Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 681–690 ENTRIES
681
JUN 20, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting - June 20, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on June 20, 2024, at 6:15 PM UTC. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stephanie. Committee Clerk Monique Creighton handled administrative duties. Supervisor Chan was excused from the meeting by a motion that passed 2-0. The committee considered one regular agenda item (an ordinance increasing the transient occupancy tax exemption) and a series of settlement items (items 2-11) that were handled without a closed session after the city attorney's office answered all questions. Public comment was opened for each item but no members of the public spoke. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Transient Occupancy Tax Exemption Increase: An ordinance to amend the Business and Tax Regulations Code to raise the daily transient occupancy tax exemption amount from less than $52 to less than $60, and the weekly exemption from less than $130 to less than $149. The ordinance also requires the controller to review the exemption amounts between September 27, 2027, and September 2029 for potential adjustments. Sunny Anguillo, Chief of Staff for President Aaron Peskin, presented the item, noting it was likely the second adjustment to the hotel tax exemption and that the controller determines the methodology. No questions were raised by the committee. - Items 2-11 – Settlements of Lawsuits and Unlitigated Claims: The committee considered five ordinances and five resolutions authorizing settlements ranging from approximately $37,000 to $2.2 million. Item 2 (Settlement of Unlitigated Claims – U.S. Department of Health and Human Services – City to Receive $441,521.39) was scheduled for a committee report at the June 25, 2024 Board of Supervisors meeting. All settlement amounts and parties were listed in the agenda. Chair Preston noted his questions had been answered directly by the city attorney's office, so the committee proceeded without a closed session. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed 2-0 (Vice Chair Stephanie aye, Chair Preston aye; Member Chan excused). - Items 2-11: Motion to forward Item 2 as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors for its June 25, 2024 meeting, and items 3-11 with a positive recommendation to the full board, passed 2-0 (Vice Chair Stephanie aye, Chair Preston aye; Member Chan excused). - The meeting adjourned immediately after the votes.

PROCEDURAL 66% · PENDING LITIGATION 18% · TAX POLICY 16%
682
JUN 18, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - June 18, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on June 18, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Eleven supervisors were present (Supervisor Mandelman absent). The meeting included approval of the consent calendar, adoption of routine ordinances, special commendations, introduction of new legislation, and a debate on a resolution supporting the Justice for Renters Act, which was continued to the following week. The meeting adjourned in memory of two individuals. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 29: Routine labor agreements and memoranda of understanding with multiple unions (e.g., Teamsters, Carpenters, SEIU, etc.) were approved unanimously. - Item 30: Ordinance to waive fees for neighborhood outdoor events organized by community-serving nonprofits, small businesses, and merchant associations – finally passed. - Item 31: Authorization for SFPUC to issue up to $1,040,007,350 in water revenue bonds for capital projects – finally passed. - Items 32-34: Interim budget ordinances for FY 2024-2025 and 2025-2026, and the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure budget – passed on first reading (32-33) and adopted (34). - Item 35: Resolution authorizing a MOU with U.S. Capitol Police for supplemental law enforcement services – adopted. - Items 36-40: Ordinances amending Administrative, Municipal Elections, Public Works, Police, and Transportation codes (cooperative purchasing, Chinese character names on ballots, ballot measure supporters/opponents, vending regulations, and entertainment zones) – passed on first reading. - Items 41-42: Appointments to the San Francisco Health Authority (7 members) and the Children, Youth and Their Families Oversight and Advisory Committee (Aaron Yen) – approved. - Item 43: Tenderloin retail hours restriction pilot program (2-year pilot, prohibiting retail food/tobacco sales in high crime areas from 12 a.m. to 5 a.m. or 2 a.m. to 5 a.m.) – passed on first reading. - Item 44: Downtown University Attraction and Retention Fund (financial incentives for public colleges in SoMa, Union Square, Financial District) – passed on first reading. - Item 45: Not before the board. Public Comments & Testimony - A speaker criticized the censorship of a prior budget meeting and called for responsibility from the mayor. - Chris Ward Klein urged the board to review a PowerPoint on AI and surveillance, asking for revocation of unauthorized access to systems. - Jim Nakfey raised concerns about the whistleblower program's confidentiality, citing 192 reports in the latest quarter, and questioned whether investigations at Laguna Honda Hospital would be disclosed. Discussion Items - Commendations (Special Order 2:30 PM): - Supervisor Dorsey honored Bob Goldfarb, executive director of the Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District, for his leadership in establishing the district, producing Folsom Street Fair, and enhancing LGBTQ visibility. - Supervisor Mandelman recognized Imani Rupert-Gordon, executive director of the National Center for Lesbian Rights, for leading the fight against anti-LGBTQ bills and securing an injunction against Florida’s ban on transgender medical care. - Supervisor Ronan celebrated Esperanza Bernal, retiring director at Instituto Familiar de la Raza, for 14 years of service and her embodiment of the principles “Eres Mi Otro Yo” and “La Cultura Cura.” - Supervisor Walton honored Dr. Mose Thornton, a podiatric surgeon who served the Bayview Hunters Point community for 34 years at Southeast Community Health Center. - Supervisor Preston recognized the OCEIA Community Ambassadors Program, noting that this year ambassadors logged over 270,000 interactions, with over 20% in languages other than English, and 60% of the team being bilingual/multilingual. - Legislation Introduced: - Supervisor Dorsey and Mandelman introduced “Recovery Housing First,” aiming to make at least 25% of permanent supportive housing (PSH) drug-free recovery-oriented housing, referencing that PSH residents account for 16% of overdose deaths citywide. - Supervisor Safai introduced a first responder student loan forgiveness fund, targeted at police, fire, sheriffs, paramedics, nurses, and 911 operators. The goal is to raise $25 million to forgive up to $25,000 per person for at least 1,000 employees. - Supervisor Stephanie and Ronan introduced an ordinance to establish the Office of Victim and Witness Rights (OVWR), integrating the SHARP office, following voter approval of Proposition D in June 2022. - Supervisor Chan reported on budget hearings, warning of a fiscal cliff in January 2025 if spending continues as proposed. She noted a $67 million savings from the Health Service Board’s decision on Medicare services and proposed that all city elected officials put 10% of their salary on reserve. - Supervisor Walton introduced an ordinance establishing a Reparations Fund to receive donations for implementing the San Francisco Reparations Plan, and a resolution urging the state legislature to reconsider the State Reparations Committee’s proposals (only 3 of 14 bills passed in May). - Item 49 – Justice for Renters Act Resolution: - The resolution supports the California ballot measure to repeal the Costa Hawkins Rental Housing Act, which restricts local rent control. Supervisor Preston argued the measure simply allows cities to expand rent control. Supervisor Stephanie and Dorsey opposed, citing concerns that the measure’s language (preventing the state from limiting local rent control) could be used by anti-housing localities like Huntington Beach to block state housing mandates. They noted opposition from state legislators Senator Atkins and Assemblymember Wicks. Supervisor Melgar and Ronan defended the resolution, with Ronan sharing a personal story of growing up in rent control. Supervisor Walton stated that repealing Costa Hawkins has long been a priority for rent control advocates. After debate, the item was continued one week on a motion by Supervisor Preston. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved: May 14, 2024 board meeting minutes approved 11-0. - Consent calendar and routine items: All passed unanimously with no objections. - Ordinances passed on first reading: Items 32, 33, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 43, 44. - Resolutions and motions adopted: Items 34, 35, 41, 42, and items 48-52 (except 49) adopted without committee reference. - Item 49 continued: The resolution supporting the Justice for Renters Act was continued to the June 25, 2024 meeting. - In Memoriam: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Wayne Williams (SFMTA employee) and Bernard Burke (lifelong San Franciscan).

PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · RENT STABILIZATION 15% · PUBLIC HEALTH 13% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 11%
683
JUN 17, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - June 17, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on June 17, 2024, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Supervisor Hilary Ronan with Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Supervisor Asha Safai. The committee considered ten agenda items, including commission reappointments, appointments, and several ordinances. All reappointments and new appointments were approved unanimously. A controversial ordinance to streamline Vision Zero contracting was amended and continued to the call of the chair. Other ordinances—including the airport surveillance policy update, downtown university attraction fund, library Read to Recovery program, and repeal of the Deemed Approved Off-Sale Alcohol Use nuisance regulations—were all approved with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Planning Commission reappointment): One speaker praised Maria Theresa Imperial's compassion and commitment to all communities, saying she exemplifies what a San Francisco planning commissioner should be. - Item 3 (Public Works Commission reappointment): One commenter complimented Director Short but criticized poor street cleaning and a neglected area around the Armory, stating “on the ground, it ain't happening.” - Item 4 (Building Inspection Commission appointment): One commenter noted great concrete work by DPW on 20th Street but complained about a 311 request for sidewalk repair near the Housing Authority that has been open for four years. - Item 6 (Vision Zero streamlined contracting): Several speakers opposed the ordinance. A woman from Mansfield & Mansfield, a small contractor, said streamlining would close the door for her company. Another speaker called the proposal “unforgivable” for not consulting the LBE community. A third speaker argued that the legislation would undermine unions, equal pay, and environmental protections. One commenter from the Latino and Black Builders Association asked the committee to pause and reach out to small businesses. Another speaker said SFMTA is a disaster and that the goal of zero traffic deaths is impossible. - Item 7 (Airport surveillance): No public comments. - Item 8 (Downtown university fund): No public comments. - Item 9 (Library Read to Recovery): No public comments. - Item 10 (Repeal of alcohol nuisance ordinance): One speaker (Small Business Commissioner Miriam Sassoonis) thanked the committee, noting the fee reduction will help merchants diversify offerings. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Reappointment to Planning Commission: Maria Theresa Imperial (incumbent) sought a term ending July 1, 2028. She highlighted her work on the racial and social equity resolution and the housing element. All supervisors spoke in support. The motion to recommend approval (amended to remove “rejecting”) passed unanimously. - Items 2 & 3 – Appointments to Public Works Commission: Fadi Zabi (incumbent) and Gerald Turner (incumbent) for two seats; Lauren Post (incumbent) as chair. Zabi noted the commission's work in hiring a new director and improving processes. Post described performance metrics, a vacancy rate reduced to 15.7% (down from over 25%), and the importance of the new HR director. Supervisor Safai pressed on vacancy rates and service impacts. All motions passed unanimously. - Item 4 – Appointment to Building Inspection Commission: Catherine Meng, an architect, was nominated. She acknowledged DBI's history of corruption and inefficiency and pledged to improve transparency and efficiency. Supervisor Safai questioned the root causes of corruption and the lengthy entitlement process. Meng agreed that streamlining could help. Motion passed unanimously. - Item 5 – Appointment to Port Commission: Stephen Engblom, an architect and urban designer, spoke about resilience, equity, and implementing existing plans for the waterfront. Supervisor Walton asked about equity in port property use; Engblom advocated a triple-bottom-line approach. Supervisor Safai discussed financial stability and port recovery. Motion passed unanimously. - Item 6 – Streamlined Contracting for Vision Zero Projects: Supervisor Safai introduced amendments to require competitive bidding through pre-qualified lists, preserving LBE requirements and the citywide PLA (pending confirmation from the City Attorney). Public Works Deputy Director Bruce Robertson estimated the process could save 6-8 weeks per contract. After public comment opposing the bill, the committee accepted the amendments and continued the item to the call of the chair for further community engagement. - Item 7 – Airport Surveillance Technology Policy Amendment: Guy Clark from SFO presented amendments to include pre-security cameras on AirTrain, shuttle buses, and live BART video streaming. The policy does not allow face recognition. No questions from committee. Motion to recommend approval passed unanimously. - Item 8 – Downtown University Attraction and Retention Fund: Supervisor Safai presented the ordinance to create a fund to attract public universities to South Market, Union Square, and the Financial District, citing the 37% office vacancy rate. He noted a small amendment to explicitly allow bond financing. Supervisor Walton asked about capital plan alignment; Safai said they would work with the capital plan. Motion to recommend approval (as amended) passed unanimously. - Item 9 – Library Read to Recovery Program: Library Director Michael Lambert and branch manager Doreen Horston described the program, which distributes free recovery literature (e.g., AA/NA books) at all 28 library locations. Over 4,000 copies have been distributed since the pilot. Supervisors expressed strong support. Motions to recommend approval passed unanimously. - Item 10 – Repeal of Deemed Approved Off-Sale Alcohol Use Nuisance Ordinance: Lorenzo Rojas from Supervisor Stephanie's office presented. The 2006 ordinance is duplicative of state law and has not been enforced recently. Annual fee of $310 disproportionate, often unequally applied. Both SFPD and DPH expressed no opposition. Supported by multiple merchant groups. Motion to recommend approval passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Planning Commission reappointment: Approved unanimously (Walton, Safai, Ronan). - Public Works Commission appointments: Fadi Zabi and Gerald Turner reappointed unanimously; Lauren Post reappointed as chair unanimously. - Building Inspection Commission appointment: Catherine Meng approved unanimously. - Port Commission appointment: Stephen Engblom approved unanimously. - Vision Zero streamlined contracting: Amendments (including pre-qualified bidders and preservation of LBE/PLA) adopted unanimously; item continued to call of the chair for further community consultation. - Airport surveillance policy: Approved unanimously, with amendments adding AirTrain, shuttle buses, and BART streaming. - Downtown university fund: Approved unanimously with an amendment allowing bond financing. - Library Read to Recovery program: Approved unanimously. - Repeal of DAO nuisance ordinance: Approved unanimously. All items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of June 25, 2024, unless otherwise stated. The meeting adjourned after item 10.

PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSION 11% · SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER POLICY 9% · BUILDING INSPECTION 7%
684
JUN 17, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - June 17, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Monday, June 17, 2024. Chair Myrna Melgar presided, joined by President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee unanimously advanced all four agenda items to the full Board: a landmark tree designation, a commemorative street name, a Polk Street legacy business zoning exception, and a Tenderloin retail hours restriction pilot. The clerk announced that the June 24, 2024 meeting is canceled and the next regular meeting will be July 1, 2024. Items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of June 25, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Coast Redwood landmark): Brian Wiedmeyer of Friends of the Urban Forest expressed strong support, noting the tree was planted in 1962, is healthy, and is highly visible on the crooked street. Other public speakers also supported landmarking, while one speaker raised unrelated comments about trees and carbon dioxide. - Item 2 (Dr. Howard Thurman Way): Many speakers supported the commemorative street name, including Anton Wong (grandson of Dr. Thurman), Reverend Dr. Dorsey Blake, Chuck Collins, Noah Griffin, Aaron Grizzell, Carol Verberg, and representatives of the Church for the Fellowship of All Peoples, Russian Hill Neighbors, and Morehouse College. They described Dr. Thurman's legacy as a theologian, mentor to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., and co-founder of the nation's first interracial, interfaith congregation. - Item 3 (Polk Street legacy businesses): Rebecca Ahn and her daughter Ayan, of Bob's Donuts, spoke in support of the proposed exception, describing their family business's long history and role in the neighborhood. - Item 4 (Tenderloin retail hours): Public comment was split but largely supportive. Supporters included Tenderloin residents, Tenderloin Community Benefit District, Central City SRO Collaborative, Lower Polk Community Benefit District, Mid-Market Community Benefit District, and UC Law San Francisco. They argued that all-night stores attract open drug activity and endanger residents. Some merchants, including Mohammed of Plaza Snacks, expressed concern about the two-year term and midnight closure, suggesting 2 a.m. to 5 a.m. instead. The Tenderloin People's Congress supported Supervisor Preston's amendments but cautioned against restricting late-night food access for SRO residents. A petition of 521 signatures in support of the original pilot was cited. Discussion Items Item 1 - Landmark Tree Designation (File 240640) The committee considered an ordinance designating the Coast Redwood at 4 Montclair Terrace as a landmark tree. President Peskin stated the Urban Forestry Council unanimously recommended the designation and highlighted the tree's visibility on a popular tourism street. After public comment, the committee voted. Item 2 - Commemorative Street Name 'Dr. Howard Thurman Way' (File 240213) President Peskin introduced the resolution to add the commemorative street name to the 2020 block of Stockton Street, honoring Dr. Howard Thurman's San Francisco legacy. Supervisors Preston and Melgar requested to be added as co-sponsors. After public comment, the committee voted. Item 3 - Planning Code - Polk Street Neighborhood Commercial District (File 240411) The ordinance would create an exception for legacy businesses to allow storefront mergers and larger restaurant uses in the Polk Street NCD. President Peskin explained it would help Bob's Donuts, a legacy business run by the Ahn family since 1977, relocate and expand one block from its current location. Planning Department staff Veronica Flores reported that the Planning Commission recommended approval with modifications: removing the prohibition on storefront mergers, conditionally permitting use sizes 2,500 square feet or greater, and removing the 4,000-square-foot non-residential use cap. After public comment, the committee voted. Item 4 - Police Code - Tenderloin Retail Hours Restriction Pilot Program (File 240407) SFPD Commander Derek Liu presented the mayor's proposed two-year pilot, which would prohibit certain retail food and tobacco establishments in a bounded high-crime area of the Tenderloin from being open between midnight and 5 a.m. The Department of Public Health could impose administrative fines of up to $1,000 per hour of violation; violations would be declared a public nuisance, the city attorney could enforce, and a private right of action was included. Liu showed photographs of nighttime crowds at Plaza Snacks (77 McAllister) and described a cycle of crime, debris, and daily 3:30 a.m. cleanups. Supervisor Preston described negotiated amendments: exempting ABC-regulated corner stores (allowing them to stay open until 2 a.m.), requiring business outreach and enhanced neighborhood services, requiring a six-month report, calling for enforcement of existing illegal conduct, and modifying the private right of action. He moved the amendments with a technical change on page 5, line 2. The committee then acted on the amended original and a duplicated file. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to recommend the ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2: Motion to recommend the resolution passed unanimously (3-0); Supervisors Preston and Melgar were added as co-sponsors. - Item 3: Motion to recommend the ordinance passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 4: Supervisor Preston's amendment (as modified) passed unanimously (3-0). The motion to send the amended original to the full Board as a committee report and continue the duplicated file to the July 1, 2024 committee meeting to finalize the private right of action language also passed unanimously (3-0).

PUBLIC SAFETY 35% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · NIGHTLIFE REGULATION 12%
685
JUN 14, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting - June 14, 2024

The Budget and Appropriations Committee held a special meeting on June 14, 2024, to hear presentations from multiple city departments regarding their proposed budgets for fiscal years 2024-2025 and 2025-2026. The meeting also considered two pieces of trailing legislation: a grant acceptance for the District Attorney's office and a reappropriation of funds for overtime costs in the Police and Sheriff's Departments. The committee heard from the City Attorney, Treasurer, Superior Court, Department of Emergency Management, Fire Department, Juvenile Probation, Adult Probation, Public Defender, Sheriff, Department of Police Accountability, Office of Inspector General, District Attorney, and Police Department. Public comment was taken on the overall budget and on the specific items. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were identified. All items were discussed individually. Public Comments & Testimony - David Moore of the San Francisco Pretrial Diversion Project expressed support for a holistic public safety strategy that addresses both the front end (jail population) and reentry services, noting a 30% workload increase due to rising jail numbers. - Anya from the People's Budget Coalition voiced concern about the mayor's budget balancing approach, stating that cutting housing and food programs while not applying similar cuts to law enforcement agencies is unfair. She urged a holistic approach to public safety funding. Discussion Items - City Attorney (David Chiu): Presented a $118 million proposed budget. Highlighted a 1,700% increase in litigation budget reserves for tax disputes, a 165% increase in fallen tree claims, and a 323% increase in flooding claims. The office has 340 FTEs with a very low vacancy rate. Two new positions funded from consumer protection funds will support affirmative litigation (worker protection and consumer protection) to generate revenue. The office also noted increased workload from Care Court and conservatorships (SB 43). - Treasurer (Jose Cisneros): Presented a budget that deletes 11 vacant positions. The office collects nearly half the city's budget annually, with property tax delinquency at 1% and business tax at 5%. Business tax collections in 2022 were $1.4 billion. The office is implementing the empty homes tax (80,000 property owners) and a business tax system replacement. The office has maintained staffing levels despite new taxes since 2010. - Superior Court (Brandon Riley): Requested $250,000 for the Civil Grand Jury and $9.6 million for indigent defense administration, with a $200,000 increase per year due to increased case filings (felonies exceeding pre-pandemic levels). The court noted a 2.7 million state budget cut. Discussion arose about potential conflicts of interest if the Public Defender's caseload becomes unmanageable, leading to supplemental requests for the Bar Association. - Department of Emergency Management (Mary Ellen Carroll): Proposed $141 million budget. 911 call answering time is at 76% against a 90% target, attributed to staffing shortages. The department is holding six academies of 15 trainees each to address vacancies (18 vacancies, 5.7% vacancy rate). The CAD system experienced outages due to aging software; a new system is being implemented but will have transitional instability. The department is focusing on climate adaptation (extreme weather resiliency program). - Fire Department (Chief Janine Nicholson): Proposed budget maintains operational staffing. Call volume is up 20% from pre-COVID, reaching 200,000 annually. Overtime budget is $65 million. Fleet is aging: over 50% of trucks are over 20 years old, and replacement costs have increased 160%. The department has 1,900 FTEs, including 800 firefighters. The community paramedicine and street crisis team are funded via off-budget positions and reallocation, causing operational strain. - Juvenile Probation (Katie Miller): Proposed budget remains stable. Referrals returned to 2019 levels after pandemic abnormalities. Caseload for probation officers increased 53% since 2019. Juvenile hall counselors work an average of 11 weeks of overtime per year. The department is investing in community programs (doubled over five years). Progress on reducing custodial bookings: percentage of arrests resulting in custody has flipped downward. The department is working on replacing concrete beds and reimagining the facility. The ranch property is being prepared for RFP. - Adult Probation (Christelle Tulach): Proposed $70 million budget, a $2.8 million increase from FY23-24. General fund support decreases by $1.8 million due to increased state funding and recoveries. Staffing reduced from 154.4 to 143.6 FTEs. Caseload managed by risk, ranging from 26 to 180 per officer. The department provides housing and supportive services through city grants (28% of budget). - Public Defender (Manohar Raju): Argued that the office is underfunded relative to law enforcement. The budget is less than 4% of the combined criminal legal system budget. Caseload for felony attorneys averages 75, compared to 40 in surrounding counties. The office needs at least 16 more attorneys and 4 more paralegals to meet constitutional standards. The office has 240 staff with 7 vacancies. High caseloads contribute to jail overcrowding and attorney burnout. The office has a 75% rate of felony charges not resulting in felony convictions due to zealous defense. - Sheriff (Paul Miyamoto): Presented a budget that includes a 36% increase in jail population year-over-year. Staffing is a critical issue: 713 sworn staff, with over 200 vacancies. Attrition is outpacing hiring. The department is relying on overtime and Proposition F retirees. The department requested $400,000 for recruitment, which was not funded. The office is moving deputies from non-custody roles to the jails. The out-of-custody population (electronic monitoring) has increased 20% to 1,700. - Department of Police Accountability (Paul Henderson): Proposed budget includes reductions to meet the 10% target. The department has 38.76 FTEs, with 18 investigators. Caseload per investigator is at the maximum of 17 recommended by the Controller. The office has not lost any cases due to jurisdictional deadlines since 2017. The department is concerned that increased law enforcement funding without corresponding oversight funding will strain resources. Prop E implementation will require additional work. - Office of Inspector General (Johnnie Wiley): The mayor's proposed budget funds only two positions (director and administrative assistant), eliminating three investigator positions. The charter requires one investigator per 100 deputies (currently 713 deputies, so 7 investigators). The office requested $2.5 million for a chief assistant and two investigators to become minimally operational. Without funding, the OIG will rely on DPA support and cannot fully fulfill its oversight mandate. - District Attorney (Brooke Jenkins): Proposed budget of $93.7 million, a 4.7% increase mainly due to COLAs and lease costs. The office has 293.75 FTEs, including 137 attorneys and 41 investigators. Caseloads: general felonies 83 per attorney, misdemeanors 150 per attorney, victim advocates 347 cases each. The office requested more paralegals to handle discovery (1.3 million pages per year, 2.2 million digital files in six months). The office noted that for every case the Public Defender handles, the DA also handles it, and that the DA's office also handles cases not assigned to the Public Defender due to conflicts. The office emphasized the need to support victims, with 42% of victims being Black or Brown. - Police Department (Chief Bill Scott): Proposed budget includes a $12 million increase beyond the department's control. Overtime spending is projected at $87.7 million for the current year. The department has 2,337.3 budgeted sworn FTEs. Hiring is improving: 2024 recruit numbers will likely exceed 2021 and 2022 combined. Property crime is down 32% year-to-date, car break-ins down 51%, violent crime down 13%. The department uses overtime to backfill for staffing shortages, exacerbated by protests (since October 7) and special events. Key Outcomes - Item 4 (Resolution accepting grant from California Victim Compensation Board for $2,530,992): The committee voted 4-0 (Peskin absent) to recommend approval to the full Board of Supervisors for the June 25, 2024 meeting. - Item 5 (Ordinance reappropriating $6,862,571 for overtime in Police and Sheriff's Departments): The committee voted 3-0 (Walton and Peskin absent) to recommend approval to the full Board of Supervisors for the June 25, 2024 meeting. The BLA report noted that the FY23-24 budgets did not reflect actual staffing and deployment decisions, leading to overspending. - Items 1, 2, 3 (Hearing on mayor's proposed budget, appropriation ordinance, and salary ordinance): The committee voted 3-0 to continue the hearing to the June 20, 2024 meeting of the Budget and Appropriations Committee. - The Mayor's Budget Office announced that a first set of technical adjustments will be introduced, including backfilling Ryan White federal cuts ($200,000/year) and other cleanup items, funded from the technical adjustment reserve and not increasing the overall budget size.

PUBLIC SAFETY 18% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 14% · PROCEDURAL 12% · PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES 12%
686
JUN 13, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - June 13, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on Thursday, June 13, 2024, at approximately 2:15 PM to consider continuances, several conditional use authorizations, planning code amendments, and a large project authorization. The meeting included public testimony on multiple items, with the commission voting on all regular calendar items. Key outcomes included approval of the Polk Street NCD amendments with staff modifications, approval of projects at 249 Texas Street, 1060-1090 Randolph Street, 700 Indiana Street, and 45 Bronte Street. Consent Calendar - Items 1-4 (200 Capp Street, 336 Pierce Street, 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard, 1131-1133 Anza Street) were proposed for continuance or withdrawal. Item 1 continued to July 11, 2024; Item 2 to August 1, 2024; Item 3 to August 1, 2024; Item 4 withdrawn. Item 10 (Density Controls in Three Historic Districts) continued indefinitely. The commission voted unanimously (7-0) to continue all items as proposed. Public Comments & Testimony - Georgia Shutish commented on the withdrawal of the Anza Street item, alleging discrepancies in tenant information and permit status. She also spoke during general public comment about a project at 1465 Masonic Street, claiming demo calculations were not adjusted and resulted in loss of rent-controlled units. - Rebecca (Bob's Donuts) testified in support of Item 9, describing difficulties with lease negotiations and the need for the legislation to relocate to 1720 Polk Street. - Multiple speakers (over 20) supported Item 12 (Randolph Street meditation center), emphasizing its positive community impact and charitable work. - Over 30 speakers supported Items 13A/B (700 Indiana Street), including scientists, tenants, union representatives, and local contractors, highlighting job creation, innovation, and community engagement. The Dog Patch Neighborhood Association and Petrero Boosters opposed, citing shadow impacts, zoning issues, and inadequate community outreach. - Two speakers opposed Item 14 (45 Bronte Street), citing scale, massing, and privacy concerns. Discussion Items - Item 9 – Polk Street NCD Planning Code Amendments: Proposed by Supervisor Peskin to allow storefront mergers for legacy businesses (specifically Bob's Donuts). Staff recommended modifications to remove the prohibition on storefront mergers and increase the principally permitted use size to 2,500 sq ft. Commissioner Braun moved to approve with staff modifications. After debate, the motion passed 4-3 (Commissioners So, Braun, Koppel, Diamond in favor; Williams, Imperial, Moore against). - Item 11 – 249 Texas Street: Conditional use for demolition and construction of a two-unit building. Staff recommended approval. After prior continuance, the project sponsor reached an agreement with neighbors. The city attorney confirmed the project is subject to SB 330. Motion to approve passed 5-2 (Commissioners Imperial and Moore dissenting). - Item 12 – 1060-1090 Randolph Street: Conditional use for legalization of a meditation center and merger of two dwelling units. Staff recommended approval, noting the project adds a family-sized unit and legalizes a long-standing religious institution. Motion to approve passed unanimously (7-0). - Items 13A & 13B – 700 Indiana Street: Shadow findings and large project authorization for a laboratory building. Staff addressed concerns about notice, shadow analysis, and use classification (laboratory vs. life science). The commission added a condition of approval referencing the 2020 Zoning Administrator letter. Motion to adopt shadow findings and approve large project authorization passed unanimously (7-0). - Item 14 – 45 Bronte Street: Conditional use for tantamount to demolition and construction of a three-story home. Staff confirmed compliance with the Bernal Heights SUD (which prohibits demolition but allows tantamount to demolition). Motion to approve passed unanimously (7-0). Key Outcomes - Item 9: Approved with staff modifications (4-3). - Item 10: Continued indefinitely (unanimous). - Item 11: Approved with conditions (5-2). - Item 12: Approved with conditions (7-0). - Items 13A & 13B: Shadow findings adopted and large project authorization approved (7-0). - Item 14: Approved with conditions (7-0). All motions passed with the required votes. The meeting adjourned after concluding the final item.

LAND USE 21% · BIOTECH INDUSTRY 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 11%
687
JUN 13, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting – June 13, 2024

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on June 13, 2024, to consider the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2024–2025 and 2025–2026, hear presentations from numerous city departments, and act on related legislation. The meeting ran from approximately 10:15 AM to well into the evening, with public comment on multiple items. Department Presentations - Asian Art Museum: Director Jay Shue reported a city general fund allocation of $11.99 million (total budget $33 million). He noted a 10% reduction in city staffing since FY 2019 and requested an additional $1.7 million to restore security, life safety, and building maintenance. The committee expressed gratitude but noted fiscal constraints. - Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco: CFO Jason Seifer presented a total budget of $84 million, with 20% from general fund. The museums served 1.3 million visitors in 2023, with 577,000 free Saturday visits since 2019. Supervisor Melgar praised the museums' recovery post-pandemic. - Academy of Sciences: CFO Jim Gohari highlighted a city budget of $7.7 million (total $80 million). The Academy faces a structural deficit and is cutting teacher professional development and the Bayview Science Institute (costing $200,000 from the Academy). Supervisors Walton and Melgar expressed concern about the cuts and urged better partnership with the SFPUC and respect for union workers. - War Memorial: Managing Director Kate Sofis reported 800,000 visitors across venues, supporting 11,500 jobs. The department is deferring capital projects and relying on 85% general fund support. - Arts Commission: Director Ralph Remington noted $17.2 million in grants to 101 nonprofits and 84 individual artists, and 203 art vendor licenses. Supervisor Melgar raised concerns about communication with communities regarding seismic retrofits at Mission Cultural Center and African American Arts and Culture Complex. - Department of Children, Youth and Families (DCYF): Director Maria Sue presented a $188 million operating budget (down from $212 million). The mayor added $11 million to expand grants, but state and federal grants decreased by $6 million. Supervisors Walton and Melgar worried about the impact on youth services, including food programs and juvenile justice. - Department on the Status of Women: Director Kimberly Ellis outlined a shift from grant-making to a watchdog role. The department's city grants fell from $13 million to $1 million, with remaining $800,000 for mental health initiatives. She highlighted San Francisco's poor rankings on gender equity (58th out of 58 in female state representation). - Human Rights Commission: Director Sheryl Davis reported a 20% citywide cut to the Dreamkeeper Initiative (approximately $10–15 million over two years). She requested a higher classification for the Office of Racial Equity position. Chair Chan questioned the efficiency of the SHARP program. - Recreation and Park Department: Director Antonio Guerra presented a budget with $8.5 million in reductions, including elimination of 5 positions and 50 unfunded FTEs. The department faces $1 million in mid-year cuts and loss of soda tax funding. Items 4–6 (grant acceptances) were discussed. - Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD): Director Sarah Dennis Phillips reported $21.1 million in reductions, including $9.6 million in workforce development. Chair Chan questioned the allocation of $2 million for a Powell Street light show while cutting workforce programs. Supervisor Melgar called for a comprehensive downtown recovery plan. - Department of Public Health (DPH): Director Grant Colfax presented a $3.2 billion budget with $47 million general fund decrease. DPH filled 96.8% of positions, with RN vacancies down 75%. Reductions include $3 million in healthy community grants (soda tax) and $2.5 million in street violence intervention. The committee forwarded items 7–10 (patient rates, Planned Parenthood grant, Maddy fund repeal). - Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH): Director Shireen McSpadden reported an $846.8 million budget for FY 2024–25, with $50.1 million for family homelessness (Safer Families initiative). The trailing legislation (items 11 and 12) allows reallocation of $13.676 million in interest from the Our City, Our Home fund and lifts the 12% cap on short-term rental subsidies. The committee amended item 11 to correct a dollar amount. - Department of Early Childhood (DEC): Director Ingrid Mejia presented a $336.6 million budget, expanding eligibility to 150% AMI. Item 13 proposes freezing the baseline for early care and education spending and using interest from the Babies and Families First Fund to offset general fund obligations. Public comment overwhelmingly opposed the diversion of Prop C funds. Public Comments & Testimony - Over 50 speakers addressed the committee, many opposing the proposed ordinance to use Baby Prop C interest for other purposes (item 13). Parents, educators, and advocates urged preservation of funds for early childhood education, arguing that the city should use reserves instead of cutting child care. - Other speakers opposed cuts to workforce development, homeless services, soda tax programs, and community-based organizations serving Latino, Pacific Islander, and Black communities. Specific concerns were raised about DCYF reductions, the loss of the Bayview Science Institute, and cuts to the Street Violence Intervention Program. Key Outcomes - Items 4 and 5 (Rec and Park grants: EV chargers and habitat conservation): Forwarded to the July 9 full board with positive recommendation. - Item 6 (USDA Forest Service reforestation grant): Continued to the call of the chair. - Items 7–10 (DPH patient rates, Planned Parenthood grant, Maddy fund repeal, and recurring grants): Forwarded to the July 9 full board with positive recommendation. - Item 11 (Our City, Our Home fund interest reallocation): Amended on page 4 to correct a dollar amount, then forwarded to the July 9 full board. - Item 12 (HSH fund expenditure plan): Forwarded to the July 9 full board. - Item 13 (Early care and education baseline modification): Continued to the call of the chair after a motion by Supervisor Melgar, who noted the need for further community discussion and amendments. - Items 1–3 (Mayor's proposed budget, appropriation ordinance, salary ordinance): Continued to the June 14 meeting of the committee.

EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 19% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 17% · PUBLIC HEALTH 12% · PROCEDURAL 7%
688
JUN 13, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - June 13, 2024

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on June 13, 2024, at 6:15 PM UTC (room 263, City Hall). Chair Catherine Stefani presided, joined by Vice Chair Myrna Melgar (referred to as Vice Chair Ingario in transcript) and Supervisor Matt Dorsey. The clerk was Monique Creighton. The committee considered one policy resolution and four liquor license applications, all of which were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Leather & LGBTQ Cultural District Report): Five speakers voiced support. Bob Brown, president of the cultural district, thanked the board and urged passage. Joe Ramirez Forcia (PRC Workforce Development) noted the district's events have placed thousands of people in first-time jobs. Paul Dowley (chair of land use committee) emphasized the district's importance as a safe queer space threatened by gentrification. Darren McKeeman (co-founder of Kink BMB) credited the district for supporting his business. Maxine Holloway, lead author of the report, described how leather culture saved lives and fostered community. No speakers opposed. - Items 2–5 (Liquor licenses): No public comment was offered on any of the four liquor license hearings. Discussion Items - Item 1 (240561): Resolution adopting the Leather and Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer Cultural District’s Cultural, History, Housing, and Economic Sustainability Strategy (CHESS) Report. Grace Lee from the Mayor’s Office of Community Development and Bob Goldfarb, executive director of the Leather & LGBTQ Cultural District, presented. The report outlines 34 strategies in six categories to preserve and sustain the district. The leather district, established in 2019, covers 24 blocks in SOMA. Key challenges include rising rents, development pressure, and displacement. The Folsom Street Fair, founded in 1984 to oppose redevelopment, now draws over 200,000 attendees. Chair Stefani added herself as a co-sponsor. Supervisor Dorsey praised the district’s work and noted recent street sign installations and banner projects. - Item 2 (240464): Type 42 on-sale beer and wine license for Embarc Wines at 2 Embarcadero Center. Officer Froines (SFPD ABC Licensing Unit) reported zero protests, low crime area, high concentration of licenses. The Alcohol Liaison Unit (ALU) recommended approval with conditions on noise, loitering, and litter. Co-owners Adam Levin-Good and Richard Garcia agreed to conditions and noted the venue would operate Monday–Friday, 1–8 PM. - Item 3 (240465): Type 90 on-sale general music venue license for Great Star Theater at 636 Jackson Street. Officer Froines reported zero protests, high crime area, high concentration. ALU recommended conditions including two uniformed security guards during live entertainment. Artistic director Paul Nathan described the theater’s history: built in 1925, the last remaining Chinese opera venue on the West Coast, hosting 100+ performances annually and drawing 3,000 visitors per week. He stated the theater brings 40,000 people to Chinatown over three months at full capacity. The applicant agreed to all conditions. - Item 4 (240466): Type 90 license for Zevi Cafe and Bistro at 67 5th Street. Officer Froines reported zero protests, high crime area, high concentration. ALU recommended conditions including security guards. Owner Mirian Zalel explained the restaurant opened in 2022 but struggled; a music venue license would help hire 10–15 employees and attract patrons. Supervisor Dorsey expressed strong support, noting the business’s perseverance through COVID. - Item 5 (240490): Type 90 license for August Hall at 420 Mason Street. Officer Froines reported zero protests, high crime area, high concentration. ALU recommended conditions. No applicant representative appeared. The committee noted no opposition from District 3 Supervisor Peskin. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Moved by Supervisor Dorsey to forward the resolution adopting the CHESS report to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Unanimous vote (3 ayes: Vice Chair Melgar, Supervisor Dorsey, Chair Stefani). - Items 2–5: Each liquor license was approved by a motion to prepare a resolution determining that issuance would serve public convenience or necessity, and to forward to the full board with a positive recommendation. All passed unanimously (3 ayes each). - All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on June 25, 2024.

LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 26% · LGBTQ+ HISTORY 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · CULTURAL DISTRICTS 13%
689
JUN 12, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
SF Budget Committee Hearing on Mayor's FY 2024-2026 Budget and Key Budget Decisions - June 12, 2024

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, held a marathon hearing on June 12, 2024, to review the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2024-2025 and 2025-2026. The meeting featured presentations from over a dozen city departments, discussions on trailing legislation, and extensive public testimony. A central theme was the difficult trade-offs required to close a projected $789 million deficit, balancing core services against cuts to community programs. Consent Calendar - Interim Budget (Items 1-3): Heard and filed. The interim appropriation and salary ordinances were forwarded to the full Board with a positive recommendation (5-0). - OCII Budget (Items 4-5): The interim and fiscal year budgets for the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure were forwarded to the full Board. - Cannabis Business Inspection Fees (Item 9): Ordinance eliminating unused DPH inspection fees and allowing CPI adjustments moved to the full Board. - Administrative Provisions, Taxes, and Graffiti Fund (Items 10, 11, 14, 15): Heard and filed; the associated ordinances were forwarded to the full Board. - Proposition J Contracts (Items 12, 13): Resolutions certifying contracted-out services (previously and not previously approved) were forwarded to the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony - Community Ambassador Program (CAP): A large contingent of CAP ambassadors, community members, and service providers spoke in strong support of restoring full funding. Speakers highlighted the program's role in overdose reversal, safety escorts, de-escalation, connecting vulnerable residents to resources, and providing dignified city jobs to formerly unhoused and immigrant workers. Speakers explicitly urged the committee to reject the Mayor's proposed cut. - Workers' Rights Community Collaborative (WRCC): Several speakers, representing Chinese Progressive Association and La Raza Centro Legal, opposed proposed cuts to the WRCC. They emphasized the program's success in recovering over $985,000 for workers and providing multilingual outreach. Speakers argued that cutting the program contradicted the recent expansion of the Language Access Ordinance. - Workforce & Homeless Services: Marnie Regan (Larkin Street) expressed concern over collective reductions to workforce programs across HSA, DCYF, and OEWD, calling the cuts contradictory to addressing the rise in homelessness. - Latinx & Arts Funding: Representatives from the San Francisco Latino Parity and Equity Coalition, Galeria de la Raza, and other organizations protested cuts to arts and culture funding, emphasizing their role in community well-being and the local economy. Discussion Items - Budget Overview & Deficit: Budget Director Anna Dooning and Controller Greg Wagner presented the $15.9 billion budget. The Controller noted the budget closes a $789 million deficit using $1 billion in one-time solutions (including a $445M drawdown of prior year fund balance) but warned of a persistent structural deficit of approximately $800 million in future years. General fund spending grows by only 0.4% in FY24-25. - Office of the Assessor-Recorder: Assessor Joaquín Torres highlighted an unprecedented surge in property tax appeals (nearly 8,000 filed in FY23-24, the highest in 25 years). He argued the proposed budget increase is necessary to defend the $4.1 billion property tax roll and minimize deferred revenue. - City Administrator's Office / OSEA Ambassador Cut: City Administrator Carmen Chu presented her budget, which exceeded the 10% general fund reduction target ($20M in savings). Cuts include reduced 311 service hours (eliminating in-person overnight call-taking) and the Mayor's decision to discontinue the OSEA Community Ambassador Program (saving $2M in FY25-26). Supervisor Preston strongly opposed the elimination, calling it a "fantastic city program" and questioning why a city-run program was eliminated while contracted programs were not. Chair Chan and Supervisor Walton voiced significant concerns. The Mayor's Budget Director stated it was a "policy decision" to prioritize safety-focused ambassadors over the community outreach role of the OSEA program. - Health Service System Board Decision: A major debate arose from the HSS Board's rejection of a competitively bid Blue Shield Medicare plan ($67M savings over 3 years) in favor of renewing a more expensive United Healthcare plan ($43M over 3 years). Chair Chan called this a "serious problem" for the deficit, demanding a report back on the next vote. Supervisor Dorsey, an HSS Board member, expressed concern about disregarding the rigorous RFP process and prudent fiduciary duty. - Ethics Commission Reclassifications: Chair Chan questioned a series of position upgrades proposed by the Ethics Commission, expressing concern about approving salary increases during a budget crisis and highlighting a citywide trend of hiring management twice as fast as line workers. She requested further analysis from the Budget and Legislative Analyst. - Prop I Revenue & Affordable Housing (MOHCD): Supervisor Preston pressed MOHCD Director Dan Adams and Budget Director Dooning, confirming that no net new Prop I funds were allocated for the Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board's recommended priorities. A detailed discussion on the Small Sites Acquisition Program followed, revealing FY25-26 has limited dedicated funding beyond regular impact fees and the housing trust fund, despite heavy investment in the current year. - Department of Public Works & HSA: Public Works detailed the use of a $16.9M supplemental (expiring at end of FY24-25) to fund 20 temporary FTE street cleaners. HSA highlighted significant state budget risks and the use of Dignity Fund growth to backfill general fund cuts rather than expand senior programming. Key Outcomes - OSEA Ambassador Program (CAP): No immediate vote to restore the cut, but Chair Chan and multiple members explicitly stated the program was a funding priority, signaling intent to restore it through the board's budget process. - Health Service System (HSS): Committee awaits outcome of the HSS Board vote on the United Healthcare renewal. Chair Chan requested a prompt report back. - Assessment Appeals Board Filing System (Item 16): Appropriation ordinance continued to the call of the chair to resolve accounting concerns regarding potential double-counting of revenue. - Full Budget (Items 6-8): Hearing on the full budget and associated ordinances continued to June 13, 2024.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 28% · PROCEDURAL 14% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 12% · PUBLIC HEALTH 6%
690
JUN 12, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – June 12, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission met on June 12, 2024, to discuss crime trends, the Collaborative Reform Initiative (CRI) implementation, proposed working groups for 2024, and other police oversight matters. The meeting included public comment, reports from the Chief of Police and Department of Police Accountability (DPA), and votes on the consent calendar and closed session. A new commissioner was welcomed, and a returning commissioner was recognized. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously voted to accept and file the SFPD's SB 1421 and SB 16 monthly report (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - A member of the public criticized the Chief for wearing a rainbow flag, calling it fictional and pride as enemy of intelligence, and discussed patrol specials and the treatment of former Chief Jane Warner. - A speaker alleged illegal access to public health/safety systems by domestic and international actors, asking the commission to work with other jurisdictions to stop a supposed civil war. - A woman reported that Officer Paul Ruedi failed to properly investigate her restraining order and death threats, leading to her fear of retaliation. - A mother of a murder victim from 2006 (Aubrey Abracasa) demanded justice and urged use of reward funds to solve unsolved homicides. - A speaker urged moving part of the Castro into the Park Station district during the boundary analysis and expressed dismay about the continued vibrancy of downtown drug markets despite health-focused strategies. Discussion Items - Weekly Officer Recognition: Officer Dennis Akmache (Traffic Company) was recognized for his role in identifying and arresting a suspect in a fatal hit-and-run collision. Lieutenant O'Connor and Chief Scott praised his proactive work; it was also noted that Officer Akmache helped save a person from overdosing en route to the meeting. - Chief’s Report: Chief Scott reported overall part I crime down 30% (almost 7,000 fewer crimes year-to-date), property crime down 33%, violent crime down 13%, car break-ins down 51%, homicides down 36% (14 vs 22), and total gun violence down 36%. He detailed a homicide at Dolores Park, a non-fatal shooting, and multiple sideshow events over the weekend where officers were assaulted with bottles, rocks, lasers, and explosives. The department’s rapid response broke up the events; air support (drones/helicopters) was noted as helpful for future management. The Chief also discussed the tenderloin drug market strategy update, mentioning a pilot where medical staff are on call for outreach by Co-Tenderloin, leading to about 50 people getting off the streets. A $1 million donation for officer wellness was discussed; it will be distributed through a separate foundation after captains submit plans. - DPA Director’s Report: Acting Director Rosenstein stated DPA opened 8 new cases, closed 13, and pending cases are trending downward. The audit division, with the Controller’s Office, followed up on a 2020 use of force audit; the department has completed 33 of 37 agreed-upon recommendations, with 4 outstanding. DPA participated in Juneteenth and Pride events, and is researching for Prop E-related changes to DGO 5.05. - Commission Reports: President Elias announced the review of police district boundaries, mandated every 10 years, with a deadline for a recommendation by January 2025 and implementation by July 2026. Vice President Carter Oberstone thanked outgoing Commissioner Byrne, welcomed Commissioner Walker and retired Judge Clay, and requested to re-agendize the SF Safe issue. Commissioner Walker reported on progress toward increasing women in policing (30x30 commitment), including a child care pilot with Supervisor Melgar’s office. - Collaborative Reform Initiative (CRI) Implementation Update: Sergeant Rivera presented that all 272 recommendations are now in various stages: 245 in substantial compliance, 24 with Jensen Hughes for validation, and 3 with California DOJ for external validation. Discussion focused on how Prop E affects use of force reporting and data collection; the department intends to rely more on body-worn cameras and is seeking technology upgrades (transcription, redaction) in the budget. Commissioner Elias pressed on the need to maintain audit capability, and Vice President Carter Oberstone questioned whether substantial compliance equates to best practices. Chief Scott and Sergeant Rivera emphasized the cultural shift and continuous improvement. Commissioner Yanez raised concerns about persistent racial disparities in stops and use of force; Chief Scott outlined strategies including the new DGO 9.07 and violence reduction efforts. - Proposed 2024 DGO Working Group List: Hitesh (community policy working group coordinator) proposed two working groups for the remainder of 2024: DGO 5.20 (Language Access Services) and DGO 6.16 (Sexual Assault Investigations), citing administrative capacity and time constraints. DPA concurred with this selection. The commission voted unanimously to approve those two working groups. Key Outcomes - Vote on Consent Calendar: Approved 6-0. - Vote on Closed Session: Commissioners voted 6-0 to hold Item 11 in closed session, then voted 6-0 not to disclose any discussion from closed session. - Vote on DGO Working Groups: Unanimously approved moving forward with working groups for DGO 5.20 (Language Access) and DGO 6.16 (Sexual Assault Investigations). - Next Steps: The Chief will present a budget request for technology to implement Prop E; the district boundary review continues with public input opportunities; the CRI report from Cal DOJ and Jensen Hughes is expected in the coming months; the SF Safe issue may be re-agendized.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 35% · PROCEDURAL 21% · PUBLIC SAFETY 14% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 11%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com