Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 851–860 ENTRIES
851
DEC 12, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - December 12, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its last regular meeting of the calendar year on Tuesday, December 12, 2023, at 2:15 PM in City Hall. The meeting included the Mayor's appearance before the board, recognition of commendations, a hearing on a tentative parcel map appeal, approval of a $39.5 million budget adjustment for the Department of Public Health, passage of a housing production ordinance, and public comment on a ceasefire resolution for Gaza. All 11 supervisors were present except Supervisor Preston for the vote on item 3. Consent Calendar - Approval of meeting minutes from November 7, 2023 (unanimous). - Items 2 through 9 on consent were approved as a block, with the exception of item 3 (severed by Supervisor Safai). - Items 14 through 28 (grants, contracts, and resolutions) were approved on the consent agenda without objection. - Items 30 and 31: Appointments to Assessment Appeals Boards No. 1 and No. 2 (Stephen Wasserman, Richard Lee, Elizabeth Miller) were approved. - Items 36 through 47 (committee reports, including historical property contracts, a lease for a temporary shelter at 2177 Jerrold Avenue, and amendments to the Planning Code) were approved on first reading. - Items 50 through 52 (adoption without committee reference: consolidation of March 5, 2024 elections, final maps for Parkmerced and 988 Harrison Street) were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - The board heard a special ADA accommodation public comment from a representative of Disability Activism SF, who criticized Mayor Breed's homelessness policies and expressed support for Supervisor Dean Preston and a ceasefire in Gaza. - During general public comment, multiple speakers urged the board to pass a ceasefire resolution immediately, citing the ongoing loss of life in Gaza. Speakers highlighted that over 3,000 Palestinians had been killed in the prior week, 90% of the population displaced, and 25,000 children orphaned since October. - One speaker criticized the board's decision to send the ceasefire resolution to committee, calling it a delay that allows continued violence. - A speaker identified as a candidate for District 3 supervisor criticized the board for worsening public safety conditions and called for more police, removing tents, and addressing drug dealing. - Several speakers offered tributes to community leaders, including Ronald Colthurst and Arnold Woods. - A speaker raised concerns about alleged false diagnoses in surveillance software. Special Order 2:00 PM – Mayor's Appearance Before the Board - Mayor London Breed delivered opening remarks highlighting that since 2018 the city has helped over 13,000 households exit homelessness, with 2022 being the largest year for such placements. She stated that San Francisco is delivering more housing than any other Bay Area county and that homeless outreach teams brought 1,500 people into shelter so far in 2023, though 63% of those encountered refused shelter. She cited specific examples from the previous week and linked street conditions to fentanyl addiction. - Supervisor Chan asked about public safety and homelessness in District 1 (Richmond), after the murder of a shop clerk. Mayor Breed responded that police staffing has increased, and that retired police ambassadors are already patrolling Clement Street. She also mentioned grants for license plate readers and surveillance technology, but noted a four-week delay in implementing the policy due to lack of support from the Budget Committee. Supervisor Chan defended the legislative process and said she is a partner. - Supervisor Safai asked about the Ocean View Library project, stating that the community has chosen the Brotherhood Way and Orizaba location after years of planning and that over $30 million is reserved. He said the administration has stalled the transfer. Mayor Breed replied that the community is divided, there is not enough funding, and the project's cost has quadrupled. She offered to instead proceed with a rehabilitation of the existing library. Special Order 2:30 PM – Recognition of Commendations - The board honored Linda Jarrell, retiring Director of the Department of Technology (DT), for her 40 years of public service, including modernizing city infrastructure and expanding broadband access to 15,000 affordable housing units. She was praised by President Peskin and City Administrator Carmen Chu. - The board recognized the Lincoln High School Mustangs football team for winning the 99th Turkey Day game and their fourth section title in five years. - The board honored POW Crago, outgoing Executive Director of the Office of Transgender Initiatives (OTI), for his work on trans-inclusive policies, housing subsidies, and a universal basic income pilot. Supervisor Mandelman, City Administrator Chu, and other supervisors expressed gratitude. - The board recognized Maestra Lidia Candila Chan, Executive Director of Asociación Mayab, for her leadership serving the indigenous Mayan community. - The board recognized Safe Passage on its 15th anniversary, a community-led program in the Tenderloin that helps children navigate to and from school. Supervisor Preston noted the program covers 15 city blocks and serves over 200 kids daily. Discussion Items - Item 3 – De-Appropriation and Appropriation of $39,500,000 for DPH Overtime: Supervisor Safai expressed dismay that funds intended to hire nurses and medical technicians were being reallocated to overtime, calling it a sign of mismanagement by the mayor. He stated he would vote for it but felt his hands were tied. The ordinance passed 10 ayes, 0 noes (Supervisor Preston absent). - Items 32-35 – Hearing on Tentative Parcel Map Appeal (1365-1371 York Street): Supervisor Ronen requested a continuance to January 30, 2024, which was seconded by Supervisor Walton and approved without objection. - Item 11 – Fire Code: Lithium-Ion Batteries in Powered Mobility Devices: Supervisor Preston introduced amendments requested by Lime and deferred further amendments to address e-bike concerns. The item was re-referred to the Land Use and Transportation Committee for January. - Item 12 – Planning and Subdivision Codes Amendment for Housing Production: This ordinance, referred without recommendation from the Land Use Committee, was passed on first reading with 9 ayes and 2 noes (Supervisors Peskin and Chan). - Item 13 – Acceptance of $15.3 Million Grant for Organized Retail Theft Prevention: Supervisor Safai highlighted the three-year collaborative effort to secure the grant. The ordinance passed unanimously. Roll Call for Introductions - Supervisor Mandelman introduced in memoriam for John Bear and Dr. Jerome Gold Goldstein. - Supervisor Preston introduced a request for a hearing on regulating AI-generated content in local election campaigns, citing concerns about deepfakes and misinformation. - Supervisor Ronen introduced a resolution for retroactive approval of an agreement with Fidelity National Information Service for the Alemany Farmers Market EBT program. - Supervisor Walton introduced an in memoriam for Ronald Colthurst, a community activist and co-founder of the Harriet Tubman Democratic Club. - Supervisor Chan (joined by Supervisor Engardio) introduced an in memoriam for Arnold Marcus Woods, a founder of the Western Neighborhoods Project and historian of western San Francisco. Key Outcomes - The $39.5 million budget adjustment for DPH overtime was passed (10-0-1). - The housing production ordinance was passed on first reading (9-2). - The York Street parcel map appeal was continued to January 30, 2024. - The lithium-ion battery fire code was amended and re-referred to committee. - The board adopted a resolution honoring Safe Passage on its 15th anniversary. - Multiple commemorative resolutions were passed for retiring and departing city employees and community leaders. - All other consent and committee report items were approved without objection or with unanimous votes. - The meeting was adjourned in memory of Jerry Goldstein, John Bear, Jack Bourbon, Arnold Woods, and Ronald Colthurst.

PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC SAFETY 11% · TRANSGENDER RIGHTS 10%
852
DEC 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee Regular Meeting - December 11, 2023

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on the morning of Monday, December 11, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shamann Walton and member Ahsha Safai. The committee considered four items: a mayoral appointment to the Sanitation and Streets Commission, a legislative reduction of the Behavioral Health Commission, an update to Form 700 filing requirements for the General Services Agency, and an extension of the Reentry Council's sunset date. The meeting included public testimony, amendments, and votes, with two items continued to January 8, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Sanitation and Streets Commission): Several speakers supported nominee Azalina Eusope. Praveen Takeda (Tenderloin Housing Clinic) praised her willingness to make tough decisions. Lorraine Louis (New Community Leadership Foundation) cited her passion and authenticity. Nafi Falli, a fellow business owner, highlighted her commitment to street cleanliness. Jamie Flanagan (Phoenix Hotel) commended her blend of business acumen and compassion. - Item 2 (Behavioral Health Commission): Leah McGeever expressed concern about removing the child advocate seat, citing children's psychological impacts from COVID-19. A subsequent speaker argued that reducing the commission size would harm ethnic diversity, noting the absence of Asian members, and suggested filling vacancies instead of cutting seats. - Item 3 (Form 700 Filers): No public comment. - Item 4 (Reentry Council): Victoria Westbrook (Re-entry Division Director, Adult Probation) urged support, stating the council is the only collective body in the city that includes 17 city departments, pretrial services, and seven formerly incarcerated individuals. Discussion Items - Item 1: Mayoral Appointment – Azalina Eusope to Sanitation and Streets Commission – Eusope, a 21-year resident, small business owner, and mother, introduced herself. Chair Dorsey highlighted her background, including being quoted in the New York Times and recognized as the face of Malaysian cuisine. Eusope emphasized the collective effort needed for sanitation and small business success. The committee voted to send the appointment to the full board. - Item 2: Administrative Code – Composition of Behavioral Health Commission – Chair Dorsey proposed reducing the commission from 17 to 11 seats to improve quorum and align with state law, which requires 50% consumers/family members, 20% consumers, 20% family members, and at least one veteran. Jessica Brown (DPH) voiced support. Supervisor Dorsey introduced amendments, including adding a seat, adjusting professional qualifications, and resetting term expirations to June 2024. Supervisor Safai questioned the removal of the child advocate requirement; City Attorney Ann Pearson noted it could be restored without a substantive amendment. The committee voted to amend and continue the item to January 8, 2024. - Item 3: Campaign and Governmental Conduct Code – Form 700 Filers – Sophie Hayward (City Administrator's Office) presented four amendments updating the list of positions required to file Form 700, including adding deputy director, transaction manager, and analyst roles, and removing an operations manager. Because the amendments were substantive, the item was continued to January 8, 2024, to allow DHR to notify labor unions. No public comment. - Item 4: Administrative Code – Reentry Council; Reporting Duties, Sunset Date – Dominica Donovan (Chief of Staff to Supervisor Stefani) explained the ordinance extends the council's sunset from June 1, 2024 to June 1, 2029, and revises annual report deadlines. The council, established in 2008, coordinates 24 members including city agencies and formerly incarcerated individuals to support reentry. The committee voted unanimously to send the item to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to strike “reject” and send to the full board passed 2–0 (Dorsey aye, Walton aye, Safai absent). - Item 2: Motion to amend (as read into record) and continue to January 8, 2024 passed unanimously (Dorsey aye, Walton aye, Safai aye). - Item 3: Motion to amend (as read) and continue to January 8, 2024 passed unanimously. - Item 4: Motion to send to the full board with a positive recommendation as a committee report passed unanimously.

PERSONNEL MATTERS 23% · MENTAL HEALTH 22% · PROCEDURAL 21% · BEHAVIORAL HEALTH 16%
853
DEC 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Special Meeting – December 11, 2023

Note: The agenda and transcript indicate the meeting was originally scheduled for December 5, 2023, but the instruction for this summary requires the date December 11, 2023. The content below reflects the actual discussion from the December 5 meeting. The Police Commission held a special meeting to consider going into closed session to discuss collective bargaining with the San Francisco Police Officers Association (POA) regarding proposed Department General Order (DGO) 9.07 on pretextual traffic stops. The meeting included public comment on that matter, a vote to enter closed session, and a subsequent vote on disclosure of closed-session discussions. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers opposed the proposed ban on pretext stops (DGO 9.07), arguing that it would create a two-tiered system where only law-abiding citizens follow traffic laws, undermine public safety (e.g., broken taillights making vehicles harder to see), and represent an end-run around state law (SB 50 failed in Sacramento). Speakers also criticized the commission for holding a last-minute closed session, calling it secretive and damaging to the commission’s credibility, especially given ongoing ethics investigations and a proposed ballot measure to reform the commission. - One speaker provided statistics: in the first two quarters of 2023, only 5% of 2,600 searches were discretionary; 58% of searches were tied to arrests or warrants; and the commission allegedly withheld racial breakdowns of searches. The speaker claimed that among discretionary stops, Black individuals were searched at 4.6%—below the overall average of 4.8%—and called for greater transparency. - Another commenter echoed prior remarks, offering no additional detail. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Public Comment on Closed Session and Vote to Hold Closed Session: After public comment, the Commission voted unanimously (4–0) to move into closed session to discuss collective bargaining with the POA concerning DGO 9.07. The Commission had a quorum: President Elias, Vice President Carter Oberstone, Commissioner Yannis, and Commissioner Benedicto (Commissioners Yi, Byrne, and Walker excused). - Item 3 – Closed Session (Not Publicly Disclosed): The Commission met in closed session with their labor negotiator (LaWanna Preston, SFPD Labor Relations Director) to discuss anticipated issues under negotiation with the POA—specifically DGO 9.07. The POA was not permitted to attend. - Item 4 – Vote on Disclosure: Returning to open session, the Commission voted unanimously (4–0) to not disclose any or all discussion from closed session, with the exception of factual updates to be included in the minutes. Key Outcomes - The Commission voted 4–0 to enter closed session (Item 2). - The Commission voted 4–0 to not disclose closed-session discussions, except for factual updates in the minutes (Item 4). - The meeting adjourned immediately after the disclosure vote.

PUBLIC SAFETY 54% · PROCEDURAL 26% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 11% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 9%
854
DEC 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting – December 11, 2023: Fleet Charging, Mural Landmarks, Housing Production, ADUs, Public Art, and PDR Conversions

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, December 11, 2023, at 9:45 AM. Chair Myrna Melgar presided, joined by Board President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee heard nine agenda items, including ordinances on fleet charging, mural landmarking, housing production, accessory dwelling units, public art for affordable housing, and conversion limits in Eastern Neighborhoods. Several items were approved and sent to the full board, while others were continued to January 22, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Fleet Charging): Mark Leeson and Peter Ziblat (Teamsters Joint Council 7) spoke in support, stating the ordinance clarifies that fleet charging stations cannot host parcel delivery activities without separate planning approval, protecting workers and ensuring proper land use. - Items 2-3 (Mural Landmarks): Multiple speakers including artists Daniel Galvez, Rodrigo Duran (Carnaval SF), Eric Arguello (Calle 24 Latino Cultural District), Roberto Hernandez, Martina Ayala (Mission Cultural Center), and Arturo Carrillo (HealthRight 360) expressed strong support for landmarking the Chata Gutierrez and Carnaval murals, citing cultural and historical significance, community identity, and the need to preserve Latino heritage in the Mission District. - Item 5 (Housing Production): Peter Papadopoulos (Mission Economic Development Agency) expressed concern that the legislation’s density bonus provisions violate the Housing Element’s commitments to prevent displacement and urged HCD to work with the city for compliance. - Item 8 (Public Art for Affordable Housing): Anne Cervantes (San Francisco Latino Historical Society) recommended the committee not move forward until questions about compliance with state public art protections are answered, and urged including local artists in procurement. Sharm Shariati, a resident at 1400 Mission, spoke in favor, describing the burden of a graffiti-covered mural on a BMR building and the inability to afford maintenance. Charlie Shamus (Council of Community Housing Organizations) supported the “look back” provisions for existing art but opposed the “look forward” elimination of art requirements for new projects, proposing alternative funding instead. - Item 9 (PDR Conversions): Lamer Bamin Touan (Swords to Plowshares) spoke in support, stating the amendment would allow the nonprofit to operate a veterans community center without incurring over $300,000 in conditional use fees, freeing resources for services. A general comment from Mr. Phil urged the committee to think critically and avoid conflicts of interest. Consent Calendar No consent calendar was designated. All items received individual discussion. Discussion Items Item 1 – Fleet Charging Locations and Parcel Delivery Service (File 230704) Supervisor Chan introduced the ordinance prohibiting parcel delivery sorting, unloading, and reloading at fleet charging stations. Planning staff confirmed the Planning Commission unanimously approved it on November 16 with a minor amendment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt the amendments and send the item to the full board for the December 12 meeting. Chair Melgar added herself as a co-sponsor. Items 2-3 – Landmark Designations for Chata Gutierrez Mural (File 231033) and Carnaval Mural (File 231034) Ana Herrera (Supervisor Ronen’s office) and Pilar LaValley (Planning) presented. The Historic Preservation Commission unanimously recommended landmarking on September 18. Both murals meet Article 10 criteria. Supervisor Peskin noted he has danced in Carnaval for years and supports the designations. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to add co-sponsors (Peskin, Preston) and send as a committee report to the December 12 board meeting. Item 4 – Building, Green Building, Mechanical, and Plumbing Codes – Amending Findings (File 231125) Carl Nisida (DBI) explained the ordinance makes technical corrections to indexes of findings for the 2022 codes, requested by the California Building Standards Commission. The changes do not alter underlying codes. The Code Advisory Committee and Building Inspection Commission both unanimously recommended approval. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send to the full board. Item 5 – Housing Production (File 231258) Aaron Starr (Planning) presented amendments to replace “building permit” with “planning entitlement” in Section 311 to comply with AB 1114 (post-entitlement permits within 15 days). President Peskin questioned the feasibility of rapid plan checks and the pace of state preemption. Peter Papadopoulos (MEDA) voiced concern about displacement and cultural asset loss. After discussion, the committee voted (3-0) to adopt Starr’s amendments, strip duplicative sections, and continue the item to January 22, 2024, for further refinement. Item 6 – State-Mandated Accessory Dwelling Unit Controls (File 230310) Starr and Natalia Fassi (Planning) presented amendments to align local code with AB 2221 and SB 897, including modifications from a recent HCD letter. President Peskin objected to receiving a 57-page amended document during the meeting without prior review, stating he could not responsibly vote. No public comment. The committee voted (3-0) to continue the item to January 22, 2024. Item 7 – Street Encroachment Permit – 12th Street Plaza (File 230419) Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey’s office) requested adoption of substantive amendments (cleanup language, accepting a sidewalk easement) and a one-week continuance for public works staff availability. No public comment. The committee voted (2-0, Preston absent) to amend and continue to January 22, 2024. Item 8 – Eliminating Public Art Requirement for 100% Affordable Housing Projects (File 230706) Tam explained the legislation was split: the original file (duplicate) was amended to remove the forward-looking waiver, focusing only on a process for removing or relocating existing art on 100% affordable housing. Planning staff (Audrey Merlone) summarized the Planning Commission’s recommended modifications (new ZA hearing criteria, minor relocation process, technical corrections). Public comment included support from residents and CCHO, and a caution from Cervantes to protect artists. The committee voted (3-0) to duplicate the file, amend the original with the commission’s modifications, send the amended version as a committee report to the December 12 board meeting, and continue the unamended duplicate to the call of the chair. Item 9 – Exceptions from Limits on Conversion of PDR, Institutional, Community, and Arts Uses in Eastern Neighborhood Plans (File 230863) Tam presented legislation to exempt changes among these uses from conditional use and replacement requirements in West Soma, with a new 25,000 square-foot ground floor cap. Planning staff confirmed the commission approved it on October 26 and supported the cap. Public comment from Swords to Plowshares supported. The committee voted (3-0) to adopt the cap amendment and send the ordinance as a committee report to the December 12 board meeting. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Amended and sent to full board (Dec. 12) with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 2-3: Sent as committee report to full board (Dec. 12) with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 4: Sent to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Amended and continued to January 22, 2024 (3-0). - Item 6: Continued to January 22, 2024 (3-0). - Item 7: Amended and continued to January 22, 2024 (2-0, Preston absent). - Item 8: Duplicate file amended and sent as committee report to full board (Dec. 12) (3-0); original duplicate continued to call of the chair. - Item 9: Amended (25,000 sq. ft. cap) and sent as committee report to full board (Dec. 12) (3-0). The meeting adjourned at approximately 12:30 PM.

PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · PROCEDURAL 17% · PUBLIC ART 11% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 8%
855
DEC 7, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting: December 7, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, December 7, 2023, commencing at approximately 1:00 PM local time. The meeting covered a wide range of items including routine continuances, a consent calendar item, commission matters, department updates, general public comment, and several regular calendar items involving land use and housing projects. Key discussions included the future of remote public comment, new state housing laws, the Stonestown development, and multiple conditional use authorizations. Votes were taken on several items, with the commission approving most projects and initiating a major rezoning. Consent Calendar - 949 Grant Avenue – Conditional Use Authorization: Approved 6-0 after Commissioner Ruiz recused due to a conflict of interest (project sponsor is their employer). The item was not removed from consent. Public Comments & Testimony - Remote Public Comment (Item 7): Multiple members of the public spoke in favor of maintaining remote public comment, citing accessibility for seniors, people with disabilities, and those unable to attend in person during work hours. Speakers included Georgia, Sue Hesser, Lorraine Petty, Anastasia Ovanopoulos, and others. They argued that eliminating remote access would reduce public participation and equity. - General Public Comment: Oscar Masariegos (NorCal Carpenters Union) spoke about the benefits of union wages and benefits; Georgia addressed a roof deck and housing conversion concerns; Harry Thomas expressed support for the 2515 Folsom Street project; Tom Radulovich (Livable City) advocated for shifting transportation impact fees from commercial to parking; David Elliott Lewis urged attention to affordable housing and priority equity geographies. - State Housing Laws (Item 12): Public commenters expressed both support and concern about new state laws, with some emphasizing the need for affordable housing and protections for vulnerable neighborhoods. - Stonestown (Item 13): Commenters generally supported the project, with some raising concerns about tower heights near Ralph Nickel Park, construction noise, and the need for more affordable units. The Housing Action Coalition and others praised the community engagement. - 530 Turk Street (Item 14): David Elliott Lewis (Tenderloin People’s Congress) expressed support for the developer but noted the low level of inclusionary housing (80% AMI). A union representative opposed the project due to lack of labor standards. Other commenters supported the project for adding housing near transit. - 67 Potomac Street (Item 15): Neighbors spoke in favor, highlighting the need for family-sized homes and the compatibility of the design with the historic district. - 27 Alvarado Street (Item 16): A neighbor spoke in support, noting the improvement of the property and the addition of housing. - 2919 Webster Street (Item 17): The DR requester (Carrie Havenrich) raised privacy and light/air concerns. Neighbor Charles Ehrlich supported the remodel. The project sponsor noted a voluntary modification to pull back the upper deck by 3.5 feet. Discussion Items - Item 5 – Adoption of Minutes: The minutes from November 16, 2023 were adopted unanimously (7-0) after no public comment. - Item 6 – Commission Comments: Commissioner Diamond highlighted the “Let’s Glow” exhibit and ice skating in Union Square. Commissioner Moore praised the Mission Housing and Meta award for the Mission project (350 units). - Item 7 – Remote Public Comment: Staff reported that the mayor’s office requested ending remote public comment. After extensive debate, a motion to cease remote public comment effective January 1, 2024 passed 4-3 (Braun, Ruiz, Moore dissenting). The commission also agreed that secondary staff could continue to participate remotely, with lead staff present in person. - Item 10 – Business Signs on Historic Buildings: Staff presented an ordinance requiring HPC hearings for signs on Article 10 (landmark) and Article 11 (conservation district) buildings. Staff recommended maintaining over-the-counter review for Article 11 signs. The commission approved the ordinance with staff modifications 5-2 (Commissioners Imperial and Moore dissenting). - Item 12 – State Housing Laws and HCD Policy & Practice Review: Informational presentation. Dan Sider reviewed HCD’s 28 actions (18 required) and timelines. Kate Connor covered five new state bills: AB 2011, SB 423, SB 4, AB 1287, AB 1114. Commissioners discussed impacts on priorities, equity, monitoring, and infrastructure. No vote was taken. - Items 13a/b – Stonestown Development: Informational presentation on the design standards and guidelines (DSG) for the 30-acre project with up to 3,500 residential units, 6 acres of parks, and a new main street. Staff recommended initiation of General Plan Amendments. The commission approved initiation and scheduling a public hearing on or after January 18, 2024 (7-0). - Item 14 – 530-540 Turk Street: Conditional use authorization for an 88-unit residential building using state density bonus (16% bonus). The project includes 13 on-site BMR units (8 at 80% AMI). Staff recommended approval. Approved 7-0. - Item 15 – 67 Potomac Street: Conditional use authorization for a 1,279 sq ft rear addition to a single-family home in a historic district. HPC had approved. Staff recommended approval. Approved 7-0. - Item 16 – 27 Alvarado Street: Conditional use authorization to increase density from 4 to 6 units by replacing a garage with a new 4-story building. Staff recommended approval. Approved 7-0. - Item 17 – 2919 Webster Street: Discretionary review of a rear addition and roof deck. Project sponsor modified the design (pulled back the upper deck 3.5 ft). Staff recommended taking DR and approving as modified. Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to take DR and approve with modifications. Key Outcomes - Continuances: All proposed continuances (2515 Folsom to Jan 18, 2024; cannabis retail to Feb 29, 2024; 1212 Union withdrawn) approved 7-0. - Consent Calendar: 949 Grant Ave approved 6-0. - Minutes: Adopted 7-0. - Remote Public Comment: Motion to end remote public comment after Jan 1, 2024 passed 4-3. Staff remote participation allowed. - Business Signs on Historic Buildings: Approved with staff modifications 5-2. - Stonestown: Initiation of General Plan Amendments approved 7-0; public hearing scheduled for or after Jan 18, 2024. - 530 Turk Street: Conditional use approved 7-0. - 67 Potomac Street: Conditional use approved 7-0. - 27 Alvarado Street: Conditional use approved 7-0. - 2919 Webster Street: Discretionary review taken and approved as modified 7-0. The meeting was adjourned at approximately 7:30 PM local time.

PUBLIC COMMENT 22% · HOUSING 16% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 9% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 9%
856
DEC 7, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting: December 7, 2023

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on December 7, 2023, at 6:15 PM UTC to consider six agenda items. The meeting included hearings on two civil grand jury reports addressing the city's hiring crisis and homelessness services contracting, approval of two Mills Act historical property contracts, a new contract for homeless outreach services, and a long-term lease for a temporary shelter site. The committee filed both civil grand jury reports and forwarded the remaining items to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Hiring Crisis): Umar Fall, SEIU Field Director, expressed support for the civil grand jury's recommendations but emphasized that the hiring process remains too long, with many steps and lack of communication to applicants. He urged the city to become a better employer beyond relying on pensions. - Item 2 (Homelessness Contracts): Michael Corboy (D2 resident) urged the city performance scorecard to include subpopulation data so citizens can evaluate how $1.7 billion in nonprofit spending is used effectively. - Item 6 (Jerrold Avenue Lease): Michael Helby, property manager and co-chair of the Market Zone Working Group, requested that the shelter prioritize unhoused individuals from the immediate district, improve lighting and cleanliness on surrounding streets, and provide community ambassadors and adequate police presence. He asked that the community stakeholder group continue to be involved in planning. Discussion Items - Item 1: Civil Grand Jury Report – "Time to Get to Work: San Francisco's Hiring Crisis" (Hearing) - Civil Grand Jury Presentation: Marvin Norman presented eight findings and 17 recommendations. Key areas: 60-day hiring timeline goal, better anticipation of employee separations, faster post-referral process, reduction of job classifications, collaboration with unions on recruitment and retention, and public dashboards. The jury noted that city departments agreed with findings 1 and 2 (vacancy rates negatively impact services; hiring takes too long) but partially disagreed with six others, though many responses indicated implementation plans. Three findings (2, 5, 6) require follow-up. - Department of Human Resources Response: Director Carol Ison reported that vacancy rates have dropped from 14% to 10.2% (permanent full-time), time to fill permanent civil service positions decreased from 255 to 197 days, and applications increased 46% year-over-year with 500 additional offers in process. She highlighted civil service reform efforts, including moving to online on-demand exams, improving candidate communication via Smart Recruiters, and launching a public people analytics dashboard within six months. DHR is also working with the Civil Service Commission to revise rules and with unions on retention and succession. - Discussion: Supervisor Chan asked about candidate communication; DHR noted automated notifications are expanding but standardized timelines for applicants are not yet in place. Supervisor Preston asked about a public dashboard; DHR committed to providing one within six months. He also questioned the 5-day mayoral approval timeline for hiring requests; DHR explained that the current process is required due to the city's financial outlook, and that a smaller number of positions have deemed-approved status. The committee filed the report. - Item 2: Civil Grand Jury Report – "Hitting the Performance Bullseye: Contracting for Better Outcomes in Homelessness Services" (Hearing) - Civil Grand Jury Presentation: Rick Ulrich presented findings that HSH contracts inconsistently use outcome-based metrics, on-site monitoring is insufficient, and the city performance scorecard does not adequately report on subpopulations (e.g., chronically homeless, racial/ethnic groups). He recommended HSH develop standardized performance measures linked to the strategic plan, improve monitoring, and enhance public reporting. The jury noted that HSH agreed with most findings but disagreed that the scorecard is the appropriate place for subpopulation data. - HSH Response: Deputy Director Emily Cohen stated that HSH generally agrees with the findings and is implementing a performance management plan aligned with the new five-year strategic plan "Home by the Bay." Key actions: consolidating data systems into a single system, standardizing metrics across agreements, and developing annual program monitoring policies. HSH will also work with the controller's office on citywide fiscal monitoring. - Discussion: Supervisor Chan raised concerns about HSH's sole-source contracting authority, noting that the mayor proposed extending it for another five years. She argued that sole-source procurement undermines performance-based contracting. Vice Chair Stephanie noted that she has introduced legislation to standardize performance measurement and monitoring, which was sent back to committee for further input from nonprofits. The committee filed the report. - Items 3 & 4: Mills Act Historical Property Contracts (Resolutions) - Presentation: Shannon Ferguson (Planning) and Elizabeth Gordon Junk (Preservation Manager) presented two contracts: (1) 988 Market Street (Warfield Building) – conversion of office to 45 residential units, with $576,259 in rehabilitation costs and $20,000 annual maintenance, estimated tax savings of $176,681 per year; (2) 2209 Webster Street – single-family Victorian home converted from medical office, with $238,000 rehabilitation and $3,800 annual maintenance, estimated tax savings of $17,817 per year. The Historic Preservation Commission recommended approval. Planning is conducting an audit of the Mills Act program and will present policy recommendations in January 2024. - Property Owner Testimony: Michael Foley and Chiao Men Li (owners of 2209 Webster) described their commitment to restoring the historic home and raising their children there. They noted the building had been abandoned for 30 years and is architecturally significant. - Discussion: Chair Preston questioned the program's value, noting that the 988 Market Street property receives a large tax savings relative to its investment ($576K investment vs. $2M estimated savings over 10 years). He and Supervisor Chan expressed concerns about the program's equity, especially during budget deficits, and the need for stronger historical significance criteria. They noted that Supervisor Peskin plans to introduce legislation to put these contracts into non-renewal status after 10 years, phasing out over 20 years. The committee sent both items to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 5: Contract with Heluna Health for Homeless Outreach Team (HOT) (Resolution) - Presentation: Deputy Director Emily Cohen and BLA Nick Menard described a new 3.5-year contract (Jan 2024 – June 2027) with Heluna Health for $36.9 million to provide street outreach and case management. The contract includes 76 FTEs (4.2 increase), a subcontract with Code Tenderloin for backup staffing, and a focus on filling staffing gaps. The BLA noted that the program costs about $9.2 million per year, 77% funded by the general fund. A small portion ($325,000/year) from Recreation and Parks for outreach in Golden Gate Park and Buena Vista Park is on the mayor's mid-year cut list. - Discussion: Supervisor Chan asked about response times; Cohen clarified that HOT is not an on-demand service but does beat-based outreach. The city's HERT team handles complaint-driven responses. Chair Preston asked about coordination with the upcoming street teams audit; Cohen confirmed the contract is flexible enough to adjust operations. The committee sent the item to the full board. - Item 6: Lease for 2177 Jerrold Avenue – Temporary Shelter Program (Resolution) - Presentation: Deputy Director Cohen proposed a 15-year lease (with two 5-year options) for a hybrid shelter with 60 cabins and 20 safe parking spaces. Annual base rent: $2.5 million, tenant improvements: $8.6 million (city share), total cost over 15 years: $44 million in rent, plus $2.5 million for utilities and taxes. The program will serve the immediate District 10 area, which has 25% of the city's unsheltered population and 50% of inhabited vehicles. The cost per slot is estimated at $90,000 per year (including services) or $201 per guest per night (lease and services). The site can expand to 200-250 cabins if funding becomes available. - Discussion: Supervisor Chan asked about length of stay; Cohen noted average stays are 90 days to 6 months, with no arbitrary limit. She clarified that the housing placement responsibility lies with the coordinated entry system, not solely the shelter provider. Chair Preston questioned whether the city analyzed purchase versus lease; Cohen stated the property was not for sale and the city lacks shelter acquisition funds, but the lease includes an option to purchase. The committee sent the item to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to file the civil grand jury report passed unanimously (Preston, Chan, Stefani). - Item 2: Motion to file the civil grand jury report passed unanimously. - Items 3 & 4: Motion to send both Mills Act resolutions to the full board with positive recommendation passed unanimously. - Item 5: Motion to send the Heluna Health contract resolution to the full board with positive recommendation passed (Preston, Chan; Stefani absent). - Item 6: Motion to send the Jerrold Avenue lease resolution to the full board with positive recommendation passed (Preston, Chan; Stefani excused). - The committee also voted to excuse Vice Chair Stefani from the remainder of the meeting.

HOMELESSNESS 31% · HUMAN RESOURCES 16% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8%
857
DEC 6, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - December 6, 2023: APEC Impact Hearing, Retail Theft Grant, and Homeless Contracting Waiver Debate

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and including Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman and Member Asha Safai (absent for later votes), met on December 6, 2023 at 10:00 AM to consider 18 agenda items. The meeting featured a lengthy hearing on the financial impacts of the APEC summit on small businesses and cultural institutions, approval of a $15.3 million grant for organized retail theft prevention including automated license plate readers, and a continued debate on extending streamlined homeless service contracting authority. Most routine grants and contract amendments were approved unanimously. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Pit Stop Public Toilet Program): Accepted a retroactive $250,000 grant from BART for three pit stops near BART stations, covering FY2021-22 expenditures. Approved unanimously with two votes (Safai absent). - Item 4 (Transitional Housing Programs): Authorized applying for and accepting $2,091,240 from the California Department of Housing and Community Development for transitional housing and $291,098 for housing navigation, supporting up to 70 foster youth. Approved unanimously. - Item 5 (Chinese Hospital Contract): Approved amendment increasing the contract to $20.6 million for subacute skilled nursing beds, extended by one year through November 2024. Approved unanimously. - Items 6 & 15 (HIV Services Grants): Accepted $15.95 million from the Ryan White Act and approved a $26.5 million contract with UCSF for HIV outpatient services through 2030. Approved unanimously after technical amendments. - Items 7 & 9 (Overdose Prevention Grants): Accepted $2.225 million from CDC and $2 million from HHS for overdose prevention collaborations, including training 400 paramedics and expanding treatment navigation. Approved unanimously. - Item 8 (Preschool Hearing Screening): Accepted $1,044,792 from PCORI via UCSF for a five-year study on hearing screening tests. Approved unanimously. - Item 10 (SFGH Foundation Grant): Accepted $180,000 for Behavioral Emergency Response Team, HIV homeless patients, and Women’s Options Clinic. Approved unanimously. - Item 11 (California Home Visiting Program): Accepted $272,000 retroactively for nurse home visiting for first-time parents. Approved unanimously. - Items 12 & 13 (McKesson Pharmaceutical Contracts): Approved amendments increasing combined not-to-exceed amounts to $2.44 billion over four years, with net city cost of $88 million after reimbursement. Approved unanimously. - Item 14 (A Better Way Mental Health Services): Approved a $13.58 million contract amendment for outpatient mental health for foster youth ages 0-21, extended through June 2027. Approved unanimously. - Item 17 (Latino Commission Substance Use Treatment): Approved a $17.6 million contract for residential and outpatient drug treatment for Spanish-speaking adults, extended through June 2027. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - APEC Hearing (Item 2): Over 20 public speakers, mostly small business owners and cultural institution representatives, expressed anger and frustration about severe revenue losses during the APEC summit (November 13-19, 2023). Losses ranged from $10,000 to over $100,000 per business. Speakers from Bonchon, Orange Hummus, The Grove, Children’s Creativity Museum, and others reported 33-94% drops in revenue due to security perimeters, protests, and the city’s “stay away” messaging. Many urged the city to use the $10 million reserve fund for direct cash subsidies, and called for accountability and transparency regarding the $20+ million spent on APEC. A petition signed by over 50 businesses was submitted. Dr. Carol Tang of the Children’s Creativity Museum noted that Veterans Day weekend, normally their busiest, saw a 23% drop. Discussion Items - APEC Financial Impacts Hearing (Item 2): Supervisor Matt Dorsey presented the hearing to assess hardships from APEC. The Yerba Buena Community Benefit District and Soma Pilipinas Cultural District provided data showing 33% drop in visitor traffic in the security zone. Scott Rowitz (YBCBD) noted $15,000 average revenue loss per small business. Raquel Rodon Diaz (Soma Pilipinas) and business owner Manuel Ramirez called for the $10 million reserve fund to be used for loss mitigation, a public hearing on APEC spending, and an audit of the $53 million estimated economic benefits. Supervisor Safai expressed concern about lack of support for small businesses and noted the city’s cleanliness during APEC raised questions about why it isn’t sustained. The hearing was continued to allow for further discussion and potential next steps. The motion to continue passed 2-0 (Safai absent). - Organized Retail Theft Grant (Item 3): The Police Department presented a $15.3 million state grant from the Board of State and Community Corrections for personnel, technology (400 Flock automated license plate readers), and data analytics to combat retail and catalytic converter theft. The grant covers October 2023 through June 2027. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) noted that less than half the funds go to patrol overtime, $2 million for vehicles, and $4 million for cameras. The grant locks in a specific vendor (Flock), raising procurement concerns. The committee amended the resolution to clarify it is approved under Charter Section 9.118 (board approval for contracts over $10 million) and duplicated the file; one version was passed to the full board with a positive recommendation, and the other continued to December 13, 2023 for final language. Passed 3-0. - Homeless Contracting Waiver (Item 18): The Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) and Public Works sought to extend streamlined contracting authority (waiving competitive bidding) for five more years (through May 2029) for homeless services and construction. HSH reported using the authority for 159 agreements with 52 nonprofits, opening 10,000 supportive housing units and 3,000 shelter beds since 2019. Supervisors Chan and Safai expressed concerns about lack of oversight, potential for corruption, and questioned why a qualified vendor list (RFQ) couldn’t be used instead of blanket sole-source. Supervisor Mandelman supported the waiver as critical for responding to the crisis. The committee voted 3-0 to continue the item to a future meeting for more information and discussion. Key Outcomes - Item 2 (APEC Hearing): Continued to the call of the chair to develop potential relief measures. Motion passed 2-0 (Safai absent). - Item 3 (Retail Theft Grant): Amended to cite Charter 9.118; forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0) and duplicated file continued to December 13, 2023. - Item 18 (Homeless Contracting Waiver): Continued to the call of the chair (3-0) to allow further review and discussions with the Office of Contract Administration. - All Other Items: Approved unanimously and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for the December 12, 2023 agenda.

PUBLIC HEALTH 18% · PROCUREMENT 15% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13%
858
DEC 5, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – December 5, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on December 5, 2023, beginning at 2:15 PM. The meeting included the consent agenda, extensive debate and votes on housing production legislation, consideration of multiple ordinances and resolutions, a special commendation for a local cross‑country champion, and several hours of public comment—the vast majority of which focused on a newly introduced resolution calling for a permanent ceasefire in Gaza. Consent Calendar - Items 1–7 (routine approvals) were adopted unanimously on a single roll‑call vote. These included a transfer tax exemption for affordable housing, five lawsuit settlements totaling $2,374,240.38 plus statutory interest, and amendments to the Police Code regarding cannabis events. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comment on adoption‑without‑committee‑reference items (39–40): One speaker requested that public comment be allocated a minimum of three minutes per speaker, but the board proceeded with the standard one‑minute limit. No speakers addressed the specific agenda items. - General public comment: Hundreds of people spoke, the overwhelming majority urging the Board to support and promptly vote on Supervisor Preston’s resolution calling for an immediate and permanent ceasefire in Gaza. Speakers included Palestinian‑American residents, Jewish community members, labor union representatives, healthcare workers, educators, youth, and city employees. Many cited the death toll of over 15,000 Palestinians (including over 8,000 children) since October 7, the displacement of 1.7 million people, and the use of U.S. taxpayer dollars to fund the Israeli military campaign. A smaller number of speakers opposed the resolution, arguing that it was outside the Board’s jurisdiction or that it should condition a ceasefire on the release of all hostages. Discussion Items - Housing Production Legislation (Items 8, 32, and 36): The Board considered three interconnected items aimed at streamlining housing production to meet state requirements and avoid decertification of the city’s housing element. - Item 8 (ordinance to amend the Planning Code) was the primary vehicle. After amendments by Supervisor Melgar (to merge language from Item 32) and Supervisor Mandelman (to add historic preservation protections for pre‑1923 buildings), the ordinance was passed on first reading by a vote of 9–2 (Supervisors Peskin and Chan voting no). - Item 36 (resolution urging the City Attorney and Mayor to respond to HCD’s policy review) was adopted 8–3 (Supervisors Engardio, Stefani, and Dorsey voting no). - Item 32 (a duplicate ordinance) was tabled unanimously after its content was incorporated into Item 8. - Other Discussion Items: - Item 9 (entertainment permit fee amendments) was initially deferred but later amended and passed on first reading after Supervisor Chan’s motion to restore criminal history disclosure requirements was adopted. - Item 24 (nonprofit contract monitoring) was sent back to committee at Supervisor Stefani’s request. - Item 33 (lithium‑ion battery safety) was continued one week to December 12. - Item 31 (“Love Our Neighborhoods” sidewalk amenity ordinance) was passed on first reading. Key Outcomes - Passed on first reading: Housing Production Ordinance (Item 8) as amended (9‑2); Wawona Street Cultural Center Special Use District (Item 23); Commercial/retail/restaurant use expansion (Item 30); Neighborhood amenities ordinance (Item 31); Entertainment permit amendments (Item 9 as amended); and numerous consent items. - Adopted: Resolution on HCD response (Item 36) (8‑3); India Basin Waterfront Park grants and behested payment waiver (Items 16‑20); affordable housing loan agreements for 1234 Great Highway and 650 Divisadero Street (Items 21‑22); Mission Bay parks agreement (Item 12); renewable diesel contract amendment (Item 15); and commemorative street name and landmark initiation (Items 34‑35). - Re‑referred to committee: Nonprofit monitoring ordinance (Item 24); duplicated entertainment permit file (Item 9). - Continued: Lithium‑ion battery safety ordinance (Item 33) to December 12, 2023. - Tabled: Duplicate housing legislation (Item 32). - Introduced: Ceasefire resolution (by Supervisor Preston, co‑sponsored by Supervisor Ronan); Dangerous landlord act (directed to City Attorney); Potrero Yard Special Use District; and formal apology to African Americans (referred to Government Audit and Oversight Committee with a hearing scheduled for February 15, 2024). - Adjourned in memory of Marvin Robinson, Leo La Rocca, Connie Moy, and Aganafer Shiffaru.

PUBLIC COMMENT 35% · FOREIGN POLICY 22% · HUMAN RIGHTS 11% · INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS 9%
859
DEC 4, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting – December 4, 2023: Appointments to Assessment Appeals Board

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on Monday, December 4, 2023, at 9:00 AM (presumed, despite a 6:15 PM timestamp in metadata). Chair Matt Dorsey presided alongside Vice Chair Shimon Walton; Supervisor Asha Safai was absent for the first agenda item but present for the second. The committee considered two appointments to the Assessment Appeals Board (AAB): three seats across AAB No. 1 and AAB No. 2. No public comments were received. All appointments were recommended to the full Board of Supervisors. Discussion Items - Appointment to Assessment Appeals Board No. 1 – Seat 3: Steven Wasserman, a real estate broker with nearly 30 years of experience in San Francisco and a current member of AAB No. 2, applied for reappointment to Board No. 1, seat 3. He stated he meets two of the five qualifying professional requirements (licensed real estate broker and prior board service). - Appointment to Assessment Appeals Board No. 1 – Seat 7: Richard Lee, a real estate broker with over 15 years of service on the Assessment Appeals Board, applied for reappointment to the alternate seat 7. He noted that the board and the Assessor’s Office will likely face thousands of COVID‑19‑related appeals and emphasized his experience in valuation and appraisal techniques. - Appointment to Assessment Appeals Board No. 2 – Seat 4: Elizabeth Miller, an attorney practicing housing and real estate law since 2008 (J.D. from USF Law School, 2008), applied for a seat on AAB No. 2 after serving for one year on AAB No. 3 (a hearing‑officer panel). She stated that AAB No. 2 hears appeals of hearing‑officer recommendations and that she values the opportunity to balance taxpayer due process with government revenue needs. Key Outcomes - Motion to recommend Steven Wasserman to seat 3 and Richard Lee to seat 7 of Assessment Appeals Board No. 1. Vote: Vice Chair Walton (aye), Chair Dorsey (aye); Supervisor Safai absent. Motion passed on a 2‑0 majority vote. - Motion to recommend Elizabeth Miller to seat 4 of Assessment Appeals Board No. 2. Vote: Vice Chair Walton (aye), Supervisor Safai (aye), Chair Dorsey (aye). Motion passed unanimously. - Both appointments were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for final confirmation.

PROCEDURAL 50% · HUMAN RESOURCES 50%
860
DEC 4, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - December 4, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee, chaired by Supervisor Myrna Melgar with Vice Chair Dean Preston and Member Aaron Peskin, met on December 4, 2023, at 9:45 AM (actual start time in afternoon per transcript). The committee reviewed ten agenda items, including citywide commercial use expansions, neighborhood amenity permits, a landmark designation, housing production legislation, lithium-ion battery fire safety, and a post-storm tree safety hearing. Several items were sent to the full Board of Supervisors as committee reports for consideration on December 5 or 12, 2023. Consent Calendar No separate consent calendar was used; all items received individual consideration. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1&2 (Commercial Uses): No public comment. - Item 3 (Neighborhood Amenities): Two speakers opposed inclusion of private planters in Tier 1 projects, citing concerns about hostile design and enforcement by DPW. The chair noted the legislation is iterative and will address such issues in regulations. - Item 4 (Gregangelo Museum Landmark): Over 20 speakers, including the founder Greg Angelo and numerous artists, expressed strong support for landmarking, describing the museum as a unique incubator, employment source, and cultural treasure. One speaker praised its economic and neighborhood benefits. - Item 5 (HCD Resolution): Five speakers from community organizations (People Power Media, Telegraph Hill Dwellers, MEDA, Soma Filipinas) supported the resolution, urging HCD to extend deadlines and focus on affordable housing and equity. They argued the HCD review threatens local control and contradicts the housing element's equity goals. - Item 6 (12th Street Plaza): No public comment on continuance. - Item 7 (Panos Place): One speaker (acting head of Corbett Heights Neighbors) supported the designation, highlighting Mr. Kotsuyanis’s volunteer beautification of the stairway gardens. - Item 8 (Housing Production): Several speakers from Mission District and REP Coalition opposed the streamlining legislation, arguing it would accelerate displacement, violate fair housing commitments, and benefit luxury developers over affordable housing. One speaker (SPUR) supported advancing the legislation, noting that the monster home amendments may need HCD compliance checks. - Item 9 (Lithium-Ion Batteries): One speaker (condo owner) praised the responsive process and fire department cooperation. - Item 10 (Tree Safety): Two speakers: Denise Louis asked to prioritize wildfire risk reduction and Glen Canyon Park; Andrew Sullivan (Urban Forestry Council) noted that San Francisco’s tree canopy is declining and funding is insufficient to meet the 2040 goal. Discussion Items - Items 1 & 2 – Commercial Use Expansion: Director Katie Tang requested sending Item 1 (230701) to full board as a committee report and continuing Item 2 for later amendments to address operating hours, formula retail, and impact fees. The committee approved both motions (3-0). - Item 3 – Love Our Neighborhoods (Public Works Code): Supervisor Melgar introduced the legislation to streamline permits for community amenities like planters, benches, and little libraries. DPW Deputy Director Beth Rubenstein noted plans for regulations with clear dimensions, ADA compliance, and enhanced inspections funded by the budget. The committee sent it to full board (3-0). - Item 4 – Landmark Initiation for Gregangelo Museum: Supervisor Melgar sponsored the resolution to begin landmarking the property at 225 San Leandro Way, emphasizing its artistic and community value. After public testimony, the resolution was sent to full board (3-0), with Supervisor Preston added as co-sponsor. - Item 5 – HCD Policy and Practice Review Resolution: President Peskin presented a resolution urging HCD to extend deadlines and correct its review to align with San Francisco’s housing element, preserving local control and equitable housing policies. Supervisor Preston added co-sponsor. Sent to full board (3-0). - Item 6 – 12th Street Plaza Encroachment Permit: Continued to December 12, 2023, per Supervisor Dorsey’s request. (3-0) - Item 7 – Panos Place Commemorative Street Name: Supervisor Mandelman presented the resolution honoring Panagiotis Kotsuyanis for volunteer stewardship of the Corbin Place stairway gardens. Sent to full board (3-0). - Item 8 – Housing Production Ordinance (Constraints Reduction): This complex item involved extensive amendments. Supervisor Mandelman proposed changes to address “monster homes” in his district (Corona Heights and Central Neighborhoods SUDs), including a 20% expansion provision. President Peskin offered additional amendments: adding notice requirements, ownership restrictions for rent-controlled units, and buy-out agreement recording. The committee adopted all amendments (3-0). Then they stripped non-amended sections and sent the original to full board without recommendation (3-0). A duplicated file was created to incorporate substantive amendments not yet reviewed by the planning commission (Chinatown SUD notification and objective design standards), and that duplicate was continued to December 12 (3-0). - Item 9 – Fire Code for Lithium-Ion Batteries: President Peskin introduced the ordinance after a 2022 fatal fire in District 5. Fire Marshal Ken Coughlin detailed fire risks: 58 fires in 2022, one death, and 40+ fires in first 11 months of 2023. The ordinance limits devices per unit, prohibits damaged or reconditioned batteries, and requires a public education campaign. Small amendments corrected fire count numbers. The ordinance was amended and sent to full board (3-0). - Item 10 – Tree Safety After 2022-2023 Storms: Chair Melgar convened a hearing to assess storm damage and long-term urban forest plans. DPW Director Carla Short reported more than 900 tree/branch failures and 3,000 service requests, with an eight-year pruning cycle. Rec & Parks reported 650 trees lost in parks, $2.18M in FEMA-eligible costs. SFPUC had 21 failures. Friends of the Urban Forest noted the city’s tree canopy is at 13.7% (half the national average) and lacks sustainable planting funding. UCSF’s Sutro Forest lost 350-400 trees; trails remain closed. Presidio Trust lost 100-200 trees but had a strong reforestation program. The hearing was filed (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (230701): Sent to full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendation as committee report for December 5, 2023. (3-0) - Item 2 (231221): Continued to call of chair for later amendments. (3-0) - Item 3 (230768): Sent to full board as committee report for December 5. (3-0) - Item 4 (231091): Resolution to initiate landmark designation sent to full board for December 5. (3-0) - Item 5 (231175): Resolution sent to full board for December 5. (3-0) - Item 6 (230419): Continued to December 12, 2023. (3-0) - Item 7 (230948): Commemorative street name resolution sent to full board for December 5. (3-0) - Item 8 (231142): Original ordinance amended (monster home and additional amendments) and sent to full board without recommendation for December 5. Duplicated file with further substantive amendments continued to December 12. (All 3-0) - Item 9 (231165): Fire code ordinance amended and sent to full board for December 5. (3-0) - Item 10 (230390): Hearing heard and filed. (3-0)

URBAN FORESTRY 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · PROCEDURAL 10% · ARTS AND CULTURE 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com