The Budget and Appropriations Committee (Chair Connie Chan, Supervisors Shamann Walton, Joel Engardio, and Board President Rafael Mandelman sitting in for excused Vice Chair Matt Dorsey) held a hearing to receive the San Francisco Youth Commission's budget and policy priorities for fiscal years 2025–2026 and 2026–2027. The Commission, composed of 17 youth appointees, presented a comprehensive set of budget and policy priorities developed through extensive community outreach, acknowledging the city's near $1 billion budget deficit and the challenging federal administration. The supervisors expressed gratitude and committed to considering the recommendations during the upcoming budget process. Public Comments & Testimony - Harper Fortgang, District 8 Youth Commissioner, expressed strong support for the climate budget priorities, urging acceleration of electrification, expansion of climate resilience, and strengthening climate literacy in schools. They specifically asked for funding for SF Environment's education program and a district-wide climate action day. - Ava Orham, mayoral appointee to the Youth Commission, expressed strong support for the continuation and expansion of free Muni for youth, emphasizing its necessity for equity, reducing financial burdens, and promoting transit use. - Emily Yang, mayoral appointee to the Youth Commission, urged support for youth workforce and employment programs, citing personal experience and the value of vocational pathways, especially for youth in underserved areas. - Adrianna Zhang, former Youth Commission chair, advocated for taking youth commissioners seriously and asked for engagement with MTA regarding respectful fare inspectors for youth. Discussion Items - The Youth Commission, led by Chair Jason Fong, presented their budget and policy priorities: 1) Increase civic engagement (pre-registration, lower voting age to 16), 2) Reduce social isolation, 3) Address food insecurity in schools (central kitchen, school food advisory), 4) Support in-school youth development programs (mental health, substance abuse, academic support), 5) Address hate crimes (police staffing, transit safety), 6) Climate resilience and literacy (electrification, respite locations, green schoolyards), 7) Housing (education workforce housing, TAY housing, affordable housing, rent control, SRO conditions), 8) Street safety and vision zero (no turn on red, slow streets, car-free spaces), 9) Transit (maintain school tripper, preserve reliability, fund free Muni), 10) Youth employment (pathways, programs in underserved areas, systemic barriers), 11) Improve police relations with youth (trainings, SFPAL), 12) Address sexual assault and harassment in schools (background checks, Title IX advisory group), 13) Reduce youth weapon access (violence prevention, safe storage, buybacks), 14) Undocumented family protections (sanctuary city, legal support, higher education cooperation). - Supervisor Walton asked how the Commission shares priorities with the school district; the Commission noted difficulty due to lack of a staffed student advisory council but have communicated with the superintendent and had a school board commissioner attend a meeting. - Supervisor Engardio suggested the Commission present directly to the school board and MTA board, and expressed interest in trade school concepts and job fairs. - Chair Chan informed the Commission that a $160 million school bond including $22 million for central kitchen and school nutrition had passed the budget committee, and reaffirmed the Board of Supervisors' unanimous support for sanctuary city status, rent control fights, and partnerships with City College. She committed to sharing the recommendations with the mayor and throughout the budget process. Key Outcomes - The committee voted 4-0 to excuse Vice Chair Matt Dorsey from the meeting. - The committee voted 4-0 to hear and file the hearing on the Youth Commission's budget priorities. - Supervisors committed to using the recommendations as a roadmap during the budget process and to advocate with other city bodies on youth priorities.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on March 18, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Shamann Walton. (Note: the official agenda and transcript date the meeting as Monday, March 17, 2025.) The committee considered items on its regular agenda, including a proposed Entertainment Zone in the Castro, an appointment to the Transbay Joint Powers Authority, and three appointments to the Commission on Community Investment and Infrastructure (CCII). The meeting adjourned without reaching the items listed under the 30-day rule. Public Comments & Testimony - On the Castro Upper Market Entertainment Zone (Item 1), the public was overwhelmingly supportive. Speakers included Chris Hastings (Lookout), Andrea Aiello (Castro Community Benefit District), Paul Miller, Terry Aston Bennett (Castro Merchants/Cliffs Variety), Sean Vergara and Tiffany Chung (Detour/Blackbird), and a representative of the Civic Joy Fund. They expressed that the zone is a vital lifeline for struggling small businesses post-pandemic, will keep alcohol sales revenue local during street closures, and will enhance neighborhood vibrancy. One speaker opposed the zone, arguing the city shows more urgency for business profits than for helping homeless individuals. - On the CCII appointments (Items 3-5), District 6 resident Leah McGeever spoke, reading excerpts from an SF Bayview article on gentrification in the Bayview and urging the commission to prioritize long-term community residents in future development. Discussion Items 1. Castro Upper Market Entertainment Zone (File 250126) Supervisor Rafael Mandelman introduced an ordinance to establish the Castro Upper Market Entertainment Zone, the fourth such zone in San Francisco after Front Street, Thrive City, and Coal Valley. The zone would allow bars and restaurants within the designated footprint on streets like 18th, Castro, Market, Church, 14th, and Noe to sell alcohol for outdoor consumption during street closures. The goal is to stimulate local businesses and cultural events, such as night markets. Supervisor Mandelman introduced a small amendment to add a half-block of 16th Street to the zone boundaries, noting the amendment made the item substantive, requiring a continuance before a final vote. 2. Transbay Joint Powers Authority Appointment (File 250202) Supervisor Mandelman presented two applicants: Charlie Lavery (Operating Engineers) and John Doherty (IBEW Local 6). Mr. Lavery was unable to attend and requested a continuance to allow internal labor discussions. 3. Successor Agency Commission (CCII) Appointments (Files 250204, 250205, 250206) The committee heard from three nominees for the Commission on Community Investment and Infrastructure: - Dr. Carolyn Ransom-Scott (Reappointment): Highlighted progress on shipyard cleanup, affordable housing development, and job training opportunities. - Earl Shaddix (listed as Earl Shaddex in the agenda text and introduced as Earl Shaddocks during testimony): Executive Director of EDOT, a Bayview/Hunters Point resident advocating for equitable small business outcomes. - Mark Miller (Appointment): Retired city manager and public works director, passionate about community service and bringing relevant expertise to the commission. OCII Executive Director Thor Kozlovsky praised all three nominees for their high caliber and commitment. Key Outcomes - Castro Upper Market Entertainment Zone (250126): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt Supervisor Mandelman's amendment. The item was continued to the next Rules Committee meeting on March 24, 2025 for a final vote. - Transbay Joint Powers Authority (250202): The committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the call of the chair. - CCII Appointments (250204, 250205, 250206): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to approve the nominations of Dr. Carolyn Ransom-Scott, Earl Shaddix, and Mark Miller, forwarding them to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Tuesday, March 18, 2025, at 10:15 AM in City Hall. The meeting covered a wide range of legislative and ceremonial items, including a debated suspension of the Empty Homes Tax, approval of consent items, public commendations for Women's History Month, and continuance of two special-order hearings. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (February 11, 2025): Approved 11-0. - Voluntary Disclosure Program (Item 1): Ordinance to amend business tax code; passed 11-0. - CalWORKs Housing Support Program (Item 3): Appropriation of $4,956,133; passed on first reading. - Airport Leases (Items 4-5): Lease modifications for FBI and Michael C. Mitchell; adopted. - Technology Marketplace Contract Amendments (Items 6-9): Four contract increases totaling over $242 million; adopted. - Settlement – Hotel Des Arts (Items 10 & 27): Settlement allowing conversion of 38 residential hotel rooms at 447 Bush Street to tourist rooms in exchange for creating 34 residential hotel rooms elsewhere; passed on first reading. - Central SoMa Commercial Development Requirements (Items 12-13): General Plan and Planning Code amendments to reduce commercial development requirements; passed on first reading. - Treasure Island Sewer Pump Stations (Item 14): Ordinance accepting infrastructure; passed on first reading. - Appointments (Items 15-18): Appointed members to the Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee, Veterans Affairs Commission, MTA Board, and Police Commission; all approved. - Committee Reports (Items 24-26): Window replacement standards, interim housing in hotels, and parking lot continuance; passed on first reading. - Adoption Without Committee Reference (Items 30-32): Transit Operator Appreciation Day, Heritage on the Marina Day, and Alexandria Theater Special Use District extension; adopted. Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Petrelli (Castro resident): Demanded a town hall after a homeless man’s death and an assault in the Castro. - Chris Ward Klein (U.S. Marine veteran): Alleged surveillance by the City Attorney’s Office and urged contact with federal authorities. - Julie Threet & Ronald F. Owens Jr. (Vaccine injury advocates): Cited adverse events and deaths from COVID-19 vaccines; requested hearings and removal of safe-and-effective claims from city websites. - Ellen Lee Jiao (former mayoral candidate): Called vaccines a bioweapon and accused the board of criminal behavior. - Richard S. T. Peterson (retired attorney): Complained about delays in obtaining a fortune-telling permit. - Gladys Wong (senior resident): Requested parking removal on Lucky Street for fire truck access. - Unnamed speaker: Criticized recovery-first drug policy and wealth inequality; referenced global conflicts and corporate abuses. - Unnamed speaker: Thanked Supervisor Dorsey for a resolution protecting tip-reporting anonymity. - Reverend Amos Brown (NAACP, former supervisor): Urged a resolution condemning the U.S. Army’s removal of Medgar Evers from a diversity webpage. Discussion Items - Empty Homes Tax Suspension (Item 2): Supervisor Fielder explained her “no” vote because the suspension would prevent collection even if the court lifted the injunction. Supervisor Chan supported suspension after hearing from the Treasurer’s Office about high administrative costs and legal uncertainty. The Controller’s Office revised the estimated annual yield from the original $25 million to $15.4 million (accounting for taxpayer response). The ordinance suspends the tax pending final litigation. - Behested Payment Waiver – Embarcadero Plaza (Item 11): Supervisors Fielder and Dorsey expressed support for the renovation but stressed the need to maintain ethical standards after the Recology scandal. The waiver was approved. - Central SoMa Plan (Items 12-13): Supervisor Dorsey highlighted the package’s role in meeting housing targets and preserving community benefits. - Special Order – Committee of the Whole (Item 19): Supervisor Walton moved to continue the DOJ reform hearing to May 6, 2025; public comment was taken; motion passed without objection. - Special Order – CEQA Appeal (Items 20-23): Appeal of environmental exemption for 2142-22nd Street Project. Supervisor Walton moved to continue to April 15, 2025; public comment (one speaker alleging attacks via technology); motion passed without objection. - Roll Call Introductions: - Supervisor Sauter introduced a resolution supporting SB 417/AB 736 (Affordable Housing Bond Act of 2026, $10 billion). - Supervisor Cheryl introduced legislation to extend the First Year Free program. - Supervisor Walton adjourned in memory of former Assistant Fire Chief Art Kenny. - Supervisor Fielder introduced a resolution calling for $2 billion in state transit funding. - Supervisor Mahmoud requested a BLA report on post-entitlement permitting. - President Mandelman introduced a resolution supporting SB 222 (climate accountability for oil companies). - Supervisor Melgar requested a hearing on SFPD Special Victims Unit staffing (65.7% reduction from 70 to 24 investigators) and adjourned in memory of Professor Dewey William Camp Jr. Key Outcomes - Empty Homes Tax Suspension: Passed on first reading 9-2 (Supervisors Walton and Fielder dissented). The ordinance suspends the tax until final court decision. - Behested Payment Waiver: Adopted without objection. - Central SoMa Package: Passed on first reading. - Settlement – Hotel Des Arts: Passed on first reading. - Committee of the Whole Hearing: Continued to May 6, 2025. - CEQA Appeal Hearing: Continued to April 15, 2025. - All appointments and consent items: Approved as listed. - Resolutions adopted: Transit Operator Appreciation Day (March 18, 2025), Heritage on the Marina Day (March 27, 2025), Alexandria Theater extension. - In Memoriam: Meeting adjourned in memory of Art Kenny and Professor Dewey William Camp Jr.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on March 17, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmoud. The committee considered four legislative items, all of which were recommended for approval to the full Board. The meeting also included public testimony and a birthday celebration for Chair Melgar. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Window Replacement Standards): Multiple speakers addressed the committee. Michael Kehen (Foxhill Hill Windows) opposed the legislation, arguing that wood windows are more energy efficient and that the change would benefit large corporations. Sophia O'Neill Roberts (Mission Housing Development Corporation) supported the ordinance, citing cost and time savings for affordable housing providers. Several residents (Garrin, Peter, Julia, Corinne Bruce) expressed support, emphasizing equity, health, noise reduction, and tenant comfort. One speaker raised concerns about wildfire smoke and indoor air quality. - Item 2 (Interim Housing in Hotels/Motels): Cynthia Gomez of Unite Here Local 2 stated that the union could “live with the amendments” after concerns about unintended consequences were addressed, and thanked the committee. - Item 3 (Parking Lots Continuation): One speaker made unrelated comments about weather manipulation and road safety, without addressing the specific item. - Item 4 (447 Bush Street Conversion): One speaker made unrelated comments about immigration and planning code manipulation, without addressing the specific item. Discussion Items Item 1: Planning Code – Window Replacement Standards Supervisor Melgar introduced the ordinance to simplify window replacement regulations, noting that nearly 20,000 window replacement permits had been filed in the past decade. The Planning Commission had recommended approval (6-1) with modifications, including clarifying that the department will not regulate frame and sash materials for replacement windows, adding exceptions for cultural districts, and aligning historic building definitions. The committee adopted those amendments unanimously and sent the amended ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Planning and Building Codes – Interim Housing in Hotels and Motels Emily Cohen (Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing) presented clarifying amendments that narrowly limited the ordinance’s scope to the Civic Center Motor Inn (lot 3519-006) and retroactively to three former shelter-in-place hotels (lots 0304-005, 0715-01, 0335-027). After a procedural sequence, the committee: (1) adopted the clarifying amendments unanimously, (2) sent the original amended file to the full Board as a committee report, (3) amended a duplicated file with additional language to allow reestablishment of hotel use for shelter-in-place hotels, and (4) continued the duplicated file to the call of the chair. All motions passed 3-0. Item 3: Planning Code – Continuation of Nonconforming Public Parking Lots in CMUO and MUR Districts Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey’s office) explained the ordinance would allow existing parking lots in Central SOMA and mixed-use residential districts to continue operating through December 31, 2026, and then apply for a conditional use authorization for up to five more years. The Planning Commission approved the ordinance on March 6, 2025. The committee sent it to the full Board as a committee report unanimously. Item 4: Planning Code – Conversion of Residential Hotel Rooms to Tourist Hotel Rooms at 447 Bush Street Deputy City Attorney Brad Rossi and Aaron Starr (Planning Department) presented the ordinance as part of a litigation settlement. The ordinance exempts 447 Bush Street from conditional use requirements for converting 38 residential hotel rooms, while requiring conversion of group housing rooms at other properties in return. The Planning Commission recommended approval unanimously. The committee voted unanimously to send it to the full Board as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Amended and forwarded to the full Board (March 18, 2025) with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Original file amended and forwarded to the full Board (March 18, 2025) as a committee report (3-0); duplicated file further amended and continued to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 3: Forwarded to the full Board (March 18, 2025) as a committee report (3-0). - Item 4: Forwarded to the full Board (March 18, 2025) as a committee report (3-0).
The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, March 13, 2025, at approximately 2:15 PM. Commission President So presided. The meeting covered continuances, consent calendar items, commission matters, department updates, and general public comment. Key actions included approving a temporary parking lot for Yellow Cab and major modifications for the Balboa Reservoir affordable housing project. Consent Calendar - Item 2 (3225 Fillmore Street): Conditional use authorization approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 4 (30 Van Ness Avenue): Modification to inclusionary housing condition approved (6-0) after Commissioner Campbell recused due to employer involvement. Public Comments & Testimony - Georgia Shudish (District 2): Criticized planning staff's interpretation of the flat policy, citing examples of interior demolitions and unit configurations that she argued violate the policy's intent. Provided a letter with suggestions for codification. - Masako Takahashi (Japan Town property owner): Urged the Commission to stop the redesign of Osaka Way (Buchanan Mall), which she said would destroy the artwork of world-famous artist Ruth Asawa. Requested restoration and renaming to Ruth Asawa Way. Noted the site is eligible for historic monument status. - Claire Mills (District 2): Called on San Francisco to negotiate with HCD to adjust RHNA allocations based on updated state population projections (2,683 new residents by 2030 vs. 82,069 required units). Argued that 55,000 units already in the pipeline are sufficient, and that other cities are pushing back against inflated mandates. - Mark Mulouf (Teamsters Local 665, on Item 3): Requested the item be pulled from consent. Stated opposition to any future conversion of the private parking lot to fleet charging without a separate conditional use process. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Alexandria Theater Special Use District): Continued to April 3, 2025, to finalize language. Unanimous vote (7-0). - Item 3 (531 Bayshore Boulevard et al.): Temporary private parking lot for Yellow Cab for up to 8 years. Staff recommended approval, noting the site has 150 spaces and the fleet has shrunk from 600 to 300 cabs. Project sponsor clarified that fleet charging and parcel delivery are separate uses not requested. Commissioner Braun moved to approve, citing no visible issues. Approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 5 (11 Frida Kahlo Way – Balboa Reservoir Block A): Major modifications to four design standards for a 159-unit, 100% affordable housing building (6 stories, 78 parking spaces, 30 public). Modifications: courtyard opening height reduced from 18 ft to 16 ft (width increased to 24.5 ft), ground floor height reduced from 15 ft to 14 ft on Lee Avenue, recess depth reduced from 8 ft to 7.5 ft for three ground-floor units, and off-street loading replaced with on-street loading. Staff and project sponsor (Bridge Housing, architects YA Studio) supported the changes, noting they enable tax credit applications and preserve unit count. Public comment raised concerns about emergency water supply for the 3,000+ new residents. Vice President Moore praised the project's complexity and community engagement. Commissioner Imperial moved to approve, seconded. Approved unanimously (7-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1 continued to April 3, 2025 (7-0). - Consent items 2 and 4 approved (7-0 and 6-0 respectively). - Item 3 approved (7-0), allowing Yellow Cab to operate the private parking lot for up to 8 years. - Item 5 approved (7-0), granting major modifications to design standards for Balboa Reservoir Block A, enabling construction of 159 affordable units starting in early 2026. - Commissioner Campbell recused from Item 4. - Minutes for February 27, 2025, adopted with correction (7-0). - General public comment included requests for planning staff to follow up on Osaka Way redesign and RHNA negotiations.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, March 13, 2025, at 6:15 PM. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Bilal Mahmood and Supervisor Danny Sauter present. The committee considered three agenda items: a liquor license transfer, a resolution on drug market intervention, and a hearing on public trash cans. Liquor License Transfer - 1266 9th Avenue (Luke's Local) Supervisor Dorsey introduced the item. Officer Freundes from the SFPD ABC liaison unit reported that the applicant, Luke's Local Inc., seeks a Type 21 off-sale general liquor license for a small grocery chain in the West Portal neighborhood. There were zero letters of protest or support. The Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval with one condition: the petitioner must actively monitor the area to prevent loitering. No public comment was offered. The committee unanimously voted to prepare a resolution finding that the transfer serves public convenience or necessity. (Vote: 3-0, Mahmood, Sauter, Dorsey aye.) Drug Market Intervention (DMI) Resolution Vice Chair Mahmood presented the resolution (Item 250197) urging implementation of a comprehensive DMI strategy to address the fentanyl crisis. He noted that the Tenderloin is home to over 3,500 children and that DMAC has seized over 300 pounds of fentanyl and made more than 2,000 felony drug arrests since 2023. Mahmood introduced an amendment to clarify that enforcement alone cannot eliminate the drug market and should be minimized whenever possible, prioritizing interagency collaboration, deterrence, and pathways to employment and rehabilitation. The amendment was adopted unanimously. No public comment was heard. The committee then voted to forward the amended resolution to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. (Vote: 3-0.) Hearing - Public Trash Cans Supervisor Sauter called the hearing to examine the city's policies for procuring, installing, and maintaining public trash cans. Presentations were given by Ian Schneider (Government Affairs Manager, DPW) and Kevin Flanagan (General Manager, Recology Golden Gate). Key Statistics and Updates - DPW manages approximately 3,000 public trash cans. Over the past 15 years, 1,500 cans have been removed. - San Francisco has about four cans per 1,000 people (compared to New York City's one per 1,000). - Approximately 800 of the city's cans have sensors that generate 311 requests when triggered (at 80% full). - DPW is working to hire a trash can manager and is developing a new can design through an RFP, funded by a $15 million reserve from refuse rate accounts. The goal is to replace all existing cans over nine years. - Recology services all public receptacles at least once per day, with a second pass on 12 dedicated routes, and a third pass in high-traffic areas (e.g., Mission District and Chinatown). - Recology's clean street carts (with automatic locking lids) are deployed in several areas, but cost about double the standard cart. - DPW has over 450 cleaning staff, but street cleaning budgets are vulnerable to general fund cuts. Discussion Supervisors questioned DPW and Recology about sensor expansion, enforcement, illegal dumping, and pilot programs. Supervisor Sauter noted that removing cans without adding alternatives can concentrate litter. Supervisor Mahmood asked about educational outreach, referencing Japan's culture of cleanliness. DPW cited past school assemblies and a campaign with the San Francisco Giants, but acknowledged difficulty in measuring impact. Public Comments Several members of the public spoke in support of more trash cans, better enforcement, and education. Key speakers: - Blair Helsing (President, North Beach Neighbors): Noted increased garbage due to more visitors and called for collaboration. - Devin Proctor (Clean Up the City volunteer): Urged the city to measure outcomes (e.g., street cleanliness audits) rather than just inputs. - Julie Christensen (former supervisor, product designer): Suggested improvements to can design (manufacturability, removable skins, plastic materials). - Alex Ludlum (Interim ED, SOMA West CBD): Stated that less than 10% of street trash in SOMA West comes from pedestrians; the rest is from illegal dumping and commercial sources. - David Thompson (resident): Described a lack of cans on Taylor Street and a broken can at Sacramento and Jones. - Michael I (Excelsior resident): Called for more cans in District 11 and suggested public-private partnerships. - Barbara Bella (Russian Hill Neighbors): Asked Recology to address accidental litter during collection, estimated at up to 30%. - Dallas Hyatt (Lower Nob Hill Cleanup co-captain): Emphasized need for more cans and cigarette butt receptacles. - Nancy Yu Law (Chinatown small business owner): Noted overflow in Chinatown and suggested placing cans at corners rather than in front of stores. - Vince Ewan (Refuse Refuse founder): Cautioned that trash cans are not a silver bullet; advocated for QR codes on cans, a drone program for illegal dumping detection, and a ban on filtered cigarette butts. Key Outcomes Supervisor Sauter committed to follow up on specific ideas, including pilot programs, expansion of clean street carts, and improved enforcement. The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair to allow for future updates and accountability. (Vote: 3-0.) Adjournment The meeting adjourned at approximately 12:30 PM (after the recess for technical issues).
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Member Joan Guar…[full markdown]
The San Francisco Police Commission held a regular meeting on March 12, 2025, with President Elias and Commissioners Leoung, Clay, and Yañez present (Commissioners Benedicto and Yi excused). Chief William Scott and DPA Executive Director Paul Henderson provided reports. Item 8 (Language Access Services Annual Report) was removed from the agenda. The meeting began with a tribute to outgoing Deputy City Attorney Alicia Cabrera, followed by approvals of the consent calendar and minutes, public comment, reports, a policy revision, and closed session. Tribute to Deputy City Attorney Alicia Cabrera The commission recognized Deputy City Attorney Alicia Cabrera for her ten years of service as the commission's legal counsel. Sergeant Youngblood, President Elias, and Chief Scott spoke in appreciation of her guidance and dedication. Cabrera was presented with a Certificate of Recognition from Chief Scott and thanked the commission. The commission welcomed incoming attorney Jen. Consent Calendar The commission approved to receive and file the following items: Internal Affairs Division Annual Report 2024; DGO 5.05 Emergency Response and Pursuit Driving Annual Report (January 31, 2025); Department Use of Non-Entity Camera Policy Quarter 3; and the SFPD and DPA SB 1421 and SB16 Month Report for February 2025. The motion passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Regarding Item 1 (Tribute): A speaker expressed that everything is reversed and stated "we are under attack," but did not represent a specific organization. - General Public Comment (Item 2): - A speaker called for disobedience to government until concerns about weather manipulation and food poisoning are addressed. - A speaker, identifying as an architect and engineer, alleged that after reporting encrypted data transmissions to Russia and evidence of human trafficking, he became a target of the SFPD's Special Victims Unit. He also claimed to have photographed SFPD officers accepting cash payments from Hells Angels associates. - A speaker raised issues about whistleblower protection and surveillance equipment, and called for an investigation into Mike Maxwell, criticizing the City Attorney's Office. - Alice Rogers, president of the South Beach Rincon Mission Bay Neighborhood Association, expressed emphatic support for the Southern District boundaries as drawn on the final police district map and hand-delivered letters from her association. - A speaker congratulated Maddie Scott on her appointment to the Police Commission and urged continued attention to unsolved homicides. - On Chief's Report (Item 5): - A speaker repeated concerns about weather manipulation and questioned SFPD's capacity to investigate it. - A speaker asked about the amount of contraband seized in the Jefferson Square Park operation; Chief Scott stated that 0.21 pounds of narcotics were recovered. - The mother of a homicide victim again sought assistance for her son's unsolved case. - On Commission Reports (Item 7): - A speaker praised the women in policing event at City Hall and expressed appreciation for representation. - On DGO 6.07 (Item 9): No public comment was offered. Chief's Report Chief Scott reported crime trends: - Overall Part I crime decreased 33% (from 7,500 to 5,021 year-to-date). - Property crime down 36% (6,599 to 4,249). - Violent crime down 14% (901 to 772). - Gun violence increased 9% (4 more shooting incidents, 2 more shooting victims); homicides by firearm unchanged at three. - Total homicide victims down 33% (4 to 3). - Homicide clearance rate: 160% (cases solved from prior years). - Auto burglaries down 55% (4,066 to 2,309). - Larceny down 15% (2,197 to 2,057). - Firearms seized: 202, up from 172 last year. He highlighted a Drug Market Agency Coordination Center (DMAC) operation at Jefferson Square Park (February 26) that resulted in 86 arrests (55 narcotics-related, including 3 for possession with intent to sell; 31 on warrants). The chief provided a breakdown by gender, race, age, and city of residence. The operation also seized 0.21 pounds of narcotics. A smaller operation at 16th and Mission on March 5 led to 4 arrests and ongoing enforcement. Other incidents: a homicide on the 900 block of Ellsworth (March 7, no arrest); a carjacking arrest following a pursuit; two juveniles arrested at Stonestown Galleria with a replica assault rifle and a ghost gun; and an officer-involved shooting on 41st Avenue (town hall scheduled for March 18, 2025). Chief Scott also noted a 30% drop in crime during the Chinese New Year parade and All-Star weekend. Commissioner Clay asked if other areas had requested similar enforcement; Chief confirmed continued hotspot enforcement, particularly on 6th Street and in the Tenderloin. DPA Director's Report Executive Director Henderson announced a risk-based audit plan and will survey commissioners. The policy division is finalizing DGO 6.16 (sexual assault) and starting stakeholder engagement for DGO 6.09 (domestic violence). He met with the new commissioner and the Board of Supervisors. The language access presentation was postponed. Case statistics: Since the last meeting, DPA opened 63 cases and closed 69. The top allegation was "officers speaking inappropriately with members of the public." Sixteen investigations have been open more than 270 days (15 told, 1 ongoing). Pending cases with the chief fell to 98 (a 12% decrease) and with the commission to 2 (a 50% decrease). President Elias inquired about the single non-told case and the status of chief hearings; Henderson noted commanders now conduct hearings and settlements have helped reduce the backlog. Commission Reports President Elias reported attending the 50th anniversary celebration of women on patrol (March 5) and announced that the commission's statement of purpose will be presented to the Board of Supervisors on March 26, 2025. Commissioner Yañez reported meeting with Supervisor Fielder about conditions on 6th Street and Bart, and noted promising support for increased staffing. He inquired about the timeline for DGO 7.01 (juvenile) updates; Chief Scott responded that responses to community recommendations have been submitted. He also asked about the pre-booking program with Judge Chan; Chief Scott said one of Judge Chan's ideas has been implemented and stakeholders are currently on a training trip. Regarding language access, Yañez raised concerns about the community input portal being down; Chief Scott confirmed the deadline was extended by two weeks. Finally, Yañez referenced the emergency response and pursuit driving annual report, noting that 25 of 80 pursuits in 2024 occurred in December after Prop D passed, and requested a future agenda item for the Board of Supervisors' letter of inquiry. President Elias confirmed the letter would be agendized in April. Revision of Department General Order 6.07 (Dog Complaints) Officer Greg Sutherland, SFPD's vicious and dangerous dog officer, presented the revised DGO 6.07, last updated in 1994. Key changes include a new definitions section, reorganization by severity, detailed hearing procedures, and clarification of non-SFPD enforcement. The commission approved the revision unanimously (4-0). Closed Session and Vote on Disclosure The commission held closed session (Items 10–12) as listed on the agenda. The transcript does not include discussion from those portions. After returning to open session, the commission voted on whether to disclose any or all of the closed session discussions (Item 13). All four present commissioners voted yes; the transcript does not indicate whether this vote resulted in disclosure or nondisclosure. Key Outcomes - Approved the consent calendar and the minutes of February 5, 12, and 19, 2025. - Approved the revised DGO 6.07 (Dog Complaints). - Agendized the Board of Supervisors' letter of inquiry regarding the January 2025 officer-involved incident and a status update on the juvenile DGO (DGO 7.01) for future meetings. - Held closed session; a vote on disclosure was taken with four yes votes, but the outcome is not specified in the transcript.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on March 11, 2025, beginning with a closed session at 2:30 PM and open session at 3:15 PM. Commissioners approved several key items, including a Memorandum of Understanding and grants for the Mission Bay Ferry Landing, amendments to the Mission Rock housing plan to deepen affordability, and received an informational presentation on a proposed arts and culture activation at Pier 29. The meeting also featured the Executive Director's report on ARPA-funded capital projects and community events. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Authorized advertising for competitive bids for Construction Contract No. 2858, Pier 90 Buildings and Wharf Demolition. (Resolution 25-12) - Item 10B: Authorized advertising for two professional services contracts for coastal flood defense design: one for the Southern Waterfront (not-to-exceed $50 million) and one for the Northern Waterfront (not-to-exceed $65 million), each with a 10-year initial term. (Resolution 25-13) - Both resolutions were adopted unanimously without public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 11 (Mission Bay Ferry Landing): Amy Alden (UCSF Senior Director of Local and State Government Relations) expressed full support for the ferry landing, noting UCSF contributed $4 million to the project. She stated the ferry would serve UCSF employees, students, outpatients, and visitors, and highlighted the electric shuttle connection. - Item 12B (Pier 29 Arts Activation): Public commenters included Anna Teresa Fernandez, a San Francisco artist with an international exhibition record, who spoke passionately about the need for free, accessible arts education and studio space, citing her own experience of finding an atelier in Florence. Verda, a graduate of the San Francisco Art Institute and local resident, expressed excitement about the project activating the North Beach/Telegraph Hill area with creative energy. Discussion Items Executive Director's Report (Item 9) Elaine Forbes reported on several topics: - Women's History Month: Noted that women earn 16% less than men on average and hold less than 10% of Fortune 500 CEO positions. Recognized President Brandon and Vice President Gilman. - Crab Crawl: The first-ever Crab Crawl on March 9, part of National Crab Day, sold out with over 280 participants, bringing residents and visitors to six Fisherman's Wharf restaurants. Vice President Gilman attended and noted the event sold out and ran out of crab. - Contracts Open House: The 8th annual event, now too large for port offices, will be held at the cruise ship terminal to help small, local, and diverse businesses connect with larger firms. - Resilience: Signed a Third Amendment to the feasibility cost-sharing agreement and a 221 design/construction MOU with the Army Corps of Engineers, paving the way for federal flood protection funding and allowing the port to lead design. - ARPA Projects: Provided updates on multiple capital projects funded by $114 million in ARPA grants, including Amador Street infrastructure, dry dock repairs, Pier 90 demolition, Hyde Street Harbor repairs, and Wharf J11 repairs. - Upcoming: Breakfast of Champions on March 21 to honor employees of the year. Commissioners expressed appreciation, with Commissioner Engblom emphasizing the importance of infrastructure for jobs and emergency readiness. Commissioner Adams urged caution about federal funding uncertainty. Commissioner Lee highlighted the need for better communication on events like the Crab Crawl and the importance of Pier 45 and the Northern Waterfront. Vice President Gilman closed the meeting by honoring Christopher Matthew Conawaki, a 25-year liveaboard at Pier 39 who recently passed away. Mission Bay Ferry Landing (Item 11A, B, C) Simon (Port Engineering Project Manager) presented an overview of the Mission Bay Ferry Landing project at 16th Street and Terry A. Francois Boulevard. Key points: - Project history: initiated in 2016, design completed in 2019, initial cost estimate $47 million, but bids exceeded budget. After litigation resolution and funding gap closed, project now estimated at $74 million (37% increase due to contaminated sediment, electrification scope, permitting changes, and five years of cost escalation). - Funding sources include: Water Emergency Transportation Authority grant ($28 million), UCSF grant ($4 million), and port/city funds ($19.8 million, with $7 million from port of which $5.6 million already spent). - The MOU with SF Bay Ferry defines design, construction, and maintenance responsibilities: port handles land-side assets; SF Bay Ferry handles water-side assets beyond the access gate. - Next steps: Phase 2A (marine demolition and sediment cap) to be advertised soon, construction summer 2025. Phase 2B design wrapping up, construction in 2026-2027. First ferry riders expected spring 2027. Commissioners expressed strong support. Commissioner Adams noted the project connects to Chase Center, Oracle Park, and UCSF, and reduces traffic and pollution. Commissioner Lee highlighted the need for more ferry connections. Commissioner Engblom supported but suggested better communication of cost escalation reasons. Vice President Gilman supported, noting the importance of the in-water work window. All three resolutions (25-14, 25-15, 25-16) were adopted unanimously. Mission Rock Housing Plan Amendments (Item 12A) Wyatt Donnelly-Landolt (Port Development) presented proposed amendments: - Background: The Mission Rock project has a 40% affordability goal overall, with a 30% minimum per phase. - Current challenges: Market conditions (post-pandemic rent decreases, higher incomes) have made leasing 150% AMI units very difficult. Parcel A is at 68% leased overall; 90% AMI units are 100% leased, but 150% AMI units are only 39% leased. - Proposed changes for Parcel A: Increase 90% AMI units from 10 to 19, maintain 54 units at 120% AMI, eliminate 150% AMI units. This results in 73 total affordable units (25% of phase one, down from 30%). To allow this, they request amending the housing plan to lower the phase minimum from 30% to 20%. - Next steps: Board of Supervisors approval needed. Commissioners discussed and ultimately supported the amendments. Commissioner Lee questioned the need for changes; staff explained market conditions. Commissioner Engblom noted the project still exceeds city inclusionary requirements (currently 12.5%). Commissioner Adams used a sports metaphor about making adjustments and noted the area's vibrancy with new businesses and energy. Vice President Gilman highlighted that the new AMI levels (90% AMI is $94,000 for single person) represent deeper affordability and support economic diversity. She also asked about the standalone affordable building for foster youth (parcel D), noting it required subsidy and that federal funding is uncertain. Staff confirmed it remains in planning but may be restructured. Resolution 25-17 was adopted unanimously. Pier 29 Arts and Culture Activation (Item 12B) – Informational Scott Landsittel (Deputy Director, Real Estate) introduced a two-year license concept for Pier 29 by Community Arts Stabilization Trust (CAST) and Art & Water (a fiscally sponsored project of the Hawkins Project). - CAST (nonprofit real estate arts organization, founded 2013) manages about 300,000 sq ft citywide, including the Warfield Office Building. - Art & Water proposed a three-pillar model: 1. Free artist workspaces for 20 emerging and 10 established mentor artists on six-month rotations, with no rent or tuition. 2. World-class exhibitions (e.g., Shepard Fairey, Boots Riley) on a sliding fee to attract visitors. 3. Free exhibition space for local artists adjacent to major shows. - The entire interior (123,000 sq ft) is designed to be movable on wheels, allowing conversion to event space for up to 2,500 people. CAST will manage the central convening space; Art & Water will curate the front Embarcadero-facing area. - CAST expects about 100,000 visitors annually and commits to 2-3 evening shows per week. - No action taken; port staff will bring back terms for a temporary license agreement at a future meeting. Public speakers and commissioners expressed strong enthusiasm. Commissioner Engblom praised the vision. Commissioner Adams spoke passionately about the importance of arts and the need for space for artists. Commissioner Lee raised sustainability concerns, asking about revenue model and event management; CAST confirmed they will self-fund initially and rely on a blend of ticketed and free events, with year two being critical for sustainability. Vice President Gilman asked about their financial capacity; CAST CEO stated they have strong balance sheets and will self-finance if needed, noting they already invested in the project. She also encouraged outreach to communities impacted by port activities (Bayview, Dog Patch, Chinatown, North Beach). President Brandon inquired about selection process for artists; presenters confirmed a public application process with an advisory committee representing diverse neighborhoods, and a focus on local talent. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (Resolutions 25-12, 25-13) adopted. - Mission Bay Ferry Landing (Resolutions 25-14, 25-15, 25-16) adopted. MOU with SF Bay Ferry, acceptance of $28M WETA grant and $4M UCSF grant approved. - Mission Rock Housing Amendments (Resolution 25-17) adopted. Housing plan phase minimum reduced from 30% to 20%, Parcel A affordability adjusted to increase 90% AMI units. Next step: Board of Supervisors approval. - Pier 29 Arts Activation: Informational presentation received. Staff to return with license terms for future action. - New Business: Commissioner Lee requested a report on cleaning and offering unused outdoor kitchens at Fisherman's Grotto for temporary pop-up uses. - Adjournment: Meeting adjourned at 6:32 PM in memory of Christopher Matthew Conawaki.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on March 11, 2025, at 2:00 PM. The meeting included a formal policy discussion with Mayor Daniel Lurie, approval of consent and regular agenda items, commendations, introductions of new legislation, and public comment. Key topics included the city's drug crisis strategy, shelter policies for homeless families, Muni funding, and the suspension of the empty homes tax. Special Order: Mayor's Appearance - Mayor Daniel Lurie appeared for a formal policy discussion with the Board. He outlined his administration's strategy to address the fentanyl crisis, emphasizing enforcement against drug dealers and expansion of treatment bed capacity, including through the recently passed fentanyl state of emergency ordinance. He also noted that senior leaders and the City Attorney would travel to Washington, D.C., to lobby for federal resources for San Francisco's economic recovery, including for Hunters Point Naval Shipyard and transportation infrastructure, while opposing proposed cuts to food, housing, and healthcare programs. - Supervisor Fielder raised concerns about displacement from enforcement actions, citing the 6th Street operation pushing drug activity into the Mission District. She called for a comprehensive four-pillar strategy (prevention/education, harm reduction, treatment, enforcement) and noted a hearing co-sponsored by several supervisors. The mayor responded that success is measured by residents' safety and clean sidewalks, and that his administration is committed to both enforcement and adding treatment capacity. Consent Agenda (Items 2-8) - The Board unanimously approved the consent agenda, which included seven lawsuit settlements totaling $4,900,900: Vincent Keith Bell ($825,000), Javier Grajeda ($30,000), Marvella Branner ($110,000), Matthew Gyves ($500,000), John Pugh ($60,000), Latoya Starks and Sanvada Kitcher ($2,880,000), and CWI 2 San Francisco Hotel, L.P. (stipulated assessed value of $216,400,000 and refund of $495,900 plus statutory interest). Unfinished Business (Items 9-12) - Item 9 (250096): Final passage of an ordinance to accept a $1,966,000 grant from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation for the jail and re-entry services program and to add three grant-funded positions at the San Francisco Public Library. - Item 10 (240904): Final passage of an ordinance updating Form 700 (Statement of Economic Interests) filing requirements. - Item 11 (241151): Final passage of an ordinance authorizing the tax collector to refund property taxes under $10,000 without a claim. - Item 12 (250002): Final passage of an ordinance removing the requirement for parking operators to certify and report unaccounted parking ticket ratios. New Business (Items 13-22) - Item 13 (241150): Ordinance passed on first reading to authorize a voluntary disclosure program and advance determination fees for taxpayers. - Item 14 (250001): Ordinance to suspend the empty homes tax pending litigation was continued to March 18, 2025, on a motion by Supervisor Fielder, who cited the need for amendments to allow collection as soon as the court permits, rather than waiting for final resolution of all appeals. - Items 15-16: Resolutions adopted to increase airport professional services contracts for cargo building projects by $10.3 million and $10 million respectively, each for a new total not to exceed $13 million. - Item 17: Lease amendment for communication facilities in Alameda County at $9,080 monthly base rent adopted. - Item 18: Resolution approving an emergency declaration for restoring the Tesla Treatment Facility's standby power supply system (estimated $700,000) adopted. - Items 19-20: Leases for community facilities at 1099 Sunnydale Avenue approved: FACES SF ($48,867.12 initial yearly rent) and Felton Institute ($24,216.48 initial yearly rent). - Items 21-22: Contract amendments for health services system software (Hyland Software, not to exceed $574,000) and administration services (P&A Administrative Services, not to exceed $4,667,457) adopted. Special Order 2:30 PM: Recognition of Commendations - Supervisor Chen honored Yolanda Coos, a community leader from the Excelsior District and immigrant advocate, for her work with families, school equity, and community organizing. - Supervisor Dorsey recognized Abby Yant, retiring Executive Director of the San Francisco Health Service System, for 35 years of healthcare leadership and her role during the pandemic. - President Mandelman presented a commendation to Nelson Berry and Urban Angels, a volunteer organization distributing clothing and food to unhoused individuals and now expanding to educational tutoring for low-income children. Introductions at Roll Call - Supervisor Melgar and Supervisor Sauter introduced a motion to formalize a parental leave policy for Board of Supervisors members, citing state law changes and the need to support elected officials who are new parents. Supervisor Sauter noted that she and her wife are expecting a daughter soon. - Supervisor Walton (with Supervisors Chan, Fielder, and Chen) called for a hearing to assess implementation of the city's Language Access Ordinance, including review of the 2025 compliance report and a pending Budget and Legislative Analyst report. - Supervisor Fielder introduced a resolution addressing family homelessness and criticizing the reinstated 90-day shelter stay policy. She reported that two families faced eviction threats on March 10, 2025, with one shelter provider threatening to call police, and called for the policy to be rescinded or reformed. - Supervisor Dorsey offered an in memoriam for Ali Jamil, a Jordanian immigrant and community member, father of Deputy City Attorney Mo Jamil. - President Mandelman offered an in memoriam for Alan Jacobs, former San Francisco Planning Director (1967-1975) and author of "Great Streets," who died at age 96 on February 18, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Petrellis (remote, ADA accommodation): Expressed concern about safety in the Castro district, citing the death of a homeless neighbor named Dale and a violent attack on a gay man near the Castro Theatre on March 9, 2025. Demanded an urgent town hall meeting with elected officials. - Salah Hakuya Chandler: Criticized the lack of African American representation in the chamber and called for dialogue on restoring the cultural heritage of the Black community. - Griffin Lee (D2 resident): Opposed the empty homes tax, arguing it would disincentivize development. Also urged the board to consider costs before implementing a fair shelter distribution policy. - Lisa Platt (D2 resident): Urged the board to prevent SFMTA service cuts this summer, suggesting evening parking meters or general fund transfers as alternatives. - Jaime Villoria (Tenderloin resident): Criticized the lack of local action to address the SFMTA deficit and urged the board to find local funding solutions rather than relying on state or regional measures. - Audrey Liu (District 1 resident): Supported a general fund transfer to SFMTA to prevent summer cuts to Muni lines, low-income tow subsidies, and crossing guards. - Leah McGeever (D6 translatinx homeowner): Raised harassment concerns involving a community member and Supervisor Dorsey's advisor. - Several taxi medallion holders and drivers: Spoke about financial hardship due to the city's purchase of medallions, calling for bailout or reduction in medallion price. - Other speakers: Addressed weather manipulation conspiracy theories (multiple speakers) and urged action on the taxi medallion crisis. Key Outcomes - Consent agenda unanimously approved (11-0). - Unfinished business items 9-12 finally passed on second reading. - New business items 13, 15-22 adopted as described. - Item 14 (empty homes tax suspension) continued to March 18, 2025, for amendments. - Adoption without committee reference (items 25-29) unanimously adopted, including resolutions recognizing Problem Gambling Awareness Month, closing sidewalks for Figma Config 2025, recognizing Ramadan, supporting state bill AB 458 (firearms in public contracts), and urging the Mayor and HSH to explore fair distribution of homeless shelters across districts. - Meeting adjourned in memory of Ali Jamil and Alan Jacobs.