Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1171–1180 ENTRIES
1171
APR 21, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting – April 21, 2022

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 21, 2022, at 18:15 UTC (11:15 AM PDT) to consider three main items: a resolution to amend the Dog Patch and Northwest Potrero Hill Green Benefit District management plan, a Mills Act historical property contract for 714 Steiner Street, and a hearing on the Dreamkeeper Initiative. The committee also convened in closed session to approve five lawsuit settlements. Chair Dean Preston presided, joined by Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Rafael Mandelman (and temporarily Supervisor Aaron Peskin for Item 1). Consent Calendar - Items 4 through 8 (five ordinances settling lawsuits against the city) were moved to closed session and recommended for approval with no public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Green Benefit District): Dennis Williams (No Racism, No Hate, San Francisco) spoke about the need for youth programs to assist Public Works with graffiti and cleanup, not directly on the resolution. - Item 1 (Mills Act): Megan Smith (Victorian Alliance) urged approval of the Mills Act application as-is, praising the owner’s preservation efforts. - Item 3 (Dreamkeeper): Over 15 public callers and in-person speakers testified. Most supported continued funding and highlighted positive impacts (e.g., small business startups, scholarships, arts programs, EMT training). Some called for more transparency, direct community input, and attention to challenges such as slow contracting and lack of minority developer contracts. Discussion Items - Item 2: Green Benefit District Management Plan Amendment – President Shamann Walton introduced a resolution to merge the maintenance and capital improvement budget categories (currently 31% and 32% of the GBD budget, respectively) to give the district greater flexibility. Ramses Alvarez (DPW) presented the benefits. The committee adopted amendments to clarify the hearing date and simplify the title, then sent the item to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 1: Mills Act Contract for 714 Steiner Street – Supervisor Aaron Peskin (substituting for Chair Preston) proposed amendments to terminate the Mills Act contract after 10 years (effective after 20 years) to recapture approximately $580,000 in property tax abatement over two decades. The owner, Leah Culver, and planning staff supported the contract as-is. After debate, the committee voted 3-0 to adopt the amendments and continued the item to the May 5 meeting for further consideration. - Item 3: Dreamkeeper Initiative Hearing – Nine city departments presented on their use of $120 million in annual funds (60 million per year) to support Black communities. Key presentations: HRC (overall coordination, $11 million), OEWD ($20.5 million, 502 entrepreneurs/trainees enrolled, 92 businesses launched), DPH ($46 million over three years, emergency grants to 400+ families), SFFD (City EMT program, 5 interns hired, 10 new interns), MOCD ($9.5 million for down-payment loans, 5 approved, 2 in escrow; senior rehab program), DCYF ($3.5 million, 14 CBOs/programs), Arts Commission ($2.1 million, 5 grants), OECE (policy council for Black educators), and DHR (29 funded positions, 17 filled, 2 promoted to permanent). All departments described how they plan to institutionalize funding. The committee continued the hearing to the call of the chair. Key Outcomes - Item 2: Motion to adopt amendments and send to full board with positive recommendation passed 3-0. Agenda: Board of Supervisors meeting on May 3, 2022. - Item 1: Motion to adopt Supervisor Peskin’s amendments (termination after 10 years) passed 3-0. Item continued to the May 5 GAO meeting. - Item 3: Hearing continued to the call of the chair for future updates. - Closed Session: Five lawsuits settled; motion not to disclose deliberations passed 3-0. Additional Notes - The meeting began with Item 2 out of order due to Supervisor Peskin joining later for Item 1. - Chair Preston recused himself from Item 1 because the property is within 500 feet of his residence. - The Dreamkeeper Initiative hearing included detailed data on outputs and early outcomes, though many programs were still ramping up.

DREAMKEEPERS INITIATIVE 35% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 12% · PUBLIC HEALTH 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7%
1172
APR 20, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Budget and Appropriations Committee Hearing on Street Teams and Police Calls - April 20, 2022

The Budget and Appropriations Committee held a hearing on April 20, 2022, to review the city's street response teams and their effectiveness in diverting non-criminal calls from the San Francisco Police Department (SFPD). The hearing focused on the Street Crisis Response Team (SCRT) and the Healthy Streets Operations Center (HSOC), as well as other teams. Supervisors, department heads, and analysts discussed progress, data challenges, and next steps. Public Comments & Testimony - Joe Adkins (virtual): Expressed distrust in SFPD data, citing historical skewing to support staffing budgets. Called for independent third-party oversight of law enforcement data and decreasing police budgets proportionally as alternative teams scale up. - Samuel Peoples (virtual, DPW employee): Stated that the Department of Public Works lacks additional funding and equipment to handle increased responsibilities from HSOC call routing. Emphasized the need for a sound needs assessment and racial equity in service teams. Discussion Items - Opening Remarks (Supervisor Ronan): Stated the goal of reducing SFPD's role in homelessness and mental health calls. Noted that 10 street teams are funded, 9 operational. SCRT has been running about a year but is not yet fully staffed. Expressed hope for success but called for critical evaluation of impact on police call volume. - Budget and Legislative Analyst (Fred Brusseau): Presented a report focusing on SCRT and HSOC. Key data: - SCRT started November 2020; in February 2022, SFPD responded to 46.6% of 800B calls, SCRT to 59% (overlap due to dual dispatch). Police response declined from 85% at start. - HSOC calls redirected to DPW after April 2020 policy change; homelessness-related calls to SFPD have dropped. - Recommended improving 911 call data tracking for police responses. - Department Presentations (DEM, Fire, DPH): - Mary Ellen Carroll (DEM): Overview of five street teams: EMS 6, SCRT, Street Overdose Response Team (SORT), Street Wellness Team (SWT), and HSOC. - Simon Payne (Fire): Fire department is common thread due to high ambulance transports for homeless (21%) and frequent users (17% of volume from 7% of users). Teams are 911-based for triage safety. - Angelica Almeida (DPH): SCRT launched Nov 2020 with 6 teams providing citywide 24/7 coverage by July 2021; seventh team not yet deployed. Teams respond to 4 calls per shift; average 14-15 minute response time. 28% of contacts result in transport to care; 60% remain in community (voluntary). Police assistance requested in only 3.6% of SCRT encounters. - Robert Smuts (DEM): Explained dispatch process; current dual-code system (800B + 25AO) leads to data overlaps. Planned June 2022 shift to Emergency Medical Dispatch (EMD) protocols will eliminate police backstop; if SCRT unavailable, an ambulance will respond. Call volume increased 35-50% in recent months, possibly due to latent demand or increased crisis. - Chief Payne: Presented dispositions: 4,039 encounters from Nov 2020 to Mar 2022. Top 10 repeat clients: 70% connected to intensive case management. - Discussion by Supervisors: - President Walton: Questioned need for a dedicated non-911 phone number to improve access. Discussed SCRT capacity: with seventh team, capacity could reach 13,000-20,000 calls/year. - Supervisor Mar: Asked about outcomes: 28% transport rate is in line with expectations; 66% of clients have follow-up via Office of Coordinated Care. Noted importance of critical case management (not yet started). - Supervisor Ronan: Expressed concern that despite investment, police call volumes for mental health/homelessness remain steady. Called for measurable impact by next year. Noted DPW capacity strain from shifted calls. - Supervisor Safai: Questioned data showing 81% of SCRT clients had only one encounter, given anecdotal experience with repeat individuals. Dr. Almeida explained that unidentified clients may be undercounted due to lack of identifiable information. - Supervisor Chan: Asked about performance metrics: response time (now 14-15 min, target under 30 min) and long-term success indicators (connections to care, reductions in 911 calls, ER overcrowding). - SFPD Response (Lieutenant Molina): Reported that SFPD responded to 47,242 mental health-related calls in 2021, with force used in only 44 incidents (99.9% de-escalation). Expressed commitment to supporting alternative teams and cited 80 hours of mental health training for officers. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (4-0 with Supervisor Mar absent) to continue the item to the call of the chair, allowing future follow-up. - Key next steps: Implementation of EMD protocols in June 2022, deployment of seventh SCRT team, expansion of SORT (second team by June 25), and development of alternative access routes (non-911). - Data tracking improvements recommended: better 911 call recording to measure police response to SCRT-eligible calls; independent evaluations underway (Harder & Company; Robert Wood Johnson Foundation). - DPW funding and capacity will be a focus during upcoming budget process.

PUBLIC SAFETY 28% · PUBLIC HEALTH 21% · EMERGENCY SERVICES 17% · HOMELESSNESS 9%
1173
APR 20, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – April 20, 2022

On Wednesday, April 20, 2022, the San Francisco Police Commission convened for its regular meeting. The agenda included the Chief's report on recent officer arrests, the annual Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) report, a discussion on departmental clearance rates, and several public comment periods. Commissioners also heard farewell remarks from outgoing Commissioner John Hamasaki. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously (6-0) approved the consent calendar, which included the Family Code 628 Incident Report Release, Quarterly Report (First Quarter 2022), SFPD and DPA SB 1421/SB16 monthly reports, the monthly Collaborative Reform Initiative (CRI) update, and the Police Commission Disciplinary Actions Report (First Quarter 2022). Public Comments & Testimony - Rita Lark urged the commission to support AB 1837 (“No Place Like Home”), which died in Sacramento, regarding locating high-risk parolees. - David Elliott Lewis, a longtime volunteer on the CIT mental health working group, praised the program's progress in de-escalation and reduced use of force, and thanked the commission for its support. - John Pro criticized the department's culture following the arrest of three SFPD officers, arguing that the department treats each incident as isolated and fails to address systemic issues. - Susan Buckman, David Aronson, and Gene Bridges (volunteers with Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community) read statements from founder Felicia Jones, decrying anti-blackness in SFPD’s use of force, arrests, and traffic stops. They cited data showing Black San Franciscans are 6 times more likely to be subject to traffic stops, 10.5 times more likely to be arrested, and nearly 16 times more likely to experience use of force compared to white residents. They called for urgent accountability. - Francisco de Conste requested the commission investigate the redistricting task force and address quality-of-life issues in public housing areas. Chief’s Report - Chief William Scott reported on the arrests of three officers (including retired officer Mark Williams) for alleged criminal misconduct, including unlawful possession of a machine gun, possession of a silencer, embezzlement, and destruction of evidence. He emphasized that internal investigations led to the charges and that the department is committed to accountability. - Crime updates: Three shootings occurred during the reporting period (April 13–15), one resulting in a homicide. Four suspects were arrested for organized retail theft at two Walgreens. A robbery series involving a firearm led to the arrest of four suspects connected to multiple auto burglaries. - Violent crime overall was up 3% compared to the prior year. - Commissioner Hamasaki questioned the department’s culture and the timing of the arrests, leading to a discussion about accountability and policy changes. Chief Scott defended the department’s progress, noting that policy revisions, body-worn cameras, and the forthcoming General Order 2.01 are helping to change culture. DPA Director’s Report - Diana Rosenstein (Chief Attorney, DPA) reported that DPA has opened 186 cases and closed 184 so far this year, with 277 cases pending. Ten cases have been sustained. She highlighted weekly trends: 15% of new allegations involved unbecoming conduct, 7% each for invalid orders, failure to write reports, failure to investigate, and improper search/seizure. - DPA is conducting a charter-mandated audit of SFPD’s handling of misconduct investigations and is developing an online case-tracking system for complainants. Commission Reports - Commissioner Byrne and Commissioner Yee reported on a meeting with UC Hastings and Urban Alchemy, praising daytime improvements in the Tenderloin but raising concerns about nighttime safety. They requested agendizing the Tenderloin situation for the June 1 meeting. - Commissioner Hamasaki gave farewell remarks, thanking staff, the city attorney, DPA, and community partners. He expressed pride in policy work on domestic violence, use of force, and CIT, but noted frustration that the department’s culture has not fully changed. - Commissioner Yannis thanked Hamasaki and requested agendizing items on community policing (DGO) and the CART (Compassionate Alternative Response Team) program to address homelessness-related calls. Presentation of the Annual CIT End of Year Report 2021 - Lieutenant Mario Molina presented the 2021 CIT report. Key statistics: 67% of SFPD officers are CIT-trained (national best practice is 20%). Officers responded to 47,242 calls for service involving persons in crisis; only 44 incidents required use of force (0.09%). The program includes 40-hour training, a field unit, a liaison program, and a working group with the Department of Public Health. - Use of force incidents involved 75 officers; 23 of those were not CIT-trained. Commissioner Yannis noted that 38 of the 75 were white officers, but Lieutenant Molina attributed this to the department’s demographic makeup. - The department has partnered with DPH clinicians who assist in crisis negotiations and provide information (via government code) to improve responses. - Commissioner Yannis asked about full compliance (100% training); Lieutenant Molina said staffing shortages make it difficult to predict, but they continue training via a mix of Zoom and in-person sessions. Discussion on Clearance Rates - Acting Deputy Chief Raj Vaswani and Chief Scott led a discussion on the department’s clearance rates. In 2020, the overall arrest rate was 8.1% of reported crimes – the lowest in 10 years. For most crime categories (robbery, aggravated assault, larceny, burglary, rape, motor vehicle theft), San Francisco’s clearance rates were below the national average; only homicide exceeded it (77% in 2021 vs. national average 61%). - Chief Scott cited property crime dominance, staffing shortages (200 fewer full-duty officers since 2020), and the complexity of repeat offenders as key factors. He noted that the department has reorganized investigations, created a retail theft unit, and is working to improve technology and analytics. - Commissioner Elias and Commissioner Yannis pressed for concrete solutions, including auditing calls to ensure proper follow-up and improving training. Commissioner Yannis proposed a quality assurance approach to supervision. - Commissioner Carter-Oberstone questioned whether the low clearance rates reflect a cultural problem with investigation quality, based on his experience as a former public defender. Deputy Chief Vaswani defended the work of investigators, noting recent successes with complex cases. Key Outcomes - The consent calendar was approved unanimously (6-0). - The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to hold Item 10 in closed session. - After closed session, the commission voted unanimously (6-0) not to disclose any discussion from closed session. - The commission agreed to agendize the Tenderloin nighttime safety situation for the June 1, 2022 meeting. - Commissioner Yannis’s requests to agendize community policing and CART were noted for future meetings. - The department committed to continuing CIT training, working toward staffing improvements, and exploring audits of investigative practices.

PROCEDURAL 45% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 28% · PUBLIC SAFETY 9% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
1174
APR 14, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting – April 14, 2022

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on Thursday, April 14, 2022, to consider four items: a health code ordinance on skilled nursing transfers, a liquor license for a neighborhood market, a follow-up hearing on anti-Asian violence and public safety response, and a detailed review of San Francisco Police Department staffing. Chair Gordon Maher presided, joined by Supervisors Catherine Stefani and Matt Haney, with Supervisor Rafael Mandelman participating for the police staffing hearing. Public Comments & Testimony - On the skilled nursing reporting item, Patrick Manatsaw thanked the committee and supported expanding data collection, but urged the committee to revisit the duplicated file before October rather than waiting until the planned hearing. - On the AAPI safety hearing, Patricia Boy (Marina/Cow Hollow Neighbors and Merchants) described persistent incidents against Asian workers and merchants and called for more effective city coordination and support. - On the police staffing hearing, dozens of callers commented. Most, including representatives of the Hotel Council of San Francisco, Golden Gate Restaurant Association, Bay Area Council, Fisherman’s Wharf Community Benefit District, Union Square businesses, BOMA San Francisco, Pier 39, IATSE Local 16, and numerous residents, strongly supported increasing SFPD staffing and resources, citing crime, slow response times, and economic recovery. A caller from GLIDE and several individuals argued that increased policing alone would not address root causes, urging investments in shelter, mental health care, alternative response teams, and an end to pretextual stops. A number of callers criticized the District Attorney and the Board of Supervisors for what they described as insufficient support for police. Discussion Items - Item 3 – Health Code – Skilled Nursing Care Transfer Reporting Requirements: Bill Barnes from Supervisor Safai’s office presented the ordinance, which would require general acute care hospitals and hospital-based skilled nursing facilities to report annually to the Department of Public Health on the number and demographics of patients transferred to out-of-city subacute/skilled nursing facilities, as well as patients who qualify for such care but are not transferred. The ordinance had been amended at the previous meeting to include more facility types and to extend the reporting deadline to October 1. Chair Maher supported the measure, describing it as critical for understanding the city’s deficit in subacute and skilled nursing care, and moved to duplicate the file to allow future amendments, including broader data collection and alignment with a comprehensive senior care plan. Supervisor Stefani asked to be added as a co-sponsor, citing her previous work on St. Luke’s and CPMC. - Item 1 – Liquor License – Dad & Son’s Market: The committee heard an application for a Type 21 off-sale license for a 1,300-square-foot grocery store at 3218 Fillmore Street. The applicant’s representative described the market as a neighborhood-serving store with a small alcohol section behind the counter, expected alcohol sales of less than 15% of total revenue, and existing security measures. Officer Salmonson presented the ALU report: 10 letters of protest, 187 petition signatures of support, no opposition from Northern Station, and an ALU recommendation to approve with a condition requiring the licensee to actively monitor adjacent property to prevent loitering. Supervisor Stefani welcomed the business, noted her office had received no concerns, and supported the recommendation. - Item 2 – Hearing – Crime and Violence Targeting Asian-American Seniors: Chair Maher presented data on the rise in anti-Asian incidents: nearly 11,000 AAPI hate incidents reported nationally to Stop AAPI Hate through December 2021, including 4,100 in California and 905 in San Francisco; SFPD preliminary data showed anti-Asian bias reports rose from 9 in 2020 to 60 in 2021 (a 567% increase). HRC Director Sheryl Davis presented a citywide public safety landscape analysis finding hundreds of separately funded programs with limited coordination, no shared framework or standardized reporting, gaps in the safety net, and a need for clearer prevention, intervention, and response strategies. Near-term recommendations included a citywide response protocol for hate incidents, better language access, standardized reporting, and community partnerships; longer-term recommendations emphasized restorative justice, cross-cultural solidarity, and investments in equity. Cynthia Choi (Chinese for Affirmative Action) and Sarah Wan (Community Youth Center), representing the Community Coalition for Safety and Justice, supported the recommendations and urged rapid implementation; Wan noted that CYC had served 88 AAPI victims since February 2021 and had created a victim/survivor fund because state compensation usually takes 30–90 days. Supervisor Stefani referenced the killing of Vicha Ratanapakdi in her district and the 500% rise in AAPI hate crimes. Public comment was taken; one in-person speaker testified. - Item 4 – Hearing – Police Department Staffing Levels: Supervisor Stefani opened the hearing, citing the 2020 Matrix Consulting Group staffing study that called for 2,176 sworn officers, with the deficit now more than 500 and projected to exceed 700. She also cited burglaries up about 40% citywide (as high as 78% in some neighborhoods), disproportionate shoplifting losses at CVS and Walgreens, lower officer-per-resident ratios than peer cities (22 per 10,000 vs. 42 in New York, 44 in Chicago, 61 in Washington, D.C.), and increases in Priority A calls. SFPD Commander Nicole Jones and senior analyst Celeste Berg presented the Proposition E staffing analysis: recommended staffing is 2,182 sworn and 554 professional staff; the sworn recommendation is virtually unchanged from Matrix’s 2,176. Additional staffing required has grown from 265 in 2020 to more than 500. Citywide full-duty staffing fell from 1,868 in January 2019 to 1,612, a 14% decline, including an 8% drop in the last six months. Non-training attrition increased about 80% from FY19 to FY22; retirements are the leading cause, with 518 officers age 50 or older projected by the end of FY22. Applications fell from nearly 3,000 in 2018 to about 1,100 in 2021; the most recent academy class graduated only 12 officers. Recruitment and retention proposals included hiring a recruiting firm, waiving the $55 application test fee, eliminating salary steps to raise starting pay, offering bonuses, establishing a retention unit, improving training reimbursements, and exploring housing supplementation. Field Operations Bureau staffing declined to 1,185 officers as of April 4, 2022, with the police officer rank at stations below 1,000. Deputy Chief David Lazar described the operational consequences, including long Priority C response times (61 minutes in September 2021, now 99 minutes), and explained that high-visibility deployments in Union Square and the Tenderloin are costly and difficult to sustain. Narcotics enforcement is down to one lieutenant, three sergeants, and a 12-officer team, and traffic company staffing is below 30% of historical levels. The department is working with the Controller’s Office on a workload-based analysis of Street Crisis Response Team calls and Priority C calls that may be transferable to other agencies. Public comment was taken, with dozens of callers. Key Outcomes - Item 3: The committee duplicated the file. The duplicated version, as amended, will be forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation; the original file was continued to the call of the chair. The motion passed without objection (Haney absent, Stefani aye, Maher aye). - Item 1: The committee directed the clerk to prepare a resolution finding that the Dad & Son’s Market liquor license serves the public convenience and necessity, and to forward it to the full board with a positive recommendation. The motion passed without objection (Haney absent, Stefani aye, Maher aye). - Item 2: The committee continued the hearing to the call of the chair to allow future updates on implementation of the HRC report and community recommendations. The motion passed without objection. - Item 4: The committee filed the hearing. The motion passed without objection (Mandelman absent, Stefani aye, Maher aye), with discussion indicating staffing funding would be a focus during budget negotiations.

PUBLIC SAFETY 37% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 35% · HATE CRIME RESPONSE 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8%
1175
APR 13, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - April 13, 2022

The Budget and Appropriations Committee met on the afternoon of April 13, 2022, chaired by Supervisor Hilary Ronen, with Supervisors Gordon Mar, Connie Chan, President Shamann Walton, and Vice Chair Ahsha Safai participating. The committee received an update on the city's five-year financial plan, took public comment, unanimously filed that hearing, and continued a hearing on citywide street teams to April 20, 2022 because the Budget and Legislative Analyst report was not ready. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel offered public comment on the five-year financial plan. He praised the revenue forecasting work, supported competitive but reasonable salaries and benefits and reducing the city's pension liability, and backed facilities maintenance, ICT, and capital plans. He urged realistic position counts instead of inflated positions offset by attrition savings, recommended not spending all surplus funds, replenishing all reserves, avoiding one-time funds for new programs, and limiting - not zeroing - nonprofit funding. - No public comment was received on the motion to continue the street teams hearing. Discussion Items - Five-Year Financial Plan Update: Mayor's Budget Director Ashley Groffenberger and Controller's Office Citywide Revenue Manager Carol Liu presented the March update. Key points included: - The January forecast projected a $108 million surplus over the next two budget years; the March update reduced that to approximately $75 million, with modest out-year shortfalls. The structural deficit in the final forecast year is about $150 million. - Revenue projections were mixed: property tax improved after incorporating actual assessment appeals; excess ERAF improved but was partially offset by state education funding changes in the governor's budget; business tax weakened because the telecommuting assumption rose from 15% to 33% beginning in FY 2022-23; hotel tax weakened, with recovery to pre-pandemic levels expected in calendar year 2026; and transfer tax weakened as large commercial real estate transfers averaged about 100 per year since COVID-19, down from about 150 pre-pandemic. - FEMA reimbursement revenue increased by $45.9 million because eligible costs were extended through June 30, 2020, but the timing of reimbursements is delayed. - Expenditure changes included replenishing the general reserve after supplemental appropriations, pension contribution rates about 1% higher than previously expected, higher workers' compensation costs, increased general fund support for Moscone Convention Center, and changes to HSA aid programs. - Risks include active labor negotiations: each 1% wage increase above CPI adds about $25 million in general fund costs. The forecast assumes no FEMA revenue for costs after this fiscal year. - In response to member questions, staff cited current-year excess ERAF of about $245 million, a projected general reserve balance of about $44 million, with a planned FY 2022-23 deposit of $48 million. Regarding recession strategy, staff said the city's main protections are the budget stabilization and rainy day reserves, and the city kept its structural deficit relatively low by avoiding new ongoing costs during COVID-19. - Supervisor Ahsha Safai asked for a fuller committee discussion of reserve requirements, noting that reserves can total nearly $1 billion while budget debates cover relatively small amounts. Chair Ronen supported the idea and offered to co-sponsor a hearing. - Citywide Street Teams Hearing: The committee considered a hearing on citywide street teams and their effectiveness on street conditions, homelessness, and behavioral health crises. Chair Ronen moved to continue the item to the April 20, 2022 meeting because the Budget and Legislative Analyst's report was not ready for department review. Key Outcomes - The committee voted 5-0 to file the five-year financial plan hearing. - The committee voted 5-0 to continue the citywide street teams hearing to the April 20, 2022 Budget and Appropriations Committee meeting. - The meeting adjourned after completing its agenda.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 74% · PROCEDURAL 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6% · HOMELESSNESS 4%
1176
APR 13, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - April 13, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular meeting on Wednesday, April 13, 2022, beginning at approximately 5:45 PM. The meeting included reports from the Chief of Police, the Director of the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), and presentations on staffing levels and the implementation of RIPA recommendations. The commission also adopted a revised Department General Order on awards and voted on closed session matters. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 1): Multiple members of the public spoke. Ms. Brown, mother of a 2006 murder victim, requested continued help and justice. Rita Lark asked about community police meetings in North Beach. Francisca raised quality of life issues and redistricting. Kate Hodge (Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community) urged the commission to track officer allegations through the system and highlighted the urgency of addressing anti-blackness. Jean Bridges (Wealth and Disparities) noted that the Q4 2021 96A report omitted racial disparity charts and that disparities were worsening; she stated the group has sought help from Attorney General Bonta. - Public Comment on Chief's Report (Item 2): One caller urged commissioners to conduct a needs assessment on staffing and criticized the lack of officer dialogue. Another caller commended the Suit Up initiative but stressed the need for broader mental health and job support, and suggested digital posters at BART stations. - Public Comment on Staffing Report (Item 6): A caller criticized the staffing analysis as not including community input and called for a true needs assessment. Another caller (Susan Buffman) urged the commission to eliminate low-level traffic stops to reduce officer workload. - Public Comment on 96A/RIPA Update (Item 7): Susan Buffman, volunteering with Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community, stated that Q4 2021 data showed black residents are 6 times more likely to be subject to traffic stops, 10.5 times more likely to be subject to a search, and nearly 16 times more likely to experience use of force compared to white residents. She questioned why SFPD omitted racial disparity charts from the Q4 report. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report (Item 2): Chief Scott reported 13 homicides year-to-date (up from 10 in 2021), violent crime up 2%, property crime larceny up 29% (including car break-ins, though down 17% from 2019-2020), non-fatal shootings down 28%, and homicide-related shootings up 60%. He discussed a stabbing homicide in the Mission, two shootings, one fatal traffic collision, and increased patrols after the New York subway incident. He highlighted the Suit Up initiative with Macy’s for at-risk young men and the lifting of the booster mandate for SFPD. Commissioners asked about strategies for addressing homicide increases in the Mission and Ingleside districts, Bay Area-wide coordination, and updates on specific investigations. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 3): Director Henderson reported 176 cases opened, 180 closed, 272 open, 9 sustained, 4 mediated, and 29 cases beyond 9 months (24 on hold). Top allegations by district were for unbecoming conduct and failure to investigate. The audit division is conducting an 18-month follow-up on the use of force audit. DPA staff received training on the Street Crisis Response Team and de-escalation. Commissioner Yannis requested breakdown by district for trend analysis. - Commission Reports (Item 4): Commissioner Yi announced an invitation to visit Urban Alchemy (next Wednesday, 2-3 PM, 200 McAllister). Commissioner Yannis reported meeting with the League of Women Voters and requested agendizing the Community Policing DGO 1.08 revision for May or June. He also raised the issue of making it easier for community members to file complaints with DPA. - Department General Order 3.09 – Department Awards (Item 5): The commission discussed and voted to adopt the revised order. Chief Scott, Director Henderson, and Sergeant Kilshaw noted it was a multi-year effort and that the new order is the most comprehensive in the nation. The motion passed unanimously (5-0). - Staffing Report Pursuant to Prop E (Item 6): Celeste Berg and Commander Jones presented the biennial staffing analysis. The report recommends 2,182 sworn officers and 554 professional staff. As of April 2022, the deficit is 459 sworn officers, up from 352 in September 2021. The methodology is workload-based, with a target of 30% time for community engagement. The report noted that staffing declines are driven by retirements and resignations, including a national trend. Commissioners discussed the need for better tracking of administrative time, analysis of non-patrol positions, and the potential for using professional staff to relieve sworn officers. The public comment included criticism of the analysis and suggestions to reduce traffic stops. - Update on Chapter 96A Report and RIPA Recommendations (Item 7): Dr. Nik Shani Kodinovich presented the status of 130 RIPA recommendations. Of the 106 applicable to SFPD, 73 are implemented, 33 remain. Seven recommendations are not yet implemented: three are in progress with the Collaborative Reform Initiative (CRI), and four are delayed due to staffing shortages. Commissioner Yannis raised the issue of collecting self-identified ethnicity data (beyond officer perception) and suggested a working group to explore best practices. Commissioner Byrne asked for details on the seven unimplemented recommendations. The presenters agreed to provide a detailed spreadsheet. - Closed Session Matters (Items 8-11): Public comment was taken on closed session items. The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to hold Item 10 in closed session and later voted unanimously not to disclose any discussion from that closed session. Key Outcomes - Adoption of DGO 3.09 (Department Awards): Passed unanimously (5-0). The revised order includes comprehensive criteria for awards, including consideration of pending discipline, and is considered a national model. - Staffing Report: The commission received the report and discussed next steps, including requests for more detailed breakdowns of non-patrol positions and a cost analysis by call type. The report will be used for future planning. - RIPA Recommendations: The commission agreed to schedule a future discussion on the status of unimplemented recommendations and the collection of self-identified ethnicity data. A working group may be formed. - Closed Session: The commission voted to not disclose any discussion from the closed session (Item 10). - Meeting Adjourned at approximately 8:30 PM (estimated).

POLICE OVERSIGHT 42% · PUBLIC SAFETY 24% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9% · PROCEDURAL 6%
1177
APR 12, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
Port Commission Meeting Summary April 12, 2022

The San Francisco Port Commission met on April 12, 2022, at 11:15 AM (UTC) to address a range of items including consent calendar approvals, contract awards, and informational presentations on LBE contracting, the Waterfront Resilience Program, leasing strategies, and a Pier 70 amendment. The meeting included public comments from tenants concerned about rent increases and support for the proposed actions. Key decisions included unanimous approvals of consent items, a contract award to Hollins Construction Inc., and a directive to staff on maritime rent relief data. Consent Calendar - Remote Meeting Resolution (Resolution 2216): Approved unanimously, allowing certain members to attend meetings remotely during the COVID-19 emergency for the next 30 days, with a directive to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. - Crane Cove Park Contract Modification (Resolution 2217): Approved unanimously, increasing the contract amount by $565,000 for Contract No. 2814R. - 2022 Uncollectable Balances Write-Off Policy (Resolution 2218): Adopted unanimously. - Memorandum of Understanding for Fire Training Facility (Resolution 2219): Approved unanimously, authorizing the purchase of approximately 2.6 acres at 1236 Carroll Avenue by the City for a fire personnel training facility. - Mutual Termination Agreement with Alioto Fish Company (Resolution 2220): Approved unanimously, terminating leases L-7491 (2829 Taylor Street) and L-9171 (360 Jefferson Street). Public Comments & Testimony - Liz Diaz (North Beach Marine Canvas): A tenant at Pier 40 for over 25 years, expressed concern over a 60% rent increase, which she characterized as an "invitation to leave." She emphasized that maritime businesses like hers are not storage, and requested the Commission work with staff to find a solution. - Margaret Cromwell (CalMarine Electronics): Stated that CalMarine has been in San Francisco since 1952 and services essential clients such as the SF Fire Department, SF Police Department, and Golden Gate Ferries. She argued that the steep rent increase could force them out of San Francisco, which would harm necessary maritime services. - Mark Bruno (Resident of North Beach): Spoke on behalf of North Beach Marine Canvas and other small businesses, asking the Commission to allow them to remain on the waterfront. He described the rent increase as an "existential crisis" and urged reconsideration. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report: Director Elaine Forbes reported on economic recovery signs, including the return of cruise operations (21 calls expected in April, including maiden call of Carnival Miracle), the off-the-boat fish sales program (crab season closed April 8 due to whale entanglements), and the submission of a $58.2 million funding application to the State Lands Commission. She also highlighted Mission Rock progress (topping off of Building A and start of Building F), and the success of the sixth annual contracts open house with 115 attendees. - Contract Award to Hollins Construction Inc. (Item 8A): Stephanie Tang, Contracts and Procurement Manager, presented the recommendation to award a $3 million, five-year as-needed technical services contract for Pier 70 and Mission Rock. The proposal scored 102.66 points after a CMD rating bonus, with 100% LBE participation. The item was approved unanimously as Resolution 2221. - LBE Contracting Activity (Item 8B): Stephanie Tang presented the first two quarters of FY 2021-22 LBE data: approximately $7.7 million in total payments, with 38% on as-needed contracts, and overall LBE participation just under 50%, exceeding aspirational goals. She also discussed recommended changes to the executive director’s delegated authority to align with new thresholds. - Waterfront Resilience Program LBE Subcontracting (Item 9A): Brad Benson, Waterfront Resilience Director, reported on LBE subcontracting outcomes for the CH2M Hill contract: 23.9% LBE participation, with 6.7% to MBE and 17.4% to WBE firms. He highlighted the program's equity actions, including a new race equity action planning task. - Living Seawall Pilot Project (Item 9B): Kelly Capone and Matt Bell presented the San Francisco Living Seawall Pilot Project, a partnership with the Smithsonian Environmental Research Center. The project will install textured tiles at three sites along the Embarcadero to study ecological enhancements provisional, with a total cost just over $1 million. The study aims to answer whether texturing benefits native species, and results will inform future seawall design. - Leasing Strategy for Vacant Spaces (Item 10A): Rebecca Benassini and Ricky Tidani presented a proposed pilot strategy to lease two vacant spaces (Ferry Plaza East Building and Pier 33 ½ restaurant space) using brokers, as the traditional RFP has not yielded success. The Commission expressed general support but requested more details on broker compensation and criteria, especially for formula retail and inclusion of local/BIPOC businesses. - Pier 70 Design for Development Amendment (Item 10B): Ryan Wassom presented the proposed amendment to clarify definitions of Retail Use and Office Use, allowing life science/lab uses on office-designated parcels without changing bulk or height. Kelly Pretzer (Brookfield) provided a project update, noting Brookfield continues to exceed LBE and local hire goals (29% LBE, exceeding 30% local hire requirement). The Commission was supportive of the amendment. Key Outcomes - Unanimous Approvals: All consent calendar items (Resolutions 2216-2220) and the contract award to Hollins Construction (Resolution 2221) were approved unanimously. - Executive Director’s Report: Commission praised the report and requested a written report on maritime rent relief program data, including how many tenants have opted in and barriers to participation. - LBE Delegated Authority: Staff will return with an action item to increase the Executive Director’s delegated authority to align with new thresholds effective July 1, 2022. - Pier 70 Affordable Housing: Commissioner Gilman requested that MOCD be invited to provide an update on the affordable housing parcel (C2A) at Pier 70. - Pier 70 Project Update: Commissioner Brandon requested an overall project update with new financial projections, to be scheduled for summer or fall 2022. - Living Seawall: Commissioner Wuho asked for periodic updates on the living seawall project and educational opportunities.

PUBLIC COMMENT 24% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 11% · PUBLIC REAL ESTATE 10% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 9%
1178
APR 12, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - April 12, 2022

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a hybrid meeting on April 12, 2022, at City Hall. Commissioners present: President Moran, Commissioner Maxwell, Commissioner Paulson; Vice President Ajami was excused. The meeting covered drought conditions, financial reports, infrastructure projects, renewable energy procurement, and land disposition. The commission approved consent calendar items, contract amendments, bond refinancings, and participation in a long-duration energy storage project. Consent Calendar - Item 9a: Awarded Job Order Contract No. JOC-85R for general engineering construction in San Joaquin, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne Counties and at Hetch Hetchy for two years. - Item 9b: Approved Amendment No. 1 to contracts with Siemens Industry Inc. and Utilicast, LLC, extending each by one year (total six years) with no cost change. - Item 9c: Accepted work by Ronan Construction for Millbrae Warehouse Loading Dock Repair; approved Modification No. 1 decreasing contract by $74,787. - Item 9d: Accepted work by Azul Works Inc. for Ocean Beach Coastal Erosion and Wastewater Infrastructure Protection; approved Modification No. 1 decreasing contract by $1,252,932. - Item 9e: Approved a 106-day increase to contract duration contingency for Various Locations Sewer Replacement No. 8 with Precision Engineering, Inc. All consent items were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Nate Rangell (California Outdoors) expressed support for working with the commission on hydro operations and win-win scenarios. - Aliza Dupree (general public) urged the commission to improve website usability and emphasized the importance of electricity education and CleanPowerSF. - Dave Warner (Palo Alto) criticized the use of a 49% rationing figure in the Urban Water Management Plan, arguing it overstated risk and was based on outdated assumptions. He urged the commission to avoid referencing that figure. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) criticized staff for not addressing the design drought, population projections, and environmental metrics despite prior commissioner requests. He claimed staff denied a Sunshine Ordinance request by citing attorney-client privilege. - Jerry Merrill (former deputy secretary, California Natural Resources Agency) requested that staff consider a flow release schedule similar to the South Fork American River and negotiate a permanent solution for whitewater releases. - Teresa Larrejo Simpson (American Whitewater) thanked the commission for past cooperation but noted that changing energy markets (duck curve) are impacting whitewater releases; she urged long-term solutions. - Anonymous caller (lower Tuolumne River) accused the commission of being subservient to irrigation districts and failing to protect trout and salmon populations, citing ongoing legal battles over water quality certification. Discussion Items - Drought Conditions Update (7a): Steve Richie reported reservoir storage at Hetch Hetchy was 300,000 acre-feet (increased to 310,000 due to runoff). System-wide demand dropped to 181 MGD in late March but jumped to 198 MGD in early April, indicating outdoor water use. The commission discussed the governor's executive order requiring Level 2 shortage actions (up to 20% reduction) and a ban on non-functional turf irrigation. Staff noted San Francisco's residential use is 42 gpcd, well below state average. The commission expressed concern about demand increases. - Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (7b): Nancy Hall presented the FY2020-21 reports, which received an unmodified opinion from KPMG and GFOA awards. The report theme was "Respond, Recover, and Reimagine." The SFPUC is the only city department that issues both reports. - Upper Islais Creek Watershed Plan Update (7c): Sarah Minnick and Steve Robinson presented a multi-benefit approach to flood management in the Alemany Corridor. The project envisions soaking up stormwater via green infrastructure, storing it, and protecting downstream areas. Cost estimate: $289 million. Community outreach included door-to-door surveys in four languages. A parallel pipe tunnel project is at 10% design. The commission will decide on a preferred alternative later in 2022. - Mountain Tunnel Improvements Contract Amendment (10): Randy Anderson and Joseph Vitrago requested approval to increase the contract by $7.78 million (total $28.78 million) and extend by three years for engineering support during construction. The project includes a new flow control facility, tunnel rehabilitation, and road improvements. The tunnel is 90 years old and critical to the regional water system. The amendment was approved unanimously. - Westside Recycled Water Pump Station Contingency Increase (11): Barbara Palacios requested a $500,000 increase in cost contingency and 300 additional calendar days for the pump station and reservoir in Golden Gate Park. Delays were due to pandemic impacts, supply chain issues, and PG&E power service problems. The project will produce 1.6 MGD of recycled water. The amendment was approved unanimously. - CleanPowerSF Long-Duration Storage Project (12): Michael Himes presented the Goal Line Project agreements with Onward Energy for a 50 MW/400 MWh lithium-ion battery near Escondido. The project will provide 17.1 MW of qualifying capacity, meeting CPUC requirements. The total cost over 20 years is not to exceed $60 million (note: agenda summary incorrectly stated $45 million). The project uses prevailing wage and a project labor agreement. The commission approved the agreements unanimously. - Surplus Land Declaration (13): Michael Carlin presented the sale of 10,925 sq ft of property in Sunnyvale to Santa Clara Valley Water District for $33,000. The land is exempt from the Surplus Lands Act. Approved unanimously. - Bond Refinancings (14 & 15): Charles Pearl presented two refinancing proposals: up to $950 million in water revenue bonds (taxable advanced refunding) and up to $475 million in wastewater refunding bonds (tax-exempt and taxable). The water refinancing aims for at least $23 million in savings (3% threshold), but current interest rate increases may delay execution. The wastewater refinancing targets $32 million in savings. The commission approved both authorizations separately. Key Outcomes - Votes: All items passed unanimously (3-0) with Vice President Ajami excused. - Directives: Staff was directed to continue drought messaging and evaluate the governor's executive order. The commission will consider a tour of the Mountain Tunnel project during outage 2. - Next Steps: Staff will seek Board of Supervisors approval for the Mountain Tunnel amendment, CleanPowerSF agreements, and bond issuances. The water bond refinancing will be executed only if interest rates allow at least 3% savings. - Closed Session: The commission asserted attorney-client privilege and went into closed session. After returning, they reported recommending settlement of the USDA Forest Service claim (unlitigated) to the Board of Supervisors and voted not to disclose further discussions.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 30% · PROCEDURAL 24% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9% · PENDING LITIGATION 9%
1179
APR 7, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - April 7, 2022

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 7, 2022, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Rafael Mandelman present. The committee considered two items: an ordinance to codify the Shelter Grievance Policy and a resolution authorizing the mayor to vote in favor of forming the Excelsior Community Benefit District. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Shelter Grievance Policy): Numerous members of the public testified in support, including Paul Bowden (Western Regional Advocacy Project), Ian James (Coalition on Homelessness), Bishop Jorge Garcia (spiritual leader), Tyler Kaiser (Coalition on Homelessness), Jennifer Friedenbach (Coalition on Homelessness), Toro Costano (human rights intern), Christopher (formerly homeless), Ben Bakowski and Uballo Campos Spinoza (shelter client advocates), Tyler Rougeau (resident), Marisela Anaya (mother of three, via interpreter), Jordan Davis, Terry Bora (Shelter Grievance Advisory Committee chair), Aliana Binder (Glyde), Anoxal Rama (HomeRise), Alejandro Nunio (Division Circle Navigation Center), Kristen Evans (volunteer), Elizabeth (via interpreter), Leon Ting Collins (case manager), Rhode Kill Johnson (formerly homeless advocate), Megan Fallon (Five Keys Schools), Yosenia (Lawrence Street Community Services), Seneza Revelow (formerly homeless), and Mari McKeever (public interest attorney). All urged codification, noting the policy’s 30-year success, the need for due process, and negative consequences when suspended during the pandemic. No speakers opposed. - Item 2 (Excelsior Community Benefit District): No public comments. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Administrative Code – Shelter Grievance Advisory Committee and Shelter Grievance Policy (File 220090): President Shamann Walton introduced the ordinance to codify the shelter grievance policy, which has existed since 1992 but was never in the municipal code. The policy provides a two-stage appeals process for shelter clients facing denial of service, helping prevent exits to the street. Walton emphasized that due process must not be suspended, even during emergencies. Supervisor Mandelman expressed concerns that codification could hinder rapid shelter expansion and that the policy might need suspension in future emergencies; he voted no. Chair Preston and Vice Chair Chan strongly supported the ordinance, arguing that regulation and due process do not impede service delivery and that transparency is essential. The motion passed 2–1. - Item 2 – Resolution – Excelsior Community Benefit District (File 220303): Bill Barnes from Supervisor Safai’s office explained that the resolution authorizes the mayor to sign petitions supporting formation of the Excelsior Community Benefit District, which would allow property owners to assess themselves for improvements. Three city-owned parcels (library, former DPH site) would be assessed about $7,000 annually. Chris Corgus from OEWD answered technical questions. The committee approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved by the committee with a 2–1 vote (Preston and Chan in favor, Mandelman opposed). The ordinance will be forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: Approved unanimously by the committee. The resolution will be forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation.

PUBLIC COMMENT 45% · HOMELESSNESS 42% · PROCEDURAL 7% · BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICTS 5%
1180
APR 6, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – April 6, 2022

This regular meeting of the San Francisco Police Commission was held on the evening of April 6, 2022, with Acting President Elias presiding. Commissioners Byrne, Carter-Oberstone, Yannis, Yi, and Hamasaki (joined later) were present. The meeting included public comment, reports from the Chief of Police and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), a quarterly presentation from the Internal Affairs Division, a discussion of the Crime Lab quality assurance database, and closed session items. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the meetings of February 2, 9, 16, and March 2, 9, 16, 2022. - A motion to accept a $50 gift card donation to the Cooperative Restraining Order Clinic was approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Mary Bow (mother of a homicide victim) spoke about the lack of communication from SFPD regarding her son's unsolved murder from 15 years ago. She requested a point of contact and updates. Chief Scott stated he had spoken with her and that the case was being reviewed. Commissioner Byrne requested that the matter be agendized for a three-month update. - Savan Bucksman, David Aronson, Jean Bridges, and another caller, all representing the organization "Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community," read statements from founder Felicia Jones. They condemned SFPD's ongoing racial disparities as shown in the department's own quarterly data: Black San Franciscans are 6 times more likely to be subject to a traffic stop, 10.5 times more likely to be arrested, and nearly 16 times more likely to experience use of force compared to white San Franciscans. They criticized the Hillard Heintze DOJ reform report as overly optimistic and failing to address systemic racism. They urged the commission to take urgent action. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report: Chief William Scott reported that while shootings are down double-digit percentages year-to-date, three homicides occurred in the past week, including a quadruple shooting at Alice Trauma Playground that left two dead. He described strategies including increased intervention efforts (22 interventions year-to-date compared to 11 all of last year), partnership with California Partnerships for a $6 million violence intervention grant, and deployment adjustments. He noted 64 ghost guns confiscated this year. Commissioner Burns raised concerns about evening conditions in the Tenderloin, and the Chief acknowledged inconsistent foot patrols due to deployment challenges. Commissioner Yi asked about summer violence prevention; the Chief outlined youth programming and targeted enforcement. - DPA Director’s Report: Acting Director Sarah Hawkins presented monthly statistics for January and February 2022. In January, 54 cases were received (37% involved officer behavior/language; 30% failure to take required action). In February, 49 cases were received (22% failure to take required action). She announced the start of a DGO 810 audit for 2021 and the launch of a civic bridge program for online complaint tracking. Outreach to the LGBTQ+ community was also highlighted. - Commission Reports: Commissioner Carter-Oberstone reported progress on a policy to address racial disparities in stop and search data, aiming for a public presentation at the first meeting in May. Commissioner Yannis requested that a conversation about policing disparities and community response be agendized for April 20. Commissioner Byrne requested an update on homicide victim services and protocols. The commission also discussed agendizing an update on the California Partnership for Safe Communities (CPE) interventions. - Internal Affairs Division Quarterly Report (Q3 & Q4 2021): Commander Paul Yep presented a detailed data-driven report. Key findings: In Q3 2021, 109 cases were opened, 15 closed within the quarter; 111 cases were closed in total. The most common allegation was neglect of duty (65 cases). In Q4 2021, 262 cases were opened (largely due to vaccination mandate enforcement), 5 closed in the quarter. Disciplinary outcomes included suspensions, admonishments, retirements, and resignations. Commissioner Yannis questioned the high number of "insufficient evidence" findings; Commander Yep explained that many cases involve uncooperative complainants or lack of evidence. Commissioner Yannis requested a comparative analysis of cases that IAD did not substantiate but DPA later substantiated, to identify process gaps. - Crime Lab Quality Assurance Database: A presentation on the database used to monitor potential contamination. The lab now only tracks evidence samples for 60 days (no reference samples), and matches are only reported through CODIS. Commander Yep noted that pending state and local legislation may require changes, which the department will follow. Key Outcomes - The commission voted unanimously to adopt the minutes and approve the consent calendar. - The commission voted unanimously to go into closed session (Item 10) and later voted unanimously not to disclose any discussion from closed session (Item 12). - Agendized items for future meetings: - Update on SFPD’s protocols for communicating with homicide victim families (in three months). - Update on the California Partnership for Safe Communities (CPE) interventions. - Conversation on policing disparities and community response (targeted for April 20, 2022). - Presentation of a policy to address racial disparities in stop and search data (first meeting in May 2022). - The commission directed the Chief to provide a breakdown of Internal Affairs cases by source (officer-initiated vs. public complaints) to better explain insufficient evidence findings.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 22% · PUBLIC EDUCATION 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · PROCEDURAL 10%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com