Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1051–1060 ENTRIES
1051
MAR 15, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - March 15, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on March 15, 2023, to consider a hearing on funding the Climate Action Plan, supplemental appropriations for the Police Department ($27.6 million) and Public Works ($25 million), and amendments to ambassador program contracts. The meeting included extensive public comment and discussion on public safety, staffing, and resource allocation. Public Comments & Testimony - Climate Action Hearing: Multiple speakers expressed urgency for climate funding. Alex Lanceburg (electrical construction industry) emphasized labor equity and program design. Dave Fahy (UA Local 38) supported a skilled workforce. Antonio Diaz (PODER) urged centering community voices. Yolanda Catzalco called for taxing corporations. Eric Brooks (Californians for Energy Choice) supported bonds and revenue bonds. Joni Eisen (District 10 resident) urged adding climate bonds to the capital plan. Elena Engel stressed the emergency nature of climate action. Susan Green highlighted the high cost of electrification for homeowners. Paul Wermer raised concerns about outreach and grid impacts. - Police Supplemental and Public Works: Public comment was deeply divided. Supporters (e.g., Olga Miranda, local 87 janitors; Bill Barnacle, Sunset merchants; Karina Velasquez, Stop Crime SF) argued that overtime funding is essential for public safety, protecting workers, and downtown recovery. Opponents (e.g., Jennifer Friedenbach, Coalition on Homelessness; Ruby Pacheco, district 7 resident; Isabella Hutchison, district 4) criticized police mismanagement, racial disparities, and the opportunity cost of diverting funds from housing, food, and social services. Several speakers noted that the overtime does not add new officers. Some janitors and workers testified about feeling unsafe and needing police presence. Discussion Items - Climate Action Funding (Item 1): The committee heard presentations from the Department of Environment, CLE (UC Berkeley), and the Office of Resilience and Capital Planning. The CLE report estimated CAP implementation costs between $2.3 billion and $22 billion. Recommendations included general obligation bonds for building decarbonization, transportation, and affordable housing; a gross receipts tax increase; a parcel tax; congestion pricing; and a commercial building carbon fee. Discussion focused on bond capacity, voter approval thresholds, and the need for equitable implementation. Supervisor Mandelman filed the report. - Police Overtime Supplemental (Item 2): Chief Scott and Assistant Chief Lazar presented staffing shortages (1,514 full-duty officers vs. 2,182 needed per 2021 study). Overtime is used for backfill, safe shopper, tourism, and violence reduction. Response times have increased (A priority: 8.8 minutes). The budget request was for $27.6 million from general reserve. The BLA report noted that overtime is driven by new programs and recommended an analysis. Supervisors expressed frustration over resource allocation, particularly the concentration of overtime in Central Station (Union Square) versus neighborhoods like the Mission. Supervisor Ronan highlighted the need for foot patrols on Mission Street and BART stations. Supervisor Walton opposed the supplemental, citing no new officers and deficits. The committee explored civilianization and recruitment strategies. - Public Works Supplement (Items 3-4): Director Short proposed $25 million for 42 additional laborers, steam cleaners, packer trucks, graffiti inspectors, and 20 illegal dumping cameras. The BLA recommended time-limiting positions (3 years). The committee broadly supported the investment. - Ambassador Contracts (Items 5-6): The committee amended the contracts to end October 15, 2023, rather than December 31, to align with budget negotiations. The mayor's office committed to coordinating ambassador programs. Key Outcomes - Climate Action Hearing: Filed (5-0 vote). - Police Supplemental (Item 2): Amended to reduce the general reserve draw from $27.6 million to $25,371,063 by reappropriating $2.27 million from within the police department (equipment, body camera savings, etc.). Also amended to require bi-weekly reporting to the Board on staffing levels and overtime use by neighborhood. The amendment passed 4-1 (Supervisor Walton dissenting). The item was then forwarded to the full board without recommendation (5-0). - Public Works Supplement (Items 3-4): Forwarded to full board without recommendation after noting the BLA recommendation to limit positions to three years. - Ambassador Contracts (Items 5-6): Amended to change end date to October 15, 2023, and forwarded to full board without recommendation (5-0). - Overall: All items (2-6) were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for the March 21, 2023 agenda without recommendation from the committee.

PUBLIC SAFETY 30% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 24% · CLIMATE ADAPTATION 9% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
1052
MAR 14, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - March 14, 2023

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on March 14, 2023, at 9:45 AM. The meeting included updates on water supply conditions, audited financial statements, capital improvement programs, and approval of a distributed antenna system (DAS) master license. Commissioners voted unanimously on routine consent items and discussed risk management, contractor accountability, and drought declarations. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the February 28, 2023 meeting. - Approved five consent items: Job Order Contract No. JOC-92 with Sierra Mountain Construction; cost and duration contingency increases for Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant repairs and Southeast Plant upgrades; and two eight-year communications site leases with New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC. All passed 5-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Nicole Sandkulla (CEO, BAWSCA): Expressed appreciation for the water supply report and urged continued coordination with the state regarding drought conditions. - Peter Drekmeier (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust): Questioned the design drought risk and recommended shortening the drought planning period to reduce expensive alternative water supply investments. He also advocated for continuing hybrid meetings. - Tim Franklin (Outside Plant Technician, CWA Local 9410): Highlighted the 2019 Geary Boulevard gas explosion caused by an unqualified subcontractor. Urged the commission to require license verification and contractor accountability for DAS installations. - Other callers: Raised concerns about the PUC's debt portfolio, contracting irregularities, and the Sunset Reservoir seismic retrofit risk assessment. Discussion Items - Water Supply Update (Item 4A): Steve Ritchie reported that precipitation is at 50% above normal, with the Tuolumne watershed tracking 1983 (the wettest year on record). Staff will recommend rescinding the local water shortage emergency and the 5% drought surcharge at the April 11, 2023 meeting. Commissioners discussed groundwater recharge, risk tolerance, and the benefits of capturing floodwater. - Audited Financial Statements (Item 4B): CFO Nancy Hom and KPMG's Lisa Avis presented a clean (unmodified) opinion for FY2021-22. No material misstatements or internal control deficiencies were noted. Commissioners asked about key risk areas (e.g., debt covenants) and best management practices. - Water Enterprise CIP Quarterly Report (Item 4C): Katie Miller reported that the $3.3 billion program has 36 projects, with $1 billion expended. Forecast cost increases of $125 million and schedule delays were attributed to scope changes, staffing constraints, and COVID. Commissioners discussed risk management, alternative delivery methods (CMGC, design-build), and the need for lifecycle cost analysis. - Water System Improvement Program Quarterly Report (Item 4D): The WSIP is 99% complete. Two projects remain: the Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery project and the Alameda Creek Recapture Project. The latter faces a $9.5 million cost variance due to erosion and corrosion issues; staff are evaluating long-term solutions. - Distributed Antenna System Master License (Item 6): Barbara Hale presented a 12-year master license for wireless facilities on SFPUC streetlight poles. Approved with amendments to correct a carrier name and clarify language. Commissioners emphasized contractor qualification, RF safety, and digital tracking of installations. The public commenter Tim Franklin urged stronger oversight. Staff directed to develop accountability mechanisms by late 2023. Key Outcomes - Approved the consent calendar (5 items) unanimously. - Approved the 2023 DAS master license agreement with amendments (5-0). - Commission directed staff to bring a resolution to rescind the local water shortage emergency and surcharge at the April 11, 2023 meeting. - Staff to report on Alameda Creek Recapture Project solutions and on asset management improvements for DAS contractor oversight. - Approved closed session settlement of litigation with M. Hernandez Construction for $137,000, subject to Board of Supervisors approval.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 17% · PENDING LITIGATION 13% · PUBLIC SAFETY 9%
1053
MAR 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting on Homelessness Oversight Commission Appointments - March 13, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey and joined by Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai, convened on Monday, March 13, 2023, at 10:15 AM to advance implementation of Proposition C, a charter amendment approved by over 67% of voters in November 2022. The measure established a Homelessness Oversight Commission to oversee the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH), which has grown from a $100 million to a nearly $700 million department. The committee considered an ordinance to extend health insurance eligibility to commission members, confirmed three mayoral appointees, and selected three board appointees from a large pool of candidates. Consent Calendar - No items were on the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel supported the health insurance ordinance for commission members but urged broader efforts to diversify board and commission membership through increased compensation and stipends. - Dale Seymour, chair of the Local Homeless Coordinating Board, emphasized the need for commissioners with deep street-level experience and warned against political appointments. - Me Alden (UCSF) supported the nomination of Dr. Jonathan Butler, highlighting his work at UCSF, the NAACP, and the African American Faith-Based Coalition. - Jordan (PSH tenant) passionately opposed the commission as a "majority mayor commission" but demanded that appointees prioritize accountability; she criticized faith-based organizations for alleged homophobia and transphobia and called for tenant voices. - Francisco De Costa criticized the city’s approach to homelessness and alleged corruption. - Francisco Herrera (Latino Task Force) sought to comment on board appointments but was redirected to the correct agenda item. - Multiple speakers during the board appointment hearing supported Tracy Mixon, Joaquin Guerrero, Jason Albertson, Kristen Evans, Bevan Dufty, and others. Speakers highlighted lived experience, advocacy, and the need for Black, trans, and community representation. - Jordan (again) opposed any appointee with ties to the Central City SRO Collaborative due to conflicts of interest. Discussion Items Item 1: Administrative Code Amendment – Health Service System Eligibility Supervisor Safai introduced an ordinance to make members of the Homelessness Oversight Commission and the Refuse Rate Board eligible for health insurance through the San Francisco Health Service System. President Peskin requested an amendment to remove the Refuse Rate Board from the ordinance, arguing that the ratepayer representative should not receive city health benefits. The committee unanimously approved the amendment and then voted to send the amended ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Items 2-4: Mayoral Appointments to the Homelessness Oversight Commission The committee heard from three mayoral nominees: - Sharky Laguana (seat for someone with lived homelessness experience): Shared his personal story of homelessness as a youth, his recovery from a terminal diagnosis, and his experience on the Small Business Commission. He emphasized data-driven decision-making, simplifying metrics, and incremental progress. - Dr. Jonathan Butler (seat for someone with advocacy/service experience): Executive Director of the San Francisco African American Faith Based Coalition, NAACP leader, and UCSF medical sociologist. He stressed the importance of faith-based organizations, qualitative data, and addressing the overrepresentation of African Americans (38-40% of homeless population, 6% of city population). - Katie Albright (seat for mental health expertise): Former CEO of Safe & Sound, former deputy city attorney, and former commissioner. She focused on mental health services, prevention, trauma-informed systems, and cross-departmental collaboration. All three answered questions about accountability and racial equity. Supervisor Walton asked each how the commission could hold HSH accountable for disparities, particularly in the Southeast sector. The committee voted unanimously to approve all three appointments. Item 6: Board Appointments to the Homelessness Oversight Commission (Seats 5, 6, 7) The committee heard from numerous applicants for three board-appointed seats: - Seat 5 (lived homelessness experience): Applicants included Joaquin Guerrero (trans leader, opened first trans navigation center), Robert Paul McCloskey, Annis Johnson (substance use counselor), Masood Samerier (merchant, Castro homelessness project), Tracy Mixon (formerly homeless mother, advocate), and Gregory Johnson (formerly homeless, community organizer). - Seat 6 (service/advocacy experience): Applicants included Andrea Salinas (clinical social worker, 25 years of service), Kristen Evans (small business owner, co-proponent of 2018 homelessness funding measure), Gay Grunfeld (lawyer, disability rights), Jason Albertson (34 years of homeless services, former HSH employee), Neil Sims (HomeRise board, LGBTQ senior housing), and Bevan Dufty (former BART director, former city homelessness director, started first navigation center). - Seat 7 (experience with homeless families/youth): Several applicants also applied for seat 6. Committee members asked each applicant about using data for accountability and addressing racial disproportionality. After public comment, Chair Dorsey expressed support for Joaquin Guerrero, Tracy Mixon, and Bevan Dufty. Supervisor Safai moved to recommend Joaquin Guerrero (seat 5), Kristen Evans (seat 6), and Bevan Dufty (seat 7). The motion passed 2-1, with Chair Dorsey dissenting. Item 5: Withdrawn Mayoral Nomination – Vikrum Aiyer Item 5 was a motion to confirm Vikrum Aiyer's appointment, but he had withdrawn his nomination. The committee voted unanimously to table the item. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Ordinance): Amended to remove the Refuse Rate Board; passed unanimously and sent to full board as a committee report. - Items 2-4 (Mayoral Appointments): Sharky Laguana, Dr. Jonathan Butler, and Katie Albright approved unanimously and forwarded to the full board. - Item 6 (Board Appointments): By a 2-1 vote, the committee recommended Joaquin Guerrero (seat 5), Kristen Evans (seat 6), and Bevan Dufty (seat 7) to the full board for confirmation. - Item 5 (Withdrawn Nomination): Tabled unanimously. - The committee emphasized that all applicants not selected are encouraged to continue serving on other oversight bodies, such as the Local Homeless Coordinating Board.

HOMELESSNESS 58% · PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · PUBLIC HEALTH 6% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 6%
1054
MAR 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - March 13, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 13, 2023, with Chair Supervisor Myrna Melgar, Vice Chair Dean Preston, and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee took public input on one accessory dwelling unit item, then continued the remaining agenda items without substantive discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 1, James Price of the Housing Action Coalition voiced support, saying ADUs are a valuable and essential tool to address the housing shortage and that the proposal brings San Francisco into compliance with successful state ADU law. - No public comment was offered on Items 2, 3, or 4; no remote callers were in the queue. Item 1: State-Mandated Accessory Dwelling Unit Controls - Planning Department staff presented an ordinance to bring local ADU rules into consistency with state law. The proposal covered two state-mandated ADU categories: state program ADUs and hybrid ADUs. State program ADUs can be approved with more flexibility, including detached units no greater than 16 feet tall with four-foot side and rear setbacks. Hybrid ADUs currently still must meet local planning code requirements except for density rules. - The ordinance would add a junior ADU option allowing conversion of up to 500 square feet within an existing or proposed single family home, with an efficiency kitchen, and requiring either the junior ADU or the primary unit to be owner-occupied. - Changes would also limit the 30-day tenant notice requirement to single-family homes where an actual tenant is present. Staff said impact fees would be waived for state-mandated ADUs smaller than 750 square feet and reduced for those 750 square feet or larger. - Staff explained that the amendment would allow one detached rear-yard ADU under the local program, matching state-law size and setback limits, so the City can still impose rent control on local program ADUs. - Planning Department staff Natalia Fossi reported that about 85% of ADUs built to date were approved through the local program and are subject to rent control and that the remainder used the state program. Supervisor Peskin also confirmed with Deputy City Attorney Peter Miljenich that rent control can be required through a local ADU program but not through the state-mandated program. - The committee adopted the amendments and voted unanimously to continue Item 1 to the March 20 hearing. Items 2 and 3: HOME-SF - Item 2 would allow projects under the Home-SF program to subject units to the local rent ordinance’s limits, and Item 3 would exclude Article 11 historic districts from the HOME-SF program. No substantive discussion occurred. The committee agreed they were not yet ready and should remain together with Item 4. Item 4: Neighborhood Commercial and Mixed Use Zoning Districts - This item would update and reorganize neighborhood commercial and mixed use zoning controls, including: permitting arts, job training, social service, and entertainment uses; allowing nighttime entertainment on certain properties; and requiring larger developments in South of Market mixed use districts, among other components. - The committee noted that Item 4 had earlier recirculated proceedings with Items 2 and 3 after state legislation further complicated the package. The chair continued all three items to the call of the chair pending further planning staff analysis. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion made in Committee to adopt the ADU amendments and continue the item to March 20; the motion passed 3–0. - Items 2, 3, and 4: Motion passed unanimously 3–0 to continue all three items to the call of the chair until pronto staff has prepared in a satisfactory manner.

ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS 56% · PROCEDURAL 37% · HOUSING 7%
1055
MAR 9, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - March 9, 2023

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stephanie, met on March 9, 2023, beginning at 6:15 PM. The meeting addressed five agenda items: two liquor license matters, a cannabis regulation ordinance, and two authorizations for parole entry agreements with the Department of Homeland Security. All votes were unanimous. Consent Calendar No items were designated as a consent calendar. All agenda items received individual consideration. Public Comments & Testimony No public comments were offered on any of the agenda items. The committee heard statements from applicant representatives and city staff only. Discussion Items Item 1: Liquor License Issuance - 1198 Pacific Avenue (Dapper) - The San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval of a Type 20 off-sale beer and wine license for Dapper Nob Hill LLC. The location is in a high-saturation census tract (108), but Central Station had no opposition. Applicant partner Sandra Folgo back spoke in support, noting the neighborhood is a food desert and the store will provide fresh groceries and coffee. President Peskin had no issues. The committee voted unanimously to prepare a resolution finding the license serves public convenience or necessity and to recommend it to the full Board on March 21. Item 2: Liquor License Transfer - 3801 3rd Street (Lucky Bayview) - SFPD recommended approval of a Type 21 off-sale general beer, wine, and distilled spirits license transfer to Save Mart Supermarkets LLC, doing business as Lucky Bayview. The location is in a low-crime area but a high-saturation census tract (612); Bayview Station had no opposition. Applicant representative Reggie Chand stated the store has been open five months and customers have requested liquor. Alcohol displays will occupy less than 2% of the store. Supervisor Walton was supportive. The committee voted unanimously to prepare a resolution and recommend approval to the full Board on March 21. Item 3: Police Code - Cannabis Regulation - This ordinance, sponsored by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, amends the Police Code to allow holders of temporary cannabis business permits to transfer an aggregate ownership interest of 50% or more after five years have passed since their permanent permit application was acknowledged, even if a permanent permit has not yet been issued. Legislative aide Jackie Thornhill and Office of Cannabis Director Nikesh Patel explained that approximately 55 temporary permit holders (supply-side businesses operating pre-legalization) are currently stuck in limbo due to a backlog in permanent permit processing. The ordinance also creates a six-month unwinding mechanism if ownership is transferred too soon. The committee voted unanimously to recommend adoption to the full Board. Item 4 & 5: Authorizing Parole Entry Agreements for Sex Offense and Murder Prosecution - These two ordinances authorize the District Attorney and Sheriff to enter agreements with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security to facilitate parole entry of two criminal defendants into the U.S. for prosecution—one for multiple sex offenses, one for murder. The agreements require immediate notification to DHS if the defendant posts bail or is released. Chair Stephanie stated she had met with victims and community leaders and emphasized that the sanctuary city policy supports public safety while seeking justice. Vice Chair Engardio affirmed the sacredness of the sanctuary city policy. Supervisor Dorsey noted that in 2019 a similar request was made but no legislative change was needed. Public comment was not received. Chair Stephanie moved to table both items, and the committee voted unanimously to table them. Key Outcomes - Items 1, 2, 3: Approved with unanimous votes to recommend to the full Board of Supervisors for its March 21, 2023 meeting. - Items 4 and 5: Tabled (motion to table passed unanimously). No further action was taken.

LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 26% · PROCEDURAL 25% · PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · CANNABIS REGULATION 18%
1056
MAR 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – March 8, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, March 8, 2023, to discuss a range of public safety issues including crime trends, department discipline backlogs, and memoranda of understanding (MOUs) with the FBI and the District Attorney. Commissioners heard public comment, received reports from the Chief of Police and the DPA Acting Director, and engaged in detailed deliberation on two controversial MOUs. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Minutes (February 15, 2023, amended): Motion carried unanimously (7-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Gloria Brown (mother of homicide victim): Urged commission to act on unsolved homicides, describing the emotional toll of her son’s 2006 murder and the lack of progress despite a $250,000 reward. Brought photos and names of alleged perpetrators. - Chris Romero (Executive Director, Municipal Executives Association): Criticized Vice President Carter Oberstone’s 40-minute questioning of a senior SFPD employee at the February 15 meeting, calling it disrespectful and harmful to morale. He urged commissioners to treat city staff with respect to aid recruitment and retention. - Vice President Carter Oberstone responded: Defended the questioning as necessary oversight, characterizing the employee’s actions as willful disregard of obligations. He stated that effective government oversight sometimes requires hard questions and that the commission’s responsibility is to ensure compliance with policies. Chief’s Report (Discussion Item 3) - Chief William Scott reported: - Violent crime down 14%, property crime down 27%, overall crime down 26% year-to-date compared to last week’s report. - Homicides increased from 4 to 7 year-to-date (as of March 8, 2023); shootings decreased 10% (from 29 to 26). - Fentanyl seizures up 63% (over 50,000 grams vs. 20,000 grams last year). 26 arrests for narcotics sales in the Tenderloin in the past two weeks. - Significant arrest: Attempted kidnapping of a baby in Bayview; suspect apprehended. - Ongoing Tenderloin operation (permanent transfer of 20 officers); community feedback positive but challenges remain overnight. - Collaboration with Urban Alchemy ambassadors in Civic Center and Tenderloin viewed as effective. - Mission District: Cap Street prostitution operation addressed with traffic enforcement and community event; displacement to other areas (16th-18th St) noted. - Commissioner Yee noted overall crime reductions and attributed them to overtime and focused strategies. - Commissioner Byrne clarified that a fight at Reardon High School was initiated by an opposing team’s players, not Reardon’s; the school’s staff were commended for containing the incident. - Public comment on Chief’s report: Ms. Brown repeated her call for action on unsolved homicides, referencing a prior presentation that suggested measures but with no follow-up. Discussion of March 2022 MOU with FBI’s Violent Gang Safe Streets Task Force (Item 6) - Assistant Chief David Lazar presented the MOU (signed March 24, 2022), which allows up to 5 full-time and 2 part-time SFPD officers (all sergeants) on the task force, working out of SFPD facilities. Key provisions: - Officers must follow all SFPD policies; conflicts resolved by officers withdrawing from affected operations. - Body-worn cameras required; all plainclothes officers now wear BWCs. - All investigative records owned by the FBI; SFPD receives information only as needed for prosecutions. - Deputized as Special Deputy U.S. Marshals; subject to FBI rules but SFPD policies prevail in conflicts. - MOU has no expiration date; any party can withdraw. - Commissioner Elias raised concerns: - Disconnect between stated practice and MOU language on record ownership and access for discipline/DPA. - Potential impediment to investigating misconduct if FBI withholds records (paragraphs 25, 26, 62). - Acting DPA Director Diana Rosenstein revealed two prior cases where DPA could not obtain task force records due to the MOU, leading to insufficient evidence findings. She noted the MOU also restricts access to equipment from the Northern California Regional Intelligence Center. - Chief Scott stated he was unaware of those cases and promised follow-up. - Commissioner Benedicto probed conflicts between paragraphs 18 (SFPD policy override) and later provisions (47, 48, 53, 54). Chief and AC Lazar affirmed paragraph 18 supersedes all. Commissioner Benedicto encouraged renegotiating the MOU to make that explicit. - Vice President Carter Oberstone questioned whether the MOU could impede supervisory notification; Chief said no. - Commissioner Yanez asked about real-time conflict resolution—officers call their lieutenant or FBI supervisor. She expressed concern about community perception of SFPD involvement in federal operations. - Commissioner Walker thanked for explanation; noted task force is regional. - Commissioner Byrne asked about MOUs with ICE, CBP, ATF, DEA. Chief confirmed no MOU with ICE; joint work with HSI on child pornography; MOU with ATF for Crime Gun Intelligence Center; no current MOU with DEA. - No public comment on this item. - Outcome: Commission decided to agendize a follow-up in four months (early fall) to review updates, with Commissioner Benedicto as liaison. Discussion of Draft MOU between SFPD and SFDA Regarding Investigation of Serious Uses of Force (Item 7) - Chief Scott requested permission to post the revised MOU (nearly finalized, pending one paragraph) publicly so DPA and the commission could review it. He argued that DPA could not fully understand SFPD’s counter-proposals without seeing the final DA agreement. - Acting Director Rosenstein strongly opposed, stating DPA already had the November draft and that the new draft would not change core issues. She detailed three areas where DPA would lose access: 1. Scene access: Current practice allows DPA walk-throughs after scene secured; SFPD’s proposal would require DA consent. 2. Contemporaneous observation of witness interviews: Currently allowed; SFPD’s proposal gives DA ultimate authority. 3. Timely exchange of records: DPA’s request for formalized access was rejected. She argued the proposed MOU would violate DPA’s charter mandate (Sec. 4.136J) for prompt and full cooperation. - Chief Scott countered that independent investigations require the investigating agency (DA) to control information flow, and that DPA should wait until negotiations complete. He asked that the parties work it out without a commissioner referee. - President Elias proposed assigning Commissioner Benedicto as facilitator. Commissioner Byrne moved to give SFPD and DPA one month to negotiate before assigning a commissioner; the motion was ruled out of order because the item was not agendized for action. - Outcome: The MOU will be posted for public and DPA review; a formal vote on assigning a commissioner will occur at the next meeting (March 15, 2023). Commissioner Benedicto will continue informal facilitation. Closed Session (Items 8-10a, 11-12) - Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to hold item 10 in closed session, asserting attorney-client privilege. After closed session, voted unanimously (7-0) not to disclose any discussion. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar (minutes of Feb. 15, 2023) adopted 7-0. - Chief’s report received; no formal action. - FBI Task Force MOU: No vote taken; commission committed to revisit in 4 months; Commissioner Benedicto will monitor. - SFPD-SFDA MOU: To be posted publicly once finalized; DPA and SFPD urged to negotiate; formal vote on commissioner assignment deferred to next meeting. - Closed session disclosure declined.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 48% · PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9% · PUBLIC SAFETY 9%
1057
MAR 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting – March 8, 2023: Ambassador Program Grant Amendments

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on March 8, 2023, at approximately 9:45 AM to consider two resolutions amending grant agreements for city ambassador programs. The committee heard presentations from the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD), Urban Alchemy, the San Francisco Tourism Improvement District, and the Department of Emergency Management. The meeting included extensive discussion about program coordination, future funding, and the process for extending contracts into the next fiscal year. Public comment was largely in favor of the programs, with a few critical voices. The committee voted to approve amendments that expanded contract authority to December 31, 2023, and continued the items to March 15, 2023, for further deliberation. Public Comments & Testimony - Support: Multiple speakers expressed strong support for both programs. Amy Hull (Trinity Housing) said Urban Alchemy made her employees and residents feel safer, especially after the pandemic. David Nail (Turk Street resident) said the program transformed his block from a “dystopian nightmare.” Jose Peche (SF Filipino American Chamber of Commerce) called the Welcome Ambassador program “working like gangbusters.” Robert Diaz and Chris Hoffman (Welcome Ambassadors) personally endorsed the program. Amy Cleary (Golden Gate Restaurant Association) emphasized the economic benefit for restaurants. Marla Sandler (Civic Center Community Benefit District) highlighted Urban Alchemy’s role in protecting UN Plaza’s farmers market and dog park. Del Seymour (Tenderloin Walking Tours) said his groups feel safer and welcomed. Ken Rich (Union Square Alliance) noted positive impact in Hallidie Plaza. - Criticism: A few speakers raised concerns. One speaker stated, “We need a commander to do a needs assessment” and accused Urban Alchemy of lacking proper paperwork and hiring from outside San Francisco. Another speaker, Leah McGeever, complained about lack of name tags, harassment of women, “camouflage uniforms that look like a militia,” and a difficult complaint process. She alleged ambassadors instigate confrontations and call homeless people “dirty and smelly.” - Nonprofit perspective: Debbie Lerman (Human Services Network) thanked supervisors for acknowledging the challenges nonprofits face with annual contract expirations and delayed payments. Discussion Items - Item 230041 – Mid-Market Foundation (Mid-Market/Tenderloin Community-Based Safety Program): OEWD requested a $3.1 million increase (from $20.49M to $23.59M) for the current fiscal year (through June 30, 2023) and a future amendment of $10 million to extend through December 31, 2023. The funding sources: $2.6 million from OEWD budget savings (small business, civic center activations) and $500,000 from a Department of Public Health work order. Urban Alchemy provides 225 community ambassadors covering 80 block faces, 7 days a week, 12 hours a day. An additional 20 ambassadors were temporarily added at UN Plaza (January–March 2023) to transition services after the Tenderloin Center closure. Layoff risk: 87 jobs if not approved. - Item 230043 – SF Tourism Improvement District (Downtown Welcome Ambassador Program): OEWD requested a $3.3 million increase (from $9.927M to $13.227M) for current year (April–June 2023) and a future amendment of $3 million to extend through December 31, 2023. The program deploys 35–40 roving ambassadors, 7 days a week, 12 hours a day. Statistics: over 6,000 welfare checks, 222,000 referrals to businesses, 1,000 positive emails. Layoff risk: 100 jobs if not approved. Budget Legislative Analyst noted restrictive RFP requirements and high administrative costs ($1.4M, 10.7% of grant). - Future Coordination: OEWD, DEM, and DPH are tasked with evaluating citywide ambassador needs for FY 23-24. Sam Dodge (DEM) said a comprehensive analysis would take about six months but could be accelerated. - Concerns about Process: Multiple supervisors criticized the piecemeal, reactive approach to contracting. Supervisor Safai called it “one of the most convoluted proposals” and noted the contract has been amended several times in short periods. Supervisor Ronen questioned the timing of these requests given an anticipated large budget deficit. Supervisor Walton stressed the need for multi-year contracts. Key Outcomes - Motion to Amend (by Vice Chair Mandelman, seconded by Supervisor Ronen): To increase Item 230041 by $10 million (from $3.1M to $13.1M) and extend the grant period to December 31, 2023; and to increase Item 230043 by $3 million (from $3.3M to $6.3M) and extend the grant period to December 31, 2023, and correct the contract start date to July 1, 2021. Passed unanimously (5-0). - Motion to Continue (by Chair Chan, seconded by Supervisor Safai): To continue both items as amended to the March 15, 2023 meeting. Passed unanimously (5-0). - Recommendation from BLA: The board request that OEWD, DEM, and DPH report on how future ambassador needs and deployment will be determined during the FY 23-24 budget process.

PUBLIC SAFETY 42% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 34% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 7%
1058
MAR 6, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - March 6, 2023: Code Enforcement Penalties and ADU Controls

Introductory paragraph: The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 6, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered two items: increasing penalties for planning and building code violations and clarifying ministerial approval for state-mandated accessory dwelling units (ADUs). Both items were recommended to the full board after amendments and procedural adjustments. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 1 (code enforcement penalties): George Sudish expressed support for increasing penalties, which were last set in 2008, and urged the committee to inquire why the Planning Commission has not used its authority to adjust demolition thresholds under Section 317 to preserve existing housing. - On Item 2 (ADU controls): Jake Grace on behalf of the Housing Coalition expressed support for the legislation. Discussion Items - Item 1 (File 220878): Planning, Building Codes - Penalties for Code Enforcement Anna Herrera from Supervisor Ronen's office presented legislation to address egregious violations, citing the 2861 San Bruno Avenue case where a developer built 20 additional units beyond the permitted 10 without adequate fire escapes. Current law caps daily fines at $250 per project. The legislation would: (1) raise the maximum daily administrative fine from $250 to $1,000; (2) impose a one-time $250,000 fee for each dwelling unit demolished or added beyond three units; (3) impose a $500,000 fee for historic building demolition or damage; and (4) treat each unit as a separate violation. Planning department staff Audrey Merlone recommended an amendment to require recording of notices of violation (NOVs) on property titles to inform future owners of outstanding penalties. The committee adopted that amendment. After an initial motion to continue was rescinded, the committee voted 3-0 to recommend the ordinance as amended to the full board. - Item 2 (File 210585): Planning Code - State-Mandated Accessory Dwelling Unit Controls The mayor's office requested a continuance to March 13, but after planning staff clarified the amendment was non-substantive, the sponsor chose to proceed. The committee voted 3-0 to recommend the ordinance as amended to the full board. Key Outcomes - Adopted amendment for Item 1 to require recording of violation notices on property titles. - Item 1 recommended to the full board with a 3-0 vote (supervisors Melgar, Preston, Peskin). - Item 2 recommended to the full board with a 3-0 vote. - Items are expected to appear on the March 14, 2023 Board of Supervisors agenda.

PROCEDURAL 55% · PLANNING COMMISSION 31% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14%
1059
MAR 2, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Considered CBD Annual Reports on March 2, 2023

On March 2, 2023, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Government Audit and Oversight Committee met in hybrid format, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston and including Vice Chair Supervisor Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan, to receive and approve annual reports for the Central Market (Mid-Market) and Civic Center Community Benefit Districts (CBDs) for Calendar Year 2021. The committee heard presentations from the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) and CBD leadership, questioned district performance and governance, heard one public comment, and unanimously forwarded both resolutions to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - One remote caller expressed frustration with the condition of United Nations Plaza and the area around City Hall, describing it as filthy and criticizing the Tenderloin Center and city management. The speaker said "the time has come to get a grip on how y'all are managing our city," noted police understaffing (strength around 2,000 with about 900 actually available), unfilled DPW positions (25% of FTE), and the proposed $27 million in overtime for police, and called for direct action to clean the plaza rather than "commentary" from supervisors. Discussion Items - OEWD presentation (Chris Corgus): OEWD reviews CBDs against four benchmarks. The Central Market CBD has a management plan assessment budget of approximately $1.2 million and a FY2021 assessment roll of about $1.7 million; it missed benchmark one by 0.13% over the allowable 10 percentage points for the management and economic development service category, and met the other three. The Civic Center CBD has a management plan assessment budget of approximately $3.1 million and a FY2021 assessment roll of approximately $3.1 million, and met all four benchmarks. Both districts' annual reports were submitted late because their management team was part of the Department of Emergency Management's joint field operations team during the Tenderloin state of emergency in December 2021. Mid-Market CBD expires in 2028; Civic Center CBD expires in 2034. - CBD executive director presentation (Tracy Everwine): Everwine described ongoing challenges in both districts, including post-pandemic drug dealing, open-air drug use, sidewalk encampments, and illegal vending. Mid-Market's solar trash can program will be disbanded in May 2023 due to repeated vandalism, theft, arson, and drug storage; replacement cans cost $6,000 each. Civic Center CBD removed over 30,000 needles in 2021, and saw increased retail theft and challenges around UN Plaza, including unpermitted vendors selling alcohol. The dog park at UN Plaza now has over 2,000 users per month but costs $200,000 per year for overnight security, raising sustainability concerns. Tables and chairs placed for farmer's market patrons were removed at the end of January 2023 because illegal vendors took them over. Everwine also reported that the co-responder safety teams (ambassador paired with a 10B officer) are effective but constrained by officer shortages, and that public safety cameras are underutilized by law enforcement. - Committee questions and concerns: Supervisor Chan asked about how the CBDs track interactions; Everwine said they use an app called GIA to log wellness checks, emergency service calls, and merchant interactions per instance, and Chan requested those statistics for both districts. Chair Preston raised governance questions about city appointees on the Civic Center CBD board, noting that the city pays about 30% of that district's revenues and holds several seats, and expressed concern that the CBD's advocacy on the Tenderloin Center closure and increased police funding appeared to mirror administration positions while lacking letters on shelter expansion. Everwine said board members have a fiduciary duty to the organization and may vote if they can be impartial, and that the board structure predates her tenure. OEWD's Corgus explained that Article 15 of the Business and Tax Regulations Code requires 20% of CBD board seats to be non-property-owning merchants, and that overall board composition is set by each district's bylaws, with best practice being at least 50% property owners. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (Supervisors Preston, Stefani, and Chan all voting aye) to send both resolutions — Item 1 (Central Market CBD, File 230072) and Item 2 (Civic Center CBD, File 230071) — to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. No further business was conducted, and the meeting adjourned.

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 32% · PUBLIC SAFETY 27% · COMMUNITY BENEFIT DISTRICTS 17% · PUBLIC WORKS 7%
1060
MAR 1, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – March 1, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on March 1, 2023, at 1:45 PM UTC. The meeting covered routine consent items, reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), commissioner updates, a demonstration of a new public comment portal for department general orders, and closed session litigation matters. Public comment included a heartfelt plea regarding unsolved homicides. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously received and filed the SFPD Firearm Discharge Review Board and In-Custody Death Report for the fourth quarter of 2022 (motion by Commissioner Walker, seconded, passed 5-0). - The minutes of February 1, 8, and 15, 2023, were initially adopted unanimously (5-0). Later, Vice President Carter Oberstone moved to rescind approval of the February 15 minutes to add omitted factual details (date of upcoming negotiations with affected bargaining units), keeping February 1 and 8 minutes approved. The motion passed 6-0. Public Comments & Testimony - A parent of a murder victim (Aubrey Apercassa, killed August 14, 2006) spoke passionately about the unsolved case, naming alleged perpetrators. She requested more resources for unsolved homicides and asked for a reward program similar to the Special Olympics fundraiser. Commissioner Yanez responded, noting the commission had agendized the issue and planned to task a policy staffer to research best practices for rewards. - No other public comments were made on agenda items. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report (Assistant Chief David Lazar): - Year-to-date homicide clearance rate is 100%; no homicides in the past week. Sexual assaults down 43% (46 to 26), aggravated assaults stable, gun violence down 4%. Two recent shootings (McLaren Park and Ferry Building) resulted in one arrest; a hate crime near headquarters and a fentanyl seller arrest in the Tenderloin were highlighted. A cannabis dispensary kidnapping/robbery in the Bayview was reported. Burglaries down 8%, auto thefts up 19%, overall theft down 16%. Stunt driving incidents were dispersed with CHP assistance. Community engagement included a Coffee with a Cop event on Capp Street and the upcoming Polar Plunge fundraiser for Special Olympics. Assistant Chief Lazar commendation for officers who de-escalated an armed suspect using time-and-distance tactics, avoiding an officer-involved shooting. - DPA Director’s Report (Paul Henderson): - 265 pending cases; 26 investigations beyond 9 months; 88 cases awaiting chief’s hearing (28 more than two years old). Top allegations this week: failure to take required action (17% of allegations). Tenderloin and Mission districts had the most allegations. DPA hosted the California Coalition of Oversight Agencies (CCOA) state conference, featuring a CMCR training collaboration with SFPD. Upcoming outreach: Hayes Valley Neighborhood Association presentation (March 6). Audit on electronic monitoring of communications draft nearing release. Henderson expressed concern about a “disturbing uptick” in SFPD’s denial of DPA requests for information in officer-involved shooting and serious cases, despite ongoing conversations with the chief. Commissioner Benedicto requested updates if not resolved. - Commission Reports: - Commissioner Benedicto: Attended Black History Month brunch with SFPD and SF Safe; joined Commissioner Walker at an IA/DPA training for night shift officers; progress on DGO 7.01 (juveniles) and DGO 10.11 (body cameras) working groups. - Commissioner Yanez: Updates on juvenile diversion efforts, including conversations with ARC and Sentinella (LA pre-booking program); joint commission meeting with probation on April 12; requested agendizing discussion on city settlements related to use of force. - Commissioner Yi: Praised the Black History Month brunch as a community-building event. - Commissioner Walker: DGO 6.1 (missing persons) update underway; met with technology staff on automating body camera data management; engaged with community on mental health response; continuing assessment of patrol specials with city attorney involvement. - SFPD Demonstration of 30-Day Public Comment Portal: - Andrew Bly (civilian, Technology Division) demonstrated a new system for collecting and responding to public comments on draft Department General Orders (DGOs). The system includes a public-facing webpage for submitting comments, an internal process for SFPD and DPA to jointly respond, and public release of comments and responses after 30 days. Commissioner Benedicto asked whether commissioners would have access to comments during the comment period; Captain Toomer confirmed access is only after the 30-day period ends, as per DGO 3.01. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved as described. - Minutes: February 1 and 8 minutes retained; February 15 minutes rescinded for revision (6-0). - Closed Session: The commission voted 6-0 to hold Item 10 in closed session (existing litigation and personnel matters) and to assert attorney-client privilege for Items 10a and 10b. After closed session, the commission voted 6-0 not to disclose any discussion and to maintain attorney-client privilege. - Next Steps: Commissioners will continue monitoring DPA request denials; policy staffer to research unsolved homicide rewards; DGO updates (juveniles, body cameras, missing persons) to continue in working groups; joint meeting with probation on juvenile diversion scheduled for April 12.

PROCEDURAL 44% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 21% · PUBLIC SAFETY 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com