Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 981–990 ENTRIES
981
JUN 9, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Special Meeting - June 9, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a special meeting on Friday, June 9, 2023, at 9:45 AM. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Member Asha Safai (arriving later), reviewed eight agenda items. Items included a lease for the YMCA at Crane Cove Park, amendments to a loan for the Balboa Reservoir project, an interagency agreement for the Transbay Downtown Rail Extension, and several Department of Public Health contract amendments and grant acceptances. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, with one amendment to item four. Item 1: Real Property Lease – YMCA of San Francisco – Building 49, Crane Cove Park - The Port of San Francisco presented a proposed 34-year lease (10-year initial term plus options) for Building 49 at 701 Illinois Street within Crane Cove Park. The YMCA will invest at least $5 million in improvements, with initial annual base rent of $92,809.80, escalating annually, plus percentage rent from private tenants. The Port will have no responsibility for maintenance, taxes, or insurance, and the YMCA will provide publicly accessible restrooms. - The Budget Legislative Analyst (BLA) reported that revenue to the Port over 10 years is approximately $288,000, net of credits for public bathrooms and seismic improvements, and recommended approval. - No public comment was received initially. Vice Chair Mandelman asked to be added as co-sponsor and expressed strong support for the project. - A motion to forward to the full board with positive recommendation passed with a roll call of 2 ayes (Mandelman, Chan) and 1 absence (Safai). Later, after Safai arrived, the committee rescinded that vote and re-voted, passing unanimously with 3 ayes. Item 2: Real Estate Loan Document Amendments – BHC Balboa Builders, LLC – Balboa Reservoir Purchase - The SFPUC presented amendments to the loan documents for the sale of the Balboa Reservoir property (purchase price $11.4 million). The project will develop 1,100 housing units, including 550 affordable units (50%), with neighborhood parks, open space, and educator housing. Bridge Housing is the master developer. The amendments allow the developer to proceed with a smaller phase one of 290 affordable units using state grant funds, with a scheduled payment of $2.8 million by December 31, 2026, and release of the deed of trust for phase one parcels. The purchase price, interest, and outside maturity date of December 2028 remain unchanged. - Vice Chair Mandelman expressed strong support, noting prior involvement as a City College trustee, and asked to be co-sponsor. Supervisor Safai also asked to be co-sponsor. - No public comment was received. - The motion to forward with positive recommendation passed unanimously (3 ayes). Item 3: Interagency Cooperation Agreement – Transbay Joint Powers Authority – Phase 2 of the Transbay Program - OEWD presented the proposed interagency cooperation agreement (ICA) for the Downtown Rail Extension (DTX), a 1.3-mile rail tunnel between the Salesforce Transit Center and the Caltrain terminal at Fourth and King Streets. The agreement covers 10 years, with anticipated revenue over $1 million for city consultation and cooperation. Ten city departments will participate, and TJPA will reimburse costs. The TJPA board has already approved the agreement. - Vice Chair Mandelman expressed support, noting the need for a unified city voice, and requested to be added as co-sponsor. - No public comment was received. - The motion to forward with positive recommendation passed unanimously (3 ayes). Items 4–8: Department of Public Health Contract Amendments and Grants These items were considered together after presentations from DPH and the BLA. Discussion included questions about trauma definitions, waitlists, and program reach. Item 4: Contract Amendment – UCSF – Behavioral Health Services for Children, Youth and Families - The amendment increases the agreement by approximately $10.2 million to a not-to-exceed amount of approximately $20 million, and extends the term from June 30, 2023 to June 30, 2027. The contract funds the Child and Adolescent Services (CAS) outpatient program and the Fuerte school-based program for newcomer immigrant youth. DPH reported that staffing issues in FY21-22 had been resolved and the program is on track to meet deliverables. - BLA recommended reducing the not-to-exceed amount to $19.8 million to reflect underspending. Supervisor Safai raised concerns about the definition of trauma and how children qualify, and DPH clarified that eligibility is based on current symptoms, not a time limit on the trauma event. Supervisor Safai also asked about waitlists; DPH noted innovative group modalities and a navigator program but did not provide specific wait times. - The committee passed a motion to amend the resolution to the BLA's recommended amount ($19.8 million). Item 5: Contract Amendment – UCSF – Mental Health Services for Infant Parent Program - The amendment increases the agreement by approximately $5.2 million to a not-to-exceed amount of approximately $14.6 million, and extends the term from December 31, 2022 to June 30, 2028. The infant parent program provides daycare consultation, the Spring Project (mental health consultation for OBGYN providers), and outpatient psychotherapy for children 0-5 and their caregivers. BLA recommended approval, noting no performance issues. - Vice Chair Mandelman requested to be added as co-sponsor, emphasizing the importance of early intervention. Item 6: Accept and Expend Grant – CDC – San Francisco Project INVEST - The retroactive grant of $9,818,147 from the CDC is for a five-year public health infrastructure program (Project INVEST) to strengthen workforce, communication, and data infrastructure. The project period is December 1, 2022 through November 30, 2027. Item 7: Accept and Expend Grant – CDPH – Physicians for a Healthy California – COVID-19 Test to Treat Equity Grant - The retroactive grant of $500,000 from the California Department of Public Health supports COVID-19 testing and treatment for people experiencing homelessness in congregate shelters, including on-site medication delivery and electronic health record tracking. The grant period is December 1, 2022 through June 30, 2023. Item 8: Accept and Expend Grant – CDPH – Syphilis Outbreak Strategy (SOS) Grant - The retroactive grant of $2,668,251 from the California Department of Public Health supports syphilis and congenital syphilis prevention strategies. The grant period is July 1, 2022 through June 30, 2027. DPH noted a 217% increase in female syphilis cases from 2017 to 2020 and that 12% of cases in 2022 were among pregnant people. The grant will expand screening, treatment, and community partnerships. - Vice Chair Mandelman requested to be added as co-sponsor for item 8, and Supervisor Safai requested to be added as co-sponsor for all items 4–8. - No public comment was received for items 4–8. - After the presentations, the committee voted to amend item 4 per the BLA recommendation (passed unanimously), then forwarded items 4–8 as a single committee report to the full board with positive recommendation (passed unanimously). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved and forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation (unanimous after rescinding earlier 2-0 vote). - Item 2: Approved and forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation (unanimous). - Item 3: Approved and forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation (unanimous). - Item 4: Amended to reduce the not-to-exceed amount to $19.8 million, then forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation (unanimous). - Items 5–8: Forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation as a committee report (unanimous). - All items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of June 27, 2023, except items 4–8 which were intended for the June 13, 2023 board agenda as a committee report. - The meeting adjourned, with the next Budget and Appropriation Committee meeting scheduled for 1:30 PM the same day.

PUBLIC HEALTH 48% · PROCEDURAL 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10% · REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 10%
982
JUN 9, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting - June 9, 2023

The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on June 9, 2023, to consider the proposed interim budget for FY2023-2024 and FY2024-2025, the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure (OCII) budget and bond issuance, and a $50 million supplemental appropriation to establish an Office of Reparations. The meeting featured presentations from the Mayor's Budget Office and OCII, extensive public testimony, and committee votes on forwarding two budget items to the full board. The reparations item was continued to June 28, 2023. Public Comments & Testimony Items 1 & 2 (Interim Budget): Multiple speakers from homeless service providers (e.g., Larkin Street Youth Services, Episcopal Community Services, Compass Family Services) strongly opposed the Mayor's proposed reallocation of Proposition C ("Our City, Our Home") funds away from Transitional Age Youth (TAY) and family housing programs toward adult shelter expansion and rapid rehousing. Speakers argued this would increase youth and family homelessness, subvert voter-approved allocations, and ignore a community-driven process. Some speakers also called for greater investment in District 10 and for health protections related to toxic sites in the Bayview/Hunters Point. Item 5 (Reparations): The vast majority of public commenters urged the committee to approve the $50 million supplemental to create an Office of Reparations under the Human Rights Commission. Speakers included members of the African American Reparations Advisory Committee, small business owners, educators, and community advocates. They stressed that the Board of Supervisors had previously committed to reparations and must "put their money where their mouth is." Many noted the historical and ongoing harms of slavery, redlining, redevelopment, and discrimination in San Francisco, and argued that this funding is a crucial first step. A few callers expressed general support for reparations but asked for careful implementation. Discussion Items Items 1 & 2: Proposed Interim Budget and Salary Ordinances – Anna Doening, Director of the Mayor's Office of Budget, presented a high-level overview of the Mayor's proposed two-year budget. She highlighted that the budget closes a $780 million deficit through departmental reductions, use of reserves, and reliance on non-General Fund sources (e.g., Our City, Our Home Fund, opioid settlement dollars). Key investments include: $98.6 million from the Our City, Our Home Fund for homelessness services (adding nearly 600 net new shelter beds), $200 million for behavioral health, $11 million (growing to $35 million) for the Student Success Fund, expanded child care, $25 million for food security, and continued funding for public safety, street cleaning, and the DreamKeeper Initiative. The budget also proposes business tax changes to aid economic recovery. Public testimony focused on opposition to the reallocation of Prop C funds away from TAY and family housing. Items 3 & 4: OCII Interim and Proposed Budgets & Bond Issuance – Thor Kaslofsky, Executive Director of OCII, presented the agency's $712 million budget, noting a $1.6 million reduction to help close the city's deficit. 90% of the budget goes to housing, parks, and infrastructure. Key projects include completion of Bayfront Park (P22) in Mission Bay, affordable housing units across all project areas, and infrastructure for the Hunters Point Shipyard. OCII plans to issue $75 million in bonds to finance enforceable obligations. The committee reviewed OCII's staff vacancies and hiring plans. Item 5: Appropriation of $50 Million from General Reserve for Office of Reparations – Supervisor Shamann Walton, the ordinance sponsor, played a video of all 11 supervisors expressing support for reparations at the March 14, 2023 board meeting. The chair of the African American Reparations Advisory Committee, McDonnell, urged the committee to fund the office to avoid yet another report sitting on a shelf. Dan Goncher from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) office estimated that staffing the office would cost about $1.6 million over two years, leaving $48.4 million for programming. He noted that $50 million is insufficient to implement all 111 draft recommendations but could pilot new programs. The BLA also stated that Proposition 209 does not prohibit the city from investing in historically marginalized communities. During Q&A, the Mayor's Budget Director confirmed that the Mayor's proposed budget does not include funding for a reparations office. Human Rights Commission Director Dr. Cheryl Davis clarified the difference between the DreamKeeper Initiative (which is race-conscious but not exclusively for Black people) and a reparations office (targeted at Black San Franciscans). She suggested the office would need at least $3 million for staffing and operations to be credible. Key Outcomes Items 1 & 2: Moved to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Motion passed 3-0 (Supervisors Chan, Mandelman, Walton voting aye; Supervisors Safai and Ronan excused). These ordinances will appear on the June 27, 2023 board agenda. Items 3 & 4: Moved to the full board with a positive recommendation. The interim budget (item 3) goes to the June 27 board meeting; the proposed budget and bond issuance (item 4) goes to the July 11 board meeting. Motion passed 4-0 (Supervisors Chan, Mandelman, Safai, Walton aye; Supervisor Ronan excused). Item 5: The committee voted to continue the item to the June 28, 2023 meeting of the Budget and Appropriations Committee. Motion passed 3-1 (Supervisors Chan, Mandelman, Safai aye; Supervisor Walton dissented). The continuation allows further budget negotiations to potentially include funding for an Office of Reparations.

REPARATIONS 44% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 14% · PROCEDURAL 6%
983
JUN 8, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - June 8, 2023

This regular meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee was held on June 8, 2023, at 6:15 PM. Chair Supervisor Catherine Stefani, Vice Chair Supervisor Joel Engardio, and Supervisor Matt Dorsey were present. The committee considered two routine liquor license applications and held a combined hearing on Sheriff's Department staffing levels (Item 3) and a resolution to enhance recruitment bonuses for law enforcement (Item 4). Consent Calendar - Item 1 – Liquor License Issuance (Arena SF, 2565 Mission Street): The committee unanimously approved a resolution finding that issuance of a Type 90 on-sale general music venue liquor license to Qualia Entertainment dba Arena SF would serve public convenience. The applicant noted the venue serves a young college-educated Asian American crowd. SFPD recommended approval with conditions including active monitoring, noise control, and uniformed security between 7 PM and 2 AM. No public comment. - Item 2 – Liquor License Transfer (Epicurean Trader, 2240 Market Street): The committee unanimously approved a resolution finding that the person-to-person, premises-to-premises transfer of a Type 21 off-sale general license to The Epicurean Trader would serve public convenience. SFPD recommended approval with a condition to prevent loitering. No public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - A former sheriff's cadet urged faster hiring for San Francisco natives, noting his own background check took 10 months. - Ken Lomba, President of the Deputy Sheriff's Association, criticized the slow hiring process (6–10 months) and argued the Sheriff's Department is treated unequally. He recommended hiring outside services for background checks to reduce time to 3–4 months. - Attorney Yolanda Huang described harmful conditions in jails due to staffing shortages, including excessive lockdowns causing mental health deterioration. She alleged Sheriff Miyamoto's policies moved deputies out of custody positions, exacerbating shortages. - A caller (name not given) supported Sheriff Miyamoto, called for a new jail and full funding of staffing, and argued retention bonuses should be offered to sheriff's deputies as they are to police and fire. - Social work student Ryan Tackett encouraged promoting alternative response units and public service roles to attract younger generations. - Another caller criticized the "patch and release" program and expressed frustration with crime. Discussion Items - Hearing on Sheriff's Department Staffing Levels (Item 3): Chair Stefani opened the hearing, noting the importance of adequate staffing for rehabilitation programs. Sheriff Paul Miyamoto reported 178 unfilled sworn positions (72% staffing out of 978 authorized). He stated that the department is committed to programs like RSVP, Roads to Recovery, and Five Keys Charter School, but staffing shortages limit movement of inmates to programs. He said the department has 18 rehabilitation coordinators and is working to reopen dorm spaces. The committee discussed the impact of shortages on AA/NA meetings, the One Family program, and recreation time. Sheriff Miyamoto noted that the state is currently auditing compliance with Title 15. Supervisor Dorsey highlighted the need to improve hiring processes and asked about inefficiencies. DHR representatives Artis Graham and Dave Johnson described efforts to streamline hiring, including continuous testing, one-day testing events, and proactive communication with applicants. They acknowledged DHR's own staffing shortages (only one 1241 analyst) and said the department is requesting additional analysts in the budget. - Resolution Urging Enhanced Recruitment Bonuses and Staffing Plans (Item 4): Supervisor Dorsey presented the resolution, co-sponsored by Chair Stefani, Vice Chair Engardio, and Supervisor Mandelman. It urges DHR to explore policies to match top recruitment bonuses offered by other Northern California agencies (e.g., Alameda offers $75,000 vs. SF's $5,000). It also urges the Police Commission and Sheriff's Department Oversight Board to develop full-duty staffing plans. The resolution was amended to correct a numbering error (page 6 line 23: "7" corrected to "73") and to split a final clause into two separate clauses for clarity. Key Outcomes - Item 3: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. Chair Stefani stated she would follow up with a letter of inquiry. - Item 4: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to approve the amendments as proposed by Supervisor Dorsey. Then the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the amended resolution to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation.

PUBLIC SAFETY 24% · JUSTICE AND CORRECTIONS 24% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 13% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
984
JUN 7, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - June 7, 2023

The San Francisco Police Commission met on June 7, 2023, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included recognition of an officer, public comment, reports from the Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), discussions on officer discipline and the Chief's hearing process, and a vote on a resolution to rescind two bureau orders. Consent Calendar - Unanimously accepted a $5,000 donation from BXP and Parks Hotel Group for the Officer of the Month awards for January, February, and March 2023. Public Comments & Testimony - Marina Resident (speaking on General Public Comment): Expressed frustration with SFPD's response to drug dealing and encampments by two individuals, Nathaniel and Ashley, in the Marina/Cow Hollow area. Claimed their activities violate the Americans with Disabilities Act and create hazardous sidewalk conditions. Urged enforcement. - James Tyne (22-year Marina resident): Supported the previous speaker, citing ongoing blockages, public health hazards, and dangerous conditions for disabled and elderly residents. - Bicyclist Commenter: Complained that SFPD does not enforce traffic laws for bicyclists, including those on electric bikes. Described a family member hit by a cyclist on the sidewalk. Noted officer initially said cyclists don't have to stop at stop signs, later corrected by a sergeant. Criticized staffing priorities. - Homicide Survivor: Played a video about the Healing Circle for homicide survivors. Noted 60% of homicide victims are people of color. Urged action on unsolved homicides. - Thierry Phil: Advocated for pushing the concept of critical thinking and responsibility in the city's approach to issues. - Paul Allen: Urged the commission to comply with Charter Section 4.102 and develop an annual statement of purpose, emphasizing the commission's significant authority. Suggested a working group. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 5): Chief Scott reported crime statistics: overall Part 1 crimes down 7% year-to-date, property crimes down 8%, violent crime up 5%. Homicides year-to-date: 22 (up from 20 last year). Homicide clearance rate: 95%. Reviewed arrests, including a suspect in the Jermaine Reeves homicide, a stabbing at a bakery, and a robbery of an elderly victim. Announced upgrades to the cold case website. Discussed the new open-air drug enforcement initiative: 8 officers and a sergeant focused on the Tenderloin, making arrests under Health and Safety Code 11550 and 647(f). As of June 6, 25 arrests made; none accepted services. Chief emphasized the initiative is not a pilot but a sustained effort, with coordination through a planned unified command center. Commissioners questioned the initiative's metrics, coordination with public health, and impact on officer morale. Chief also noted a vehicle pursuit review is underway after a fatal incident. - DPA Director's Report (Item 6): Acting Director Diana Rosenstein reported DPA statistics: 263 cases pending (same as last year), 28 sustained (down from 32), 10 cases mediated. Noted 24 cases past the 270-day mark. Also mentioned an enhanced disciplinary study for 2019-2020 is in development. - Commission Reports (Item 7): Commissioners reported activities. President Elias requested agendizing the CHP/National Guard report for next week. Commissioner Benedicto requested a resolution supporting CART. Vice President Carter Overstone reported on working group meetings for DGO 810 (First Amendment surveillance). Commissioner Walker attended the police academy graduation (9 graduates) and is working on recruiting more women. Commissioner Yi attended community events. Commissioner Yanez followed up on pre-booking juvenile diversion. - DPA Key Issue Report: SFPD's Handling of Officer Discipline (Item 10): Steve Flaherty presented two key issues: (1) No written criteria for holding discipline in abeyance; 14 of 126 suspensions (11%) were held in abeyance during 2019-2021. (2) No timeframes for resolving appeals of chief's intended discipline; 55% of DPA cases (28 of 51) were pending chief's hearing for over a year. DPA recommended against using abeyance except in negotiated settlements, citing due process concerns. Chief Scott argued abeyance can be a valuable tool for correcting behavior if codified. Commissioners discussed the need for consistent criteria and timely hearings. - Chief's Disciplinary Hearing Process (Item 9): Commander Paul Yep, Lieutenant Angel Wilhelm, and Sergeant Craig Wells presented. 124 officers are pending chief's hearings. Causes of backlog: COVID-19, staffing shortages, hearing officer availability, lack of data tracking. Changes implemented: setting dates with notice of intent to discipline (since November 2022), hiring an analyst. Proposals: update DGO 2.07 with 180-day timeline, train commanders as hearing officers, and share discovery workload with DPA. Commissioners discussed the feasibility of commanders hearing cases and the need for timely scheduling. - Resolution to Rescind Plain Clothes and Social Media Bureau Orders (Item 11): Commissioner Benedicto introduced a revised resolution stating that the commission disapproves of the department's issuance of Bureau Orders without commission approval. The resolution directs the chief to rescind the Plain Clothes Bureau Order after DGO 5.08 is enacted, and the Social Media Bureau Order after a commission-led DGO process is completed. The chief agreed to the outcomes. After debate, the resolution passed 5-2 (Commissioners Byrne and Yee dissenting). Commissioner Byrne objected to the 10-day deadline for the department to submit a draft, preferring 30 days, and to the first

POLICE OVERSIGHT 36% · PROCEDURAL 20% · PUBLIC SAFETY 20% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8%
985
JUN 5, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
Rules Committee Meeting - June 5, 2023: Appointment and Wild Parrot Designation

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, June 5, 2023, at 9:15 AM (local time) under Chair Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Supervisor Asha Safai. The committee considered two items: the appointment of Elizabeth Winnegrad to the Children and Families First Commission and an ordinance to designate the wild parrot as the official animal of San Francisco. Both items received unanimous support and were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Appointment): Naeema Charles (SF Early Care and Education Advocacy Coalition), Maria (San Francisco Children of Nature Collaborative), and Monique Gidry (Gidry's Early Care and Education Program) spoke in favor of Elizabeth Winnegrad, citing her leadership, strategic planning, and community partnerships. No opposition was voiced. - Item 2 (Wild Parrot): Naeima (SF ECE advocacy coalition) supported the designation, noting a similar successful bill for California's dinosaur. Eileen Bogan (SPEAK) supported the ordinance but urged a strategic plan to protect parrot habitats, food sources, and health. David Pilpel supported the ordinance, noting it does not preclude future designations. Discussion Items - Item 1: Appointment to Children and Families First Commission – Applicant Elizabeth Winnegrad described her 20+ years in early childhood education, including managing the SF ECE program at the Low Income Investment Fund. She discussed the impact of COVID on children and ongoing efforts to connect children to nature. Supervisor Safai praised her work on child care projects in District 11. The committee unanimously recommended her appointment to the full board. - Item 2: Official Animal – Wild Parrot – Mike Farrah (Supervisor Melgar's office) presented the ordinance with bird-themed puns. Chair Dorsey stated that the city can address serious issues while celebrating its blessings. Vice Chair Walton expressed support but noted the process could have been more inclusive, urging public participation. Supervisor Safai highlighted the parrot as a symbol of welcoming and change. The committee voted to send the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (230539): Motion to recommend Elizabeth Winnegrad to seat six on the Children and Families First Commission passed 3-0 (Walton aye, Safai aye, Dorsey aye). Appointment moves to the full Board of Supervisors. - Item 2 (230451): Ordinance to amend the Administrative Code to designate the wild parrot as the official animal of San Francisco passed 3-0 (Walton aye, Safai aye, Dorsey aye). The item moves to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation.

EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 36% · PUBLIC COMMENT 32% · PROCEDURAL 19% · WILDLIFE CONSERVATION 13%
986
JUN 5, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - June 5, 2023

The Land Use and Transportation Committee met on June 5, 2023, beginning shortly after 1:45 PM (following a brief interruption and resumption). The committee considered three agenda items: landmark designation for the Church for the Fellowship of All Peoples, and two related ordinances to promote commercial-to-residential adaptive reuse and downtown revitalization. All items were advanced with amendments; the adaptive reuse items were continued to June 12, 2023. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Landmark Designation): Multiple speakers testified in strong support. Rev. Dorsey Blake, presiding minister of the church, expressed gratitude and noted that Sue Bailey Thurman had hoped for landmark status before her death in 1996. Peter Fitzsimmons shared personal memories of attending the church school in the 1950s and hearing Dr. Howard Thurman speak. Steve Leet, a member of the congregation, praised the welcoming community. Aaron Grizzell, Executive Director of the Northern California Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Community Foundation, emphasized Dr. Thurman's role as a mentor to Dr. King and his legacy. Brian Caston, chair of the church's Board of Trustees, thanked the committee. - Items 2 & 3 (Adaptive Reuse): Marissa Rodriguez, CEO of the Union Square Alliance, enthusiastically supported the legislation, noting it aligned with their strategic plan. Ann Christine from SPUR supported the concept but urged tying incentives to a specific number of units (e.g., first 5,000) rather than a fixed five-year timeline, and recommended adopting the planning commission's suggested modifications. Chris Wright, Vice President of Advance SF, expressed strong support, calling it an essential step. Jim Chapel, a former Union Square Alliance board member, commended the measure. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Landmark Designation for the Church for the Fellowship of All Peoples (File 230493): Planning staff Pilar LaValley presented the case, highlighting the church's significance as one of the first interracial, intercultural, interdenominational churches in the U.S., and its association with Dr. Howard Thurman and Sue Bailey Thurman. The Historic Preservation Commission had unanimously recommended approval. Committee members praised the work and added themselves as co-sponsors. A unanimous vote recommended the ordinance to the full board. - Item 2 – Commercial to Residential Adaptive Reuse and Downtown Revitalization (Files 230371 & 230372): President Peskin and Planning staff Lily Langlois presented the legislation, which streamlines zoning for adaptive reuse of vacant office space in the C3 district east of Van Ness Avenue (expanded to Franklin Street via amendments), diversifies commercial uses, and includes a five-year sunset (2028). Eight amendments recommended by the Planning Commission were adopted, including raising the allowable building addition from 20% to 33% of gross floor area (max one story), waiving TDM requirements for adaptive reuse, and preserving privately owned public open spaces (POPOs). The committee discussed the rationale for waiving bike parking and TDM, with President Peskin arguing that offices had denser occupancy and that such barriers could hinder conversions. The item was continued to June 12, 2023, to finalize amendments. - Item 3 – Development Impact Fees for Adaptive Reuse Projects (File 230372): Presented by Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey's office) and Lily Langlois. This ordinance would waive certain development impact fees for eligible adaptive reuse projects (exempting inclusionary housing fees). Amendments to match the geographic boundary and eligibility criteria of Item 2 were adopted. The committee discussed the specific fees: Transportation Sustainability Fee (TSF) – likely not triggered anyway given office-to-residential direction; Child Care Fee – still applies but at a lower rate; Public Art Fee – only if expansion exceeds 25,000 sq ft; Bike Parking Fee – moot because bike parking requirements are being waived. The item was continued to June 12, 2023, to add a conforming sunset date. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously (3-0) to recommend the landmark designation ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors. - Item 2: Adopted eight amendments as recommended by the Planning Commission, then continued the amended ordinance to June 12, 2023, by a 3-0 vote. - Item 3: Adopted amendments (boundary and eligibility criteria), and continued the amended ordinance to June 12, 2023, by a 3-0 vote. The committee expressed intent to align the sunset date with Item 2.

HISTORIC PRESERVATION 28% · LAND USE 19% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 18% · PROCEDURAL 14%
987
JUN 1, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - June 1, 2023

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on June 1, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan. The committee considered a contract amendment for HealthRIGHT 360, a hearing on community ambassador programs, a response to a civil grand jury report on the emergency firefighting water system, an airport parking contract, and multiple labor agreements. Key actions included forwarding items to the full Board of Supervisors and continuing the ambassador hearing. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (230537): Approved a resolution amending the contract with HealthRIGHT 360 for check-writing services, increasing the amount by $60.6 million to a total not-to-exceed $107,416,172, and extending the term through December 31, 2025. The contract is largely pass-through funds for behavioral health services, with only $35,000 annually for actual check-writing fees. The committee forwarded the item to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Items 5-14: Approved a series of ordinances adopting and implementing memoranda of understanding (MOUs) with various unions, including the San Francisco Fire Fighters Union Local 798 (Units 1 and 2), Municipal Executives Association (Fire and Police), Service Employees International Union Local 1021 (Amendments 2, 3, and 4), and compensation for unrepresented employees. These agreements include a 10.75% general wage increase over three years, retention pay, and specific adjustments for 911 dispatchers and emergency response workers. The committee forwarded all items to the full board with positive recommendations. - Items 15-35: Approved closed session litigation items, including settlements of lawsuits and unlitigated claims, and an authorization to expend funds for Yosemite Slough sediment studies. The committee recommended these items to the full board. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (HealthRIGHT 360): One public commenter expressed skepticism about the large contract amount, questioning the lack of tangible proof of services. No other comments. - Item 2 (Community Ambassadors): Numerous speakers testified in strong support of the community ambassador programs, including representatives from the Latino Task Force, Oasis for Girls, Mission Neighborhood Resource Center, Chinese Culture Center, Tenderloin Community Benefit District, and former ambassadors. They highlighted the programs' role in providing safety escorts, de-escalation, multilingual support, and workforce development. One commenter criticized the lack of standards and accountability, alleging drug dealing by ambassadors. Another caller supported the OCEA program and urged continued funding. - Item 3 (Emergency Firefighting Water System): Two public commenters urged the committee not to accept the studies and to continue the item, citing discrepancies in cost estimates and the need for transparency. They questioned the transfer of the system to the SFPUC and rising cost estimates. - Item 4 (Airport Parking): One commenter, the owner of SF Parking LLC (a local small business), spoke in favor of the contract, highlighting the benefits of the joint venture for small businesses. Discussion Items - Item 2 (Community Ambassadors): The committee held a comprehensive hearing on the city's community ambassador programs, with presentations from the Department of Emergency Management (DEM), Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD), Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs (OCEIA), and others. Key points include: - Inventory: 34 programs identified, 19 public agency-funded and 15 Community Benefit District (CBD) programs. 32 programs operate 7 days a week or weekdays, covering all supervisorial districts. - Funding: Programs use city funds, grants, and special assessment revenue. OEWD funds six programs with $8.5 million annually; OCEIA's CAP program has a budget of $4.1 million for FY23-24, with a drop in FY24-25. - Training: Common training includes de-escalation, Narcan, CPR, crisis intervention, and trauma-informed care. Some programs (e.g., Urban Alchemy) provide advanced scenario-based training. - Accountability: Varies by program; OCEIA ambassadors are city employees with progressive discipline; CBD programs are overseen by their boards. Complaints are handled through program-specific channels. - Geographic Deployment: Historically ad hoc, with new DEM coordinator role to improve coordination. Supervisor Preston noted gaps in coverage, e.g., in the Tenderloin, and called for a needs assessment. - SFPD Ambassadors: Supervisor Preston expressed concern about the use of retired police officers under the

PROCEDURAL 27% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 25% · PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7%
988
JUN 1, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting Summary - June 1, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular meeting on Thursday, June 1, 2023, starting at 1:15 PM UTC. The meeting covered a variety of items including continuances, consent calendar approvals, a major housing density proposal for the West Side, an awning amnesty program, certification of an environmental impact report for SFO's Shoreline Protection Program, two conditional use authorizations (one for a hotel at 420 Sutter Street and one for intermediate length occupancy units at 1550 Mission Street), and a discretionary review withdrawal. The commission voted unanimously on many items, with notable votes on the Family Housing Opportunity SUD and the 420 Sutter Street hotel project. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Continued): The commission unanimously voted to continue the item for 290 San Bruno Avenue (parcel delivery services) to June 15, 2023. - Item 3 (Approved): The commission unanimously approved the conditional use authorization for 3998 18th Street to establish a 1,359 square foot Formula Retail Specialty Grocery Store. - Item 2 (Pulled): 1550 Mission Street was pulled from consent at the request of a public commenter and later heard as a regular calendar item. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: - Eileen Boken (self) expressed concerns about city transparency and credibility, citing survey results (64% and 76%) indicating the city is going in the wrong direction. She questioned the planning department's decisions regarding RHNA allocations and the housing element. - Corey Smith (Housing Action Coalition) expressed support for housing element compliance across the Bay Area and emphasized the need for more ministerial approval of housing. He noted the opportunity for middle-income housing. - Georgia Shudish expressed concerns about the residential flat policy and preservation of existing housing, citing examples of projects she believes are detrimental. - A public commenter (name not captured) raised concerns about tenant displacement protections under SB 330, questioning how the department will verify developers' claims and enforce right-to-return provisions. - Francisca Acosta expressed concerns about the housing element's 82,000-unit goal and quality of life issues, and criticized the commission's land acknowledgement for not honoring the Moach Malone tribe. Discussion Items - Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District (Item 8): - Supervisor Melgar introduced the ordinance, emphasizing the need for more housing types on the West Side, including for seniors, families, and young adults. She highlighted the history of redlining and zoning that limited density. - Supervisor Engardio voiced support and previewed future amendments to allow six-story buildings on corner lots (up to 65 feet), with potential height bonuses for lot mergers. - Planning staff (Veronica Flores) presented eight recommended modifications, including incorporating RM1 zoning, adjusting density exceptions, and removing certain ownership requirements. - Public comment included support from the Housing Action Coalition and San Francisco Land Use Coalition, but opposition from groups like the Race Equity and All Planning Coalition, who argued the legislation lacks affordable housing guarantees and anti-displacement protections. - The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to approve the ordinance with staff recommendations 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, and 8, but not recommendations 3 and 4. - Awning Amnesty Program (Item 9): - Katie Tang (Office of Small Business) presented the ordinance on behalf of Mayor Breed and Supervisor Peskin, aimed at helping small businesses comply with unpermitted awning and sign regulations. - Planning staff (Aaron Starr) recommended modifications, including limiting the program to business signs and removing the five-year look-back requirement. - DBI representative Patrick Hannon expressed concerns about waiving sign inspection requirements and fees, citing cost and safety. - The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to approve with staff recommendations, despite DBI's concerns. - SFO Shoreline Protection Program (Item 10): - Staff (Tanya Schainer) presented the final EIR for the Shoreline Protection Program, which aims to protect SFO from flooding and sea level rise. - Public comment included the Mayor of Millbrae, who requested a delay to address noise and vibration concerns from the project. - The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to certify the final EIR. - 420 Sutter Street Hotel (Items 11a-c): - The project proposes demolishing a two-story building and constructing a 12-story, 149-room hotel with ground-floor bar/restaurant and rooftop public open space. - Public comment included support from Unite Here Local 2 and the Union Square Alliance, but opposition from San Francisco Heritage, who argued the design is incompatible with the historic district. - During deliberation, several commissioners expressed preference for residential use but supported the hotel for its potential economic benefits. - The commission approved the project and conditional use authorization with a 4-2 vote (Commissioners Imperial and Moore dissenting). The Zoning Administrator granted the variance for bike parking. - 1550 Mission Street ILO Units (Item 2): - The project proposes designating 40 dwelling units as intermediate length occupancy (ILO) units in a 549-unit building. - Public comment raised concerns about the pace of ILO designations and the concentration of ILOs in certain buildings. - The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to approve the conditional use authorization. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unanimously continued to June 15, 2023. - Item 3: Unanimously approved (6-0) for consent. - Item 8: Unanimously approved (6-0) with staff recommendations 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, and 8; recommendations 3 and 4 were not adopted. - Item 9: Unanimously approved (6-0) with staff recommendations. - Item 10: Unanimously certified the final EIR (6-0). - Item 11a-c: Approved (4-2) with conditions; variance granted by Zoning Administrator. - Item 2: Unanimously approved (6-0). - Item 12 (Discretionary Review): Withdrawn by the applicant. Commissioner Braun's motion to approve the Family Housing Opportunity SUD incorporated staff recommendations 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, and 8, but not 3 and 4. The commission also directed the planning director to arrange a meeting with the Mayor of Millbrae to discuss concerns about the SFO project.

PUBLIC COMMENT 18% · HOUSING 18% · PROCEDURAL 10% · LAND USE 9%
989
MAY 25, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Regular Meeting - May 25, 2023

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, May 25, 2023. Chair Supervisor Catherine Stephanie presided, with Vice Chair Joel Ingario and Supervisor Dorsey also present. The clerk was Mr. John Carroll. The committee considered four agenda items: a liquor license for a music venue, a health code amendment regarding conservatorship proceedings, a resolution supporting state behavioral health legislation, and a police code amendment to cease accepting new cannabis retail permit applications. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, expected to appear on the Board's agenda of June 6, 2023. Agenda Item 1: Liquor License Issuance - 628 Divisadero Street - The Independent Officer Salmuson from the SFPD ABC Liaison unit reported zero letters of protest and zero letters of support for the Type 90 on-sale general music venue liquor license. The location is in plot 6-4-2, which is considered high crime, and in census tract 164, which is considered high saturation. The Northern Police District has no opposition. Two conditions were recommended: (1) the petitioner shall actively monitor the area under their control to prevent loitering on adjacent property, and (2) between 12 noon and 2 a.m. or at any time the premise is providing entertainment, the petitioner shall provide at least one uniform security guard licensed by the California Department of Consumer Affairs. John Gunton, general manager of The Independent for 10 years (with 5 prior years at the venue), spoke in support, noting the venue is approaching its 20th anniversary in February. He stated the license would allow them to compete in an increasingly competitive market and that they take the well-being of the neighborhood seriously. The committee voted unanimously to forward a resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. Agenda Item 2: Health Code - Designating City Attorney for Conservatorship Proceedings Jackie Thornhill, legislative aide to Supervisor Mandelman, presented the ordinance. Section 4121 of the health code currently designates the city attorney for most conservatorship proceedings but the district attorney for Murphy conservatorships (for individuals found mentally incompetent to stand trial under Section 1370 of the state penal code with outstanding felony charges involving great physical injury or death of another person). The ordinance consolidates all conservatorship proceedings in the City Attorney's office, noting these are civil, not criminal, proceedings. The District Attorney's office has informed the committee they support the ordinance. Public comment: Ken from San Francisco commented on an out-of-state case involving a man released from custody after being ruled incompetent, and expressed broader criticism of the board's approval rating and public sentiment. Supervisor Dorsey, who previously worked in the City Attorney's office, supported the ordinance and noted both offices are in agreement. The committee voted unanimously to send the ordinance to the full board. Agenda Item 3: Supporting SB 43 and SB 363 (Eggman) - Behavioral Health Modernization Jackie Thornhill presented the resolution urging the California State Legislature to pass SB 43 and SB 363, authored by Senator Susan Eggman. SB 43 would amend the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act to expand the definition of "gravely disabled" for conservatorship eligibility to include conditions that will result in substantial risk of serious harm to the physical or mental health of a person due to a mental health disorder or substance use disorder. SB 363 would require the State Department of Health Care Services to develop a real-time online dashboard displaying information about the number of beds available in different types of facilities across the state. The resolution is endorsed by the Big City Mayors Coalition, the National Alliance on Mental Illness California, the State Association of Psychiatrists, and the Psychiatric Physicians Alliance of California. Supervisor Dorsey added her name as co-sponsor. The committee approved amendments presented with the legislation and voted unanimously to send the resolution to the full board with positive recommendation as amended. Agenda Item 4: Police Code - Ceasing Acceptance of New Cannabis Retail Permit Applications Supervisor Safai presented the ordinance to cease acceptance of new cannabis retail permit applications. He stated the purpose is to support the existing cannabis industry and address neighborhood concerns about saturation. He noted that Proposition 64 legalized adult use cannabis, and San Francisco built on an existing network of medical cannabis providers dating back to Proposition 215. He cited the equity program requiring at least 40% ownership by verified equity applicants, the backlog of pending applications, the need to focus on enforcement against the illegal market, and concerns about underage usage. Nikesh Patel, Director of the Office of Cannabis, presented data on the retail market landscape: - 33 equity-owned businesses currently permitted by the Office of Cannabis (31 storefront retail, 2 delivery-only) - 47 legacy businesses (32 medical cannabis dispensaries permitted by the Department of Public Health, 15 delivery-only retail businesses) - Approximately 100 pending applications from verified equity applicants (63 storefront retail, 9 delivery-only, 28 micro businesses) - 71 pending applications from non-verified equity applicants (legacy businesses), of which approximately 24 are very unlikely to move forward because they have been inactive for a significant period - 292 verified equity applicants who have not yet submitted applications for cannabis business permits, with 5 additional individuals currently in the process of being verified - Office of Cannabis processing time has been reduced from approximately 18 months to 9-12 months - The Office of Cannabis recommended including a sunset provision based on a metric or timeline, and providing additional runway for the 292 verified equity applicants to submit applications Public comments in support included: - Marlene Tran, community activist in Visitation Valley and retired teacher, thanked the sponsors and stated Visitation Valley has been "plagued" with several cannabis proposals, two of which were accepted, and "we really don't want that kind of services" in the low-income bedroom community. - Hazel Lee, living in the Portola area, noted a short street already has one cannabis store and another is proposed near a children's learning center, stating "This is really ridiculous" and expressing support for Supervisor Safai. - Jakari Donaldson, equity owner and CEO of California Street Cannabis Company, stated equity owners are "facing an extinction event," that "we simply have too many dispensaries and not enough customers," and that operators are not permitted federal bankruptcy protections, so if they cannot meet tax burdens they will be "financially ruined for potentially the rest of our lives." - Ben Blyman, civilian and dispensary owner in the equity program, stated cannabis businesses were "sold a bill of goods" and are "in dire, dire straits." He suggested additional provisions including pausing licenses that have not received land use approval, asking the planning department to weigh saturation more heavily, adding buffer zones, and enforcing the 45-day permit shot clock. - Bram Goodwin, Brownie Mary Democratic Club, rose in support but requested an academic-style study on retail as part of the moratorium, stating "we're really flying blind." - Malcolm Joshua Whites, social equity owner of a cannabis club on Union Street, stated the equity applicant owner's portion is "worth nothing" due to oversaturation, and requested that social equity applicants with leases and approved building permits be granted up to a year from when the ordinance takes effect to secure new investors. - David Hooper supported the measure, citing oversaturation relative to the number of buyers with disposable income and the time spent on contested cannabis applications. - Johnny Delaplane, President of the San Francisco Cannabis Retailers Alliance, stated the alliance "100% support[s] this legislation as written" and would be open to further amendments limiting the total number of cannabis retail stores. - Connor Johnston, co-owner of social equity retail locations, supported the legislation but expressed discomfort with "strange bedfellows" created alongside anti-cannabis reactionaries. He noted the illegal market in California is twice the size of the legal market, and recommended setting the trigger as whether an applicant has received land use approval. - Nina Parks, representing Equity Trade Network, supported a moratorium but wanted more conversation on the timeframe, stating the market is oversaturated and cannot continue to support what exists. Public comments in opposition included: - Tony argued the city has fewer than half the dispensaries it had under the medical system in 2008, and stated cannabis is important for fighting nuclear and biological threats. - Chris Callaway, described as San Francisco's first equity retail dispensary permit holder, opposed preventing businesses from opening in the city, advocated for a fair market approach, and requested that if the legislation passes, an exemption be carved out for 100% equity-owned businesses. - Shauna Goknar, Executive Director of Access of Love SF, stated the organization stands in opposition until there is a fuller conversation, noting state grant money for medical cannabis research, arguing "we cannot use equity like a controlled crash," and reporting that very few dispensaries have compassion programs despite SB 34. - Gilbert, a disabled veteran who uses cannabis instead of pharmaceuticals, argued the committee is being "gaslit and deceived," stated no data was presented, and questioned the saturation claims. Supervisor Chan joined the meeting and proposed an amendment, to be considered at the full board, requiring the controller to submit a report to the Board of Supervisors no later than June 30, 2027, analyzing the financial impact of the moratorium on the city and the city's cannabis industry, the operational impact on the Office of Cannabis, and the impact on city neighborhoods. She noted the cannabis business tax will become effective again in January 2026 and the report would allow the board to assess tax revenue before deciding whether to continue the moratorium. Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson stated the language was drafted but not yet approved as to form, and it is likely not to be a substantive amendment. Supervisor Dorsey expressed support, noting the importance of supporting law-abiding businesses from unfair and illegal competition from the illegal drug marketplace, and asked to be added as a co-sponsor. The committee approved amendments presented by Supervisor Safai and voted unanimously to send the ordinance to the full board with positive recommendation as amended. Supervisor Chan's amendment will be finalized and considered at the full board. Key Outcomes - All four agenda items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. - Agenda Item 1 (Liquor License - The Independent): Unanimous vote to prepare a resolution finding the issuance would serve public convenience or necessity. - Agenda Item 2 (City Attorney for Conservatorships): Unanimous vote to send the ordinance to the full board. - Agenda Item 3 (SB 43 and SB 363 Support): Amendments approved unanimously; resolution sent to the full board with positive recommendation as amended. - Agenda Item 4 (Cannabis Retail Permit Moratorium): Amendments approved unanimously; ordinance sent to the full board with positive recommendation as amended. Supervisor Chan's amendment requiring a controller's economic report by June 30, 2027, will be considered at the full board. - Items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda of June 6, 2023.

CANNABIS REGULATION 79% · PROCEDURAL 5% · BEHAVIORAL HEALTH 5% · PUBLIC COMMENT 5%
990
MAY 25, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting – May 25, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, May 25, 2023, at approximately 1:00 PM. Chair President Tanner presided, with Vice President Moore and Commissioners Braun, Diamond, Imperial, and Coppel present. Commissioner Ruiz was absent. The meeting covered continuances, routine approvals, and three substantive items: a conditional use authorization (CUA) to remove an unauthorized dwelling unit at 19 Heron Street, a CUA to subdivide and redevelop 32 Byxbee Street, and a mandatory discretionary review (DR) for Sutro Tower’s cladding removal. All votes were unanimous. Consent Calendar - Items 1 & 2 – Continuances: The commission unanimously (6-0) continued Item 1 (Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District) to June 1, 2023, and Item 2 (326 27th Street CUA) to July 27, 2023, after taking no public comment. - Item 4 – Adoption of Minutes: Draft minutes for March 23, April 27, May 4, and two May 11 meetings were approved unanimously (6-0) without public comment. Public Comments & Testimony General Public Comment (before regular calendar): - George Ashutish criticized demolition calculations, alleging that housing losses are disguised as alterations, and urged the commission to read his emailed comments on the Sanchez Street project. - David Osgood (Rincon Point) opposed new signs on the landmark Rincon Annex, arguing they are unnecessary and that streamlined permitting harms historic resources. - A caller from the California Office of Traffic Safety noted that California leads the nation in accidents involving bicyclists, pedestrians, and motorcyclists, and asked to share safety program details. - Logan (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods) questioned whether the housing element accurately accounts for west-side/east-side differences in PDR sites, demographics, market dynamics, and flood risk. Public Comment on Sutro Tower (Item 10): - Siou Ling Chen (Midtown Terrace liaison) opposed requiring an annual open house, stating Sutro Tower already engages with neighbors through other events. - Michael Farrell (Aide to Supervisor Myrna Melgar) read a letter from the supervisor supporting the project but raising concerns about lead paint on salvaged panels and road repairs, and emphasizing the need for student engagement. - Walter Kaplan (Forest Knolls liaison) urged the commission to remove the salvage panel distribution (due to lead paint) and the annual open house requirement, while supporting the overall agreement, especially the road repair. - George Wooding (Midtown Terrace Homeowners Association) supported vertical cladding elimination but opposed certain proposed conditions, favoring Supervisor Melgar’s alternative recommendations and seeking limited road repairs. Discussion Items - Item 5 – Commission Comments/Questions: Commissioner Imperial expressed concern about the vacancy of the C2Y (Citywide) Director after Anne Marie Rogers left, stressing the need for a diverse pool and a person of color in the role. Director Hillis responded that Rogers took a job at Treasure Island, and the department will seek commission input on the hiring process and job description. Hillis also noted that Claudia Flores is leaving for the Office of Racial Equity, and both will be invited to future meetings for recognition. - Item 6 – Director’s Announcements: Director Hillis mentioned that the Urban Land Institute (ULI) has conducted a technical services panel on downtown issues (office vacancy, conversions, ground-floor activation) and will present findings to the city and commission. - Item 7 – Review of Past Events: Aaron Starr (Manager of Legislative Affairs) reported on recent Board of Supervisors actions: the Land Use Committee recommended landmark designation for Westwood Park gates and a fee waiver for small businesses; the full board passed two Home SF ordinances and continued the Castro Theater landmark amendment. Two CUA appeals were heard: at 301 Tolland (Waymo parking garage) the board voted unanimously to overturn the commission’s approval, and at 1160 Mission Street the board approved amended conditions after a settlement. - Item 8 – 19 Heron Street (CUA to remove unauthorized unit): Staff presented a request to remove a 3,200-square-foot unauthorized nine-bedroom dwelling unit from the second floor of a historic industrial building in Western Soma. The project sponsor argued that legalizing the unit was financially infeasible given the industrial context and concrete construction. No public comment was submitted. Commissioners expressed concern about safety of the unpermitted unit and asked about enforcement follow-up; staff confirmed the conditions of approval would be recorded and the enforcement case would remain open until removal is verified. The commission approved the CUA unanimously (6-0) with staff conditions. - Item 9 – 32 Byxbee Street (CUA for subdivision and two homes each with ADU): Staff described a project to subdivide a 5,000-square-foot lot into two 2,500-square-foot lots, demolish an existing single-family home, and build two new three-story homes (30.5 ft tall) each with a ground-floor ADU (total 4 units). The sponsor noted that an SB9 triplex option was ineligible due to a prior LSA act. No public comment. The commission praised the design and density increase. Approved unanimously (5-0, with Commissioner Moore apparently recused? but listed as aye; transcript says 5-0). - Item 10 – 1 La Avanzada Street (Sutro Tower – Mandatory DR for cladding removal): The project seeks permanent removal of metal panel cladding from Sutro Tower’s vertical legs, repainting the remaining structure in white and orange. An informational hearing in fall 2022 had directed staff to evaluate the no-clad alternative. Staff recommended approval with preservation conditions, including off-site interpretive panels, salvage panel distribution, roadway repairs, and an annual open house. The sponsor (Kristen Thal Peters) supported the project but opposed the salvage panel condition (lead paint concerns) and the open house, and proposed a student engagement alternative. After extensive public comment, Commissioner Diamond moved to approve with amendments: remove the fallback on-site interpretive panel location, delete the salvage panel condition entirely, delete the annual open house requirement, and add a student engagement condition (Condition 1B from sponsor’s proposal, with updated references). The motion was seconded and passed unanimously (5-0, but roll call listed 6 ayes; transcript says 5-0). Key Outcomes - Continuances: Approved for Items 1 and 2. - Minutes: Approved for four prior meetings. - Item 8 (19 Heron Street): CUA approved (6-0). The unauthorized residential unit must be removed, and enforcement will continue until completion. Conditions recorded on title. - Item 9 (32 Byxbee Street): CUA approved (5-0). Subdivision and construction of two single-family homes each with an ADU (4 total units) allowed. - Item 10 (Sutro Tower): Discretionary review taken and project approved with amended conditions (5-0). Key changes: (1) Interpretive panels must be off-site; no on-site fallback. (2) No requirement to distribute salvaged panels due to lead paint. (3) No annual open house requirement. (4) Added Condition 1B – student engagement: sponsor to commission an artist to create a work inspired by the tower and present it to students at Clarendon Elementary within 18 months. Cleanup and road repair conditions retained. Commission also commended staff and neighbors for collaborative process.

PUBLIC COMMENT 26% · CONDITIONAL USE AUTHORIZATION 26% · ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 17% · PROCEDURAL 15%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com