Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1071–1080 ENTRIES
1071
FEB 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee Meeting – February 13, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on February 13, 2023, at 10:15 AM in a hybrid format. Chair Matt Dorsey presided, joined by Vice Chair Shamann Walton and member Ahsha Safai (remote). The committee addressed six agenda items, including appointments to assessment appeals boards, an extension for the Reinvestment Working Group, homelessness oversight amendments, and a controversial proposal to exempt certain construction contracts from Chapter 12X’s prohibition on contracting with states that have discriminatory laws. Assessment Appeals Board Appointments (Items 1–3) - Item 1: Hearing to appoint one member to Assessment Appeals Board No. 1 (term ending September 2, 2024). Applicant Karina Mitchell testified. Due to a clerical error in the vacancy notice, the committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the February 27 meeting. - Items 2 & 3: Appointments for Assessment Appeals Boards No. 2 and No. 3. Steven Wasserman (Item 2) and Betsy Miller (Item 3) testified. Both were recommended to the full board with positive recommendations, with Wasserman assigned to Seat 5 and Miller to a seat with a matching term expiration. The motion passed unanimously. Reinvestment Working Group Extension (Item 4) - Presentation by Supervisor Dean Preston (sponsor), Khalid Samurai (LAFCO policy analyst), and Kristen Evans (RW chair). The ordinance extends the deadline for the working group to submit its business and governance plans for a public bank to September 30, 2023, and its sunset to December 31, 2023. Draft plans were received on February 10, 2023, with final MFC plan expected by March 31 and public bank plan by May 31. The estimated startup cost is $20 million for a non-depository MFC and $50 million for a full depository public bank, with projections of profitability within three years. Public comment strongly supported the extension. The committee voted unanimously to send the item to the full board with a positive recommendation. Homelessness Oversight Commission Amendments (Item 5) - Introduced by Supervisor Safai, with presentation by Emily Cohen (Deputy Director of HSH). The amendments streamline oversight bodies: increase the Local Homeless Coordinating Board from 9 to 11 seats to better align with HUD standards, shift Shelter Monitoring Committee staffing from DPH to HSH, and clarify reporting lines. Public comment (including from SMC members Britt Creech, Dale Seymour, and others) raised concerns about perceived conflicts of interest from moving SMC staffing to HSH, arguing it could undermine impartial oversight. The committee voted to accept the amendments and continued the item to February 27, with both motions passing unanimously. Removing Construction Agreements from Chapter 12X (Item 6) - Presented by Supervisor Safai. The ordinance exempts Chapter 6 public works construction contracts from 12X’s prohibition on contracting with companies headquartered in states with anti-LGBTQ, abortion-restrictive, or voter-suppression laws. Presenters from PUC (Ivy Fine), Public Works (Bruce Robertson), and SFO (Judy Musqueda) cited reduced competition, higher costs, and specialized needs (e.g., airport equipment from Texas-based firms). Public comment (from small business owners, minority contractor groups, and LGBTQ advocates) overwhelmingly opposed the measure, arguing that 12X protects local LBEs and that no data justify the change. Supervisor Walton opposed, stating it would harm local contractors and reward corporations that flee San Francisco. Chair Dorsey supported the change, noting 12X has not changed any state laws and that it increases taxpayer costs. The committee voted 2-1 to send the item to the full board without recommendation (Dorsey and Safai in favor; Walton against).

PUBLIC COMMENT 25% · PUBLIC BANK 17% · PROCUREMENT 16% · CONTRACT MANAGEMENT 12%
1072
FEB 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting – February 13, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 13, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Myrna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered two ordinances: one updating neighborhood commercial and mixed-use zoning controls (File 220340) and another amending the definition of tourist or transient use under the Hotel Conversion Ordinance and establishing an amortization period (File 220815). Public comment was heard on both items. The committee voted to amend and continue the first item to February 27, 2023, and initially voted to amend and send the second item to the full board, but later rescinded that motion and continued it to the same date. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Zoning Controls): James Hewitt, assistant business manager for the International Union of Teachers and Allied Trades, spoke in favor. He stated that the ordinance would make his union hall's use legal, allowing him to proceed with ADA compliance work at 65 Oak Grove Street. - Item 2 (Hotel Conversion Ordinance): Two speakers opposed the ordinance. Brian O'Neill, attorney for Hotel des Arts and other SRO owners, argued that the ordinance would take away clients' business without compensation, that the amortization period is insufficient, and that the BIC (Board of Appeals) lacks authority to hold quasi-judicial hearings. He requested a continuance due to lack of notice. Ryan Patterson, also representing Hotel des Arts, echoed the request for continuation, stating the amendment changing the file number required new notice. Both speakers submitted written comments. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Planning Code Amendments (File 220340): Madison Tam, representing Supervisor Dorsey (sponsor), presented the ordinance as part of the planning department's code reorganization effort since 2014. Aaron Starr of the planning department detailed substantive changes, including: allowing accessory arts activities, liberalizing institutional uses, exempting childcare and residential care facilities from FAR limits, and modifying nighttime entertainment controls along Folsom and 11th Streets. President Peskin raised three concerns: (1) the removal of a long-standing provision restricting adult entertainment within 1,000 feet of another (page 23), (2) the addition of group housing to section 803.8, which could be an upzoning, and (3) moving good-neighbor policies from the planning code to the entertainment commission's policy, which could be changed without board approval. The committee agreed to continue the item to allow further review of these issues. The committee voted to adopt the amendments circulated by Supervisor Dorsey. - Item 2 – Hotel Conversion Ordinance (File 220815): President Peskin presented the ordinance, which updates Chapter 41 of the Administrative Code following a 2017 lawsuit. He noted that the environmental review (negative declaration) was upheld by the Planning Commission. He proposed a minor amendment to correct a file number reference (striking 190946 and inserting 220815). After public comment, President Peskin made a motion to amend and send the amended file to the full board. The committee voted 3-0 in favor. However, later in the meeting, after a brief recess, President Peskin consulted with the deputy city attorney and moved to rescind sending it to the full board. The committee voted 3-0 to rescind that action. Then President Peskin moved to continue the item to the next meeting on February 27, 2023, which passed 3-0. Key Outcomes - Item 1 – Zoning Controls: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt the amendments circulated by Supervisor Dorsey and to continue the item to the February 27, 2023 Land Use and Transportation Committee meeting. - Item 2 – Hotel Conversion Ordinance: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to amend the ordinance (correcting the file number) and initially send it to the full board. Subsequently, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to rescind that motion and instead continue the amended ordinance to the February 27, 2023 meeting. No final action was taken. Both items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda of February 27, 2023, unless otherwise stated.

LAND USE 58% · PROCEDURAL 29% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10% · PUBLIC SAFETY 3%
1073
FEB 9, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Public Safety Committee Meeting - February 9, 2023

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee convened on February 9, 2023, at City Hall, chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stephanie, with Vice Chair Supervisor Engardio and Supervisor Dorsey. The committee heard one agenda item: an ordinance to repeal the city's permitting requirements for overdose prevention programs (safe consumption sites). The ordinance, introduced by Supervisor Ronen, was supported by the mayor's office and several public health advocates. After public testimony and discussion, the committee voted unanimously to send the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Tom Paulino (Mayor's liaison to the Board of Supervisors) spoke in support, stating the repeal would accelerate deployment of overdose prevention sites and cited the "New York model" as a novel approach to address legal uncertainty. He emphasized the alarming rate of overdose deaths and urged the committee to support the measure. - Andy Stone (HIV Advocacy Network, 700 members) expressed full support, describing the overdose crisis as a "moral crisis" and calling for bold action similar to San Francisco's response to the AIDS crisis. - Curtis Bradford (long-term recovery, former IV drug user) shared personal testimony that harm reduction services saved his life, and urged the committee to be "bold and brave" in taking action. - Mark Solomon (North Mission resident, Act Up alum) opposed the ordinance, citing concerns about a proposed safe consumption site at St. John's Church at 15th and Julian, adjacent to a senior center, near the American Indian Friendship House Recovery Center, and less than 1,000 feet from Marshall Elementary School (in violation of Health and Safety Code Section 11380.5). He requested a carve-out requiring hearings for sites near schools or recovery centers, and criticized billionaire funding (Soros and Bloomberg). - Mary Silla (Director of Policy, National Harm Reduction Coalition) supported the amendment, noting overdose prevention centers have operated internationally for decades, in New York for the past year, and have been legalized in Rhode Island. She also noted the U.S. Department of Justice's stance in the Safe House litigation. - Alliana (Policy Associate, member of Safe Ring Side and Treatment on Demand Coalitions) supported the measure, citing research that overdose prevention centers increase connections to treatment, and noted hundreds of reversals at the Tenderloin Center. - Sheba Bandiva (District 6 resident, Public Policy Manager at HomeRise, member of Treatment on Demand and other coalitions) supported the ordinance, noting an average of two accidental overdose deaths per day in San Francisco, and urged funding for wellness hubs. - Lara Thomas (Senior Director of HIV and Harm Reduction Policy, San Francisco AIDS Foundation, District 10 resident) supported the measure as a step toward opening life-saving services, while noting that funding still needs to be addressed. - Michael Rupe (District 9 resident, co-drafter of San Francisco Principles 2020) supported the ordinance, recalled touring a site in Copenhagen, and noted that two people he knew died on New Year's Day from relapses, stressing urgency. - Wesley Saver (Senior Policy Manager, Glide) supported the measure, referencing the 2017 Safe Injection Services Task Force report, and emphasized that supervised consumption is evidence-based and cost-effective, and not an alternative to treatment. - Calder Lorenz (Director of Operations, Guvio Project, Mission district resident) supported the ordinance, citing his experience in Vancouver, BC, when safe injection sites were introduced, and said services would bring people inside safely. - Carolyn Gooson (Local Policy Director, Public Defender's Office) spoke in support, calling the ordinance an evidence-based public health approach and urging investment in interventions that support people rather than criminalize them. - Layla (longtime harm reduction advocate) supported the measure, noting the lack of consumption sites and the daily loss of life, and urged acknowledgment of the reality of drug use. - Mr. Kensler (member of the public) opposed the ordinance, stating he did not see how the sites help people recover, and recommended not moving forward unless there was a pathway to recovery. Discussion Items Supervisor Dorsey acknowledged frustrations with the delay, attributing it to legal challenges at the federal level, particularly a case in Philadelphia, and criticized the Biden administration for not providing guidance. He noted his own experience with abstinence-based recovery but stressed that harm reduction is necessary to keep people alive. Supervisor Engardio expressed support, stating "every life saved is worth saving" and emphasized using all tools, including harm reduction and abstinence-based recovery. Chair Stephanie asked the Department of Public Health about the city's role if a nonprofit group were to operate a safe consumption site. Eileen Lochran (Overdose Prevention and Community Initiatives Manager, DPH) responded that DPH would provide strong oversight, community engagement, and ensure adherence to policies and that programs are "good neighbors." Supervisor Engardio also asked Mayor's office representative Tom Paulino about the mayor's statements on accountability for drug dealers, and Paulino confirmed that enforcement and accountability are part of the mayor's approach. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to approve the ordinance and send it to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The measure is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on February 28, 2023.

PUBLIC HEALTH 61% · PUBLIC SAFETY 20% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10% · PROCEDURAL 9%
1074
FEB 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – February 8, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on February 8, 2023, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included discussions on overdue policy revisions, a surveillance camera policy update, public safety reports, and budget presentations for the SFPD and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA). The commission voted to approve the SFPD’s proposed budget for fiscal years 2024-2025 and held a closed session. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: A mother of a murder victim (2006 unsolved homicide) pleaded for more resources to solve cold cases, naming alleged perpetrators and noting a $250,000 reward. She urged the commission to address unsolved homicides. - Public Comment on Item 6 (DGO deadlines): No public comment was offered. - Public Comment on Item 8 (Surveillance cameras): No public comment was offered. - Public Comment on Chief’s Report: The same mother spoke again, reiterating her frustration with unsolved homicides and the lack of progress on her son’s case. - Public Comment on DPA Budget: No public comment was offered. - Public Comment on Closed Session items: No public comment was offered. Discussion Items - Item 6 & 7 – DGO Revision Deadlines (DGOs 8.10, 6.18, 9.03): Vice President Carter Oberstone led a review of missed deadlines under DGO 3.01. Director Kwood (DPA) detailed email exchanges showing the department failed to respond to recommendations for DGO 8.10 (First Amendment activities) for months. The department did not request an extension until December 20, 2022, after the December 6 deadline. Chief Scott acknowledged the department was “not responsive” and took responsibility. Commissioner Benedicto discussed DGO 9.03 (mandatory blood tests) and 6.18 (warrant arrests). For 9.03, DPA’s recommendations from June 2021 had not been answered; Deputy Chief Perea committed to a draft by March 10, 2023. For 6.18, a November 28, 2022 deadline was missed, but a draft was submitted on February 1, 2023. The commission decided to reschedule the discussion on DGO 8.10 to a future meeting when the executive sponsor and subject matter expert could attend. - Item 8 – Surveillance Camera Policy Update (Admin Code 19B): Aja Steves (SFPD) presented the implementation plan for the non-city entity surveillance camera pilot ordinance (effective November 6, 2022, sunsetting January 2024). The department created a new request form (SFPD Form 619) requiring captain-level approval, except for exigencies or significant events. Training will roll out in phases starting with captains and lieutenants. Commissioners discussed the form’s language, the need for voluntary consent language for private entities, and language access. The first quarterly report is due by June 1, 2023. Commissioner Benedicto requested real-time updates in the Chief’s Report and a future commission presentation. - Item 2 – Chief’s Report: Assistant Chief Lazar reported on crime trends: violent crime up 3% year-to-date, property crime down 20%, homicides up 25% (5 vs. 4 last year), 18 shootings (up from 15). 89 firearms seized year-to-date. He highlighted a fentanyl seizure of 20 pounds (plus 14 pounds in Oakland), a rescue of a 14-year-old human trafficking victim, and new strategies in the Tenderloin (Operation Disruption) and on Capp Street (prostitution enforcement). The MOU with the DA’s office is nearing completion. - Item 3 – DPA Director’s Report: Director Henderson noted 9 cases pending with the commission, 89 with the chief. The most common allegations this week: failure to take required action (21%) and inappropriate behavior (13%). DPA completed a review of SFPD’s 24-month updates on the 2020 use of force audit; 10 of 37 recommendations remain open. New staff were introduced. - Item 4 – Commission Reports: Commissioners gave updates on DGO assignments (9.07, 10.11, 7.01, 5.16), a joint meeting with the Juvenile Probation Commission, and an AAPI community summit. Commissioner Byrne requested that U visa certification information be posted on the commission website. - Item 9 – SFPD Budget Hearing (FY 2024-2025): CFO Patrick Leong presented the proposed budget, noting the mayor’s directive to cut general fund support by 5% in FY24 and 8% in FY25. The department has 297 sworn vacancies and faces a shortage of officers. Overtime backfill is critical. The budget includes $1.2 million in cost reductions but no personnel cuts. Commissioners questioned vehicle replacement, civilianization, and the number of officers on administrative duty. The commission voted 6-0 to approve the budget as a recommendation to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 10 – DPA Budget Presentation (FY 2024-2025): Nicole Armstrong presented DPA’s $9 million budget (85% salary/fringe). Proposed changes include adding a 1091 IT apprentice, converting a temporary outreach coordinator to permanent, and funding for digitizing case files and improving data sharing with SFPD. DPA currently handles over 700 cases annually. The commission discussed the need for better data integration between DPA and SFPD, especially for the upcoming Benchmark system. No vote was taken; the presentation was for discussion. Key Outcomes - Vote to approve SFPD budget (FY 2024-2025): 6-0 in favor (motion by Commissioner Walker, second by Commissioner Benedicto). - Motion to hold Item 13 in closed session: Unanimous (6-0). - Motion not to disclose closed session discussion: Unanimous (6-0). - Rescheduled DGO 8.10 discussion: The commission will re-agendize the item for a future meeting when the deputy chief and subject matter expert can attend. - Next steps on surveillance camera policy: The department will update the Form 619 with voluntary consent language, provide translation, and include live monitoring usage in the Chief’s Report. The first quarterly report is due June 1, 2023. - DPA budget: No action taken; the presentation was for discussion. The commission expressed support for DPA’s funding needs and data-sharing initiatives. - MOU with DA’s office: The department expects to provide the draft MOU to the commission by the end of the week. The current MOU expires February 28, 2023; an extension may be needed.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 27% · PUBLIC SAFETY 20% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 12% · SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY 9%
1075
FEB 6, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting: Appointments, Homelessness Oversight, and Remote Public Comment Debate (Feb 6, 2023)

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, February 6, 2023, at 10:15 AM, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey. The agenda included three appointments to regional bodies, an ordinance to implement Proposition C (homelessness oversight), and a highly contentious motion to end unlimited remote public comment at board and committee meetings. The meeting lasted several hours, with extensive public testimony on the remote comment issue. Consent Calendar (Appointments) - Item 1 (230086): Motion appointing Supervisor Myrna Melgar to the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) Executive Board, term ending June 30, 2023. Passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2 (230096): Motion reappointing Supervisor Catherine Stefani to the Golden Gate Bridge, Highway and Transportation District Board of Directors, term ending January 31, 2025. Passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 3 (230095): Motion reappointing Supervisor Matt Dorsey to the same bridge district board, term ending January 31, 2025. Supervisor Dorsey recused himself due to a small stipend. Passed 2-0 (Peskin aye, Safai aye). Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 1 (Melgar appointment): Michael Petrellis spoke in support, citing Melgar's ability to speak at length during commendations as a qualification. A caller from the San Francisco Tenants Union also supported the appointment. Another caller (Jill Cunflower) supported Melgar, calling the first commenter disrespectful. - On Item 2 (Stefani reappointment): Michael Petrellis again spoke in support, using the same talking style. Others called in support, including David Pilpel who noted Supervisor Stefani's good service on the bridge board. - On Item 3 (Dorsey reappointment): Michael Petrellis spoke in favor, referring to Dorsey as a "cop" and joking about his ability to talk. David Pilpel supported the reappointment and noted Dorsey's recent first meeting attendance. - On Item 4 (Homelessness ordinance): Michael Petrellis expressed support for the new homeless oversight body, urging the board to spend less time on commendations and more on homelessness. Dale Seymour, who served on the local homeless coordinating board for 6–8 years, urged that the new commission not be politically connected and represent street-level communities. He noted 99% of nonprofits work hard. - On Item 5 (Remote public comment ending): Over 38 people called in and several spoke in person, overwhelmingly opposing the motion. Speakers included representatives from Senior and Disability Action, GLIDE, Housing Action Coalition, San Francisco Tenants Union, Race and Equity in All Planning Coalition, and many others. Key arguments: the pandemic is not over; remote access enables participation by disabled people, working parents, seniors, those in far-flung neighborhoods, and immunocompromised individuals; requiring a 72-hour notice for reasonable accommodation is a barrier; the motion is undemocratic and ableist. A few callers (e.g., Alan Burradell) supported the motion, arguing there are many other ways to engage and that unlimited remote comment is unmanageable and a threat to democracy. One caller (Beverly Upton, Domestic Violence Consortium) noted that remote comment allows survivors of domestic violence to participate safely. Discussion Items - Item 4 (230122 – Homelessness Oversight Commission): Supervisor Safai presented the ordinance implementing Proposition C (passed Nov. 8, 2022, with 68% of the vote). The ordinance streamlines advisory bodies, requires the Controller to conduct mandatory audits of homeless services, and focuses the local homeless coordinating board solely on the continuum of care. Safai noted the homeless services budget has grown from $100M to nearly $700M. He requested to duplicate the file to allow for additional amendments not ready that day, and to continue the duplicated file for one week (to Feb. 13). The committee approved the continuance (3-0) and sent the original ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5 (221008 – Limiting Teleconferencing and Remote Public Comment): Supervisor Mandelman presented the motion to end unlimited remote public comment, effective March 1, 2023, when state and local COVID-19 emergency orders expire. He argued that unlimited remote comment leads to excessively long meetings (citing the car-free JFK debate and redistricting commission), costs city resources, and does not necessarily capture broader public sentiment. He proposed continuing remote comment only as a reasonable accommodation under the ADA. President Peskin suggested removing the 72-hour advance notice requirement and replacing it with "prior to the start of the meeting." He also emphasized the need for a uniform policy across all city Brown Act bodies. Supervisor Dorsey supported taking time to harmonize rules across all 130 bodies and to consider the impact on city staff. After extensive public comment (over 90 minutes of testimony), the committee voted to continue the item to the call of the chair, with a commitment to bring it back before the Feb. 27 deadline. The motion passed 2-0 (Peskin absent). Key Outcomes - Items 1, 2, 3: All appointments passed unanimously and sent to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. - Item 4: The original ordinance (implementing Prop C) was sent to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). A duplicate file was created and continued to the February 13, 2023 meeting for additional amendments. - Item 5: The motion to end remote public comment was continued to the call of the chair (2-0), with the understanding that the committee will revisit it before the February 27, 2023, deadline. No amendments were adopted at this meeting.

PUBLIC COMMENT 48% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 20% · PROCEDURAL 10% · PUBLIC HEALTH 10%
1076
FEB 6, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting – February 6, 2023: Shared Spaces Program Grace Period Extension

On February 6, 2023, the Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar and joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin, held a hybrid meeting. The sole substantive agenda item was an ordinance (File No. 230025) to amend the Administrative Code to extend the grace period for pandemic shared spaces permits by an additional 120 days (resulting in a total 180-day grace period) and to facilitate conversion to post-pandemic permits. Staff from the Planning Department (Robin Abad), the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (Monica Munowich), and the Fire Department (Assistant Fire Marshal Chad Law) presented. Public Comments & Testimony - Lori Thomas, Executive Director of the Greater Downtown Restaurant Association and a parklet operator, expressed full support for the proposed extension and the collaborative approach with city departments, emphasizing the need to help operators transition to post-pandemic permits. Discussion Items - Grace Period Mechanics: President Peskin sought clarification on whether the 120-day extension in the ordinance, combined with an existing 60-day wind-down, totals 180 days. City staff confirmed the cumulative effect is 180 days. A potential drafting error regarding underlined language was noted and referred to the Deputy City Attorney for correction. - Abandoned or Neglected Parklets: President Peskin expressed concern about parklets that are abandoned or not diligently maintained during the extended grace period. He indicated plans to introduce amendments at a future hearing to allow enforcement actions (e.g., notices of violation, removal) despite the grace period, and to address situations where property owners cannot be located to grant consent for parklets. - Application Status and Outreach: Supervisor Preston noted that in his district, only 75 of 206 operators had applied for the post-pandemic program, and citywide about 350 operators had not yet submitted applications. He asked about targeted outreach to those who have not responded, and staff committed to partnering with his office and providing updated numbers. - Curb Management and Enforcement: Chair Melgar raised concerns about safety and congestion where parklets conflict with transit, loading zones, and emergency access, citing examples on Irving Street and Valencia Street. Monica Munowich described the city’s curb management strategy, which includes block-by-block assessments to determine parklet placement, relocation, or removal. Communication with businesses has been ongoing for months. - Transition of Parklet Ownership: Chair Melgar asked about a scenario where a business leaving a parklet could easily transfer the permit to an incoming business. Staff indicated that Department of Public Works facilitates such transfers, and encouraged applications before the March 31 deadline. Key Outcomes - Motion to Forward with Positive Recommendation: The committee voted 3-0 (Melgar, Preston, Peskin) to send the ordinance (without amendments) to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Motion to Continue Duplicated File for Amendments: The committee also voted 3-0 to duplicate the file and continue it to the call of the chair, pending amendments from President Peskin regarding enforcement against abandoned parklets and property owner consent procedures. The meeting adjourned after these motions.

PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 55% · PUBLIC WORKS 23% · PROCEDURAL 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
1077
FEB 2, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - February 2, 2023

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 2, 2023, at 6:15 PM (the transcript indicates a morning meeting, but the provided time is used). Chair Dean Preston presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Member Connie Chan. The committee considered two items: an annual report for the Greater Union Square Business Improvement District (BID) and a hearing on a citywide nonprofit performance audit, which was continued to February 16, 2023. Discussion Items Item 1: Greater Union Square Business Improvement District Annual Report (FY2020-2021) The committee received a resolution approving the annual report for the Union Square Alliance (formerly Greater Union Square BID). Mimi Haraki of the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) presented the oversight findings, confirming the BID met all four benchmarks: budget compliance, non-assessment revenue obligations, budget-to-actuals within 10%, and proper carry-forward designation. Marissa Rodriguez, CEO of the Union Square Alliance, detailed services during the pandemic, including cleaning (385,000 lbs of trash removed, 18,634 hazardous waste units, 43,075 quality-of-life incidents addressed), safety services (24/7 dispatch, private security, SFPD ambassador program), and marketing/activations (rebranding, Saturday music series, art walks, holiday lighting). Supervisor Preston inquired about the SFPD ambassador program, distinguishing it from other ambassador models (CBD hospitality ambassadors, city program via OCEIA). Rodriguez clarified that retired police officers (unarmed, part-time) perform community policing and are not replacing other services. Supervisor Chan noted the need for cost-effectiveness across multiple ambassador programs. Public comment was not offered. The committee voted 3-0 to forward the resolution with a positive recommendation to the full Board. Item 2: Hearing on Citywide Nonprofit Performance Audit Report This item, sponsored by Vice Chair Stefani, was rescheduled to February 16, 2023, as it was inadvertently placed on the agenda. Supervisor Stefani moved to continue. Public comment was taken on the continuance; several nonprofit representatives spoke in support of accountability while highlighting challenges: burdensome reporting, underfunded contracts, delayed payments, and lack of cost coverage for infrastructure. Speakers included Debbie Lerman (San Francisco Human Services Network), Kylan Fowler and Julian Johnson (San Francisco Community Health Center), Ilko Lund (Larkin Street Youth Services), Vita (Chinese Culture Center), Andrew Tan (Safe and Sound), and Natalie Assoon (Richmond Area Multiservices). The committee voted 3-0 to continue the hearing to February 16, 2023. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 2, multiple public commenters expressed support for accountability but stressed the need for mutual accountability between the city and nonprofits, citing extensive reporting requirements, capped indirect rates, and funding delays that strain resources. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to forward the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation passed 3-0 (Preston, Stefani, Chan). - Item 2: Motion to continue the hearing to February 16, 2023, passed 3-0.

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 29% · NONPROFIT SERVICES 23% · PUBLIC SAFETY 18% · PROCEDURAL 15%
1078
FEB 1, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Regular Meeting - February 1, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular monthly meeting on Wednesday, February 1, 2023, starting at approximately 1:45 PM Pacific time. The meeting included public comment, reports from the Chief of Police and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), commission reports, a discussion on military equipment under AB 481, and approval of two revised Department General Orders (DGOs). The meeting was chaired by Vice President Carter Oberstone after a procedural opening led by Commissioner Kevin Benedicto in the President's absence. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Minutes (January 11 and January 18, 2023): Approved unanimously (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Paulette Brown (mother of murder victim Arbory Abracasa) pleaded for help solving her son's homicide, noting the lack of resolution and the pain shared by mothers of victims of both police and community violence. She urged the commission to prioritize unsolved cases. - Barry Chironjo (taxi driver) complained about excessive street closures around Union Square on a Saturday night, causing lost income and difficulty accessing hotels. He asked for a way to file a claim for lost income. - Sidon Buckman (District 6 resident, member of the Black Community) criticized Chief Scott's statement on the Tyree Nichols murder, arguing that praising the Memphis Police chief's response was insufficient. He called for firing corrupt officers, banning minor traffic stops, and genuine reform to prevent similar incidents in San Francisco. - David Calderon (son of murder victim Carmelita Holbrook) accused the SFPD and DPA of delaying his case, pointing to inappropriate handling by a specific SFPOA representative. He requested help holding agencies accountable. - Ramona Burton (sister of murder victim Mark Anthony Coates) reminded the commission of her brother's unsolved case and expressed solidarity with other grieving families. - Cheryl Thornton (District 10 resident) supported Paulette Brown, emphasizing the disproportionate number of unsolved Black homicide cases and demanding resolution. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Chief William Scott): Overall Part 1 serious crime was down 20% year-over-year for January 2023. Notable incidents included a homicide on January 28 (Missouri St.), a suspicious death in the Bayview, a non-injury shooting at California and Polk, a carjacking of an elderly couple at Laguna and Lombard, and a threat to a Jewish high school on January 26 (call traced to out-of-state). Two homicide arrests were made from cases dating to November 2021 and September 2022. The department prepared for the Lunar New Year Parade on February 4. - DPA Director's Report (Chief of Staff Sarah Hawkins): Received 24 cases with 52 allegations in the prior two weeks, primarily for failure to take required action, inappropriate behavior, and failure to investigate. DPA participated in community outreach and station trainings. Two outstanding policy issues: DGO 6.18 (warrant arrests) and DGO 9.03 (DUI arrests) – both overdue. Commission discussed missed deadlines and the Chief committed to delivering draft DGO 6.18 to DPA by the end of the week. - Commission Reports: - Commissioner Walker: Noted no women in the 277th recruit class; urged a focus on the 30x30 pledge (women recruitment) and asked for an agenda item on recruitment obstacles. Also reported ongoing work on patrol specials, technology for body-worn cameras, and DGO revisions. - Commissioner Benedicto: Highlighted that January 11 commission vote on DGO 9.07 (pretext stops) was especially timely following the Tyree Nichols killing. He read names of victims (Philando Castile, Willie McCoy, Dante Wright) and expressed pride in the city’s reform leadership. - Commissioner Byrne: Described a ride-along in the Tenderloin on January 20, witnessing Sgt. Melissa Chung revive a woman overdosing on fentanyl after three Narcan doses. He criticized the lack of police resources at night and called for prioritizing life-saving efforts in the Tenderloin. - Commissioner Yi: Reported on a community town hall in Chinatown (Jan. 20) and upcoming Lunar New Year celebration in Visitation Valley on Feb. 5. Echoed support for additional resources in the Tenderloin and praised the revival efforts. - Sparks Report (3rd & 4th Quarter 2022) : Presented by Captain Dennis Doomer (WDU) and DPA Policy Director Janelle Kwood. The department currently processes 61 DGOs. Five were adopted by the commission in the period, six approved for meet and confer, and many others in various stages. Chief Scott noted the pace of policy work is unprecedented in his six years. DPA highlighted the foot pursuit policy as upcoming and emphasized that labeling it

POLICE OVERSIGHT 58% · PUBLIC SAFETY 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · PROCEDURAL 5%
1079
JAN 30, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
SFPUC Special Budget Hearing: Proposed FY2023-24 Budget and 10-Year Capital Plan – January 30, 2023

This special meeting of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) was held on Monday, January 30, 2023, at 6:15 PM UTC (actual start time was morning). The Commission reviewed proposed mid-cycle changes to the FY2023-24 operating budget, the 10-year capital plan, and the 10-year financial plan for all SFPUC enterprises (Water, Hetch Hetchy Water, Wastewater, Hetch Hetchy Power, and CleanPowerSF). Staff presented a balanced capital plan totaling $8.8 billion over ten years, reduced from the previous $9.9 billion plan. The meeting served as a workshop ahead of formal adoption scheduled for the February 14, 2023 regular meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Nicole Sanculabis, CEO of the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA), submitted a letter with ten questions and expressed that the wholesale water sales projections do not reflect state-mandated housing plans. She supported the projects in the capital plans. - Francisco De Costa criticized the presentation for lacking vision and a needs assessment, and called for an audit of contractors. - Peter Dreckmeyer, Policy Director for the Tuolumne River Trust, highlighted that the Long-Term Vulnerability Assessment does not model Bay-Delta Plan flows, which could equate to a 15% increase in demand, and urged the Commission to address design drought assumptions and water demand projections. - David Pilpel (multiple comments) generally supported the staff work and noted the importance of condition‑based asset management for water and sewer mains. He also questioned the cost allocation for Treasure Island and suggested interdepartmental real estate coordination. Discussion Items - Budget Context and Approach: General Manager Dennis Herrera and CFO Nancy Hom outlined the challenges: ongoing drought, economic uncertainty, high inflation, rising interest rates, volatile power markets, and deliverability constraints. The agency moved from an unbalanced 10-year plan to a balanced $8.8 billion plan, focusing on affordability and deliverability. The operating budget for FY2023-24 is $1.8 billion, with significant increases in power purchase costs ($118 million). Capital costs consume over 30% of operating revenues now, projected to reach 50% by the end of the decade. - Water Enterprise: AGM Steve Ritchie presented a $2.2 billion 10-year capital plan. Major projects include ozone treatment at Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant, dam improvements, Millbrae Yard consolidation, and the 2000 Marin facility. Cuts were made in water main replacement (from 12 to about 6 miles per year) and alternative water supplies. Commissioners expressed concern about the impact on service reliability and urged smarter asset management. - Hetch Hetchy Water Enterprise: Ritchie also presented a $977 million plan (reduced from $1.354 billion). Key projects include Moccasin powerhouse rehabilitation, San Joaquin Pipeline life extension, and O'Shaughnessy Dam outlet valve replacement. Deferred projects (e.g., Cherry Dam spillway, Kirkwood powerhouse) were detailed. Commissioners requested a clear list of deprioritized projects. - Wastewater Enterprise: AGM Greg Norby presented a $4.9 billion plan (down from $5.9 billion), dominated by the Biosolids Digester Project ($2.4 billion) and sewer system improvements. Trade-offs included deferring some green infrastructure and flood resilience projects. Commissioner Maxwell stressed the importance of green infrastructure and accountability. President Jajami raised concerns about emerging contaminants and brine management. - Hetch Hetchy Power and CleanPowerSF: AGM Barbara Hale presented a $595.5 million 10-year plan for Hetch Hetchy Power and a $73 million plan for CleanPowerSF. No new funds were requested for FY2023-24 redevelopment projects. Funds were requested for retail distribution, customer programs, public purpose programs (e.g., community solar), street lighting, and the PG&E acquisition process. Commissioners discussed equity in power reliability for underserved communities and the need to plan for potential acquisition of PG&E assets. Key Outcomes - No formal votes were taken; the budget and capital plan will be adopted at the February 14, 2023 regular meeting. - Staff received direction to continue improving capital planning and deliverability, with an emphasis on asset management, risk-based prioritization, and inter‑enterprise collaboration. - The Commission requested more detailed reporting on green infrastructure partnerships, alternative funding sources (e.g., federal infrastructure funds), and the long‑term risks of deferred projects. - Staff will present a water supply plan by July 1, 2023, and a review of affordability metrics later in the spring. - The meeting was adjourned after all agenda items were heard.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 26% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 12% · CAPITAL PLANNING 12% · PROCEDURAL 9%
1080
JAN 30, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco BOS Rules Committee Meeting – January 30, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee convened at 10:15 AM on January 30, 2023, under Chair Aaron Peskin, Vice Chair Supervisor Raphael Mandelman, and Supervisor Connie Chan. The committee considered five appointment motions, an ordinance prohibiting preemptive resignation letters from city commissioners, and the Sheriff's Department's military equipment policy under AB 481. Consent Calendar None. All agenda items received full discussion or public comment. Public Comments & Testimony Item 2 (Resignations Ordinance): Six callers spoke via telephone and one in person. - Michael Roupe (District 9 resident), representing the Harvey Milk LGBTQ Democratic Club's anti-corruption caucus, expressed support for the ordinance. - Wesley Saber (senior policy manager for Glide) stated the organization strongly supports the ordinance, arguing preemptive resignation letters undermine independent decision-making and erode public trust. - Tab Buckner spoke in strong support, calling the practice contrary to accountability. - Brent Turner, speaking for the Harvey Milk LGBTQ Club's anti-corruption caucus, expressed full support, citing the mayor's tactics as corrupting. - Chris Arvin, a former city commissioner, said the ordinance is absolutely necessary for basic ethics. - Edward Hernandez (District 11 resident, tech workers coalition) supported the ordinance, arguing it is needed to prevent undue influence over commissioners. - Alan Burrodell dissented, supporting Supervisor Mandelman's view that the board should look inward rather than restrict mayoral authority. - David Pilpel suggested additional amendments to cover bodies created by resolution and to harmonize the ordinance with the online appointments database. Item 1 (AB 481 Sheriff's Equipment Policy): Three callers spoke via telephone and one in person. - Arthur Koch (District 9 resident, San Francisco Friends Meeting/Quakers) supported the policy but raised concerns about the use of submachine guns and chemical launchers in jails, and advocated for a private right of action and decommissioning of automatic assault weapons. - Regina Smeed (District 2 resident) praised the collaborative process and recommended using resources from the Othering and Belonging Institute. - John Lindsay Poland (American Friends Service Committee) recognized the Sheriff's Office engagement but expressed real concern about the continued authorization of submachine guns (MP5s) with few restrictions, proposing decommissioning or adding deployment limitations. Discussion Items Item 2 – Administrative Code – Resignations from City Boards and Commissions (File 221270): Supervisor Dean Preston, primary sponsor, introduced the ordinance in response to revelations that the mayor had requested undated resignation letters from police commissioners. He argued it protects commissioners from undue influence and circumvention of charter removal procedures. Supervisor Mandelman expressed a different view, stating he is not deeply offended by the practice and believes mayoral authority in public safety is important; he declined to support the ordinance. Chair Peskin shared a personal experience on the Coastal Commission and supported the ordinance. The committee voted 2‑1 (Chan and Peskin aye, Mandelman no) to send the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Item 1 – Administrative Code – Funding, Acquisition, and Use of Certain Sheriff’s Department Equipment (File 221062): Chair Peskin praised the Sheriff’s Department for a collaborative process with the American Friends Service Committee. He introduced several non‑substantive amendments: updating recitals on page 2, shifting the annual reporting deadline to December 13 (aligning with the Police Department’s policy), and requiring a public meeting before the Sheriff’s oversight body. The Sheriff’s Office (represented by Ronnie Singh) accepted the amendments and noted willingness to revisit equipment policies next year. The committee approved the amendments and then sent the amended item to the full board with unanimous positive recommendation. Items 3‑6 – Appointments to External Bodies: The committee considered and amended appointment motions: - Item 3 (Golden Gate Bridge District): amended to correct term end date from 2023 to 2025. - Item 5 (Association of Bay Area Governments): initially introduced for Supervisor Hillary Ronen, but a last‑minute substitution for Supervisor Myrna Melgar was made after a recess; the item was continued to the next rules committee meeting on January 31. - Items 4 (California State Association of Counties alternate) and 6 (Local Agency Formation Commission) were approved as submitted. A roll‑call vote passed items 3, 4, and 6 as committee reports for the full board on January 31. - Item 7 (Local Agency Formation Commission alternate for Supervisor Connie Chan): after excusing Supervisor Chan from the meeting due to conflict of interest (she was the appointee), the committee voted to send it with recommendation to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 2 (Resignations Ordinance): Passed committee on a 2‑1 vote (Chan and Peskin aye, Mandelman no) and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for consideration on January 31, 2023. - Item 1 (AB 481 Sheriff’s Equipment Policy): Committee adopted non‑substantive amendments and unanimously forwarded the ordinance and policy to the full board with a positive recommendation. The policy will be subject to annual review by December 13. - Appointments: Items 3, 4, and 6 were approved as committee reports for the full board. Item 5 was continued to the next rules committee meeting (January 31, 2023) after substituting Supervisor Melgar for Supervisor Ronen. Item 7 was approved as a committee report after excusing Supervisor Chan.

PUBLIC COMMENT 27% · PROCEDURAL 25% · SHERIFF'S OFFICE 23% · COMMISSION GOVERNANCE 13%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com