Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 551–560 ENTRIES
551
JAN 13, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - January 13, 2025

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Monday, January 13, 2025, at 9:45 AM. Chair Miranda Melgar presided, joined by temporary committee members Supervisors Jackie Fielder and Blauma Mood. The committee considered three items, all of which received unanimous positive recommendations to the full Board of Supervisors. No members of the public provided oral testimony on any agenda item. Discussion Items Item 1: Acceptance and Recording of 132 Avigation Easements – SFO Noise Insulation Program - Presented by Deanna Volick (SFO). The resolution authorizes acceptance and recording of 132 avigation easements from property owners in San Mateo County as part of the federally funded noise insulation program. The easements protect the airport from future lawsuits by acknowledging the city's right to permit aircraft noise and other environmental effects. SFO staff noted that outreach is conducted directly by the airport, and the program has no formal MOU with San Mateo County. Item 2: Sunnydale HOPE SF – Phase 1A3 Infrastructure Acceptance - Presented by Jason Liu and Ryan Ren Zyland (Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development). This ordinance accepts new public infrastructure (streets, sidewalks, utilities, open space) for phase 1A3 of the Sunnydale HOPE SF project. The completed infrastructure supports three new buildings: a community center and two 100% affordable housing buildings, adding 170 new units (127 replacement units for former public housing residents). The overall Sunnydale redevelopment will transform the former 775-unit public housing site into 1,770 housing units (775 replacement, 200 additional affordable, 700 market rate) plus community amenities. Item 3: Planning Code Amendment – Health Service Uses in West Portal Neighborhood Commercial District - Presented by Chair Melgar and Aaron Starr (Planning Department). The ordinance amends the Planning Code to permit health service uses up to 5,000 gross square feet without a conditional use permit in the West Portal NC District. This change allows Dr. Lily Moside's existing business to move and expand within the corridor. The Planning Commission recommended approval. Chair Melgar introduced a technical amendment to correct a block and lot number (adding 'B' to read Block 2909B, Lot 17). Supervisor Mahmoud voiced support while noting a preference for holistic commercial corridor rezonings. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Avigation Easements): Motion to recommend approval to the full Board passed unanimously (3-0: Melgar, Fielder, Mahmood). - Item 2 (Sunnydale Infrastructure): Motion to recommend approval passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 3 (West Portal Health Uses): Motion to adopt the technical amendment and then recommend the amended ordinance to the full Board passed unanimously (3-0 on each motion). - All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of January 28, 2025, unless otherwise stated. - The next regular committee meeting is scheduled for January 27, 2025.

PUBLIC COMMENT 45% · PROCEDURAL 30% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 25%
552
JAN 9, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting – January 9, 2025

The San Francisco Planning Commission held its first meeting of 2025 on January 9, 2025, spanning a full agenda of continuances, consent items, informational presentations, conditional use authorizations, and a discretionary review. Key actions included approving a planning code amendment for a new school at 99 Rhode Island Street (6–1), receiving an update on the SF Railyards planning program, reviewing two housing projects on steep slopes in Bernal Heights, authorizing a social service facility for Friends of the Children SF Bay Area (7–0), and deciding not to take discretionary review on a fire-rated wall dispute (5–2). Consent Calendar - Item 5 – 331 West Portal Avenue: Conditional Use Authorization for a personal service, formula retail use (The Coder School) was approved unanimously (7–0). Public Comments & Testimony - Continuance Calendar: Several speakers (Linda Shaw, Joe Duncan, Alejandra Leonard, Olga Galvez, Marcia Lee) from St. Thomas Moore community supported continuances of items related to 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard, asking for alternative location proposals. All continuances were granted unanimously. - General Public Comment: Georgia Schutish raised concerns about the demo calcs loophole at 1647 Sanchez Street, urging adjustments to preserve sound housing and codify the flat policy. - Item 11 – 99 Rhode Island Street: Jackson Nutbyer (SF Chamber of Commerce) and Celia Schumann (Show Place East) spoke in support of the planning code amendment to allow a new school. - Item 13 – SF Railyards: Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) expressed excitement about the planning progress and transit-oriented development. - Items 14/15 – 134 Porter & 113 Roscoe Streets: Georgia Schutish questioned geotechnical review under SB 423; a Bernal Heights resident raised concerns about the lack of community notice and loss of affordable housing character. - Item 17 – 1932-1934 Jefferson Street: DR requester Ottorino Passian argued the proposed fire wall solution was worse than the existing condition; project owner Jeff Dreammer and wife Vivian rebutted, noting the neighbor had signed off on the original plans and that the fire wall was the only feasible remedy. Discussion Items - Item 1–4 (Continuances): All four items were continued to later dates (January 23, February 6, February 13, 2025) by unanimous vote. - Item 11 – 99 Rhode Island Street Planning Code Amendment: Staff explained that the ordinance would allow personal service and school uses to exceed size limits at the 60,000 sq ft building, currently vacant. The HEBA Academy plans a pre-K–5 school. Commissioner Moore supported, noting the positive neighborhood transformation; Commissioner Williams voted against, citing insufficient information. Motion passed 6–1. - Item 13 – SF Railyards Planning Program: Staff presented a concept plan for public realm improvements around the 20-acre site, addressing connectivity, green spaces, and pedestrian safety. The presentation covered five parallel projects: the Portal (DTX), Pennsylvania Avenue Extension, Caltrain’s Preliminary Business Case, the Railyards Neighborhood Planning Effort, and Prologis's development plans. Commissioners praised the interagency coordination and stressed the need for early public realm investments and climate resilience. No action was taken. - Items 14 & 15 – 134 Porter Street & 113 Roscoe Street Housing Projects: Informational presentation for projects totaling 26 units on steep slopes (up to 60%). Commissioner Moore raised concerns about construction phasing, open space, and accessibility for families. Commissioner Williams questioned the lack of neighborhood notice under SB 423; staff noted a new dashboard and alert system but acknowledged that direct notification is not required. No action was taken. - Item 16 – 4100 3rd Street Social Service Facility: The project would convert an existing mixed-use building (former restaurant and group housing) into a 6,000 sq ft social service facility for Friends of the Children SF Bay Area, a mentoring program serving children in Bayview. The nonprofit has served 120 children with 83% high school graduation/GED rates and 93% avoiding juvenile justice. Staff recommended approval with conditions. Commissioner Braun expressed concern about losing eight group housing units but ultimately supported the trade-off. Motion passed unanimously (7–0). - Item 17 – 1932-1934 Jefferson Street Discretionary Review: The DR requested review of a permit to build a one-hour fire-rated wall on a roof deck and stair landing to comply with an NOV. Staff recommended not taking DR, finding no exceptional circumstances. The DR requester argued the wall would block light and privacy; the project owner stated the wall was necessary and that the neighbor had approved the original positioning. After debate, a motion to not take DR and approve the project passed 5–2, with Commissioners Williams and Braun dissenting. Key Outcomes - Continuances: Items 1–4 continued to Jan 23, Feb 6, and Feb 13, 2025 (unanimous). - Consent Calendar: Item 5 approved 7–0. - Item 11: Planning code amendment for 99 Rhode Island Street recommended for approval (6–1). - Item 12: Preservation Design Standards continued (no date specified). - Item 16: Conditional use authorization for 4100 3rd Street approved with conditions (7–0). - Item 17: Discretionary Review not taken; project approved (5–2). - Commission Matters: December 5 and December 12, 2024 minutes adopted (7–0). - Subcommittee Disbanded: The subcommittee for 2588 Mission Street was officially disbanded; a community hearing will be held at City Hall on February 6, 2025 at 5 PM with translation and overflow room.

PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · LAND USE 15% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 12% · BUILDING INSPECTION 12%
553
JAN 8, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Inaugural Meeting - January 8, 2025

The Board of Supervisors held its inaugural meeting on January 8, 2025, at 10:15 AM, to swear in elected members, elect a new Board President, and hear remarks from members, the Mayor, and the public. All 11 supervisors were present, and the meeting concluded with the unanimous election of Supervisor Raphael Mandelman as Board President. Roll Call, Credentials, and Oath of Office - The meeting began with a roll call and the Pledge of Allegiance. The Clerk reported receipt of election certificates for the newly elected and re‑elected members: Connie Chan (District 1), Stephen Sherrill (District 2), Danny Sauter (District 3), Bilal Mahmoud (District 5), Myrna Melgar (District 7), and Chyanne Chen (District 11). The Controller certified that surety bond requirements were met. - Presiding Judge Rochelle C. East of the Superior Court administered the ceremonial oath of office to the newly elected and re‑elected supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - A total of eight members of the public addressed the board. Several speakers congratulated the supervisors and expressed confidence in the new board, with one speaker stating they were “thrilled” by the nomination of Supervisor Mandelman and another calling him a “real bridge builder.” One speaker opposed Mandelman’s election, claiming he “does not intend to end homelessness for trans people” based on a prior vote. Other speakers focused on general policy concerns, including the need to preserve arts funding, address downtown safety, and not overlook the Black community. Discussion Items - Nomination and Election of Board President: Supervisor Matt Dorsey placed Supervisor Raphael Mandelman’s name into nomination, praising his experience, temperament, and ability to work across ideological lines. The nomination was seconded by Supervisor Chyanne Chen, who noted Mandelman’s respectful treatment of colleagues. No other nominations were made. Following public comment, the board proceeded to vote. All 11 supervisors voted for Mandelman, resulting in a unanimous 11‑0 election. - Remarks by Members and the Mayor: - Mayor Daniel Lurie addressed the board, commending the supervisors for their unanimous vote and pledging “honest, open, transparent conversations” with the board. He highlighted the need for results and expressed optimism for San Francisco’s future. - Each of the newly elected or returning supervisors made brief remarks: Connie Chan thanked District 1 voters and spoke of the importance of love and perseverance; Stephen Sherrill emphasized public safety, housing, and small‑business support; Danny Sauter pledged to address homelessness, public safety, and economic vitality; Bilal Mahmoud committed to “humane, just and fair” governance; Myrna Melgar focused on housing, transit, and child care; Jackie Fielder highlighted public safety, sanctuary city protections, and tenant rights; Chyanne Chen stressed unity and support for working families and small businesses. - Returning supervisors Rafael Mandelman (now President), Matt Dorsey, and Shamann Walton offered brief congratulations and advice, with Walton urging the board to work together despite disagreements. Key Outcomes - Raphael Mandelman elected President of the Board of Supervisors by a vote of 11–0 for a two‑year term. - Supervisor Danny Sauter announced that his first official action would be to call a hearing on the “First Year Free” program to waive fees for new small businesses. - The board adjourned after the President’s closing remarks, with members proceeding to a community celebration in Chinatown. Remarks by the President - President Mandelman thanked his colleagues and District 8 voters, acknowledged the city’s challenges (including a nearly $1 billion budget deficit), and called for collaboration, good faith, and hope. He noted the importance of balancing social justice with efficient public service delivery.

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 33% · PROCEDURAL 28% · PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · HOMELESSNESS 6%
554
DEC 17, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – December 17, 2024

The Board of Supervisors held its final regular meeting of 2024, featuring farewell appearances by Mayor London Breed and outgoing Supervisors Aaron Peskin, Hillary Ronen, Dean Preston, and Ahsha Safaí. The board approved a consent agenda, took up several legislative items, heard a public hearing on an environmental appeal for a cannabis cultivation project, and adopted commendations for departing members. Consent Calendar - Items 1–14 were approved unanimously (9-0), including ordinances on transfer tax exemptions for port leases, certificate of participation for Treasure Island infrastructure (up to $65,000,000), appropriations, settlements, planning code amendments, and appointments. - Item 15 (Marina Smallcraft Harbor fee increase) was approved without objection. - Item 16 (non-renewal of Mills Act contract for 2209 Webster Street) was adopted. - Item 17 (response to Civil Grand Jury report on living wage) was approved. - Item 18 (laboratory uses in Urban Mixed Use district) was re-referred to committee on a motion by Supervisor Walton, seconded by Supervisor Melgar. - Item 19 (30 Van Ness Avenue Special Use District) passed on first reading (9-0). - Item 20 (Portal Project MOU) was adopted. - Item 21 (appointment of Estela Ortiz to Sheriff's Department Oversight Board) was approved. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comment was heard on items 32–35 (commendations) and general public comment. Numerous speakers thanked outgoing supervisors for their service, particularly for tenant rights, affordable housing, and progressive policies. Several speakers urged the board to preserve the Dreamkeeper Initiative funding, citing its positive impact on the Black community. Discussion Items - Mayor's Appearance (Special Order 2:00 p.m.) – Mayor London Breed gave her final address, thanking the board and city employees, highlighting achievements such as low crime rates, increased treatment for fentanyl addiction, and over 20,000 people exited from homelessness. Supervisors made farewell remarks praising her leadership. - Items 22–23 (Appointments to Board of Appeals and MTA Board) – The board rejected both nominations (5-4) after a motion to continue failed. Supervisor Peskin argued for a clean slate for the incoming mayor. - Item 24 (Mayoral appointment to Police Commission) – Withdrawn by the mayor earlier in the day. - Item 29 (Liquor license for Vita Brevis Club) – Approved unanimously (9-0). - Special Order 3:00 p.m. – Appeal of Categorical Exemption for 1719 Wallace Avenue Cannabis Cultivation – The board heard arguments from appellant Barbara Tassa, who argued the project should undergo full CEQA review due to proximity to residences and cumulative air quality impacts. The Planning Department and project sponsor defended the exemption, citing compliance with regulations and small scale (1,000 sq ft of cultivation). The board voted 9-0 to affirm the categorical exemption. - Legislation Introduced – New ordinances were introduced by outgoing supervisors: Supervisor Mandelman (protection of LGBTQ/reproductive health organizations’ disclosure exemptions), Supervisor Peskin (ban on city funding to 501c4 organizations), Supervisor Ronen (private right of action for healthy building violations), and Supervisor Preston (hearing request on SFPD overtime audit). Key Outcomes - Consent agenda approved (9-0) with 14 items. - Re-referral of Item 18 (laboratory uses) to committee. - Passage of Item 19 (30 Van Ness SUD) on first reading (9-0). - Rejection of mayoral appointments (Items 22–23) by 5-4 vote. - Affirmation of categorical exemption for 1719 Wallace Avenue cannabis cultivation (9-0). - Adoption of commendations (Items 32–35) for outgoing Supervisors Safaí, Ronen, Preston, and Peskin, with December 17, 2024 declared as Supervisor Ahsha Safaí Day, December 22 as Hillary Ronen Day, January 7, 2025 as Dean Preston Day, and recognition of Aaron Peskin’s service. - Adoption of Items 36–38 (final maps and other resolutions) without objection. - Meeting adjourned in memory of Varoon Soak, Bob Dockendorf, Judge Raymond Joseph Arata, Pia Harris, and Joseph Kreitz.

PUBLIC COMMENT 27% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 12% · CANNABIS REGULATION 8% · PROCEDURAL 7%
555
DEC 12, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Hearing Summary – December 12, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission held its regular hearing on Thursday, December 12, 2024, at 2:15 PM. The meeting addressed a variety of items including continuances, consent calendar approvals, and several substantive regular calendar items. Key discussions involved interim housing in hotels and motels, delegation of authority for below-market-rate units, development impact fee waivers for office-to-residential conversions, and several conditional use authorizations. All votes and decisions are recorded below. Consent Calendar - Item 7 (2024-006235CUA): 301 Junipero Serra Boulevard – Conditional Use Authorization for formula retail instructional service. Approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 8 (2024-007308DNX): 555 Pine and 430 Bush Streets – Was pulled off consent by Commissioner Moore and heard separately (see below). Public Comments & Testimony - Continuance Calendar: A member of the public (speaker name not provided) requested that a continuance at 500 Laguna Street not be extended again, citing a five-year struggle with a cannabis retail conditional use authorization that expired in 2023. They noted the lack of a formal revocation process for such projects. - General Public Comment: Georgia Shootish spoke regarding Section 317 of the Planning Code. She argued that the “tantamount to demolition” values have never been adjusted as intended, and urged the commission to use its legislative authority to preserve existing housing, especially in priority equity neighborhoods. - Item 13 (Interim Housing in Hotels and Motels): - Randy Shaw (Tenderloin Housing Clinic) opposed, criticizing lack of community outreach and negative impacts of existing shelter hotels on the Tenderloin neighborhood. He requested a continuance. - Simon Sin (owner, COVA Hotel) supported, noting his hotel operated successfully as a tourist hotel but the neighborhood declined after the pandemic. He supported interim housing as a solution that provides dignity. - Cedric Agbar supported the ordinance, emphasizing that hotels are ideal for interim housing with existing amenities and that the ability to revert to tourist use protects the hospitality industry. - Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) supported, calling it a cost-effective, creative solution that enhances dignity. - Item 14 (Delegation of Authority for BMR Units): Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) spoke in support, stating it streamlines processes and speeds up housing production. - Item 15 (Development Impact Fees for Conversions): - Multiple speakers supported: Jackson Nubier (Chamber of Commerce), James Stallworth (Brownstone Shared Housing), Mark Babson (Emerald Fund), Dan Feder (Wilson Meany), Erica McClitus (SPUR), Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition), Lisa Fullman (architect), Jack Sylvan (SDG/SPUR), Mark Skolnikov (Group I). They argued waiving fees is essential to make office-to-housing conversions financially feasible and revitalize downtown. - Charlie Shamus (Council of Community Housing Organizations) opposed, stating the waiver undermines affordable housing strategies, eliminates community benefits, and contradicts housing element goals. - Item 16 (216 Montana Street): Haiyan Yu, an adjoining neighbor, expressed concerns about loss of light and view due to the proposed zero-lot-line construction, requesting a setback or light well. - Items 17a/b (336 Pierce Street): No public comments. Discussion Items - Item 8 (555 Pine and 430 Bush Streets – Downtown Large Project Authorization): Staff presented a proposal for a 28-foot rooftop emergency generator reaching 129 feet, exceeding the 80-foot height limit. Commissioner Moore raised concerns about noise, emissions, vibration, seismic safety, visual impact, and lack of community outreach. The project sponsor explained that alternative locations (e.g., first floor of 555 Pine) were infeasible due to cost and technical challenges. After discussion, the commission approved 6-1, with Commissioner Moore voting against. - Item 13 (Interim Housing in Hotels and Motels – Planning Code Amendment): Deputy Director Emily Cohen (HSH) explained the ordinance allows tourist hotels/motels to be used for interim housing without losing their hotel use classification, enabling more non-congregate shelter options. Commissioners Imperial, Williams, and Moore advocated for a continuance to allow community outreach and engagement with new supervisors. Commissioners Campbell and Braun argued the urgency of providing shelter outweighs delays. The commission voted 4-3 to recommend approval with anticipated amendments to include relocation requirements for residents when interim housing ends. - Item 14 (Delegation of Authority for BMR Owned Units): Staff explained the delegation allows the planning director to administratively adjust affordable price/income limits for certain resold BMR units, avoiding the need for individual commission hearings. Commissioner Imperial expressed sensitivity about delegating power, while Director Hillis clarified it is routine and limited. The motion passed 5-2. - Item 15 (Development Impact Fees and Requirements for Non-Residential to Residential Conversions): The ordinance waives impact fees and inclusionary housing requirements for office-to-residential conversions in C2/C3 districts to stimulate downtown recovery. Staff recommended three modifications (technical corrections, zoning administrator’s ability to interpret prior conditions, and extending pipeline date to April 1, 2025). Commissioners debated the trade-off between incentivizing conversions and losing revenue for affordable housing. Commissioner Braun proposed referring the sunset issue to the Technical Advisory Committee (TAC). The commission voted 5-2 to approve with modifications 1 and 3, and with a referral to TAC for reassessment of the waiver. - Item 16 (216 Montana Street – Conditional Use Authorization): The project demolishes an existing single-family home and constructs two new three-story buildings, each with a primary unit and an ADU (total 4 units). Neighbor concerns about light and view were addressed by the architect, who noted a 4-foot light well and that the basement is partially underground, minimizing impact. The commission approved unanimously (7-0). - Items 17a/b (336 Pierce Street – Revocation and Conditional Use Authorization): Staff recommended revoking a 2019 approval for a rear building reconstruction (which never progressed) and granting a new CUA to remove an unauthorized dwelling unit (UDU) due to life-safety egress issues. The property owner agreed. The commission voted unanimously (6-0, with Commissioner Imperial absent? Actually all present voted, but minutes show 6-0? The transcript shows 6-0 with roll call: Ayes all, no nays. So 6-0.) to revoke the prior CU and approve the new CU. Key Outcomes - Continuances: All items (1-6) continued to future dates as proposed, passed unanimously. - Consent Calendar: Item 7 approved unanimously. Item 8 heard separately. - Item 8 (555 Pine & 430 Bush): Approved 6-1 (Commissioner Moore dissenting). - Item 13 (Interim Housing in Hotels/Motels): Approved with amendments (relocation requirements) by 4-3 (Commissioners Williams, Imperial, Moore dissenting). - Item 14 (Delegation of Authority for BMR Units): Delegation adopted 5-2 (Commissioners Imperial, Moore dissenting). - Item 15 (Impact Fee Waiver for Office-to-Residential Conversions): Approved with modifications 1 and 3, and referral to TAC for reassessment, by 5-2 (Commissioners Williams, Imperial dissenting). - Item 16 (216 Montana Street): Conditional use authorization approved unanimously (7-0). - Items 17a/b (336 Pierce Street): Revocation and new conditional use authorization approved unanimously (6-0). Next Steps: The commission will reconvene in January 2025. The subcommittee for 2588 Mission Street (Commissioners President So, Williams, and Campbell) will hold a community hearing in early 2025.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 21% · LAND USE 16% · HOMELESSNESS 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9%
556
DEC 12, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - December 12, 2024

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, December 12, 2024, at approximately 10:00 AM (the agenda lists 18:15 UTC, but the transcript begins with "Good morning"). The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Joel Engardio. The clerk was Monique Creighton. The committee heard three items: a liquor license application, a hearing on traffic enforcement and street safety, and a hearing on law enforcement data dashboards. Liquor License Issuance - 969 Market Street - Vita Brevis Club - The committee considered a Type 48 on-sale general public premises liquor license for VBC SF LLC (doing business as Vita Brevis Club) at 969 Market Street, located in District 6. The applicant plans a cocktail lounge with an art gallery and live performances. - Officer Freunds from the SFPD Alcohol Beverage Control Liaison Unit reported zero letters of protest or support. The area is in a high-crime census tract. Tenderloin station had no opposition. The Alcohol Liaison Unit recommended approval with three conditions: active monitoring of loitering, no audible noise beyond the premises, and two licensed uniformed security guards during live entertainment. - Chair Dorsey expressed enthusiastic support, noting the business’s role in the mid-market comeback and positive feedback from constituents. - The applicant’s counsel, Nick Cola, stated acceptance of all proposed conditions. - No public comment was received. - Motion: To prepare a resolution finding the license serves public convenience and necessity, and forward it to the full board with a positive recommendation as a committee report. Passed unanimously (2 ayes). Public Comments & Testimony - On the traffic enforcement item, two members of the public spoke: - Jody Madeiris, Executive Director of Walk San Francisco, expressed support for the committee’s oversight and Commander Jones’ efforts, but noted citation numbers are still insufficient. She called for traffic enforcement to be a departmental priority and for better data transparency. - A resident near Market and Octavia supported increased enforcement, specifically at the Octavia Boulevard and Gough Street corridors, and urged collaboration with SFMTA for physical street improvements. - On the data dashboards item, one member of the public recounted a wrongful arrest due to a name mix-up, criticizing the accuracy of criminal justice data. Discussion Items 1. Hearing on Traffic Enforcement and Street Safety (Item 2) - Supervisor Rafael Mandelman called the hearing to review SFPD’s traffic enforcement progress and the 2025 plan. He noted that despite improvements, enforcement levels remain far below pre-2020 levels and that departmental prioritization is needed. - Commander Jones presented the 2025 Traffic Enforcement Plan. Key data: - 12,467 citations issued through October 2024 (preliminary November totals near 13,000), up from about 5,000 in all of 2023—the highest in four years. - 42 traffic fatalities through December 12, 2024, potentially the deadliest year in a decade. 25 of 42 involved pedestrians. - SFPD staffing: 29 motorcycle officers assigned to traffic company, but three retiring and two on long-term disability, leaving 18 riders in January. Department-wide deficit of over 500 officers below the authorized 2,074. - Strategies include directed enforcement, enforcement waves (50 wave operations since May 2024), integrated enforcement, and education. New focus on speed and pedestrian safety, with 11 priority crash locations and a list of pedestrian crash locations. - Technology: drones for sideshow enforcement, radar/LIDAR equipment needed for motorcycles (estimated $1,200 per bike, 30 sets needed), and automated speed enforcement cameras from SFMTA. - Goals for 2025: obtain radar/LIDAR equipment, expand publicity, partner with DPH to measure enforcement outcomes, deploy message boards, and improve court data feed. - Supervisor Engardio asked about the feasibility of stationing an officer at a single intersection; Commander Jones explained the wave concept covers more locations. - Supervisor Mandelman stressed the need for departmental-wide prioritization, measurable targets (while avoiding illegal quotas), and a future discussion with the Chief of Police. He moved to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. - Motion: To continue the hearing to the call of the chair. Passed unanimously (2 ayes). 2. Hearing on Law Enforcement Data Dashboards (Item 3) - Vice Chair Engardio called the hearing to explore how the Superior Court and Sheriff’s Office provide public access to criminal justice data. - Superior Court: Brandon Riley (Court Executive Officer) and Michael Corrier (Chief Data Officer) presented: - A criminal case information portal launched in April 2024, providing online access to calendars, registers of action, and case indexes for criminal cases—previously not available online. - A criminal case data dashboard (first in California) launched in November 2024, updated daily, showing aggregate data on filings, clearances, pending cases, dispositions, trials, and outcomes by felony/misdemeanor. Legal constraints under Penal Code 13300 prohibit sharing summary criminal offender record information, limiting publicly accessible details. - Future plans: online criminal records requests and a kiosk at 850 Bryant Street, targeted for spring 2025. Technical challenges include sealing records and consistent user experience. - Sheriff’s Office: Tara Moriarty (Director of Communications) and Lucas Jennings (Senior Administrative Analyst) presented: - Currently available data: jail population stats, historical trends, inmate locator (requires partial name), and reports on sfsheriff.com. Data is de-identified to protect privacy. Partnerships with DataSF, BSCC, and other agencies enable additional public dashboards. - Challenges: outdated software, staffing constraints, manual record keeping. A new jail management system under development will improve data tracking. A $5M MacArthur Foundation grant supports jail population analysis; the Sheriff’s Office took over data oversight from the DA in November 2024. - Future steps: expand booking data with charge-level detail on DataSF, but must avoid re-identification of individuals. - Supervisor Engardio emphasized transparency for public trust and journalists. He noted the importance of reducing barriers to data access. - Motion: To file the hearing. Passed unanimously (2 ayes). Key Outcomes - Liquor License (Item 1): Approved and forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (2-0). - Traffic Enforcement (Item 2): Hearing continued to the call of the chair; committee will reconvene after Q1 2025 for updated data and discussion with departmental leadership (2-0). - Law Enforcement Data Dashboards (Item 3): Hearing filed; committee pledged continued collaboration with the Superior Court and Sheriff’s Office to improve data transparency (2-0). Adjournment The meeting adjourned after completing the agenda.

TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 40% · PUBLIC SAFETY 25% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 8% · CRIMINAL JUSTICE DATA MANAGEMENT 7%
557
DEC 10, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - December 10, 2024

The Port Commission met on December 10, 2024, at 11:15 AM to review the year-end report, approve consent items, discuss amendments to the General Plan and BCDC Special Area Plan, and authorize agreements with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for the Waterfront Coastal Flood Study. The meeting also included a retirement tribute and public comments on unpaid subcontractor work. Consent Calendar - 8A – Approved market rent structure for a new 5-year lease at 360 Jefferson Street with Portco Inc. DBA Safe Harbor (initial base rent $3/sq ft/month + 8.75% percentage rent). Resolution 2456. - 8B – Awarded Construction Contract No. 2852R (Amador Street Infrastructure Improvements) to JMB Construction Inc. for $10,236,543, with a 10% contingency ($1,023,654), total not to exceed $11,260,197. Resolution 2457. - 8C – Awarded Professional Service Contract 1000034740 (Herons Head Park Biological and Physical Monitoring) to Environmental Science Associates for $679,232. Resolution 2458. - 8E – Approved retroactive no-fee license with Kayaks Unlimited for 3,467 sq ft of paved land and 8,395 sq ft of park open space at Islais Creek Landing, term 10 years from July 1, 2020, with two 5-year options. Resolution 2460. Public Comments & Testimony - Tracy Zoo (Board President, Kayaks Unlimited) expressed support for the Kayaks Unlimited lease (8E), highlighting the club’s mission to provide affordable kayaking access and stewardship of Islais Creek Park, and noted diverse community groups served. - Reva Murphy (RMA – Riva Murphy Associates, woman-owned LBE) spoke during public comment on non-agenda items, stating she was not paid $111,000 for completed work on Building A at Mission Rock Campus. She alleged that general contractors Swinerton and F.D. Thomas ignored requests and issued a deductive change order of $99,000, effectively wiping out her final payment. She requested the Commission’s help in resolving the dispute. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (7A): Elaine Forbes presented the Port’s 2024 year-end report. Key statistics: 280 staff managing 7.5 miles of waterfront; 91 cruise calls with 365,000 passengers; 1.4 million visitors to Alcatraz; 10–12 million visitors to Pier 39; 400+ tenants; 33 new leases; $143 million in port revenue; $105 million in grant funding; $2 billion capital backlog. Highlights included the opening of Bayfront Park and China Basin Park, 357 homes at Mission Rock (30% affordable), and $55 million for ferry electrification. Forbes also announced the retirement of Phil Williamson after 28 years; multiple staff and commissioners praised his contributions. - Item 8D (Travel to Paris): Forbes recommended pulling this item from consent due to the mayor’s travel ban. The item would authorize staff to deliver 48 pieces of lost art (Archie Lokakoff) to a Paris museum, engage with Port of Le Havre, and research placemaking. After discussion, commissioners tabled the item to a future meeting, with consensus to seek a waiver for one staff member and explore museum-funded travel for another. - Item 9A (Waterfront Plan Amendments): Diane Oshima presented an informational update on interagency work with the San Francisco Planning Department and BCDC to align the General Plan, Planning Code, and Waterfront Special Area Plan with the Port’s 2023 Waterfront Plan. Key focus: amending the 50% rule in Fisherman’s Wharf to allow uses consistent with the Burton Act, and amending the Exploratorium’s fill removal requirement to instead provide a public education program on sea level rise. Next steps: BCDC Commission action expected in February/March 2025. - Item 10A (Feasibility Cost Sharing Agreement Amendment 3): Kelly Capone (Waterfront Resilience Program) requested authorization to amend the Army Corps of Engineers cost-sharing agreement, adding $3.2 million (total study cost $19.2 million, 50/50 cost share) and extending the study duration by 12 months (total 8 years 2 months). The amendment includes an accelerated funding clause. Resolution 2461. - Item 10B (MOU with Army Corps of Engineers): Steven Real (Waterfront Resilience Program) presented a Section 221 in-kind MOU to allow the Port to advance design and construction of coastal flood defenses (Downtown and South Beach Coastal Resilience Projects) before congressional authorization, preserving eligibility for future federal credit. The MOU does not commit the Port to expenditures. Resolution 2462. - Item 10C (Wharf J9 Replacement Project Contract Modification): Chris Horiuchi requested authorization to modify Construction Contract No. 2861 for Phase 1 (float and gangway) to extend the substantial completion date by 105 days (to February 14, 2025) and increase the contract value by $300,000 (to $4.2 million) for additional pile repairs at Wharf J8. The work is being performed by LBE Yerba Buena Engineering & Construction. Resolution 2463. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (excluding 8D): Resolutions 2456, 2457, 2458, and 2460 adopted unanimously. - Item 8D: Tabled to a future meeting; staff directed to seek a waiver for one traveler and explore alternative funding. - Item 10A: Resolution 2461 adopted unanimously. - Item 10B: Resolution 2462 adopted unanimously. - Item 10C: Resolution 2463 adopted unanimously. - Public Comment (non-agenda): President Brandon directed Executive Director Forbes to work with Reva Murphy to resolve the unpaid subcontractor issue and report back to the Commission. - New Business: Commissioner Adams suggested arranging a photo with outgoing Mayor London Breed before her term ends; staff will attempt to coordinate.

PUBLIC COMMENT 30% · INFRASTRUCTURE 18% · PUBLIC WORKS 16% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 10%
558
DEC 10, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Meeting – December 10, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Tuesday, December 10, 2024, at 10:15 a.m. The meeting included approval of the consent calendar, a special order at 3:00 p.m. to hear an appeal of the SFMTA's decision on overnight recreational large vehicle parking restrictions, four commendations, and numerous regular agenda items covering housing, port leases, settlements, and policy amendments. The board voted 7–3 to conditionally reverse the SFMTA's RV parking ban, overturning the mayor-backed policy. Consent Calendar - Approved Items 1–14 en bloc, including routine ordinances: fee eliminations, $571 million in general obligation bonds for seawall, earthquake safety, and affordable housing; settlement approvals (Scott Edwards – $650,000; Annamarie Faro – $195,000; Rick Lam – $350,000; Maria Elena Rosales – $95,000; Steven Benvenuto – $70,000; Michael J. Turon – 2722-2724 Folsom Street); planning code amendments and street vacations; administrative code changes for Shelter Monitoring Committee, Surveillance Technology Ordinance, Artificial Intelligence Inventory, and Rapid Rehousing Policy. Public Comments & Testimony - RV Parking Ban Appeal (3:00 p.m. Special Order): Over 40 speakers, including representatives from La Raza Community Resource Center, Coalition on Homelessness, Compass Family Services, and individuals living in RVs, urged the board to reverse the SFMTA decision. Key points: the ban would harm the 1,400+ people living in vehicles (90% of unsheltered families are in vehicles); towing would destroy the only shelter for many families, children, seniors, and disabled persons; the city lacks sufficient shelter beds (over 500 families on waitlist) and safe parking sites; the policy would disproportionately affect immigrants, people of color, and low-income workers. Several speakers cited a lack of meaningful outreach and housing offers before enforcement. Discussion Items - Item 15 – Settlement for Paul Wildes and Reed Sandberg: Ordinance authorizing a $3,250 payment plus injunctive relief for alleged discrimination. Passed 7–3 (Supervisors Walton, Peskin, Preston voting no). - Items 16–18 – Port of San Francisco Items: Lease terminations and new leases for Waterfront Plaza (57-year term, $1M initial rent) and Pier 45 Sheds A & C, plus transfer tax exemption for port leases. Approved 10–0. - Items 19–23 – Treasure Island Infrastructure Financing: Certificate of participation up to $65M, appropriation of $65.55M, and related resolutions. Approved en bloc. - Items 25–28 – Homelessness Support Housing Leases and Grants: Ground lease with Abode Property Management ($1 rent), $14.2M grant for supportive housing, $43.5M amendment for St. Vincent de Paul, $17.8M amendment for Compass Family Services. Approved. - Item 32 – Embarcadero Plaza Grant (BXP): Deferred to committee on motion by Supervisor Chan (seconded by Ronan) for further capital planning discussion. - Items 38–39 – Casa Adelante Affordable Housing (1515 South Van Ness): Up to $107.6M in revenue notes and $45.2M loan for 168-unit 100% affordable project. Approved with celebratory remarks by Supervisor Ronan. - Item 40 – Potrero Yard Modernization Project: Endorsed design-build-finance-operate-maintain agreement (milestone payments up to $200M, annual payments up to $42.2M over 30 years). Approved. - Item 41 – Bay FC Training Facility Lease on Treasure Island: 25-year lease with extensions, $28,000/month after occupancy. Approved. Supervisor Dorsey noted co-sponsors and commended the project. - Items 45–47 – Referred Items from Budget Committee (Marina Fees, HomeRise, Mid-Market Foundation): Supervisor Chan explained the difficult choices due to budget deficits, audit flags, and overspending. All three items were approved. - Items 49–52 – RV Parking Restrictions Appeal: After extensive public comment, the board considered three motions: (50) Affirm SFMTA decision; (51) Conditionally reverse; (52) Prepare findings. Supervisor Preston moved to table item 50 and adopt items 51 and 52, seconded by Supervisor Walton. - Discussion: Supervisors Mandelman and Melgar expressed concerns about resources and the need for safe parking sites first, but ultimately supported the reversal. Supervisor Safai called the policy a political ploy and supported the appeal. - Vote: 7–3 (Supervisors Dorsey, Engardio, Mandelman dissenting). The SFMTA decision was conditionally reversed; the board will adopt written findings based on the appeal arguments. - Item 56 – Chevron Unlitigated Claims (Kern County Property): Conveyance of city-owned land in Kern County to Chevron. Supervisor Chan explained her no vote, citing climate concerns. Passed 8–2 (Chan, Melgar no). - Commendations (2:30 p.m. Special Order): Recognitions for Airport Director Ivar Sattero (retiring after 40 years), League of Women Voters of San Francisco, Andrew Jordan Nance (Mindful Arts SF), Tracy and John Gallardo (Mission District community leaders), and Presidio Bay Foundation (for Scholars Summer Program). Key Outcomes - Conditionally reversed SFMTA's overnight RV parking ban (7–3). The board directed preparation of written findings for the reversal, effectively nullifying the policy. - Approved $571M general obligation bonds for capital projects (consent). - Approved over $107M for Casa Adelante affordable housing at 1515 South Van Ness. - Endorsed Potrero Yard modernization with key financial terms. - Approved Bay FC training facility lease on Treasure Island. - Defeated (deferred) Embarcadero Plaza grant to committee for capital plan alignment. - Approved settlement agreements for lawsuits totaling approximately $2.66 million (Items 53–55) and several smaller settlements. - Adopted 2025 board meeting schedule with amendments (removed September 23 for Rosh Hashanah; moved December 2 meeting to November 25). - Seniority lottery for four incoming supervisors (Cheyenne Chen, Jackie Fielder, Bilal Mahmud, Danny Sauter) was conducted; order of seniority will be posted.

HOMELESSNESS 33% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · PUBLIC SAFETY 7% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 7%
559
DEC 10, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
SFPUC Commission Meeting Summary – December 10, 2024

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held its regular meeting on Tuesday, December 10, 2024, at 9:30 AM. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of minutes, a continued Citizens’ Advisory Committee annual report, a detailed General Manager’s Report covering policy, capital programs, audits, budgets, and wastewater projects, a consent calendar of seven contracts, and a regular calendar with a childcare center lease, surplus land sales, major program management contract, meter diagnostic services, cross-connection control rule updates, and a grant to the San Francisco Unified School District. The meeting recessed for approximately 30 minutes for a mayoral event and experienced initial technical difficulties with remote public comment, which were later resolved. Closed session addressed several legal matters. Consent Calendar - Item 7a-7g: Approved unanimously with no public comment. Items included contracts for corrosion consulting, fire/life safety systems, water main and sewer replacement on Grand View Avenue (contract WD-2875, $10,145,959), job order contract modifications, sewer pipe replacement (WW-760, $9,228,23), and equipment/software maintenance for water pollution control plants (CS-1248). Item 7B was questioned by Commissioner Arce regarding a micro-LBE contractor’s license; staff confirmed the prime must hold the C16 license. Public Comments & Testimony - Dave Warner (speaking during general public comment and on item 6B): Expressed concerns about governance, stating the commission is not given real choice on key financial plans or water rates. He also argued that capital project cost variance reports may be misleading because budgets are reset annually. - Peter Drechmar (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust): During general public comment, he noted that the annual water resources report shows regional water deliveries at 179,000 acre-feet (far below the 2020 Urban Water Management Plan projection of 216,000 acre-feet for 2025). He urged prioritizing accurate demand projections in the upcoming 2025 Urban Water Management Plan to avoid over-investment in unnecessary supplies. - James Bryant and Demetrius Williams (local contractors): During the Wastewater Enterprise quarterly report, they thanked the SFPUC for contracting opportunities, noted a 45% hyperlocal participation rate on projects, and expressed desire for continued access to major projects such as Headworks and Biosolids. Discussion Items - Item 5 – CAC Annual Report: Continued to the next meeting because the presenter was unavailable. Unanimously approved continuation. - Item 6 – General Manager’s Report: - 6a – Annual Policy & Government Affairs Update (Emily Lamb): Highlighted securing Board of Supervisors approval of the biannual budget, supporting the $10 billion state climate bond (approved by voters), engaging on nearly 300 state bills, and advocating for federal low-income water assistance. The team will brief incoming elected officials in January 2025. - 6b & 6c – Water Enterprise CIP & Water System Improvement Program (Katie Miller): Reported 52 water enterprise projects with a total $4.0 billion budget. 52 regional WSIP projects are 99% complete. Noted one major bid variance: the Sunol Valley Ozone project low bid was 28% ($40 million) above the engineer’s estimate; the contract was awarded with funds from a future budget. Commissioner Stacy asked about Lake Merced water level restoration delays – attributed to Daly City staffing shortages. - 6d – Audit & Performance Review Q1 (Irella Blackwood): Completed 7 audits in Q1. The Revenue Bond Oversight Committee will sunset in January 2025; the audit bureau will assume oversight functions. 11 audit recommendations were closed during Q1. - 6e – Budgetary Report Q1 (Laura Bush): Projected operating shortfalls for water ($7.3M) and wastewater ($6.6M) due to lower retail volumes and delayed billing ( $15M outstanding, $9M already collected). Power and CleanPowerSF showed positive results ($56.6M and $31.8M) due to lower power purchase costs. All financial policy targets are expected to be met. Commissioner Jamdar questioned the across-the-board decline in retail sales; staff cited slower-than-expected economic recovery and return to office. - 6f – Wastewater Enterprise Quarterly Report (Bessie Tan): Provided updates on the Sewer System Improvement Program (SSIP) – 127 projects, 67.7% complete. Highlighted new sewer lining techniques and the Treasure Island resource recovery plant (40% complete). Commissioner Arce praised LBE contracting and requested future presentations on LBE subcontracting percentages on major projects. - Item 11 – Award Program Management Contract to HDR Stantec JV (Katie Miller): Awarded a 10-year, $80 million contract to support water and Hetch Hetchy capital programs. The joint venture scored highest in all proposal phases and committed 20.83% LBE (15 firms). Commissioner Tom questioned the value of external expertise; Miller cited need for global best practices in cost estimating, technology, and operations/maintenance. Commissioner Stacy noted the program management contract will help transition from one-time WSIP to a rolling 10-year CIP. - Item 14 – Meter Maintenance Diagnostic Services (Steve Ritchie): Awarded a 5-year, $2.4 million contract to Olea Networks for large meter diagnostic services (part of water loss reduction). The proposal included 78% LBE participation. Commissioner Leverone praised the high LBE percentage. - Item 15 – Amended Cross-Connection Control Regulations (Andrew Degraca): Adopted unanimously. The state updated rules for the first time in 35 years, requiring all services (including residential and fire services) to be evaluated. Over 35,000 devices in San Francisco; fire service backflow preventers must be replaced above ground over 10 years. - Item 16 – Grant to SFUSD for Environmental Education (Blair Randall): Approved a three-year, $2,228,775 grant ($742,925 annually) to support teacher and student learning about SFPUC operations, green infrastructure, and career awareness. Components include student climate action fellowships, teacher professional development, and updated K-12 watershed curricula. Commissioner Arce recused himself (wife on SF Board of Education), excused by vote. Key Outcomes - Approval of Minutes (October 22 and November 12, 2024): Unanimously approved. - Consent Calendar (Items 7a-7g): Unanimously approved. - Lease to C5 Children’s School (Item 8): Approved a 5-year lease (with one 4-year extension option) at $1/year for the childcare center at 525 Golden Gate Avenue. The lease requires prioritizing children of PUC employees, then other city employees, and local families eligible for subsidized care. - Surplus Land Declarations & Sale (Items 9 and 10): - Item 9: Adopted findings and approved sale of Parcel 9 (50-foot strip in San Bruno) to the City of San Bruno for $5,000, appraised value. Property is used as a public road and encumbered with BART easements. - Item 10: Adopted findings and approved sale of a 46,097-square-foot remnant of Parcel 21 in South San Francisco for $132,000, facilitating the city’s civic campus and affordable housing projects. HCD confirmed exempt surplus land status. - Item 11 – Program Management Contract: Awarded to HDR Stantec Joint Venture, subject to Board of Supervisors approval (Charter Section 9.118). - Item 12 – Contract Duration Increase (WW-697): Approved 316-day extension with no cost change. - Item 13 – Contract Duration Increase (WW-705): Approved 155-day extension with no cost change. - Item 14 – Meter Diagnostic Services: Awarded to Olea Networks, Inc. - Item 15 – Cross-Connection Control Amendments: Adopted unanimously. - Item 16 – SFUSD Grant: Approved, with Commissioner Arce recused. - Closed Session Action: The commission recommended settlements for items 21, 22, and 23 (unlitigated claims). No action taken on items 24-26 (existing litigation – discussion only). Attorney-client privilege was asserted for all closed session items.

PROCEDURAL 42% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 9% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 6%
560
DEC 9, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Regular Meeting – December 9, 2024

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on December 9, 2024, at 6:15 PM UTC (10:15 AM local) to deliberate nine items. Chaired by Supervisor Shimon Walton, with Vice Chair Ahsha Safai and Member Aaron Peskin, the committee also heard from Supervisor Hillary Ronen. Items included modifications to affordable housing reporting, sunsetting the Mental Health SF Implementation Working Group, a progress hearing on Mental Health SF, consolidation of prevailing wage laws, a proposal to establish an Office of Citywide Food Coordination (tabled), and four mayoral appointments—one approved, three rejected. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (241083): Ordinance amending Administrative Code to replace quarterly 100% affordable housing reports from the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development with semi-annual reporting beginning July 31, 2025. Moved forward with positive recommendation. Passed unanimously (Walton, Safai, Peskin aye). - Item 2 (240984): Ordinance changing the sunset date for the Mental Health SF Implementation Working Group from September 1, 2026, to the effective date of the ordinance. Moved forward as a committee report. Unanimous. Discussion Items - Item 3 (241148): Hearing on the progress, successes, and remaining provisions of Mental Health SF. Dr. Hillary Kunins, Director of Behavioral Health Services, presented key achievements: approximately 400 new residential care and treatment beds, creation of the Office of Coordinated Care (serving over 8,500 distinct individuals in FY23-24), 24/7 citywide Street Crisis Response Team (diverting 97% of eligible behavioral health 911 calls from police), expanded pharmacy and access hours (70 additional service hours per week), and a 32% increase in methadone admissions and 46% increase in buprenorphine prescriptions. Challenges include volatile funding from Proposition C (30-40% below spending plan), data integration limits due to 42 CFR Part 2 confidentiality, and ongoing site acquisition for the Mental Health Service Center. Supervisors Ronen, Safai, Peskin, and Walton praised the progress. The hearing was filed unanimously. - Item 4 (240985): Ordinance moving prevailing wage, apprenticeship, and hours of labor requirements from the Administrative Code to the Labor and Employment Code. The file was duplicated and referred to the Budget and Finance Committee; the original proceeded to the full board with a positive recommendation. Unanimous. - Item 5 (241119): Ordinance establishing the Office of Citywide Food Coordination within the Human Services Agency and dissolving the Food Security Task Force. Public comment was divided; several speakers opposed the fast track and lack of community input, while others supported the office as a needed coordination step. Chair Walton moved to table the item, emphasizing the need for broader community engagement. Motion to table passed unanimously. Appointments - Item 6 (241110): Appointment to the Sheriff’s Department Oversight Board (seat term ending March 1, 2025). Two applicants: Estella Ortiz and Neil Hellenan (unable to attend due to trial). Ortiz, a community advocate with personal and professional experience in reentry and violence prevention, was appointed on a motion by Chair Walton. Unanimous. - Item 7 (241161): Mayoral appointment of Joanna Gubman to the Board of Appeals (term ending July 1, 2028). Public comment was supportive, but the committee voted to reject the nomination, citing the recent mayoral election and preference for the incoming mayor to make appointments. Motion to reject passed unanimously. - Item 8 (241162): Mayoral appointment of Sara Barz to the Municipal Transportation Agency Board of Directors (term ending March 1, 2027). Public comment was supportive, but the committee voted to reject for the same reason. Motion to reject passed unanimously. - Item 9 (241163): Mayoral appointment of James Byrne to the Police Commission (term ending April 30, 2028). Byrne spoke about his focus on the Tenderloin and police deployment. The committee voted to reject unanimously over concerns about timing of the appointment. Key Outcomes - Items 1, 2, and 4 forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Item 3 (hearing) filed. - Item 5 (food coordination) tabled. - Item 6: Estella Ortiz appointed to the Sheriff’s Department Oversight Board. - Items 7, 8, 9: Mayoral nominations rejected by the committee.

PUBLIC COMMENT 29% · MENTAL HEALTH 28% · FOOD ACCESS 13% · PROCEDURAL 11%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com