Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 871–880 ENTRIES
871
NOV 14, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
Port Commission Meeting – November 14, 2023: APEC, Wharf J9, and Offshore Wind

The Port Commission met on Tuesday, November 14, 2023, from 11:15 AM to 4:23 PM. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of minutes, public comment, the Executive Director’s report, consent calendar items, a presentation on the Wharf J9 replacement project, and an informational update on offshore wind energy. Key decisions included authorizing advertising for bids on the Wharf J9 float and gangway project and amending the commission’s meeting calendar for 2024. Consent Calendar - Item 7A (Amendment to Port Commission Rules of Order) was pulled for separate discussion; the remainder of the consent calendar was approved. - Item 7B: Accepted and expended a $50,000 grant from the California Department of Parks and Recreation Division of Boating and Waterways for removal, storage, and disposal of surrendered/abandoned vessels (Resolution 2349). - Item 7C: Approved updates and clarifications to the Fiscal Year 2023-24 Parameter Rental Rate Schedule (Resolution 2350). Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made on any agenda item during the meeting. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Elaine Forbes): - Highlighted APEC week activities, including the opening of a Ferris wheel at Fisherman’s Wharf and the port’s role in hosting dignitaries. Noted temporary closures of Embarcadero air lanes for security. - Reported that the commercial Dungeness crab season south of the Sonoma-Mendocino line was delayed due to high humpback whale numbers. - Announced the return of the Pier 20½ boat launch to full service after storm damage. - Stated that the city and Army Corps of Engineers agreed to release the draft adaptation plan for sea level rise and earthquake resilience after six years of work. - Provided updates on Mission Rock and Pier 70: Pier 70 infrastructure completion (588 residential units, 100,000+ sq ft of maker/PDR/retail, up to 460 sq ft commercial) and anticipated commission action in December 2023; Mission Rock acceptance expected in 2024. - Noted November as Native American Heritage Month and the port’s commitment to increasing Native American representation in its workforce. - Item 7A (amendment to Rules of Order): - Commissioner Harrington proposed amending the proposed 2024 schedule to move the November 5 (Election Day) meeting to November 19. The commission approved the amendment and the resolution. - Item 8A – Wharf J9 Replacement Project, Phase 1 (Float & Gangway): - Presented by Wendy Proctor (Acting Deputy Director, Engineering). The project will fabricate and install a new float and gangway at Fisherman’s Wharf, aiming to support off-the-boat fish sales by the 2024 crab season. The bid documents include an 8% Local Business Enterprise (LBE) goal, which commissioners Harrington and Adams criticized as too low. Director Forbes noted the goal is set by the city’s Contract Monitoring Division and that the port has achieved much higher LBE participation on other projects. She agreed to explore giving extra bidding points for exceeding the LBE goal. The commission authorized advertising for bids (Resolution 2351). - Item 9A – Offshore Wind Energy Update: - Presented by Andre Coleman (Deputy Director, Maritime) and Simon Betzalil (Capital Projects Manager). The port has identified three potential sites: Pier 70 (operations & maintenance), Pier 80 (component storage/fabrication), and Pier 94/96 (primary staging area). A conceptual study estimated infrastructure costs around $1 billion, with design costs approximately $10 million. The port is pursuing state and federal grants, including AB 209 funding. Commissioners discussed the need for workforce development, local hire, and environmental reviews. The update was informational; no action was taken. Key Outcomes - Approved: Minutes of the October 10, 2023 meeting (unanimous). - Approved: Consent Calendar items 7B and 7C (unanimous). - Approved: Resolution 2348 (amended Rules of Order) with the November 2024 meeting moved to November 19 (unanimous). - Approved: Resolution 2351 (authorizing advertising for bids on Wharf J9 Phase 1 contract) (unanimous). - Directive: Staff to explore adding extra points in bidding for LBE participation above the 8% goal and to report back on ways to increase LBE engagement on long-term projects. - Next steps for offshore wind: Continue stakeholder engagement, pursue grant funding, and prepare an RFP for design, with a focus on Pier 94/96 improvements that could also address seismic resilience.

MARITIME OPERATIONS 27% · OFFSHORE WIND DEVELOPMENT 24% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · PUBLIC WORKS 8%
872
NOV 14, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting – November 14, 2023

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on Tuesday, November 14, 2023, at 9:30 AM. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of prior minutes, reports from the General Manager on policy and government affairs and the 2023 power revenue bond sale, a consent calendar with several items, a discussion and vote on a settlement with PG&E, communications, and commissioner-initiated items. The meeting also included a closed session for legal counsel. Consent Calendar - Item 6a: Award Job Order Contract No. JOC-102R for general engineering construction in Hetch Hetchy counties. - Item 6b: Award Job Order Contract No. JOC-103 for general engineering construction in San Francisco, San Mateo, Santa Clara, and Alameda counties. - Item 6c: Amend Contract No. PRO.0105 with Century Urban LLC to extend the contract duration by three years, seven months, and two weeks. Pulled for discussion; approved after clarification. - Item 6d: Award Contracts Nos. PRO.0281.A-C for as-needed project management support services. Pulled for discussion; approved after discussion on internal capacity. - Item 6e: Approve an increase of $2,000,000 to the contract cost contingency and 956 calendar days to the contract duration. Pulled for discussion; approved after explanation of project completion status. - Item 6f: Approve an increase of $119,000 to the contract cost contingency for Contract No. WD-2851(I) at 525 Golden Gate Avenue. - Item 6g: Award Contract No. WD-2874 for water main replacement on Joost Avenue. - Item 6h: Award Contract No. WD-2902 for San Andreas Reservoir Road Improvements to Anvil Builders Inc. All consent calendar items were approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony No members of the public provided comment during any public comment period. Discussion Items - Annual Policy and Government Affairs Update (Item 5a): Emily Lamb presented the update. The team secured approval for 27 local legislative items, handled over 100 constituent requests, and led a successful statewide coalition for an extension of the state’s arrears payment program, releasing an additional $600 million statewide. SFPUC expects $22 million from this round, plus $16 million previously. At the federal level, the agency opposes proposed cuts to the State Revolving Fund (SRF) from $2.5 billion to under $100 million annually. Commissioner Ajami requested that the commission be informed when SFPUC’s association members take positions that conflict with San Francisco values. - Results of 2023 Power Revenue Bond Sale (Item 5b): Nikolai Sklarov reported that after commission approval on September 20, 2023, the bonds were marketed and priced on September 27, closing on October 12. The bonds had a 3.3 times subscription rate, producing a true interest cost of 4.56%. The issuance of $123.9 million in bonds yielded $131 million in proceeds, used to defease $117.7 million in commercial paper. This was the largest issuance year in SFPUC history. Commissioner Jami questioned why the power bonds were not designated as green bonds; staff explained they are self-certified but moving toward external certification due to SEC concerns. - Settlement with PG&E (Item 7): Barbara Hale presented a settlement to resolve a 2019 FERC complaint regarding PG&E’s refusal to provide secondary voltage service to city customers. The settlement allows SFPUC to connect 30 megawatts of metered customers at secondary voltage for existing Hetch Hetchy customers, city departments, and related public entities. In exchange, the city will dismiss the complaint and waive monetary damages. Commissioners expressed frustration with PG&E’s practices but acknowledged the settlement provides certainty. The settlement was approved unanimously (5-0). Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved all items (6a-6h) with a 5-0 vote, after pulling items 6c, 6d, and 6e for discussion. - Item 7 Settlement: Approved unanimously (5-0) to authorize the settlement with PG&E and take it to the Board of Supervisors for approval. - Closed Session Announcement: After closed session, the commission announced they are not recommending approval of the settlements in items 12 (Walt Sheps claim, $36,837) and 13 (undetermined claimants from September 11, 2023 water main break). Item 14 was pulled from the closed session calendar. - Commissioner Initiatives: Commissioner Maxwell requested an analysis of the correlation between staff vacancies (over 600 positions down) and contracting out. Commissioner Ajami advocated for a comprehensive asset mapping system for the city. No formal action was taken.

PENDING LITIGATION 24% · PROCEDURAL 15% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 13% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 9%
873
NOV 14, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – November 14, 2023

The Board of Supervisors convened on Tuesday, November 14, 2023, at 2:15 p.m. to consider a full agenda. Key actions included final passage of a $300 million affordable housing bond for the March 2024 ballot, a 10–1 vote to place a non-binding policy urging SFUSD to offer eighth-grade algebra on the same ballot, and a contentious debate over a charter amendment giving the mayor veto power over certain SFMTA revenue proposals. The meeting also featured commendations, a committee-of-the-whole hearing, and multiple public comment periods. Consent Calendar - Item 1 – Waived competitive bidding to purchase 14 used compressed natural gas buses from Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport for $350,000. (Passed unanimously) - Item 3 – Increased fees for reproduction and notary services by the Department of Administrative Services. (Passed unanimously) - Item 5 – Amended the Health Code to regulate medical specimen test collection sites. (Passed unanimously) - Items 6–8 – Approved three real estate leases: 716–720 Sacramento Street ($370,000 annual base rent), 2205 Jennings Street ($264,000), and 42 Gough Street ($44,472). (Passed unanimously) - Item 9 – Accepted a retroactive $1,510,695 HUD grant for Housing Opportunities for Persons with AIDS. (Passed unanimously) - Item 10 – Extended a contract with Bar None Auction for auction services, anticipating $2,900,000 in revenue. (Passed unanimously) - Item 11 – Authorized a retroactive participation agreement with the California Department of Health Care Services for Medi-Cal administrative activities (anticipated revenue ≥$1,000,000). (Passed unanimously) - Item 14 – Authorized $99,000 from the SoMa Community Stabilization Fund for a strategic plan. (Passed unanimously) - Item 15 – Approved a 10‑year memorandum of understanding with the Friends and Foundation of the San Francisco Public Library. (Passed unanimously) - Item 16 – Approved airport surveillance technology policies (application-based transport tech, license plate readers, gunshot detection). (Passed unanimously) - Item 17 – Confirmed the mayoral appointment of Kent Lim to the Successor Agency Commission (term ending November 3, 2026). (Passed unanimously) Public Comments & Testimony SFMTA Charter Amendment (Committee of the Whole – 3:00 p.m.): - Audrey Liu (District 1 resident) opposed the amendment, warning it would create a “single point of failure” and threaten SFMTA’s ability to raise revenue amid a projected $200 million deficit. - Cyrus Hall (sustainable transportation advocate) urged a “no” vote, arguing the amendment gives the mayor new power and ignores looming operational deficits ($119 million in 2024, $230 million in 2025). He noted the Board already has the power to send SFMTA’s budget back with a two‑thirds vote. - Dylan Fabris (SF Transit Riders) opposed the amendment, stating it “does not provide the political accountability we need” and opens the budget to political meddling that could lead to service cuts. - Amy Cleary (Golden Gate Restaurant Association) supported the amendment, citing the problematic parking meter extension plan and the need for greater oversight of SFMTA programs. - Christopher Peterson (SF League of Conservation Voters) strongly opposed, calling the amendment contrary to the Transit‑First Policy and the city’s climate action plan. - Abdahadou (SEIU Local 87) supported the amendment, saying extended parking meter hours until 10 p.m. would harm overnight workers (3,000 members) already facing layoffs and vacancies. General Public Comment: - Several street vendors from the Mission District (Rodrigo Lopez, Cesar, and others) asked for clearer communication about the 90‑day ban on Mission Street vending, noting they are legitimate small business owners with permits and taxes. They requested financial assistance during the ban and expressed concern over lost holiday merchandise. - Ron Carter reported that $7,000 of his food stamp benefits were stolen and suspected the stolen goods are sold on Mission Street; he urged enforcement against fraud. - Multiple speakers supported Supervisor Safai’s ordinance to protect the Marina Green waterfront, arguing it must remain open and accessible. - John Trezvenia and Vid Prabakin (SF Bar Association president) spoke on the judiciary resolution: the former opposed the resolution as an attack on voters’ constitutional right to elect judges; the latter urged unanimous support for an independent judiciary. - Salah Hakuya Chandler requested a consulate for the African Hebrew Israelite community at 1536 Buchanan Street. Discussion Items Affordable Housing Bond (Item 2): - President Peskin thanked all supervisors for co‑sponsoring the $300 million general obligation bond for affordable housing, including workforce and senior housing. The bond will appear on the March 5, 2024 ballot and requires a two‑thirds voter approval. The ordinance was passed finally on a unanimous vote. District 7 Vision Zero Projects (Item 4): - Supervisor Melgar explained that $527,000 was reappropriated to 17 community‑selected projects, including a mural on the Clarendon Pedestrian Bridge and a rainy‑day fund for small businesses. The ordinance passed on first reading. E‑Bike Delivery Pilot Grant (Item 12): - Supervisor Preston highlighted a $605,620 U.S. Department of Energy grant to expand the city’s electric bicycle delivery pilot from 30 to 80 participants. He noted that delivery drivers are eager to transition to e‑bikes, reducing emissions and congestion. The resolution was adopted. State Housing Law Compliance (Item 13): - Supervisor Preston moved an amendment to strike the phrase “will likely underproduce low-income units” and replace it with “absent the commitment of additional funding from local, regional, state, and/or federal sources, the Bay Area is at risk of underproducing.” The amendment was adopted, and the resolution passed as amended. Eighth‑Grade Algebra Ballot Measure (Item 23): - A declaration of policy urging SFUSD to offer algebra in eighth grade. Supervisor Walton, a former school board member, argued the measure is unenforceable and that the district is already working on a plan. Supervisors Engardio, Safai, Ronan, and Preston supported the measure as a way for voters to express their voice. Supervisor Ronan noted that the city has a partnership with SFUSD on math interventions (e.g., Japanese “problem‑solving” teaching) and that the real issue is closing the opportunity gap. The measure passed 10–1, with only Supervisor Walton voting no. Police Staffing Charter Amendment (Item 18): - Supervisor Dorsey clarified that the procedural vote to continue the item to November 28 was not an expression of support. The item was continued without objection. SFMTA Charter Amendment (Items 19–21 – Committee of the Whole): - Supervisor Safai introduced the amendment to allow the mayor to disapprove SFMTA proposals on fares, parking meter rates, and hours of operation. He argued it formalizes what already happens in practice. Supervisor Dorsey opposed, calling it a “solution in search of a problem” that repoliticizes the agency and undermines Prop A (2007). After public comment, item 20 (modifying the submission timeline) passed 6–5 (yes: Walton, Chan, Peskin, Preston, Ronan, Safai; no: Dorsey, Engardio, Mandelman, Melgar, Stephanie). Item 21 (the charter amendment itself) was continued to November 20 on a unanimous 11–0 vote. Judiciary Resolution (Item 27): - President Peskin severed the item from the consent calendar and sent it to the Government Audit and Oversight Committee for further discussion. Supervisor Ronan requested removal of his name as a co‑sponsor, stating he supports the general principle but disagrees with parts of the resolution. Supervisor Preston emphasized the need to distinguish between legitimate criticism of judicial decisions and Trumpian intimidation tactics, citing the mayor’s and governor’s recent attacks on Magistrate Judge Donna Ryu. Marina Green Ordinance (Introduced by Supervisor Safai): - Supervisor Safai introduced an ordinance prohibiting the Recreation and Park Department from undertaking environmental review that would extend the West Harbor Marina more than 150 feet beyond its current boundary. He argued that the current design would block public access to the Marina Green, a “priceless San Francisco treasure.” President Peskin co‑sponsored the legislation. Key Outcomes - Affordable housing bond finally passed (unanimous). - Eighth‑grade algebra ballot measure ordered submitted to the March 2024 election (10 ayes, 1 no). - State housing law compliance resolution adopted as amended (unanimous). - SFMTA charter amendment – timeline modification approved (6–5); the amendment itself continued to November 20 (unanimous). - Police staffing charter amendment continued to November 28 (unanimous). - Judiciary resolution sent to committee. - Marina Green ordinance introduced and referred to committee. - Commendations presented to Isaiah Zazi (catalytic converter etching volunteer) and organizers of Castro Halloween 2023. - Adjournment in memory of Brandon McCapes, Felicia Smith, Maria Reyes Garcia, and Fred Chan.

PUBLIC COMMENT 23% · PROCEDURAL 11% · PUBLIC EDUCATION 11% · STREET VENDING REGULATION 9%
874
NOV 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
Rules Committee Meeting - November 13, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on Monday, November 13, 2023, at approximately 10:00 AM. Chair Matt Dorsey presided, joined by Vice Chair Shimon Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai. The committee heard eight agenda items, including appointments, policy declarations, and initiative ordinances for the March 5, 2024 ballot. Key decisions included advancing a non-binding ballot measure urging SFUSD to offer eighth-grade algebra, and hearing and filing several initiative ordinances sponsored by Mayor London Breed. Consent Calendar - No items were placed on the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 2-3 (Eighth Grade Algebra): Numerous parents, students, and community members spoke in support of restoring algebra to the eighth grade. Speakers included Rex Ridgway (grandparent), Jeff Lucas, John Tresvenia (District 11 resident), Ali Partovi and his daughter Lola (age 6), Selena Chu (SFUSD parent), Autumn Loyan (SF Guardians), Lawrence Lee, Chanel Visvalley, and others. Several speakers emphasized equity and the need to challenge all students. One speaker, a mother, spoke in Mandarin and had her comment translated to support the measure. - Item 4 (Transfer Tax Exemption): Lamar Heistec of Asian Inc. urged inclusion of local business enterprises in the conversion incentive program. - Item 5 (Police Policies): Tess Wellbourn, Joel Haile (ACLU NorCal), and Julie Trond (Bar Association of San Francisco) opposed the measure, citing concerns about weakening oversight, vehicle pursuits, and surveillance technology. Matt Susk (District 3 resident) expressed support for efficiency and drone use. - Item 6 (Substance Abuse Screening): Tess Wellbourn opposed the measure, arguing it would increase homelessness and was punitive. No other public speakers. - Item 7 (Foot and Bike Patrols): No public comment. - Item 8 (Emergency Management Charter): No public comment. Discussion Items - Item 1: Appointments to Ballot Simplification Committee – The committee heard from nominees Betty Packard (incumbent, seat 2) and Ruth Grace Wong (new, seat 3). Packard noted the committee's 27-year track record of accurate ballot digests. The committee voted unanimously to recommend all three nominees to the full Board of Supervisors. - Items 2-3: Declaration of Policy – Eighth Grade Algebra – Supervisor Joel Engardio, the lead sponsor, presented the non-binding ballot measure urging SFUSD to offer algebra by eighth grade. He cited a Stanford study showing the current policy (delaying algebra until ninth grade) failed to help struggling students and held back advanced learners. Supervisor Safai shared his experience with the Algebra Project, a civil rights math literacy program. Supervisor Dorsey noted personal and economic competitiveness reasons. The committee voted unanimously to file the hearing (item 2) and send the ballot measure (item 3) to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 4: Initiative Ordinance – Transfer Tax Exemption for Office-to-Residential Conversion – Anne Taupier of OEWD presented the mayor's measure, which would waive transfer taxes on the first conversion of office to residential use, cap the program at 5 million square feet, and allow the Board of Supervisors to amend the transfer tax without voter approval. Supervisor Dean Preston spoke in strong opposition, calling it a "Trojan horse" that would gut Prop I (which raised $300 million). Vice Chair Walton criticized the provision allowing the board to eliminate the tax without voter approval. Supervisor Safai questioned the projected revenue loss (30-150 million over 30 years) and the lack of a replacement plan. The committee voted unanimously to hear and file the item (no position on the measure). - Item 5: Initiative Ordinance – Police Department Policies and Technology – Andres Powers (Mayor's Office) and Police Chief William Scott presented the measure, which would standardize community engagement, limit administrative time to 20% of officers' duty, allow vehicle pursuits for violent misdemeanors and felonies, authorize body-worn camera use in lieu of written reports for certain incidents, and permit a one-year pilot of surveillance technology before board approval. Supervisor Safai questioned the pursuit policy and noted the chief's prior statements favoring policy through the commission. Vice Chair Walton opposed the pursuit expansion and blanket technology approval, calling it a "right-wing attempt." Chair Dorsey noted the need for nimble technology use, citing other Bay Area cities. Public comment was largely opposed. The committee voted unanimously to hear and file. - Item 6: Initiative Ordinance – Substance Abuse Screening for CAAP Recipients – Andres Powers and Trent Rohr (HSA Director) presented the measure requiring single adult CAAP recipients (about 5,200 people) to undergo screening for illegal drug use and, if reasonable suspicion exists, participate in treatment. The measure does not require drug testing or sobriety. Rohr explained implementation would follow models from LA and New York. Supervisor Safai raised concerns about defining "reasonable suspicion" and administrative costs. Vice Chair Walton criticized the punitive approach and urged investment in mental health services. The committee voted unanimously to hear and file. - Item 7: Initiative Ordinance – Foot and Bike Patrol Strategy – Supervisor Safai, the sponsor, requested to continue the item, but after clarification, the committee simply heard and filed it without discussion. - Item 8: Charter Amendment – Department of Emergency Management – Supervisor Safai moved to amend the election date from March 2024 to November 5, 2024, and continue the item to the call of the chair. The committee approved the amendment and continued the item. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unanimous vote to recommend Christine UNRWA, Betty Packard, and Ruth Grace Wong to the full Board for appointment to the Ballot Simplification Committee. - Items 2-3: Unanimous vote to file the hearing (item 2) and send the ballot measure (item 3) to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 4: Unanimous vote to hear and file the initiative ordinance (no position taken). - Item 5: Unanimous vote to hear and file the initiative ordinance. - Item 6: Unanimous vote to hear and file the initiative ordinance. - Item 7: Unanimous vote to hear and file the initiative ordinance. - Item 8: Unanimous vote to amend the election date to November 5, 2024, and continue the item to the call of the chair. All items that were heard and filed are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on November 28, 2023, unless otherwise noted.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 22% · PROCEDURAL 18% · SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER POLICY 16% · PUBLIC EDUCATION 13%
875
NOV 13, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - November 13, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on November 13, 2023, with Vice Chair Dean Preston presiding and Board President Aaron Peskin also present. Supervisor Melgar was excused. The committee considered three items related to arts and culture, all of which were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Agenda Item 1 (Leather & LGBTQ Cultural District street signs): Bob Brown, President of the Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District board, spoke in support, noting that the signage would enhance the district's international reputation. David Hyman, board member and chair of the arts and culture committee, emphasized that wayfinding signage communicates the area's unique queer culture—including leather culture, the bear community, and kink values—to both locals and visitors. Stephen O'Kay, a 28-year San Francisco resident and member of the leather community, expressed support, stating that municipal signage is important because it affirms government backing for the district's identity, not just during Pride events but year-round. - Agenda Item 2 (MTT Way commemorative street name): Multiple speakers voiced strong support. Priscilla Geislin, Chair of the San Francisco Symphony Board of Governors, highlighted Michael Tilson Thomas's (MTT) impact on the city, including spearheading a Pride concert when LGBTQ+ civil liberties were threatened and performing with Metallica at Chase Center. Matthew Spivey, CEO of the San Francisco Symphony, detailed MTT's 25-year tenure, his Grammy-winning Mahler project, and his role in championing American composers. Mark Buell, a neighbor and friend, noted that recent Beethoven Ninth performances were sold out with standing ovations, reflecting public adoration. Kathy Payne, San Francisco Symphony piccolo player, called MTT's arrival a golden age and described his ability to connect audiences to the emotional power of music. One additional speaker offered brief support, urging that arts not be weaponized. - Agenda Item 3 (Non-profit arts education special use district): No public comments were received. Discussion Items - Item 1: Leather & LGBTQ Cultural District Street Signs – Resolution to add placemaking street signs reading "Leather & LGBTQ Cultural District" to 26 existing signs in the South of Market area, bounded by Brannan, 3rd, Mission, 12th, and Division Streets. Brian Dahl, Legislative Aide to Supervisor Dorsey, presented the item, noting the cultural district was established in 2018 to recognize SOMA's history as a leather and LGBTQ hub since the 1950s–1960s. No committee questions. - Item 2: MTT Way Commemorative Street Name – Resolution to add "MTT Way" to the 200 block of Grove Street, adjacent to Davies Symphony Hall, honoring Michael Tilson Thomas's 25 years as San Francisco Symphony Music Director and his broader contributions. Mr. Paulino from the Mayor's Office presented, listing MTT's honors (12 Grammys, National Medal of Arts, Kennedy Center, etc.). Former Senator Mark Leno spoke in support, noting MTT's worldwide renown and the idea came from his husband Joshua Robison. President Peskin praised MTT as a living landmark and teacher of history and culture. Vice Chair Preston added pride that the location is in District 5. - Item 3: Non-Profit Arts Education Special Use District – Ordinance to amend the Planning Code and Zoning Map to create a special use district at 800 Chestnut Street (the former San Francisco Arts Institute) to allow an unaccredited arts institution with residential components. President Peskin explained the Historic Preservation Commission and Planning Commission both unanimously recommended approval, aiming to extend the site's arts use for another 152 years. Veronica Flores confirmed the commissions' recommendations. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to forward to full Board with positive recommendation passed unanimously (2–0, with Melgar excused). - Item 2: Motion to forward to full Board with positive recommendation passed unanimously (2–0). - Item 3: Motion to forward as a committee report to the full Board for consideration on November 14, 2023 (Board of Supervisors meeting the next day) passed unanimously (2–0). - The committee will not meet on November 20, 2023 due to the Thanksgiving holiday; next meeting scheduled for November 27, 2023.

PUBLIC COMMENT 45% · ARTS AND CULTURE 34% · PROCEDURAL 21%
876
NOV 9, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - November 9, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, November 9, 2023, commencing at approximately 2:00 PM and continuing into the evening. The commission considered continuances, a consent calendar item, commission matters, department announcements, general public comment, and a lengthy regular calendar including a new arts education special use district, a comprehensive downtown recovery update, a coastal zone permit for the Great Highway pilot project, and several conditional use authorizations. A discretionary review request for a residential addition on Jackson Street was also heard. Commissioner Moore recused herself from item 15 (Taylor Street) due to proximity. All votes taken during the meeting were unanimous, with several items passing 7-0 or 6-0. Consent Calendar - Item 5 (1600 Mission Street): Request for Conditional Use Authorization approved unanimously (6-0) on consent. Public Comments & Testimony - Non-Profit Arts Education Special Use District (Item 10): Multiple speakers, including representatives from ODC, California College of the Arts, and local galleries, expressed strong support for the legislation to allow a non-accredited arts educational use at the former San Francisco Art Institute site, citing preservation of the historic campus and Diego Rivera mural, and cultural revitalization. - Downtown Update (Item 11): Members of the Equity Council and community organizations raised concerns about equitable investment, transparency in funding allocations (e.g., Tyler Florence contract), safety, and the need to include BIPOC and immigrant communities in planning. Several callers supported car-free concepts like Grand Embarcadero and emphasized parking availability. The Union Square Alliance and Mid-Market stakeholders also commented, urging support for the Market Street Arts Plan and clean/safe initiatives. - Great Highway Pilot Project (Item 12): Public comment was sharply divided. Supporters cited over 2.8 million visits, 65% voter approval, improved coastal access, and community events (e.g., 10,000 at Halloween). Opponents argued the closure diverts traffic to residential streets, increases emissions, delays emergency responders, and damages dunes and snowy plover habitat; they called for a full environmental impact report (EIR) rather than an after-the-fact permit. - 2395 Sacramento Street (Item 16): Supporters (including Housing Action Coalition and Northern Neighbors) praised the adaptive reuse of a historic library, provision of family-sized units (24 units including 3 affordable), and design sensitive to the landmark. Opponents (neighbors, preservationists) raised concerns about inadequate CEQA review, loss of rear yard open space, wind, noise, vibration, privacy, and the undermining of the landmark program for only three affordable units. A petition with over 200 signatures was submitted, though neighbors questioned its authenticity. - 3160 Jackson Street (Item 17 – Discretionary Review): The DR requesters (adjacent property owners at 46 and 50 Presidio Avenue) argued the proposed three-story addition would reduce light, privacy, and views, and alleged the project sponsor submitted misleading geotechnical and arborist reports, including omission of a key paragraph about excavation. The sponsor and staff maintained the project meets code and design guidelines, with significant concessions made to mitigate impacts. Discussion Items - Item 10 – Non-Profit Arts Education Special Use District: Staff presented the proposed SUD at 800 Chestnut Street (former SFAI campus) to allow non-accredited post-secondary arts education. The Historic Preservation Commission had recommended approval. The commission voted unanimously to recommend approval to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 11 – Downtown Update: OEWD, Planning staff, the Equity Council, and ULI Advisory Services Panel provided presentations. Key data: office attendance at 42% of pre-pandemic; vacancy 33%; 5.5 million sq ft of demand; hotel occupancy at 80%; international travel at 97%. Strategies include clean/safe initiatives, business tax relief, office attraction tax credit, adaptive reuse, public realm improvements (e.g., UN Plaza skate park, Winter Walk), and three geographic focus areas (Mid-Market, Union Square, Downtown Gateway). ULI recommended creating a downtown revitalization authority, master leasing, and a comprehensive plan. Commissioners emphasized equity metrics, family-sized housing, and regular updates. - Item 12 – Great Highway Pilot Project (Coastal Zone Permit): Staff and Rec & Park presented the after-the-fact permit for weekend/holiday car-free use of the Upper Great Highway between Lincoln Way and Sloat Boulevard, with traffic calming on adjacent streets. The pilot runs through December 31, 2025. Department found the project consistent with the Local Coastal Program and General Plan. Commission approved the permit unanimously (7-0), with conditions. - Item 13 – 342 Moultrie Street: Request to remove an unauthorized dwelling unit from a garage and revert to parking/storage. Costs to legalize ($379,552) deemed infeasible. No public comment. Commission approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 14 – 170 Sea Cliff Avenue: Demolition and new construction of a single-family dwelling with an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) added per commission request at the prior hearing. The ADU is a 597-sq-ft unit on the ground floor. Design includes a car lift to preserve view corridor. Commission approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 15 – 1152 Taylor Street: Knob Hill Cafe expansion into adjacent vacant retail space. No public comment. Commissioner Moore recused. Approved unanimously (6-0). - Item 16 – 2395 Sacramento Street: Conditional use authorization for a 24-unit residential project (including 3 affordable units at 80% AMI) utilizing the state density bonus, with waivers for height, rear yard, and exposure. Historic landmark building preserved, with new six- and seven-story additions. Commission discussed concerns about rear yard and public outreach but found the project well-designed and consistent with state law. Approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 17 – 3160 Jackson Street (Discretionary Review): Commission considered whether to take discretionary review of a three-story addition to a single-family house. After hearing from DR requesters (neighbors citing loss of light/privacy and misleading documents) and project sponsor (citing compliance with code and design concessions), the commission found no extraordinary circumstances and voted unanimously (7-0) to not take DR and approve the project. Key Outcomes - Item 10 (Arts Education SUD): Approved 6-0. Recommendation to Board of Supervisors. - Item 11 (Downtown Update): Informational; no vote. Commissioners requested regular progress memos and equity metrics. - Item 12 (Great Highway Pilot): Coastal zone permit approved 7-0 with conditions. - Item 13 (342 Moultrie Street): Conditional use authorization approved 7-0. - Item 14 (170 Sea Cliff Avenue): Conditional use authorization approved 7-0. - Item 15 (1152 Taylor Street): Conditional use authorization approved 6-0 (Moore recused). - Item 16 (2395 Sacramento Street): Conditional use authorization approved 7-0. - Item 17 (3160 Jackson Street): Discretionary Review not taken; project approved 7-0.

PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION 13% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 10% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 8%
877
NOV 9, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - November 9, 2023

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on Thursday, November 9, 2023, at San Francisco City Hall. Chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stefani, with Vice Chair Joel Engardio and Supervisor Matt Dorsey, and joined by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman for the latter two items, the committee unanimously approved a liquor license for The Stud, advanced an extension of the cannabis events pilot program, and held a four-hour-plus hearing on treatment on demand. Items acted upon are scheduled to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on November 28, 2023. Public Comments & Testimony Item 1 – The Stud liquor license - Kevin Clark, a 30-year resident and neighbor on Moss Street, said he was "very excited about the stud's return" and welcomed the bar "with open arms." - Katie McKee, a Langton Street neighbor and Soma West CBD board member, said the neighborhood was excited to have The Stud on her block. - Sharon Retton, a Langton Street neighbor and small business owner, called the bar "a piece of San Francisco history" that the community missed dearly. Item 2 – Cannabis events pilot program extension - Ali Jamalian, chair of the city's cannabis oversight committee and president of the state cannabis advisory committee, voiced strong support, citing the need to identify venues satisfying state regulations while working on state-level changes. Item 3 – Treatment on Demand hearing - Tom Wolf, recovery advocate, said the city has been beset by "missed opportunity after missed opportunity," citing the 2020 shelter-in-place hotels and the Tenderloin Linkage Center, and called for funding real recovery solutions. - Eliana Binder, policy manager at Glide and a Treatment on Demand Coalition member, urged full implementation of a fully funded, evidence-based public health approach, saying "coercive and punitive methods are not the way forward." - Sheba Bandiba, Glide policy associate, highlighted DPH's overdose prevention plan focusing on the Black community (which suffers overdose deaths at five times the city rate), expanded access at the Behavioral Health Access Center, at-home buprenorphine distribution, and other steps, while urging more investment in community-based organizations. - Lydia Branston, executive director of the Gubio Project, defended harm reduction tools as engagement devices, pushing back on characterizations that harm reduction work "is killing people." - Laura Thomas, San Francisco AIDS Foundation, praised the DPH report and stressed pay parity, warning that DPH recruitment "pulls from those of us in the nonprofit world" who pay less and lack pensions. - Philip Lasseter, a person in recovery for 21 years, opposed punitive approaches, saying "forced abstinence can be deadly" for those using fentanyl and that criminalization had no impact on his own desire to change. - Marsha Hoffman and Keislin Noson, both from Positive Directions Equals Change, credited abstinence-based programs with saving their lives; Hoffman expressed opposition to distributing drug paraphernalia. - Leah Paradiso, harm reduction coordinator and recovering alcoholic/addict, credited medically assisted treatment and harm reduction for her recovery, and urged against taking cash assistance away from people who use drugs. - Donna Hilliard, Co-Tenderloin executive director, described a community health worker training pipeline that turns lived experience into careers, and called for scaling up peer-to-peer support. - Jennifer Friedenbach, Coalition on Homelessness, called for trauma-informed care, culturally and linguistically specific programs, and reduced regulatory barriers to medically assisted treatment. - Gary McCoy, Health Right 360 vice president, urged building a full continuum of care and collaborative problem-solving. - Several other commenters shared lived experience and emphasized the need for 24/7 drop-off/stabilization centers, better coordination among providers, and treating housing as part of recovery. Discussion Items Item 1 – Liquor License for The Stud (1123 Folsom Street) Supervisor Dorsey, whose district contains the site, introduced the item, calling The Stud one of the nation's most famed drag bars and one of the city's oldest LGBTQ+ establishments. SFPD ABC Liaison Officer Salmussen reported zero letters of protest and zero letters of support. The site is in a high-crime census tract and a high-saturation area, but Southern Station had no opposition. ABC recommended approval with four conditions, including noise limits tied to the entertainment permit, continuous supervision of an outdoor patio when alcohol is served, and active monitoring to prevent loitering on adjacent property. Rachel Ryan, president and general manager of The Stud, recounted the bar's history dating to 1966 and its evolution into a cooperatively owned LGBTQ nightclub, saying the new space would keep "San Francisco's oldest queer bar around for generations to come." The committee voted unanimously to direct staff to prepare a resolution finding public convenience/necessity and to recommend it to the full board. Item 2 – Police Code: Cannabis Events Pilot Program Extension Supervisor Mandelman's ordinance would amend the Police Code to move the sunset of the cannabis event pilot program from December 31, 2023, to January 1, 2027 (i.e., extend it by three years). Sophie Hayward (Office of the City Administrator) said the pilot has shown that existing state rules support only large outdoor events, and the goal is to identify locations for smaller or indoor events and work on location-based permits. Nikesh Patel, director of the Office of Cannabis, detailed state requirements - organizer licenses, fencing, security personnel, separate retail/consumption areas, and obscured public visibility - that make events costly; that seven permits have been issued; and that ending the pilot would likely generate more applications but no more approved events. Ben Van Houten (OEWD) outlined planned research with industry stakeholders on site identification and economic recovery. Public comment was supportive. The committee passed the ordinance unanimously with a positive recommendation. Item 3 – Hearing on the State of Treatment on Demand This was a comprehensive hearing on San Francisco's treatment-on-demand policy, co-sponsored by Chair Stefani and Supervisor Mandelman. It included testimony from city departments, providers, and advocacy groups. - Department of Public Health (DPH): Hillary Cunnins, director of Behavioral Health Services, reported that the specialty substance use services budget is about $91 million (34% general fund, 14% Prop C, 52% state/federal). In FY 2022-23, approximately 4,600 unique individuals were treated in licensed programs; about two-thirds (3,000) were experiencing homelessness, and about 2,100 also had a mental health diagnosis. Opioids, stimulants (mainly methamphetamine), alcohol, cannabis, and cocaine were the top substances. DPH said median wait time for residential treatment rose to five days in the last fiscal year. She acknowledged the city is "falling short" of treatment on demand and is working with providers on data, workforce, and capacity, including adding five dual-diagnosis beds and contracting for out-of-county medically supported withdrawal management beds. Interim Medical Director David Pating cited workforce shortages, state/federal regulations on methadone, and the need for better population-level demand measures. In response to questioning, DPH said demand appears to be rising and that it is working with UCSF on prevalence estimates. Regarding HR360, Cunnins said the widely reported claim that half of those seeking detox were not served was based on data depicting "half got in that same day," with reasons ranging from higher levels of care to voluntary departure; she said that data is being refined. - Fire Department: Assistant Deputy Chief Simon Pang presented first-responder data. In six months, 53% of street crisis engagements chose to remain in the community (an improvement from 70% in 2020). In a seven-day straw poll, only six out of about 210 engagements (2%) "said I want treatment now." He said 90% of overdose victims are transported to emergency rooms, but hospital follow-through is weak; 6% of Narcan-reversed patients are seen again within 72 hours. 25% of all ambulance patients are homeless, and 58% of re-engagements within 72 hours are homeless. He recommended more stabilization capacity, minimized transfer points, and better consumer knowledge of services. - District Attorney's Office: Assistant DA Susan Christian said the office needs a full-time behavioral health clinician due to a 600% increase in mental health diversion petitions since 2022. She cited gaps in jail discharge planning, a need for more licensed clinicians, a shortage of psychiatric and residential beds (especially for sex-offender registrants and arsonists), and a lack of state funding for diversion programs. She also noted that 17% of jail residents are from out of county, 41% are unsheltered/transient, and 41% identify as San Francisco residents. - Public Defender's Office: Licensed clinical social worker Fatima Aveyan reported improvements in wait times for some English-speaking residential programs (e.g., HealthRight 360, Salvation Army's Harbor Lights), and noted St. Anthony's now has a Spanish-speaking counselor. But many clients still wait weeks or months in jail, influencing their decisions to accept pleas, and there are insufficient services for Spanish speakers, transitional-age youth, and people with sex- or arson-related charges. She urged funding for community-based case management and peer workforce development. - Pretrial Diversion Project: Directors Tiara Sims and Key Bernard said the in-custody referral (ICR) program had 104 referrals in September, and 64% still needed additional services or faced barriers. They described a new Pretrial Treatment Project, funded for only one fiscal year through June 2024, that pays directly for residential treatment, overcoming insurance and out-of-county issues, but noted persistent barriers including language, MAT acceptance, dual diagnosis, and lack of aftercare. They also highlighted cases where clients rejected treatment because they feared losing a shelter bed. - Treatment on Demand Coalition: Vitka, a former drug user and HealthRight360 leader, emphasized staffing as the central crisis, with 75 vacancies at HealthRight360 alone. She said HealthRight360 served 14,000 people in residential treatment over the last decade, with a national average of 50% leaving prematurely. She called for wage parity for nonprofit staff, direct contracting that reflects true costs, and a redefinition of "treatment" to include a continuum of services that keeps people connected. - Recovery Coalition: Steve Adami, executive director of The Way Out and former adult probation re-entry director, presented data: 19,000 people cycle through homelessness annually; 8,000 are homeless on any given night; 4,000 are on the streets; 70% are addicted to drugs; and there is one detox bed per 100 homeless people struggling with addiction. Craig Johnson and Tom Wolf described the "revolving door" and urged a stabilization center, direct access to providers (bypassing bureaucratic assessments), wage parity, and funding for faith-based and abstinence-based programs. They also criticized the current system for enabling open-air drug scenes. - Human Services Agency (HSA): Director Trent Rohr outlined the proposed March 2024 ballot initiative (Substance Use Screening, Evaluation, and Treatment Initiative) for County Adult Assistance Program (CAP) recipients. He said CAP has about 5,300 single adults without children; 20% are homeless, 30% formerly homeless; 13% of CAP clients died of overdose in a 12-month period; and over 20% of DMAC arrests were people on public assistance. The initiative would require screening and, if needed, treatment for those reasonably believed to use illegal drugs, with cash assistance discontinued only after willful failure. HSA would directly pay landlords to avoid homelessness, and savings would go into a treatment fund. Rohr said the city would contract for treatment slots and provide same-day transportation. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (The Stud): The committee unanimously moved to prepare a resolution finding that issuance of the type 48 license serves public convenience/necessity, and referred it to the full board with a positive recommendation. Vote: 3-0 (Engardio, Dorsey, Stefani). - Item 2 (Cannabis events): The committee unanimously passed the ordinance to extend the pilot program through December 31, 2026, and sent it to the Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Vote: 3-0. - Item 3 (Treatment on Demand): The committee heard and filed the hearing by unanimous consent. DPH's next treatment on demand report is expected in February 2024, and Supervisor Mandelman indicated the committee would hold another hearing to review progress. Note: The meeting agenda and transcript indicate all item actions are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of November 28, 2023.

SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER POLICY 50% · PUBLIC HEALTH 16% · HOMELESSNESS 7% · PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES 6%
878
NOV 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Meeting, November 8, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman, convened on November 8, 2023, to consider nine agenda items including grant acceptances, contract amendments, compliance resolutions, and real property leases. All items were approved unanimously (2-0, with Supervisor Safai excused). The meeting featured presentations from city departments and reports from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA). Consent Calendar No items were placed on consent; each item received individual discussion and a roll-call vote. Public Comments & Testimony No members of the public offered testimony on any agenda item. Discussion Items Item 1: Decarbonizing Deliveries Grant (Resolution 231084) The Department of the Environment presented a resolution to retroactively accept a $605,620 grant from the U.S. Department of Energy for an electric bicycle pilot for delivery workers, building on an existing state-funded program. The grant will support up to 50 additional participants, aiming for a total of 80 delivery workers. The BLA reported that the city must provide a one-to-one match, which will be satisfied by a previously awarded California Energy Commission grant, requiring no general fund money. Supervisor Chan expressed support, noting the program's origins with former Supervisor Gordon Mar and connections to LAFCO. The committee forwarded the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Medi-Cal Administrative Activities Participation Agreement (Resolution 231062) The Department of Public Health presented a retroactive participation agreement with the California Department of Health Care Services for County-Based Medi-Cal Administrative Activities (CMA). The program currently generates over $13 million annually in federal reimbursement for the city. The new agreement eliminates the previous three-year renewal requirement and removes the cap on claiming, allowing for potentially increased revenue. Supervisor Chan asked about the CalAIM program but was informed it is not directly relevant. The item was approved. Item 3: Auction Services Contract Amendment (Resolution 231059) The Office of Contract Administration requested approval of a third amendment to the contract with Bar None Auction for surplus asset auction services, extending the term by one year and increasing anticipated revenue by $800,000 for a total of $2.9 million over five years. The city pays no fees; the auction company is compensated through buyer premiums. The committee approved the amendment. Item 4: State Housing Law Compliance for OBAG 3 Funding (Resolution 231085) SFMTA presented a resolution affirming the city's compliance with certain state housing laws to access approximately $22 million in OBAG 3 grant funds from the Metropolitan Transportation Commission. The funds support transit optimization and pedestrian safety projects, including improvements on the Embarcadero and the 29 Sunset corridor. The resolution is required by MTC Resolution 4505 and must be completed by December 31, 2023. The committee approved. Items 5 & 6: SoMa Community Stabilization Fund and HOPWA Grant (Resolutions 231117 and 231012) The Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development presented items 5 and 6 together. Item 5 authorized spending $99,000 from the SoMa Community Stabilization Fund to develop a new five-year strategic plan, following an RFQ process and unanimous recommendation from the community advisory committee. Item 6 retroactively approved a $1,510,695 HOPWA grant from HUD for permanent supportive housing for people with AIDS, providing rental subsidies and case management for 80 individuals through Catholic Charities. Both items were approved. Items 7, 8, & 9: Real Property Leases (Resolutions 230999, 231000, 231035) The Director of Real Estate presented three lease actions. - Item 7: 716-720 Sacramento Street – A fourth amendment to the lease for the Chinatown Child Development Center (CCDC) operated by DPH. The term runs from July 1, 2023 (retroactive) to June 2026, with two one-year extension options. Annual base rent is $370,000 ($40/sq ft), a decrease from the previous rate. The BLA noted a typographical error in the lease document and recommended an amendment to explicitly make the resolution retroactive. After discussion, the committee agreed to amend the resolution to include retroactive language. The CCDC provides comprehensive mental health services to children and families. Future plans depend on a proposed public health and safety bond in November 2024 to co-locate with Chinatown Public Health Center. - Item 8: 2205 Jennings Street – A new three-year lease for approximately 10,000 sq ft of warehouse and 5,000 sq ft of parking for the Department of Technology's Public Safety Division, at an annual base rent of $264,000. This replaces a prior site at 1755 Eggbert that was sold, requiring a 60-day vacate notice. - Item 9: 42 Gough Street – A new three-year lease for 1,744 sq ft of space for a parent resource hub managed by the Human Services Agency, at an initial base rent of $44,472 per year. The space supports foster parents and youth with resources and activities. All three items were approved, with item 7 as amended. Key Outcomes - All nine resolutions were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations by votes of 2-0 (Supervisor Safai excused). - Resolution 230999 (Item 7) was amended to include retroactive language to July 1, 2023, as recommended by the BLA. - No public testimony was received on any item. - The committee's actions are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda of November 14, 2023.

REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 34% · PROCEDURAL 23% · PUBLIC HEALTH 15% · HOUSING 11%
879
NOV 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
Police Commission Meeting: APEC Briefing and Consent Calendar - November 8, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on November 8, 2023, at 1:45 PM, with Vice President Carter Overstone presiding. The meeting included a Chief's report on crime trends and APEC preparations, a DPA Director's report on caseload, public comment on various issues, and a consent calendar approval. Item 6 (presentation on pursuit policy) was pulled from the agenda. The commission also entered closed session on an undisclosed matter. Consent Calendar - The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to receive and file: SFPD's third quarter 2023 Audit of Electronic Communication Devices for Bias, SFPD's firearm discharge review board and in-custody death review board quarter three 2023, 2023 Department Award Certification, and SB 1421 and SB16 monthly reports. Public Comments & Testimony - Speaker 1: Criticized the commission's interpretation of studies linking arrests to drug overdoses, stating the studies caution against confusing causation and correlation. Urged the commission to understand the First Amendment and public meeting laws. - Naj Daniels (SEIU 1021): Representing 911 dispatchers, expressed concern that the Department of Police Accountability is sending complaints to the Department of Emergency Management for possible discipline of dispatchers without affording due process, as civilians are not entitled to a 3303 hearing. - San Francisco resident (born and raised): Praised the SFPD as well-trained and conscientious but asserted that there is anti-police bias on the commission, referencing the summer 2020 defunding of $120 million and suggesting disparities in use of force may have causes outside the department. - Mother of homicide victim Aubrey Abracasa (murdered 2006): Pleaded for justice and closure for unsolved homicides, asking for consistent use of digital posters at district stations to help solve cases. She later reiterated this during public comment on the DPA report. - Alan Buradell: Expressed support for the first speaker and later during Chief's report public comment read from a DSA newsletter detailing planned protests during APEC, noting participation by sitting commissioners and supervisors. - Speaker during DPA report public comment: Asked how the public can determine how many DPA cases are initiated internally versus by the public. Directed to annual reports and offered to speak with an investigator. - No public comment on commission reports or closed session items. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report (Chief Bill Scott): - Crime Statistics: Total part 1 crime down 7% (about 3,200 fewer crimes year-to-date). Violent crime up 3% (128 more incidents). Property crime down 8%. Homicides: 49 year-to-date (9% increase from 45), clearance rate 72% (expected to rise to 76% after recent arrests). Shootings down 6% (175 victims, 148 incidents). - Notable Incidents: Homicide on October 30 in Tenderloin (no arrest); road rage shooting on Halloween; home invasion on November 2 where suspects impersonated police, resulting in a traumatic brain injury; stunt driving event with 50 vehicles. - APEC Preparation: Approximately 600 SFPD officers assigned to APEC events; additional 50+ officers from 10 outside agencies (CHP, San Mateo County Sheriff, Brisbane PD, etc.) assisting with dignitary escorts and venue security. MOUs with outside agencies focus on reimbursement and operational roles; outside agencies follow their own policies and tactics. Mutual aid contingency plans with Alameda County Sheriff’s Office if needed. Security zones around Moscone Center and other venues, with local traffic allowed but checkpoints. Public can find updates at sf.gov/APEC-2023. - Commissioner Questions: Commissioner Carter Overstone asked about MOUs and whether they affect DGO 3.01 – Chief responded they are operational and do not rise to that level. Commissioner Byrne asked about coordination – Chief explained Secret Service is lead, SFPD coordinates local protests and First Amendment activity. Outside officers only work venues, not patrol. - DPA Director’s Report (Acting Executive Director Sarah Hawkins): - Caseload: 689 cases opened this year compared to 201 last year, representing an increase requiring at least two full-time investigators. 22 cases past 270-day mark (down from 23 last year), 317 pending (vs 245). 8 cases pending with commission, 88 with chief. 19 new cases in the past week. - Allegation Breakdown: 17% conduct unbecoming, 12% neglect of duty, 12% use of force. - No audit report this week; full misconduct audit expected in January. YouTube channel relaunched. - Commissioners noted the caseload increase and resource challenges. - Commission Reports: - Commissioner Yanyez: Attended juvenile probation commission hearing; reported anticipated passage of a resolution supporting a pre-booking diversion program with SFPD. DGO 7.01 (juvenile policy) open for public comment until December 13. Community policing plan updates posted on district websites. - Commissioner Benedicto: Also highlighted DGO 7.01, thanking community stakeholders. Attended Solutions Conference hosted by San Francisco Chronicle; 10 pilot programs presented, including a public safety proposal. Plans to have authors present to commission early next year. - Commissioner Byrne: Announced December 6 award ceremony (public should note no regular meeting that day). - Commissioner Walker: Thanked officers for response to neighborhood incidents; noted conference aligned with commission discussions on alternatives. - Item 6 (Presentation on Pursuit Policy) was pulled from the agenda. - Closed Session: - Public comment on closed session: none. - Motion to proceed to closed session (Item 9) passed unanimously (6-0). - After closed session, motion not to disclose any discussion passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar approved unanimously. - Item 6 (Pursuit Policy presentation) removed from agenda. - Commission voted 6-0 to enter closed session and later voted unanimously not to disclose the closed session discussion. - No regular meeting on November 15, 2023. - Next regular meeting (December 6) replaced by award ceremony.

PUBLIC SAFETY 31% · PROCEDURAL 27% · PUBLIC COMMENT 25% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 14%
880
NOV 7, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - November 7, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on November 7, 2023, with nine members present (Supervisors Melgar and Ronen excused). The meeting covered a wide range of items including settlements, a $300 million affordable housing bond, charter amendments, emergency declarations, and extensive public comment from city workers. Key votes and decisions are detailed below. Consent Calendar - Settlements (Items 1-3): Approved three lawsuit settlements: Katy Sullivan ($207,500, employment dispute), Twilio Inc. ($18,000,000, telephone user tax refund), and Adam Smith et al. ($130,401.66, expedited conversion program fee). Passed unanimously. - Community Policing Strategy (Item 4): Ordinance requiring the Chief of Police to adopt a foot and bike patrol strategy passed unanimously. - Airport Bus Purchase (Item 7): Authorized purchase of up to 14 used compressed natural gas transit buses from Phoenix for not to exceed $350,000. Passed. - Administrative Fees (Item 10): Increased fees for reproduction and notary services by Department of Administrative Services. Passed. - Lease, Grants, Contracts (Items 12-15): Approved lease at 2789-25th Street ($0 base rent, 27 years), grant from Friends of Jackson Park ($12,440,735 for playground renovation), contract for radiation detection badges ($420,000), and retroactive contract amendment with Western States Oil ($35,450,000). All passed. - Emergency Declarations (Items 16-17): Adopted two emergency declarations for Trocadero Clubhouse repairs ($1,850,000) and winter storm debris removal ($2,100,000). Supervisor Chan noted the department failed to submit resolutions within 60 days but committed to correcting the protocol. Adopted despite being referred without recommendation. - Shelter Contract (Item 18): Approved amendment with Five Keys Schools and Programs for 685 Ellis Shelter, not to exceed $27,296,994, extending term to June 30, 2026. Passed. - Safe Swab Ordinance (Item 19 original): Passed on first reading. Ordinance regulating medical specimen collection sites, establishing hygiene, privacy, and penalty standards. Supervisor Preston noted the ordinance was needed after questionable COVID-19 testing tents appeared. He duplicated the file to add amendments (outlawing payment for tests) and sent the duplicate to committee. Original passed unanimously. - Liquor License Transfer (Item 20): Approved transfer for Fig & Thistle at 313 Ivy Street. Passed. - Grand Jury Report (Item 21): Adopted resolution responding to civil grand jury report on small business support. Passed. Public Comments & Testimony - DPW Street Inspectors (multiple speakers): A group of inspectors from the Bureau of Street Use and Mapping testified against the street vendor enforcement program. They reported being assigned to impound stolen goods from unpermitted vendors, facing verbal abuse, threats of violence (including weapons brandished, racial slurs, and death threats), and psychological trauma. Several speakers described being punched, threatened with gang members, and having to wear stab-proof vests. They argued the task is law enforcement, not their job, and called for the board to reassign this duty to police or create a specialized unit. Speakers included Teresa McNamara, Alistair Jones, Ferdi Huri, and others. They also expressed lack of support from management. President Peskin responded that state law (SB 946) removed criminal enforcement options, tying the city's hands. - Veterans Alley Supporters: Amos Gregory, co-founder of the Veterans Alley Mural Project, spoke in support of Supervisor Preston's resolution to rename Shannon Alley to Veterans Alley. He described the project as a safe space for veterans to express themselves through art, and noted a sister project in Tijuana. - Ady Barkan Tribute: A former supervisor (unidentified by name) spoke in memory of Ady Barkan, a health care activist who died at age 39 from ALS. Barkan co-founded the nonprofit Be a Hero and advocated for Medicare for All. The speaker noted his influence on local progressives and his work for universal health care. - Other Speakers: Comments also addressed surveillance at SFO, remote public comment (request to restore), and a commenter supporting the Veterans Alley name change. Discussion Items - Item 5: Charter Amendment on SFMTA Budget Approval (Mayoral Authority): Supervisor Safai introduced a charter amendment to require the mayor to affirmatively approve (or disapprove) certain SFMTA proposals (fare increases, parking meter rates, hours/days) as part of the budget. He noted the mayor appoints all five SFMTA commissioners. After discussion, the board adopted amendments: changing

PUBLIC COMMENT 33% · PUBLIC SAFETY 18% · PROCEDURAL 12% · PUBLIC HEALTH 11%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com