanimously (5-0). Items included re-award of a construction management contract to Town Cent Management Incorporated CM Pros joint venture and an increase for the College Hill Reservoir roof substructure replacement after a full inspection revealed additional decay. Public Comments & Testimony - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) commented on Item 4A, noting that the water supply report title changed from “drought conditions” and questioned the timing of the drought emergency declaration when storage was over a million acre-feet. On Item 5, he criticized the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) for not analyzing the Tuolumne River Voluntary Agreement and urged commissioners to examine peer review issues. During general public comment, he reported that only 466 salmon returned to the Tuolumne River this season, far below the 38,000 federal doubling goal. - Speaker (Gloria Barry) on Item 8 supported the SFUSD internship grant and suggested it could be expanded as a form of reparations, urging partnership with a new Department of Reparations. - Speaker (Nicole Sinkula-Bosca) on Item 4B praised the Mountain Tunnel project and noted that the original billion-dollar tunnel alternative was avoided through repairs. - Speaker (public) on Item 7 urged the commission to tap into the federal infrastructure bill for solar projects. - Speaker (public) on Item 9 highlighted past flooding collaboration with Caltrans and called for commissioner orientation on flood risk. Discussion Items - Item 4A: Water Supply Conditions Update – Steve Ritchie reported that reservoir storage is near capacity, precipitation at Hetch Hetchy exceeds 50 inches (double March average), snowpack is 250% of the April 1st median, and water demand remains low (13% savings baseline). The Governor lifted the 15% reduction order, and staff will bring a proposal to lift the local drought emergency and surcharge at the April 11 meeting. Commissioner Maxwell asked about flood risk on the Tuolumne; Ritchie explained the Dos Rios floodplain project performed well. Commissioner Rivera inquired about Trinity Reservoir’s low storage due to inter-basin transfers. - Item 4B: Hetch Hetchy CIP Quarterly Report – Randy Anderson reported $211 million spent (27% completion) on the program, with 17 projects (9 pre-construction, 6 in construction, 2 closeout). Cost variances totaled $34 million due to revised budgets. Highlights: Mountain Tunnel shaft excavation completed, bypass tunnels tied in during 49-day winter outage, and major equipment delivered to Moccasin Powerhouse. Commissioner Maxwell and Commissioner Stacy discussed incorporating climate extremes into design; Anderson noted a balancing act with costs. Commissioner Paulson asked about replacing 100-year-old penstocks with cracks – alternatives under study for 80-100 year design life. - Item 4C: Wastewater Enterprise Quarterly Report – Carolyn Chu (standing in for Stephen Robinson) reported SSIP at 52.6% completion ($4.4 billion program, $5.97 billion budget, $49.1 million over forecast). Cost increases from headworks, new trades buildings, and equipment delays. Southeast area major projects: biosolids construction ongoing; headworks delayed 20 months to 2026 due to wet weather restrictions, complexity, and supply chain issues. Southeast Community Facility grand opening occurred. Commissioner Maxwell asked about a large 84-inch pipe in a photo – Chu clarified it is permanent. - Item 4D: Report on SFPUC Activities – General Manager Eric Sandler announced a scheduling error (missing time in Prop 218 rate hearing notice) will move the rate hearing from May 9 to May 23. Public comment noted the error was caught by a community member. - Item 5: BAWSCA Report – Nicole Sinkula-Bosca presented updated per capita water use: 60 gallons per day residential, 26% reduction from peak (despite 33% population increase). She discussed recycled water projects (South Bay, Peninsula) and noted BAWSCA will update its long-term water supply strategy to 2045. Commissioners discussed on-site reuse and direct potable reuse. Commissioner Stacy commended the focus on recycling. - Item 7: $865 Million Bond Issuance – The commission authorized issuance of 2023 Series A, B, and C bonds (A and B for new wastewater projects, C for refunding). The package includes green bonds for SSIP, refinancing of 2018 mandatory put bonds, and use of low-interest federal WIFIA loans locked at 1.45%. Underwriters: BofA (Series A/B) and Goldman Sachs (Series C). The good faith estimate assumes 5% interest, but staff noted the inverted yield curve may allow lower rates. Ratings affirmed with stable outlook. - Item 8: SFUSD Work Based Learning Grant Amendment – Approved increase of $28,350 and three-year extension (total $34,350 over four years) to host three summer interns per year at the College Hill Learning Garden. The program prioritizes students from environmental justice communities. - Item 9: Special Ordinance for Caltrans Cooperative Agreements – Approved recommendation to the Board of Supervisors to waive certain administrative codes allowing cooperative agreements with Caltrans for engineering review on Lower Alemany and Folsom stormwater projects. Commissioners asked about labor standards; staff confirmed state prevailing wages would apply. Key Outcomes - Minutes of March 14, 2023 approved unanimously (4-0). - Consent Calendar approved unanimously (5-0). - Item 7: Bond Issuance approved unanimously (5-0) – authorizes up to $865 million in 2023 Series A/B bonds for wastewater and Series C for refunding; delegates authority to General Manager. - Item 8: SFUSD Grant Amendment approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 9: Special Ordinance for Caltrans approved unanimously (4-0) – recommendation to Board of Supervisors. - Rate Hearing Rescheduled – Due to a time omission in the Prop 218 notice, the sewer/water rate hearing moved from May 9 to May 23, 2023. A corrected notice will go out April 7. - Drought Emergency Lifting – Staff will present a resolution to lift the local drought emergency and surcharge at the April 11, 2023 meeting. - Future Discussion – Commissioner Maxwell requested a comprehensive overview of all SFPUC internship programs and their fields.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, March 23, 2023, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Supervisor Joel Engardio (acting) with members Supervisor Dorsey and Supervisor Safai (substituting for Chair Stefani). The committee considered three agenda items: two liquor license applications and a resolution adopting the Japantown Cultural Heritage District's Cultural, History, Housing, and Economic Sustainability Strategy (CHESS) Report. All items received unanimous approval and were recommended to the full Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Mainstay Markets): No public comments were offered in person or remotely. - Item 2 (Brick and Mortar Music Hall): No public comments were offered in person or remotely. The applicant, Michael O'Connor (co-owner), spoke in support, noting the business's 12-year history and acceptance of proposed conditions. Supervisor Safai expressed support for nightlife venues and highlighted pending legislation to waive license fees and raise gross receipts thresholds for small businesses. - Item 3 (Japantown CHESS Report): Multiple speakers provided testimony in strong support, including community leaders, cultural district representatives, and board members. Speakers highlighted the report's significance as a community-led roadmap to preserve Japantown—one of only three remaining Japantowns in the nation—after historical traumas of incarceration and urban renewal. Representatives from SOMA Pilipinas, Castro LGBTQ, Transgender, Leather & LGBTQ, and Sunset Chinese Cultural Districts also voiced support. No opposition was voiced. Discussion Items - Item 1 – 230082 Liquor License Transfer for Mainstay Markets (655 22nd Street): Officer Salmanson of SFPD ABC Liaison Unit reported zero letters of protest or support, low-crime area (Plot 315), high saturation area (Census Tract 226), and recommended approval with conditions to monitor loitering and limit entertainment noise. The applicant's representative, Rebecca Stamy White, confirmed the grocery store's aim to provide one-stop shopping. The committee unanimously voted to prepare a resolution of public convenience or necessity and to send it to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 – 230089 Liquor License Issuance for Brick and Mortar Music Hall (1710-1712 Mission Street): Officer Salmanson reported one letter of protest, zero support letters, high-crime area (Plot 404), low saturation area (Census Tract 2010). Mission Station had no opposition; Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval with three conditions: monitoring loitering, noise limits, and requiring a uniformed security guard during entertainment hours (1 PM–2 AM). The applicant accepted conditions. The committee unanimously voted to prepare a resolution of public convenience or necessity and to send it to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 – 230264 Japantown Cultural Heritage District's CHESS Report: Kira Geithman (Associate Director of Policy, Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development) and Grace June Lee (Cultural Districts Program Manager) provided background on the Cultural Districts Program, established in 2018. Susie Kagami (Japantown Cultural District Manager) presented the CHESS report, which builds on 13 years of community engagement and 25 strategies across six focus areas: preservation, economic/workforce development, land use, housing, and community landownership. The report addresses the displacement of Japanese Americans and aims to secure Japantown's future. Supervisors Safai and Dorsey expressed strong support, with Safai noting Japantown as "one of the things that's going right with San Francisco" and Dorsey adding herself as a co-sponsor. The committee unanimously voted to adopt the resolution and recommend it to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to prepare a resolution finding public convenience or necessity (passed unanimously). Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation (passed unanimously). - Item 2: Motion to prepare a resolution finding public convenience or necessity (passed unanimously). Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation (passed unanimously). - Item 3: Motion to adopt the resolution endorsing the Japantown Cultural Heritage District's CHESS Report (passed unanimously). Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation (passed unanimously). All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on April 4, 2023.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a hearing on March 22, 2023, at 4:00 PM, to receive the San Francisco Youth Commission's budget and policy priorities for fiscal years 2023-2024 and 2024-2025. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Supervisors Hilary Ronen, Shamann Walton, Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman, and Supervisor Ahsha Safai present. The Youth Commission presented a comprehensive set of recommendations organized by its committees, focusing on transportation, housing, justice, civic engagement, and LGBTQ+ issues. Presentation by the Youth Commission The Youth Commission, led by Chair Emily Wynne (District 11), presented its annual budget and policy priorities report, which was finalized on March 6, 2023. Commissioners from four committees and a task force detailed the following key proposals: - Housing, Recreation & Transit (HRT) Committee: - Restore 100% of Muni service, especially lines critical for youth like the 28R (which served 40% youth riders). - Expand the school tripper program to ensure equitable distribution. - Fund studies for car-free streets (e.g., JFK Drive saw 36% more daily active trips after car-free designation). - Provide funding to fully implement and maintain Slow Streets. - Improve and promote large parks, particularly John McLaren Park, which was viewed as dangerous and unkept. - Restore the 76X bus to Marin Headlands, which served one-third of households without cars. - Explore public transit access to Camp Mather for employees and families. - Open an additional navigation center for transitional-age youth (TAY) to supplement the one at 700 Hyde Street, hire more case managers, and allocate funding for permanent services at supportive housing. - Urge Vision Zero progress: traffic deaths in 2022 tied a decade high at 32; enforce "Focus on the Five" traffic violations; support automated speed enforcement. - Continue and make permanent the Free Muni for Youth program (61% of current users did not participate in the previous means-tested program). - Study removal of the central freeway, citing past successes like the Embarcadero and Octavia Boulevard. - Transformative Justice (TJ) Committee: - Fund community-based alternatives to youth incarceration; note that juvenile hall remains open with only 22 youth in a 150-bed facility. - Implement a Narcan program in all San Francisco schools, citing that fentanyl is responsible for 77% of teen drug-related deaths nationally and rising overdoses locally. - Restore Bayview Hunters Point: implement the 2021-2022 civil grand jury report; ensure environmental safety for future developments; fund community initiatives like the Bayview Hunters Point Environmental and Climate Justice Leadership Academy. - Civic Engagement & Education (CEC) Committee: - Oversee and invest in school safety infrastructure; SFPD responded to 790 violent crime incidents at SFUSD schools since 2013, and many schools lack basic systems like PA systems and remote door buzzers. - Require safe firearm storage information be sent to families; state law now mandates this. - Restart the Safer Schools Task Force on sexual assault and harassment; in 2022, SFUSD investigated only 5 of 24 Title IX complaints. - Increase voter pre-registration: a Youth Commission survey found 60% of eligible youth were not pre-registered, half because they didn't know they could. - Put a charter amendment on the ballot to lower the voting age to 16 (lost by less than 1% in 2020). - Increase funding for diverse mental health staff in schools; a survey showed wellness centers do not meet cultural or linguistic needs. - LGBTQ+ Task Force: - Grant $350,000 to the LGBTQIA+ Coalition on Safety for security infrastructure and staffing (Lyric Center received five bomb threats in 2022). - Implement inclusive middle school health curriculum; only 10% of lessons cover queer identity. - Hire properly credentialed health teachers; many schools use uncredentialed staff. - Create safe spaces in schools and connect with organizations like Lyric and the LGBT Center. - Assess school climate using tools like the GLSEN School Climate Survey. Discussion by Committee Members Supervisors commended the Youth Commission for its thorough presentation and commitment. Supervisor Ronen noted she had to leave early. Vice Chair Mandelman left early but expressed support for transportation and LGBTQ+ priorities. Supervisor Walton praised the youth for their social justice work, especially on issues affecting underserved communities. Supervisor Safai provided detailed feedback, noting that a seat for transitional-age youth was created on the new Homelessness Oversight Commission, suggested studying the submersion of the central freeway rather than removal, pointed to Crystal Springs as an alternative recreation area, and emphasized that mental health funding (e.g., the Seneca program cut) will be a budget priority. Supervisor Chan urged the Youth Commission to brief all supervisors and the Mayor's office before her proposed budget on June 1, 2023, and to track future budget hearings. Chair Wynne asked how to keep recommendations a priority; Safai suggested ongoing follow-up with all supervisors and public comment. Key Outcomes - The hearing was filed by motion of Chair Chan, seconded by Supervisor Safai, with a vote of 3-0 (Supervisors Ronen and Mandelman absent). - The committee received the Youth Commission's budget and policy priorities report and will consider them during the city's budget process. - No public comments were made. - The meeting adjourned at approximately 5:00 PM.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and joined later by Supervisor Asha Safayi, met on March 22, 2023. The committee considered six items: a contract modification with Jefferies LLC, a grant acceptance for the Public Defender's Adachi Project, a de-appropriation and appropriation for the Gene Friend Recreation Center, and four resolutions authorizing grant applications for affordable housing projects under the state's Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities (AHSC) program. The meeting lasted from approximately 10:15 AM to conclusion. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 4-7 (AHSC Grant Applications): James Washington spoke generally about housing and the RAD program, expressing concern that public housing tenants are being forgotten. He did not directly address the items at hand. - Item 3 (Gene Friend Rec Center Funding): Alan Lowe, former commissioner, stated that the 2013 development agreement for 706 Mission Street contemplated a public process for all three streams of payments (annual, one-time, and condo sale annuity). He argued the city must honor that obligation and that no funds should be spent without following the process, referencing a February 2022 GAO hearing. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Contract Modification with Jefferies LLC: Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson requested approval to amend a litigation consulting contract, extending it from April 1, 2023 to September 17, 2027 and increasing the amount by approximately $5.5 million to a new not-to-exceed $15.5 million. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) noted the contract was redacted for privilege but recommended follow-up on solicitation details. No questions were raised. The committee voted to forward with a positive recommendation (2-0, with Safayi absent). - Item 2 – Ford Foundation Grant for Adachi Project: Public Defender Mano Raju presented the Adachi Project, a storytelling initiative producing documentary films and photojournalism about the human impact of the justice system. The Ford Foundation awarded a $200,000 grant (disbursed to project partner even/odd LLC) to support short film production for 2022-2024. No funds go to the city. The committee voted to forward (2-0, after excusing Safayi). - Item 3 – De-Appropriation and Appropriation for Gene Friend Rec Center (Continued): Melinda Stockman Sullivan (Rec & Park) described the $59.3 million project at Folsom & 6th Streets, noting a 24,000 sq ft design with two gyms, two multi-purpose rooms, and more. The item would transfer $1.7 million from Rec & Park to the 706 Mission Street Fund (half to MOHCD, half to Rec & Park) to be spent after community input from the SOMA Community Stabilization Committee. The BLA reported that only $1.5 million remains due to prior spending. Supervisor Chan questioned why, after the board approved an additional $11.1 million in bond funds for this project on January 25, the department now seeks this money. Rec & Park's Sarah Madlin explained that impact fee collections improved, reducing the needed bond borrowing. Chan expressed concern that spending had occurred without a required community process. The city attorney noted the development agreement did not require community process for this one-time payment, but the fund legislation did for ongoing payments. After public comment, Chan moved to continue the item to the call of the chair for further clarity on the legal requirement. The motion passed 3-0. - Items 4-7 – AHSC Grant Applications for Affordable Housing Projects: Sheila Nicolopoulos (MOHCD) presented four resolutions authorizing joint applications for state AHSC (Cap-and-Trade) funding. Each project is eligible for up to $50 million total ($35 million housing loan, $15 million transportation grant). The projects are: (4) 160 Freelon Family (Related Companies/SF Housing Development Corp.), (5) 850 Turk Street (MidPen Housing), (6) Balboa Reservoir Building A (Bridge Housing, 159 units), and (7) Transbay 2 East Family (Mercy Housing California, 184 units with 40 for homeless families). The city must assume joint and several liability. Non-substantive amendments were introduced for item 7 to clarify MTA improvements. The committee voted to approve all four items with amendments to item 7 and forward them to the full board. Vice Chair Mandelman and Supervisor Safayi requested to be added as co-sponsors. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Passed (2-0) and forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 2: Passed (2-0) and forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 3: Continued to the call of the chair (3-0). The chair requested the city attorney to clarify if the 2013 development agreement required a community process, and directed the controller to explore mechanisms to halt further spending from the account pending the committee's decision. - Items 4-7: Passed (3-0) as amended (item 7 non-substantive amendments) and forwarded to full board, where they are expected on the April 4, 2023 agenda.
The Rules Committee met on Monday, March 20, 2023, at 10:15 a.m. UTC. Chair Matt Dorsey led the meeting with Vice Chair Walton and Member Asha Safai; Committee Clerk Victor Young managed the agenda and public comment. The committee heard six items and unanimously forwarded recommendations to the full Board. Discussion Items Item 1 – Reentry Council Pretrial Services Seat (File 221245): An ordinance to add a Board-appointed seat to the Reentry Council for the agency administering pretrial services. Anna Herrera, on behalf of Supervisor Hillary Ronen, presented; David Moroff, CEO of SF Pretrial, described the agency's role and noted its caseload was about 1,800 clients, including 950 in certificate management. Victoria Westbrook said the Reentry Council has 24 members and that the idea was not formally voted on by the council, but no co-chair objected. The committee moved a positive recommendation. Item 2 – Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee Appointments (File 230289): The committee interviewed candidates for eight seats. Qualified applicants included incumbents Marna Armstead and Abby Cabrera, youth nominee Linda Yee, and others. Vice Chair Walton moved to appoint Chester Williams (seat 1), John Aisha Anna (seat 2), Marna Armstead (seat 3), Francis Abby Cabrera (seat 4), Jamie Schmidt (seat 5), Linda Yee (seat 6), Eva Holman (seat 15), and Laura Urban (seat 16). A residency waiver was approved for Chester Williams. Item 3 – Food Security Task Force Appointments (File 230290): The committee interviewed Jade Kizon and Austin Dalmaso; Earl Campbell Barby was unable to attend. The committee moved to forward Dalmaso (seat 12), Campbell Barby (seat 13), and Kizon (seat 15), with a residency waiver for Kizon. Item 4 – Ethics Commission Appointment (File 230053): Commissioner Larry Bush was not present. A public commenter said Bush was the only applicant and urged approval, but the committee unanimously continued the appointment to the call of the chair. Item 5 – Public Works Commission Appointment (File 230126): Gerald Turner presented his background, including nearly 20 years of public service and a 141-unit permanent supportive housing project at Mission Bay. Lauren Post, Public Works Commission chair, said the commission needed his real estate development expertise on a $4 billion capital portfolio. The committee moved to appoint Turner to seat 1. Item 6 – Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District Public Financing Authority No. 1 (File 230160): Lee Lutanski (OEWD) and Anna Vandegna (Controller's Office) presented the Power Station EIFD. The 29-acre former Potrero Power Station site is entitled for mixed-use development with 30% affordable housing, but is at risk of stopping due to financial conditions. The EIFD would use incremental property tax revenue, capped at 50% of annual tax increment, with total district debt payments limited to 5% of annual property tax revenue. Vice Chair Walton offered an amendment adding that the Controller's Office provide administrative and clerical support unless reassigned in the annual budget. The committee forwarded the amended ordinance to the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1: No public comments. - Item 2: Blake Young, co-chair of Shape Up San Francisco’s coalition, urged the committee to consider diversity and intersectionality so appointees can meaningfully represent communities disproportionately affected by sugary drinks; he recommended reappointing current members and noted the 16-member committee spends over 900 hours annually. - Item 3: West Saver, Glide Senior Policy Manager, praised Campbell Barby and also supported Jade Kizon and Austin Dalmaso, describing all three as exemplary. - Item 4: Two callers supported Larry Bush; one objected to the continuance and recommended immediate approval. - Item 5: Lauren Post, Public Works Commission chair, strongly supported Gerald Turner; a public caller also supported forwarding his nomination. - Item 6: One commenter asked what community benefits the Power Station project would provide. Another commenter criticized the EIFD as not vetted with the community, raised environmental contamination and abatement concerns, and asserted that only one or two entities would benefit while developers operate as they please. Key Outcomes - Unanimous positive recommendation for Item 1 (Reentry Council pretrial services seat). - Unanimous approval of eight Sugary Drinks Tax Advisory Committee appointments, plus a residency waiver for Chester Williams, to be sent as a committee report. - Unanimous approval of three Food Security Task Force appointments, plus a residency waiver for Jade Kizon, as a committee report. - Unanimous vote to continue the Ethics Commission appointment to the call of the chair. - Unanimous positive recommendation for Gerald Turner to the Public Works Commission. - Unanimous vote to send the EIFD/PFA ordinance, as amended, to the full Board with a positive recommendation.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Land Use and Transportation Committee met on March 20, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered nine agenda items, including resolutions condemning Texas anti-immigrant property laws, amendments to ADU regulations, a hearing on evictions in permanent supportive housing, extensions of COVID-19 tenant protections, property conveyances, wage theft bonds, a commemorative street naming, shared spaces program, and pregnancy discrimination protections. Several items were passed, amended, or continued. Public Comments & Testimony Public comment was taken on each item. For Item 4 (Texas SB 147), multiple speakers including Texas State Representative Jean Wu, advocates from Chinese for Affirmative Action, and retired judges expressed strong opposition to the bill, highlighting its racist and unconstitutional nature. For Item 2 (PSH evictions), numerous tenants and advocates shared personal experiences of eviction, harassment, lack of support, and retaliation, calling for a tenant bill of rights, better oversight, and an end to non-payment evictions. For Item 3 (COVID protections), tenants and housing rights organizations urged a 60-day wind-down period to allow rent relief funds to be distributed. For Item 7 (commemorative street naming), one business owner expressed concern about the name change affecting her business, but it was clarified that the street name remains (only a commemorative addition). Other items had minimal or no public comment. Discussion Items Item 4: Resolution Condemning Texas State Senate Bill No. 147 (Kolkhorst) – Supervisor Connie Chan presented the resolution, noting it also condemns related bills SB 552 and 711. She emphasized the racist history of alien land laws and the need for solidarity. Amendments to include the additional bills were moved by President Peskin. The item was passed as amended with a positive recommendation to the full board. Item 1: Planning Code – State-Mandated ADU Controls – The committee discussed amendments to conform to recent state law changes (height increase from 16 to 18 feet, allowing two ADUs in detached structures for multifamily buildings, rent control implications). City staff recommended focusing on existing 2020 state changes first. The committee decided to duplicate the file, amend one version with the 18-foot change, and continue the duplicate to the call of the chair. Item 2: Hearing – Evictions in Permanent Supportive Housing (PSH) Project-Based Sites – Supervisor Preston convened this hearing to examine eviction causes and prevention. Presentations were given by Emily Cohen (HSH) on data showing a 1.29% eviction rate in 2022 (142 evictions out of nearly 11,000 households), enhanced services investments, and partnerships with DPH. Dara Papo (DPH) described the FACS program (mobile health teams) and site-based nursing. Provider representatives Lauren Hall and Tremesia Garner discussed challenges including non-payment of rent (noting $875,900 in arrears at Tenderloin Housing Clinic from Sept 2022-Mar 2023), violence, cluttering, and the need for a continuum of housing. Tenant Cheryl Shanks shared experiences of unsafe conditions, harassment, and fear of eviction. Discussion highlighted the lack of coordinated rehousing after eviction, the need for improved data collection (including attorney firm tracking), and the importance of standardized eviction policies. The hearing was continued to the call of the chair. Item 3: Administrative Code – COVID-19 Tenant Protections (60-day extension) – Supervisor Preston moved to extend eviction protections for 60 days after the local state of emergency ends, to allow time for rent relief funds to be disbursed. The committee duplicated the file and passed the original as a committee report, with the duplicate continued. Item 5: Conveyance of Real Property – 160 Freelon Street (Affordable Housing) – Robert Baca (MOHCD) presented the land dedication for 85 affordable units, including units for formerly homeless families. The resolution was approved as a committee report to allow the project to apply for $34 million in state funding. Item 6: Police, Building Codes – Wage Theft Bonds – Supervisor Mandelman introduced a cleanup ordinance to move the trigger for labor compliance bonds from site permit issuance to the first construction document, to reduce costs. The item was passed with positive recommendation. Item 7: Commemorative Street Name – “Randall Kline Alley” – President Peskin proposed adding a commemorative designation to the 200 block of Linden Street honoring Randall Klein, founder of SF Jazz. Public comment included support from SF Jazz CEO and a business owner's concern. The item was passed to the full board. Item 8: Administrative Code – Shared Spaces Program Extension – The committee adopted amendments regarding consent and abandonment provisions, but due to substantive amendments, the item was rescinded and continued to the April 3, 2023 meeting for further discussion. Item 9: Police Code – Prohibiting Pregnancy Discrimination in Housing – Supervisor Melgar requested continuation to the call of the chair while amendments are finalized with the Human Rights Commission. The item was continued. Key Outcomes - Item 4: Passed as amended (3-0) to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 1: Duplicated file; original sent forward (3-0), duplicate amended (16’ to 18’) and continued to call of chair (3-0). - Item 2: Hearing continued to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 3: Original passed as committee report (3-0); duplicate continued to call of chair (3-0). - Item 5: Approved as committee report (3-0). - Item 6: Passed to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 7: Passed to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 8: Vote rescinded; item continued to April 3, 2023 meeting (3-0). - Item 9: Continued to call of chair (2-0, with one absence).
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on March 16, 2023, at 6:15 PM (scheduled start) under Chair Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Supervisor Catherine Stefani and Member Supervisor Connie Chan. The committee heard two substantive items: an ordinance strengthening displaced worker protections for janitorial, security, and building maintenance employees, and a resolution urging internet service providers to provide affordable internet for seniors and people with disabilities. The committee also deliberated on 12 closed session litigation items. All items were forwarded to the full Board with positive recommendations. Discussion Items Item 1: Ordinance Amending Police Code – Displaced Worker Protections - Supervisor Ahsha Safaí, sponsor, presented the ordinance to strengthen Article 33C of the Police Code. The measure requires an awarding authority (e.g., tenant or building owner) to provide the name of a successor contractor within three days of hiring, and if no successor is hired within 10 days, the terminated contractor must provide a list of employees to the awarding authority for transfer. It also authorizes administrative enforcement by the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (OLSE) and allows the City Attorney to bring civil action. The ordinance was prompted by the displacement of janitorial workers at 1355 Market Street (Twitter headquarters) in late 2022, where Twitter terminated a contractor and refused to provide successor information, leaving workers unable to retain their jobs. - Olga Miranda, Secretary-Treasurer of the San Francisco Labor Council and President of SEIU Local 87, expressed full support for the legislation. She reported that approximately 60 union members were affected by the Twitter situation, and that the company had hired and fired two subsequent janitorial companies. She noted the workers' unemployment benefits were running out, their insurance ended in January 2023, and that 32 SEIU members died during the COVID-19 pandemic. - Pat Mulligan (OLSE) and Deputy Director Halle Albert were available for questions. - Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson confirmed that the ordinance adds enforcement options without limiting employees' existing private right of action. - The committee members (Preston, Stefani, Chan) all expressed strong support and added themselves as co-sponsors. - Supervisor Safaí offered three technical amendments (deleting an extra "and" on page 2 line 16, deleting an incorrect code citation on line 21, and clarifying enforcement timing on page 6 lines 12-14), which were adopted. - Public comment included two speakers from SEIU Local 87 who thanked the committee. - Vote: Unanimously (3-0) moved to forward the ordinance as amended to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Resolution Urging Internet Service Providers to Provide Affordable Internet for Seniors and People with Disabilities - Supervisor Dean Preston, author, introduced the resolution calling on AT&T, Verizon, Comcast, and others to expand affordable internet access. He noted that 1 in 8 San Francisco residents lack home high-speed internet, 1 in 7 public school families lack home computer access, and only about 25% of eligible households (estimated 126,000) are enrolled in the federal Affordable Connectivity Program (ACP). Specific data: in the Tenderloin, approximately 3,500 eligible households are not enrolled; in the Western Addition, over 2,600 eligible are not enrolled. - Presentations were made by: - Senior and Disability Action (SDA): Peter Estes and Dasom Desimna described their Free Wi-Fi Campaign, identifying four main barriers: ACP under-enrollment, inadequate eligibility criteria for San Francisco's high cost of living, digital redlining (uneven infrastructure investment), and lack of language access. They estimated that subsidizing internet access for all San Franciscans up to 80% of Area Median Income (AMI) would cost $2–3 million per month, and universal fiber upgrades could cost around $35 million (based on a 2015 city plan). - AT&T: Cammy Blackstone highlighted AT&T's $2 billion national digital divide commitment, its Access program (free for ACP-eligible customers), the Visitation Valley Connected Learning Center, and partnerships with community organizations. - Verizon: Sophia Garcia described Verizon's Forward program (free home internet for ACP enrollees), digital skills training goals (10 million youth by 2030), and over 80 community events in 2022. - Comcast: Dylan Young detailed the Internet Essentials program ($9.95/month for 50 Mbps, $29.95 for 100 Mbps, both fully covered by ACP), serving over 10 million low-income people nationally, and highlighted partnerships with Self-Help for the Elderly and community hubs. - Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) and Department of Technology: Ray Lashaux (Digital Equity Manager) and Brian Roberts (Policy Analyst) reported on the Fiber to Housing program, which has connected over 9,000 units in 75 affordable housing complexes and navigation centers. They are planning to add 5,000 more units and secure $5 million in capital funding for FY 2024-25. A Chinatown SRO pilot reached 5 buildings but faced challenges with primitive wiring and negotiations with small landlords. - During committee questioning, Supervisor Preston pressed the ISPs on whether they would extend discounted or free internet to residents above 200% of federal poverty but still low-income by San Francisco standards (e.g., those qualifying for local benefits). AT&T and Comcast stated they are focused on increasing ACP enrollment and do not adjust pricing locally; Verizon expressed openness to further conversation but no commitment. - Public comment was extensive (over 20 speakers in person and by phone). Many SDA members and community advocates urged passage, citing the necessity of internet for healthcare, social connection, and civic engagement. Some criticized the ISPs for inadequate language support and digital redlining. Supportive comments also came from Community Tech Network, Asian Pacific Community Center, and others who lauded ISP partnerships. - Vice Chair Stefani emphasized the need for a comprehensive city-led approach beyond reliance on ISPs, noting that San Francisco has discussed universal internet for 20 years. She urged more city investment and expressed caution about using the term "digital redlining" without proof. - Chair Preston acknowledged the broader context but stressed the resolution's immediate goal: maximizing use of existing ACP and ISP programs through better outreach and partnership. - Vote: Unanimously (3-0) moved to forward the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Closed Session Items (Items 3–14) - The committee unanimously voted to recommend to the full Board 12 litigation settlement items, including settlements of lawsuits and unlitigated claims (totaling over $10 million in payments and receipts). The committee voted not to disclose closed session discussions (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Displaced Worker Protections): Ordinance amended and forwarded to full Board (3-0). - Item 2 (Affordable Internet Resolution): Resolution forwarded to full Board (3-0). - Items 3–14 (Litigation Settlements): All recommended to full Board (3-0); closed session discussion not disclosed. - Next meeting: The committee adjourned. Items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on April 4, 2023.
The San Francisco Police Commission held its regularly scheduled meeting on March 15, 2023, at 1:45 PM (agenda start time) at the Public Safety Building. The meeting featured reports from SFPD and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), approval of revised Department General Orders (DGOs) on search warrants and death cases, and closed session discussions. Consent Calendar - Approved the SFPD and DPA SB 1421 and SB16 monthly reports unanimously (7-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Unsolved Homicide Case: A mother of a murder victim (Arbor Abercassa, killed August 14, 2006) expressed frustration during both general public comment and under the Chief’s Report. She noted that a $250,000 reward has yielded no tips and demanded action on unsolved homicides. President Elias responded that a policy analyst is being hired to research best practices from other jurisdictions. The speaker also named alleged perpetrators and asked why no answers have been provided since a December 2022 presentation. - No other public comments were made on any agenda items. Discussion Items Chief's Report (presented by Assistant Chief Denise Flaherty) - Crime Statistics: Overall crime down 13% year-to-date; violent crime up 5%; property crime down 15%. Specifics: aggravated assaults down 4%, burglaries down 8%, larceny down 16%, auto burglaries down 11%. Citywide robberies up 19% (firearm-involved robberies up 39%, knife-involved up 58%). No new homicides in the prior week; total homicides revised to 10 due to reclassification of a suspicious death. - Significant Incidents: A shooting on March 12 at 16th and Mission (victim shot twice, no arrest); a catalytic converter theft arrest on March 6 involving a stolen vehicle and handgun (suspects linked to three other incidents, including one where shots were fired); a hot prowl burglary on March 9 on Treat Street (dementia-suffering family member present); an aggravated assault at a bar on March 12 (victim knocked unconscious). - Enforcement Efforts: Tenderloin operations continue; partnership with Park and Rec and DPW for UN Plaza closures (dusk to dawn). Businesses have shifted to 7th and Market area, where a mobile command post is no longer present. Daily strategy discussions with AC Lazar. - Recruitment: Applications increased from 250 to 900 in a quarter; one-day testing implemented (written, physical, interview). Retention unit working to bring back officers who left for other departments. - Commissioner Questions: President Elias requested data on BART (by bus) operations for 2023 and breakdown of the 87 chief’s hearings (including ages and IA backlog). Commissioner Byrne asked about a stabbing on a Muni bus (possible hate crime); AC Flaherty lacked details. Commissioner Benedicto asked about a Chase ATM fraud case in the Mission; follow-up promised. Commissioner Yee raised concerns about arson numbers and 7th & Market conditions. Commissioner Yanyez questioned slow response times and inadequate staffing (e.g., Ingleside station has 7 officers on swing watch). DPA Director’s Report (Paul Henderson) - Caseload: 133 active cases; 9 pending before the commission, 88 pending with the chief. 25 cases over two years old. 20% of new allegations concern officer behavior/language; 17% for failure to take required action. Largest number of allegations came from the Mission District. - Outreach: DPA 101 presentations to air on SFGovTV; final draft of audit on SFPD’s monitoring of communications for bias sent to department (comments due March 17, then public release). Commission Reports - President Elias: Finalizing trial rules with city attorney; handling findings of fact for discipline cases. - Vice President Carter Oberstone: Revised language for DGO 9.07 (pretext stops) posted to website; changes made at request of chief and mayor’s office. - Commissioner Benedicto: Final working group meeting for DGO 7.01 (youth interactions); starting DGO 10.11 (body-worn cameras); acknowledged two-year anniversary of Atlanta spa shootings; drafted a labor relations resolution to codify meet-and-confer procedures. - Commissioner Yi: Reported on merchant walk in San Bruno corridor (reporting crimes) and Bayview station visit (high homicides and shootings). Announced March 25 event for Wong Kim Ark (birthright citizenship). - Commissioner Walker: DGO on missing persons with DPA; meeting with patrol specials group and CART about coordinating alternative responses. - Commissioner Byrne: Immigration-related DGO on back burner; will ride along in Tenderloin in April; meeting with D4 supervisor. Item 6: Approval of Revised DGO 5.16 – Search Warrants - Discussion: Commissioner Benedicto presented a compromise after years of negotiation (original policy from 1997). Over 60 recommendations considered. Major changes include: requiring officers to “provide the search warrant and consult” with the DA’s office on all warrants (not just description); first-time addressing geofence warrants with strict limits; updated no-knock warrant rules (only permissible to prevent imminent threat of physical violence, with multiple approvals). Both DPA and SFPD agreed to final language on March 14. Two minor amendments adopted (striking “for the exigency” and aligning “shall provide the search warrant and consults” phrasing). - Vote: Approved unanimously (7-0). Item 7: Approval of Revised DGO 6.05 – Death Cases - Discussion: Commissioner Byrne questioned a provision on Miranda warnings for juveniles vs. adults. Policy states officers should not Mirandize a homicide suspect (wait for homicide investigators), but per DGO 7.01, juveniles must be Mirandized. Discussion clarified that officers are trained not to interrogate suspects at scene; no written policy explicitly prohibits interrogation but practice is to wait. No further concerns raised. - Vote: Approved unanimously (7-0). Closed Session (Items 8–11) - The commission voted unanimously to hold Item 10 (Closed Session) and later voted not to disclose any discussion (asserting attorney-client privilege). No public comment received. Key Outcomes - Approved DGO 5.16 (Search Warrants) – effective for meeting and conferring with bargaining units. Includes modern provisions on geofence warrants and no-knock restrictions. - Approved DGO 6.05 (Death Cases) – effective for meeting and conferring with bargaining units. - Directives: SFPD to provide in writing the number of BART operations in 2023; breakdown of chief’s hearing backlog (ages, IA backlog) and response to specific incidents (Chase ATM fraud, Muni stabbing, 7th & Market conditions). - Pending: Commission to consider revised DGO 9.07 (pretext stops) and finalize labor relations resolution in April.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, March 15, 2023, at 10:15 AM in a hybrid format. Chair Connie Chan presided, joined by Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman and later by Supervisor Asha Safayi. The committee considered nine agenda items, including resolutions, ordinances, and contract amendments, and forwarded most to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Key discussions centered on safe consumption site funding, a property assessment system contract, a shelter services agreement, and an infrastructure financing district. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Safe Consumption Sites): Ally Anakin, policy associate for Clyde and member of the Safe Friendside and Treatment on Demand coalitions, expressed full support for the resolution, citing the overdose crisis and the need for supervised consumption sites to save lives, particularly among Black, Indigenous, and people of color. - Item 5 (Power Station EIFD): Multiple union representatives (John Corso, UA Local 38; Ruby Gonzalez, Building Trades; Dan Torres, Sprinkler Fitters; Eddie Reyes, Iron Workers) and Gene Deckenbach (Friends of Jackson Park) spoke in support, emphasizing job creation, community benefits, and the project's labor agreement. They noted 300 unemployed workers in Local 38 alone. - Item 6 (Embarcadero Safe Navigation Center): Alice Rogers, chair of the site's advisory group, expressed personal support, citing Five Keys' consistent success in meeting benchmarks. A later speaker criticized the cost and lack of health department reports. Megan Fallon, co-director of housing services at Five Keys, provided public comment and later answered supervisor questions, detailing intake processes, community partnerships, and the bed supply chain delay. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Safe Consumption Sites - Behested Payment Waiver): Tom Paulino (Mayor's Office) presented the resolution, which would allow the Mayor's Office and Department of Public Health to solicit donations from city contractors for safe consumption sites. Vice Chair Mandelman noted it was a second such waiver, following a unanimous January approval for the Civic Bridge program. The committee forwarded the item with a positive recommendation (2-0, Supervisor Safai absent). - Item 2 (TNC/Taxi Business Registration Fee Suspension): Board President Aaron Peskin sponsored the ordinance to extend the suspension of business registration fees for transportation network company drivers and taxi drivers through FY2027-2028, citing a state law that eliminated local requirements for TNCs. The committee forwarded it (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 3 (Sapient Corporation Contract Amendment): Assessor-Recorder Joaquin Torres presented the amendment to increase the contract for property assessment system replacement from $21.4 million to $27.2 million, with a reduced term of nine years. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) reported that the city is paying more for less due to delays, and recommended a six-month progress report. The committee approved the item with a condition that the Assessor return in September 2023 for an update (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 4 (California Appropriations Limit): Michael Mitten (Controller’s Office) presented the resolution establishing the FY2022-2023 appropriations limit at $10.6 billion, based on population decline (-0.7% for the Bay Area) and cost-of-living increases (7.55% or 10.65%). The BLA recommended approval. The committee forwarded it (3-0). - Item 5 (Power Station Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District): Lee Lutenski (OEWD) and Anna Vandegna (Controller’s Office) presented the resolution to establish an EIFD for the 29-acre Potrero Power Station site, which would use incremental property tax revenue to fund public improvements. The project includes 30% affordable housing and labor harmony. The committee forwarded it (3-0). - Item 6 (Five Keys Schools Grant Amendment): Dylan Schneider (HSH) presented the second amendment to extend the Embarcadero Safe Navigation Center contract through December 2027, increasing the total not-to-exceed amount to $36.6 million. The site currently serves 120 guests, with plans to expand to 200 beds. Questions focused on bed supply chain delays, data collection, and exit outcomes. The committee forwarded it (3-0). - Item 7 (James Irvine Foundation Grant): Orion Willis (OEWD) presented the retroactive acceptance of a $900,000 grant to support the Northern California Apprentice Network, focusing on tech and tech-adjacent apprenticeships for underrepresented populations. The committee forwarded it (3-0). - Item 8 (Hunters Point Shipyard Block 56 Revenue Note): Jasmine Quo (OCI) presented the resolution for a $36.3 million multifamily housing revenue note to finance construction of 73 affordable units (72 for households at 50% AMI or less). Construction is expected to begin in April 2023. The committee forwarded it (3-0). - Item 9 (706 Mission Street Fund Appropriation): President Peskin presented the ordinance to transfer $1.7 million from Rec and Park and GSA to MOHCD. An amendment was introduced to split the funds equally between two subfunds, clarifying inconsistencies. The committee voted to amend and continue the item to the March 22, 2023, meeting (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 2: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 3: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation, with a requirement for the Assessor to return in six months (September 2023) for a progress update (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 4: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 7: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 8: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 9: Amended to split the $1.7 million between two subfunds and continued to the March 22, 2023, Budget and Finance Committee meeting (3-0).