The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a regular meeting on March 1, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with members Supervisors Hillary Ronen, Shamann Walton, and Asha Safai. The committee heard two major items: a six-month budget status report for fiscal year 2022-2023 and the Controller's Annual Performance Report, with a focus on emergency response times and street cleaning. The committee voted to file the first hearing and continued the second to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel (on item 1) thanked the Controller's Office for the comprehensive report, noting the tough budget year and urging focus on needed programs and cost-effective services. - A brief, unattended caller appeared on item 2 but did not speak. Discussion Items - Item 1: Hearing on Six-Month Budget Status Report (FY 2022-2023) - Michelle Ellersma (Controller's Office) presented the report, projecting a $77 million increase in fund balance compared to the prior projection, reducing the two-year budget shortfall from $728 million to $652 million. Revenue is $30 million above budget, driven by stronger hotel tax, sales tax, property tax, and interest income, offset by weakness in business tax and a $156.7 million shortfall in property transfer tax. Departmental spending is largely at budget, but the Police Department is projected to overspend overtime by $28 million, prompting a proposed supplemental from the general reserve. Other shortfalls include Laguna Honda Hospital revenue at DPH and city planning permitting revenue. The general reserve balance is projected at $100.8 million, and any supplemental would need to be repaid in the next fiscal year. - Supervisor Walton questioned the use of ending fund balance versus reserves for the police supplemental. Budget Director Anna Dennon explained that using the general reserve is more responsible due to uncertainty in projections, though it adds to the next year's deficit. Supervisor Safai noted that using ending balance would not require repayment, potentially reducing the deficit impact. Supervisor Walton expressed concern that the supplemental would increase the $728 million deficit. - Item 2: Hearing on Performance Measures – Controller’s Annual Performance Report - Controller's Office Overview (Natasha Mihal): Presented the FY 2021-22 annual performance report, highlighting 800+ measures. Key concerns: Vision Zero fatalities reached 37 in 2022 (highest since policy enactment), safety net program caseload changes, and 911 call response, ambulance response, and street cleaning response times all declined from FY21 to FY22. - Department of Emergency Management (DEM) (Robert Smutz): 911 call response time (95% within 15 seconds standard) dropped significantly. Staffing fell from 150 effective dispatchers to 122, due to a hiring freeze, nine losses from vaccine non-compliance, and slow hiring (only 17 of 36 funded positions filled this year). A dedicated recruiter hired in October 2022 boosted applications from 200 to 724 per two-month cycle. However, full staffing may not be reached until end of 2025, and service standard recovery is estimated for late 2024. Changes to drug use policy and typing requirements were made to widen the applicant pool. - San Francisco Fire Department (Deputy Chief Tom O'Connor, Chief Sandy Tong, Chief Neils Tanglerini): Ambulance response time (90% within 10 minutes) fell to 87-88% after October 2022. A supplemental of 60 FTEs increased daily ambulances by 6-9 and reduced phantom medic calls from 6% to 3% of calls. However, call volume rose 6-9% since 2021, including 16,736 calls shifted from police to community paramedicine, and overdose calls up 25%, behavioral health up 38%, unknown medical up 56%. Ambulance patient offload time (APOT) increased by 19 minutes since 2019, averaging 51 minutes at the 90th percentile, driven by hospital staffing shortages. CPMC Van Ness had the longest APOT (52 minutes). SF General’s diversion rate fell to 45% in February 2023, but remains above the 30% target. Traffic congestion also slowed response times by 80-90 seconds over four years. Deputy Chief O'Connor noted the department needs additional firefighters, EMTs, and paramedics. - Public Works - Bureau of Street and Environmental Services (BSES) (Superintendent Chris McDaniels): Street cleaning request response time (95% within 48 hours) fell to about 82% in 2023 due to a 25% vacancy rate (100 of 400 budgeted FTEs unfilled). Service requests increased from 147,000 in 2021 to a projected 161,000 in 2023. Proactive night cleaning on Mission Street, Civic Center, and Tenderloin is underway. Illegal dumping is a major issue, particularly in the Bayview, with construction debris from the South Bay. A new HR director is implementing aggressive hiring. The department is also pulled for special events, rain response (catch basins, sandbags), and the Tenderloin emergency declaration. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to file the hearing passed unanimously (5-0). - Item 2: Motion to continue the hearing to the call of the chair passed unanimously (5-0), allowing future hearings on additional departments. - Next Steps: The committee will consider police and street cleaning budget supplementals in upcoming meetings. The Controller's Office will provide a five-year forecast update at the end of March and another quarterly update in May.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Port Commission convened on Tuesday, February 28, 2023, at 10:15 AM. The meeting included approval of minutes, an executive session, announcements, public comment, the Executive Director's report, consent calendar items, and informational presentations on lease amendments and a proposed development in Fisherman's Wharf. Commission President Kimberly Brandon presided; Vice President Willie Adams was absent. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the February 14, 2023 meeting unanimously. - Resolution 2309: Approved an operations agreement with APS West Coast Inc. to operate Benicia and Antioch locations as Foreign Trade Zone No. 3 subzone for five years with a four-year extension option. - Resolution 2310: Approved a Fiscal Year 2023-24 supplemental appropriation for Mission Bay Parks operations and Proposition J contracts for maintenance at Mission Rock and Pier 70. - Resolution 2311: Authorized a sole source grant of $100,000 to Foodwise (a port licensee) for quarterly activations of the Ferry Terminal Plaza in conjunction with the Saturday Farmers Market. Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Gregory, President of the African American Construction Collective, requested a larger parking/lease space at Pier 94/Backlands, citing stolen equipment and broken-down trucks. Executive Director Forbes agreed to work with him. - Andrea Akers, Operations Manager at Foodwise, described the success of quarterly pop-up events (beginning with Juneteenth 2021) that showcase Black-owned businesses, noting the events are free, family-friendly, and bring new visitors to the waterfront. She requested continued port support. - Devin Oakry, Operations Coordinator at Foodwise, explained the behind-the-scenes support provided to vendors (permits, site visits, logistics) to help them succeed. - Christine Farn, Executive Director of Foodwise, thanked the port for 30 years of partnership and emphasized the community connections and racial equity focus of the events. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Item 9A): Elaine Forbes reported on economic recovery, noting visitor numbers surpassing city predictions; cruise is having a banner year; restaurant sales at 66% of pre-pandemic levels; parking and excursions at 90%. She highlighted Mission Rock's 40% affordable housing (102 units marketing in March 2023, 199 total affordable in phase one) and resilience projects (Islais Creek planning, Amador Street reconstruction, Pier 70 cap removal, Crane Cove Park playgrounds, Heron's Head Park signage). Southern Waterfront receives the most grant funding. She recognized women commissioners and leaders for Women's History Month. - Commissioner Comments: Commissioner Stephen Lee supported recovery efforts, especially the Southern Waterfront. Commissioner Gail Gilman requested an informational hearing on Mission Rock's marketing plan due to the 140% AMI threshold and one-year lease-up deadline; also praised the Islais Creek project. President Brandon commended the port's role in economic recovery and secured grant prospects. - Item 11A – Environmental and Planning Services Contracts: Elizabeth Alexander Toot presented a request to award three as-needed contracts (up to $2.5M each, four-year term with one-year extension) to AEW Engineering, SCA Environmental, and CDIM Engineering, and create a pre-qualified pool. The procurement emphasized equity (implicit bias training, DEI scoring, LBE outreach). All three awardees are LBE primes. Previous LBE utilization: AEW 18.01%, CDIM 12.61%, SCA 42.86% (goal for new contracts: 15%). Commissioner Lee asked about scoring for on-time performance; staff noted ongoing City Attorney discussions. Commissioner Gilman asked about past LBE goal achievement and why many firms joined as subcontractors rather than primes. - Item 12A – Boudin's Chowder Hut Lease Amendment: Don Cavanaugh presented an amendment to extend the deadline for $900,000 in improvements (down from original $4.5M) to enclose three of eight patio sides with motorized louvers, preserving the tenant's five-year option. Tenant cited COVID and inflation. Commissioner Lee supported the revised cost and timeline. Commissioner Gilman encouraged better curb appeal and activation given nearby shuttered businesses. - Item 12B – Fisherman's Wharf Unsolicited Proposal: David Billprey presented the outreach process for a proposal from Fisherman's Wharf Revitalization LLC to develop Seawall Lot 300/301 and Pier 45 sheds A and C with an experiential museum, event center, hospitality, short-term vacation rentals, and resilience improvements. Two public meetings and a Northern Advisory Committee meeting are planned. Commissioner Gilman stressed broad outreach to residents, neighborhood associations, and fish processors. Commissioner Lee raised parking concerns; staff noted the proposal is early-stage and community input will shape it. President Brandon emphasized protecting fishery and maritime tenants. - New Business (Item 13): Commissioner Gilman recorded a request for an informational item on leasing up Mission Rock phase one affordable housing. Key Outcomes - Approved minutes of February 14, 2023. - Adopted Consent Calendar resolutions 2309, 2310, and 2311 (all unanimous). - Adopted Resolution 2312 (unanimous) authorizing three contracts for environmental and planning services and creating a pre-qualified pool. - Directed staff to conduct extensive outreach for the Fisherman's Wharf proposal, including evening and tenant-focused meetings, and to consider parking and community concerns. - Commissioner Gilman's request for a Mission Rock marketing update informational item was recorded. - Meeting adjourned at 4:16 PM. Executive Session - Commission went into closed session (one item) and reconvened in open session with no reportable action. Note: Meeting date is February 28, 2023, as stated in the agenda and transcript. No minutes were available for this meeting.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on February 28, 2023, starting at 9:45 AM (teleconference). The commission reviewed a drought update, quarterly audit and budget reports, a hiring process overview, a BAWSCA update, and approved modifications to the floodwater management grant program and a water transfer agreement between Mountain View and East Palo Alto. Public comment was heard on several items. The meeting also included a closed session for legal counsel. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of February 14, 2023 (unanimous). - Approved Modification No. 1 to Job Order Contract JOC-87 with Sinclair General Engineering Construction, Inc., increasing the contract amount from $5,000,000 to $7,500,000. - Awarded Job Order Contract No. JOC-91, General Engineering Construction, for a total not-to-exceed $5,000,000. - Approved an increase of $180,000 to contract cost contingency and 180 calendar days to contract duration contingency for Pipe and Plan (item 6c). - Approved an increase of 34 consecutive calendar days to contract duration contingency with J. Flores Construction Company, Inc. (item 6d). Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4a (Drought Update): Peter Drekmeier (Tuolumne River Trust) argued that the update should be renamed to "Water Supply Conditions Update" as reservoirs are filling, and criticized the lack of environmental focus on the Tuolumne River ecosystem, noting a very bad salmon season and potential commercial salmon season cancellation. - Item 4d (Hiring Process): Two callers commented. One questioned the lack of career opportunities for residents of pollution-burdened areas (Bayshore and others). The second caller (Peter Drekmeier) criticized the SFPUC for environmental failures, withholding public information, and not incorporating workshop findings into policy changes. - Item 5 (BAWSCA): Peter Drekmeier noted that a $13 million infiltration gallery project in the new voluntary agreement is already nearly complete, making it embarrassing to include; he urged early implementation of unimpaired flows. A second caller criticized BAWSCA for distributing water outside San Francisco while ignoring citizen concerns. - Item 8 (Water Transfer): Nicole Sandkulla (BAWSCA CEO) expressed strong support for the transfer, noting it took six years to negotiate. Peter Drekmeier supported the transfer but urged consideration of unintended consequences like job-housing balance and suggested allowing cities to give back take-or-pay water. - Item 10 (General Public Comment): Peter Drekmeier criticized moving general public comment to the end of the agenda, noting a drop from an average of 13 speakers to 2. A second caller accused the SFPUC of being the worst city department and suppressing public comment. Discussion Items - 4a. Drought Conditions Update: Assistant GM Steve Ritchie reported that as of February 21, 2023, storage was high and expected to fill. Snowpack was at 170% of the April 1 median. Deliveries were at 152 million gallons per day (MGD), well below previous drought years. The governor issued a new executive order on February 13 continuing the drought emergency; the state may relax outflow conditions, potentially affecting curtailments. Commissioners expressed satisfaction with precipitation. - 4b. Quarterly Audit and Performance Review: Audit Director Irella Blackwood reported that 7 of 29 planned audits (24%) were completed by Q2. The PG&E franchise fee audit for 2019-2020 found PG&E properly paid $15,585,120 in franchise fees on $1.7 billion gross receipts. Four audit recommendations were pending but resolved as of January. Commissioner Paulson requested that lessons learned be shared. - 4c. Quarterly Budget Status Report: CFO Nancy Hom projected positive operating results for all enterprises. Water: $161 million net operating result ($34.9 million positive variance). Wastewater: $121.2 million ($22.4 million positive). Power: $62.7 million ($39.9 million positive). CleanPowerSF: $11.8 million ($8.9 million positive). Higher power purchase costs were offset by reserve contributions. Commissioners questioned why CleanPowerSF's power purchase variance was only 13% despite spot market prices quadrupling; staff explained most power is locked in contracts. A request was made for staff to provide the ratio of long-term contracts to spot market purchases. - 4d. Hiring Process Overview: Chief People Officer Wendy Macy presented a detailed overview of vacancies (very high, with some enterprises over 25% vacancy rate). Since July 1, 2022, 191 new staff were hired, 190 moved internally, and 162 left. The pandemic period saw exits outpacing hires. Macy outlined a "North Star" goal to streamline hiring, improve candidate outreach, and use data dashboards. Commissioners asked about exit interviews, career stage attrition, candidate pools, and website accessibility. Commissioner Stacy noted the careers page is not user-friendly. The commission requested an update at the next quarterly meeting. - 5. Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Update: CEO Nicole Sandkulla reported that the Tuolumne River parties signed an MOU for a voluntary agreement for the Bay Delta Plan, including additional flows and $64 million in habitat improvements over 8 years. She urged early implementation. President Jami expressed commitment to leadership on environmental goals and agreed to continue discussions. - 7. Floodwater Management Grant Assistance Program Modifications: Sarah Minick proposed eliminating the 80-90% cost share requirement and making the grant cover 100% of eligible costs (up to $100,000 per property) to increase participation. Since January 1, 2023, 88 interest forms were received, a spike. The program had distributed only $59,000 per year historically. The commission unanimously approved the modifications. - 8. Minimum Water Purchase Transfer Agreement: Alison Castama presented a retroactive permanent transfer of up to 1.0 MGD of Mountain View's minimum annual purchase to East Palo Alto, following a 2017 ISG transfer. The agreement was approved by East Palo Alto and Mountain View councils and all wholesale customers. The commission unanimously approved, authorizing the GM to amend the water supply agreement. Commissioner Stacy endorsed the policy as it removes perverse incentives against conservation. - 11. Items Initiated by Commissioners: Commissioner Maxwell requested a "state of the environment" report focusing on the watersheds and ecosystem indicators. President Jami noted previous discussions on ecosystem indicators and agreed to a presentation. The commission directed staff to prepare such a report. Key Outcomes - Approved consent calendar items (6a-6d) unanimously (5-0). - Approved modifications to the Floodwater Management Grant Assistance Program to provide 100% cost share (5-0). - Approved the Minimum Water Purchase Transfer Agreement between Mountain View and East Palo Alto, retroactively, for up to 1.0 MGD (5-0). - Directed staff to prepare a state of the environment report on watersheds for a future meeting. - Directed staff to provide an update on the hiring process improvements, including website accessibility and recruiter onboarding, at the next quarterly meeting. - Moved to closed session to discuss two litigation items (Goldmark claim and another); voted not to disclose discussions. - Adjourned.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, February 27, 2023, at 10:15 AM. The committee considered four mayoral appointments and two legislative items. The meeting lasted several hours, with extensive public testimony on the proposal to discontinue remote public comment. Below is a summary of each agenda item and the committee's actions. Appointment to Assessment Appeals Board No. 1 (Item 1) - The committee unanimously recommended (3-0) the appointment of one member to Seat 6, term ending September 2, 2025, to the full Board with a positive recommendation. No public comment was received. Chair Dorsey noted that residency is not required due to state law. Mayoral Appointment to Commission on Community Investment and Infrastructure - Tamsen Drew (Item 3) - The committee heard from Tamsen Drew, a former senior project manager at the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure (OCII). She discussed her experience at Hunters Point Shipyard and Candlestick Point, including the Tetra Tech falsification scandal and the need for independent oversight of Navy cleanup. She also addressed the Certificate of Preference program. Supportive public comments were made by Andrew Robinson (East Cut CBD), Jermaine Jones, Tanika Moss (All Home), Essen Josephaba, Sujata Shrivasava (SPUR), and Deanna. Concern was raised by Francisco DeCosta and William Zieber about environmental cleanup and community trust. The committee voted unanimously to amend the motion to strike "reject" and send to the full board with a positive recommendation. Mayoral Appointment to Historic Preservation Commission - Victoria Gray (Item 2) - Victoria Gray, a native San Franciscan with a background in art history and auction work, appeared for the historian seat. She emphasized her expertise in historic interiors and objects. President Peskin questioned whether she met the Secretary of the Interior's professional qualifications for history. He argued that her experience at an auction house does not constitute a professional institution and that her scholarly contributions are insufficient. Supervisor Safai expressed conflict, noting the importance of collaboration with preservation community. The public, including Carolyn Monte (San Francisco Heritage), opposed the nomination, while Richard Johns (outgoing historian) and others supported. The committee voted 2-1 (Safai dissenting) to send the appointment to the full board with a positive recommendation. Motion to Discontinue Remote Participation and Remote Public Comment (Item 5) - This motion, sponsored by Supervisor Mandelman, would discontinue remote participation by supervisors and remote public comment except as required for disability accommodations. The committee heard 16 telephone callers and several in-person speakers, all in opposition to the motion. Speakers cited barriers for seniors, people with disabilities, working parents, immunocompromised individuals, and those far from City Hall. Many argued that requiring a 72-hour ADA accommodation request is burdensome and discriminatory. Deputy City Administrator Jennifer Johnston presented the Mayor's Office guidelines for city policy bodies, which allow time-limited remote comment for non-ADA reasons. Chair Dorsey proposed amendments to preserve the status quo but withdrew when it became clear they would not pass. The committee then voted unanimously (3-0) to send the motion to the full Board without recommendation. Ordinance Related to Homelessness Oversight Commission (Item 4) - Supervisor Safai presented amendments to the administrative code and business and tax regulations code, as required by Proposition C (November 2022 election). The amendments streamline oversight by moving the Shelter Monitoring Committee (SMC) staffing from the Department of Public Health (DPH) to the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH). Public commenters from the Coalition on Homelessness, SMC members, and advocates strongly opposed moving SMC under HSH, arguing it creates a conflict of interest. Supervisor Walton supported the move for nimbleness. After discussion, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unanimous positive recommendation to full Board. - Item 3: Unanimous positive recommendation to full Board (after amendment). - Item 2: Positive recommendation to full Board on a 2-1 vote (Safai dissenting). - Item 5: Sent to full Board without recommendation (unanimous). - Item 4: Unanimous positive recommendation to full Board as committee report.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, February 27, 2023, at 1:45 PM. Chair Mirna Melgar presided, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered four agenda items: amendments to the Planning Code for neighborhood commercial zones; amendments to the Administrative Code regarding tourist/transient use definitions and amortization; amendments to building code penalties (continued); and the creation of a new Special Use District (The Village) serving the Native American community. Item 1: Planning Code – Neighborhood Commercial and Mixed Use Zoning Districts Madison Tam, representing Supervisor Dorsey’s office, presented the 210-page ordinance. She noted that a prior administrative error had incorrectly stricken the 1,000-foot buffer for adult entertainment (Section 303); an amendment was circulated to restore it. President Peskin expressed concern about the error being hidden in a long document, but acknowledged it was inherited from previous supervisors. Public Testimony: Tom Radulovich, Executive Director of Livable City, spoke in support, emphasizing the legislation’s benefits for arts uses, cultural institutions, and community spaces in SOMA. No other public comments were received. Key Outcomes: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt the amendment to Section 303 and to continue the item as amended to the March 13, 2023 meeting. The continuance allows coordination with another pending piece of legislation. Item 2: Administrative Code – Definition of Tourist or Transient Use; Amortization Period President Peskin introduced a general findings amendment (read into the record) stating the ordinance is necessary to protect housing supply and minimize displacement, balancing hotel owners’ interests. Public Testimony: Linda Chapman (Knob Hill Neighbors) expressed concern about enforcement and the shift from a 30-day minimum to shorter terms; she noted that many registered residential units are unaccounted for. Ryan Patterson (counsel for Hotel des Arts) opposed the 30-day requirement, arguing it would make units unaffordable for low-income tenants and lead to vacancies and blight. He requested time to review the new findings. A remote caller supported the preservation of residential units over tourist use. Key Outcomes: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt the general findings amendment, then voted unanimously (3-0) to send the item as amended to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation for consideration on March 7, 2023. Item 3: Planning and Building Codes – Penalties for Code Enforcement Chair Melgar announced that Supervisor Ronen requested a continuance because amendments were not yet finalized. No public comments were offered on the continuance. Key Outcome: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the item to the next meeting (week of March 6, 2023). No substantive discussion occurred. Item 4: Planning Code, Zoning Map – The Village Special Use District (80 Julian Avenue) Alex West (Planning Department) presented the proposal to create a Special Use District at 80 Julian Avenue, allowing a six-story, 41,000-square-foot mixed-use facility for San Francisco’s Native American population. The project includes a youth recreation center, elder services, dental and medical clinics, 21 group housing rooms (including a floor for mothers with children), a roof garden, and administrative headquarters for the American Indian Cultural District. The Planning Commission recommended approval on January 26, 2023. Peter Bratt (Friendship House) and Dawila Harrison described the project as fulfilling the vision of Helen Waukazoo, the organization’s founder, to provide a one-stop healing and cultural center. Public Testimony: Over a dozen speakers (including family members, program participants, and community leaders) spoke overwhelmingly in support, citing the project’s role in healing, cultural preservation, and addressing substance abuse. No opposition was voiced. Speakers emphasized that the site is on stolen Ohlone land and called for deeper reconciliation beyond land acknowledgments. Key Outcomes: Supervisors Preston and Melgar requested to be added as co-sponsors. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend approval of the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on February 23, 2023, to consider one agenda item: a hearing on whether transferring a Type 48 on-sale general public premises liquor license to Francisco Javier Via Lobos for Las Margaritas at 3336 24th Street in District 9 would serve the public convenience or necessity. After hearing the police report and applicant testimony, the committee voted unanimously to prepare and forward a positive recommendation to the Board of Supervisors. Discussion Items - Liquor License Transfer – Las Margaritas (3336 24th Street): Officer Salmanson of the SFPD ABC Liaison Unit presented the Public Convenience or Necessity (PCN) report. The report noted zero letters of protest and zero letters of support. The officer said the location is considered a high-crime area and census tract 209 is a high-saturation area. Mission Station expressed no opposition. The ABC Liaison Unit recommended approval with conditions: the petitioner must actively monitor the area under their control to prevent loitering on adjacent property, and entertainment must not be audible at nearby residences or consideration points. - Francisco Javier Via Lobos, the applicant, described the business as a neighborhood place where local residents and tourists can socialize over drinks. He stated the bar would operate entirely indoors, have at most two or three televisions, a maximum capacity of 50 people, and flexible operating hours. (Note: The agenda lists the business name as Las Margaritas, while the transcript reads Los Margaritos.) Key Outcomes - The committee unanimously (3–0) directed the clerk to prepare a resolution finding that public convenience or necessity would be served by the license transfer. - The committee then unanimously (3–0) voted to send that resolution to the Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation from the Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee. The item was expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda of March 7, 2023.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a hearing on February 16, 2023, to discuss the August 2022 Citywide Nonprofit Performance Audit Report. The hearing examined the city's $1.4 billion annual contracting with nonprofit organizations, focusing on performance measurement, monitoring practices, and transparency. The committee also considered closed session items on litigation settlements. Public Comments & Testimony - Sherilyn Adams (Larkin Street Youth Services / HSN) emphasized the burden of inconsistent department requirements, noting her organization had 28 monitoring visits from various departments. She called for streamlined processes and adequate funding for compliance infrastructure. - Michael Blacker (Swords to Plowshares) highlighted the challenge of balancing paperwork with direct service delivery and urged support for frontline staff. - David Linnell (Meals on Wheels) noted that a recent budget increase covered only 8.5% of a 22% cost increase, forcing his organization to fundraise 56% of its budget. He warned that negative press about a few nonprofits can harm fundraising for all. - Beverly Upton (San Francisco Domestic Violence Consortium) reported that most member agencies were in compliance and that local nonprofits leverage city dollars four to one. She offered to collaborate on transparency efforts. - Debbie Lerman (Human Services Network) called for the city to support struggling nonprofits with resources and assistance rather than only criticism, emphasizing that services are vital to economic recovery. - Laura Lala Chavez (Lyric) echoed the burden of multiple department visits and supported improving the monitoring process. - West Saver (Glide) noted that noncompliance often stems from chronic underfunding, contract inconsistencies, and payment delays that can approach a year. He advocated for centralized reporting and using monitoring results for capacity building. - Doug Stiles (Huckleberry Youth Programs) cited late contract certifications causing cash flow problems of hundreds of thousands of dollars and supported multi-year contracts with escalators. - Jessica (District 4 Youth and Families Network) stressed that recent negative publicity is damaging and misleading, and urged focus on the impact of underfunded contracts and wages. - Alani (public caller) expressed frustration that many nonprofits are hard to reach or have limited hours, and that the public does not see enough change despite large funding amounts. - Mr. DeCosta (public caller) alleged corruption and lack of whistleblower incentives, claiming departments favor certain nonprofits. Discussion Items - Presentation by Controller's Office: Mark Delarosa (Director of Audits), Amanda Kelly, Wendy Lee, and Laura Marshall presented the audit findings and the citywide Nonprofit Monitoring and Capacity Building Program. The audit covered over 2,000 contracts totaling $1.6 billion in fiscal year 2017-18, with a sample of 30 contracts across 13 CBOs totaling $42.8 million. Key findings: performance measures lack consistency across departments; reporting and monitoring vary greatly; and there is limited data sharing. Three recommendations focused on standardizing performance measurement, strengthening monitoring collaboration, and creating a centralized data system. - Monitoring Program Details: The program monitors 192 contractors accounting for 85% of nonprofit spending. In fiscal year 2021-22, most contractors were in conformance; 15 had unresolved findings. Two organizations were placed on red flag status and two on elevated concern. Most common findings involved cost allocation procedures and board oversight. - Supervisor Questions: Supervisor Stephanie asked about Baker Places and how red flag status was communicated. Controller's office explained that departments are notified but defunding decisions rest with departments; they are exploring better board notification. Supervisor Chan asked about definitions of core vs. expanded monitoring, how findings are used in contracting decisions, and capacity building support. Controller's office clarified that risk assessment determines monitoring level, and capacity building is offered via consultants. Supervisor Preston raised concerns about connecting wage pressures to compliance issues and the need for baseline compliance checks (e.g., attorney general filings). - Discussion on Multi-Year Contracts: The controller's office is exploring allowing departments to include cost escalators in multi-year contracts, moving away from flat funding. The current budget process centralizes escalation decisions, which may not reflect true service costs. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to file the hearing, with plans for future legislation to improve transparency and oversight (motion by Vice Chair Stephanie, seconded by Supervisor Chan, all in favor). - In closed session, the committee recommended items 2–8 (litigation settlements) to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) not to disclose the closed session discussions.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, February 15, 2023, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included a certificate of appreciation presentation, public comment, consent calendar, reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), a disciplinary review board presentation, adoption of a new general order on behavioral health referrals, and a discussion on missed policy revision deadlines. The commission also held a closed session. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously (7-0) received and filed the following items: SFPD and DPA's 1421 and SB16 report, 2022 fourth quarter document protocol report, fourth quarter audit of electronic communication devices for bias, family code 6228 semi-annual report and resolution of the sexual assault evidence kit, and the annual report for DGO 11.02 secondary employment calendar year 2022. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Certificate of Appreciation): The sister of honoree Rome Jones thanked the commission for honoring him, highlighting his work as a change agent. Julie Tron, a working group participant, emphasized the need for systemic inclusion of community members in such groups, noting that outreach via CPABs is not happening sufficiently. - Item 2 (General Public Comment): Multiple speakers from the Central City SRO Collaborative’s safety committee reported noticeable improvements in the Tenderloin neighborhood over recent weeks, citing cleaner streets and reduced drug dealing. They requested sustainability of these efforts and asked for increased foot patrols. One caller urged the commission to conduct more accessible outreach to help the average person understand police data and policies. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Certificate of Appreciation: Chief William Scott presented certificates to Angela Jenkins and Rome Jones for their contributions to the bias working group, particularly their advocacy for including "bias by proxy" in DGO 5.17, which was later hailed as a model by California. Both honorees spoke about the difficulty of engaging with law enforcement and their commitment to improving policy. Commissioners praised their unique perspectives and sacrifice. - Item 4 – Chief’s Report: Chief Scott reported that year-to-date major crime is down, with property crime decreasing 21% and violent crime slightly down. He described targeted enforcement in the Tenderloin: 23 arrests in the prior six days, increased fentanyl seizures, and a strategy of “holding ground” after arrests to prevent dealer return. In the Mission District, new resources have been deployed to address prostitution on Capp Street, including motorcycle officers. Chief Scott confirmed SFPD adheres to the sanctuary city policy, distancing the department from recent media coverage about proposed carve-outs. He also noted a potential new drug, xylazine (“tranq”), which is resistant to Narcan. - Item 5 – DPA Director’s Report: Executive Director Paul Henderson reported 17 cases pending trial, 9 pending commission decision, and 88 pending chief’s decisions. The highest complaint precinct was Mission (5 complaints), followed by Northern (3). DPA is developing a new online complaint form for officers to streamline submissions. An audit on SFPD’s monitoring of department communications is in draft, expected to be sent to the department by end of February. - Item 7 – SFPD 2022 Third Quarter Disciplinary Review Board: Chief of Staff Sarah Hawkins presented results: aggregate trends included discourteous conduct, failure to write incident reports, failure to thoroughly investigate, and failure to title body-worn camera videos. DPA trends included failure to take required action and failure to activate BWC. Policy failures: supplemental incident report not properly assigned and need to ensure auto-population of incident titles. Recommendations: update Department Bulletin 11-273, improve IT system, and develop training on social media use. Vice President Carter Overstone praised a joint IA-DPA training for officers. - Item 8 – DGO 11.13 (Behavioral Science Unit Referrals): Deputy Chief Nicole Jones presented a new policy creating directed and recommended referrals to the Behavioral Science Unit for employee mental health and wellness. Directed referrals are mandatory; recommended are voluntary. Confidentiality is key, and no written records are kept for voluntary referrals. Commissioners supported the policy, recognizing officer stress. Vice President Carter Overstone asked about intersection with EIS; Deputy Chief Jones clarified the policy provides a mechanism for required meetings. The commission voted to adopt. - Item 9 – Discussion of Deadlines for DGO 8.10 Revision: Vice President Carter Overstone led a detailed inquiry into why the department missed a December 6, 2022 deadline to respond to DPA’s stage one recommendations on DGO 8.10 (First Amendment activity guidelines). Deputy Chief Raj Vaswani, the executive sponsor, cited the Pelosi investigation and staffing constraints. He acknowledged he did not seek an extension despite sending 189 tweets in the period. The Vice President expressed concern about the double standard this sets for officer discipline. Chief Scott asked that officers not be subjected to disciplinary inquiries in public; President Elias acknowledged the frustration but stressed accountability for overdue DGOs. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (Item 3): Approved unanimously (7-0). Items included SFPD and DPA’s 1421 and SB16 report, fourth quarter document protocol report, bias audit, sexual assault evidence kit report, and secondary employment annual report. - DGO 11.13 (Item 8): Adopted unanimously (7-0) with instructions to meet and confer with bargaining units only on mandatory subjects and to set clear boundaries to avoid unreasonable delays. - Closed Session (Items 10-13): The commission voted unanimously to hold closed session and later voted not to disclose any discussions, asserting attorney-client privilege. - Next Steps: The commission will continue to monitor DGO revision timelines. The chief’s office and DPA will work to reduce the backlog of 88 pending disciplinary cases. The department will extend the agreement with the district attorney’s office on surveillance ordinance until end of March. DPA’s audit draft is due to the department by end of February.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, February 14, 2023, in a hybrid format at the Port Commission Hearing Room and remotely. The meeting began with a closed session at 2:00 PM, reconvened in open session at approximately 2:45 PM, and adjourned at 4:15 PM. All votes were unanimous (3-0) with Vice President Adams absent. No public comments were received on any agenda item. Consent Calendar - Resolution 23-06: Approved a resolution adopting findings under state urgency legislation to allow certain members to attend meetings remotely during the COVID-19 emergency for the next 30 days, directing staff to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. - Resolution 23-07: Approved a resolution recommending the Board of Supervisors settle the lawsuit Burchell et al. v. City and County of San Francisco (San Francisco Superior Court Case No. CGC-20-588665) for $6,200,000, with the Port’s share limited to its $100,000 insurance deductible. This settlement relates to the May 23, 2020 fire at Pier 45. Executive Director’s Report - Elaine Forbes, Executive Director, reported on economic recovery, equity initiatives, and key projects. Highlights included: - The Port’s sixth annual Contract Open House scheduled for March 30, 2023, at Pier 27 (James R. Herman Cruise Ship Terminal), featuring keynote speaker Assessor-Recorder Joaquin Torres. - Approval of a water purchase agreement for non-potable uses at China Basin Park. - Release of $25 million in RM3 funding for the Mission Bay Ferry Terminal project after court resolution. - Preparation to sell two historic floating dry docks (Dry Dock 2 and Eureka Dry Dock) at Pier 70 as part of a shipyard transition plan. - Mission Rock development progress: first building (Parcel G, future Visa HQ) received a temporary certificate of occupancy; additional TCOs expected in spring for Parcel B (life sciences) and Parcel A (254 apartments, 100 below-market-rate units). - Welcome to new Communications Director Justin, formerly of Oakland Mayor’s office and San Francisco Chronicle. Discussion Items Item 11A – Tenant Improvement Allowances (Resolution 23-08) - Deputy Director of Real Estate and Development Rebecca Benassini presented a proposal to authorize offering tenant improvement allowances up to $20 million from stimulus funds, with a waiver of Administrative Code Chapter 6 public contracting rules for certain port leases. The waiver would apply to leases approved by the Port Commission and Board of Supervisors, and would not affect prevailing wage, local hire, or other lease provisions. - Commissioners expressed strong support for the concept, noting it would reduce capital barriers for small and BIPOC businesses and spur economic recovery. Concerns were raised about prioritization, fund allocation, and ensuring that infrastructure improvements (e.g., fire sprinklers, ADA) are prioritized. Commissioners requested a clear strategy before funds are deployed, and a term sheet for each lease. The resolution was approved unanimously (3-0). Item 12A – Mission Bay Parks Supplemental Appropriation and Prop J Contracts - Acting Deputy Director of Finance Nate Cruz, Deputy Director of Planning David Beaupre, and Rebecca Benassini presented an informational overview of a proposed FY 2023-24 supplemental appropriation of approximately $1 million (fully covered by Community Facilities District revenues) to fund operations of certain Mission Bay parks (P21–P24) and to approve Proposition J contracts for maintenance of non-standard improvements (e.g., specialized streetlights, bollards, planters) at Mission Rock and Pier 70. The port would take over maintenance of bayfront parks; Recreation and Park Department would manage the other parks. The Prop J contract for Mission Rock would be at $0 cost because the developer affiliate would use master association fees; for Pier 70, a contract with a Brookfield affiliate would provide cost savings. - Commissioner questions focused on long-term funding shortfalls (CFD expiration in 2044) and potential impacts on the harbor fund. Staff indicated plans to seek general fund support and noted potential revenue from a restaurant pad in Bayfront Park. No action was taken; staff will return for formal action at a future meeting. Key Outcomes - Unanimous approval (3-0) of Consent Calendar: Resolutions 23-06 and 23-07. - Unanimous approval (3-0) of Resolution 23-08 authorizing tenant improvement allowance program with Chapter 6 waiver, up to $20 million. - The following new business items were recorded for future reports: 1. Interdivisional briefing on lease-up of Mission Rock affordable housing units with MOHCD. 2. Review of insurance, safety, and risk mitigation in the context of economic recovery. 3. Strategy for supporting nonprofits with Port storage and industrial spaces. 4. Update on the Blue Greenway plan, completed projects, and remaining opportunities. - No other actions were taken.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on February 14, 2023, at 9:45 AM via teleconference due to the ongoing COVID-19 emergency. President Ajami presided. The commission adopted renewed findings for hybrid meetings, approved minutes, received updates on drought conditions and bond disclosure training, approved a consent calendar, and conducted public hearings to adopt the FY 2023-24 operating budget, 10-year capital plan ($8.79 billion), FY 2023-24 capital budget ($1.6 billion), and 10-year financial plan. Other actions included approving credit facilities and dealer agreements, updating water waste restrictions for construction, and authorizing an amended MOU with Recreation and Parks for Lake Merced management. Consent Calendar - Item 6a-h approved unanimously (5-0). Included contract amendments for control systems integration (Item 6a), wastewater/stormwater services (Item 6b), acceptance of work for Auxiliary Water Supply System Pump Station No. 1 improvements (Item 6c), contract contingency increases (Item 6d), award of water main replacement contract (Item 6e), and acceptance of work on other contracts (Items 6f, 6g, 6h). - Commissioner Rivera praised the pump station project as a “great accomplishment” involving a 100-year-old underground system. Commissioner Paulson noted positive public feedback on neighborhood infrastructure work. Public Comments & Testimony - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) urged the commission to revisit the design drought length, stating that climate change will shift snowmelt earlier and that the SFPUC could gain an additional year’s water supply over an 8.5-year period. He also recommended reducing planned alternative water supply volumes to avoid overbuilding. - Patricia De Costa (public caller) advocated for releasing water for salmon and criticized the commission’s environmental record. - Dave Warner (Palo Alto resident) commented on bond disclosure, questioning the SFPUC’s debt load ($15.7 billion) and market risk. During general public comment, he thanked commissioners for discussing affordability metrics. - SPEAK (Sunset Parkside Education and Action Committee) urged the PUC to exercise its option to purchase the solar array on Sunset Reservoir’s North Basin and advocated for thin-film solar on South Basin. - Nicole Sinko LaBaska (Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency) supported the capital plan for water enterprise but requested earlier engagement in future budget processes. - Two callers criticized contract cost overruns and lack of transparency on Items 6c and 6d, noting a 30% cost overrun and 8-year delay on Pump Station No. 1. Discussion Items - Drought Conditions Update (Item 5a): Steve Ritchie reported that reservoir storage is nearly full (Hetch Hetchy 300,000 acre-feet, Calaveras full), snowpack matches 2017 (second wettest year), and cumulative precipitation is on par with 1983 (wettest year). City water deliveries are below all recent years due to wet weather. Ritchie recommended waiting until mid-April for a final drought declaration decision due to state emergency orders still in place. - Bond Disclosure Training (Item 5b): Deputy City Attorney Mark Blake and counsel Steven Spitz provided training on federal securities law responsibilities, emphasizing accurate and complete official statements, and the need for a transparent process. - Budget and Capital Plan Hearings (Items 8-11): CFO Nancy Hamm presented the FY 2023-24 operating budget ($1.785 billion), 10-year capital plan ($8.79 billion), FY 2023-24 capital budget ($1.6 billion), and 10-year financial plan. Key points: - The capital plan is 11% lower than last year’s $9.9 billion, achieved through deliverability analysis and prioritization. - Wastewater is the largest share ($4.9 billion); water main replacement funding held steady at $475 million, with a shift to risk-based replacement targeting 9-10 miles/year. - Combined water/wastewater bill for average household projected to rise 90% over 10 years (from $138/month to $224/month). - Power enterprise faces significant cost increases due to market volatility (4x energy prices) and transmission charges. - Commissioners stressed the need for aggressive project management, contractor accountability, and attention to affordability metrics. President Ajami noted the 2.5% median household income threshold is outdated and that the PUC is exploring better measures. - Credit Facilities (Items 12-13): Capital Finance Director Nikolai Sklarov reported that competitive bidding secured lower letter of credit rates from Bank of America (power: 0.29%, wastewater: 0.27%), saving money. - Water Waste Restrictions (Item 14): Steve Ritchie presented amendments clarifying that recycled water must be used for construction whenever available, with exceptions only if recycled, well, or groundwater is unavailable. - Lake Merced MOU (Item 16): Ritchie introduced an updated MOU with Recreation and Parks, clarifying responsibilities for recreation and utility access. The PUC will continue lead shot cleanup at the former Pacific Rod and Gun Club site. Key Outcomes - Item 3 (Adopt renewed findings for hybrid meetings) passed 4-0 (Commissioner Paulson absent for vote). - Items 4 (Minutes of Jan 24 and Jan 30) both approved 4-0 (Commissioner Paulson absent for vote). - Consent Calendar (Item 6) approved 5-0. - Item 7 (Award contract WW-733) approved 5-0 as amended to correct “cleaning” to “inspection”. - Items 8-11 (Operating budget amendment, 10-year capital plan, capital budget, and 10-year financial plan) each approved 5-0. The capital budget authorization includes up to $1.447 billion in debt issuance subject to Board of Supervisors approval. - Items 12-13 (Letter of credit and dealer agreements) approved 5-0. - Item 14 (Water waste restrictions update) approved 5-0. - Item 16 (Lake Merced MOU) approved 5-0. - Item 19 (Items initiated by commissioners): No items were initiated. - Closed Session: The commission asserted attorney-client privilege (5-0). Commissioner Stacey recused from Item 22 (Bridge Housing settlement) due to conflict. After closed session, the commission announced a recommendation to the Board of Supervisors to approve a settlement of $100,000 for a ruptured water main claim. No other actions were taken.