Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1081–1090 ENTRIES
1081
JAN 30, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - January 30, 2023

This regular meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Land Use and Transportation Committee was chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Darren Peskin. The committee considered two items: a planning code amendment to allow nighttime entertainment in the SoMa Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District, and an administrative code waiver to permit two shared spaces parklets on a Valencia Street sidewalk bulb-out. Both items were approved with positive recommendations to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 - SoMa Nighttime Entertainment: Bob Goldfarb, Executive Director of the Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District, urged passage, stating that nightlife venues are the lifeblood of the district and have historically provided safe spaces for the community. He noted that current zoning prevents new nightlife venues in most of SoMa and that the amendment would allow businesses to flourish. - Item 2 - Valencia Street Shared Spaces: Amparo Vigil, owner of Puerto Alegre Restaurant (50+ years on Valencia Street), expressed gratitude for the shared spaces program, which helped her family business survive the pandemic. Nikki, co-owner of Blondie's Bar (32 years on Valencia Street), echoed the sentiment, stating that the extra outdoor space is essential for small business viability in San Francisco. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Ordinance 221104): The committee continued consideration of a planning code amendment that had been amended substantively in a previous meeting. The ordinance would make nighttime entertainment a principally permitted use on properties fronting Folsom Street between 7th and Division Street in the Folsom Street Neighborhood Commercial Transit District, the Regional Commercial District, and the Western SoMa Mixed Use General District, removing certain restrictions. Madison Tam from Supervisor Dorsey's office was present to answer questions. No further discussion occurred. - Item 2 (Ordinance 221271): Ana Herrera from Supervisor Ronin's office presented the ordinance, which would waive administrative code requirements to allow two food service shared spaces (parklets) on a sidewalk bulb-out on the 500 block of Valencia Street. The bulb-out is located mid-block rather than at an intersection and was never activated for pedestrian use. The parklets are operated by Puerto Alegre Restaurant (546 Valencia) and Blondie's Bar (540 Valencia), both long-standing women-led businesses. The permanent shared spaces program would not otherwise permit parklets on bulb-outs, necessitating this legislation. Robin Abad from the Shared Spaces Program and city attorney John Malmot were available online for questions. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to approve the ordinance with a positive recommendation to the full Board of Supervisors. The motion was made by Chair Melgar, with all supervisors voting aye. - Item 2: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The motion was made by Chair Melgar, with all supervisors voting aye. Both items were placed on the February 7, 2023 Board of Supervisors' agenda.

PUBLIC WORKS 37% · PROCEDURAL 24% · PUBLIC COMMENT 23% · NIGHTLIFE REGULATION 16%
1082
JAN 26, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Public Safety Committee Meeting - January 26, 2023: Four Liquor License Approvals

The committee, chaired by Acting Chair Matt Dorsey with Supervisor Joel Engardio, convened on January 26, 2023 at 6:15 PM to consider four liquor license applications. All items received positive recommendations to the full Board of Supervisors with unanimous 2-0 votes. Item 1: Liquor License Transfer - Postscript, 499 Jackson Street - Applicant Postscript Collective LLC sought a Type 21 off-sale license for a specialty grocery store. No letters of protest or support were filed. The location is in a high crime area (plot 140) and high saturation census tract (61101). SFPD recommended approval with a condition to prevent loitering. The committee voted to forward the item as a committee report for the January 31, 2023 Board meeting. Item 2: Liquor License Transfer - Bar Agricole, 1540 Mission Street - Applicant Bar Agricole Inc. sought a Type 21 off-sale license for a retail shop complementing its restaurant. Two letters of support, zero protest. The site is in a high crime area (plot 204) and high saturation census tract (177). SFPD recommended approval without additional conditions. The committee voted to forward the item as a committee report for the January 31, 2023 Board meeting. Item 3: Liquor License - SinombreSF, 312 Harriet Street - Applicant CN Nombre SF LLC sought a Type 48 on-sale public premises license for a post-pandemic recovery project. No letters of protest or support. Located in a high crime area (plot 268) and high saturation census tract (180). SFPD recommended approval with two conditions: prevent loitering and ensure entertainment is not audible at nearby residences. The committee voted to forward with positive recommendation. Item 4: Liquor License Transfers - Total Wine & More, 1750 Harrison Street - Applicant California Wine and Spirits LLC sought Type 21, 42, and 86 licenses for a new store at a former OfficeMax site. Two letters of protest were under ABC review; zero support letters. Located in a high crime area (plot 405) and high saturation census tract (177). SFPD recommended approval with a condition to prevent loitering. The committee voted to forward with positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - All four items were approved by a 2-0 vote (Supervisor Engardio and Acting Chair Dorsey). Items 1 and 2 were specifically designated as committee reports for the Board of Supervisors meeting on January 31, 2023. Items 3 and 4 will be forwarded to a future Board meeting (expected on February 7, 2023 unless otherwise stated). No public comments were received on any item.

LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 52% · PROCEDURAL 35% · REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 9% · PUBLIC COMMENT 4%
1083
JAN 24, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - January 24, 2023: Elections, Burton Tribute, Bond Issuance, and Waterfront Plan

The Port Commission met on Tuesday, January 24, 2023, starting at 10:30 AM and adjourning at approximately 5:53 PM. The meeting included elections for commission leadership, a tribute to departing Commissioner John L. Burton, public comment on union organizing, approval of a long-term lease for the historic SS Jeremiah O'Brien, authorization of a $42 million seawall bond issuance, and an informational presentation on revisions to the Waterfront Plan. All votes were unanimous unless noted. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2301: Adopted findings under state urgency legislation to allow remote meeting attendance during the COVID-19 emergency (unanimous). - Resolution 2302: Retroactively authorized modification of construction contract 2795 (Heronshead Park Path and Electrical Improvements) extending the substantial completion date by 71 days to a total of 269 days (unanimous). - Resolution 2303: Authorized execution of a grant agreement with the San Francisco Parks Alliance to accept $3,250,000 for proposed Crane Cove Park enhancements (unanimous). Public Comments & Testimony - Public Comment on Non-Agenda Items (Alcatraz Cruises Unionization): - Robert Estrada (IBU Regional Director) reported that Alcatraz Cruises workers voted 82% to unionize in September 2022, but only one bargaining session has occurred. He stated the company disputes the inclusion of captains in the union, even though captains were the first to seek representation. He noted that a negotiating team member was terminated the day after the first session, allegedly for leaving drips in a coffee drip tray. He expressed concern that the company is delaying negotiations and urged the commission to support the workers. - Robert Hedrick (Snack bar attendant, Alcatraz City Cruises) said he earns $19/hour, which is insufficient to live in San Francisco, and that scheduling is unstable. He asked for the commission's support to achieve a fair contract. - Jack Alvin (Deckhand, Alcatraz City Cruises) stated that the company has been slow to negotiate and that workers have been ready to meet in good faith. He asked the port to help ensure their rights to collectively bargain are respected. - Tristan Senough (Senior deckhand, Alcatraz Cruises) said the captains were the first to organize and that the company is trying to divide workers by claiming captains are supervisors. He noted that the NLRB has ruled that the company must negotiate over the captains' inclusion. He asked the port to support unity among workers. - Commissioner John L. Burton, in his final meeting, expressed strong support for the union, stating he would walk the picket line if necessary and contribute to the strike fund. He called the company's stance unfair and contrary to other waterfront operators. - Public Comment on Executive Director's Report: - Ellen Jonk (Co-chair, Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee) spoke in support of Commissioner Burton, thanking him for his service and leadership on maritime and labor issues. Discussion Items Election of Port Commission President and Vice President (Item 9A) - Commissioner Burton nominated Kimberly Brandon for President; no other nominations. Public comment was none. The commission voted unanimously to elect Kimberly Brandon as Port Commission President for 2023. - Commissioner Brandon nominated Willie Adams for Vice President; no other nominations. The commission voted unanimously to elect Willie Adams as Vice President. Both expressed gratitude and commitment to the port's work in 2023. Executive Director's Report (Item 9B) - Director Elaine Forbes reported on the port's response to January 2023 atmospheric rivers, noting that the port team deployed sandbags, cleared drains, secured assets, and managed power outages. She highlighted the port's financial recovery: a profit of $15.7 million in FY2022 compared to a loss of $47.9 million the prior year, achieving balanced operating expenses to revenues. - She announced a banner year expected for cruise calls, continued waterfront activation (including commercial crabbing and Dungeness crab season opening December 31), and a youth-focused field trip on sea level rise held January 20 with Abraham Lincoln High School and the Exploratorium. - Forbes noted that the port has completed 24 community engagements on the draft Waterfront Adaptation Strategies, connecting with 450 community members. Feedback prioritizes flooding safety and indicates that lower sea-level rise strategies are insufficient. She also mentioned a $50 million FEMA grant application for the Downtown Coastal Resilient Project. - The report concluded with a tribute to Commissioner Burton, highlighting his role in securing $117 million in ARPA funding, which prevented layoffs and allowed the port to rebuild staffing and equipment. Multiple staff members (Dominic Reno, Nate Cruz, Boris Elpin, Tim Felton) spoke in appreciation of Burton's advocacy and legacy. Maritime Lease – SS Jeremiah O'Brien at Pier 35 (Item 11A) - Deputy Director Andre Coleman and Dimitri Amara presented a proposed 10-year lease (with one 5-year option) for the National Liberty Ship Memorial to berth the SS Jeremiah O'Brien at Pier 35 North, relocating from Pier 45 after the 2020 shed fire. The lease includes 732 sq ft of land, 18,500 sq ft of apron, and 48,000 sq ft of submerged land. - Base rent increases from $2,351/month to $3,661/month, with 5% increases every five years. Participation rent rises to 7.5% for tickets and 10% for film/retail. The tenant commits $50,000 in improvements (gate, safety railing, security lighting). - Commissioners expressed strong support, noting the vessel's historical significance and educational value. Commissioner Lee applauded the preservation effort. Vice President Adams emphasized the need to preserve such relics for younger generations. The item was approved unanimously via Resolution 2304. Waterfront Resilience Program – Second Bond Issuance (Item 12A) - Brad Benson and Nate Cruz presented a request to issue $42 million in Proposition A seawall bonds (second issuance) to fund early projects, adaptation strategies, and the Army Corps of Engineers flood study. Total appropriations to date would reach $106.5 million. - The funds will support pre-design and detailed design of six Embarcadero early projects, including the Wharf J9 project, Pier 15 bulkhead retrofit, Ferry Building seawall upgrade, and the Downtown Coastal Resilience Project. A third issuance is planned for 2024 for construction. - Commissioners noted the challenging interest rate environment and the importance of moving quickly. Vice President Adams warned of potential federal debt ceiling fights. The resolution (2305) was approved unanimously. Informational Presentation on Waterfront Plan Revisions (Item 13A) - Diane Oshima presented proposed final revisions to the Draft Waterfront Plan, incorporating public comments from swim clubs (Dolphin and South End), SFMTA, BCDC, and others. Key revisions include: - Explicitly including open-water swimming as a water recreation activity on the entire waterfront. - Updating transportation terminology from “alternative modes” to “low carbon” to align with city climate goals. - Updating policy 21 to reflect that the Embarcadero Blue Greenway connection has been created and should be maintained. - Oshima also outlined interagency coordination with the Planning Department (to align General Plan elements and zoning) and with BCDC (to remove the 50% replacement fill rule and geographic vicinities, allowing a unified approach across the entire 7.5-mile waterfront). - Discussion focused on the Embarcadero promenade: Commissioner Brandon and others expressed concern that the plan language could be interpreted to allow cyclists on the promenade, which they want reserved for pedestrians. Oshima offered to delete references to cyclists on the promenade in the text. Director Forbes noted that the port code change would be the ultimate mechanism. Commissioner Gilman requested that the 50% rule be removed for the entire waterfront, not just the northeast. The item was informational only; no vote was taken. Key Outcomes - Elections: Kimberly Brandon elected President, Willie Adams elected Vice President for 2023 (unanimous). - Consent Calendar: Resolutions 2301, 2302, 2303 adopted unanimously. - Lease Resolution 2304: Approved unanimously – 10-year lease for SS Jeremiah O'Brien at Pier 35. - Bond Resolution 2305: Approved unanimously – $42 million second issuance of seawall bonds. - Waterfront Plan: Informational only; staff will incorporate commission direction on promenade language and return for action on February 14, 2023. - New Business: Commissioner Gilman requested an interdepartmental informational hearing on street vending, particularly alcohol and cannabis sales, inviting DPH, SFPD, and DPW. Commissioner Lee requested a list of available leases and information on how to post contract/job opportunities for small businesses, and an update on port staffing and hiring challenges. Director Forbes acknowledged the issues and will work to bring updates. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of the victims of the Monterey Park and Half Moon Bay mass shootings. Motion passed unanimously.

PUBLIC COMMENT 18% · PROCEDURAL 17% · LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 13% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 13%
1084
JAN 24, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting – January 24, 2023

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a hybrid teleconference meeting on January 24, 2023, beginning at 9:45 AM. Vice Chair Sophie Maxwell presided, with Commissioners Paulson, Rivera, and Stacy present (President Ajami excused). The meeting covered drought conditions, hiring process improvements, a major power scheduling contract amendment, and approvals for workspace at the new Southeast Community Center. All votes were unanimous (4-0). Consent Calendar - Approved three routine contracts: (1) Award of Contract No. WD-2889, As-Needed Water Service Line Replacements, $26,663,850 to JMB Construction, Inc.; (2) Acceptance of work for Contract No. WW-687, Force Main Rehabilitation at Embarcadero and Jackson, total $7,835,217; (3) Approval of a 365-calendar-day increase to contract duration contingency for Contract No. WW-697, As-Needed Main Sewer Replacement No. 8, with JDB & Sons Construction, Inc. Public Comments & Testimony - Drought Update (Item 6a): Peter Drekmeier (Tuolumne River Trust) noted the SFPUC has great water rights and expressed concern that excess water is being released rather than kept for environmental flows. Dave Warner (Palo Alto resident) argued the system had over five years of supply at the drought’s low point and highlighted impacts on Tuolumne salmon. Lindy Higgs (Modesto resident) made an emotional plea for a healthier Tuolumne River. - Hiring Process (Item 6b): One caller alleged corruption and employee targeting at the SFPUC; Peter Drekmeier thanked Commissioner Maxwell for pursuing the issue and urged that information requests be tracked on the advance calendar. - Water Supply Assessment (Item 9): Peter Drekmeier repeated a call for a joint workshop between the Planning Department and SFPUC to better align water supply and development decisions. - General Public Comment (Item 15): Multiple speakers (Paul Wormer, Dave Warner, Elliott Hellman, Aliva Dupree, Jennifer Hagee) urged the Commission to approve a proposed MOU with LAFCO to fund studies on green banking, natural gas decommissioning, battery storage, EV charging, and climate action plan implementation. Dave Warner also criticized General Manager Herrera for not fully participating in Bay Area Water Stewards meetings and requested commissioner attendance. Discussion Items Drought Conditions Update (Item 6a) – Steve Ritchie, Assistant GM for Water, presented a brightening water supply picture: - Hetch Hetchy Reservoir storage at 291,000 acre-feet (capacity 360,000), with heavy snowpack making a fill likely. - Water bank storage is full; Calaveras Reservoir is full and spilling. - Statewide, Shasta and Oroville reservoirs have recovered significantly (104% and 87% of average, respectively). - Precipitation at Hetch Hetchy to date exceeds the 1983 wettest-year record line, but the season is not over. - Bay Area year-to-date precipitation is 5 inches above average. - Customer demand remains low; the 11% conservation target is being exceeded. - Final water supply declarations for wholesale customers will be made in mid-April. Hiring Process Overview (Item 6b) – Wendy Macy, Chief People Officer, outlined SFPUC’s hiring challenges and reforms: - Hiring is governed by city charter, Civil Service rules, and DHR. The SFPUC’s average time-to-hire (78 days for permanent civil service) compares favorably to other departments but remains a competitive disadvantage. - Key internal initiatives: prioritization dashboards, lean process improvements (eliminating redundant steps), and an “Exempt to Permanent” program to transition temporary staff. - SFPUC is advocating for citywide changes: continuous testing cycles and remote testing options to widen candidate pools and increase equity. - Retention strategies include flexible hybrid work, exit surveys, and engagement surveys. - Commissioner Maxwell pressed for more detail on baseline vacancy rates, classification-specific issues, and measurable progress; she asked for a follow-up report in late February. BAWSCA Report (Item 7) – Nicole Sandkulla, CEO of Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency, presented results of a survey of member agencies’ drought response actions: - Of 26 agencies, 20 have advanced metering infrastructure; 19 enforce two-day-per-week watering schedules; 24 have rebate and conservation programs. - Unique actions highlighted: Daly City seeking new recycled water customers; Menlo Park implementing a drought surcharge; San Jose banning high-water-use turf and overhead sprinklers in new construction. - Sandkulla thanked SFPUC staff for skilled management during recent storms and pledged continued coordination. Power Scheduling Contract Amendment (Item 13) – Barbara Hale, Assistant GM for Power, requested a $636 million increase to Contract No. PRO.0152 with APX Inc (total not to exceed $895,742,800) to cover higher pass-through payments to the California ISO: - Higher wholesale electricity prices driven by global factors (Ukraine war, natural gas exports, China reopening, supply chain delays) and regional events (September 2022 heat dome). - The contract’s capacity was being consumed faster than anticipated; a first amendment (executed Jan. 6, 2023) added $125 million to bridge to this regular approval. - The requested increase is based on forward price projections for 2023–2024. - No change to contract scope or duration. - Commissioners noted the irony of a public power agency facing market volatility; staff explained that Hetch Hetchy benefits from selling surplus power at high prices, while CleanPowerSF may require rate increases later in spring. Southeast Community Center Leases and Licenses (Items 11 & 12) – Rosanna Russell, Real Estate Director, presented approvals for below-market workspace for nonprofits: - Item 11 (Licenses): Approved two below-market licenses (month-to-month, 18-month max) for Charity Cultural Services (2 workstations) and Five Keys Schools and Programs (1 workstation) at $437/month each (50% of FMV plus service fee). Also approved an amendment to SFPUC Real Estate Guidelines (Section 4.4.1) to delegate authority to the General Manager to approve future similar market licenses for the Community Hub. - Item 12 (Leases): Approved five-year below-market leases for Third Street Youth Center and Clinic ($3,804/month), Into Action Incorporated ($4,708/month), and Five Keys Schools and Programs ($4,487/month) for a total of 5,771 rentable square feet on the third floor of the Southeast Community Center. Rents are at 50% of appraised FMV with 3% annual escalations. - The center is attracting strong demand; staff reported a waiting list for programming and that the building is already active. Key Outcomes - Item 3: Unanimously adopted renewed findings for hybrid meetings under COVID-19 urgency legislation. - Item 4: Minutes of January 10, 2023 approved. - Item 5: Retirement resolution for Jack Lum (35 years) adopted with appreciation. - Item 8: Consent Calendar approved (three contracts). - Item 9: Water Supply Assessment for 395 Third Street approved. - Item 10: Authorized acceptance and expenditure of state funds ($92,119 for 212 Hetch Hetchy Power accounts; $1,244,798 for CleanPowerSF customers) for COVID-19 arrearage relief under the California Arrearage Payment Program (CAP22). Credits to be applied by February 5, 2023. - Item 11: Approved two below-market licenses at Southeast Community Center and amended real estate guidelines to delegate future similar approvals to the General Manager. - Item 12: Approved three below-market leases for nonprofits at Southeast Community Center. - Item 13: Approved second amendment to Contract PRO.0152 with APX Inc, increasing capacity by $636 million (total $895,742,800) and authorized the General Manager to seek Board of Supervisors approval for the amendment and an increase to the administrative cap under Admin Code Section 2143. - Item 16: Commissioner Maxwell directed staff to return with a detailed hiring process update in late February; Commissioner Stacy received information about past water supply workshops and the Bay Area Water Stewards meetings.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 24% · HUMAN RESOURCES 23% · PROCEDURAL 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13%
1085
JAN 23, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - January 23, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on January 23, 2023, to consider four items: amendments to support nighttime entertainment in the SoMa Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District, a grocery store replacement in the Polk Street Neighborhood Commercial District, a resolution supporting affordable housing at the DMV site on Fell Street, and the adoption of the Housing Element 2022 Update. The committee heard public testimony, debated each item, and voted to advance them to the full Board of Supervisors. Item 1: SoMa Nighttime Entertainment Uses (Planning Code Amendment) - Overview: Supervisor Dorsey introduced legislation to allow nighttime entertainment as a principally permitted use in the Folsom Street corridor and Western SoMa, removing existing 200-foot buffers that had created a de facto moratorium on new entertainment venues. The Planning Commission recommended approval with clerical amendments to expand the scope. - Public Comment: No public comment was offered. - Discussion: Supervisor Dorsey described the history of queer nightlife in SoMa and the need to support the Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District. Planning staff presented the recommended amendments. The committee voted to adopt the amendments and continue the item to the next committee meeting for final approval. Item 2: Grocery Stores in Polk Street Neighborhood Commercial District - Overview: President Peskin introduced a narrowly tailored ordinance to allow ByRite grocery to replace the former Real Foods location at 2200 Polk Street, expanding into an adjoining space. The Planning Commission had recommended a broader expansion to all NCDs, but Peskin limited the scope to this specific site. - Public Comment: One caller, Linda Chapman from Knob Hill Neighbors, expressed general support for larger grocery stores but noted that the area south of the site also needs grocery access. She also mentioned the loss of other grocery stores in the area. - Discussion: Supervisor Preston added as co-sponsor and praised ByRite’s community involvement on Divisadero. The committee adopted findings of public necessity and sent the item to the full board as a committee report. Item 3: Supporting Affordable Housing at the DMV Site (1377 Fell Street) - Overview: Supervisor Preston introduced a resolution urging the state to prioritize affordable housing at the state-owned DMV field office site, which occupies an entire city block at Fell and Divisadero Streets. The DMV had recently released a Request for Interest (RFI) for housing development on the site. - Public Comment: Several callers supported the resolution, including Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition), who noted the need to address the 110 parking spaces required by the RFI, and Alan Burradell, who expressed skepticism about the term "affordable housing" citing past failures. Others from the Tenants Union and SF YIMBY praised the effort. - Discussion: Planning Director Rich Hillis confirmed the site is well-suited for housing. Supervisor Preston noted the site could yield 200-350 units depending on whether the DMV office is retained or relocated. The committee voted to send the resolution to the full board. Item 4: Housing Element 2022 Update - Overview: The committee considered the adoption of the General Plan Housing Element update, which sets goals for 82,000 new housing units (46,500 affordable) over eight years. The state Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) had issued a preliminary certification letter. The plan includes strategies to rezone western neighborhoods, streamline permitting, and affirmatively further fair housing. - Public Comment: Over 20 callers spoke, with many from the Race and Equity in All Planning (REP) coalition and housing advocacy groups. Key themes: support for the plan but concern about implementation, need for dedicated affordable housing funding (especially from Proposition I), frustration with the Mayor’s Office of Housing (MOHCD) for not spending allocated funds on acquisitions, and calls for land banking and social housing studies. - Discussion: Extensive debate among committee members. Supervisor Preston criticized the lack of enforceability and the administration’s failure to use available funds (e.g., Prop I, COP deal funds) for site acquisitions. Director Hillis and MOHCD Director Shaw defended the city’s production record and noted ongoing efforts to improve acquisition processes. Supervisor Melgar highlighted infrastructure needs on the west side. The item was sent to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Amended and continued to next committee meeting. - Item 2: Approved as a committee report (unanimous). - Item 3: Approved as a committee report (unanimous). - Item 4: Approved as a committee report (2-0, with President Peskin excused).

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 56% · PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · LAND BANKING 8% · HOUSING CRISIS ACT 4%
1086
JAN 19, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - January 19, 2023: LBE Disparity Study Resolution and Closed Session Settlements

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on January 19, 2023, at 10:15 a.m. (local time) to consider a resolution urging the City Administrator to conduct a disparity study of the Local Business Enterprise (LBE) program and to discuss 11 settlement and litigation items in closed session. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the resolution to the full board and to forward the closed‑session items with a positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Hanley Chan (disabled veteran, San Francisco native) expressed strong support for the study, noting that the state has a Disabled Veteran Business Enterprise (DVBE) program and asking why the city cannot do the same. He urged the committee to "make history." - Courtney Ellington (Veterans Affairs Commissioner, woman‑, minority‑, and service‑disabled veteran‑owned business) supported the research but questioned whether the study would address the real problem of contracts not being fulfilled. She cited personal experience of being listed as a subcontractor but never contacted after the prime contractor won the bid. - Omar Farmer (veteran, black male, San Francisco entrepreneur) fully supported the disparity study, stating it would bring more aspiring small business owners into the fold and lead to more equitable outcomes. - Ann Travantes (San Francisco Latino and Black Builders Association) recommended not conducting a full‑blown disparity study, noting that existing data from the SFTA disparity study could be used. She reported a 78% drop in African American‑owned businesses and a 75% drop in Latino‑owned businesses in the city since 2004. She also stressed the need for enforcement and for departments to resume tracking data as they did before Proposition 209. - Alex Chu (President, San Francisco Coalition for Economic Equity) strongly supported the study, calling it long overdue, and noted that minority‑owned businesses have struggled even before the pandemic. - Bruce Giron (President, National Association of Minority Contractors, Northern California chapter) supported the study with urgency, stating that Proposition 209 has been "more effective psychologically than it ever was envisioned to be" and that a disparity study is a necessary first line of defense against an unfair infrastructure. - Dr. Matthew Ajra K (President, San Francisco African American Chamber of Commerce) warned that a disparity study could confirm the decimation of African American businesses caused by Proposition 209, thereby showing no availability and leading to a circular argument. He urged the city to create programs to ensure businesses exist before the study confirms their absence. - Lamar Heisteck (President, Asian Inc.) stood shoulder‑to‑shoulder with other organizations, thanked Supervisor Melgar for sponsoring the resolution, and noted that LBEs hire locally and are a workforce development solution. He also mentioned that the Contract Monitoring Division already has utilization data and that a disparity study has been long overdue. Discussion Items - Resolution 221209 – Urging the City Administrator to Conduct an LBE Disparity Study - Sponsor: Supervisor Mirna Melgar introduced the resolution, explaining that the LBE program has never been measured since its inception following Proposition 209. She emphasized the need to analyze disparities for women‑owned, minority‑owned, and disabled veteran‑owned businesses, particularly in the context of pandemic recovery. She noted that small businesses, especially those owned by disadvantaged groups, had less access to capital and bureaucratic support. - Presentation by City Administrator’s Office: Deputy City Administrator Rachel and Project Manager Ann Tan presented an overview of what a disparity study entails. Key points: - A disparity study compares business utilization (contracts awarded) to business availability (businesses ready, willing, and able). - Typically includes legal review, utilization analysis, availability analysis, qualitative research, and recommendations. - Many jurisdictions have conducted such studies; costs range from $400,000 to $1 million, and completion takes one to three years. - The City Administrator’s Office already started internal research to prepare for the study and can begin developing the solicitation immediately to save time once funding is available. - Committee Discussion: - Supervisor Chan asked about immediate changes that could be made without waiting for the study. Deputy City Administrator Rachel cited low‑hanging fruit such as centralizing information and outreach to small businesses. - Supervisor Mandelman asked about common themes from other jurisdictions’ findings. Ann Tan mentioned unbundling large contracts, networking, mentoring, and addressing upstream issues like access to capital. - Supervisor Mandelman also asked about the one‑to‑three‑year timeline. Ann Tan explained that data harmonization across departments and thorough qualitative research take time. The committee encouraged parallel work on immediate improvements. - Chair Preston, Vice Chair Chan, and Supervisor Mandelman all added their names as co‑sponsors of the resolution. Key Outcomes - Vote on Resolution 221209: The committee voted unanimously (3‑0) to recommend the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors. (Vice Chair Chan aye, Member Mandelman aye, Chair Preston aye.) - Closed Session (Items 2–12): The committee convened in closed session to discuss 11 settlement and litigation items (settlements ranging from $0 to $1,399,196, including claims by SEIU, Margarita Herrera, Dante King, Michael Oakes, Jo‑Theresa Elias‑Jackson, Cassandra McQuaid, Osterweis Capital Management, AT&T Mobility, A2Z Development USA, AmerisourceBergen, and a tolling agreement for the Sir Francis Drake Hotel). - Vote to Forward: The committee voted unanimously to forward items 2–12 with a positive recommendation to the full board. - Vote to Not Disclose: The committee voted unanimously (3‑0) not to disclose the closed session discussion. - Next Steps: The resolution and the settlement items will appear on the Board of Supervisors’ agenda on January 31, 2023.

PROCEDURAL 35% · LOCAL BUSINESS ENTERPRISE 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · PENDING LITIGATION 13%
1087
JAN 18, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - January 18, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on January 18, 2023, at 1:45 PM to address a full agenda including public comment, consent calendar items, departmental reports, consideration of a revised Field Training Program DGO, the SFPD budget, a collaborative reform update, and a closed session. Key themes included staffing shortages, crime trends, police accountability, and community concerns about unsolved cases, racial disparities, and the Tenderloin drug market. Consent Calendar - SFPD SB 1421 and SB 16 Report & DPA SB 1421 and SB 16 Report: The commission voted unanimously (7-0) to receive and file the reports. No public comment was offered. Public Comments & Testimony - Paulette Brown (mother of Aubrey Abacasa, murdered in 2006) pleaded for justice, stating that a $250,000 reward has not been paid and that perpetrators' names are known. She urged the commission not to let her pleas fall on deaf ears. - David Elliott Lewis (civilian member of SFPD Crisis Intervention Training team) raised critical staffing shortages: the CIT unit is down to 3 active members out of a minimum need of 8, impairing its national model training and response capacity. - Susan Buckman (District 6, volunteer with Parity for the Black Community) expressed frustration over persistent anti-black disparities in use of force, arrests, and traffic stops. She questioned data changes in the Q2 2022 report that showed a drop from Black people being 15 times more likely to face force to 9 times, while 'unknown/other' race reports doubled. - Prativoteki (Tenderloin Housing Clinic, Central City SOROT Collaborative) criticized the city for treating the Tenderloin as a containment zone for open-air drug dealing and demanded a clear community policing plan. - Gloria Barry (District 10) urged SFPD to finalize evidence in the Collier Gwynn case (homeless woman assault) and stated that commission meetings do not constitute community outreach, echoing a prior comment by Commissioner Walker. - Francisco De Costa highlighted inconsistencies in reward amounts for homicide tips and alleged that police misled the community about a victim's condition. - Kate Haj (volunteer with Parity for Black Community) echoed concerns about data transparency and criticized community policing implementation as officers standing in groups rather than engaging with residents. - Ramona Burton (sister of Mark Anthony Coates) called for revisiting the tip reward process and deploying more functional cameras in areas with gunshot detection. - Additional public comment during the Chief's Report: Paulette Brown returned to discuss ghost guns; Gloria Barry noted a typo in the meeting access code and warned against criminalizing homeless individuals who refuse services. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 3): Chief William Scott provided an update on significant incidents, including: the investigation into a person sprayed with a water hose (ongoing, working with DA); a catalytic converter theft where suspects fired at officers (one in custody); 17 car break-ins on Filbert Street (January 15); three shooting incidents (including four victims in one Mission district incident); a juvenile robbery on January 14 (three suspects arrested). The department's community liaison unit offered services to 8 crime victims that week. Corrections to crime trend data (robbery arrow direction) were noted. Commissioners discussed the Collier Gwynn arrest warrant (confirmed), the live-monitoring ordinance (not yet used), the MLU negotiations (meeting with mediator scheduled), and a federal injunction on homeless encampments (no change). Commissioner Yee asked about a shooting spike in the Mission (four in one incident) and community violence response. Commissioner Yannis announced confidential gun drop-off option at district stations and inquired about future gun buybacks (United Players holds two per year). - DPA Director's Report (Item 4): Director Paul Henderson reported that so far in 2023, DPA has opened 17 cases, closed 17, with 271 pending open (0 sustained or mediated). 31 cases have exceeded nine months; 21 are tolled due to ancillary litigation. A know-your-rights training was held for 40 students at John O'Connell High School. DPA and the Controller are completing a follow-up review of SFPD's 24-month responses to the 2020 use of force audit; results are due back from SFPD on January 20. Future reports will include outstanding issues related to late filings in investigations, audit, and policy. - Commission Reports (Item 5): Commissioner Benedicto updated on DGO progress: 5.16 (search warrants) nearing final commission action, 7.01 (juveniles) advancing, 10.11 (body cameras) and 3.01 deadlines being monitored. Vice President Carter Oberstone honored former deputy city attorney Zach Porianda for his service. Commissioner Yee reported meeting with Ingleside station captain and APAC; community concerns about crime reporting for monolingual speakers. Commissioner Yannis mentioned ongoing work on juvenile DGO, early intervention system, social media DGO, and community policing manual. President Elias thanked DPA and IA for training on discipline at Richmond station. - Department General Order 3.13 – Field Training Program (Item 6): The commission approved (7-0) the revised DGO (last updated 1998) authorizing the department to meet and confer with bargaining units. The motion included instructions to negotiate only on matters within scope of representation and to avoid unreasonable delays. A public comment asked about incorporating community interaction training; no other public testimony was offered. - SFPD Budget Update (Item 7): CFO Patrick Leong presented a detailed budget overview. Key points: The mayor instructed departments to reduce 5% of adjusted general fund support (additional 3% next year). SFPD priorities are hiring/recruitment (64 new hires in 2022), overtime ($47.2M actual vs $14.6M budgeted last year), technology (new RMS system), management support, and civilianization. Sworn staffing stands at 1,788 (including 28 recruits), down 331 officers in 3 years, with 384 eligible to retire. The city is 537 officers below the Prop E staffing recommendation of 2,182. Response times are deteriorating: Priority A calls over 9 minutes (target 8), Priority B over 33 minutes (target 20), Priority C over 76 minutes (target 60). Calls for service dropped 38% since 2019, primarily due to reduction in officers' on-view activity. Violent crime is up 6.2% for 2022. Commissioners questioned retirement eligibility, response time drivers, civil dispute calls, budget allocations (90% wages), interdepartmental charges, SB 960 non-citizen hiring, body camera holster activation, training budget, and civilianization efforts. Public comment included calls to address attrition and conduct a needs assessment. - Collaborative Reform Initiative Quarterly Update (Item 8): Sergeant Gabriel Rivera reported that of 272 original recommendations, 245 are substantially compliant, leaving 27 open. Sustainability efforts continue; a contract with Jensen Hughes was finalized. Four project plans address remaining recommendations: use of force/arrest data collection; data-informed personnel development; community policing (manuals and plans); and management tools/discipline metrics. Standalone recommendations include complaint data aggregation, strategic plan, community policing manual, and disparate deadly force analysis (timeline extended). The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to receive and file the report. - Closed Session Items (Items 9-12): After public comment on closed session matters, the commission voted to proceed into closed session. Upon return, the commission voted (unanimously) to not disclose Item 11 except for Items 11C and 11D, which Commissioner Benedicto argued fall outside the scope of representation and are legally required to be public under the Brown Act. This mirrors a prior transparency action from October 12, 2022. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved unanimously. - DGO 3.13 (Field Training Program): Approved for meet and confer with specific instructions on scope of bargaining. - SFPD Budget Update: Received; a follow-up presentation is scheduled for February 8, 2023. - Collaborative Reform Initiative Update: Received and filed. - Closed Session Disclosure: Only Items 11C and 11D will be made public; all other closed session discussions remain undisclosed.

PROCEDURAL 30% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 28% · PUBLIC SAFETY 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
1088
JAN 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - January 11, 2023: Pretext Stops Policy Adopted

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, January 11, 2023, at approximately 1:45 PM. The primary agenda item was the discussion and approval of Department General Order (DGO) 9.07, "Curtailing the Use of Pretext Stops." After extensive public comment and deliberation, the commission voted 4-2-1 to adopt the policy, directing the department to meet and confer with bargaining units while limiting the scope of negotiations. The meeting also included a presentation on the Homicide Reward Fund, the Chief’s report on crime trends, and routine consent calendar items. Consent Calendar - The commission voted unanimously to receive and file the following reports: Police Commission reports of disciplinary actions for Q4 2022, DGO 1102 Annual Report, Safe Streets Q3 2022, Third Quarter Bias Audit Report 2022, and the Third Quarter Report for the FDRB. Public Comments & Testimony - Homicide Victims’ Families: Ramona Burton (sister of Mark Anthony Coates, Sr., murdered Dec. 7, 2019) and another speaker (mother of a murdered son) urged the commission to improve the homicide reward process and allocate more resources to solve unsolved cases. Ms. Burton noted her brother’s reward was raised to $100,000 and questioned its effectiveness. - Pretext Stops Policy: Dozens of speakers commented on DGO 9.07. Supporters, including members of the “Coalition to End Bias Stops” (Glide, ACLU, Public Defender’s Office, Bar Association, etc.), argued that pretext stops are racially biased, ineffective, and a wasteful use of resources. They cited data showing Black San Franciscans are stopped at six times the rate of whites and searched at ten times the rate. Opponents, including Frank Noto (Stop Crime Action), expressed concerns that reducing stops would lead to more crime and traffic accidents, and that the policy should emphasize “deprioritization” rather than a ban. Several Asian American community members called for more outreach before finalizing the policy. - General: A speaker from the community urged daily gun buyback programs and better support for victims. Discussion Items - Presentation on Homicide Rewards (Item 7): CFO Patrick Leong and Captain Ahern presented the Homicide Reward Fund, established in 2016. There are 17 active reward cases (19 victims) with amounts up to $250,000. The last payout was in 2013 ($2,500). Commissioners discussed the high bar for payout (must lead to arrest, prosecution, and conviction) and considered alternative models with lower thresholds for anonymous tips. - Chief’s Report (Item 4): Chief Scott reported year-to-date crime statistics: violent crime down 18%, property crimes down 38%, but homicides up 100% (2 vs. 1). He highlighted a tragic shooting on Jan. 4 at Japan Center Mall where a 15-year-old killed a security guard; two arrests made. Fentanyl seizures in 2022 nearly doubled to 65,367 grams. He also updated on the MOU with the District Attorney and the surveillance policy tracking forms. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 5): Executive Director Henderson reported 6 new cases opened (vs. 13 last year), 277 open cases pending. Top allegations were officer behavior/speech and failure to take required action. He noted release of an audit on SFPD compliance with First Amendment activity guidelines for 2021. - Commission Reports (Item 6): Commissioners reported on ride-alongs (Tenderloin), working group progress, and scheduling of future items. Vice President Carter-Overstone requested agenda time to discuss compliance with DGO 3.01 deadlines for revising DGO 8.10 (First Amendment activities). Commissioner Yanez requested a focused conversation on the RIPA report recommendations. - DGO 9.07 – Pretext Stops (Item 8): The commission heard a presentation from retired Chief Harold Medlock of Fayetteville, NC, who implemented a policy to eliminate stops for regulatory violations and focus on moving violations (speeding, reckless, DWI, red lights, stop signs). He reported that crime, complaints, and use of force all decreased while community trust increased. Following the presentation and public comment, commissioners debated amendments. Chief Scott expressed support for the policy after “ban” language was removed and suggested adding “deprioritization” language. Commissioner Byrne moved to table for inclusion of chief’s language, but the motion was not voted on after the main motion passed. Several amendments were added: five non-substantive changes (e.g., “sun down” changed to “darkness”) and one substantive change adding “articulable facts” to the definition of reasonable suspicion. The final motion from Commissioner Benedicto included three specific instructions for the meet-and-confer process: (1) direct SFPD and DHR not to bargain on management matters, (2) set clear boundaries to prevent unreasonable delays, and (3) appoint DPA policy director Janelle Kwood as subject matter expert at bargaining sessions. Key Outcomes - DGO 9.07 Adopted (4-2-1): The commission voted to approve draft DGO 9.07 and send it to meet and confer with affected bargaining units. Voting yes: Commissioners Benedicto, Yannis, Vice President Carter-Overstone, and President Elias. Voting no: Commissioners Byrne and Yee. Commissioner Walker was absent. - Instructions for Meet-and-Confer: The commission directed SFPD and the Department of Human Resources not to meet and confer on parts of the DGO that constitute management matters under California law, to set clear boundaries to avoid unreasonable delays, and to allow Janelle Kwood to attend bargaining sessions as a subject matter expert. - Homicide Reward Presentation Acknowledged: Commissioners requested additional data on tip outcomes and agreed to revisit the topic with comparisons to other jurisdictions. - Consent Calendar Approved Unanimously: Routine reports were received and filed. - Minutes Approved: The minutes of December 7 and 14, 2022, were adopted unanimously. - Closed Session: The commission voted unanimously to go into closed session (Item 12) and later voted not to disclose any discussion. - Item 9 (Parental Leave Policy): Was removed from the agenda without discussion. Note: The meeting concluded with the closed session and vote on disclosure. No further action was taken on the chief’s proposed language, but President Elias directed staff to post it for future consideration.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 36% · PROCEDURAL 33% · PUBLIC SAFETY 13% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 6%
1089
JAN 10, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - January 10, 2023

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on January 10, 2023, via teleconference due to the ongoing COVID-19 health emergency. The meeting included reports on drought conditions, capital improvement projects, and approval of several contracts and rate schedules. Commissioners also heard extensive public comment on the recent decision to move general public comment to the end of the agenda and ultimately decided to continue a proposed memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the San Francisco Local Agency Formation Commission (SF LAFCO) for further discussion. Consent Calendar - Item 6: Consent calendar approved unanimously (5-0). Items included routine approvals and actions. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 4 (Approval of Minutes): Multiple callers expressed concerns about the December 13, 2022 minutes, specifically regarding the decision to move general public comment later in the agenda. Callers requested more detail in the minutes and argued the change was a substantive shift that hindered public participation. - On Item 5a (Drought Update): Public comments urged the commission to take a year off the drought designation, drop litigation against the state water board, and increase flows in the Tuolumne River to protect endangered fish. Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) noted that SFPUC had captured enough water in one month to last a year and that storage could last five years. Heinrich Elbert (Sierra Club) criticized the commission for being risk-averse regarding human water use but willing to take high risks to the ecosystem. Catherine Gere (Cal Alto) urged goodwill and removal of the drought designation. - On Item 5c (Wastewater Enterprise): Peter Dreckmeyer commented on rising wastewater costs and the coming financial crisis, urging a deep dive into budget discussions. - On Item 10 (MOU with SF LAFCO): Public commenters criticized the proposed $800,000 expenditure, calling it a waste of ratepayer money and questioning the value of the studies. - On Item 13 (General Public Comment): A large number of callers (Dave Warner, John Rose Pepe, Mary Butterwick, Lawrence Abbott, Molly Colton, John McManus, Elizabeth Dockerty, and others) strongly objected to moving general public comment to the end of the meeting. They argued it reduces accessibility, disproportionately affects hourly workers and those with limited time, and undermines democratic participation. Some suggested setting a fixed time for general comment as a compromise. - On Item 15 (Closed Session): One caller urged the commission to use the closed session to discuss transparency regarding denial of public records requests. Discussion Items - Item 3 - Hybrid Meeting Findings: Commissioners adopted renewed findings under state urgency legislation to allow hybrid in-person meetings during the COVID-19 emergency. Passed 5-0. - Item 5 - General Manager's Report: - 5a - Drought Update: Steve Ritchie reported that as of January 10, 2023, SFPUC reservoir storage on the Tuolumne system was 465,000 acre-feet (AF) and increasing. Calaveras Reservoir began spilling for the first time since the new dam was completed in 2019. Precipitation in December 2022 was nearly three times the average (14.26 inches vs 4.35 inches average). Snowpack reached 100% of the April 1st median. Water available to the city increased from 200,000 AF on January 3 to 250,000 AF on January 9. The drought is not declared over due to ecosystem and groundwater recovery needs. - 5b - Hetch Hetchy Capital Improvement: Katie Miller reported 17 projects in the program, 9 in pre-construction, 7 in construction, with 26% completion ($196 million spent). The Moccasin Powerhouse generator rewind was delayed one year due to contractor procurement and staffing issues; compensation will be negotiated. The mountain tunnel shutdown was delayed from January 3 to at least January 17 due to high turbidity. - 5c - Wastewater Enterprise: Steve Robinson reported on the Sewer System Improvement Program (SSIP) with 70 projects totaling $4.4 billion. The Southeast Community Center at 1550 Evans reached substantial completion in October 2022. The Wawona stormwater project is already providing flood relief. The biosolids and headworks projects have cost increases captured in the new budget. - 5d - Activities: General Manager Herrera commended staff for emergency response during the atmospheric river events, noting coordination with DPW and other agencies. - Item 8 - CDD Campus Design: Awarded contract to Mark Cavanero Associates for $27.8 million over 5 years for design of the new City Distribution Division campus at 2000 Marin. The contract was advertised three times due to responsive proposal issues. Passed 5-0. - Item 9 - Elevator Maintenance: Awarded sole-source contract to Otis Elevator Company for $950,000 over 8 years for proprietary elevator maintenance at 525 Golden Gate Ave. Commissioners expressed hope for future competition. Passed 5-0. - Item 10 - MOU with SF LAFCO: Staff presented a proposed MOU for $800,000 over 3 years 5 months for studies on battery storage, natural gas decommissioning, EV adoption, and clean energy technologies. Commissioners expressed concerns about value, efficiency, and use of ratepayer funds. The item was continued (pulled) for further discussion after a motion by President Ajami. - Item 11 - Electric Home (E-ELEC) Rate Schedule: Staff presented an opt-in time-of-use generation rate for customers with qualifying electric technologies (EV, storage, heat pumps). The rate was designed using PG&E's E-ELEC ratios applied to CleanPowerSF's E1 rate. The rate is expected to save customers approximately 3% on their total bill. Commissioners approved the rate 5-0. Key Outcomes - Item 3: Resolution adopting hybrid meeting findings passed (5-0). - Item 4: Minutes of December 13, 2022 approved (5-0). - Item 6: Consent calendar approved (5-0). - Item 7: Amendment with CA Department of Fish and Wildlife approved (5-0). - Item 8: Contract award for CDD Campus design approved (5-0). - Item 9: Sole-source elevator maintenance contract approved (5-0). - Item 10: MOU with SF LAFCO continued for further discussion; no vote taken. - Item 11: E-ELEC rate schedule approved (5-0). - Item 16 (Closed Session): Commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and approved settlement in Andrea Cervantes v. City and County of San Francisco (Case No. CGC-20-586083) for $400,000, subject to Board of Supervisors approval. Commissioner Rivera recused herself from this item due to prior professional relationship with a defendant. - The commission acknowledged public concerns about the relocation of general public comment and indicated willingness to revisit the policy if problematic.

PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · PROCEDURAL 18% · ELECTRIC SERVICE REGULATION 9% · PENDING LITIGATION 9%
1090
DEC 14, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - December 14, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, December 14, 2022, at 2:00 PM to discuss a range of public safety and policy items. Key highlights included a detailed data presentation on racial disparities in traffic stops by SPUR, the decision to postpone a vote on proposed Department General Order (DGO) 9.01 on pretext stops to incorporate additional feedback, approval of revised grooming standards, and updates on crime trends and departmental operations. Consent Calendar - SFPD and DPA SB 1421/SB 16 Monthly Reports: Received and filed unanimously (7-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Members of the public called for collaborative governance, expressed frustration over perceived anti-blackness in policing, and urged the commission to consider the impact of police stops on communities of color. One speaker criticized the commission for overstepping its authority by trying to change law enforcement practices without legislative changes. - Public Comment on Item 2 (Stop Data Presentation): Several callers supported ending racially biased stops, citing data showing black drivers are stopped at disproportionate rates and that pretext stops rarely lead to public safety outcomes. A deputy public defender urged the commission to vote on DGO 9.01 without further delay. - Public Comment on Later Items: No public comments were made on the consent calendar, chief's report, or DGOs. Discussion Items - Stop Data Presentation (Item 2): Jacob Denny, Policy Director at SPUR, presented an analysis of 2019 RIPA traffic stop data. Key findings included: - Black drivers are stopped at a rate 5 times higher than white drivers (4,640 stops per 10,000 black residents vs. 1,000 per 10,000 white residents). - Black drivers are disproportionately stopped for equipment violations (e.g., license plate issues, expired registration) and are less likely to receive a citation compared to white and Asian drivers. - The proposed DGO 9.01 would eliminate approximately 10,000 stops per year, reduce racial disparities, and have minimal impact on public safety (less than 1% of these stops result in arrests or recovery of firearms). - Commissioners asked about citation rates, geographic patterns, and the effect on Latino and other communities. The data showed that black drivers are 9 to 10 times more likely to be stopped for certain infractions (e.g., failure to display registration tags) compared to white drivers. - President Elias Pulled DGO 9.01 from the Agenda: During the meeting, President Elias announced that DGO 9.01 (Traffic Stops) would be removed from the calendar to allow for additional meetings with stakeholders, including the Mayor's Office of Disability and the MTA. He cited the need for further input after receiving feedback from commissioners and the public. - Chief's Report (Item 4): Chief Scott reported: - Violent crime up 6% year-to-date, property crime up 4%. - Homicides at 53 (up 2% from 52 in 2021), firearm deaths down 15%, shootings down 6%. - 172 shooting incidents, 195 victims of gun violence. - 1,004 weapons seized, including 163 ghost guns. - Discussion on side shows: a recent event involved 200 cars; the department's strategy focuses on breaking up shows and post-event enforcement (19 impounds to date). - Holiday deployment in Union Square and other commercial corridors uses overtime, which will exceed budget. - DPA Director's Report (Item 5): Director Henderson reported: - 659 cases opened, 752 closed this year, 242 pending. - 55 sustained cases (up from 46 at this time last year). - Top allegations: failure to take required action and inappropriate behavior/speech. - An audit of DGO 8.10 was provided to SFPD on December 8; response due December 22. - Commission Reports (Item 6): Commissioners discussed DGO deadlines. Vice President Carter Oberstone expressed concern that the department missed deadlines under DGO 3.01 (e.g., DGO 8.10 on First Amendment activities) and requested the matter be agendized. Commissioner Yanez called for a future discussion on juvenile justice and weapons policy under AB 481. - Revised DGO 11.08 – Grooming Standards (Item 9): The chief presented a revised policy updating grooming standards (tattoos, facial hair, hairstyles). After debate, the commission approved the policy 6-1, with Commissioner Byrne dissenting because he wanted a per se exemption for Sikh turbans rather than requiring a religious exception. The policy will be used to meet and confer with the police union. - Revised DGO 3.17 – ID Cards (Item 10): Approved unanimously (7-0) as an administrative update. - Rescind DGO 10.09 – Computer Management Committee (Item 12): Approved unanimously (7-0) as the policy is outdated and no longer in use. - Awards Certification Panel (Item 8): The commission approved awards for two officers (recommended by the chief) after a closed session review. Key Outcomes - DGO 9.01 (Pretext Stops): Postponed; President Elias will reconvene meetings with stakeholders and bring a revised draft in January 2023. - Chief's Report: Received and filed; Chief Scott answered questions on deployment, side shows, and the Department Operations Center. - DPA Report: Received and filed. - Approved Policies: - DGO 11.08 (Grooming Standards) passed 6-1. - DGO 3.17 (ID Cards) passed 7-0. - Rescinded DGO 10.09 (Computer Management Committee) 7-0. - Awards: Approved for two officers. - Closed Session: The commission voted to not disclose any discussion from the closed session (Item 15). - Next Steps: The commission will recess until January 11, 2023, with further meetings planned for DGO 9.01 and other policy items.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 50% · PROCEDURAL 13% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 10% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com