Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 931–940 ENTRIES
931
SEP 12, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – September 12, 2023

On Tuesday, September 12, 2023, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened its regular meeting at 2:00 PM. The meeting included the mayor’s formal policy discussion on open‑air drug market enforcement, approval of major opioid settlement agreements, a contested environmental appeal for a single‑family home at 939 Lombard Street, and several resolutions addressing overdose awareness, homelessness, and city contracts. The board voted on dozens of items, with most passing unanimously except where noted. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: Unanimously approved the July 18 and July 25, 2023 board minutes after public comment. - Settlements – Opioid Lawsuits (Items 2‑4): Finally passed ordinances authorizing settlements totaling approximately $267.3 million from Walgreen Co. ($229,610,002 over 15 years), Teva Pharmaceuticals ($24,797,604 over 13 years), and Allergan ($12,916,274 over 5 years) for improper opioid dispensing and misleading marketing. - Guaranteed Income Exemption (Item 5): Passed on first reading an ordinance to exempt payments from guaranteed income pilot programs from County Adult Assistance Program determinations. - Certificates of Participation – Capital Projects (Item 6): Authorized up to $77,170,000 in tax‑exempt or taxable certificates to finance capital improvement projects. - Leases and Agreements (Items 7‑9): Approved a lease with the California Highway Patrol for radio equipment space at 125 Christmas Tree Point ($9,000 initial rent, 10‑year term), a recreation lease for Selby & Palou Mini Park ($2,000 annual rent, three 5‑year options), and a maintenance agreement with Caltrans for transportation art. - Laguna Honda Emergency Declaration (Item 10): Approved a resolution for repairs not to exceed $28,400,000, after Supervisor Melgar thanked the committee and interim Director Carla Short. - Grants and Sole‑Source Negotiation (Items 11‑13): Retroactively accepted a $150,000 grant from Blue Shield California Foundation for domestic violence programs; authorized the SFPUC to accept up to $538,051 from the California Department of Water Resources for the Zoo Recycled Water Project; and exempted from competitive bidding a potential lease with Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized, LLC for Seawall Lot 300/301 and Pier 45. - Committee Reports – Homelessness Grants (Items 19‑22): Adopted four resolution amendments increasing grant amounts: Homeless Prenatal Program ($23,461,035), Brilliant Corners – Young Adult Rapid Re‑Housing ($27,309,402), Tenderloin Housing Clinic – Master Lease Hotels ($241,657,513), and Five Keys Schools and Programs – Bayshore Navigation Center ($25,071,113). All passed unanimously. - Adoption Without Committee Reference – Miscellaneous (Items 26‑29, 32): Unanimously approved resolutions including retroactive 90‑day extensions for Planning Commission reviews, urging plan approval for the How Weird Street Faire, declaring September 2023 as Transit Month, and a resolution recognizing September 2023 as Childhood Cancer Awareness Month. Public Comments & Testimony - 939 Lombard Street CEQA Appeal: Approximately nine speakers (parents and community members) opposed the project, citing risks of landslides, shadows on the schoolyard at Yick Wo Elementary, noise, dust, and hazards to 200+ students, especially special‑needs children. One caller spoke in support, arguing construction could be an educational opportunity. - General Public Comment (after 3:00 PM): Several speakers addressed overdose awareness, transphobia concerns about an upcoming convention, criticism of city policies (public drug use, algebra tracking in schools), and support for harm‑reduction services including safe consumption sites. Discussion Items - Mayor’s Appearance – Drug Market Enforcement (Special Order 2:00 PM): Mayor London Breed reported that from end‑May 2023, police made 616 arrests for drug sales in the Tenderloin and SoMa (up from about 350 in all of 2022), seized over 200 pounds of fentanyl (2.5× more than the same period last year), and the District Attorney has filed 566 drug cases in 2023. She emphasized a need to “strengthen our laws to compel more people into treatment” and to pair any safe consumption sites with aggressive enforcement. The command center structure shifted from the Department of Emergency Management to the Police Department to improve inter‑agency coordination. A public dashboard of metrics is being developed. The mayor and President Peskin discussed the need for clear metrics and reducing bureaucracy. - Commendation – Devon Han (Special Order 2:30 PM): Supervisor Ronin presented a posthumous commendation to 15‑year‑old shooting victim Devon Han. The supervisor publicly apologized for unknowingly writing a letter on behalf of the man who later admitted to the murder. The victim’s mother, Sheree Johnson, accepted the honor and criticized systemic failures, stating she is pursuing a claim against the city. - 939 Lombard Street CEQA Appeal (Special Order 3:00 PM): The board heard an appeal of the Planning Department’s Class 1 and Class 3 categorical exemption for demolishing a carport and building a 5,173‑sq‑ft, 40‑foot‑tall single‑family home adjacent to Yick Wo Elementary School. The appellant (neighbor Martin Ng) argued that the project poses unusual circumstances (landslide risk, shadows, noise, dust). The Planning Department countered that the project meets CEQA exemption criteria, that the site is not unique (14 other elementary schools on steep slopes in SF), and that the appellant provided no substantial evidence of significant impacts. The project sponsor’s attorney noted the school itself did not appeal, and that pier foundations would actually reduce load on the shared retaining wall. After debate, the board voted 11‑0 to affirm the exemption (Item 16) and table the reversing motions (Items 17‑18). - Overdose Awareness Day Resolution (Item 25): Supervisor Ronin introduced a resolution recognizing August 31, 2023 as International Overdose Awareness Day, amended to include a broad range of strategies (wellness centers, overdose prevention sites, abstinence programs). Lengthy debate ensued: Supervisor Dorsey expressed support for supervised consumption services but objected to wording he felt separated wellness hubs from safe consumption; Supervisor Preston argued that without safe consumption sites the city is failing to save lives; Supervisor Ronin criticized colleagues for being dishonest about their positions. The resolution passed 11‑0 as amended. - Fill Vacant Permanent Supportive Housing Units (Item 31): Supervisor Preston’s resolution urging the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing to fill at least half of vacant PSH units within 90 days and maintain a vacancy rate no greater than 5% thereafter. Several supervisors expressed support, noting a pilot program for same‑day placement. The resolution passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Opioid Settlements Approved: Three ordinances authorizing $267.3 million in total settlements with Walgreen Co., Teva, and Allergan were finally passed. - Another Planet Entertainment Concert Permit (Item 14): Passed 10‑1 (Supervisor Chan voting no due to neighborhood impact concerns) to allow post‑Outside Lands concerts at Golden Gate Park’s Polo Field for 2024‑2026, with minimum permits of $1.4 million (two‑day) and $2.1 million (three‑day). - 939 Lombard Street CEQA Appeal Denied: The board voted 11‑0 to affirm the categorical exemption, allowing the project to proceed. - Portsmouth Square Elevators Emergency Declaration (Item 30): Referred to the Budget and Finance Committee (moved by Supervisor Safai, seconded by Supervisor Chan). - In Memoriam: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Peter De Luca and James Wing Chow. - Future Hearings: Supervisor Safai’s letter of inquiry on traffic enforcement will be heard at the September 28 Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee. Supervisor Stephanie’s nonprofit oversight legislation and other introduced items will advance through committees.

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · PUBLIC SAFETY 11% · PUBLIC HEALTH 10%
932
SEP 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
SF Rules Committee Appoints Health Authority and Reentry Council Members - September 11, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee convened a regular meeting on Monday, September 11, 2023, at approximately 11:15 AM PT (18:15 UTC) in City Hall. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Dorsey, with Supervisors Chan and Safai present, considered two appointments. Vice Chair Walton was excused via motion. The meeting began with a moment of silence to honor the victims of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. Discussion Items - Appointment to San Francisco Health Authority (Seat 9): The committee heard from Norlissa Cooper, nominated by the San Francisco Labor Council. Ms. Cooper described her 15 years of clinical experience at San Francisco General Hospital, 10 years of executive committee leadership, and training as a critical ethnographer focused on health care disparities. She expressed her goal to reduce health care disparities in San Francisco by increasing access to quality, culturally relevant services while meeting state and local goals. Chair Dorsey highlighted her background in fighting big tobacco and asked about the Health Authority's potential role in tobacco cessation. Ms. Cooper suggested expanding services, including addressing secondhand smoke and engaging children and families. No public comments were received. - Appointment to Reentry Council (Seat 6): This was the inaugural appointment to seat six, created by Supervisor Ronan's legislation, requiring a representative from the entity primarily responsible for administering pretrial services involving alternatives to incarceration. David Morroff from San Francisco Pretrial was the sole applicant. He noted his agency has provided pretrial services for 47 years and is responsible for approximately 70% of individuals released from the county jail. He expressed enthusiasm for serving in a leadership capacity on the Reentry Council to shape public safety and community responses. Supervisor Safai praised the agency's work in addiction and employment areas. No public comments were received. Key Outcomes - The committee unanimously recommended Norlissa Cooper for seat 9 on the San Francisco Health Authority (term ending January 15, 2024), with a roll call vote of 3 ayes (Chan, Safai, Dorsey). The appointment moves to the full board. - The committee unanimously recommended David Morroff for seat 6 on the Reentry Council (term ending June 1, 2024), with a roll call vote of 3 ayes (Chan, Safai, Dorsey). The appointment moves to the full board. - Both appointments are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on September 19, 2023. - No other business was conducted, and the meeting adjourned.

PUBLIC HEALTH 46% · PROCEDURAL 37% · CORRECTIONS AND REENTRY 17%
933
SEP 11, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting – September 11, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on September 11, 2023, at 9:45 AM. Chair Mirna Melgar presided, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered six items, including an extension of interim zoning controls for parcel delivery services, acceptance of a park on Yerba Buena Island, a shared spaces waiver for a Taraval Street business, a continuance for a cultural center special use district, amendments to development impact fee reductions, and a continuance of a conditional use requirement for residential projects. Public Comments & Testimony Public comment was taken on several items. Speakers included representatives from Teamsters Local 350, 665, and 2785, as well as the Sierra Club, who supported the parcel delivery interim zoning controls extension with an amendment lowering the square footage threshold from 10,000 to 5,000 feet. Public comment on the development impact fee reduction amendments featured support from the Housing Action Coalition, architects, and residents, who urged inclusion of 10-24 unit and Home-SF projects. On the Wawona Street cultural center SUD, commenters supported a continuance, raising concerns about the coastal zone permit and potential precedent. Discussion Items Item 5 – Parcel Delivery Interim Zoning Controls Extension Supervisor Peskin recused himself due to stock in Amazon. The committee considered Resolution 230817, extending interim zoning controls requiring conditional use authorization for parcel delivery services. An amendment was offered to lower the threshold from 10,000 to 5,000 square feet (non-substantive, approved as to form). Supervisor Preston expressed support. The item passed 2-0 (Peskin excused) and was forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation as amended. Item 1 – Treasure Island/Yerba Buena Island – The Rocks Park Acceptance Ordinance 230858 accepting improvements at the Rocks Dog Park on Yerba Buena Island and dedicating it to public use. Bob Beck of the Treasure Island Development Authority presented an update: 229 housing units completed, 745 under construction, and infrastructure progress. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 2 – Administrative Code – Treatment of Seating Area at Taraval Street and 46th Avenue as Sidewalk for Shared Spaces Program Ordinance 230767 waiving requirements to classify a traffic island seating area used by White Cap Bar as sidewalk for shared spaces. Tita Bell (Supervisor Engardio’s office) and Monica Munowich (SFMTA) explained the need. No public comment. Unanimous vote (3-0) to forward to the full board. Item 3 – Planning Code, Zoning Map – Wawona Street and 45th Avenue Cultural Center Special Use District Ordinance 230505 to create a special use district for a cultural center. The sponsor requested a continuance to October 30, 2023. Public comment in support of continuance noted coastal zone permit issues. Chair Melgar commented on the importance of the Irish community center. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue to October 30. Item 4 – Planning, Administrative Codes – Development Impact Fee Reductions Ordinance 230855 reducing inclusionary housing requirements and impact fees. Supervisor Safai introduced amendments to include 10-24 unit projects and Home-SF projects. President Peskin offered a technical amendment (page 16 drafting error). Public comment in support. The committee adopted both amendments (unanimous) and continued the ordinance to the September 18, 2023 meeting for a committee report. Item 6 – Planning Code – Conditional Use for Residential Projects in RM, RC, and RTO Districts Ordinance 230596 requiring conditional use for residential projects that do not maximize density. Supervisor Peskin moved to continue to the call of the chair. No public comment. Unanimous vote (3-0) to continue. Key Outcomes - Item 5: Approved amendment lowering threshold to 5,000 sq ft; forwarded to full board (2-0). - Item 1: Forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 2: Forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 3: Continued to October 30, 2023 (3-0). - Item 4: Amendments adopted; continued to September 18, 2023 (3-0). - Item 6: Continued to call of the chair (3-0).

PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · PARCEL DELIVERY SERVICES 17% · PROCEDURAL 16% · PARKS AND RECREATION 14%
934
SEP 7, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
SF Government Audit and Oversight Committee Hearing on Fire Prevention and Victim Support - Sept 7, 2023

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on September 7, 2023, at 6:15 PM UTC to address fire prevention strategies and support for victims of residential fires. Chair Dean Preston led the hearing, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan. The committee heard from Fire Marshal Ken Coughlin, HSA Disaster Preparedness Director Doris Barone, and DBI Acting Deputy Director Matt Green. The hearing highlighted critical gaps in the city's response, including delays in Red Cross deployment, limited staffing at HSA, and the need for sprinkler retrofits in older buildings. Key outcomes included a commitment to develop a multilingual one-page resource guide for displaced residents within 30 days and a motion to continue the item to the call of the chair, which passed unanimously. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - A speaker who experienced a fire in the McAllister/Divisadero area emphasized that sprinklers would have greatly helped, noting that the building had only one fire escape and was difficult to evacuate. They also stressed the importance of providing a physical information sheet at fire scenes. - Trey Flanders (North Beach Tenants Committee) called for timelines on repairs, tenant tracking, and low-interest loans for older landlords to afford fire prevention upgrades. They noted that renters insurance can be inadequate and that the Good Samaritan program information is hard to find. - Charlie Goss (San Francisco Apartment Association) highlighted past fire safety legislation, including tenant disclosures and fire alarm upgrades, and raised concerns about fires caused by lithium-ion batteries, supporting state bill SB 712. - Jill Cunzler (urban photographer) expressed concerns about homeless encampments near residential buildings and the need for safe sleeping places. - Dan Torres (Sprinkler Fitters Local 483) expressed support for retrofitting multi-unit buildings with sprinkler systems, citing new technologies that reduce cost and displacement. - Multiple representatives from the Transgender, Gender Variant, Intersex Justice Project (TGIJP) testified about the inadequacy of the city's response to the 120 Hyde Street fire, stating that their organization had to use its own funds for hotels and that the Red Cross provided minimal assistance. They emphasized the lack of coordination and follow-up. - Eric Schnauble (TGIJP) reiterated the lack of on-site support and follow-up, noting that it took about two and a half months to get clients back into subsidized housing. Discussion Items - Fire Prevention Data & Sprinklers (Fire Marshal Ken Coughlin): Fire Marshal Coughlin presented data showing a 15% reduction in two-alarm-or-greater residential fires from 2017–2023 compared to 2004–2016, with a spike in 2022 (25% increase). He noted that 90% of fires occur in low-rise buildings (under 75 feet) and that outside fires (trash, encampments) have increased significantly, expected to exceed pre-pandemic levels by 2.5 times. He explained that current codes require sprinklers in new construction and specific existing buildings (e.g., SROs with 20+ rooms), but not for most older apartment buildings. He discussed the 2022 fire code requiring sprinklers in 125+ residential high-rises over 12 years and noted that no owners have yet been required to install sprinklers due to habitual violations. - HSA Response & Support (Doris Barone): Director Barone detailed the coordinated response model involving SFHSA, SFFD, DEM, and the American Red Cross. She explained that the Red Cross provides immediate assistance (client assistance cards, hoteling) and that HSA offers up to three weeks of hoteling and a maximum four-year rental subsidy for eligible households. She noted that one full-time staff member handles all stabilization cases, supported by three rotating on-call duty officers, and that there is a significant need for long-term case management. She also highlighted challenges with Red Cross volunteer recruitment, causing response times of 1–3 hours, and that if the Red Cross cannot deploy within three hours, HSA and DEM can be notified to send personnel. - DBI Building Inspection (Matt Green): Deputy Director Green explained DBI's 24/7 on-call inspector response, which issues notices of violation, requires engineers' reports within 72 hours, and sets timelines for securing buildings and completing repairs. He noted that property owners are required to secure vacant buildings within 72 hours and that DBI can escalate to abatement orders or emergency orders if owners fail to comply. Supervisor Chan raised concerns about looting following fires, and Green acknowledged building security challenges. Key Outcomes - Motion to continue the item to the call of the chair passed unanimously (3-0). - Development of a one-page multilingual resource guide for fire victims, to be completed within 30 days, with cooperation from SFFD, HSA, DBI, and community stakeholders. - Discussions on expanded sprinkler requirements for existing low-rise and mid-rise buildings, with consideration of new technologies and potential funding sources (e.g., housing bond). - Consideration of increasing HSA staffing for disaster response and case management, given the current one-person capacity. - Exploration of using NERT volunteers to supplement Red Cross response times. - Committee members encouraged renters to obtain renters insurance and landlords to participate in the Good Samaritan program.

FIRE SAFETY 46% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · PUBLIC SAFETY 15% · PROCEDURAL 5%
935
SEP 7, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting – September 7, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular meeting on Thursday, September 7, 2023, at 1:15 PM UTC (9:15 AM PDT). The meeting included continuance of several items, approval of consent calendar items, discussion of a major citywide planning code amendment to expand commercial uses, a public hearing on the draft Environmental Impact Report for the San Francisco Gateway Project, and a conditional use authorization for a residential project with a history of an Ellis Act eviction. The commission voted on multiple items, with several motions passing unanimously and some with dissenting votes. Consent Calendar - Item 4 (3995 Alemany Boulevard): Approved unanimously (7-0) for a conditional use authorization to expand a Formula Retail Use. - Items 5 & 6 (225 Gough Street, 11 Franklin Street 602): Approved unanimously (6-0, with recusals) for conditional use authorizations. - Item 7 (2900 Franklin Street): Approved unanimously (6-0, with recusal) for a Verizon Wireless facility. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 8 (255 10th Avenue): Supervisor Chan’s legislative aide read a letter urging the commission to maximize housing unit availability instead of allowing conversion to a single-family home. Several community members expressed concern about the loss of residential care facilities and the trend toward “mega mansions.” - On Item 15 (Citywide expansion of commercial uses): Over 50 letters were received, mostly in support. Speakers included representatives from the Chinatown Community Development Center (opposing professional services in Chinatown), the Small Business Commission (supporting the overhaul), and the San Francisco Land Use Coalition (raising concerns about restaurant density and outdoor patios). - On Item 16 (SF Gateway EIR): Multiple community members from Bayview Hunters Point testified about historical environmental injustice, health impacts, and inadequate analysis of cumulative impacts. Building trades representatives supported the draft EIR, citing mitigation measures and job opportunities. - On Item 17 (79 28th Street): Neighbors and tenant advocates spoke against the project, citing the previous Ellis Act eviction of an elderly couple and the loss of affordable rent-controlled units. The current owners testified about their lack of knowledge of the property’s history. Discussion Items - Continuances (Items 1–3): Item 1 (eliminating public art requirement for 100% affordable housing) was continued to November 2, 2023. Items 2 (parcel delivery services definition) and 3 (51 Prosper Street) were continued indefinitely or to a future date. Commissioner Ruiz recused from Item 1. - Item 8 (255 10th Avenue – Residential care facility conversion): Vice President Moore pulled the item from consent. Commissioners debated the loss of a residential care facility and the opportunity to add density. The project was approved 5-2, with Commissioners Imperial and Moore opposed. - Item 9 (815 Powell Street – Sixt car rental at Fairmont Hotel): Commissioner Moore argued the size and use were inappropriate for the iconic corner, preferring a café or smaller retail. A motion to continue failed 2-5. The project was approved 6-1, with Commissioner Moore dissenting. - Item 15 (Citywide expansion of commercial, restaurant, and retail uses): This was a comprehensive planning code amendment introduced by Mayor Breed. Staff presented modifications, including retaining the distinction between retail and non-retail professional services. The commission voted 6-0 to approve the ordinance with staff recommendations, passing along commissioner comments on size limits and neighborhood-specific concerns. - Item 16 (San Francisco Gateway Project – Draft EIR): The commission held a public hearing on the draft EIR for a 2.1 million sq. ft. PDR project at 749 Toland Street and 2000 McKinnon Avenue. The comment period was extended to October 16, 2023. Commissioners noted the need for further analysis of cumulative impacts, visual impacts, and the effect of parcel delivery services on citywide traffic. - Item 17 (79 28th Street – Conditional Use Authorization): The project proposed a rear addition to expand a single-family dwelling and legalize an unauthorized unit. Despite a history of an Ellis Act eviction and community opposition, the commission approved the project 7-0, noting the design was appropriate and the current owners were not responsible for the prior eviction. Key Outcomes - Continuance votes: Items 1, 2, and 3 were continued as proposed (unanimous with recusals). - Consent Calendar approvals: Items 4, 5, 6, 7 approved unanimously (with recusals for 5, 6, 7). - Item 8: Approved 5-2 (Commissioners Imperial and Moore dissenting). - Item 9: Approved 6-1 (Commissioner Moore dissenting). - Item 15: Approved 6-0 (Commissioner Ruiz recused). The commission forwarded the ordinance to the Board of Supervisors with staff recommendations and additional comments on professional services, size limits, and neighborhood carve-outs. - Item 16: No action taken; public comment period extended to October 16, 2023. Staff will prepare responses to comments and schedule an informational hearing. - Item 17: Approved 7-0. - General Public Comment: Heard on various topics including the need to codify the residential flat policy, support for streamlining housing approvals, and concerns about large project review procedures.

ZONING AND LAND USE 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · LAND USE 12% · ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 12%
936
SEP 6, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - September 6, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, September 6, 2023, at 1:45 PM, with Vice President Carter Overstone presiding. The meeting included recognition of an officer, public comment, the Chief’s and DPA Director’s reports, commission reports, a joint presentation on quarterly policy activity, and adoption of several revised Department General Orders (DGOs). The commission also entered closed session for labor negotiations. Consent Calendar - The commission voted 5-0 to receive and file the consent calendar, which included approvals for travel, cash awards, and quarterly reports (CIT annual report, bias audit, SB 1421/16 reports). Commissioner Carter Overstone agendized the CIT 2022 report for future discussion. - The minutes of July 12 and July 19, 2023 were adopted 5-0. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: - A mother whose son was murdered on August 14, 2006 (17 years ago) asked the department to find new ways to solve unsolved homicides and to increase rewards or mechanisms for tipsters. She stated her son’s case remains unsolved. - A speaker addressed several DGOs scheduled for approval (2.01, 2.02, 2.03, 5.07, 5.16, 9.01, 9.02) and noted that DGO 9.07 on pretext stops, passed by the commission in January and April 2023, has not yet returned from meet and confer. He urged an update and adherence to the commission’s resolution limiting the meet-and-confer timeline. Discussion Items Chief’s Report Chief Bill Scott reported on crime trends and incidents: - A fatal incident on August 24, 2023 (3500 block of Richmond): a convenience store employee died after a confrontation over shoplifting escalated. The suspect struck the victim with a baseball bat; the victim died August 28. - Two non-fatal shootings (August 30 and September 1) with no arrests yet. - Significant arrests: On September 4, a suspect rammed a stolen vehicle into patrol cars and a building; officers arrested him. On August 31, a robbery suspect was caught in Oakland after a rental van burglary; three firearms (including two AR-style rifles) were recovered. A sexual assault at Crocker Amazon Park on August 31 (juvenile victim) remains unsolved. - Overall crime: Part I crime was down 3% (about 1,200 fewer incidents) driven by property crime (-3.4%). Violent crime was up 4% (+132 incidents). Homicides: 38 this year versus 33 at the same time last year. Firearms recovered: 740 total (112 ghost guns), a 7% increase year-to-date. - Drug enforcement: Year-to-date 467 arrests for public drug use or intoxication since late May 2023; only 1 (now 2) individuals accepted treatment. The department has 8 officers and 1 sergeant on daytime intervention, plus a night squad of 6 officers. - Dolores Hill Bomb: Chief Scott reported he did not have complete updates on whether all youth were (1) handcuffed, (2) mirandized, and (3) released to a guardian, noting investigations by the department and DPA are ongoing. - Bait car program: Reintroduced but resource-constrained; no specific number of cars disclosed. DPA Director’s Report Executive Director Henderson reported that DPA has opened 544 cases year-to-date (468 in 2022), with 298 pending, 39 sustained, and 19 mediated. 21 investigations exceeded nine months (17 due to legal holds). 57 new cases were received in the past four weeks; the top allegation was neglect of duty (18%). The sexual assault kit audit is awaiting the controller’s review. The Dolores Hill Bomb investigation update will be provided in writing by week’s end. Commission Reports - Commissioner Walker reported on ongoing work: recruiting women to the force, childcare feasibility, and the patrol specials program. - Commissioner Carter Overstone agendized two items: (1) the dispute over DPA’s access to department documents and body-worn camera footage for officer-involved shooting investigations; (2) a review of the vehicle pursuit policy, citing recent injuries and deaths. He proposed an officer town hall. - Commissioner Yi highlighted community events and presented a certificate to the SFPD for the Chinatown car show. - Commissioner Yanez requested an update on the juvenile DGO 7.01 draft, which has been delayed for six months. Chief Scott said he would review her email. Sparks Reports (2nd Quarter 2023) SFPD and DPA presented their quarterly policy activity. DPA’s recommendations included: posting all SFPD policies online, increasing CIT unit staffing to a minimum of 8 sworn, raising the age for expedited missing child response to 17, mandating command staff to wear body-worn cameras, and granting DPA access to the department’s BWC viewing platform. Chief Scott expressed conceptual support for most recommendations but opposed the CIT staffing mandate as an operational matter. A debate ensued about DGO 3.01 deadlines; the department argued that some steps lack specific timelines. DPA disagreed, stating that sequential milestones require timely movement. The commission agreed to revisit 3.01. Adoption of Department General Orders - DGO 5.01 (Use of Force) – Amendment to allow preemptive deployment of tire deflation devices (spike strips) outside of pursuits. Data from March 2022 to May 2023 showed 46 preemptive deployments, 86 arrests, and 27 handguns/4 assault rifles recovered; only one minor injury. The commission voted 5-0 to adopt the revised order and send it to meet and confer, with an amendment to strike the word “recklessly” from the condition that an operator is “likely to flee recklessly.” - DGO 2.01 (General Rules of Conduct) – Adopted 5-0 with 30 business day implementation delay. - DGO 2.02 (Alcohol Use) – Adopted 5-0 with 30 business day implementation delay. - DGO 2.03 (Intoxicants/Drugs) – Adopted 5-0 with 30 business day implementation delay. - DGO 5.07 (Rights of Onlookers) – Adopted 5-0 with 90 business day implementation delay. - DGO 5.16 (Search Warrants) – Adopted 5-0 with 90 business day implementation delay. - DGO 9.01 (Traffic Enforcement) – Adopted 5-0 with a typographical amendment (deleting a duplicate paragraph and renumbering) and 30 business day implementation delay. - DGO 9.02 (Vehicle Crashes) – Adopted 5-0 with 30 business day implementation delay. - SB 1421/16 Protocols – Adopted 5-0 with no implementation delay. Key Outcomes - All consent calendar items and minutes were approved unanimously. - The commission voted 5-0 to adopt DGO 5.01 with an amendment to remove “recklessly” and to send it to meet and confer. - Eight other DGOs (2.01, 2.02, 2.03, 5.07, 5.16, 9.01, 9.02, and SB 1421/16 protocols) were adopted unanimously, each with specified implementation delays. - The motion to disclose non-privileged closed-session discussion failed (2–3). The motion to not disclose passed (4–1). - Commissioner Carter Overstone agendized future discussions: the DPA document access dispute, vehicle pursuit policy review, and a presentation on department deployment practices. - The department agreed to provide the Dolores Hill Bomb investigation update in writing. - The commission requested a status update on the juvenile DGO 7.01 draft.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 39% · PROCEDURAL 27% · PUBLIC SAFETY 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7%
937
SEP 6, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - September 6, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee convened on September 6, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman and Member Ahsha Safai. The committee considered ten agenda items, including sole source negotiations, grants, lease agreements, a bond-like certificate of participation, an emergency declaration for Laguna Honda Hospital repairs, and a multi-year permit for concerts at Golden Gate Park's Polo Fields. Most items were recommended to the full Board; the concert permit was sent without recommendation due to outstanding neighborhood concerns. Consent Calendar (No formal consent calendar was used; all items received individual discussion and votes.) Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Fisherman's Wharf Sole Source): No public speakers. - Item 2 (Caltrans Art Maintenance): No public speakers. - Item 3 (Zoo Recycled Water Grant): No public speakers. - Item 4 (Domestic Violence Grant): No public speakers. - Item 5 (Guaranteed Income Exemption): No public speakers. - Item 6 (CHP Communications Lease): No public speakers. - Items 7 & 8 (COP & Laguna Honda Emergency): Rudy Gonzalez (Secretary-Treasurer, San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council) spoke in support, citing the need for improvements at Laguna Honda Hospital and the benefits of the certificates of participation. - Item 9 (Selby & Palou Mini Park Lease): No public speakers. - Item 10 (Polo Fields Concerts): Over 30 speakers, including representatives from labor unions (IATSE, Teamsters, Operating Engineers, Plumbers), small business owners, Richmond and Sunset residents, and community organizations. The overwhelming majority voiced strong support, citing economic benefits, union jobs, tourism, and the positive track record of Another Planet Entertainment. A few speakers noted concerns about traffic and parking but acknowledged ongoing mitigation efforts. Chair Chan noted that many Richmond residents at a previous community meeting had expressed unease about the additional impacts. Discussion Items - Item 1 (230842) - Sole Source Negotiations – Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized, LLC: President Aaron Peskin sponsored the resolution to waive competitive bidding for Port property at Seawall Lot 300/301 and Pier 45, allowing exclusive negotiations with Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalized LLC for a mixed-use development. Port staff Mike Martin and Lou Gerardo presented, emphasizing the need for revitalization and the early stage of the process (24–36 months of exclusive negotiations ahead). Supervisors Chan and Mandelman added as co-sponsors. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (230716) - Maintenance Agreement with Caltrans for Transportation Art: Trent Tiger (Public Works) described the Potrero Gateway Public Art Project, including a maintenance agreement for sculptures on Caltrans right-of-way. The city will perform routine upkeep; $10,000/year estimated cost. The BLA recommended approval. No public comment. Unanimous (3-0) to forward to full Board with positive recommendation. - Item 3 (230816) - Accept Grant – San Francisco Zoo Recycled Water Project: Anahida Fala (SFPUC) presented a $538,051 grant from the California Department of Water Resources to construct a pipeline delivering recycled water to the zoo. Total project cost is $3.975 million, with the balance from SFPUC capital funds. Discussion about water rates: recycled water will be charged the same as potable water due to blended rate structure. Supervisors Chan, Mandelman, and Safai added as co-sponsors. Unanimous (3-0) to forward with positive recommendation. - Item 4 (230814) - Accept Grant – Leveraging Collaboratives to End Domestic Violence Program: Cameron Lucas (Department on the Status of Women) requested retroactive acceptance of a $150,000 grant from Blue Shield of California Foundation to fund the Healing Roots Podcast aimed at addressing domestic violence. A brief administrative delay explained. No public comment. Unanimous (3-0) to forward with positive recommendation. - Item 5 (230702) - Exempt Guaranteed Income from CAAP Determinations: Susie Smith (Human Services Agency) presented an ordinance to exempt payments from guaranteed income pilot programs when determining eligibility for County Adult Assistance Programs (CAAP). This supports a new state-funded pilot for foster youth. Supervisors added as co-sponsors. No public comment. Unanimous (3-0) to forward with positive recommendation. - Item 6 (230480) - Communications Lease with California Highway Patrol: Claudia Gorham (Real Estate) presented a 10-year lease for 400 sq ft and an antenna at Christmas Tree Point, with initial annual base rent of $9,000 (up from $55/month). No public comment. Unanimous (3-0) to forward with positive recommendation. - Items 7 & 8 (230833 & 230811) – Certificates of Participation and Emergency Declaration for Laguna Honda Hospital: These items were considered together. Olivia Chen and Grant Carson presented the $77.17 million COP authorization (not to exceed) to finance critical repairs and street repaving, including $4 million for Laguna Honda water tank replacement. BLA noted total debt service of $136.3 million. Then Ron Alameda (Public Works) presented the emergency declaration for up to $28.4 million in repairs at Laguna Honda Hospital to meet regulatory requirements for recertification. BLA raised concerns about the open-ended nature and suggested amendments. After discussion, Chair Chan proposed amendments to limit the authorization to $28.4 million and to swap out the OMACL cabinet replacement for emergency power replacement. The committee adopted the amendments (3-0) and then forwarded item 8 as amended with a positive recommendation (3-0). Item 7 was also forwarded with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 9 (230573) - Property Lease – Selby & Palou Mini Park: Chris Towns (Rec & Park) presented a 10-year lease renewal for a DOT-owned lot under Highway 280, used as passive open space. Annual base rent $2,000 with 4% annual increases. No public comment. Unanimous (3-0) to forward with positive recommendation. - Item 10 (230710) - Permit Issuance – Another Planet Entertainment – Polo Field Concerts: Sarah Madlin (Rec & Park) proposed a three-year permit for a two- or three-day concert the weekend after Outside Lands, with a minimum permit fee of $1.4 million (two-day) or $2.1 million (three-day) per year. Benefits include free downtown concerts, free Muni for attendees, a $10,000 annual community benefit fund per district, and economic activity ($68 million estimated for Outside Lands). Extensive public comment was overwhelmingly supportive. Chair Chan expressed concerns about impacts on Richmond residents, noting unresolved issues from a community meeting (parking, road access, noise, wildlife). She acknowledged the benefits but sent the item to the full Board without recommendation to reflect that concerns remain. Vice Chair Mandelman and Member Safai voiced strong support. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward without recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3: Moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 4: Moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6: Moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 7: Moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 8: Amended to limit scope and amount ($28.4 million; swap OMACL for emergency power); then moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 9: Moved to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 10: Moved to full Board without recommendation (3-0).

PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · PUBLIC WORKS 14% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 12% · CAPITAL PLANNING 10%
938
SEP 5, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
City and County of San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - September 5, 2023

The Board of Supervisors met in regular session on Tuesday, September 5, 2023, its first meeting after the summer legislative recess, with all 11 members present. The agenda included approval of minutes, consent calendar items, unfinished business on development impact fees, opioid litigation settlements, roll-call introductions, a 2:30 p.m. commendation ceremony, public comment, and the for-adoption-without-committee-reference calendar. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes for June 27, July 11, and the June 26 and June 28 special meetings, 11-0. - Adopted consent items 1 through 6 unanimously, including: a contract amendment with Western Area Power Administration for power and scheduling coordinator services, extending the term and increasing the maximum contract amount to $41,500,000, with a waiver of certain Municipal Code requirements; settlements of unlitigated claims for The Wiseman Group Interior Design, Inc. ($40,000) and AppLovin Corporation ($4,197,820.54 plus statutory interest); the Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District zoning and code amendments; Small Business Month fee waivers including for awning installation and business signs; and the Park Code amendment on PROSAC membership. Discussion Items - Items 7 and 8, the development impact fee ordinances, were passed 10-1 with Supervisor Preston voting no. The ordinances amend the Planning, Building, and Administrative Codes to modify development impact fee indexing, deferral, and waivers, adopt the San Francisco Citywide Nexus Analysis, and make CEQA findings. - Items 9 through 11, the opioid litigation settlements, were passed on first reading 11-0. The ordinances authorize settlements of lawsuits filed by the City and the people of California against Walgreen Co. for $229,610,002 over 15 years; Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc. and related entities for $24,797,604 over 13 years; and Allergan Finance, LLC and Allergan Limited for $12,916,274 over 5 years. The lawsuits alleged public nuisance and unfair competition law violations from misleading opioid marketing and large-volume opioid distribution in San Francisco. Supervisor Preston thanked the City Attorney's office and urged transparency in the use of funds. Controller Ben Rosenfield stated that proceeds will be held in segregated accounts with reporting and eligible-use requirements, that the adopted budget appropriated approximately $100 million in settlement proceeds over the current and next fiscal years, and that payments are front-loaded over a horizon of up to nearly 20 years. Roll Call Introductions - Supervisor Mandelman introduced a resolution proclaiming September Transit Month in San Francisco. - Supervisor Preston introduced a resolution urging the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing to fill at least half of vacant permanent supportive housing units within 90 days and maintain a vacancy rate no higher than 5%. He cited 7,754 people experiencing homelessness, more than 1,000 vacant permanent supportive housing units representing over 10% of the portfolio, and more than 700 units ready for referral. - Supervisor Preston also joined President Peskin in introducing a resolution concerning the UN Plaza activation pilot and the displacement of the Heart of the City farmers market. He stated that the market has operated for 42 years, serves more than 20,000 people on Wednesdays and Sundays, includes more than 50 California farmers, and administers the largest farmers market EBT program in the nation with over $1 million per year in grant-funded incentives. He noted a discrepancy between an initial six-month pilot description and Rec and Park's later description of a two-year pilot. - Supervisor Ronan made extended remarks in support of opening wellness centers and overdose prevention centers, urging the mayor to give a clear mandate to the Department of Public Health. She described visits to New York and Rhode Island, said the city is losing three lives per day to overdose, and introduced an Overdose Awareness Month resolution. - Supervisor Safai introduced a letter of inquiry on retail theft and violence, requesting data from SFPD and the District Attorney and asking the mayor to explain why an assistant district attorney position was denied; announced a student village special use district proposal for downtown; and introduced a resolution recognizing September as Childhood Cancer Awareness Month. - Supervisor Stephanie asked the Controller to audit the HealthRight 360 detox contract, citing a roughly $360 million, 10-year contract and concerns about service delivery and continuity after a COVID-related shutdown. - Supervisors Walton and Chan introduced fire safety and disaster preparedness legislation, including sprinkler inspection changes, sprinkler requirements for accessory dwelling units, and fire safety access requirements. Chan and Peskin pressed for restoration of the city's outdoor emergency siren system, with Peskin indicating he would seek a supplemental appropriation of about $5 million if funding is not identified. Peskin also criticized the $1.8 million UN Plaza skate park proposal as lacking public process and requested a hearing on city corruption. Special Order 2:30 P.M. - Recognition of Commendations - The Board recognized the Asian Firefighters Association for a one-week humanitarian mission to Lahaina, Maui after the August 8 fire. President Stan Lee reported that 12 active and retired firefighters and first responders served at the Lahaina Gateway Center Distribution Depot, served about 2,500 residents and 450 cars daily, provided about 2,200 hot meals per day, raised $6,000 before departure, and helped fight a fire alongside the Maui Fire Department. A second mission is planned for October. Public Comments & Testimony - A farmer associated with the Heart of the City farmers market opposed the farmers market relocation, citing the cost of removing brick, environmental concerns, and lack of consultation, and urged the Board to reconsider. - Several speakers asked the Board to condemn a transphobic conference scheduled at the Hilton Financial District and an associated protest; one speaker expressed support for Supervisor Ronan's overdose awareness resolution and for filling permanent supportive housing vacancies. - John Anderson of 350 San Francisco supported accepting the municipal finance corporation and public bank reports, urging quick and transparent implementation. - Two speakers asked the Board to place an eighth-grade algebra measure on the March 2024 ballot, saying SFUSD's elimination of eighth-grade algebra has hurt student preparation and equity. - A homeless speaker asked for housing assistance and help locating her daughter. - Remote callers asked for funding for the 1150 Fillmore meeting site station, opposed the UN Plaza farmers market relocation and skate park plan, supported restoring the emergency siren system and eighth-grade algebra, and commented on Castro Theater dark nights and dissatisfaction with city services. For Adoption Without Committee Reference - Item 16, commemorating the 50th anniversary of Bruce Lee's passing, was adopted unanimously. - Item 14, accepting receipt of the Final Governance Plan, Business Plan and Viability Study for a San Francisco Municipal Financial Corporation and a San Francisco Public Bank, was adopted unanimously. Supervisor Preston described the plan as a game-changing tool and said San Francisco can create the first municipal bank in the nation, focused on affordable housing, small businesses, underserved communities, and green infrastructure. - Item 17, recognizing September 29, 2023 as Korean Chuseok Day and honoring the Korean Center, was adopted unanimously. - Item 15, the International Overdose Awareness Day resolution, was continued one week to September 12, 2023. Supervisor Dorsey moved the continuance, saying the final resolved clause urging the mayor's office to open new wellness centers made the item non-routine and not eligible for unanimous adoption. He said he supports supervised consumption sites but cannot support wellness hubs without supervised consumption services, and he called for reallocating $18.9 million to jail-based services. Supervisor Ronan defended the resolution and criticized inaction. Supervisors Chan and Melgar added themselves as co-sponsors and supported moving forward; Supervisor Mandelman questioned the Department of Public Health's approach; and Supervisor Preston urged immediate issuance of RFPs. The continuance was accepted without objection. Key Outcomes - The minutes and consent calendar were approved 11-0. - The development impact fee ordinances passed 10-1. - The opioid settlement ordinances passed on first reading 11-0. - The public bank and municipal financial corporation plan was accepted unanimously. - The International Overdose Awareness Day resolution was continued to September 12, 2023. - The Bruce Lee 50th anniversary and Korean Chuseok Day resolutions were adopted unanimously. - The Board recognized the Asian Firefighters Association, and the meeting was adjourned in memory of Joan Joaquin Wood, R. Sherman Layman, and Nancy Werfel.

PUBLIC COMMENT 26% · PUBLIC HEALTH 25% · PUBLIC SAFETY 8% · PROCEDURAL 5%
939
AUG 22, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - August 22, 2023

San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - August 22, 2023\n\nThe San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on August 22, 2023, at 9:45 AM. The meeting included approval of minutes, a quarterly audit report, an update from the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA), consent items, a contract amendment for the Los Vaqueros Reservoir Expansion planning, and a land transfer for the new Treasure Island Wastewater Treatment Plant. Commissioners also heard public testimony on community mitigation commitments and initiated several items for staff follow-up. No closed session was held.\n\n Consent Calendar\n- Item 6a: Awarded Job Order Contract No. JOC-97, General Engineering Construction, to Ground Control Inc. in an amount not-to-exceed $5,000,000.\n- Item 6b: Accepted work performed by Western Water Constructors, Inc., under Contract No. WW-667 for the Mariposa Dry Weather Pump Station Improvements.\n- Both items were approved unanimously by a roll call vote (3-0).\n\n Public Comments & Testimony\n- On Item 5 (BAWSCA Update): Peter Drekmeier (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust) participated in the regional roundtable and praised the process. He urged the SFPUC to conduct sensitivity analyses on demand scenarios, noting that population projections show potential decreases, and cautioned against over-investing in expensive alternative supply.\n- On Item 7 (Los Vaqueros Amendment): Nicole Sandkulla (CEO, BAWSCA) expressed support for the proposed amendment. Peter Drekmeier questioned the investment, suggesting that future nutrient discharge regulations may make wastewater recycling a more multi-beneficial option than the reservoir expansion.\n- General Public Comment (Item 11): Toya Jones and Ronin Jackson, descendants of Dr. Espinola Jackson, spoke about unmet commitments from the Southeast Community Center mitigation agreement. They stated that the PUC promised to keep 1800 Oakdale Avenue as a landmark and to provide college credit courses, senior programs, job training (including biosolids treatment), and other resources at 1550 Evans Avenue. They presented a video of Dr. Jackson meeting with a former general manager and demanded the PUC honor these promises. President Ajami acknowledged the concerns and noted that staff is investigating the four topics previously raised (1800 Oakdale, 1550 Evans, educational building, greenhouses).\n- On Item 12 (Commissioner-Initiated Items): Peter Drekmeier thanked President Ajami for proposing to move general public comment back to the top of the agenda.\n\n Discussion Items\n- Quarterly Audit and Performance Review Report (Item 4a): Irella Blackwood (SFPUC Audit Director) reported that as of June 30, 2023, 18 audits (46% of the year’s plan) were completed, 15 (39%) were in progress, and 6 (15%) were scheduled. Three audits were completed in Q4, including the Energy Center franchise fee audit (focused on $338,000 paid to the city) and two green energy verification audits. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) is conducting a Chapter 6 compliance audit (motion M22-85) involving 24 staff and 400 hours of work on nearly 40 contracts totaling $740 million. A parallel BLA conflict-of-interest audit is also in progress. The bureau anticipates completing 11 audits in Q1 FY24 and launching four new audits. Commissioner Maxwell inquired about the frequency of BLA audits (every three years per department) and possible overlap with internal audits.\n- Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency Update (Item 5): Nicole Sandkulla presented findings from a regional reliability roundtable held via four workshops from May 2022 to February 2023. The effort aimed to identify collaborative one-water opportunities. Project information sheets were collected, mapping surface water, stormwater, recycled water, and other projects with a combined potential yield of 21–40 MGD. Key takeaways include strong interest in grant assistance (to be provided by BAWSCA) and recognition of natural partnerships. Discussion touched on demand management, on-site reuse policies, and the need to differentiate demand reduction from housing opposition. Commissioner Ajami noted that the projects on the map have been similar for a decade, but the timing is now ripe for collaboration due to climate threats.\n- Los Vaqueros Reservoir Expansion Amendment No. 5 (Item 7): Steve Ritchie (Assistant General Manager for Water) presented a request to increase the contract by $8,673,000 (SFPUC share $1,239,000) for planning and extend the duration by 12 months. The project would add 115,000 acre-feet of storage; SFPUC’s potential allocation is 40,000 acre-feet for dry-year supply. Ritchie noted that the schedule is being driven by state/federal grant opportunities and that a final project decision is expected early 2024. Complex negotiations among eight agencies on service agreements, cost allocation, and operational rules are underway. Commissioner Maxwell questioned the certainty of the schedule, and Ritchie answered “cautiously yes.” Commissioner Ajami inquired about the allocation process and modeling. A resolution amendment was proposed to delete a duplicate whereas (the fifth whereas), which was accepted.\n- Treasure Island Wastewater Treatment Plant Land Transfer (Item 9): Staff presented real estate transactions to accept a 7-acre parcel (Block Lot 892801) in fee for the treatment plant and to execute a 66-year lease for 3 acres (Block Lot 8946002) for constructed wetlands at no cost. The treatment plant parcel was removed from the State Lands Commission public trust via a trust exchange; the wetlands parcel remains under trust consistent with public use. The project received a notice to proceed for construction on August 21, 2023. Commissioner Stacy confirmed that all CEQA mitigation measures are being implemented. Commissioner Ajami asked about lease renewal after 66 years and technological options to bypass wetlands if needed. Staff noted that a new lease could be renegotiated or the plant could discharge directly to the bay with regulatory approval.\n\n Key Outcomes\n- Approval of Minutes of August 8, 2023: Approved unanimously (3-0).\n- Consent Calendar: Approved unanimously (3-0).\n- Amendment No. 5 for Los Vaqueros Reservoir Expansion: Approved unanimously (3-0) with an amendment to delete the fifth whereas in the resolution.\n- Certificate of Acceptance and Lease for Treasure Island WWTP: Approved unanimously (3-0) to authorize the General Manager to recommend acceptance and execute the wetland lease.\n- Items Initiated by Commissioners (Item 12): President Ajami requested staff to:\n 1. Move the general public comment period back to the top of the agenda.\n 2. Provide a report on California’s best-value selection requirements for projects, including how SFPUC currently uses best-value procurement.\n 3. Explore holding job fairs at the Southeast Community Center and report on job training programs.\n 4. Prepare a report on TIDA’s electricity issues (brownouts/blackouts) on Treasure Island, including the relationship between SFPUC and TIDA and options for more fundamental system investments.\n- No Closed Session: The closed session was cancelled.

PUBLIC COMMENT 24% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 21% · REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 11% · AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE 10%
940
AUG 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Regular Meeting - August 8, 2023

The Port Commission met on August 8, 2023, at 11:15 AM (adjourned at 5:36 PM) with President Kimberly Brandon, Commissioners Gail Gilman, Ed Harrington, and Stephen Lee present; Vice President Willie Adams was absent. The meeting covered the Executive Director's report on summer waterfront events and equity initiatives, an amended debt policy, a comprehensive maritime portfolio overview, approval of a lease for a distillery tasting room at Pier 50, an informational presentation on establishing a Community Facilities District (CFD) for the Pier 70 Historic Core, authorization of a $2.7 million contract for Pier 50 earthquake improvements, and an update on the San Francisco Waterfront Coastal Flood Study conducted with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes – July 11, 2023: The minutes were approved unanimously by a voice vote. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made in person or remotely on any agenda item. Discussion Items Executive Director’s Report (Item 6A) - Director Elaine Forbes reported on a busy July and early August: events included a Tony Lindsay concert, Ferry Building’s 125th anniversary Summer Ferry Fest (August 17), Crane Cove Park’s new recurring market, and the upcoming APEC summit (November 12–17). She highlighted the transfer of 10 acres of Mission Bay parks, a summer internship program with 21 interns including a maritime cohort, and the Generation Climate youth workforce summit. Commissioners praised staff for activating the waterfront and supporting economic recovery. Commissioner Harrington noted the small staff’s impressive output; Commissioner Gilman shared a personal ferry experience as evidence of tourism return; Commissioner Lee emphasized entertainment’s role in economic recovery. Finance & Administration – Amended Port Municipal Debt Policy (Item 7A, Resolution 2338) - Nate Cruz, Deputy Director of Finance, presented an informational and action item to amend the debt policy (first issued 2009, last amended 2016). Changes included updating SEC Rule 15c2-12 disclosure events and terminology (financial advisor → municipal advisor). The port’s active debt portfolio totals about $70 million (original $85 million) with annual debt service of $6 million. Commissioner Harrington asked about future issuances; Cruz noted potential refinancing is unlikely due to current market conditions. The policy was approved unanimously. Vote: 4–0. Maritime Portfolio (Item 8A) - Andre Coleman, Deputy Director of Maritime, presented an overview of the port’s maritime business. Key statistics: FY2023 revenues were $6 million higher than FY2018–19; record cruise operations – 110 calls, 391,000 passengers, $7.3 million in passenger revenue; auto volumes at Pier 80 up 49% (29,000 units); excursion operations at 80% of pre-pandemic levels; a successful project cargo operation (400 metric tons of fiber optic cable). Near-term objectives include a new ice machine (target late 2024), fuel dock reactivation (TBD), Wharf J9 project (Q4 2024), and a new lease with Martin Marietta at Pier 92. Commissioner Lee inquired about public docking and southern waterfront restaurant opportunities; Commissioner Gilman urged promotion of water taxis. The presentation was informational. Real Estate & Development – Lease with Hotaling & Co. (Item 9A, Resolution 2339) - Jennifer G., Senior Property Manager, presented a proposed new five-year lease for a 3,000 sq. ft. tasting room at Pier 50 Shed B Southwest Bulkhead. Hotaling & Co. (a current non-retail tenant) will operate a distillery tasting room, tours, and events. Base rent $3.75/sq. ft. with 3% annual increases and 7% participation rent; 90-day rent abatement for improvements. Total base rent revenue over the term: $695,000. The lease was approved unanimously. Eric Gilliland, VP of Operations for Hotaling, explained the company’s history (former Anchor Distilling) and brands (Junipero Gin, Old Potrero rye). Commissioners expressed support and requested an invitation to the grand opening. Vote: 4–0. Real Estate & Development – Community Facilities District at Pier 70 (Item 9B) - Wyatt Donald Elandall and Phil Williamson presented an informational update on the Pier 70 Historic Core project (completed last year). Project costs increased from $81M to $140M, but sublease revenues exceeded projections ($44/sq. ft. vs. $29/sq. ft.). The port received $2.5M in 2022 (vs. anticipated $850K in 2024). The CFD would levy two special taxes: a facility tax ($2.73/sq. ft., escalating 2% annually) and a service tax ($0.80/sq. ft., escalating CPI up to 5%), both based on the property’s net leasable area (322,000 sq. ft.). Funds would support Crane Cove Park operations and maintenance. No action taken; a resolution of intention is expected in September 2023, with formation by early 2024 after Board of Supervisors approval and a landowner election (port votes as sole landowner). Commissioner Lee asked about impact on rents; staff noted the taxes are reinvested into site amenities. Waterfront Resilience – Pier 50 Earthquake Improvement Contract (Item 10A, Resolution 2340) - Carlos Cologne, Waterfront Resilience Program Administrator, requested authorization to award a $2.7 million contract to GHD/Structus JV for pre-design and evaluation services for Pier 50 earthquake improvements. The RFP was issued from a pre-qualified pool; four proposals received. GHD/Structus initially submitted a non-responsive bid due to a system upload error, but after investigation the port staff rescinded the non-responsiveness letter, finding the firm acted in good faith. The firm ranked first in scoring. No protests were received. The contract was approved unanimously. Vote: 4–0. Waterfront Resilience – Coastal Flood Study (Item 10B) - Brad Benson, Waterfront Resilience Director, provided an update on the Army Corps-led San Francisco Waterfront Coastal Flood Study. The study is evaluating seven adaptation strategies (defend, accommodate, retreat) with an emphasis on equity, nature-based solutions, and multi-benefit plans. Public outreach involved 16 events, 500+ participants, 170,000+ content interactions. Key public concerns: contamination in the southern waterfront, life safety, transportation disruption, and support for higher sea level rise projections. The Army Corps expects a tentatively selected plan by September 7, 2023, a draft integrated feasibility report in November 2023, and a final recommendation in April 2024. Project costs are likely in the billions; federal share up to 65% with 35% local match. Brian Harper, Army Corps Planning Chief, affirmed the study’s importance as a national model. Commissioners emphasized urgency and asked about accelerating timelines. The presentation was informational. Key Outcomes - Resolution 2338: Approved the Amended Port Municipal Debt Policy (unanimous). - Resolution 2339: Approved Lease L-17080 with Hotaling & Co. for a Pier 50 tasting room (unanimous). - Resolution 2340: Authorized a $2.7 million contract with GHD/Structus JV for Pier 50 earthquake improvements (unanimous). - Consent Calendar: Minutes of July 11, 2023, approved (unanimous). - Informational items: Maritime portfolio, CFD formation, and Coastal Flood Study received with no votes; next steps include returning for CFD action and continued public engagement on flood adaptation.

MARITIME OPERATIONS 15% · PORT MANAGEMENT 11% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 11% · REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 10%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com