Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1091–1100 ENTRIES
1091
DEC 13, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting – December 13, 2022

The San Francisco Port Commission met on December 13, 2022, to discuss and vote on a range of items including consent calendar approvals, amendments to the Harbor Traffic Code for Chase Center events, authorization for engineering services contracts, and informational updates on the Waterfront Resilience Program’s bond issuance and equity actions. The meeting also featured the Executive Director’s report, which highlighted achievements in 2022, introduced a new Economic Recovery Manager, and honored retiring staff and a former commissioner. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Approved a resolution adopting findings under state urgency legislation to allow remote attendance during the COVID-19 emergency. - Item 10B: Authorized advertising for competitive bids for Construction Contract No. 2848 (Roundhouse 2 Roof, Solarium, and Windows) via Resolution 2263. - Item 10C: Approved an operating agreement with Aeroground, Inc. (dba Menzies Aviation) for a Foreign Trade Zone usage-driven site at 606 McDonald Road, with a five-year term and a four-year extension option (Resolution 2264). - Item 10D: Authorized filing amendments to the California Building Standards Code and adoption of the 2022 Port of San Francisco Building Standards Code effective January 1, 2023 (Resolution 2265). - Item 10E: Authorized advertising a Request for Proposals for Heron’s Head Park Marsh Revegetation and Transitional Age Work Training Program (Resolution 2266). All consent items were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony No public comments were made on any agenda item, including the Executive Director’s report, the consent calendar, and discussion items. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A): Elaine Forbes reported that the commercial Dungeness crab season is delayed to at least December 30 due to whale entanglement risks, a pattern since 2015. She thanked the commissioners for their stewardship and highlighted a $16 million profit for the year despite a projected loss, driven by strong maritime revenues and waterfront activation. Forbes introduced Megan Wallace as the new Economic Recovery Manager. Wallace presented the port’s economic recovery strategy focused on safety, equity, and vibrancy through phased activation, internal changes to lower barriers for small tenants, and improved engagement. Forbes also provided updates on equity initiatives, resilience projects (including $5 million from Speaker Pelosi for a flood study), and reminded the commission of the 30-day review period for write-off accounts. - Harbor Traffic Code Amendment for Chase Center (Item 11A): Staff requested approval to amend the Port’s Harbor Traffic Code to relocate accessible shuttle parking, establish designated loading zones, and increase commercial loading time limits on streets around Chase Center (Terry Francois Boulevard, Illinois Street, 16th Street, and Warriors Way). The changes aim to improve traffic management on game/event days. Commissioner Lee expressed support but asked about impacts on small businesses like Mission Rock Resort; staff confirmed those areas are unaffected. The item was approved unanimously (Resolution 2267). - Engineering Services Contracts (Item 12A): Staff presented a Request for Qualifications to award four contracts (each up to $4 million over five years) for as-needed engineering and related professional services to the highest-scoring firms: Coe and Telemon JV, GHD and Structus JV, Arcadis and Lotus Water, and a fourth team. A pre-qualified pool of seven additional firms was also created. The process included an initial rejection and rebid due to an unconventional proposal. Staff highlighted new equity measures, including a scored Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion plan (1 point) and caps on subcontracting credits for secondary/tertiary scopes to increase certainty for LBEs. Commissioner Gilman commended the outreach and suggested future plans could be shared publicly. Approved unanimously (Resolution 2268). - Waterfront Resilience Program – Second Bond Issuance (Item 13A): An informational update on the proposed $42 million issuance of Proposition A bonds to fund early Embarcadero projects (six of 23 identified projects are advancing). Staff reported $64.5 million already appropriated; the new bond would bring total to $106.5 million. The funds will support planning and design, with construction expected by end of 2024. A third bond issuance is anticipated in 2024 depending on market conditions. Commissioners expressed support and noted urgency due to flooding risks. - Waterfront Resilience Program – LBE and Equity Actions (Item 13B): Staff reported on LBE participation for the CH2M Hill contract, with actual LBE spending at 27.2% as of September 2022, exceeding the 21% goal. CH2M is on track to surpass its commitment. The presentation also covered workforce development plans (implementation plan due March 2023) and LBE support programs. Commissioner Gilman commended the progress and suggested aiming for 200% of the goal. - New Business (Item 14): Commissioner Lee requested future reports on tourist access from cruise ships (e.g., hop-on/hop-off bus loading zones) and enforcement against illegal vendors. Commissioner Gilman requested an informational update on economic recovery for Fisherman’s Wharf (north of Pier 39) and an assessment of wayfinding signage along the waterfront. These items were referred for future staff action. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Resolutions 2262–2266 adopted unanimously. - Harbor Traffic Code Amendment (Item 11A): Resolution 2267 adopted unanimously, updating parking and curb restrictions for Chase Center events. - Engineering Contracts (Item 12A): Resolution 2268 adopted unanimously, awarding four contracts and establishing a pre-qualified pool of seven firms. - Waterfront Resilience Program (Items 13A and 13B): Informational; no vote taken. Staff will return in January 2023 for approval of the second bond issuance and in 2023 for further updates on workforce development and LBE plans. - Adjournment: The meeting adjourned in memory of former Commissioner Michael Hardeman, who served from 1994 to 2010.

PROCEDURAL 28% · LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 23% · EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR'S REPORT 9% · CONTRACT MANAGEMENT 9%
1092
DEC 13, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - December 13, 2022

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on December 13, 2022, starting at 9:45 AM. The meeting was conducted via hybrid teleconference due to the COVID-19 emergency. President Jami presided with Commissioners Maxwell, Paulson, and Stacy present; Commissioner Rivera was excused. The commission addressed a broad agenda including adoption of state urgency legislation for hybrid meetings, approval of minutes, general public comment, communications reports, the Citizens' Advisory Committee (CAC) annual report, the General Manager's report (covering drought conditions, budget status, capital plan, and an algal bloom update), revisions to commission rules of order, consent calendar items, and several regular calendar items involving partnerships, contracts, and infrastructure projects. The meeting concluded with a closed session regarding a pending settlement. Consent Calendar - Item 10 (Consent Calendar) was approved unanimously (4-0). This included rescinding a prior contract award, approving amendments, awarding contracts for emergency planning and construction management, accepting completed work, increasing contract durations, and approving a license agreement with the City of Los Altos. A member of the public requested item 10a be severed, but the commission did not remove it. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 5): Eight callers spoke. Topics included requests for sediment studies in the Tuolumne River system (Bob), presentation of demand study results (Nicole Sandkulla, BAWSCA CEO), a request to sever consent item 10a, criticism of commission failures regarding salmon and building standards, a call for a hearing on the emergency firefighting water system report, concerns about fire hydrant maintenance and freshwater flows for the Bay Delta, criticism of SFPUC's data integrity and transparency (Peter Dreckmeyer, Tuolumne River Trust), and a comment on water conservation and environmental impacts (Lawrence Abbott). One caller expressed sadness over land acknowledgment and systemic racism. - Communications (Item 6): Callers commented on the Alternative Water Supply Report (Dave Warner), demand projections and rationing scenarios (Peter Dreckmeyer), and the Water Enterprise Environmental Stewardship Policy (Bob Stanley, Mark Gonzalez). Concerns were raised about transparency in water supply needs and the need for independent review. - Citizens' Advisory Committee Report (Item 7): Multiple callers spoke in support of adopting workforce and environmental justice standards for Clean Power SF and California Community Power energy projects (Alex Lanceburg, Benjamin Eichert, Melissa Yu, Joni Eisen, Jill Zamek, Emily Gartenberg, Batouin Eyes Daggy, Eric V, Roth Delai, Jason Kumakelko). - General Manager's Report (Item 8): Callers commented on the drought update (requesting data transparency), budget status (David Pilpel, caller on energy alternatives), and budget development (David Pilpel, caller on SFPUC culture, Nicole Sandkulla, caller on dams and young people). - New Commission Business (Item 9): David Pilpel supported the revised rules of order; Peter Dreckmeyer expressed concern about moving general public comment to later in the agenda. - Consent Calendar (Item 10): David Pilpel commented on items 10c and 10j, urging more in-house staffing and better project descriptions. Another caller again requested 10a be severed but was informed only commissioners can pull items. - Regular Calendar Items (Items 11-17): Comments on Item 11 (Yosemite MOA) from a caller on Buffalo soldiers history. Item 12 (P3 biogas) from David Pilpel on typographical errors and delegation concerns. Item 13 (sewer rehabilitation) from David Pilpel on PG&E risks and project coordination. Item 14 (South Bay feasibility study) from Nicole Sandkulla (support) and Peter Dreckmeyer (cautious, questioning cost allocation). Item 15 (Los Vaqueros) from Nicole Sandkulla (support) and Peter Dreckmeyer (concern over lack of discussion on alternative water supplies). Items 16 and 17 had no public comments. Discussion Items - Adoption of Hybrid Meeting Findings (Item 3): Unanimously approved (4-0). - Approval of Minutes (Item 4): Unanimously approved (4-0). - Communications (Item 6): Commissioners commended staff for comprehensive reports. No action required. - Citizens' Advisory Committee Annual Report (Item 7): Chair Moises Garcia presented the CAC's work, including resolutions on grid reliability, water supply, clean power SF transition, transparency, and public power. Discussion on Girl Scout Camp closure at Lake Merced clarified that it is not shuttering. Several callers urged the commission to adopt the CAC's resolution on workforce and environmental justice standards. Commissioners expressed support and requested staff to agendize the resolution. Assistant GM Barbara Hale explained the status of similar policies at the California Community Power JPA. - General Manager's Report (Item 8): - 8a Drought Update: Steve Ritchie reported recent storms improved conditions: Calaveras Reservoir received first significant inflow (3,000 acre-feet) since 2019; upcountry precipitation at Hetch Hetchy reached 10 inches; local precipitation at 4.92 inches (above monthly median); snowpack near 50% of average; water available to city jumped to 13,000 acre-feet. Salmon counts on Stanislaus River (3,400) and Tuolumne River (602) are below historical averages. Commissioners asked about turbidity management; staff noted post-storm monitoring. - 8b Quarterly Budget Status: Laura Bush reported positive operating results for Water ($38.3M) and CleanPower SF ($21.1M), but a small shortfall in Power (-$1.3M) due to high power purchase costs attributed to inflation and the Ukraine war. Policy ratios are on track. - 8c FY2023-24 Budget & 10-Year Capital Plan: Nancy Hom presented the budget process and challenges: ongoing drought, economic uncertainty, rate study, historical underspending. Key priorities include responsible management, affordability, environmental stewardship, and workforce retention. The capital plan faces a $1.3B unfunded gap; staff are working to align budgeting with deliverability. Commissioners discussed recruitment and retention, noting citywide vacancies (5,000 jobs). President Jami requested a report on HR strategies. - 8d Water Enterprise CIP Quarterly: Katie Miller reported 36 projects with $3.3B total budget; $28M expended in Q1. One project (Millbrae HVAC) saved $9M. - 8e WSIP Quarterly: Three remaining projects; Alameda Creek Recapture reported $4M forecasted increase. - 8f Algal Bloom & Nutrient Reduction: Amy Chastain presented on the August 2022 harmful algal bloom, the worst in 30 years, caused by nitrogen from wastewater plants. SFPUC has two treatment plants discharging to the bay. Options: side-stream treatment ($100M, 15-20% removal) or full-stream treatment ($1B, 80% removal). Southeast Plant is on a congested site; space is preserved for future nutrient removal. Commissioners emphasized monitoring and interim solutions. President Jami noted the Bay Area's science collaboration model. - Commissioner Maxwell requested a report from Human Resources on vacancies and retention. - New Commission Business (Item 9): Hearing to adopt revised Rules of Order. Commissioners approved the changes, including moving consent/regular calendar earlier, revising rate-setting language, and adding parental leave provisions. Public comment raised concern about moving general public comment later, but commissioners clarified it is not a demotion. - Regular Calendar: - Item 11 (Yosemite MOA): Approved (4-0). Minor administrative amendment to MOU with National Park Service. - Item 12 (P3 Biogas Project): Approved (4-0) to use public-private partnership delivery method for the biogas utilization project at Southeast Treatment Plant. The commission will recommend a special ordinance to the Board of Supervisors. Discussion focused on risk allocation and monitoring. - Item 13 (Sewer Rehabilitation): Approved (4-0) a contract with Anvil Builders for $15.8M to connect the Channel Force Main to the Islais Creek Transport/Storage Box. Also authorized an agreement with PG&E for utility work. - Item 14 (South Bay Purified Water Feasibility Study): Approved (4-0) a $300K feasibility study (SFPUC share $100K) with San Jose and Santa Clara. - Item 15 (Los Vaqueros Reservoir Expansion): Approved (4-0) Amendment No. 4 increasing contract by $7.66M (SFPUC share $1.09M) for planning studies. Commissioners noted no commitment to construction. - Item 16 (Residential Green Infrastructure Grant): Approved (4-0) a $155K grant agreement with Greenprint Partners for a pilot program. - Item 17 (Alameda County RCD Agreement): Approved (4-0) a $8.5M, 9-year agreement for watershed management services. - Closed Session (Items 18-22): The commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and entered closed session to discuss a pending settlement with the San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board. After closed session, they announced recommendation to the Board of Supervisors to approve an unlitigated claim of $236,500 for effluent limitation violations. The commission voted not to disclose the closed session discussions. Key Outcomes - Approved (4-0): Hybrid meeting findings, minutes, consent calendar (Item 10), revised Rules of Order (Item 9), Yosemite MOA (Item 11), P3 delivery method for biogas (Item 12), sewer rehabilitation contract and PG&E agreement (Item 13), South Bay feasibility study (Item 14), Los Vaqueros amendment (Item 15), residential green infrastructure grant (Item 16), Alameda County RCD agreement (Item 17). - Directed: Staff to agendize the CAC's workforce/environmental justice resolution; Assistant GM to provide report on vacancies and retention strategy; staff to bring back updates on nutrient reduction at Southeast Plant. - Closed Session: Commission asserted privilege, recommended settlement approval to Board of Supervisors, and voted not to disclose discussions. - Next Meeting: The regular meeting of December 27, 2022 was canceled.

PUBLIC COMMENT 33% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 20% · PROCEDURAL 7% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 7%
1093
DEC 8, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - December 8, 2022

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, December 8, 2022, at 6:15 PM UTC. Chair Gordon Maher presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stephanie and Committee Member Myrna Melgar. The committee considered four agenda items: two liquor license transfers, an ordinance on military leave pay for private-sector employees, and a hearing on jail health services. All votes were unanimous. Public Comments & Testimony Item 3 – Private Sector Military Leave Pay - Hanley Chan, Veterans Affairs Commissioner, expressed strong support, noting his own experience as a National Guardsman. - Courtney Ellington, Veterans Affairs Commissioner and CEO of One Vet One Voice, urged passage, citing significant pay problems for mobilized reservists. - Francisco De Costa, a veteran, commended the city for stepping up and emphasized the need to support veterans. Item 4 – Hearing on Jail Health Services - A District 2 resident supported Supervisor Stephanie’s efforts and raised concerns about city employees with secondary employment at nonprofits. - Paulina, a District 4 resident, thanked Supervisor Stephanie for the hearing. - Marie Harabia, a District 1 resident, expressed alarm about “double dipping” and urged enforcement of rules. - Tanya Tillman, from Mothers Against Drug Addictions and Death, criticized the lack of data on linking incarcerated individuals to services after release and shared her son’s experience. - Joe Kunzler, a regular caller, stressed the need to address recidivism and thanked the chair for his service. Discussion Items Item 1 – Liquor License Transfer – Luke’s Local (580 Green Street) - Officer Salmondson from the SFPD ABC Liaison unit reported the location is in a high-crime, high-saturation area. Central station had no opposition. The Alcohol License Unit (ALU) recommended approval with a condition to prevent loitering. Ten letters of protest had been received but were unverified. - Scott Stern, controller of Luke’s Local, described the business as a full-service grocery store (90% food, less than 10% alcohol) with no issues at other locations. He emphasized community convenience. - Supervisor Stephanie praised the business, noting its positive impact on Union Street. - Chair Maher noted that Supervisor Peskin (whose district includes the location) supported the transfer. Item 2 – Liquor License Transfer – South Sea Dipper (270 Columbus Avenue) - Officer Salmondson reported zero letters of support; the location is in a high-crime, high-saturation area. ALU recommended approval with conditions to monitor loitering and control noise. - Mark Rennie and Brian Sheehe (Future Bars Group) presented the concept: a rotating cocktail bar in the historic Italian American Bank building, changing themes every 6–12 months, intended to bring positive foot traffic to the Broadway corridor. The business would be adjacent to their existing bar, Devil’s Acre, but operate under a separate license. Item 3 – Ordinance Amending Police Code – Private Sector Military Leave Pay - Chair Maher introduced the Military Leave Pay Protection Act, requiring large San Francisco employers (100+ employees) to pay the difference between military and civilian pay for reservists and National Guard members for up to 30 days per calendar year. An estimated 2,000 San Franciscans serve as reservists. Public employees already receive similar protection. Supervisor Maher cited an example: an E-5 sergeant earning $99/day in the military could lose $140/day if their civilian rate is $30/hour. - Pat Mulligan from the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (OLSE) confirmed about 4,300 employers with 100+ employees would be impacted. OLSE planned informational outreach and administrative rulemaking. - The ordinance had co-sponsors: Supervisors Stephanie, Melgar, Dorsey, Preston, and Walton. - The committee noted that this would be a first-of-its-kind policy nationally, attracting interest from other jurisdictions. Item 4 – Hearing on the State of Jail Health Services - Dr. Hallie Hammer, Director of Ambulatory Care for DPH, presented an overview: approximately 11,000 annual intakes; services at three jails; staffing challenges (high turnover, burnout, vacancies) mitigated through a nurse registry; rollout of EPIC electronic health record with Wi-Fi issues at County Jail 3 causing documentation delays; mortality rates far lower than other California jails; no COVID-19 hospitalizations or deaths among inmates. - Alyssa Riker, Director of Programs for the Sheriff’s Office, described discharge planning programs targeting pre-trial releases, frequent arrestees, and older adults. Collaboration with community-based organizations, Medi-Cal enrollment, and a new Department of Homelessness assessment initiative starting in January 2023 were highlighted. - Supervisor Stephanie questioned: the sheriff’s staffing shortage (192 deputies short); the impact on programming (e.g., AA/NA meetings, RSVP anger management program operating at limited capacity); mandatory overtime for nurses; secondary employment among jail health staff; and the need for better data on treatment referrals and waitlists. - Supervisor Melgar inquired about EPIC implementation, staff training, and data-sharing with nonprofit partners. - Dr. Hammer and Tanya Mara (Director of Jail Behavioral Health) outlined efforts to address burnout, including a workplace violence prevention policy, peer support programs, complex care meetings, and support groups for African American staff and women. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Luke’s Local liquor license): Unanimous vote (3–0) to prepare a resolution finding that the license serves public convenience or necessity and send it to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (South Sea Dipper liquor license): Unanimous vote (3–0) to prepare a similar resolution and forward it with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 (Private Sector Military Leave Pay ordinance): Unanimous vote (3–0) to send the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report for consideration at its December 12, 2022 meeting. - Item 4 (Hearing on Jail Health Services): Unanimous vote (3–0) to file the hearing. Supervisor Stephanie requested follow-up information: data on mandatory overtime, minimum staffing gaps, secondary employment among jail health leadership, impact of sheriff’s shortages on programming, and tracking of post-release service linkages and waitlists.

PUBLIC HEALTH 26% · JUSTICE AND CORRECTIONS 19% · REENTRY SERVICES 9% · LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 6%
1094
DEC 7, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - December 7, 2022: Pretext Stops, Juvenile Arrests, and DPA Audit

The San Francisco Police Commission met on December 7, 2022, at 1:45 PM UTC (rescheduled to evening) to discuss a range of policing issues, including a proposed Department General Order (DGO) 9.01 to curtail pretextual traffic stops, a presentation on juvenile and transitional-age youth arrests in the Tenderloin, and a key issues report from the Department of Police Accountability (DPA) on the SFPD's public reporting of officer misconduct and discipline. The meeting also included the Chief's report on crime trends, a presentation from the Human Rights Commission (HRC) on community feedback regarding traffic stops, and other routine items. Consent Calendar - Approved acceptance of a $3,000 donation from Hung On Tong Society to the SFPD Police Foundation for the SFPD Holiday Toy Drive. (Unanimous) Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Multiple speakers criticized the SFPD's proposed use of killer robots, racial disparities in policing, and the lack of transparency. One speaker urged the commission to address anti-blackness in traffic stops and use of force. Another speaker raised concerns about homelessness and the closure of the Delancey Street Center. - On DGO 9.01 (Pretext Stops): Dozens of callers and in-person speakers expressed support or opposition. Supporters argued that pretext stops disproportionately harm Black and brown communities, waste resources, and do not improve public safety. Opponents claimed the policy would legalize minor infractions, reduce traffic safety, and undermine police authority. Several speakers shared personal experiences of being racially profiled during traffic stops. - On Tenderloin Juvenile Arrests: Advocates from CARC (Community Assessment and Referral Center) and Huckleberry Youth Programs described challenges in diverting youth from the criminal justice system and called for better coordination among agencies. Discussion Items Chief’s Report (Chief William Scott): - Violent crime is up 7% year-to-date, property crime up 4%. Homicides down 2% (51 vs 52). Gun violence down 6% overall. Seized 961 firearms year-to-date, including 163 ghost guns. Fentanyl seizures in the Tenderloin totaled over 60,000 grams, nearly double 2021. Reported no homicides for the week, but several school bomb threats (unsubstantiated). Deputy report on stunt driving: 200 cars gathered for a sideshow; 40 vehicles seized since follow-up investigations began. - MOU with DA and court extended to January 30, 2023, pending resolution. Human Rights Commission Presentation (Dr. Cheryl Davis, Jessica Campos, Sarah Sang): - HRC conducted 19 community engagements with over 300 participants and a survey with 200+ respondents to gather feedback on proposed traffic stop reforms. Key themes: community members felt stops for minor infractions (e.g., tinted windows, expired registration, sleeping in car) were not related to public safety and often led to racial profiling. Many reported being stopped without cause and experiencing trauma. Recommendations included better officer training, more community engagement, and improved data collection and transparency. HRC emphasized the need for a culture shift, not just policy changes. Discussion on DGO 9.01 “Traffic Enforcement & Curtailing the Use of Pretext Stops”: - Vice President Carter Oberstone outlined the draft policy: bans stops for nine low-level infractions (e.g., failure to signal, broken taillights, expired registration, sleeping in car) unless there is a public safety need. Also restricts consent searches and investigatory questions without reasonable suspicion. Requires enhanced data collection. The goal is to reduce racial disparities and reallocate resources to more effective crime-fighting. - Commissioners debated the policy. Some expressed concerns about public safety, especially regarding turn signals, registration, and sleeping in cars. Others cited evidence that such stops do not reduce crashes or crime and disproportionately harm people of color. The Chief noted that the department is reviewing the draft and will provide feedback by the end of the week. Commissioner Yee raised concerns about community education and the impact on seniors. Commissioner Byrne questioned whether the policy aims to reduce stops or disparities, and cited Virginia’s experience where disparities persisted despite fewer stops. Commissioner Benedicto and Carter Oberstone responded that a comprehensive approach (including restrictions on searches) can reduce disparities, and that jurisdictions like Oakland and Nashville have seen success. - Public comment was extensive and polarized. Presentation on Tenderloin District Narcotics Arrests of Juveniles and Transitional-Aged Youth: - Lieutenant Kevin Healy presented data: from 2018 to 2022, juvenile arrests for narcotics dealing in Tenderloin have increased slightly (30 in 2022 YTD vs 29 full year 2021). Most were cited rather than booked. Chief Scott noted that juveniles are being used by drug trafficking organizations. - Representatives from CARC explained diversion programs and current gaps, especially during non-operating hours (after 10 PM and weekends). They called for coordinated response and better follow-up for youth who fail to attend intake. DPA Key Issue Report on Public Reporting of Officer Misconduct and Discipline: - Steve Flaherty presented findings: SFPD failed to comply with multiple reporting requirements under Administrative Code 96A and Police Commission Resolution 97-04. Specifically, SFPD did not publish monthly reports on DPA-sustained cases, did not report pending discipline decisions, and used vague categories for misconduct allegations. Also, SFPD did not meet the 45-day timeline for discipline decisions in 67% of cases (average 59 days, range 7–288 days). The report recommended better data presentation and alignment with best practices from other cities. - Chief Scott acknowledged the issues and stated a captain has been assigned to fix the systemic problems, but noted challenges with legacy data systems. Key Outcomes - Adoption of Minutes: Approved with an amendment (correcting spelling of Commissioner Lee to Yi). Unanimous. - Consent Calendar: Approved donation for holiday toy drive. Unanimous. - DGO 2.01 (General Rules of Conduct): Approved revised version to go to meet-and-confer with the Police Officers Association. Unanimous. - Closed Session: Voted to enter closed session and assert attorney-client privilege regarding Item 15. Unanimous. Afterwards, voted not to disclose closed session discussions. Unanimous. - Next Steps for DGO 9.01: Chief Scott will provide feedback on the latest draft by the end of the week; further discussion and possible vote scheduled for a future meeting. - DPA Audit Follow-Up: Chief Scott assigned a captain to address reporting deficiencies; Commissioner Benedicto requested a written response and presentation from the department after the holidays. Director Henderson suggested assigning a commissioner to oversee compliance. - Adjournment: Meeting adjourned after closed session.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 42% · PUBLIC SAFETY 15% · PROCEDURAL 13% · JUVENILE JUSTICE 10%
1095
DEC 1, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - December 1, 2022

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, met on December 1, 2022, to discuss a proposed citywide trauma response to gun violence, receive annual reports from five Community Benefit Districts (CBDs), and deliberate on three litigation settlements in closed session. The committee heard public testimony and took action on all items. Hearing on Proactive Citywide Trauma Response to Gun Violence The committee heard a presentation from the Department of Public Health (DPH) on a draft protocol to proactively reach out to neighbors within a one-block radius of a shooting within 72 hours to offer trauma counseling and resources. DPH's Stephanie Felder and Max Roca outlined the current notification system and proposed enhancements, including a Gun Violence Healing Response Outreach Coordinator. Key statistics: 85% of those impacted by gun violence are Black and Latino men; 29% of all violent gun crimes in 2019 took place in Bayview, Potrero Hill, and Visitation Valley. The protocol would be implemented in phases, prioritizing high-impact areas including the Western Addition, Fillmore, and Tenderloin (added during discussion). DPH noted that funding is needed, and implementation would take several months after securing funds. Supervisor Preston expressed urgency and suggested exploring Dreamkeeper funding via the Human Rights Commission. Public commenters requested inclusion of the Tenderloin as a priority area and emphasized the need for culturally competent, on-the-ground services. The committee voted unanimously to file the hearing. Community Benefit Districts Annual Reports The committee reviewed and approved annual reports for FY2020-2021 for five CBDs: Fisherman's Wharf Landside and Portside, Japantown, Noe Valley, and North of Market/Tenderloin. OEWD's Chris Corgus presented findings. Japantown CBD met three of four benchmarks, excelling in non-assessment revenue (12 times minimum). Noe Valley CBD met all benchmarks after renewal. Fisherman's Wharf Portside CBD sunset at end of 2020. North of Market/Tenderloin CBD met all benchmarks but had past reporting delays. Representatives from each CBD presented highlights: Japantown's cleaning stats (20,000 lbs trash collected), Noe Valley's sidewalk washing and tree maintenance, Fisherman's Wharf's 37,000 lbs trash collected and 133,000 website users, and Tenderloin's cleaning team responding to 90% of 311 requests. Public commenters praised the CBDs and called for more support for grassroots organizations. The committee voted unanimously to send the resolutions to the full board with a positive recommendation. Closed Session Items The committee convened in closed session to discuss three litigation settlements: an unlitigated claim for 100-120 Powell Owner L.P. ($5,362,325), a settlement with Sunset Scavenger Company et al. providing a $25,000,000 credit to ratepayers, and a settlement of a lawsuit for Victor Jimenez ($100,000). Public comment included Teamsters Local 350 urging approval of the Recology settlement and requesting an employee owner representative on the board per Proposition F. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the settlements to the full board. Chair Preston and Vice Chair Chan noted the importance of transparency and the implementation of Prop F for rate-setting. Key Outcomes - Filed hearing on citywide trauma response. - Approved and forwarded CBD annual reports to full board. - Recommended three litigation settlements to full board. - Directed that the final executed settlement agreement be made publicly available.

PROCEDURAL 17% · PUBLIC HEALTH 15% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 15% · PUBLIC SAFETY 12%
1096
NOV 17, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - November 17, 2022

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on November 17, 2022, to consider a motion for two new performance audits, a resolution authorizing the Next Generation Clipper system MOU, a Mills Act historical property contract, and annual reports from the Tourism Improvement District, Moscone Expansion District, and six Community Benefit Districts (CBDs). The committee also convened in closed session to discuss litigation settlements. All public agenda items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (BLA Audit Plan): Leen Boken, representing Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods, urged the board to expand the scope of the conflicts-of-interest audit to include the citywide affordable housing loan committee. He stated that voting members can approve their own projects, that the committee lacks minutes, and cited specific concerns about projects like 2550 Irving Street. - Items 4-10 (CBD Annual Reports): Linda Chapman, a resident of Knob Hill, spoke critically of the Lower Polk CBD, alleging illegal fundraising from developers and governance failures, and stating that the neighborhood has suffered from a "nightlife and vice district" culture. She called for an inspector general office. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Motion to Amend the BLA Audit Plan: Chair Preston introduced a motion directing the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) to conduct two proactive performance audits for FY2022-2023: (1) a multi-part audit of delegated procurement authority under Chapter 6 of the Administrative Code for public works contracts, and (2) a citywide audit of how conflicts of interest are managed. BLA Analyst Dan Goncher explained that delegated authority allows department heads to approve construction contracts up to $1 million without commission approval and between $1M and $10M with only commission approval, bypassing centralized procurement—an area never before audited. The conflicts audit will review tools like Statements of Economic Interests and explore best practices from other jurisdictions. Both audits are intended to proactively address potential corruption, not in response to specific scandals. Public comment was heard. The committee voted unanimously to send the motion to the full board. - Item 2 – Next Generation Clipper MOU: Diana Hammonds, SFMTA Revenue Manager, presented a resolution authorizing the SFMTA Director to execute an amended MOU with the Metropolitan Transportation Commission and 23 other Bay Area transit operators for the Next Generation Clipper system. Key changes include a shift from variable transaction fees to a fixed monthly operating cost, with MTC covering 50% of ongoing costs and operators splitting the remainder based on usage. The 10-year agreement will support roll-out of virtual Clipper cards, cellular-connected fare equipment, and an account-based system. BLA Analyst Nick Minard noted that MTA's pre-COVID costs were $8.4M, dropped to $3M during the pandemic, and are projected to be $7.1M in FY2022-23 and $9.7M in FY2023-24 due to dual-system transition, then stabilizing between $6.5M and $8.5M annually. Discussion touched on fare capping and the exclusivity of Clipper for regional integration—a 12-year-old MTC resolution discourages competing systems, but SFMTA can still offer products not yet available on Clipper (e.g., day passes, lifeline passes) via the Muni Mobile app. The committee voted unanimously to forward the resolution. - Item 3 – Mills Act Historical Property Contract for 942-944 Fell Street: Chair Preston recused himself because the property is within 500 feet of his residence. Vice Chair Chan presided. Gretel Gunther of the Planning Department presented the application for a 10-year rolling contract. The property is a contributor to the Alamo Square Historic District, built in 1908, valued under $3 million. The proposed rehabilitation plan includes siding repair, roof replacement, window repair, and other work costing $308,100 over 10 years, with annual maintenance estimated at $8,655. The Assessor-Recorder estimated annual property tax savings of $11,687. Owner Julie Chin spoke in support, emphasizing her commitment to stewardship, tenant retention (both units occupied since mid-2021), and the property's visibility to tourists. The committee voted unanimously (2—0) to recommend approval. - Items 4-10 – Annual Reports of Tourism and Community Benefit Districts: Mimi Hiraki of the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) summarized the compliance of eight districts with statutory benchmarks. Key findings: The Tourism Improvement District (TID) and Moscone Expansion District (MED) met all benchmarks, though their assessments tied to hotel revenue were significantly impacted by the pandemic; the TID's $5 million line of credit was extended to December 2022. The Yerba Buena CBD missed the non-assessment revenue benchmark due to the pandemic but has since secured a $300,000 state grant and a $200,000 OEWD grant. The East Cut CBD met all benchmarks, collecting 149,000 pounds of trash and 2,959 graffiti tags; it manages three parks and launched a 311 dispatch pilot. The Castro/Upper Market CBD renewed with 72% weighted assessment; graffiti abatement increased 31% and human feces collection 57%; it transitioned from patrol special police to unarmed community ambassadors. The Ocean Avenue CBD failed three of four benchmarks; OEWD presented serious governance deficiencies from its strategic plan, including board inexperience, lack of financial controls, and poor communication. OEWD requested a Controller's audit for FY2022-23. New Executive Director Christian Martin (six weeks on the job) acknowledged the issues and said a board training consultant had been hired, with improvements expected by Q1 2023. The Discover Polk CBD missed the non-assessment revenue benchmark but met all others; it is working to secure a grant from the Academy of Art University. The Lower Polk CBD met all four benchmarks, continuing its tenant-landlord clinic and working with a consultant to improve board governance. The committee voted unanimously to forward all eight resolutions to the full board. - Closed Session (Items 11-17): The committee convened in closed session to discuss seven litigation settlement items. After reconvening, the clerk reported that the committee voted unanimously to recommend items 11 through 15 and item 17 (lawsuits involving Phi Associates/Drisco Hotel, John LaSalle, Crystal & Martha Gomez, Linda Gebroe, Onjanette Hudson, and Visa U.S.A. Inc.) to the full board, and to continue item 16 (settlement for 100-120 Powell Owner L.P., L.L.C.) to the December 1, 2022 meeting. The committee voted unanimously not to disclose the closed session discussions. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to direct BLA audits – forwarded to full board (3—0). - Item 2: Resolution on Next Generation Clipper MOU – forwarded to full board (3—0). - Item 3: Resolution for Mills Act contract at 942-944 Fell Street – forwarded to full board (2—0, Preston recused). - Items 4-10: Resolutions for TID, MED, and six CBD annual reports – all forwarded to full board (3—0). - Closed Session (Items 11-17): Items 11-15 and 17 recommended for approval; item 16 continued to December 1, 2022. Committee voted not to disclose discussions.

PROCEDURAL 21% · COMMUNITY BENEFIT DISTRICTS 18% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 17% · PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION 8%
1097
NOV 16, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - November 16, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, November 16, 2022. The meeting featured an early presentation by the Center for Policing Equity (CPE) on racial disparities in traffic stops, reports from the Chief of Police and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), adoption of an SB16 personnel records policy, a review of DPA quarterly statistics, an Early Intervention System (EIS) update, and a closed session. Due to a WebEx technical issue, the originally scheduled general public comment period was moved and reopened later in the meeting. Agenda Order and Technical Note - Item 7 (CPE presentation) was taken out of order at the start of the meeting before the regular general public comment. - The first general public comment period was interrupted by a WebEx technical difficulty; the Commission later reopened general public comment before moving to the consent calendar. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Minutes for the meetings of October 19, 2022 and November 2, 2022 was moved, seconded, and passed unanimously (6 yes; Commissioner Yi initially noted he was not present on November 2 and was told he could not abstain under the charter, then voted yes). - Consent Calendar items were received and filed by a 6-0 vote. Items included SFPD and DPA SB1421/SB16 monthly reports, the Collaborative Reform Initiative monthly update, and the SFPD/DPA quarterly document protocol for Q3 2022. Public Comments & Testimony - Gene Bridges, volunteering with Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community, stated that public comment had been "effectively cut off" because phone participation started late. He argued that CPE's findings support eliminating pretext stops, cited DOJ criticism of SFPD, and said SFPD's own data show Black San Franciscans are 5 times as likely to be stopped, 10 times as likely to be arrested, and 15 times as likely to experience force. He called for required narrative justifications for stops and accountability. - A second caller from the same group expressed frustration that the commission had not shown urgency, said community members had contacted Attorney General Bonta, and challenged the notion that San Francisco needs a "special" approach while also waiting for evidence from other cities. - Susan Buckman, also volunteering with Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community, commented on the consent calendar, saying California and SFPD have some of the worst racist and violent policing outcomes in the nation and arguing that SFPD resists accountability and the release of personnel records under SB1421/SB16. Discussion Items Presentation by the Center for Policing Equity (CPE) on Traffic Stops - Presenters: Charlotte Reesing (Government Affairs Manager) and Scarlett Neath (Policy Research Manager) presented CPE's white paper on redesigning traffic safety. CPE said it partners with over 60 law enforcement agencies in 30 states and uses science to reduce bias. - CPE Recommendations: End pretextual stops; invest in public health approaches to road safety; limit fines and fees; pilot alternatives to armed enforcement; and improve data collection and transparency. - Key Statistics Cited: Pretext stops produced contraband or arrest in only 0.03% of analyzed stops; Fayetteville, NC reduced non-safety-related stops from 56% to 32% after reform; Virginia's law produced a 7.5% reduction in stop volume but unchanged racial disparities; Los Angeles saw pretext stops fall from 21% to 12%; an analysis of San Diego Sheriff's data estimated $43.9 million in officer hours spent on low-yield stops. - CPE Positions: CPE said "situations predict bias much more than individual biases," and expressed support for banning all pretextual stops. They stated research shows no measurable negative effect on crime in jurisdictions that adopted such bans, citing Washington state and Fayetteville. They also said departments should document reasons for stops and leadership should communicate the intent of reform. - Commissioner Questions and Positions: - President Elias asked whether banning pretext stops would create a safety risk, noting officer concerns about losing a crime-fighting tool. CPE responded that studies show no negative impact on crime and that the yield from such stops is very low. - Commissioner Benedicto asked why the reforms should be adopted as a holistic package. CPE said the combination reduces disparities while maintaining road safety, and that each element reinforces the others. - Commissioner Walker questioned whether there is data showing all three approaches work better than one, and suggested pilot programs to test what works. CPE said individual reforms have evidence, but no jurisdiction has implemented all three together; they offered to share further data. Commissioner Walker also expressed concern about existing infrastructure for mail-in tickets and repair vouchers. - Commissioner Yi asked about projected budgets for fine/fee changes and alternatives to armed enforcement. CPE mentioned income-based waivers, repair voucher programs (e.g., Lights On in Chatham County, GA and Minnesota), and cautioned that automated enforcement must be implemented equitably. - Commissioner Yannis asked about cost analyses and whether changes improved clearance rates. CPE said they were unaware of cost studies but that policy changes are low-cost, and no study yet shows clearance rate improvements; they encouraged San Francisco to become a leader. - Chief Scott said he had read the report, thanked CPE, and said SFPD has been working with CPE. Chief's Report - Chief Scott reported weekly crime trends: violent crime up 7% (311 more crimes than last year), property crime up 6% (just short of 3,000 more); robberies up 5%, aggravated assaults up 10%; burglaries down 21%, larceny up 13%, auto burglaries steady at 9%; homicides up 2% (one additional), firearm-related homicides down by 4; 961 guns seized, including 163 ghost guns. - He detailed three homicides, several auto burglary and catalytic converter arrests, and said holiday deployment had begun in Union Square and shopping corridors, with foot beats and ambassadors in several neighborhoods. - No public comment was offered. DPA Director's Report - Acting Director Diana Rosenstein reported DPA statistics: 601 cases opened in 2022 (vs. 695 last year), 636 closed (vs. 781), 245 pending (vs. 274), 53 sustained (vs. 43), and 18 mediated (vs. 36). Twenty-three cases were past the 270-day mark. - She highlighted outreach at station meetings, a NACO presentation, an active shooter training attended by DPA staff, and ongoing audit work. She also thanked the commission for signing intern certificates and said officers are eager for more training. - She mentioned a draft MOU between DPA and SFPD; Chief Scott said SFPD received it, met with the District Attorney, and would follow up with DPA. Commission Reports - Commissioner Benedicto reported on DGO 9.01 community listening sessions (at least 9-10 total) and the CIT awards. - Commissioner Walker reported on the hate crimes DGO work, recruitment commitments (including the 30x30 contract), and meetings with community/business groups to coordinate public safety efforts. - Commissioner Yannis reported on an upcoming ride-along, DGO 701 juvenile work, and a request to agendize a data review of the video feed collection program. - Commissioner Yi reported on DGO updates and meetings. DPA Quarterly Reports – Q1, Q2, Q3 2022 - DPA Operations Manager Nicole Armstrong presented quarterly data. - Highlights included the launch of the new complaint portal, over 90 policy recommendations, 68 cases where body-worn camera footage was outcome-determinative, 17 mediated cases, and 16 interns contributing over 400 research hours. - Armstrong noted a national downward trend in complaints to oversight agencies, high rates of "decline to state" demographics among complainants, and plans for training investigators to ask demographic questions and an officer portal. - Commissioner Yannis asked about national trend data; DPA clarified the comparison was for cases received, and sustained-rate data may not be directly comparable. Commissioner Benedicto asked about the drop in policy failure findings in Q3; DPA attributed it to case resolution timing rather than a specific cause. - Discussion turned to body-worn cameras. Acting Director Rosenstein said when in doubt, turn it on; Chief Scott noted cost and privacy concerns, but mentioned future technology that could activate cameras in critical incidents. SB16 Personnel Records Policy (Item 9) - The Commission considered adopting a joint policy document for release of personnel records under California Penal Code Section 832.7 as amended by SB16. - Acting Director Henderson/Rosenstein requested advance engagement and pointed out that page three incorrectly listed "Department of Public Accountability" instead of "Department of Police Accountability." - The Commission amended the document to correct the name, then voted 7-0 to adopt the policy. Early Intervention System (EIS) Q2 2022 (Item 10) - Commander Paul Yep and Sergeant Darwin Naval presented the EIS quarterly update. - EIS alerts rose to 471 in Q2 2022, a 429.2% increase over Q1; 16.2% of active sworn members (321 officers) generated at least one alert, compared to the usual 3-4%. There were 1,945 indicator points vs. 267 in Q2 2021. - The increase was attributed to the revised DGO 5.01 use-of-force thresholds and new CDW reporting software. Of the alerts, 70% were active/pending review; one intervention remained active. - The department is migrating to the Benchmark early intervention system. - Chief Scott explained the numbers were inflated by the previous 5.01 reporting criteria and said the newly approved revision (set to take effect December 8, 2022) should normalize the numbers. - Commissioner Yannis asked about interventions; Sergeant Naval explained they are individualized plans created with the member and supervisor, with check-ins at 90 days, 180 days, and one year, and can include training, counseling, or behavior health check-ins. Key Outcomes - Adopted minutes of October 19 and November 2, 2022 (6-0). - Received and filed the consent calendar (6-0). - Adopted the SB16 personnel records policy with an amendment correcting the DPA's name (7-0). - Held a closed session after voting to do so (7-0), and voted not to disclose any discussions held in closed session. - Referred future topics: a possible Benchmark presentation to the Commission, a December review of the video-feed data collection rollout, and continued work on DGOs including 9.01, 7.01, and hate crimes. - Next steps from the CPE presentation: the Commission will continue its DGO 9.01 policy process using CPE's report and public feedback; CPE offered to share additional data with Commissioners.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 53% · PUBLIC SAFETY 15% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 9% · PROCEDURAL 8%
1098
NOV 10, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting – November 10, 2022

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on November 10, 2022, to consider two liquor license applications and the Mental Health Services Act (MHSA) annual update. The committee voted unanimously to approve resolutions for both liquor license items and to forward the MHSA update to the full board. Public Comments & Testimony - Chez Brando Liquor License (Item 1): Mark Bruno, a 34-year neighborhood resident, opposed the license, citing the small size (under 300 square feet) and potential noise conflicts with upstairs residences, given the applicant’s plan to use shared outdoor space. He noted the area already has four alcohol-serving establishments and is near an elementary school. - PianoFight Liquor License Transfer (Item 2): No public comments were made. - Mental Health Services Act Update (Item 3): No public comments were made. Discussion Items - Chez Brando Liquor License (775 Filbert Street): Officer Samelson reported one letter of protest and three letters of support. The Alcohol Liaison Unit (ALU) recommended approval with conditions: no loitering and no audible noise at nearby residences. Applicant Brandon Jesse provided emotional testimony about his 23-year history in North Beach, the loss of two brothers during the process, and his vision for a quiet wine bar focused on French-American cultural connections and community education. He agreed to the conditions. Committee members expressed support. - PianoFight Liquor License Transfer (144-146 Taylor Street): Officer Samelson reported zero letters of protest or support. The ALU recommended approval with the same conditions. Applicant Rob Reddy, co-founder, described PianoFight as a live performance venue and restaurant in the Tenderloin, deeply involved in community organizations. The request was to convert the type 47 license to type 48 to remove the food requirement, as the kitchen lost money. Committee members thanked him and noted Supervisor Preston’s support. - Mental Health Services Act Annual Update (FY2022-2023): Tracy Helton, Acting Deputy Director of MHSA, presented the annual update. Key points: MHSA is funded by a 1% tax on millionaires, generating about $39 million annually for San Francisco. In FY21-22, the program funded 83 programs serving 46,355 unduplicated clients. Highlights included 12 full-service partnership programs for severe mental illness, 7 peer programs, 8 workforce development programs. Outcomes included 6,462 fewer days in criminal justice settings for justice-involved clients, and 95% of stigma reduction participants reported increased understanding of mental health recovery. A new $5.4 million innovation project focuses on culturally congruent practices for Black/African American communities. Peer specialists are critical; two certificate programs are funded (with R.A.M.S. and City College). The state restricts MHSA funds from direct substance use disorder treatment, but recent legislation allows serving co-occurring disorders. The committee asked about peer advocate roles and funding volatility. Key Outcomes - Chez Brando (Item 1): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to prepare a resolution finding the license serves public convenience/necessity and to send it to the full board with a positive recommendation as a committee report. - PianoFight (Item 2): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to prepare a resolution and send it to the full board with a positive recommendation as a committee report. - Mental Health Services Act (Item 3): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt the resolution authorizing the FY2022-2023 annual update and to forward it to the full board with a positive recommendation. (The initial motion to file the hearing was corrected; only the resolution vote was needed.)

LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 41% · MENTAL HEALTH 38% · PROCEDURAL 14% · SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT 5%
1099
NOV 8, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - November 8, 2022

The Port Commission convened on November 8, 2022, at 10:45 AM to consider consent items, approve expansions to the retail fish sales program and transit shelter advertising agreement, and receive informational presentations on contracting, building code, and Embarcadero traffic safety improvements. Public comments centered on concerns about proposed lane reductions on the Embarcadero near Fisherman's Wharf. Consent Calendar - The Commission unanimously approved the consent calendar, including resolutions 22-51 through 22-59 (items 10A-10I): authorizing remote meeting attendance under COVID-19 emergency, sole source negotiations for retail at Pier 50 Shed B, lease with Autodesk at Pier 9, purchase of non-potable water from Mission Rock Utilities, modification to construction contracts for Crane Cove Park and Heron's Head Shoreline, acceptance of $796,100 in grant funds from SF Bay Restoration Authority, revision to operating reserve policy, and recertification of the Sanitary Sewer Management Plan. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 12A: Mark Gleason of Teamsters Local 853 expressed support for the transit shelter advertising agreement amendment, noting it would increase maintenance staffing and improve working conditions. No other public comments were received on other consent or action items. - Item 15A: Seven remote callers representing Fisherman's Wharf businesses (e.g., Pier 39, Capurro's, Boudin Bakery, Wax Museum) opposed the proposed field test to reduce northbound Embarcadero lanes from two to one at Broadway. They argued the change would exacerbate traffic congestion, harm the economic recovery of the wharf (still below pre-COVID visitation), and requested an economic impact study. They noted that 50% of Pier 39's visitors arrive by car and that the corridor is the primary north-south artery for tourists. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Item 9A): Director Forbes and Legislative Affairs Manager Boris Delepine reported on legislative achievements, including a $9.6 million federal grant for Amador Street reconstruction, $1.2 billion in state port infrastructure funding, and advocacy for offshore wind and sea level rise funds. The Port also launched equity initiatives, such as BIPOC-owned business pop-ups and racial equity training. - Retail Fish Sales Expansion (Item 11A): The Port's Maritime Division presented on expanding the retail sales program to allow fish processing tenants at Fisherman's Wharf to sell directly to the public, similar to existing off-the-boat sales. The Commission approved the expansion unanimously (Resolution 22-60), with a one-year review. - Transit Shelter Advertising Agreement (Item 12A): SFMTA and Port staff presented a second amendment to the agreement with Clear Channel Outdoor, extending the term five years through December 2027 and reducing the minimum annual guarantee. In exchange, Clear Channel will increase shelter cleaning from two to three times per week (six days a week), hire 15 additional maintenance staff, create an asset management program with $6 million in capital investments, and surrender shelter ownership at term end. The Commission approved the amendment unanimously (Resolution 22-61). - MOU with SF Environment (Item 12B): Informational presentation on a proposed five-year MOU for a building material reuse center at Seawall Lot 344, operated by SF Community Recyclers. The rent would exceed $1 million over the term. Staff recommended directing the item to the SAC and returning for approval. Commissioners expressed support, emphasizing beautification and inventory management. - LBE Contracting Activity (Item 13A): Contracts Manager Stephanie Tang reported that 60% of contracts subject to the LBE program were awarded to LBEs in FY 2021-22, with 88% of dollars going to LBEs. She highlighted improvements such as form-based RFPs, advanced notice to LBE firms, and pre-qualified pools, which have increased participation and reduced barriers. - Port Building Code Amendments (Item 14A): Chief Harbor Engineer Rod Iwashita presented proposed amendments to the 2022 Port Building Code, including requirements for floating structures not regulated by the Coast Guard, expanded site permit regulations, and special inspection requirements for aluminum welding. No action taken; action item to follow. - Embarcadero Quick-Build Traffic Safety (Item 15A): SFMTA planner Casey Hildreth presented evaluation results of the Central Embarcadero Quick-Build project, which added a protected bikeway. Bikeway usage increased to 78-94% of wheeled device users. However, the Broadway intersection experienced significant northbound left-turn delays. SFMTA proposed a field test in early 2023 to convert to two left-turn lanes and one through northbound lane to improve intersection throughput. Commissioners debated the proposal, with concerns from Lee, Brandon, and Commissioner Gilman about impacts on Fisherman's Wharf businesses, the lack of full Muni service, and the timing of the test during an off-peak season. No vote was taken; the Commission directed staff to continue engagement with stakeholders and consider economic analysis before any test. Additionally, the Commission requested a report on homeless services at transit shelters. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar adopted (Resolutions 22-51 through 22-59). - Resolution 22-60 adopted: Approved expansion of retail fish sales program to include fish processing tenants at Fisherman's Wharf. - Resolution 22-61 adopted: Approved second amendment to transit shelter advertising agreement with SFMTA and Clear Channel Outdoor. - No action on Embarcadero lane test: Commission directed staff to conduct further outreach and consider an economic impact study before implementing a field test at Broadway. - Direction to staff: Return with a report on homeless services at port-area transit shelters, and continue monitoring promenade safety with current measures before any code changes.

TRANSPORTATION 22% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · PROCEDURAL 11% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 10%
1100
NOV 8, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - November 8, 2022

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a hybrid meeting on Tuesday, November 8, 2022, starting at approximately 9:45 AM. The meeting included adoption of renewals for hybrid meeting procedures, approval of minutes, updates on drought conditions, audit reports, an in-depth presentation on the decline of Lower Tuolumne River fall-run Chinook salmon, and approval of several contracts. Key actions included unanimous approval of all agenda items, including a consent calendar of four contracts and resolutions, a supplemental appropriation for a clean energy efficiency program, and a contract for electrical distribution work. Consent Calendar - Item 9a: Accepted work performed by Alta Group, Inc. for Contract No. WD-2858R, Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Water Quality Modular Office, total contract amount $1,272,839. - Item 9b: Approved plans, specifications, and award of Contract No. WW-684 for sewer replacement on 45th, 46th, 47th Avenues, Vicente, Wawona Streets, and Sloat Blvd. in the amount of $7,342,613. - Item 9c: Approved a 365-day increase to the contract duration contingency for Contract No. WW-700 (as-needed sewer cleaning and inspection) with Pipe and Plant Solutions, Inc. - Item 9d: Approved plans, specifications, and award of Contract No. WW-705 for various locations sewer replacement No. 10 in the amount of $4,739,540, with an amendment correcting the resolution date from August 8, 2011, to August 8, 2022. All consent calendar items passed unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 5): - David Pilpel noted the new PUC letterhead, enjoyed a tour of the Oceanside treatment plant, praised quick repair of a water main break at Union and Fillmore, and highlighted recent rainfall. - A speaker expressed concern that major developments (e.g., at Lake Merced) are approved without updated sound needs assessments, urging conservation and that existing pipes are not being upgraded. - Another caller questioned the jurisdictional issues for a possible vertical expansion of the Oceanside recycled water facility, including the National Guard site and the outfall pipe within the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary. - A caller requested an update on water rates, stating that wholesale rates ($2,000 per acre-foot) appear highest in the state and projected to increase 50% in 10 years, asking for comparisons and impacts of demand and WISER bonds. - Barry Nelson (Golden State Salmon Association) welcomed Commissioner Stacy and noted the serious challenges facing salmon runs and the Bay-Delta ecosystem. - Item 3 (Adopt renewed hybrid meeting findings): One caller (Barry Nelson) was initially on the wrong item but offered no substantive comment. - Item 4 (Minutes approval): David Pilpel offered minor non-substantive edits. - Item 6 (Communications): David Pilpel appreciated the timely presentation of a report to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 7A (Drought update): A caller urged inviting local tribes to comment on river conditions and referenced the RICA Act. - Item 7B (Audit report): A caller requested a final audit on building 1550 after quality control. - Item 7C (Salmon update): Multiple public comments: - A caller criticized the presentation for not mentioning river temperature, algae, pesticides, or inviting partner agencies. - Another caller noted that historical salmon counts (pre-dam) were much higher, showing an 80% decline over recent 21-year periods and a 98% reduction from historical peaks; argued the disconnect between spring flows and salmon counts is due to destruction of habitat, not hatchery fish. - Barry Nelson (Golden State Salmon Association) argued that the flow-salmon population relationship was historically strong and that the problem is killing of wild salmon eggs and juveniles, not hatchery fish; said Tuolumne River has the worst record in the Sierra Nevada. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) pointed out a data discrepancy: the slide used two different counting methods (carcass surveys vs. weir counts), with weir counts being 2.5 times higher, so recent bars are inflated; also urged the Commission to voluntarily contribute flow as per a previous proposal. - Dave Warner thanked for the report and said the goal should be higher than 3,000 fish. - John McManus (Golden State Salmon Association) noted that river temperatures often exceed the 53.4°F needed for egg incubation, and that increased Delta exports after 2000 contributed to the 2008-09 collapse, not ocean conditions. - Cindy Charles (Tuolumne River Trust board) suggested looking at juvenile salmon condition (size, health), not just numbers. - Item 10 (West Side Recycled Water Project amendment): David Pilpel commented on the complexity of financing and suggested improving the resolution's layout. - Another caller noted inconsistency in the PUC accepting state funds for recycled water while suing the state over the Delta plan. - Item 12 (Electrical distribution contract): David Pilpel asked about potential need for Civil Service Commission or Board of Supervisors approval and about outreach to IBEW Local 6. - Closed Session (Item 13): David Pilpel requested a one-sentence summary of the underlying claim in the settlement (Oaks v. City). Discussion Items - Item 3: Adopt Renewed Findings for Hybrid Meetings – Staff presented resolution to continue hybrid meetings under state urgency legislation. Unanimously approved (5-0). - Item 4: Approval of Minutes – Minutes of the October 24, 2022 special meeting approved as amended with minor edits. Unanimous (5-0). - Item 6: Communications – Commissioners reviewed the advance calendar, correspondence log, net energy metering report, chlorate exceedance notification, and power quarterly report. Chair Jamy thanked staff. - Item 7A: Drought Conditions Update – Steve Ritchie reported reservoir storage at 73% (Hetch Hetchy) and 45% (Water Bank); state reservoirs (Shasta, Oroville, Folsom, San Luis) at 25-31% capacity. Recent storm brought 2 inches of rain to Hetch Hetchy; snow level at 4,000 feet. Demand is tracking at 171 mgd (as of last week), close to 2015 levels. State suspended curtailments on Tuolumne River diversions due to increased flows. Discussion included requests for more historical precipitation charts and acknowledgment of increasing extremes. No vote required. - Item 7B: Quarterly Audit and Performance Review – Audit Director Irvella Blackwood reported that 14% of the portfolio is completed, 54% in progress, 32% upcoming. First-quarter audits included the controller's post-audit and physical inventory. Seven open recommendations from social impact program; two from revenue bond funds. Upcoming audits include FY 2021-22 audited financials, franchise fee audits, and cybersecurity risk assessment. - Item 7C: Lower Tuolumne River Fall-run Chinook Salmon Update – Bill Sears presented a detailed biology and population update. Escapement as of Nov 7 was 356 fish, on par with 2020. Historical peaks of 40,000 fish have declined 98% over the long term. Spring flow-escapement relationship has broken down since 2000. Factors include hatchery strays (50-100% of fish), drought, ocean conditions, and invasive hyacinth. The SFPUC is party to the Voluntary Agreement for pulse flows and habitat restoration. Commission discussion focused on the impact of hatchery fish (introgression), need for 100% marking, role of temperature and pesticides, and the need for a holistic approach. Committed to providing regular updates and addressing missing data (e.g., carcass survey vs. weir count discrepancy). - Item 7D: Report on SFPUC Activities – General Manager Herrera highlighted the opening of the Southeast Community Center on October 22, 2022, noting volunteer efforts and community benefits. - Item 10: Amendment for West Side Recycled Water Project – Staff requested authorization to increase the State Revolving Fund loan/grant amount from $186,220,000 to $191,094,031 and extend the construction completion date to October 7, 2024, to align with project budget and schedule changes. Unanimous (5-0). - Item 11: Supplemental Appropriation for CleanPowerSF Community Food Service Energy Efficiency Program – Staff requested Board of Supervisors approval of $4,579,056 in supplemental appropriation from CPUC ratepayer public purpose program funds. Unanimous (5-0). - Item 12: Award Contract for As-Needed Electrical Distribution Installation & Construction Support – Staff awarded a two-year, $11.5 million contract to VIP Power Line Corporation. The contract was re-advertised after initial lack of bids. VIP is signatory to IBEW Local 1245 and has qualified staff. Commission discussed outreach to IBEW Local 6 (public sector union) and confirmed Local 6 was informed and supportive. Unanimous (5-0). Key Outcomes - Approved renewed hybrid meeting authority (5-0). - Approved minutes of October 24, 2022 (5-0). - Approved consent calendar (Items 9a-9d) as amended (5-0). - Authorized amendment to State Revolving Fund loan/grant for the West Side Recycled Water Project, increasing to $191M and extending completion to October 2024 (5-0). - Authorized supplemental appropriation of $4,579,056 for CleanPowerSF energy efficiency program (5-0). - Awarded Contract No. PW-009R to VIP Power Line Corporation for $11.5 million (5-0). - Held closed session to discuss litigation (Oaks v. City) and approved settlement of $95,000 with a full and final release; motion passed not to disclose discussions (5-0).

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 27% · PROCEDURAL 22% · FISHERIES MANAGEMENT 22% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com