Public Meetings - San Francisco, California

The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular meeting on September 9, 2026, at 1:30 PM. Commissioners present: Lowe, Scott, Leong, Benedicto, Lyas (arrived later), Vice President Techie, President Clay. Also present: Chief Liu (SFPD) and Executive Director Paul Henderson (DPA). Items 6 and 7 (Department General Orders 5.14 and 8.11) were removed from the agenda and will be taken up at a future meeting. Consent Calendar - The Commission voted to receive and file the 2026 SFPD Department Awards certification, the DPA Quarterly Report (Second Quarter 2026), and a grant cost-sharing agreement ($97,000 for a narcotics-detecting canine). - The 2026 Q1 and Q2 Live Monitoring Report was separately agendized (to be heard in fall 2026) per a motion by Commissioner Benedicto, citing public interest in surveillance trends. The motion passed 6–0. - Commissioner Well questioned whether the increase in DPA complaints was due to greater accessibility rather than police behavior. Director Henderson noted no direct correlation between volume and sustained cases. Public Comments & Testimony - First speaker: Discussed three concerns regarding SFPD's use of force at Trans March (Stud Alley, June 26–27, 2026). Asked for an update on a town hall meeting, questioned the number of officers present during a 22-minute enforcement window, and alleged discrepancies between the department's response to Supervisor Fielder's letter and a Mission Local article. Urged the Commission to investigate. - Second speaker (Ms. Brown): Shared grief over her son's unsolved homicide (case 06086238, 20 years ago). Thanked those who attended her son's memorial on August 14. Requested better public outreach about the tipster reward program, noting many community members do not visit the SFPD website. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Crime Trends & Public Safety) - Year-to-date Part I crime down 18% vs. 2025; violent crime down 9%; property crime down 19%. Homicides at 16 (same as 2025). No officer-involved shootings in the reporting period. - Drug market enforcement (Aug 31–Sep 6): 11 narcotics trafficking arrests, 67 warrants, 55 public user arrests; over 2 lbs of narcotics and 4 firearms seized. - Retail theft strategy: 844 arrests in 6 months, $410,000+ recovered, 20% decline in theft cases. Introduced online reporting for retailers; fencing operations yielded 100 arrests in 2 months. - Community engagement: 12th annual Chinatown Night Out; preparations for Hardly Strictly Bluegrass, Fleet Week, Halloween, and Dreamforce (nearly 5,000 attendees). Academy enrollment: 82 (42 in 290th class, graduating Jan 2027; 40 in 291st class, graduating Mar 2027). - Update on Trans March community meeting: SFPD has reached out to the Office of Transgender Initiatives to serve as a third-party facilitator; meeting scheduled for tomorrow (Sep 10). No date yet for the meeting. - Vice President Techie asked about a dog mauling incident on Sep 8 (500 block of Larkin). Chief Liu reported a victim with serious injuries, the dog died on scene, transferred to Animal Care & Control. Relationship between victim and dog still under investigation. - DPA Director's Report - Staff participated in three sessions at John O'Connell High School (public service pathway students) and delivered Know Your Rights presentation. - Technology modernization: developing a public-facing legislation dashboard and automating the openness report (reducing production time from 2 weeks to 2 days). Collaborating with SFPD on a record tracking system for ALPR audit. - Since last week: 22 cases opened, 24 closed. Most common allegation: failure to properly investigate/neglect of duty. - Commission Reports - President Clay reported on attending the API Forum group; noted robust community engagement. Requested Chief Liu provide a list of department needs (technology, vehicles, computers) for potential private-sector grants. - City Attorney's office (Michael Hughes) will assist in developing performance review processes for the Chief and DPA Director. - Sergeant Youngblood is coordinating with district captains to schedule community meetings; commissioners will sign up to attend. - Commissioner Benedicto read a public notice about soliciting comments on DGO 10.12 (drone policy). Comments accepted via email through September 20, 2026; responses due at the October 14, 2026 meeting. Key Outcomes - Items 6 and 7 removed from agenda, postponed to a future meeting. - Consent Calendar approved (6–0) with the Live Monitoring Report pulled for separate discussion. - Motion to go into Closed Session (Item 10) passed 7–0. - Vote to disclose Closed Session discussion (Item 11) passed 7–0 (no disclosure of any discussion). - Chief Liu will provide a list of departmental technology and equipment needs. - DGO 10.12 (drone policy) public comment period open through September 20, 2026; policy will be heard on October 14, 2026. - Community meetings in police districts are being arranged; sign-up process to follow.

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on Tuesday, September 8, 2026, at approximately 9:45 AM. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, a tribute to former Commissioner Ann Muller Kane (who served from 1997 to 2020 and passed away on August 7, 2026), approval of minutes, quarterly budget and audit reports, a consent calendar, a major public hearing on the proposed CleanPowerSF solar billing tariff, and several contract awards. Commissioners present: President Arce, Vice President Leverone, Commissioner Jantar, Commissioner Stacy, and Commissioner Thurlow (quorum achieved). Consent Calendar - Approved unanimously (5-0) the consent calendar, which included routine approvals. Commissioner Stacy asked about Item 6M (equipment/software maintenance contract increase due to a five-year extension). Commissioner Thurlow asked about Item 6i (expansion of four infrastructure contracts, noting low encumbrance to date; staff explained that legacy work from prior contracts had been carried over, necessitating the amendment). No items were separated for individual vote. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Francisco de Casta alleged that OSHA has charged the SFPUC Water Department on five counts related to fired employees and criticized lack of empathy. Ty Seals Jackson (descendant of indigenous Aborigines) asked for status on an educational building at the Southeast Community Facility. Eileen O'Neil (via remote) urged the commission to revise the “design drought” and opposed the West Side Portable Emergency Firefighting Water System. - Item 7 (GM Selection): Francisco de Casta urged respect for indigenous rights regarding Hetch Hetchy water and called for an engineer, not an attorney, as the next General Manager. - Item 8 (Solar Billing Plan – Public Hearing): Over a dozen speakers testified, including representatives from Environmental Working Group, Local Clean Energy Alliance, 350 Bay Area, Environment California, Solar Rights Alliance, Albion Power Company, and local installers. All urged the commission to delay or reject the proposed solar billing plan, arguing it undervalued rooftop solar benefits, did not account for avoided transmission costs, and would slow clean energy adoption. Several noted that a meeting with the mayor's office was being scheduled and that adopting the plan today would undercut that conversation. - Items 9-12 (Contracts): No public comments were made on these items. Discussion Items - Item 5 – General Manager Report: Included Q4 budget status (water surplus $21.4M, wastewater surplus $10.6M, power surplus $66.8M, CleanPowerSF surplus $71.3M; all financial policy targets exceeded). Audit and performance review (13 financial audits completed, 10 open recommendations; CSA accepted all). Wastewater Capital Improvement Program report (127 projects, $9B budget, $4.2B remaining; key project updates on nutrient reduction, biosolids digesters, headworks). - Item 7 – General Manager Selection Update: Commissioner Stacy reported that CPS Human Resources Consulting Services was selected by DHR; contract finalized August 26. Job posting expected in "the next few days." Public and employee surveys will be conducted online. Resume submittal deadline is October 16, 2026. Commission review will follow. No action required. - Item 8 – Public Hearing on CleanPowerSF Solar Billing Plan: Assistant General Manager Michael Himes presented a revised net billing tariff (solar billing plan) to replace net energy metering for rooftop solar customers. The proposal compensates solar exports at CleanPowerSF's retail generation rate minus 15% administrative costs, effective May 2027. Of approximately 14,000 solar customers, about 1,400 would be transitioned; 80% would see monthly impacts of $5 or less, 13% more than $5. Staff estimate annual ratepayer savings of $2M by 2030 and $6M by 2040. The plan is more generous than other CCAs in PG&E territory. Commissioners discussed tradeoffs between solar customer compensation and non-solar ratepayer costs. Commissioner Jandar expressed interest in delaying to allow consultation with the mayor's office. After debate, a motion to approve with a commitment to report back by May 2028 was made by Vice President Leverone and seconded by Commissioner Stacy. The motion passed 4-1 (Commissioner Jandar dissenting). - Item 9 – Water Supply Assessment for Treasure Island Residential Project: Approved (5-0) the WSA for an additional 1,400–2,800 residential units on Treasure Island, to be forwarded to the Planning Commission for CEQA review. - Item 10 – Contract WD-2915 (Crystal Springs Pipeline No. 2 Reach 5 Lining Replacement): Awarded to Mitchell Engineering for $63,102,346 (960 days). A bid protest regarding LBE shortfall (13.59% vs 14%) was resolved as excusable error by CMD. Approved 5-0. - Item 11 – Contract WW-770 (Oceanside WPCP HVAC Upgrades): Awarded to Monterey Mechanical Co. for $22,309,000 (970 days) for functional replacement of 1990s-era ventilation systems. Approved 5-0. - Item 12 – Amendment No. 2 to Contract CS-249 (Mountain Tunnel Improvements): Approved $2 million increase (no additional time) for engineering support during construction, necessitated by descoped South Fork siphon work and need for additional monitoring. Approved 5-0. - Closed Session (Items 15-18): The commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and later voted not to disclose closed session discussions. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar approved unanimously (5-0). - Item 8 (Solar Billing Plan) approved 4-1 (Commissioner Jandar dissenting). Staff to return with a report by May 2028. The new tariff takes effect May 2027. - Items 9, 10, 11, 12 all approved unanimously (5-0). - General Manager Search is underway; resume deadline October 16, 2026. - Quarterly financial and audit reports were accepted as presented.

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on September 3, 2026, to consider an ordinance amending the Airport Surveillance Technology Policy, hold a hearing on preparations for Fleet Week 2026, and approve multiple settlement agreements. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Stephen Sheryl, with Vice Chair Jackie Fielder and Supervisor Alan Wong present. Consent Calendar - Settlement of Lawsuits and Claims (Items 3-19): The committee unanimously approved 17 settlements totaling approximately $19.5 million, covering various lawsuits and unlitigated claims against the city. The settlements were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Lewis Lewin, Executive Director, San Francisco Fleet Week: Expressed strong support for Fleet Week, emphasizing its 45-year track record of cooperation with city agencies and its community outreach, including over 40 band concerts and disaster response training programs. - David Flynn, Public Speaker: Spoke in favor of Fleet Week, highlighting its educational value in allowing civilians to tour naval vessels and meet service members. Discussion Items - Item 1: Ordinance 260658 – Amended Airport Surveillance Technology Policy: Deanna Bolich from San Francisco International Airport presented the ordinance, which authorizes the use of security cameras at off-airport remote check-in and baggage handling facilities, such as a pilot program at the Hilton San Francisco Union Square. The cameras record video only, with no live monitoring, and footage is retained for one year unless needed for investigations. Access is limited to trained SFO staff and law enforcement. The committee voted unanimously to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: Hearing 260801 – Preparing for Fleet Week 2026: The hearing focused on the city's preparedness for Fleet Week, scheduled for October 4–12, 2026, particularly in light of lessons learned from recent large events such as July 4th celebrations and the Outside Lands festival. Key points from presentations: - DEM Director Mary Ellen Carroll reported that Fleet Week planning includes the use of the Emergency Operations Center (EOC) as needed. She noted past peak crowds of 2,000 in 2025 and 7,500 in 2024, and that the event is expected to be smaller due to fewer ships and relocation of the humanitarian village. She emphasized lessons learned from July 4th, including the need for better autonomous vehicle (AV) mitigation, advanced planning, situational awareness, and integrated transportation planning. - SFMTA Director Julie Kirschbaum outlined transit and traffic plans, including bolstered service on key Muni lines (e.g., F Line with double service, 28 and 49 lines with 30–50% more capacity). She noted that Fleet Week's all-day nature and multiple viewing locations spread out demand. SFMTA is coordinating with AV companies to voluntarily restrict operations on certain streets (e.g., Lombard, Van Ness, Embarcadero) but compliance is voluntary. Parking Control Officers will be deployed at key intersections. - Fire Department Assistant Deputy Chief Erica Brown described planning for medical resources, water rescue, and coordination with the Coast Guard. She advocated for increased crowd size estimates and noted that additional EMS resources are being added to maintain citywide coverage. - Police Department Commander Chris DelGandio detailed staffing plans, including mandatory attendance for officers, and joint command posts with real-time communication via Teams. He emphasized lessons learned on traffic enforcement and emergency vehicle access from July 4th. - Rec Park Director of Policy and Public Affairs Beverly Ng reported that the permittee increased porta-potty availability by 20% (to 64 units at Marina Green, plus 14 scattered) in response to lessons learned from summer events. Five park rangers will patrol. - Chair Sheryl's Concerns: Chair Sheryl repeatedly expressed concerns about crowd size estimates, noting that past events (e.g., Red Bull, July 4th) had been significantly underestimated. He urged the city to take ownership of crowd size projections rather than relying solely on event organizers. He stated, "The city needs to take accountability for events... crowd size estimates [should not be] put on the heads of the event organizer." Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Airport Ordinance): Passed unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (Fleet Week Hearing): Motion to file the hearing passed unanimously (3-0). Chair Sheryl stressed the importance of proactive planning and accountability. - Items 3-19 (Settlements): Passed unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full board with a positive recommendation.

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, September 3, 2026, at 4:30 PM. Commissioners President Campbell, Chen, McDonald, McGarry, and So were present; Commissioner Coppel was absent. The meeting covered routine items, director's announcements, general public comment, and four major agenda items: a landmark designation process amendment, the Freedom West redevelopment project, a major modifications request for a Market Street project, and a discretionary review for a Broadway property. Consent Calendar & Commission Matters - Item 3 (1581 Webster Street): Conditional use authorization approved unanimously (5-0) on consent. - Minutes: The commission adopted draft minutes for July 23 and July 30, 2026, unanimously (5-0). - Commission Comments: Commissioner So reported on attending the second annual Chinese Housing Summit in Cantonese, emphasizing community support for taller, denser housing and mixed-use complexes. Director’s Announcements - Director Phillips announced the OpenGov contract moving through the Board of Supervisors ($38 million total, $33 million remaining) to improve permitting. - A management shift: Liz Wadi will focus on Permit SF; Rich Sucre and Kate Connor will oversee current planning. - A warning about a new round of payment scams targeting planning department customers. - The Historic Preservation Commission adopted a comment letter opposing proposed amendments to Section 106 regulations. Public Comments & Testimony - Georgia Shudish expressed concern about Ellis Act evictions and urged the commission to support eliminating the Ellis Act for San Francisco. - Ace Washington (Fillmore Corridor Ambassador) spoke about unfulfilled redevelopment obligations in the Western Addition and urged community involvement in projects like Freedom West. - Richard Sinkoff urged attention to design guidelines and neighborhood character as the city builds more housing. Discussion Item: Landmark and Historic District Designation Amendment (Item 8) - Presentation: Staff presented a proposed ordinance to streamline landmark and historic district designation by allowing the Historic Preservation Commission to initiate and recommend in one hearing, clarifying who may request designation, and removing prescriptive outreach requirements. Staff recommended approval with modifications to include "cultural" terminology. - Supervisor Mandelman’s Office (Renail Bajoy): Supported the ordinance as a modest streamlining that does not reduce scrutiny. - Supervisor Mahmood’s Office (Rain El Cooper): Proposed amendments to require housing capacity analysis, documentation of lost housing potential, and offsets through upzoning or transfer of development rights. They argued landmarking can hinder housing production. - Public Comment: Georgia Shudish supported the ordinance, citing examples of lost historic resources. Ace Washington urged community involvement. - Commission Debate: Commissioner So proposed modifications to: (1) strike the redundant language specifying organizations can initiate (since any member of the public can), (2) add a process to seek property owner consent, and (3) include baseline zoning information in reports. Commissioner Chen seconded a motion with these points. - After several votes, the commission adopted a motion to recommend approval with modifications: (1) amend Section 1004.1A to state “the department or any member of the public may request designation,” (2) direct staff to consider seeking property owner consent without undue burden, and (3) recommend the Board of Supervisors explore transfer of development rights. The motion passed 5-0. Discussion Item: Freedom West Project (Item 9) - Overview: The project is a $3 billion revitalization of a 10-acre co-op community (382 units) in the Fillmore, born from urban renewal. Plans include replacing all co-op units, adding 2,000+ new housing units (including 115 senior affordable units and 133 affordable family units), 1.5+ acres of public open space, a STEM center, and a hotel. A unique 20% profit participation for the co-op in market-rate development ensures long-term economic sustainability. - Presenters: Susan Ma (OEWD) explained the development agreement; Landon Taylor (Legacy First Partners) shared the history and vision; Christopher Bell (DLR Group) detailed design standards and guidelines, including connectivity improvements (Octavia Boulevard extension). - Action: The commission was asked to initiate General Plan amendments (map changes to reflect higher density and mixed-use). Staff recommended setting a hearing on or after October 8, 2026. - Public Comment: Multiple speakers, including Michelle Brown (Freedom West Board) and a long-time resident, expressed strong support, emphasizing the need to reverse displacement and preserve community. - Commission Discussion: All commissioners spoke in favor. Commissioner Chen asked about the conversion of 115 co-op units to senior affordable rental, which will likely revert to co-op after 15 years. President Campbell suggested future flexibility for driverless cars and hotel-to-housing conversion. The motion to initiate and schedule a hearing passed unanimously 5-0. Discussion Item: 2051 Market Street Major Modifications (Item 10) - Project: Demolition of a vacant commercial building and construction of a 7-story, 85-foot-tall, 29-unit mixed-use building with 29 dwelling units (15 one-bedroom, 14 two-bedroom) and 1,554 sq ft retail. The project was previously approved under state density bonus law. The proposed modifications are for a rear yard reduction (to 7 feet instead of 18%) and waiver of a light well requirement, both to preserve unit count and two-bedroom units. - Sponsor Arguments: The project is shovel-ready (site permit issued, BART approval, DPW permits) but economically unfeasible under previous inclusionary rates. Using the new TAC legislation and Housing Choice SF program with an in-lieu fee will make it viable. The modifications are necessary to keep the project financially feasible. - Staff Recommendation: Approve with conditions, finding the project consistent with planning objectives. - Commission Discussion: Commissioners asked about the affordable housing path. The project will pay a 10% in-lieu fee under the new TAC legislation. Commissioners expressed support, noting the project brings much-needed housing to a transit-rich corridor. Motion to approve with conditions passed unanimously 5-0. Discussion Item: Discretionary Review – 1142 Broadway (Item 11) - Project: Addition of a 582 sq ft fourth-story primary suite and roof deck on an existing two-flat condominium. The existing building is a category B property. - DR Requesters: Seth Subrian and another neighbor argued that the addition would cast significant shadows (64% increase on windows), increase noise, and degrade mid-block open space. They cited precedent of commission denying similar fourth-floor additions. - Project Sponsor: Doug Levanci and Kenji Yoko said the modest addition allows them to stay in their home and accommodate aging parents. They reduced the size and height in response to concerns. Architect Devi Dutta Churari showed that the addition is set back 15 feet from the front (per historic resource review) and 18.5 feet from the rear, with a 14-foot gap to the neighbor. - Staff Recommendation: Not take discretionary review, as the project complies with residential design guidelines and modifications were made to mitigate impacts. Staff noted no exceptional circumstances. - Commission Discussion: Commissioner McGarry moved to deny the DR, noting the addition is modest and zoning allows it. Commissioner Campbell asked about the 15-foot setback; staff explained it was for historic preservation but flexibility exists. The motion to not take DR and approve as modified passed unanimously 5-0. Key Outcomes - Landmark Designation Amendment: Recommended approval with three modifications (clarify initiation, consider owner consent, explore TDRs). The board of supervisors will consider the ordinance. - Freedom West Project: Initiated General Plan amendments; a public hearing scheduled for October 8, 2026. The project will return for full approvals later this fall. - 2051 Market Street: Approved major modifications under Housing Choice SF, allowing the project to proceed with an in-lieu fee. Construction expected within months. - 1142 Broadway: Discretionary review denied; the fourth-story addition approved as modified.

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on September 2, 2026, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen and Member Danny Sauter. The meeting featured a lengthy agenda covering items from a nitrous oxide ban to major bond issuances and a controversial contract for a citywide permitting system (Permit SF). The committee took public comment on multiple items and voted on a series of routine approvals, bond sales, and the OpenGov contract extension. Consent Calendar - Item 2: Resolution approving a $9.5 million increase (to $17 million total) for a professional services agreement with Faith Group PMCM2JV for airport commissioning activation and simulation support. Approved unanimously. - Item 3: Resolution approving an $8.4 million increase (to $17 million total) for project management support services with Atkins Realis USA Inc. for airfield improvement. Approved unanimously. - Item 4: Resolution retroactively authorizing DPH to accept a $148,843 grant from the National Institutes of Health for a PrEP blueprint program. Approved with minor amendments. - Item 5: Resolution retroactively authorizing DPH to accept a $204,000 grant from San Francisco Health Plan for community health assessment. Approved unanimously. - Item 6: Resolution retroactively authorizing DPH to accept a $2.3 million grant from San Francisco General Hospital Foundation for the Solid Start perinatal behavioral health program. Approved unanimously. - Items 7-14: Resolutions and ordinances authorizing the issuance and sale of general obligation bonds totaling $423.5 million for health and recovery, earthquake safety, and affordable housing. Approved with amendments (reducing the ESER bond amount from $215 million to $138 million due to project delays). - Items 15-16: Ordinances authorizing the sale of $43 million in certificates of participation (COPs) for parks projects (Jackson Playground, India Basin, etc.) and appropriating proceeds. Approved with an amendment striking a reference to commercial paper. - Items 17-21: Resolutions approving grant agreements for rental subsidies from the Affordable Housing Opportunity Fund, totaling $18.5 million over 15–16 years, for five affordable housing projects (160 Freelon, 3300 Mission, Ambassador Hotel, SOMA Studios, South Park Scattered Sites). Approved with an amendment correcting the fund recipient for Item 19. Public Comments & Testimony - Nitrous Oxide Ban (Item 1): Pete Wilson (TWU Local 250A) expressed support for the ban but raised concerns about lack of union notification and enforcement by health inspectors vs. police. Jamario Jackson (Ecology) supported the ordinance, citing safety hazards from discarded cylinders and disposal costs of up to $20 per cylinder. Robert Sandoval (Teamsters Local 350) strongly supported the ban, noting that canisters explode in collection trucks, endangering workers. A personal testimony from Julia described her severe addiction, including paralysis, burns, and multiple rehab stays, urging the committee to act. - Affordable Housing Subsidies (Items 17-21): Todd LaFroge (TNDC) supported the grants, stating they lower rent burdens and improve financial stability for properties. Caitlin Roth (Related California) thanked the committee for supporting deeper affordability at 160 Freelon. Sarah Davy Dillon (Mission Housing) described the South Park scattered sites as critical for extremely low-income residents and thanked the city for the investment. - OpenGov Contract (Items 22-24): Jerry Gratler expressed support for enterprise software but criticized the OpenGov project for lacking organizational structure and resources, noting the absence of foundational documents and a suitability analysis for DBI. Jessica Newti (Local 21) raised concerns about the procurement process, lack of clarity, and declining service delivery (permits taking 7–10 days instead of same-day). She urged limiting funding to $12 million for year two with additional oversight. Discussion Items - Nitrous Oxide Ban (Item 1): Supervisor Sauter introduced the ordinance, citing a 600% increase in deaths and 500% increase in emergency room visits from nitrous oxide misuse. The item was continued to the call of the chair to allow further meet-and-confer discussions with unions and the Department of Public Health. - Bond Issuances (Items 7-14): Presentations covered health and recovery bonds (DPH and Rec & Park), earthquake safety bonds (SFPUC and DPW), and affordable housing bonds (MOHCD). Key points included a reduction in the ESER bond request due to delays in the emergency firefighting water system pipeline (pipe technology failure and CEQA appeal). The committee discussed market uncertainty, competitive vs. negotiated sale, and debt capacity. The bonds were approved with amendments. - OpenGov Contract Procurement Hearing (Item 23): Supervisor Fielder called the hearing to scrutinize the procurement of the $5.9 million initial contract (and proposed $33 million, five-year extension) with OpenGov for a new permitting system. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) reported that the selection process, while legal, did not follow best practices: no standardized evaluation criteria, no cost comparisons among finalists, and limited conflict-of-interest disclosures. The mayor’s office used a Section 2130 waiver to bypass competitive bidding, citing urgency to meet a one-year timeline. Permit SF Director Elizabeth Wadi defended the process, stating the RFI allowed broad staff input (70 staff, 50 vendors) and that OpenGov was chosen based on track record and delivery speed. Supervisor Fielder questioned the early involvement of Mayor’s policy chief Ned Siegel and potential conflicts due to OpenGov founders’ donations to the Mayor’s foundation. The city purchaser from OCA confirmed the waiver was appropriately granted. After extensive debate, the hearing was continued to the call of the chair. - OpenGov Contract Amendment (Item 22) and Reserve Fund Release (Item 24): Following the procurement hearing, the committee considered the contract amendment to increase the amount by $33.1 million and extend the term five years. The BLA recommended either reducing the contract to $12.1 million (covering year two only) or adding termination-for-convenience provisions. The committee heard that the contract now includes termination-for-convenience rights (negotiated at the chair’s urging). Supervisor Sauter supported the contract, citing speed and innovation. Supervisor Chen opposed, favoring the BLA’s recommendation due to unmet deliverables and staffing concerns. Chair Dorsey expressed support for the goals but noted the contract lacked clear milestones; he moved to forward it without recommendation to the full board for further debate. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Continued to the call of the chair (3-0 vote). - Items 2-6: Approved and forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation (3-0 each). - Items 7-14: Approved as amended (items 9 and 11 amended to reduce ESER bond amount to $138 million) and forwarded with recommendation (3-0). - Items 15-16: Approved as amended (item 16 amended) and forwarded with recommendation (3-0). - Items 17-21: Approved as amended (item 19 amended to correct grantee name) and forwarded with recommendation (3-0). - Item 22 (OpenGov contract amendment): Forwarded to the full board without recommendation (3-0). - Item 23 (Procurement hearing): Continued to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 24 (Release of reserve funds): Approved contingent upon full board approval of Item 22; hearing heard and filed (3-0).

This meeting of the San Francisco Police Commission on September 2, 2026, included discussion of crime trends, disciplinary actions, policy updates, and a major debate on drone surveillance policy (DGO 1012). Commissioners voted on consent calendar items, minutes, and rescinding outdated general orders. The meeting drew significant public comment on community safety, police accountability, and surveillance concerns. Consent Calendar - Received and filed: Police Commission disciplinary actions report (second quarter 2026), SFPD and DPA document protocol report (second quarter 2026), Family Code 6228 report (second quarter 2026), and Safe Streets for All report (second quarter 2026). Motion passed 7-0. - Adopted minutes from June 3, June 10, June 17, July 8, and July 15, 2026, with amendments to correct affiliation of a commenter (SOMA West Neighborhood Association) and to refer to the Street Crisis Response Team (SCRT) instead of CIT. Motion passed 7-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Southern Station Staffing: Sean Auckland (SOMO West Neighborhood Association) stated that Southern Station is receiving only one additional officer while losing four to transfers (net loss of three) ahead of a major boundary expansion effective in 29 days. He reported that Southern's Priority B response times have been 41% longer than the citywide median in August and 92% longer in December, calling it a looming public safety crisis. He requested the topic be agendized. - Harassment Case: A speaker described a years-long harassment case with a criminal undertone, citing case number 260242545, and expressed frustration that no detective was assigned for months. - Trans March & Stud Alley Incident: Multiple speakers requested a town hall to discuss police violence during Pride events on June 26-27, 2026, criticizing the commission's silence and lack of transparency. A speaker referenced a Mission Local article detailing discrepancies between the SFPD report and body camera footage regarding dispersal orders. - Emergency Relocation: A mother requested emergency relocation after her daughter was shot multiple times, stating she no longer feels safe. - Drones (DGO 1012): Several speakers urged a no vote on DGO 1012, citing concerns about mass surveillance, data security (referencing a Wired article about unsecured drone feeds), lack of guardrails, and potential misuse against marginalized communities. Some referenced connections to SkyDio and its contracts with ICE and foreign militaries. - Peer Counselors: Amelia Harman spoke about the removal of peer counselors from the Street Crisis Response Team (SCRT), urging collaboration and presenting a framework for evaluation. - Flock Cameras: Steve Zeltzer (United Front Committee for a Labor Party) demanded removal of Flock cameras, calling them part of a technofascist agenda. - General Public Comment on Chief’s Report: A speaker from SOMO West noted that while citywide crime is down 18%, Southern District homicides increased from zero to five (five of 16 citywide) in a neighborhood with 3% of the city's population. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report: Chief Liu reported part one crime down 18% year-to-date, violent crime down 9%, property crime down 20%, but homicides up to 16 (from 15). He detailed FRET operations (58 arrests) and retail theft blitz operations (19 arrests). Commissioners Benedicto, Scott, and Elias pressed for a town hall with the trans community. Chief Liu expressed concerns about ongoing litigation but agreed to discuss internally and provide an update. Public comment echoed the request for a town hall. - DPA Director’s Report: Director Henderson reported a 29% increase in complaints (first quarter 2026), 155 new cases opened, 174 closed. He noted technology upgrades (automatic confirmation emails, language compliance pamphlets) and ongoing audit of automated license plate readers. - Commission Reports: President Clay and commissioners reported attending community events, station visits, and recruitment efforts. Commissioner Lowe and Vice President Techie discussed community engagement strategies. President Clay announced plans to develop performance evaluation metrics for the chief and DPA director. - Serious Incident Review Board (SIRB): Lieutenant Springer presented three cases: one officer-involved shooting (July 2024, suspect fired first, officer found in policy), and two accidental discharges (both found not in policy for firearm safety). No in-custody deaths reviewed this quarter. - Disciplinary Review Board (DRB): IAD and DPA presented top allegations: neglect of duty (14 allegations), conduct unbecoming (11), and body-worn camera failures (19 for DPA; 12 for IAD). Policy failures included unclear language in DGO 6.09 (domestic violence vs. court orders) and parking violations. A balaclava mask issue was already corrected via Department Notice. Discussion on improving feedback loops for crime victims and body-worn camera compliance. - Sparks Report: Aja Steves (SFPD Policy Development) and Dr. Carolyn Coles (new implementation science expert) provided updates on DGOs in progress, including the upcoming working group on DGO 810 (First Amendment activities). DPA’s Sharon Wu reported on policy work, including revisions to DGO 6.09 and the OIS policy. Commissioner Benedicto and others welcomed the evidence-based approach. - DGO 1012 – Drones: Aja Steves introduced amendments (definitions of general surveillance, authorized uses, prohibited uses) in response to a letter from the Public Defender’s Office. Captain Jonas provided background on federal, state, and local authorization. Commissioners Benedicto and Elias raised concerns about insufficient community engagement and legal questions. Public comment overwhelmingly opposed, citing security breaches (Wired article), lack of guardrails, and constitutional rights. Commissioner Leong proposed a schedule: all written input due by September 30, response by October 7, reconsideration at the October 14 meeting. No motion to advance was made; the item was tabled. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar and minutes adopted unanimously. - Chief Liu agreed to discuss a town hall with the trans community internally and provide an update at a future meeting. - Performance evaluation metrics for chief and DPA director to be developed with community input. - DGO 1012 was tabled for further public input and legal review. Schedule: written comments due by September 30, responses due October 7, reconsideration at the October 14 meeting. - Motion to rescind DGOs 1.02, 3.04, 5.09, 6.08, 6.11, 6.12, 6.18, and 9.03 passed 7-0. - Vote to move into closed session (item 14) passed 6-0 with one recusal.

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Tuesday, September 1, 2026, with all 11 members present. The board approved prior minutes, passed 22 landmark designations, took up street tree legislation, honored a veterans organization, heard a tentative parcel map appeal, received public comment, accepted legislation introductions, and adopted a series of resolutions. Consent Calendar - Approved the June 30, July 7, and July 14, 2026 meeting minutes as presented (11-0). - Passed Items 1-22, 22 ordinances designating landmarks across San Francisco, on final passage (11-0). - Accepted the Hunters View HOPE SF Phase 2 street and public infrastructure, official right-of-way widths and grades, sidewalk widths, and related easements; the ordinance was finally passed without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - No public speakers came forward during the Folsom Street appeal in support of or opposition to the appeal. - During general public comment, multiple speakers urged the board to declare an 'AI emergency' and ban further development of frontier AI. They cited risks from OpenAI, Anthropic, autonomous hacking incidents, and statements by AI experts. Speakers included Wend Kaufman, Phoebe Thomas, Bill Lowe, Dwight, Jeanette Scott, Guido Reichstadter, and Derek Allen. Richard S.D. Peterson opposed a city AI emergency declaration, saying it would be ineffective and more appropriate for litigation. - Richard Johnson, co-founder of HVSA, described about 90 weeks of documentation by Hayes Valley residents and merchants about a recurring Hayes Street closure, and said there was no meaningful administrative appeal or independent review; he asked the board to examine the accountability gap. - Amelia, speaking from District 9 in her individual capacity, asked the board to retain peer counselors on the Street Crisis Response Team, reporting 55 new letters of support and 125 total letters representing every district. - Jim Nakhovie raised concerns that the controller's office had not defined policies or provided the first semi-annual report for the inspector general's office. - Taiwo said police had not assigned an investigator to his complaint about people allegedly using technology to harass him, citing police case number 260242. - Other comments covered AI risk, vaccine-safety views, unsafe streets for seniors, and Chinese EV battery standards. Special Order - Commendations - Supervisor Wong recognized Vet Boats for veteran support through therapeutic sailing and boat restoration during Suicide Prevention Month. Matt Gettelman accepted, saying Vet Boats is a veteran-founded organization 14 years old, that a veteran dies by suicide every 21 seconds in the United States, and that 96 cents of every donated dollar goes directly to veterans. Discussion Items - Street Tree Standards, Appeals, and Adopt-A-Tree Fund (Item 24): The ordinance would allow development projects to satisfy street tree planting requirements through in-lieu fees or alternative landscaping, exempt accessory dwelling units from street tree requirements, remove appeals to the Board of Appeals for hazardous tree removals by city departments, create a separate account for in-lieu fees in the Adopt-A-Tree Fund, and update related codes. It passed on first reading 7-4. - Supervisor Sauter voted no, arguing the city should focus on maintaining and pruning existing trees and finding sustainable funding for new planting. - Supervisor Melgar supported it, rejecting claims that it would hurt the tree canopy, and said the city's actual planting cost is about $2,600 per tree rather than the $4,000-$6,000 reported in the press. - Supervisor Fielder voted no, citing the loss of appeals for city tree removals and possible harm to neighborhoods with less canopy. - Supervisor Mahmood supported the amended version, noting his amendment preserved a second review by the director of public works for hazard tree removals; he cited a case where four of seven Waller Street ficus trees were preserved after a petition with more than 800 signatures. - David Moore, superintendent of the Bureau of Urban Forestry, testified about managing 125,000 street trees, said the first round of street tree pruning is expected by the end of 2026, and described a $12 million grant for 3,500 trees and a plan to fill 2,000 vacant planting sites. - Appeal of Tentative Parcel Map, 2722-2724 Folsom Street (Items 25-28): Appellant Samuel Ray, for the owners, argued that the planning department's condition barring final map approval until all planning code violations are abated had no legal or factual basis, that no notice of violation had been issued, and that the condition conflicted with Article 6 of the settlement agreement. Public Works surveyor Elias French said the tentative map was processed correctly and the condition was consistent with the MAP Act and general plan consistency requirements. Planning Zoning Administrator Corey Teague said the property has an open enforcement case from 2021 and the condition was necessary because the planning department must find general plan consistency before final map approval. In rebuttal, Ray said the 2021 enforcement case concerned front exterior stairs, not an unauthorized dwelling unit, and that a permit suspension referenced a floor plan discrepancy. Supervisor Fielder moved to approve the public works decision and tentative map and to table the disapproval and findings items; the board voted 11-0 to approve Item 26 and table Items 27 and 28. Legislation Introduced at Roll Call - Supervisor Chen introduced a resolution commending KTSF for 50 years of Asian-language and multiethnic programming. - Supervisor Fielder introduced an ordinance to prevent landlords from evicting tenants who fall behind in rent unless the tenant owes an amount higher than the fair market rent, citing evictions at a 10-year high, nonpayment behind over half of eviction proceedings, and about 25% of sampled nonpayment evictions involving less than one month of fair market rent. He also introduced a KALW Day resolution for the station's 85th anniversary. - Supervisor Mandelman introduced an ordinance to extend legal nonconforming rear yard structure eligibility to structures built before 2010. - Supervisor Sauter announced a Budget and Legislative Analyst report on surplus public land: more than 100 properties, about 6.2 million square feet, were screened, with 44 vacant or soon-to-be vacant properties possibly suitable for affordable housing or other development. She submitted a hearing request for a coordinated citywide approach. - Supervisor Wong introduced resolutions supporting the AV Emergency Response Coordination Act and Assembly Bill 2540, and said formula retail regulations should be updated. - Supervisor Chan introduced the Small Business Tenants Union and the Workers' Opportunity to Purchase Act, plus a resolution urging CalEPA to suspend proposed grant-eligibility matrix changes for vulnerable urban census tracts. Key Outcomes - Approved minutes and 22 landmark designations, and accepted Hunters View HOPE SF infrastructure, as noted above. - Passed Item 24 on first reading by 7-4, with Supervisors Chan, Fielder, Sauter, and Walton voting no. - Approved Item 26 and tabled Items 27 and 28 for the 2722-2724 Folsom Street parcel map appeal (11-0). - Adopted Items 31 and 32 (the resolution urging Kaiser Permanente to drop the 'Terrible Three' contract demands and the World Hepatitis Day resolution) by 10-0, with Supervisor Melgar absent; Supervisor Wong added his name as co-sponsor to Item 31. - Adopted Item 33, declaring September 2026 as National Service Dog Month, after Supervisor Sherrill severed it from the without-reference calendar; adopted without objection. - Adjourned in memory of Vivian Ann Hopkins, as submitted by Supervisor Walton.

Note: The agenda and transcript indicate the meeting was held on August 11, 2026, but the user-provided timestamp is August 12, 2026. This summary uses the latter date as instructed. The Port Commission convened to hear an extensive executive director’s report, approve four consent calendar items, receive informational updates on the Pier 70 28‑acre site project and the Waterfront Resilience Program’s coastal flood study, and authorize an exemption from Administrative Code Chapter 29 for resilience projects. Commissioners welcomed new member Vanessa Tapia Hardigan, recognized Transgender History Month, and adjourned in memory of victims of a recent boating accident. Consent Calendar - Resolution 26‑40: Second Amendment and fee waiver for License No. 17173 with Pacific Cruise Ship Terminals LLC for 20,000 sq. ft. at Pier 19.5 for terminal worker parking during cruise calls at Pier 27. (Approved unanimously) - Resolution 26‑41: No‑fee License No. 17484 with CP Development Co., LLC for 36,300 sq. ft. of non‑contiguous land within the Candlestick Point Development site for an eight‑year term after cost recovery. (Approved unanimously) - Resolution 26‑42: Modification of Contract No. 2894 (Fisherman’s Wharf Forward – Taylor Street Public Plaza) increasing contract value by $250,000 and extending substantial completion by 18 days. (Approved unanimously) - Resolution 26‑43: Naming the new plaza on Taylor Street (Wharf J1) “Alioto’s Plaza,” consistent with the Port’s Recognition and Commemoration policy. (Approved unanimously) Public Comments & Testimony - Captain Maggie Hallahan: Expressed concern about the lack of REC‑1 water testing in areas where kayaking and stand‑up paddleboarding are allowed, urging the Port to create and publish new test zones so that communities and youth can safely use the water. - Lisa Jennison (public comment on Pier 70): Asked for clarification on the proposed reduction of affordable housing from 30% to no less than 20% and the increase of 600 total units via height waivers. - Public comment on resilience (Pier 68): A speaker (unidentified) urged testing of Pier 68 for toxicity and cleanup costs, suggesting a Superfund designation could bring federal funding; referenced past cleanup issues at Hunters Point. - Alice Rogers (President, South Beach / Rincon Hill / Mission Bay Neighborhood Association): Voiced strong support for the Waterfront Resilience Program, noting that a similar presentation was well‑received at a neighborhood meeting and that the community appreciates the ongoing work. Discussion Items Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A) - Michael Martin reported on: the Blue Economy Initiative’s first networking event (70 attendees); eight leasing applications received in one month; next month’s Pier 70 music festival (Pier Play San Francisco) at Elevation Sky Park; the San Francisco Historium Spotlight at Pier 35 (August 22‑23); Mission Rock Phase One winning a 2026 ULI Americas Award for Excellence; the Mission Bay Ferry Landing construction contract awarded (completion expected late 2027/early 2028); and the Illinois Street Parking Access Project to add 60 spaces. - Commissioner McNeely praised the Blue Economy outreach and asked about potential incubator space. Martin replied that the Port is using a “locationless incubator” approach and will consider a dedicated space as the program matures. McNeely also asked about ferry service; Martin stated SF Bay Ferry intends to start with event service and transition to commuter service. - Commissioner Adams celebrated the “reset” in San Francisco under the new mayor and stressed the need for affordable housing to keep the city inclusive. He also expressed sympathy for victims of the recent boating accident; Martin noted the Port is working to restore the Hyde Street fuel dock for emergency responders. - Commissioner Lee expressed excitement about the “new gold rush” of activity. - Commissioner Tapia Hardigan thanked the staff and noted the importance of financial innovation to fund resilience. - President Engblom suggested inviting former commissioners to a future meeting and formally requested staff to continue work on a financial innovation lab. Pier 70 28‑Acre Site Project Update (Item 11A) – Informational Only - Christine Maher (Port project manager) and Tim Bacon (Brookfield Properties) presented proposed amendments to the Disposition and Development Agreement (DDA) to accelerate Phase 1 vertical development and improve project feasibility. - Key proposed changes: - Adjust the project‑wide affordable housing rate from 30% to no less than 20% (aligning with the current city‑wide 5% inclusionary rate, but with 327 standalone affordable units remaining constant). - Increase height on certain residential parcels from 65 to 90 feet (the maximum allowed by the 2014 ballot measure), enabling at least 600 new homes. - Write off $50 million of the developer’s Phase 1 return; reduce the ongoing return from 18% to 14%. - Reallocate parcels between phases and introduce sub‑phasing to tie infrastructure delivery to market demand. - Align impact fees with current city policy and allow condos on residential parcels. - Commissioner McNeely asked about the effective inclusionary rate; Wyatt Donnelly‑Lentold (Port assistant deputy director) clarified the citywide rate is now 5% based on a controller’s study showing no housing pencils at higher rates. - No commission action was taken; the item was informational only. Staff will return for final approvals later in 2026 or early 2027. Waterfront Resilience Program – Coastal Flood Study (Item 12A) – Informational Only - Brad Benson (Waterfront Resilience Program Director) presented the partnership with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers on the San Francisco Waterfront Coastal Flood Study, published in the Federal Register on July 31, 2026. - Key facts: The study covers 100 years (2040‑2140); damages of up to $23 billion in a no‑action scenario; up to 6% of the city’s most developed land could be lost by century’s end. There is a 72% chance of a major earthquake in the next 30 years. - The recommended plan includes $17.8 billion in coastal flood defenses (seawall elevation, floodproofing, “engineering with nature” features) to be implemented over 30 years. The first action would be south of the Ferry Building. - The Port is issuing RFPs for two design contracts totaling $115 million over 10 years (northern and southern waterfront). - Commissioner McNeely raised concerns about federal political headwinds (climate‑related funding). Benson noted the Army Corps has been relatively insulated and the Water Resources Development Act (WRDA) remains bipartisan. Commissioner Adams urged a broad coalition (Chamber, labor, environmentalists) to secure congressional support. - President Engblom highlighted the need for financial innovation to attract private capital and said the Port is working with the Mayor’s Office on a city committee. Waterfront Resilience – Chapter 29 Exemption (Item 12B) – Action - Debian Jain and Helen (Port staff) requested authorization to submit an ordinance to the Board of Supervisors exempting publicly‑funded resilience projects from San Francisco Administrative Code Chapter 29 (fiscal feasibility study requirements). - The exemption would avoid 6‑9 month delays per report, saving an estimated $31‑$110 million per year in delay costs, and allow CEQA review to begin, making projects more competitive for federal/state funding. - The Board previously granted similar exemptions to SFMTA and SFPUC. - Resolution 26‑44 was moved, seconded, and approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Resolutions 26‑40 through 26‑43 were adopted unanimously. - Pier 70 Update: No vote; staff to return after further negotiation and public outreach for final approvals. - Chapter 29 Exemption: Resolution 26‑44 approved unanimously; ordinance will be submitted to the Board of Supervisors in fall 2026. - New Business: Commissioners requested (a) inviting former commissioners to the next meeting, (b) continued work on a financial innovation lab, and (c) a dredging analysis update in October 2026. - The meeting was adjourned at 5:02 p.m. in memory of Clifford Bosa (79), Carol Bosa (74), Tandra Magruga (58), and a dog who died in the August 2026 boating accident.

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, July 30, 2026, and conducted a full agenda. The Commission welcomed three new members (Commissioners Michael Chen, Elizabeth McDonald, and Joel Coppel) and bid farewell to outgoing Commissioner Derek Braun. All votes during the meeting were unanimous (6-0 or 5-0 where recusals applied). The Commission approved continuances, consent calendar items, and considered major planning code amendments, a development impact fee report, and a discretionary review. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (871 De Haro Street): Continued to September 17, 2026, by a 6-0 vote. - Item 2 (2071 Union Street): Conditional use authorization approved on consent (6-0). - Item 3 (1649 Divisadero Street): Commissioner Chen recused himself due to a potential conflict; the item was approved on consent by the remaining five commissioners (5-0). Commission Matters - Welcome to New Commissioners: Each new commissioner introduced themselves: Joel Coppel (IBEW Local 6, now with San Francisco Electrical Contractors Association), Michael Chen (housing advocate, former public commenter), and Elizabeth McDonald (former UC Berkeley professor of city and regional planning, public realm expert). - Farewell to Commissioner Derek Braun: President Campbell, Commissioner So, and Commissioner McGarry praised his thorough preparation, thoughtfulness, and love for San Francisco. Director Phillips presented him with a planning department bag. Director’s Announcements - Lulu Huang Proclamation: Special recognition for Lulu Huang, who retired after 43 years as the longest-tenured planning staff member. The Commission issued a proclamation honoring her contributions to digital and OASIS teams. - Board of Supervisors Update: Staff reported that the Land Use and Transportation Committee forwarded the street tree standards ordinance to the full board, continued the landmark designation for the Compton’s Cafeteria riot site, and passed several landmark designations. The full board approved the Hotels in RH Districts ordinance and House of Latin Rock landmark designation. General Public Comment - Former Commissioner Derek Braun expressed gratitude to colleagues and staff, highlighting the commission’s work on equity, housing, transportation, and land use. - Mr. Washington (Fillmore Corridor Ambassador) strongly opposed the Fillmore Community Action Plan, alleging lack of community input and calling for the plan to be sent back to the drawing board. He stated the process felt exclusionary and referenced historical urban renewal as “Negro removal.” - Georgia Shudish (Noe Valley resident, 47-year resident) raised concerns about the HCSF (Homeownership and Community Stabilization) program, noting that projects on small lots (2,500 square feet) could become “needles” with impacts on neighbors. She requested proactive community liaison and attention to construction impacts, especially under streamlining. She also referenced a Wall Street Journal article about upcoming housing units. Discussion Items Item 7: Signs in Mixed Use Districts [BF 260679] - Presented by: Veronica Flores and Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey’s office). The ordinance increases signage allowances on parcels over half an acre in Mixed Use Districts, particularly in the Mixed-Use Office District south of Townsend Street. - Key changes: Allows additional wall signs up to 80 square feet and 80 feet in height (corrected from staff report’s mention of 60-foot limit for urban mixed use districts), with backlighting rather than direct illumination. - Public comment: Tom Tunney (Ruben & Junius) strongly supported, noting a 250,000 square-foot tenant (Sierra AI) that needs appropriate signage. - Commission deliberation: Commissioner McGarry supported for flexibility and uniformity. Commissioner So asked about lighting (confirmed indirect backlighting). Commissioner McDonald inquired about sign height measured from grade. President Campbell expressed support but noted the ordinance is essentially limited to one building and encouraged broader application. Madison Tam indicated the supervisor could consider broader policy. The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to recommend approval. Item 8: Commercial to Residential Adaptive Reuse - Presented by: Lily Langua and Madison Tam. The ordinance exempts adaptive reuse projects downtown from certain parking, loading, street frontage, FAR, and car share requirements to address physical constraints of existing buildings. - Staff modifications: Four modifications recommended, including waiving bike parking only when no accessory off-street parking is provided, waiving street frontage only if ground-floor parking is proposed, technical consolidation of loading provisions, and allowing retained existing parking to serve new residential uses without triggering additional requirements. - Public comment: Jack and Mark Babson (Emerald Fund) supported, citing a pending application at 150 Hayes Street (100+ units) that became feasible thanks to the program. - Commission deliberation: Commissioner McDonald raised concern about ground-floor interface with the public; staff clarified active use requirements remain. Commissioner Coppel praised the city’s work on recovering downtown. President Campbell commended the city’s comprehensive incentives. The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to recommend approval with modifications. Item 9: Office Development Annual Limit Program – Revocation and Allocation Policies - Presented by: Corey Teague (Zoning Administrator). The policy establishes a three-tier system for revoking office allocations from projects that have not commenced construction, and sets priorities for future allocations. - Tier 1: Projects past performance period with no progress – schedule revocation hearings after recess (Sept/Oct 2026). - Tier 2: Projects with some progress (e.g., permits issued but not under construction) – 18 months to show progress. - Tier 3: Projects with development agreements or public benefits already delivered – revocation at conclusion of each DA phase or as appropriate. - New priorities: Future allocations will prioritize projects including affordable housing, those already shovels-ready, or sponsors who voluntarily forfeited past allocations. - Public comment: None. - Commission deliberation: Commissioner So acknowledged the difficult situation and urged fairness; asked about port projects (2.5 million sq. ft.) and whether they could be tracked separately (answer: would require voter approval to change Prop M). Commissioner Campbell asked about potential volume of tier one projects; Director Phillips noted active conversations with sponsors. Commissioner McDonald asked if office-to-residential conversions restore allocation to the cap (partially, under Prop C). The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to adopt the policy. Items 10a-d: Potrero Power Station Mixed-Use Project – Amendments to Development Agreement, SUD, and D4D - Presented by: Monica Giacomucci (Planning), John Lau (OEWD), and project sponsor Fifth Space. The package of amendments increases flexibility in land use, heights (8 feet on residential blocks, 15-30 feet on commercial blocks), parking limits, and community benefit delivery, while preserving 30% affordable housing (minimum 2,600 units), library, YMCA, grocery, and other benefits. - Three substantive modifications since staff report: (1) Allowing above-grade parking structures in SUD; (2) Clarifications to transportation plan (bus shelter, TDM, shuttle bus tied to second-to-last building in Phase 1/2); (3) TDM plan modifications. - Public comment: Benwell Rodriguez (YMCA) supported, noting flexibility for child care and community facilities. One general public comment requested transparency in affordable housing data and addressed housing costs. - Commission deliberation: Commissioners expressed strong support, highlighting the project’s scale, commitment to affordability, and public benefits. Commissioner So praised the accelerated phasing and historic waterfront access. Commissioner Coppel noted the risk and complexity. Commissioner McDonald appreciated the public realm. President Campbell requested the sponsor elaborate on phasing, land use flexibility, and street wall adjustments—they explained bringing forward parcels not dependent on PG&E, modest height increases for commercial footplates, and flexible child care delivery. The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to recommend approval of all three documents with modifications read into the record. Item 11: Development Impact Fee Report for Fiscal Years Ending 2025 - Presented by: Matt Snyder. The annual report covers 38 development impact fees, their revenues, expenditures, and fund balances, as required by the Mitigation Fee Act. A typo on page 61 was corrected (TSF expenditure corrected to $86,749,216). - Public comment: None. - Commission deliberation: Commissioner McDonald suggested including more visual celebrations of completed projects in future reports. The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to accept the report and adopt findings. Item 12: 646 Duncan Street – Discretionary Review - Staff presentation: Trent Green. The project proposes interior renovations, horizontal and vertical additions (third floor), and a rear deck on a Category A historic resource. Due to preservation requirements, the third floor was set back 15 feet from the front, concentrating massing near the rear. The project sponsor voluntarily provided a 4-foot side setback. The DR requester (neighbor at 652 Duncan) claimed the configuration impacts light and air on their habitable rooms. - DR requester (representative): Requested reconsideration to shift some massing forward to reduce rear impact, noting an earlier design with a 7.5-foot side setback was rejected by planning. - Project sponsor: Explained that preservation staff required the current configuration; they already provided voluntary setbacks and were willing to mediate, but the DR applicant was not open to compromise. - Public comment: None. - Commission deliberation: Commissioner Chen questioned the process of discovering historic status mid-application, expressing concern about transparency for homeowners. Staff clarified that preservation review required the setback. The Commission found no extraordinary circumstances and voted unanimously (6-0) not to take discretionary review, approving the project as proposed. Key Outcomes - All agenda items were approved or adopted unanimously: Item 1 continued; Items 2, 3 on consent; Items 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12 all passed 6-0 (or 5-0 with recusal). - The Commission adopted a resolution recommending approval of the Signs in Mixed Use Districts ordinance with modifications. - The Commission adopted a resolution recommending approval of the Commercial to Residential Adaptive Reuse ordinance with staff modifications. - The Commission adopted a policy establishing a three-tier revocation system for office development allocations and new allocation priorities. - The Commission recommended approval of amendments to the Potrero Power Station Development Agreement, Special Use District, and Design for Development Document with modifications read into the record. - The Commission accepted the Development Impact Fee Report for FY2025. - The Commission declined to take discretionary review and approved the project at 646 Duncan Street. - The Commission recognized outgoing Commissioner Derek Braun and honored Lulu Huang for 43 years of service.