Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 561–570 ENTRIES
561
DEC 9, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - December 9, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on December 9, 2024, at 9:45 AM, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston and President Aaron Peskin. Supervisor Shamann Walton also participated for several items. The committee considered seven agenda items, including code corrections, a landmark designation, laboratory use restrictions, a major transit project MOU, a fire station redevelopment, a special use district for a stalled housing project, and minimum density standards. Several items generated significant public comment and debate, leading to amendments and split votes. Agenda Item 1: Building and Planning Codes – Code Corrections and Updates - Discussion: Aaron Starr (Planning Department) presented the annual code corrections ordinance, amending building and planning codes to fix typographical errors, update cross-references, and make minor substantive updates. The Planning Commission recommended approval on September 19, 2024, with modifications already incorporated. A last-minute amendment request from a member of the public (related to 2270 McKinnon self-storage site) was deferred due to lack of city attorney review. - Public Comment: Mark Gleason (Teamsters 665) and John Kevlin (project sponsor) spoke in support of the amendment, noting it would enable a self-storage project with a project labor agreement. No opposition. - Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to recommend the original ordinance to the full Board. A duplicated file was created, amended to include a finding that the Planning Commission recommended additional amendments to be considered later, and continued to the call of the chair. Agenda Item 2: Planning Code – Landmark Designation – Ladies’ Protection and Relief Society (3400 Laguna Street) - Discussion: Pilar LaValley (Planning Department) presented the community-sponsored landmark designation for the Julia Morgan-designed main building, Stone Cottage, and front garden. The Historic Preservation Commission recommended approval on October 16, 2024. The owner, Heritage on the Marina, supported the designation. - Public Comment: Carolyn Kiernot (Page & Turnbull, representing owner) and Mike Hebel (Protect Our Marina’s Heritage) expressed full support. - Outcome: Unanimous vote to recommend to the full Board. Agenda Item 3: Planning Code – Laboratory Uses in the Urban Mixed Use Zoning District - Discussion: Veronica Flores (Planning Department) reported that the Planning Commission voted 5-1 to recommend disapproval on August 1, 2024, arguing the ban would conflict with the general plan, drive up demand in PDR districts, and harm job diversity. Laurel Arvenitis (OEWD) opposed the legislation, citing high vacancy rates and the need for in-person jobs. Supervisor Walton, the sponsor, argued the ordinance clarifies the 2021 removal of life science from UMU by including biotechnology in the prohibition. He noted that many life science businesses already exist in Dogpatch and Mission Bay and that the ordinance would include amendments to exempt the 700 Indiana project. Deputy City Attorney Brad Russi confirmed that because the Planning Commission disapproved, an 8-vote majority would be needed for final passage. - Public Comment: Seven speakers: Alison Heath (Patrow Boosters) and J.R. Epler (Patro Boosters) supported the legislation, emphasizing the need to protect vibrant mixed-use neighborhoods. Jackson Nutier (Chamber of Commerce), Rolando Tirado (Chamber of Commerce), Christy Sherilla (Biocom California), and Catherine Domaney (Dogpatch resident) opposed, citing economic impact, job losses, and harm to small businesses. Donovan Lacey (Dogpatch Neighborhood Association) supported the ban, noting the Board’s 2021 decision to remove the life science SUD. John Kevlin (MBC Biolabs, 700 Indiana) requested a carve-out for projects with applications on file. - Outcome: Motion by President Peskin to recommend to the full Board passed 2-1 (Preston and Peskin aye, Melgar no). Supervisor Walton indicated amendments would be introduced at the Board meeting on December 10 to exempt the 700 Indiana project. Agenda Item 4: Portal Project Implementation Memorandum of Understanding – Transbay Joint Powers Authority - Discussion: Hava Kronenberg (SFMTA) and Jesse Kaler (SFCTA) presented the MOU among six partner agencies for Phase 2 of the Transbay Program (downtown rail extension). The agreement has a term over 10 years and imposes no financial obligations on the city. The SFMTA Board endorsed it the prior week. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Unanimous vote to recommend to the full Board. Agenda Item 5: Endorsement of Key Terms – EQX Jackson SQ Holdco LLC – Fire Station 13 and Mixed-Use Tower - Discussion: President Peskin introduced the resolution, noting that a 2020 agreement with Related California was no longer viable post-pandemic. Jonathan Cherry (OEWD) and Matthew Whitty (Related California) presented a revised project: a new standalone fire station on Battery Street, a 200-key hotel, 20 stories of office space, and activation of Merchant Street. The resolution is non-binding; a final development agreement is expected in mid-2025. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Unanimous vote to recommend to the full Board. Agenda Item 6: Planning Code, Zoning Map – 30 Van Ness Avenue Special Use District; Amendment of Agreement for Sale of Real Estate - Discussion: Monica Giacomucci (Planning) and Lee Lutenski (OEWD) explained that the 30 Van Ness (Hayes Point) project, approved in 2020 with 333 units and 25% on-site affordable housing, paid $41 million in impact fees in 2023 and began construction but paused in September 2023. The project does not qualify for the city’s pipeline fee reductions because it had already paid fees. The proposed SUD would waive the Section 415 inclusionary requirement (25% on-site) in exchange for the $41 million already paid, making the project financially viable. President Peskin proposed amendments to reduce the inclusionary requirement to 12.8% (on-site, off-site, or in-lieu) but not grant the additional 33% fee reduction, and to require the developer to waive any right to claw back the $41 million if the project fails. The developer’s counsel, Jim Abrams, argued the SUD already ensures the fees are not refunded and that the project needs the full 33% fee reduction for feasibility. Supervisor Preston expressed concerns about the loss of affordable housing, the discounted land sale ($17 million less due to affordable housing commitment), and the community agreement with SOMCAN that still requires 25% inclusionary. The developer acknowledged discussions with SOMCAN are ongoing. Supervisor Melgar noted the absence of District 6 Supervisor Dorsey and that the matter would go to the full Board. - Public Comment: Tracy Everwine (Civic Center CBD) and Scott Nielsen (Intersection for the Arts) supported the project, highlighting benefits to public realm and arts. Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) urged support for the original SUD as approved by the Planning Commission, warning that partial reduction might not make the project feasible. Jim Abrams (Lendlease counsel) reiterated that the SUD already protects the city’s fees. - Outcome: President Peskin’s amendments were adopted 2-1 (Preston and Peskin aye, Melgar no). The amended ordinance was then recommended to the full Board on a 2-1 vote (same split). Supervisor Melgar voted no, noting she reserved the right to vote differently at the full Board. Agenda Item 7: Planning Code – Minimum Densities for Residential Projects in RM, RC, and RTO Districts - Discussion: President Peskin presented the ordinance, which was amended the previous week to adopt Planning Department recommendations establishing objective minimum density standards. It applies to RM, RC, and RTO districts (excluding R1, R2, R3, and Mission RTO) and includes provisions for expansions of single-family homes. - Public Comment: Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) expressed concerns about feasibility for small or irregular lots, but supported the intent. - Outcome: Unanimous vote to recommend to the full Board. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Recommended to full Board (unanimous); duplicated file continued for future amendment. - Item 2: Recommended to full Board (unanimous). - Item 3: Recommended to full Board (2-1); amendments to exclude 700 Indiana to be introduced at Board meeting. - Item 4: Recommended to full Board (unanimous). - Item 5: Recommended to full Board (unanimous, non-binding endorsement). - Item 6: Recommended to full Board as amended (2-1); amendments reduce inclusionary housing from 25% to 12.8% but do not include 33% fee reduction; sunset date of May 1, 2029, if construction not commenced. - Item 7: Recommended to full Board (unanimous). The committee canceled its next meeting, marking the last meeting of the year.

LAND USE 39% · PUBLIC COMMENT 18% · PROCEDURAL 10% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 10%
562
DEC 5, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - December 5, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular meeting on Thursday, December 5, 2024, beginning in the afternoon. The commission considered continuances, consent calendar items, commission matters, public comment, and several regular calendar items, including planning code amendments, a neighborhood action plan endorsement, and a cannabis retail use authorization. All votes were unanimous except where noted. Consent Calendar - Item 2 (1515 Union Street): Conditional Use Authorization for a pilates studio (Club Pilates) was approved unanimously (6-0) on the consent calendar without public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Shutish spoke about the alteration at 4267 24th Street, criticizing the use of demo calculations under Section 317 and arguing that the process has enabled speculative development and income inequality. She urged the commission to adjust demo calcs and fix the flat policy. - Item 9 (West Portal Health Services): Dr. Lili Mossadi, the ophthalmologist seeking to expand, described her 26 years serving the neighborhood and the risk of closure if the move is delayed. She noted a six-to-eight-month patient backlog and the need to serve seniors who cannot travel downtown. Paul Barbadda, a longtime merchant, and Michael Ferrer from Supervisor Melgar's office also spoke in support. - Item 11 (Mission Action Plan 2030): Over 50 public speakers addressed the commission, with the vast majority in support. Supporters included community members, business owners, and representatives from organizations such as MEDA, Mission Housing, the American Indian Cultural District, and Calle 24. They highlighted the plan's role in preventing displacement, preserving culture, and building affordable housing. A few speakers expressed concerns about safety, cleanliness, and the concentration of affordable housing, while others criticized the involvement of Calle 24 due to past controversies. The opposition was addressed by proponents who emphasized the equity focus and community-driven process. Discussion Items - Item 1 (1533 Sloat Boulevard): A continuance to January 30, 2025, was approved unanimously (6-0). - Item 4 (Minutes): The minutes of November 14 and 21, 2024, were adopted with a correction (Commissioner Braun's disclosure moved from item 16 to item 15). - Item 6 (2025 Hearing Schedule): The commission amended the proposed schedule to cancel January 30 (Lunar New Year), April 24 (Easter/Orthodox Easter), and September 4 (first Thursday after Labor Day). The amended schedule was approved unanimously (6-0). - Item 9 (West Portal Health Service Uses): Planning staff recommended approval with modifications to remove the 4,000 sq ft cap entirely. Commissioners debated the policy implications, with Commissioner Braun favoring broader reform. Ultimately, a motion to approve without modifications (as proposed by Supervisor Melgar) passed unanimously (6-0). - Item 10 (Third Street Alcohol RUD): Staff recommended approval with modifications to remove the Bayview NCD from the RUD and conditionally permit bars and nighttime entertainment. Most commissioners felt this needed more community input and voted to approve the ordinance as proposed by Supervisor Walton. The motion passed 5-1 (Commissioner Campbell dissenting). - Item 11 (Mission Action Plan 2030 Strategies): Oscar Grande from the Planning Department presented the history, progress, and five emerging strategies: stabilizing small business spaces, improving street conditions, enhancing cultural vitality, expanding affordable housing, and planning in partnership. The commission endorsed the plan unanimously (6-0) after a lengthy public comment period. Several commissioners noted the need to address pedestrian safety and correct a typo in Table 7 (120 units, not 12). - Item 13 (4994 Mission Street Cannabis Retail): The project sponsor proposed a 1,300 sq ft cannabis retail store (Basanova, Inc.) with no on-site consumption. Approximately 60 letters of opposition were received, citing safety and proximity to child-serving facilities, while 66 letters supported the project. The owner operates a compassion program. After public comment, Commissioner Williams opposed due to proximity to other cannabis retailers and child care centers, but the motion to approve with conditions (including a prohibition on on-site consumption) passed 5-1 (Commissioner Williams dissenting). Key Outcomes - Unanimous Approval (6-0): Continuances, consent calendar, minutes, 2025 hearing schedule (with amendments), West Portal health service use (as proposed), Third Street Alcohol RUD (as proposed), Mission Action Plan 2030 endorsement. - Approved 5-1: 4994 Mission Street cannabis retail use (Commissioner Williams dissenting). - Items Continued: Item 1 (1533 Sloat Blvd) to January 30, 2025; Item 12 (1035 Howard Street) to January 16, 2025; Item 14 (2459-2461 Francisco Street) withdrawn. - Next Steps: The department will track data on use size caps and present further analysis in 2025. The Mission Action Plan 2030 will continue with community engagement to refine strategies and advocate for resources.

PUBLIC COMMENT 27% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 16% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 11% · CANNABIS REGULATION 8%
563
DEC 5, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting - December 5, 2024

This was the last regularly scheduled meeting of the Government Audit and Oversight Committee chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston for the year, held on December 5, 2024. The committee addressed a Mills Act historical property contract non-renewal, a hearing on the SF Safe scandal (continued to the call of the chair), a grand jury report update, and a motion to commission a performance audit of the San Francisco Zoo. The meeting was briefly interrupted by an earthquake and tsunami warning. Closed session items included settlements of lawsuits. Mills Act Historical Property Contract Non-Renewal - The committee heard from Supervisor Aaron Peskin, sponsor of a resolution to non-renew a Mills Act contract for 2209 Webster Street. The contract would terminate after 10 years, allowing the property owner to recoup capital investments. Supervisor Chan co-sponsored. The resolution was approved unanimously (2-0) to forward to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Hearing on SF Safe (SF SAFE) – Continued to Call of Chair - Supervisor Peskin presented a detailed overview of the ongoing investigation into SF Safe, a nonprofit that received over $700,000 in misused public funds. Former director Kyra Worthy faces 34 felony charges. The committee had subpoenaed former board President Daniel Lawson and former Treasurer Tom Yeah, but they did not appear. Their attorney provided written responses that Supervisor Peskin characterized as unsatisfactory and contradicted by the District Attorney's affidavit. The police department's Acting Assistant Chief Walsh testified about SFPD's involvement and gift acceptance. Supervisors pressed for accountability for unpaid employees and questioned the department's oversight. The hearing was continued to the call of the chair, with Supervisor Chan expected to take over the file in the new year. Civil Grand Jury Report – Living Wage - Supervisor Chan reported that the Board had re-established the Committee on City Workforce Alignment (Ordinance 220879), partially implementing recommendation R1. The committee voted to update the city's response to the grand jury report and file the hearing. The motion passed unanimously. Performance Audit of the San Francisco Zoo - Supervisor Melgar introduced a motion to direct the Budget and Legislative Analyst to conduct a performance audit of the San Francisco Zoo for FYs 2024-25 and 2025-26. Public comment included support from zoo employees and union representatives citing a no-confidence vote, and opposition from zoo leadership and board members who argued the audit could jeopardize panda acquisition and was redundant with AZA accreditation. Supervisor Melgar emphasized the audit was a routine best practice and not punitive. Supervisor Chan co-sponsored. The motion was approved unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full Board. Closed Session Items - The committee convened in closed session to discuss settlements of lawsuits and unlitigated claims, including Chevron and Park Hotels matters. After closed session, the committee voted to forward item 5 to the full Board without recommendation (unanimous) and items 6 through 8 with positive recommendation (unanimous). The committee voted not to disclose closed session discussions. Key Outcomes - Mills Act contract: Forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation. - SF Safe hearing: Continued to call of chair; subpoena enforcement to be pursued. - Grand jury response: Updated recommendation R1; hearing filed. - Zoo audit: Motion to direct BLA audit passed; forwarded to full Board. - Closed session settlements: Forwarded to full Board as committee reports for December 10 meeting.

PROCEDURAL 24% · PUBLIC SAFETY 22% · AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE 13% · ZOO GOVERNANCE 13%
564
DEC 4, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - December 4, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on December 4, 2024, to consider 33 agenda items, including leases, financings, contracts, grants, fee adjustments, and policy resolutions. The meeting lasted from 10:15 AM to after 6 PM, with a recess for a press conference. The committee approved most items, often with amendments, and forwarded them to the full Board of Supervisors. Notable debates occurred over the Pier 45 Fisherman's Wharf development, the Potrero Yard modernization project, the Mid-Market/Tenderloin safety program, Marina fees, and the HomeRise contract. Consent Calendar - Items 7-10: Retroactive grants for COVID-19 test kits ($1.4M), San Francisco General Hospital Foundation ($180,000), Ryan White HIV/AIDS grant ($15.7M), and Southeast Health Center renovation ($1M) – all approved unanimously. - Items 12-13: Waterfront Plaza lease termination and new lease (57-year term, $1M initial annual base rent) and transfer tax exemption for certain Port leases – approved. - Item 15: Airport Commission bond-related authorizations – approved. - Item 16: Recology contract for city refuse collection (7-year initial term, not to exceed $119M) – approved. - Item 17: Prevailing wage rates for various workers – approved. - Item 18: Sole source agreement with Low Income Investment Fund for Child Care Facilities Fund ($67.7M) – approved. - Items 22-23: Casa Adelante affordable housing at 1515 South Van Ness (168 units, $45.2M city loan, $107.6M bonds) – approved. - Item 24: Emergency preparedness grants (UASI, etc.) – approved. - Item 25: DA's auto fraud grant ($1.2M) – approved. - Item 26: Child Support Services lease at 101 New Montgomery (7-year, $580K annual base rent) – approved. - Item 27: Compass Family Services urgent accommodation vouchers ($9.6M increase) – approved. - Item 29: St. Vincent de Paul Multi-Service Center South shelter contract (amended to 12-month extension, $17.6M) – approved. - Item 33: Extension of Budget and Legislative Analyst services contract with Harvey M. Rose Associates (6-year extension) – approved. Public Comments & Testimony - Bay FC Training Facility (Item 1): Multiple speakers, including Bay FC CEO Brady Stewart, youth soccer players, and community organizations, expressed strong support. No opposition. - Potrero Yard (Item 11): Rudy Gonzalez of Building Trades spoke in support, noting union commitments. - Fisherman's Wharf (Item 14): Heated debate. Commercial fishermen and crab boat owners opposed the term sheet, arguing it would displace the fishing industry. Labor unions (carpenters, plumbers, teamsters) and tourism representatives strongly supported the project. The developer committed to ongoing engagement. - Mid-Market/Tenderloin Safety Program (Item 19): Dozens of Urban Alchemy practitioners, residents, and business owners testified in support, emphasizing improved safety, overdose reversals, and employment for formerly incarcerated individuals. A few speakers opposed, citing gentrification or questioned effectiveness. - Marina Fees (Item 20): A resident opposed the increase, citing lack of community engagement and impact on small boaters. Another speaker supported the project but urged better maintenance. - Embarcadero Plaza Renovation (Item 21): Speakers supported the project but urged community input, including skateboarders. - 1174 Folsom Supportive Housing (Items 30-31): Many LGBTQ+ youth advocates, service providers, and residents spoke in favor, citing the need for housing for homeless youth, especially transgender and queer youth. A few speakers urged inclusive drug policies. Discussion Items - Item 1: Bay FC Training Facility Lease – Approved. The resolution authorized a 25-year ground lease with Bay FC for a training facility on Treasure Island. The lease provides $330,000 initial annual base rent, escalating 2% per year, with no public financing for improvements. Revenue over 25 years estimated at $9.66M. The committee added co-sponsors and forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 2-6: Treasure Island Financing – Approved. These items authorized $65M in certificates of participation (first tranche of $115M), an appropriation of $65.5M, and contributions from CFD and IRFD districts to fund Stage 2 infrastructure. The 10-year capital plan was amended. The BLA noted the net general fund cost of $5.2M annually after offsets. The committee forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 11: Potrero Yard Modernization (DBFOM) – Approved with amendments. The resolution conditionally approved a design-build-finance-operate-maintain agreement for the bus yard, with not-to-exceed limits including $75M milestone payment, $200M payment by 2033, and $42.2M maximum annual availability payment. The BLA reported the project would be $121M more expensive than conventional financing. The committee amended the resolution to remove delegation of authority to the MTA board, adding endorsement of key terms and SBE/DBE plans. The amended resolution was forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 14: Fisherman's Wharf Pier 45 Term Sheet – Approved with amendments. The resolution found the project fiscally feasible and endorsed a non-binding term sheet for a $548M redevelopment. The project includes renovation of Shed A, reconstruction of Shed C, and development of Seawall Lot 300/301. The committee added an amendment urging the Port to consider impacts on the commercial fishing industry and seek input from stakeholders. The amended resolution was forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 19: Mid-Market/Tenderloin Safety Program – Approved without recommendation. The amendment increased the grant to Mid-Market Foundation by $3.76M (instead of $7.7M) to continue ambassador services through April 2025. The BLA raised concerns about administrative costs ($1.5M) and recommended direct contracting. The committee voted to forward without recommendation (3-0) after debate about effectiveness and budget constraints. - Item 20: Marina Fees Increase – Approved without recommendation. The ordinance raised fees for slips at the Marina Small Craft Harbor by 15.7% in FY25-26 (cumulative 31.4% over two years). The BLA noted the increases were needed to eliminate a $650K general fund subsidy. The committee forwarded without recommendation (3-0). - Item 21: Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park Renovation – Approved. The resolution authorized a partnership with BXP and the Downtown Partnership for design and improvements, with $2.5M in private funds for design and up to $10M for construction. The committee forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 28: HomeRise Transitional Housing Contract – Approved without recommendation. The amendment extended the contract by six months (through Dec 2025) and increased funding by $2.9M (reduced from $2.9M to $2.7M after BLA recommendation). The provider, HomeRise, is under a corrective action plan due to a controller's audit with 62 action items. The committee expressed concerns but agreed to a six-month extension with a hearing scheduled for April 2025 to review progress. The item was forwarded without recommendation (2-0, with Supervisor Melgar excused). - Items 30-31: 1174 Folsom Supportive Housing – Approved with amendments. The resolutions approved a ground lease (55-year term) and a property management agreement ($14.2M) for 42 units of permanent supportive housing for young adults (ages 18-24), with a focus on LGBTQ+ youth. The lease addendum clarified that drug-related violations could be grounds for tenancy termination. The items were forwarded with positive recommendation (2-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 2-6: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 7-10: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 11: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation as amended (3-0). - Items 12-13: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 14: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation as amended (3-0). - Item 15: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 16: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 17: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0, Vice Chair Mandelman excused). - Item 18: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0). - Item 19: Forwarded to full board without recommendation as amended (3-0). - Item 20: Forwarded to full board without recommendation (3-0). - Item 21: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 22-23: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 24: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 25: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 26: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0). - Item 27: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0). - Item 28: Forwarded to full board without recommendation as amended (2-0). - Item 29: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation as amended (2-0). - Items 30-31: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation as amended (2-0). - Item 32: Continued to the call of the chair (2-0). - Item 33: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0). The committee also excused Supervisor Melgar for the latter part of the meeting. The meeting adjourned after 7 PM.

PUBLIC SAFETY 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · HOMELESSNESS 11% · PUBLIC WORKS 6%
565
DEC 4, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - December 4, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, December 4, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included a weekly officer recognition, public comments, monthly reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), and discussions on several proposed policy changes, including revisions to the Body Worn Camera policy (DGO 10.11) and a resolution on the SFPD Reward Policy. The meeting was adjourned after a closed session. Weekly Officer Recognition - Officer Ashley Mully (Star 1496) from Ingleside Station was recognized for her exceptional work, including leading an investigation into an illegal gambling establishment that resulted in the seizure of illegal gambling machines, weapons, and drugs. She was praised for volunteering her personal time and for her advocacy for domestic violence survivors. Public Comments & Testimony - Chris Ward Klein requested the Police Commission to influence the SFPD to subpoena records from the City Attorney's office related to HMIS/Oracle technology, alleging a crime influencing. - Paul Allen suggested that at the first meeting of 2025, the Chief should report on the three most consequential positive actions and three most consequential challenges for public safety in 2024. - Paulette Brown (mother of murder victim Aubrey Abercassa Jr.) spoke about the unsolved homicide of her son, highlighting the need for action on reward policy and urged the commission to pass the resolution. She noted a street renaming ceremony scheduled for December 11, 2024. - A speaker (identified as a member of the public) commented on the need for self-control and criticized technology (AI/COVID). - Another speaker expressed gratitude to the commission for listening and requested tipster payments to solve homicides. Discussion Items 1. Chief's Report (Item 5) Chief Scott reported that year-to-date (as of December 1, 2024), Part 1 crimes (violent and property) are down 30% compared to the same period last year, with a 32% reduction in property crimes and a 14% reduction in violent crimes. Notable statistics: - Homicides are down 34% (33 this year vs. 50 last year), on pace for a 60-year low. - Car break-ins are down 56% (over 10,000 fewer incidents). - Gun violence reduced by 26%; gun-related crime in the Southeast part of the city down 50% due to the VRI strategy. - Two homicides occurred on November 29, 2024 (one stabbing, one shooting), both under investigation with leads. - Significant arrests included a suspect in a 2023 homicide (Maxwell Maltzman) and a suspect in a shooting of a pregnant victim. 2. DPA Director's Report (Item 6) Acting Director Sharon Will reported: - The stop data audit response from SFPD is expected by December 18, 2024; DPA will provide a report to the commission in January 2025. - DPA opened 16 new cases this week, with the top allegation being officers behaving or speaking inappropriately. - 21 cases open for more than nine months (20 of those old). - Joint training with SFPD on use of force is ongoing. 3. Commission Reports (Item 7) - Commissioner Yee thanked departing Commissioner Deborah Walker. - Commissioner Benedicto noted upcoming agenda items: juvenile rebooking program update (Item 11) and DGO 7.01 expected in January. He requested a response from the department on the community letter regarding 7.01 by December 20, 2024; Chief Scott agreed. - Commissioner Yanez reported progress on DGO 5.20 (language access) and requested a future agenda item on community policing metrics and data collection. She also raised concerns about the live monitoring request form clarity regarding optional participation. 4. Reward Policy Resolution (Item 10) Vice President Carter-Oberstone presented a resolution requesting the Board of Supervisors amend the Administrative Code to update the homicide reward policy. The resolution included three principles: (1) permit anonymous tips, (2) allow payment to tipsters with criminal history (excluding involvement in the crime), and (3) raise reward amounts. Commissioner Elias proposed adding a fourth principle: "Notwithstanding any other provision, no payout will be made to a person who is providing false information to solely obtain a monetary reward." The amendment was accepted by the motion maker. The resolution was unanimously adopted (5-0). It is dedicated to Paulette Brown, mother of Aubrey Abercassa Jr. 5. Body Worn Cameras (DGO 10.11) (Item 14) The department presented revised DGO 10.11, but the commission postponed a vote to the next meeting due to Commissioner Clay's request to participate and the need for further discussion on three sticking points: (a) requiring body worn camera activation during command post briefings, (b) striking the exemption for recording sensitive tactical discussions, and (c) the interview process for officers after critical incidents (cognitive interview vs. initial statement). Chief Scott and tactical experts argued for exemptions to protect officer safety and tactics; Vice President Carter-Oberstone and working group members argued that the working group's unanimous recommendations should be followed and that redaction after the fact is sufficient. No public comment was made on this item. 6. Disciplinary Review Board (Item 8) and Firearm/In-Custody Death Reports (Item 9) Lieutenant Lisa Springer presented findings from Q2 2024: - Top aggregate trends: failure to appear at range (27.59%), conduct unbecoming an officer (19.54%), neglect of duty/body worn camera (14.94%), neglect of duty/failure to take required action (13.9%). - Two IAD cases resulted in policy/training failures: one involving a sergeant who muted BWC during a stop of an off-duty intoxicated officer, and another involving a sergeant who lost a department radio. - DPA reported two policy failures: (1) a sworn member misreported stop data (1,193 out of 1,198 stops listed as white individuals) and (2) a case involving DGO 6.14 (psychological evaluation) which was pulled from the agenda. - An officer-involved shooting (Q3 2024) was reviewed; the officer unintentionally discharged his firearm during a takedown. Immediate corrective training was implemented. 7. Juvenile Re-Booking Diversion Program Update (Item 11) Director Lacey provided an update: an MOU was drafted and sent to stakeholders (Juvenile Probation, DA, Public Defender, CARC). Meetings have been held with the DA, JPD, and Judge Chan (Unified Family Court) who gave positive feedback. Still awaiting feedback from the Public Defender's office and JPD. Commissioner Yanez expressed urgency, noting that an estimated 11 youth could have been eligible in the last two years. Commissioner Benedicto requested another update in Q1 2025. 8. DGO 5.18 (Persons in Custody and Transportation) (Item 12) Lt. Mark Moreno presented the revised order, which replaces "prisoner" with "persons in custody," adds definitions and a vulnerable populations section, and updates transportation procedures. The commission unanimously voted to approve the revised DGO for use in meeting and conferring with bargaining units. Key Outcomes - Adoption of Minutes: Minutes of November 6 and November 20, 2024, were approved with one revision (noting Assistant Chief Lazarus sat in for the Chief). - Resolution on Reward Policy (Item 10): Unanimously passed (5-0) with an added safeguard against false information payouts. - DGO 5.18 (Item 12): Unanimously approved (4-0) for meet and confer. - DGO 10.11 (Item 14): Vote postponed to a future meeting. - Closed Session (Items 16-18): Motion to go into closed session passed; motion to not disclose discussions except for item 17A passed. - Referrals: Chief to respond to community letter on DGO 7.01 by December 20, 2024. Juvenile re-booking update scheduled for Q1 2025. Discussion on community policing metrics to be agendized.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 36% · PROCEDURAL 23% · PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8%
566
DEC 3, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - December 3, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, December 3, 2024, at 10:15 AM. The meeting included adoption of a consent agenda, debate on a lawsuit settlement involving a trans income program, passage of multiple ordinances and resolutions, and commendations for retiring city officials and community leaders. The board also heard public comment on remote public comment access and other matters. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 15 were approved unanimously, including appropriations for earthquake safety bonds ($6.18 million), multiple lawsuit settlements (totaling $1.86 million), firearm procurement policy changes, and amendments to the Police Code regarding public bath houses and reproductive health facility access. Public Comments & Testimony - Several members of the public, representing Senior and Disability Action and the Remote Public Comment Coalition, urged Supervisor Walton (District 10) to place reinstating remote public comment on the December 9 Rules Committee agenda. Speakers cited accessibility barriers for individuals with disabilities, chronic conditions, and those living far from City Hall. Multiple speakers held moments of silence to honor those unable to comment. - One speaker criticized the city's support for trans people and opposed the settlement on the trans income program, alleging transphobic input into legislation. - A foster parent highlighted the need for long-term, relationship-based support for youth in the child welfare system. - Other speakers addressed topics including the KPFA radio station, COVID-19 vaccine safety, and personal experiences with city services. Discussion Items Settlement of Lawsuit – Paul Wildes and Reed Sandberg (Item 31) - The board considered a settlement of a lawsuit filed by two individuals alleging discrimination based on transgender status, sex, race, and ethnicity against city officials. The settlement proposed payment of approximately $3,250 in attorney's fees and costs, plus injunctive relief limiting future city efforts to establish a basic income program for trans people. - Supervisor Preston opposed the settlement, arguing the injunctive relief would tie the hands of future administrations and that the lawsuit's request was moot since the program had ended. He stated, "We should not tie the hands of the incoming mayor and the incoming board for future programs." - Supervisor Ronan supported the settlement, expressing pride in the city's support for the trans community but criticizing the program's structure, and noting that rejecting the settlement could lead to a worse outcome and higher costs. He said, "We're not going to be dumb about the way we spend our money." - The board voted 7-3 to approve the settlement, with Supervisors Walton, Peskin, and Preston voting no. Artificial Intelligence Inventory Ordinance (Item 38) - Supervisor Ronan introduced an ordinance to amend the Administrative Code to create a publicly available inventory of all AI tools used by city departments, with reporting requirements and enforcement measures. He noted that the Department of Technology had hired a new Deputy Director of Emerging Technologies to lead the effort. The ordinance passed unanimously. Rapid Rehousing Policy (Item 39) - An ordinance declaring city policy to provide up to five years of rapid rehousing assistance to eligible households, with annual hearings and reports by the Homelessness Oversight Commission, passed unanimously. Other Regular Agenda Items - Items 16-30, 32-37, 40-41 were approved unanimously, including: - Appropriation of $571 million in general obligation bond proceeds for seawall, earthquake safety, and affordable housing projects. - Grant acceptance for India Basin Shoreline Park ($757,000) and Havelock Pedestrian Bridge ($500,000). - Modification of airport solid waste contract ($22.4 million). - Approval of liquor license transfers for AJ's Bar and Nihon Whisky Lounge. - Amendments to the Shelter Monitoring Committee and Standards of Care ordinance. - Appointment of members to the Citizens Committee on Community Development and the SOMA Community Stabilization Fund Community Advisory Committee. Commendations - The board adopted resolutions honoring: - Jesse Smith, retiring Chief Assistant City Attorney, for 32 years of service. - Steve Pulliam, Executive Director of the Heart of the City Farmers Market, for food justice work. - Members of the Mental Health SF Implementation Working Group, for five years of oversight. - DeJada Durden, Deputy Director of Operations at Public Works, for leadership and 20 years of service. - All commendations were approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 31 (Settlement): Approved 7-3, with a $3,250 payment and injunctive relief limiting future trans income programs. - Consent Agenda and all other regular agenda items: Approved unanimously. - Public Comment: Speaker requests to reinstate remote public comment at committee meetings were noted but not voted on. - Legislation Introduced: Supervisors introduced new business, including a resolution urging SFMTA to paint red zones at all crosswalks (Supervisor Walton) and an ordinance to prioritize recovery housing in Prop 1 funding (Supervisor Dorsey). - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Doug Gourney, Robert Drucker, Joseph Ignatius Kelly, Ida Bakalinski, and Peter Salfazio.

PERSONNEL MATTERS 18% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · PUBLIC WORKS 9% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 8%
567
DEC 2, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - December 2, 2024

This meeting of the Land Use and Transportation Committee, chaired by Vice Chair Dean Preston (Acting) and joined by Board of Supervisors President Aaron Peskin, considered five legislative items. Supervisor Melgar was excused. The committee heard public testimony, debated each item, and took actions including forwarding, continuing, and tabling legislation. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (2301 Chestnut Street Special Sign District): Scott Shelterworth, COO of Original Joe's, expressed support for the sign district, stating it would help the public find the entrance and keep pathways clear. - Item 2 (Disability Access Improvements): Henry Carnelis, president of a small business association, expressed disappointment with the proposed continuance, arguing the ordinance is costly for small businesses (sidewalk costs up to $70,000, total costs $80,000–$100,000) and has become a “cash cow for architects.” - Item 3 (Impact Fees for Changes of Use from PDR): - Pisa Eugenio (SamCAN and Soma Pilipinas) requested amendments to preserve PDR zoning and fees, proposing exemptions only for child care, nonprofits, and residential care facilities. - Peter Papadopoulos (Mission Economic Development Agency) echoed concerns, recommending maintaining the jobs-housing linkage fee and limiting fee cuts to community-serving uses to avoid incentivizing conversions to biotech or high-end restaurants. - J.R. Epler (Patro Booster's Neighborhood Association) opposed the fee cuts, arguing they undermine PDR preservation strategies and that the fees fund needed neighborhood infrastructure. - Item 4 (30 Van Ness Avenue Special Use District): - PJ Hanyo (SamKan) noted the developer had breached a 2020 community benefits agreement requiring 25% affordable units and requested a continuance to allow for good-faith negotiations. - Another speaker (unidentified) urged the committee to act with haste, stating the project would create 1,000 jobs for blue-collar workers who are suffering in the current downturn. - Item 5 (Conditional Use for Residential Projects): No public comment. Discussion Items - Item 1: 2301 Chestnut Street Special Sign District (File 240931) – Supervisor Dorsey, the sponsor, introduced the ordinance to allow two projecting signs at 2301 Chestnut Street. Planning staff recommended approval with a modification to allow all corner commercial businesses in NC districts to have two projecting signs; they also suggested a sunset clause. Dorsey agreed to duplicate the file to work on the expansion. The committee forwarded the original ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation and continued the duplicate file to the call of the chair. - Item 2: Disability Access Improvements for Places of Public Accommodation (File 240982) – Adam Tongsavet (Supervisor Mandelman’s office) requested a continuance to January 27, 2025, to allow more stakeholder engagement. The committee granted the continuance without discussion. - Item 3: Impact Fees for Changes of Use From PDR to Other Non-Residential Uses (File 240901) – Director Katie Tang (Office of Small Business) presented the ordinance on behalf of Mayor Breed’s office. She noted the sponsor wanted to keep the legislation as introduced to reduce business costs, citing that the fees range from $15,000 to $100,000 and affect about four projects per year. Supervisor Preston questioned whether the fees were actually a barrier. Supervisor Peskin moved to table the ordinance, stating that community groups had offered reasonable amendments but the mayor’s office refused to compromise. The committee voted to table the item. - Item 4: 30 Van Ness Avenue Special Use District (File 240872) – Supervisor Peskin reported that productive discussions were underway with stakeholders and his staff. He and the sponsor (Supervisor Preston on behalf of the item) agreed to continue the item for one week to allow further negotiations on a compromise. - Item 5: Conditional Use for Residential Projects in RM, RC, and RTO Districts (File 230596) – Supervisor Peskin, the sponsor, presented amendments to replace the interim conditional-use scheme with minimum density standards set at 75% of maximum density, and to cap single-family home expansions at 25% over a decade. He moved to adopt the amendments and continue the item to the December 9 meeting. The committee adopted the amendments and continued the item. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to forward the original ordinance (2301 Chestnut Street Special Sign District) to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed 2-0 (Melgar excused). The duplicated file was continued to the call of the chair. - Item 2: Motion to continue the ordinance to the January 27, 2025 land use meeting passed 2-0. - Item 3: Motion to table the ordinance (PDR impact fee elimination) passed 2-0. - Item 4: Motion to continue the ordinance to the December 9, 2024 land use meeting passed 2-0. - Item 5: Motion to adopt the amendments and continue the ordinance as amended to the December 9, 2024 land use meeting passed 2-0.

PUBLIC COMMENT 39% · LAND USE 24% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 14% · PROCEDURAL 11%
568
NOV 25, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Regular Meeting – November 25, 2024

The Port Commission met on Monday, November 25, 2024, at 9:45 AM, convened by President Kimberly Brandon. The meeting spanned approximately 7 hours, concluding at 4:54 PM. Commissioners present: President Brandon, Vice President Gail Gilman, Willie Adams, Stephen English, and Stephen Lee. The agenda covered routine approvals, a major waterfront resilience contracting strategy, a bond issuance, maritime dredging industry analysis, and an economic recovery update. Public comment periods were held on each item but no members of the public spoke. Consent Calendar - Item 11A (Resolution 2452): Retroactively approved travel for Commissioners to Boston, Massachusetts (October 27–30, 2024) to attend the American Association of Port Authorities Annual Convention. Approved unanimously. - Item 11B (Resolution 2453): Adopted the 2025 Port Commission calendar, setting meeting dates outside the regular second-Tuesday schedule (including fourth Tuesdays in February and April). Approved unanimously. Executive Director’s Report - Elaine Forbes reported on equity (Native American Heritage Month, student programs), economic recovery (Welcome Center opening, $1.43 million grant for Fisherman’s Wharf beautification, Foodwise Black Holiday Market), resilience (World Economic Forum tour, King Tides partnership with Exploratorium), and key projects: - Bayfront Park (5.4 acres) opened near Chase Center. - EPA Clean Ports Grant of $55 million awarded for zero-emission ferry network (first electrified 400-passenger ferry, downtown terminal electrification, Mission Bay Ferry Landing, workforce development). - Joint project with Mayor Breed to redesign Embarcadero Plaza (Port owns a portion of the property). - Crane Cove Park dog park and play area expected completion September 2025. - Pier 23 and Pier 27 repairs underway. - Commissioners commended staff, particularly for the EPA grant and improved public spaces. Discussion Items 12A – Waterfront Resilience Program Contracting Strategy (Informational) - Brad Benson presented a proposed shift from a single program management contract (Jacobs, since 2017) to multiple contracts: - A new Program Advisory Services Contract (5-year, $40 million, with a 5-year extension option) to manage program oversight, environmental clearance, cost estimating, and hazardous materials. - Three design contracts for early projects (e.g., Pier 15/9 seawall, South Beach). - Two large planning/design contracts for the Army Corps draft plan: Southern Waterfront (up to 10 years, $50 million) and Northern Waterfront (up to 10 years, $65 million), incorporating the Downtown Coastal Resilience Project. - Staff highlighted a funding gap of $742 million through FY2029–2030, to be filled by bonds, city contributions, Proposition 4 (California climate bond), and potential federal authorization in 2026. - Commissioners expressed support for the staged approach, collaboration with city agencies, and robust public engagement. Commissioner Adams urged bipartisan federal lobbying; Commissioner Lee questioned design lifespan (50+ years) and requested priority for northern waterfront infrastructure to help small businesses. 12B – Authorization to Advertise RFP for Program Advisory Services (Resolution 2454) - Staff requested approval to advertise a 5-year, $40 million contract (with extension option) for program advisory services. The contract will support management, Army Corps interface, environmental compliance, communications, funding advocacy, workforce development, and real estate coordination. - Commissioner Gilman asked about conflict-of-interest provisions for bidders; staff confirmed that consultants cannot review their own designs and that the City Attorney is consulted. The resolution was approved unanimously. 12C – Third Bond Issuance of $124 Million (Resolution 2455) - Carlos Cologne presented the request to issue $124 million of 2018 Proposition A (Embarcadero Seawall Earthquake Safety) bonds. Previous bond sales: first ($49.7 million, nearly exhausted), second (2023, $14.2 million spent, remaining $21 million for design contracts). This third sale funds program advisory services, early projects, and the Army Corps Flood Study over the next 2.5 years. - Commissioner Lee questioned the high planning cost ($124 million) with no construction until 2027; staff noted that all expenditures are for planning and design. Commissioner Adams inquired about port labor costs. The resolution was approved unanimously. 13A – Maritime Dredging & Construction RFI (Informational) - Elizabeth Alexander Toot presented results of a survey and Request for Interest (RFI) to assess LBE and other firm capabilities for dredging and marine construction. - Key findings: - Shallow dredging: 1 LBE has performed from barge; 2 LBEs from shoreline; 2 LBEs do professional services (e.g., hydrographic surveying). - Deep water dredging: only 3 non-LBE firms identified (2 with local equipment); all face staffing challenges due to short dredge windows (June 15 – November 30). - Marine construction: 2 LBEs have done pile driving; 5 other certified firms have related experience. - Barriers: small project sizes, jurisdictional certification requirements, lack of equipment and insurance for LBEs. - Staff recommended: (1) publish expected requirements and pathways, (2) advertise an “as-needed” general construction contract for shallow/deep dredging, (3) later establish an “as-needed” marine construction contract series (with task-order bidding) to create stepping stones for LBEs. - Commissioners discussed coordination with other Bay Area ports, equipment rentals as LBE credit, and using principal experience (not just firm) for qualifications. Vice President Gilman suggested exploring cooperative contracting with other ports. 14A – Economic Recovery Efforts (Informational) - Megan Wallace reported that Port revenues have exceeded pre-pandemic levels, but expenses continue to grow. Focus areas: - Waterfront Walk: Signage system RFP in early 2025; installation spring 2025. - Southern Waterfront: Pilot community-driven activation, demolition of Pier 90 grain silos and Pier 96 cranes, Amador Street improvements, new truck and two staff for maintenance. - Fisherman’s Wharf: Gateway transformation (pergolas, planters, seating) has improved illegal vending issues; two new leases expected at 300 and 340 Jefferson Street; Wharf J9 gangway/float for off-boat fish sales. - Commissioners praised the gateway makeover and suggested technology-enhanced wayfinding (citing New York examples). Commissioner Lee requested a future meeting with local fishermen and proposed pop-up leases for vacant spaces. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Resolutions 2452 and 2453 adopted unanimously. - Resolution 2454 (Advertise RFP for $40M contract): Approved unanimously. - Resolution 2455 (Third bond issuance of $124M): Approved unanimously. - No votes on informational items (12A, 13A, 14A), but staff directed to proceed with planned next steps: present a detailed funding plan in early 2025, bring back contract awards for approval, and continue coordination with city departments and other ports. - New Business: Vice President Gilman requested updates on Wharf J9 project and Cal Maritime/Cal Poly merger opportunities. Commissioner Lee requested a site visit with fishermen (to be scheduled in early 2025 after Chinese New Year). - Meeting adjourned at 4:54 PM.

PROCEDURAL 34% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 18% · PROCUREMENT 12% · PUBLIC WORKS 9%
569
NOV 21, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Hearing - November 21, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, November 21, 2024, to consider a shortened agenda after several items were continued. The meeting began at approximately 1:00 PM Pacific Time. Key actions included approval of a consent calendar item, adoption of minutes, an informational presentation on a housing project at 5172 Mission Street, approval of a mandatory discretionary review allowing an in-lieu fee payment for inclusionary housing at 986 South Van Ness Avenue, and approval of a conditional use authorization for a cannabis cultivation facility at 1126 Shafter Avenue. All votes were unanimous (5-0). Consent Calendar - Item 3: 1201 Sutter Street, Unit 212 – Conditional Use Authorization – Approved unanimously. No public comment or request to remove from consent. - Item 4: 986 South Van Ness Avenue – Discretionary Review – Pulled off consent by Commissioner Williams and considered separately under the regular calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: No speakers came forward. - Item 12 (5172 Mission Street): No public comment was offered during the informational presentation. - Item 13 (1126 Shafter Avenue): No public comment was offered; however, staff noted that five written comments opposing the project were received after the staff report was published, focusing on the concentration of cannabis businesses in the Bayview Hunters Point neighborhood and impacts on low-income, immigrant, and senior populations. Discussion Items - Item 12: 5172 Mission Street – Informational Presentation (SB 423) – Project sponsor Daniel Paris, architect and co-owner, presented plans to demolish an existing two-story commercial building and construct a three-story residential building with five dwelling units and four accessory dwelling units (ADUs), totaling nine units. The site is 25 feet wide, limiting egress to a single stair design. The ground floor would feature a lobby/common area as a retail space could not be accommodated due to egress requirements. Commissioner Williams noted the displacement of an existing botanica business and asked about assistance for the tenant. The project sponsor agreed to help the business find a new space. Commissioner Imperial encouraged activating the storefront with rotating art or pop-up uses. No action was taken; it was an informational item. - Item 4: 986 South Van Ness Avenue – Mandatory Discretionary Review – Staff presented because the property owner was unable to attend (tested positive for COVID-19). The fully constructed five-story, 15-unit building has not been occupied. The owner requested to modify the inclusionary housing compliance method from providing two on-site below-market-rate (BMR) units plus one voluntary BMR unit to a payment of the in-lieu fee, due to market conditions. The owner had also planned to change tenure from ownership to rental but rescinded that request. The owner is working with United to Save the Mission (USM) to identify a nonprofit to purchase the building as 100% affordable housing through the end of 2024. If that fails, the in-lieu fee payment would avoid foreclosure. Commissioners expressed preference for the nonprofit sale and noted the in-lieu fee could fund affordable housing elsewhere. The commission voted to take discretionary review and approve the modification with conditions. - Item 13: 1126 Shafter Avenue – Conditional Use Authorization – Staff presented a request for a conditional use authorization to establish an industrial agriculture use (cannabis cultivation) in an existing vacant industrial building within the PDR-2 zoning district. The project would address a notice of violation (NOV) for unpermitted construction by reducing an upper mezzanine to meet code. Commissioner Braun clarified that the previous unpermitted operator was different from the current applicant, who is in the Office of Cannabis equity applicant track. The department found the project consistent with the General Plan and recommended approval. The commission voted to approve with conditions. Key Outcomes - Continuances: All proposed continuances (Items 1, 2A, 2B, 10, 11, 14) were approved unanimously. Item 2B (variance) was continued to a variance hearing on December 4, 2024. Items 1 and 14 were continued to January 2025. - Consent Calendar: Item 3 (1201 Sutter Street) approved 5-0. - Minutes: Draft minutes of November 7, 2024, adopted 5-0. - Item 4 (986 South Van Ness): Motion to take discretionary review and approve with conditions passed 5-0. The owner may pay the in-lieu fee if the nonprofit sale does not materialize. - Item 13 (1126 Shafter Avenue): Motion to approve conditional use authorization with conditions passed 5-0.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 28% · PROCEDURAL 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · LAND USE 14%
570
NOV 21, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit & Oversight Committee Meeting - November 21, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on November 21, 2024, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston and joined by Supervisor Connie Chan. The meeting focused on closed session items regarding settlements of lawsuits and unlitigated claims. After closed session, the committee reported actions on 13 items, with public comment heard on the Chevron settlement and a guaranteed income program settlement. Public Comments & Testimony - Julia Sebastian (Climate Policy Director, Jobs of Justice San Francisco) opposed the settlement agreement with Chevron (Item 1), arguing it violates San Francisco's ordinance (236-16) requiring the city to end involvement in oil and gas extraction and to produce a just transition plan. She requested the committee vote no to allow proper public process and offered partnership for workforce development alternatives. - A member of the public (speaking on Item 12, settlement of lawsuit Paul Wildes and Reed Sandberg) expressed concern that settlement terms would restrict future guaranteed income programs for marginalized groups, specifically transgender individuals and people of color. They criticized language in the settlement referring to "biological males" and "biological females" as transphobic and asked for clarification on implications for future programs. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Chevron Settlement (Continued): Supervisor Chan thanked Chair Preston for supporting a continuance of this item to December 5, 2024. She expressed hope for further discussions with Chevron regarding investment in green jobs programs and protection of workers, emphasizing the need for a just transition. - Item 12 – Guaranteed Income Program Settlement (Forwarded Without Recommendation): Chair Preston stated he was not comfortable supporting the settlement. He acknowledged the city attorney's work but argued that at a time when trans rights are under attack, the city should not consent to efforts to undermine trans rights or future benefit programs. He noted the pilot program is complete and funds paid out, so any injunctive relief is moot. He opposed tying the hands of future city leadership. Key Outcomes - The committee voted to excuse Vice Chair Stephanie for the meeting (2-0, with Vice Chair excused). - In closed session, the committee took the following actions: - Items 2–11 and 13 (Settlements): Forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 1 (Chevron Settlement): Continued to the December 5, 2024 regular meeting of this committee. - Item 12 (Paul Wildes and Reed Sandberg Settlement): Forwarded to the full board without recommendation. - The committee voted not to disclose closed session discussions (2-0). - Items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on December 3, 2024, unless otherwise noted.

PUBLIC COMMENT 50% · LGBTQ+ HISTORY 41% · PROCEDURAL 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com