The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on Tuesday, October 11, 2022, at 9:30 AM via teleconference due to the COVID-19 emergency. The meeting included reports on drought conditions and CleanPowerSF’s Integrated Resource Plan, as well as extensive public comment regarding water management on the Tuolumne River. Several agenda items were removed, including the Annual Citizens’ Advisory Committee update, the Upper Islais Creek Watershed Approach, and the Closed Session. Consent Calendar - Item 11a (Contract No. WD-2847): Approved – replacement of 8- and 16-inch ductile iron water main on Laidley Street and side streets. - Item 11b (Contract No. WW-709R): Approved – various locations sewer replacement No. 13. - A public commenter requested more background details on such contracts in future consent calendars. The Commission voted unanimously (3-0) to approve the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 6) and Comments on Drought Update (Item 9a) and CleanPowerSF (Item 9c): Over 25 members of the public spoke. Most commenters urged the Commission to increase flows to the Tuolumne River, drop the lawsuit against the State Water Board’s Bay Delta Plan, revise the “design drought” (an 8.5-year planning scenario), and invest in water recycling. Speakers included: - Castille Willie (staff attorney, State of California Fairman) – requested reevaluation of design drought to benefit Bay Delta ecosystem and tribal/environmental justice communities. - Peter Dreckmeier (policy director, Tuolumne River Trust) – noted San Francisco has over four years of water storage (966,000 acre-feet) and urged action; highlighted that unimpaired flow in the lower Tuolumne was 9% last year. - Barry Nelson (Golden State Salmon Association) – said the Tuolumne River has the worst salmon record of any Sierra Nevada river; called for science-based flow standards. - John McMahon (president, Golden State Salmon Association) – stated San Francisco is “drowning in water” while the river is dewatered; urged SFPUC to withdraw lawsuits. - Several speakers (including Danny Zaki, Sierra Club; Molly Colton, Sierra Club California; Mary Butterwick; and others) emphasized environmental justice, indigenous water rights, harmful algae blooms, and salmon population declines. Many noted that only 186 Chinook salmon were counted last year. - Nicole Sandkulla (CEO, BAWSCA – representing 26 wholesale customers and 1.8 million residents) – thanked staff for thoughtful discussion and stressed importance of balancing conservation with regional economic health. - David Pilpel – commented on communications items (7d, 7e, 7f) and the need for timely reporting. - Public comment on Consent Calendar: David Pilpel asked for more background on sewer replacement projects. Discussion Items - Item 3 – Annual Election of Officers: Postponed to a future meeting when the fifth commissioner would be installed. Motion carried 3-0. - Item 4 – Renewed Findings for Hybrid Meetings: Adopted to allow continued hybrid teleconference meetings due to COVID-19. Motion carried 3-0. One caller (David Pilpel) spoke on the item but had only a procedural comment. - Item 5 – Approval of Minutes of September 13, 2022: Continued to next meeting due to a discrepancy (the agenda referenced September 13 but minutes were for September 27). Motion carried 3-0. - Item 7 – Communications: The Commission acknowledged the reports (advance calendar, contract advertisement, correspondence log, franchise compliance, CleanPowerSF quarterly, and quarterly contract awards). Commissioner Maxwell expressed appreciation for the thorough reports. Public comment was heard. - Item 9a – Drought Conditions Update: Steve Ritchie (Assistant GM for Water) presented: - Storage at Hetch Hetchy was 89% of average; total system storage (966,000 acre-feet) equates to approximately 4.6 years of demand. - The San Francisco Bay Area received 24.1 inches of rain in water year 2022 (above average), but upcountry precipitation was below median. - Customer water savings reached 13% in San Francisco and 9% wholesale (July–September 2022), resulting in about 10.3% overall reduction from base year. - Staff is evaluating strategies for deeper conservation if drought continues, including possible two-day-per-week outdoor irrigation limits. - Commissioner Rivera asked about projections for continued conservation and policy options (e.g., onsite reuse). Commissioner Maxwell asked about reaching a target per capita usage (e.g., 45 gallons/person/day) to become more drought-resilient. Commissioner Ajami raised concerns about wastewater capacity impacts from reduced water use. Mr. Ritchie noted that the physical system means water released from Hetch Hetchy goes into Don Pedro Reservoir, operated by irrigation districts. - Item 9c – CleanPowerSF Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) Modeling Results: Cheryl Taylor (Operations Manager, CleanPowerSF) presented: - Four portfolios were modeled: two conforming (base case and 95% time-coincident) and two alternate (Mayor’s EV/building electrification targets, and 50% local resource procurement). - Staff recommends the 90% time-coincident portfolio as it balances affordability, reliability, clean energy, and local investment. The 90% case requires 922 MW of new resources by 2035 and is only 4% more costly than the base case. - The local resource procurement alternative would serve 50% of load with local resources by 2030 but would increase annual revenue requirement by roughly 50% by 2032. - Commissioners asked about time coincidence, demand forecasting, transmission planning, and local geothermal resources. Staff clarified that the 90% time-coincident portfolio provides a “happy medium” without excessive overbuilding. - Written feedback is due October 14; final approval will be sought at the October 25 meeting. Key Outcomes - Annual Election of Officers: Postponed (3-0) to a later meeting when a fifth commissioner is appointed. - Hybrid Meeting Findings: Adopted (3-0) to continue teleconference meetings. - Approval of September 13 Minutes: Continued (3-0) to next meeting due to date error. - Consent Calendar: Approved (3-0) with contract awards for water main and sewer replacement. - Drought Update: Staff will work with BAWSCA and wholesale customers to develop concrete conservation measures (e.g., two-day irrigation limits) to be presented by November 2022. - CleanPowerSF IRP: Staff will present the final preferred conforming portfolio (90% time-coincident) for adoption at the October 25, 2022 commission meeting, with submission to CPUC by November 1, 2022.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on October 6, 2022, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Raphael Mandelman. The committee considered six agenda items, including a Mills Act contract non-renewal, naming a supportive housing development, extending cannabis sunset dates, a hearing on the city's rent relief program, and a response to a civil grand jury report on Hunters Point Naval Shipyard. All items were approved or continued. Mills Act Historical Property Contract Non-Renewal – 621 Waller Street - Item 1: Resolution approving non-renewal of a Mills Act contract for 621 Waller Street due to unauthorized work. Supervisor Aaron Peskin (sponsor) noted the property owners signed the contract in 2014 but failed to comply, leading to enforcement action by the Planning Department. The Historic Preservation Commission unanimously recommended non-renewal rather than immediate termination. Property owner Renee Zelger expressed regret and stated they spent $140,000 on repairs and had worked with the city since 2020 to resolve unpermitted work. Supervisor Peskin countered that the contract requires compliance with city laws. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. Naming Supportive Housing for Margot Antonetti – 1321 Mission Street - Item 2: Ordinance to name the permanent supportive housing development at 1321 Mission Street in memory of public health advocate Margot Antonetti, who passed away on May 26, 2020. Supervisor Mandelman (sponsor) highlighted her three decades of work creating hundreds of supportive housing units and influencing HIV, harm reduction, and homelessness policies. Lauren Hall, Executive Director of DSH, and Sherilyn Adams, Executive Director of Larkin Street Youth Services, gave presentations noting the building has 120 studio units and 39 units for families, with modern amenities. Public comment was not offered. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Cannabis Sunset Date Extension - Item 3: Ordinance extending the sunset date for medical cannabis dispensary provisions and temporary cannabis business permits from December 31, 2022, to December 31, 2024. Supervisor Mandelman (sponsor) stated the extension is needed to allow businesses that came forward during the amnesty program to continue operating while their permanent applications are processed. Nikesh Patel, Director of the Office of Cannabis, reported that 33 medical cannabis dispensaries are active, 60 temporary permit holders exist, and the office has cleared a backlog of equity applicant applications, issuing 31 equity permits. The office has hired three additional staff to process remaining applications. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the ordinance to the full board. Hearing on City’s Rent Relief Program - Item 4: Hearing to review the city’s rent relief program, prompted by the September 21, 2022 announcement that the program would pause accepting new applications effective September 23. Chair Preston expressed concern about the short notice and the need to protect tenants. Eric Shaw, Director of MOHCD, reported that the program has served nearly 5,000 households with $34 million distributed, and $43 million remains available. There is a backlog of about 4,500 pending applications, with 250–300 new applications per week. The pause aims to clear the backlog and improve processing times; the program expects to resume in a few weeks to months. Public comment included praise for case managers and a request to allow re-applications for those with intermittent income. The committee voted to continue the item to the call of the chair (3-0). Civil Grand Jury Report – Hunters Point Naval Shipyard - Items 5 & 6: Hearing (Item 5) and resolution (Item 6) responding to the civil grand jury report “Buried Problems and a Buried Process: The Hunters Point Naval Shipyard in a Time of Climate Change.” President Walton’s chief of staff Natalie G. presented amendments to the resolution, which the committee adopted. The amendments include agreeing with findings F4, F5, and partially F6; implementing recommendation R2 (independent commission and third-party study); not implementing R3 and R7 but creating a short-term task force within 18 months; and urging the mayor to implement accepted findings. Public comment strongly urged the Board to refuse land transfer unless cleaned to unrestricted residential standards, and criticized the EPA for not requiring full cleanup. The committee voted to adopt the amendments, then passed the amended resolution (Item 6) to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0), and filed Item 5 (3-0) after initially voting to continue. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Mills Act non-renewal): Approved unanimously (3-0) to full board. - Item 2 (Naming building): Approved unanimously (3-0) to full board. - Item 3 (Cannabis sunset): Approved unanimously (3-0) to full board. - Item 4 (Rent relief hearing): Continued to call of the chair (3-0). - Item 5 (Grand jury hearing): Filed (3-0) after initial motion to continue was rescinded. - Item 6 (Grand jury response): Amended and approved unanimously (3-0) to full board.
The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular meeting on Wednesday, October 5, 2022, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included presentations on recruitment of women, a status update on sustained DPA cases, and community policing plans. Commissioners voted on several routine items, adopted revised department general orders, accepted gifts and grants, and heard public comment on racial disparities and other issues. The meeting lasted approximately four hours and included a closed session. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Minutes: The commission adopted the minutes for the meetings of September 7 and September 21, 2022, by a unanimous vote. The minutes for September 14 were tabled due to a dispute over whether a second motion had been properly made regarding the election of officers; the commission will review the video recording before taking action. - Awards Certification Panel (Item 9): The commission unanimously approved the panel’s recommendations for police awards, as listed in the chief’s letter. - Revised Department General Order 2.08 (Item 11): The commission unanimously approved revised DGO 2.08, “Peace Officer Rights in Disciplinary Investigations,” for meet and confer with the SFPOA. - Acceptance of Gift Vehicles (Item 13): The commission unanimously adopted a resolution urging the Board of Supervisors to authorize the Chief to accept and expend an in-kind gift of two utility vehicles (estimated market value $38,644.58) from the Union Square Alliance for high-visibility patrol. - Acceptance of Cal OES Grant (Item 14): The commission unanimously adopted a resolution urging the Board of Supervisors to authorize the Chief to accept a $69,818 grant from the California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services for the crime lab’s continuing education and instrumentation. Public Comments & Testimony - Racial Disparities and Accountability: Several callers speaking for the group Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community (including David Aronson, Susan Buckman, and Jean Bridges, reading statements from founder Felicia Jones) expressed frustration with persistent anti-black disparities in SFPD use of force, arrests, and traffic stops. They called the commission’s attention to a lack of urgency, the need for reporting on repeat-offender officers with demographic data (citing DOJ COPS recommendation 69.3), and the omission of pre-2017 officer-involved shootings from recent presentations. One caller specifically noted that Black San Franciscans are 15 times as likely to experience use of force as white San Franciscans, according to the 2022 Q1 report. - Opposition to Gift Vehicles: Susan Buckman, speaking for herself, opposed accepting the utility vehicles from the Union Square Alliance, calling it a “bribe” and warning that such gifts could lead to mission creep similar to the federal drug war. - Unsolved Homicide: Paul Ed Brown thanked the commission and District Attorney Brooke Jenkins for assistance obtaining a headstone for his son, who was murdered in 2006, and reiterated the need for resolution in unsolved cases. - Community Policing Criticism: Gloria Barry (District 10) criticized SFPD’s community policing efforts, urging better marketing, attendance at non-police events, and an end to using police cars for photos with Black children. - Traffic Enforcement: Paul Allen (brief technical issue) referenced a draft traffic enforcement order (9.01) in supplemental written comments. Discussion Items - Recruitment of Women (Item 3): The commission heard two presentations. First, Maureen McGoff, founder of the 30x30 Initiative, described research showing women officers use force less often, have fewer lawsuits, and are more effective at searches. She noted that only 12% of sworn officers and 3% of police leaders nationally are women, and that SFPD had announced its intention to join the 30x30 initiative (confirmed by Chief Scott on September 12). McGoff emphasized low-cost strategies: improving recruitment messaging, removing bias in hiring assessments, providing fitting equipment (vests, uniforms), lactation spaces, and childcare. Second, Commander Nicole Jones presented SFPD’s current efforts: 14.3% sworn women (above national average), 17% of leadership, and 19% of academy recruits in 2022 are women. She outlined recruitment events (95% had at least one female recruiter), elimination of height-weight requirement, replacement of the trigger pull test, and planned partnerships with a marketing firm and a recruiting firm. Commissioners discussed the need for paid parental leave, childcare, suitable firearms, and more women in specialty units (none currently on SWAT or Tactical). Chief Scott confirmed the department is reviewing a new weapon and has approved outer body armor carriers that better fit women. Commissioner Walker emphasized telling success stories to attract recruits. - Chief’s Report (Item 4): Chief Scott reported year-to-date crime statistics: violent crime up 8% overall, homicides down 7% (40 compared to 43 in 2021), gun-related homicides down 18%, total gun violence down 4%. Gun recoveries are up 6% (805 firearms, including 163 ghost guns). The clearance rate for homicides is 60%. He highlighted three recent homicide arrests and announced a renewed effort in the Tenderloin, combining enforcement with transportation to services (using unmarked vans). Commissioners questioned the effectiveness of previous Tenderloin surges; Chief Scott acknowledged displacement and limited resources, but said the focus is on collaboration with DPH and service providers. He also noted a planned meeting with a judge to resolve remaining issues in the MOU with the DA (expiring October 17). Commissioner Yi noted improvements in daytime Tenderloin conditions but continuing issues at night. Commissioner Byrne pressed for more night deployment. Chief Scott said a more equitable overtime plan is being negotiated with the POA to sustain night patrols. Commissioner Yannis raised concerns about increased juvenile detentions (18 currently, up from an average of 4-5) potentially linked to drug arrests, and urged diversion efforts and attention to human trafficking victims. Chief Scott mentioned ongoing work on a pre-arrest diversion program with Probation Chief Miller. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 5): Director Paul Henderson reported 2,526 cases opened year to date, 566 closed, 236 pending, and 49 sustained (up from 39 last year). 83 cases are pending with the chief. He announced plans to issue interim audit reports instead of waiting for full final reports, to enable faster action. He suggested the commission request a comprehensive list of all academic partnerships in the department. - Commission Reports (Item 6): Several commissioners reported progress on DGO assignments. Vice President Carter Oberstone noted a three-hour town hall with traffic officers on DGO 9.01 (pretext stops) and set 90-day clocks for DGOs 6.08, 8.03, 8.10, and 9.05. Commissioner Benedicto reported on DGOs 7.01 (juvenile policy) and 5.16 (search warrants), and noted that interim audit reports may be ready by November. Commissioner Yannis requested agendizing a revision of DGO 2.09 (social media) and an update on the new early intervention system (benchmark). President Elias set 90-day clock for DGO 5.08. - Sustained DPA Cases Pending Chief’s Review (Item 7): Commander Paul Yep presented a status report on 89 sustained cases as of September 16, 2022. Breakdown: 7 closed, 19 open-assigned to attorney, 46 open pending chief’s hearing (member appeal), 6 open pending chief’s hearing appeal (requesting commission hearing), 7 open pending chief’s review, 1 open pending meet and confer, 3 waiting for commission hearing. President Elias asked about the oldest case and the number of multiple-offense cases. Commander Yep agreed to provide those data. Director Henderson commended the transparency and requested additional information on 3304 statute-of-limitations violations, reasons for rescheduled hearings, and the volume of cases with multiple sustained findings. The commission agreed to follow up. - Community Policing Plans (Item 8): Commander Juan Young and Captain Chris Del Gandio presented the department’s community policing plans (DGO 1.08). Plans are now published as public-facing slide presentations on the website. A new ordinance (Supervisor Mar) requires enhanced community engagement, foot/bike patrol emphasis, and language access. Captain Del Gandio noted a four-hour training for captains. Commissioner Yannis requested more granular quantitative data (number of events, participants, survey results) to measure engagement and ensure consistency across stations. Director Diana Oliva Roche said the department is seeking an academic partner to develop data-driven metrics and is studying other cities (NYPD, Seattle). The commission pushed for inclusion of critical voices and language access in all plans. - Revised DGO 8.01 (Item 12): The commission was scheduled to vote on revised DGO 8.01, “Major and Critical Incident Evaluation and Notifications.” Chief Scott requested a last-minute change to language on first-arriving supervisor responsibilities (adding “when feasible” to establishing a command post to avoid conflict with active-attacker training). Commissioner Byrne objected to voting on an un-posted change, citing consistency with past commission practice. President Elias agreed to hold the item over to the next meeting so the revised version can be posted for public review. The DGO will be brought back the following week. Key Outcomes - Minutes: Adopted for September 7 and 21; tabled for September 14 (pending review of video). - DGO 2.08: Approved unanimously for meet and confer. - Awards Panel: Approved unanimously. - Gift Vehicles: Approved unanimously (resolution to BOS). - Cal OES Grant: Approved unanimously (resolution to BOS). - DGO 8.01: Continued to next meeting (October 12) to incorporate minor change and allow public review. - Closed Session: Unanimous vote to hold, and later unanimous vote not to disclose any discussion. - SFPD Joining 30x30: Chief Scott announced the department publicly committed to the 30x30 initiative on September 12; the official paperwork is forthcoming. - Notice of POST Audit: The chief confirmed that POST has a scheduled general background investigation audit (annual), but it is unrelated to recent Alameda County issues. - Next Steps: Commissioners will continue working on assigned DGOs. The next meeting will include the re-posted DGO 8.01 and possibly an update on the DA MOU.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met in a hybrid special session on Thursday, September 29, 2022, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston and also attended by Vice Chair Connie Chan and Board President Shamann Walton (sitting in for Supervisor Mandelman, who was excused). The committee took up three major matters: the civil grand jury report on Hunters Point Naval Shipyard, the city's comprehensive overdose prevention plan, and a resolution regarding the taxi upfront fare pilot. Public Comments & Testimony - Hunters Point: Community members and advocates expressed deep frustration and distrust, saying agencies had failed the Bayview Hunters Point community. Speakers included Ariane Harrison (Marie Harrison Community Foundation), who said she had test results showing plutonium, uranium, silica, and lead-based isotopes in community members; Dr. Ahimsa Sumchai (Hunters Point Community Biomonitoring Program), who urged reinstatement of the Hunters Point Shipyard Restoration Advisory Board and implementation of Proposition P as an ordinance; and Dan Hirsch (Committee to Bridge the Gap), who argued the Navy planned to leave the majority of contamination covered up rather than fully cleaned and urged the Board not to accept transfer of the land without a 100% complete cleanup. Dr. Robert Gould (San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility) expressed outrage at the mayor's dismissal of the grand jury report. - Overdose Prevention: Public comment was overwhelmingly in favor of the DPH plan and overdose prevention centers, with many speakers urging faster and broader implementation. Tom Wolf, a recovery advocate, criticized the plan for omitting the word "recovery" and called for treatment on demand. Representatives from DISH, HomeRise, Gubbio Project, Safer Inside Coalition, Treatment on Demand Coalition, and others urged full funding for peer overdose responders, "Brave Button" programs, naloxone saturation in supportive housing, and citywide overdose prevention centers. Ellen Graham (Mothers Against Drug Death) expressed frustration about lack of recovery services and cautioned against supervised consumption sites, citing negative findings she attributed to Vancouver. - Taxi Pilot: Taxi drivers, medallion holders, Grey Panthers, Teamsters, and community members largely supported Supervisor Chan's resolution to remove third-party dispatch, citing Uber's predatory pricing, data opacity, harm to the taxi industry, and risks to seniors and paratransit riders without smartphones. Some taxi drivers, including Flywheel president Hansu Kim and several medallion holders, supported the third-party arrangement, saying it would bring more trips and income to taxi drivers. Discussion Items - Hunters Point Naval Shipyard (Items 1 & 2): The committee heard a report on the Civil Grand Jury report "Buried Problems and a Buried Process: The Hunters Point Naval Shipyard in a Time of Climate Change," released June 1, 2022. The Board was asked to respond to findings four, five, and six and recommendations two, three, and seven on pages 37 and 38. U.S. EPA Region 9 Assistant Director Angeles Herrera said the site is a priority, that EPA will require the Navy to assess vulnerabilities and develop adaptive plans for climate change, and that EPA will elevate concerns to the Pentagon if necessary. DTSC Northern California Division Chief Naline Cowbell said the department recognizes climate change as an urgent crisis and will address sea level rise and groundwater rise through the five-year review. A letter from the San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board was read because water board staff were unavailable due to a previously scheduled racial equity and environmental justice training. Mayor's Office representative Tom Paulino said the administration would not amend its written response but would work collaboratively if the Board created a task force or independent study. Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson noted that a subpoena request to the Navy was possible under Board rules but unlikely to be completed within the grand jury response timeline. President Walton proposed amendments to the Board response, including changing recommendation R2 to "will be implemented," creating a short-term task force for recommendation three, and implementing recommendation seven within 18 months. - Comprehensive Overdose Prevention Plan (Item 3): The Department of Public Health presented its plan, released the day before the hearing. Dr. Hilary Kunins described the national crisis, with more than 100,000 overdose deaths in the U.S. in 2021, and highlighted severe racial disparities in San Francisco, with Black/African American residents dying at exponentially higher rates. The plan includes wellness hubs with overdose prevention services, expanded medications for addiction treatment, increased naloxone distribution from 47,000 to 75,000 kits annually in the first one to two years and to 100,000 kits in three to four years, and completion of a public data dashboard. Epidemiologist Alex Kral of RTI International said existing harm reduction services work and should be expanded, and that overdose prevention sites have no negative peer-reviewed findings. Jeanette Zanipatin of Drug Policy Alliance argued against criminalization and involuntary treatment, noting people are 120 times more likely to die of opioid overdose in the first two weeks after incarceration. Maurice Byrd of Harm Reduction Therapy Center said the war on drugs is racist and called for regulation and safer supply. In response to Supervisor Preston, Dr. Kunins confirmed the first wellness hub is planned to open by December 2022, with a second in 2023, while saying the city aims to minimize any gap when the Tenderloin center closes. - Taxi Upfront Fare Pilot Resolution (Item 4): Supervisor Chan introduced a non-binding resolution urging the SFMTA Board of Directors to remove third-party dispatch from the taxi upfront fare pilot. SFMTA Director of Taxis Kate Toran explained that the pilot was approved in September 2021, the third-party provision was added in April 2022, and applications had been received from Aero, Flywheel, and Yo Taxi. She said the one-year pilot includes opt-out rights for drivers, data reporting through an API, quarterly public meetings, and the ability to adjust rules. SFCTA Deputy Director Joe Castelone said TNCs have resisted sharing data with the city, and only one set of data had been received from the CPUC in about ten years. Supervisor Chan and Chair Preston raised concerns about dynamic pricing, data asymmetry, paratransit access, and what the city would receive from Uber in exchange. Public comment was split, with many drivers opposing the arrangement and others supporting it as an additional source of income. Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2 (Hunters Point): The hearing and Board response were continued to the committee's next regular meeting on October 6, 2022, to allow President Walton, the City Attorney, and other parties to finalize amendments to the response. No final Board response was adopted. - Item 3 (Overdose Prevention): The committee filed and closed the hearing on the comprehensive overdose prevention plan by a 2-0 vote. Supervisor Preston said the plan is a strong starting point and emphasized that safe consumption sites work and must be implemented "to the greatest extent legally possible." - Item 4 (Taxi Pilot): The committee adopted Supervisor Chan's clarifying amendments to the resolution by a 2-0 vote, then voted 2-0 to continue the item to the call of the chair. Supervisor Chan said she would facilitate further conversations among SFMTA, SFCTA, taxi workers, and stakeholders before the SFMTA's next quarterly public meeting in November 2022. The resolution itself was not approved or rejected.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a hybrid in-person and remote meeting on September 27, 2022, at City Hall Room 400. The meeting included recognition of retiring employees and Commissioner Anson Moran, updates on drought conditions, a retail drought response framework, a capital financing plan, and approvals of several consent calendar items and two regular agenda items. The commission also voted to recommend a settlement in closed session. Consent Calendar - Item 12C was initially pulled by Commissioner Maxwell for questions regarding contract delays due to COVID and material delivery. Staff confirmed that delays resulted in non-compensable time extensions, with cost-sharing on health and safety measures. The item was then adopted with the rest of the consent calendar. - The consent calendar (Items A, B, C) was approved unanimously (3-0) after public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 5): Six callers spoke during general public comment. The majority expressed urgent concerns about the Tuolumne River ecosystem and the SFPUC's water management strategies. Key points included: - Carol Ruth stated that the 8.5-year design drought would be a "eulogy for the Tuolumne River," citing a drop from 25,000 salmon returns in the 1950s to 186 in 2021. She urged reduction of the design drought by at least one to two years. - Jan Dorman (Friends of the River) encouraged the commission to revisit design drought assumptions and incorporate climate change, state in-stream flow requirements, and demand sensitivity. - Mary Butterwick and Martin Gothberg called for increasing flows, dropping the lawsuit against the State Water Board, and improving public information requests. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) criticized a new voluntary agreement as likely to fail and cited a lack of transparency in response to Public Records Act requests. - Julianne Frizell and Les Kitler similarly urged protection of the ecosystem and reconsideration of the lawsuit. - Retirement and Recognition (Items 7 & 8): Public comment included: - Craig Byrne, spouse of retiree Sarah Blaine, thanked the commission for recognizing his wife's service during COVID and wildfires. - Ed Harrington, former SFPUC General Manager, praised Commissioner Moran's service and his unique qualifications for Seat 4. - Peter Dreckmeyer expressed appreciation for Commissioner Moran's willingness to engage despite policy disagreements. - BAWSCA Update (Item 9): Two callers commented. One speaker (Peter Dreckmeyer) noted that water price increases from the WSIP had driven demand reductions and criticized the commission for inconsistent use of demand projections. Another caller referenced the 1974 legislation and water rights issues. - Closed Session (Items 16-18): No public comments were submitted. Discussion Items - Retirement Recognitions (Item 7): Five retirees were recognized for distinguished service: Sarah Blaine (engineer, 26 yrs), Leonid Weinstein (maintenance planner, 26 yrs), Colin Riley (truck driver, 33 yrs), Petronia Torres (customer service manager, 37 total yrs), and Virginia Sarmiento (customer contact manager, 31 yrs). Commissioners expressed gratitude for their dedication and impact. - Recognition of Commissioner Anson Moran (Item 8): Commissioner Moran was honored for nearly 50 years of service to the SFPUC, including as General Manager (1993-2000) and Commissioner (2009-2022). Speakers (General Manager Herrera, Commissioners, former GM Ed Harrington, and staff) praised his expertise, leadership, and calm demeanor. He was presented with a commemorative water meter. - BAWSCA Update (Item 9): Nicole Senko, CEO of Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency, presented data on water use trends. Key points: Regional residential per capita use declined from 71 gpcd in fiscal year 2013 to 66 gpcd in fiscal year 2021. July 2022 water use was 14% lower than July 2019, but not as low as 2015 levels. She discussed challenges in achieving further reductions and efforts to promote greywater reuse and demand-side management. Commissioner Jemmy requested benchmarking of commercial customers and exploration of rate decoupling. - General Manager's Report (Item 10): - Drought Conditions (10A): Ellen Levin reported that reservoir storage is at less than half of capacity for water bank. September storms brought 1.43 inches of precipitation at Hetch Hetchy, but no water was available from those storms. Outreach included a partnership with the San Francisco Giants (PSAs at 29 home games). - Retail Drought Response Framework (10B): Fan Lau presented a framework for mandatory reductions among three customer sectors: irrigation first (percentage reduction from base year), then residential (per capita allocation), then non-residential (percentage reduction, with different percentages for essential services). The framework will inform billing system upgrades and will require commission approval before implementation. Commissioner Jemmy noted the importance of benchmarking and rate decoupling. - Capital Financing Plan FY 2023 (10C): Nikolai Sklarov presented the plan. The SFPUC has $7 billion in outstanding debt. Interest rates are rising (75 basis point Fed hike anticipated). The plan includes $515,000 for a basis-of-design report for the Peninsula Pure Water Project (MOA with multiple agencies). Financing will come from WIFIA and state revolving funds. Water and wastewater bond issuances are expected in early 2023. - New Commission Business (Item 11): Commissioner Jemmy requested that staff explore rate decoupling to align revenue with fixed infrastructure costs as water use declines, noting that similar decoupling is already used for the power enterprise. - Amend Section F (Water Efficient Irrigation) (Item 13): Julie Ortiz presented a procedural update to require organic mulch to comply with SB 1383. The item passed unanimously. - Peninsula Pure Water Project MOA (Item 15): Approved authorization for a $515,000, 27-month agreement with six agencies to prepare a basis-of-design report for a regional potable reuse project (capacity 5-12 MGD). Commissioner Jemmy requested scenario analysis including on-site reuse impacts. Key Outcomes - Votes: - Adopted renewed findings allowing hybrid meetings (3-0). - Approved minutes of September 13, 2022 (3-0). - Consent calendar (Items A, B, C) adopted after removal of Item C for discussion (3-0). - Item 13 (mulch amendment) passed (3-0). - Item 15 (Peninsula Pure Water MOA) approved (3-0). - Motion to assert attorney-client privilege for closed session passed (3-0). - Closed Session: The commission voted to recommend settlement of the personal injury claim (Victor Jimenez vs. City) in the amount of $100,000, subject to Board of Supervisors approval. No disclosure of closed session discussions was authorized. - Directives: Staff was directed to bring forward information on rate decoupling for discussion at a future meeting. - Next Steps: The commission will continue drought monitoring and may consider mandatory retail reductions if dry conditions persist. The urban water demand projection update from BAWSCA is expected by end of 2022.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, September 22, 2022, at 6:15 PM. Chair Supervisor Gordon Mar presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and eventually Committee Member Myrna Melgar (who was absent for the first vote but present for later votes). The agenda consisted of three routine liquor license transfer hearings. No public comment was offered on any item. Regular Agenda Items Item 1 – Liquor License Transfer (Type 20 and Type 86) – 556 Hayes Street – True Sake - Presentation: Officer Salmanson of the SFPD ABC Liaison Unit reported zero letters of protest or support. The location is in a high crime plot and high saturation census tract. Northern Station had no opposition; the Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval with a condition to actively monitor adjacent property to prevent loitering. - Applicant: Bo Timkin, owner of True Sake, described the 20-year history of the business in Hayes Valley and plans to expand to serve customers better. - Committee Action: Chair Mar noted Supervisor Preston’s support. A motion was made to prepare a resolution of public convenience and necessity and send to the full board with a positive recommendation. The vote was 2-0-1 (Stefani aye, Mar aye, Melgar absent). Later, upon request, the committee rescinded that vote and re-voted to send the item out as a committee report. The rescission motion passed 2-0-1; the subsequent motion to issue a committee report passed 3-0 (Melgar now voting aye). Item 2 – Liquor License Transfer (Type 20) – 221 Sansome Street – 7-Eleven - Presentation: Officer Salmanson reported zero letters of protest or support. The location is in a high crime plot and high saturation census tract. - Applicant: Ryan Kroll, on behalf of franchisees Sarge and Mike Singh, stated that customers had requested beer and wine sales for convenience. The application included 118 support signatures. The planning department and police recommended approval subject to standard conditions, which the applicant accepted. - Committee Action: Chair Mar noted Supervisor Peskin’s support. A motion was made to prepare a resolution and send it as a committee report to the full board with positive recommendation. The vote was 2-0-1 (Stefani aye, Mar aye, Melgar absent). Item 3 – Liquor License Double Transfer (Type 57, converted from Type 47) – 735 Montgomery Street – Chief S.F. - Presentation: Officer Salmanson reported zero letters of protest or support. The location is in a high crime plot and high saturation census tract. He explained that the double transfer moves an existing license to a new location and converts it to a type 57 (special on-sale general for a private club). - Applicant: Victor Marquez introduced Chief S.F., a private membership organization focused on supporting women executive leaders, with venues in other cities and now opening in San Francisco. He emphasized the need for a safe space for women leaders to network and mentor. - Committee Action: Chair Mar noted Supervisor Peskin’s support. A motion to prepare a resolution and send as a committee report passed unanimously 3-0 (Stefani aye, Melgar aye, Mar aye). Key Outcomes - All three license transfers were approved and will be forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation as committee reports. - No public comment was received on any item. - The meeting adjourned after concluding all business.
The San Francisco Police Commission convened on Wednesday, September 21, 2022, at 1:45 PM UTC for a regular meeting. The agenda covered the Chief’s Report, DPA Director’s Report, commission reports, presentations on policy development (Sparks Report), a new DPA case management system, DPA’s mediation program, and DPA’s Law & Justice Reform Internship, followed by a closed session. Commissioners present: President Elias, Vice President Carter Overstone, Commissioner Walker, Commissioner Benedicto, Commissioner Yanez, and Commissioner Yi (arrived late). Commissioner Byrne was excused. Acting Chief David Lazar filled in for Chief Scott, and DPA Director Paul Henderson initially had tech issues but later joined. Consent Calendar - The Commission unanimously approved the consent calendar (5-0), receiving and filing SFPD SB 1421 and SB16 monthly reports (July–August 2022) and DPA SB 1421 and SB16 monthly reports (August–September 2022). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Susan Buffman, volunteering with Welcome Disparities in the Black Community, read a statement from founder Felicia Jones expressing frustration over perceived anti-Blackness in SFPD’s use of force, arrests, racial profiling, and traffic stops. She criticized the working group process for the pretext traffic stops policy and urged commissioners to take responsibility. - Public Comment (General): David Calderon raised ongoing complaints about the mishandling of his mother’s homicide case (Carmelita Holbrook), stating DPA Director Henderson had failed to contact him as instructed in July. He also alleged investigator misconduct and requested direct assistance. - Public Comment (General): A speaker identified as Ms. Brown thanked the police commission and DA Brooke Jenkins for supporting a headstone for her son Aubrey Aberkassa, murdered in 2006, and said she was awaiting the headstone’s installation. - Public Comment (Chief’s Report): None. - Public Comment (DPA Director’s Report): David Calderon again appealed for help with his mother’s case, claiming conflicting information from DPA and SFPD. - Public Comment (Commission Reports): A caller discussed traffic enforcement, saying the article about low ticket numbers was not fully wrong, and urged police to focus on pedestrian safety issues like cars encroaching on crosswalks. - Public Comment (Case Management System): Francisco De Costa asked how the new system would track cases that are resurrected after long delays, citing his experience with officer complaints. - Public Comment (Mediation Program): A caller praised the restorative justice model but criticized SFPD’s rigid policies and the handling of POPS recommendations. - Public Comment (Internship Presentation): None. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report: Acting Chief Lazar reported a 7% increase in violent crime (3,784 vs. 3,553) and an 8% increase in property crime (30,453 vs. 33,000). He highlighted weekly declines in burglaries (down 22%, about 1,000 fewer) and arson (down 13%), but noted increases in larceny (up 18%), auto burglaries (up 12%), motor vehicle theft (up 4%), rapes (up 9%), robberies (up 4%), and assaults (up 10%). There were 38 homicides, 131 shooting incidents, and 151 shooting victims. Officers recovered 758 firearms (up 4% from 2021) and 129 ghost guns. He detailed a Tenderloin microgrant (from the U.S. DOJ COPS Office) that funded increased foot patrols, community outreach, and youth partnerships, resulting in 466 engagements, 59 arrests, 325 citations, and 82 admonishments. Daily joint field operations meetings with city and community partners are underway. He also recognized Officer of the Month awards and upcoming events (Dream Force, Fleet Week, Coffee with a Cop). - Chief’s Report – Commissioner Q&A: President Elias asked whether burglary reduction strategies could be applied to violent crime; Acting Chief Lazar said similar tactics are used (focused enforcement, community engagement, life coaches). Regarding surveillance technology (19B), Lazar stated the Board of Supervisors approved it on first reading, with a second reading expected in a week; the department will develop policies and training before deploying temporary live monitoring. President Elias said she would agenda the item for the first meeting in October. Vice President Carter Overstone asked about DGO 3.01 not being posted; Lazar committed to following up. Commissioner Benedicto asked about the Tenderloin grant; Lazar confirmed the grantor and said an after-action report is expected when the grant ends in November. Commissioner Yi praised airport officers for handling a rally well. Commissioner Yanez asked about engagement with DPH for substance users; Lazar described referrals and ongoing coordination, acknowledging HIPAA challenges. Commissioner Walker raised the need for other agencies to participate in treatment on demand. - DPA Director’s Report: Director Henderson reported year-to-date statistics: 488 cases opened, 522 closed, 244 active, 48 sustained (vs. 37 last year), 16 mediated, 24 cases over nine months, and 79 cases pending with the Chief’s office. He shared monthly data for June, July, and August: the most common allegations were officers speaking/behaving inappropriately (34%–40%) and failing to take required action (25%–38%). He attended the NACOL conference and highlighted ongoing outreach. He also explained that witnesses can file self-reported complaints anonymously, and DPA conducts independent investigations. - Commission Reports: President Elias announced that the surveillance item and the department’s presentation on DPA numbers would be agendized for the first October meeting. She also noted that DGOs would be assigned to commissioners to expedite revisions. Vice President Carter Overstone reported attending a town hall on DGO 9.01. Commissioner Yanez raised concerns about low traffic enforcement numbers from an article; Acting Chief Lazar corrected that there are only 23 motorcycle officers (not 45) and that enforcement has increased since the article. - Sparks Report (SFPD/DPA General Orders Status): Catherine McGuire (SFPD) presented the Q2 2022 status update on DGO development, noting progress on DGOs 2.01, 8.01, and 11.08. She acknowledged delays in publishing DGO 3.01 but committed to publishing it by September 28, 2022. Janelle Kaywood (DPA) reported on policy work, including collaboration on a disengagement policy. Sergeant Donald Anderson explained the disengagement policy concept (a tactical decision to delay contact, based on POST definitions and state law 835A). DPA made 28 recommendations; the policy passed concurrence in Q3 and is expected to be presented to the Commission in Q4. Commissioner concerns: Vice President Carter Overstone stressed that the department cannot unilaterally extend implementation dates after a DGO is passed. Commissioner Benedicto asked about body-worn camera policy expiration and requested more detail in future Sparks reports. - DPA Case Management System: Nicole Armstrong and consultants from ZS Associates presented a new complainant portal, developed pro bono through the Mayor’s Civic Bridge program. The portal allows complainants to track case status using a case number and PIN, upload documents, and receive real-time updates. It is live now and integrated with DPA’s Salesforce system at zero additional cost. Director Henderson suggested the system could potentially be adapted for SFPD or the Commission. Commissioners praised the tool’s transparency and user-friendliness. - DPA Mediation Program: Ally Schulteis, Director of Mediations, explained the program as a voluntary alternative to investigation, facilitating dialogue between complainants and officers. The program uses approximately 40 pro bono co-mediators, covers allegations like rudeness or neglect of duty, and excludes cases like use of force. Mediation closures are confidential and no discipline is recommended. Exit surveys show high satisfaction. Trends include increased mediations with station representatives and cases from the Tenderloin and Traffic Company. Goals include increasing case numbers and visibility. - DPA Law & Justice Reform Internship: DPA staff presented the summer 2022 internship program, which includes professional development, speaker series, and community engagement. A highlight was the interns’ policy recommendation on foot pursuits, citing that foot pursuits increase the likelihood of police using force by 345%, and recommending SFPD establish a foot pursuit policy, collect data, and prohibit pursuits based solely on flight. Director Henderson praised the interns’ evidence-based work. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar adopted unanimously (5-0). - DGO 3.01 to be published and posted to Power DMS by September 28, 2022; a confirmation letter will be sent to the Commission. - Surveillance technology item agendized for the first Commission meeting in October 2022. - The department will provide a presentation on Chief’s hearing cases at the first October 2022 meeting. - Acting Chief Lazar clarified traffic officer staffing (23 motorcycle officers) and committed to continued enforcement. - Disengagement policy passed concurrence and will be presented to the Commission in Q4 2022. - DPA’s case management portal is live and self-sufficient. - Interns’ foot pursuit recommendations were acknowledged and will be considered. - Motion to hold closed session passed (4-0, with Commissioner Walker absent); motion to disclose closed session discussion failed, and the Commission voted not to disclose (4-0). - Meeting adjourned.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston and joined by Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Rafael Mandelman (later excused and replaced by Board President Shamann Walton for items 3-4), convened on September 15, 2022, to hear and respond to three civil grand jury reports: on capital construction projects, the Hunters Point Naval Shipyard cleanup, and park accessibility. The committee also approved multiple closed session litigation settlements and tolling agreements. Key themes included accountability for contractor performance, the need for independent oversight of the Navy's cleanup, and improving park accessibility information for the public. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1-2 (Capital Construction): Francisco DeCosta criticized lack of enforcement, citing cost overruns on the Central Subway and SFPUC projects. Dennis Williams (Fillmore Merchant Collaborative) argued for inclusion of Black-owned contractors. The 2022-23 Civil Grand Jury foreperson thanked the previous jury for their work. - Items 3-4 (Hunters Point Shipyard): Multiple community members and activists (e.g., Ariane Harrison, Dr. Hensa Porterson Chai, Bradley Angel, others) expressed strong support for a full cleanup and criticized the Navy's absence. Speakers demanded independent testing, an oversight committee, and accountability. Daniel Hirsch noted that 90-97% of radiological tests were falsified by a Navy contractor. Several speakers urged the Board to block land transfer until 100% cleanup. - Items 5-6 (Parks): Anthony David highlighted trip hazards in parks and called for warning signs. David Oska argued the grand jury report did not go far enough, citing threats to parkland from development. Discussion Items Items 1-2: Civil Grand Jury Report - "Shovel Ready: Best Practices and Collaboration to Improve San Francisco’s Capital Construction Program" - Civil Grand Jury Presentation: Michael Hoffman and Jason Golz summarized findings: a contractor performance evaluation database created via Admin Code Chapter 6 in 2016 remains unused since February 2020; no accountability for non-use; no project manager; database platform no longer supported; $40 billion in capital projects planned through 2029. They recommended the database be revived, expanded to include SIP program compliance and feedback from non-Chapter 6 departments, and that the Controller periodically audit construction performance. - Mayor’s Office Response (Douglas Legg): Agreed improvements are needed but cited staffing shortages (20% vacancy at Public Works), the need to change low-bid contracting practices, and that the database alone won't solve problems. He noted that Public Works will be the lead agency but could not provide a firm timeline for implementation. - Public Works Response (Ron Alameda): Detailed history: database built at $250,000, pilot done, but COVID halted rollout; now unsupported platform; no budgeted project manager; staffing and funding gaps. Presented three options: restart as-is, reassess value, or step back and focus on alternative delivery methods like best-value procurement and partnering. - Supervisor Mandelman’s Questions: Pressed for why the database has not been implemented; expressed frustration that no timeline exists. Civil grand jury emphasized that $4 billion is spent annually without a feedback loop. - Votes: The committee approved Supervisor Mandelman’s amendments to the board response (agreeing with all findings except finding 7, and setting deadlines for implementation reports). The hearing (item 1) was continued to the call of the chair; the resolution (item 2) was sent to the full board with a positive recommendation. Items 3-4: Civil Grand Jury Report - "Buried Problems and a Buried Process: The Hunters Point Naval Shipyard in a Time of Climate Change" - Civil Grand Jury Presentation: Sarah Miles and Jeff Watson highlighted risks from shallow groundwater rise due to sea level rise at the Superfund site, noting that the city’s resilience maps have a hole over the shipyard. They recommended an independent groundwater rise study (R1) and a city oversight committee (R3) to monitor the CERCLA process. They criticized the Mayor for rejecting all seven recommendations. - President Walton’s Remarks: Stated the Navy and EPA refused to attend; reiterated that 100% cleanup must occur before any land transfer. He read into the record responses from the Navy and EPA (both written). The Navy claimed they have accounted for sea level rise (e.g., armored shoreline at Parcel E2). EPA said the five-year review (due 2023/2024) will consider climate impacts. - DPH Response (Dr. Susan Phillip): DPH’s role is to provide input, not regulate; they rely on the five-year review process. They disagreed with the need for a new oversight committee but said they would improve communication. DPH has only minimal staff (one person) dedicated to the shipyard. - OCII Response (Thor Kavloski): Described his agency’s role in redevelopment; read the Navy’s letter. He acknowledged the need for independent expertise but said the city lacks capacity. - Supervisor Preston’s Questions: Pressed DPH on whether they have the capacity to independently verify Navy data; DPH said they will assess after the next five-year review. Preston expressed disappointment that the Mayor rejected all recommendations and urged collaboration. He asked the Mayor’s office to clarify if they would cooperate with any board-created oversight body; they said yes. - Vote: The hearing and resolution were continued to September 29, 2022 (moved by President Walton). Items 5-6: Civil Grand Jury Report - "Safe and Accessible Parks for All" - Civil Grand Jury Presentation: Tony Al summarized findings that parks’ pathway conditions are not evaluated for safety/accessibility; the park evaluation program scores (done quarterly by Rec & Park and Controller) focus on appearance, not surface condition or ADA compliance. Scores are not posted on individual park pages. Recommended adding a pathway condition score, posting scores on park webpages, and improving on-site signage. - Rec & Park Response (Dennis Kern): Disagreed with findings 1 and 2, partially agreed with finding 3. Argued the park evaluation program is appearance-based and not designed to assess structural/ADA issues. They are adding a third ADA coordinator. They will migrate accessibility information to the new website by end of 2022 but oppose posting quarterly scores due to workload. - Vice Chair Chan’s Questions: Challenged the department’s claim that integrating scores is too difficult; she urged them to be open to the recommendation. She noted the department updates the website annually and could include this information. - Vote: The committee approved Vice Chair Chan’s amendments (agreeing with all findings) and sent the resolution (item 6) as amended to the full board with a positive recommendation; the hearing (item 5) was filed. Items 7-17: Closed Session Litigation Items - The committee convened in closed session to discuss tolling agreements and settlements. Upon returning to open session, the clerk reported that items 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17 were sent to the board with positive recommendation; item 12 was continued. The committee voted not to disclose closed session discussions. Key Outcomes - Items 1-2 (Capital Construction): The committee approved amendments to the board response (agreeing with all findings except finding 7) and sent the resolution to the full board. The hearing was continued to the call of the chair for follow-up within six months. - Items 3-4 (Hunters Point): The hearing and resolution were continued to September 29, 2022, to allow further deliberation. The Navy and EPA did not appear; written statements were entered into the record. - Items 5-6 (Parks): The board response was amended to agree with all findings and to urge Rec & Park to set baseline pathway condition scores by March 31, 2023. The hearing was filed, and the resolution sent to the full board. - Closed Session: Settlements for lawsuits and unlitigated claims ranging from $37,500 to $9,190,511.54 were approved. Tolling agreements for three real property transfer tax disputes were also advanced. The committee voted not to disclose closed session discussions.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, September 14, 2022, at 1:45 PM. The agenda included officer elections, the Chief’s report on crime trends, department presentations on disciplinary cases and bias findings, the quarterly firearm discharge review, adoption of a collision review board policy (DGO 3.07), and approval of a revised use-of-force policy (DGO 5.01) to proceed to meet-and-confer. The commission also held public comment and a closed session. Public Comments & Testimony - David Aronson, Gene Bridges, and Kate Hodge (volunteers with Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community) read statements from founder Felicia Jones. They expressed “anti-blackness in terms of use of force, arrests, and racial profiling or traffic stops by the SFPD,” stating that the commission and department lack urgency. They criticized the working group process for DGO 9.01 (traffic stops), alleging unfair police overrepresentation and private meetings. They noted that a Black San Franciscan is 15 times as likely as a white resident to experience use of force, 10 times as likely to be arrested, and five times as likely to be stopped. They called for accountability and transparency. - Dak Jill (Public Defender’s Office) commented on Item 6, noting that two cases (IAD 2018-0182 and IAD 2019-0070) had sustained untruthfulness allegations but were listed as not subject to public disclosure under SB 1421, which he questioned. - One caller supported the revised DGO 5.01 process, praising collaboration and the message it sends to officers. Election of Commission Officers - Commissioner Benedicto moved to elect Cindy Elias as President and Max Carter-Oberstone as Vice President. A competing motion by Commissioner Walker to elect Larry Yee as President and Cindy Elias as Vice President was not seconded. The vote on the first motion was 4–3 in favor (Elias, Carter-Oberstone, Benedicto, Yannis yes; Walker, Byrne, Yi no). Public comment supported Elias’s focus on bias. Discussion Items Chief’s Report (Chief William Scott) - Crime trends: Violent crime up 6% year-to-date; homicides down 3%. Shootings down 9% (126 incidents, 145 victims vs. 159 last year). Homicides: 26 vs. 29 last year. Property crime up 9%; auto burglaries up 12%; burglaries down 23%. - Firearm recoveries: 729 total year-to-date, including 129 ghost guns. - Tenderloin enforcement: 371 possession-for-sale bookings; seized 68,000 grams of narcotics, including 39,148 grams of fentanyl. - Recent homicides: Sept 6 shooting (600 block Larch) and Sept 10 stabbing (arrest made). Three other shooting incidents reported with no arrests. - Stunt driving: Large event Sept 10–11 involving 200–300 spectators; 39 cars seized since enforcement began. - MOU with DA: Extended to October 17, 2022; discussions ongoing. - Follow-up: Barricades at Mission Station removed. - Questions from commissioners about MOU delays, coordination of traffic enforcement reforms, and gun violence reduction strategies in Bayview (with $6M CalBIP grant expansion to Mission). DPA Director’s Report (Acting Director Sarah Hawkins) - Case statistics: 474 cases opened, 507 closed, 247 pending. 48 sustained, 16 mediated. 25 cases past 270-day mark (15 tolled). 10 cases pending with commission, 86 pending with chief (down from 90). - Top allegations: Failure to take required action, bias policing, failure to comply with DGO 5.04, inappropriate behavior. - Outreach update: Working on complaint form QR codes linking to FAQs. - Discussion on 86 cases pending with chief: President Elias requested joint department-DPA presentation on timelines for next meeting. Item 6 – Disciplinary Cases Remanded to Chief (2020–Present) - Commander Paul Yap presented the process and 10 cases with their chief’s determinations and SB 1421 releasability. Two slides listed case numbers, remand dates, chief’s findings, and preliminary release determination. - Chief Scott noted this was about transparency; cases are completed even after officer separation. - Public comment raised concerns about two untruthfulness cases not disclosed. Commander Yap agreed to re-review with the City Attorney. Item 7 – IAD Bias Findings (Last Five Years) - Commander Yap presented 22 cases since 2019 containing potential bias components; 12 originated from the electronic bias audit. - For Q1 2022 closed IAD cases (46 cases, 143 allegations): racial breakdown – 41% White, 22% Asian/PI, 18% Hispanic, 12% Black, 7% other. Gender: 29% female, 3% other. - Q2 2022 (51 cases, 182 allegations): 40% White, 27% Asian/PI, 9% Black, 5% other. Gender: 80% male, 16% female, 4% other. - Discussion on audit process: automated keyword search, followed by multi-layered review. Commissioner Yannis asked about contextualization and use of performance improvement plans; Chief Scott clarified this is separate from EIS. Item 8 – Firearm Discharge Review Board (Q2 2022) - Deputy Chief Robert O’Sullivan presented one case (OIS 20-004 from Nov 17, 2020, on Market Street). Suspect armed with knife and frying pan; officers used ERIW, 40mm foam, and lethal force; sheriff’s deputies deployed tasers; suspect taken into custody. No in-custody deaths in quarter. - Update on outstanding OIS cases from 2017 to 2022, including those with DA, Cal DOJ, and administrative investigations. - DPA noted they now present simultaneously with IAD at FDRB. Item 9 – Adoption of DGO 3.07 (Collision Board of Review) - Policy updated from 1997; language changes including removal of “accident” and clarification of board composition. Unanimously adopted (6–0). Item 10 – Revised DGO 5.01 (Use of Force Policy) - Key changes presented by Captain Harvey, Lieutenant Nevin, and Sergeant Crudo: - Physical control reporting threshold lowered to force “reasonably likely to cause pain or injury” or that causes transitory pain/injury. - Safeguarding dignity: Officers shall not direct subjects to involuntarily sit, lay, or kneel on ground unless specific articulable safety concerns exist; must document those concerns. - Drawing/exhibiting firearm: must be documented with justification; pointing a firearm requires objectively reasonable belief that deadly force may be justified; must advise subject if feasible. - Also includes duty to intervene (state law) and monthly public reporting of drawing/exhibiting stats. - Chief Scott thanked commissioners for listening to officer input. Unanimously approved (6–0) to send to meet-and-confer. Closed Session Items (Items 11–14) - Public comment: none. Unanimous votes to go into closed session (Item 12) and not to disclose discussions (Item 14). Key Outcomes - Elected officers: Cindy Elias as President, Max Carter-Oberstone as Vice President (4–3 vote). - Adopted DGO 3.07 (Collision Board of Review) unanimously. - Approved DGO 5.01 revisions to proceed to meet-and-confer unanimously. - Directed joint presentation on 86 cases pending with chief at next meeting. - Voted to go into closed session and not to disclose discussions. - Scheduled next listening session on DGO 9.01 for September 20, 2022, at Bayview Opera House.
The San Francisco Port Commission held its regular meeting on September 13, 2022, at 2:00 p.m. in the Port Commission Hearing Room at the Ferry Building. Vice President Kimberly Brandon presided in the absence of President Willie Adams. Commissioners John Burton, Gail Gilman, and Steven Lee were present. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of minutes, and a series of informational presentations and action items covering economic recovery, resilience, seismic risk, and waterfront planning. Consent Calendar - The Commission unanimously approved four consent items (Resolutions 22‑43, 22‑44, 22‑45, 22‑46): - 7A – Remote meeting authorization: Adopted findings under state urgency legislation to allow remote attendance during the COVID‑19 emergency. - 7B – Environmental RFQ: Authorized issuance of a Request for Qualifications for as‑needed environmental and related professional services. - 7C – Rent forgiveness for China Basin Ballpark Company (Lease L‑16410): The Port will forgive $523,133.81 in past due base rent (March 2020 – April 2021) and waive late fees, interest, and attorneys’ fees. - 7D – Rent repayment/forgiveness for Seawall Lot 337 Associates (Lease L‑16417): The Port will forgive $100,000 in past due rent; the tenant will pay $644,078.21; and the Port will waive late fees, accrued interest, and attorneys’ fees. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 8A – Dungeness Crab Pilot Program: Two callers (Nick Krieger, fishing vessel owner, and John Barnett, president of the Crab Boat Owners Association) spoke in strong support of making the pilot permanent. They noted the program’s success in increasing public access, supporting small boat operators, and driving local visitors to Fisherman’s Wharf. - Item 10A – Waterfront Resilience Early Projects: Diane Walton (Dolphin Club) expressed gratitude for inclusion in resilience discussions and requested continued visibility for water recreation users. - Item 11A – Draft Waterfront Plan Revisions: Pia Hinkle (member of the Waterfront Plan Advisory Group and Dolphin Club) and Fran Hegeler (president of the South End Rowing Club) thanked staff for collaboration and urged that the plan better incorporate the needs of open‑water swimmers, rowers, and paddlers. They noted that the two clubs together represent about 4,000 people. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (6A): Director Elaine Forbes reported on economic recovery, highlighting $140 million in state sea‑level‑rise funding secured for urban waterfronts. She announced upcoming events (Portola Music Festival at Pier 80 on Sept. 24‑25, movie night at Crane Cove Park on Sept. 30, and Fleet Week Oct. 8‑9). The Director also recognized Chief Financial Officer Katie Petrucione for her six years of service as she departs for the City Administrator’s office; several staff members and commissioners offered commendations. - Maritime – Dungeness Crab Pilot Program (8A): Maritime staff presented results of the one‑year pilot, during which more than 15,000 pounds of crab were sold directly to the public from fishing boats. The program was reported to have no negative impact on wholesale fish sales and boosted foot traffic. The Commission unanimously approved Resolution 22‑47 to make the Dungeness Crab sales a permanent component of the Retail Fish Sales Program at Fisherman’s Wharf. - Engineering – Southern Waterfront Earthquake Assessment (9A): Chief Harbor Engineer Rod Iwashta and project manager Matt Wickens presented the first comprehensive seismic hazard study for facilities south of Mission Creek. Key findings: high liquefaction and lateral spreading risk at Piers 50, 80, and 94/96. The port has allocated $13 million in the 2022‑23 capital budget for further assessments and conceptual retrofits, and a $3.5 million FEMA grant application is pending for Pier 94/96 seismic evaluation. Estimated full mitigation costs are roughly $100 million or more per facility. The presentation was informational; no vote was taken. - Waterfront Resilience Program – Early Projects (10A): Deputy Program Manager Stephen Real provided an update on six Embarcadero early projects: Wharf J‑9, Piers 15, 9, Ferry Building, Piers 5‑22½ (Yerba Buena Cove coastal flood risk), and Piers 24½‑28½ (bulkhead and wharf seismic retrofit). The projects are in pre‑design; alternatives analysis will follow. The port is targeting a construction start in 2024. Public engagement continues, including a walking tour the following week. - Planning & Environment – Draft Waterfront Plan Revisions (11A): Diane Oshima presented proposed revisions to the Draft Waterfront Plan (the port’s master plan, last updated in 2019). Revisions include alignment with the new Strategic Plan, Racial Equity Action Plan, and Waterfront Resilience Program. A public comment period runs through October 1, 2022. Staff is also working with the Dolphin Club, South End Rowing Club, and city partners on further refinements. The presentation was informational; no vote was taken. Key Outcomes - Votes: The Commission unanimously approved the consent calendar (Resolutions 22‑43, 22‑44, 22‑45, 22‑46) and Resolution 22‑47, making the Dungeness Crab sales program permanent. - Directives: Staff will continue to advance the six Embarcadero early projects, with a decision on which to priority within the next year. The Southern Waterfront assessment will inform capital planning and grant applications. The Draft Waterfront Plan revisions will be finalized after public comments and environmental review (CEQA), with a follow‑up briefing to the Commission expected later in 2022. - Next Steps: The Commission is scheduled to hear updates on adaptation strategies at the October 11, 2022 meeting. A FEMA grant decision for Pier 94/96 is anticipated in fall 2022.