The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, August 1, 2024, chaired by President Sue Diamond. The meeting included continuances, consent calendar approvals, a farewell to outgoing President Diamond, and three regular calendar items: an expansion of the Central Neighborhoods Large Residence Special Use District (SUD), a proposal to ban laboratory uses in the Urban Mixed Use (UMU) zoning district, and a conditional use authorization for removal of an unauthorized dwelling unit. The meeting lasted approximately three hours and saw public testimony on all major items. Consent Calendar - Items 5–8 were approved unanimously (7-0). These included conditional use authorizations for 901 Bush Street 502, 2300 Polk Street, 737 Irving Street, and the 2024 Code Corrections Ordinance (Planning Code and Building Code amendments). - No public comment requested removal of any item. Public Comments & Testimony - Georgia Schutish (general public comment) presented concerns about alterations that are effectively demolitions (e.g., 7,000–9,700 sq ft homes) lacking proper demolition calculations, and urged tightening of demo calc rules. - Eileen Boken (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods) thanked Commissioner Diamond for her service and welcomed Commissioner McGarry. - Cynthia Gomez (UNITE HERE Local 2) opposed the Bay Hotel (8th Street) operator's attempt to count 56 rooms at $3,200/month as affordable housing, alleging illegal conversion and lack of enforcement. - On Item 14 (Central Neighborhoods SUD expansion): - Ellen Friedman (Cole Valley resident, 35 years) supported the ordinance but opposed the 4,000 sq ft allowance, citing monster home impacts on affordability. She suggested a special fee on homes over 3,000 sq ft. - Mark Jensen (Stanyan Street resident) supported the expansion for preserving neighborhood character. - Gary Peterson (Stanyan Street) supported the SUD expansion, noting the importance of tasteful remodeling. - On Item 15 (Laboratory uses in UMU): - Dozens of speakers, including scientists, biotech executives, and community advocates, urged disapproval of the ban. They cited the need for in-person lab work, job creation (25,000 jobs, $8 billion economic output), and the city's competitive advantage. - Helen Chen (molecular biologist, CEO of Elixia) emphasized innovation and walkability benefits. - Veronica Schauba (senior scientist) highlighted collaboration with UCSF and 24/7 access. - Kathleen Molnar (PhD scientist, 12-year resident) praised the mixed-use vitality of Dog Patch. - Dennis Williams Jr. (community leader) opposed the ban, arguing it would harm equity and job opportunities for District 10. - Mary Ludlam (biotech founder) stressed that labs are long-term, in-person businesses that anchor neighborhoods. - Christy Sherrilla (Biocom California) noted the life science sector supports 25,000 jobs and $8 billion in economic output. - Nicole Kimes (founder, Shulte Therapeutics) highlighted the role of startup biotech in innovation. - No public comment was heard in favor of the ban. Discussion Items Item 14: Central Neighborhoods Large Residence SUD Expansion (Planning Code and Zoning Map Amendments) - Staff (Audrey Merlone) and Supervisor Mandelman's aide (Calvin Ho) presented the ordinance to expand the SUD to include Cole Valley and delete the Corona Heights SUD, applying a 3,000 sq ft hard cap per unit (effective January 1, 2025, per SB 423). Staff recommended approval with three modifications: (1) exclude accessory garage space from gross floor area; (2) allow one unit up to 4,000 sq ft if an additional unit of at least 800 sq ft is added; (3) exclude shared spaces in multi-unit buildings from unit size calculations. - Commissioners debated modification 2. President Diamond, Commissioner Braun, and Commissioner McGarry supported it as an incentive for density. Commissioner Imperial, Vice President Moore, Commissioner Williams, and Commissioner So opposed it, arguing it undermines the spirit of the cap. Commissioner Imperial suggested capping the maximum at 3,000 sq ft instead. - A motion to approve with modifications 1 and 3 only (not 2) passed 4-3 (Commissioners Braun, Williams, Imperial, Moore in favor; McGarry, So, Diamond against). - Commissioner Diamond noted she would have introduced a motion with all three modifications if the first motion failed. Item 15: Laboratory Uses in Urban Mixed Use (UMU) Zoning District (Planning Code Amendments) - Staff (Veronica Flores) presented the ordinance sponsored by Supervisor Walton, which would ban laboratory uses in the UMU district and add
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaOn July 31, 2024, the Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafaya Mandelman and Member Miranda Malgar. Supervisor Asha Safayi also participated as the sponsor of item 2. The committee considered seven agenda items, including financing the acquisition of the Music Concourse Garage, a transfer tax reduction for union-built housing, and acceptance of various grants. All items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Item 1: Authorizing Certificates of Participation for Concourse Garage Acquisition - Presentation by Recreation and Park Department (Antonio Guerra) and Controller's Office (Grant Carson). - The ordinance authorizes up to $29 million in certificates of participation (COPs) to finance the acquisition of the 800-space underground parking garage in Golden Gate Park. - Key details: Outstanding construction debt of $21.6 million to First Republic Bank; $500,000 to repay subordinate debt to de Young Museum and California Academy of Sciences; $1.1 million prior reserve; total sources $30.1 million; estimated true interest cost 4.67%; average annual debt service $1.74 million; projected net revenues $3.2 million per year. - BLA recommended amending the ordinance to specify the $500,000 use for museum loan repayment. - Public comment: None. - Outcome: Committee adopted the amendment and voted 3-0 (Chan, Mandelman, Melgar) to forward to full board with recommendation. (Mandelman and Melgar added as co-sponsors). Item 2: Transfer Tax Reduction for Union Labor-Built and Union Pension Fund-Financed Housing - Ordinance sponsored by Supervisor Safayi to reduce real property transfer tax from 5.5%/6% to 3% for eligible properties: newly constructed (after June 3, 2014) with at least 12% rent-restricted affordable units, built with 100% union labor, and with at least $25 million in union pension fund investment. - Covers transfers on or after effective date through January 1, 2034 (shorter sunset for pre-effective date properties). - BLA noted estimated general fund revenue reduction of up to $5 million per year over 11 years; controller's office estimated high end impact at about $5 million, but likely lower due to screening difficulties. - Public comments: Seven speakers in support, including representatives from Operating Engineers Local 3, Plasters & Cement Masons Local 300, Carpet/Linoleum/Soft Tile Workers Local 12, Painters Local 913, Housing Action Coalition, Laborers District Council, and developers. They emphasized job creation, pension fund investment, and unlocking stalled projects. - Outcome: Committee voted 3-0 to forward to full board with positive recommendation. (Mandelman and Melgar added as co-sponsors). Item 3: Fentanyl Overdose Prevention Grant Acceptance - Retroactive resolution authorizing Department of Public Health to accept $1,281,000 from California Department of Public Health for the Fentanyl Overdose Prevention Grant, March 1, 2024 – February 28, 2027. - Program focuses on advancing racial equity and data-driven responses, including expanded services for Black/African American communities and improved overdose surveillance. - Retroactive approval requested due to administrative delays. - Public comment: None. - Outcome: Committee voted 3-0 to forward to full board (Mandelman added as co-sponsor). Item 4: County Victim Services Program Grant Acceptance - Retroactive resolution authorizing District Attorney's Office to accept $364,146 from California Governor's Office of Emergency Services (Cal OES) for the County Victim Services Program, plus $91,000 in city matching funds, for January 1 – December 31, 2024. - Services include victim compensation, court navigation, and mental health support for homicide survivor families, particularly in high-crime districts. - In 2023, 54 homicides investigated, 162 survivors served. - Public comment: None. - Outcome: Committee voted 3-0 to forward to full board (Mandelman added as co-sponsor). Item 5: Grant Agreement Amendment – Bay Area Community Resources (COVID Response Resource Hub) - Resolution approving second amendment to grant with Bay Area Community Resources, increasing total not-to-exceed amount from $10 million to $14,779,999, extending term through June 30, 2025, and providing $4.78 million in additional funding (including $1.68 million retroactive backfunding for FY 2023-24). - BACR operates four community economic recovery hubs (Mission, Bayview, Excelsior, Visitation Valley) serving 10,000 clients annually. - BLA recommended adding retroactive language. - Public comment: None. - Outcome: Committee adopted retroactive amendment and voted 3-0 to forward to full board. Item 6: India Basin Shoreline Park Redevelopment Grant Acceptance - Resolution authorizing Recreation and Park Department to accept $5.5 million from California State Coastal Conservancy for the third phase of India Basin Waterfront Initiative. - Project includes new public access, pathways, central lawn, boathouse, floating dock, Bay Trail segment, and shoreline habitat restoration. Construction expected January 2025 – January 2027. - Public comment: None. - Outcome: Committee voted 3-0 to forward to full board (Mandelman added as co-sponsor). Item 7: Buchanan Street Mall Project Grant Acceptance (Retroactive) - Resolution retroactively authorizing Recreation and Park Department to accept up to $8,124,800 from National Park Service (via California State Parks) for renovation of three blocks of Buchanan Street Mall. - Project includes lighting, safety, water infrastructure, and beautification; total budget $34.6 million; completion expected June 2026. - Public comment: None. - Outcome: Committee voted 3-0 to forward to full board (Mandelman added as co-sponsor). Key Outcomes - All seven items were approved by the committee (3-0 votes) and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for consideration after the summer recess (scheduled September 3, 2024). - Several items were amended to add retroactive language or specificity as recommended by the Budget and Legislative Analyst. - The meeting was adjourned after completing all business, with the committee noting it was the last meeting before the summer recess.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its last regular meeting before the summer recess on July 30, 2024, at 10:15 AM. With a quorum of 10 supervisors (Supervisor Walton excused), the board adopted a consent agenda, passed several ordinances and resolutions, heard special commendations, and conducted public comment. Key actions included ordering a charter amendment for firefighter retirement to the November ballot, passing a pretrial diversion contract amendment (9-1), and approving various grants and leases. Consent Calendar - Items 1–8 were adopted unanimously as routine, including settlement agreements, a memorandum of understanding with SEIU Local 1021, and building code amendments. Public Comments & Testimony - Several members of the public spoke on a range of issues: Chris Workline raised concerns about public health surveillance credentials; Jim McApee requested a full accounting of Laguna Honda Hospital certification; Leah McGeever spoke against homeless encampment sweeps; Peter Warfield criticized the library's new mission statement; and a speaker urged action on fentanyl in schools and playgrounds. - Honey Mahogany, Director of the Office of Trans Initiatives, spoke in support of the resolution declaring August 2024 as Transgender History Month. Discussion Items - Item 12 (Fire Department Retirement Charter Amendment): Supervisor Stephanie sponsored a charter amendment to lower the maximum service credit retirement age from 58 to 55 for firefighters hired on or after January 7, 2012, citing elevated cancer rates. The board ordered it submitted to the November 5, 2024 election. - Item 14 (Pretrial Diversion Contract Amendment): The board debated a $34,668,237 contract amendment with the San Francisco Pretrial Diversion Project. Supervisor Stephanie expressed concerns about data validity and noncompliance with SB 36. Supervisor Chan noted the Budget and Legislative Analyst recommended approval. The resolution passed 9-1 (Stephanie opposed). - Item 23 (Lease for Twin Peaks Petroleum): Supervisor Melgar presented a 20-year lease for a legacy gas station at 598 Portola Drive, with a requirement to transition to biofuels. Supervisor Preston opposed due to environmental opposition. Passed 9-1 (Preston opposed). - Item 29 (First Responder Student Loan Forgiveness Fund): Supervisor Safai introduced a ballot measure to create a fund for sworn police, fire, sheriff, paramedics, nurses, and dispatchers. After debate, the board voted 6-4 to place it on the November ballot. - Item 35 (Ban on Algorithmic Rent-Setting): Supervisor Peskin introduced an ordinance to prohibit algorithmic devices for setting rents. Passed unanimously. Commendations - The board honored Fire Chief Janine Nicholson (retirement), Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson (new role), Sutro Stewards (Mount Sutro restoration), and Green Cross (20th anniversary). Introductions and Memoriams - Supervisors introduced legislation on renovictions, BMR homeownership program fixes, and downtown master permitting for arts activation. - The board adjourned in memory of Maureen Sullivan, Nathan Perkis, Larry Bush, and Officer Luciano Ortega. Key Outcomes - Charter Amendment for Fire Department Retirement (Item 12): Ordered submitted to November 2024 ballot. - Pretrial Diversion Contract Amendment (Item 14): Approved 9-1. - Twin Peaks Petroleum Lease (Item 23): Approved 9-1. - First Responder Student Loan Forgiveness Fund (Item 29): Placed on November ballot (6-4). - Ban on Algorithmic Rent-Setting (Item 35): Passed unanimously. - Appointments: Amy Campbell and Sean McGarry to Planning Commission, Kavin Williams to Building Inspection Commission, and Raquel Redondiez to Yerba Buena Gardens Conservancy Board. - Resolutions Adopted: Transgender History Month (August 2024), Korean Chuseok Day (September 17, 2024), and others. - Ballot Arguments: Assigned supervisors to write proponent/opponent arguments for November measures. - Grants and Contracts Approved: Included retroactive grants for emergency management, Boys & Girls Clubs, Centers for Equity and Success, Eviction Defense Collaborative, and Positive Resource Center.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 29, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Chair Miranda Melgar presided, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Member Aaron Peskin. The committee considered three items: updating the Infill Opportunity Zone for congestion management, landmarking the Gilbert Baker Rainbow Flag at Harvey Milk Plaza, and banning automated rent-setting software. All items were recommended to the full Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - No items were designated as consent; all three agenda items were heard as regular agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Infill Opportunity Zone): No public speakers. - Item 2 (Rainbow Flag Landmark): Multiple speakers expressed support: - Ralph Hibbs (representing Gilbert Baker Foundation) read a statement noting a petition of over 8,000 signatures and 29 letters from international queer leaders. He emphasized the flag's global recognition as the eighth most recognized symbol. - Andrea Aiello (Executive Director, Castro Community Benefit District) urged landmarking to ensure the flag flies 24/7, stating it is a beacon of hope for visitors worldwide. - Harry Brough (Castro Ambassador) argued the Gilbert Baker flag is the original seed from which all other LGBTQ+ flags derive and should be enshrined. - Terry Aston Bennett (President, Castro Merchants, flag steward) shared that Gilbert Baker requested the flag never fly at half-mast, even upon his death, and that it is a dangerous oversized flag needing full-mast display. - Former Supervisor Jeff Sheehy recounted the 1997 installation as an art project by Gilbert Baker, calling it his only permanent public art installation. - Item 3 (Ban on Automated Rent-Setting): Three speakers supported the ordinance: - Lena Mybaum (Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco, tenant in a Veritas/Brookfield building) cited dramatic rent increases and harassment linked to algorithmic pricing. - Lucas Wiley (Housing Rights Committee intern) argued that even with new corporate landlords, the same algorithmic data drives up rents, undermining tenant protection efforts. - Mitchell Oberg (Affordable Housing Alliance, San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition) stated the practice is price fixing and illegal, urging speedy passage. Discussion Items - Item 1: Resolution Updating Infill Opportunity Zone (IOZ) for Congestion Management (File 240758) - Supervisor Mandelman introduced the item. Chan Ho Chow (Transportation Authority) presented slides. The resolution updates SF's IOZ to align with state law (SB 743), expanding the zone from dark pink to light pink area on the map. This exempts road segments within the IOZ from vehicle level-of-service (LOS) deficiency planning, allowing focus on movement of people and goods. The expansion includes I-80 from Bay Bridge to US 101. Chow noted that the zone is based on half-mile radius from major transit stops with service frequency ≤15 minutes. Chair Melgar asked about excluded areas (e.g., Brotherhood Way, Monterey Boulevard, Slott Boulevard) and was told boundaries depend on transit frequency and regional transportation plan updates. - No public comment. Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation passed unanimously. - Item 2: Ordinance to Landmark Rainbow Flag at Harvey Milk Plaza (File 240725) - Supervisor Mandelman introduced the ordinance, noting the flag was created by Gilbert Baker in 1978 and raised at Harvey Milk Plaza in 1997. He proposed an amendment (page 5, line 9) specifying the flag shall fly at full mast 24/7, consistent with Baker's wishes and past practice. The Historic Preservation Commission recommended approval on May 15, 2024. - Public comment was overwhelmingly in favor. Supervisor Preston added as co-sponsor. - Motion to adopt the amendment and send the amended ordinance to the full board as a committee report passed unanimously. - Item 3: Ordinance Banning Automated Rent-Setting (File 240766) - Supervisor Peskin introduced the ordinance, which prohibits landlords from using algorithmic devices (e.g., RealPage, Yardi) that share non-public competitor data to set rents or occupancy levels. He cited investigations by DOJ, FBI, and multiple state attorneys general. RealPage claims its clients often do not follow recommendations, but Peskin noted the company declined to testify and requested a continuance, which was denied. Lee Hepner (American Economic Liberties Project) presented evidence: RealPage covers 16 million units nationwide (8% of all rentals), and its software has been shown to increase rents 3–7% above market, restrict supply by encouraging vacancy, and raise eviction rates. He displayed a chart showing vacancy and rent rising in parallel after RealPage's adoption, contrary to market logic. - Supervisor Peskin offered two amendments: (1) a non-substantive narrowing of definitions (page 3, lines 16–24) on the original file; (2) a substantive amendment on the duplicated file to expand the private right of action to nonprofit organizations whose primary mission is tenant protection. He also noted Supervisor Chan as co-sponsor. - Public comment supported the ban. - Motion to adopt the non-substantive amendment on the original file passed. Then motion to send the original file as amended to the full board as a committee report passed. Then motion to adopt the substantive amendment on the duplicated file and continue the duplicated file to the call of the chair passed. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (IOZ Update): Passed unanimously to recommend to the full Board of Supervisors. Expected on the Board's agenda September 3, 2024. - Item 2 (Rainbow Flag Landmark): Passed unanimously as amended (full-mast requirement) and sent as a committee report to the full Board, with consideration scheduled for July 30, 2024. - Item 3 (Ban on Automated Rent-Setting): - Original file amended and recommended to the full Board as a committee report (positive recommendation), expected on the Board's agenda September 3, 2024. - Duplicated file amended (expanded private right of action) and continued to the call of the chair. - All motions passed with three ayes: Chair Melgar, Vice Chair Preston, and Member Peskin.
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on July 25, 2024, to discuss several items including updates to the Inclusionary Affordable Housing Program manual, informational presentations on proposed housing developments under SB 423, an office conversion inventory, the Freedom West redevelopment project, and a request to remove a child care center condition. Votes were taken on two items. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: A representative from Save Our Neighborhoods (SAN) expressed concerns about toxic soil contamination at the proposed 3601 Lawton project, urging that public health not be skirted for housing production. - Item 5 – Inclusionary Housing Manual: Over 20 speakers testified, including real estate agents, housing case managers, current BMR renters and homeowners, and community advocates. Key concerns included inadequate language access in lease-up processes (Arabic, Spanish, Tagalog, Filipino), dual agency restrictions for realtors, resale pricing formulas causing hardship for sellers (e.g., a family unable to sell their BMR unit for two years), lack of notification about rental subsidies, credit score and deposit barriers, and criminal history checks. Several speakers noted that while the manual improves some processes, more work is needed to ensure equitable access. - Item 6 – 263 Lee Avenue: One speaker supported the project as much-needed housing. - Item 7 – 1965 Market Street: One speaker supported the project and urged approval. - Item 8 – Office Conversion Inventory: One speaker supported office-to-residential conversions and criticized regulatory processes. - Item 9 – Freedom West: Multiple speakers, including Freedom West Board President Matty Scott, a representative from Bethel AME Church, and a union bartender from Local 2, expressed strong support for the community-driven redevelopment plan, emphasizing the importance of preserving affordable co-op housing and creating good union jobs. - Item 10 – 199 Fremont Street Childcare: One speaker supported the removal of the child care center, noting the burdensome evidence-gathering process required. Discussion Items - Item 5 – Inclusionary Affordable Housing Program Manual Updates: Commissioner Imperial recused. Staff from Planning and MOHCD presented updates to the manual, which governs 18% of San Francisco's affordable housing units (about 6,000 of 33,000 total affordable units). The manual aims to modernize policies, streamline processes, and center equity. Key changes include allowing income eligibility transfer between projects, reducing documentation requirements, adjusting resale pricing formulas for homeownership units, and lower down payment requirements. The Commission discussed language access, enforcement of new requirements, rental subsidies, credit scoring, and criminal history policies. Commissioners expressed satisfaction with responses but requested follow-up on language access solutions and a memo on child care brokerage services. - Item 6 – 263 Lee Avenue (Informational): Project sponsor presented plans for a two-unit, three-bedroom residential building on a church site. The project is using SB 423 streamlined approval. Staff explained the concurrent tribal consultation process. Commissioners asked about the process and timeline for ministerial approval. No action taken. - Item 7 – 1965 Market Street (Informational): Project sponsor presented a 200-unit building on a transit corridor, with 28 affordable units (14% of total). The design includes a historic building rehabilitation and a new tower set back 12 feet. Commissioners praised the location and design. No action taken. - Item 8 – Draft Office Conversion and Demolition Inventory (Informational): Staff presented the draft inventory under Proposition C, which adds back converted/demolished office square footage to the office allocation cap. The inventory includes 29 sites totaling over 2.5 million square feet. Public comment period open until August 19, 2024. Commissioners asked about the 1986 start date and conversion uses. No action taken. - Item 9 – Freedom West (Informational): Staff and project sponsors presented a master plan to redevelop the 382-unit limited equity co-op into up to 2,400 units, including replacement units, a senior affordable housing building (115 units), retail, a hotel, a performing arts center, and a STEM innovation center. The project is guided by four principles: keep co-op intact, replace all units without raising housing costs, create long-term economic self-sustainability, and involve residents in design. Commissioners commended the community engagement, economic sustainability model (including co-op ownership of retail and profit-sharing), and the plan to restitch Octavia Street as a pedestrian-friendly corridor. No action taken. - Item 10 – 199 Fremont Street / 342 Howard Street – Childcare Condition Removal: Staff recommended approval to rescind a condition requiring on-site childcare, as the facility operated for 21 years and closed in 2021. The project sponsor marketed the space for eight months with no interest. The Department of Early Childhood supported removal. Commissioners noted the shift in childcare demand from downtown to residential areas and supported the potential for a new retail use. A motion to approve with conditions was made and seconded. Key Outcomes - Item 5 – Inclusionary Housing Manual: Motion to adopt the amended manual passed 5-0 (Commissioner Imperial recused). Commissioners requested staff to explore technology solutions for language access and to provide a memo on how the child care brokerage requirement (Section 165) will be fulfilled. - Item 10 – Childcare Condition Removal: Motion to approve the rescission of Condition 2H with conditions passed 5-0. Conditions include requiring the project sponsor to continue providing child care brokerage services and staff to report back to the commission on how that requirement will be implemented. - All other items were informational only; no votes were taken.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, July 25, 2024, at 11:15 AM Pacific Time (18:15 UTC) to consider two applications for Type 90 on-sale general music venue liquor licenses. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stephanie, with Supervisor Dorsey present. Vice Chair Engardiel and Supervisor Joel were excused. Both items were approved unanimously and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Discussion Items - Item 1: Liquor License Issuance – 65 Post Street (Seven Social, formerly The Record Bar) - Applicant: SR Visions LLC, doing business as Seven Social (previously The Record Bar at 177 Eddy Street). - Location: 65 Post Street, in census tract 117 (high concentration area) and police plot 500E (low crime area). - Zero letters of protest or support. - The Alcohol Beverage Control (ABC) recommended approval with four conditions: (1) no noise audible beyond the licensed premises; (2) active monitoring to prevent loitering on adjacent properties; (3) maintain litter-free area; (4) employ two uniformed security guards (licensed by the State of California Department of Consumer Affairs) when providing live entertainment. - Mark Rennie, representing the applicant, stated the location is a beautiful space with no nearby residences and noted the owner’s 20+ years of successful bar operation with minimal complaints. - Supervisor Dorsey expressed support, praising the activation of downtown space and referencing the city’s comeback. - Chair Stephanie noted President Peskin (District 3) had no objections. - Motion: Direct the clerk to prepare a resolution finding that issuance serves public convenience or necessity. Passed 2-0 (Dorsey aye, Stephanie aye; Engardiel and Joel excused). - Item 2: Liquor License Issuance – 2801 Leavenworth Street (Reverb) - Applicant: Talldoor Entertainment LLC, doing business as Reverb. - Location: 2801 Leavenworth Street (corner of Bay and Leavenworth, inside the old Cannery complex), in census tract 102.02 (high concentration area) and police plot 100 (high crime area). - Zero letters of protest or support. - ABC recommended approval with three conditions (identical to item 1 conditions 1, 2, and 3; condition 4 requiring security guards was omitted). - Mark Rennie introduced co-owner Eric Villa Lobos, noting the venue can hold about 400 people, is zoned commercial (C3-C2), with the nearest residence 150 yards away. The applicant runs a successful promotion company (Talldoor Entertainment) and plans to host electronic dance music events. - Supervisor Dorsey again expressed appreciation for activating the space and supporting San Francisco’s comeback. - Chair Stephanie confirmed President Peskin had no issues. - Motion: Direct the clerk to prepare a resolution finding that issuance serves public convenience or necessity. Passed 2-0 (same vote). Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke on either item. Key Outcomes - Both liquor license applications (Seven Social at 65 Post Street and Reverb at 2801 Leavenworth Street) were recommended for approval by the committee. The committee voted unanimously (2-0) to forward each resolution to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The board is expected to consider these items on September 3, 2024, unless otherwise stated. Adjournment - The meeting adjourned after completing both agenda items.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 24, 2024, beginning at approximately 9:00 AM local time. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, joined by Supervisor Myrna Melgar (substituting for Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman) and Supervisor Matt Dorsey. The committee considered 16 agenda items, including real property leases, fee waivers, grant agreements, contract amendments, and bond documents. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 - Twin Peaks Petroleum Lease: Walter Kaplan (Forest Knolls neighborhood) spoke in support, emphasizing the gas station's role as a legacy business and community asset. Richard Carillo (Office of Small Business) confirmed the business is an official legacy business. - Item 3 - Flower Market Permit Transfer: Andrew Poulos, the prospective permittee, supported the transfer, highlighting the iconic nature and beautification. - General: A recurring speaker offered tangential comments on education, safety, and criticism of the mayor. One speaker raised concerns about SFGov TV censorship. - Other items had few or no public speakers; public comment on most items was minimal. Discussion Items 1. Item 1 - Real Property Lease - Twin Peaks Petroleum (598 Portola Drive): Resolution approving a 20-year lease with Twin Peaks Petroleum at an initial annual base rent of approximately $156,600. Supervisor Melgar noted the site is unsuitable for affordable housing after city assessment, and the lease requires the tenant to sell alternative fuels. The committee forwarded it unanimously. 2. Item 2 - Transportation Code - Fee Waivers for Neighborhood Outdoor Events: Ordinance waiving street closure fees for community events. Supervisor Chan proposed amendments adding a sunset date (June 30, 2027) and clarifying language. The Budget Legislative Analyst (BLA) estimated a total revenue loss of about $2.2 million. The committee adopted the amendments and forwarded the ordinance. 3. Item 3 - Assignment of Market Street Flower Market Permit: Resolution approving transfer of a sidewalk flower stand permit from Byron Yoendez to Andrew Poulos. Supervisor Dorsey spoke in support; committee forwarded. 4. Item 4 - Contract Amendment - San Francisco Pretrial Diversion Project: Resolution increasing the contract by $14.9 million to a total not to exceed approximately $34.7 million, extending through June 2026. The Sheriff's Office and Pretrial Diversion presented performance data: 79% court appearance rate and high safety rates. BLA noted improved monitoring. Forwarded. 5. Item 5 - Grant Agreement - Eviction Defense Collaborative: Resolution approving $11,062,913 for housing subsidies to seniors and adults with disabilities. BLA recommended adding retroactive language; committee approved the amendment and forwarded. 6. Item 6 - Real Property Lease Amendment - Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy (Pier 31 & 33): Resolution amending a lease to build a cafe and retail space. The Port discussed COVID-related delays, forgiving $50,000 in back rent and increasing rent credits to $800,000. BLA noted the Conservancy has $30 million unrestricted cash, making the $300,000 benefit a policy matter. Committee forwarded. 7. Item 7 - FEMA Hazard Mitigation Grant: Resolution to accept $189,558 for a concrete building safety program financing guidance document. The Office of Resilience presented. Forwarded. 8. Item 8 - Contract Amendments - Natural Resources Specialized and Technical Services: Resolution increasing three PUC contracts by $7 million each to $21 million, extending through 2029. BLA recommended performance monitoring improvements. Forwarded. 9. Item 9 - CARESTAR Foundation Grant: Resolution to accept $125,000 for community paramedicine programs. DEM noted San Francisco is the only approved program in California. Forwarded. 10. Item 10 - Emergency Management Performance Grant: Resolution to accept $350,321 retroactively for emergency preparedness. DEM explained delay due to staff transition. Forwarded. 11. Item 11 - In-Kind Gift - San Francisco Public Health Foundation: Resolution to accept $57,264 in dental supplies for school screenings. Retroactive due to MOU delays. Forwarded. 12. Item 12 - Contract Amendment - Positive Resource Center: Resolution increasing contract to $15.4 million for emergency financial services to people with HIV. BLA found performance satisfactory. Forwarded. 13. Item 13 - Grant Agreement - Boys & Girls Clubs of San Francisco: Resolution approving $30.2 million for after-school and year-round programs. BLA noted low attendance at Malcolm X Academy due to chronic absenteeism; DCYF Director Maria Sue discussed partnership with school district to address systemic issues. Forwarded. 14. Item 14 - Grant Agreement - Centers for Equity and Success: Resolution approving $10.8 million for youth justice programs. BLA found performance satisfactory. Forwarded. 15. Item 15 - Loan Agreement - MEDA Small Properties (2901 16th Street): Resolution approving $30 million loan under Small Sites Program for acquisition and rehab of 63 units (20 for formerly homeless). Supervisor Melgar expressed support. Forwarded. 16. Item 16 - Multifamily Housing Revenue Bonds - SFHA Scattered Sites: Resolution approving bond amendment to return $1.8 million in unused rent reserves to MOHCD. Technical change. Forwarded. Key Outcomes - All 16 items were approved by the committee and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Votes were unanimous (3-0) on each item. - Amendments approved: - Item 2: Added sunset date of June 30, 2027, and clarified inclusion of Sunset District streets. - Item 5: Added retroactive language to reflect start date of July 1, 2024. - Item 15: Supervisor Melgar added as co-sponsor. - Several items were approved retroactively (Items 7, 9, 10, 11) due to administrative delays. - The committee emphasized performance monitoring for contracts, particularly for the Sheriff's pretrial contract and PUC natural resources contracts.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a special meeting on Tuesday, July 23, 2024, at 5:30 PM UTC, to consider a charter amendment proposing a new Deferred Retirement Option Program (DROP) for sworn police officers and modifications to staffing reporting requirements. After extensive debate and public comment, the board voted 8-3 to continue the item as a committee report to the regular Board of Supervisors meeting later that same day. Public Comments & Testimony - Rebecca Jackson (VP of Re-entry, Community Ford; co-chair of women's housing coalition) opposed the measure, citing recent budget cuts to essential services and layoffs at community organizations while the city considers doubling police salaries. - Leslie Who (social worker and educator, SFUSD) opposed, noting 146 unfilled teacher positions, her own low pension, and the contrast with the high pay proposed for police. - Efraim Barrera (Director, Latinal Task Force) opposed, calling the DROP a costly and ineffective retention bonus that would harm funding for violence prevention programs. - Liam McGeever (District 5 resident) opposed, arguing that policing is a failed institution and that funds should go to supporting vulnerable populations like transgender people. - Joel Haila (Director, Criminal Justice Program, ACLU of Northern California) opposed, stating the amendment does not solve the staffing crisis, adds to the deficit, and rewards officers with 25+ years while the highest attrition is at 6 years of service. - Zach Dillon (Public Defender's Office) opposed, noting the lack of data before spending money and that DROP does not curb overtime. - Renee Garcia (student, District 10) opposed, citing the 2008-2011 DROP failure that cost $52 million and urging investment in housing and mental health services. - Maina Young (40-year resident, District 1) commented on police response times and road closures. - Richard Correa (retired SFPD commander) supported the DROP, stating it is well-crafted and will slow retirements to allow time for recruitment. Discussion Items - Charter Amendment – Police Staffing and Voluntary Deferred Retirement Option Program (Item 1) - Supervisor Ronin presented a detailed PowerPoint opposing the DROP. She highlighted that SFPD recruitment is improving (since June 2022 the board has approved approximately $270 million in investments including a $166 million MOU with the POA), that officers with 25 years already receive a 20% retention premium, and that the average officer leaving has 6.3 years of service—not 25. She cited the failed 2008 DROP which cost the city at least $52 million and provided data showing officers could earn over $200,000 extra annually through DROP. She urged colleagues to remove their names from the ballot measure. - Supervisor Dorsey (author) argued that SFPD faces an unprecedented staffing crisis: from 2,182 needed full-duty officers (per Prop E), the number dropped to 1,583 in May 2024, with only 769 on patrol. He noted that separations have outpaced hires for four consecutive years, and projected 322 more retirements over five years. He emphasized the DROP is narrowly tailored: limited to sergeants and below engaged in frontline policing, a five-year term, with reforms to prevent abuse (e.g., pausing payments during long-term leave). He stated the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) estimates the program could postpone 50 retirements in 2025, and the Controller estimated a cost of $0–$3 million per year. - Supervisor Preston questioned the lack of data on why officers leave and criticized the board for approving hundreds of millions for police without evidence. He asked whether the measure could be amended to also cover teachers, 911 dispatchers, and Muni drivers. Supervisor Dorsey declined amendments. - Supervisor Safai supported the DROP, noting the BLA projection of up to 130 deferred retirements over three years, which would buy time while recruitment academies produce fewer graduates (e.g., last class below 15). - Supervisor Walton opposed, stating the DROP is fiscally irresponsible in a budget deficit year and does little to improve recruitment among younger people. - Controller Greg Wagner explained the cost analysis: a high-cost scenario of $19 million in additional unfunded liability amortized over five years, leading to $3 million per year; a low-cost scenario of $5.4 million total ($0.6 million per year). He noted that previous DROP cost estimates assumed backfilling would stop, but this analysis assumed continued hiring. Key Outcomes - Motion to continue the item as a committee report to the July 23 regular Board of Supervisors meeting passed 8-3. Voting aye: Supervisors Chan, Dorsey, Engardio, Mandelman, Melgar, Peskin, Safai, Stephanie. Voting no: Supervisors Preston, Ronan, Walton. - The charter amendment will be considered by the full board at the 2:00 PM meeting later that day, with the board's action likely to place it on the November 2024 ballot.
The Board of Supervisors held a special meeting on July 23, 2024, to consider a motion to call from the Rules Committee a proposed charter amendment (File No. 240544) related to police staffing and a voluntary deferred retirement option program, and to modify the submission timeline under Board Rule 2.22.7. The meeting included debate on the committee process, public testimony, and two votes on the motion. Public Comments & Testimony - A member of the public spoke in strong opposition to the charter amendment, characterizing it as a "ripoff by the cops" and claiming that officers and sergeants would receive approximately $300,000 per year for five years. The speaker accused the board of prioritizing police interests over public welfare and urged voters to reject the measure if placed on the ballot. - Leah McGeeber (District 6 resident) criticized the board for focusing on police funding instead of addressing high maternal mortality rates among Black women and the cancellation of a monthly stipend program for homeless transgender individuals. She argued the board was driven by fear of losing power and had failed to defend data-backed social programs against conservative opposition. Discussion Items - Motion to Call from Committee: The sole item was a motion to call the charter amendment from the Rules Committee and adjust the submission deadline. Supervisor Ronin, who had resigned as Rules Committee chair, explained her opposition, stating that after in-depth review with the Controller’s Office, Retirement, and Human Resources, she concluded the proposal was a mistaken policy that would be unpopular. She argued the committee structure is vital for thorough review and that the maneuver bypassed proper process. President Peskin countered that there is a long pattern of bringing ballot measures to the full board for deliberation, even after committee amendments. Supervisor Chan supported the motion, citing Board Rule provisions and noting that chairs could have tabled the item to prevent this situation. Supervisor Preston opposed the motion, thanking Supervisor Ronin for her committee work. - City Attorney Inquiry: Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson confirmed that a previous tabling of the item might have made it harder to bring back, but she could not be certain. Supervisor Ronin maintained that the rules were being circumvented. - Rescission and Second Vote: After public comment, Supervisor Mandelman moved to rescind the earlier vote, seconded by Supervisor Stephanie. Without objection, the previous vote was rescinded, and the board proceeded to a second roll-call vote on the same motion. Key Outcomes - The motion to call the charter amendment from committee and modify the submission time was approved on two separate votes, each with a tally of 7 ayes and 2 noes. Supervisors Preston and Ronin voted against; Supervisors Chan, Dorsey, Engardio, Mandelman, Peskin, Safai, and Stephanie voted in favor. (Supervisors Melgar and Walton were excused.) - As a result, the charter amendment (File No. 240544) was called from the Rules Committee and considered later that morning during a subsequent special session at 9:05 a.m., where the board would deliberate on the amendment itself.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, July 23, 2024, starting at 10:15 AM. The meeting included a consent agenda, unfinished business items (Stonestown development, city budget, charter amendments), special orders (commendations and a public hearing on a $390 million general obligation bond), committee reports, new business introductions, public comment, and adoption of resolutions without committee reference. Key votes included approval of the Stonestown project (10-0 after recusal), the two‑year budget (10-1), several charter amendments for the November 2024 ballot, and the health service system plan (passed on first reading). Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 7 were approved unanimously as routine. These included amendments to health, business, and tax regulations codes, grant agreements, hotel operator agreements, workforce housing revenue bonds, park acceptance, and a requirement for pharmacies to stock buprenorphine. Public Comments & Testimony - Great Highway: One speaker opposed converting a section of the Great Highway into a park, stating the road has been there forever and that Golden Gate Park is nearby. - Free City College (Item 61): Multiple speakers (students, a former student trustee, a faculty member, and a CCSF trustee) urged the Board to support the resolution urging the Department of Children, Youth, and Their Families to negotiate an updated MOU for the Free City College program. They emphasized the program’s role in removing financial barriers and supporting first‑generation and low‑income students. One speaker noted that Free City helped her earn a degree as a disabled Latinx student. - Subway Worker Exploitation (Item 62): Several members of Trabajadores Unidos spoke in support of the resolution supporting workers at Subway franchises. They reported that workers were paid $13/hour (below the $20/hour fast‑food minimum wage), experienced wage theft, and faced unsafe conditions. One speaker read a testimony from a Nepali worker who described unpaid wages and poor conditions. - Other: A speaker raised concerns about alleged online harassment and questioned the cancellation of certain city commission meetings. A former teacher supported Free City College. A speaker commented on an algorithmic transparency issue not on the agenda. Discussion Items - Item 8 – Cova Hotel Agreement Amendment: Ordinance to increase the agreement with Shin International Inc. for the Cova Hotel (homeless shelter) by $1.7 million to a total of $16 million, extending the term through March 31, 2025. Passed 10-1 (Supervisor Mandelman voted no). - Items 9-12 – Stonestown Development Project: Four ordinances approving a development agreement, an enhanced infrastructure financing district, general plan amendments, and zoning map changes for a 30‑acre mixed‑use project with affordable and market‑rate housing and six acres of open space. Supervisor Engardio recused himself. Passed 10-0. - Items 13-26 – City Budget (FYs 2024-2026): A package of 14 ordinances appropriating funds, setting salaries, adjusting fees, and reallocating approximately $13.7 million from the Our City, Our Home Fund for homelessness services. Passed 10-1 (Supervisor Preston voted no). Item 24 (homelessness fund reallocation) passed on first reading. - Item 27 – Charter Amendment: Our Children Our Families Initiative: Submitted to the electorate unanimously (11-0) to create a coordinated outcomes‑based service delivery for children, youth, and families. - Item 28 – Charter Amendment: Commission Reform: Established a task force to recommend streamlining city commissions. Passed 7-4 (Supervisors Stephanie, Dorsey, Engardio, and Melgar voted no). - Item 29 – Charter Amendment: Inspector General: Created an Inspector General in the Controller’s Office with subpoena and search warrant powers. Passed 11-0. - Item 30 – Charter Amendment: Affordable Housing Opportunity Fund: Required the city to appropriate at least $8.25 million annually starting FY 2026-27 for rental subsidies for extremely low‑income seniors, families, and people with disabilities. Passed unanimously (11-0). - Item 31 – Charter Amendment: Nurse Retirement Credit and Public Safety Communications Retirement: Allowed per diem nurses to buy back up to three years of service credit and moved public safety communications personnel to a safety retirement plan. Passed unanimously. - Item 32 – Gross Receipts Tax Rate Reduction for Hotels (NAICS 721): Lowered tax rates for accommodation businesses. Passed 9-0 (two absences). - Item 33 – Health Service System Plans and Contribution Rates for CY 2025: Approved after extended discussion about the change from UnitedHealthcare to Blue Shield of California. Director Yant explained that Blue Shield’s bid was significantly lower (a difference of about $43-67 million over three years) and that provider networks are nearly identical (less than 2% difference). The Health Service Board initially rejected the RFP result, but after board composition changes, approved it 3-2. Passed on first reading (unanimous on roll call). - Items 49-50 – Special Order 3:00 PM: General Obligation Bond Hearing: Public hearing and final passage of a $390 million bond for health, safety, and vibrancy projects, including up to $50 million for shelters and interim housing (including tiny homes permanently affixed). Supervisor Safai clarified that sleeping cabins qualify as real property. Passed on final reading. - Items 35-48 – Various Leases, Agreements, Permits, and Licenses: All approved unanimously on same‑house‑same‑call votes (details in agenda). - Item 51 – Charter Amendment: Police Staffing and Deferred Retirement Option Program (DROP): Defined full‑duty sworn officer, modified staffing report frequency, and created a voluntary DROP for officers, sergeants, and inspectors. Passed 8-3 (Supervisors Preston, Ronan, and Walton voted no). - Item 52 – MOU Amendment with SEIU Local 1021 (Nurses): Addressed staffing and hiring of registered and public health nurses. Passed 11-0. - Items 53-54 – Building Code Amendments: Extended deadlines for disability access improvements and exempted vacant storefronts due to public infrastructure construction from registration requirements. Both passed on first reading. - Item 55 – Charter Amendment: Fire Department Service Retirement Pension: Continued one week to July 30, 2024. - Items 56-57 – Appointments: Approved reappointment of Jose Lopez to the Board of Appeals and appointment of Pamela Troy to the Ballot Simplification Committee. - New Business / Introductions: - Supervisor Ronan introduced a resolution for National Health Center Week (August 4-10) recognizing the Community Clinic Consortium. - Supervisor Engardio introduced a request for a ballot measure on the future of the Upper Great Highway (park vs. road) and called for a planning process to address traffic concerns. Supervisor Melgar co‑sponsored and supported the measure. - Supervisor Mandelman introduced a resolution recognizing July 2024 as Disability Pride Month. - Items 60-62 – Adoption Without Committee Reference: - Item 60: Resolution declaring August 2024 as Afghan American Heritage Month – adopted unanimously. - Item 61: Resolution urging DCYF to negotiate an updated MOU for the Free City College program – adopted unanimously. - Item 62: Resolution supporting workers exploited at Subway franchises – adopted unanimously. Key Outcomes - Votes and Decisions: - Stonestown development: passed 10-0. - Two‑year budget: passed 10-1 (Preston no). - Charter amendments submitted to voters (Nov. 2024): Inspector General (11-0), Commission Reform (7-4), Children & Families (11-0), Affordable Housing Fund (11-0), Nurse/Public Safety Retirement (11-0), Police DROP (8-3). Fire pension charter amendment continued one week. - Health Service System plan: approved on first reading after debate. - General obligation bond ($390M): finally passed. - All other routine items and resolutions adopted unanimously. - Referrals and Next Steps: - The Free City College resolution urges an updated MOU; no binding action. - The Subway worker resolution expresses support but does not mandate action. - Supervisor Engardio’s request for a Great Highway ballot measure and planning process will be further considered. - Commendations: Recognized probation services (especially Victor Williams), Fire Station 19, community volunteer Shelley Constantini, and the Transgender District’s Entrepreneurship Accelerator graduates.