Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1161–1170 ENTRIES
1161
MAY 11, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting, May 11, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission held a regular meeting on May 11, 2022, at 5:45 PM UTC, to discuss crime trends, department morale, and a proposed policy to end pretext stops. The meeting included public comment, reports from the Chief of Police and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), and presentations on electronic communication device audits, the Early Intervention System (EIS), the Green Pin Campaign, and the Firearm Discharge Review Board (FDRB). Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved the SFPD DPA document protocol quarterly report (Q1 2022) and the Limited English Proficiency annual report 2021. Public Comments & Testimony - Susan Buckman (Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community) quoted Felicia Jones, accusing the commission of anti-blackness and lack of urgency regarding use of force, arrests, and racial profiling. - Jean Bridges (Wealth and Disparities) cited SFPD data: Black San Franciscans are 6 times more likely to be stopped, more than 10 times more likely to be arrested, and nearly 16 times more likely to experience use of force compared to white residents. She demanded an end to routine traffic stops. - Francisco de Costa urged more police to address quality-of-life issues and drugs, and later suggested training volunteers to reduce police calls. - Wesley Savers (Glide) and Eliana Bender (Glide) supported the draft DGO 9.01 to end pretext stops, representing the coalition to end bias stops (over 60 organizations). - Clara Mobley (SF Bicycle Coalition) asked for a more comprehensive list of pretext violations. - Ken Say (League of Women Voters) expressed concern that working groups have been used for delay and intimidation. - Carolyn Gusin, Zach Dillon, Angela Chan (Public Defender's Office) and others supported a strong policy, citing 27,000 stops in 2021. - Kit Hodge (Wealth and Disparities) credited Felicia Jones for years of advocacy and demanded meaningful consequences for biased stops. - Eric Arguello (Glide), Danielle Harris (public defender), Brian Cox (Public Defender), Lindsay Chung (SF Bicycle Coalition), David Aronson (Wealth and Disparities), and Tess Wellborn (resident) spoke in favor of ending pretext stops. - Brian Hogsman (Walk SF) argued that low-level stops do not address traffic safety, which is primarily caused by speeding and failure to yield. - An anonymous caller (likely representing the Police Officers Association) opposed the policy, claiming it was not based on data and attacking Commissioner Overstone. - Susan Uffman dismissed the anonymous caller’s attacks and encouraged the commission to proceed. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report: Chief William Scott reported that homicides are up 15% year-to-date (13 vs. 15), gun violence is down 12%, and property crimes (especially larceny) are up 25%. He detailed shootings, arrests, ghost gun seizures (344 in 2022), and a carjacking ring. He also updated on a $6 million state grant for gun violence reduction and ongoing MOU mediation with the District Attorney’s office. - DPA Director’s Report: Paul Henderson reported 236 open cases, 21 sustained, 32 cases beyond 9 months (22 tolled). He noted a drop in use-of-force allegations at Central Station and a new annual report forthcoming. - Commission Reports: - Commissioner Giannis described a five-day “Sojourn” trip to civil rights sites in the South, calling it a valuable step toward reconciliation and urging continued investment. - Commissioner Byrne reported a night beat in the Tenderloin, observing open drug dealing and noting only 12 officers on duty; he requested more resources. - Commissioner Benedicto spoke at a press conference by the coalition to end bias stops, expressing excitement for the DGO 9.01 process. - DGO 9.01 – Pretext Stops: Commissioner Carter Overstone introduced the draft policy, which bans stops for 15 low-level offenses and limits consent searches and investigatory questions. The policy aims to reduce racial disparities and free up resources for serious crime. Chief Scott and DPA staff voiced strong support. The commission opened a 30-day public comment period (through June 11, 2022), with plans for working groups and community listening sessions. - Audit of Electronic Communication Devices (Q1 2022): Commander Paul Yap reported that of 52 CLETS hits, 412 email hits, and 50 text hits, only one email was flagged as potentially biased (but was a quote from a meeting). Commissioners asked for historical data on bias-related discipline. - Early Intervention System (Q3 2021): Commander Yap presented data: 71 alerts, 37 members with one alert, 11 with two, 4 with three. Mission Station had the most alerts (18). Only one performance improvement plan was initiated. Commissioners questioned the one-year reporting lag and the system’s effectiveness. Sergeant Naval explained that alerts measure activity, not necessarily misconduct, and that supervisors use discretion. - Green Pin Campaign: The commission approved a temporary modification of DGO 10.01 to allow officers to wear green pins during May 2022 for Mental Health Awareness Month. - Firearm Discharge Review Board (Q4 2021): Deputy Chief Robert O’Sullivan summarized three officer-involved shootings (one in 2018, two in 2020) and two accidental discharges. All three shootings were deemed within policy, though tactical issues were noted in one. The two discharges were out of policy. Commissioners discussed why administrative investigations remain pending in some cases due to ongoing criminal investigations. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar approved unanimously. - DGO 9.01 introduced; public comment open until June 11, 2022; working groups and listening sessions to follow. - Green pin campaign approved unanimously. - FDRB findings: two officer-involved discharges (OID) out of policy, three officer-involved shootings (OIS) within policy, with recommendations for tactical improvements. - Commission directed staff to provide data on the number of bias-related investigations resulting in discipline and to improve the timeliness of EIS reports. - The commission will revisit the MOU with the District Attorney’s office at a future meeting.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 68% · PUBLIC SAFETY 10% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7% · PROCEDURAL 4%
1162
MAY 10, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - May 10, 2022

The San Francisco Port Commission convened on Tuesday, May 10, 2022, at 10:30 AM. The meeting included a land acknowledgement, approval of minutes, an executive director's report on racial equity, a commendation for outgoing Commissioner Doreen Wuho, election of a new Vice President, approval of a consent calendar, and authorization of an Islais Creek interpretive program. Public comment was heard on several items. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2224: Aligning the port executive director’s delegated authority with the administrative code. - Resolution 2225: Authorizing a request for qualifications for as-needed engineering and related services (contracts up to $4 million each, five-year term) and creating a pre-qualified pool for two years. - Resolution 2226: Adopting findings under new state urgency legislation to allow remote meeting attendance during the COVID-19 emergency for 30 days, with a directive to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. All three resolutions were approved unanimously (voice vote). Public Comments & Testimony - On Items Not Listed on the Agenda: Alex Sobel, representing the grassroots group Grand Embarcadero, expressed full support for a car-free Embarcadero, describing it as safer, greener, and more resilient. He stated that the current roadway dedicates more than half of the space to cars, the bike lane is not protected, and a car diet would improve sustainability and resilience. He urged the commission to embrace the idea. - On Executive Director’s Report & Commissioner Wuho’s Farewell: Multiple speakers—including Jack Bear (representing the San Francisco Giants and Mission Rock Project), Diane Oshima (former port staff), Mike (port staff), and Katie Petruccioni (port CFO)—offered public comment expressing gratitude for Commissioner Wuho’s 11 years of service. They highlighted her strategic thinking, financial expertise, and dedication to affordable housing (e.g., 88 Broadway, Mission Rock with 40% affordability) and resilience efforts (Proposition A in 2018). Jack Bear noted her role in a late-night negotiation that increased Mission Rock affordability to 40%. - On Item 11A (Islais Creek Interpretive Program): Oscar James (Bayview native resident) expressed strong support for the project, emphasizing the importance of telling the Ohlone story and labor history. Derek Green (Archie Green Fund for Labor Culture and History) and Harvey Schwartz (ILWU and Copra Crane Labor Landmark Association) both spoke in favor, praising the inclusive community process and the design. Schwartz called the program “beautiful” and urged adoption of Resolution 2227. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report – Racial Equity Action Plan (REAP) Update: Executive Director Elaine Forbes and DEI Manager Tony Autry presented the 2022 REAP progress report. Key points: - Since publishing the plan in December 2020, the port has made progress on all goals, including: creating a diversity calendar, applying racial equity lens to policies (e.g., COVID vaccine mandate), and establishing a relationship with the Office of Racial Equity (ORE) via an infrastructure cohort. - In 2021, 20 of 30 selected REAP actions were completed. For 2022, the port used a collaborative division-based process to select 5–8 goals per division, focusing on equitable discipline, HR practices, and external partnerships (e.g., community benefit agreements for BIPOC tenants). - Goals include: a mentorship program for BIPOC staff, hiring 10 interns annually from under-resourced neighborhoods, and exceeding the mayor’s goal of 40% contracts to LBE firms. - Commissioners commended the effort, with Vice President Wuho noting the port is leading citywide. Commissioner Burton suggested sharing best practices with other city agencies. - Election of Port Commission Vice President: Commissioner Kimberly Brandon was nominated by Commissioner Gilman and elected unanimously (voice vote). She expressed gratitude and commitment to continuing the port’s work. - Islais Creek Interpretive Program (Item 11A): David Beaufray (Planning & Environment) presented the program, which uses $70,000 from California Coastal Conservancy and a $35,000 gift from Archie Green Fund, plus existing funds ($625,281 total). The program will install interpretive exhibits at three sites along Islais Creek, covering labor history, ecology, resilience, and Ohlone stories. The design includes perforated panels with hidden messages (e.g., “Bayview,” “We are still here”). Completion is expected by September 2023. Commissioners expressed enthusiastic support, with Commissioner Gilman urging use of resilient materials. - New Business: Commissioner Gilman requested that future MOUs with other city departments include equity goals and actions. No formal vote was taken, but the request was noted. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar Approved: Resolutions 2224, 2225, and 2226 passed unanimously. - Islais Creek Interpretive Program Authorized: Resolution 2227 passed unanimously, accepting the grants and awarding the design contract. - Kimberly Brandon Elected Vice President: Unanimous voice vote. - Acknowledgment of Commissioner Wuho’s Service: The commission adopted a proclamation from Mayor London Breed declaring May 10, 2022 as “Doreen Wuho Day” in San Francisco. Commissioner Wuho delivered farewell remarks summarizing her 11-year tenure. - Staff Commendation: President Willie Adams praised staff for their work.

PROCEDURAL 24% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 15% · RACIAL AND SOCIAL EQUITY 13%
1163
MAY 10, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - May 10, 2022

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a hybrid meeting on May 10, 2022, to discuss drought conditions, approve consent calendar items, and adopt wholesale water rates for fiscal year 2022-2023. The meeting included updates on reservoir storage, a plan for ecological releases from Hetch Hetchy Reservoir, and a 15.9% wholesale water rate increase. Several public comments addressed water management, the Tuolumne River, and utility accountability. Consent Calendar - Items 9a, 9b, 9c, 9f, 9g: Approved unanimously (3-0) after items 9d and 9e were removed for separate discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Three callers spoke. One criticized the transfer of AWAS (Administrative Water and Sewer) from PUC to the City Administrator, alleging it was used for budget balancing and inconsistent with Prop 218. A second speaker (Jeff Pentorino) shared personal experiences kayaking the Tuolumne River and urged balanced water management. A third (Peter Drekmeier, Tuolumne River Trust) requested a timeline for improving flows on the Tuolumne River, noting no progress since workshops. A fourth speaker alleged corruption and lack of outreach on a $400 million facility. Alita Dupree praised CleanPowerSF’s renewable content (54.5%) and asked for further increases. - Comment on Drought Update (Item 7a): Peter Drekmeier expressed support for the pulse release to fill Pumaut Valley Pond but criticized SFPUC’s opposition to functional flows below Don Pedro Dam, stating the lower Tuolumne River received only 14% of unimpaired flow over two years, endangering salmon. Another caller accused the commission of “greedy evil ways” and called for saving salmon. Alita Dupree asked SFPUC to ensure basic water needs for San Francisco residents. - Comment on Wholesale Water Rates (Item 10): Peter Drekmeier noted that the Bosca rates are expected to rise 15% next year, causing 3% demand decline, and alleged SFPUC presented different demand projections to different audiences. Nicole St. Kulabovka (CEO of a customer group) voiced support for the rate increase, stating it complies with the Water Supply Agreement. Discussion Items - Drought Conditions Update (Item 7a): Steve Ritchie (Assistant GM for Water) reported that Hetch Hetchy Reservoir stood at 332,000 acre-feet (rising to 350,000) and would soon spill due to April storms and snowmelt. He explained a planned pulse release of up to 4,100 cubic feet per second to flood Pumaut Valley for ecological benefits (endangered foothill yellow-legged frog, native trout, bats). The release mimics natural hydrology and is part of the Upper Tuolumne River Ecosystem Program. He noted that last year’s storage was lower due to dry conditions, while this year’s cool weather preserved snowpack. Commissioner Maxwell asked about long-term monitoring; Ritchie confirmed ongoing work with the National Park Service. Commissioner Paulson praised the presentation. - Item 9d – SFUSD Work-Based Learning Grant: Commissioner Maxwell questioned the $6,000 amount and scope. General Manager Herrera explained it supports two youth for summer stipends at the SFPUC learning garden, part of the Mayor’s Youth Jobs+ program. Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 9e – Consultant Selection for Water Enterprise Services: Commissioner Maxwell raised concerns about the evaluation points (895 written, 100 overhead/profit, 5 diversity) and a staff statement about a “separate panel” of diversity experts. Kendra Cox clarified it was a pass/fail evaluation, not a panel, and called the agenda language an error. Maxwell expressed disappointment, stating the 5-point allocation seemed insignificant. She moved to pull the item. The item was pulled for revision. - Wholesale Water Rates for FY2022-2023 (Item 10): Aaron Franks (Rates Admin) proposed a 15.9% increase, raising the rate from $4.10 to $4.75 per hundred cubic feet (CCF). Drivers included a $44 million drawdown of the $87 million balancing account (owed to wholesale customers), reduced water sales due to drought (forecast 113.7 million gallons per day), and increased debt service and O&M costs. The untreated water discount rate for Coastside County Water District also rose to $0.43/CCF. Commissioner Paulson noted the large increase after five years of flat rates. Maxwell asked about smoothing future volatility. Franks explained the increase was driven by drought-induced lower volumes; wholesale customers were consulted. Approved unanimously (3-0). Key Outcomes - Adopted renewed findings for hybrid meetings under COVID-19 urgency legislation (Item 3) – passed 3-0. - Approved minutes of April 26, 2022 (Item 4) – passed 3-0. - Consent Calendar (less items 9d and 9e) – passed 3-0. - Approved SFUSD Work-Based Learning Grant (Item 9d) – passed 3-0. - Pulled Item 9e (consultant selection) for revision due to inaccurate description of diversity evaluation process; will be re-agendized. - Adopted wholesale water rates for FY2022-2023 (Item 10) – passed 3-0, effective July 1, 2022. - Staff will revise Item 9e to clarify the diversity evaluation criteria and correct the agenda language.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 41% · PUBLIC COMMENT 27% · PROCEDURAL 16% · PROCUREMENT 11%
1164
MAY 5, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
May 5, 2022 Regular Meeting of the Government Audit and Oversight Committee, San Francisco Board of Supervisors

Historical Property Contract (Item 1) Supervisor Peskin recused himself due to proximity to the property (714 Steiner Street) but later acted as voting member after motion. The resolution approved a historical property contract (Mills Act) with a 20-year term and tax savings over $500,000 to recoup public investment. The committee previously amended the item on April 21. With no public comment, the committee voted unanimously to forward the resolution to the full board with positive recommendation. Community Benefit District Annual Reports (Items 2–5) The committee heard presentations on annual reports for the East Cut (FY 2019-20), Central Market (CY 2019-20), North of Market Tenderloin (FY 2018-19 and 2019-20), and Civic Center (CY 2020) Community Benefit Districts. OEWD reported that all four CBDs met their benchmarks. The North of Market Tenderloin CBD had delayed reporting due to bookkeeping changes exacerbated by the pandemic but had since addressed issues. Each director highlighted pandemic response services (e.g., sanitizing, meal delivery by East Cut, encampment cleanup by Mid-Market). One public commenter called in but did not speak. The committee voted unanimously to send the resolutions to the full board with positive recommendation. Hearing on Taxpayer-Funded Communications and Policing (Item 6) Chair Preston opened the hearing citing concerns about orchestrated narratives favoring increased police funding. Presentations: - Mayor’s Office (Tom Paulino): Described coordination with public safety departments, a $1.3M communications budget (8 staff), and no written policies or external PR contracts. One-third of press releases mentioning SFPD called for more staffing; another third touted police reform. No press release acknowledged racial disparities. - SFPD (Assistant Chief Bob Moser): Presented the Strategic Communications & Media Relations Unit, budgeted at $1.6M (9 positions, currently 8). The unit handles 300 media emails/month, press passes, and social media. A request to add a videographer was noted. No external PR contracts except for recruitment. Policies exist for media relations but not for overall strategic communications. - Alec Karakatsanis (Civil Rights Corps): Testified nationally about “copaganda,” criticizing SFPD for focusing on certain crimes (e.g., retail theft) while ignoring wage theft, downplaying persistent racial disparities, and using reform rhetoric without substantive change. He argued the department’s claims of success are unsupported. - Discussion: Chair Preston questioned SFPD about the term “strategic communications” and the omission of disparities from press materials. Supervisor Mandelman defended the department’s reform efforts and called Karakatsanis’s testimony “gaslighting.” - Public Comment: 13 speakers; many supported the hearing and criticized police propaganda and overpolicing, calling for reallocation of funds. A few defended SFPD. Chair Preston concluded that the city’s communications shape public perception and called for transparency and policies. - Outcome: The hearing was filed (2-0, Supervisor Mandelman not voting). Hearing on City Electric Vehicle Fleet (Item 7) Called by Supervisor Myrna Melgar to assess progress on the 2017 zero-emission mandate (100% light-duty fleet by end of 2022). Presentations: - Department of Environment (Lowell Chu): Noted the worsening air pollution in the city and the need to reduce traffic emissions. - SFPUC (Catherine Spaulding): PG&E interconnection delays (requiring costly primary service equipment) are a major barrier. PUC is working on new rates and incentive programs (EV Charge SF) but faces federal regulatory challenges. - City Administrator's Office (Douglas Legg): Only 13% of light-duty sedans (about 800) are zero-emission; 65% of waivers are due to lack of charging infrastructure. Progress includes moving 64 vehicles to the 49 South Van Ness Garage and converting them to plug-in hybrids/battery EVs. A comprehensive inventory and roadmap are lacking. Telematics data will inform rightsizing. - Discussion: Supervisor Melgar urged a roadmap, interdepartmental pooling, and equity (prioritizing neighborhoods with higher pollution). Supervisor Mandelman expressed concern about falling short of the 2022 goal. - Public Comment: Four speakers (including a UC Berkeley lecturer) urged immediate action, noted available electric pickup trucks, and called for transparent planning. - Outcome: The hearing was continued to the call of the chair (unanimous). Key Actions - Approved (unanimous) forwarding of Items 1, 2-5 to the full board with positive recommendation. - Filed Item 6 (hearing on communications) on a 2-0 vote. - Continued Item 7 (hearing on EV fleet) to the call of the chair.

PUBLIC SAFETY 27% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 22% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · ELECTRIC VEHICLES 12%
1165
MAY 4, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Meeting: Budget Analysis, Prop I Housing, and HIV/AIDS Funding - May 4, 2022

The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, chaired by Supervisor Hilary Ronan, met on May 4, 2022, to hold three hearings: a review of historical city budgets and actual expenditures, recommendations from the Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board for the use of Proposition I revenue in fiscal year 2022–2023, and a report on federal HIV/AIDS funding and city investments. The committee discussed vacancy rates, salary savings, affordable housing strategies, and HIV prevention and care funding. Public Comments & Testimony - During the budget hearing, David Pilpel spoke in support of realistic position counts in department budgets with less attrition savings. - A caller commended Supervisor Ronan for fiscal prudence and requested a retroactive analysis of how unspent dollars from vacant positions were spent. - On the Prop I hearing, over a dozen members of the public and representatives from labor, tenant, senior, and disability organizations testified in strong support of the Oversight Board's recommendations, emphasizing the need for social housing, educator housing, SRO elevator repairs, and deeply affordable housing for seniors and people with disabilities. - During the HIV/AIDS hearing, many long-term survivors and advocates spoke passionately about the need to maintain funding for care, housing subsidies, mental health services, and to avoid destabilizing the current safety net through funding shifts. Discussion Items - Item 1: Hearing on Historical Budgets vs. Actual Expenditures - Dan Goncher of the Budget Legislative Analyst (BLA) presented findings showing general fund actual revenues were $5.7 billion in FY2020-21 (3% decrease from FY2018-19), while actual expenditures were $5 billion (19% increase). General fund actual expenditures were below budget by an average of 3% over the three fiscal years reviewed. Salary savings citywide were $22 million in FY2020-21. The report included three policy options: requesting the controller to report annually on year-end variances, asking for more information on use of two reserve funds (Federal/State Emergency Grant Disallowance Reserve and Fiscal Cliff Reserve), and requesting departments to report on projected vacancy savings during budget hearings. Committee members expressed frustration over high vacancy rates and the practice of using unfilled positions as a funding source, with Chair Ronan stating she would require detailed vacancy justifications. - Item 2: Hearing on Recommendations of the Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board - Supervisor Dean Preston introduced the item, noting Prop I passed in November 2020 and is projected to raise $170 million annually. The Oversight Board recommended allocating the available $136 million for FY2022-23 into several buckets: $60 million for land acquisition (geographic equity, educator housing), $12 million for educator housing construction, $15 million for non-tax credit construction, $15 million for accessibility upgrades in co-ops and public housing, $10 million for elevator/accessibility in residential hotels, $11.5 million for preservation, $0.5 million for organizational sustainability, $3 million for city staffing/feasibility of a municipal housing agency, and $6 million for innovation (e.g., land trusts). Community members and labor representatives spoke in favor, emphasizing workforce housing needs and the voter mandate. - Item 3: Hearing on Federal HIV/AIDS Funding and Investments - Bill Bloom (Director of HIV Health Services) and Tracy Packer (Director of Community Health Education Promotion) presented. Federal HIV care funding has been reduced by 60% over 20 years, to just over $15 million currently. The city has backfilled cuts with general fund, but prevention funding (CDC) was cut significantly in 2018, also backfilled. DPH is shifting to a "Health Access Points" (HAP) model to address persistent disparities among Black/African American and Latinx populations, people who inject drugs, and others. Chair Ronan and Supervisor Walton raised questions about equity and service gaps. Public commenters urged continued backfill of federal cuts and highlighted the needs of long-term survivors, including housing subsidies and mental health support. Key Outcomes - Item 1 was filed unanimously on a 5-0 vote (Supervisors Safai, Maher, Chan, Walton, Ronan all aye). - Item 2 was continued to the call of the chair on a 4-1 vote (Supervisors Ronan, Maher, Chan, Walton aye; Supervisor Safai absent; the motion passed 4-0 with Safai absent). - Item 3 was filed on a 4-1 vote (Supervisors Ronan, Safai, Chan, Walton aye; Supervisor Maher absent; the motion passed 4-0).

BUDGET AND FINANCE 25% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · PUBLIC HEALTH 15%
1166
MAY 4, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Regular Meeting - May 4, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission held a regular meeting on Wednesday, May 4, 2022, beginning at approximately 5:45 PM. The meeting included public comment, adoption of minutes, a chief's report on crime trends, a DPA director's report, commission reports, and a presentation of the first quarter 2022 Sparks report on policy proposals. The commission also voted on a closed session item and elected not to disclose discussions from that session. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Minutes for April 6, 13, and 20, 2022: The minutes were adopted on a 4-1 vote, with Commissioner Benedicto voting no. Public Comments & Testimony - Francisco De Costa: Expressed concern about the police force reduction from 2000 to 1100 officers, stating quality of life issues cannot be addressed without a full force. - David Aronson (Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community): Quoting founder Felicia Jones, condemned anti-blackness in SFPD use of force, arrests, and traffic stops. Stated that black San Franciscans are six times as likely as white to be subject to a traffic stop, and called for elimination of low-level stops. - Susan Buffman (Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community): Repeated similar statistics, citing cities like Berkeley that have reduced disparities by ending low-level stops. - Kate Hodge (Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community): Quoted Felicia Jones, emphasized that black San Franciscans are six times as likely to be stopped, more than 10 times as likely to be arrested, and 16 times as likely to experience use of force. Demanded an end to racial profiling in traffic stops. - Ms. Brown: Requested justice for her son Aubrey Abacaso, murdered August 14, 2006; case remains unsolved. - Jessica Jenkins: Reported a friend on a bicycle was ticketed by a traffic motorcycle officer, citing unequal enforcement against cyclists while dangerous driving goes unaddressed. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Assistant Chief Mosier): - Part one crimes up 10% year-over-year; violent crimes up 4%; property crimes up 11%. - Burglaries decreased 30%; larceny (including auto break-ins) increased 23%. - Homicides up 25% (no homicides in the past week); gun violence down 12%; non-fatal shootings down 18%. - Reported three recent shootings (May 1, April 29 twice) with no arrests yet. - Responses to demonstrations following leaked Supreme Court draft on Roe v. Wade: two peaceful gatherings (approximately 1500 participants total). - Salesforce Tower climber incident: subject climbed to 64th floor, taken into custody, cited for trespassing. - Arson barricaded subject on Larkin Street: subject set mattress on fire, armed with knife, eventually taken safely into custody. - Three stunt driving events over the weekend involving large crowds. - Fatal hit-and-run collision on May 1 near Turk and Taylor. - DPA Director's Report (Executive Director Henderson): - 221 cases opened in 2022; 203 closed; 293 open; 16 sustained; 6 mediated. - 29 cases beyond 9 months (25 tolled due to civil/criminal cases). - Past two weeks: 27 new cases; top allegations: officer behaving badly/inappropriate speech (43%) and failure to write incident report (11%). - Top districts for allegations: Central (9) and Tenderloin. - Ongoing audit of SFPD misconduct handling; survey sent to current/former commissioners. - Monthly statistical report available online. - Commission Reports: - Commissioner Yi recognized May as Asian Heritage Month and Mental Health Awareness Month for officers. - Commissioner Benedicto expressed interest in working on pretext stops and advancing the search warrant DGO. - Commissioner Carter Oberstone reported weekly meetings with DPA and department on pretext stop DGO, which is on the agenda for next week. - Vice President Elias requested that internal affairs cases begin tracking race and gender of officers subject to discipline, and asked for additional correlations (e.g., case volume, sustains). - Sparks Report (First Quarter 2022): - Presented by SFPD's Director of Policy (name not given) and DPA's Janelle Kaywood. - Summary of pending and adopted policies: DGO 5.01 (adopted and in effect), DGO 6.09 (adopted, effective July 12), DGO 3.01 (pending), DGO 9.01 traffic enforcement (in discussions). - New policies: disengagement policy and directed referrals to Behavioral Sciences Unit (under discussion). - Department bulletins: one expired (juvenile interrogations) – reissued as a department notice on May 2 after discovery; lapse caused concern. - Pretext stop recommendations: prioritize stops impacting public safety; limit enforcement of minor infractions; restrict questions about unrelated criminal activity, consent searches, and probation/parole status. - New crisis intervention debriefing order implemented; first incident review planned. - DPA revived recommendations on DNA evidence procedures to ban use of victim DNA in unrelated investigations. - Discussion on the lapsed juvenile DB: Commissioners questioned how it expired unnoticed and why notification was delayed. Department acknowledged internal safeguards will be implemented. - Public Comments on Sparks Report: - Wesley Favor (GLIDE): Supported ending pretext stops, endorsed by 59 local organizations; urged a banned list of stops. - Brian Cox (Deputy Public Defender): Called for aggressive approach with no exceptions; requested data capture on any exception. - David Aronson: Supported DPA recommendations, citing racial disparities; encouraged expedited elimination of pretext stops. - Additional caller (name not given): Reported a motorcycle officer (unit 330) targeting cyclists near the car-free JSK area, requesting the officer be spoken to. Key Outcomes - Adoption of Minutes: Approved 4-1. - Closed Session: Voted unanimously (5-0) to hold item 9 in closed session. - Disclosure of Closed Session Discussions: Voted unanimously (5-0) not to disclose any discussions from the closed session. - Next Steps: - Pretext stop policy will be presented for public discussion at the next commission meeting (week of May 9). - Search warrant DGO expected to be agendized by end of May or early June. - Commission to receive a list of upcoming expiring department bulletins and notices. - Internal Affairs to provide data on race and gender of disciplined officers.

PROCEDURAL 49% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 31% · PUBLIC SAFETY 10% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9%
1167
APR 28, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
San Francisco PSNS Committee Meeting - April 28, 2022

The committee, chaired by Supervisor Gordon Maher and joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani, met on Thursday, April 28, 2022, starting at 9:00 AM (local time). Member Haney was excused. The meeting addressed two agenda items: a proposed ordinance on community policing plans and a hearing on the Emergency Firefighting Water System (EFWS) 2050 Planning Study. Item 1: Community Policing Plans (File 220240) Supervisor Maher introduced an ordinance to require SFPD to create community policing plans for each district station, incorporating foot and bike patrols and community input. He stated that amendments were not yet ready and moved to continue the item to the May 12, 2022 PSNS meeting. The motion passed unanimously (2-0). No public comment was offered. Item 2: Hearing on EFWS 2050 Planning Study (File 220108) The hearing focused on the SFPUC's recently completed planning study for expanding the city's high-pressure firefighting water system to all unprotected neighborhoods by 2034, as called for in Board Resolution 484-19. John Scarpola (SFPUC) presented the study, which outlined a conventional EFWS expansion (Option 1, $2B unescalated), a seawater-only option (Option 2, $2.7B), and a combined option (Option 3, $2.9B). The study estimated 2050 firefighting water demand at 255,000 gallons per minute (GPM), compared to the current system's 80,000 GPM. Completion timelines ranged from 2034 (requiring significant additional resources) to 2046. Phase 1 of the West Side Potable EFWS is funded and under construction. Public Comments & Testimony - Nancy Werfel (representing 67 retired firefighting experts) and Dick Morton (citywide coalition) urged rejection of the planning study, arguing it fails to meet the 2034 deadline, lacks a comprehensive plan and financing, and does not prioritize unlimited seawater. They recommended removing EFWS from SFPUC oversight, placing a standalone bond on the fall 2022 ballot, and immediately acquiring 20 hose tenders. - John Thalacky (Sunset resident) advocated for a dedicated seawater system to preserve potable water during drought and noted potential ISO rating improvements. - Jeanette (West side resident) emphasized the importance of hose tenders as an interim measure and requested more details on facilities needed to house additional apparatus. - Erica Zwike (District 4) urged grant writing for federal and state funds and suggested starting the permitting process for seawater pump stations early. Discussion Items Supervisor Maher questioned the timeline discrepancy (2034 vs. 2050) and financing. John Scarpola clarified that 2050 refers to demand projections, while 2034 is a build-out target. Brian Strong (Office of Resilience and Capital Planning) noted that the next 10-year capital plan (starting summer 2022) has only $1.2 billion available for all city bond projects, making full EFWS funding challenging. He suggested exploring federal grants, state funds, or local mechanisms like utility user taxes. Deputy Chief Tom O'Connor (SFFD) reported that three new hose tenders are under contract, with the first arriving by September 2022, and two more funded, bringing the total to 10 by mid-2024. He noted that housing 20 hose tenders would require additional fire stations. Supervisor Maher stressed the need for a financing plan and urged departments to prioritize the project. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Community Policing Plans) was continued to the May 12, 2022 PSNS meeting. - Item 2 (EFWS Hearing) was continued to the call of the chair, with Supervisor Maher committing to push for a financing plan and accelerated hose tender acquisition. - The committee heard extensive testimony and departmental updates but took no binding votes on the EFWS expansion. Next Steps The next PSNS meeting is scheduled for May 12, 2022, where the community policing ordinance will be considered with amendments. The EFWS expansion will be revisited after the capital planning process begins in summer 2022.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 30% · PUBLIC SAFETY 18% · PUBLIC WORKS 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9%
1168
APR 27, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Hearing on DPW Split and Sanitation Streets Dept Formation, April 27, 2022

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a hearing on April 27, 2022, to discuss the implementation of Proposition B, which splits the Department of Public Works (DPW) into two new departments: Public Works (PW) and the Sanitation and Streets Department (SAS). The hearing focused on financial and budgetary needs, staffing vacancies, and the impact on street cleanliness. Chair Hilary Ronen led the meeting, with Supervisors Walton, Chan, Safai, and Mar (initially absent but later present) in attendance. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were listed on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel (member of the public) expressed opposition to Proposition B, stating he opposed it in November 2020 and still does, but acknowledged the need to make it work. He raised concerns about costs and time, potential slowdowns from new commissions, and suggested that the new SAS department should have a single deputy director rather than multiple to protect civil service status. He also appreciated the staff work and looked forward to eventually reuniting the departments. Discussion Items - City Administrator Carmen Chu provided an overview of the implementation process, noting that Proposition B focused on oversight and creating two departments but did not add direct street services funding. She highlighted over 50 meetings with employees and union representatives and the submission of mandatory legislation. - Rachel Alonzo, Prop B Project Director, detailed progress: 60 steering committee and working group meetings, hiring of a commission secretary, and development of performance measures. She introduced the concept of referring to the split as a 'spin-off' rather than a 'split' to ease staff concerns. - Bruce Robertson, CFO of Public Works, presented budget submittals and organizational charts for the new departments. He noted the budget included a $6 million placeholder for additional costs and that two budgets were submitted, one mid-fiscal year, an unprecedented event. - Interim Director Carla Short discussed the rationale for keeping enforcement functions within Public Works, citing the synergy with permitting and inspection. She also addressed staffing vacancies, noting the vacancy rate was about 30% previously but now in the upper 20s. She explained that vacancies are partly due to the uncertainty of Proposition B and the 'great resignation.' - DeJada Durden, Deputy Director of Operations, provided details on staffing: there are 43 vacant general laborer positions in operations, and a daily absenteeism rate of 25%. She emphasized that even filling all positions would not meet the need. - Budget Director Ashley Groffenberger stated the mayor is weighing the department's needs against other budget priorities, and it may be difficult to fund all requested initiatives. - Supervisor Safai questioned the need for both a director and deputy director of operations, and pushed for using already budgeted vacant positions before requesting new ones. - Supervisor Ronen emphasized street cleanliness as a top priority and highlighted the need for more staff to enforce laws like the shared spaces program and street vending regulations. - Supervisor Mar asked about contract administration improvements and gave an example of a multi-departmental project (gray water line on Sunset Boulevard), which will be led by Public Works but involve SAS. Key Outcomes - The committee filed the hearing (motion passed 4-0, with Supervisor Chan excused). - Supervisor Chan was excused for the remainder of the meeting (motion passed 4-0). - The committee emphasized the need for the mayor's budget to include additional staff and resources for street cleanliness and enforcement. - Supervisor Ronen requested follow-up information from Public Works regarding Recology trash can pickup frequency and whether the city can require more frequent servicing of overflowing cans. Follow-Up Items - The mayor's office will consider the department's budget requests, which include 88 additional FTE and over $23 million in first-year costs. - Public Works will provide a written answer regarding Recology contract provisions. - The implementation timeline continues: commissions to be seated in July 2022, with full powers by September 1 (PW) and October 1 (SAS).

PUBLIC WORKS 41% · STAFFING 17% · SANITATION AND STREETS 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15%
1169
APR 26, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Regular Meeting – April 26, 2022

The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, April 26, 2022, at 10:15 a.m. The meeting included an executive session, consent calendar, engineering contract award, discussions on port-owned properties south of India Basin, public art processes and a proposed installation, a proposed lease renewal, and new business. Commissioners heard public testimony, debated equity and environmental justice concerns, and directed staff to return with actionable plans. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: The Commission unanimously approved Resolution 2222, amending the Pier 70 Special Use District design for development to clarify definitions of retail and office use without altering building bulk, height, or development capacity. The amendment was previously approved by the Planning Commission on March 3, 2022. Public Comments & Testimony - Shared Spaces Fee: A restaurant tenant opposed the Port’s proposed fee on additional tables allowed during the pandemic, calling it a “double dip” that undermines restaurants still recovering financially. The speaker urged the Commission to ensure the program is equitable. - India Basin Property & Blight: Timothy Allen Simon, a resident of the Candlestick Heights community, expressed deep concern about blight, dust, and environmental racism affecting residents, children at Bret Hart School, and Gilman Playground. He criticized the Port for allowing “abandoned and blighted” conditions while investing in other areas, and called for a “deep investigation” into the Port’s culture and indifference. Executive Director’s Report - Economic Recovery: Executive Director Elaine Forbes announced that the State Lands Commission had just approved the Port’s second tranche of $58.2 million from the American Rescue Plan Act, preventing layoffs and enabling deferred capital maintenance. She also highlighted that the Carnival Miracle will begin 20 home‑port voyages from Pier 27 on Thursday, April 28, bringing thousands of passengers and crew to the waterfront. - Equity Initiatives: The Port launched a six‑month senior‑level mentoring program for junior staff. Staff also participated in a career fair at Civic Center Plaza that attracted 1,500 attendees, largely from communities of color, to promote diverse talent pipelines. - Key Projects: Port maintenance gardeners, in partnership with tenants and 20 volunteers, celebrated Earth Day by cleaning Islais Creek, planting over 100 new plants, and laying new bark at Rincon Park and Islais Creek. Discussion Items Item 11A – Heron’s Head Shoreline Resilience Contract (Action) - Proposal: Award construction contract No. 2841 to Dixon Marine Services for $2,038,631, with a 10% contingency ($203,863), for a total authorization not to exceed $2,242,494. The project will construct a living shoreline to mitigate erosion, restore habitat, and pilot nature‑based sea‑level rise adaptation. - Outreach: The contract was advertised February 22; 12 firms attended the pre‑bid meeting, six of which were Local Business Enterprises (LBEs). The SBE/DBE goal was 20%; Dixon Marine’s team achieved 98% SBE/DBE participation, including their own self‑performed work. - Funding: The project is funded entirely by grants (San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority, Ocean Protection Council, California Department of Fish and Wildlife, National Coastal Wetlands Conservation Program, and a material donation from Martin Marietta). No Port funds are anticipated. - Schedule: Notice to proceed expected in July 2022, substantial completion by December 2022. Post‑construction monitoring will continue for up to 10 years. - Commission Action: Motion to approve, seconded, passed unanimously. Item 12A – Port‑Owned Property South of India Basin (Informational) - Overview: Chief Operating Officer Mike Martin presented maps and described four categories of Port holdings: (1) parcels slated for transfer to the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure (OCII) for Hunters Point Shipyard Phase 2/Candlestick Point; (2) parcels for the fire training facility (approved for transfer April 12); (3) properties near Yosemite Slough with environmental management issues; (4) unimproved “paper streets” not accepted for city maintenance. A 2011 resolution to transfer parcels to OCII has not been executed because the developer (Five Point) is not yet ready; the Port continues to own and manage the land. - Air Quality & Blight Concerns: New residents near Phase 1 raised complaints about dust from nearby operations. The Port’s tenant, Detail General, was found to be in compliance but is not renewing its lease in response to community concerns. Port staff have installed K‑rail barriers and coordinated with OCII, Bay Area Air Quality Management District, and the City Attorney to address illegal activities on adjacent private properties. - Yosemite Slough Contamination: Sustainability Manager Rich Berman explained that PCBs, lead, and other contaminants from a former drum‑refurbishing company (Bay Area Drum) have polluted sediments. EPA is leading a Superfund cleanup; the City (SFPUC is lead) has been conducting studies. Cleanup is expected to begin in 2023 or 2024. The Port recently investigated its stormwater lines and found no additional contamination pathways. - Commissioner Response: All commissioners expressed deep concern about environmental racism and neglect. Commissioner Brandon called the situation “embarrassing” and “environmental racism at its finest.” Vice President Wuho requested a timeline and project plan. President Adams asked Executive Director Forbes what she was prepared to do. Forbes proposed a joint hearing with the OCII commission and a commitment to report back in 60–90 days with a plan covering maintenance, security, and next steps. The Commission agreed. Item 12B – Public Art Process & Proposed Temporary Installation at Pier 14 (Informational) - Public Art at the Port: Dan Hodapp explained that public art arrives either through the city’s 2% for Art program (administered by the Arts Commission) or via unsolicited proposals. The Port lacks a dedicated public art program, staff, or budget. Staff plan to create a transparent web page with requirements and locations, and conduct outreach to BIPOC arts organizations. - Proposed Installation: Artist Denise DeLarue presented “Time Equals 30,” a 23‑foot‑long replica of a blue whale skull made from recycled plastic. The sculpture aims to raise awareness about plastic pollution; by 2050 there could be more plastic than fish in the ocean. The installation would be at Pier 14 for six months, with an educational program supported by the San Francisco Department of the Environment. The Arts Commission Director Ralph Remington expressed enthusiastic support. Commissioners praised the project and echoed the need for a clear, inclusive public art policy. Item 13A – Proposed Renewal Lease with Aardvark Storage Unlimited (American Storage) (Informational) - Proposal: Renew a five‑year lease with a one‑year option for 274,163 square feet of paved land at Seawall Lot 344 (6.29 acres). Current rent is $82,000/month ($0.30/sq ft); the parameter (market) rate is $0.45/sq ft (a 51% increase). Staff propose using a leasing incentive tool (Resolution 2116) to ramp the rent up to parameter gradually over the lease term. The new lease would generate over $1 million in revenue. - Discussion: Commissioner Brandon questioned why the tenant was not immediately brought to parameter, given it had been paying an unpaved‑land rate despite using paved land. Vice President Wuho noted the structural problem of large rent gaps. Staff explained that the low initial rate and 4% annual increases left a significant gap, and that tenant retention is crucial given a 20% vacancy rate at the Port. Commissioners emphasized that this should not set a precedent and that future leases should include gradual escalations to avoid such gaps. No vote was taken; staff will return for approval on May 10, 2022. Key Outcomes - Contract Award: Resolution 2223 authorizing the Heron’s Head Shoreline contract to Dixon Marine Services was adopted unanimously. - Consent Calendar: Resolution 2222 (Pier 70 SUD amendment) was adopted unanimously. - India Basin Properties: The Commission directed staff to return within 60–90 days with a comprehensive plan addressing maintenance, security, and next steps for Port‑owned properties south of India Basin. A joint hearing with the OCII commission was also recommended. - Public Art Policy: Staff will develop a transparent public art web page and conduct targeted outreach to diverse artists, returning with a draft policy later in 2022. - Lease Renewal: Staff will bring the Aardvark Storage proposal back to the Commission on May 10, 2022, for formal approval and subsequent Board of Supervisors approval. - New Business: The Commission noted that Vice President Doreen Wuho notified Mayor Breed she will not seek reappointment; her last day is May 10, 2022. Commissioners thanked her for 11 years of service. Meeting adjourned at approximately 5:40 p.m.

PROCEDURAL 31% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · PUBLIC REAL ESTATE 13% · PUBLIC ART 11%
1170
APR 26, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - April 26, 2022

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a hybrid meeting on April 26, 2022, at 9:45 AM in City Hall Room 400. The meeting included a land acknowledgement, adoption of hybrid meeting findings, approval of previous minutes, general public comment, employee retirement recognitions, updates from the Bay Area Water Conservation Agency (BAWCA), a drought update, and approval of several items on the consent and regular calendars. The commission also entered closed session to discuss a settlement. Consent Calendar - Item 11a: Approved an eight-year lease to the County of San Mateo for approximately 40,000 square feet on Montara Mountain for a communications facility. - Item 11b: Accepted work by A. Ruiz Construction Co. & Assoc., Inc. for paving and approved increasing the contract to a total of $22,940,706. - Item 11c: Approved an increase of $101,000 and approximately two years to the contract duration for mechanical systems inspection, maintenance, and repairs at 525 Golden Gate Avenue. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 5): Francisco DeCosta expressed concern about community benefits linked to sewer system improvement projects and alleged that a suspended contractor, Garrett Smith, was allowed to proceed. He also criticized the city administrator's office. Marty (Tuolumne County) thanked the commission for supporting whitewater recreation flows on the Tuolumne River, noting the tourist industry. Nate Frangale (California Outdoors) reiterated appreciation for staff's work on balancing needs. Teresa Larray Hostman (American Whitewater) thanked staff for the annual Tuolumne River Recreation Coordination meeting and the tentative flow summary. - Communications (Item 6): Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) noted that a request from former Commissioner Harrington (November 9, 2021) for environmental measures in the drought report was missing from the Outstanding Commission Request Report. He also criticized the response to President Moran's request about population projection disparities between Plan Bay Area and California Department of Finance, calling it inadequate. - Drought Update (Item 9a): Peter Dreckmeyer commented that the 182,000 acre-feet available from the Tuolumne River was close to the 187,000 acre-feet needed, suggesting things looked good. Francisco DeCosta questioned the need for a needs assessment on pipeline linkages and criticized water use by tech companies and swimming pools in the region. - WSIP (Item 14): BAWCA CEO Nicole Senko LaBosca submitted formal comments expressing three primary concerns: the 44-month schedule extension (to February 2027) requires continued state oversight; the Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery Project may need additional funding; and the notice of change fails to discuss possible lower project yields from the Alameda Creek Recapture Project and the Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery Project. BAWCA recommended a written report by January 2023 with updated cost and yield estimates and proposed replacement projects. Francisco DeCosta questioned the claimed $29 million savings on Calaveras Dam and criticized cost overruns. - Closed Session (Item 15): Francisco DeCosta commented that the city should have contested the claim in court rather than settling. Employee Retirement Recognitions - The commission recognized three retiring employees: John Martin (25 years, stationary engineer at Southeast Treatment Plant), Manfred Wong (25 years, senior manager in Infrastructure Bureau), and Marge Viscara (36 years, manager of Customer Service Bureau). Resolutions were read, and staff spoke in their honor. The retirees expressed gratitude. Commissioners thanked them for their dedication. Bay Area Water Conservation Agency Update - CEO Nicole Senko LaBosca (BAWCA) updated the commission on the responsibilities of the SFPUC to its 26 wholesale customers serving 1.8 million residents. She noted that implementation of the Bay Delta Plan could result in a loss of 90 million gallons of water per day and require rationing up to 50% during a multiple-year drought. She urged a fresh commission strategy for productive negotiations and referenced Governor Newsom's support for voluntary agreements. Commissioner Maxwell responded that BAWCA's customers are also the SFPUC's customers. Discussion Items - Drought Conditions Update (Item 9a): Steve Richie, Assistant General Manager for Water, reported that Hetch Hetchy Reservoir was at 320,000 acre-feet and expected to fill. He noted that releases were being made to accommodate snowmelt. Statewide, Shasta Dam was at 47% capacity, a problem for the Central Valley Project. Bay Area precipitation for the year was above average (22.39 inches). System-wide water demand was about 183 million gallons per day (MGD), with a 7% reduction since July 1, 2021, but only 2% since January 2022. Richie recommended moving the conservation target from 10% to 11% system-wide, keeping San Francisco at 5% and requiring wholesale customers to reduce by about 16%. He expressed confidence in achieving summer reductions. Commissioners discussed the volatility of precipitation patterns, the need for strategic planning, and the importance of outdoor irrigation cuts. Commissioner Maxwell requested a report on river health conditions; Richie said a draft was being prepared with the city attorney's office. - General Manager's Report (Item 9b): General Manager Herrera highlighted a study with Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory using DOE supercomputers to model future storm precipitation. The study found that by the end of the century, storm total precipitation could increase by 37%, making storms like the October 2021 category 5 storm common. A guidebook for planners will be published by year-end. - Item 12: Lease Amendment at 1980 Oakdale Avenue: Rosanna Russell, Real Estate Director, presented the first amendment for an eight-year lease of warehouse and office space for the Water Enterprise City Distribution Division. Monthly base rent for the first year is $85,337.85, subject to CPI increases. The city has a unilateral right to terminate after December 31, 2027 with 270 days' notice. Approved unanimously. - Item 13: Fund Balance Reserve Policy Revision: Christina Aligar Cordero, Director of Financial Planning, presented the revision to incorporate a CleanPowerSF fund balance reserve into the SFPUC-wide policy, replacing the standalone 2018 CleanPowerSF reserve policy. The new policy sets a minimum of 150 days cash on hand (41% of operating expenditures) and a target of 180 days (50%) for CleanPowerSF, reflecting program maturity, volatile power markets, and best practices from other CCAs. The revised policy will be evaluated quarterly. Approved unanimously. - Item 14: Water System Improvement Program (WSIP) Changes: Katie Miller presented the proposed Notice of Change to the State Water Resources Control Board and Seismic Safety Commission. The program completion date is extended from May 2023 to February 2027 (44 months). Schedule extensions are requested for eight projects, budget increases for five projects (totaling about $20 million for Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery, $10 million for Alameda Creek Recapture), and scope modifications for three projects. The overall program budget remains $4.8 billion due to savings from completed projects (e.g., $29 million from Calaveras Dam). Reasons for changes include COVID-19 delays, permitting challenges, and higher bid costs. Commissioners discussed the modifications to chemical treatment processes for safety and the reasons for the Alameda Creek Recapture cost increase. BAWCA expressed concerns. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Adoption of Hybrid Meeting Findings (Item 3): Unanimously approved (4-0). - Approval of Minutes (Item 4): Unanimously adopted (4-0). - Consent Calendar (Item 11): Unanimously passed (4-0). - Lease Amendment (Item 12): Unanimously approved (4-0). - Fund Balance Reserve Policy Revision (Item 13): Unanimously adopted (4-0). - WSIP Notice of Change (Item 14): Unanimously approved (4-0). - Closed Session (Item 17): The commission recommended settlement of an unlitigated claim (Any Jew vs. City and County of San Francisco) for $30,000 to the Board of Supervisors. No disclosure motion was made. - Directives: Staff was directed to send the WSIP Notice of Change to the State Water Resources Control Board and the Alfred E. Alquist Seismic Safety Commission. Staff will provide a report on river health conditions at a future meeting. Staff will respond to BAWCA's comments on the WSIP changes.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 34% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 15% · PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com