Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 651–660 ENTRIES
651
JUL 22, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Regular Meeting - July 22, 2024

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 22, 2024, to consider several items including a charter amendment for firefighter pensions, an initiative ordinance for first responder student loan forgiveness, and multiple appointments to city commissions and councils. The committee voted on most items, with one nomination continued for further community engagement. Charter Amendment: Fire Department Service Retirement Pension (Item 1) - The committee considered a charter amendment to lower the age at which firefighters hired after January 7, 2012, reach the highest age factor for pension from 58 to 55. - Public Comment: One speaker opposed the amendment, arguing it burdens vulnerable populations. Floyd Rollins, president of San Francisco Firefighters Local 798, expressed strong support, citing cancer as the number one killer of firefighters. - Discussion: Chair Safai noted the updated controller report showing a first-year fiscal impact of $3.7 million, down from over $10 million. He emphasized long-term savings from reduced cancer claims. Supervisor Peskin supported the compromise. - Key Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to send the charter amendment to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Initiative Ordinance: First Responder Student Loan Forgiveness Fund (Item 2) - Supervisor Safai introduced an ordinance to create a fund for student loan forgiveness and job-related education expenses for first responders, including police, fire, sheriff, paramedics, nurses, and 911 dispatchers. The goal is a $25 million fund forgiving up to $25,000 per employee. - Discussion: Supervisor Peskin opposed putting the ordinance on the ballot, arguing it could be passed by the Board of Supervisors directly. Supervisor Walton supported it, citing federal student loan forgiveness examples. - Key Outcome: The committee voted 2-1 (Walton and Safai aye, Peskin no) to send the initiative ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Appointment: Ballot Simplification Committee (Item 3) - Pamela Troy was appointed to Seat 1 for a term ending November 30, 2024. The committee voted unanimously to send the appointment to the full board. Appointments: Reentry Council (Items 4) - Five of 18 applicants were appointed: Billy Hong Lee (Seat 1), Anthony Parti (Seat 2), Joanna Polito (Seat 3), Lorenzo Castaneda (Seat 4), and David Maroff (Seat 6). The committee emphasized preference for San Francisco residents. Vote was unanimous. Reappointment: Board of Appeals - Jose Lopez (Item 5) - The committee unanimously approved the reappointment of Jose Lopez for a four-year term, removing language rejecting the nomination. Reappointment: Building Inspection Commission - Kevin Williams (Item 6) - The committee unanimously approved the reappointment of Kevin Williams for a two-year term, removing language rejecting the nomination. Appointment: Planning Commission - Sean McGarry (Item 7) - Sean McGarry, a 30-year construction professional and union representative, was nominated. Public comment in support from labor representatives. Committee discussed his approach to housing element, transit corridors, and community engagement. Vote was unanimous to send to full board. Appointment: Planning Commission - Amy Campbell (Item 8) - Amy Campbell was unable to attend due to a pre-planned vacation. Her written statement was read. Committee approved sending her nomination to the full board with a positive recommendation, despite her absence. Vote was unanimous. Appointment: Municipal Transportation Agency Board of Directors - Mike Chen (Item 9) - Mike Chen, a 10-year resident and former chair of the SFMTA Citizens Advisory Council, was nominated. Extensive discussion on community outreach, especially in Chinatown, and concerns about the agency's engagement. Supervisor Peskin requested a continuance to allow Chen to meet with Chinatown Trip and other transit advocates. - Key Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the call of the chair. Key Outcomes - The committee forwarded most items to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, except the MTA appointment which was continued. - All votes were unanimous except for the first responder loan forgiveness ordinance (2-1). - The committee emphasized the importance of community engagement, cultural competency, and representation in appointments.

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 22% · CORRECTIONS AND REENTRY 18% · PROCEDURAL 13% · PLANNING COMMISSION 10%
652
JUL 22, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - July 22, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, July 22, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Chair Marina Melgar presided, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Member Aaron Peskin. The committee considered two ordinances: one amending the Building Code to exempt storefronts vacant due to public infrastructure construction from registration requirements, and another extending deadlines for disability access improvements. Both items were approved as committee reports for the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony - One member of the public spoke on agenda item number two (disability access deadlines), offering a brief, non-substantive comment about the term "disability" and stating, "Have a nice day, guys." No other public comments were received. Discussion Items - Item 1: Building Code - Vacant Storefronts and Infrastructure Construction (File 240499) – Sponsored by Supervisor Connie Chan (District 1), this ordinance adds a third exemption to the vacant storefront registration requirements. The exemption applies when a storefront is vacant due to a public infrastructure construction or maintenance project that impacts access for more than 30 days. Storefront owners or leaseholders may submit evidence to the Department of Public Works (DPW) to qualify for a 180-day exemption from registration. Supervisor Chan stated the legislation addresses disproportionate impacts on small businesses from major city construction, citing constituent experiences. The committee adopted amendments proposed by the sponsor and voted to send the ordinance as amended to the full Board. - Item 2: Building Code - Deadlines for Disability Access Improvements (File 240297) – Sponsored by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman (District 8), this ordinance further extends the compliance deadlines for existing buildings with places of public accommodation to make primary entries and paths of travel accessible to persons with disabilities. Supervisor Mandelman noted this extension runs through the end of 2024, continuing efforts with the Department of Building Inspection and other agencies to develop a longer-term fix. The committee voted to recommend the ordinance to the full Board. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Vacant Storefronts): The committee approved amendments and recommended the ordinance as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors on a unanimous vote (3-0: Preston aye, Peskin aye, Melgar aye). The item is expected to appear on the Board agenda for July 23, 2024. - Item 2 (Disability Access Deadlines): The committee recommended the ordinance as a committee report to the full Board on a unanimous vote (3-0: Preston aye, Peskin aye, Melgar aye). The item is expected to appear on the Board agenda for July 30, 2024. Both items were considered under the 30-day rule and received positive recommendations without opposition.

PROCEDURAL 57% · LAND USE 26% · DISABILITY RIGHTS 17%
653
JUL 18, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - July 18, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on Thursday, July 18, 2024, with President Diamond presiding. The meeting included continuances, consent calendar approval, commissioner matters, department matters, and three regular calendar items. All votes were unanimous, with Commissioner Williams recusing herself for the third item. The commission approved a special sign district, a union headquarters, and a residential legalization, while also forwarding comments to the Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - Items 1a and 1b, for properties at 3901 Noriega Street and the southwest corner of 46th Avenue, were continued to August 1, 2024, by a 5-0 vote. - Consent calendar items 2-9 were approved unanimously 5-0, including large project authorizations, conditional use authorizations, and a code amendment update for 2222 Broadway Street. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: A speaker (name not given) addressed the commission regarding the 363 Jersey Street case, criticizing enforcement of approved permits and highlighting a pattern of alterations not matching approvals. The speaker urged the commission to adjust demolition controls, codify flat policies, improve front-end enforcement, and reduce interior wall removal allowances. The speaker also mentioned SB 423 and the need to close loopholes. - Item 15 (555 9th Street): No public comments were made. - Item 16 (3433 3rd Street): Union members present stood in support of the project. Albert Sannibal, a long-time Local 22 member, spoke about the union's lack of a permanent hall and requested approval. - Item 17 (3756 22nd Street): No public comments were made. Discussion Items - Item 15: Establishing the 555 9th Street Special Sign District – An ordinance sponsored by Supervisor Dorsey would create a special sign district for the shopping center at 555 9th Street, allowing signs similar to those in C3 districts, with exceptions for additional wall signs and video signs at pedestrian entrances (subject to size, height, and content restrictions). Staff recommended approval. Commissioner Moore expressed concerns about the shopping center's pedestrian engagement and asked for broader context discussions. Commissioner Braun noted the balance between automobile-oriented signage and pedestrian improvements. Commissioner Sew proposed a condition that illuminated signs turn off when businesses close, but the project sponsor could not commit immediately. The commission approved a motion (6-0) to adopt a recommendation for approval, with comments conveyed to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 16: 3433 3rd Street – Carpenters Local 22 Headquarters – A conditional use authorization for a planned unit development: a two-story office building (8,800 sq ft office, 7,400 sq ft assembly hall, totaling 16,200 sq ft) with 30 parking spaces and bike parking. The project involves a modification to front setback and landscaping requirements due to the corner site's acute angle (58 degrees) and sea level rise considerations. Staff received six support letters and noted corrections to conditions. Commissioner Williams recused herself due to a conflict as a union member. The project was approved unanimously 5-0. - Item 17: 3756 22nd Street – Legalization of Excess Excavation – A conditional use authorization to legalize excess excavation from 2017, increasing gross floor area from 3,405 to 3,965 square feet, including an elevator, den, media room, and bathroom. The work was discovered in 2023 via a DBI audit linked to corrupt former employees. The current owners (Kim and Paul Albright) purchased the property in 2022 and were unaware of the violation. The project sponsor and attorney argued for approval, noting the owners' clean hands and the fairness issue. Commission discussion highlighted the need for a legislative solution to protect innocent buyers. The project was approved unanimously 6-0. Key Outcomes - Items 1a and 1b continued to August 1, 2024 (5-0). - Consent calendar items 2-9 approved (5-0). - Minutes for June 13 and June 20, 2024, adopted (5-0). - Recommendation for approval of the 555 9th Street Special Sign District adopted (6-0), with comments to be sent to the Board of Supervisors. - Conditional use authorization for 3433 3rd Street approved (5-0, with Commissioner Williams recused). - Conditional use authorization for 3756 22nd Street approved (6-0). - The commission emphasized the need for a legislative fix for innocent owners affected by enforcement cases stemming from corrupt former DBI employees.

PUBLIC COMMENT 27% · LAND USE 17% · PLANNING COMMISSION 12% · URBAN DESIGN 9%
654
JUL 18, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Hearing – July 18, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 18, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Supervisor Connie Chan and Supervisor Joel Engardio (appointed to the committee during the meeting). The committee considered two main items: an amendment to a Memorandum of Understanding with SEIU Local 1021 regarding registered nurses and public health nurses, and a hearing on the San Francisco Housing Authority’s Faircloth to RAD plan. The committee also held a closed session to discuss litigation settlements and approved forwarding those items to the full board. Discussion Items - Item 1 – MOU Amendment (SEIU Local 1021 – Staff and Per Diem Nurses): Jonathan Wright from the Department of Human Resources presented the first amendment to the 2024-2027 MOU. The amendment addressed a last-minute adjustment to a staffing position in a side letter, with no additional financial impact. The committee voted to forward the item to the full board with a positive recommendation as a committee report. - Item 2 – Hearing on San Francisco Housing Authority’s Faircloth to RAD Plan: Chair Preston opened the hearing with remarks on the background of the program, noting that public housing residents, tenant organizers, and the National Housing Law Project had pushed for two years to utilize the Faircloth to RAD program. Dr. Tanya Ledajou, CEO of the San Francisco Housing Authority (SFHA), and Daniel Adams, Director of the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD), presented the plan. They explained that the program allows housing authorities to use their Faircloth Authority (the gap between current public housing units and the federal cap) to produce new public housing and convert it to RAD units with 20-year renewable operating subsidies. The baseline RAD rents are low (about 35% of Area Median Income), but a rent augmentation pilot program (expiring September 30, 2024) can increase subsidies to 110% of Fair Market Rent. The city plans to submit placeholder applications for the full 3,667 units of Faircloth Authority by the deadline to reserve the rent augmentation option. An initial cohort of 750 units (new construction and preservation) has been identified, with a kickoff meeting with developers scheduled for the following week. Challenges include the complexity of the application process, the need for local Housing Authority reserves to fund the augmentation, and the uncertainty of the pilot’s extension. The committee discussed the timeline, the flexibility to transfer reserved authority to other projects, and the need for coordination with other funding sources like Proposition 1. Chair Preston emphasized the importance of public transparency and collaboration. Supervisor Chan raised questions about the nexus between Faircloth to RAD and other programs (e.g., Homekey) and the need for a clear strategy to serve extremely low-income households. The committee voted to continue the item to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2: Charlie Shamus, representing the Council of Community Housing Organizations, expressed support for the plan to request rent augmentation for the full Faircloth Authority. He urged the city to leverage the maximum allowable 3,688 units and stated that community housing organizations, preservation organizations, and land trusts are eager to partner with the city. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (MOU Amendment): Forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation as a committee report (2 ayes: Preston, Chan; Vice Chair Stephanie absent). - Item 2 (Faircloth to RAD Hearing): Continued to the call of the chair (3 ayes: Preston, Chan, Engardio; Vice Chair Stephanie excused). The committee intends to receive an update after the September 30, 2024 deadline. - Items 3-7 (Litigation Settlements): After closed session, the committee voted to forward all five settlement items to the full board with a positive recommendation (3 ayes: Preston, Chan, Engardio; Vice Chair Stephanie excused). The committee also voted not to disclose the closed session discussions (3 ayes). - Closed Session Discussions: Not disclosed as per the motion.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 63% · PROCEDURAL 17% · PUBLIC HOUSING 6% · HOMELESSNESS 5%
655
JUL 17, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - July 17, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on July 17, 2024, at 6:15 PM (18:15) to consider 16 agenda items, including leases, contracts, grants, tax amendments, and health service rates. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, joined by Supervisor Mirna Melgar and Board President Aaron Paskin (later Vice Chair Rafaya Mandelman joined). The committee voted on all items, with several amendments and one continuation. Public Comments & Testimony Public comment was taken on every item. Most items had no speakers. Notable public comments: - On Item 1 (Twin Peaks Petroleum lease): Multiple speakers expressed support for the legacy business, including the owner Michael Gareeb and the Legacy Business Program Manager. Speakers cited the station's importance to the community and its status as an independently owned business. - On Item 16 (Health Service System rates): Numerous retirees and retired firefighters spoke against the proposed switch from United Healthcare to Blue Shield for Medicare Advantage PPO. They raised concerns about loss of providers, reduced customer service, and questioned the legality of the Health Service Board's vote. One speaker noted the scoring favored United Healthcare in non-financial categories. Several speakers urged the committee to reject the resolution. Discussion Items - Item 3 – Gross Receipts Tax Rate for Accommodations: Ordinance to lower tax rates for NAICS 721, contingent on November 2024 ballot measure. The controller’s office confirmed the measure is revenue neutral/positive. The committee forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 1 – Twin Peaks Petroleum Lease: 20-year lease for city-owned property at 598 Portola Drive for a gas station/auto care. Supervisor Melgar explained the property's history, the need for tank upgrades, and the commitment to offer biofuels. The budget analyst noted competitive bidding issues but recognized vacancy concerns. The committee amended the lease to change the option from 10 years to 5 years and continued the item to July 24, 2024, for a final vote. - Item 2 – Electrical Supplies Contract: Contract with Rexel USA for $26.2 million over 3 years with 4-year extension option. The committee praised the performance monitoring clause. Approved unanimously. - Item 4 – Specialty Services Access Grant: Retroactive acceptance of $250,000 grant from San Francisco Health Plan to improve specialty care access at ZSFG. Approved. - Item 5 – Geriatric Emergency Department Grant: Retroactive acceptance of $376,000 grant from San Francisco General Hospital Foundation for geriatric ED planning. The grant date error was corrected. Approved. - Item 6 – Calpine Energy Solutions Amendment: Six-month extension and $2.5 million increase for CleanPowerSF billing services. The committee amended the resolution to reduce the not-to-exceed amount to $34,745,425 as recommended by the budget analyst. Approved. - Item 7 – Power Purchase Agreement with IP Easley II: 10-year, $75 million PPA for solar energy from Riverside County. The committee noted the competitive process and fixed-price benefits. Approved. - Item 8 – Release of Reserved Funds for PUC Headquarters: Hearing to release $2.5 million for the New City Distribution Division Headquarters. The project had earlier procurement issues but now on track. Approved. - Item 9 – Air Premia Lease Agreement: 10-year lease for Korean airline at SFO. Expected revenue of $37.9 million. Approved. - Item 10 – Customs and Border Protection Agreement: Retroactive approval of a reimbursable services agreement since 2014. The committee amended the resolution to correct the termination notice from 60 to 90 days. Approved. - Item 11 – DFS Group Lease Amendment: Reduced percentage rent to 33% for May-Dec 2023, contingent on construction of new locations. The cost to the General Fund is $1.3 million, but not budgeted. Approved. - Items 12 & 13 – Leases for APA Family Services and Five Keys: Five-year leases at below-market rates for nonprofits at 1099 Sunnydale. The committee discussed the need for lease provisions to reference grant agreements. Approved. - Item 14 – Lease Amendment for 2 Gough Street: Amendment to expand HSA space by 8,000 sq ft. The committee amended the resolution to correct the base rent from $312,012 to $260,090 due to timing. Approved. - Item 15 – Ground Lease for Affordable Housing: 75-year ground lease for 168 affordable units at 1515 South Van Ness. The project recently received a $37.9 million state loan. Approved. - Item 16 – Health Service System Plans and Rates: Ordinance approving 2025 health plans and contribution rates. The committee heard extensive public comment opposing the switch from United Healthcare to Blue Shield for Medicare Advantage. The health service system defended the RFP process, noting savings of $67 million over three years. Chair Chan asked about formulary changes and customer service. The city attorney confirmed the board cannot amend the package and must vote up or down. The committee voted to forward to full board with positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Continued to July 24, 2024, after amendment. - Items 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16: All forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, with the following amendments: - Item 6: Reduced not-to-exceed amount to $34,745,425. - Item 10: Corrected termination notice to 90 days. - Item 14: Corrected base rent to $260,090. - All votes were 3-0 (Vice Chair Mandelman absent for some votes, but present for most). - Items are expected to appear on the July 23, 2024 Board of Supervisors agenda unless otherwise stated.

HEALTH SERVICES 27% · REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · PUBLIC HEALTH 10%
656
JUL 17, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting Summary - July 17, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission met on July 17, 2024, at 1:45 PM (UTC). The meeting included an officer recognition, reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), a presentation on the Law Enforcement Equipment Policy Annual Report (AB 481), approval of revised Department General Orders (DGOs) 5.03 (Investigative Detentions) and 5.05 (Emergency Response and Pursuit Driving), and a closed session. Items 7 (DGO 7.04 on Safeguarding Children) and 12E/F were removed from the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers addressed the commission during general public comment. Topics included calls for a Peace Corps-style exchange program for first responders, allegations of misconduct by a senior city official submitted to the FBI, support for ballot measures limiting the commission's authority, and concerns about police tactics at the Dolores Hill Bomb event. - During the AB 481 discussion, a speaker from the American Friends Service Committee criticized the department for not fully disclosing its firearms inventory and failing to demonstrate need for additional weapons, citing declining gun violence. - One speaker urged the commission to focus on foot patrols and community engagement as crime-reduction strategies. Discussion Items - Weekly Officer Recognition: Officer John Norment (Bayview Station) was recognized for 17 years of service, including work on the Third Street Footbeat, public housing detail, and community programs (reading partners, wilderness excursions). Commissioners and Chief Scott praised his mentorship and community policing. Chief Scott noted Officer Norment will retire in September due to a medical condition. - Chief’s Report: Chief Scott reported a 32% reduction in Part I crimes year-to-date (about 9,000 fewer crimes), property crimes down 34%, violent crimes down 11%, homicides down 38% (18 vs. 29 year-to-date), and a 94% homicide clearance rate. Car break-ins were down 55% (just over 5,000 vs. nearly 11,000). Four non-fatal shootings occurred during the reporting period. A tragic case involving a missing child (Ellie Lorenzo) was mentioned: her father committed suicide in San Francisco; the child was later found deceased in San Jose. Side show incidents have decreased (22 this year vs. 45 all of last year). - DPA Director’s Report: Executive Director Henderson announced DPA has zero cases not tolling (lowest in agency history) and will present four cases in closed session (one-third of the pending backlog). DPA met with Internal Affairs to improve efficiency. An audit on stop data is complete and undergoing edits; it will address data sharing issues. DPA opened 9 cases and closed 28 since the last meeting. - Commission Reports: Commissioner Walker requested a September 18 update on the 30x30 initiative to increase female officer representation. Commissioner Elias reported a meeting with the Body Worn Camera (BWC) unit; the unit has 8 of 10 staff and receives 4-5 footage requests daily, with each minute of video taking 3-5 minutes to redact. Commissioner Benedicto acknowledged work on DGOs 7.01 and 7.04 (pulled for community input). Commissioner Yañez noted his father’s recent passing and advocated for a juvenile pre-booking diversion program, citing 370 unduplicated juvenile referrals since January 2022. Vice President Carter Oberstone noted DGO 9.07 (de-emphasizing non-safety traffic stops) became effective that day. - Law Enforcement Equipment Policy Annual Report (AB 481): Policy Manager Aja Steves presented the inaugural annual report, posted June 11, 2024. The report covers items acquired before January 1, 2022 (e.g., armored vehicles, flashbangs, assault rifles for specialized units). The department reported no complaints about the equipment itself. Commissioners expressed concern that state law requires a community engagement meeting (not just two-minute public comment) and that the report was submitted six months late (received extension to June 15). Commissioner Clay noted no sanction exists for late filing. The commission asked for additional community meetings before sending to the Board of Supervisors. It was clarified that drones (UAVs) are not included but a separate use policy will be required. - DGO 5.03 (Investigative Detentions): The revised order requires officers to articulate on BWC the factors supporting a pat-search (e.g., belief subject was armed, source/age of information). Commissioner Benedicto offered clarifying amendments (changing present tense to past tense). Commissioner Elias expressed concern that pat-searches are intrusive and data shows racial disparities, but supported the order as compliant with Prop E. The commission voted 6-1 to approve (Vice President Carter Oberstone opposed). - DGO 5.05 (Emergency Response and Pursuit Driving): The revised order complies with Prop E by expanding circumstances for pursuits. The commission added a requirement to report apprehension data (green language) despite the chief’s objection that it’s not required by Prop E. The vote was 5-2 in favor (Commissioners Walker and Yee opposed). Key Outcomes - Approved: DGO 5.03 (Investigative Detentions) – 6 yes, 1 no. - Approved: DGO 5.05 (Emergency Response and Pursuit Driving) – 5 yes, 2 no. (Includes additional apprehension data reporting.) - Directed: The department to hold additional community engagement meetings on the AB 481 annual report and bring an update to the commission in September. - Scheduled: A discussion on the juvenile pre-booking diversion program for the September meeting. - Noted: DGO 7.04 (Safeguarding Children) and items 12E/F were removed from the agenda; DGO 7.01 will be agendized in the future. - Closed Session: The commission voted unanimously (9-0) to enter closed session for Item 12 (discussed four discipline cases from DPA) and voted unanimously not to disclose any discussion.

PROCEDURAL 37% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 29% · PUBLIC SAFETY 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13%
657
JUL 17, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - July 17, 2024

Note: The agenda and transcript reference July 16, 2024, but the exact timestamp for this meeting is July 17, 2024, per user instruction. The meeting was held virtually and in person at Port Commission chambers. The Port Commission convened on July 17, 2024, with all four commissioners present (President Kimberly Brandon, Vice President Gail Gilman, Commissioners Willie Adams and Stephen Lee). The meeting included an executive session, executive director’s report, consent calendar, and an informational presentation on a sediment remediation project. No votes were taken on substantive items beyond consent. Executive Director’s Report - New Art Installation: A 9-foot bronze sculpture titled "Sound Turn to Noise" by Thomas J. Price, depicting a young Black woman in jogging clothes, has been installed on the waterfront. It aims to challenge traditional memorialization norms. - Fourth of July Weekend: The port saw 2017-level sales (unaudited) at Fisherman’s Wharf, with high attendance, clean streets, and successful coordination with SFMTA and SFPD. Jefferson Street was closed to traffic. - Resilience Milestone: On June 28, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers approved the Agency Decision Milestone for the port’s waterfront resilience study, described as one of the Corps’ most innovative and consequential studies. - Hydrogen Ferry: The port joined a ribbon-cutting for the nation’s first commercial passenger ferry powered by hydrogen, a 75-passenger vessel offering free service between Piers 41 and the downtown ferry terminal for six months. - Insurance Savings: A new broker and policy resulted in lower premiums and better coverage for emergencies. - Intern Program: Seven interns from Project Pull, Enterprise for Youth, and Opportunities for All are working at Pier 50 and other departments; they were welcomed by commissioners. - Commissioner Comments: All commissioners praised the report, with special emphasis on the art installation’s inclusivity, Fisherman’s Wharf recovery, and the resilience study’s significance. Consent Calendar - 10A: Authorization to advertise competitive bids for Construction Contract No. 2857, Crane Cove Park Playgrounds and Dog Park (Resolution 2432). Passed unanimously. - 10B: Reduction of crab and salmon receiver lease rents by up to 50% for five months (May 15–October 15, 2024) due to economic disruption from the closure of the 2023/2024 commercial salmon season and shortened Dungeness crab seasons (Resolution 2433). Passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - On Consent Calendar (10B): Three speakers expressed support for the rent reduction. - Kenny Bellov (owner of Two by C at Pier 45) reported losing 200,000 pounds of fish offloaded in 2023 vs. 2022, costing $2 million in revenue. He thanked the commission for relief. - Jeanette Kaido (Kaido Fisheries) thanked staff for their work on the relief numbers. - Sarah Bates (commercial fisher and board member, San Francisco Community Fishing Association) noted this is the second year of a complete salmon closure without federal disaster funds, and a nine-week crab season vs. normal seven months. She stressed that without local buyers, the entire fishery infrastructure is at risk. - No public comments were made on other agenda items. Discussion Items - 11A: Informational Presentation – PG&E Beach Street Offshore Sediment Remediation Project - Catherine Purcell (Port Planning & Environment) detailed the cleanup of PAH-contaminated sediments from the former manufactured gas plant, covering areas from Pier 43½ to East Marina. Remediation will involve dredging and capping over five years (2025–2029) during June–November in-water work windows. - Current pre-remediation work includes 22 working group meetings with tenants (e.g., Red and White Fleet, Blue and Gold Fleet, Pier 39, USS Pampanito) to minimize operational impacts. - Construction will be waterside only; no landside traffic or pedestrian access impacts are anticipated. - Sediment will be barged off-site (final disposal site pending water board approval), and environmental protections include turbidity curtains, sound attenuation, and marine mammal monitoring. - Commissioner Lee expressed concern about impacts to ferry and charter operations at Pier 39 and 41½, especially during summer. Purcell confirmed that temporary relocations are being planned but not yet finalized. - Commissioner Brandon asked about community concerns; Purcell noted feedback focused on minimizing public impacts and understanding the construction schedule. - Purcell confirmed PG&E is funding the entire project, including tenant and port consultant costs. The port is compelled as property owner to support remediation. New Business - Commissioner Lee requested a future briefing on the status of redevelopment plans for historic finger piers. Director Forbes agreed to provide an update. - Commissioner Adams expressed interest in meeting with legacy fishermen to explore additional support beyond fee reductions, such as promoting direct sales from boats. Key Outcomes - Minutes Approved: June 11, 2024 meeting minutes adopted unanimously. - Consent Resolutions Adopted: Resolutions 2432 and 2433 passed unanimously. - No Other Votes: All other agenda items were informational or administrative. - Next Steps: Staff to schedule briefing on finger pier redevelopment; Commissioner Adams to arrange meeting with fishermen; PG&E to continue permitting and community outreach for remediation starting summer 2025.

EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR'S REPORT 32% · ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 15% · PROCUREMENT 13% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
658
JUL 16, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Special Meeting – July 16, 2024: $390M Bond Election Items Advanced to Full Board

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar, met in a special session on July 16, 2024, to consider two related items: a resolution and an ordinance calling for a November 5, 2024 special election on a general obligation bond not to exceed $390 million. The bond would fund acquisition or improvement of real property for primary health care, emergency medical services, skilled nursing, mental health, substance use disorder services, seismic upgrades, emergency shelter, transportation, pedestrian and street safety improvements, and related costs. The committee previously continued the items on July 10, 2024, pending amendments tied to the potential passage of ACA 10, which would lower the voter approval threshold for such bonds. Discussion Items - Chair Chan noted the items were continued from July 10 due to amendments reflecting the potential change from ACA 10 (a state constitutional amendment on the November 2024 ballot that would lower bond approval thresholds). The amendments ensure that if voters approve ACA 10, the bond results will reflect that change. - No committee members had questions. The clerk reported no speakers in public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - No public speakers were present or submitted oral comments. Key Outcomes - Motion to forward items to the full board with a positive recommendation as committee reports. The motion passed unanimously (3–0): Vice Chair Mandelman (aye), Member Melgar (aye), Chair Chan (aye). - The meeting was adjourned after concluding all business.

PROCEDURAL 100%
659
JUL 16, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - July 16, 2024

The Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on July 16, 2024, covering a wide range of items including the city's two-year budget, several special commendations, an update on police reform recommendations, development agreements for the Stonestown project, extensions of hotel shelter contracts, and multiple charter amendments for the November ballot. The meeting featured extensive debate on the budget, with one supervisor voting against it, and a detailed presentation on the implementation of 272 U.S. Department of Justice reform recommendations for the San Francisco Police Department. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: June 11, 2024 regular board meeting and June 12, 2024 special budget committee meeting minutes were approved unanimously (11-0). - Items 1-24 (Budget Package): The budget and appropriation ordinance, salary ordinance, and associated fee and grant items were passed on first reading and resolutions adopted. The package included amendments to reallocate $2.75 million from Union Square free parking funding to arts and culture activation in multiple downtown districts. Final vote: 10-1 (Supervisor Preston opposed). - Items 25-26: Planning code amendments and street acceptance for 1629 Market Street were finally passed. - Items 28-30, 47-48 (Stonestown Development): Supervisor Engardio recused himself. The ordinances approving a development agreement, establishing an enhanced infrastructure financing district, and amending the planning code and zoning map for the Stonestown project were passed on first reading and resolutions adopted (10-0). - Item 31: Extension of the SFPUC Green Infrastructure Grant Program delegation was passed (11-0). - Items 33-34: Lease extensions for the Adante and Monarch Hotels (shelter sites) were passed (11-0). - Item 35: Workforce housing revenue bond ordinance was passed on first reading (11-0). - Items 36-42: Various resolutions and ordinances regarding SFPUC contracts, property acquisitions, and park dedications were adopted on same house same call. - Item 43: Continued to July 23, 2024. - Items 45-46: Bond election ordinance for up to $390 million for health, safety, and street improvements – amended to comply with ACA 10 (lowered voter threshold to 55%) and passed on first reading; continued to July 23 for committee of the whole. - Item 49: Interim zoning controls for Upper Market Street and Castro Street were adopted. - Item 50: Ordinance requiring pharmacies to stock buprenorphine was passed on first reading. - Item 51: Liquor license for Fate Collective (475 Haight Street) was approved. - Items 54-57: Charter amendments on children and youth, inspector general, affordable housing fund, and retirement benefits were each continued one week. Public Comments & Testimony - During Committee of the Whole (Police Reforms): Several speakers praised Chief Scott and the department's progress, including crisis intervention training and community engagement. One speaker urged continued support for the CIT program. A mother of a murder victim, Paulette Brown, thanked Chief Scott for his responsiveness. A few speakers expressed concerns about side shows, police staffing, and the integrity of stop data. One speaker criticized the focus on technology and urged competence-based hiring. - General Public Comment: A worker advocate described Subway franchise violations of minimum wage laws, requesting board support. A City College instructor urged the board to protect the Free City College program. A Fillmore corridor ambassador asked for city department partnerships. A mother of a slain teen, Paulette Brown, thanked the board for a street renaming resolution. Several speakers addressed national political issues, but the president reminded them of electioneering rules. Discussion Items - Budget Debate (Items 1-24): Budget Chair Chan opened by noting the city faces a $1 billion deficit and that the budget still increases structural deficits. She highlighted restored funding for public health, oral health, food access, and youth services, but conceded that the budget does not fully fund cost-of-living adjustments for nonprofit partners. Supervisors Preston, Safai, Melgar, and Walton each spoke. Preston opposed the budget due to divestment from social housing (Prop I revenue diverted), unconditional increases in police funding, and lack of overdose prevention sites. He voted no. Safai expressed disappointment in initial mayoral cuts but supported the final budget. Melgar and Walton praised restorations for children, youth, and community services. The board adopted an amendment to redirect $2.75 million from Union Square parking subsidies to downtown arts and culture activation. - Committee of the Whole – Police Reform Update (Item 44): Chief William Scott presented progress on 272 DOJ recommendations. He reported that 245 recommendations have been found substantially compliant; the remaining 27 were submitted to the California DOJ in 2024. Highlights included a 64% decline in use of force (2017-2021), a 79% decline in pointing firearms, a 50% reduction in officer-involved shootings, and increased diversity in recruits (52% people of color in 2016 to 81% in 2023). Executive Director Catherine McGuire outlined plans for sustainability managers and oversight. Supervisors questioned the chief about disparities in stops, data reporting delays (Q4 2023 and Q1 2024 racial disparity reports not yet released), foot patrol staffing, language capacity, side shows (only 5 vehicles seized in 2024), and recruitment of women (30x30 pledge). The chief committed to improving data systems, expanding foot beats as staffing increases, and developing a women's advancement committee. The item was continued to January 28, 2025. - COVA Hotel Extension (Item 32): Supervisor Preston detailed a seven-month extension for the 95-unit shelter hotel on Ellis Street. He cited community concerns about street conditions and announced commitments from the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) for: prioritizing Tenderloin referrals, an interagency MOU for cleaning, and funding for community ambassadors on the block (7:30am-5:30pm, 7 days a week, no later than September 1, 2024). HSH representative Dylan Schneider confirmed these commitments. Supervisor Safai urged HSH to be more proactive in managing shelter impacts. The ordinance passed 10-1 (Supervisor Mandelman opposed). - Stonestown Development (Items 28-30, 47-48): Supervisor Melgar presented the project, which will redevelop the Stonestown Mall into a mixed-use neighborhood with 3,500 housing units (20% affordable), a senior village, six acres of open space, and ground-floor retail. The project is a key component of the city's housing element. The legislation was approved 10-0. Key Outcomes - Budget: Passed on first reading (10-1). Final adoption expected at a subsequent meeting. - Police Reform Update: Continued to January 28, 2025. The board will receive the California DOJ's assessment of the remaining 27 recommendations in the coming months. - Community Ambassadors for 600 Block of Ellis: The Department of Emergency Management and HSH committed to fund ambassadors starting no later than September 1, 2024. An interagency MOU will be drafted. - Charter Amendments: Five charter amendments were introduced and continued one week. The board also scheduled special meetings on July 23, 2024, to consider a motion to discharge a police staffing charter amendment from the Rules Committee. - Street Renaming: Supervisor Preston introduced a resolution to honorarily rename the 1500 block of Grove Street as Aubrey Abacasa Jr. Street. - Subway Worker Resolution: Supervisor Ronan introduced a resolution supporting workers at Subway franchises who were denied minimum wage and overtime. - Afghan American Heritage Month: Supervisor Dorsey introduced a resolution declaring August 2024 as Afghan American Heritage Month. - Free City College Resolution: Supervisor Melgar introduced a resolution urging the city to negotiate an updated MOU with City College that preserves the program's original intent.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 18% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · PROCEDURAL 9%
660
JUL 15, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - July 15, 2024: Charter Amendments and Great Highway Ballot Measure

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 15, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronen, with Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Member Asha Safai. The committee considered several charter amendments for the November 5, 2024 ballot, including items on police accountability, children and youth services, an inspector general, affordable housing, retirement benefits for nurses, firefighters, and police, and a hearing on an initiative ordinance to permanently close a portion of the Upper Great Highway to create an oceanside park. The committee also discussed the city's fiscal challenges, including an $800 million budget deficit. Consent Calendar - Item 2 (Children & Youth Services): Passed unanimously as a committee report with positive recommendation. The charter amendment would create the "Our Children, Our Families" initiative to coordinate services, require outcome-based budgeting, and place conditions on school district funding. - Item 3 (Inspector General): Passed unanimously as a committee report. The measure would establish an Inspector General in the Controller's Office with subpoena and search warrant authority. - Item 4 (Affordable Housing Opportunity Fund): Passed unanimously as a committee report. The measure would create a fund for rental subsidies for extremely low-income seniors, families, and persons with disabilities, requiring at least $8.25 million annually starting in FY 2026-27. - Item 5 (Nurse Retirement Credit and Public Safety Communications Personnel): Passed unanimously as a committee report. The measure would allow certain nurses to purchase up to three years of service credit and move public safety communications personnel to a safety retirement plan. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Electing DPA Director): A speaker recounted historical issues with the Office of Citizen Complaints and urged Supervisor Walton not to back down, supporting the concept of citizen oversight. - Item 3 (Inspector General): H. Brown expressed strong support, calling it a "wonderful move" and praising the Controller. - Item 4 (Affordable Housing): John Avalos (Council of Community Housing Organizations) supported the measure but noted that $8.25 million is insufficient and that future revenue measures would be needed. Another speaker recalled a similar past measure that funded the school district. - Item 6 (Fire Department Pension): Fire Chief Janine Nicholson testified that the one-year averaging provision (pension spiking) has led to inefficiencies, with employees taking short-term positions to boost pensions, then burning sick time. Adam Wood (Firefighters Local 798) explained that the one-year averaging was intended to remove incentives for firefighters to stay longer given elevated cancer risks. Floyd Rollins (Local 798 president) resented any implication that the measure was a veiled attempt to gain benefits, emphasizing the goal of saving lives. - Item 7 (Police DROP): H. Brown opposed the program, arguing it would retain the worst officers. Adam Wood (Firefighters) supported moving the measure forward, citing immediate public safety needs due to severe understaffing. - Item 8 (Great Highway): Lucas Lux (Friends of Great Highway Park) noted that the pilot park received over 3 million visits and urged letting voters decide. Zach Lipton (volunteer) supported the measure, citing planning studies showing a maximum of three minutes added driving time and the opportunity for a transformative park. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Electing DPA Director): Supervisor Walton moved to continue the matter to the call of the chair, stating he wanted more collaboration to ensure independent investigations of police misconduct. The motion passed unanimously without public comment opposition. - Item 6 (Fire Department Service Retirement Pension): Extensive debate. Chair Ronen proposed an amendment to remove the one-year averaging provision (pension spiking), which she argued was financially irresponsible during a budget crisis and not related to cancer risk. She noted that the measure would cost $9.2 million in FY25, with the pension spiking portion accounting for $5.5 million. Supervisor Safai defended the original provision, arguing it was paired with lowering the retirement age to discourage firefighters from staying longer. The committee voted 2-1 (Safai dissenting) to amend and continue the item to July 22, 2024. - Item 7 (Police Staffing and Deferred Retirement Option Program): Chair Ronen moved to continue to the call of the chair, citing lack of data on officer departures, the failure of a prior DROP program, and the need to address root causes of recruitment issues rather than a costly band-aid. She noted the original cost estimate was $80 million, reduced to $600,000–$3 million after amendments. Supervisor Dorsey argued the program would delay 50 retirements in the first year and help address attrition. The motion passed 2-1 (Safai dissenting). - Item 8 (Great Highway Initiative Ordinance): Supervisor Engardio presented the measure, noting that the southern portion (south of Sloat) is already set to close due to erosion, and that the ballot measure would only close the Lincoln-to-Sloat section, with traffic improvements planned. Supervisors expressed support, with Supervisor Safai emphasizing the need for SFMTA to commit to traffic signal improvements. The hearing was filed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Continued to the call of the chair (unanimous). - Items 2, 3, 4, 5: Recommended to the full Board of Supervisors as committee reports with positive recommendations (all unanimous). - Item 6: Amended (removed one-year averaging provision) and continued to the July 22, 2024 Rules Committee meeting (2-1 vote, Safai dissenting). - Item 7: Continued to the call of the chair (2-1 vote, Safai dissenting). - Item 8: Hearing filed; the initiative ordinance will proceed to the full board for consideration.

CHARTER AMENDMENTS 17% · PUBLIC SAFETY 14% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 14% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 13%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com