The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on June 3, 2024, at 10:00 AM (agenda start time) under Acting Chair Supervisor Shamon Walton, joined by Supervisor Safai and Supervisor Chan (substituting for Supervisor Ronan). The committee considered seven agenda items, including a controversial ordinance to streamline contracting for Vision Zero projects, multiple appointments to city commissions, and amendments to vending enforcement rules. Several items were continued to the June 10 meeting, while others were approved or rejected. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 1 (Vision Zero contracting), multiple speakers opposed the ordinance, arguing it would waive competitive bidding, local business enterprise (LBE) requirements, and environmental protections. One speaker stated, "You should kill this entire ... it's not needed. Just because somebody's not doing their job doesn't mean you lower the bar." Another criticized SFMTA's track record, saying, "You want to take the guardrails off of an agency that has one of the worst track records ... for transparency." - On Item 6 (Police Commission reappointment of Debra Walker), public comment was divided. Supporters praised her integrity, fairness, and efforts to bridge divides. One speaker said, "Deborah Walker’s sense of ethics alone are important to the Commission’s balance." Opponents accused her of undermining the commission by supporting Proposition E and causing meetings to be canceled. One speaker claimed, "She has been the mayor's tool to shut down the police commission." Discussion Items - Item 1 – Streamlined Contracting for Vision Zero Projects (Ordinance 240501): Supervisor Chan, the sponsor, stated the city has not met its Vision Zero goal and that delays in contracting have slowed safety improvements. The ordinance would allow SFMTA and Public Works to waive certain administrative code provisions (competitive bidding, LBE, equal benefits, etc.) for Vision Zero projects for three years. Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson clarified that the legislation does not waive federal or state requirements. Supervisor Safai expressed concerns about the lack of a specific project list, dollar caps, and potential for sole-source contracts. SFMTA representative Joel Ramos could not provide detailed project timelines or costs. Public Works’ Alex Burns estimated the waiver could reduce procurement time from 9–10 months to 5–6 months and identified about 15 potential projects. The committee amended the long title to clarify the three-year limit and that the purpose is to expedite contracts. The item was continued to June 10, 2024, for further negotiations. - Item 4 – Appointments to Our City, Our Home Oversight Committee: Four seats were filled from five applicants. Nancy Gitoito, a community advocate with lived experience of homelessness, spoke about her work with the African diaspora and her refusal to evict black tenants. Jennifer Friedenbach, reappointed to Seat 8, highlighted the impact of Proposition C funding, noting that without it homelessness would have increased 34%. The committee approved Chanel Williams (Seat 2), Kezia V. Martinez (Seat 4), Julia DiAntonio (Seat 6), and Jennifer Friedenbach (Seat 8). - Item 5 – Appointment of C. Don Clay to Police Commission: Judge Clay, a 45-year resident and former presiding judge, stated his desire to serve as a continuation of public service. He emphasized the need for mutual respect between the community and police. In response to a question about the commission's power, he said, "You always gotta be on the side of restricting power." Supervisor Safai asked about the 272 DOJ reforms; Clay had not studied them but acknowledged their importance. The committee approved the appointment unanimously. - Item 6 – Reappointment of Debra Walker to Police Commission: Commissioner Walker, a 45-year resident and veteran of multiple commissions, discussed her work on police reform, alternatives to policing, and the HART program. She supported Proposition E, arguing it would improve officer morale and recruitment. Supervisor Safai pressed her on her statement that there was "way too much input from people who don't know what it's like to be a cop" and on her support for Prop E, which he argued undermined the commission's authority. Chair Walton expressed concern that she did not believe the commission should set policy for the department. The committee voted to reject the reappointment (2-0, with Chan absent). - Item 7 – Vending Requirements and Restrictions (Public Works Code): Supervisor Safai introduced amendments to streamline enforcement against illegal vending, particularly fencing of stolen goods. The amendments allow a verbal warning to be documented and remain effective for 120 days, enabling inspectors to take enforcement action without repeated warnings. Director Short noted it would help "address the bad actors who are ... involved in fencing of stolen goods." The committee approved the amendments and continued the item to June 10, 2024. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Vision Zero contracting): Amended and continued to June 10, 2024, for further discussion on project lists and vendor qualifications. - Item 2 (Jessica Campos, Child Care Planning Council): Approved unanimously and forwarded to the full Board. - Item 3 (Jayshawn Anderson, Sanitation and Streets Commission): Approved unanimously. - Item 4 (Our City, Our Home Oversight Committee): Approved: Chanel Williams (Seat 2), Kezia V. Martinez (Seat 4), Julia DiAntonio (Seat 6), Jennifer Friedenbach (Seat 8). - Item 5 (C. Don Clay, Police Commission): Approved unanimously. - Item 6 (Debra Walker, Police Commission): Rejected (2-0, Supervisor Chan absent). - Item 7 (Vending enforcement): Amended and continued to June 10, 2024. Note: All items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on June 11, 2024, unless otherwise stated.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThis regular meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Land Use and Transportation Committee convened on June 3, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Chair Mirna Melgar presided, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Member Aaron Peskin. The committee considered three agenda items, including a Divisadero Street liquor store exemption, a Lovejoy's Tea Room parklet waiver, and amendments to the Wawona Street/45th Avenue Cultural Center Special Use District and Local Coastal Program. All items were approved unanimously and recommended as committee reports to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Divisadero Street liquor store exemption): Tick Falletti (James Lewis) of Falletti Foods expressed support for the exemption, noting the site's vacancy and the need for flexibility. He stated that the proposed tenant, Bitters and Bottles, would complement the existing grocery store. No opposition was voiced. - Item 2 (Lovejoy's Tea Room parklet): Celine O'Driscoll, co-owner, spoke in support, emphasizing the parklet's role in sustaining the business and retaining employees. Two additional community members, Leo Cassidy and Redmond Lyons, also voiced support, citing the tea room's value to the neighborhood. - Items 3 & 4 (Cultural Center SUD and Coastal Program amendments): Opposition speakers included Eileen Bogan (SPEAC) and several community members who argued the ordinance was a backdoor to bypass appeals to the California Coastal Commission, referenced nearly 1,200 pages of written opposition, and criticized the process as insufficiently public. Supporters included Jean Connolly, Stephanie O'Sullivan, John Kevlin (attorney for the Irish Center), Liam Reedy (UICC president), and others, who highlighted the center's community role, decades of service, and adherence to all required processes. Discussion Items - Item 1: Divisadero Street Neighborhood Commercial Transit District – Liquor Store Exemption (File 240263): Supervisor Preston introduced the ordinance, which would exempt the Falletti's Plaza mixed-use project at 1275 Fell Street from the Divisadero Alcohol Restricted Use District (RUD), originally recommended by the Planning Commission in 2004. He noted the site had been vacant since the Bank of America closed during the pandemic. The Planning Commission unanimously recommended approval on May 23, 2024, with technical amendments. Planning staff presented the amendments, which included citing the correct assessor's blocks and updating the NCT reference. Chair Melgar noted the broader trend of bank closures and looked forward to future discussions. - Item 2: Lovejoy's Tea Room Parklet on Clipper Street (File 240503): Adam Tongsebut from Supervisor Mandelman's office presented the ordinance, which would waive administrative code requirements to allow the parklet to occupy both the parking lane and a portion of the sidewalk on the 100 block of Clipper Street. The parklet had to relocate from Church Street due to pedestrian visibility requirements at a Muni Metro stop. The sidewalk on Clipper Street is 15 feet wide, leaving 10 feet of clearance. The parklet is critical for the business's post-pandemic recovery. - Items 3 & 4: Wawona Street and 45th Avenue Cultural Center Special Use District and Local Coastal Program Amendments (Files 240228, 240563): Supervisor Engardio, the sponsor, explained the ordinance supports the redevelopment of the United Irish Cultural Center (UICC) at 2700 45th Avenue, a neighborhood gathering space since the 1970s. The amendments incorporate feedback from the California Coastal Commission, including clarifying the 100-foot height limit and designating principally permitted uses. President Peskin provided context on the Coastal Act, noting that only three appeals from San Francisco have reached the Coastal Commission in 40 years, and that the change aligns with other municipalities. Planning staff confirmed the SUD is effective but not yet operative pending Coastal Commission certification. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to approve the technical amendments and recommend the amended ordinance as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors for the June 4, 2024 meeting. - Item 2: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend the ordinance as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors. - Items 3 and 4: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend item 3 (ordinance) as a committee report and item 4 (resolution) to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation.
This meeting of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) convened at 9:30 AM with a quorum present (President Paulson, Vice President Rivera, Commissioner Jami, Commissioner Stacy). The commission approved a consent calendar of seven items, debated the Stonestown development agreement and a major water supply planning amendment, and unanimously approved a $75 million renewable energy contract. Public comment highlighted community concerns about sewage infrastructure in the Bayview, water supply adequacy, and strong support for the Stonestown project. Consent Calendar - Item 7a: Awarded Contract No. WD-2903 for site remediation at 520 John Muir Drive Phase 2 to Anvil Builders, Inc. - Item 7b: Awarded Contract No. WW-751 for as-needed sewer inspection to Pipe and Plant Solutions, Inc. - Item 7c: Awarded four contracts (PRO.0291 A-D) for professional energy engineering consulting services to Veregy Pacific LLC, kW Engineering, Inc., and others. - Item 7d: Approved a 90-calendar-day extension to the duration contingency for Contract No. WW-719A (Folsom Area Stormwater Improvements), citing a conflicting PG&E electrical transmission line larger than expected. - Item 7e: Approved Amendment No. 3 to Contract No. PRO.0028 (New Headworks Facility) with HDR Engineering, Inc. - Item 7f: Accepted work performed by Wilson Utility Construction Company under Contract No. HH-1007 (Transmission Line 7/8 Upgrades). - Item 7g: Accepted work performed by Hernandez Engineering under Contract No. WD-2819 (As-Needed Water Main Replacement). All consent calendar items were approved unanimously (4-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: A speaker urged the commission to read the Emerson document regarding Bayview/Hunter's Point community benefits and the SSIP system improvement project. Joy Somphon (Bayview resident) requested more advocacy and outreach for the 94124 area regarding sewage issues. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust): Noted that as of May 2024, the SFPUC has 481,000 acre-feet of water entitlement, demand has been under 200 MGD (225,000 acre-feet/year) for nine years, and reservoir storage can last over six years. He argued that these figures should be considered when investing in expensive alternative water supplies and requested a discussion on the alternative water supply plan at the June 11 meeting. - Stonestown Development (Item 11): Multiple speakers supported the project. Mauricio Chavez (NorCal Carpenters Union) said it will create 800 construction jobs per year. Rudy Gonzalez (Secretary-Treasurer, SF Building Trades Council) and Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition) also voiced strong support. Neko Stewart, a local resident, praised the transformation of surface parking lots into housing and parks. - Los Vaqueros Reservoir (Item 13): Peter Dreckmeyer again spoke, arguing that the 20,000 acre-feet of storage would cost $13 million per year (over $260 million in 20 years) for water that is not needed given the SFPUC's current ample storage and declining demand. Discussion Items - Item 5a – Quarterly Audit and Performance Review Report: Irella Blackwood (Audit Director) presented. As of March 31, 2024, 21 audits (59% of the planned portfolio) were completed, with 29% in progress. The bureau conducted an inventory management assessment, finding overall dollar value accuracy of 98.2% (inaccuracies totaling $347,000). Key recommendations addressed field tracking system issues. 11 audit recommendations remain open. Commissioner questions focused on inventory scope and delays in rent collection from Crystal Springs Golf Partners. - Item 5b – General Manager Report: General Manager Herrera reported that the SFPUC's two-year operating and capital budget (totaling over $7 billion) was approved by the Budget and Appropriations Committee with $6 million in cuts per year, and is proceeding to the full Board of Supervisors. - Item 6 – Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Report: Nicole Sandkulla (BAWSCA CEO) affirmed BAWSCA's support for the recently adopted 8.8% wholesale water rate increase, citing necessary investments in the Hetch Hetchy system, capital improvements, and long-term water supply planning. She emphasized the importance of continued engagement. - Item 11 – Stonestown Development Agreement: Molly Petrick presented a 43-acre mixed-use master plan with up to 3,500 housing units (20% affordable), six acres of parks, and commercial space. Commissioner Rivera expressed concern that the developer is not required to install the Emergency Firefighting Water System (EFWS); staff noted the fire department made that determination. Commissioner Stacey noted that the developer will pay an in-lieu fee for a mobile hose tender system. The commission authorized the General Manager to consent to the development agreement. - Item 12 – CleanPowerSF Renewable Power Purchase Agreement: Julia O'Geen (Director of Origination and Power Supply) presented a 10-year, $75 million PPA with IP Easley LLC for a 50 MW slice of a 400 MW solar project in Riverside County. The project uses U.S.-made components and has a project labor agreement. Commissioner Jami asked about portfolio management, time coincidence, and battery storage. The contract was approved. - Item 13 – Los Vaqueros Reservoir Expansion Project Planning Amendment: Steve Ritchie (Assistant GM for Water) provided a detailed presentation on the multi-party project to expand the reservoir by 115,000 acre-feet and build a pipeline to the South Bay Aqueduct. The amendment extends the planning agreement by 12 months (no additional funds). The SFPUC is considering purchasing 10,000–20,000 acre-feet of storage at an average annual cost of $9.5–$13 million. Key challenges include securing water rights, conveying water through the South Bay Aqueduct, and institutional complexity. The commission approved the amendment. - Item 14 – Onsite Water Reuse Grant Program: Taylor Nakudian (Water Resources Program Manager) presented modifications to lower potable water offset thresholds (e.g., 3.6 million gallons over 10 years for up to $200,000), shorten the required construction schedule from 4 to 2 years, and clarify requirements for prevailing wage, insurance, and grantee property ownership. The modifications were approved. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (Items 7a-7g): Approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 8 (Contract with USDA Forest Service): Approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 9 (Bay Corridor Phase 4 Water Improvements): Approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 10 (Hayes Valley Sewer Improvements): Approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 11 (Stonestown Development Agreement): Motion to authorize the General Manager to consent passed 4-0 (Vice President Rivera and others voiced concerns about fire safety; the item was approved). - Item 12 (CleanPowerSF PPA): Approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 13 (Los Vaqueros Planning Amendment): Approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 14 (Onsite Water Reuse Grant Program Modifications): Approved unanimously (4-0). - Next Steps: The alternative water supply plan discussion requested by Commissioner Stacy will occur at the June 11, 2024 meeting. The SFPUC staff will continue negotiating the Los Vaqueros project and bring a final decision to the commission within 6–12 months.
The San Francisco Planning Commission held a special closed session hearing on Thursday, May 23, 2024, at 2:00 PM (assumed start time based on agenda). The meeting included public comment on matters to be considered in closed session, a vote to assert attorney-client privilege, a closed session for conference with legal counsel regarding existing litigation, and a report in open session that no action was taken during the closed session. Public Comments & Testimony - George Shutish requested that the public be allowed to hear the closed session discussions, noting that the public had alerted staff, the commission, and the Board of Supervisors to the UDU (Unlawful Detainer? or other acronym – not defined in transcript) and that the UDU is central to the issue. He acknowledged the importance of attorney-client privilege but suggested that if privilege was asserted, the commission should discuss the matter when doors reopen. No other public comments were made. Discussion Items - Motion to Assert Attorney-Client Privilege: Commissioner Sowe (or Seo, as transcribed) moved to consider a motion to assert attorney-client privilege regarding the matters listed as Conference with Legal Counsel (item 2 on the agenda). The motion was seconded and put to a vote. Key Outcomes - Vote on Motion to Assert Attorney-Client Privilege: The motion passed unanimously with a vote of 6–0 (Commissioners Sowe, Williams, Braun, Imperial, Moore, and President Diamond all voting “Aye”). Commissioner Coppel was absent. - Closed Session Held: The commission then proceeded into closed session for conference with legal counsel regarding existing litigation (item 3). - Report on Closed Session: After reconvening in open session, the commission reported that no action was taken during the closed session. A motion to that effect was seconded by Commissioner Williams.
The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on May 23, 2024, to address a full agenda including continuances, approval of minutes, general public comment, and eight regular calendar items. The meeting involved extensive debate on zoning code amendments, conditional use authorizations, and an informational hearing on a major affordable housing project. Procedural and Consent Items - Continuances: The commission unanimously approved the continuance of Items 1 (320-322 Frederick Street), 2 (1310 Junipero Serra Blvd), and 3 (350 Rhode Island Street – withdrawn) to June 6, 2024, and Items 16 (336 Pierce Street) and 17 (1131-1133 Anza Street) to June 13, 2024. Tenants from Item 17 requested the item be heard that day, but staff noted that new tenant information required review. The commission allowed the tenants to speak during General Public Comment. Vote: unanimous. - Minutes: The commission adopted the draft minutes from May 9, 2024, with a correction on Item 8 (action at 638 Rhode Island Street changed to “take DR and approve with modifications”). Vote: unanimous. General Public Comments & Testimony - A speaker discussed demolition calculations for 474 Valley Street and provided a handout with a chart advocating for adjusted thresholds under Section 317. - Tenants from 1131-1133 Anza Street (Juan Lopez, Noah, Celestina Belasco) stated that the original development application contained incorrect tenant history, that they were not notified by the landlord, and that they hold month-to-month leases, making them feel vulnerable. - A remote speaker (Ms. Hester) asked that advanced calendars include more complete information. Discussion Items Item 9: 135 Kissling Street – Rezone and Vehicle Storage Amendments - Proposal: Ordinance to rezone 135 Kissling Street from RED to REDMX and conditionally permit vehicle storage lots in REDMX and WMUG districts. Staff recommended a modification to include the WMUG district. - Positions: Supervisor Dorsey’s office and the project sponsor (Royal Motors) supported the changes, stating they correct an oversight from the code reorganization. Staff argued the amendment restores a previously allowed use. - Commission Debate: Commissioners Imperial and Moore expressed concerns about broader land use implications and the lack of analysis for the WMUG expansion, but the majority viewed the change as correcting an inadvertent error. - Outcome: Approved 4-2 with staff’s recommended modification (Commissioners Imperial and Moore voting against). Item 10: Density Exception on Specified Lots (Peskin Amendments) - Proposal: Legislation by Supervisor Peskin to allow form-based density in well-resourced neighborhoods with a requirement that units added above base density must be rent-controlled, and that state density bonus cannot be combined with it. - Positions: Staff presented analysis showing the Peskin option would yield fewer units than the state bonus. Many public speakers opposed the piecemeal approach, called for a comprehensive rezoning plan, and argued that rent control is not equivalent to affordable housing. Development advocates supported the Mayor’s version and criticized the cap on the state bonus. - Commission Debate: Commissioners struggled with the lack of economic analysis and piecemeal nature. A motion to approve the Peskin legislation without staff recommendations failed 3-3. No alternative motion passed, resulting in an effective disapproval. - Outcome: The commission did not recommend approval (automatic disapproval due to inability to reach a majority). Item 11: Divisadero Street NCT – Liquor Store Use Amendment - Proposal: Ordinance to allow a liquor store at Folletti Foods Plaza; staff recommended two modifications: (1) a broader amendment to conditionally permit liquor stores throughout the Divisadero NCT, and (2) technical cleanup of footnotes. - Positions: Supervisor Preston’s office supported the project but had not yet taken a position on the broader amendment. Tick Folletti spoke in support, emphasizing the store would complement his grocery. - Commission Debate: Commissioners praised the project and urged the Supervisor to explore the broader policy change with community input. - Outcome: Approved unanimously with Modification 2 (technical amendments) and encouragement to pursue Modification 1. Item 12: 880 McAllister Street – SB 423 Informational Hearing (Freedom West 2.0) - Proposal: Informational presentation on an upcoming SB 423 development application for a 115-unit 100% affordable senior building, part of the larger Freedom West co-op redevelopment. - Positions: Project sponsor (McFarland Capital Partners) and co-op board members described a community-driven process with over 1,000 touchpoints, emphasizing that existing residents would be protected and the project would provide services and long-term affordability. Public comment was supportive. - Commission Debate: Commissioners asked about long-term maintenance and activation of street-level spaces, expressing enthusiasm for the project. - Outcome: Informational only; no action required. Item 13: 249 Texas Street – Conditional Use for Demolition and New Two-Unit Building - Proposal: CUA to demolish and construct a two-unit residence. Staff recommended approval. - Positions: Organized opposition from neighbors argued that the Board of Supervisors’ prior disapproval should stand and that the project would eliminate naturally affordable units. The project sponsor and architect denied allegations of evictions and stated the new units would be rent-controlled and larger. - Commission Debate: The commission was deeply divided. A motion to approve with a condition for a key-coded elevator failed 3-3. A subsequent motion to continue to June 13, 2024 passed 4-2, with the sponsor expressing frustration but the majority preferring to allow time for possible resolution and to have a full commission. - Outcome: Continued to June 13, 2024. Item 14: 680 Mission Street – Intermediate Length Occupancy (ILO) for 35 Units - Proposal: CUA to classify 35 dwelling units (7% of 486 units) as ILO (rentals from 31–364 days). Staff recommended approval. - Positions: Project sponsor cited benefits as a housing bridge and for downtown revitalization. No public comment offered. - Commission Debate: A commissioner asked about a prior fire incident; staff confirmed the building passed all inspections. Project sponsor noted that only five of the 35 units are currently vacant; the rest are under one-year leases. - Outcome: Approved 5-1 (Commissioner Williams dissented). Item 15: 466 Elizabeth Street – Legalization of Unpermitted Demolition and Renovation - Proposal: CUA to legalize a demolition that exceeded thresholds during renovation due to dry rot and structural issues. Staff recommended approval, noting that no procedural requirements were bypassed and that the two rent-controlled units would be preserved. - Positions: The contractor described emergency removal of a failing wall. Public comment raised concerns about demolition thresholds and urged better notification. - Commission Debate: Commissioners acknowledged the emergency circumstances and noted that the project maintains the same massing and unit count as previously approved. - Outcome: Approved unanimously with conditions. Key Outcomes - Continuances Approved: Items 1, 2, 3, 16, 17. - Approved: Item 9 (rezone), Item 11 (Divisadero NCT liquor with technical amendment), Item 14 (680 Mission ILO), Item 15 (Elizabeth Street legalization). - Disapproved: Item 10 (Peskin density exception) – commission effectively disapproval. - Continued: Item 13 (249 Texas Street) to June 13, 2024. - Informational: Item 12 (Freedom West 2.0) – no action.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on May 22, 2024, to review the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2024-2025 and 2025-2026, along with several trailing legislation items. The committee heard presentations from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) and department heads, accepted public comments, and voted on numerous items including budget approvals, bond authorizations, and fee adjustments. Public Comments & Testimony - Language Access Ordinance: Jose Un from Chinese for Affirmative Action expressed support for strengthening language access services. - SFPUC Budget and Bonds: Multiple speakers (Eileen Bulkin, Peter Dreckmeyer, Mary Butterwick) urged the committee to condition approval on a full independent audit of the SFPUC's financial and operational practices, citing concerns about debt service ratios, cost overruns, and environmental impacts on the Tuolumne River. - DBI Fee Increase and Community Co-Enforcement: Several representatives from tenant advocacy organizations (Priti Bateke, Juan Garcia, Becky, Sonica) spoke in support of the fee increase but requested that the community co-enforcement programs be funded through DBI's budget rather than the general fund, emphasizing the programs' role in language access and handling thousands of calls. Discussion Items - Item 1: Language Access Ordinance Amendments (Supervisor Walton): Proposed lowering the threshold for requiring language services, adding Vietnamese by 2026, and requiring new signage and digital content translations. OCEIA presented staffing needs of approximately $600,000 for new positions and reclassifications. The BLA noted fiscal impacts but considered approval a policy matter. - Item 2: Proposition J Contract Certification: Controllers office confirmed no new contracting-out proposals; all are long-standing. Approved without debate. - Items 3-5: Budget Hearings for Selected Departments: The committee reviewed BLA recommendations for multiple departments. Key points: - Airport: Agreed to $7.77M (FY24-25) and $680.9K (FY25-26) in one-time savings. - Retirement System: Agreed to $8.81M (FY24-25) and $630K (FY25-26) in savings. - Public Library: Agreed to $726K (FY24-25) and $283K (FY25-26) in savings, but a policy recommendation to upgrade a secretary to a manager position was debated. The library argued for a safety officer position (OSHA/ADA), citing a cost savings of $12,694 annually after eliminating a DPH work order. BLA noted long-term costs. Committee deferred decision on the upgrade, placing dollars on reserve. - Port: Agreed to $461K (FY24-25) and $227K (FY25-26) in savings. - SFPUC: Agreed to $4.8M (FY24-25) and $6.05M (FY25-26) in savings. BLA recommended a hearing on capital project cost escalation strategies. - Department of Building Inspection (DBI): Agreed to $50K annual savings. A policy recommendation to upgrade a commission secretary position (1555 to 0922 manager) was not accepted; committee kept the position at 1555. - Item 6: Library Grant Acceptance: Accept $1,080,375 from Friends of the San Francisco Public Library for FY24-25. - Item 7: Port Grant Acceptance: Retroactively accept $118,314 from DHS Port Security Grant Program. - Item 8: Board of Appeals Surcharges: Increase surcharges on DBI and planning permits from $39 to $44 to cover costs. - Item 9: DBI Fee Increase: Ordinance to increase fees over three years to achieve cost recovery, based on a fee study. Community co-enforcement funding shifted to general fund; advocates requested return to DBI budget. - Items 10-13: SFPUC Capital Budget and Bond Authorizations: - Item 10: Appropriation for capital projects ($1.79B FY24-25, $1.8B FY25-26). - Items 11-13: Bond authorizations for wastewater (up to $1.72B), power (up to $293M), and water (up to $1.04B). BLA highlighted debt service costs ($221.5M/year) and affordability concerns. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (4-0-1, Vice Chair Mandelman absent). - Item 2: Forwarded to full board (4-0). - Item 6: Library grant resolution forwarded to full board (5-0). - Item 7: Port grant resolution forwarded to full board (5-0). - Item 8: Ordinance forwarded to full board (4-0). - Item 9: DBI fee increase ordinance forwarded to full board (4-0, one member absent). - Items 10-12: SFPUC capital budget and bond authorizations (wastewater and power) forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (5-0). - Item 13: Amended to add $5 million for Pine Lake Main Break Emergency, then continued to the June 5, 2024, meeting (5-0). - Items 3-5: Hearing (item 3) was filed; budget and salary ordinances (items 4-5) were continued to the call of the chair to be considered alongside general fund departments. - Policy Recommendation on Library Position: The committee did not approve the upward substitution of a secretary to manager; the dollars were placed on reserve for further discussion during the June budget process. - SFPUC Oversight: Committee accepted BLA recommendation to hold a hearing by June 2026 on capital cost management and procurement reform for Chapter 6 departments. - DBI Commission Secretary Upgrade: Not approved; position remains at 1555 classification.
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on May 22, 2024, to consider multiple resolutions including real property leases, airport concessions, a three-year Mental Health Services Act plan, and grant agreements for homeless services. The committee voted unanimously to forward all items to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, with one amendment to the Urban Alchemy 711 Post Street shelter contract. Consent Calendar - Items 1 and 2: Resolutions approving 15-year and 10-year leases with Trinity Center, LLC at 1145 Market Street for the Law Library ($599,000 initial base rent) and Health Service System ($588,787.05 initial base rent), both with 3% annual increases. Approved unanimously. - Item 3: Resolution approving a seven-year museum store lease at Harvey Milk Terminal 1 with Love from USA Group, Inc. (minimum annual guarantee $205,000). Approved unanimously. - Item 4: Resolution approving amendment to the Terminal 3 coffee and quick serve concession lease with Elevate Gourmet Brands SFO group, removing the SF Mac and Cheese Kitchen facility, reimbursing $279,627 for unamortized construction costs, and reducing the minimum annual guarantee from $375,000 to $185,000. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 5 (Mental Health Services Act Plan): Multiple speakers, including Tracy Helton, Mark, Maria Jimenez, Nancy, Erin Rubin, Frank Johnson, and Angela Tang (CEO of Rams), expressed strong support for MHSA-funded programs, particularly peer support, vocational services (Rams Higher Ability), and prevention programs (Fuerte). They urged avoiding cuts and highlighted personal success stories of recovery and employment. - On Item 6 (SF New Deal grants): Carol Tang (Children's Creativity Museum), Raquel Redondias (SOMA Pilipinas), and Scott Roitz (Yerba Buena Community Benefit District) thanked the committee and emphasized the importance of grants for small businesses impacted by the APEC summit, calling for continued community engagement. - On Items 9 and 10 (Urban Alchemy contracts): Brian Shepherd, Dwight Jones, Danielle Killingsworth, Everett Butler, and others from Urban Alchemy spoke in support, detailing their work at 33 Gough and 711 Post Street, including housing placements, community engagement, and maintaining clean and safe neighborhoods. Discussion Items - Item 5 (Mental Health Services Act Three-Year Plan): Jessica Brown (DPH) presented the FY 2023-2026 integrated plan, covering outcomes (e.g., 86% decrease in arrests for older adults in full service partnerships, 87% decrease in mental health emergencies for adults) and the upcoming transition under Proposition 1 (reducing funding categories from five to three). Vice Chair Mandelman expressed concern about the plan's disconnect from acute behavioral health needs and homelessness, and urged a stronger focus on severe mental illness. Chair Chan asked about the timeline for aligning with Prop 1 requirements; the department plans to return for briefings before 2026. - Item 6 (SF New Deal Grant Amendment): Josio Cruzetta (OEWD) presented the amendment to add $2.455 million for small business grants in the APEC-impacted SOMA area and Tenderloin. Supervisor Dorsey thanked the committee and stakeholders. The BLA report noted that $2 million from the APEC fund was previously approved. No questions from the committee. - Items 7 & 8 (Episcopal Community Services): Emily Cohen (HSH) presented amendments for the Flexible Housing Subsidy Pool (item 7, $29.5 million total, serving 130 adults annually) and Housing Navigation (item 8, $16.7 million, serving 600 clients annually). Chair Chan inquired about performance metrics; the committee added a requirement to measure average placement time (currently 61 days). - Items 9 & 10 (Urban Alchemy): Emily Cohen presented amendments for the 33 Gough Cabin Program (item 9, $11.6 million, 9-month extension through March 2025) and 711 Post Street shelter (item 10, $30.4 million, 24-month extension). The BLA reported compliance issues at 33 Gough that were remediated. Chair Chan requested a shorter extension for 711 Post to align contract terms; the department amended item 10 to a 12-month extension (through June 2025) with a reduced total of $22.25 million. The amendment was approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - All items (1-10) were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, with the following specific actions: - Item 5: Approved as presented, with expectation of future briefings on Prop 1 implementation. - Item 8: Approved with added requirement to track and report average placement time for housing navigation. - Item 10: Amended to reduce the term from 24 months to 12 months (through June 30, 2025) and the total not-to-exceed amount to $22,246,326; then approved. - All votes were unanimous (3-0) with Chair Chan, Vice Chair Mandelman, and Member Melgar voting in favor. - Items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda of June 4, 2024.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, May 21, 2024, starting at 2:00 PM. The meeting included roll call, the Pledge of Allegiance, a land acknowledgment, approval of the April 16, 2024 meeting minutes (11-0), a special appearance by Mayor London Breed, multiple commendations, public hearings, and introduction of new legislation. The meeting adjourned after approximately 3 hours. Consent Calendar - Item 2: Ordinance to de-appropriate $4.75 million from permanent salaries and appropriate $4.75 million to overtime in the Police Department's Airport Division for FY2023-2024. Passed on first reading. - Item 3: Resolution authorizing a revocable permit for Mission Neighborhood Centers, Inc. to use 355 sq. ft. at the Hall of Justice for a children's waiting room (5-year term, $1 annual rent). Adopted. - Item 4: Resolution retroactively accepting a $1.4 million grant increase (new total $5.6 million) from the California Employment Development Department for WIOA programs. Adopted. - Item 5: Resolution approving a second amendment to the Carahsoft Technology Corporation agreement for Salesforce products, increasing the not-to-exceed amount to $20.6 million and extending the term through June 30, 2030. Adopted. - Item 6: Resolution authorizing a $20.9 million loan for 1005 Powell Street under the Small Sites Program for extremely low-income housing. Adopted. President Peskin noted the need for ongoing ELI subsidies. - Item 7: Ordinance designating a sidewalk portion on 24th Street for a commemorative plaque honoring Peter Gabel. Passed on first reading. - Item 8: Resolution approving an easement agreement with Midtown Lands LLC. Adopted. - Items 9-11: Resolutions determining that liquor licenses for Castro Theatre, The Lab, and Domaine SF serve public convenience. Adopted. - Item 12: Ordinance approving the Human Services Agency's surveillance technology policy for call recording. Passed on first reading. - Item 13: Ordinance (Housing Needs Report and DAS name updates) passed on first reading. - Item 14: Motion to veto Ethics Commission regulations (proposed rules 1.126-9 and 1.127-4) was tabled after the Ethics Commission provided clarifying memo. Supervisor Ronan moved to table, seconded. - Item 18: Ordinance requiring conditional use authorization for parcel delivery services. Passed on first reading. Special Orders 2:00 PM – Mayor's Appearance Mayor London Breed appeared for a formal policy discussion. Supervisor Safai asked about collaboration on sober housing, referencing a $3.6 million allocation from the previous budget. Mayor Breed confirmed her commitment to abstinence-based recovery programs, noting over $20 million invested in seven locations, and expressed willingness to work with Supervisor Safai's office. The exchange concluded with both parties agreeing to collaborate. 2:30 PM – Commendations - Jennifer Choi: Chief Trial Deputy in the City Attorney's Office, recognized for leading the gun violence restraining order program (13 filed in 2024) and code enforcement work. She is a first-generation Korean immigrant. - Heather Woodward: Founder of the creative writing department at Ruth Asawa School of the Arts (SOTA), retiring after 27 years. Recognized for her dedication to student writers. - Nicole Bonn: Director of the Mayor's Office of Disability, departing to lead the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund. Recognized for 30+ years of disability advocacy, including creating the Disability Community Cultural Center and leading pandemic response. - San Francisco Asian Police Officers Association (SFAPOA): Recognized for promoting career development of AAPI officers, community engagement, and recruitment. A recruitment video featuring Sergeant Colbert Chu was shown. 3:00 PM – Hearings - Item 15: Hearing on the progress of the U.S. Department of Justice findings and recommendations. Supervisor Walton moved to continue the hearing to July 16, 2024. Motion approved without objection. - Items 16-17: Public hearing on the report of delinquent charges for code enforcement violations. Department of Building Inspection staff reported 14 properties removed from the list after negotiations. The board amended the resolution to remove those properties and then adopted the resolution as amended. Public Comments & Testimony - Code Enforcement Hearing: Several property owners spoke, disputing fees or seeking extensions. Most resolved issues with DBI staff, leading to removals from the list. - General Public Comment: - Multiple taxi medallion holders (including medallion numbers 1225, 624) described business losses due to rideshare apps and airport construction. They requested city assistance, such as reducing medallion prices or requiring TCP permits for rideshares. - Richard S.T. Peterson reported a Muni rear door design flaw that injured his hand; he urged corrective action. - Jim McAfee alleged misconduct at Laguna Honda Hospital regarding his domestic partner's care and recertification. - Another speaker criticized case management services in homeless housing programs, calling for better oversight and an ombudsman. Discussion Items (Roll Call for Introductions) - Supervisor Dorsey introduced a charter amendment for the November 2024 ballot to re-establish minimum police staffing at 2,074 full-duty officers (starting July 1, 2025), create a deferred retirement option program (DROP) for sworn officers, and require periodic staffing adjustments. Co-authored by President Peskin and Supervisor Stephanie, with six co-sponsors. - Supervisor Melgar introduced a charter amendment to revamp the Our Children, Our Families Council, creating a seven-member body to align city and SFUSD spending with measurable outcomes. Also introduced a resolution urging the Department of Early Childhood to expand childcare investments, including a 10-year spending plan and support for 24/7 childcare for first responders. - President Peskin introduced three charter amendments: (1) creating an Affordable Housing Opportunity Fund for seniors and families (targeting 2,100 ELI households), (2) establishing an Inspector General within the Controller's Office to investigate fraud, waste, and abuse, and (3) two versions of a government reform measure to streamline commissions while preserving public oversight, in response to the Together SF initiative. - Supervisor Safai introduced a charter amendment to improve retention and recruitment of nurses and 911 dispatchers by allowing buyback of up to three years of retirement credit for temporary nurses and equalizing retirement benefits for dispatchers. Noted 20% vacancy rate for dispatchers and 170+ vacant RN positions. - Supervisor Preston introduced a resolution supporting state bills (AB 2655, AB 2839, AB 3211, SB 1228) to address AI-generated deceptive content in elections. Also introduced a resolution condemning racist threats against the Williams family, which was amended to include a major fire at the family home on May 21, 2024. The board urged SFPD and SFFD investigations and temporary housing support. Key Outcomes - Passed: All consent calendar items (items 2-12, 13, 18); resolutions on AI in elections (item 22) and condemning racist threats (item 23, as amended); amended code enforcement assessment resolution (item 17). - Tabled: Ethics commission regulation veto (item 14). - Continued: DOJ hearing (item 15) to July 16, 2024. - Referred to Committee: Resolution urging restoration of $25 million in DCYF funding (item 24) sent to Government Audit and Oversight Committee. - Introduced: Multiple charter amendments for November 2024 ballot, including police staffing, children/youth accountability, affordable housing, inspector general, government reform, and nurse/dispatcher retention.
The San Francisco Rules Committee met on May 20, 2024, at 10:00 AM, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronin, with Vice Chair Supervisor Shamann Walton and member Supervisor Asha Safai. The committee considered five items: reappointments, a surveillance technology policy for automated speed enforcement, a hearing on the quality of services by Eugene Burger Management Corporation at Hope SF sites, and a hearing on the implementation of Proposition C (homelessness oversight). All items were acted upon, with unanimous votes for the first three, a continuation of the fourth, and a filing of the fifth. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (240433): Motion to reappoint Supervisor Catherine Stefani to the Reentry Council for a term ending June 1, 2026. Passed unanimously to the full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 2 (240404): Motion to approve the mayoral reappointment of Mark Dunlop to the Treasure Island Development Authority Board of Directors for a term ending February 26, 2028. Passed unanimously after amending to remove the word "rejecting" from the motion. - Item 3 (240367): Ordinance approving the surveillance technology policy for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency's use of an automated speed enforcement system, authorized by California Assembly Bill 645. The system captures rear license plate images of speeding vehicles, with data retained for 5–120 days depending on violation status. Passed unanimously to the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4 (Hope SF Hearing): Multiple residents and advocates testified about poor conditions at Sunnydale and Potrero Hill. Kywa Smith, a resident of 1101 Connecticut, stated she was interrogated by property manager Sonny Patel after reporting a flood and later received an email threatening her housing. Edward Hatter, executive director of Potrero Hill Neighborhood House, described dog feces, trash chutes, and long-unrepaired leaks. Tanika Blue, a resident, expressed safety concerns and said residents are uncomfortable bringing issues to management. Siobhan Hunter, a community organizer, said the Hope SF initiative is not thriving and called for more oversight. A speaker named Jordan criticized the implementation of Proposition C, saying the commission lacks tenant representation and fails to address evictions and scattered-site supportive housing. Discussion Items - Item 4 (230614): Hearing on SFHA's Report of Quality of Services by Eugene Burger Management Corp – Supervisor Walton, the hearing author, highlighted ongoing issues: illegal leasing of vacant units by Eugene Burger staff, excessive trash, and unresponsive maintenance. The San Francisco Housing Authority (SFHA) Director Dr. Letter You reported that 133 units at Sunnydale and 231 at Potrero are slated for demolition, with daily monitoring of vacant units. She noted that the housing authority has only two housing officers on site (down from 16) and that proposals for 24/7 armed security ($100,000/month) are under review. Eugene Burger representative Teresa Pegler defended the company's efforts, including a vacant unit monitoring plan and increased trash pickup, but could not comment on the ongoing investigation into illegal rentals. Bridge Housing and Mercy Housing provided updates on redevelopment and resident services. Supervisor Walton expressed frustration, noting that the housing authority is responsible for Eugene Burger's actions and that illegally rented tenants become the city's responsibility. He requested quarterly reports from SFHA and MOCD on property management performance. - Item 5 (230148): Hearing on Status of Proposition C Implementation – Supervisor Safai, the hearing author, reviewed the progress of the Homelessness Oversight Commission, established in May 2023. Director Shireen McSpadden reported that the commission has held 14 meetings, approved 52 contracts, and appointed 10 members to advisory bodies. The vacancy rate for permanent supportive housing has dropped from about 1,100 to 640 units (7% vacancy). The commission reviews monthly data on housing placements, shelter vacancies, outreach, and evictions. City Controller Greg Wagner outlined upcoming audits, including an assessment of the shelter system in fiscal year 2024-25. Commissioner Kristen Evans highlighted racial disparities in eviction data and denial-of-service rates at shelters (as high as 15%). Supervisor Safai noted that the mayor's family homelessness plan will be presented to the commission after the budget process. The hearing was filed. Key Outcomes - Item 1, 2, 3: All passed unanimously with positive recommendation to the full Board of Supervisors (scheduled for June 4, 2024). - Item 4: Motion to continue the hearing to the call of the chair passed unanimously. Supervisor Walton requested quarterly reports from SFHA and MOCD on Eugene Burger and Bridge Housing performance, and directed that the housing authority explore contract termination options if violations are confirmed. - Item 5: Motion to file the hearing passed unanimously. The committee will reconvene in one year for a follow-up on Proposition C implementation. Note: The meeting minutes were not available; summary is based on the agenda and raw transcript.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Land Use and Transportation Committee met on May 20, 2024, at 9:45 AM PT. Chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston, the committee considered four agenda items: an ordinance requiring conditional use for parcel delivery services, approval of street resurfacing projects funded by Senate Bill 1, landmark designation for the Gregangelo Museum, and a resolution supporting a curbside electric vehicle charging feasibility study. All items received unanimous positive recommendations to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Parcel Delivery): Mark Malouf, business agent for Teamsters Local 665, expressed the union's continued support for the conditional use legislation, noting its unanimous passage at prior meetings. - Item 3 (Gregangelo Museum Landmark): Over 20 public speakers testified in support, including Gregangelo himself, local artists, and community members. Many emphasized the museum's role as a creative hub and its embodiment of San Francisco's LGBTQ+ and counterculture history. One speaker from the Office of Small Business noted the museum's application for the Legacy Business Program is pending the outcome of this designation. At the Historic Preservation Commission hearing, there were 55 public comments (48 in support, 7 opposed). - Item 4 (EV Charging): Mark Malouf (Teamsters) supported the resolution as amended to specify public-only use. Susan Green (San Francisco Climate Emergency Coalition) urged climate action. Ryan Peterson (District 8 resident) encouraged faster rollout and integration with bike infrastructure. Paul Wermer suggested expanding the study to include e-bike charging and storage. Discussion Items - Item 1 (240193) – Parcel Delivery Service: Supervisor Connie Chan, the sponsor, explained the ordinance had previously been continued for substantive amendments regarding educational institutions and employment analysis (including AI and autonomous vehicles). The Planning Commission approved the amendments unanimously on consent. The committee voted 3-0 to send it as a committee report to the Board for possible consideration on May 21, 2024, making it retroactive to March 31, 2024. - Item 2 (240416) – SB1 Road Funds: Sylvia Ho (Public Works) and Edmund Lee presented a resolution approving 212 blocks for resurfacing using FY2024-25 RMRA funds. The projects are in design and expected to be advertised for construction by early 2025. Supervisor Preston inquired about coordination with SFMTA on Oak Street bike lane work. President Peskin noted the poor condition of Stockton Street between Columbus and Union. The committee voted 3-0 to recommend approval. - Item 3 (240353) – Gregangelo Museum Landmark: Heather Samuels (Planning Department) presented the Historic Preservation Commission's unanimous recommendation for landmark designation. The museum, at 225 San Leandro Way, is recognized as a folk art piece evoking 1960s-80s counterculture and LGBTQ+ communities. The committee voted 3-0 to recommend approval, with all three members adding themselves as sponsors/cosponsors. - Item 4 (240270) – Curbside EV Charging: Supervisor Mandelman, the sponsor, introduced the resolution supporting SFMTA and SFE's feasibility study. Hannah Trun (SF Environment) and Maya Price (SFMTA) presented the scope, noting that San Francisco needs 1,760 public chargers by 2030 but currently has fewer than 1,000. They highlighted challenges including grid capacity, permitting (encroachment permits taking 6-18 months), and funding. The committee discussed the need for coordination, prioritizing residential areas over commercial corridors, and leveraging federal Inflation Reduction Act tax credits via direct pay. The resolution was amended to add "funding strategies" to the requested report and to specify public-only use. The committee voted 3-0 to recommend the amended resolution. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Passed 3-0 with a positive recommendation as a committee report for the Board's May 21, 2024 meeting. - Item 2: Passed 3-0 with a positive recommendation to the full Board. - Item 3: Passed 3-0 with a positive recommendation to the full Board; all committee members added as co-sponsors. - Item 4: Passed 3-0 (after amendments) with a positive recommendation to the full Board. The amendments included adding "funding strategies" to the report and specifying the chargers are for public use only.