The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on Thursday, March 24, 2022, at 6:15 PM UTC (rescheduled from earlier in the day) to consider four agenda items. Chair Gordon Maher presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stephanie and Member Matt Haney (later excused and replaced by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman for the latter part of the meeting). The committee took action on a liquor license, advanced subacute care reporting legislation, and held a combined hearing on housing and LPS conservatorships. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were considered. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Liquor License): No public comments were received. - Item 4 (Subacute Care Reporting): Multiple speakers urged expansion of subacute bed capacity and accountability. Raquel Rivera and Antonio Rivera, family members of a patient transferred out-of-county, called for shared hospital responsibility, higher nursing ratios, and tracking of out-of-county discharges. Dr. Teresa Palmer criticized slow progress and urged including residential facility transfers. Vivian Imperiale and Patrick Manette Shaw emphasized the need for in-county care and identified delays in opening promised beds at Chinese Hospital. Carolyn Kennedy expressed support for reporting to evaluate care quality. - Items 2 & 3 (Conservatorships): Rachel Rodriguez, a social worker, highlighted acute psych bed shortages and the impact on 5150 thresholds. Carolyn Kennedy (Rescue SF) urged accelerated bed acquisition and streamlining hiring/leasing. Other callers stressed the need for better electronic health record coordination and more aggressive use of existing conservatorship laws. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Liquor License (950 Mason Street, Bin 415 LLC): The SFPD ABC Liaison reported zero protests, the site is in a high-crime/high-saturation area, but Central Station had no opposition. Applicant Michael Legao stated the license would be used for wine education and guided tastings inside the Fairmont Hotel. The committee voted 2-0 to recommend approval to the full board, determining the license would serve public convenience and necessity. - Item 4 – Health Code: Subacute Care Reporting (Called Out of Order): Supervisor Safayi presented amendments to expand reporting to skilled nursing facilities and move the due date to October 1, 2022. The ordinance aims to track out-of-county transfers for subacute and skilled nursing care, addressing a longstanding lack of hospital-based subacute beds. Kelly Hiromoto (DPH) confirmed ongoing efforts to add beds at Chinese Hospital and private facilities. The committee adopted amendments (2-0) and continued the item to April 14, 2022. - Items 2 & 3 – Combined Hearing: Housing Conservatorship Implementation and LPS Conservatorships: The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) presented an update on LPS conservatorships, noting wait times for locked subacute beds have doubled (San Francisco Healing Center: 20 to 111 days; other facilities: 51 to 103 days). Jill Nielsen (Public Conservator) and Dr. Angelica Almeida (DPH) reviewed the restrictive SB 1045 (housing conservatorship) pilot, reporting only two active conservatorships in FY2022, but 14 individuals accepted voluntary services. Supervisor Mandelman expressed frustration over slow bed acquisition and proposed modernizing the LPS definition of grave disability. The committee filed both hearings (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion passed (2-0) to send a positive recommendation to the full Board of Supervisors for the liquor license. - Item 4: Amendments adopted (2-0); item continued to April 14, 2022. - Items 2 & 3: Motion to file (3-0) with no further action; Supervisor Mandelman indicated future updates would be requested.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on Tuesday, March 22, 2022, at City Hall. Commissioners addressed a range of issues including the ongoing drought, water supply reliability, a drought surcharge, capital improvement programs, green infrastructure grants, and a contract authorization for electrical distribution work. The meeting included public testimony from representatives of environmental groups, ratepayers, and community members. Consent Calendar - Item 10 (Consent Calendar): The Commission unanimously approved the consent calendar, which included: - Acceptance of work performed by Buhler Construction for Golden Gate Avenue Roof Access and Fall Protection. - Approval of a 210-day increase to the construction duration contingency for the Mariposa Dry Weather Pump Station Improvements with Western Water Constructors, Inc. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 5): - A caller urged the SFPUC to ensure vendors comply with sanctions on Russia, specifically citing Emerson Electric's work with the PUC. - A speaker advocated for kitchen electrification, citing electric cooking on Navy submarines, and asked for help with electric vehicle charging infrastructure. - A caller offered an indigenous perspective on land stewardship and criticized historical dispossession. - Peter Dreckmeier (Tuolumne River Trust) expressed disappointment that a follow-up on drought workshops and vulnerability assessments had not been agendized in five months. He noted that only 578 salmon returned to the Tuolumne River last fall, calling it a crisis. He said the PUC is not prioritizing the issue. - David Pilpel reported he was unwell but stated he believes the water quality is excellent and thanked staff. - Another caller criticized the PUC for lack of accountability and transparency on community benefits, requesting a meeting with the community benefits manager. - Item 6 (Communications): A caller supported the water heating system memorandum and non-potable water systems, emphasizing water and energy savings. - Item 7 (BAWSCA Update): Peter Dreckmeier responded to BAWSCA's presentation, arguing that the 50% rationing figure is based on inflated demand projections (255 MGD vs. current demand) and that the Bay Delta plan is the correct path, not voluntary agreements. He claimed the SFPUC has enough water in storage for 4.5 years. - Item 8A (Drought Conditions): Peter Dreckmeier noted the SFPUC has enough water in storage to last 4.5 years, questioned the need for a drought surcharge, and argued that conservation does not benefit the Tuolumne River because conserved water is stored behind dams. - Item 8B (Drought Surcharge): Peter Dreckmeier raised concern that customers will be penalized for conserving water when the agency has ample storage. Discussion Items - Item 3 (Hybrid Meeting Renewal): The Commission unanimously adopted renewed findings under state urgency legislation to allow hybrid in-person meetings during the COVID-19 emergency and directed staff to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. - Item 4 (Approval of Minutes): The minutes of the March 8, 2022 meeting were approved unanimously. - Item 6 (Communications): Commissioner Jamy acknowledged the district-scale water reuse and water heating system memos. Steve Ritchie (AGM for Water) responded to a question about homeowner communications on lead pipes, stating the agency provides lead-free faucets and sends notices about continuous water consumption (leaks). Commissioner Maxwell reported receiving such a leak notice and found it effective. Ritchie said the agency is considering developing a mobile app for customer water use data but it has been low priority. - Item 7 (BAWSCA Update): Nicole Sandkulla (CEO of BAWSCA) presented an update. She highlighted that the SFPUC has a perpetual obligation to provide up to 184 million gallons per day to BAWSCA members, who pay over $270 million annually. She warned that the State Water Board’s Bay Delta plan could force up to 50% rationing for water users during multiple drought years, which she called catastrophic. She urged the SFPUC to resolve Tuolumne River issues through voluntary agreements to avoid legislative intervention. She stated that the governor and state board support voluntary agreements and asked for the Commission’s plan to meet state requirements. - Item 8 (General Manager’s Report): - 8A – Drought Conditions (Steve Ritchie): Ritchie reported that statewide drought persists, Hetch Hetchy Reservoir is likely to fill but the entire storage system is unlikely to fill. The state water board has sent curtailment letters to 2,000 water rights holders. SFPUC’s total demand reduction from January 1 to March 3 was about 7%, with a target of 10% system-wide reduction from FY 2019-20 demand. Summer water use reduction is critical; the goal is to keep demand below 200 million gallons per day. Ritchie noted that Governor Newsom’s call for 15% reduction from calendar 2020 was not well thought out. The agency is coordinating with the rafting community on flow releases. Commissioner Jamy asked about the impact of early snowmelt and reservoir management; Ritchie said they run daily scenarios and expect 10,000 acre-feet of runoff in the coming days. Commissioner Jamy also requested a tutorial on the water bank. - 8B – Drought Surcharge Update (Charles Pearl & John Cote): Pearl explained the 5% retail water and wastewater drought surcharge effective April 1, 2022. The surcharge is temporary and intended to be net-neutral if customers conserve. Projected revenue shortfalls: $36 million for water enterprise (9% below budget) and $30 million for wastewater (4% below budget). Cost savings and fund balance will cover part of the gap; the surcharge will offset about $3 million for water and $4 million for wastewater this fiscal year. John Cote described the outreach campaign: a web portal, bill inserts, social media (Facebook, Instagram), Muni bus ads, and multilingual print/radio ads in Chinese, Filipino, and Spanish. Website traffic has more than doubled. Commissioner Jamy requested metrics on effectiveness, including calls to customer service and Google search trends. Commissioner Maxwell asked about monitoring workforce development in the Green Infrastructure Grant Program. - 8C – Hetch Hetchy Capital Improvement Program (Katie Miller): Miller reported $134 million spent (24% completion), 10 projects in pre-construction, 7 in construction. The first mountain tunnel shutdown was completed successfully. Key project milestones: Moccasin Dam alternative analysis chose an auxiliary spillway; Tesla Valve House received valves; Mountain Tunnel shaft dug to 70 feet. No new cost variances. - 8D – Wastewater Enterprise Quarterly Report (Steve Robinson): Robinson reported 48% completion of the 70-project program ($3.65 billion). Highlights: Ocean Beach sand placement (short-term improvements) with regrading of steep slopes; Taraval sewer segment B awarded. For the Southeast area major projects: biosolids digester bids were at or below estimates; headworks facility is seeing above-ground concrete work; community center is fully enclosed with interior and landscaping underway. Commissioner Jamy asked about digital control and remote access for new facilities; Robinson said the distributed control system (DCS) project is underway to integrate modern technology. Commissioner Maxwell requested that acronyms be spelled out in presentations. - Item 11 (Sewer Inspection Contract): The Commission approved awarding contract WW675 (5th-18th Upper Larkin Street sewer inspection) to Pipe and Plant Solutions Inc. for approximately $2.2 million. The low bidder (Red Zone Robotics) was deemed non-responsive. Two bids were received; the engineer’s estimate was $2.2 million. - Item 12 (Green Infrastructure Grant Program): Greg Norby presented modifications to the grant guidelines. Based on previous Commissioner feedback, workforce development will be retained as a ranking criterion (staff had proposed removing it due to low uptake). Staff described proactive outreach and a new competitive cycle that will score applicants based on how many co-benefits they address. Commissioner Maxwell asked about monitoring and ensuring applicants prioritize workforce development; staff committed to communication and performance monitoring. - Item 13 (State Revolving Fund Loan for Mountain Tunnel): The Commission authorized the General Manager to execute an installment sale agreement for up to $238,218,951 from the Drinking Water State Revolving Fund at an interest rate of approximately 1.1% (half the California GO bond rate). This is expected to save $130 million in ratepayer costs over 30 years. A cost-sharing agreement with the Power Enterprise for $65 million was also approved. Commissioner Maxwell asked about interest payments; Pearl clarified interest begins one year after the first draw. - Item 14 (Electrical Distribution Contract Negotiation): The Commission authorized the General Manager to negotiate with qualified contractors for contract PW009R (as-needed electrical distribution installation and construction support) after two competitive bids received no responses. Barbara Hale (AGM for Power) cited a workforce shortage for journey-level line workers and difficulty recruiting. Despite modifying general conditions based on contractor feedback, no bids were received. The item allows direct negotiation; any contract award will return to the Commission. Commissioner Paulson voted no, expressing concern about going outside the normal competitive process, though he acknowledged the urgency. The motion passed 3-1. Key Outcomes - Approved unanimously (Items 3, 4, 10, 11, 12, 13): - Hybrid meeting renewal. - March 8 meeting minutes. - Consent calendar. - Sewer inspection contract award (Pipe and Plant Solutions). - Updated Green Infrastructure Grant Program guidelines (retaining workforce development criteria). - State Revolving Fund loan for Mountain Tunnel project ($238 million) and cost-sharing with Power Enterprise. - Approved 3-1 (Item 14): Authorization to negotiate with qualified contractors for as-needed electrical distribution services; Commissioner Paulson opposed. - Closed Session: The Commission met in closed session regarding litigation on water right curtailments. No action was taken, and discussions were not disclosed.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met in hybrid format on Thursday, March 17, 2022, beginning at 18:15 UTC. Chair Dean Preston presided, joined by Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Rafael Mandelman. Clerk Erica Major handled the roll and public comment procedures. The committee approved routine items, held hearings on SFMTA's racial equity plan and plastic pollution, and acted on litigation settlements. Discussion Items - Item 1: Dogpatch and Northwest Potrero Hill Green Benefit District Annual Report FY2020-2021 - Public Works liaison Ramses Desalvarez and GBD Executive Director Julie Christensen presented. The district spans 200 blocks and 70 acres; 77% of stakeholders pay less than $200 per year. It has logged over 6,800 volunteer hours and attracted nearly $800,000 in grants and donations. Financials received a negative declaration from Rhina Accounting Agency. Supervisor Mandelman asked why this GBD succeeded when others failed; Christensen cited land-use pressures, city neglect, and a strong Public Works partnership. No public comment. The committee voted 3-0 to recommend approval to the full board. - Item 2: Retroactive Grant Authorization for Office of Chief Medical Examiner - The OCME sought to accept $312,966 from the California Department of Public Health Substance and Addiction Prevention Branch for an Overdose Prevention Initiative, adding one temporary forensic toxicologist. COO David Serrano Sewell clarified the grant is not yet executed; retroactivity refers only to the ordinance after state approval. He reported that 90-day death certificate completion rose from 30% in January 2021 to 82% by August 2021, and the office achieved NAME accreditation. Supervisor Chan asked about communication with families in drug-related deaths, referencing the Jackson-Sales case. No public comment. The committee voted 3-0 to recommend approval. - Item 3: Hearing on SFMTA Racial Equity Plan Implementation - Supervisor Chan called the hearing due to employee reports of a toxic environment. Racial Equity Officer Josephine Ankoya presented data showing management classifications are predominantly white, while the workforce is roughly 14% white. A two-year discipline analysis found disproportionate outcomes for Black transit operators, especially women in attendance-related cases. The agency is building a racial equity policy, mandatory training, and improved tracking, but has not yet established regular reporting intervals. Director Jeff Tumlin made brief remarks and left. Public comment included current and former employees describing retaliation and inaction. The committee voted 3-0 to continue the item to the call of the chair. - Item 4: Hearing on Plastic Recycling Management and Plastic Pollution - Recology, Public Works, and the Department of Environment presented. Recology reported that 15% of collected trash is plastic, 32.4% of landfill-bound material from Pier 96 is plastic, and estimated annual plastic tonnage ranges from 8,000-10,000 tons from recycling residuals plus about 15,000 tons from gray bins. Public Works operates street cleaning with roughly 350 staff and a $110 million annual budget, removing about 1 million pounds of trash per week. SF Environment noted two-thirds of litter is single-use foodware and highlighted reusable foodware programs. Public comment from Save the Bay and Jobs with Justice supported source reduction and a corporate plastic tax. Supervisor Chan discussed possible local policies, including banning plastic shipping materials and exploring litigation and a tax measure. The committee voted 3-0 to file the hearing. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1 and 2: No public comment. - Item 3: Dante King (Black Employees Alliance, former SFMTA ombudsperson) said the agency used a Black woman to provide cover and cited examples of harsher punishment for Black workers. Jesse Rosemar (former transportation planner) accused Director Tumlin of promoting an executive with a known toxic record. P.J. from Samgan asked about BIPOC outreach for hiring. Shayda Haigu (Local 21 president) cited retaliation fears. Adrian Larne (SFMTA worker) said management labeled racism discussions a liability. Kathy Gassard (Black and African American Affinity Group) called for manager-level dashboards and accountability. - Item 4: Henry Hoffman (Save the Bay) urged policies against top plastic polluters, noting 80% of ocean plastic comes from land and communities spend $428 million annually on cleanup. Julia Sebastian (Jobs with Justice SF) supported a progressive corporate plastic tax to fund climate jobs. Closed Session Litigation - Items 5-9 were four ordinances and one resolution settling lawsuits and unlitigated claims, including settlements for David Alfaro et al., Dennis Richards et al., Leticia Avila, Lawrence Thomas, and Christine H. Russell. No public comment. The committee convened in closed session and afterward voted 3-0 to forward all five items to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1 recommended to full board (3-0). - Item 2 recommended to full board (3-0). - Item 3 continued to call of chair (3-0). - Item 4 filed (3-0). - Items 5-9 recommended to full board after closed session (3-0).
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on March 10, 2022 at 6:15 PM. Chair Gordon Maher presided, joined by Members Catherine Stephanie and Matt Haney. Clerk Alisa Samara conducted the proceedings. Discussion Items - Item 1: Hearing on the transfer of a Type 21 off-sale general beer, wine and distilled spirits liquor license to Express Market Inc., doing business as Wally’s Community Market, located at 453 O’Farrell Street, District 6, to determine if it serves public convenience or necessity. The item was continued to the March 24, 2022 meeting. - Item 2: A motion to continue item number two to the March 24, 2022 meeting was made and passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 3: Ordinance to lift the suspension of certain provisions of the graffiti removal and abatement ordinance regarding issuance of violations and reinstating the collection of assessed fees and fines. Supervisor Peskin, who sponsored the original suspension legislation, presented the item. The committee heard the item and opened public comment; no further action is recorded. Key Outcomes - Item 1 was continued to March 24, 2022. - Item 2 was continued to March 24, 2022. - Item 3 was introduced and discussed; no vote was taken within the provided transcript.
The Port Commission of the City and County of San Francisco met on March 8, 2022, at 10:15 AM. The meeting began with a land acknowledgement, roll call, and a brief public comment period on the executive session, which had no speakers. The Commission voted unanimously to enter closed session and later voted not to disclose any closed session discussions. After reconvening, the Pledge of Allegiance was recited, followed by announcements. The consent calendar was considered and passed unanimously with four resolutions. An informational presentation on the Mission Rock project was initiated but not completed in the available transcript. No further agenda items were discussed in the provided record. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2212: Approval of personnel nominations for E.B. Min, Joe Igber, Noelle Yuen, Meng-Hsiu Chen, and Ken Lindberg as proposed by the Executive Director. - Resolution 2213: Approval of a settlement agreement for Lease L-15017 with Paul Furman (d/b/a Bay Natives), including a new lease for 5,000 square feet at Pier 94 at $0.45/sq ft base rent, back rent of $1,500/month to reduce outstanding balance, waiver of late fees and interest through the five-year term, and potential forgiveness of remaining balance if no default. - Resolution 2214: Adoption of findings under state urgency legislation to allow certain commissioners to attend meetings remotely during the COVID-19 emergency for 30 days, with a directive to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. - Resolution 2215: Adoption of new procedures for public comment at Port Commission meetings, allowing in-person or teleconference participation. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made during the public comment periods for the executive session or the consent calendar. Discussion Items - Item 11A – Mission Rock Project Update: Phil Williamson, project manager, began an informational presentation on the Mission Rock project, including an intent for the port to enter into an agreement for the purchase of non-potable water from Mission Rock Utilities at Seawall Lot 337. The presentation was cut off in the transcript; no details on outcomes or further discussion were available. - Item 12A – Proposed 2022 Legislative Priorities: This item was listed on the agenda but not discussed in the provided transcript. Key Outcomes - The Commission voted unanimously to go into closed session and to not disclose any discussions from that session. - All four consent calendar resolutions (2212, 2213, 2214, 2215) were adopted unanimously. - No other votes or decisions were recorded in the available transcript.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission held its hybrid in-person meeting on March 8, 2022, at City Hall Room 400. The meeting began at approximately 9:45 AM and included adoption of renewed COVID-19 emergency findings, approval of minutes, public comments, communications reports, annual audited financial statements, a general manager's report covering alternative water supply, drought conditions, budget status, and capital improvement programs, consent calendar approvals, and regular calendar items. Commissioners also held a closed session. Consent Calendar - Approved items 10a through 10e unanimously (4-0). Items included contracts for San Joaquin Pipeline Valve and Safe Entry Improvements, selection of Brown and Caldwell/SRT Consultants, acceptance of work by Minerva Construction and Cal State Constructors, and a contract duration extension for Oceanside Water Pollution Control Plant. Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel (multiple calls): Supported hybrid meetings, requested late handouts be posted online, noted typo in minutes, supported consent calendar maps, suggested drought emergency reassessment, and asked about program guideline notice requirements. - Leva Dupree: Supported hybrid approach, stressed accessibility and mask availability. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust): Urged commission to revisit design drought and respond to NGO letters from January and February; criticized lack of movement after workshops. - Irvine (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods): Questioned redundancy for Harry Tracy and Mountain Tunnel; opposed making San Jose and Santa Clara permanent customers. - Doug Block (Teamsters Joint Council 7): Urged cancellation of lease with Tower Parking/Amazon at 2000 Marin, citing non-union practices. - Speaker on community benefits: Requested action on community benefits from Bayview and ethics commission. - Tom Francis (BAWSCA): Praised alternative water supply program and quarterly reports. - Dave Warner (Palo Alto): Discussed cost implications of design drought and alternative supply planning; urged revisiting design drought duration. - Caller on water leaching: Stated concern about millions of gallons of drinking water used for flushing and leaching. - Caller on Emerson DCS: Raised concerns about Emerson's past contract and questioned Amazon involvement on Treasure Island. Discussion Items - Item 3 - Renewed Findings for Hybrid Meetings: Adopted 4-0. - Item 4 - Approval of Minutes of Feb 22, 2022: Approved 4-0. - Item 6 - Communications: Discussed Stern Grove Restoration cost increase from $4M due to additional scope (mold, slope stabilization, tennis court). Commissioner Jami asked about baseline conditions; staff explained restoration to original design. - Item 7 - Annual Audited Financial Statements: KPMG presented clean audit for FY2020-21 for Water, Wastewater, Hetch Hetchy, and CleanPowerSF. No control deficiencies or misstatements. Commission praised clean audit. - Item 8a - Alternative Water Supply Planning: Manisha Kothari presented roadmap and progress. Planning phase midpoint; alternative water supply plan due by July 1, 2023. Gap between supply and demand in 2045 is 84 MGD. Commissioner Jami requested better tracking of recycling and greywater to reduce demand. Commissioner Maxwell asked about stakeholder engagement. - Item 8b - Drought Conditions Update: Steve Ritchie reported reservoir storage at Hetch Hetchi 300,000 AF (vs 180,000 last year), snowpack 300,000 AF water equivalent. Demand dropped to 169 MGD after dry February. City reductions 14.5%; wholesale 5%; system-wide 8% from FY19-20 levels. Commissioner Maxwell asked about making room for runoff. - Item 8c - Quarterly Budget Status Report: Laura Bush presented Q2 FY21/22 results. Water and wastewater operating shortfalls due to drought conservation and slow COVID recovery; surcharge effective April 2022. Hetch Hetchy and CleanPowerSF positive. Commissioner Jami noted demand may not bounce back; suggested strategic rate setting and tracking decoupling bill. - Item 8d - Water Enterprise CIP Quarterly Report: Katie Miller reported 36 projects with $2.7B budget, 31% complete. Cost variances in planning phase; new categories for variance tracking being implemented. Commissioner Paulson asked about variance glossary. - Item 8e - Water System Improvement Program Quarterly Report: WSIP at 99% completion; Calaveras Dam moved to closeout. Schedule now forecast to complete Feb 2027 (45 months late) due to permit delays. Cost forecast remains $4.8B. Commissioner Maxwell congratulated Susan Howe for ASCE Opal Award. - Item 11 - Sole Source Designation for Emerson DCS: Approved 4-0 to authorize sole source for Treasure Island wastewater treatment plant DCS to ensure compatibility. - Item 12 - Green Infrastructure Grant Program Guidelines: Continued to next meeting after Commissioner Paulson requested retaining job training co-benefit language removed in proposed revisions. Commission directed staff to bring back revised guidelines. Key Outcomes - Approved: Renewed hybrid meeting findings (Item 3), minutes (Item 4), consent calendar (Item 10), Emerson sole source (Item 11). All 4-0. - Continued: Green Infrastructure Grant Program Guidelines (Item 12) to next meeting with job training co-benefit language reinstated. - Noted: President Moran will work on schedule for design drought discussion; staff to engage with environmental groups on alternative water supply; budget briefing on drought surcharge before implementation at next meeting. - Closed Session: Commission authorized settlement recommendation to Board of Supervisors; voted not to disclose discussions.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee met on March 2, 2022, at 9:30 AM to consider three agenda items: establishing budget process goals for FYs 2022-2023 and 2023-2024, a hearing on progress increasing mental health system beds, and a hearing on Youth Commission budget priorities. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Matt Haney and included Supervisors Walton, Ronan, Safai, and Mar. Supervisor Ronan was designated as the incoming chair for the next budget cycle. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Budget Process Goals): David Pilpel provided public comment, noting a minor typo in the motion and urging that public comment be taken on each department during June presentations, that the budget webpage be refreshed, and that past documents remain accessible. He also requested a review of the SF.gov budget page to clarify dates and fiscal years. - Items 2 and 3: No public comments were received. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Budget Process Goals): Chair Haney introduced a motion establishing shared budget priorities including housing affordability, homelessness services, mental health and substance use treatment (Mental Health SF), early care and education, youth services, climate action, COVID recovery, public safety ambassadors, and API cultural corridor preservation. An amendment was offered to add "prioritizing commercial assets and historic preservation for the API community and API Cultural Corridor Preservation." The amendment passed unanimously (5-0). The amended motion was then forwarded to the full Board with a positive recommendation (5-0). - Item 2 (Mental Health Beds Progress): Supervisor Ronan chaired the hearing, calling attention to the 408 additional beds identified in Dr. Anton Nigussie Bland's 2020 bed optimization report and the lack of progress since. Judge Michael Bergert of San Francisco Superior Court testified that his drug court and community justice courts face severe shortages of dual diagnosis residential treatment beds. He presented data showing individuals waiting up to 264 days in jail for an interview and over eight months for a bed. Judge Bergert stated that drug court treatment staff have never successfully placed a client into Baker Places or Progress Foundation—the two main dual diagnosis providers. Judge Charles Crompton noted that without proper treatment, individuals decompensate in jail and often return to the courts after release. Dr. David Pating and Kelly Kirkpatrick from the Department of Public Health (DPH) reported that 89 of the planned 400 new beds have been opened, with 20 beds at the Summ Rise drug sobering center expected soon. They cited barriers including real estate acquisition timelines (1.5–3 years), state licensing, and competition with other counties. Dr. Hillary Cunnins acknowledged the urgency and promised better data tracking. Supervisor Mandelman expressed frustration with the slow pace, noting that locked subacute capacity had increased by only two beds since a prior report, and urged DPH to own facilities. Supervisor Ronan demanded a clear, metric-based plan with specific bed opening dates and prioritization of dual diagnosis beds. Supervisor Safai suggested examining internal DPH spending and pursuing regional partnerships. The hearing was filed (4-0, with Chair Haney absent). - Item 3 (Youth Commission Budget Priorities): Youth Commissioners Adriana Zhang, Vanessa Pimentel, Emily Wynn, and Jaden Tanaka presented an omnibus budget resolution passed in January 2022. Priorities included: funding youth voter outreach and pre-registration; fee waivers for IDs and driver's licenses; expanded justice system alternatives (e.g., re-entry programs, alternatives to incarceration); cutting the police department budget by at least 50% and reallocating funds to social services, wellness centers, and mental health; 400 units of permanent supportive housing for transitional-age youth (TAY); free Muni for all youth up to age 23 (extending the one-year pilot); and compensating youth commissioners and advisory body members. Commissioners also described the importance of the 29 Sunset Rapid Project and regional transportation integration. Supervisors praised the presentation and expressed strong alignment, particularly on stipends for commissioners and free Muni. The hearing was filed (4-0, with Member Mar absent). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Budget Process Goals): Amended motion forwarded to full Board with a positive recommendation. Vote: 5-0. - Item 2 (Mental Health Beds): Hearing filed. Vote: 4-0 (Haney absent). DPH committed to providing a detailed plan with specific bed targets and timelines during upcoming budget hearings. - Item 3 (Youth Commission Priorities): Hearing filed. Vote: 4-0 (Mar absent). Supervisors committed to considering youth priorities during the budget process.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met remotely on Thursday, February 24, 2022, chaired by Supervisor Gordon Mar, with members Catherine Stefani and Matt Haney. The committee considered two agenda items: a liquor license transfer for Pacific Cocktail Haven and the annual submission of departmental overdose prevention policies. Both items were approved with positive recommendations to the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Liquor License Transfer): No public comments were received after a brief technical recess to correct the call-in number. The applicant, Andy Chan, partner at Pacific Cocktail Haven, testified about the business's history, a fire that destroyed their previous location, and their commitment to the neighborhood. He noted letters of support from Supervisor Peskin's office and the Union Square Merchant Association. - Item 2 (Overdose Prevention Policies): Multiple callers testified. Laura Thomas from SF AIDS Foundation thanked departments for collaboration but urged the city to implement supervised consumption services (safe consumption sites) in housing and shelters. Paul Aguilar (HIV Advocacy Network) described losing his partner to a fentanyl overdose and called for safe consumption sites, noting New York City prevented 15 overdose deaths in its first week. Andy Stone (SF AIDS Foundation) shared a personal story and emphasized harm reduction. Wesley Saver (Glide, Safer Inside Coalition) praised collaboration but criticized the Tenderloin emergency declaration process and HSOC operations that confiscate harm reduction supplies. Laura Guzman (DOE Project) stressed the need for resources beyond online training, including funding for naloxone and implementation support. Discussion Items - Liquor License Transfer (Item 1): The SFPD ABC Liaison Unit presented conditions for the type-48 license for Pacific Cocktail Haven at 550 Sutter Street (formerly at 580 Sutter). Conditions include monitoring for loitering, no audible noise, supervision of the outdoor patio, and alcohol service only between 12 p.m. and 10 p.m. The area is in a high crime (plot 158) and high saturation (census tract 121) zone, but Central Station had no opposition. Supervisor Mar noted Supervisor Peskin's support and moved to forward a positive recommendation. - Overdose Prevention Policies (Item 2): Supervisor Haney, sponsor of the 2021 legislation requiring annual reports, led the item. He noted that nearly 700 people died from drug overdoses in each of the last two years, with 46 deaths in January 2022. Presentations came from the Department of Public Health (Eileen Loughran), Homelessness and Supportive Housing (Dylan Schneider), Human Services Agency (Susie Smith), and Department of Emergency Management (Sam Dodge). They described interdepartmental collaboration, development of overdose prevention policies, online training modules (targeted for late summer 2022), a naloxone clearinghouse, and expanded harm reduction resources. Supervisor Stefani raised concerns about metrics for success, noting 71.4 million dollars spent on overdose prevention and treatment last fiscal year, yet the crisis worsens. She questioned how DPH tracks outcomes (e.g., connections to treatment or abstinence-based recovery) and whether detox beds are sufficient. She also raised issues about bias against uniformed responders. Supervisor Haney asked about tracking overdose incidents in housing, requiring training for all staff, and fentanyl test strip distribution. Supervisor Mar highlighted the need for budget resources. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to direct the clerk to prepare a resolution determining that the liquor license transfer serves public convenience and necessity and forward it to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2: Motion to forward the resolution receiving the 2021 overdose prevention policies to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Passed unanimously (3-0). The resolution acknowledges the annual submissions from DPH, HSH, HSA, and DEM and encourages continued implementation and reporting. Both items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of March 8, 2022.
The Port Commission met on Tuesday, February 22, 2022, at 11:15 AM to discuss the Executive Director’s report on the strategic plan update, the biennial budget and federal stimulus funds, a new write-off policy, and a proposal to sell land to the city for a fire training facility. The meeting was held virtually via teleconference. Approval of Minutes - The minutes of the February 8, 2022 meeting were adopted unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 6A (Executive Director’s Report): No public comments. - Item 7A (Budget): No public comments. - Item 8A (Write-Off Policy): No public comments. - Item 8B (Fire Training Facility MOU): Four speakers commented in support: John Bucher (President, Fire Fighters Local 798), Army Morgan (San Francisco Fire Commissioner), Steven Nakajo (Vice President, San Francisco Fire Commission), and one caller opposed, citing concerns about contamination, liquefaction, and sea-level rise. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report & Strategic Plan Update: Director Elaine Forbes presented an update to the Port’s 2021–2025 Strategic Plan, focusing on economic recovery and growth. Goals include developing an economic recovery plan, closing an $8 million shortfall by 2025, implementing at least three strategies yielding $3 million in ongoing revenue/cost savings, and using federal stimulus (ARPA) to fund capital projects and restore cuts. Commissioners expressed support, emphasizing the need for long-term strategies and equity. - Item 7A – Fiscal Year 2022‑23 and 2023‑24 Biennial Budget and ARPA Funds: Nathan Cruz presented the budget, highlighting a healthy fund balance due to $114.8 million in ARPA stimulus. The budget restores positions, funds capital projects, and includes a new “economic recovery czar” position. Commissioners raised no further questions and voted to approve Resolutions 22‑09 and 22‑10. - Item 8A – Uncollectible Balances Write-Off Policy: Rebecca Benassini presented a policy to replace a 1984 resolution, detailing write-off procedures requiring confirmation of uncollectibility by staff, City Attorney, and Controller, with a 30‑day notice to the Commission. Commissioner Brandon expressed concerns about transparency and the lack of a centralized list to prevent future leases to bad actors. After discussion, Vice President Wuho moved to table the item for further review, including consultation with external auditors and development of enhanced reporting and tenant vetting measures. The motion passed unanimously. - Item 8B – MOU for Fire Personnel Training Facility (Informational): Staff and partners presented plans to sell 2.6 acres of Port property at 1236 Carroll Avenue to the City for $5–$6 million (fair market value) to assemble a 7.5‑acre site for a new fire training facility. The site requires state legislation to lift public trust restrictions. Fire Chief Jeanine Nicholson and Deputy Chief Thomas O’Connor outlined the need for training space, including props for fire, EMS, and community programs. An environmental review (Mitigated Negative Declaration) was completed and approved by the Board of Supervisors on February 8, 2022. Commissioners expressed support and requested details on contamination, liquefaction, traffic, and building heights. The item will return for action in April 2022. - Item 9 – New Business: President Adams requested two future reports: (1) an inventory of Port properties south of Islais Creek, and (2) a review of leasing policies to strengthen financial protections. Key Outcomes - Adopted unanimously: Minutes of February 8, 2022. - Adopted unanimously (Resolutions 22‑09 and 22‑10): Approval of the Fiscal Year 2022‑23 and 2023‑24 Biennial Operating and Capital Budget, and acceptance of federal stimulus funds (ARPA) for FY 2021‑22. - Tabled unanimously (Resolution 22‑11): The 2022 Uncollectible Balances Write-Off Policy was tabled for further review of auditor input and transparency measures. A revised policy is expected at a future meeting. - No vote on MOU: The informational presentation on the fire training facility MOU was well-received; staff will return with a final MOU for approval at the April 12, 2022 meeting.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on February 22, 2022, at 9:45 AM via teleconference due to the COVID-19 emergency. Commissioners present: President Moran, Commissioner Maxwell, Commissioner Paulson; Vice President Jami excused. The meeting covered 19 agenda items, including routine approvals, public comments, reports, and several major contracts and policy actions. Consent Calendar - Item 11a, 11b, 11c: Approved three consent items: Job Order Contracts JOC-86 and JOC-87 (each $5,000,000) for general engineering construction, and a 180-day contract duration extension for Contract WD-2668 (Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery). All passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 5): Multiple speakers addressed the commission: - A speaker called for transparency and accountability in community benefits, alleging discrepancies and lack of outreach. - A speaker criticized the transfer of the Auxiliary Water Supply System (AWAS) from the Fire Department to SFPUC, arguing it has led to questionable modifications and urging a transfer back. - Dave Warner (Palo Alto resident) praised the Long-Term Vulnerability Assessment (LTVA) and climate workshop, recommending a five-year update cycle. He noted that the LTVA found no clear change in average precipitation but expected 4°C warming, making severe droughts rarer. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) claimed SFPUC’s official filing inflated current water demand by 22% (citing 238 MGD vs. actual 195 MGD), calling it a violation of the Sunshine Ordinance. He also highlighted San Francisco’s water conservation success: 82 MGD in 1998 to 37.3 MGD today despite population growth. - Barry Nelson (Golden State Salmon Association) raised concerns about SFPUC’s letter supporting the Tuolumne River Voluntary Agreement, stating it lacks scientific basis and ignores peer review. He urged a public forum on salmon declines (80% in three years). - A speaker (CleanPowerSF user) urged the commission to continue working for clean, renewable electricity and affordable conversions, noting her all-electric kitchen. - David Tilpel (regular attendee) stressed the importance of maintaining remote public participation in future hybrid meetings. - Item 7 (RBOC Report): Public comment included Francisco De Costa criticizing the revenue bond oversight, alleging failures and FBI involvement. David Tilpel defended the committee’s narrow focus, and Peter Dreckmeyer requested more detailed future presentations. - Item 8 (BAWSCA): Dave Warner thanked CEO Nicole Sandkuhle for the innovative approach to demand projections. - Item 13 (CDD Campus Design): Four callers spoke in favor: Ellen Lewenberger (Mark Cavagnero Associates), Yakuaski (YA design), Felicia Venom (Mark Cavagnero Associates), and Ann Cervantes (San Francisco Latino and Black Builders Association), who urged breaking larger projects into smaller trade packages for local BIPOC businesses. - Item 15 (Tumbleweed Energy Storage): Alex Lanceburg (San Francisco Electrical Construction Industry) commended labor standards but criticized CC Power’s lack of institutional transparency and labor guidelines. Another speaker supported the project for mitigating solar curtailment and enhancing resilience. - Item 18 (CAP Program): David Tilpel raised concerns about outreach to the Citizens Advisory Committee, comparison with other utility discount programs, and use of an outside contractor for customer data verification. Discussion Items - Item 3 – Remote Meetings Extension: Adopted renewed findings under state urgency legislation to continue remote meetings for 30 days. Passed 3-0. - Item 4 – Minutes: Approved minutes of February 8, 2022. Passed 3-0. - Item 6 – Communications: President Moran asked staff to prepare a schedule for unfinished business workshops. - Item 7 – Revenue Bond Oversight Committee (RBOC) Report: Chair Etora Lile presented the annual report (January 2020 – June 2021), highlighting bond sales monitoring, performance audit findings, and recommendations. Commissioners thanked the committee. - Item 8 – Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Update: CEO Nicole Sandkuhle presented an update on demand projections. She showed that projections have consistently overestimated actual demand due to droughts and COVID. BAWSCA is conducting a 2022 demand study update with sensitivity analysis to quantify uncertainty. Key statistic: BAWSCA region population increased 27% since 1990, while total water use decreased 13% and residential per capita use decreased 30%. - Item 9a – Drought Conditions Update: Ellen Levin reported that Hetch Hetchy Reservoir is at 84.2% capacity (crossed 300,000 acre-feet), curtailments on Tuolumne River are suspended. Precipitation in January was driest on record at Hetch Hetchy; February storms brought some relief. Overall demand reduction since July 2021 is 8.7% compared to baseline (FY 2019-20). - Item 9b – Quarterly Audit and Performance Review: Nancy Holm presented the Q2 FY 2021-22 audit portfolio. Five audits completed, including the Social Impact Partnership Program audit (7 recommendations). Inventory counts showed challenges at some divisions. 97% of 256 total audit recommendations are closed; 7 remain open. Welcomed new Audit Director Irella Blackwood. - Item 12 – Tree Services Contracts: Awarded four master tree services contracts (not-to-exceed $9,700,000) to A&L Builders Inc., Arborist Now Inc., CPEX Group Inc., and Professional Tree Care Company. Duration 1,826 days. Passed 3-0. - Item 13 – CDD Campus Design Contract: Staff presented plan to award $27,800,000 design contract to Mark Cavagnero Associates (MCA) for a new City Distribution Division campus at 2000 Marin. Only one responsive bid received; two other bidders were deemed non-responsive due to material errors in overhead and profit schedules. Commissioners questioned the process but approved. Passed 3-0. - Item 14 – Groundwater Storage Phase 2A: Awarded contract WD-2878A ($6,850,000) to Marine Ship Development LLC for retrofitting well pump systems. Only one responsive bid; second bidder did not meet license requirements. Passed 3-0. - Item 15 – Tumbleweed Long Duration Energy Storage: Authorized CleanPowerSF to participate in the 69 MW lithium-ion battery project (8-hour discharge) via California Community Power (CC Power). Total not-to-exceed $65 million over 15 years (20-year term including pre-operations). Discussion focused on labor standards and need for stronger institutional policies at CC Power. Passed 3-0. - Item 16 – UDC Operations Agreement with CAISO: Authorized General Manager to enter into a Utility Distribution Company operations agreement for the new substation at Potrero. Term for life of substation. Passed 3-0. - Item 17 – COVID-19 Relief Extension: Extended moratorium on shutoffs, liens, and late fees until July 1, 2022 (from March 31, 2022), and late fee resumption delayed to July 1, 2023. Staff noted federal relief from ARPA will pay off a significant amount of customer debt. Passed 3-0. - Item 18 – Customer Assistance Program (CAP) Memorialization: Approved moving CAP rules into water service regulations, with streamlined enrollment (self-certification, online application, annual third-party verification). Discount changed to uniform 25% for water and sewer (from 15%/35%). Income eligibility remains at 200% federal poverty level. Passed 3-0. - Item 19 – Water Waste Restrictions Update: Updated permanent water waste restrictions to align with state regulations, including prohibitions on watering during rain and on hardscapes. Passed 3-0. Key Outcomes - Votes: All consent and regular calendar items passed unanimously (3-0). - Directives: Staff to prepare a schedule for unfinished business workshops (Item 6). - Next Steps: For the Tumbleweed project, staff will seek Board of Supervisors approval in March and execute agreements by April 25, 2022. For CAP, implementation of online application and verification process will proceed. - Reports: The commission received the RBOC annual report, BAWSCA demand study update, drought update, and quarterly audit report; no specific actions taken.