The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on October 26, 2023, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stephanie, with Vice Chair Joel Ingario and Supervisor Dorsey. The clerk was John Carroll. The committee considered two agenda items: a liquor license transfer for Fig & Thistle and an ordinance regulating medical specimen test collection sites. No public comments were offered for either item. Both items were approved and recommended to the full Board of Supervisors. Liquor License Transfer - Fig & Thistle - The committee considered a hearing to determine whether the person-to-person premise-to-premise transfer of a Type 48 on-sale general public premises liquor license to 7682 LLC doing business as Fig & Thistle at 313 Ivy Street would serve public convenience or necessity. - Lieutenant Steve Jonas from the SFPD ABC liaison unit presented: zero letters of protest or support; the site is in a high crime area (Plot 558) and high saturation census tract (162.00); Northern Station has no opposition. SFPD recommended approval with conditions requiring active monitoring of adjacent property to prevent loitering and ensuring entertainment is not audible at nearby residences. - The applicant representative stated the business is approximately 500 square feet, has operated for 10 years, is active in the community, and plans to remain low-key. - No public comment. - Motion by the chair to prepare a resolution finding the transfer serves public convenience or necessity and recommend approval to the full board; passed unanimously (Vice Chair Ingario aye, Supervisor Dorsey aye, Chair Stephanie aye). Ordinance on Medical Specimen Test Collection Sites - Supervisor Preston’s legislative aide, Melissa Hernandez, introduced an ordinance amending the Health Code to regulate sites that collect medical specimens on behalf of clinical laboratories for COVID-19, flu, RSV, or other viruses. - Background: Questionable COVID testing tents appeared in the Tenderloin, paying constituents for tests, copying personal ID documents, using no PPE, and failing to return results. After the health officer’s emergency order ended in February 2023, no regulations existed for such sites. - The ordinance requires sites to partner with a governmental entity, licensed health care provider in the city, or an educational/academic institution; establish hygiene, sanitation, and privacy standards; adhere to HIPAA; and makes violations a public health nuisance subject to administrative penalties by the Department of Public Health. - Dr. Susan Phillip, Health Officer for San Francisco, expressed SFDPH support, noting unregulated sites undermine trust in testing as winter virus season approaches. She issued a temporary health order on October 11, 2023, but the ordinance provides permanent regulations. - Supervisor Dorsey asked about the business model and misrepresentation of test results. Hernandez confirmed that operators appear to mislead constituents and that the city attorney’s office has investigated. Dorsey noted potential criminal conduct and asked about coordination with the DA; Hernandez said they had not yet but could follow up. - No public comment. - Motion by Supervisor Dorsey to recommend the ordinance to the full board with positive recommendation; passed unanimously (Vice Chair Ingario aye, Supervisor Dorsey aye, Chair Stephanie aye). Key Outcomes - The committee unanimously approved and recommended to the full Board of Supervisors the resolution finding the liquor license transfer for Fig & Thistle serves public convenience or necessity, with conditions. - The committee unanimously approved and recommended to the full Board of Supervisors the ordinance regulating medical specimen test collection sites. - No further business; meeting adjourned.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Board President Aaron Peskin (substituting for excused Vice Chair Mandelman), met on October 25, 2023, to consider nine agenda items. The meeting included presentations, budget and legislative analyst reports, public testimony, and votes on contract amendments, a gift acceptance, an emergency declaration, special tax bonds, and a proposed $300 million affordable housing general obligation bond for the March 5, 2024 ballot. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1-2 (JCYC Opportunities for All & YMCA TARC grants): Tracy Gallardo (District 10 office) supported the OFA program, emphasizing its success in reaching disconnected youth and the need to reimburse JCYC. One speaker expressed distrust, alleging corruption. No other public comment. - Item 3 (Harvey Milk Plaza gift): Brian Springfield (Executive Director, Friends of Harvey Milk Plaza) endorsed the gift, noting endorsements from multiple community groups. Amy Callender (SF Parks Alliance) supported the redesign's accessibility and community focus. One speaker urged transparency and conflict-of-interest declarations. - Item 4 (Fillmore water main break emergency): One speaker noted the importance of pipe replacement with plastic materials. - Items 6-7 (Mission Rock special tax bonds): One speaker criticized the rush, urging focus on homelessness first. - Items 8-11 (Affordable housing bond): Numerous speakers supported the bond, including John Avalos (CCHO), Rebecca Jackson (Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice), Erica Drate (Community Forward), and others from the Women's Housing Coalition, who highlighted the need for housing for women survivors of violence. Julian Ball (Bishop Housing) and Manson Leong (Self-Help for the Elderly) emphasized senior and family needs. Mitchell Omerberg (Affordable Housing Alliance) noted the no-property-tax-increase structure. One speaker questioned the definition of "affordable" and criticized numerical flinging. Discussion Items - Items 1-2: Grant Amendments - JCYC ($13.7M) and YMCA TARC ($5.4M) – DCYF and Human Rights Commission presented. The BLA noted discrepancies in participant data (800 vs. 2,200 for JCYC) and recommended a Controller's audit. The committee amended item 1 to reduce the not-to-exceed amount by $400,000 (to $13.3M) per BLA recommendation. Item 2 was also amended retroactively per BLA recommendation. - Item 3: Gift Acceptance - Harvey Milk Plaza Redesign – Public Works presented the $1.275M gift of design documents. The committee expressed gratitude and added Supervisor Chan as co-sponsor. - Item 4: Emergency Declaration - Fillmore Water Main Break – SFPUC reported a 16-inch water main break (Sept 10-11, 2023) causing major disruption; estimated repair cost $3.5M (within $5M not-to-exceed). Work nearly complete. Committee flagged the need to revisit PUC pipe maintenance prioritization in the May budget. - Item 5: Citywide Project Labor Agreement Hearing – Continued to November 15, 2023, at Supervisor Safai's request. - Items 6-7: Mission Rock Special Tax Bonds – Port presented a $58.335M bond issuance (fourth series) to reimburse developer horizontal infrastructure costs. $48M in remaining developer equity awaits phase two. Interest rates estimated at 5.86% but may be higher. Bonds are not general fund obligations. - Items 8-11: $300M Affordable Housing Bond – Two competing proposals: Mayor's (items 8-9) and President Peskin's (items 10-11). Peskin's amendments added $30M for housing for survivors of domestic violence, labor and climate findings, and language clarifying no property tax increase. The committee tabled items 8-9 and continued items 10-11 as amended to the Nov 1, 2024 meeting. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (JCYC grant): Amended to reduce amount by $400,000; forwarded to full board without recommendation; Controller's office to perform a financial audit. - Item 2 (YMCA TARC): Amended to include retroactive language; forwarded to full board with recommendation. (Vote taken after initial adjournment via resumption.) - Item 3 (Harvey Milk gift): Forwarded to full board with recommendation (unanimous). - Item 4 (Fillmore emergency): Forwarded to full board with recommendation (unanimous). - Item 5 (PLA hearing): Continued to November 15, 2023 (unanimous). - Items 6-7 (Mission Rock bonds): Forwarded to full board with recommendation (unanimous). - Items 8-9 (Mayor's bond proposal): Tabled (unanimous). - Items 10-11 (Peskin's bond proposal): Amended (five categories: labor, climate, women/survivors housing, senior findings, tenant pass-through clarification); continued to November 1, 2024 meeting (unanimous). Supervisors Chan and Safai added as co-sponsors.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on October 24, 2023, at 9:30 AM. The meeting included approval of minutes, general public comment, a report on the passing of two former staff members, an update from the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) on the Water System Improvement Program (WISIP), a revised water supply assessment for the Stonestown project, and a discussion on changes to remote public comment procedures. The commission also held a closed session on labor negotiations, with no action taken. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes of October 10, 2023: The minutes were approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Two callers spoke. Mary Butterwick urged the commission to revisit the 8.5-year design drought used for Tuolumne River flow releases, calling it "extremely conservative" with a return period of 1 in 25,000 years. She requested analysis of flows using a 7.5-year design drought and reasonable demand projections, and urged the commission to drop its lawsuit against the State Water Board Bay Delta plan. Peter Dreckmeyer, Policy Director for the Tuolumne River Trust, noted that reservoir storage is at 93.4% and Don Pedro is nearly full, yet fall attraction flows were low. He requested an update on the river environment and salmon, and referenced the Multi-Enterprise Climate Program update, questioning whether staff had looked at drought occurrence intervals. - Item 5A (General Manager Report): No public comment. - Item 6 (BAWSCA Update): No public comment. - Item 7 (Stonestown Water Supply Assessment): No public comment. - Item 9 (Commissioner Initiated Items): Peter Dreckmeyer commented that the proposed change to remote public comment is "a huge disappointment and another blow to the public." - Item 10 (Closed Session Public Comment): No public comment. Discussion Items - General Manager Report (Item 5A): General Manager Dennis reported on the passing of two notable former SFPUC staff: Don Furman, a longtime deputy city attorney and water law expert, and Tony Irons, former city architect and deputy general manager. Commissioners honored their contributions. - BAWSCA Update (Item 6): Nicole Stanko, BAWSCA CEO, presented findings from the commission's review of the WISIP annual report. She noted that the $4.8 billion program is 99% complete, but two projects—Alameda Creek Recapture and Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery—have experienced delays and budget concerns. BAWSCA recommended the commission: 1) direct staff to plan a Notice of Change for the WISIP completion schedule; 2) provide updated budgets for the two projects and secure funding; and 3) assess the impact of project changes on water supply reliability goals. The commission took no immediate action. - Revised Water Supply Assessment for Stonestown (Item 7): Steve Ritchie, Assistant General Manager, presented a revised water supply assessment for the 27-acre Stonestown project at 3251 20th Avenue. The revision was needed due to a change in project variant and updates to retail water demand based on the city's 2022 Housing Element (adding 100,000 units over 20 years). Staff concluded there is sufficient water supply for the project. The commission approved the assessment (5-0). - Commissioner Initiated Items (Item 9): President Paulson introduced a discussion on limiting remote public comment, following a Board of Supervisors decision and a mayoral directive. Commissioner Maxwell and Stacy raised concerns about the process for disabled individuals and the honor system for verifying disabilities. The city attorney clarified that requests would be made through the commission secretary on an honor basis with advance notice. Commissioner Jamy expressed concern about the speed of the change and its potential to discourage engagement. The commission directed the secretary to incorporate the new remote participation instructions into future meeting notices. - Closed Session (Items 10-14): The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to assert attorney-client privilege and entered closed session for a conference with the labor negotiator (unrepresented employee). After returning, the commission announced no action was taken and voted unanimously (5-0) not to disclose the discussions. Key Outcomes - Approved the minutes of October 10, 2023 (5-0). - Approved the revised water supply assessment for the Stonestown project (Item 7) (5-0). - Directed the secretary to update public participation instructions to limit remote public comment, with accommodations for individuals with disabilities, effective at the next meeting. - No action was taken on the BAWSCA recommendations or on the closed session matter. - Commissioner Jamy requested a future presentation on the Multi-Enterprise Climate Program update, specifically on capital-aligned climate planning and the Clean Climate Bond Initiative.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Tuesday, October 24, 2023, at 2:15 PM. The meeting included a special appearance by Mayor London Breed for a formal policy discussion, approval of routine consent items, public comment on a range of issues, and votes on several ordinances and resolutions. Key topics included preparations for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, affordable housing development at Parcel K in Hayes Valley, behavioral health and homeless services, implementation of Senate Bill 43 on conservatorship, and community concerns about a proposed tiny cabin village. Consent Calendar - Items 2–11 (Consent Agenda): Approved unanimously (11 ayes). Included: amendments to the Administrative Code for city budget preparation and multi-year grants; salary ordinance changes for the Police Department; administration of the Empty Homes Tax; delegation of authority to amend leases for 100% affordable housing; road closure at John F. Shelley Drive; Police Code changes on drawing firearms by armed guards; Health Code requiring pharmacies to stock opioid antagonists; suspension/debarment of contractors for labor law violations; surveillance technology policy for the Department of Elections; and establishing the Labor and Employment Code. Public Comments & Testimony - APEC Summit: Numerous speakers expressed concerns about the impact of the APEC summit (November 2023) on vulnerable communities. Speakers included seniors, immigrant workers, small business owners, labor union members, and activists. They requested transparent information about security zones and checkpoints, protection of the right to protest, and that $10 million in reserve funds be redirected to community services instead of policing. Some supported Supervisor Chan’s resolution to mitigate impacts. - Affordable Housing at Parcel K: Residents of Hayes Valley (including Robin Levitt, Andrew Signer, and Natalie Burdick) urged the city to issue a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) for 100% affordable housing on Parcel K, a city-owned site that has been stalled for nearly 20 years. Over 450 signatures were collected in support. - Tiny Cabin Village (1979 Mission): Several District 9 residents opposed the proposed 60–70 tiny cabin village near Marshall Elementary School, citing lack of community input, potential for increased blight and crime, and a cost of $100,000 per unit. They demanded more transparent due diligence. - General: Speakers also addressed the need for a family support hub for homicide victims, opposition to APEC trade policies, and concerns about the displacement of homeless individuals. Discussion Items - Mayor Breed’s Appearance (Special Order 2:00 PM): The mayor discussed APEC preparations, stating it will generate nearly $53 million for the local economy and that over 1,200 volunteers signed up. She committed to working with supervisors on community outreach. - Topic 1 – Parcel K (Supervisor Preston): Supervisor Preston asked Mayor Breed to commit to issuing an RFQ for affordable housing on Parcel K by end of 2023. Mayor Breed said she needed to verify facts with her office and noted that broader housing policy changes are also needed to meet the city’s housing element goal of 46,000 affordable units in eight years. No commitment was made. - Topic 2 – Behavioral Health and Homeless Services on West Side (Supervisor Melgar): Supervisor Melgar reported a significant increase in homeless individuals and drug addiction on West Portal Avenue, from 2–3 before the pandemic to 15–20 now. She requested dedicated staff for outreach. Mayor Breed acknowledged the challenge, cited new conservatorship tools (SB 43) effective January 1, 2024, and pledged to work together. - Topic 3 – Senate Bill 43 Implementation (Supervisor Mandelman): Supervisor Mandelman praised the mayor’s support for SB 43, which expands conservatorship eligibility to include substance use disorder. He expressed concern about a lack of appropriate locked subacute and board-and-care beds. Mayor Breed noted that such beds are expensive and that the city added about 350 of its 400-bed goal, but that 12% of people conserved succeeded in community settings. She called for state help and improved efficiency. - Commendations (Special Order 2:30 PM): - Tony Delorio (Teamsters Local 665) was honored for his labor leadership and community work. - Vernon Ng (District 7) was commended for intervening in a violent attack at Shaw’s Ice Cream, subduing an assailant using Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. - Castro Street Fair Board of Directors was recognized for 50 years of the fair, which has raised over $1.6 million for Castro-based nonprofits. - Committee Reports: - Item 24 (Castro Street Nighttime Entertainment): Passed on first reading (10 ayes, 1 no) after being forwarded without recommendation from the Land Use and Transportation Committee. - Adoption Without Committee Reference (Items 28–37): - Item 28 (APEC Resolution): Urged mayor and city agencies to inform residents, prioritize funds for mitigation, protect free speech, and uphold sanctuary policies. Adopted unanimously (11 ayes). - Item 29 (SoMa Pilipinas Gateway): Sent to committee for further discussion, with Supervisor Safai added as co-sponsor. - Items 30–37: Adopted unanimously (11 ayes), including recognitions, planning extensions, and committee reports. Key Outcomes - Consent Agenda: Approved 11-0. All ordinances passed on first reading. - Item 20 (Cash Revolving Funds): Passed on first reading (9 ayes). - Item 21 (Graffiti Advisory Board): Passed on first reading (11 ayes). - Item 22 (IHSS Public Authority Appointments): Motion approved unanimously. - Item 23 (Historic Preservation Commission Appointment): Motion approved unanimously. - Item 24 (Castro Street Nighttime Entertainment): Passed on first reading (10-1, Peskin dissenting). - Item 28 (APEC Resolution): Adopted unanimously (11 ayes). - Item 29: Sent to committee. - Items 30–37: Adopted unanimously (11 ayes). - Mayoral Policy Discussion: Topics were filed after discussion; no binding actions taken. - Public Comment: Concluded without further board action.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, October 23, 2023, at 6:15 PM (UTC) to consider four major items: a charter amendment to set minimum police staffing levels, an ordinance on community policing foot and bike patrols, a charter amendment requiring mayoral approval for certain SFMTA budget proposals, and a charter amendment to formally establish the Department of Emergency Management in the city charter. The meeting included extensive public testimony and debate. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Police Staffing): Over 30 public speakers. A majority expressed strong support for the charter amendment, citing concerns about crime, slow response times, and the need to recruit and retain officers. Several speakers (e.g., representatives from SEIU Local 1021, building trades) opposed the amendment, arguing it was unfunded (estimated cost up to $300 million over five years) and would divert resources from other public safety services like 911 dispatch, mental health, and firefighting. A few speakers called for continued defunding of police or criticized the measure as a step backward. Supporters included neighborhood associations, small business owners, and victims of crime. - Item 2 (Community Policing): A handful of speakers supported foot and bike patrols, emphasizing community engagement and deterrence. A few speakers opposed, arguing that increased police presence does not improve safety and leads to surveillance and harassment. - Item 3 (SFMTA Oversight): Several speakers (primarily from SEIU Local 87 and janitorial workers) supported the charter amendment, stating that parking meter extensions and fare increases hurt low-wage workers who work evening shifts. One speaker opposed, arguing it would politicize transit funding and lead to service cuts. - Item 4 (Emergency Management): No public comments were offered. Discussion Items Item 1: Charter Amendment - Minimum Police Department Staffing and Five-Year Annual Funding Requirement Chair Matt Dorsey (sponsor) presented the amendment to re-establish a minimum staffing level of 2,074 full-duty sworn officers within five years, with graduated annual targets (1,700 in FY24-25 to 2,074 by FY28-29). The measure creates a Police Full Staffing Fund set at $75,000 per officer short of the minimum (up to 400 positions), allows a temporary freeze during budget emergencies (deficit $250 million), and permits philanthropic donations. San Francisco Police Chief Bill Scott, Commander Nicole Jones, and Deputy Chief Peter Walsh detailed staffing crises: current full-duty sworn officers at 1,475 (down from 1,800 in 2019), retirement eligible officers at 391, and increased response times (e.g., A-priority calls from 7 to 9 minutes). They highlighted recruitment challenges, lack of competitive bonuses (only $5,000 for laterals vs. $75,000 in Alameda), and the need for better outreach and support programs. Vice Chair Shimon Walton raised concerns about the feasibility of guaranteeing minimum numbers and equity in distribution of officers. Supervisor Asha Safai supported the intent but called for a comprehensive safety approach and a dedicated funding source. Public comment was heard. Item 2: Administrative Code - Community Policing and Foot and Bike Patrols Supervisor Safai (sponsor) introduced an ordinance requiring the chief of police to adopt a foot and bike patrol strategy for each district, with annual police commission hearings on community policing. Chief Scott expressed support but cautioned that staffing shortages make it difficult to prioritize patrols over 911 response. The item was continued to October 30, 2023, because amendments from the department were not yet ready. Item 3: Charter Amendment - Mayor Approval Required for Certain SFMTA Budget Proposals Supervisor Safai (sponsor) proposed that the mayor must affirmatively approve in writing any SFMTA budget proposals that change fares, parking meter rates, or hours/days of operation. The amendment aims to create accountability for decisions that impact working families. Director of SFMTA (Jeffrey Tumlin) opposed, warning it could lead to service cuts and politicize transit funding. Chair Dorsey expressed concern about politicizing MTA, noting previous voter measures (Prop A 2007, Prop E 1999) intended to insulate transit from politics. The motion to recommend to the full board passed 2-1, with Dorsey voting no. Item 4: Charter Amendment - Establishing the Department of Emergency Management in the Charter Supervisor Safai (sponsor) presented a charter amendment to formally establish the Department of Emergency Management (DEM), set qualifications for its director (to match current Director Mary Ellen Carroll's expertise), and codify the director's appointment authority. No public opposition was voiced. The motion passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Police Staffing): Charter amendments were adopted in part (lowering staffing targets and clarifying fund use). A proposed amendment to allow the Board of Supervisors to override police commission staffing reductions was rejected. The item was continued as amended to the October 30, 2023 Rules Committee meeting (vote: 2-1, Walton no). - Item 2 (Community Policing): Continued to October 30, 2023, without a vote on the merits (unanimous). - Item 3 (SFMTA Oversight): Recommended to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (vote: 2-1, Dorsey no). - Item 4 (Emergency Management): Recommended to the full Board of Supervisors unanimously.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on October 23, 2023, to consider two items: an ordinance to amend zoning controls in the Castro Street Neighborhood Commercial District to allow nighttime entertainment with conditional use authorization, and an ordinance to create a Non-Profit Arts Education Special Use District. The committee voted to send the first item to the full board without recommendation and continued the second item to November 6, 2023. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Castro Street NCD): Andrea Ayello, Executive Director of the Castro Community Benefit District, expressed support for the ordinance, stating it is critically important to align the Castro NCD with the rest of the neighborhood and for the success of the Castro Theater. Ralph Hibbs, a Castro resident and treasurer of the Castro CBD, also voiced support. - Item 2 (Non-Profit Arts Education SUD): Eileen Bocan spoke in support of the legislation, noting that the proposed SUD is more restrictive and consistent with the Zoning Administrator's criteria for the Burnal Heights SUD. She also raised questions about other proposed SUDs. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Castro Street NCD): Chair Melgar introduced the ordinance from Supervisor Mandelman’s office. The committee discussed the motion. Vice Chair Preston requested to send the item to the full board without recommendation to preserve his previous position on the Castro Theater. The chair withdrew her original motion for a positive recommendation and moved to send without recommendation. - Item 2 (Non-Profit Arts Education SUD): Supervisor Peskin moved to continue the item to November 6, 2023, due to a lack of quorum at the Historic Preservation Commission. The committee accepted the motion. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Castro Street NCD): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report without recommendation. The motion passed with Vice Chair Preston, Member Peskin, and Chair Melgar all voting aye. - Item 2 (Non-Profit Arts Education SUD): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the item to the regular meeting of November 6, 2023. The motion passed with all members voting aye.
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, October 19, 2023, to consider a variety of land use items including continuances, consent calendar approvals, a discretionary review, a grant acceptance, and an informational presentation on the Potrero Yard Modernization Project. The meeting began with roll call showing five commissioners present (Moore, Braun, Imperial, Koppel, Ruiz) with Commissioners Tanner and Diamond absent. The meeting lasted from approximately 1:00 PM to late afternoon, with public comment taken both in person and remotely. Consent Calendar - All items on the consent calendar (Items 7, 8, 10-16) were approved unanimously (5-0) with the exception of Item 9 (38 Mars Street) which was pulled by the Commission Chair for separate consideration. Approved items included conditional use authorizations for 450 Sutter Street, 2208 Mission Street, 1539 Sloat Boulevard, 1515 Waller Street, 930 Pine Street (Units 114 and 214), 3911 Alemany Boulevard, 3431 19th Street, and 637 Irving Street. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Several speakers addressed the commission. Georgia spoke about the need to adjust demolition calculations to preserve existing affordable housing, noting that most projects are speculative. Sandra Dratler, representing Faith in Action and the San Francisco Land Use Coalition, presented data showing that only 18% of permits require conditional use or discretionary review hearings, and that the majority of discretionary reviews involve expansions of single-family homes rather than new housing units. Audrey Roman continued the presentation, showing that for multi-unit buildings, 57% of discretionary reviews were for expansions, not unit creation, and that 19% of conditional use authorizations for existing multi-unit buildings involved unit removals. Sue Hascher requested a presentation on the status of office approvals, noting that many approved office spaces are not being built. - Public Comment on Continuances: One member of the public asked for clarification on Item 22 (Non-Profit Arts Education Special Use District) which was continued. Discussion Items - Item 9 – 38 Mars Street (Discretionary Review): This item was pulled from the consent calendar. The project sponsor, Lucas Eastwood, described a vertical and horizontal addition to an existing single-family home. The DR requester had agreed to a five-foot setback modification but did not withdraw the DR. The DR requester was not present at the hearing. The Commission approved the project as modified, with the condition that the roof deck be non-occupiable, citing the need to memorialize the agreement. - Item 23 – Yosemite Slough Grant: Katie Lee, the department's new budget and grants analyst, presented a grant from the California Office of Planning and Research to fund a community-based adaptation plan addressing climate risk in the Bayview. The Commission approved acceptance of the grant unanimously. - Items 24A/B – Potrero Yard Modernization Project: Staff from the Planning Department, SFMTA, and the Potrero Neighborhood Collective (PNC) presented an informational update and initiation of General Plan Amendments. The project includes rebuilding the 100-year-old bus yard, adding 223 bus parking spaces (up from 153), and constructing up to 513 housing units (100% affordable) on the site. A variant was discussed that would allow rooftop space for paratransit operations (reducing housing to 103 units) if housing funding is delayed. The Commission expressed support for the project but raised concerns about the cost and design implications of the variant. The Commission voted unanimously to initiate the General Plan Amendments and schedule a hearing on or after January 11, 2024. - Commission Comments and Questions: Commissioner Moore highlighted the groundbreaking of the 108-unit affordable housing project at the former Potrero power plant. Discussion also covered budget cuts (director noted a $1-1.5 million fee revenue shortfall and potential future cuts), the planning code audit with a racial and social equity lens, and concerns about cannabis retail vacancies. Commissioner Imperial requested data on how conditional use authorizations are categorized for the consent calendar. Key Outcomes - Continuances: All proposed continuances were approved unanimously (5-0). Items continued include: Item 1 (exceptions from conversion limits) to November 2, 2023; Items 2A/B (355 Lombard Street) to November 2, 2023; Item 3 (342 Moultrie Street) to November 9, 2023; Items 4A/B (10 Seacliff Avenue) to November 30, 2023; Item 5 (67 Potomac Street) to December 7, 2023; Item 6 (2536 California Street) to January 25, 2024; Item 22 (Non-Profit Arts Education SUD) to November 2, 2023; and Item 25 (129 Laidley Street) to November 30, 2023. - Consent Calendar Approval: All consent items except Item 9 were approved unanimously. - Item 9 (38 Mars Street): Approved with modifications (non-occupiable roof deck) by a 5-0 vote. - Item 23 (Yosemite Slough Grant): Approved acceptance of grant award unanimously. - Items 24A/B (Potrero Yard Modernization): Initiation of General Plan Amendments approved and hearing scheduled for January 11, 2024 or later, by a 5-0 vote. - Minutes: The draft minutes from September 28, 2023 were adopted unanimously. - Director's Announcements: Noted that the APEC conference (November 11-16) may affect the November 16 hearing; a possible earlier start time of 10 AM is being considered. The Board of Supervisors voted to cease remote public participation, but the Planning Commission continues to offer it.
On October 19, 2023, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Government Audit and Oversight Committee convened a regular meeting, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston. The committee addressed the UN Plaza Activation Project and the relocation of the Heart of the City Farmers Market, continued a resolution on taxi dispatch, and held a closed session to discuss litigation settlements. Supervisor Mandelman filled in for Vice Chair Stephanie, and Supervisor Connie Chan joined later. Consent Calendar - None Public Comments & Testimony - UN Plaza Activation Project (Item 1): - David Elliott Lewis (Co-chair, Tenderloin People's Congress) refuted claims of public input, stating the community was not consulted and that the farmers market was misled about the project being a six-month pilot. - Carrie Barnes (President, Noe Valley Democratic Club) expressed support for the UN Plaza makeover, emphasizing the need for revitalization and criticizing the 'eviction' framing. - Hillary Brown (PROSAC representative, District 5) raised concerns about disabled access at the new farmers market location. - Adele Framer (SF Farmers Market shopper) stated that community is site-specific and that the farmers market was a stakeholder in the Civic Center Public Realm Plan but not this new plan. - Jim (lifelong skateboarder) spoke in support of the skateboard activation area, citing cultural and mental health benefits. - Simon Vloya (Tenderloin resident) criticized the lack of community engagement and the quick implementation, arguing it contradicts the Civic Center Public Realm Plan. - Beck Trebesh (San Francisco Parks Alliance) expressed support for the activation plans, highlighting diverse uses and potential for downtown revitalization. - Casey Rios (Tenderloin People's Congress) called the presentation 'spin,' citing a 30-degree temperature differential between UN Plaza and the new market location, exceeding OSHA break points. - Tess Wellbourne supported previous comments about problems with the plans, calling for portable bathrooms and questioning the removal of seating. - Francisco Leon (ambassador for UN Plaza) shared positive comments from customers about the new skate park and workout areas, as well as improved accessibility for disabled persons. - Trader Jeff (long-term market patron) reported that some farmers are struggling and missing from the new location. - Susan Bryan (resident) questioned the skate park's safety and potential lawsuits, supporting the farmers market. - Jackson Nutyers (San Francisco Chamber of Commerce) expressed support for the UN Plaza Activation Project, citing seven days of activation and downtown reimagining. Discussion Items - UN Plaza Activation Project and Heart of the City Farmers Market (Item 1): - Sarah Madlin (Recreation and Parks Department) presented the UN Plaza Activation Project, emphasizing the Civic Center Public Realm Plan as its basis. She cited 545 overdose calls in the last year and 33 overdose deaths within one block of UN Plaza since January 1, 2020. The project includes skate elements, chess tables, ping pong, fitness equipment, and a fountain, with a budget of $2 million from Rec Park's capital funds. Construction is expected to be complete by mid-November, with a two-year pilot and data tracking via Placer AI. - Eline Satou (Civic Center Community Benefit District) detailed technical assistance for the relocated farmers market, including new layout planning, free 90-minute parking, and vendor permits. She reported that stall fees increased by 11% in September 2023 compared to September 2022, and EBT transactions increased by 7.6% per market day. - Supervisor Preston expressed disappointment over the lack of transparency and community engagement, noting that the initial information indicated a six-month pilot, but later it was revealed to be a two-year project. He questioned the lack of a plan B if the farmers market does not thrive, and highlighted the heat from new asphalt affecting produce, bathroom access, and the need for longer-term permits. - Supervisor Chan argued that the farmers market was effectively evicted from its space, and questioned the design process that excluded it. - Supervisor Mandelman praised Rec Park's work on Civic Center Plaza but acknowledged the need for support for the farmers market, emphasizing the urgency of addressing the crisis at UN Plaza. - The committee moved to continue the item to the call of the chair. - Taxi Upfront Fare Pilot (Item 2): - Supervisor Chan requested a continuance to November 16, 2023, explaining that SFMTA is collecting a third quarter of data, which would provide nearly a year's worth for a more complete analysis. SFMTA agreed with this timeline. - Closed Session (Items 3-8): - The committee convened closed session to discuss six settlement ordinances and resolutions, totaling over $21 million. The committee voted to not disclose the matters. Key Outcomes - Item 1 continued to the call of the chair (motion passed 3-0). - Item 2 continued to November 16, 2023 (motion passed 3-0). - Closed session items (3-8) approved, with matters not disclosed (motion passed 3-0). - Motion to excuse Supervisor Stephanie passed 2-0 (Supervisor Chan absent). Note: The meeting began with an announcement that the Board of Supervisors had changed rules to end remote public comment due to misuse, but this agenda included the option as originally noticed.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, October 18, 2023, to discuss crime trends, receive presentations on the Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) 2022 annual report and the Q3 2023 Sparks reports from SFPD and DPA, approve revised DGO 9.04 (Seat Belt Policy), and hear public comment. The meeting was called to order at 1:45 PM by Vice President Carter Oberstone, with Commissioners Walker, Benedicto, Byrne, and Yee present (Yanyez excused). Chief Scott and DPA Executive Director Henderson also attended. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously approved (5-0) the consent calendar, which included receiving and filing a Starbucks coffee donation ($800, $80 per district station) for National Coffee with a Cop and the 2023 Department Awards Certification. Public Comments & Testimony - Paul Allen urged the commission to comply with Section 4.1022 of the city charter by developing an annual statement of purpose, calling the current delay "a laughable excuse." - Angela Tickler criticized the commission's approval of DGO 5.25 (foot pursuit policy), arguing it endangers officers and is part of a "plan to micromanage the SFPD out of existence." She claimed the commission is not authorized to involve itself in tactical decisions. - Jake Conner Birtega, co-president of Iconic D3, demanded an investigation into how private information was leaked to the press, stating that public trust in the commission is eroding. - Paulette Brown, whose son was murdered in 2006, pleaded for the commission to support hiring outside investigators for unsolved homicides, saying she has been seeking justice for 17 years. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 4): Chief Scott reported a 6% decrease in overall part one crime (about 2,200 fewer crimes compared to the previous year). Property crime fell 7%, but violent crime rose 3%. Homicides stand at 43 (up from 42), with a clearance rate of 72%. Firearm seizures increased 2% (866 total), and ghost gun seizures rose 10% (176). The chief highlighted successful arrests from an organized retail theft blitz at Walgreens (6 of 8 suspects arrested) and bait car operations (5 arrests). He also briefed the commission on preparations for the upcoming APEC conference, which will involve significant street closures and security measures, and provided updates on a shooting at the Chinese consulate. - Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) 2022 Annual Report (Item 7): Sergeant Laura Colleen and Officer Elizabeth Prillinger presented the CIT unit's work. The unit consists of four sworn officers. Key statistics: 77% of patrol officers are trained on the 40-hour CIT certification, and 100% on the one-day field tactics course. In 2022, there were 2,308 mental health detentions and approximately 39,000 calls for service involving mental health. Use of force occurred in 333 of those calls (0.001%), with 285 being control holds. The field unit uses a co-responder model with DPH clinicians. The unit also conducts training for outside agencies and hosts international visitors. Commissioners praised the unit's work and discussed the need for more staffing and a dedicated crisis response team. - Sparks Reports Q3 2023 (Item 8): SFPD's Policy Development Division Manager Aja Steeves reported that SFPD has 33 DGOs in development and 49 department bulletin notices. The new Policy Development Division was established in May 2023. DPA Policy Director Janelle Kwood presented concerns about SFPD stop data reliability, including officers entering multiple race categories, failing to enter stops, and entering wrong race information. DPA called for an external review. Regarding languishing DGOs, 12 of the original 26 have been adopted or are in meet and confer, while 14 remain pending. There was extensive discussion about the interpretation of DGO 3.01 and delays in the revision process. The chief confirmed that DGO 1.06 is finalized and will be submitted soon. - Revised DGO 9.04 Seat Belt Policy (Item 10): The commission unanimously approved (5-0) a revised, simplified Department General Order 9.04 on seat belt policy, to be used in meet and confer with affected bargaining units. Key Outcomes - The commission voted unanimously to approve the consent calendar. - The commission approved the revised DGO 9.04 (Seat Belt Policy) for meet and confer, with a 5-0 vote. - The commission voted 5-0 to hold Item 13 (Closed Session) and later voted not to disclose any discussion from closed session. - The commission postponed the weekly officer recognition to November 1. - The commission noted that Item 9 (Presentation on increase of Use of Force on people of color) was removed from the agenda and will be rescheduled. - Discussion continued on the need for a third-party audit of SFPD stop data and for timely resolution of languishing DGOs. The commission may schedule a future agenda item to review the 14 pending DGOs.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Tuesday, October 17, 2023, to consider a wide-ranging agenda including budget reform for nonprofit contracts, implementation of the voter-approved Empty Homes Tax, amendments to shelter and homeless service contracts, and a controversial change to remote public comment rules. The board also recognized community members with commendations and introduced several new resolutions. Consent Calendar - Lawsuit Settlements (Items 1-11): Unanimously approved 11 settlements totaling $3,649,280.01, covering claims against the city. - Routine Items (Items 13, 15-41, 43-45): Passed without discussion on a single “same house, same call” vote each. These included the Police Department salary ordinance (Item 13), airport concession leases and contracts, property leases, grants, health services amendments, liquor license transfers, code amendments (Items 29-32, 36-38), appointments, and homeless service grant amendments (Items 43-45). Public Comments & Testimony - Domestic Violence Awareness: Beverly Upton of the San Francisco Domestic Violence Consortium spoke in support of Domestic Violence Awareness Month, noting that 20,000 people call community-based organizations about domestic violence annually. She urged continued efforts to reduce domestic violence homicides, which have decreased from 15-16 per year to zero in some years. - Other Speakers: Comments covered homelessness, police response, international issues, and personal experiences. Several speakers delivered offensive or hateful remarks, which later influenced the board's discussion on remote public comment. Discussion Items Budget and Nonprofit Contracting Reform (Item 12) Supervisor Hillary Ronen presented a resolution requiring city departments to include cost-of-living adjustments in multi-year contracts with nonprofit organizations, ending the practice of last-minute budget negotiations. The ordinance passed on first reading. Empty Homes Tax Implementation (Item 14) Supervisor Dean Preston presented the implementing ordinance for the voter-approved Empty Homes Tax (Proposition M, Nov. 2022, 55% approval). The tax applies to buildings of three or more units vacant for more than half the year, with exceptions, effective Jan. 1, 2024. The ordinance passed on first reading. Homeless Shelter Contract Performance (Items 42-44) The Budget and Legislative Analyst raised concerns about the Cova Hotel non-congregate shelter operated by Episcopal Community Services (ECS), citing a “complete failure” to meet operational and programmatic requirements, including lack of staff training, service referrals, and wellness checks. The board approved a 10-month extension through August 2024, with a commitment to monitor performance during the budget process. Supervisor Ronan noted that a new site manager had been hired and improvements were beginning. Remote Public Comment Rules Change (Item 46) - Proponent (Supervisor Peskin): Moved to end remote public comment except for legally required disability accommodations, citing a pattern of racist and anti-Semitic comments from anonymous remote participants. He expressed openness to future alternatives like state law changes. - Opponents (Supervisors Preston, Engardio, Melgar): Argued remote comment is vital for working people, parents, seniors, and caregivers. They suggested alternatives such as a time delay or requiring registration, rather than eliminating the option entirely. - Supporters (Supervisor Walton, others): Contended the change would not harm people with disabilities or seniors and was needed to prevent outside interference and hateful speech. - Vote: 8-3 in favor (Peskin, Ronan, Safai, Stephanie, Walton, Chan, Dorsey, Mandelman for; Preston, Engardio, Melgar against). The motion carried. Commendations (Special Order 2:30 p.m.) - Andrea Carla Michaels (“Pizza Lady”): Recognized for distributing unsold pizzas to unhoused neighbors in the Lower Polk/Tenderloin area and for operating a citizen lost-and-found service. She credited rent control for enabling her volunteer work. - Carl Nolte: Honored for over 60 years of journalism at the San Francisco Chronicle. The board declared October 18, 2023 as “Carl Nolte Day.” Key Outcomes - Passed on first reading: Budget reform ordinance (Item 12), Police Department salary ordinance (Item 13), Empty Homes Tax implementation (Item 14), affordable housing lease delegation (Item 29), park road closure (Item 30), firearms drawing prohibition (Item 31), opioid antagonist requirement (Item 32), contractor debarment (Item 36), surveillance technology policy (Item 37), and Labor and Employment Code (Item 38). - Adopted resolutions: All consent calendar settlements (11 items); airport contracts and leases (Items 15-20); property lease (Item 21); grants (Items 22-24, 26-28); health services amendment (Item 25); CalRecycle grants authorization (Item 27); gun violence victim support (Item 33); liquor license transfers (Items 34-35); committee reports including homeless shelter amendments (Items 42-45). - Approved appointments: Maxine Anderson to the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force; Brenda Kwee McNulty and Aimee Brown to the Treasury Oversight Committee. - Approved rules change: Remote public comment eliminated (except for disability accommodation) effective after the meeting (Item 46). - Introduced legislation: Resolutions on stolen vehicle ticketing and Marina Harbor project (Supervisor Safai in collaboration with President Peskin); SOMA Pilipinas Gateway arch (Supervisor Dorsey); cannabis event permit extension through 2026 (Supervisor Mandelman); joint plan for inhabited RVs at Lake Merced (Supervisor Melgar). - Adjourned in memory: Tyrrell Porter Sr. (by Supervisor Walton) and Charles “Chuck” Feeney (by President Peskin).