The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 1, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Jackie Fielder, with Vice Chair Sandra Souter and Supervisor Cheryl. The committee considered two items: an amendment to an MOU with the California Electronic Recording Transaction Network Authority (CERTNA) for electronic recording services, and a resolution of intention to renew and expand the Ocean Avenue Community Benefit District (CBD). Both items were passed with positive recommendations to the full Board of Supervisors. Discussion Items Item 1: MOU Amendment with CERTNA - Holly Lung, Manager of Legislative Affairs for the Office of Assessor Recorder, presented a resolution to amend the MOU with CERTNA. The amendment extends the agreement through January 10, 2035, and increases the per-title recording cost from $0.30 to $0.34. The cost increase is estimated at $5,000–$7,000 annually based on historical document volumes (average 160,000 over 10 years, 118,000 over 3 years). Currently, about 75% of recordings are electronic, with nearly 800 entities submitting electronically. The alternative provider, Secure, would require a $100,000 buy-in fee and renegotiation of nearly 800 MOUs, creating a significant burden. The committee unanimously approved sending the item to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Ocean Avenue Community Benefit District Renewal and Expansion - Jackie Hazelwood, Program Director of Community Benefit Districts at OEWD, presented the resolution of intention to renew and expand the Ocean Avenue CBD for a second 15-year term. The CBD, formed in 2010, underwent a strategic plan in 2021 and a Controller's audit in FY 2022-23 that produced 19 recommendations. The audit was closed in July 2024 after recommendations were addressed. The district met the 30% property owner threshold in March 2025. The renewal includes a small expansion to include Lakeside Village, a commercial corridor currently not covered. The balloting period begins May 23, 2025, and concludes at a committee of the whole on July 8, 2025. If approved, services would commence in January 2026. Services include cleaning, maintenance, graffiti removal, and marketing. Public Comments & Testimony - Kath Sakalakis, representing Lakeside Village, spoke in support of the expansion, noting that the CBD's cleaning and graffiti removal services have been effective since they started working with the Ocean Avenue Association in July 2023. She emphasized the difficulty of fundraising for maintenance and the desire to spread fixed costs over a larger area. - Christian Martin, Executive Director of the Ocean Avenue Association, expressed support for the renewal and highlighted community collaboration. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send Item 1 (MOU Amendment with CERTNA) to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send Item 2 (Ocean Avenue CBD Resolution of Intention) to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report with a positive recommendation. - The next steps for the CBD include ballots mailed on May 23, 2025, and counting at the committee of the whole on July 8, 2025.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Budget and Finance Committee met on April 30, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Member Joel Engardio. The committee considered 17 agenda items involving contracts, grants, leases, and policy changes. All items were approved with positive recommendations, including two amendments, and will be forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors on May 6, 2025. Public comment was limited to one minute per speaker due to the length of the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 5 & 6 (Homebridge IHSS contracts): Lupe Martinez from SEIU 2015 expressed support for home care providers at Homebridge, urging the committee to secure livable wages as contract negotiations are ongoing. - Item 10 (HealthRight 360 amendment): Griffin Lee from Connected SF opposed full approval, recommending a one-year contract term due to recent scrutiny and staffing concerns at HealthRight 360. Brad Burke shared a personal testimony crediting HealthRight 360 with saving his life, expressing gratitude. A third speaker, a union ironworker and former homeless individual, also praised the program for helping him overcome addiction. Discussion Items - Item 3 (Ocean Beach Climate Adaptation Project): The SFPUC requested an amendment to the design contract with Moffatt & Nichol-AGS JV, increasing the not-to-exceed amount from $5.75 million to $12.75 million and extending the term by six years. The increase was driven by Coastal Commission mandated design changes (including additional restrooms, trail outlooks, and dune habitat mitigation) and the complexity of coordinating multiple stakeholders (city agencies, National Park Service, San Francisco Zoo). The BLA recommended approval. The committee approved unanimously. - Item 4 (Transmission Pipelines Engineering Contract): The SFPUC requested an amendment with AECOM Technical Services, increasing the contract from $7 million to $14 million (no term change) for three pipeline projects (San Joaquin Valve, Moccasin Powerhouse Bypass, Moccasin Penstock Rehabilitation). The increase was due to unforeseen conditions and aging infrastructure, with the capital plan for these projects growing from $299.4 million to $670.3 million. Supervisor Engardio asked detailed technical questions about design changes and safety features. The BLA recommended approval. The committee approved unanimously. - Items 5 & 6 (Homebridge IHSS Contracts): HSA presented two resolutions: a new four-year contract (Item 5) worth $158.4 million and an amendment (Item 6) adding $2.4 million to the existing contract for the remainder of FY2024-2025. Discussion centered on performance metrics—Homebridge met most objectives but fell short on authorized hours served (55% vs 65% target) and client survey response rates. Supervisor Chan proposed approving the new contract but releasing only the first year's funding ($39.6 million) and requiring annual reporting on performance. HSA and the City Attorney confirmed the feasibility. The committee approved Item 5 as amended (reduced not-to-exceed to $39.6 million) and Item 6 without amendment. - Items 9 (Community Forward SF – A Woman’s Place): DPH requested a three-year extension and $19.8 million increase (new total $42 million) for mental health, substance abuse, and transitional housing services. Director Sai noted strong performance and ongoing efforts to improve contract oversight. The BLA reported the transitional housing program lacks defined objectives but recommended approval. Supervisor Chan encouraged cross-departmental coordination for women’s services. Approved unanimously. - Item 10 (HealthRight 360 Amendment): DPH requested a three-year extension and $141.4 million increase (new total $305 million) for substance abuse and mental health services. HealthRight 360 provides about 75% of the city’s residential treatment beds. Director Sai detailed recent safety improvements (e.g., hourly bed checks, drug-free environment enforcement) and emphasized the need for multi-year contracts to maintain staffing. Vice Chair Dorsey expressed strong support, citing HealthRight 360’s recovery-oriented programs and apprenticeship pipeline. The BLA noted high exits from outpatient programs and data collection issues but overall good performance. Approved unanimously. - Items 11 & 12 (ATM Leases at SFO): The airport requested approval of three-year leases with Bank of America (minimum guarantee $250,000/year) and Wells Fargo ($350,000/year). Both were competitively bid. Approved unanimously. - Items 13 & 14 (Homekey+ Grant Applications): MOHCD and HSH presented applications for $18 million (835 Turk Street) and $32.5 million (1035 Van Ness Avenue) for permanent supportive housing. The Van Ness amount was amended to $37.5 million based on additional eligible costs. Both projects target formerly homeless individuals with behavioral health challenges, with 835 Turk providing 106 units and Van Ness providing 124 units. Approved unanimously after amendment. - Items 15-17 (Balboa Reservoir Grants): MOHCD presented three resolutions to accept state grants for affordable housing at Balboa Reservoir: Building E AHSC ($29.6 million), Building A AHSC ($45.7 million), and a combined Infill Infrastructure Grant ($20.1 million). These will fund 287 affordable units and associated transportation/infrastructure improvements. Construction on Building E is expected fall 2025. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - All 17 agenda items were approved by a 3-0 vote (Chan, Dorsey, Engardio). - Amendments: Item 5 (Homebridge new contract) was amended to reduce the not-to-exceed amount to $39.6 million (first year only), with the remaining contract years subject to annual review. Item 14 (Van Ness Homekey+) was amended to increase the grant request to $37.5 million. - Next Steps: Items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on May 6, 2025. For items 13 and 14, the city will submit applications to the state by May 30, 2025, and return to the board for accept-and-expend legislation if awarded.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee (Chair Connie Chan, Vice Chair Matt Dorsey, members Joe Engardio, Shamann Walton, and President Rafael Mandelman) convened on April 30, 2025, to hear a performance audit of the San Francisco Police Department's overtime expenditures and to consider a supplemental appropriation ordinance. The hearing was introduced by Supervisor Walton and co-sponsored by Supervisor Fielder. The committee heard presentations from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) and from SFPD leadership, followed by public testimony and a vote on the ordinance. Discussion Items - BLA Audit Presentation (Nick Menard): The audit covered FY2018-2023. Key findings: SFPD overtime tripled during the period, while sworn staffing decreased by 21%. Sick leave per officer increased 77%. Only 12% of officers accounted for 32% of all overtime hours. 13% of overtime cards had approval errors (missing signatures, self-approval). 51,000 hours of 10B (privately funded) overtime were worked by officers who should have been ineligible under the MOU due to excessive sick leave. The BLA made 29 recommendations (26 agreed to by SFPD, 14 partially agreed, 3 disagreed). The audit also noted that special initiatives (Union Square Safe Shopper, Tenderloin Triangle, tourism) cost $30.8 million without clear performance metrics. - SFPD Response (Dr. Diana Oliva Roche, Assistant Chief David Lazar): SFPD acknowledged the audit and reported it had already implemented or made significant progress on 85% of the recommendations since the audit period. They formed an overtime compliance unit, launched an overtime dashboard, and improved backfill tracking. They disagreed with recommendations on flexible watch assignments and tying fitness awards to sick leave, citing morale and operational concerns. Assistant Chief Lazar emphasized that the department is 525 officers short of the recommended 2,074 and that unprecedented staffing shortages drive overtime. He highlighted that crime is down (e.g., 22-year low in car break-ins) but argued that overtime is necessary for public safety. - Sheriff’s Department Presentation (Patrick Laring): The sheriff requested a $30 million overtime transfer plus $1 million for building maintenance, funded partly by $5.4 million from the General Reserve. The sheriff noted improved hiring (30 new deputies), but a 65% increase in jail population since July 2023 has driven overtime. The jail population is now around 1,200-1,300. The department de-appropriated capital projects (bus, fire panels) to offset costs, and increased revenue from U.S. Marshals. - Committee Debate: Supervisors expressed frustration with recurring overtime shortfalls and mismanagement. Supervisor Walton questioned why only a small percentage of officers work most overtime and how officers can call in sick then work 10B. Supervisor Fielder criticized the 10B program as a “rent-a-cop” system that pulls officers from neighborhoods for private entities. She noted the audit found 51,000 hours of MOU-violating 10B work. Supervisor Dorsey acknowledged the staffing crisis but stressed that mismanagement undermines public trust. President Mandelman asked about verifying improvement and noted that the department must fix the problem to justify continued funding. Chair Chan noted the police budget has grown to nearly $850 million and questioned how future growth can be sustained amid city deficits. Public Comments & Testimony - Most speakers opposed the additional overtime funding, citing the audit’s findings of abuse and arguing that money should instead support social services, housing, and community programs. - Several speakers highlighted the double-dipping of sick leave and 10B work, calling it corrupt. - Some speakers pointed to cuts in homeless services, youth programs, and gender-based violence prevention while police overtime receives tens of millions. - A few speakers supported the police but called for accountability. Key Outcomes 1. Hearing on SFPD Overtime Audit (Item 1): The committee voted unanimously (5-0) to hear and file the hearing. 2. Supplemental Appropriation Ordinance (Item 2): The committee adopted amendments (proposed by the Mayor’s Office) that were non-substantive, adjusting line items within the same total appropriation of $92,050,000 ($61M for SFPD overtime, $30M for Sheriff overtime, $1M for building maintenance). The ordinance was then forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation by a unanimous vote (5-0). The motion to forward with a positive recommendation was not seconded.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on April 29, 2025, at 10:15 AM. The meeting began with a roll call (all 11 members present), a land acknowledgement, and the Pledge of Allegiance. The board approved the March 25, 2025 meeting minutes, adopted the consent agenda, and considered a range of routine and high-profile items, including a contentious housing notice ordinance, a massive lease and tenant improvement package, and multiple appeals concerning a proposed project at 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard. The meeting also featured commendations for community members, public comment, and a closed session. Consent Calendar - Items 1–6 (Settlements: Chau Nancy Xiong – $285,000; Jenny Ramirez Valdivia – $75,000; San Francisco Apartment Association et al. – $135,000; Planning Code amendments for 3250 19th Avenue Special Sign District and removal of conditional use for formula retail on Van Ness Avenue; Administrative Code – Content and Data Subscriptions) were adopted unanimously (11–0). Public Comments & Testimony - St. Thomas More School representatives (principal, attorney) asked for a continuance of the 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard appeals to allow more time for negotiations with the golf club. The board later continued those hearings to May 13, 2025. - Paulette Brown (mother of unsolved homicide victim) spoke in support of Supervisor Dorsey’s proposed Homicide Reward Fund reforms, noting that tipsters fear coming forward and that the current reward structure has never paid out. - Multiple speakers (including representatives from the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition, Walk SF, and community members) urged the board to fully fund Vision Zero and safe street infrastructure, citing 200 traffic deaths over five years and $2.5 billion in costs. - Dozens of speakers (including representatives from the Council on American-Islamic Relations, Muslim community leaders, and youth) spoke in support of recognizing April as American Muslim Appreciation and Awareness Month (Item 47), emphasizing the need to combat anti-Muslim bias and highlight contributions. - Several home care workers (from the Home Bridge program) requested additional funding for wages, stating they are essential yet underpaid. - Other speakers addressed the Chinese Railroad Workers Day resolution, library privacy, and veterans’ disability issues. Discussion Items - Unfinished Business – Item 7 (Planning Code – Notice for Housing Element Rezoning): Passed 8–3 (Supervisors Dorsey, Mahmoud, and Melgar voting no) after a roll call vote. The ordinance requires notice of rezoning intended to comply with housing element law. - New Business Items 8–42: Most were adopted without objection or on a single roll call. Key items included: - Item 8: Appropriation of $8.5 million from revenue surplus and $11.8 million for tenant improvements at 1455 Market Street for the Human Services Agency (passed 11–0). - Item 9: Lease amendment with Hudson 1455 Market LLC for 226,000 rentable square feet, initial year base rent $1.9 million, not to exceed $15.5 million for tenant improvements (adopted). - Item 10: Retroactive lease of Adante Hotel (610 Geary Street) for non-congregate shelter (93 units, $1.48 million annual base rent, one-year term with option) (adopted). - Items 12–24: Various grants, contracts, and designations (e.g., $7 million PRO Housing grant, $66.2 million FAA airport grant, $1.07 million scrap metal contract, $30 million and $85 million insurance brokerage contracts, acceptance of a Rivian R1S from Mayor Daniel Lurie valued at $134,106, and HUD grants for ESG, CDBG, HOPWA, and HOME programs) – all adopted. - Item 25: Planning Code amendment eliminating 200-foot buffer for nighttime entertainment in Western SoMa (passed on first reading). - Item 26: Existing Building Code amendment requiring inventory of seismically vulnerable concrete buildings and voluntary retrofit standards (passed on first reading). - Item 27: Sunset Chinese Cultural District’s Cultural, History, Housing, and Economic Sustainability Strategy Report (adopted). - Item 28: Declaration of 772 Pacific Avenue as exempt surplus land for 100% affordable housing (adopted). - Item 29: Administrative Code amendment creating Valencia Street, Ellis Street, and Yerba Buena Lane entertainment zones (passed on first reading). - Item 30: Annual Surveillance Report from 23 city departments (adopted). - Item 31: Appointments to Commission of Animal Control and Welfare (6 members, approved). - Items 32–33: Reappointments of Supervisors Mandelman and Dorsey to the Association of Bay Area Governments Executive Board (approved after excusing the members). - Committee Report – Item 42 (Mission Rock Housing Plan Amendments): Approved reduction of minimum inclusionary affordable housing percentage per phase at Seawall Lot 337 (passed 11–0). - Special Order 2:30 PM – Commendations: The board recognized multiple individuals and groups: - Mark Selby and Angelica Medina Selby (District 7) for 15+ years of volunteer litter cleanup in parks and streets. - La Mea (owner of Temos Cafe, District 9) for creating a community space bridging Palestinian and Latino cultures. - Late Lt. Col. Robert Powell (posthumous, District 4) for 28 years as JROTC instructor at Lincoln High School. - Lincoln High School Mock Trial Team (city champions) and Boys’ Varsity Basketball Team (fourth consecutive section championship). - Ghazi Shami (CEO of Empire, District 5) for building a global independent record label in San Francisco, honoring Arab American Heritage Month. - Saeed and Hisham Basisu (owners of Buffalo Whole Foods and Noe Hill Market, District 8) for operating neighborhood corner stores and continuing their father’s legacy. - Special Order 3:00 PM – Appeals (Items 34–41): The board held hearings on the categorical exemption and conditional use authorization for the 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard project (demolition of nine structures and construction of a 20,000 sq. ft. maintenance building). After public comment, the board voted to continue both hearings to May 13, 2025, without objection. - Roll Call for Introductions: Supervisors introduced new business: - Supervisor Dorsey: Legislation to reform the Homicide Reward Fund (allow rewards upon filing charges, not just conviction; enable anonymous tipsters; end automatic disqualification for prior criminal history). - Supervisor Fielder: Resolution supporting Assembly Bill 670 (counting preservation of affordable housing toward regional housing targets). - Supervisor Mandelman: Hearing request on SFMTA’s EV curbside charging feasibility study and public charging path. - Supervisor Melgar: Hearing request on the BLA report on traffic crash costs and Vision Zero funding. - Supervisor Sauter: Resolution approving port commission lease for 340 Jefferson Street (future Salvadorian restaurant Chasca Rio). - Supervisor Cheryl: Resolution supporting Assembly Bill 1181 (banning PFAS in firefighter turnout gear by 2027). - Supervisor Walton: Added as co-sponsor to Item 49. - Supervisor Chan: Resolution declaring Public Works Week in San Francisco. - Supervisor Chen: Adjourned meeting in memory of Antoinette Jamil. Key Outcomes - Approved (unanimous unless noted): - Consent Agenda items 1–6 (11–0). - Item 7 (Housing Element Rezoning Notice) passed 8–3 (Dorsey, Mahmoud, Melgar opposed). - All new business items 8–42 (most on voice vote or 11–0). - Committee report Item 42 (Mission Rock housing plan) 11–0. - Commendations and appointments (Items 31–33) approved. - Items 46, 48, 49, 51, 52 (for adoption without committee) adopted 11–0. - Item 47 (American Muslim Appreciation and Awareness Month) adopted after being severed, with Supervisor Melgar added as co-sponsor. - Item 50 (Parkinson’s Awareness Month) adopted with an amendment (added “not” to diagnosis clause). - Continued: Appeals at 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard (Items 34–41) were continued to May 13, 2025, after public comment and a motion by Supervisor Melgar (seconded by Walton). - Closed Session: Board convened for existing litigation; no action taken; public disclosure of deliberations was declined. - Next Steps: The May 13, 2025 meeting will reconvene the 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard hearings. The Board will also hold hearings on EV curbside charging (June 2, 2025) and street safety (date TBD).
The Board of Supervisors Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Shimon Walton and joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Sherrow and President Mandelman, met on April 28, 2025, to consider three appointments: two to oversight bodies and one mayoral reappointment to the SFMTA Board. The meeting included public testimony and unanimous votes on all actions. Appointments to Citizens’ General Obligation Bond Oversight Committee - Applicants: Three seats were originally available, but applicant Kate McGee withdrew. Incumbent Andrea Crawford (Seat 1) and new applicant Min Chang (Seat 3) appeared. - Speaker (Andrea Crawford): A District 3 resident and mother, she highlighted her service as the only woman and only African American on the committee, monitoring the 2016 bond portfolio (six components, many projects delayed by COVID but now ramping up). She requested reappointment to see projects through to completion by mid-2026. - Speaker (Min Chang): CEO of nonprofit HomeBridge, managing over 1,100 clients and 540 staff. She cited 36 years of experience, including Fortune 100 and management consulting, and familiarity with budgets and operations. - Public Comment: Tita Bell, aide to Supervisor Sauter, expressed support for Andrea Crawford for continuity. - Outcome: Motion passed unanimously (Chair Walton, Vice Chair Sherrow, President Mandelman ayes) to recommend Andrea Crawford for Seat 1 to the full Board. Seat 3 was continued to the call of the chair. Appointment to Transbay Joint Powers Authority - Applicant: Charlie Lavery appeared; a second applicant was absent. - Speaker (Charlie Lavery): District representative and trustee for the International Union of Operating Engineers. He noted his work on the Transbay project, including negotiating the original PLA for the transit center, and five terms on the TJPA Citizens Advisory Council. He emphasized infrastructure as equity. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Motion to recommend Mr. Lavery with a residency waiver passed unanimously. Mayoral Reappointment to SFMTA Board – Mike Chen - Applicant: Mike Chen, renominated by the mayor for a four-year term. He summarized recent board work: modernizing train dispatch, improving speed cameras, street reconfigurations (Beach, Oak, Valencia), and addressing a $322 million budget deficit (20% of operating budget). He highlighted his prior service on the SFMTA CAC (including two years as chair) and his priorities in outreach, customer experience, and data-driven solutions. - Public Comment: - Support: Bob Akasvandiari (SF Democratic Party), Sam Moss (Mission Housing), SFMTA Board Chair (appeared to support continuity), Thomas Lee (community activist), Robin Pam (Kidsafe SF), Melissa Buckingham Adams (District 1 Muni rider), Brian Kwan (District 1 activist). Supporters cited his empathy, listening skills, multimodal advocacy, and ability to navigate the budget crisis. - Opposition: Griffin Lee (DT Unite) expressed concern about Mike Chen being lobbied by contracted groups (e.g., SF Bike Coalition) and called for a stronger financial background to address the $320 million deficit, particularly considering West Side residents. - Outcome: Motion to strike the rejecting language and forward Chen’s reappointment with a positive recommendation passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Andrea Crawford recommended to full Board for Citizens’ GO Bond Oversight Committee (Seat 1); Seat 3 continued. - Charlie Lavery recommended to full Board for Transbay Joint Powers Authority, with residency waiver. - Mike Chen’s reappointment to SFMTA Board approved for forwarding to full Board.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 28, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Jayan Chen and Supervisor Bilalma Mahmood. The committee considered five agenda items: amendments to the Mission Rock Housing Plan, establishment of the Alexandria Theater Special Use District, condominium conversion of accessory dwelling units, and landmark designations for two early residential historic districts in the Mission Dolores neighborhood. Public comment was heard on each item, including repeated calls for attention to the former Safeway site in the Fillmore. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Mission Rock): A speaker expressed general approval of the item but used the opportunity to lobby for community engagement on the Fillmore Safeway redevelopment. - Item 2 (Alexandria Theater): The same speaker reiterated lobbying for the Fillmore Safeway site, demanding more community involvement. - Item 3 (ADU Condominium Conversion): Ivy Vogen (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods) urged the committee to accept amendments proposed by the Anti-Displacement Coalition and continue the item to June 2, 2025, noting the controversial nature of state enabling legislation AB 1033. Mitchell Omerberg (Affordable Housing Alliance and Anti-Displacement Coalition) expressed hope that continued collaboration could lead to legislation not opposed by tenant groups. The recurring speaker again raised the Fillmore Safeway issue. - Items 4 & 5 (Historic Districts): Peter Lewis, founder and past president of the Mission Dolores Neighborhood Association (MDNA), thanked the committee and described 20 years of work to protect historic resources, emphasizing that the association is not opposed to new housing. The new president of MDNA also voiced support, noting 300,000 annual visitors to Mission Dolores. Discussion Items - Item 1 (250264): Mission Rock Housing Plan Amendments – Wyatt Donnelly Landold (Port Commission) presented amendments to reduce the minimum percentage of inclusionary affordable housing per phase from 30% to 20% (actual phase one percentage 24.8%). The change responds to weak demand for 150% AMI units; at Parcel F (Verde), 77% of 90% AMI units were leased, while only 39% of 150% units were leased. The proposal increases 90% AMI units at Parcel A from 10 to 19, maintains 54 at 120% AMI, and eliminates 150% AMI units. No tenants are displaced; they will receive lower rents. Supervisor Melgar clarified that the developer’s overall 40% affordability obligation remains unchanged, and the change is revenue-neutral. Supervisor Chen noted that 150% AMI units have historically struggled to lease. - Item 2 (241198): Alexandria Theater Special Use District – Robin Burke (Supervisor Chan’s office) presented legislation to create a Special Use District at the northwest corner of Geary and 18th Avenue, allowing up to eight stories with 75 two- to three-bedroom units, including 12% on-site affordable housing. The project requires preservation of historic elements (facade, blade sign, marquee, sunburst chandelier, murals). A non-substantive amendment was added to require two public hearings (Planning Commission and Historic Preservation Commission) for any density bonus application. The project team (architects, attorney, property owner) expressed commitment to submit a project application quickly. Supervisor Chen expressed regret that the city could not acquire the site for 100% affordable housing but deferred to the district supervisor. - Item 3 (241069): Condominium Conversion of Accessory Dwelling Units – Supervisor Myrna Sugario, the sponsor, reported that the legislation had been amended to incorporate planning department recommendations and that stakeholder discussions were ongoing. The committee continued the item to the call of the chair to allow further negotiations on tenant protections. - Items 4 & 5 (250297, 250298): Landmark Designations – Chula-Abbey and Alert Alley Early Residential Historic Districts – Supervisor Rafael Mandelman (Board President) introduced the resolutions to initiate the landmark process for two districts in the Mission Dolores neighborhood, comprising 53 contributing properties. The districts reflect pre-1906 and post-earthquake development eras. Rich Sucre (Deputy Director, San Francisco Planning) noted extensive community outreach, including forums in June and December 2024 and a virtual forum in January 2025. The process will continue with Historic Preservation Commission and Planning Commission reviews before returning to the Board of Supervisors. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to recommend the resolution as a committee report to the full Board of Supervisors for April 29, 2025, passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2: Motion to adopt the non-substantive amendment and recommend the ordinance as amended to the Board of Supervisors passed unanimously (3-0). (Note: The item was not on the committee report agenda, so it will not go to the board on April 29.) - Item 3: Motion to continue the ordinance to the call of the chair passed unanimously (3-0). - Items 4 & 5: Motion to recommend both resolutions to the Board of Supervisors with positive recommendation passed unanimously (3-0).
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 24, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey with Vice Chair Bill Mahmood and Supervisor Danny Sauter. The committee considered three items: a routine liquor license transfer, a proposed ordinance to establish a "Recovery First" substance use disorder treatment policy, and a required hearing on the Tenderloin Retail Hours Restriction Pilot Program. All items were advanced or continued unanimously after extensive public testimony. Consent Calendar - Liquor License Transfer – Far East Cafe Social Club (627 Grant Avenue): The committee approved the transfer of a Type 48 on‑sale general liquor license to Far East Cafe Inc. for the space next door, which has been vacant for several years. SFPD reported zero calls for service and no letters of protest. Standard conditions were attached. Supervisor Sauter noted community and planning support. The committee voted unanimously to prepare a resolution finding public convenience or necessity and forward it to the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony - Recovery First Ordinance (Item 2): Over 70 members of the public spoke, reflecting deep division. Supporters, including former Supervisor Bill Maher, recovery program clients (from Positive Direction, Harbor Light, Salvation Army), and community groups (Connected SF, the Joseph McPhee Center), argued that abstinence and long‑term recovery must be the city’s primary goal. They cited personal stories of successful sobriety and criticized harm reduction as enabling. Opponents, including physicians, harm‑reduction providers (SF AIDS Foundation, Harm Reduction Therapy Center, Glide, Skywatchers), and individuals with lived experience, stressed that recovery is non‑linear and that harm reduction keeps people alive long enough to seek treatment. They warned that an abstinence‑only focus would increase stigma, push people into risky behaviors, and lead to more deaths. Several speakers called for housing first and more treatment capacity. The San Francisco Marin Medical Society voiced conditional support after amendments incorporating a broader definition of recovery. - Tenderloin Retail Hours Pilot (Item 3): More than 20 speakers, mostly Tenderloin residents, community organizers (Chinatown CDC, Central City SRO Collaborative, Tenderloin Community Benefit District), and business representatives, emphatically supported continuing the pilot. They described dramatic improvements in noise, trash, drug activity, and safety. A few speakers requested the program be expanded to other problem areas such as 6th Street. No opposition was voiced during the hearing. Discussion Items - Recovery First Substance Use Disorder Treatment Policy (Ordinance 250190): Supervisor Dorsey introduced amendments crafted with the San Francisco Marin Medical Society to broaden definitions of “remission” and “recovery,” explicitly including medication‑assisted treatment, contingency management, and other evidence‑based approaches. The amendments changed the title and long title to “Recovery First Substance Use Disorder Treatment Policy” and set “long‑term remission of substance use disorders for individuals” as the primary goal. Dorsey read a support letter from Chief Health, Homelessness, and Family Services Kunal Modi. After public comment, the committee voted unanimously to accept the amendments and then to forward the amended ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Status Update – Tenderloin Retail Hours Restriction Pilot Program (Hearing 250272): Commander Derek Liu and Dr. Diana Arroche of SFPD presented data showing a 13 % reduction in overall reported crime in the Tenderloin district and an 18 % drop in total calls for service (dispatched plus on‑view) within the pilot zone between midnight and 5 a.m. Heat maps illustrated reduced crime intensity. Photos showed cleared sidewalks at formerly problematic corners. The Department of Public Health reported eight violations at five businesses, with fines and referrals to the City Attorney. Commander Liu recommended maintaining the pilot because lifting it would risk a return to previous conditions. Vice Chair Mahmood and Supervisor Sauter asked about displacement (noted on 6th Street) and the feasibility of expanding the program. No action was taken beyond receiving the report. Key Outcomes - Liquor License Transfer: Motion to prepare a resolution of public convenience/necessity and forward it to the full Board passed 3‑0 (Dorsey, Mahmood, Sauter). - Recovery First Ordinance: Motion to accept amendments passed 3‑0; motion to forward amended ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation passed 3‑0. - Tenderloin Retail Hours Pilot: Motion to continue the hearing to the call of the chair passed 3‑0. No further action was taken on the pilot itself.
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan with Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Member Joel Engardio, met on April 23, 2025, to consider 17 agenda items including leases, grants, contracts, technology plans, and other fiscal matters. All items except one were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. No public speakers appeared for any item. Consent Calendar (Routine Approvals) - Item 1: Retroactive lease with ROSHAN INVESTMENTS LLC for the Adante Hotel (610 Geary Street) as a non-congregate temporary shelter (93 units) for one year starting April 1, 2025, with annual base rent of $1,484,280, 3% annual increases, and a maximum surrender payment of $100,000. Approved unanimously. - Item 2: Appropriation of $8.5 million from projected revenue surplus, deappropriation of $3.3 million from capital projects at 1235 Mission Street, and total appropriation of $11,846,898 for tenant improvements and furniture at 1455 Market Street for the Human Services Agency. Approved unanimously. - Items 6-9: Resolutions for HUD grant programs for FY2025-2026: Emergency Solutions Grants ($1,868,094), Community Development Block Grant ($25,967,476 plus estimated program income of $5.85 million), Housing Opportunities for Persons with AIDS ($8,202,000), and HOME Investment Partnership ($7,360,416). All approved unanimously. - Items 11-12: Designation of outreach and official newspapers for FY2025-2026, including the San Francisco Examiner as the official daily newspaper. Approved unanimously. - Item 13: Five-year revenue contract with Circosta Iron and Metal Co., Inc. for sale of city-owned scrap metal, with estimated revenue of up to $1,069,575. Approved unanimously. - Items 14-15: Three-year insurance brokerage service contracts with Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. ($30 million not to exceed) and Alliant Insurance Services ($85 million not to exceed) for property insurance premiums. Approved unanimously. - Item 17: Retroactive acceptance of an in-kind gift from Mayor Daniel Lurie of a zero-emission Rivian R1S vehicle (estimated value $134,106) for official city business, primarily for mayor's transportation. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke on any agenda item during the meeting. Discussion Items - Item 3 (PRO Housing Grant): The Planning Department presented a $7 million HUD grant (retroactive to January 2025) to remove housing barriers, supporting activities to unlock 13,000 affordable units, preserve affordable housing, expand housing types in high-opportunity neighborhoods, and implement outreach. The Budget and Legislative Analyst recommended approval and suggested a future hearing on outcomes. The committee approved forwarding to full board. - Item 4 (Airport Infrastructure Grant): SFO requested acceptance of a $66.3 million FAA Airport Infrastructure Grant for the Boarding Area G Gates Enhancement Project (total project cost $143 million). Airport will provide $76.7 million matching funds from general airport revenue bonds. SFO confirmed a backup plan if federal funds are not dispersed. Approved. - Item 5 (Calpine Energy Solutions Contract): The SFPUC presented a competitively procured $17 million, three-year contract for CleanPowerSF billing, data management, and customer care services (15% cheaper than previous contract). Includes $200,000 in community benefits. Approved. - Item 10 (Five-Year ICT Plan, FY2025-2030): The Committee on Information Technology (COIT) presented the plan detailing goals to modernize digital operations, improve online services, and enhance accessibility. Key initiatives include replacing legacy systems, cloud migration, data sharing, moving services to SF.gov, and emerging technology. Projected technology investment over five years is $181.9 million, down 22% from the previous plan, while department requests total $201.9 million. COIT recommended increasing allocation to pre-COVID levels and creating new funding models. Discussion included questions on progress of the Justice system (30-year-old project) and the SF.gov migration deadline (2029). The committee expressed support but requested more details during the budget process. Approved forwarding to full board. - Item 16 (CEC Charging Infrastructure Grant): The City Administrator's Office presented a grant from the California Energy Commission for charging infrastructure for government fleets. The resolution was amended to increase the grant amount to $5,047,167 and specify city matching funds of $2,828,859 from various sources (including $540,000 from general fund capital plan and $1.3 million from existing fleet management budget). The item was continued to the April 30, 2025 meeting. Key Outcomes - Items 1-15 and 17: All forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors on April 29, 2025, with positive recommendations (unanimous votes by Chair Chan, Vice Chair Dorsey, and Member Engardio). - Item 16: Continued to the April 30, 2025 Budget and Finance Committee meeting after amendments to increase grant amount and specify matching funds were accepted.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a regular meeting on April 23, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan. The committee heard two major items: a five-year financial plan update and a detailed review of proposed funding reductions for community development programs, including civil legal services, gender-based violence services, and community building. The meeting featured extensive public testimony from over 70 speakers, many of whom shared personal stories of how proposed cuts would impact their lives. Discussion Items Item 1: Five-Year Financial Plan Update and Mayor's Budget Instructions The committee heard from Mayor's Budget Director Sophia Kitler and the Controller's Office. The March 2025 update showed an $817.5 million shortfall over the next two years, an improvement of $58.5 million from the December 2024 report, but with continued structural deficits exceeding $1 billion over five years. Key revenue changes included increased business tax projections (14% rise in worldwide sales), lower hotel and sales tax forecasts, and reduced FEMA reimbursement expectations. The Mayor's office has instructed departments to reduce the structural deficit by about one-third. Director Kitler noted significant uncertainty from federal policy changes, including potential impacts on Medicaid, food stamps, and immigration enforcement rhetoric damaging hotel tax. The Mayor's office is using four levers: reviewing federal grants, essential contracts, vacancies, and as a last resort, filled positions. Supervisor Walton asked whether the state's May revise would bring good news; Director Kitler responded "I wouldn't count on it." The committee voted 5-0 to hear and file the item. Item 2: Funding for Community Collaboration, Community Building, Domestic Violence, Financial Capability, and General Legal Services The committee heard from Dan Adams, Director of the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD), and Deputy Director Julia Savori. MOHCD manages community development programs funded primarily through general fund (38% of total grant making). The department received 300 proposals totaling $198 million in requests, nearly double available funding. After initial budget reductions and additional cuts, the department reduced an $11 million reduction target to roughly $5 million by eliminating 11 positions and moving programs to off-budget sources. Key recommendations: maintaining flat funding for immigrant legal services, eviction prevention, and gender-based violence services; but eliminating funding for general civil legal services, financial literacy, and community building portfolios. The department acknowledged additional reduction targets of about $2 million received the prior week, with no proposal yet on how to address them. Supervisor Chen noted District 11 would be disproportionately impacted, with 95% of clients extremely low-income, 71% primarily non-English speaking, and 61% over age 60. Supervisor Engardio stressed the importance of looking beyond neighborhood facades and the cost-effectiveness of early legal intervention. Supervisor Walton asked about conversations with the Mayor's office for restoration; Director Adams said they are in frequent conversation but have no full view of overall budget dynamics. The committee voted 5-0 to hear and file the item. Public Comments & Testimony Over 70 members of the public testified, the majority opposing the proposed cuts. Key themes: - General Civil Legal Services: Speakers from Open Door Legal, Justice and Diversity Center, Bay Area Legal Aid, and others testified that cutting these services would increase homelessness and cost the city more in the long run. Several clients shared stories of how free legal aid prevented eviction, secured benefits, or stopped domestic violence. One speaker noted that each homeless individual costs $80,000 per year, while preventing homelessness through legal aid costs far less. Open Door Legal faces a $2.2 million cut (one-third of its budget), which would force layoffs of 15 attorneys and close at least one office, reducing client representation by 900 per year. - Gender-Based Violence Services: Speakers from the Cooperative Restraining Order Clinic (CROC), St. James Infirmary legacy programs, Lion Martin Community Health Services, Freedom Forward, and others described cuts to restraining order legal services, street outreach to sex workers, and youth trafficking prevention. CROC's coordinating attorney said 516 domestic violence survivors and their children would lose legal services. The sex worker outreach program (late-night van) faced a $500,000 cut, jeopardizing the only program of its kind for black and brown trans sex workers. Freedom Forward's Hype Center, the only drop-in center preventing commercial sexual exploitation for youth 14-24, would lose 85% of its budget. Several survivors testified that CROC helped them obtain restraining orders that saved their lives. - Community Building and Financial Capability: Speakers from Soma Pilipinas, the Latino Parity and Equity Coalition, and the LGBT Center emphasized that community building grants are essential infrastructure for organizing, cultural preservation, and coordinating services. The Filipino community described how community building funds supported language classes, anti-displacement work, and cultural events. Financial coaching programs at the LGBT Center and others would be eliminated, affecting clients working toward financial stability. - Workforce Development: Joe Wilson from Hospitality House urged prioritizing neighborhood job centers and earn-and-learn programs, noting that the locus of suffering is concentrated in six to eight zip codes. - Public Safety: A police officer testified that he gives referral cards to CROC and other services, and cutting them would undermine his ability to help victims. Key Outcomes - The committee voted 5-0 to hear and file both agenda items. - Chair Chan noted that this hearing is a start, and further budget hearings will follow as the Mayor proposes his budget by June 1, 2025. - Supervisor Chan stated the committee shares a commitment to preventing homelessness and that civil legal services are critical. She urged continued dialogue with the Mayor's office and community partners. - The committee acknowledged the unprecedented fiscal uncertainty at the federal level and the need to protect the city's most vulnerable residents.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, April 22, 2025, for a regular meeting that began at 11:30 a.m. and adjourned at 4:14 p.m. The meeting was dominated by tributes to outgoing Commission President Kimberly Brandon, who served 28 years, and also included votes on a consent calendar and a new restaurant lease. Consent Calendar - Item 7A: Approved the Port’s 10-Year Capital Plan for Fiscal Years 2026 to 2035. - Item 7B: Approved a 30-month lease agreement for arts and culture activation at Pier 29 with CAST at Large, LLC (Community Arts Stabilization Trust). - Item 7C: Approved a Mutual Termination Agreement with Scoma’s Restaurant, subject to Board of Supervisors approval. - Item 7D: Approved a Settlement Agreement with Castagnola Restaurant, resolving all balances due. The port will receive $300,000, with terms including rent waivers and reopening requirements. All consent items passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony During the recognition of Commissioner Brandon, multiple individuals spoke in support of her legacy: - Port staff and community members (David Beaupre, Dan Hodap, Alice Rogers, Byron Rhett, and others) praised her commitment to equity, community engagement, and the Southern Waterfront. - Lieutenant Governor Elena Kounalakis (remote) highlighted her trailblazing role as the first African American woman on the commission. - Timothy Allen Simon commended her work to promote economic opportunity despite Proposition 209 limitations. - Diane Oshima (remote) credited her with transforming the waterfront vision. - Commissioner Brandon’s father spoke of her lifelong dedication to San Francisco. Discussion Items - Item 8A: Approved a new 10-year lease with two 5-year options for 340 Jefferson Street Partners, LLC, for a restaurant space at 340 Jefferson Street (former Pompeii’s Grotto). The operator, Chasca Rio, will serve Salvadoran cuisine. Financial terms: base rent $10,395/month (Year 1), 3% annual increases, 5.5% percentage rent. Port will provide $470,000 in tenant improvement allowance from the ARPA Tenant Attraction and Retention Fund. The lease includes a port option to terminate if gross sales do not reach approximately $2.1 million by the end of the third year. The item was approved unanimously. Recognition of Outgoing Commission President Kimberly Brandon - Executive Director Elaine Forbes delivered a comprehensive tribute, noting Brandon’s 28 years of service, her role as the first African American woman on the commission, and her longest tenure since 1968. Forbes credited Brandon with mentoring staff, championing community advisory committees, advancing equity in contracting, and leading major projects (e.g., Cruise Terminal Plaza, Crane Cove Park, Mission Rock, Pier 70, resilience partnership with Army Corps). - Commissioners and staff shared personal reflections, emphasizing her preparation, patience, and advocacy for justice and inclusion. - Commissioner Brandon responded with gratitude, noting her confidence in the commission’s future and pledging to remain engaged. - A proclamation from Supervisor Shamann Walton was read honoring her service. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar items 7A–7D approved unanimously. - Item 8A (340 Jefferson Street lease) approved unanimously. - Commissioner Willie Adams requested an update on Pier 45 development; staff noted the item is on the forward calendar and a briefing will be scheduled. - Meeting adjourned at 4:14 p.m.