Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 861–870 ENTRIES
861
NOV 30, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - November 30, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on November 30, 2023, at approximately 20:15 UTC (12:15 PM local) to address a broad agenda including continuances, consent calendar approvals, zoning code amendments, housing initiatives, enforcement penalty guidelines, and several conditional use and discretionary review items. The meeting was streamed live via SFGov TV and included public comment both in-person and remotely. All roll call votes were unanimous (6-0) unless otherwise noted. Consent Calendar - Continuances (Items 1-4): Approved unanimously. 619 Marina Boulevard (DR) continued to January 25, 2024; 838 Market Street (office allocation) continued indefinitely; 1270 Pacific Avenue (DR) and 2266 43rd Avenue (DR) withdrawn. - Consent Calendar (Items 5-8): Approved unanimously. Included conditional use authorizations at 690 Sacramento Street, 16 Jessie Street 30, 2060 Polk Street, and a discretionary review at 1128 Lake Street. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: - Anastasia Yovinopoulos (SF Tenant Union & Rep Coalition) criticized the mayor's constraints reduction ordinance for initially stripping rent control protections, noting planning staff flagged non-compliance with policy 26 but failed to alert the commission; four commissioners voted for the ordinance, prompting concern. - Sue Master requested a joint hearing with the Department of Building Inspection (DBI) to address project processing delays and urged the planning department to publish written communications regarding HCD housing element pushback. - Item 16 (Constraints Reduction): - Carolyn Kennedy (Dolores Heights Improvement Club) supported Supervisor Mandelman's amendments, citing a reduction in proposed large homes in her neighborhood (from 35+ significant demolitions/renovations 2014-2021 to only one project over 3,000 GSF since December 2021). - Christopher Roach (AIA SF) expressed support for the underlying ordinance but strongly opposed Mandelman's amendments, calling the 3,000 sf cap arbitrary. - Georgia Shutish supported the 3,000 sf cap, providing examples of typical home sizes in Noe Valley. - Zach Weisenberger (Young Community Developers) raised equity concerns, requesting amendments to protect cultural districts from displacement, including objective design standards and continued hearings for state density bonus projects. - Jonathan Randolph expressed skepticism about home size restrictions, noting large homes can be converted to multi-family units. - Ozzy Realm (Tempest Go Line Coalition) criticized commissioners for voting for legislation that ignored housing element policies, particularly regarding rent control demolition. - Item 19 (Enforcement Penalties): Georgia Shutish supported the criteria; Sue Master reiterated the need for a joint DBI meeting; another speaker supported penalties but suggested prioritizing tenant harm and financial gain. - Item 20 (129 Laidley Street): Neighbors (John Seymour, Kim Richardson, David Hahn) opposed the project, citing privacy violations, excessive size, and failure to comply with residential design guidelines. They requested reductions to preserve mid-block open space and privacy. Discussion Items - Item 12: 2024 Hearing Schedule - Commission adjusted proposed cancellations: added March 28 (Easter), September 5 (post-Labor Day), October 3 (Rosh Hashanah); reinstated October 31; kept August 1 and other cancellations. Final schedule approved unanimously. - Item 15: 900 Kearny Street SUD - Approved ordinance creating a Special Use District to permit non-retail professional services and arts activities, fixing a zoning table error. Unanimous. - Item 16: Constraints Reduction Ordinance - Supervisor Mandelman's amendment to sunset CU requirements in Corona Heights and Central Neighborhoods SUDs, replacing with a 3,000 sf unit cap (later amended). Staff recommended increasing to 3,500 sf and allowing 20% expansions. After discussion, motion passed 4-2 with a 3,500 sf cap, 20% expansion allowance, and a five-year serial permitting restriction. Voting no: Commissioners Ruiz and Imperial. - Item 17: Expanding Housing Choice - Informational presentation on rezoning for housing capacity. Staff proposed concentrating growth on transit corridors, with an estimated capacity for 54,000 new housing units. Public comments supported the effort but raised design and community concerns. Commission discussion focused on design standards, buffer zones, and west side development. - Item 18: UC College of the Law - Informational update on academic village housing (656 units) and upcoming Unite Here Local 2 project. Commission praised the partnership and progress. - Item 19: Enforcement Penalty Guidelines - Adopted resolution outlining 10 criteria for imposing penalties up to $250,000 for unauthorized unit additions/removals. Added a new criterion to consider penalties from past cases. Unanimous. - Item 20: 129 Laidley Street - Approved conditional use authorization for a new two-unit building (one 3,720 sf unit and one 908 sf ADU). Neighbors opposed due to size and privacy, but staff found compliance with RDG. Unanimous. - Item 21: 10 Sea Cliff Discretionary Review - DR requestor and sponsor reached an agreement on enhancing privacy with planters. Commission approved the DR with modifications. Unanimous. Key Outcomes - Vote on Constraints Reduction (Item 16): Approved with modifications: 3,500 sf max unit size, 20% expansion allowance, five-year look-back for serial permits. Passed 4-2 (Ruiz, Imperial against). - Adoption of 2024 Hearing Schedule: Approved with changes to cancellations and reinstatements. - Approval of 900 Kearny SUD: Unanimous. - Adoption of Enforcement Penalty Guidelines: Unanimous, with an added criterion for past penalties. - Approval of 129 Laidley Street CUA: Unanimous. - Approval of 10 Sea Cliff DR with modifications: Unanimous. Notes - Commissioner Ruiz disclosed that his employer (CCDC) submitted a letter supporting the 900 Kearny SUD; he determined no conflict and voted. - Commissioner Moore was absent; all votes were 6-0 unless stated. - The meeting adjourned after approximately 5 hours of deliberation.

HOUSING ELEMENT 22% · PUBLIC COMMENT 17% · ZONING AND LAND USE 10% · LAND USE 10%
862
NOV 29, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - November 29, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and including Supervisor Asha Safai (later excused) and Board President Aaron Peskin, convened on November 29, 2023, at 6:15 PM UTC to consider 14 agenda items. The committee heard presentations, received Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) reports, and voted on funding for violence prevention, police code reform, grants, contracts, affordable housing loans, and a major waterfront park initiative. Public comment was heard on several items, with strong community support for the India Basin Waterfront Park project. Routine Approvals and Consent Items - Item 1 (De-Appropriation/Appropriation – District 10 Violence Prevention): Unanimously forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. $270,000 for training and violence prevention in District 10. - Item 3 (Auto Insurance Fraud Grant): Retroactive resolution accepting $312,297 from California Department of Insurance. Unanimously approved. - Item 5 (Renewable Diesel Contract Amendment): Approved amendment increasing contract to $86.75 million and extending term to October 31, 2024. Funding primarily from enterprise departments (77% MTA). - Item 6 (SF Health Plan Grant for Homelessness Consulting): Retroactive grant of $341,000 for CalAIM infrastructure. Approved unanimously. - Item 7 (Chinese Hospital Contract – Subacute Beds): Amended to increase not-to-exceed amount to $20.64 million due to potential licensure delays. Continued to December 6, 2023, for amendment finalization. - Item 8 (DPH Overtime Supplement): Budget-neutral $39.5 million transfer from salaries to overtime. Approved unanimously, with committee expressing concerns about high overtime reliance (123% increase). - Items 9 & 10 (Affordable Housing Acquisition Loans): Amended to state city intent to acquire land. $24 million for 1234 Great Highway (216 senior units) and $15 million for 650 Divisadero (95 family units). Unanimously approved. Discussion Items Item 2: Police Code – Entertainment Permits Reform The committee discussed a comprehensive reform package to simplify entertainment permitting, waive fees for pandemic-era businesses, and eliminate outdated requirements. Supervisors Safai and Chan questioned safety implications of removing criminal history disclosure from applications, but were assured the police department still reviews all applications. The entertainment commission committed to reporting back on outcomes. Unanimously approved to full board with Supervisor Safai as co-sponsor. Item 4: Mission Bay Parks – Transfer and Maintenance Agreement The committee approved the transfer of Mission Bay parks from the redevelopment agency to Recreation and Park Department and Port. Funding from Community Facilities District (CFD) 5 supports operations. Supervisor Safai expressed frustration over delays in opening Bayfront Park (now expected in January 2024). The CFD is projected to suffice until about 2030 before potential deficits. Unanimously approved. Items 11-14: India Basin Waterfront Park – Grants and Behested Payment Waiver The committee considered four resolutions accepting grants totaling $55.8 million from the San Francisco Foundation, Trust for Public Land, A. Philip Randolph Institute, and San Francisco Parks Alliance for a 10-acre waterfront park and equitable development programs. The package also included a six-month waiver from the behested payment ordinance to allow fundraising from private donors. Chair Chan requested the waiver be separated from the accept/expend resolution for clarity. The committee voted to duplicate item 11, creating separate resolutions for the $50 million grant and the behested payment waiver (amended to six months). All items were forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 2, 4, 5, 9, 10: No public speakers. - Items 6, 7, 8: No public speakers. - Items 9, 10: Several speakers supported the affordable housing projects, emphasizing the need for deeply affordable units for formerly homeless seniors and families. Speakers urged inclusion of certificate of preference holders and reparative language. - Items 11-14: Over 20 community members testified in strong support, highlighting programs like the Baby Safety Swim and Splash program, workforce development, and the importance of safe recreational space for youth. Speakers urged approval without delay, citing long-standing inequities in the Bayview-Hunters Point community. Key Outcomes - All items except Item 7 were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for the December 5, 2023, meeting with positive recommendation. - Item 7 was continued to the December 6, 2023, committee meeting to finalize the amended not-to-exceed amount. - Item 11 was duplicated: one resolution for accepting the $50 million grant, another for the behested payment waiver with a six-month sunset. - The committee emphasized the need for sustainable overtime management at DPH and realistic budget assumptions in future cycles.

ENTERTAINMENT POLICY 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · PARKS AND RECREATION 11% · PUBLIC HEALTH 8%
863
NOV 28, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting – November 28, 2023

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held its regular meeting on Tuesday, November 28, 2023, beginning at 9:30 AM. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of prior minutes, reports from the General Manager, a consent calendar, and several major policy items including updates to Level of Service goals for water and power enterprises, adoption of affordability metrics, approval of a revised Integrated Resource Plan for Hetch Hetchy Power, and a Memorandum of Understanding with the San Francisco Airport Commission. All voting items were approved unanimously, with one commissioner recused on a specific item. Consent Calendar - Approved the consent calendar (items 6a–6e) by unanimous roll call (4–0). Items included acceptance of work performed under various contracts, award of a job order contract not-to-exceed $5,000,000, and a contract duration extension. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided oral testimony during any of the public comment periods. Written comments were received on item 7 (Water Enterprise Level of Service Goals) and item 12 (Affordability Metrics) and were noted for the record. Discussion Items - Green Bond Update (Item 5a): Nikolai Skalarov presented an overview of the SFPUC’s green bond program, noting that the SFPUC was the third largest green bond issuer in the U.S. before 2023, and that 2023 was the largest issuance year to date. He discussed the evolution of certification (self-certification in 2015, later programmatic certification by Climate Bonds Initiative and Sustainalytics), the relatively small U.S. municipal green bond market, and the political backlash against ESG investing. Commissioners asked about the potential for borrower-level certification and the costs/benefits of issuing green bonds. Staff indicated an RFP for new certification services would be issued in spring 2024. - Quarterly Audit and Performance Review (Item 5b): Audit Director Irella Blackwood reported that as of September 30, 2023, 10 of 30 planned audits (33%) were completed. Physical inventory counts at five bureaus showed a variance of 1.81% ($237,689 out of $13,114,958). Recommendations from previous audits remained open for two audits. Commissioners requested benchmarking against industry norms and suggested including such context in future reports. - Water Enterprise Level of Service Goals (Item 7): AGM Steve Ritchie presented the amended 2023 goals, which expanded the original 2008 goals (focused on WSIP) to include operations, maintenance, local system issues, and sustainability. New goals address in-city seismic reliability, delivery reliability, water supply restoration timelines, and environmental stewardship. The commission discussed the need to explicitly incorporate climate resilience and equity as overarching principles. The item was approved 4–0. - Power Enterprise Level of Service Goals (Item 8): AGM Barbara Hale presented the first-ever Level of Service goals for the Power Enterprise, comprising five broad goals and 19 specific objectives with nearly 100 performance metrics. Goals cover power supply, transmission, distribution, city programs, and administration. Commissioners emphasized that climate resilience and equity should be embedded throughout all goals. The item was approved 4–0. - Water Supply Assessment – Potrero Yard Modernization Project (Item 9): Commissioner Stacy recused herself due to a potential conflict of interest. AGM Ritchie presented the revised water supply assessment reflecting updated housing element numbers. The item was approved 3–0 (Commissioner Stacy recused). - Water Supply Assessment – 655 4th Street Project (Item 10): Similar routine assessment presented. Approved 4–0. - Hetch Hetchy Power Integrated Resource Plan (Item 11): Julia O’Geen presented the 2023 update, forecasting that retail sales will grow approximately 5% per year over the next decade, requiring about 150 megawatts of new renewable energy supply by 2033. The analysis considered four load forecast scenarios and three hydroelectric generation scenarios. Commissioners questioned the use of historical data and suggested incorporating more extreme climate scenarios. The plan was approved 4–0. - Affordability Metrics Policy (Item 12): Financial Planning Director Aaron Corvanova proposed adopting two new metrics: a typical household target (3% of 40th percentile income) and a low-income household target (7% of 20th percentile income, or 5% with discounts). The current median household metric (2.5% of median income) was deemed insufficient. The policy requires reporting and proposing mitigation if targets are projected to be exceeded. The item was approved 4–0. - Memorandum of Understanding with SFO (Item 13): AGM Hale presented an MOU authorizing up to $50 million for the Airport to manage replacement of two substation transformers, with SFPUC reimbursement. Approved 4–0. - Closed Session (Item 18): The commission met in closed session to discuss proposed settlement of litigation (Shelly Nguyen v. City and County of San Francisco). The commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and later voted unanimously to not disclose the closed session discussions. The settlement was recommended for Board of Supervisors approval. Key Outcomes - Approved unanimously (4–0): Minutes of November 14, 2023; Consent Calendar; Water Enterprise Level of Service Goals; Power Enterprise Level of Service Goals; Water Supply Assessment for 655 4th Street; Hetch Hetchy Power Integrated Resource Plan; Affordability Metrics Policy; MOU with SFO (up to $50M). - Approved 3–0 (Commissioner Stacy recused): Water Supply Assessment for Potrero Yard Modernization Project. - Closed Session: Commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and not disclose discussions. The settlement of $35,000 for vehicle collision litigation was recommended for approval by the Board of Supervisors. - Next Steps: Staff will issue an RFP for green bond certification in spring 2024; continue monitoring customer load growth and renewable resource procurement; and develop affordability metrics for the Power Enterprise.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 15% · PROCEDURAL 13% · ENERGY MANAGEMENT 13% · GREEN BONDS 12%
864
NOV 28, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Meeting – November 28, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Tuesday, November 28, 2023, beginning at approximately 2:15 p.m. The meeting covered a wide range of topics, including a contentious charter amendment on minimum police staffing, a transfer tax exemption for affordable housing, several land use and housing items, and commendations for community leaders. The board voted 6-5 to place the police staffing charter amendment on the March 2024 ballot, and unanimously approved the transfer tax exemption. A major housing streamlining ordinance was continued for one week. Consent Calendar - Items 1–17 were approved unanimously on a single roll call. These included settlements and unlitigated claims totaling over $2.9 million, a Vision Zero project appropriation, a non-profit arts education special use district, and approval of airport surveillance technology policies. Special Orders – Commendations (2:30 p.m.) - In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS) Providers Day: Supervisor Chan recognized the city’s 26,000 IHSS providers, declaring November 28, 2023 as IHSS Provider Day. Several providers spoke about the importance of their work and urged stable funding. - Martha Ryan – Homeless Prenatal Program (HPP): Supervisor Ronan honored Martha Ryan, founder and executive director emeritus of HPP, which has served over 100,000 families in 34 years. Ryan and new executive director Shalina Eskridge spoke about the need for family housing. - Joe Martinez – Mission Child Care Consortium: Supervisor Safai honored Joe Martinez, who led Mission Child Care for 46 years, building it into the largest private child care facility in San Francisco (serving 220 children). Martinez credited the board and Mayor Ed Lee for helping the consortium purchase its building. Public Comments & Testimony - Speakers addressed a variety of topics: concerns about the APEC security perimeter’s impact on small businesses, complaints about police deployment and transphobia, calls for rent control, and praise for the city’s homeless services. One speaker urged the board to investigate the dangers of voice technology. Another speaker, a city employee, warned that DPW workers are burnt out and that overtime is not a solution to staffing shortages. Discussion Items - Item 18 – Charter Amendment: Minimum Police Department Staffing and Funding (Unfinished Business): The board debated a charter amendment that would set a minimum number of sworn officers and create a fund for hiring bonuses, but only if voters first pass a tax measure generating sufficient revenue. Supervisor Safai, the sponsor of the amended version, argued the measure ensures fiscal responsibility and a dedicated funding source. Supervisor Engardio opposed, calling it “aspirational” and “messy,” noting it does not immediately fund police. Supervisor Ronan criticized the amendment as tying future revenue to police funding, potentially diverting money from other public safety needs. Supervisor Dorsey, the original author, said the measure was “hijacked” and now serves as a “cop tax scheme.” Supervisor Preston argued the police department is already fully funded but cannot recruit enough officers, and that the real issue is deployment. Supervisor Stefani supported sending the measure to voters, saying it gives them a chance to express their desire for more police. The vote was 6-5 to submit the charter amendment to the March 2024 ballot. - Item 19 – Transfer Tax Exemption for Affordable Housing (New Business): The board unanimously approved an ordinance broadening the exemption from increased transfer tax rates for certain rent-restricted affordable housing transfers, making it retroactive to January 1, 2017, and extending it through December 31, 2030. - Items 20–26 (New Business – Grants, Leases, Bonds): The board approved several resolutions authorizing: a $3.9 million state grant for the Buchanan Mall Project, three port leases (Recology, Anderson Enterprises, Mission Rock parcels), $10 million in bonds for Treasure Island infrastructure, a $26.6 million loan amendment for Sunnydale HOPE SF, and $17 million in special tax bonds for Treasure Island Improvement Area No. 2. All passed without objection. - Item 32 – Housing Production Streamlining (Committee Reports): This ordinance, aimed at complying with state housing law, was continued for one week (to December 5, 2023) after Supervisor Mandelman requested time to add an amendment addressing “monster homes.” The committee had received a corrective action letter from the state Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) 45 minutes before the meeting. The board voted 11-0 to continue the item. Key Outcomes - Charter Amendment on Police Staffing (Item 18): Passed 6-5 (Safai, Melgar, Peskin, Stefani, Walton, Chan in favor; Dorsey, Engardio, Mandelman, Preston, Ronan opposed). The measure will appear on the March 2024 ballot. - Transfer Tax Exemption (Item 19): Approved 11-0. - Housing Streamlining Ordinance (Item 32): Continued to December 5, 2023, by a 11-0 vote. - IHSS Providers Day Resolution: Adopted unanimously. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Marcelino Marshall Espinoza, grandfather of Supervisor Peskin’s chief of staff.

PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 12% · HOMELESSNESS 12% · PROCEDURAL 9%
865
NOV 27, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - November 27, 2023

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, November 27, 2023, at approximately 10:00 AM (agenda time 6:15 PM). The meeting, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey and joined by Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Supervisor Asha Safai, considered six items: an ordinance to standardize monitoring of nonprofit contracts, amendments to the police department's automatic license plate reader (ALPR) policy, surveillance technology policies for the Fine Arts Museums and multiple city departments, and two reappointments for Supervisor Rafael Mandelman. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were considered. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Nonprofit Monitoring): Speakers included Lucia Oregon (San Francisco Latino Parity and Equity Coalition) who supported the ordinance but urged collaborative performance goal-setting and cautioned against burdensome reporting. Debbie Lerman (San Francisco Human Services Network) noted that the ordinance echoes recommendations from a 2003 task force and supported accountability. Janice Canalan (Family Resource Center Alliance) and Hope Kmare (Compass Family Services) voiced support, emphasizing the need for co-created standards. Amanda Alvarado Ford (La Rasa Centro Legal) proposed edits to ensure legal aid expertise is consulted. Rami Tan, a local architect, supported the legislation and urged focus on metrics for administrative costs and service effectiveness. One speaker requested two-minute public comment time (not granted). - Item 2 (ALPR Policy): Public commenters overwhelmingly supported the policy. Kevin Warrell (Police Officers Association) endorsed it. Other speakers argued that the technology is already used by SFMTA and by many other agencies, and that failing to adopt it would undermine public safety. One speaker criticized delays and accused Supervisor Safai of obstruction; Chair Dorsey directed the speaker to stay on topic. - Item 3 (Fine Arts Museums Surveillance Policy): No public comment. - Item 4 (Multi-Department Social Media Monitoring): No public comment. - Items 5 & 6 (Reappointments): No public comment. Discussion Items - Item 1: Administrative Code – Monitoring of Nonprofits Contracting with the City (File 230973) - Supervisor Catherine Stefani, the sponsor, stated the ordinance implements recommendations from the City Controller's August 2022 audit, which found inconsistent performance measurement and lack of uniform guidelines for the city's 600+ nonprofit contracts (totaling over $1.7 billion). - Laura Marshall (Controller's Office) explained the ordinance would: (1) standardize programmatic monitoring, (2) update the corrective action policy, (3) increase transparency via annual reports and a public dashboard, and (4) require audited financial statements from nonprofits receiving at least $750,000 in city contracts. - Supervisors Walton and Safai raised questions about the $750,000 audit threshold, coordination across departments, potential costs to nonprofits, and the need to account for varying funding sources (federal, state, local). Marshall noted that the controller's office will develop implementation plans by September 1, 2024. - Supervisor Safai requested to be added as a co-sponsor, which was accepted. - The motion to forward to the full board with a positive recommendation passed 3-0. - Item 2: Administrative Code – Surveillance Technology Policy – Police Department – Automatic License Plate Readers (File 231161) - Chief Bill Scott presented the policy amendments, which are needed to accept a $15.3 million state grant for 400 new ALPR cameras. The amendments would allow: (1) multiple vendors instead of a single specified vendor, (2) use of grant and other funding sources beyond the SFPD operational budget, and (3) flexible data formats as technology evolves. - Chief Scott noted that 70% of crimes involve a vehicle, and cited South San Francisco’s 80% reduction in car burglaries and 50% reduction in auto thefts after installing ALPR. He emphasized urgency due to recent organized retail theft incidents. - Supervisor Safai questioned the timeline from COIT approval (September 21) to the current hearing (November 27), and whether the legislative process could have been avoided. Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson explained that the board must approve policy changes under Article 19B. Chief Scott noted that the 30-day hold was waived, and the companion accept-and-expend ordinance is scheduled for December 6, 2023, with final approval expected in January 2024. - Supervisor Walton asked about data storage (vendor-managed vs. local) and restrictions on vendor use of data. Chief Scott stated that vendors cannot sell data and must comply with CJIS, CLETS, and CORI requirements. - The motion to forward to the full board with a positive recommendation passed 3-0. - Item 3: Administrative Code – Surveillance Technology Policy for Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco (File 230918) - Paul Peterson (Fine Arts Museums) presented the policy for camera management and video monitoring systems at the de Young Museum and Legion of Honor. The policy defines authorized and restricted use to protect art collections and ensure public access. - No questions from committee members. Motion passed 3-0. - Item 4: Administrative Code – Approval of Surveillance Technology Policy for Multiple City Departments (File 231109) - Gillian Johnson (COIT Director) presented a single policy covering 28 city departments using social media monitoring software. The policy standardizes authorized uses: publishing content, communicating with the public, and analyzing engagement. The policy was approved by PSAB and COIT in June 2023, with a non-substantive correction for the Department of the Environment. - Chair Dorsey praised the multi-department efficiency model. Motion passed 3-0. - Items 5 & 6: Reappointment, California State Association of Counties (File 231209) and Reappointment, Association of Bay Area Governments Executive Board (File 231210) - Chair Dorsey read a statement from Supervisor Rafael Mandelman’s staff outlining his work on fentanyl overdose crisis, Proposition 1, and regional housing and climate efforts. - No questions or comments. Motion to forward both reappointments passed 3-0. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved 3-0 to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: Approved 3-0 to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The 30-day hold was waived; the companion grant acceptance ordinance is scheduled for December 6, 2023. - Item 3: Approved 3-0 to the full Board of Supervisors. - Item 4: Approved 3-0 to the full Board of Supervisors. - Items 5 & 6: Approved 3-0 to the full Board of Supervisors.

AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE 29% · PUBLIC SAFETY 16% · PROCEDURAL 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14%
866
NOV 27, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use Committee Meeting - November 27, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar and joined by President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston, held a regular meeting on November 27, 2023, to consider six agenda items related to planning code amendments, coastal program updates, public works permitting, and housing production. The meeting featured extensive public comment, discussions of amendments, and several votes. Consent Calendar No items were considered on the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1 & 2 (Irish Cultural Center SUD): Multiple speakers expressed support for the redevelopment, citing the center's cultural importance and community programs. Others opposed the project, raising concerns about procedural irregularities, insufficient public notification, potential environmental impacts on the coastal zone, and a 509-page augmentation document that was allegedly introduced without proper commission review. - Item 3 (Love Our Neighborhoods): Public comment focused on concerns that planters and other amenities could be used to displace homeless individuals. Some speakers urged the committee to reject hostile architecture. - Item 4 (Commercial/Retail/Restaurant Uses): One speaker supported the legislation as a way to revive music venues in the Haight-Ashbury. Another expressed confusion over technical abbreviations used in the discussion. - Item 5 (Housing Production): A wide range of testimony was heard. Supporters urged passage to meet state housing element deadlines, avoid loss of state funding, and increase housing supply for all income levels. Opponents argued the ordinance prioritizes market-rate development over affordable housing, undermines equity goals, weakens tenant protections (including rent-controlled housing), and violates the city's obligation to affirmatively further fair housing. - Item 6 (HCD Extension Resolution): Supporters described the resolution as a necessary response to HCD’s overly aggressive timeline and lack of focus on affordable housing and equity. Opponents argued the resolution is unproductive theater that signals bad faith to the state and risks decertification of the housing element. Discussion Items Items 1 & 2 (Wawona Street and 45th Avenue Cultural Center Special Use District) Supervisor Joel Engardio presented the ordinance to facilitate redevelopment of the Irish Cultural Center at 2700 45th Avenue. The proposed 6-story building would include community facilities, restaurant, bar, theater, aquatic center, and more. Planning staff outlined required Local Coastal Program amendments due to the site’s location in the coastal zone. President Peskin noted that San Francisco has not sought Coastal Commission certification for many citywide ordinances adopted since 1986, and that this project represents a first step toward compliance. Amendments were adopted to add findings about the local coastal program and to adjust the timing of the resolution to align with full board action on December 12, 2023. Item 3 (Love Our Neighborhoods – Public Works Code Amendments) Chair Melgar described the ordinance as streamlining permits for neighborhood amenities such as little libraries, string lights, planters, and murals. Director Carla Short of Public Works confirmed that tiered permitting (registration for simple projects, streamlined permits for moderate projects, and engineering review for complex ones) would be implemented. Supervisor Preston raised concerns about fees for existing unpermitted string lights; Director Short indicated they would be grandfathered in. Chair Melgar read a series of amendments into the record, including definitions for decorative street lights, sidewalk libraries, and neighborhood string lighting, as well as clarifications on liability and inspection fees. The item was continued to December 4, 2023, as amended. Item 4 (Citywide Expansion of Commercial, Restaurant, and Retail Uses) Director Katie Tang of the Office of Small Business presented amendments related to limited corner commercial uses, formula retail controls, and priority processing. Supervisor Peskin raised questions about a broad fee waiver in section 406 for changes of use, which appeared to only apply to conversions from PDR to non-PDR; it was agreed to remove that subsection from the main file and place it in a duplicated file for further refinement. After public comment, the committee adopted amendments proposed by both staff and Supervisor Peskin, then duplicated the file and continued it to December 4, 2023, for further work on remaining items. Item 5 (Housing Production Ordinance) This major item, relating to planning code amendments to encourage housing production, had been the subject of multiple prior hearings. Supervisor Mandelman (present via remote participation) outlined his priorities: protecting rent-controlled housing from streamlined demolition, ensuring notification for interested parties, adding anti-monster home protections, and protecting historic properties from demolition. Planning staff presented amendments that removed carve-outs for the Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District, applied protections for rent-controlled units (no demolition of any rent-controlled units without conditional use authorization), and refined pre-application meeting requirements. President Peskin proposed amendments to align with earlier Supervisor Melgar SUD provisions regarding buyouts, relocation benefits, mailed notice, holding periods, and income limits for Hope SF. Supervisor Preston criticized the administration for initially proposing to streamline demolition of rent-controlled housing, noting that the delay was due to that policy dispute. Public comment was extensive. After debate, the committee adopted amendments from Supervisor Mandelman (historic building language) and from planning staff. The ordinance was then sent without recommendation as a committee report to the full board for its November 28 meeting. A duplicated file was continued to the call of the chair. Item 6 (Resolution to Request HCD Extension and Revision) President Peskin introduced a resolution directing the city attorney and lobbyist to formally request that the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) extend the housing element implementation deadline and revise its Policy and Practice Review letter to better align with the city’s adopted housing element, including its equity and affordable housing commitments. The resolution also calls for HCD to respect San Francisco’s charter city authority and legislative process. Public comment was divided. The committee adopted amendments (not specified) and continued the item as amended to the next meeting. Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2: Approved amendments and forwarded the ordinance (230505) with a positive recommendation to the full board for December 5, 2023; the resolution (231137) was forwarded with a positive recommendation for December 12, 2023. Both votes were unanimous. - Item 3: Adopted amendments as read by Chair Melgar; then continued the ordinance as amended to the December 4, 2023 land use committee meeting (unanimous). - Item 4: Adopted amendments from staff and Supervisor Peskin; duplicated the file and continued the duplicate as amended to December 4, 2023; the original file was forwarded without further action (unanimous). - Item 5: Adopted two sets of amendments (historic building language and planning staff amendments); sent the twice-amended ordinance as a committee report without recommendation to the full board for November 28, 2023; duplicated file continued to the call of the chair (unanimous). - Item 6: Adopted amendments and continued the resolution as amended to the next meeting (unanimous).

HOUSING 22% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · PROCEDURAL 13% · ENCROACHMENT PERMIT 8%
867
NOV 20, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
Special Meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors - November 20, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a special meeting on Monday, November 20, 2023, at 9:15 AM. The sole agenda item was a proposed charter amendment (Item 1) that would have granted the mayor authority to disapprove certain SFMTA fare and parking meter rate increases. After public comment and discussion, the sponsor moved to table the item, and the board unanimously voted to table it. Public Comments & Testimony - One member of the public spoke in support of the charter amendment, arguing that the current system allows an unelected SFMTA director to set parking meter hours and fares without oversight from elected officials. The speaker expressed that transportation fees greatly impact residents and businesses, particularly in lower-income areas, and that the mayor should have authority over these decisions. Discussion Items - Item 1: Charter Amendment – Mayoral Authority to Disapprove Certain SFMTA Budget Proposals - Supervisor Safai, the sponsor, explained that the amendment was intended to provide accountability by allowing the mayor to block fare and parking meter increases. He noted that thousands of written public comments opposed SFMTA's late-night and extended Sunday parking meter plans. However, after discussions with transit advocates and a commitment from SFMTA to halt their original plan to extend parking meter hours and days, Safai stated he was withdrawing the proposed charter amendment. He cited the need for small businesses and working families to recover from the COVID economic crisis. - Supervisor Safai moved to table the item, which was seconded by Supervisor Ronin. Key Outcomes - The Board of Supervisors voted unanimously (9-0) to table Item 1, effectively withdrawing the charter amendment from consideration. Supervisors Melgar and Stephanie were excused and absent. - The meeting adjourned in memory of Tina Willis Silva, a longtime Chinatown resident and president of the Ping Yuan Residents Improvement Association.

PROCEDURAL 50% · CHARTER AMENDMENTS 50%
868
NOV 16, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting – November 16, 2023

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, November 16, 2023, at City Hall. Chair Dean Preston presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan. The committee considered two agenda items: a motion to commission two additional performance audits and a resolution regarding the taxi upfront fare pilot program. It also approved thirteen settlement agreements in open session without closed session. Discussion Items Item 1: Motion to Amend the Budget and Legislative Analyst Services Audit Plan – Management of Street Cleaning by Public Works and Interdepartmental Agreements – FY2023-2024 Chair Preston introduced the motion to direct the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) to conduct two additional performance audits in the current fiscal year. The first audit would examine the efficiency, effectiveness, and equity of street cleaning operations by Public Works, responding to the 2023 City Survey that found street cleanliness ratings at their lowest and per capita cleaning costs ($40+) far exceeding peer cities (approx. $9). The second audit would review interdepartmental work orders, which total nearly $100 million in the general fund and $251 million citywide, to assess cost-effectiveness and documentation practices. Dan Goncher (BLA) provided supporting analysis, noting no performance audit of street cleaning had occurred in at least five years and that interdepartmental services lacked formal agreements. The item passed unanimously without public comment. Item 2: Resolution Urging Removal of Third-Party Dispatch from the Taxi Upfront Fare Pilot Program Supervisor Chan, the sponsor, requested a continuance to the call of the chair due to SFMTA staff unavailability. She proposed amendments to the resolution that would shift from urging removal of third-party dispatch to requiring SFMTA to develop additional metrics (e.g., whether trips supplement or replace street hails), collect quarterly data on total charges to passengers, and submit reports directly to the Board of Supervisors. The resolution would condition support for the pilot (extended to June 30, 2025) on a demonstrated 10% or greater increase in driver revenue. Chair Preston expressed support for the data-driven approach but voiced concerns about potential cannibalization of non-Uber taxi hails and the need to protect traditional taxi customers. Public Comments & Testimony During public comment on Item 2, several speakers shared perspectives: - A taxi driver (name not stated) highlighted inequities in surge pricing and urged tracking exact passenger payments versus driver earnings, noting that taxi drivers do not benefit from surge pricing and that regular customers (seniors, disabled, hospitality) are being neglected. - Muafa Kustafa (Manager, Flywheel Taxi) argued that removing third-party dispatch would be a mistake because it introduces young riders to taxis and increases driver income; he emphasized the program is a work in progress. - Izzy (CEO, Flywheel Technologies) stated the pilot is entirely optional for drivers, provides detailed trip information, and has generated significant additional earnings (hundreds per day). He noted that fewer than 1% of Uber riders cancel upon learning they will ride in a taxi. - A 10-year Flywheel driver reported that third-party dispatch now provides over 50% of his daily income and introduces Uber riders to the Flywheel app; he prioritizes street hails and Flywheel calls over Uber rides. - Wab (owner-operator) stated the pilot saved his medallion business, giving an example of $800 in Uber rides versus $0 in taxi hails on a recent day. - Evelyn Ingle (Taxi Workers Alliance) supported the resolution, citing the Board’s historical role in taxi regulation and the need for oversight to protect labor and consumer protections; she warned that drivers may be forced into Uber rides if the taxi business dries up. - Mark Ruberg (Taxi Workers Alliance) urged support for the resolution, expressing concerns that a 2.5-year pilot is too long and could entrench Uber’s influence; he called for protections against Uber acquiring financial or managerial interests in taxi companies. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The motion was approved unanimously (3-0) and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: The committee unanimously (3-0) adopted Supervisor Chan’s amendments and continued the item to the call of the chair (expected at the December 7, 2023 meeting). - Items 3–16: Thirteen settlement agreements (lawsuit and unlitigated claim settlements ranging from $35,000 to $1,361,454.60) were approved unanimously (3-0) without closed session after no public comments, and sent to the full Board with a positive recommendation.

PUBLIC COMMENT 31% · TRANSPORTATION 25% · TAXI INDUSTRY CRISIS 19% · PROCEDURAL 14%
869
NOV 16, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Rescheduled Meeting - November 16, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a rescheduled regular hearing on Thursday, November 16, 2023, at 10:00 a.m. The commission addressed continuances, a consent calendar, a discussion on remote public comment, department matters, and four regular calendar items. Key outcomes included a vote to continue the remote public comment discussion to December 7, 2023, approval of a planning code amendment eliminating public art requirements for 100% affordable housing projects (5-1), and unanimous approval of a fleet charging definition amendment and two conditional use authorizations. Continuance Items The commission voted unanimously (7-0) to continue three items to January 2024 and one item (1701 Fillmore Street) to January 18, 2024. Item 1314 Page Street was continued to February 1, 2024, at the applicant's request due to scheduling conflicts. Consent Calendar The commission unanimously approved the consent calendar, including Item 4 (initiation of planning code amendment for exceptions and extensions for existing uses), Item 5 (1155 Pine Street 1 CU), Item 6 (201 Sansome Street 1005 CU), and Item 7 (1068 Florida Street CU). Item 8 (1701 Fillmore Street) was continued. Commission Matters: Remote Public Comment The commission discussed a directive from the mayor's office to cease remote public comment, following the Board of Supervisors' lead. Several public commenters spoke in favor of retaining remote access, citing accessibility for seniors, workers, and BIPOC communities, and noting the lack of abuse in Planning Commission meetings. Commissioners expressed support for continuing remote comment, citing increased participation and the value of public input. The commission voted unanimously (7-0) to continue the discussion to December 7, 2023, to allow for further dialogue with the mayor's office and to develop protocols for handling abusive speech. Department Matters Director Hillis provided an update on the response to HCD's policy and practice review, due the week after Thanksgiving. A hearing on state law changes and the review is scheduled for December 7. The legislative affairs manager reported on the Board of Supervisors' land use committee approval of a nonprofit arts educational special use district at 800 Chestnut Street, which was subsequently passed by the full board. The Historic Preservation Commission approved legacy business registry applications for Elixir, El Palacio, Heroes Club, and Friends of Scrap, and continued its own remote public comment decision. General Public Comment One speaker requested the commission codify the residential flat policy with objective design standards to preserve flat configurations, citing examples of flats being altered into mega units. Regular Calendar: Item 14 – Eliminating Public Art Requirement for 100% Affordable Housing Projects Supervisor Dorsey's office presented legislation to amend Planning Code Section 429, waiving the public art requirement for 100% affordable housing projects and allowing relocation or removal of existing art. The legislation was prompted by a case at 1400 Mission Street where an on-site mural became a graffiti target, burdening affordable homeowners. Planning staff recommended five modifications, including amending the Administrative Code to exempt affordable projects, and three clarifications to the relocation process. Public commenters from CCHO, Soma Filipinas, and others expressed concerns about eliminating public art, citing equity and cultural value, and requested more time to find dedicated funding sources. After discussion, the commission voted 5-1 (Commissioner Imperial dissenting) to approve with modifications 1, 3, 4, and 5, and a finding encouraging further communication between departments and stakeholders. Regular Calendar: Item 15 – Fleet Charging Locations and Parcel Delivery Service Planning Code Amendment Supervisor Chan presented an ordinance to amend the definition of fleet charging to prohibit parcel delivery service as an accessory use, clarifying that only charging is allowed. Planning staff recommended modifications to allow separate approval for parcel delivery uses. Public commenters from the Teamsters Union supported the amendment, requesting additional language to prohibit maintenance and data download activities. The commission voted unanimously (7-0) to approve with staff recommendations, noting support for further clarity. Regular Calendar: Item 16 – 248 Valley Street Conditional Use Authorization The project proposed tantamount demolition of a single-family dwelling and construction of a four-story, two-unit building with a fourth-floor setback. The site is a large 38-foot-wide lot in Noe Valley. Public commenters raised concerns about scale, privacy, and light, and asked for more time to work with the developer. The project sponsor argued the design respects context with setbacks and light wells. The commission found the project consistent with residential design guidelines and voted unanimously (7-0) to approve. Regular Calendar: Item 17 – 56 Conrad Street Conditional Use Authorization The project proposed a vertical and horizontal addition to an existing single-family home in Glen Park, resulting in a unit over 3,000 square feet. The lot is steep, and the design includes a third-floor setback. Public comment was minimal. The commission noted the project fits the neighborhood context and voted unanimously (7-0) to approve. Key Outcomes - Continuances: Approved 7-0, with one date change. - Consent Calendar: Approved 7-0. - Remote Public Comment: Continued to December 7, 2023, 7-0. - Item 14 (Public Art Waiver): Approved 5-1 with modifications and a finding. - Item 15 (Fleet Charging): Approved 7-0 with staff recommendations. - Item 16 (248 Valley St): Approved 7-0. - Item 17 (56 Conrad St): Approved 7-0.

PUBLIC COMMENT 28% · PUBLIC ART 21% · CONDITIONAL USE AUTHORIZATION 14% · PROCEDURAL 9%
870
NOV 15, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - November 15, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, November 15, 2023, at 18:15 UTC (11:15 AM local). The committee was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Asha Safaí present. Supervisor Matt Dorsey also joined for the first item. The committee heard presentations, took public comment, and voted on several items, including health care rate trends, a project labor agreement hearing continuance, a transfer tax exemption for affordable housing, grant acceptance for Buchanan Mall, port lease approvals, a loan amendment for Sunnydale HOPE SF, and bond issuances for Treasure Island. Consent Calendar - There was no separate consent calendar; all items were considered individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Health Plan Rate Trends): One public speaker expressed that "health is not for sale" and argued against profiting from health care, stating that the current approach is not the future. - Item 3 (Transfer Tax Exemption): John Avalos, representing the Council of Community Housing Organizations (CCHO), spoke in support, emphasizing that the transfer tax increase created unexpected financial burdens for nonprofit housing developers and that the exemption would relieve pressure and benefit tenants. Several other speakers, including Kevin Kitching (Mission Housing) and Katie Lamont (TNDC), also expressed support and thanked staff for collaboration. One speaker (Terry Phil) suggested that "affordable" needs to be defined more clearly. - Item 8 (Sunnydale Loan Amendment): One public speaker advised to "fix what is there" rather than destroy, expressing general concern about the project. - Item 9/10 (Bonds): One speaker commented that the presentation was boring but urged the city to make Treasure Island beautiful, cautioning against building "rabbit cages" and fake beauty. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Hearing on San Francisco Health Plan Rate Trends: Supervisor Chan requested the hearing to understand health care cost escalation ahead of the budget process. Health Service System (HSS) Executive Director Abby Yant presented data showing that 2024 premium increases jumped to 10.3% overall, a $79 million increase, which was $31 million more than budgeted. Factors included health care wage inflation, workforce shortages, increased mental health and substance abuse services, chronic conditions, long COVID, and cost shifting from Medicare/Medicaid. The CMS reimbursement increase for Medicare Advantage was lower than in past years (3.2% vs. typical 6%), leading to a 15% premium increase for the UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage plan. The HSS is pursuing an RFP for Medicare Advantage plans to gather market information. Supervisor Matt Dorsey commended HSS staff for their work. Chair Chan asked clarifying questions about the 2% of members (approximately 2,500 individuals) driving 79% of costs (approximately $640 million). The hearing was filed unanimously. - Item 2 – Hearing on Citywide Project Labor Agreement and Annual Reports: Supervisor Safaí requested a continuance to December 6, 2023, to allow more time for participants to prepare. No public comment was made. The continuance was approved unanimously. - Item 3 – Transfer Tax Exemption for Affordable Housing: Supervisor Dean Preston presented an ordinance to broaden the exemption from increased transfer tax rates for rent-restricted affordable housing, apply it retroactively to January 1, 2017, extend it through December 31, 2030, and waive penalties and interest. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) estimated a fiscal impact of $30-45 million in reduced general fund revenues over the entire period. Supervisor Preston, Chair Chan, Vice Chair Mandelman, and Supervisor Safaí all expressed support, with several adding as co-sponsors. Public comment was supportive. The ordinance was forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 4 – Grant Acceptance for Buchanan Mall: Tony Moran from Recreation and Park presented a resolution to accept a $3.9 million grant from California State Parks for the Buchanan Mall Project. The grant requires a one-to-one match, which will be met through other sources. The project will renovate two of five blocks, and a deed restriction will require the park remain public open space in perpetuity. No public comment. The resolution was forwarded unanimously. - Items 5, 6, 7 – Port Leases: Presented together. Item 5 (Mission Rock lease amendments) was technical, clarifying port participation in future sales/refinancing. Item 6 (Recology lease at Pier 96) approved a six-year lease at $369,500/month initially, increasing 3% annually, with tenant paying for seismic and facility condition assessments (up to $1 million). Item 7 (Anderson Enterprises lease at Pier 68/70) approved a three-year lease with three one-year options, initial monthly rent of $66,702.15, and total revenue over the initial term estimated at $2.5 million. BLA reports recommended approval. No public comment. All three items were forwarded unanimously. - Item 8 – Sunnydale HOPE SF Loan Amendment: MOHCD staff presented a request to increase the loan by approximately $1.5 million to a total of $26,567,405 for infrastructure phase 1A3. Reasons included extreme weather, unforeseen conditions, and temporary power connection costs. BLA noted some costs were avoidable and recommended a report back on cost-sharing with the developer and an agreement between MOHCD and SFPUC. Supervisor Safaí expressed frustration about city permitting delays and requested the city report back within 30 days on the PUC reimbursement amount and on whether there will be a cost-sharing agreement. Vice Chair Mandelman and Supervisor Safaí added themselves as co-sponsors. One public speaker commented. The resolution was forwarded unanimously with the added condition of a 30-day report back. - Items 9 and 10 – Treasure Island Bond Issuances: TIDA and Office of Public Finance presented two resolutions. Item 9 authorizes issuance of up to $10 million in tax increment bonds (IRFD), and Item 10 authorizes up to $17 million in special tax bonds (CFD). The bonds will fund infrastructure and affordable housing on Treasure Island. Estimated true interest costs are approximately 6.4-6.6%. BLA provided analysis. Chair Chan noted that Item 10 was introduced only a week prior, but she was comfortable moving forward given its close relationship to Item 9. No public comment besides a general remark. Both resolutions were forwarded unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Hearing filed unanimously (3 ayes). - Item 2: Hearing continued to December 6, 2023, unanimously. - Item 3: Ordinance forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3 ayes). Supervisors Mandelman and Safaí added as co-sponsors. - Item 4: Resolution forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3 ayes). Supervisors Mandelman and Safaí added as co-sponsors. - Items 5, 6, 7: All three resolutions forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3 ayes). - Item 8: Resolution forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3 ayes), with a verbal commitment from MOHCD to report back within 30 days regarding the PUC reimbursement and the status of a cost-sharing agreement with SFPUC. Supervisors Mandelman and Safaí added as co-sponsors. - Items 9 and 10: Both resolutions forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3 ayes). The committee will not meet next week due to the Thanksgiving holiday; the next meeting is scheduled for December 6, 2023.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 27% · HEALTH SERVICES 24% · PUBLIC FINANCE 12% · PROCEDURAL 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com