Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 571–580 ENTRIES
571
NOV 20, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting – November 20, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar, met on November 20, 2024, to consider 14 items. The committee continued one item (Worker Justice Fund) to allow further negotiations and approved the remaining 13 items—including contract modifications, grant acceptances, fee eliminations, and service agreements—sending them to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public comment was absent on all items. Discussion Items & Key Outcomes 1. Worker Justice Fund (Item 1) – Ordinance to establish a fund for workers who have not received payment from employers for violations of city worker protection laws. Chair Chan noted concerns about workload on the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement and expressed a desire to avoid pitting workers against workers. Vice Chair Mandelman acknowledged competing claims and hoped to reach agreement in the new year. Supervisor Melgar voiced strong support for the fund as a safety net for immigrant workers. Result: Continued to the call of the chair (unanimous 3-0). 2. Airport Solid Waste Contract – $22.4 million (Item 2) – Resolution approving a $13.1 million increase and three-year extension (through February 2028) for South San Francisco Scavenger Co. to provide waste management services at SFO. The airport reported the contractor met or exceeded obligations. Result: Approved 3-0. 3. Fee Elimination and Administrative Provisions (Item 3) – Ordinance to waive 49 regulatory license fees (totaling $10 million annually) following voter approval of Proposition M. The Treasurer-Tax Collector’s office presented that 91% of San Francisco restaurants and 87% of nightlife businesses will see their license bills eliminated, saving typical mid-sized restaurants at least $1,400 per year and nightlife businesses at least $850 per year. The ordinance also increases the small business exemption threshold for shared spaces from $2.5 million to $5 million in gross receipts and indefinitely waives business location/device fees for taxi and ride-share businesses. The Budget Analyst noted 80% of the revenue loss affects the Department of Public Health, with backfill expected from future business tax revenues. Vice Chair Mandelman praised the elimination of “annoying and pointless” fees. Result: Approved 3-0. 4. India Basin Shoreline Park Grant – $756,728 (Item 4) – Resolution retroactively accepting a state grant for the India Basin Shoreline Park Project to create a resilient shoreline, expand wetlands, and buffer against storm surges and sea level rise. The project is part of the India Basin Waterfront Initiative; construction is expected summer 2025. Result: Approved 3-0. Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor. 5. Havelock Pedestrian Bridge Safety Improvement – $500,000 (Item 5) – Resolution accepting a state earmark to construct a 370-foot sidewalk with curb ramps connecting the Havelock Bridge over I-280 to City College, improving pedestrian safety. Supervisor Melgar thanked outgoing Assemblymember Phil Ting. Result: Approved 3-0. 6. Central Subway Train Control System Contract Modification – $29.8 million (Item 6) – Resolution approving modification number four to the agreement with Hitachi Rail GTS USA Inc. (formerly Thales) for the advanced train control system. The modification adds $2.1 million to cover design changes, delay compensation (136 days of delayed site access), and replenishment of retention funds recovered from the prime contractor. The Budget Analyst recommended approval. Result: Approved 3-0. 7. Behavioral Health Infrastructure Grant Applications – Up to $144 million (Item 7) – Resolution authorizing the Department of Public Health to apply for state bond funds (Proposition 1, March 2024) to expand behavioral health beds. Six projects are proposed, adding 175 beds, including: 16 dual diagnosis beds, 40 medical adult residential SUD treatment beds, 12 PES beds at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital, 50 locked subacute treatment beds at the Behavioral Health Center, capital improvements for a future mental health service center, and a partnership with UCSF for 50 locked subacute and 6 acute psych beds at their St. Francis campus. Applications due December 13, 2024; award notices expected May 2025. Vice Chair Mandelman called the application “giddy” and emphasized the critical need for locked subacute beds to support conservatorship and reduce system bottlenecks. Result: Approved 3-0. 8. Bay Area Community Resources Grant – $16.8 million (Item 8) – Resolution retroactively approving a five-year grant (July 2024–June 2029) for after-school and beacon programs. The Budget Analyst noted that one program, “A Home Away From Homelessness,” served only two children in 2022-23 (one for a meaningful duration) and recommended the department report back at the end of the academic year. The acting director explained the program serves highly transient homeless youth and that a new strategy (academic support) will be tried. Result: Approved 3-0. 9. Mission Graduates Grant – $10.7 million (Item 9) – Resolution retroactively approving a five-year grant for beacon and summer programs. The Budget Analyst noted that a program at Bessie Carmichael School was understaffed but positions have since been filled. Supervisor Melgar asked about the Bryant Elementary School Beacon, which was not included because the school did not participate in the RFP; gap funding is being provided. Result: Approved 3-0. 10. Police Forensic Science Grant – $72,275 (Item 10) – Resolution retroactively accepting a state grant for the Paul Coverdell Forensic Science Improvement Program to maintain crime lab accreditation and reduce case backlogs. Result: Approved 3-0. 11. Naloxone Distribution In-Kind Gift – $81,300 (Item 11) – Resolution retroactively accepting 1,800 units of naloxone from the state Naloxone Distribution Project. Since 2019, SFPD has deployed naloxone 994 times, with 60% of deployments in the Tenderloin district and 15% in the Southern district. Result: Approved 3-0. 12. Water Service Contract – Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory – $66.4 million (Item 12) – Resolution approving a 10-year water service contract (2025–2034) with the U.S. Department of Energy, continuing a relationship since 1960. Estimated revenue of $66.4 million over the term. Result: Approved 3-0. 13. CleanPowerSF Greenhouse Gas-Free Energy Purchase – $8.955 million (Item 13) – Resolution approving a one-year contract with PG&E to purchase hydroelectric greenhouse gas-free energy for 2025 to meet clean energy targets. The contract includes binding arbitration; the general manager signed it subject to board approval. Result: Approved 3-0. 14. Treasure Island Master Lease Amendment – One-Year Extension (Item 14) – Resolution approving amendment number 49 to extend the master lease with the U.S. Navy through November 30, 2025, on the same terms. The Navy requires annual extensions. Result: Approved 3-0. Public Comments & Testimony No members of the public spoke on any agenda item. Key Outcomes - Item 1 continued to the call of the chair (3-0). - Items 2 through 14 approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for the December 3, 2024 meeting (all 3-0 votes).

EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 14% · PROCEDURAL 12% · PUBLIC HEALTH 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8%
572
NOV 20, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - November 20, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, November 20, 2024, in open session. The meeting included reports from the Police Department and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), discussion on policy updates, and commission reports. Several items were pulled from the agenda, including the Healthy Street Operation Center presentation and a donation from the POA. The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to enter closed session. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously voted to receive and file the consent calendar, which included safe sheets for Q3 2024, SFPD's Family Code 628 quarterly report, and SP1421/SB16 monthly reports. The donation from the POA was pulled from the consent calendar prior to the vote. Public Comments & Testimony - Douglas Styles, Executive Director and CEO of Huckleberry Youth Programs, expressed support for the revised DGO 7.01 (juvenile interactions policy), noting the working group's efforts and urging approval. He praised the new tool for guiding officers in interactions with youth and mentioned the need for expedited approval to improve equitable experiences. Commissioners thanked him and noted the item is expected to be calendared in January. - A mother of a homicide victim (son Arbor Casa, murdered in 2006) spoke about her son's street naming ceremony on Grove Street, scheduled for December 4 or 11, and requested support from the commission. She also reiterated her ongoing quest for justice and help from Vice President Carter-Oberstone on tipsters. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 4): Assistant Chief David Lazar presented annual crime statistics, noting a 30% overall reduction in incidents year-to-date, with 14,000 fewer incidents. Violent crime dropped 14%, gun violence down 26% (47 fewer shootings), and homicides down 34% compared to 2023 (31 vs. 48). Homicide clearance rate stands at 83%. Vehicle break-ins fell to 8,238 (from over 18,000 the prior year). Gun seizures reached 1,039, the highest since 2018. He detailed several recent incidents, including a non-fatal shooting of a pregnant woman (suspect still at large), a commercial burglary arrest via vehicle ramming, a burglary crew arrest, a multi-agency narcotics operation seizing fentanyl and other drugs, and an officer-involved shooting of a dog attacking a pedestrian. The DMAC (Drug Market Agency Coordination Center) operation in the Tenderloin resulted in 54 arrests and 864 grams of narcotics seized between November 3–17. - DPA Director's Report (Item 5): Acting Director Jermaine Jones reported that DPA's audit division completed a report sent to SFPD for review, with responses due December 10. The investigations unit opened 24 new cases and closed 26 since the last meeting; neglect of duty allegations were the most common (failure to investigate and property handling). There are 20 cases open over 270 days (19 tolled), 107 sustained cases pending with the chief (down from 120), and 5 pending with the Police Commission. Commissioners requested an extension for the audit response deadline due to the holidays, and Jones agreed to follow up. - Sparks Report Q3 2024 (Item 8): Captain Chris Delgandio (SFPD Policy Development Division) and Acting Director Jones presented the third-quarter Sparks report, covering 28 DGO updates (one duplicate corrected). Eleven updates came from the 2024 annual review list, 12 carried over from 2023, and 5 were property-mandated. After quarter close, five DGOs (5.01, 5.03, 5.04, 5.05, 5.06) were issued. Working groups advanced DGO 5.20 (nearly complete) and the sexual assault policy. Jones highlighted a case involving SWATting, where DPA provided federal guidance to SFPD. Vice President Carter-Oberstone asked about DGO 5.18 status (scheduled for December 4) and inquired about the policy-making process under DGO 3.01. Delgandio affirmed adherence to current policy. - Commission Reports (Item 6): President Elias reminded commissioners to submit items for the December 4 meeting and announced the December dark period. Commissioner Benedicto reported attending the 30th anniversary memorial for Officer James Gelf and advocated for using the family's advocacy to restrict access to weapons of war. He also requested a report on SFPD's current federal partnerships, their implications under sanctuary city policies, and potential dissolution impacts, with a draft due by December 15. Assistant Chief Lazar confirmed the department would prepare the report. Key Outcomes - The commission unanimously voted (7-0) to receive and file the consent calendar. - The commission voted unanimously to enter closed session (Item 11) after no public comment on closed session matters. - Commissioner Benedicto's request for a report on federal partnerships was accepted, with a deadline of December 15, 2024, for an initial draft. - The commission noted the final meeting of the year on December 4, 2024, after which the commission will be dark following the Board of Supervisors schedule.

INDIGENOUS RIGHTS 33% · PUBLIC SAFETY 19% · PROCEDURAL 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11%
573
NOV 19, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - November 19, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, November 19, 2024, starting at 10:15 AM. The meeting included a consent agenda, a special appearance by Mayor London Breed, commendations, committee reports, and adoption of resolutions. Supervisor Catherine Stefani attended her last meeting before assuming her State Assembly seat, and the board declared November 19, 2024, as Catherine Stefani Day. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (severed by Supervisor Stefani): Development Agreement Amendment for 3333 California Street project by Laurel Heights Partners, LLC. Supervisor Stefani expressed strong support, noting extensive community outreach and endorsements from neighborhood associations. The item was passed unanimously. - Items 2–4 were adopted unanimously without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - Several speakers addressed the board during general public comment. Della Edwards requested assistance with a business permit for the San Francisco Century pop-up. Dmitri Akushkin reported an ethics complaint against former probation director Steve Adami, alleging violation of the one-year cooling-off period, and asked for accountability. Susan Pfeiffer reminded the board of Covered California open enrollment for 2025, including new eligibility for DACA recipients. Jim McPhee spoke against ranked-choice voting. A speaker raised concerns about black plastic meal trays used by a health department-sponsored agency, citing potential health risks. Beverly Epton of the San Francisco Domestic Violence Consortium thanked Supervisor Stefani for her leadership on domestic violence services. Mayor’s Appearance - Mayor London Breed appeared for a formal policy discussion (2:00 PM special order). She congratulated Supervisor Stefani on her election to the State Assembly. The mayor addressed fears in immigrant communities regarding mass deportation threats under the new presidential administration. She reported that the city has increased immigrant legal defense funding by 40% to nearly $7 million, allocated $3.5 million to Delor Street Mission Action for Immigrant Support, increased the Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs budget from $2.8 million to $4.1 million, and boosted the Public Defender’s Immigrant Defense Unit budget to $2.4 million. She affirmed the city’s commitment to sanctuary policies and ongoing efforts to protect residents. Special Order Commendations (2:30 PM) - Supervisor Ronan honored Antonio Diaz, founding director of PODER (People Organizing to Demand Environmental and Economic Justice). Diaz was recognized for 30 years of environmental justice leadership, including securing over 1,700 affordable housing units, creating Parque Niños Unidos, and co-founding the Mission Anti-Displacement Coalition. - Supervisor Safai honored Roberto Zentejo and Zentec Corp for 40 years of tax and accounting services to the Latino community in the Excelsior. Zentejo’s family immigrated from Guatemala in 1966; he is a product of San Francisco public schools and San Francisco State University. Discussion Items - Committee Reports (Items 22–26) were forwarded from the Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee (November 14, 2024). - Item 22: Ordinance to repeal Article 26 of the Police Code on public bathhouse regulations. Passed 11-0. - Item 23: Ordinance to amend the Administrative Code setting a June 24, 2025, end date for firearms procurement exemptions. Passed 11-0. - Item 24: Ordinance to expand buffer zones around reproductive health facilities from 25–50 feet to 100 feet, align with state law, require annual SFPD training on reproductive health access laws, and classify impersonation of healthcare providers as harassment. Supervisor Stefani spoke passionately in support, noting a recent incident at Planned Parenthood. The ordinance was co-sponsored by Supervisors Ronan, Dorsey, Mandelman, Peskin, and Engardio. Passed 11-0. - Item 25: Resolution authorizing DPH to access criminal history for massage business permits. Passed. - Item 26: Resolution adopting the Mental Health Services Act annual update for FY2024-2025. Passed. - Roll Call for Introductions: - Supervisor Ronan introduced a hearing request for an update on Mental Health SF. - Supervisor Walton introduced an ordinance to designate Leland Avenue in Visitacion Valley as a Neighborhood Commercial District (NCD), led by community merchants. - Supervisor Dorsey introduced a resolution urging full implementation of Proposition 36 (Drug Addiction and Theft Reduction Act), which passed statewide and in all 11 supervisor districts. The resolution emphasizes treatment-mandated felonies (TMFs) and enforcement equity in priority communities. - Supervisor Preston announced the release of a 118-page Budget and Legislative Analyst report, “Four Pillars for Success,” comparing San Francisco’s drug crisis response to Zurich’s four pillars (prevention, treatment, harm reduction, enforcement). Key findings: only 25% of San Franciscans with opioid use disorder receive medication (vs. 75% in Zurich); 40% of non-fatal overdoses appear from unintentional fentanyl consumption; enforcement-focused coordination (DMAC) lacks an interdepartmental approach. Recommendations include a comprehensive citywide drug policy, safe consumption sites (key to both harm reduction and enforcement), and city-operated wellness hubs. - Supervisor Preston also offered an in memoriam for Mirabai Martin Parker, owner of Mercury Cafe in Hayes Valley. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Items 2–4 adopted; Item 1 (3333 California Street) passed unanimously after being severed. - Mayor’s Appearance: No formal action, but policy discussion recorded. - Committee Reports 22–26: All passed 11-0. - Items 5–9 (General Obligation Bonds): Ordinance and resolutions authorizing issuance and sale of bonds totaling up to $747 million (series 2024B earthquake safety up to $225M, 2024C affordable housing up to $70M, 2024D affordable housing up to $152M, Proposition A 2024 up to $300M) passed unanimously. - Items 10–19 (Various contracts and grants): All passed unanimously, including: - Item 10: $17M amendment for transmission pipeline engineering (Kennedy/Jenks/AGS). - Item 11: $266,100 easement acquisition from Kaiser Foundation Hospitals. - Items 12–13: $5.7M and $5.9M CDC grants for HIV prevention. - Item 15: $26.5M airport services contract modification. - Items 16–17: $38M and $19.6M contracts for rehabilitation and AIDS foundation. - Item 18: $563.8M contract for train control system (Hitachi Rail). - Item 19: $319,000 grant for auto insurance fraud program. - Item 20: Official street naming for Hunters View Phase III (Memory Lane, Fairfax Avenue). Adopted. - Item 21: Reappointment of Supervisor Mandelman to California State Association of Counties. Approved after motion to excuse him from voting. - Item 29: Retroactive 90-day extension for Planning Commission review of Central SoMa/TTD commercial development requirements. Adopted. - Item 30: Resolution commending Supervisor Catherine Stefani. Adopted unanimously; November 19, 2024, declared Catherine Stefani Day in San Francisco. - Adjournment: Meeting adjourned in memory of Dennis Kelly (former UESF president), Troy Hiram Dangerfield (police lieutenant and advocate for minority recruitment), and Jeffrey Harold Cooperman (artist, swimmer, and photographer).

PROCEDURAL 35% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · PUBLIC SAFETY 12% · PUBLIC HEALTH 7%
574
NOV 18, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting – November 18, 2024

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on Monday, November 18, 2024 at 9:45 AM (actual start after roll call). Chair Walton presided, joined by President Peskin, Supervisor Ronan (sitting in), and Supervisor Safai (later excused). The committee heard seven agenda items: amendments to the Administrative Code on rapid rehousing, shelter monitoring, Mental Health SF, AI inventory, and surveillance technology; plus appointments to two advisory bodies. Several items passed to the full Board with positive recommendation; one was continued to a future meeting due to substantive amendments. 1. Administrative Code – Rapid Rehousing Policy (File 241038) Supervisor Ronan introduced an ordinance declaring city policy to provide up to five years of rapid rehousing assistance to families assessed as at risk of returning to homelessness if given only a short-term subsidy. She offered minor, non-substantive amendments (e.g., changing the initial eligibility window from three years to two years based on data, clarifying scope and assessment triggers). Emily Cohen (HSH Deputy Director) presented, noting a 70% success rate for current programs, that 92% of successful exits occur within three years, and that extending all families to five years could cost up to $32 million annually if every household took the full extension. Chair Walton and Supervisor Ronan criticized that figure as inflated, noting that very few families currently reach five years and that the estimate assumed no families would exit early. Public comment was overwhelmingly in favor: speakers shared personal stories of struggling with short subsidies, argued that longer subsidies prevent the revolving door of homelessness, reduce trauma for children, and make landlords more willing to participate. Data from Compass Family Services showed families receiving 25+ months of support had an 86% chance of stable housing vs. 50% for shorter terms. The committee accepted the amendments and voted unanimously to send the amended ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation. 2. Administrative Code – Shelter Monitoring Committee and Standards (File 240871) Dylan Schneider (HSH) presented amendments to reduce the frequency of shelter monitoring site visits, clarify complaint procedures, expand eligibility for seat one on the committee, and establish new minimum standards (e.g., shower stalls with working hot/cold water controls, minimum passing space). No public comment was offered. The committee voted unanimously to send the item to the full Board with positive recommendation. 3. Administrative Code – Mental Health SF Implementation Working Group (File 240984) Supervisor Ronan introduced an amendment to sunset the working group upon the effective date of the ordinance (early January 2025) instead of July 2025, citing completed work and quorum challenges. The amendment was deemed substantive by the City Attorney, requiring continuance to the next Rules Committee meeting. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously to continue the item. 4. Administrative Code – Artificial Intelligence Inventory (File 241022) Supervisor Ronan presented an ordinance requiring the Chief Information Officer to compile a publicly available inventory of AI systems used by the city, including 22 questions covering purpose, accuracy, bias, and impact on workers. She offered minor, non-substantive amendments recommended by civil liberties experts (e.g., replacing “efficiencies” with “internal administration”). CIO Michael Maxman gave a presentation on the city’s AI guidelines, staff training partnerships, and a three-month ChatGPT pilot with over 1,500 participants. One public commenter raised concerns about algorithmic bias, environmental impact, and the need for human staffing instead of AI replacement. The committee accepted the amendments and voted unanimously to send the amended ordinance to the full Board with positive recommendation. 5. Administrative Code – Surveillance Technology Ordinance Amendments (File 240983) President Peskin presented amendments to streamline the existing surveillance technology ordinance (Chapter 19B), reducing reporting burdens, clarifying exemptions, and allowing departments to submit policy changes directly to the Board without COIT review. Julia Crushell (COIT privacy analyst) provided details. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously to send the item to the full Board with positive recommendation. 6. Appointments – Citizen’s Committee on Community Development (File 230892) The committee considered reappointing Clinton Loffman (seat two) and appointing Linnell Sulligan (seat three). Both applicants briefly described their experience with HUD programs and community development. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously to approve the appointments. 7. Appointment – SOMA Community Stabilization Fund Community Advisory Committee (File 241034) The committee considered seven members: reappointments of Misha Olivas, Raquel Redondiez, Norman Lind, Christian Martin (with a residency waiver), Janetta Johnson, and new appointments of Henry Karnilowitz and Tanya Reyes. Norman Lind and Henry Karnilowitz spoke. Brian Chu (MOHCD) confirmed the other applicants’ willingness to serve. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously to approve all appointments and the residency waiver. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Rapid Rehousing): Amended and sent to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 2 (Shelter Monitoring): Sent to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 3 (Mental Health SF): Continued to next Rules Committee meeting due to substantive amendment. - Item 4 (AI Inventory): Amended and sent to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 5 (Surveillance Technology): Sent to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 6 (Citizen’s Committee on Community Development): Appointments approved. - Item 7 (SOMA Community Stabilization Fund): Appointments approved with residency waiver.

HOMELESSNESS 22% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 17% · PROCEDURAL 13% · TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION 13%
575
NOV 18, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting – November 18, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on November 18, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Chair Supervisor Mirna Melgar presided, joined by President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee considered five agenda items: two were continued to a later date, two were recommended for approval, and one was tabled. No public comments were offered on any item. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Planning Code – Impact Fees for Changes of Use): Chair Melgar noted that the Mayor’s Office and Office of Small Business requested additional time to meet with stakeholders. The committee voted unanimously to continue this item to December 2, 2024, after taking public comment (none offered). - Items 2 and 3 (Transit Center Open Space Fee Waiver for 524 & 530 Howard Street and Summary Street Vacation over Natoma Street): Madison Tam from Supervisor Dorsey’s office presented the companion ordinances, which facilitate a proposed 672-unit residential project (68 affordable units) and a pedestrian bridge connecting to the Transbay Transit Center rooftop park. The developer agreed to pay $2.3 million to the TJPA in lieu of the waived fee. The Planning Commission had recommended unanimous approval. No public comment. The committee moved to recommend both ordinances to the full Board with a positive recommendation, voting unanimously. - Item 4 (30 Van Ness Avenue Special Use District): Ms. Tam requested a continuance based on ongoing discussions. The committee voted unanimously to continue this item to December 2, 2024, after no public comment. - Item 5 (Planning Code – Affordable Price and Income Limits for BMR Units): No public comment. Chair Melgar moved to table the ordinance. The committee voted unanimously to table it (no further action at this meeting). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Continued to December 2, 2024 (unanimous). - Items 2 & 3: Recommended to the Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (unanimous). Expected to appear on the December 3, 2024 Board agenda. - Item 4: Continued to December 2, 2024 (unanimous). - Item 5: Tabled (unanimous). All votes were 3-0 in favor of the motions made by Chair Melgar.

LAND USE 64% · PROCEDURAL 26% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
576
NOV 14, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting – November 14, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, November 14, 2024, to consider a range of items including continuances, a consent calendar, commission matters, department updates, general public comment, and several regular calendar items. The meeting began with a roll call – Commissioners Present: President So, Braun, Campbell, Imperial, McGarry, Williams. Commissioner Moore was absent. The Commission voted on continuances, approved a consent calendar item, heard public comment on SB 423 projects, and deliberated on significant policy items including impact fee waivers for PDR conversions, a special sign district, citywide objective design standards, an informational presentation on the Tenderloin Community Action Plan, a housing project at 2083 Ellis Street, major modifications for India Basin, and an office development authorization at 620 3rd Street. Consent Calendar - Continuances (Items 1–4, 17): The Commission unanimously (6-0) voted to continue the following items: Item 1 (1126 Shafter Avenue) to November 21, 2024; Item 2 (4994 Mission Street) to December 5, 2024; Item 3 (411 Clipper Street) to December 12, 2024; Items 4A & 4B (2588 Mission Street) to January 23, 2025; and Item 17 (986 South Van Ness Avenue) to November 21, 2024. - Item 5 – Consent Calendar (1423 Polk Street): The Commission unanimously (6-0) approved a Conditional Use Authorization for 1423 Polk Street. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: A speaker showed photos of 235-237 Jersey Street, arguing that the city's flat policy must preserve the configuration of flats and prevent displacement. Another speaker, Bridget Maley (Neighborhoods United San Francisco), opposed the 1738 Filbert Street project (a nine-story building under SB 423), stating it is overscaled and that the city is not notifying neighbors. She urged the Commission to protect neighborhood character. - Item 10 – Impact Fees Change of Use: Public comment included opposition from Zachary Friel (SomCAN/Philippinas) and Peter Papadopoulos (MEDA/United to Save the Mission), who argued that waiving fees would incentivize loss of PDR space and undermine affordable housing funding. They requested a two-week continuance for further refinement. - Item 11 – Special Sign District: No public comment. - Item 12 – Citywide Objective Design Standards: Multiple speakers commented. George Shitish noted the absence of Commissioner Moore and urged caution. Christopher Roach (AIA SF) supported the standards as a living document but suggested adjustments to ground-floor commercial and fenestration requirements. Courtney Dam Kroger (Neighborhoods United SF) requested a continuance, citing insufficient time for public review and the need to consider preservation standards together. Others, including Catherine Howard, Stan Hayes (Telegraph Hill Dwellers), Claire Mills, and Monica Morse, echoed concerns about the rushed process, lack of neighborhood-specific standards, and the need for more community input. Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) spoke in support. - Item 13 – Tenderloin Community Action Plan: Numerous community members and organizational representatives spoke in strong support, sharing personal stories of positive impacts from TCAP-funded projects (tutoring, teen drop-in center, night navigator program, cultural events). They urged the Commission to continue funding and staffing beyond June 2025. - Item 14 – 2083 Ellis Street: George Shitish and Bridget Maley opposed the project, arguing it is overscaled, destroys a historic resource, and fails to provide meaningful affordable housing. They noted the project's location in a priority equity geography and potential demolition of a Category A building. - Item 15 – India Basin (700 Innes Avenue): One speaker (a community member) requested that the developer ensure local contracting opportunities. Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) and Kurt Grimes (A. Philip Randolph Institute) spoke in support, emphasizing community benefits and workforce commitments. - Item 16 – 620 3rd Street: No public comment. Discussion Items - Item 10 – Impact Fees for Changes of Use from PDR to Other Non-Residential Uses: The Commission considered a proposal to waive impact fees for changes of use from production, distribution, and repair (PDR) to other non-residential uses (excluding hotels and offices). Staff (Katie Tang, Mayor's Office of Small Business) presented data showing that on average four projects per year are subject to these fees, with collected amounts ranging from $10,000 to $700,000. The department supported the ordinance to promote business growth. Commissioners debated the impact on affordable housing funding and PDR retention. Commissioner Braun moved to recommend approval with a recommendation to maintain the jobs-housing linkage fee (or only partially waive it) and to continue exploring modifications with community input. The motion passed 4-2 (Commissioners Williams and Imperial dissenting). - Item 11 – 2301 Chestnut Street Special Sign District: The Commission considered a proposal to create a special sign district allowing two projecting signs for the corner commercial unit at 2301 Chestnut Street (Little Original Joe's). Staff recommended a broader modification to allow two projecting signs for all corner businesses in neighborhood commercial districts citywide. The Commission unanimously (6-0) approved the item with the staff modification. - Item 12 – Citywide Objective Design Standards: The Commission considered adopting the first chapter of the Citywide Design Standards, which set objective design standards for projects subject to the Housing Accountability Act (HAA). Staff presented the standards, which apply to residential projects with two or more units and mixed-use projects at least two-thirds residential. The standards cover site design (stepbacks, modulation) and architecture (facade articulation, ground floor treatment, fenestration). Public comment was divided, with many urging a continuance for more community input and to align with preservation standards. Commissioner Williams moved to continue to December 5, 2024, but the motion failed 2-4. Commissioner Braun then moved to approve the standards and schedule a six-month action item to review and potentially amend them. The motion passed 4-2 (Commissioners Williams and Imperial dissenting). - Item 13 – Tenderloin Community Action Plan (Informational): Staff presented an update on the TCAP, a three-year community-driven initiative funded by $4 million from Mayor Breed. The plan has funded 21 projects through participatory budgeting, including a school street, teen drop-in center, night navigator program, and cultural events. The team is developing a Tenderloin Investment Blueprint to guide future investment. Community members and partner organizations (United Way Bay Area, St. Anthony's, TNDC, etc.) testified in strong support, asking for continued funding and staffing. Commissioners expressed unanimous support and committed to advocating for the program in the upcoming budget cycle. - Item 14 – 2083 Ellis Street (Informational): The project proposes a seven-story, nine-unit residential building (eight new units plus retention of one existing unit) on a 8,000-square-foot lot. The existing Category A Victorian cottage would be partially retained with a 15-foot setback. The project requires waivers for unit exposure, rear yard, and height under SB 423. Staff noted that the project is in early stages; formal code compliance and historic review have not yet occurred. Commissioners discussed the condition of the building, potential for tantamount demolition, and the need for accelerated landmarking of vulnerable Category A structures. No action was taken as it was informational. - Item 15 – 700 Innes Avenue (India Basin Major Modifications): The Commission considered major modifications to the India Basin Special Use District to allow 75 small lot homes (with 75 ADUs) in the flats portion. The modifications relate to ground floor use, setbacks, and loading. The project is part of a larger 1,575-unit development. Staff recommended approval. Commissioner So raised concerns about inconsistencies between renderings and technical drawings (colors, window types). The project sponsor clarified that the governing documents are the technical drawings, which show three material palettes. Commissioner Williams asked about community benefits and local contracting. The Commission unanimously (6-0) approved the modifications. - Item 16 – 620 3rd Street (Office Development Authorization): The Commission considered an office development authorization for a 49,990-square-foot office addition atop a historic warehouse (contributor to the Clyde and Crooks Landmark District). The project would also provide retail space on Third Street and activate the Rich Street facade. The Historic Preservation Commission approved a certificate of appropriateness and recommended an active use waiver. The Commission unanimously (6-0) approved the authorization with conditions. Key Outcomes - Votes: - Continuances: Approved 6-0. - Consent Calendar (Item 5): Approved 6-0. - Item 10 (Impact Fee Waiver): Motion to recommend approval passed 4-2 (Braun, Campbell, McGarry, So in favor; Williams, Imperial against). - Item 11 (Special Sign District): Approved 6-0 with staff modification. - Item 12 (Design Standards): Motion to continue failed 2-4; motion to approve with six-month review passed 4-2. - Item 15 (India Basin Modifications): Approved 6-0. - Item 16 (620 3rd Street): Approved 6-0. - Directives: - Staff directed to continue community conversations on Item 10 and explore potential modifications to the impact fee waiver. - For Item 12, staff to schedule a six-month action item to review and amend the design standards, and to develop additional chapters for small-scale projects, cultural districts, and priority equity geographies. - Staff to work on accelerating landmarking of vulnerable Category A buildings (discussed in Item 14). - Next Steps: - Item 10 will go to the Board of Supervisors with the Commission's recommendation. - Item 11 will proceed to the Board with the citywide modification. - Item 12 standards will be adopted and implemented; preservation design standards will be heard at the Historic Preservation Commission on November 20, 2024, and return to Planning Commission later. - Item 13: The Tenderloin Investment Blueprint will be finalized by early 2025 and brought back for endorsement. - Item 14: The project sponsor will file a formal development application after tribal review; staff will conduct code compliance and historic review. - Item 15: The small lot homes will move forward with infrastructure and affordable housing phases. - Item 16: The office development authorization is approved; building permit process to follow.

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 18% · URBAN DESIGN 17% · PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11%
577
NOV 14, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Regular Meeting - November 14, 2024

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, November 14, 2024, at 10:15 AM PST. Vice Chair Joel Engardio presided, joined by Supervisor Dorsey, with Chair Catherine Stephanie excused. The committee considered seven items, including the repeal of outdated bathhouse regulations, liquor license approvals, and new protections for reproductive health facilities. All items were forwarded to the full Board with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Public Bath Houses): Five speakers expressed strong support for the repeal of Police Code Article 26. David Hyman (Leather & LGBTQ Cultural District) called the article \"archaic, ambiguous, and insulting\" and said it is economically harmful. Harry Brough described bathhouses as important social and connection spaces. Justice Dumlau (San Francisco AIDS Foundation) urged basing public health decisions on science rather than stigma. Laura Thomas (San Francisco AIDS Foundation) supported shifting regulation to the Health Department. Andy Stone (HIV Advocacy Network) thanked the committee for helping create spaces for queer community connection. - Item 6 (Reproductive Health Facility Protections): Two speakers supported expanding buffer zones. Julia Vicentin, a patient escort volunteer, described increasing protester harassment including trailing patients, yelling through megaphones, and using a toddler to deliver messages. Ruth Nunez, Senior Center Director of San Francisco Planned Parenthood, emphasized the need for the expanded buffer zone to protect patients and staff. Discussion Items 1. Police Code - Repeal of Public Bath House Regulations (Item 240966): Sponsor Supervisor Mandelman presented the ordinance to repeal Article 26 of the Police Code, which dated to 1973 and regulated bathhouses. He noted previous efforts in 2020 (Health Code amendments) and 2022 (Planning Code changes) had removed other barriers, but Article 26 remained, creating conflicts with new health regulations and requiring SFPD involvement. SFPD Principal Legislative Liaison Carl Nasita confirmed the department supports repeal, stating Article 26\'s provisions (e.g., prohibiting locked doors and requiring patron registers) are incompatible with Health Code Article 47. The committee voted unanimously (2-0) to forward the ordinance with a positive recommendation. 2. Liquor License Issuance - Nihon Whisky Lounge (Item 240978): SFPD Officer Friens reported zero letters of protest or support. The applicant, Khaled Dajani, described the venue as an upscale Japanese establishment that operated from 2005 until COVID, now reopening. The area is designated high crime, but Mission Station had no opposition. Conditions include monitoring for loitering, litter control, and requiring two uniformed security guards during live entertainment. The committee unanimously forwarded a resolution of public convenience or necessity. 3. Liquor License Transfer - AJ\'s Bar (Item 240948): Officer Friens reported zero letters of protest or support. The applicant, AJ, described moving the bar from 9th and Mission to 1250 Market Street, with $75,000 invested. He pledged affordable options ($5 beers, $6 cocktails) and active management. The area is high crime, Tenderloin Station had no opposition. Conditions include noise control, loitering monitoring, and litter cleanup. The committee unanimously forwarded a resolution. 4. Background Checks for Massage Permits (Item 240919): Patrick Fosdall (DPH Environmental Health) presented a resolution to allow DPH to access state and federal criminal history for massage business applicants, replacing the exclusive use of SFPD for background checks. The change aims to provide an easier, more equitable option for businesses owned mostly by women of color, while maintaining safety. No public comment. Unanimous forward. 5. Mental Health Services Act Annual Update FY2024-2025 (Item 240957): Jessica Brown (DPH) presented the annual update, noting the transition from MHSA to the Behavioral Health Services Act (BHSA) after Proposition 1 (March 2024). Key outcomes from FY2022-23: Full Service Partnership saw 88% fewer mental health/substance use emergencies for adults and 96% fewer arrests for youth. 53% of school-based clients improved relationships; 85% of wellness clinic clients felt less isolated; 100% of vocational program graduates succeeded; 95% of peer-to-peer participants increased understanding of mental health needs. The city held 5 community planning meetings with over 150 participants. The update sustains 85+ programs and plans to align with Proposition 1 requirements by summer 2026. Unanimous forward. 6. Protecting Access to Reproductive Health Facilities (Item 241040): Sam Logan (Supervisor Stephanie\'s office) presented an ordinance to expand buffer zones from 25-50 feet to 100 feet, aligning with state law AB 1356. It also mandates annual SFPD training on enforcement, requires biennial meetings with facilities, and classifies impersonating a health care worker as harassment. The 40 Days for Life campaign resulted in 28 security incidents at Planned Parenthood Northern California (July-September 2024). SFPD Policy Director Diana Roche expressed support. Unanimous forward. 7. Firearms and Ammunition Procurement Policy - End Date (Item 241039): Dominica Donovan (Supervisor Stephanie\'s office) presented a clerical amendment to set an end date of June 24, 2025, for a one-year exemption period allowing current suppliers to adjust to new minimum qualifications for firearms/ammunition suppliers. No public comment. Unanimous forward. Key Outcomes - All seven agenda items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors as committee reports with positive recommendations, each by a 2-0 vote (Vice Chair Engardio and Supervisor Dorsey in favor; Chair Stephanie excused). - Items 1, 4, 5, 6, and 7 will appear on the November 19, 2024 Board of Supervisors agenda; liquor license resolutions (Items 2 and 3) will appear on the December 3, 2024 Board agenda unless otherwise stated.

PUBLIC COMMENT 28% · PUBLIC HEALTH 24% · PUBLIC SAFETY 11% · MENTAL HEALTH 11%
578
NOV 13, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - November 13, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee met on November 13, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, joined by Supervisor Myrna Melgar (Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman excused). The committee considered 18 items, including a new Worker Justice Fund, several contracts, grants, and bond issuances. Public comments were heard on the Worker Justice Fund, with many workers and advocates expressing support. Most items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Worker Justice Fund (Item 1): Over 20 speakers testified in support, including workers from the Chinese Progressive Association, Legal Aid at Work, Mujeres Unidas Activas, and others. They shared personal stories of wage theft, unpaid wages, and the need for a safety net. Many emphasized that workers often cannot recover wages when employers go bankrupt or disappear. The fund was described as a 'fund of last resort' to ensure workers receive their hard-earned pay. No public comments were made on other items. Discussion Items - Worker Justice Fund (Item 1): Supervisor Hillary Ronen presented an ordinance to create a Worker Justice Fund, administered by the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (OLSE), to provide restitution to low-wage workers who have not been paid due to employer violations. Amendments were introduced to narrow eligibility to minimum wage violations (with one exception for a Burger King case), to redirect only 50% (instead of 100%) of OLSE penalty revenues to the fund, and to allow OLSE up to three years to claim unclaimed funds. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) estimated a general fund impact of up to $1.5 million annually (including $700,000 in diverted revenue and up to $800,000 for four new positions). The fund is projected to pay out $100,000–$300,000 per year, covering about 248 workers in the first year. The item was continued to the November 20 committee meeting. - Airport Professional Services Agreement (Item 2): Resolution approving a modification to extend a contract with Professional Business Providers, Inc. for operation and maintenance of passenger boarding bridges and baggage handling systems. The term was extended by two years (through July 2027) and the contract amount increased by $13.3 million to a total not-to-exceed $26.5 million. The BLA recommended approval. The item was forwarded to the full board. - Hitachi Rail Train Control System (Item 3): Resolution approving a contract with Hitachi Rail GTS USA Inc. for design, procurement, system implementation, and support for a communications-based train control system (replacing a 25-year-old system). The contract includes a 9-year design/procurement phase ($212 million), 10 years of support ($114 million), and two 5-year options ($237.7 million), totaling up to 29 years. The BLA recommended striking a clause allowing unlimited $2 million contract amendments and instead capping amendments at 5% of total contract value ($28.2 million). The committee adopted that amendment and forwarded the resolution to the full board. - Plumbing Supplies Contract (Item 4): Resolution approving a seven-year agreement with Underground Republic Waterworks for plumbing supplies, not-to-exceed $50.4 million. The BLA recommended approval. The item was forwarded. - Engineering Services for Transmission Pipelines (Item 5): Resolution approving a $10 million increase to a contract with Kennedy/Jenks Consultants and AGS, Inc. for engineering services on five transmission pipeline projects, raising the total to $17 million. The BLA recommended approval. The item was forwarded. - Real Property Acquisition from Kaiser (Item 6): Resolution approving the purchase of easements from Kaiser Foundation Hospitals for a water pipeline and electrical utilities in South San Francisco for $266,100. The BLA recommended approval. The item was forwarded. - HIV Prevention Grants (Items 7 & 8): Two resolutions retroactively authorizing acceptance and application of CDC grants for HIV prevention and surveillance. The total grant amount is $5.7 million (acceptance) and $5.9 million (application). The BLA recommended approval. The items were forwarded. - RAMS Vocational Rehabilitation Contract (Item 9): Resolution approving a 3.5-year extension and $22 million increase to a contract with Richmond Area Multi Services, Inc. for vocational rehabilitation programs, raising the total to $38.1 million. The BLA noted improved performance and recommended approval. The item was forwarded. - SF AIDS Foundation Contract (Item 10): Resolution approving a 3.5-year extension and $10 million increase to a contract with the San Francisco AIDS Foundation for mental health and substance abuse treatment services (Stonewall Project), raising the total to $19.6 million. The BLA recommended approval. The item was forwarded. - Bond Items (Items 11–17): These included an appropriation of $6.2 million in interest earnings from earthquake safety bonds for the emergency firefighting water system (Item 11), and approvals for the sale of $571 million in general obligation bonds across four programs (Seawall, Earthquake Safety, Affordable Housing 2019 and 2024). The bond proceeds will fund projects including the Embarcadero Seawall, fire and police facilities, emergency firefighting water system, and affordable housing. The BLA recommended approval. The committee approved an amendment to correct the title of Item 11 to 'emergency fire fighting water system.' Items 12 and 13 (Seawall-related) were moved to the December 3 board meeting to allow the Port Commission to act first. The remaining items were forwarded to the November 19 board meeting. - DA Auto Insurance Fraud Grant (Item 18): Resolution retroactively authorizing acceptance of a $318,857 grant from the California Department of Insurance for the Automobile Insurance Fraud Program. The committee encouraged the DA's office to submit future grants in a more timely manner. The item was forwarded. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Worker Justice Fund): Continued to the November 20, 2024 committee meeting as amended. - Item 2 (Airport Contract): Approved and forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 (Hitachi Rail Contract): Amended to limit delegated authority to 5% of contract value, then approved and forwarded. - Item 4 (Plumbing Supplies): Approved and forwarded. - Item 5 (PUC Engineering): Approved and forwarded. - Item 6 (Kaiser Easement): Approved and forwarded. - Items 7 & 8 (HIV Grants): Approved and forwarded. - Item 9 (RAMS Contract): Approved and forwarded. - Item 10 (AIDS Foundation Contract): Approved and forwarded. - Item 11 (Interest Earnings): Amended (title correction) and forwarded to the full board. - Items 12 & 13 (Seawall Bonds): Moved to the December 3, 2024 board meeting. - Items 14–17 (Other Bonds): Approved and forwarded to the November 19, 2024 board meeting. - Item 18 (DA Grant): Approved and forwarded.

LABOR RELATIONS 29% · PUBLIC FINANCE 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · WORKER JUSTICE FUND 9%
579
NOV 12, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - November 12, 2024

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held its regular meeting on Tuesday, November 12, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The meeting included a consent calendar, reports, public hearings, and votes on contracts, policy amendments, and the sunset of COVID-era collection procedures. All votes were unanimous (4-0) among President Kate Stacy, Vice President Arce, Commissioner Jamdar, and Commissioner Lavaroni. Consent Calendar - Item 7a: Award of Contract No. WW-729 for various sewer replacement to J. Flores Construction Company, Inc. (lowest responsive bidder). - Item 7b: Award of Contract No. WW-740 for large diameter sewer inspection to Pipe & Plant Solutions, Inc. - Item 7c: Award of Contract No. WD-2876 for water main replacement and installation on San Bruno Ave. and Blanken Ave. - Item 7d: Award of Contract No. WD-2910 for procurement and installation of medium and large diameter valves for regional pipelines. - All consent items were approved without separate discussion, following a question from Commissioner Lavaroni about compensable delay provisions. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Barbara Folger, a 55-year resident, stated she uses only 60 gallons of water per day (33% less than the 90-gallon projection on her bill) and criticized SFPUC’s planned investments that could triple her bill by 2045. Costa expressed frustration with the commission, alleging unfulfilled promises and lack of accountability. Scott Wells (Sierra Club Bay Chapter) urged settlement of the SF vs. EPA lawsuit, warning that the Supreme Court could weaken the Clean Water Act. Peter Drekmeier (Tuolumne River Trust) argued the SFPUC’s “design drought” is overly conservative, citing that actual demand is far below projections. Mary Butterwick called for reducing the design drought by one year to protect salmon. Additional callers addressed water supply planning and the need for transparency. - Item 6 – BAWSCA Report: Public commenters thanked outgoing CEO Nicole Sandkulla for her service but reiterated concerns about demand projections and the design drought. Peter Drekmeier noted that system delivery in FY2023-24 was 184 MGD, well below the 265 MGD obligation, and called for a workshop to address the balancing act between reliability and cost. - Item 12 – SIP Program: Community representatives (Risa Schwartz from Children’s Book Project, Kathy Bradley from Emerson, and callers from Stantec and IntoAction) praised the Social Impact Partnership Program (SIP) for funding local nonprofits and schools, with one speaker noting over $2.5 million in community benefits from Stantec and partners. - Item 13 – Sunset COVID Procedures: No public comment was offered on this item. - Item 16 – Closed Session: Peter Drekmeier urged the commission to investigate its role in the SF vs. EPA lawsuit, warning of reputational harm. BAWSCA Report (Item 6) Nicole Sandkulla, retiring CEO of the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA), delivered farewell remarks. She highlighted the success of the $4.8 billion Water System Improvement Program (WSIP) and urged a holistic, scenario-based approach to future challenges (climate change, growth, regulation). She emphasized building trust with water users through transparency. Commissioners thanked her for her decades of collaboration. Discussion Items - Item 8: Appointed President Kate Stacy to serve on the San Joaquin Tributaries Authority Commission. Approved unanimously. - Item 9: Staff requested approval to increase the cost contingency by $1,578,919 and duration by 542 days for Contract No. WD-2868R (as-needed paving for water main repairs). The original contract (May 2021, $13.9M) has been modified multiple times due to major breaks (e.g., $1.8M in restoration at Green and Fillmore). A new contract is expected by March 2025. Commissioner Arce questioned cost escalation adjustments for contractors. Approved unanimously. - Item 10: Approved Modification No. 1 to Job Order Contract No. JOC-98 (electrical construction) with U.S. Electric Technologies Inc., extending duration to 5 years and increasing the not-to-exceed amount by $2.5 million (to $7.5 million). Approved unanimously. - Item 11: Approved Amendment No. 1 to Professional Services Contract No. PRO.0183 (Residential Green Infrastructure Grant Program with Greenprint Partners), increasing funding by $500,000 (to $600,000 per year) and extending through 2028. The pilot has completed two projects; over 300 residents expressed interest. Commissioners discussed stormwater capture metrics and program administration. Approved unanimously. - Item 12: Public hearing to adopt amendments to the SFPUC’s Social Impact Partnership Program (SIP) Rules and Regulations. The amendments align with a recently passed ordinance (effective Nov. 18, 2024) that requires proportional increases in SIP commitments whenever contracts are amended. Staff presented updates on transparency (public dashboard, registry, 6,700 CAP customers) and accountability. Commissioners praised the program. Approved unanimously. - Item 13: Sunset COVID-19 pandemic procedures for water and sewer bill collection, resuming normal shutoffs and liens effective after the meeting. The SFPUC has over 14,000 accounts in arrears (up from 2,700 pre-pandemic). Customers enrolled in the Customer Assistance Program (CAP) or with extenuating circumstances will be exempt. A new dedicated CAP staff position (3-year pilot) was approved. Director Andris noted that state arrears relief did not correct payment behavior. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Unanimous approvals on all action items (items 7a-d, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 17, 22). - The commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege for closed session matters (Item 17) and later voted not to disclose the closed session discussion (Item 22). - A settlement was recommended for an unlitigated claim (Item 18) during closed session; no details were disclosed. - The meeting adjourned after closed session, with no additional business. Closed Session Items 17-20 were discussed in closed session regarding anticipated and existing litigation, including the SF vs. EPA case. The commission voted to assert privilege and later not to disclose the discussions.

PUBLIC COMMENT 25% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 21% · PROCEDURAL 17% · LEGAL 9%
580
NOV 7, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - November 7, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, November 7, 2024, to consider a variety of land use items including continuances, consent calendar approvals, commission and department matters, and several major legislative and project-specific items. The meeting featured extensive public comment and discussion on proposals to reduce commercial development requirements in Central Soma, modify the 30 Van Ness project's affordable housing and office allocations, and legalize a residential unit merger on Cumberland Street. Consent Calendar - Items 6 & 7 – Unanimously approved: Conditional Use Authorization for a Formula Retail Financial Service bank at 1699 Van Ness Avenue and a wealth management office at 3533 California Street. Commission Matters - The Commission adopted draft minutes for October 17 and October 24, 2024, as amended. - Commissioner Braun highlighted that the California Department of Housing and Community Development granted San Francisco a Pro Housing Designation, qualifying the city for state grant funding and priority processing. Department Matters - Director’s announcements included a reflection on community resilience post-election and reports on recent Board of Supervisors actions, including the passage of ordinances to increase affordable price/income limits for certain BMR units and creation of the Asia Senior Housing Special Use District. - The Historic Preservation Commission recommended approval of Legacy Business Registry applications for Leier’s German Specialties and The Gary Print Shop. General Public Comment - A resident presented a video advocating for flat preservation and expressed concerns about the city’s enforcement of the flat policy. - A remote caller asked the Commission to hold a public presentation on its rules and adopt a hearing calendar for 2025. Discussion Items Items 13a & 13b: Central Soma & Transit Center District Commercial Development Requirements - Proposal: Amend the General Plan, Planning Code, and Zoning Map to remove the requirement that large sites in these districts provide two-thirds non-residential square footage, allowing more housing. - Staff Recommendation: Approve with a modification to exempt projects under 600 feet in height (only in Central Soma) from the office allocation requirement, and clarify eligibility for state/local bonus programs. - Public Comment: Multiple community groups (Soma Filipinas, SomCAN) opposed the legislation, citing lack of public process, potential loss of promised community benefits (33% affordable housing, parks, pool, childcare), and risk of gentrification. They urged preserving site-specific benefits and requiring additional affordable housing. The project sponsor (Strata Investment Group) and Housing Action Coalition supported the change, arguing it would unlock stalled projects and generate impact fees for community benefits. - Commission Discussion: Commissioners expressed concern about retaining original community benefits, affordable housing targets, and need for a complete neighborhood plan for Central Soma. Commissioners agreed on the importance of preserving site-specific benefits for key sites. - Vote: Motion to approve with modifications (600-foot height cap limited to Central Soma, exploration of site-specific benefits, prioritization of the SOMA Chess (Cultural Heritage) Implementation Plan, and encouragement of a complete neighborhood plan). Passed 7-0. Item 14: 10 South Van Ness Avenue – Informational Presentation - Proposal: SB 423 preliminary application to re-entitle the site for a 755-foot, 952-unit tower (including 73 on-site BMR units) using state density bonus and ministerial approvals, replacing a previously approved 590-foot, 1,012-unit project. - Public Comment: A speaker requested better notification for SB 423 projects and raised concerns about cumulative infrastructure impacts, fire service, and segregation of affordable units. The Housing Action Coalition expressed support. - Commission Comments: Commissioner Moore noted the project reduces unit count while increasing height, and criticized the loss of public realm improvements (wider sidewalks, BART entrance) from the prior approval. Other commissioners encouraged the sponsor to be a good neighbor and incorporate community feedback. No vote taken. Items 15a, 15b, & 15c: 30 Van Ness Avenue – Special Use District, Conditions Amendment, Office Allocation - Proposal: Create a Special Use District to waive the inclusionary affordable housing requirement for the project, and approve a large-cap office allocation (additional 18,000 sq ft of office) to improve feasibility after the project paid $41 million in impact fees (including $14.4M for affordable housing) but stalled due to market conditions. - Staff/OEWD Support: The legislation provides parity with pipeline projects that received fee reductions; the $41M paid is already being used by the city. - Public Comment: Multiple speakers (Housing Action Coalition, Building Trades, local businesses, arts organization) supported the amendments to restart construction and bring 330 homes and jobs. - Commission Discussion: Commissioners recognized the need to restart construction at a key intersection, though Commissioner Imperial expressed regret over losing on-site affordable housing. Others noted the paid fees support nearby affordable housing. - Vote: Motion to approve all three items (SUD, Downtown Project Authorization amendments, Office Development Authorization). Passed 5-1 (Commissioner Imperial dissenting). Item 16: 250-252 Cumberland Street – Conditional Use Authorization - Proposal: Legalize an unpermitted merger of two flats into a single-family home by re-establishing a smaller unit on the first floor, reducing garage space, and restoring the front facade to correct prior violations. The current owners inherited the illegal merger from a previous developer. - Public Comment: Neighbors supported the project, noting the homeowners were not responsible for the prior work. A housing advocate requested that the findings not characterize the re-created unit as “overly large” and urged codification of the flat policy. - Commission Discussion: Commissioners sympathized with the owners, who face substantial costs. Commissioner Williams inquired about legal recourse against prior developers. The motion was amended to approve “as-built” conditions, removing the requirement to alter the front facade. - Vote: Motion to approve with the “as-built” amendment. Passed 7-0. Key Outcomes - Continued Items: Items 1–4 continued to future dates; Item 5 withdrawn. - Consent Calendar Approved: Items 6 and 7 passed unanimously. - Central Soma Amendments: Approved with modifications (7-0) – sends recommendation to Board of Supervisors to reduce commercial requirements, cap height at 600 ft in Central Soma only, preserve site-specific benefits, prioritize SOMA Chess Plan, and encourage complete neighborhood planning. - 30 Van Ness SUD & Office Authorization: Approved 5-1, enabling project restart with modified affordable housing obligations and expanded office space. - Cumberland Street Unit Merger: Approved 7-0 as-built, legalizing re-establishment of a second unit without requiring facade changes.

LAND USE 33% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 24% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com