Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 531–540 ENTRIES
531
FEB 5, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Regular Meeting – February 5, 2025

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 5, 2025, at 6:15 PM (UTC) to consider nine agenda items, including appropriations, grant agreements, a professional services contract, and a hearing on the city's five-year financial plan. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Supervisor Joan Engardio, voted unanimously to forward most items to the full board with positive recommendations, continued one item to a date certain, and continued the financial plan hearing to the call of the chair. No public speakers appeared for most items, with the exception of a representative from Catholic Charities on item five. Discussion Items Item 1 – Appropriation for MTA – Portsmouth Square Garage and Transit Fares - Ordinance appropriating $526,000 from the General Reserve to the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency to support free two-hour parking in the Portsmouth Square Parking Garage (January 28 – February 28, 2025) and free transit fares for Lunar New Year Parade weekend (February 15–16, 2025). The amount was increased from $250,000 and language regarding ambassadors was removed. The committee voted 3-0 to forward to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 2 – Grant Applications for Transitional Housing Programs - Resolution authorizing the Human Services Agency to apply for and accept up to $4,210,804 from the California Department of Housing and Community Development for a Transitional Housing Program (for foster youth aged 18–25) and up to $629,926 for a Housing Navigation and Maintenance Program (for child welfare–involved youth aged 18–21). The funding was already anticipated in the FY24-25 budget. The committee voted 3-0 to forward to the full board. Item 3 – Lease Amendment with BART – Rent Credit for Fare Gates - Resolution approving a rent credit not to exceed $3,150,000 to BART for the Next Generation Fare Gates Replacement Project at the San Francisco International Airport station. The rent credit will be applied as an abatement of BART's monthly rent ($208,000) for approximately 15 months. The work was completed in October 2024, but the amendment requires Board and Mayoral approval. The committee voted 3-0 to forward to the full board. Item 4 – Professional Services Agreement – Water Capital Program Management - Resolution approving a 10-year, $80 million contract with HDR Stantec JV to provide program management consulting services for the SFPUC's Water Enterprise capital improvement programs (Hetch Hetchy, Regional, and Local). The contract includes a 20.83% Local Business Enterprise commitment and a social impact partnership of $1,045,450 in financial contributions and $166,500 in volunteer hours. The Budget and Legislative Analyst noted the contract is about 1.8% of total capital spending, below the typical 5% benchmark. The committee voted 3-0 to forward to the full board. Item 5 – Grant Amendment – Catholic Charities – Family Rapid Rehousing - Resolution approving a fourth amendment to the grant agreement with Catholic Charities for the SF Home Rapid Rehousing Program for Families, extending the term through June 30, 2026, and increasing the not-to-exceed amount by $4.1 million to a total of approximately $14.5 million. The amendment adds capacity to serve 29 additional households (total 66 households). Catholic Charities reported that 82% of clients exited to permanent housing, 94% of referred families were placed into housing (average 65 days vs. 75-day requirement), and 97% maintained housing for 12 months. The program is funded by Prop C and general fund. A public speaker, Catherine Lee (Deputy Director of Innovation and Program Strategy at Catholic Charities), expressed gratitude and commitment to the program. The committee voted 3-0 to forward to the full board. During discussion, Supervisor Chan asked about the shelter waiting list (320 families) and the cost of family shelter ($212/night) versus rapid rehousing ($30,000/year). The department noted that the limiting factor for shelter capacity is funding, not hotel availability. Items 6 & 7 – Grant Agreements with Young Community Developers and Bay Area Community Resources - Item 6: Resolution approving a new five-year grant agreement (July 1, 2024 – June 30, 2029) with Young Community Developers for the Black to the Future program ($1.7 million) and School Site Mentoring program ($473,520), total not to exceed $12.4 million. The Budget and Legislative Analyst noted that Black to the Future had served only about a quarter of its budgeted clients in FY23-24, so the new grant reduces the client target from 300 to 180 with a commensurate budget reduction. The department explained that the right-sizing was due to lower family engagement and families moving out of the neighborhood. - Item 7: Resolution approving an amendment to an existing grant with Bay Area Community Resources, increasing the contract amount by approximately $2.3 million to a new total of $10.5 million, with no change to the five-year term. The amendment adds funding for Career Pathways for Undocumented Youth ($650,000/year) and a one-time $70,740 from Juvenile Probation for the Reset Justice Collaborative. The department corrected an error in the submitted amount, requesting approval of an amended total of $1,537,840 for the additional funding. The committee voted to amend item 7 as recommended, then voted 3-0 to forward both items to the full board. Item 8 – Marina Improvement and Remediation – Fiscal Feasibility Findings - Resolution to adopt findings of fiscal feasibility for the Marina Improvement and Remediation project. The sponsor, Supervisor Sherrill, requested a continuance to March 19, 2025, to allow further community conversation. The committee voted 3-0 to continue to that date. Item 9 – Hearing on Five-Year Financial Plan Update and Mayor’s Budget Instructions - Hearing on the city’s five-year financial plan update (FY2025-26 through FY2029-30) and the Mayor’s budget instructions. Benjamin McCloskey, Interim Director of the Mayor’s Budget Office, presented the fiscal outlook: a two-year deficit of $876 million ($253 million in FY25-26 and $623 million in FY26-27), with a projected $1 billion deficit in FY27-28 alone. Expenditure growth ($1.7 billion over five years) far outpaces revenue growth ($520 million). Key risks include state budget challenges, federal grant uncertainty (including $234 million in FEMA reimbursements), and local property/business tax appeals. Mayor Lurie’s additional instructions include a citywide hiring freeze (effective January 9, 2025, through end of fiscal year), a pause on new contracts not yet signed, and a requirement for departments to propose 15% permanent reductions in general fund spending. The committee discussed the hiring freeze’s impact on temporary positions, the need to address contract redundancy, and the importance of the upcoming six-month controller’s report. The hearing was continued to the call of the chair. Key Outcomes - Items 1–7: All forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations (3-0 votes). - Item 8: Continued to the March 19, 2025, Budget and Finance Committee meeting (3-0). - Item 9: Continued to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 7 Amendment: The committee approved a correction to the contract amount as recommended by the Budget and Legislative Analyst and the department (3-0). - No public speakers appeared on any item except item 5 (Catherine Lee, Catholic Charities). - The committee will receive the controller’s six-month financial report later in February and continue budget deliberations in the coming months.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 23% · HOMELESSNESS 22% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 11% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 10%
532
FEB 5, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – February 5, 2025

The San Francisco Police Commission met on February 5, 2025, to receive reports from the Police Chief and DPA Director, discuss departmental and DPA budgets for fiscal years 2026-2027, and address public comments. Items 7 (Body Worn Cameras DGO), 10, 11, 12 (Closed Session), and 13 were pulled from the agenda. Consent Calendar - The Commission unanimously voted to receive and file the following items: - DPA's retention policy - Safe Streets for All fourth quarter 2024 update - Donation of a horse to SFPD's mounted unit valued at $22,000 - SFPD's annual secondary employment report for 2024 - Semi-annual report on sexual assault evidence kits (July 1 – December 31, 2024) - Resolution urging the Board of Supervisors to retroactively authorize acceptance of 1,800 units of naloxone (valued at $81,300) for the naloxone distribution project Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 1): - One speaker used a metaphor of a rabbit in a trap to criticize the commission and the mayor, urging the election of the police chief. - A second speaker honored Nick Grant, a barista who subdued a thief with bear spray, and called for recognition. - A third speaker, Ms. Brown, expressed disappointment over the impending departure of Vice President Max Carter Oberstone, citing his role in implementing a resolution to encourage tipsters. She asked for his retention and support for unsolved homicides, referencing her son's murder. - Public Comment on Chief's Report: - Ms. Brown again spoke, requesting that leaders who help families of homicide victims stay in their positions. She displayed a photo of her son and urged the public to come forward with information on his case. - Public Comment on DPA Director's Report: - No public comment. - Public Comment on Commission Reports: - No public comment. - Public Comment on SFPD Budget: - Ms. Brown asked whether reduced crime levels would free up investigators to work on unsolved homicides. Chief Scott responded that the drop in homicides has allowed more time for cold cases, noting her assigned investigator recently had surgery. - Public Comment on DPA Budget: - No public comment. Discussion Items Chief's Report (Item 4) - Chief Scott presented weekly crime trends: total violent crimes down 14%, total property crimes down 39%. Homicides year-to-date: 1 (vs. 3 last year), robberies down 22%, assaults up 2%. Property crime reductions led by car burglaries down 76% (451 vs. 1,100 a year ago). Shootings up 7% (16 victims vs. 15). - Detailed five non-fatal shootings from January 27 to February 2, including an officer-involved shooting on January 27 at 9th and Mission (victim in stable condition). - Significant arrests: an underground gambling operation in the Tenderloin with seizure of over $30,000 cash; a DMAC fugitive operation netted 59 arrests in one day. - Seven blessing scams reported; awareness efforts led to one potential victim recognizing the scam and calling police. - Commissioner Yi asked about the shooting suspect's criminal history and possible mental health issues; Chief Scott said the investigation is ongoing, including ballistics checks. - President Lyons asked about ICE rumors. Chief Scott said several false alarms had been verified as inaccurate (e.g., a mistaken claim about ICE on Muni buses). He reiterated SFPD does not participate in immigration enforcement. President Lyons requested an update at the next meeting on the department's policy regarding interactions with federal agents given the sanctuary city status. DPA Director's Report (Item 5) - Executive Director Paul Henderson reported: 44 new cases opened, 29 closed. Top allegation: neglect of duty. Nineteen investigations open for more than 270 days, 16 of which are

POLICE OVERSIGHT 30% · PUBLIC SAFETY 26% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 18% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14%
533
FEB 4, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - February 4, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on February 4, 2025, for its regular meeting. The board passed Mayor Lurie's emergency ordinance granting expanded powers to tackle the fentanyl and homelessness crisis after significant debate and amendment, approved over $70 million in various grants and contracts, and recognized several retiring public servants and community leaders. Consent Calendar - Items 1-9: All routine items on the consent calendar were approved unanimously. These included the appropriation of $40 million in General Obligation Bond proceeds for preservation and seismic safety, settlement of two lawsuits for a combined total of $545,016.38, planning code amendments for health service uses, and the establishment of a Cole Valley Entertainment Zone. Public Comments & Testimony - ADA Accommodations (Start of Meeting): Three individuals needing accommodation spoke against the impending closure of the Bayview Vehicle Triage Center (VTC). Ramona Mayan argued the closure violated the City Charter due to a lack of a public hearing. Kelly Hughes, a wheelchair user with a pending HUD complaint, stated her RV repairs were stalled by the city and requested a 90-day extension, alleging retaliation related to her ADA advocacy. A third speaker echoed the need for more time to complete essential vehicle repairs. - General Public Comment: Speakers expressed opposition to the VTC closure, with Aaron Wilson urging the city to provide more RV parking, not less. Residents voiced mixed views on the city's enforcement strategy; one speaker described enforcement-focused plans as a "new kind of carceral purgatory," while another voiced strong support for Mayor Lurie and District Attorney Brooke Jenkins' approach to improve street safety. Jim McFee raised concerns about financial transparency and patient costs at Laguna Honda Hospital. A taxi worker requested the board regulate autonomous vehicles and better support Muni. Discussion Items - Commercial Vacancy Tax Exemption (Item 12): The board passed an ordinance exempting commercial spaces in neighborhoods impacted by long-term city construction projects (over 180 days) from the commercial vacancy tax. (Passed on first reading.) - Emergency Ordinance on Homelessness, Drug Abuse, and Mental Health (Item 13): This was the central debate. Supervisor Chan introduced amendments limiting non-governmental donations to $10 million, narrowing the scope of behested payment waivers, and setting a January 8, 2026, sunset date. Supervisor Fielder expressed conditional support, stating the ordinance represented an "unprecedented transfer of power" and she was putting "great faith" in Mayor Lurie to execute responsibly. Supervisor Mahmood supported the ordinance for cutting government red tape. Supervisor Walton strongly opposed the ordinance, arguing the board was "putting the cart before the horse" and granting a "blank check" without a concrete plan. The amended ordinance passed on first reading with a 10-1 vote, with Supervisor Walton dissenting. - Grants and Contracts (Items 14-18): The board approved a $21.5 million grant amendment with Episcopal Community Services for rapid rehousing. It also approved over $48 million in retroactive agreements with the Community Youth Center of San Francisco, Instituto Familiar de la Raza, and the Richmond District Neighborhood Center for youth and community programs. Supervisor Sauter disclosed a prior professional relationship with the Richmond District Neighborhood Center's fiscal sponsor. - Other Business (Items 10-11, 20-29): The board unanimously approved financing for Port projects, liquor license transfers, property leases, a planning code amendment for 99 Rhode Island Street, an exemption for Midtown Park Apartments from construction contracting requirements, and the naming of "Jesai Kingston Way" as a commemorative street. - Commendations and Recognitions (Special Order 2:30 PM): - The Lincoln High School girls' flag football team was honored for winning the first-ever girls' Turkey Day Bowl championship. - Joyce Armstrong was celebrated as a Black History Month honoree for decades of community advocacy. - Brian Chu was recognized upon his retirement from the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development after 20 years of service. - Dr. Grant Colfax received a special commendation for his six-year tenure as Director of the Department of Public Health, where he led the city through the COVID-19 pandemic, reduced nurse vacancy rates to zero percent, and oversaw a 72% decline in HIV infections since 2012. - New Legislation Introduced: Supervisor Fielder introduced a resolution recognizing February 2025 as Teen Dating Violence Awareness and Prevention Month. Supervisor Mandelman introduced an ordinance to establish a Castro Upper Market Entertainment Zone. Supervisor Melgar introduced a resolution supporting SFMTA's joint development goals. Supervisor Sherrill introduced a resolution supporting Assembly Bill 381 (Human Trafficking Procurement Prevention Act). Supervisor Dorsey called for a hearing on staffing needs in the District Attorney's office to implement Proposition 36. - For Adoption Without Committee Reference: The board unanimously adopted resolutions urging pharmacies to address pharmacy deserts (Item 32) and recognizing February 2025 as Black History Month (Item 33). Key Outcomes - Mayor Lurie's emergency ordinance to address the fentanyl crisis passed on first reading with a 10-1 vote, amended to include stricter financial oversight, spending caps, and a January 2026 sunset. - All consent items and the vast majority of the regular agenda were approved without objection or by unanimous vote. - Over $70 million in grants and contracts were approved for housing, youth, and health services. - The board adopted proclamations for Black History Month and Teen Dating Violence Awareness and Prevention Month. - The meeting was adjourned in memory of Richard Bolingbroke and Alan Baird.

PUBLIC COMMENT 24% · PUBLIC HEALTH 17% · HOMELESSNESS 15% · PROCEDURAL 8%
534
FEB 3, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Regular Meeting - February 3, 2025

The Rules Committee met on February 3, 2025, at 6:15 PM UTC, chaired by Supervisor Walton, with Vice Chair Sherrill and President Mandelman. The committee considered several items including a military equipment use policy, updates to conflict of interest code filing requirements, an amended airport surveillance technology policy, and multiple supervisory appointments. The meeting lasted approximately 30 minutes. Public Comments & Testimony - One member of the public, Leah McGeever (District 6 resident), spoke during the appointments (items 4-11). She opposed Supervisor Matt Dorsey’s appointment to the Reentry Council (Item 10), arguing that his legislative focus on criminalization and incarceration of homeless and drug-addicted individuals is at odds with the council’s mission of supporting justice-involved and formerly incarcerated people. Discussion Items Military Equipment Use Policy and Additional Equipment Approval – 2024 Annual Report (Item 1) Chair Walton expressed concern about approving a chemical weapon while an investigation into a training incident in San Mateo County that affected nearby schoolchildren is still ongoing, with an unclear timeline. He stated he would prefer to either continue the item or separate the chemical weapon from the request. He moved to forward the item to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). Campaign and Governmental Conduct Code – Form 700 Filing Requirements (Item 2) President Mandelman explained that this is a routine biennial update required by the Political Reform Act. Deputy City Attorney Brad Russian presented minor substantive amendments: adding the commission streamlining task force (approved via Prop E), adding and deleting assessor-recorder filers, and adding San Francisco Unified School District filers. The committee adopted the amendments unanimously and then voted to continue the amended item to the next Rules Committee meeting on February 10, 2025. Both motions passed unanimously (3-0). Administrative Code – Amended Airport Surveillance Technology Policy (Item 3) Guy Clark, IT Cybersecurity Compliance Manager at the San Francisco Airport, presented an amended policy that combines the existing automated license plate reader (ALPR) and ground transportation management system policy with the new parking assist/parking guidance system. The parking assist system uses cameras to guide drivers to available spaces and help them locate their vehicles via license plate lookup, but does not retain license plate data. The committee voted to recommend the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). Appointments to Regional and Local Bodies (Items 4-11) The committee called all eight appointments together: Item 4 – Supervisor Bilal Mahmood to Bay Area Air Quality Management District; Item 5 – Supervisor Connie Chan to Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC); Item 6 – Supervisor Matt Dorsey as alternate to BCDC; Item 7 – Supervisor Danny Sauter to Golden Gate Bridge, Highway and Transportation District; Item 8 – Supervisor Connie Chan to Free City College Oversight Committee; Item 9 – Supervisor Myrna Melgar to Metropolitan Transportation Commission; Item 10 – Supervisor Matt Dorsey to Reentry Council; Item 11 – Supervisor Matt Dorsey to Association of Bay Area Government Executive Board. After public comment, the committee voted to recommend all appointments to the full Board of Supervisors. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Military Equipment Policy): Forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation. - Item 2 (Conflict of Interest Code): Amended and continued to the February 10, 2025 Rules Committee meeting. - Item 3 (Airport Surveillance Policy): Recommended for approval to the full Board of Supervisors (appears on February 11, 2025 agenda). - Items 4-11 (Appointments): All eight appointments recommended for approval to the full Board of Supervisors. No other business was before the committee, and the meeting adjourned.

PROCEDURAL 54% · TECHNOLOGY AND INFRASTRUCTURE 21% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 10% · JUSTICE AND CORRECTIONS 8%
535
FEB 3, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - February 3, 2025

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 3, 2025, at 9:45 AM. Presiding was Chair Mirna Melgar, joined by Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood. The committee addressed three agenda items: an ordinance amending the Inclusionary Housing Ordinance to allow state tax credits for mixed-income projects, a hearing on the closure of the Safeway at 1355 Webster Street in the Fillmore District, and a resolution for a commemorative street name designation. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Inclusionary Housing): Multiple speakers expressed support, including representatives from the Housing Action Coalition, SF YIMBY, labor unions (carpenters, electrical workers), and community members. One speaker noted the project would bring 303 units (101 affordable, 202 market-rate) and a child care center. Some speakers urged that the city prioritize 100% affordable projects and ensure certificate of preference holders are included. - Item 2 (Safeway Closure): Over 40 speakers testified, most expressing anger, frustration, and a sense of abandonment. Key themes: historical trauma from redevelopment, need for a full-service grocery store, pharmacy, and banking; concerns about safety and the parking lot; calls for eminent domain, community ownership, and immediate interim solutions. Speakers included community leaders (Reverend Amos Brown, Japan Town Task Force, Booker T. Washington Center), residents, and union representatives. Several speakers criticized Safeway’s lack of cooperation and urged the city to hold the corporation accountable. Discussion Items 1. Planning Code - Inclusionary Housing Ordinance (File 240873) - Purpose: Allow market-rate projects using California Debt Limit Allocation Committee (CLDAC) and Tax Credit Allocation Committee (TCAC) financing to provide additional affordable units beyond inclusionary requirements. - Amendments: Supervisor Souter proposed narrow exemptions from the Non-Potable Water Ordinance (NPO) for projects providing at least 100 on-site affordable units, using state subsidies, and obtaining a building permit by July 1, 2025. Supervisor Chen proposed amendments to: (1) affirm city policy prioritizing 100% affordable projects for TCAC/CLDAC subsidies, (2) require developers to provide an additional 25% (effectively 4% more) of the baseline inclusionary requirement, and (3) require MOHCD to monitor and report on impacts to 100% affordable projects. - Staff Reports: Veronica Flores (Planning) confirmed the Planning Commission recommended approval with technical clarifications. City Attorney Brad Russian stated amendments do not require re-referral to Planning Commission. - Committee Discussion: Chair Melgar expressed concern about using environmental regulations as a trade-off but supported the amendments. Both sets of amendments were adopted unanimously (3-0). The ordinance was continued to the February 10, 2025 meeting. 2. Hearing - Safeway Closure at 1355 Webster Street (File 250050) - Context: Safeway announced closure in January 2024, initially set for March 2024, extended to January 2025. Pharmacy closed February 7, 2025. The store is privately owned; a pending sale to a developer (Align Real Estate) has been announced but no formal plans submitted. - Presentations: - Food Security Task Force (Sissy Bonini): 1 in 4 San Franciscans are food insecure. The Western Addition (zip 94115) has 34,000 residents, 4,000 below poverty, 4,000 CalFresh recipients. Chronic disease rates are 4x higher for Black residents. The city cut $35.4 million from food programs between FY22-23 and FY24-25. - OEWD (Diana Ponce de Leon): City worked with HRC to hold community meetings, expand paratransit services (shuttles, taxi vouchers), and support food giveaways. Next steps: explore legislative reform, activate the parking lot, and attract a new grocery store. - Planning Department (Rachel Tanner): The site is zoned for mixed-use; a grocery store could return. A conditional use permit (CUP) for formula retail would take 6-9 months, plus 3-6 months for tenant improvements. Options to streamline: eliminate CUP for grocery stores. - SFPD Captain Jason Sawyer: Theft was not uniquely from the community; arrests showed no pattern. Parking lot issues required Safeway’s cooperation, which was difficult. Security is needed post-closure. - Public Testimony: Over 50 speakers, including community leaders, residents, and representatives from Booker T. Washington Center, Japan Town Task Force, NAACP, and labor. Key demands: immediate interim food access, a full-service grocery store, community control, and accountability. Many called for eminent domain or the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act (COPA). - Supervisor Mahmood’s Comments: He committed to (1) legislative reform to expedite a replacement grocery store, (2) short-term activation and food distribution, and (3) long-term affordable grocery store. He acknowledged the trauma of redevelopment and the need for transparency. 3. Commemorative Street Name - "Jesai Kingston Way" (File 250049) - Proposal: Rename Ingerson Avenue between 3rd and Griffith Streets to honor Jesai Kingston, a young community leader and advocate. - Action: No public comment. Approved unanimously (3-0) as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors for February 4, 2025. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Inclusionary Housing): The ordinance was amended twice (Souter amendments on NPO exemption and Chen amendments on prioritization and affordability requirement) and continued to February 10, 2025, for a vote. All amendments passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2 (Safeway Closure): The hearing was filed (no vote). Supervisor Mahmood outlined three work streams: legislative reform for expedited grocery replacement, short-term activation and food resources, and long-term grocery store. Continued community engagement and interdepartmental coordination were promised. - Item 3 (Street Naming): Resolution approved as a committee report (3-0) for Board of Supervisors consideration on February 4, 2025.

FOOD ACCESS 21% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 16% · LAND USE 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13%
536
JAN 29, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - January 29, 2025

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Supervisor Joan Guardio, met on January 29, 2025, to consider 15 agenda items. The committee forwarded most items to the full Board of Supervisors with recommendations, including a major ordinance to accelerate the city's response to homelessness, drug overdoses, and mental health crises. The meeting included presentations from department heads, budget analyst reports, and public testimony. Item 1: Clean Slate Grant – Retroactive Acceptance of $250,000 from Crankstart Foundation - Discussion: Public Defender Minod Rajou and Clean Slate Unit Manager Kelly Pretzer presented the grant to fund the managing attorney position. The grant period is July 1, 2024 – June 30, 2025, retroactively approved. Since 2017, Crankstart has provided approximately $1.9 million. The Clean Slate Unit has expunged 60,000 records since 1999, and a 2019 Harvard study found a 25% wage gain within two years of expungement. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Motion to forward to full board with positive recommendation passed unanimously (3-0). Items 2: Episcopal Community Services Rapid Rehousing Amendment – Not to Exceed $21,524,980 - Discussion: Deputy Director Emily Cohen (HSH) presented the third amendment to extend the grant term through June 2027 and increase funding by $11.5 million to serve 305 adults (up from 230). The program provides 12-24 month rental subsidies and case management. The budget analyst noted that the contractor had missed the 75-day housing placement target in the past two fiscal years (over 100 days), but recent improvements have brought it to 74.4 days. Chair Chan expressed concern about underspending and placement delays. Vice Chair Dorsey asked about use of "Our City, Our Home" funds, confirming this falls under the temporary housing carve-out (up to 12% of 50% housing allocation). - Public Comment: Chris Calendrillo (ECS Chief Program Officer) thanked the committee. Two other speakers: one questioned the number of clients housed, and another praised the partnership with faith-based organizations. - Outcome: Motion to forward to full board with positive recommendation passed (3-0). Items 3 & 4: Port of San Francisco Certificates of Participation Refunding – Up to $25,000,000 - Presentation: The Controller's Office presented two ordinances to refund outstanding 2013B and 2013C COPs for the Port of San Francisco, generating projected savings. Current good faith estimate shows 2.9% NPV savings, but current market rates project over 5%. The city will only issue if savings exceed 3% threshold. The lease asset is Pier 27 cruise terminal. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Motion to forward both ordinances to full board with positive recommendation passed (3-0). Item 5: Coro Northern California Fellowship – In-Kind Gift Valued at $345,000 - Discussion: MOHCD Director of Policy Sheila Nicolopoulos presented the two-year fellowship to research SRO housing policy. The fellow starts February 3, 2025. Chair Chan noted the minimal retroactivity (one day). - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Motion to forward to full board with positive recommendation passed (3-0). Item 6: Portsmouth Square Garage Free Parking, Transit Fares, and Ambassadors – $250,000 from General Reserve - Discussion: SFMTA's Joel Ramos presented the request for free two-hour parking at Portsmouth Square Garage (Jan 28 – Feb 28, 2025), free Muni on Feb 15-16, and community ambassadors. The total cost estimated at $559,000, but the ordinance only appropriated $250,000. Budget analyst noted the General Reserve must be replenished. Chair Chan proposed an amendment to increase the appropriation by $276,000 (to cover parking and transit fares only, striking ambassador language), and to continue the item to the next meeting. The amendment was made and the item continued to February 5, 2025. - Public Comment: Several speakers supported free parking and ambassadors, one questioned ambassador staffing. - Outcome: Motion to amend and continue passed (3-0). Item 7: Commercial Vacancy Tax Exemption for Construction Zones - Discussion: Chair Chan sponsored the ordinance to exempt commercial spaces in districts with city-led public infrastructure projects lasting over 180 days, retroactive to 2022 for Taraval Street districts. Treasurer's Office Amanda Freed explained the automatic exemption process. Supervisor Guardio co-sponsored. - Public Comment: One speaker expressed frustration with vacancies and criticized city policies. - Outcome: Motion to forward to full board with positive recommendation passed (3-0). Item 8: Core Initiatives to Address Homelessness, Drug Overdose, and Mental Health – Major Ordinance - Discussion: This was the most debated item. Mayor Lurie's policy advisor Ali Bondi and policy director Kunal Modi presented the ordinance, which creates a "shot clock" for board approval of contracts (45 days), waives competitive bidding, delegates authority, and provides a behested payment waiver for six months. The ordinance defines five core initiatives: 24/7 drop-off stabilization center, interim shelter beds, treatment beds, hiring public safety/behavioral health professionals, and tapping philanthropic funding. The administration emphasized urgency, citing 4,300 unsheltered residents and a fentanyl crisis. The budget analyst (Nick Bernard) warned of risks: increased costs, potential for waste/fraud/abuse, and loss of board oversight. He noted that even during COVID, FEMA required competitive bidding. The analyst called it a "policy matter" for the board. - Amendments: The mayor's office offered 15 amendments, including: reducing the contract threshold from $50M to $25M, capping non-governmental donations at $10M, adding a one-year sunset (Jan 8, 2026), requiring quarterly reports, and clarifying that state/federal procurement rules still apply. The committee adopted all amendments. - Public Comment: Extensive testimony (over 20 speakers). Supporters included labor unions (Laborers Local 261), recovery advocates, small business owners, and residents who cited the severity of the crisis. Opponents included the LBE community (concerned about waiving local business enterprise requirements), harm reduction advocates (who wanted clearer goals and metrics), and some residents who questioned the approach. The mayor's office clarified that LBE requirements were not waived. - Outcome: Motion to amend adopted (3-0). Motion to forward amended ordinance to full board with positive recommendation adopted (3-0). Items 9-12: Department of Children, Youth and Families – Four Grant Agreements (Total $48.7M) - Discussion: Acting Director Sharice Dorsey Smith presented the five-year contracts with Community Youth Center of San Francisco ($13.7M + $11.7M), Instituto Familiar de la Raza ($12.9M), and Richmond District Neighborhood Center ($10.4M). She described new performance measures focusing on academic outcomes and violence prevention. An amendment corrected two typos in item 9 (youth numbers reduced from 60 to 40 and 640 to 230). - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Motion to amend item 9 and forward all four resolutions to full board with positive recommendation passed (3-0). Item 13: HSA/EDD Lease at 745 Franklin Street – $105,090/year - Discussion: Director of Real Estate Andrico Penick presented the five-year lease for the Jobs Now program. A typo corrects the end date from 2030 to 2029. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Motion to amend and forward to full board passed (3-0). Item 14: DPH Mental Health Clinic Lease at 729 Filbert Street – $437,146.50/year - Discussion: The lease amendment reduces rent from $55.30 to $39.50 per square foot. Lease term retroactive to Feb 1, 2024 through Jan 31, 2029. Budget analyst requested more information from DPH about operations, which Chair Chan urged to provide. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Motion to forward to full board with positive recommendation passed (3-0). Item 15: SFPD License with U.S. Coast Guard on Yerba Buena Island – $0 Rent - Discussion: The license allows SFPD to use a 2,700 sq ft building as a substation, replacing the Treasure Island substation. The city pays operating expenses; tenant improvements estimated $700K-$2.5M. Vice Chair Dorsey supported the no-cost lease. Chair Chan raised concerns about capital planning for police stations. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Motion to forward to full board with positive recommendation passed (3-0). Key Outcomes - The committee forwarded all items except Item 6 (continued) to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. - Item 6 was amended to increase funding for parking and transit fares only and continued to the February 5, 2025 meeting. - Item 8 was significantly amended with 15 amendments, including a reduced contract threshold, donation cap, and sunset date. - The committee emphasized oversight and transparency, particularly for the core initiatives ordinance.

PUBLIC HEALTH 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · PROCEDURAL 11% · HOMELESSNESS 11%
537
JAN 28, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – January 28, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on January 28, 2025, beginning at 10:15 a.m. The board approved the minutes from December 17, 2024, acted on a consent agenda, heard from Mayor Daniel Lurie, recognized commendations, continued a hearing on law enforcement reforms, and debated an appeal of a CEQA exemption for the Mid-Valencia Curbside Protected Bikeway project. The meeting included multiple public comment periods and concluded with the adoption of several resolutions. Consent Calendar - Approval of meeting minutes from December 17, 2024 (passed 11–0). - Settlement of lawsuit – Stern Grove Festival Association – $225,016.38 (Item 241164). - Settlement of lawsuit – Arthur Bailey Jr. – $320,000 (Item 241165). - Settlement of unlitigated claim – James Hourihan – $75,000 (Item 241167). - Numerous routine items from the regular agenda (Items 5–23, 29–32, 35, 37, 39–41) were adopted without objection. These included appropriations, agreements, and zoning amendments. Public Comments & Testimony - Dozens of speakers commented on the Mid-Valencia bikeway appeal, with merchants and residents expressing concerns about parking, business viability, and safety, while cyclists and advocacy groups supported the project as a life-saving infrastructure improvement. General public comment covered sanctuary city policy, taxi medallion issues, homelessness, and the mayor’s fentanyl emergency order. Discussion Items - Mayor's Appearance (2:00 p.m. Special Order): Mayor Daniel Lurie discussed his Fentanyl State of Emergency Order and invited collaboration. Supervisor Chan asked about the closure of St. Ann’s Home in the Richmond; the mayor committed to supporting residents and exploring future uses of the site with multiple city departments. - Commendations (2:30 p.m.): The board recognized Monica Walters, outgoing CEO of Wu Yee Children’s Services, for her decades of advocacy for early childhood education. The board also honored Teamsters Local 665 on its 100th anniversary, with several supervisors praising the union’s history and adaptability. - Committee of the Whole (3:00 p.m.): A hearing on the progress of U.S. Department of Justice recommendations regarding police reforms was continued to March 18, 2025, by a unanimous vote (11–0). - Mid-Valencia Bikeway Appeal (Items 25–28): The board heard a CEQA appeal filed by Vamanos, a community organization, arguing that the planning department’s statutory exemption determination was improper due to impacts on historic resources and unusual circumstances. The planning department explained that the project qualifies for a sustainable transportation statutory exemption (SB 922/SB 288) and that no further environmental review is required. The SFMTA presented extensive outreach efforts and the design evolution from center-running to curbside bikeways. After over an hour of public comment, Supervisor Fielder moved to affirm the exemption (Item 26) and table Items 27 and 28. The motion passed 10–0 (Supervisor Mandelman recused). - New Business Introductions (Roll Call): Supervisors introduced several items, including: - Supervisor Sherrill: a hearing on large commercial vacancies and an ordinance to permit formula retail on Van Ness Avenue. - Supervisor Walton: a resolution urging medical providers and pharmacies to expand services to underserved neighborhoods, and in memoriams for Rosa Ivalia Lima and Alan Beltran. - Supervisor Fielder: a resolution reaffirming San Francisco’s commitment to its Sanctuary City Ordinance (Item 37), which was adopted. - Supervisor Engardio: an in memoriam for Sue Tai No. - Supervisor Chan: a resolution condemning the executive order on birthright citizenship. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved (11–0). - Consent agenda and routine items adopted without objection. - Mid-Valencia bikeway appeal denied; statutory exemption affirmed (10–0). The project may proceed. - Committee of the Whole continued to March 18, 2025 (11–0). - Resolutions adopted: Lunar New Year (Item 35), Dreamforce sidewalk closure (Item 36), sanctuary city reaffirmation (Item 37), urging Walgreens to reconsider closures (Item 38), commending Monica Walters (Item 41), and others. - In memoriams read for Sue Tai No, Daniel Goldstein, Rosa Ivalia Lima, Alan Beltran, and Ina Dent Dearman.

PUBLIC COMMENT 23% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 19% · IMMIGRATION POLICY 15% · PROCEDURAL 9%
538
JAN 28, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - January 28, 2025

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on January 28, 2025, at 9:30 AM. The meeting covered water supply planning, contract awards, a joint powers agreement, employee recognitions, and public comments on water system management and affordability. Commissioners voted on several items, including consent calendar approval, contract modifications, and a water supply assessment for a development project. Consent Calendar - Item 7a – Contract WW-741R, Various Locations Spot Main Sewer Replacement No. 1, was approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: - Mr. DeCosta raised concerns about fire hydrant and cistern inspections, citing the 1989 earthquake and Southern California fires. He urged commissioners to clarify maintenance responsibilities between SFPUC and DPW. - Dave Warner criticized staff presentations as biased, particularly on demand projections, drought planning, and rates. He urged commissioners to increase due diligence, bring in outside experts, and hold workshops. - On Item 5a (Water Supply Planning): - Tom Smegel (BAWSCA CEO) expressed appreciation for the presentation and highlighted the importance of the level-of-service goal. He noted BAWSCA's upcoming regional water demand study. - A public speaker urged the commission to read the Raker Act, prioritize San Francisco's needs, and consider Indigenous water rights. - Jason Foster (Islais Richmond) requested that managing costs be added to planning priorities and that stakeholders reach consensus on planning assumptions. - Peter Drekmeier (Tuolumne River Trust) found the presentation outdated and called for a workshop. He questioned the design drought severity and cited data from the Long-Term Vulnerability Assessment (LTVA) showing the 1987-92 drought was a 1-in-420-year event. - Dave Warner again spoke, emphasizing data-driven risk assessment and stating that the LTVA indicated climate change may reduce drought frequency. - On Item 6 (BAWSCA Report): Peter Drekmeier commented, urging BAWSCA to closely review the Alternative Water Supply Plan. - On Item 9 (Water Supply Assessment): Peter Drekmeier argued the assessment lacked analysis of job-housing balance and recommended a joint meeting with the Planning Commission. - On Item 10 (Millbrae Campus Contract): Jason Foster asked about change order history and contract provisions related to performance audit findings. Discussion Items - Item 5a – San Francisco Water Supply Planning: Assistant General Manager Steve Ritchie presented an overview, noting that 85% of supply comes from the Tuolumne River, with the SFPUC using 14% of river flow. Current residential per capita use in San Francisco averages 41 gallons per day (among lowest in CA), and wholesale customers average 55 gallons per day. The planning premise includes an 8.5-year design drought (1987-92 plus two dry years) with no more than 20% rationing from a 265 MGD baseline. Challenges include the Bay-Delta Plan (potential 93 MGD impact), state curtailments, population growth (82,000 new units in SF over 10 years), and climate change. Alternative supplies include purified water (Pure Water Peninsula, South Bay), groundwater storage, and projects with Turlock/Modesto irrigation districts. Commissioners asked about the design drought’s conservatism, snowpack vs. rain impacts, trade-offs between storage and environmental flows, cost implications, and the feasibility of achieving 20% rationing given already low per-capita use. Ritchie emphasized that the system cannot go to zero storage, and the commission must plan for worse droughts. - Item 5b – Employee Retirement Recognition: Two retirees were honored: Michael Lacey (25 years, wastewater painter, also served in Navy and COVID health screening) and Frank McPartland (26 years, capital budget manager, not present). Commissioners thanked them for their service. - Item 6 – Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Report: Tom Smegel (CEO) noted BAWSCA’s role in reviewing SFPUC capital plans per the water supply agreement, which assures water supply reliability for 40,000+ businesses and communities. - Item 8 – First Amended Joint Powers Agreement (JPA) of the San Joaquin Tributaries Authority: Steve Ritchie explained the JPA updates to expand the authority’s focus beyond legal advocacy to include environmental protection and beneficial uses. The authority hired an executive director. Commissioners expressed interest in collaboration and re-engaging former member irrigation districts. Approved unanimously. - Item 9 – Water Supply Assessment for 447 Battery Street and 530 Sansome Street: Ritchie stated the assessment is a legally required document for the Planning Department, confirming water supply is sufficient for the project, which includes a 19-story tower with hotel, office, and commercial space, plus a standalone fire station at 447 Battery. Commissioner Arce noted a prior residential variant (256 apartments) but clarified the current proposal does not include housing. The assessment was approved 4-0 after public comment. - Item 10 – Contract WD-2900, Millbrae Campus Improvements: Project manager Tracy Cale presented the $269 million CMGC contract with Clark Construction ($5.1 million for pre-construction). The project will consolidate 400 staff from multiple locations, modernize the water quality lab, and meet essential facility seismic standards. Construction in three phases; environmental review pending. Approved unanimously. - Item 11 – Contract WD-2878A, Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery Phase 2A: Staff requested a 300-day increase in duration contingency (to 1,258 calendar days) with no cost change due to delays in installing vertical turbine line shafts (contractor did not initially follow manufacturer’s O&M manuals). Approved unanimously. - Item 12 – Contract WW-719A, Folsom Area Stormwater Improvements: Staff requested a $350,000 cost increase and 140-day duration increase due to unexpected issues during 60-inch sewer pipe installation on 11th Street (including damage to Muni overhead lines, absorbed by contractor). Approved unanimously. - Item 14 – Items Initiated by Commissioners: Commissioner Arce reported attending the Citizens Advisory Committee meeting and appreciated the dialogue. - Closed Session: The commission discussed Ralph Bauer vs. City and County of San Francisco. In open session, Commission Stacy announced a settlement recommendation was approved. Key Outcomes - Approved unanimously: Consent Calendar (Item 7a). - Approved unanimously: First Amended JPA of San Joaquin Tributaries Authority (Item 8). - Approved unanimously (4-0): Water Supply Assessment for 447 Battery/530 Sansome (Item 9). - Approved unanimously: Millbrae Campus CMGC contract (Item 10). - Approved unanimously: Duration contingency increase for Regional Groundwater Storage contract (Item 11). - Approved unanimously: Cost and duration contingency increases for Folsom Area Stormwater contract (Item 12). - Closed Session: The commission voted to recommend settlement of the Ralph Bauer case.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 37% · PUBLIC COMMENT 18% · PROCEDURAL 13% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 8%
539
JAN 27, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Regular Meeting – January 27, 2025

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, January 27, 2025, at City Hall. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Shamann Walton, joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Sherrill and later by President Rafael Mandelman. The committee considered six agenda items, including the creation of a new entertainment zone in Cole Valley, the Sheriff's annual military equipment use report, an exemption for affordable housing repairs, a payroll deduction fund for law enforcement assistance, and two reappointments. The meeting adjourned after approximately one hour. Consent Calendar - Item 3 (Midtown Park Apartments Exemption): Unanimously recommended to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. No public comment was received. - Item 4 (Employee Donations to Bay Area Law Enforcement Assistance Fund): Unanimously recommended as a committee report after public comment. - Item 5 (Reappointment of Supervisor Joel Engardio to Golden Gate Bridge Board): Unanimously recommended as a committee report despite public opposition. - Item 6 (Reappointment of Supervisor Shamann Walton to Bay Area Air Quality Management District Board): Unanimously recommended as a committee report. Chair Walton recused himself from the vote. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Sheriff's Military Equipment Use Policy): Leah McGeever (District 6 resident) opposed further militarization, stating the APEC zone fencing made her feel unsafe, and raised concerns about weapon use under the current federal administration. A second speaker questioned why a new chemical agent launcher would be approved given an ongoing investigation into a training incident. An McGee (civilian volunteer and academic expert) supported all of the Sheriff's requests, arguing that training and tools improve public safety. - Item 1 (Cole Valley Entertainment Zone): Dan Surratt (President, Cole Valley Merchants Association; owner of Finnegan's Wake) expressed strong support, noting community outreach at a December 2024 holiday market and letters from the Cole Valley Improvement Association. Jim Angelis (owner of Cole Valley Tavern and Vice President of the merchants association) supported the zone as a resident and business owner, citing struggling businesses and empty storefronts. - Item 4 (Bay Area Law Enforcement Assistance Fund): John Ehrlich (Secretary of BayLEAF) clarified that the fund is not requesting city money but only the ability to receive employee payroll deductions. Leah McGeever expressed sadness that widows and families must rely on charitable donations. - Item 5 (Reappointment of Supervisor Engardio): Eileen Boken (District 4 resident) opposed the reappointment, stating the supervisor's office was closed and dark on multiple occasions, and argued that the district's core functions and the city's $1 billion projected deficit require full attention, not additional board service. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Ordinance 241197 – Cole Valley Entertainment Zone): President Mandelman introduced the ordinance to create an entertainment zone on Cole Street (between Frederick and Parnassus) and Carl Street (between Schrader and Clayton). Ben Van Houten (Director of Nightlife Initiatives, OEWD) explained that entertainment zones allow adjacent restaurants and bars to sell open, to-go beverages in outdoor areas during street closures for events like night markets. State law requires beverages in non-metal, non-glass containers and a process to identify patrons over 21. The ordinance included a technical fix to remove a duplicative ABC permit requirement following changes in state law (SB 969). Non-substantive amendments were adopted unanimously. - Item 2 (Resolution 250017 – Sheriff's Military Equipment Use Policy Annual Report): Sheriff Miyamoto presented the 2024 annual report and requested approval for continued use of existing equipment, replenishment of used items, and one new item: a VKS Pro and PPC breacher (pepper ball launcher) capable of deploying chemical irritant from up to 150 feet with a targeting system. He detailed equipment usage: unmanned drones deployed at APEC; mobile command vehicle used for three events; breaching shotgun used only in training; 21 special response team and 24 patrol rifles deployed but not discharged; chemical agents and flashbangs used only in training. He reported a May 21, 2024 incident where chemical agent training at the San Bruno complex affected an adjacent school when a container's doors were open; the Sheriff's Office halted outdoor training, revised procedures, and is cooperating with the Bay Area Air Quality Management District. No formal misconduct complaints were received by the Department of Police Accountability in 2024. Supervisor Sherrill questioned patrol areas (DPH sites, civic center, Operation Safe Streets) and the difference between drones and robots (no recording or delivery capability). The committee voted to continue the item to the February 3, 2025 meeting, citing the ongoing investigation and the desire for a full committee present. - Item 3 (Ordinance 241207 – Midtown Park Apartments Exemption): Sheila Nicolopoulos (Director of Policy, MOHCD) presented the request to exempt 1415 Scott Street (140-unit affordable housing built 1964, predominantly African-American and senior households) from Administrative Code Chapter 6 contracting requirements. The city acquired the property after a private developer defaulted on a HUD-insured mortgage. Urgent repairs include boilers, plumbing, roof, fire sprinklers, and soft story improvements. 34 vacancies are held for tenant relocation. The exemption allows specialized contractors while requiring prevailing wage, apprenticeships, and SBE contracting. No public comment. Unanimously recommended. - Item 4 (Ordinance 241068 – Employee Donations to Bay Area Law Enforcement Assistance Fund): Sergeant Art Howard (SFPD Behavioral Science Unit, Executive Director of BayLEAF) requested that BayLEAF be added to city payroll deduction options. The fund provides financial and mental health support to active and retired law enforcement survivors and families across nine Bay Area counties. Since 2000, $2 million has been disbursed. The board covers all administrative costs, so 100% of donations go directly to aid. No questions from committee; after public comment, unanimously recommended. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unanimously recommended to the full board as a committee report (with amendments). - Item 2: Continued to the February 3, 2025 Rules Committee meeting. - Item 3: Unanimously recommended to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 4: Unanimously recommended as a committee report. - Item 5: Unanimously recommended as a committee report. - Item 6: Unanimously recommended as a committee report (Chair Walton recused).

PUBLIC SAFETY 29% · PROCEDURAL 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · ENTERTAINMENT POLICY 13%
540
JAN 27, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - January 27, 2025

This meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Land Use and Transportation Committee was called to order by Chair Mirna Melgar. Supervisor Cheyenne Chen was excused due to illness. The committee considered three agenda items: an ordinance to allow a school at 99 Rhode Island Street, a resolution adopting the Castro LGBTQ Cultural District's Cultural, History, Housing, and Economic Sustainability Strategy (CHHESS) report, and an ordinance on disability access improvements (continued to a future meeting). All items were moved forward with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (99 Rhode Island Street): Jackson Nutbeer, representing the San Francisco Chamber of Commerce, expressed support for the ordinance, stating that schools foster vibrant communities. Celia Schumann, representing Show Place East (11 Rhode Island Street), spoke in support, noting the positive evolution of the neighborhood and the school as a logical next step. - Item 2 (Castro LGBTQ Cultural District CHHESS Report): Multiple speakers expressed strong support. Dr. Emily Murase Sheeher (Japantown Cultural District director) commended the work and urged approval. Roberto Ordenana (GLBT Historical Society executive director) emphasized the importance of the report and the need to fund the activities outlined. Ben Chavez Gilliam (GLBT Historical Society board chair) shared personal testimony about the significance of the Castro. Brian Springfield (Friends of Harvey Milk Plaza) highlighted collaboration on inclusive plaza design. Jennifer J. Dubb Wagoner (Eureka Valley Neighborhood Association president) praised the cultural humility work and urged citywide adoption of similar approaches. Discussion Items - Item 1 (99 Rhode Island Street): Supervisor Matt Dorsey introduced an ordinance to allow the property at 99 Rhode Island Street (Assessor's Block 3912, Lot 2) to exceed cumulative use size limits in the PDR-1 Design District to accommodate a pre-kindergarten through fifth grade school operated by HEBA Academy. The Planning Commission approved the measure on January 9, 2025. The committee voted to recommend the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (Castro LGBTQ Cultural District CHHESS Report): Calvin Ho (Office of Supervisor President Mandelman) introduced the item. Grace Lee (MOHCD Cultural Districts Manager) provided an overview of the Cultural Districts Program. Tina Aguirre (Castro LGBTQ Cultural District Director), along with co-authors Gerard Koskovich and Jen Reck, presented the CHHESS report, which is a strategic plan for preserving and strengthening the LGBTQ+ community in the Castro. The report covers six priority areas: economic and workforce development, tenant protections and housing, placekeeping and placemaking, cultural humility and competence, arts and culture, and history and heritage. Examples included small business grants, affordable housing for LGBTQ elders, DEIA training, the Living Lesbian Legends Project, and collaboration on Harvey Milk Plaza redesign. The committee voted to recommend the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors. - Item 3 (Disability Access Improvements): An ordinance amending the Building, Administrative, and Public Works Codes to remove local requirements for accessible primary entries and paths of travel in places of public accommodation. The committee voted to continue this item to the February 10, 2025 meeting without discussion, per the request of the sponsor. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to recommend the ordinance to the Board of Supervisors passed 2-0 (Melgar and Mahmood aye; Chen excused). - Item 2: Motion to recommend the resolution adopting the CHHESS report to the Board of Supervisors passed 2-0 (Melgar and Mahmood aye; Chen excused). - Item 3: Motion to continue the ordinance to the February 10, 2025 meeting passed 2-0 (Melgar and Mahmood aye; Chen excused).

CULTURAL DISTRICTS 23% · LAND USE 20% · LGBTQ+ HISTORY 19% · PROCEDURAL 15%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com