Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 541–550 ENTRIES
541
JAN 23, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - January 23, 2025

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, January 23, 2025, at 8:15 PM UTC. The meeting included continuations, consent calendar approvals, a discussion on a previously approved project at 4100 3rd Street, general public comment, informational presentations on the department budget, aging and disability housing plan, and office conversion inventory, followed by two regular calendar items: a resolution for active use waiver at 1035 Howard Street and a conditional use authorization for a tantamount demolition at 28-30 Day Street. All votes were unanimous (6-0) where taken. Consent Calendar - Items 4 & 5: Approved unanimously. Item 4 (2900 Alemany Boulevard) established a 33,000 sq ft gym (Touchstone Climbing). Item 5 (1210 9th Avenue) established a formula retail use (Mixt). Public Comments & Testimony - 4100 3rd Street Discussion: Multiple community members spoke against the previously approved conversion of group housing to social services, citing inaccurate statements in the application and lack of community engagement. Bayview residents expressed need for active retail and protection of the African American cultural district. Supporters from Friends of the Children emphasized the program's benefits for underserved youth. - General Public Comment: Georgia Shudish presented photographic evidence of flats policy violations and argued for codification. A second speaker presented a theory on time and fusion. - Budget Presentation: Over a dozen speakers, including representatives from the American Indian Cultural District, Tenderloin community organizations, and Mission Housing, urged the commission to approve the equity budget, emphasizing its role in supporting marginalized communities and downtown recovery. - Aging and Disability Housing Plan: Ocean Coast from Senior and Disability Action spoke in support of funding an implementation coordinator and dedicated elevator maintenance funds. - 1035 Howard Street: Approximately 20 speakers opposed the waiver, citing concerns about self-storage use, insufficient community benefit, and adverse impacts on the Soma Pilipinas Cultural District. Union representatives and project supporters highlighted job creation, historic preservation, and long-term community space agreements. - 28-30 Day Street: Five neighbors and a resident read letters of strong support, praising the project sponsor's community engagement and the design improvements. Discussion Items - Item 9 – 4100 3rd Street: Commissioners revisited a previously approved housing removal CU. Discussion centered on community engagement gaps, the importance of early coordination with the supervisor's office, and internal process improvements. No action taken. - Item 12 – FY2025-2027 Budget & Work Program: Chief Financial Officer Deborah Landis presented a $1.4 million general fund reduction, offset by new federal grants ($7M from HUD, $3M from EPA, etc.). The budget prioritizes equity, maintaining core services, and adjusting to declining permit volume. Commissioners supported the approach and requested mid-year tracking. - Item 13 – Aging and Disability Affordable Housing Implementation Plan: Senior Planner Melina Leon Ferrera outlined six objectives and 49 actions to address housing needs for older adults and adults with disabilities. Key priorities include funding a coordinator, piloting assisted living facilities, and elevator maintenance. Commissioners commended the interagency collaboration. - Item 14 – Office Conversion and Demolition Inventory: Zoning Administrator Corey Teague presented the final inventory, identifying 2.3 million sq ft of office conversions/demolitions since 1986, credited under Proposition C. The inventory boosted the large cap from 100,000 to over 2 million sq ft. Key Outcomes - Item 16 – 1035 Howard Street (Active Use Waiver): Approved unanimously with a resolution to waive active use requirements on upper floors only, consistent with HPC recommendations. Added non-binding encouragements for transparent roll-up doors (if compatible with Mills Act), off-street loading where feasible, and a perimeter corridor on upper floors to improve visibility. The ground floor must be fully code-compliant; staff will continue to refine the plans. - Item 15 – 28-30 Day Street (Tantamount Demolition CU): Approved unanimously with conditions. The project preserves two existing rent-controlled flats and adds a new fully accessible unit, resulting in a net gain of one unit. The sponsor received extensive neighbor support and made voluntary setbacks to protect views. All motions passed 6-0.

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 14% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 11%
542
JAN 23, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Regular Meeting - January 23, 2025

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on January 23, 2025, at 6:15 PM. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Joel Engardio present. The committee considered two liquor license transfer applications. Both items were approved unanimously with recommended conditions. Discussion Items - Item 1: Liquor License Transfer for Bitters and Bottles (1275 Fell Street, District 5) – Officer Freundes from SFPD's ABC Liaison Unit presented a Public Convenience or Necessity (PCN) report for Bar Ants LLC, doing business as Bitters and Bottles, applying for a Type 21 off-sale general liquor license. There were zero letters of protest and zero letters of support. The location is in Plot 642C (high crime area) and Census Tract 164 (high concentration area). Park Station had no opposition. The recommended condition requires the petitioner to actively monitor the area to prevent loitering on adjacent property. Supervisor Dorsey noted that Supervisor Dean Preston's office supports the business. No public comment was received. The committee voted to prepare a resolution finding that the license would serve public convenience and necessity. - Item 2: Liquor License Transfer for City Choice Market (301 5th Street, District 6) – Officer Freundes presented a PCN report for City Choice Market Inc., applying for a Type 21 off-sale general liquor license. There were zero letters of protest and zero letters of support. The location is in Plot 264A (low crime area) and Census Tract 178.01 (low concentration area). Southern Station had no opposition. Recommended conditions include monitoring the area to prevent loitering and maintaining the adjacent areas free of litter. Supervisor Dorsey, whose district includes this location, expressed support, noting positive feedback from constituents. The applicant was present and thanked the committee. No public comment was received. The committee voted to prepare a resolution finding that the license would serve public convenience and necessity. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to prepare a resolution and forward to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed 2-0 (Vice Chair Engardio aye, Chair Dorsey aye). - Item 2: Motion to prepare a resolution and forward to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed 2-0 (Vice Chair Engardio aye, Chair Dorsey aye). - Both items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on February 4, 2025.

LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 60% · PROCEDURAL 40%
543
JAN 22, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Regular Meeting – January 22, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee met on January 22, 2025, at 6:15 PM. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman and Supervisor Matt Dorsey (sitting in for Supervisor Melgar, who was excused). The committee considered 12 regular agenda items, including grant acceptances, contract amendments, bond issuances, and affordable housing loans. All items were approved unanimously with positive recommendations to the full Board of Supervisors. No public comments were offered on any item. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1 (241105): Resolution to retroactively accept and expend a $410,000 grant from the California Department of Industrial Relations for workers' rights enforcement. Supervisors Chan, Dorsey, and Mandelman added themselves as co-sponsors. The committee moved the item forward with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (241058): Resolution to approve an amendment to the AECOM Technical Services contract for the Mountain Tunnel Improvement Project, increasing the amount by $9.5 million to a total of $34 million and extending the term by five months. The SFPUC presented the project scope, including a 150-foot-deep shaft, 11 miles of tunnel lining repair, and five outages. The BLA noted no performance issues. The committee approved. - Item 3 (241090): Resolution to retroactively accept and expend a $496,684 grant from the James Irvine Foundation for the Public Workforce Capacity Fund, supporting worker-owner cooperative models. OEWD explained the grant will scale existing cooperatives with 86 members and 48 employed. The committee approved. - Item 4 (250033): Resolution to accept and expend a $750,000 grant from the Metropolitan Transportation Commission for the Visitacion Avenue Pedestrian and Bicycle Safety Improvement Project. Recreation and Park Department presented the project, which includes connectivity improvements and a 20-year maintenance obligation. The committee approved. - Item 5 (241215): Resolution to retroactively accept and expend a $750,000 grant from the California Department of Health Care Services (via Heluna Health) for implementing MATCH therapy for youth. DPH presented plans to train 24 therapists and serve 384 youth. The committee approved amendments to remove PCIT references and correct the number of youth from 1,800 to 384. The amended resolution was approved. - Item 6 (241156): Resolution to approve a contract with Pitney Bowes, Inc. for mailroom equipment and supplies, not to exceed $23,550,000 over five years. OCA noted 99% of the cost is for USPS postage, with discounts of 4 cents per letter and up to 88% on shipping. The committee approved. - Item 7 (241152): Resolution to approve a contract with Agurto Corporation (Pestec) for integrated pest management services, not to exceed $15,500,000 over five years. OCA described the competitive RFP process and the environmentally safe practices required by the San Francisco Environment Code. The committee approved. - Item 8 (241089): Resolution to accept and expend a $23,405.32 donation from the Margaret Seneshen Living Trust for the Police Department Mounted Unit. SFPD noted the unit is the second longest-serving mounted unit in the country. The committee approved. - Items 9 & 10 (241170 & 241171): Resolutions to authorize the sale of up to $40 million in General Obligation Bonds (Preservation and Seismic Safety, Series 2025E) and appropriate the proceeds for affordable housing acquisition and rehabilitation. MOHCD and OPF presented the financing structure, including a 40-year term, an estimated interest cost of $71.5 million, and a property tax impact of $0.31 to $4.52 per year for a $600,000 home. The民 committee approved an amendment to correct the bond type from certificates of participation to general obligation bonds. Both items were approved as amended. - Item 11 (241175): Resolution to authorize application for a $1.5 million grant from the California Department of Housing and Community Development's Prohousing Incentive Program, supporting 95 units of affordable senior housing at 976 Mission Street. MOHCD noted the city received the prohousing designation in October 2024. The committee approved. - Item 12 (241135): Resolution to approve a loan amendment with 2530 18th LLC for 100% affordable housing at 2530-18th Street, increasing the total loan amount to $11,846,900. MOHCD explained the project was redesigned to increase units from 74 to 96 and eliminate HPP office space to improve financing feasibility. The committee approved. Key Outcomes - All 12 agenda items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, each by a unanimous vote of 3-0 (Mandelman, Dorsey, Chan). - Items 1, 3, 5, 9, 10, and 11 had supervisors added as co-sponsors. - Items 5 and 9 were amended prior to approval: Item 5 removed references to PCIT and corrected youth count; Item 9 corrected the bond instrument from certificates of participation to general obligation bonds.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 24% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 21% · PROCEDURAL 18% · PROCUREMENT 12%
544
JAN 16, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - January 16, 2025

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular meeting on Thursday, January 16, 2025, at 8:15 PM (UTC). The meeting covered a range of items including continuances, consent approvals, commission matters, department updates, an informational presentation on the Racial and Social Equity Action Plan, an informational presentation on an SB 423 project, and a discretionary review hearing for a two-unit development on Clipper Street. Commissioners elected new officers and engaged in extensive discussion regarding a prior project controversy in the Bayview. Consent Calendar - Item 4 – 2740-2744 Mission Street (Pollo Campero): The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to approve a Conditional Use Authorization allowing an existing limited restaurant and formula retail use to expand. - Continuances (Items 1, 2, 3): All three items were continued unanimously (7-0) to future dates: 1035 Howard Street (Active Use waiver) to January 23, 2025; 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue (fleet charging) to February 13, 2025; 77 Broad Street (discretionary review of addition) to February 27, 2025. Commission Matters - Land Acknowledgement: The Commission acknowledged the unceded ancestral homeland of the Ramaytush Ohlone people. - Comments & Questions – 4100 Third Street Project: Commissioners discussed a letter from Supervisor Walton’s office regarding potential misrepresentation of support letters for the project (approved the prior week). Deputy Director Liz Wadi clarified that letters in the file pertained to a grant, not the project itself, and that no falsehoods were presented. Commissioners acknowledged the confusion and agreed to improve communication protocols. Commissioner Williams initially moved to re-hear the conditional use but rescinded the motion after discussion; the Commission agreed to agendize a broader conversation on communication strategies for the Bayview in a future meeting. - Election of Officers: The Commission unanimously elected Commissioner So as President and Commissioner Moore as Vice President (7-0). Department Matters - Director’s Announcements & Review of Past Events: Director Hillis reported that the Board of Supervisors on December 17, 2024, denied a CEQA appeal (9-0) for the 1719 Wallace Avenue cannabis cultivation project. He also noted land use committee appointments (Supervisor Melgar as chair) and an upcoming ordinance for health service uses in West Portal. The Historic Preservation Commission approved legacy business applications for Cha Cha Cha, Golden Gate Park Band, City Optics, and San Francisco Flower Mart, and discussed a North Beach National Register Historic District nomination (comments due January 31, 2025) and preservation alternatives for 530 Sansome/447 Battery Street. Racial and Social Equity Action Plan (Item 10) - Presentation: Carla DeMessa (Community Equity Division) presented the department’s Racial and Social Equity Action Plan, focusing on new external strategies (Equitable Planning and Community Engagement) to supplement internal operations. The plan is mandated by the Office of Racial and Social Equity. Community testimony from the Equity Advisory Council (Dell Seymour, Mary Travis Allen, William Ortiz Cartagena, Majid Crawford, Masakimi, Raquel Redondiez) emphasized historical harms, the need for continued trust-building, and the importance of community-led planning. Public comment from three Tenderloin residents supported the plan and highlighted community pride. - Commission Discussion: Commissioners expressed strong support. Commissioner Imperial stressed resources for Bayview, legal binding for community benefits, and downtown recovery as an equity strategy. Commissioner Braun prioritized internal capacity, tools for tracking, and integration of community input. Commissioner Moore called for resources allocation and inclusion of adjacent neighborhoods in downtown recovery. Commissioner Williams noted departmental diversity gaps and asked about staff retention and the equity council’s expansion. Commissioner Campbell raised concerns about objective design standards in cultural districts and the feasibility of some environmental justice actions. The Commission thanked staff and the Equity Advisory Council. The plan will return for adoption in March 2025. Informational Presentation – 1474 South Van Ness Avenue (Item 11) - Presentation: Project sponsor Riyadh Ganam (RG Architecture) presented plans for a nine-unit development (one affordable unit at very low AMI) on a 40-foot-wide lot, including restoring a historic single-family home and constructing a six-story, eight-unit building along Cypress Street. The project uses SB 423 streamlining. - Public Comment: Barbara Heffernan (Neighborhoods United SF) opposed, citing demolition of a Category A historic resource and out-of-scale design. Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) supported the project, emphasizing housing production. Richard Carillo, as a resident, opposed, calling it a demolition and arguing state laws threaten neighborhood character. - Commission Comments: Commissioners acknowledged this is an informational hearing only (no vote). Commissioner Campbell praised densification and bike parking but suggested design refinements (minimize elevator overrun, improve color harmony). Commissioner Moore noted the project as a thoughtful SB 423 example and asked about potential single-stair design. Commissioner Williams expressed concerns about insufficient affordable housing and project scale. Commissioner Imperial echoed concerns about SB 423’s impacts. Director Hillis noted the project has not yet been reviewed for compliance, highlighted that the site currently has two units (potentially triggering rent control protections), and that under city code the affordable unit would not be required (since under 10 units, Section 415 does not apply). The presentation was for information only; no action taken. Discretionary Review Calendar – 411 Clipper Street (Item 12) - Staff Presentation: David Winslow (Staff Architect) reported that the project proposes demolishing a one-story single-family home and constructing a three-story, two-unit building. The DR requesters (neighbors at 431 and 409 Clipper) argued the project is designed as a single-family monster home (approx. 5,700 sq ft total) and that the demolition classification is misleading. Staff recommended two modifications: (1) create separate street-facing entrances for each unit to prevent illegal merger; (2) eliminate a proposed 30-inch parapet by using a one-hour-rated roof assembly to reduce bulk at the rear. The building is within an eligible historic district; demolition is not considered a negative impact. The Commission received 15 opposition letters and 18 support letters. - DR Requester (Scott Emblage): Arguing the project is a disguised single-family home (unit one: 2,676 sq ft with 1 bedroom; unit two: 2,991 sq ft with 3 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, 2 powder rooms) and that the claimed retention of one wall is a ploy to avoid full demolition requirements. He urged denial unless redesigned as a legitimate two-unit. - Project Sponsor (Mariam, designer): Responded that the design creates two distinct units, has been modified after planning staff input, and retains an existing wall (concrete basement portions) to protect neighbor’s egress. The project is within the allowable envelope; large setbacks were incorporated. The sponsor stated intent is not to create a single-family home. - Public Comment: Seven speakers (residents and neighbors) opposed, citing excessive bulk, scale, and lack of genuine two-unit design. One speaker (Brian Elliott) said he would support if truly two units. No speakers from the public spoke in support. - Commission Discussion: Commissioner Braun stated she cannot assert the project is a single-family home under planning code, and supported staff modifications (two separate doors). Commissioner Moore expressed strong concerns that the project shows signs of being a single-family home, noting the illogical unit layouts and questionable retention of a wall. She called for a continuance to allow the licensed architect to answer questions. Commissioner Campbell argued the project meets code as two separate units (two kitchens) and supported staff recommendations, noting potential illegal mergers can be addressed by enforcement. Commissioner Williams questioned the demolition threshold. - Vote: Commissioner Campbell moved to take DR and approve with staff modifications. The motion passed 6-1, with Commissioner McGarry voting against. Key Outcomes - Election of Officers: President So and Vice President Moore elected unanimously (7-0). - 4100 Third Street Discussion: The Commission will agendize a future item to discuss communication strategies in the Bayview, not to reconsider the project. - Racial and Social Equity Action Plan: The Commission received the informational presentation and will consider adoption in March 2025; feedback from commissioners will be incorporated. - 1474 South Van Ness Avenue: No action taken; informational presentation concluded. - 411 Clipper Street (DR): The Commission voted 6-1 to take discretionary review and approve the project with two staff-recommended modifications: (1) separate street-facing entrances for each unit; (2) elimination of the 30-inch parapet via a one-hour-rated roof assembly at the rear.

RACIAL AND SOCIAL EQUITY 25% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 15% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9%
545
JAN 16, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - January 16, 2025

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on January 16, 2025, its first meeting of the year. Chair Chan presided, with Clerk Monique Creighton and SFGov TV broadcasting. The committee considered four litigation settlement items, took public comment, and unanimously forwarded the items to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Litigation Settlements - Items 1 through 4 were considered jointly: two ordinances and two resolutions settling lawsuits and unlitigated claims against the city. - Settlement of unlitigated claims with Stripe, Inc. for $49,000,000. - Settlement of lawsuit with Stern Grove Festival Association for $225,016.38. - Settlement of lawsuit with Arthur Bailey Jr. for $320,000. - Settlement of unlitigated claim with James Hourihan for $75,000. - The committee did not go into closed session to discuss these items. Public Comments - No members of the public spoke on these items; public comment was closed. Key Outcomes - Chair Chan moved to forward Items 1-4 to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - The motion passed unanimously: Chair Chan, Member Sherrill, and Member Salter all voted aye (3 ayes). - Items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of January 28, 2025, unless otherwise stated.

PROCEDURAL 100%
546
JAN 15, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - January 15, 2025

The San Francisco Police Commission met on January 15, 2025, at 1:45 PM. Commissioners present: Clay, Benedicto, Yanyez, Yi, Vice President Carter Oberstone, and President Elias (arrived later). Chief Scott and DPA Executive Director Henderson also attended. The meeting covered officer recognition, adoption of revised Department General Orders (DGO 6.14 and 8.03), the Chief’s report on 2024 crime trends, an update on the Early Intervention System (EIS), a presentation on federal partnerships, and DPA’s audit of stop data completeness and accuracy. Several items were approved unanimously. Consent Calendar - Received and filed: SFPD’s 2024 Limited English Proficiency Report, Police Commission Reports of Disciplinary Actions for Q4 2024, donations to the Toy Drive (toys/books valued at $200–$300 and $9,000 from the SF Police Community Foundation), SFPD and DPA’s Q3 2024 Document Protocol Reports, and SB 1421 monthly reports for November and December 2024. Motion carried 6-0. Public Comments & Testimony - David Elliott Lewis (CIT working group, Mental Health Association of San Francisco): Praised Officer Sostaro’s courage and urged the commission to support Mayor Lurie’s proposed police-friendly mental health drop-off center. - Mother of Abre Abrakasa (unsolved homicide victim): Asked for continued help solving her son’s 2006 murder, thanked the commission for implementing a tipster reward system, and requested that photos of victims be displayed at all district stations. - Other speakers: Commented on the LA wildfires, self-control, and religious themes; one speaker criticized the department’s handling of the Mario Woods case. Discussion Items Weekly Officer Recognition (Item 1) - Officer Christina Sostaro (Taraval Station) was honored for her bravery on October 18, 2024. While responding alone to a threat at Phil’s Coffee, she was assaulted by a suspect who punched her approximately 30 times in the head. She fought for six minutes until backup arrived, using OC spray and baton; the suspect was apprehended. Commissioners and Chief Scott commended her professionalism and humility. Public comment echoed praise. Revised DGO 6.14 – Psychological Evaluation for Adults (Item 12) - Lieutenant Anderson presented the revised order, emphasizing decriminalization of mental health crises, de-escalation, diversion, and collaboration with non-law enforcement agencies. The update incorporates SB 43 definitions and adds guidelines for search warrants and gun violence restraining orders. - Commissioner Yanyez proposed a friendly amendment to replace “psychiatric evaluation” with “mental health assessment” in Section E2, citing that officers are not qualified to conduct clinical evaluations. The department agreed. The DGO was approved 6-0. Chief’s Report (Item 5) - Chief Scott reported on the JP Morgan Health Care Conference (8,000+ attendees, positive feedback), preparation for the NBA All-Star Game and Chinese New Year parade, and a recent vehicle pursuit resulting in arrests and two injured officers (non-life-threatening). - 2024 Crime Trends: Homicides hit a historic low of 35 (lowest since 1960); car break-ins down 56% (31,000 in 2017 to 9,000 in 2024); robbery and assault decreased; homicide clearance rate 90%. The department was found in substantial compliance with 96.7% of CRI recommendations. - 2025 early data: Overall serious crime down 51% year-to-date; car break-ins down 71% from same period last year. - Blessing scams: Losses of $375,000 reported; department coordinating with DA and media to raise awareness. - Vehicle fatality: An officer struck and killed a pedestrian crossing outside a crosswalk in Bayview; investigation ongoing. - ALPR cameras: 350 of 400 installed; within two months all will be active, contributing to stolen vehicle recoveries. Early Intervention System (EIS) Q3 2024 (Item 8) - Sergeant Darren presented: A data gap from May 2024 due to a missing pipeline between Benchmark Analytics and the AIM database caused use-of-force and pursuit incidents not to be incorporated. Approximately two-thirds of EIS alerts rely on use-of-force data. - Pilot program at Northern and Tenderloin stations encountered technical issues; fixes expected by end of week. Retroactive data will be restored. Department-wide rollout anticipated Q2 2025. - Q3 data: DPA complaints down 2.3%; IAD complaints down 64.5%; Tenderloin station had the most alerts (15) and indicator points (37). Federal Government Partnerships (Item 9) - Commanders O’Brien and Lew presented an overview of SFPD’s federal partnerships, including task forces, MOUs, and grants (over $19 million). Discussion focused on the incoming Trump administration’s threats to sanctuary cities and potential impact on funding and cooperation. - Chief Scott stated the department has not initiated re-engagement with the Joint Terrorism Task Force but acknowledged the need for timely intelligence sharing. MOUs require compliance with local policies; officers can disengage from activities violating sanctuary city laws. Commissioners requested that any discussions about rejoining JTTF be reported. DPA Audit of Stop Data (Item 10) - Director Flaherty presented the final audit, finding three main issues: (1) SFPD’s audits do not ensure completeness or accuracy; (2) training and guidance can be strengthened; (3) system transitions caused a 33% error rate in 2023 stop data submitted to Cal DOJ (validation errors, missing narratives, invalid data combinations). - Specific examples: 36% of stops in dispatch were not recorded in stop data; 111 individuals in 2022 had all seven racial categories selected (28% of multi-race stops); zero-stop days increased significantly in some districts. - 15 recommendations included supervisory review (SFPD currently does not require it, unlike comparable departments), linking stop data to dispatch records, and creating a data governance unit. - Chief Scott acknowledged the decision to forgo supervisory review in 2018 due to staffing shortages but agreed to revisit. He committed to working with Vice President Carter Oberstone on a manageable quarterly audit package. The department will reassess feasibility of supervisory review within the year. A data governance unit is proposed but currently under a hiring freeze. - Commissioner Clay urged action; Commissioner Benedicto requested a data collection DGO be prioritized. The audit was received with appreciation for its thoroughness. Revised DGO 8.03 – Crowd Control (Item 11) - The DGO was adopted unanimously with a 45 business day implementation delay as requested by the Chief. Key Outcomes - DGO 6.14 (Psychological Evaluation): Approved 6-0 with friendly amendment changing “psychiatric evaluation” to “mental health assessment.” - DGO 8.03 (Crowd Control): Approved 6-0; implementation in 45 business days. - Consent Calendar: Adopted 6-0. - Minutes of December 4, 2024: Adopted 6-0. - Closed Session: Vote not to disclose discussions (6-0). - Directives: Chief to work with Vice President on quarterly stop data audit framework; department to reassess supervisory review for stop data; priority given to data collection DGO; future updates on federal partnership discussions and EIS pilot progress scheduled. - Next meeting: Items identified for future agendas include language access DGO follow-up, commission reports on 7.01, 10.11, and pre-booking diversion program updates.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 36% · PROCEDURAL 32% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7% · PUBLIC SAFETY 7%
547
JAN 14, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – January 14, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Tuesday, January 14, 2025, at 10:15 AM. The meeting covered unfinished business, roll call for introductions of new legislation, public comment on a range of community issues, and a special order Committee of the Whole to urgently accept and expend over $132 million in federal grants before a change in federal administration. The board approved minutes from prior meetings, advanced a key housing project at 30 Van Ness Avenue, and processed a large omnibus grant package with several amendments. Consent Calendar - Approval of Meeting Minutes: Minutes from November 19, 2024, December 3, 2024, and December 10, 2024 were approved unanimously (11-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Safeway Closure (Fillmore): Numerous speakers from the Fillmore, Western Addition, Japan Town, and Hayes Valley neighborhoods described the impending closure of the Fillmore Safeway as a state of emergency. They demanded a hearing, raised concerns about a resulting food desert for seniors and working families, and called for community involvement in any redevelopment of the site. Many speakers invoked the history of the Fillmore redevelopment and asked for reparative action. - Other Community Issues: Speakers also addressed the need for funding for the Special Police Officers Association (SPOA) training center at 1807 Folsom Street, with several ex-felons describing how the program helped them avoid recidivism. Other comments touched on the Great Highway closure, taxi driver struggles, and general concerns about homelessness and drug use. Discussion Items Unfinished Business – 30 Van Ness Avenue Special Use District (Item 1) - Supervisor Dorsey introduced amendments to align the project with the city’s TAC guidelines for impact fee reductions, including a credit for fees already paid. Supervisor Melgar seconded the motion, noting the project is a stalled “hole in the ground” at Market and Van Ness and that the community benefits should be preserved. - The amendments were deemed non-substantive and did not require additional public comment. The board voted 11-0 to adopt the amendments and then passed the ordinance on first reading as amended. Roll Call for Introductions - Supervisor Chen: Introduced a resolution celebrating 2025 as Year of the Snake for Lunar New Year. - Supervisor Dorsey: Announced co-sponsorship of Mayor Lurie’s fentanyl emergency legislation, calling fentanyl “deadlier than anything we have seen since the darkest days of the AIDS crisis.” - Supervisor Fielder: Introduced a resolution reaffirming San Francisco’s sanctuary ordinance, citing community anxiety over promised mass deportations. - Supervisor Mahmood: Co-sponsored the fentanyl emergency ordinance and called for a hearing on the Fillmore Safeway closure, reporting that produce and meat are no longer being ordered and pharmacy services end February 7. - Supervisor Melgar: Prioritized housing element compliance, co-op housing legislation, saving Muni service, and universal child care; requested a planning code change to help fill large commercial vacancies after multiple Walgreens closures. - Supervisor Sauter: Requested a hearing on trash can policy and clean streets, noting the city has 1,500 fewer trash cans than 15 years ago. - Supervisor Sherrill: Requested a hearing on the “First Year Free” fee waiver program for small businesses (set to expire July 1) to explore making it permanent. - Supervisor Walton: Expressed caution on the mayor’s fentanyl proposal, stating supporting it without a specific plan is “premature.” Special Order 3:00 PM – Committee of the Whole (Federal Grant Package) - The board convened as a Committee of the Whole to consider 15 grants totaling more than $132 million from various federal agencies. Six city departments presented: Environment, Port, Public Works, Public Health, Recreation and Parks, and Human Services. - Key grants include: $55.3 million for a zero-emission ferry network (Port), $20 million for Bayview Connections road and transit improvements (Public Works), $20 million for building performance standards (Environment), $15 million for EV charging (Environment), $1.6 million for overdose fatality review (Public Health), and $832,804 for refugee support services (Human Services). - Supervisor Chan moved to send Item 10 (Visitation Avenue safety project, $750,000 state grant) back to the Budget and Finance Committee because it is a state, not federal, grant; the motion was seconded by Fielder and passed without objection. - All other items were amended to reflect fiscal impact determinations, clarify grant agreements, and ensure any new positions created are subject to future salary ordinance approval. The amendments were approved unanimously, and the resolutions were adopted as amended. Key Outcomes - 30 Van Ness Ordinance: Passed on first reading (11-0) after amendments to align impact fees with current guidelines and provide credit for fees already paid. - Fentanyl Emergency Legislation: Multiple supervisors co-sponsored Mayor Lurie’s ordinance; the board will consider it after committee review. - SafeWay Closure Hearing: Supervisor Mahmood will hold a hearing in Land Use and Transportation Committee to examine the Fillmore Safeway closure and community impacts. - Federal Grant Package: 14 of 15 grant resolutions were adopted, with one (Item 10) referred to committee. All adopted grants are placed on Board of Supervisors reserve until Budget and Finance Committee reviews and releases funds, preserving oversight. - Other Referrals: Hearing requests on trash cans, “First Year Free” program, and commercial vacancy planning code changes were introduced and will be scheduled for committee hearings. - Meeting Adjourned: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Colonel Pete Glykenhouse.

PUBLIC COMMENT 25% · PROCEDURAL 16% · PUBLIC HEALTH 8% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 6%
548
JAN 14, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - January 14, 2025

The San Francisco Port Commission held its regular meeting on January 14, 2025, at 10:15 AM. The meeting included approval of minutes, an executive session, public comments, election of officers, reports from the Executive Director, consent calendar items, a discussion on South Beach Marina repairs, and an informational presentation on lease negotiations with Bauer Intelligent Transportation. Key decisions included the adoption of a $55.4 million EPA grant for zero-emission ferries and approval of a contract modification for marina repairs. Consent Calendar - Item 11A: Authorized modification of Construction Contract No. 2788R for Hyde Street Harbor Repairs, retroactively extending the substantial completion date and increasing the contract amount. (Resolution 2501) – Approved unanimously. - Item 11B: Authorized acceptance and expenditure of a $55,386,000 grant from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Clean Ports Program for the San Francisco Waterfront Emissions-Free Ferry System Project. (Resolution 2502) – Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Ellen Jonk (Co-chair of the Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee, speaking personally and as a representative) praised Port staff for leadership, congratulated the Port and WETA on securing the $55 million EPA grant, and recommended that Mayor Lurie look to the Port as a model department. She also noted challenges in securing congressional appropriations for flood studies. - Pete Stitnik (Managing Partner at Water Bar and Epic Steak, Port tenants for 17 years) expressed frustration with the lengthy approval process for tenant improvements, citing a nine-month wait to install five gas heaters to comply with fire regulations. He urged the Port to streamline bureaucratic processes to encourage investment. Discussion Items - Item 10A – Election of Port Commission President and Vice President: Commissioner Kimberly Brandon was nominated and re-elected as President, and Commissioner Gail Gilman was nominated and re-elected as Vice President, both by unanimous vote. Commissioners noted the need for consistent leadership during economic recovery and seawall resilience work. - Item 10B – Executive Director’s Report: Director Elaine Forbes presented an overview of economic vibrancy, equity initiatives, and resilience projects. She highlighted the completion of the first Prop A project (ADA-accessible float at Fisherman’s Wharf), the upcoming offshore wind grant announcement, and the zero-emission ferry network. She also discussed the citywide hiring and contracting freeze, emphasizing the Port’s need to maintain staffing for safety and capital projects. Director Forbes announced the departure of Deputy Director Nate Cruz after nine years; staff and commissioners offered tributes. - Item 12A – South Beach Marina Repairs (Contract Modification): Noel and Andre Coleman (Maritime) presented a request to increase the contract by $1.7 million and extend the completion date by 474 days due to unexpected concrete deterioration and corrosion discovered during repairs. The staff compared costs favorably to the Wharf J9 project ($452/sq ft vs. $520/sq ft). Commissioners questioned the oversight but approved the resolution unanimously (Resolution 2503). - Item 13A – Informational Presentation on Settlement and Lease Negotiations with Bauer Intelligent Transportation: Kimberly Beale (Real Estate) detailed the Port’s history with the tenant, including outstanding rent disputes (Port claims $6.4 million; tenant claims $2.87 million), COVID-19 rent relief programs, and proposed settlement terms. The Port’s best and final offer included a $500,000 upfront payment, a rent credit for sprinkler installation, and a payment plan. Gary Bauer, owner of Bauer Intelligent Transportation, argued that the Port’s previous offers had been more favorable and that the current terms were unaffordable, given the need to borrow for sprinkler installation. Commissioners expressed frustration and urged Bauer to accept the Port’s offer, noting that the Port had moved significantly and that the tenant’s business is not maritime, so the Port must adhere to public trust obligations. No vote was taken; the item was informational. Key Outcomes - Minutes Approved: Minutes of the December 10, 2024 meeting were adopted unanimously. - Executive Session: The Commission voted to hold a closed session and later voted not to disclose any discussions. - Officers Elected: Kimberly Brandon re-elected President, Gail Gilman re-elected Vice President (unanimous). - Consent Calendar: Resolutions 2501 and 2502 adopted unanimously. - South Beach Marina Repairs: Resolution 2503 adopted unanimously, authorizing a $1.7 million increase and 474-day extension. - Bauer Lease Negotiations: No action taken; staff and commissioners urged the tenant to accept the Port’s final offer. The Port may consider further steps if no agreement is reached. - New Business: Commissioner inquired about the transition at Fisherman’s Wharf CBD benefit district and asked about Port outreach to counterparts in Los Angeles following the wildfires. The Executive Director noted the California Association of Port Authorities meeting the next day. - Adjournment: The meeting adjourned at 5:30 PM.

PROCEDURAL 45% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9% · PUBLIC WORKS 7% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 7%
549
JAN 14, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting – January 14, 2025

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on January 14, 2025, to discuss and vote on a range of infrastructure, budget, and operational items. The meeting included a public hearing on FY2025-26 budget priorities, approvals of multiple contract modifications and new projects, reports from the Citizens Advisory Committee (CAC), and public comments on fire safety, water management, and procurement practices. All major consent and regular calendar items were approved except the budget hearing, which was discussion-only. Citizens Advisory Committee (CAC) 2023-2024 Annual Report - Moses (Moises), CAC Chair, presented the committee's annual report, highlighting priorities on affordability and equity. He noted that affordability policy is being closely monitored and that Treasure Island residents face power outage rates four times higher than the rest of San Francisco. He also announced he is stepping down to join Mayor Lurie's administration. Commissioner Arce committed to attending the next CAC meeting on January 21, 2025. - Community member Jody Sobel, a CAC member, elaborated on Treasure Island outages: over 18 outages per year, each lasting 4-5 hours, affecting a population that is over 60% low-income. She urged the Commission to take action on a CAC resolution requesting an engineering analysis and oversight of Treasure Island power infrastructure. - Public commenters Dave Warner and Peter Dreckfire praised the CAC's work and echoed support for its priorities. Public Comments & Testimony - Francisco de Casta called for a presentation on the SFPUC's emergency firefighting system in light of Los Angeles wildfires, and requested a review of a 15-year-old plan (the “Amazon document”) linked to the source system improvement project. - Jason Foster highlighted a December 20, 2024 performance audit by the San Francisco Budget and Legislative Analyst, noting findings on procurement, vendor management, and contract accountability. He urged better staffing and tools for capital project delivery. - Mary Butterwick urged the Commission to revisit its design drought policy (currently 8.5 years) and align flow standards on the Tuolumne River with the Bay-Delta Plan, criticizing the Tuolumne River Voluntary Agreement as a delay tactic. - Dave Warner noted that the water enterprise capital improvement plan showed $600 million in cost overruns (about 20%) on budgeted projects already in progress as of Q4 FY2024. - Peter Dreckfire called for the performance audit to be placed on the next agenda, raised concerns about change orders and cost overruns, and mentioned the SFPUC's lawsuit against the EPA regarding sewage discharges. He also noted that commercial salmon season has been closed for two seasons. - During the consent calendar, Jason Foster questioned contract cost growth and transparency, particularly on items 7A (O'Shaughnessy Dam) and 7D (Customer Care and Billing). - On Item 11 (Mountain Tunnel), Jason Foster criticized the de-scoping of work and subsequent cost increases as frustrating to ratepayers. Discussion Items - Item 6a: Interim Financing Program Introduction – Nikolai Skolarov presented a plan to expand the SFPUC's short-term credit facilities by $950 million (to a total authorized capacity of $2.45 billion) to lower financing costs for capital projects. The program uses commercial paper and bank facilities to avoid premature bond issuance. The Board of Supervisors unanimously approved the expansion effective December 25, 2024. The Commission will vote on specific facilities at the February 11, 2025 meeting. Commissioner Leveroni asked about commercial paper terms and received clarification. - Item 9: Public Hearing on FY2025-26 Budget Priorities – Laura Bush presented the budget timeline and three priorities: affordability, responsible management, and investing where it matters. The FY2026 budget is the second year of a two-year fixed budget with minimal changes. She noted a 10-year capital plan of $11.8 billion (as adopted last year). Commissioners discussed affordability, workforce development, local hiring, and the balance between operational risk and ratepayer impacts. Commissioner Arce emphasized support for programs like workforce development and local contracting. The hearing was for discussion only; adoption will occur at the February 11, 2025 meeting. - Item 8: Radio Communications Site Lease Amendment – Josh Keene presented an amendment to expand the lease at Mount Allison for SCADA and emergency radio communications. The rent increases from $5,700/month to just over $9,000/month (59% increase). The site is critical for fire and emergency coordination in the watershed. Approved unanimously. - Item 10: Southeast Treatment Plant Buildings Project – Robert Mao presented a $15.27 million project to replace three end-of-life buildings with two new mass timber structures, improving workspace and safety for wastewater staff. The project is LEED-designed and will be the first mass timber building designed by public staff in San Francisco. Environmental review was approved in December 2024. Approved unanimously. - Item 11: Mountain Tunnel Improvements Contract Modification – Randy Anderson requested two approvals: (1) a deductive change order removing $15.77 million in scope (South Fork siphon extension and roadway work) due to safety and constructibility issues, and (2) a $13.03 million increase in construction cost contingency for unanticipated conditions (tunnel lining repair and lining changes). The revised cost limit is $150.17 million, $2.7 million less than the original. Commissioner questions focused on the safety issue and the deferral of work to a future contract. Approved unanimously after public comment. - Item 12: San Joaquin Pipeline Valve and Safe Entry Improvements Phase 2A – Jimmy Lung requested an increase of $2.3 million and 205 calendar days to purchase large-diameter valves for the later Phase 2B contract to meet an outage timeline. Approved unanimously. - Item 13: Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozonation Amendment – Brian DeSorr requested a $9.6 million increase and 4-year extension for engineering services during construction of the ozone facility, including support for a new pump station and O&M. The construction contract (WD-2897) came in at $234.7 million, significantly over the original $183 million estimate. Commissioners questioned cost growth and scope additions. Approved unanimously. - Item 15: Items Initiated by Commissioners – Commissioner Arce raised two topics: (1) potential state legislation to dissolve the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) and consolidate grid control regionally, and (2) future plans for Hummingbird Farm, a partnership with PODER for wetland restoration and workforce development. Commissioner Jamdar expressed interest in aligning with CAC power subcommittee priorities on affordability and climate action. President Stacy acknowledged these items for future discussion. Consent Calendar - Item 7a: Amendment to Contract PRO.0017 for O'Shaughnessy Dam Outlet Works – not-to-exceed $5,250,000 (9.5 years). - Item 7b: Contract HH-1009 for San Joaquin Pipeline Valve and Safe Entry Improvements Phase 3. - Item 7c: Contract JOC-93 for General Engineering Construction – not-to-exceed $7,500,000 (5 years). - Item 7d: Contract PRO.0298 for Customer Care and Billing Transformation to TMG Utility Advisory Services, Inc. All consent items were approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Approved unanimously: Minutes of December 10, 2024 (Item 3). - Approved unanimously: Consent Calendar (Items 7a-7d). - Approved unanimously: Radio Communications Site Lease Amendment (Item 8). - Approved unanimously: Southeast Treatment Plant Buildings Project (Item 10). - Approved unanimously: Mountain Tunnel Improvements Contract Modification (Item 11). - Approved unanimously: San Joaquin Pipeline Valve and Safe Entry Improvements Phase 2A (Item 12). - Approved unanimously: Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozonation Amendment (Item 13). - Approved unanimously: Motion to assert attorney-client privilege for closed session (Item 17) and the closed session settlement recommendation. - Discussion only: FY2025-26 Budget Priorities Hearing (Item 9) – next steps include adoption at February 11, 2025 meeting. - General Manager committed to scheduling a presentation on the emergency firefighting system at a future meeting. - New business: Commissioner Arce initiated discussion on CAISO dissolution and Hummingbird Farm; Commissioner Jamdar expressed interest in CAC power subcommittee priorities.

ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 29% · PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · PROCEDURAL 16% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 9%
550
JAN 13, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - January 13, 2025: Cannabis Oversight and African American Arts District

The San Francisco Rules Committee held a regular meeting on January 13, 2025, at 10:15 AM (18:15 UTC), chaired by Supervisor Walton, with Supervisors Dorsey and Chen, and President Mandelman in attendance. The committee considered two ordinances: one to extend the sunset date of the Cannabis Oversight Committee and another to re-establish the African American Arts and Cultural District Community Advisory Committee. Both items were approved unanimously and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided oral comment on either agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Ordinance 241088): Cannabis Oversight Committee Sunset Date Extension – President Mandelman introduced an ordinance to extend the committee's sunset from January 1, 2025 (when it had expired) to January 1, 2027, with retroactive effect. The committee advises the Board and Mayor on cannabis regulation, including equity operator grants and illicit market challenges. Supervisor Walton moved to forward the item with a positive recommendation. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2 (Ordinance 241072): African American Arts and Cultural District Community Advisory Committee – Chair Walton presented an ordinance to re-establish the advisory committee, extend the deadline for a required written report from city departments describing the district's cultural attributes and preservation strategies, and set a new sunset date of June 2028. The motion to forward to the full board passed unanimously (3-0). Key Outcomes - Both ordinances (241088 and 241072) were approved unanimously by the Rules Committee without amendment. - The items are scheduled to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on January 28, 2025. - No additional business was conducted; the meeting adjourned shortly thereafter.

CANNABIS REGULATION 44% · PROCEDURAL 30% · ARTS AND CULTURE 26%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com