Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 691–700 ENTRIES
691
JUN 11, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting Summary: June 11, 2024

The San Francisco Port Commission met on June 11, 2024, to address waterfront management, activation, and resilience. The meeting featured an extensive Executive Director's report that celebrated Pride Month and Juneteenth on the Waterfront, recognized three retiring staff members (Alan Jin, David Wu, Dan Hodap), and honored outgoing Commissioner Ed Harrington. The Commission unanimously approved the consent calendar (with the exception of one item voted on separately), debated and approved an amended grant for the Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefit District to activate the Little Embarcadero, and received an informational presentation on the San Francisco Waterfront Coastal Flood Study. Consent Calendar - Approved Items (10A-E): The Commission approved resolutions for a hazardous materials management contract (10A), Harbor Traffic Code amendments at Mission Rock (10B), a sole source grant to the Smithsonian Environmental Research Center for the Living Seawall Pilot Project (10C), a no-fee license with Pacific Cruise Ship Terminals LLC (10D), and a five-month fee waiver for commercial salmon and Dungeness crab fisheries (10E) to address economic disruption from fishery closures. - Item 10F Deferred for Separate Vote: The Commission removed Mission Bay Parks acceptance (10F) from the consent calendar to adopt revised language regarding the park improvements and acceptance process. - Public Comment on Consent: Representatives from the local fishing industry testified in support of the fishery relief. Jeanette Kaido (Kaido Fisheries) expressed support for the relief but requested the port consider including fish processors in the program. John Barnett (Crab Boat Owners Association) and Larry Collins (San Francisco Community Fishing Association) expressed gratitude for the relief, with Collins detailing hardships caused by "gross mismanagement" by the federal government. - Outcome: Resolutions 2425-2429 (10A-E) were approved unanimously. Resolution 2430 (10F) was approved unanimously with the introduced amendments. President Brandon directed staff to explore expanding the fishery relief to include fish processors. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Item 9A): Executive Director Elaine Forbes provided a wide-ranging report, including Pride Month celebrations, the Juneteenth on the Waterfront event (featuring 17 food and 10 retail vendors), a new Thomas J. Price sculpture, summer internship programs, and the Heron's Head Park Coastal Erosion Project receiving a civil grand jury award. The report notably included heartfelt tributes to retiring staff Alan Jin (17 years at port), David Wu (17.5 years), and Dan Hodap (26 years), as well as departing Commissioner Ed Harrington. Commissioners expressed deep gratitude for their service and highlighted the importance of equity, design excellence, and collaboration. - Little Embarcadero Activation Project (Item 11A): Staff presented a proposal to amend the Fisherman's Wharf CBD grant by reallocating $400,000 and adding $1,032,200 to fund a $1.4 million first-year activation program. The project features pergolas, container kiosks, seating, and art murals to beautify the area, deter unpermitted vending, and draw visitors. Several public speakers representing Pier 39, Boudin Bakery, Red and White Fleet, and San Francisco Travel expressed strong support. Commissioners Lee and Gilman raised concerns about enforcement coordination and long-term funding sustainability. Staff confirmed the funding is from federal stimulus and that a sustainable funding model is necessary for future years. Resolution 2431 was approved unanimously. - Waterfront Coastal Flood Study (Item 12A): Staff provided an informational update on the draft $13.5 billion feasibility study. They highlighted robust community engagement with 14 public events, 970 participants, and over 50 briefings. Key public feedback included a strong desire for nature-based solutions, health concerns over contamination, and questions about the study area limits. The City's formal comment letter emphasized closing the Yosemite Slough gap, addressing inland drainage risks, and managing contaminated sites. The next milestone is the Army Corps Agency Decision milestone at the end of June 2024. Key Outcomes - Fleet Relief Expansion Directed: Staff were directed by the Commission to explore adding fish processors to the commercial fishery relief package and return with a proposal. - Little Embarcadero Activation Approved: Resolution 2431 authorized the CBD grant amendment, moving forward with the summer activation project. - Mission Bay Parks Acceptance: Resolution 2430 was formally adopted, completing the acceptance of Parks P19 and P22. - New Business Directions: Staff were directed to update the Commission on past and future congressional community funding requests and develop an equitable approach to the kiosk selection process for the Little Embarcadero project. The meeting was adjourned. No meeting minutes were provided alongside the agenda and transcript.

PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 19% · PROCEDURAL 16% · LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 16% · PUBLIC WORKS 12%
692
JUN 11, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - June 11, 2024

This regular meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors occurred on June 11, 2024, at 10:15 AM (UTC). The board considered a consent agenda of routine items, heard from Mayor London Breed on a proposed bond, debated the reappointment of Police Commissioner Deborah Walker, approved numerous resolutions and labor agreements, and introduced an imperative charter amendment regarding the Student Success Fund. Public comment was heard on language access, transgender sanctuary, and worker rights. The meeting adjourned after approximately three hours. Consent Calendar - Items 1–15 were approved unanimously without objection. These included ordinances on the Language Access Ordinance, SFPUC budgets and bond issuances, building fees, lawsuit settlements, planning code amendments (Wawona Street Cultural Center SUD, Divisadero Street NCD, landmark designation, parklet treatment), and surveillance technology policy. - Items 16–35 were adopted on a single vote (same house, same call) without discussion. These included fee waivers for neighborhood events, COVID-19 lease extensions for airport concessions, retroactive grants for election security and accessibility, an SFMTA agreement with Friends of the Cable Car Museum, a Meals on Wheels grant ($49.7M), a security guard contract ($33.8M), a Sunnydale HOPE SF infrastructure loan ($52.4M), overdose reduction program agreements, refugee housing grants for Ukrainians, a housing incentive program grant ($3.2M), a grant for an LGBTQ history museum ($5.5M), SFPUC water revenue bonds (up to $1.04B), and the Local Coastal Program amendment. Public Comments & Testimony - Language Access (items 79 and general): Multiple speakers, including representatives from the Filipino Community Center, Chinese for Affirmative Action, Arab Resource and Organizing Center, and South of Market Community Action Network, urged the board to reaffirm commitment to language access. They cited challenges faced by limited-English-proficient residents in accessing city services, housing, and public safety, and called for increased bilingual staffing and funding for community-based translation services. - Alcatraz City Cruises Workers (item 76): Several deckhands and a retired union member spoke in support of a resolution urging Hornblower Group to negotiate a fair contract with Inland Boatmen’s Union members. They described low wages ($19/hr), delay tactics, and an attempt to hire replacement workers during a strike, and requested the board's endorsement. - Transgender Sanctuary City (item 75): Members of the trans community, including the director of the Office of Transgender Initiatives and staff from trans-led organizations, spoke in strong support of the resolution declaring San Francisco a sanctuary city for transgender, gender non-conforming, non-binary, and two-spirit people. They highlighted increased demand for services from asylum seekers and the importance of protecting trans immigrants. - Women's Housing and Survivors: Representatives from the San Francisco Women’s Housing Coalition urged the board to expedite release of Notices of Funding Availability (NOFA) for housing for survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault, and human trafficking, funded by the March 2024 bond. - Other: A veteran called for peace and community unity; a speaker advocated for an end to corruption; a parent discussed education and bilingual programs. Discussion Items - Mayor's Appearance (2:00 PM Special Order): Mayor London Breed addressed the board regarding a proposed General Obligation bond for the November 2024 ballot. She highlighted amendments investing over $104.5 million in capital improvements at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital and Laguna Honda Hospital, and funding for economic revitalization including Harvey Milk Plaza and Powell Street Station improvements. She thanked supervisors for collaboration. President Peskin noted the bond would be filed after public comment. - Police Commission Reappointment – Deborah Walker (Item 36): Supervisor Dorsey moved to amend a motion to reject the mayor's reappointment of Commissioner Walker by changing “reject” to “approve.” A lengthy debate ensued. Supporters (Dorsey, Melgar, Mandelman, Stefani) praised Walker's decades of service, her work on LGBTQ+ issues and the “30 by 30” initiative to increase female police officers. Opponents (Walton, Ronen, Preston) argued that Walker's public statements questioning the police commission's role in setting policy and her stance on pretext stops undermined civilian oversight. After an amendment vote (7-3 in favor), the item as amended passed 7-3, with Supervisors Preston, Ronen, and Walton voting no. Commissioner Walker addressed the board, reaffirming her belief in civilian oversight and her work on discipline and policy. - Police Commission Appointment – C. Don Clay (Item 37): Approved 10-0 on roll call. - Other Appointments (Items 38–40): Jayshawn Anderson to Sanitation and Streets Commission approved unanimously. Jessica Campos to Child Care Planning Council approved. For the Our City, Our Home Oversight Committee, Supervisor Mandelman divided the question; Shanell Williams was approved on a voice vote, while the remaining three (Kenzia Villias-Martinis, Julia D’Antonio, Jennifer Friedenbach) were approved 7-4 after debate about differences in policy approach. - Labor Agreements (Items 41–69): A list of 29 MOUs and collective bargaining agreements with various unions, effective July 1, 2024 through June 30, 2027, was approved 11-0. Supervisor Preston commended the bargaining teams. - Panda Bear Donation Waiver (Item 70): Resolution to authorize solicitation of donations for hosting pandas at the SF Zoo, amended in committee to add transparency. Passed 9-2, with Supervisors Peskin and Ronen voting no. - Children’s Funding Resolution (Item 71): Urging restoration of $25M cut to DCYF through private donations, adopted 11-0. - Student Success Fund Charter Amendment (Imperative Item): Supervisor Ronen introduced a motion to waive the deadline to introduce a charter amendment clarifying that the Student Success Fund (passed 2022) cannot be counted against the children’s baseline. She explained the fund was meant to be additive and that its inclusion in baseline was a recent discovery. Supervisor Melgar seconded, noting it was unintentionally shortchanging children. The board voted 11-0 to adopt the imperative motion, allowing introduction. - Commendations (2:30 PM Special Order): Recognitions were given to: - DEM IT team for completing the 911 dispatch center renovation on time and on budget ($12.3M project, adding 5 workstations, completed Feb 2024). - Michael Boland, Chief Park Officer at the Presidio Trust, for 34 years of service including Chrissy Field and Tunnel Tops. - Dr. Susan Ehrlich, CEO of Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital, for her leadership through COVID and beyond. Key Outcomes - Consent agenda (Items 1–35): All passed unanimously. - Police Commission Reappointment (Item 36): Motion to approve Deborah Walker passed 7-3 (Chan, Dorsey, Engardio, Mandelman, Melgar, Peskin, Stefani voted aye; Preston, Ronen, Walton voted no). - Police Commission Appointment (Item 37): C. Don Clay approved 10-0. - Other Appointments: Jayshawn Anderson and Jessica Campos approved. For Our City, Our Home Oversight Committee: Shanell Williams approved; remaining three approved 7-4. - Labor Agreements (Items 41–69): Approved 11-0. - Panda Bear Donation Waiver (Item 70): Adopted 9-2. - DCYF Funding Resolution (Item 71): Adopted 11-0. - Imperative Item – Student Success Fund Charter Amendment: Motion to waive deadline adopted 11-0, allowing introduction of a charter amendment. - Resolutions (Items 74–85, except 75 and 79): Adopted unanimously. Item 75 (Trans Sanctuary City) adopted as amended; Item 79 (Language Access) adopted. - Adjournment: Meeting adjourned at approximately 6:15 PM local time (after 4 hours of proceedings).

PROCEDURAL 21% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 18% · LANGUAGE ACCESS 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7%
693
JUN 11, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - June 11, 2024

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on June 11, 2024, to discuss the Water Enterprise Capital Improvement Program, the Alternative Water Supply Program, and several contract awards. Commissioners heard extensive public testimony on water supply planning, river flows, and rate impacts. They approved the consent calendar, a construction contract, contract amendments for natural resources services, and the 2024 Wildfire Mitigation Plan. The meeting also included a closed session on litigation. Consent Calendar - The Commission unanimously approved the consent calendar (items 6A–6D) with no discussion or public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 4): Multiple speakers addressed the Commission: - A community member from Bayview Hunters Point urged the SFPUC to address environmental justice and health impacts, stating that the SFPUC is mandated to help the community but has been "nonchalant." - Mary Butterwick (San Francisco resident) urged the Commission not to appeal the Sacramento Superior Court ruling on the Bay Delta Plan and instead work with the state to set instream flow standards. She noted that the proposed Tuolumne River Voluntary Agreement is a delay tactic and that salmon counts are critically low. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust) criticized the SFPUC for defending the status quo and urged commissioners to hold staff accountable. He referenced a 1970s lawsuit over wholesale rates and called for a long-term capital improvement strategy. - A caller expressed concern about SFPUC's $8.5 billion debt and projected annual rate increases of at least 8%, questioning the budget planning. - Francis Mendoza (from the Philippines, representing California Salmon) spoke in support of indigenous water rights and urged the Commission to reconsider the alternative water supply plan, which he said would double water rates, decrease river flows, and increase the budget to over $20 billion. He called for stopping water diversion for salmon. - Another caller argued that the design drought plan was overly conservative and that demand projections should be more realistic, suggesting that balancing water use across years could reduce the need for expensive alternative supplies. - Public Comment on Item 5A (Water Enterprise CIP): - A speaker criticized the Commission for focusing on materialistic projects and ignoring the salmon and water leases. - Peter Dreckmeyer noted staff's excellent presentation but highlighted the $633 million cost variance and warned that the Alternative Water Supply Plan would also see significant cost overruns. - Public Comment on Item 5B (Alternative Water Supply Program): - Many callers spoke, including representatives from BOSCA, environmental groups, and residents. Common themes: the design drought assumption is too conservative; demand projections should be lower; the plan risks financial crisis and ratepayer burden; sensitivity analysis and alternative scenarios are needed; the plan should prioritize conservation and on-site reuse. Callers urged the Commission to reduce the design drought by one year and use realistic demand figures. - No public comment on items 6, 7, 8, 9, or 12 (closed session matter). Discussion Items - Approval of Minutes (Item 3): Due to technical issues, approval of the May 14 and May 28, 2024 minutes was continued to the next meeting. - Report of the General Manager (Item 5): - 5a. Water Enterprise Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Quarterly Report: Katie Miller, Director of Water Capital Programs, presented an update as of Q3 FY2023-24. The program includes 38 projects with a total budget of $3.1 billion. About 30% has been spent. A cost variance of $633 million (20% increase) is forecast due to scope refinement and post-pandemic pricing. Key highlights: the Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozone Project bid prices were high but staff recommended award; Pillar CEDOS Dam Improvements alternatives (full replacement at $273 million vs. lowering reservoir at $63 million); Southern Skyline Ridge Trail construction underway; College Hill Reservoir project nearing completion; 2000 Marin site headquarters design development completed. Commissioners discussed cost increases, the need for life-cycle cost analysis, innovation in projects, and the importance of data and sensing infrastructure. Assistant General Manager Robinson noted ongoing delays with PG&E but improved coordination. - 5b. Annual Alternative Water Supply Program Report: Manisha Kothari presented the annual progress report. The Alternative Water Supply Plan, finalized in February 2024, serves as a roadmap. The projected dry-year water supply gap is 92–122 MGD (depending on demand vs. obligations). Six projects are in planning: Los Vaqueros and Daly City projects (construction funded in 10-year CIP, online 2030–2032), plus purified water programs (planning only). Program spending to date: $12.4 million. The report includes 15 recommendations, including revisiting demand projections and incentivizing wholesale customer conservation. Commissioners expressed support for the plan but raised concerns about cost, environmental benefits, the need for more aggressive demand management, and the potential for on-site reuse and recycled water. Commissioner Stacy urged exploring recycled water at the Southeast and Oceanside plants. Commissioner Ajami emphasized that demand is the key driver and that partnerships with BOSCA and better data are needed. President Paulson noted the historical challenge of water supply. - 5c. Report on Recent Activities: General Manager announced the sudden passing of employee Oscar Muron, an emergency planning lead. The Commission observed a moment of silence. - Item 7: Award Contract No. WW-742 (Southeast Plant Health & Safety Improvements): Staff requested approval to award to Anvil Builders Inc. for $18,700,490 with a 940-day duration to address structural, mechanical, and electrical reliability issues in buildings from the 1950s. No questions; approved. - Item 8: Approve Amendment No. 1 to Natural Resources Specialized and Technical Services Contracts: Steve Richie presented amendments to three contracts (with AECOM, ATS, and Avila) increasing each by $7 million for ongoing watershed management and mitigation work. No questions; approved. - Item 9: Adopt 2024 Wildfire Mitigation Plan: Ethan Billigmeyer presented the annual update. The plan covers SFPUC electrical assets in high fire-threat districts. Zero reportable ignitions in the last two years. Accomplishments in 2023 include drone inspections, upgraded pole standards, satellite vegetation monitoring, and controlled burns. The plan will be filed with the California Office of Energy Infrastructure Safety by July 1, 2024. Commissioners discussed risk prioritization, prescribed burns, and insurance for power assets. Cheryl Sperry noted that SFPUC is going to market for insurance and has received interest. - Items 10–11: Communications were received as information; no commissioner-initiated items. - Items 12–16 (Closed Session): The Commission deliberated on a litigation matter (RES System Three LLC claim). After closed session, they voted to recommend approval of the settlement and not to disclose the discussion. Key Outcomes - Minutes: Continued to next meeting. - Consent Calendar (Item 6): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 7 – Contract WW-742: Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 8 – Contract Amendments: Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 9 – 2024 Wildfire Mitigation Plan: Resolution adopted unanimously (3-0). - Closed Session (Item 14): The Commission voted unanimously to recommend Board approval of the settlement and not to disclose discussions (3-0). - Next Steps: The Alternative Water Supply Plan will be updated as new data emerges; staff will continue demand modeling and engage with BOSCA. The wildfire mitigation plan will be filed by July 1. The next meeting is scheduled for June 25, 2024.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 48% · ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8% · PROCEDURAL 7%
694
JUN 10, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting – June 10, 2024

The San Francisco Rules Committee convened on June 10, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronen, with Vice Chair Shamann Walton and Supervisor Ahsha Safaí. The committee reviewed eight agenda items, including appointments, streamlining Vision Zero contracting, vending enforcement, election code amendments, entertainment zones, and cooperative purchasing. Public comment was taken on each item. All votes were unanimous unless noted. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (Vision Zero): Trisha Gregory (co-owner Heavyweight Trekking, micro LBE) opposed waiving LBE requirements without data and community input. Lasonia Mansfield (Mansfield Construction) opposed, citing lack of outreach to micro LBEs. John Tresvinia (District 11 resident) opposed, arguing the bill waives civil rights protections and should not be expedited. Tequisha Alicia (QA Consulting) urged inclusion of CMD and small business representatives. - Item 7 (Entertainment Zones): Ben Bleiman (president of Entertainment Commission, owner of Harrington’s) supported, citing positive feedback loops for downtown. Laurie Thomas (Golden Gate Restaurant Association) supported, noting 2.4 restaurant closures per opening. Che Walton (manager of Schroeder’s) supported, emphasizing employee retention and foot traffic. - Item 8 (Cooperative Purchasing): Renard Monroe (executive director, Youth First) supported, citing successful park renovations in District 11. Discussion Items - Item 3 – Administrative Code: Streamlined Contracting for Vision Zero Projects Supervisor Ronen introduced an amendment on behalf of Supervisor Chan requiring annual reporting by August 15, 2025. Supervisor Safaí proposed a further amendment to create a qualified vendor list via an RFQ process before expediting contracts. SFMTA’s Hoy Ramos clarified the legislation authorizes (not requires) expediting for eligible projects. Public Works’ Bruce Robertson noted 86% of recent Vision Zero projects had LBE primes. The committee voted to adopt the reporting amendment and continued the item to June 17 to finalize the RFQ amendment. - Item 4 – Public Works Code: Vending Requirements and Restrictions Supervisor Safaí presented a hostile amendment (held for one week) closing a loophole: once a vendor is given notice of illegal vending, that notice remains valid for 120 days without re-noticing. The item passed to the full board. - Item 5 – Municipal Elections Code: Chinese Character-Based Names Director John Arns presented amendments aligning local rules with state law, requiring two years of public use and declarations for birth names. Passed to full board. - Item 6 – Municipal Elections Code: Supporters and Opponents on Ballot Questions Director Arns recommended opting out of listing supporters/opponents for local measures to avoid exceeding six ballot cards in November 2024. Each additional card costs $800,000–$850,000. The committee passed the ordinance to opt out conditionally. - Item 7 – Administrative, Police, Transportation Codes: Entertainment Zones Ben Van Houten (OEWD) presented the framework and first zone on Front Street (California to Sacramento). Businesses (Harrington’s, Schroeder’s, Royal Exchange) will drive programming with music and games, targeting a post-Labor Day launch. The committee added supervisors as co-sponsors and passed the item. - Item 8 – Administrative Code: Cooperative Purchasing Kelly Rednick (Rec & Park) presented projected 25% cost savings and faster delivery for small projects (e.g., playgrounds). 37 playgrounds are past useful life. The committee added Supervisor Ronen as co-sponsor and passed the item. - Items 1 & 2 – Appointments: Item 1: Aaron Yin reappointed to the Children, Youth, and Their Families Oversight and Advisory Committee. Item 2: Seven appointees (Jen Chang, Roland Pickens, Joseph Wu, Stephen Fugaro, Norlisa Cooper, Abigail Lawrence Alderson, Jutaporn Chellajaroen) approved for the Health Authority. Both passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to appoint Aaron Yin passed unanimously. - Item 2: Motion to appoint seven members passed unanimously. - Item 3: Amendment (reporting requirement) adopted; item continued to June 17, 2024. - Item 4: Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation passed unanimously. - Item 5: Motion to send to full board passed unanimously. - Item 6: Motion to send to full board passed unanimously. - Item 7: Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation (adding co-sponsors) passed unanimously. - Item 8: Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation (adding co-sponsor) passed unanimously.

PROCUREMENT 17% · NIGHTLIFE REGULATION 17% · PUBLIC HEALTH 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12%
695
JUN 6, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting on Expanding Housing Choice, June 6, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, June 6, 2024, at 20:15 UTC. The meeting covered continuances, consent calendar items, commission matters, and a major informational presentation on the Expanding Housing Choice (Housing Element Zoning Program). The commission heard extensive public comment and held a lengthy discussion on rezoning, objective design standards, historic preservation, and community outreach. Consent Calendar - The commission approved items 4A, 4B, and 4C (555 Howard Street – Downtown Project Authorization, Conditional Use Authorization, and Variance) on consent by a unanimous 6-0 vote. Commissioner So disclosed a prior professional relationship with the project architect but stated it would not affect impartiality. - The Zoning Administrator granted the variance for item 4C with standard conditions. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: - Ahmad Mohazab (architect, project at 1131-1133 Anza Street) apologized for the project sponsor’s error in renting units during the permit process and announced withdrawal of the permit. - Sue Hester (remote) requested the commission schedule a hearing and notify tenants regarding the Sam Bruno project. - Item 10 – Expanding Housing Choice: - Corey Smith (Housing Action Coalition) expressed full support for building housing at all income levels as an anti-displacement strategy, noting historic low housing production and urging faster action. - Justin Dulzell (Small Business Forward) opposed the rezoning, arguing it would devastate small businesses without commercial rent control or tenant protections; he called for right-to-return and relocation payments. - Jim Warshell (Victorian Alliance) advocated for both new development and preservation, urging completion of the citywide historic survey and simpler landmarking. - Christopher Roach (Studio VARA, AIA) spoke in favor, supporting the rezoning and the mayor’s direction to remove density controls, and praised the objective design standards for allowing creativity. - Jan Diamond (resident) questioned the need for broad upzoning given 74,000 units already in the pipeline. - George Seary (resident) argued that increased population would not improve the city and that existing pipeline projects should be prioritized. - Eric Munsing (Duboce Triangle Neighborhood Association) supported increased density, especially in well-resourced west side neighborhoods, but requested clarity on how state density bonus would interact with height limits. - Jonathan Meade (resident) opposed unregulated upzoning, warning it would displace small businesses and rent-controlled tenants, and called for a real plan instead of reliance on the free market. - Isaac Santiago (Housing Rights Committee) opposed rezoning, citing negative impacts on public housing residents, specifically the Plaza East redevelopment. - Kath Sakalakis (Lakeside Village) spoke in favor of upzoning, hoping her children could afford to live in San Francisco, and criticized fear-based outreach. - Gail Baugh (Hayes Valley) urged inclusion of wind shear baffling in tall buildings, micro-retail spaces, and living alleys in design standards. - Ozzy Room (San Francisco Landies Coalition) opposed the plan, questioning the feasibility of mid-rise construction costs and the methodology of community engagement. - Bob Hare (Barbary Coast Neighborhood Association) expressed concern about the state density bonus overriding local standards and cited the proposed 24-story tower at 955 Sansome as an example of unintended consequences. - Tim Rifield (Carpenters Union Local 22) urged inclusion of labor standards in the rezoning program to ensure a skilled workforce. - Carolyn Kennedy (Dolores Heights Improvement Club) opposed blanket upzoning, arguing it would not produce affordable housing without subsidies and would harm neighborhood character. - Sharon (Chinatown Community Development Corporation) requested community-specific objective design standards for cultural districts and priority equity geographies. - Marlene Morgan (Cathedral Neighbors Association) suggested focusing on large opportunity sites rather than damaging small commercial corridors. - Jane Natoli (YIMBY Action) supported the rezoning and objective design standards, emphasizing the need for more homes in neighborhoods like the Richmond. - Annie Freiman (SPUR) commended the work on design standards and historic preservation, and urged a strong rezoning map that addresses state density bonus issues. - Courtney Dam Kroger (former HPC member) warned that upzoning would destroy cultural resources, rent-controlled housing, and small businesses, and requested better outreach and a session with the Historic Preservation Commission on design standards. - Aurora Robinson (resident) cautioned that development often displaces long-term residents and called for inclusive planning. - Kevin McCarthy (Forest Hill) requested more community outreach, noting that residents only recently learned of the rezoning and had legitimate concerns about schools, traffic, and subsidence. - Bridget Malee (resident) opposed upzoning, arguing it would not solve the affordability crisis and that better outreach to property owners is needed. - Lori Brook (Cow Hollow Association) highlighted that many residents are unaware of the plans and called for a pause. - Robert Fruckman (San Francisco YIMBY) supported density and state density bonus, emphasizing the fair housing mandate and the need for affordable housing. - Siddhar Kadali (first-time attendee) shared a personal story of struggling to afford to stay in San Francisco and supported the upzoning proposal. Discussion Items - Consideration of Items Proposed for Continuance: All items (45 Bronte Street, 320-322 Frederick Street, 3901 Noriega Street, 305 Liberty Street) were continued to future dates by a unanimous 6-0 vote. The Zoning Administrator also continued associated variance items. - Commission Matters: - Land acknowledgement read by Commissioner So. - Draft minutes from May 2 and May 23 hearings were adopted unanimously. - Commissioner comments: Discussion centered on the six-month report for the 45 Bronte Street project. Commissioners requested detailed tenant status updates and debated whether to hold a public hearing. Staff agreed to require a baseline and delta of tenant occupancy changes. - Department Matters: - Director’s announcements: None. - Review of past events: Staff reported on recent Board of Supervisors land use committee actions (Divisadero Street NCT liquor store ordinance, Irish Cultural Center local coastal program amendment) and Board of Appeals decisions (45 Bernard Street roof deck appeal). The Historic Preservation Commission approved legacy business applications and other permits. - Item 10 – Expanding Housing Choice (Informational Presentation): - Staff (Lisa Chen, Rich Sucre, Trent Greenan) presented an update on the zoning program, community engagement findings, historic preservation approach, and draft objective design standards. - Community engagement summary: Over 2,000 survey respondents; outreach included open houses, focus groups, and partnerships with community organizations. Key themes: broad recognition of housing crisis, polarization on height/density, concerns about tenant and small business displacement. - Historic preservation: Accelerating landmark designations, developing objective design standards for historic resources, and completing the SF Survey (120,000 parcels; field survey of neighborhood commercial districts nearly complete). - Objective design standards: Draft aims to replace subjective design guidelines with objective rules covering site design (block size, stepbacks, modulation) and architecture (fenestration, articulation). Standards are intended to be flexible and enforceable, but may be waivable under state density bonus law. - Commission discussion: President Diamond raised concerns about waivability of key standards (stepbacks, modulation) under state density bonus; staff and city attorney noted potential to explore subdivision code or local density bonus as alternatives. Commissioners debated mailed notice timing, small business impacts, tenant protections, affordable housing feasibility, and the need for better enforcement against misrepresentation by project sponsors. Commissioner So provided detailed technical feedback on the design standards (stepbacks on narrow sites, wind studies, transformer vault coordination, fenestration materials). Commissioner Moore criticized the abstract approach and urged incorporating lessons from existing density bonus projects and comprehensive planning. Commissioner Williams questioned how the rezoning would achieve the 57% affordable housing mandate and called for stronger consequences for applicant dishonesty. Commissioner Imperiale emphasized tenant tracking, small business protections, and community-specific design standards. The commission agreed to schedule future informational hearings on state density bonus, enforcement, and infrastructure. Key Outcomes - No action taken on Item 10; it was informational only. - Direction to staff: - Proceed with mailed notice to property owners affected by rezoning as soon as feasible. - Explore legal options to prevent key objective design standards (stepbacks, modulation, large block break-up) from being waived under state density bonus law. - Schedule future informational hearings on state density bonus, enforcement tools, and infrastructure. - Continue community engagement, particularly with priority equity geographies and cultural districts. - Refine objective design standards to address affordability, construction feasibility, and community-specific needs; anticipate adoption in August 2024. - Prepare analysis of worst-case and best-case scenarios for density bonus along proposed corridors. - Develop a report on small business displacement impacts from past upzonings (e.g., Ocean Avenue). - Coordinate with MOHCD on affordable housing site identification. - Consent and continuance motions passed unanimously (6-0).

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 28% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 12% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 10% · URBAN DESIGN 10%
696
JUN 6, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting – June 6, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee (GAO) of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on June 6, 2024, to consider four main items: (1) a retroactive MOU with the U.S. Capitol Police for supplemental law enforcement at the Pelosi residence, (2) a behested payment waiver to solicit donations for hosting panda bears at the San Francisco Zoo, (3) a resolution urging the Mayor and the Department of Children, Youth and Their Families (DCYF) to seek private donations to restore $25 million in cuts, and (4) a consent block of 29 labor agreements covering city employees (MOUs/collective bargaining agreements). All items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Panda Item (Item 2): Multiple speakers opposed the panda plan, citing the zoo’s history of animal neglect (e.g., a tiger escape, a keeper chased by a grizzly, a penguin decapitated, a baby gorilla crushed), aging facilities (some 70 years old), and financial risks. One speaker noted that 6,000 people signed a petition in six days urging cancellation. Speakers argued pandas are not tools for tourism and that the zoo lacks expertise and safe enclosures. - DCYF Cuts (Item 3): Several representatives from community-based organizations testified about the devastating impact of funding reductions. Youth SF (executive director) described serving thousands of students with a tech-recreation program and a waiting list of 400. Hunters Point Family (25 years in Bayview Hunters Point) said it received zero funding for the next cycle and will have to lay off 18 staff, ending summer youth programs. Mission Neighborhood Health Center (Adelante youth program) noted its 57-year history and that its $255,000 grant was cut to zero. Speakers urged restoration of funds, emphasizing that safe neighborhoods rely on these programs. Discussion Items - Item 1 – MOU with U.S. Capitol Police: The SFPD legislative liaison presented a retroactive MOU (Jan–Dec 2024) to staff a fixed post at the Speaker’s residence using off-duty officers, reimbursable by the Capitol Police. No reduction in on-duty services. Chair Preston asked that future MOUs be brought before the committee before they take effect to avoid retroactivity. No public comment. Motion to forward with positive recommendation passed unanimously. - Item 2 – Panda Bear Behested Payment Waiver: Chair Preston presented amendments developed with the Mayor’s office addressing concerns raised at a prior hearing: narrowing who may solicit donations, allowing simultaneous fundraising for capital improvements at the zoo, and including a list of known potential donors. The amendments were adopted. Public comment opposed the plan. Motion to amend and forward as a committee report passed unanimously. - Item 3 – Urging Restoration of DCYF Cuts: Supervisor Safai introduced the resolution after the Mayor announced $11.2 million in partial restoration (out of $12 million/year in cuts). DCYF Director Sue stated the RFP process awarded $97 million initially, and with the Mayor’s addition the total reached $103 million. She could not provide the exact remaining gap, as funds were still being allocated and the city attorney consulted on whether a new competitive process is needed. Supervisors expressed frustration that the process harmed nonprofits and families, noting 36 organizations were completely defunded (e.g., Hunters Point Family, Inner City Youth, Youth SF). Supervisor Chan emphasized that restoring the full $25 million would require cuts elsewhere. Motion to forward with positive recommendation passed unanimously. - Items 4–32 – Labor Agreements: DHR Director Eisen and staff presented 28 ordinances covering 26 bargaining units (21 settlements, 5 arbitration awards). Key terms: 13% wage increase over three years for most unions, with a city minimum wage of $25/hour for all employees (impacting SEIU and Laborers); nurses received a 17.5% increase and 47 new positions. Total wage cost: $78.6 million in year one, $346.9 million over three years; combined wages and benefits total $471.6 million. Additional highlights: improved safety measures, new training programs, vacancy-filling commitments, a contracting pilot with SEIU and Local 21, and a vacancy dashboard promised by January 1, 2025. Public comment was limited to an unrelated housing complaint. Motion to forward all items with positive recommendation passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Amended as circulated; forwarded as a committee report (3-0). Expected at full board June 11. - Item 3: Forwarded as a committee report (3-0). Expected at full board June 18. - Items 4–32: All 29 labor agreements forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). Expected at full board June 11. - Meeting adjourned after all business completed.

PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 21% · LABOR RELATIONS 17% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 12%
697
JUN 5, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting – June 5, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee met on June 5, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar. The committee reviewed 20 agenda items, including funding for Ukrainian refugee housing, an LGBTQ history museum, infrastructure for the Sunnydale HOPE SF project, a security guard contract, and a fee waiver ordinance for neighborhood outdoor events. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, some with amendments. Public comment was limited to a few items. Consent Calendar - Item 1: Resolution approving the second amendment to the management and operation agreement between the SFMTA and Friends of the Cable Car Museum, extending the term five years (through June 30, 2029) and generating $237,733 in concession fee revenue. Passed unanimously. - Items 2 & 3: Resolutions retroactively authorizing the Human Services Agency to accept and expend grants from the Federal Office of Refugee Resettlement: $1,472,856 for Housing Assistance for Ukrainians (serving up to 130 households) and $500,000 for Ukrainian Refugee Support Services (intensive case management and benefits linkages). Both passed unanimously. Supervisors Chan, Mandelman, and Melgar added as co-sponsors. - Items 5 & 6: Resolutions retroactively authorizing the Department of Elections to accept California Secretary of State funds: $168,000 for election security (improving physical security at offices and warehouse) and $60,380.03 for polling place accessibility training. Passed unanimously. - Item 9: Resolution authorizing a five-year contract with Good Guard Security Inc. for unarmed security guard services at Human Services Agency locations, not to exceed $33,760,000 (with two one-year renewal options). Funded 75% from general fund. Passed unanimously. - Items 10 & 11: Resolutions approving COVID-19 lease extensions for two airport concession tenants: Farley’s Community Cafe (2 years 4 months) and Joe & the Juice (3.5 years), bringing additional minimum annual guarantee rent of $1,596,266. Passed unanimously. - Item 13: Resolution retroactively authorizing a grant agreement between HSH and San Francisco Health Plan for the Housing and Homelessness Incentive Program, not to exceed $3,227,884 (through Dec 31, 2025). Funds support enhanced healthcare services at permanent supportive housing (pilot at Kelly Cullen Community) and accessibility improvements. Passed unanimously. - Item 14: Resolution retroactively approving an agreement with the National Association of County and City Health Officials for the Reducing Overdose through Community Approaches Mentorship Program, anticipated revenue $98,999 (July 1, 2023–July 31, 2024). Includes non-binding arbitration clause. Passed unanimously. - Items 15 & 16: Resolutions retroactively authorizing the Department of Public Health to accept grants: $2,597,683 from CA Department of Health Care Services for Path Justice-Involved Capacity Building (behavioral health linkages for individuals exiting prison/jail) and $1,124,506 from CDC for Capacity Building Assistance for High-Impact HIV Prevention (three-month extension). Passed unanimously. - Item 18: Resolution approving a six-year extension of the landfill disposal agreement with Recology San Francisco (or until an additional 1.6 million tons of waste disposed), subject to Charter approval. Expected to provide 4.3 more years of disposal capacity. Passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4 (LGBTQ History Museum): Several speakers urged approval, including Roberto Ordeñana (executive director, GLBT Historical Society), Annie Rivera (executive director, Galería de la Raza and board member, GLBT Historical Society), Ben Chavez Gilliam (board chair), Jamie Santos (secretary), Rachel Picorney (treasurer), and Yva Virus (longtime resident). They emphasized the importance of a permanent space for LGBTQ history, especially given rising hateful attacks, and the economic and cultural benefits for San Francisco. - Item 12 (Meals on Wheels): Jennifer Steele, CEO of Meals on Wheels San Francisco, expressed gratitude for the partnership and commitment to providing high-quality nutrition services to navigation centers and shelters. - Item 20 (Neighborhood Outdoor Events Fee Waiver): Angie Pettit (Sunset Mercantile) spoke in support, noting the importance of fee waivers for small businesses and community events, and requested consideration for larger community events. Discussion Items - Item 4 (LGBTQ History Museum): The Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development (Brian Chu) presented a resolution to apply for and accept a $5.5 million state grant from the California Natural Resources Agency to establish a permanent LGBTQ history museum in San Francisco. The city will administer the funds and issue an RFP for a community-based organization to operate the museum. Supervisor Mandelman praised the project, noting it has been a long-term goal. The GLBT Historical Society already operates a small museum on 18th Street. The resolution passed unanimously and will be forwarded to the full board. - Item 7 (Sunnydale HOPE SF Infrastructure): Jason Liu (Policy Director, HOPE SF) and Ryan Vinzent (Senior Project Manager, MOHCD) presented a resolution authorizing a loan not to exceed $52,362,512 for Phase 3 infrastructure improvements at Sunnydale (15 acres). This phase includes preparation for two affordable housing buildings (184 units), two market-rate buildings, two parks, and public right-of-way. Construction is set to begin July 2024 and complete by Q1 2026. The Budget Legislative Analyst recommended approval and suggested a status update on state funding by end of 2024. The committee approved unanimously. - Item 8 (Treasure Island Market Rate Housing): Director Bob Beck (Treasure Island Development Authority) presented a resolution approving a 10-year extension (with a three-year option) of the sublease and property management agreement with John Stewart Company for market-rate rental housing on Treasure Island. The number of units under management is decreasing (currently 324, expected to drop to 100–150 by 2030) as residents transition to new affordable housing, and former Navy housing will be demolished for redevelopment. The Budget Legislative Analyst noted limited interest from other proposers. Chair Chan emphasized the need to ensure fair treatment of remaining tenants. The resolution passed unanimously. - Item 12 (Meals on Wheels Shelter Meals): Emily Cohen (Deputy Director, HSH) presented a resolution approving a five-year grant agreement with Meals on Wheels San Francisco (not to exceed $49,737,600) to provide two meals daily to over 2,300 guests across 15 shelters and navigation centers. The agreement consolidates meal services, with hot meals at three sites and frozen meals at others ($7.15–$8.00 per meal). The Budget Legislative Analyst noted that past meal satisfaction surveys showed only 30–50% positive responses; the new contract adds focus group requirements and performance measures on fruit/vegetable consumption and food insecurity. The committee approved unanimously. - Item 19 (Annual Retail Food Special Event Permit): The Office of Small Business (Katie Tang) and Department of Public Health (Jen Calvert) presented an ordinance to create a new annual permit for food vendors participating in special events, reducing administrative burden. Due to missing public notice for fee advertisement, the item was continued to the call of the chair. Supervisor Melgar was added as co-sponsor. The item was continued unanimously. - Item 20 (Neighborhood Outdoor Events Fee Waiver): The Office of Economic and Workforce Development (Alessandra Lozano) presented an ordinance to waive city fees (permits, inspections, staffing) for qualifying single-day neighborhood events (max 3 blocks, 8am–10pm, free and open to the public). The estimated annual cost to the general fund is $700,000, with $1.1 million in waived MTA fees. Supervisor Mandelman moved an amendment to limit fee waivers to 12 events per year per organizer, which was adopted. Supervisor Engardio then proposed an amendment to allow up to six blocks for night markets on specific Sunset Boulevard streets (Irving, Noriega, Taraval between 19th and Great Highway). The file was duplicated, the amendment adopted on the duplicate, and then the duplicate as amended was continued to the call of the chair for further fiscal analysis. The original amended ordinance was forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - All items on the regular agenda were approved unanimously (3-0) and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, except for those continued. - Item 17 (Purchase of real property at 624 Laguna Street) was continued to the call of the chair. - Item 19 (Annual retail food special event permit) was continued to the call of the chair due to incomplete fee advertisement. - Item 20 (Neighborhood outdoor events fee waiver) was amended twice: first to limit eligible events to 12 per year (Mandelman), then on a duplicated file to allow up to six blocks for specified Sunset night markets (Engardio). The original amended ordinance was forwarded to the full board; the duplicated amended ordinance was continued to the call of the chair. - The committee scheduled a future meeting for continued items.

PUBLIC COMMENT 22% · PUBLIC HEALTH 12% · PROCEDURAL 9% · LGBTQ+ HISTORY 9%
698
JUN 5, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - June 5, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission met on June 5, 2024, to address a full agenda including officer recognitions, public comment on police conduct and unsolved homicides, reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), adoption of two Department General Orders, presentations on the Disciplinary Review Board findings and the Internal Affairs Division annual report, and a presentation on the BolaWrap non-lethal restraint device. The commission also held a closed session. Consent Calendar - The commission received and filed SFPD's and DPA's document protocol reports for the first quarter of 2024 and accepted a donation of a facility dog (estimated value $2,000). Public Comments & Testimony - A member of the public commented on a mural depiction (49ers square foot) and criticized intelligence operations. - A mother of a murder victim (Arbor Casa, killed August 14, 2006) pleaded for justice and named alleged perpetrators, requesting a cold case witness program ("Tracer program"). - Two speakers described a May 30, 2024 incident where they alleged an SFPD officer refused to activate body camera, refused to identify himself, and enabled an assault on them. They called for the officer's termination. - Another speaker reported an encounter with Officer L. Wong, alleging threats and bragging about connections. - A retired teacher urged foot patrols and proposed legalizing sex work and gambling to revitalize Mission Street. - A speaker criticized the city for not funding homicide tip rewards, referencing prior presentations, and urged action. Chief’s Report - Chief Scott reported a 30% reduction in part one crimes year-to-date (6,500 fewer crimes), highlighting a 38% reduction in homicides (13 vs. 21 last year) and a 51% drop in car break-ins. Gun seizures totaled 503 (up 60 from last year), including 74 ghost guns (down from 117). - Major incidents: four non-fatal shootings (one arrest), a stabbing arrest, a robbery arrest, a burglary arrest at a marijuana grow house, and a narcotics operation in the Tenderloin (10 arrests, 522g narcotics seized). A coordinated operation with multiple agencies led to two Oakland suspects arrested with heroin, fentanyl, methamphetamine, and over $7,000 cash. - Stunt driving events on June 1 involved 40 cars across multiple districts; no arrests but follow-up investigation underway. - Mutual aid requests: SFPD sent officers to Cal Poly Humboldt, UC Berkeley, UC Santa Cruz, and San Francisco State for protest-related assistance; no reportable uses of force. - Commissioner Benedicto requested a future agenda item to discuss coordinated protest response strategy. DPA Director’s Report - Executive Director Henderson reported 57 new investigations opened and 97 closed since last meeting, a 15% reduction in pending cases. - DPA received the 2024 Distinguished Knight Award from the Association of Local Government Auditors for its report on SFPD's discipline process. - DPA hosted a two-day training for 15 California oversight practitioners; attended by national oversight leaders. - The annual internship and fellowship cohort includes 25 students (5 law, 20 undergrad) from 14+ colleges, representing 9 HBCUs. The program partners with 12 city agencies. - Commissioner Benedicto and Commissioners Yee and Yanez welcomed the interns and thanked DPA staff. Commission Reports - Commissioner Yee reported attending the SFPD 281st recruit class graduation (15 new officers) and visiting Carribrow stations. Discussion Items Adoption of Department General Order 6.20, “Member-Involved Domestic Violence” - The DGO was presented with minor wording changes. A commissioner asked why a definition of domestic violence was not included; staff explained that definitions reside in DGO 6.09 to avoid needing to update this order when definitions change. Chief confirmed a waiver from community engagement process. The commission adopted the DGO unanimously (4-0). Adoption of Department General Order 3.12, “Department Training Plan” - No substantive changes; only an email address update. Chief issued a waiver for the proper process. The commission adopted the DGO unanimously (4-0). Presentation on SFPD’s Disciplinary Review Board Findings, 3rd and 4th Quarter 2023 - DPA attorney Diana Rosenstein presented. Aggregate trends included neglect of duty (general, body-worn camera, failure to appear at range, conduct unbecoming). Policy failure cases: an officer establishing a nonprofit without an MOU; an incident involving a probation search when no one was home. Training failures: one case in Q4 related to a probation search. Office of Equity and Inclusion found no negative bias trends. Recommendations include creating MOUs for programs with on-duty officer participation. Chief confirmed MOU for Operation Genesis is complete; other programs (PAL, Wilderness, etc.) will have MOUs by year-end. Presentation on Internal Affairs Division Annual Report 2023 - Lieutenant Lisa Springer presented. In 2023, 271 cases opened, 250 closed (93% closure rate). Top allegations: conduct unbecoming (30%), neglect of duty general (24%), body-worn camera issues (18%). Of closed cases, 66.6% resulted in non-disciplinary action (admonishment, retraining, etc.), 33.4% in discipline (written reprimand to termination). Director Henderson requested more detailed closed-case summaries; Springer agreed to consider. Presentation on BolaWrap Non-Lethal Remote Restraint System - Captain Sean Perdomo and Sergeant Bugarin presented the BolaWrap, a restraint device that deploys a 7.5-foot Kevlar cord from a handheld device (ranges: under 10 ft optimal, up to 25 ft). It is classified as a type 1 use of force (equivalent to handcuffing) under policy 5.01. The pilot program will train 55 officers (50 specialist team members, 5 tactical unit) in a 10-hour course, with a one-year trial. Deployment considerations include loud noise (similar to gunshot) and bright light. Commissioners asked about potential escalation from noise, need for lethal cover, wind effects, and training layering with CMCR. Chief clarified lethal cover will be present if subject poses threat of serious injury. The device is designed to not resemble a firearm. The commission expressed support for the pilot. Key Outcomes - Adopted DGO 6.20 (Member-Involved Domestic Violence) unanimously (4-0). - Adopted DGO 3.12 (Department Training Plan) unanimously (4-0). - Received and filed reports on DRB findings and IAD annual report. - Supported the BolaWrap pilot program; rollout expected after training in July/August 2024. - Voted to hold item 16 in closed session (4-0) and later voted not to disclose any discussion from closed session (4-0). - A future meeting item on protest response strategy was calendared.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 58% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · PROCEDURAL 10% · PUBLIC SAFETY 9%
699
JUN 5, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Regular Meeting - June 5, 2024

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Supervisors Mirna Malgar, Shamann Walton, Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman, and President Aaron Peskin, convened on June 5, 2024, to consider two items: a bond issuance for the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) and the Controller's Nine-Month Budget Status Report for FY2023-2024. Both items were advanced unanimously with no public testimony. Consent Calendar - No items were designated as consent calendar in the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided testimony on either item. Discussion Items Item 1: SFPUC Water Revenue Bond Issuance (File 240455) - An ordinance authorizing the issuance of tax-exempt or taxable water revenue bonds and other indebtedness by the SFPUC in an aggregate principal amount not to exceed $1,040,007,350 to finance capital water and Hetch Hetchy projects. The item had been continued from the previous week due to an amendment adding $5 million for emergency repairs at Pink Lake and Pine Lake. No further discussion or questions were raised. The committee voted to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (5-0). Item 2: Hearing - Controller's Nine-Month Budget Status Report (File 240485) - Michelle Aller Smith from the Controller's Office presented the report, which covered the current fiscal year (FY2023-2024) general fund. Key findings included a net revenue shortfall of $104 million citywide (driven by weakness in business, sales, hotel, and transfer tax revenues, and lower FEMA reimbursements), offset by a $198 million operating surplus across departments (largely from mid-year cuts and savings). The Department of Public Health showed a $52 million shortfall at Laguna Honda Hospital due to low patient census, offset by higher-than-budgeted revenue at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital. Reserves: the fiscal cliff reserve had a balance of $130 million, and the Free City College reserve ($6.9 million) was fully spent in the current year. The mayor's proposed budget (not yet reviewed in this report) may use these reserves differently. The committee asked clarifying questions about the Free City College reserve, the public health revenue management reserve, and the status of FEMA reimbursements (still ongoing). The hearing was heard and filed without objection (5-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (SFPUC Bond Issuance): Motion to forward to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed unanimously (5 ayes: Mandelman, Melgar, Walton, Peskin, Chan). - Item 2 (Budget Status Report): Motion to hear and file the report passed unanimously (5 ayes). - No other items were considered; the meeting adjourned.

PUBLIC FINANCE 67% · PROCEDURAL 21% · PUBLIC HEALTH 12%
700
JUN 4, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - June 4, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, June 4, 2024, beginning at 10:15 AM. All 11 members were present. The meeting included approval of minutes, consent calendar items, regular agenda items, committee reports, roll call introductions, special order commendations, and public comment. Numerous resolutions and ordinances were adopted, and several commendations were presented. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 12 were approved without objection, including settlements, budget appropriations, and various routine actions. - Items 13 through 49 were passed on same house, same call, including grant amendments, leases, ordinances related to the Public Utilities Commission, language access, building fees, surveillance technology, landmark designation, and community benefit district reports. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers from Parent Voices San Francisco and early childhood education advocates expressed full support for Baby Prop C funding and urged the board to ensure that funding stays with children and families. Speakers highlighted the need for respite care, expanded eligibility, and support for children with special needs. They thanked Supervisors Melgar, Chan, Ronan, and Safai for sponsoring a resolution on child care. - Speakers from City College of San Francisco appealed the SFMTA's Frida Kahlo Way Quick Build Project, requesting signatures to proceed with an appeal. They presented an alternative plan and expressed disappointment that protocol prevented other supervisors from signing without the district supervisor's authorization. - Other public comments addressed a public hearing request regarding housing conditions, and a critique of intelligence and pride. Discussion Items - Special Order Commendations (2:30 PM): The board recognized several individuals and groups: - Amy Appel for swimming from the Golden Gate to the Farallon Islands (17 hours, 43°F water, no wetsuit). - Sabejit Sev Ghosh (Yerba Buena Gardens Conservancy) and Dr. Carol Tang (Children’s Creativity Museum) for co-hosting the Climate Action Youth Summit with nearly 1,000 attendees. - Gary Virginia and Donna Sachet for 25 years of the Pride Brunch, which raised over $645,000 for PRC. - Jerry Coleman, veteran prosecutor (45 years in the SFDA’s office), for his post-conviction immigration relief work under Penal Code 1473.7, handling over 350 cases with a 98.6% approval rate and preventing deportations. Supervisor Ronan criticized the district attorney for not renewing his contract. - Roll Call Introductions: Supervisors introduced various resolutions and ordinances: - Supervisor Walton: Resolutions urging employers to recognize Juneteenth and reaffirming language access; in memoriams for Francis Marie Mitchell and Oscar Mauricio Moron. - Supervisor Mandelman: Announced low-value contracting reform recommendations from the city administrator; introduced ordinance expanding the large residence special use district to Coal Valley; introduced resolution declaring San Francisco a sanctuary city for transgender, gender nonconforming, and intersex people; in memoriam for Hope Wood and Margaret “Peggy” Moore. - Supervisor Melgar: Resolution congratulating Mexico on electing its first female president and urging a sister city relationship with Mexico City. - Supervisor Peskin: Resolution opposing Governor Newsom’s May budget revision to eliminate adult acupuncture benefits from Medi-Cal; introduced in memoriam for Ellen Espinoza Tovar. - Supervisor Preston: Congratulations to students on the last day of SFUSD school year. - Supervisor Ronan: Resolution supporting SB 925 to allow law enforcement to combat fencing of stolen goods; criticized DA Brooke Jenkins for not renewing Jerry Coleman’s contract. - Supervisor Stefani: Resolutions supporting AB 2917 (gun violence restraining orders) and recognizing June 10 as Portuguese Day in San Francisco. Key Outcomes - All consent and regular agenda items (1–49) were approved as recommended, many on unanimous roll call votes (11-0 or 10-0 where a supervisor was excused). - Committee reports for items 41–43 were adopted, including the Wawona Street Cultural Center Special Use District, Divisadero Street liquor store permit, and Clipper Street shared space ordinance. - Items 46–49 (adoption without committee reference) were adopted, including resolutions supporting state bills on Medi-Cal nutrition interventions, homicide victims’ families’ rights, stopping hate littering, and urging the Department of Early Childhood to expand childcare support. - Commendations were presented and accepted. - The meeting adjourned in memory of Francis Marie Mitchell, Oscar Mauricio Moron, Hope Wood, Margaret “Peggy” Moore, and Ellen Espinoza Tovar.

PUBLIC COMMENT 32% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 16% · IMMIGRATION POLICY 10% · PUBLIC SAFETY 5%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com