Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1101–1110 ENTRIES
1101
NOV 3, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - November 3, 2022

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Raphael Mandelman, met on November 3, 2022, to discuss two regular agenda items: a hearing on the Ethics Department's audit processes and a resolution urging no gap in services following the planned closure of the Tenderloin Center. The committee also convened in closed session to discuss a lawsuit settlement. The meeting resulted in the continuation of the audit hearing to the call of the chair, forwarding of the resolution to the full board (2-1), and continuation of the settlement item to November 17. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were considered. Public Comments & Testimony - Ethics Audit Hearing: No public comments were received on item one. - Tenderloin Center Resolution: A large number of public comments were received, both in person and via phone. Many speakers (e.g., Marnie Regan from Larkin Street Youth Services, Jennifer Friedenbach from Coalition on Homelessness, Lydia Branston from Gubbio Project, Curtis Bradford from Tenderloin People's Congress, and representatives from Glide, HomeRise, and San Francisco AIDS Foundation) expressed strong support for the resolution, urging the committee to ensure no gap in services. They argued that the center saves lives and that closing it without a replacement would lead to overdoses and deaths. Several speakers criticized the mayor's office for lack of planning and called for an extension. A few speakers opposed the resolution, including a representative from the Mid-Market Community Benefit District who questioned the center's effectiveness and noted increased open-air drug use, and Ellen Grant from Mothers Against Drug Addiction and Death, who argued that the center attracts drug dealing and does not promote wellness. One caller raised concerns about the Honduran cartel and the need to declare a state of emergency for fentanyl. - Closed Session Settlement: One caller (Ellen Grant) spoke about liability concerns regarding the continuum of care but was redirected to the specific closed session item. Discussion Items Item 1: Hearing on Ethics Department Audit Processes (220139) - Supervisor Aaron Peskin, the hearing sponsor, stated that the Ethics Department had fallen behind on mandatory audits of publicly financed campaigns. He noted that as a candidate in 2020, he has been unable to obtain a schedule for his own audit, which remains unperformed two years later. He expressed disappointment that the department lacked a written audit plan and had not accepted an offer from the Controller's office for assistance. - Leanne Pelham, Director of the Ethics Department, reported that the department currently has an audit manager and three audit staff. She outlined the backlog: two audits from the 2019 election cycle are expected to be completed by December 2022; 14 mandatory audits from the 2020 cycle remain uninitiated, though two have been started (chosen because those candidates received the most public financing); and five audits from the 2022 cycle will be required. She estimated that with external auditors, the 2020 audits could begin by the third quarter of fiscal year 2023 (by end of March 2023) and take 10–12 months to complete. She attributed delays to the pandemic, staffing vacancies, and time needed to implement recommendations from a 2020 BLA performance audit. She noted that the department had asked for an additional senior auditor position in the budget but the mayor's office did not include it. - Supervisor Peskin pressed for a written schedule. Director Pelham committed to providing a detailed timeline by close of business the next day (November 4). - Vice Chair Chan asked whether the department treats repeat violators differently. Director Pelham said they do not fast-track or treat committees differently based on past findings, but she agreed to consider the suggestion. - Chair Preston raised the issue of campaign accounts remaining open for years because candidates wait for audits to close, effectively creating unregulated officeholder accounts. He suggested that delayed audits incentivize candidates to keep accounts open indefinitely. Director Pelham noted that in Los Angeles, officeholder accounts are highly regulated and suggested that as a possible alternative. - The committee voted to continue the item to the call of the chair (unanimous). Item 2: Resolution Urging Continuation of Services After Closure of the Tenderloin Center (221090) - Chair Preston introduced the resolution, expressing frustration that the mayor's office and Department of Public Health (DPH) had not provided a plan to replace services at the Tenderloin Center (TLC) after its scheduled closure on December 4, 2022. He noted that the center has seen 112,000 visits and reversed 280 overdoses since opening in January 2022, serving about 400 people per day. - Dr. Hillary Cunnins, Director of Behavioral Health Services for DPH, presented a slideshow of the TLC's impacts (including 1,000 shelter referrals, 8,000 showers, 25,000 health/social service connections) and outlined DPH's overdose prevention plan, which includes opening two "wellness hubs" in the next year. She stated that the first hub is not in the Tenderloin area and is not intended as a replacement. She said DPH is aggressively exploring options for a Tenderloin site but has not identified one. - Tom Paulino from the mayor's office participated remotely. He stated that the TLC was always temporary and that DPH is working to identify alternative sites. He could not commit to an extension of services beyond December 4. - Krista Gaeta, DPH's Tenderloin response director, described a transition plan that includes warm handoffs to other providers, on-site Narcan distribution after closure, and wayfinding for services. She acknowledged that not all services (especially overdose prevention) can be easily transferred. - Supervisor Mandelman expressed reservations about the resolution, noting that he has other priorities for DPH (such as treatment beds and step-down facilities) and does not view the TLC model as successful in stabilizing the neighborhood. He voted against forwarding the resolution. - Chair Preston and Vice Chair Chan strongly supported the resolution, criticizing the lack of a replacement plan and urging an extension. Chair Preston asked DPH to specify site requirements (ideal 5,000 sq ft indoor/outdoor space in Tenderloin). DPH indicated current budget could cover a scaled-down site through the fiscal year. - The committee voted to forward the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation (2-1, with Supervisor Mandelman dissenting). Item 3: Closed Session – Settlement of Lawsuit (220729) - The committee convened in closed session to discuss a settlement regarding Phi Associates (Drisco Hotel) and Swords to Plowshares (loan payoff of $2,000,000). After closed session, the committee reported that an amendment was accepted and the item was continued to the November 17, 2022 meeting. A motion not to disclose closed session discussions passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Ethics Audit Hearing): Continued to the call of the chair. Director Pelham committed to providing a written audit schedule by November 4, 2022. - Item 2 (Tenderloin Center Resolution): Forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (vote: 2-1, with Mandelman opposed). The resolution urges no gap in services and replacement of the Tenderloin Center. - Item 3 (Closed Session Settlement): Continued to the November 17, 2022 meeting after an amendment was accepted. No details disclosed.

PUBLIC HEALTH 33% · AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE 16% · PROCEDURAL 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9%
1102
NOV 2, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - November 2, 2022

This meeting of the San Francisco Police Commission on Wednesday, November 2, 2022, convened at 1:45 PM and covered a wide range of topics including a presentation on racial disparities in traffic stops, the adoption of a revised use of force policy (DGO 5.01), a grant for violence intervention, and updates on department accountability. The commission heard extensive public comment, approved several items, and deferred action on a memorandum of understanding with the District Attorney's Office. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Minutes (October 12, 2022): Approved unanimously (6-0). - Consent Calendar Items: Received and filed, including the SFPD Family Code 6228 quarterly report for the second and third quarters of 2022, and approval to accept four tickets from the San Francisco Police Credit Union for the SF PAL golf tournament (valued at $900). Approved unanimously (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Paul Allen (retired lawyer, 30-year resident) argued for a more rigorous process before adopting a traffic enforcement order, including citywide hearings and an evidentiary memorandum. He expressed concern about adverse consequences for public safety and police morale. - Ms. Brown (mother of murdered son Abre Abacasso) pleaded for progress on unsolved homicides, stating she has the names of perpetrators but no action taken. - Callers raised issues about camping enforcement, anti-blackness in policing, and called for urgency in addressing racial disparities. Several callers (including members of Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community) demanded stronger oversight and criticized the pace of reform, with one noting black San Franciscans are 15 times more likely to be subject to use of force than white residents. - Deputy Public Defender Brian Cox urged the commission to enact a strong traffic stop policy (DGO 9.01) and emphasized the harms caused by pretext stops. - Susan Bachman (Wealth and Disparities) expressed concern that police officers' opinions in work group meetings are not representative of community interests. - Evan Sean Bland (Walk SF) asked SFPD to focus on five most dangerous driving behaviors to improve Vision Zero goals. - Other callers supported limiting pretext stops and requested data per capita by race. Discussion Items - Racial Disparities in Traffic Stops (Item 7): Magnus Lofstrom, policy director at PPIC, presented findings from a study of 3.4 million traffic stops by California's 15 largest law enforcement agencies in 2019. Key findings: - 211,000 stops resulted in no enforcement and no discovery of contraband; officers spent 80,000 hours on these stops. - 905 stops led to firearm confiscation, with 75 in San Francisco (50 for non-moving violations). - Racial disparities peaked around midnight, with black and Latino drivers overrepresented in searches but less likely to be found with contraband. - Veil of darkness analysis suggested evidence of racial bias in stop decisions by local law enforcement. - Recommendations included mailing citations for non-moving violations, automated enforcement for moving violations, implicit bias training, diversifying police staff, and reallocating officers to same-race neighborhoods. - Commissioners expressed interest in local data and requested follow-up on San Francisco-specific outcomes. - Chief's Report (Item 4): Chief Bill Scott reported crime trends: overall crime up 7% year-to-date, violent crime up 8%, property crime up 7%. Homicides down 2% (43 total), shootings up slightly. 890 firearms seized (5% increase), including 163 ghost guns. Fentanyl seizures in the Tenderloin reached 52,867 grams, nearly double 2021. Chief provided details on the October 28 attack on Paul Pelosi, commending dispatcher Heather Grimes and officers for rapid response. Other incidents included four non-fatal shootings and two fatal collisions. - DPA Director's Report (Item 5): Director Paul Henderson reported 570 open cases, 52 sustained cases (up from 41 last year), 18 mediated cases, and 22 cases beyond nine months. Updates on audits and outreach. - Commission Reports (Item 6): Commissioners reported on DGO assignments and listening sessions for DGO 9.01 (traffic stops). President Elias highlighted a Glide program where officers engage in plain-clothes community service. Several more listening sessions were announced. - Revised Use of Force Policy (DGO 5.01) (Item 8): After discussion, the commission adopted the revised policy unanimously (6-0) with an effective date of December 8, 2022. The policy expands reporting requirements, prohibits neck/throat restraints even if inadvertent, adds a safeguarding dignity section, and was developed collaboratively with SFPD, DPA, and the Police Officers Association. - $6 Million Grant for Violence Intervention (Item 9): The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to urge the Board of Supervisors to retroactively authorize acceptance of a $6,000,000 grant from the California Board of State and Community Corrections for the California Violence Intervention and Prevention Program. The grant funds life coaching and cognitive behavioral therapy for individuals at risk of gun violence. - MOU between SFPD and SFDA (Item 10): Discussion was held but no vote taken. Chief Scott and Director Henderson reported ongoing negotiations; a meeting with the judge was rescheduled for November 4, 2022. The commission deferred action to the November 16 meeting, with Vice President Carter Oberstone raising concerns about information sharing and the need for independent investigations. Commissioner Byrne noted the commission's role is not merely advisory. Key Outcomes - Adopted: Minutes of October 12, 2022 (6-0). - Adopted: Consent calendar items (6-0). - Adopted: Revised DGO 5.01 (Use of Force Policy) effective December 8, 2022 (6-0). - Adopted: Resolution urging Board of Supervisors to accept $6 million grant (6-0). - Deferred: Approval of draft MOU with San Francisco District Attorney's Office to November 16, 2022, pending further negotiation. - Calendared: Presentation on San Francisco-specific traffic stop data for December 2022, and a report on impact of Tenderloin policing on youth for December 7, 2022. - Next Meeting: The commission will not meet November 9; next regular meeting is November 16, 2022.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 38% · PROCEDURAL 28% · PUBLIC SAFETY 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7%
1103
OCT 27, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee: Treatment on Demand and SFUSD Sexual Violence Hearings - October 27, 2022

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Gordon Mar, held a two-part meeting on Thursday, October 27, 2022, beginning at 9:15 AM and reconvening at 4:00 PM for a special order. The morning session focused on an update on the FY2020-2021 Annual Proposition T (Treatment on Demand) report, while the afternoon session addressed student experiences of sexual assault and harassment at SFUSD schools. The meeting featured presentations from city departments, community organizations, and extensive public testimony, including from youth advocates. Public Comments & Testimony - Morning session (Prop T): Multiple speakers expressed concerns about unmet demand for treatment, including from the Treatment on Demand Coalition, which noted staffing shortages, pay inequity, and the need for low-threshold services. Public commenters urged faster action on step-down beds, culturally competent care, and addressing open-air drug markets. - Afternoon session (SFUSD): Over a dozen students and youth advocates testified, describing failures in reporting processes, victim-blaming by staff, and lack of support for survivors. Specific demands included consent education from elementary school, mandatory training for athletic coaches, transparent Title IX investigations, and immediate separation of perpetrators from victims. Discussion Items - Proposition T Hearing (9:15 AM – 2:00 PM): - Supervisor Mandelman opened by criticizing the city’s lack of a clear process to measure unmet treatment demand, noting overdose deaths rose 478% from 2015 to 2020. He urged better data and policy focus. - Dr. Hilary Cunnins (DPH) reported on the continuum of care, noting that 40% of San Francisco Health Network patients with substance use disorder received services (above the national 10%). Wait times: withdrawal management <1 day, residential treatment median 4 days. Gaps identified for Spanish speakers, dual-diagnosis patients, and justice-involved individuals. - Adult Probation (Chief Christelle Tulach, Steve Adami, Destiny Kletch) highlighted a 3% recidivism rate, 55 re-entry programs serving 2,700 people, and reduced wait times for treatment from 49 to 6 days through partnerships with DPH. They launched the MENA Project (75-bed dual-diagnosis housing) and Positive Directions TRP Academy. - Treatment on Demand Coalition (Laura Thomas, Sarah Short) stressed that demand measurement must include people discouraged by past negative experiences, and called for a community process to allocate opioid settlement funds. They emphasized workforce equity and low-threshold overdose prevention. - Criminal justice partners: - David Moroff (Pretrial) noted staffing challenges and that clients’ past negative experiences with treatment are not tracked, leading to broken trust. - Malethi Alphamongkol (Public Defender) outlined barriers: DPH packet requirements causing 2-3 month delays, lack of Spanish-language and dual-diagnosis beds (only one 12-bed Spanish inpatient program). - Susan Christian (DA) reported 3-6 month wait times for residential treatment for justice-involved individuals, and called for more gender-affirming and dual-diagnosis beds, plus interim stabilization facilities. - Lt. Mario Molina (SFPD) described a “revolving door” where officers spend hours connecting people to care only to see them return to the streets. He noted that since 2018, officers administered Narcan 695 times, saving lives. - Gary McCoy (HealthRIGHT 360) emphasized the need for step-down residential beds, stating the current few hundred should be tripled or quadrupled. - SFUSD Sexual Violence Hearing (4:00 PM – 6:30 PM): - Student delegates Isabella Hansen and Cal Kenoshita presented demands from the 2021-2022 student walkouts: mandatory consent education from elementary school, training for walk-on coaches, accessible Title IX resources (posters, Synergy), a separate class change process for survivors, and a mandatory consent seminar for student athletes. - Kisara Williams (SFUSD Office of Equity) reported that on October 11, 2022, the Board of Education approved a policy requiring investigations under both Title IX and the bullying/harassment policy. A Title IX Student Advisory Group is ongoing. She acknowledged that prior communication about the two-track investigation process was poor. - Maria Su (DCYF) committed to expanding wellness centers and mental health services in high schools and middle schools, and to partnering with SFUSD on curriculum and training. - Allison Ludbuster (DPH) described the KSARC program (child/adolescent trauma services) and crisis response teams available to students. - Dulce Garcia (SHARP Office) presented complaint forms for survivors and a planned youth town hall and healing summit. She noted that while no formal complaints against SFUSD have been filed, most requests for support involve high school-age students. - Adele Fils Carpenter and Shela Cervantes (City College Project Survive/Expect Respect) detailed peer-led prevention education: two-day curriculum in 9th grade health classes, reaching 230 classrooms pre-pandemic (80 this semester). They called for investment to expand to 11th/12th graders and to address staffing shortages at City College and community organizations. Key Outcomes - Proposition T Hearing: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to file the hearing. Supervisor Mandelman indicated he would continue to press for better metrics on unmet demand, including from justice-involved populations. - SFUSD Sexual Violence Hearing: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the item to the call of the chair, signaling ongoing oversight. Supervisor Melgar committed to formally transmitting the hearing’s findings and student demands to the SFUSD Board of Education, and to exploring revival of the Safer Schools Sexual Assault Task Force with youth representation.

SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER POLICY 24% · PUBLIC EDUCATION 24% · PUBLIC HEALTH 21% · PUBLIC COMMENT 5%
1104
OCT 24, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Special Meeting - October 24, 2022: Officer Elections, Policy Updates, and Major Contract Awards

This special meeting of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) convened at 9:45 AM on Monday, October 24, 2022, via teleconference due to the COVID-19 emergency. The Commission elected new officers, received updates on drought conditions, water conservation outreach, and policy affairs, and voted on several major contracts and programs. A quorum was present with five commissioners. The meeting lasted approximately four hours and included extensive public comment on environmental and water management issues. Consent Calendar - Item 11a: Extension of participation in the Bay Area Regional Heat Pump Water Heater Contractor Incentive Program. - Item 11b: Approval of a $410,000 cost increase and 100-calendar-day extension for Water Main Replacement on 17th Street. - Item 11c: Approval of plans and award of $3,274,441 for Cathodic Protection for Transmission Pipelines, Phase 2. - Item 11d: Acceptance of work by Precision Engineering, Inc., for As-Needed Main Sewer Replacement No. 7. - Item 11e: Acceptance of work by J. Flores Construction Company, Inc., for As-Needed Spot Sewer Replacement No. 38, totaling $13,808,733. - Item 11f: Acceptance of work by JMB Construction Inc., totaling $4,671,834 over 652 days. All consent calendar items were approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony General Public Comment (Item 6) Eight callers spoke on a range of issues. Key themes included: - Toxic algae blooms in San Francisco Bay: Multiple speakers urged the Commission to take concrete action, such as recycling wastewater to remove nutrients, and criticized the SFPUC for not doing enough. Speakers included Peter Belton (resident), Judy Irving (documentary filmmaker), and Mary Butterwick (resident). - Tuolumne River flows and salmon: Several speakers, including Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) and Nathan Rangel (California Outdoors), called for increased in-stream flows, withdrawal of lawsuits against the State Water Board, and adoption of a less conservative drought design. They noted that only 22 salmon were counted on the Tuolumne River compared to 541 on the Stanislaus River. - Welcome to new commissioners: Public speakers welcomed Commissioner Stacy and expressed hope for more active commission engagement. - Policy concerns: Eileen Vogen requested inclusion in a site tour of the Oceanside Treatment Facility. Denise Mue (Center for Biological Diversity) urged action to protect Bay Delta ecosystems. David Pilpel raised audio technical issues and a Brown Act concern regarding public access. Comments on Specific Agenda Items - Item 3 (Election of Officers): Peter Dreckmeyer supported Commissioner Ajami for President and Commissioner Maxwell for Vice President. David Pilpel echoed support based on seniority. - Item 7 (Communications): Three callers, including David Pilpel, complained about audio problems preventing the public from hearing speakers at the lectern, citing the Brown Act. Peter Dreckmeyer commended the Lagrange habitat restoration project and urged attention to flows. - Item 8 (BAWSCA Update): David Pilpel and Peter Dreckmeyer commented on audio issues and water conservation benefits. Dreckmeyer noted that water conserved rarely benefits the environment. - Item 9a (Drought Update): One caller, Francisco De Costa, criticized the Commission for not prioritizing salmon and for lacking focus. - Item 9b (Drought Outreach): David Pilpel praised the outreach efforts and suggested edgier messaging. Peter Dreckmeyer urged similar energy for salmon issues. - Item 9c (Policy & Government Affairs Update): David Pilpel noted a minor letterhead error. - Item 12 (Social Impact Partnership): Thirteen callers spoke, most in support. Supporters included Tanish Collins (SF Black Wall Street), representatives from PENCO Builders, YCD, students and graduates from Tuolumne County programs, and workforce development organizations. David Pilpel opposed the program, arguing it is ripe for abuse and that benefits should be included in project scopes. - Item 13 (Contract Modification, Headworks): One caller commended the leadership, another (David Pilpel) supported the item but requested clearer documentation on scope and environmental review. - Item 14 (CleanPowerSF IRP): Two callers supported the filing, including Jeremy Pollock (WAPCO) who praised community engagement. - Item 15 (Water Supply Assessment): Four callers commented. Eileen Vogen urged continuation for more robust analysis. David Pilpel supported. Two callers criticized the project and the SFPUC's approach to water supply. - Item 16 (Radio Equipment Agreement): No public comment. - Item 17 (Security System Products): No public comment. - Item 18 (Treasure Island WWTP): No public comment. Discussion Items Item 3: Annual Election of Officers Commissioners elected new officers for one-year terms. Commissioner Ajami was nominated and unanimously elected President (5-0). For Vice President, Commissioner Maxwell was nominated; she accepted. Commissioner Paulson expressed interest, resulting in a roll call vote: President Ajami aye, Commissioner Maxwell aye (self), Commissioner Paulson no, Commissioner Rivera aye, Commissioner Stacy aye. The motion passed 4-1. Commissioner Ajami emphasized priorities including climate change, staff retention, and equity. Item 4: Adopt Renewed Findings for Hybrid Meetings Approved unanimously (5-0) to continue hybrid meetings under state urgency legislation. The Commission directed the secretary to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. Item 5: Approval of Minutes (September 27 and October 11, 2022) Approved after public comment and noting a correction for the September 27 date. Vote: 5-0. Item 7: Communications Reports included the Advance Calendar, Contract Advertisement, Correspondence Log, Low Carbon Fuel Standard Credit Sales Fund Annual Report, Multi-Enterprise Climate Program Update, Green Infrastructure Grant Program, Quarterly Report on PG&E Grid Connection Disputes, and Update on Lower Tuolumne River Pilot Habitat Restoration Projects. Commissioners questioned staff on green infrastructure project completion and habitat restoration monitoring. Technical audio issues were noted but partially resolved by switching microphones. Item 8: Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Update Nicole Sandkulla (CEO, BAWSCA) presented an overview of the agency, which represents 26 wholesale water suppliers serving 1.8 million residents. She reported that the region uses 24% less water than in 1986-87 despite a 32% population increase, and that average residential use has dropped 37% since 1986. She expressed concern about declining conservation savings and highlighted ongoing efforts with member agencies to prepare for a potentially dry 2023. The presentation ended without a formal vote. Item 9: Report of the General Manager - 9a (Drought Conditions Update): Steve Richie reported that Hetch Hetchy reservoir is 75% full (normal), but the water bank is at 44% (lower than normal). Precipitation for the water year is essentially zero. He noted that water demand has flattened close to the 2015 target but fell short of the 11% reduction goal. Staff plans to work with BAWSCA to refine conservation measures for 2023. - 9b (Drought Public Outreach Summary): Betsy Rhodes presented a comprehensive campaign including 78 million impressions, 155,000 clicks, and partnerships with the San Francisco Giants. The campaign achieved a 10.5% water use reduction (target 11%). She outlined improvements needed and a planned hiatus for winter. - 9c (Annual Policy and Government Affairs Update): Megan Scott reported on achievements including 35 Board of Supervisors items, tracking over 300 state bills, and securing over $20 million in ratepayer assistance. She noted upcoming federal funding opportunities from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act and Inflation Reduction Act. Item 12: Social Impact Partnership (SIP) Program Ronnie Versher and Chelsea Ballard presented the program, which has been operating since 2011 and included in over 90 contracts. They highlighted improvements: a public dashboard, strengthened verification, and drafted rules and regulations. The Commission voted unanimously (5-0) to authorize staff to seek formal authorization from the Board of Supervisors and to develop formal rules and regulations. Item 13: Modification No. 5 to Contract WW-628 (New Headworks) Jignesh Desai requested a $58,572,067 increase (to $548,823,816) and a decrease in contingency, with no change to scope. The project is 70% complete on Scope 3, with substantial completion targeted for September 2023. Vote: 5-0. Item 14: CleanPowerSF 2022 Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) Cheryl Taylor presented the recommended conforming portfolio (90% time-coincident renewable energy by 2030). This portfolio was ranked best on affordability, reliability, and risk. The Commission adopted it as the preferred portfolio and authorized submission to the California Public Utilities Commission by the November 1, 2022 deadline. Vote: 5-0. Item 15: Water Supply Assessment for 3251 20th Avenue (Stonestown) Project Steve Richie presented the assessment required by state law for projects with over 500 dwelling units. The assessment concluded water supply is adequate under all scenarios. The Commission approved the assessment (5-0), which is not a project approval but a technical document for the planning department. Item 16: Agreement with VB Nimbus, LLC for Radio Equipment Steve Richie requested approval of a five-year site use agreement (four optional five-year extensions) for 345 square feet on a tower in Tracy, CA, for $2,500/month with 3% annual increases. Approved (5-0). Item 17: Sole Source Finding for Security System Products Ron Flynn requested approval of a General Manager's finding that Lenel OnGuard and Milestone XProtect security products are necessary to match existing systems. The Commission approved (5-0) after discussion about the risks of sole source reliance and periodic evaluations. Item 18: Award of Contract DB-132, New Treasure Island Wastewater Treatment Plant Jignesh Desai presented the award to PCL Construction and Stantec Consulting Services JV for $165,032,269 with a 1,095-day duration. The plant will include biological nutrient removal and produce Title 22 recycled water. The Commission approved (5-0) after negotiation efforts saved $5.6 million. Key Outcomes - Election of President: Commissioner Ajami elected President (5-0). - Election of Vice President: Commissioner Maxwell elected Vice President (4-1, with Commissioner Paulson voting no). - Hybrid Meeting Resolution: Adopted (5-0) with a directive to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. - Minutes Approval: Approved (5-0) for September 27 and October 11, 2022. - Consent Calendar: Approved (5-0) all six items. - Social Impact Partnership Program: Authorized (5-0) to seek Board of Supervisors approval, develop rules, and staff the program. - Contract Modification (Headworks): Approved (5-0) increase to $548,823,816 and contingency decrease. - CleanPowerSF IRP: Approved (5-0) preferred conforming portfolio for filing. - Water Supply Assessment (Stonestown): Approved (5-0) for conveyance to planning department. - Radio Equipment Agreement: Approved (5-0) for five-year term with extensions. - Security System Sole Source Finding: Approved (5-0) General Manager’s finding. - Treasure Island WWTP Contract: Awarded (5-0) for $165,032,269 to PCL/Stantec JV. - Audio Fix: The meeting was recessed briefly to address audio issues affecting public comment; the problem was partially resolved by switching microphones.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 42% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · PROCEDURAL 8% · SOCIAL IMPACT PARTNERSHIP 4%
1105
OCT 20, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
BOS Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - October 20, 2022

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston and joined by Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Raphael Mandelman, met on October 20, 2022 to consider three major agenda items: a hearing and response to the 2021-2022 Civil Grand Jury report on the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH), an updated report from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) on residential vacancies in San Francisco, and a retroactive memorandum of understanding (MOU) for the Urban Areas Security Initiative (UASI) grant. The committee also convened in closed session to discuss multiple settlement and litigation items. Public Comments & Testimony - Civil Grand Jury report (Items 1 & 2): Multiple members of the public spoke. Jordan Davis (noting lived experience) emphasized that 70% of homeless were formerly housed in San Francisco and cautioned against stigmatizing those who came from elsewhere. A District 8 resident expressed frustration with "voluntary homeless" individuals who refuse shelter, calling for treatment rather than housing. Rick Crane (via phone, a grand jury committee member) highlighted that the fastest-growing homeless cohort is those aged 65 and older, and that HSH is "playing catch-up" on elder adult issues. He also stressed communication failures. - Residential Vacancies report: Several speakers from Faith in Action and community members testified in Spanish and English, calling the high vacancy rate a "moral crisis." Brenda Cordova and Pablo Toro noted elders forced to work past 65 due to rent burdens. Matt Alexander (Board of Education member) noted 2,500 homeless students against 60,000 vacant units. Kristen Evans (small business owner) cited challenges retaining staff due to housing costs and supported vacancy taxes. Francisco De Costa criticized the city for building market-rate housing while neglecting low-income needs. - UASI MOU (Item 3): One caller criticized the presentation as convoluted and lacking understanding of security measures, referencing failures of the Office of Emergency Services. No other public comment. Discussion Items - Civil Grand Jury Report on HSH (Items 1 & 2): Will McCaw (President Pro Tem) and Court Gross (report author) presented findings and recommendations focused on improving communication, data transparency, and oversight. The jury recommended better use of data beyond the Point-in-Time (PIT) count, a more user-friendly website, expanded neighborhood outreach, creation of an oversight commission (on the November ballot), and attention to the aging homeless population. The mayor's office partially agreed with most findings. Emily Cohen (HSH Deputy Director) noted a 15% decrease in unsheltered homelessness since 2019, a strategic plan due in January 2023 centered on racial equity and lived experience, and ongoing work on dashboards and older adult services. She estimated 20,000 people experience homelessness annually (inflow rate: for every 1 housed, 4 become homeless). Supervisors debated the adequacy of the PIT count, the importance of 70% locally-housed statistic, and the need to tie budget to outcomes. Supervisor Mandelman questioned the gap between progress and public perception, noting HSH's focus on housing rather than street management. - Residential Vacancies (Special Agenda Item 1): Fred Brusseau (BLA) presented an update using 2021 American Community Survey data. Vacant units rose from 40,548 in 2019 to 61,473 in 2021 (52% increase; 14.9% of all housing). The largest increases were in "for rent" (17,514 units, +142%) and "other vacant" (21,493 units). San Francisco's overall vacancy rate became the highest among comparable U.S. cities. The report noted a population decline of 66,348 over the same period. Supervisor Preston expressed concern that landlords may be holding units off the market, potentially including rent-controlled units. Vice Chair Chan asked about distinguishing corporate housing and short-term rentals in the data; BLA noted limitations but offered to cross-reference with registries. The committee discussed policy interventions like a vacancy tax. - UASI MOU (Item 3): Molly Giesen Fields (Regional Grants Manager, DEM) presented a resolution retroactively approving a four-year MOU (Dec 2021 – Nov 2025) with nine Bay Area jurisdictions for federal Homeland Security grants. San Francisco serves as primary grantee and fiscal agent. The MOU was delayed due to staffing transitions; the committee questioned the retroactive timing. No other discussion. - Closed Session (Items 4-18): The committee convened in closed session to discuss 15 settlement/litigation items (settlements ranging from $25,125 to $2,000,000). After closed session, the committee recommended Items 4-10 and 12-18 to the full board and continued Item 11 to November 3, 2022. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Hearing): Filed (unanimous). - Item 2 (Board Response to Grand Jury): Approved as amended (3-0) with responses: (a) agree with finding F4A (no oversight commission), (b) partially disagree with F4B (advisory groups not inefficient), (c) recommendation R4 already implemented (ballot measure). Sent to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 3 (UASI MOU): Continued to the call of the chair (unanimous). - Closed Session Items: Items 4-10 and 12-18 recommended to full board; Item 11 continued to November 3, 2022. - Residential Vacancies Report: Continued to the call of the chair (unanimous); BLA will provide a neighborhood map in December 2022 and consider further analysis of rent-controlled vacancies and corporate housing.

PROCEDURAL 36% · HOMELESSNESS 33% · HOUSING 11% · PUBLIC HEALTH 10%
1106
OCT 19, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - October 19, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, October 19, 2022, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included a certificate of appreciation, public comment on unsolved homicides and racial disparities, a chief's report on crime statistics, and extensive debate on a draft MOU between SFPD and the District Attorney's Office. The commission also approved a new disengagement procedures policy and received reports on internal affairs and disciplinary review board findings. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the October 5, 2022 meeting. - The consent calendar (SFPD 1421/SB16 reports, DPA 1421/SB16 report, police commission disciplinary actions Q3 2022, and collaborative reform update) was received and filed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Certificate of Appreciation Public Comment: Mary Bowe, mother of a murdered son, expressed concern about disparities in reward amounts for unsolved homicides and lack of transparency in reward payouts. She noted her son's reward is $75,000 while others range from $10,000 to $250,000. Susan Martin, from Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community, criticized the commission for framing the incident as a feel-good story about police-public collaboration, stating it was a civilian risking his life to prevent a police murder. - General Public Comment: Multiple speakers, including Paulette Brown, Mary Bowe, Anna Oliver, and David Aronson, spoke about unsolved homicides, lack of justice, and anti-blackness in policing. They called for urgency in addressing racial disparities and criticized the lack of transparency in the reward system. Felicia Jones (via caller) and others noted that the SFPD has paid zero rewards for unsolved homicides in nearly a decade and that the process for increasing rewards lacks community input. Several speakers also expressed frustration with the commission's handling of DGO 9.01 (traffic stops) and lack of response to their emails. - Chief's Report Public Comment: Paulette Brown again spoke about her son's unsolved murder, stating that the reward system fails and that she knows who killed her son but no action has been taken. - Item 8 (MOU) Public Comment: Several callers supported the draft MOU, praising DA Brooke Jenkins and Chief Scott for their collaboration. A few opposed, citing concerns about politicization and the need for more community input. One caller, David Aronson, argued the MOU is not ready due to lack of clarity on use of force and community engagement. - Item 11 (Disengagement DGO) Public Comment: One caller expressed excitement about the policy but asked for clarification on "special relationships." Discussion Items - Presentation of Certificate of Appreciation: Sergeant Lee presented a certificate to Anthony Cluis for his bravery on July 25, 2022, when he intervened to prevent a machete-wielding suspect from attacking SFPD officers. Cluis physically blocked the suspect, removed weapons from the room, and helped de-escalate the situation. Commissioners praised him for potentially saving lives and encouraged him to consider a career in law enforcement. - Chief's Report: Chief Scott reported on crime trends: violent crime up 7% year-to-date, property crime up 7%. Homicides decreased 5% (43 total, clearance rate 61%). Gun seizures totaled 849 (including 163 ghost guns), up 4%. Fentanyl seizures exceeded all of 2021. He highlighted recent swatting calls at schools and a bomb threat at Lyric in the Mission District. He also noted that no reward payouts have occurred during his tenure and agreed to agendize the issue of reward disparities. - DPA Director's Report: Chief of Staff Hawkins reported 546 open cases, 574 closed, 256 pending, 51 sustained, 18 mediated. Two audits in progress: one on officer misconduct handling, another on compliance with DGO 8.10. Outreach included tabling at Phoenix Day and distributing materials to library branches. - Commission Reports: Commissioners reported on various DGO assignments. Commissioner Benedicto attended CMCR training and noted progress on DGO 9.01 (traffic stops) with community listening sessions. Commissioner Yanez requested a separate working group for the social media DGO. Vice President Carter Overstone noted that the Committee on Revision of the California Penal Code recommended limiting certain traffic stops and consent searches, aligning with the draft DGO 9.01. President Elias updated on DGO 5.08 (non-uniformed officers) and stressed that commissioners should be consulted on working groups. Commissioner Byrne raised concerns about commissioners using commission letterhead for letters to the Board of Supervisors; it was agreed to agendize the protocol. - Discussion on MOU between SFPD and DA (Item 8): Chief Scott explained the new MOU includes an evidence case management system and a confidential dispute resolution process. DPA expressed concerns about not being included in negotiations and requested specific language to ensure their access to crime scenes, interviews, evidence, and declination letters. Commissioner Benedicto moved to not approve the MOU as written and to direct the chief to return to the DA and mediator with suggested changes including DPA's input. The motion passed 4-3 (Walker, Byrne, Yi opposed). Commissioner Byrne then moved that the department and DPA meet and confer on the issues raised and report back within 45 days; that motion passed unanimously. - Presentation of IAD Open and Closed Cases (Item 9): Commander Yep reported 59 cases opened in Q1 2022 and 69 in Q2, with neglect of duty being the most common allegation. For Q1, 46 cases closed with 143 allegations; 54 were improper conduct. For Q2, 51 cases closed with 182 allegations; 58 improper conduct. The most common actions were no further action, written reprimands, admonishments, and suspensions. Commander Yep also outlined new procedures to expedite chief's hearings, including scheduling hearings two months in advance and limiting continuances. - Presentation of Disciplinary Review Board Findings (Item 10): Acting Assistant Chief Flaherty and DPA policy director Keywood presented trends and recommendations. Common trends included body-worn camera failures, failure to write incident reports, and property processing issues. Eight recommendations were made, including updating background investigation manuals, property processing policies, and body-worn camera guidance for hospital settings. The commission commended the collaboration between SFPD and DPA. - Discussion on Disengagement Procedures DGO (Item 11): Chief Scott and DPA's Keywood presented the draft DGO on disengagement, emphasizing it is a strategic de-escalation tactic, not de-policing. The policy was developed with input from the CIT working group and aims to provide clear procedures for incident commanders to disengage when safe. Commissioners praised the policy and unanimously approved it for meet and confer with the POA. Key Outcomes - Certificate of Appreciation: Awarded to Anthony Cluis. - MOU Rejection (Item 8): Motion passed 4-3 to not approve the draft MOU and to direct the chief to return to the DA and mediator with suggested changes (including DPA's input). A separate motion to have SFPD and DPA meet and confer on issues and report back within 45 days passed unanimously. - Disengagement Procedures DGO (Item 11): Approved unanimously for meet and confer with the POA. - Closed Session: Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to go into closed session (Item 14) and later voted unanimously (7-0) not to disclose any discussion from closed session. - Future Agenda Items: The chief agreed to agendize the reward system issue; the commission will also agendize the protocol for use of letterhead by commissioners. - Next Meetings: The next regular meeting is scheduled for November 2, 2022. The commission will also hold a community listening session on DGO 9.01 on October 26, 2022 at Glide Memorial Church.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 35% · PROCEDURAL 22% · LAW ENFORCEMENT COLLABORATION 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
1107
OCT 13, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Public Safety & Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - October 13, 2022

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on October 13, 2022, with Chair Gordon Mar, Vice Chair Catherine Stefani, and Member Myrna Melgar present for the main agenda. The committee approved three liquor license transfers, held an extensive hearing on traffic enforcement and street safety, and continued a scheduled special-order hearing on SFUSD sexual assault and harassment response to October 27, 2022. Note: The raw transcript also includes unrelated broadcast segments (a mayoral drug-enforcement press conference and a District 6 candidate forum) that are not part of this committee meeting and are not summarized here. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1-3 (liquor licenses): No public comment was offered in chambers or by phone. - Item 4 (traffic safety hearing): Sarah Benton testified about her 20 years of homelessness and problems with vehicle purchases and citations. Wesley Saver, senior policy manager at Glide and representing the Coalition to End Biased Stops (over 80 organizations), called for ending pretext stops and said racial disparities in traffic enforcement are persistent and harmful. Brian Hogsman of WALK SF urged SFPD to focus enforcement on the five most dangerous driving behaviors on the High Injury Network, noting 15 pedestrian deaths this year and that 93% of pedestrian fatalities occurred on the High Injury Network. A caller criticized the meeting's length and outdated technology. Adam Kavlaka (District 6) said SFMTA often refuses to enforce bike-lane blocking and gave examples in SOMA. Another caller strongly supported Supervisor Stefani's position and law enforcement and criticized ending remote testimony. Lisa Church (District 3) expressed frustration that drivers face no consequences and said the city's systems seem designed for drivers. A Bayview/D10 resident, part of a bike-first family, urged automated enforcement and better design/enforcement, citing speeding on Third Street and a February hit-and-run at Third and Fairfax. An Ingleside resident said enforcement has been declining for a decade and criticized agencies for blaming COVID. - Item 5 (special order): On the motion to continue the SFUSD hearing, there were zero public commenters in chambers or on the phone line. Liquor License Transfers - Item 1 (Murphy's Pub, 217 Kearny St): Officer Salmanson from SFPD's Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval. John Murphy explained the downtown business was slow and food service had become cost-prohibitive, so he sought a type 48 license to serve liquor competitively. The committee voted to forward the license to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (Expensify Lounge, 88 Kearny St): Officer Salmanson recommended approval; Rebecca Stamy White said Expensify planned a members' lounge with alcohol service incidental, 8 a.m.-6 p.m. Monday-Friday. The committee voted to forward with a positive recommendation, noting Supervisor Peskin's support. - Item 3 (SaveMart/Lucky, 3801 3rd St): Officer Salmanson reported zero letters of protest and two in support, and recommended one condition requiring monitoring of adjacent property to prevent loitering. Reggie, the new store manager, said Lucky Bayview would be a full-service grocery store, with over 90% of employees hired from District 10, local vendor partnerships, and an opening on October 26. The committee voted to forward with a positive recommendation, noting Supervisor Walton's support. Traffic Enforcement and Street Safety Hearing - Supervisor Mandelman called the hearing, citing Vision Zero's 2024 goal, 27 traffic deaths in 2021 (10% lower than 2020 but near the 28 average since 2014), and an SFPD citation decline from about 74 per day in 2019 to about 10 per day currently. - Community analysts Steven Breach and Luke Bornheimer presented data from 64,200 SFPD citations (September 2017 onward). Since 2014, 244 people had died and over 26,000 had been injured; a crash injury occurred about every 3.7 hours and a fatality about every 13 days. In the past 18 months, 43% of citations focused on the five most dangerous violations; only 28% in equity priority communities; 60% of citations were on the High Injury Network, but only 18% combined High Injury Network with focus-on-the-five. They recommended more infrastructure, transparent data, automated enforcement, and a focus on the five dangerous violations on the High Injury Network. - Supervisor Melgar raised infrastructure gaps in District 7, described her own near-miss while biking, and asked about staffing, equity, and links to climate goals. Supervisor Stefani stressed police staffing shortages, supported more officers and traffic enforcement, and expressed concerns about unarmed traffic enforcement. - Commander Peter Walsh (SFPD) detailed the decline: in 2019, Traffic Company had five squads (7 sergeants, 45 officers) plus two Vision Zero squads; by 2022 it had four sergeants and 22 officers (47 active-duty in the full traffic company including supervisors and ancillary posts). He cited Ferguson, RIPA data collection, body cameras, the pandemic, and department-wide staffing as factors. He reported 21 Vision Zero fatalities through August 2022, versus 23 in all of 2019. - Tom McGuire and Sean McCormick (SFMTA) said the city is not on track for 2024, but engineering investments help. SFMTA issues about 1.2 million parking citations per year pre-COVID and generates about $90 million in revenue for Muni. PCO staffing is about 261 available against 326 authorized, with about 25 vacancies. McCormick reported 33,000-plus citations in 2022 for double parking, bike-lane, bus-zone, and obstruction violations versus 40,000-50,000 pre-COVID, with early 2023 trends up 25%. They discussed 311 heat maps (Valencia/Folsom), bus-camera enforcement limitations, and reliance on state law changes for photo or bounty enforcement. Special Order: SFUSD Sexual Assault and Harassment Hearing - The hearing (220471) was scheduled as a 4:00 p.m. special order, but the committee continued it to the October 27, 2022 PSNS meeting because key members and stakeholders were not available. Upon reconvening, the committee voted to excuse Supervisors Melgar and Stefani and formally continued the item with no public comment. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Murphy's Pub liquor license): approved 3-0; forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation as a committee report. - Item 2 (Expensify Lounge liquor license): approved 3-0; forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 3 (SaveMart/Lucky liquor license): approved 3-0; forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 4 (Traffic Enforcement and Street Safety hearing): continued to the call of the chair by a 3-0 vote. - Item 5 (SFUSD sexual assault/harassment hearing): continued to October 27, 2022, with Supervisors Melgar and Stefani excused; the vote was 2-0 (Walton and Mar).

TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 21% · PUBLIC SAFETY 16% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 15% · SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER POLICY 10%
1108
OCT 12, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - October 12, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission met on October 12, 2022, at 1:45 PM to discuss a range of public safety, policy, and operational issues. The meeting included the Chief's crime report, updates on surveillance technology legislation, a traffic safety quarterly report, a presentation on reimagining policy development, and a vote to approve a revised department general order. The meeting also featured public comments on police accountability, community engagement, and unsolved homicides. Public Comments & Testimony - David Aronson (District 1 resident, volunteer with Wealth & Disparities in the Black Community) expressed frustration with anti-blackness in SFPD practices, criticized the DGO 9.01 working group process for lacking community input and limited public comment time, and called for urgent action. - A caller commented on last week's meeting, expressing dismay that the police chief was unaware of the department's engagement with the 30x30 initiative despite a presentation. - Susan Buckman (member of Wealth & Disparities in the Black Community) criticized the DGO 9.01 working group for having an overly heavy police presence and questioned Commissioner Carter Oberstone's impartiality, alleging he raised his voice at a community member. - David Calderon requested assistance regarding SFDPA case 00046105-21 (his mother's homicide), alleging intentional mishandling by SFPD and DPA and lack of response from officials. - Ms. Brown (mother of Aubrey Abercaster, murdered August 14, 2006) pleaded for help solving her son's case and asked if the reward could be increased. - David Aronson returned to comment on Item 5, urging the commission to require per capita demographic reporting for surveillance to prevent over-surveillance of Black and Brown communities. - Julie Tron (resident of District 8, speaking for the Bar Association) expressed concerns that the new surveillance policy remains unconstitutional without warrants and offered training assistance from former U.S. attorneys. Chief's Report Chief Bill Scott reported weekly crime trends: violent crimes up 8%, property crimes up 7%, total part one crime up 7% (about 2,700 more crimes than last year). Homicides down 9% (40 year-to-date), with a 61% clearance rate. Firearm homicides down 18% (27 vs. 33 last year). Gun violence incidents down 2%. Seized 814 weapons (163 guns). Fentanyl seizures nearly doubled to 48,754 gross grams, with 420 arrests and $116,962 seized from street-level dealers. Significant incidents: a homicide on Market Street (stabbing), a shooting on Griffith Avenue (second victim died Oct. 10), non-fatal shootings, arrests in a homicide and a residential robbery series, a stunt driving event involving 75-100 vehicles, and a seizure of 3.5 kg of fentanyl. The chief also announced official engagement with the 30x30 initiative. In response to questions, he confirmed a mediated agreement with the DA's office on MOU language, expected to present to the commission by Oct. 19. He also agreed to agendize a discussion on youth detention trends. DPA Director's Report Director Paul Henderson reported that in 2022, DPA has opened 538 cases, closed 567, and has 248 open. Sustained 50 cases (up from 39 last year). Mediated 18 cases. 22 cases have investigations exceeding nine months (18 due to tolling). Commission Reports - Commissioner Benedicto updated on DGO 9.01 working group (final meeting Oct. 20), upcoming CMCR training, and reported progress on several DGOs: 5.07 (rights of onlookers) entering concurrence; 6.16, 6.18, 7.01, 7.02 meetings being convened; 9.03, 10.11, 6.01/02 starting 90-day clock. - Commissioner Walker discussed community meetings on street safety, work on DGO 5.22 (transgender interactions), and updates on other DGOs. - Commissioner Yi highlighted outreach to Southeast Asian communities and focus on DGO 6.14 (5150 holds). - Commissioner Byrne reported a complex disciplinary case in closed session and will provide DGO updates in November. - Commissioner Yannis reported ongoing contact with department on assigned DGOs. - Vice President Carter Oberstone noted the DGO 9.01 working group is in its final stretch. - President Elias started the 90-day clock on DGO 5.08 (non-uniformed officers). Surveillance Technology Update (Chapter 19B) Aja Steves (Special Projects Manager) presented the approved non-city entity surveillance camera policy (STP/SIR), effective Nov. 5, 2022, with a 15-month sunset. The policy authorizes: (1) temporary live monitoring (max 24 hours, no recording, with captain approval); (2) requesting historical footage for criminal investigations; (3) requesting historical footage for internal investigations. Quarterly reports due June 1, 2023, will include census tract data. The department committed to training and forms before use. Discussion included concerns about racial disparities, data tracking, and community outreach. Commissioners requested the forms and training materials be presented before rollout. Public comment raised constitutional concerns and the need for warrants. Safe Streets for All Quarterly Report Commander Peter Walsh presented Vision Zero data. Year-to-date traffic fatalities: 24 (21 vision zero). Pedestrian deaths are the highest category. Focus on the five violations: speeding, red-light running, failure to yield, etc. Total traffic citations by district vary widely. Traffic enforcement staffing reduced from 45 officers in 5 squads (2019) to 22 officers in 4 squads (2022). Commissioners requested stop data (not just citations) for 2018-2019 and more granular data on education vs. enforcement. Discussion also covered scooter-related injuries and fatalities. Reimagining Policy Development Deanna Olivar Roche (Director of Policy and Public Affairs) presented internal recommendations to restructure policy development. Key changes: moving policy writing to the Chief of Staff's office, creating a Policy Development Unit, and establishing a Community and Policy Working Group Unit. Nine recommendations included transitioning policy writing oversight, redefining working groups, implementing a tier system, and a honeymoon phase for piloting policies. Hiring of professional policy writers and facilitators is underway, expected by end of November. Director Henderson (DPA) stressed the need to implement DGO 3.01 and ensure DPA access to subject matter experts. Chief Scott confirmed access but with oversight. Vice President Carter Oberstone asked for more concrete community outreach; the chief stated the new structure will increase community input for DGO revisions. Approval of Department General Order 8.01 Commissioner Benedicto moved to approve revised DGO 8.01 (Major and Critical Incident Evaluation and Notifications) for meet and confer with the Police Officers Association. The DGO had not been updated since 1994. The motion passed unanimously (7-0). Credit was given to Jermaine Jones for his work on the policy. Closed Session and Disclosure The commission voted to hold Item 11 in closed session. After closed session, a motion to disclose discussion on Item 11A passed 6-1 (Commissioner Yi dissented). The disclosed item was a letter from the Police Officers Union regarding the duty to intercede language in DGO 5.01. Key Outcomes - Approved DGO 8.01 for meet and confer (unanimous). - Voted to disclose closed session Item 11A (6-1), releasing the POA letter. - Chief reported MOU with DA's office agreed; expects to present to commission by Oct. 19. - Chief committed to agendize a report on youth detention trends and training on adolescent brain development. - Data requests: Commissioners requested stop data (not just citations) for 2018-2019, and tracking of education vs. enforcement in traffic stops. - Surveillance policy rollout: Department to present forms and training materials to commission before implementation. - Policy Development restructuring: New staff to be hired and onboarded by end of November, with increased community working groups planned.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 27% · PUBLIC SAFETY 20% · PROCEDURAL 13% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 12%
1109
OCT 11, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Hearing on Mayor's Undated Resignation Letter Policy - October 11, 2022

On October 11, 2022, at 6:15 PM UTC, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Government Audit and Oversight Committee held a special hearing to investigate the mayor's practice of requiring appointees to sign undated resignation letters. The hearing featured testimony from Mayor London Breed's Chief of Staff, Sean Elsbernd, and Police Commissioner Max Carter-Oberstone, who revealed the practice and its impact on commissioner independence. The committee heard public comment and voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - Callers expressed strong support for Commissioner Carter-Oberstone and condemned the mayor's practice, calling it a violation of the city charter and an abuse of power. Several urged the Ethics Commission to investigate. - Dennis Williams (sub-chair of the film or emergency collaborative) stated the practice was "egregious conduct" and a form of bullying, and called for recall of Mayor Breed. - Tab Buckner argued that selective designation of commissioners to sign letters indicated inconsistency and bias, and that pressuring commissioners after appointment is a charter violation. - Kevin Ortiz noted that the letters were "weaponized" to silence commissioners and undermine their independence. - Amy Farrell Weiss questioned the mayor's motives, especially regarding pretextual stop policies, and accused the mayor of abusing power. - Erica's Mike wondered if the practice extended to other mayoral appointees, such as the redistricting task force. - Lisa Aubrey called the practice a "very big deal" and criticized the mayor's representative for being unresponsive. - Michelle Kong suggested the practice may have predated Mayor Breed and called for accountability. - Jupiter Peraza expressed concern that the mayor's influence over non-commission appointments (e.g., District 6 supervisor, district attorney) could compromise independence. Discussion Items - Supervisor Dean Preston (Chair) opened the hearing, stating that the practice of undated resignation letters is inconsistent with the city charter, which protects commissioners from unilateral removal. He noted that the city attorney had issued a memo finding the practice unlawful. - Sean Elsbernd (Chief of Staff) testified that the practice originated with Mayor Breed at the start of her tenure, intended to address extreme ethical situations similar to former Port Commissioner Mel Murphy. He stated that the letters were not required for nomination, but were requested on a case-by-case basis. He acknowledged that the city attorney's opinion led the mayor to end the practice. - Commissioner Max Carter-Oberstone testified that during his reappointment process, he was asked to sign an undated resignation letter, which he felt was a requirement. He described pressure from the mayor's office to support their preferred police commission president and to delay or derail a policy on pretextual stops. He stated that the existence of the letter created a chilling effect, though no one explicitly threatened to use it. He also noted that he was called a "liar" by the mayor after he voted for a different commission president. - Supervisor Connie Chan (Vice Chair) questioned the mayor's rationale, noting that the charter already provides removal processes and that the practice undermines democratic governance. She highlighted the mayor's public statement that she wanted "a level of control" over commissioners. - Supervisor Hillary Ronan expressed concern about the mayor's public name-calling and threats of "serious consequences" for commissioners who disagree. She emphasized the importance of independent commission oversight, especially for the police commission. Key Outcomes - The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair (2-0, with Vice Chair Chan and Chair Preston voting aye), pending further responses to letters of inquiry. - The mayor's office has ended the practice of requesting undated resignation letters, following the city attorney's public memo that the practice is inconsistent with the charter. - The city attorney's memo warned that such letters could threaten the independence of appointed officials and undermine charter protections. - Commissioner Carter-Oberstone rescinded his resignation letter before it could be used, and his testimony revealed that the mayor's office pressured him on policy matters, raising concerns about improper influence. - Supervisor Preston announced that legislation may be introduced to prevent future mayors from engaging in this practice.

PUBLIC COMMENT 26% · CHARTER AMENDMENTS 25% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 19% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 14%
1110
OCT 11, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting — October 11, 2022

The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, October 11, 2022, beginning at 10:15 AM. The meeting included presentations on waterfront climate adaptation, several real estate and development projects, and financial matters. Commissioners unanimously approved the consent calendar and adjourned in memory of community advocate Michael Hammond. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2248: Approval of findings under state urgency legislation to allow remote meeting attendance by commissioners during the COVID-19 emergency. Adopted unanimously. - Resolution 2249: Authorization of a maintenance dredging contract (2022-2024) with Dutra Group for $7,238,750, plus a 10% contingency ($723,875), for a total not to exceed $7,962,625. Adopted unanimously. - Resolution 2250: Approval of a retroactive month-to-month license with San Francisco Community Fishing Association (2,424 sq ft shed space, 1,602 sq ft apron space) at Pier 45 Shed D. Adopted unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 11a (Waterfront Adaptation): One caller raised the risk of tsunami waves (35-50 ft) and suggested learning from other countries. The caller was thanked for their comments. - Item 12a (TZK Broadway Hotel): Hip Digame, research analyst for Unite Here Local 2, expressed strong support for the developer, noting a model agreement ensuring a neutral unionization process for future hotel workers. - Item 12c (YMCA Building 49): Tamara Hicks, owner of Daily Driver (bagel and cream cheese business), spoke emotionally about the partnership with the YMCA and her love for San Francisco. She thanked the commission and staff. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 9a): Director Elaine Forbes highlighted economic recovery successes: Fleet Week attendance, record cruise calls (119 projected for the year), Portola Music Festival (though noise complaints received), and the reopening of historic ferry Klamath at Pier 9. She also noted a $25 million state investment announced at Mission Rock to support women and underserved populations entering construction trades. She honored Vice President Kimberly Brandon’s 25 years of service and her upcoming induction into SF State Alumni Hall of Fame. The report concluded with a remembrance of Michael Hammond, a long-time port advocate and SAC member. - Waterfront Resilience Program (Item 11a): Deputy Program Manager Adam Barrett described seven draft adaptation strategies (A–G) to address coastal flooding, seismic risk, and inland flooding. Strategies range from no action (A) to managed retreat (G). The port is working with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers on a coastal flood study. Public engagement will continue through winter 2022–2023, with a preferred plan expected by summer 2023. Commissioners asked about coordination with other city projects, equity considerations, and backup power for pumping systems. - TZK Broadway Hotel (Item 12a): Ricky Tijani and developer Jay Wallace provided an update on the mixed-use project (192-room hotel, Teatro Zenzani theater, 14,000 sq ft open space) at Seawall Lots 323/324. COVID-19 delayed construction; financing is being reassembled (estimated total cost $162 million). The developer reaffirmed commitment to labor neutrality and community engagement. Commissioners expressed support and encouraged continued progress. - Autodesk Lease (Item 12b): Property Manager Don Kavanaugh presented a proposed 12-month lease renewal (with a 12-month option) for 30,590 sq ft at Pier 9. Rent will increase to market rates (approximately $124,000/month). Autodesk has invested $3 million in improvements. Commissioners supported consolidating associated agreements into the new lease. - YMCA Building 49 at Crane Cove Park (Item 12c): Jamie Hurley and YMCA representative Tekaija Gardner detailed a proposed multi-use lease for Building 49. The YMCA will be master tenant, with subtenants Daily Driver (food) and Doll Patch Paddle (water sports). The YMCA will invest at least $5 million in tenant improvements, with an additional $1 million recommended for seismic upgrades (50% cost share with port). Initial term 10 years, with extension options up to 34 years and 9 months. Year-1 base rent is $93,500; percentage rent applies to subtenants. The YMCA will maintain public restrooms. Commissioners praised the community benefits and equity focus. - Mission Rock Recycled Water Purchase Agreement (Item 12d): Phil Williamson and Josh Keene explained the agreement to purchase non-potable water from Mission Rock Utilities for China Basin Park and other port areas. The system treats wastewater on-site, saving 43,000 gallons of potable water per day (13.9 million gallons/year). Port’s annual cost is estimated at $615,000 (capacity charge $550,000 + usage charge $65,000). A special service tax from Mission Rock development will backstop the obligation if the port must manage the park directly. Commissioners asked about financial risks and benefits; staff noted the structure avoids direct port expenditure through assignment to a park tenant. - Finance & Administration (Item 13a): Acting Deputy Director Nate Cruz reported that the port failed its debt coverage test in FY2021 (operating loss of $44 million) but passed the second test using fund balance. A consultant recommended adjusting leasing practices, seeking interagency savings, and refining expense categorization. Staff propose increasing the operating reserve requirement from 15% to 50% of operating expenses to better prepare for emergencies. Commissioners supported the increase and noted the port’s strong recovery trajectory. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Unanimously approved Resolutions 2248, 2249, and 2250. - Executive Session: Commission voted unanimously to enter and later reconvene in open session; no disclosure of discussions reported. - Adjournment: Meeting adjourned at approximately 6:12 PM in memory of Michael Hammond. - Next Steps: Staff will return with final versions of the YMCA lease (target approval early 2023), the Autodesk lease, and the Mission Rock water purchase agreement (to Board of Supervisors in 2023). The waterfront adaptation team will conduct public outreach through winter 2022–2023, with a draft plan due summer 2023.

PROCEDURAL 29% · SEA LEVEL RISE 14% · LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 10% · HOTEL INDUSTRY 8%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com