Public Meetings - Torrance, California

No agenda or minutes were available for this meeting. The transcript captures a cooking demonstration focused on a Parmesan squash recipe. The speaker described a dish involving fresh ingredients, hazelnuts, and butter, attributed to a famous English chef known for vegetarian dishes. The recipe was presented as suitable for side dishes or main dishes, especially during holidays, and noted that squash is available year-round in Southern California. The participants discussed the versatility and health benefits of squash.

The Torrance City Council held a regular meeting on December 17, 2024, beginning with a closed session at 5:00 p.m. and reconvening for public business at approximately 6:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber. The meeting lasted until approximately 1:07 a.m. the following day. Key actions included adoption of a mobile home space rent stabilization ordinance (SRSO), approval of a 260-unit townhome development (Fashion Square at Del Amo), extension of the city’s 3290 temporary housing program for homeless individuals, and approval of a contract for supplemental parking enforcement. Several consent calendar items were also approved. Consent Calendar - Item 8A: Adopted Resolution 2024-90 setting wages and working conditions for Torrance City Employees Association (TCEA) for FY 2024-2028, with a total expenditure of $1,454,464. - Item 8B: Approved plans, specifications, and a public works agreement for citywide traffic signal improvements at Lomita Blvd and Madison St (T-171), appropriating $537,790 in HSIP grant funds and awarding a contract to PTM General Engineering Services, Inc. for $615,015 (with a 15% contingency), for a two-year period. - Item 8C: Adopted Ordinance 3940 (second reading) granting a pipeline franchise to Zenith Energy West Coast Terminals LLC. - Item 8D: Adopted Ordinance 3941 (second reading) amending the municipal code on original art display and establishing a mural policy. - Item 8E: Approved a cost-sharing MOU with Hermosa Beach, Manhattan Beach, and Redondo Beach for the Beach Cities Green Streets Project (S-194) and appropriated $550,607 in Measure W funds. - Item 8F: Authorized submission of Torrance Transit’s Agency Safety Plan for FY 2024-2025. - Item 8G: Authorized a purchase order with Rush Truck Centers for 34 replacement vehicles ($2,796,887). - Item 8H: Approved an easement quitclaim deed with Torrance Unified School District for the Hamilton Adult Education Center. - Item 8I (pulled for discussion): Approved a consulting services agreement with Chee Salette for design and construction administration of the WWII Camp Wall Monument at Columbia Park (not-to-exceed $500,000). - Item 8J: Approved Transit Department participation in the Statewide Transit Mutual Assistance Compact (TransMAC). - Item 8K (pulled for discussion): Awarded a contract to ACE Parking Management, Inc. for supplemental parking enforcement services ($565,594) for one year. - Item 8L: Accepted and filed the Investment Report for October 2024. - Item 8M: Approved side letter agreements with Torrance Fire Fighters Association (bilingual pay) and Torrance Municipal Employees-AFSCME Local 1117 (parking enforcement). - Item 8N: Approved City Council minutes of November 19, 2024. - Item 8O: Approved an eighth amendment to the legal services agreement with Rutan & Tucker LLC ($1,500,000) for Hi-Shear litigation costs. - Item 8P: Accepted and filed October 10, 2024 meeting minutes of the Community Planning and Design Committee. - Item 8Q: Approved a consignment agreement with Fitz Contemporary for artwork loan to Torrance Art Museum. Public Comments & Testimony - Oral Communications (General): Six speakers addressed the council. Topics included: - Paul Vallejo urged the city to publicize anti-discrimination ordinances and enhance training for employees and law enforcement to address rising hate crimes, particularly against LGBTQ+ individuals. - Joe Edwards called for sustained funding for HIV prevention, PrEP, and support services. - Charlie Salinas spoke about misdirected anger and the need for respectful treatment. - Carrie and Mary Ann spoke about the death of Christopher DeAndre Mitchell in 2018, demanding an independent civilian police oversight commission; they noted it was the sixth anniversary of his death. - One speaker sarcastically praised the council for raising fees and giving $30,000 raises to leaders, expressing concern about affordability. - Public Hearing 9A (Mobile Home Rent Stabilization): Approximately 15 speakers testified, overwhelmingly in support of the SRSO. Speakers included Assemblymember Al Muratsuchi (who urged passage), a representative from Supervisor Janice Hahn’s office (supporting preservation of affordable housing), and numerous residents of Skyline Mobile Home Park. Residents described rent increases ranging from 10% to 18% annually, with one reporting a 91% increase over a year. Many said their fixed incomes (Social Security) could not keep up, forcing them to consider leaving their homes. Mike Masera, representing park ownership, defended the owner’s subsidy program and offered to reopen multi-year leases if the SRSO were not adopted. Several speakers criticized the subsidy as unenforceable and a “smoke screen” for excessive increases. One resident said she was “terrified.” - Public Hearing 9B (Fashion Square at Del Amo): Two speakers commented. Don Lamb (applicant) presented the project, highlighting its 260 ownership townhomes, compliance with zoning, and traffic impact (estimated 135 additional daily trips). One resident asked for clarification on modifications to variance and development permit boundaries; staff explained the changes align with Del Amo Fashion Center entitlements. One speaker (Andy Porchop) supported the project but raised concerns about drainage from a nearby restaurant. - Public Hearing 9C (Benevolence Industries Bonds): Two speakers commented, questioning why the council needed to act on a bond issuance where the city has no financial liability. Staff explained it was a federal TEFRA requirement. - Item 10A (Artesia Blvd Recycled Water): One speaker criticized the use of recycled water for irrigation as a health concern and supported discontinuing it. - Item 10B (Homeless Update): One speaker (Andy Porchop) criticized the program as spending millions while homelessness persists, noting that some of tonight’s mobile home residents may become homeless. - Item 10F (Budget Review): One speaker (Andy Porchop) complimented the presentation but criticized tax and fee increases. - Item 10G (KPIs): Same speaker made comments about boredom and taxes. - Item 10H (Investment Report): Similar remarks from the same speaker. Discussion Items - Item 8I (WWII Camp Wall Monument): Councilmember Kalani noted the project was years in the making and thanked Assemblymember Al Muratsuchi for securing a $5 million grant. The item was approved unanimously. - Item 8K (Supplemental Parking Enforcement): Councilmembers discussed the contract’s scope, revenue neutrality, and consistency with existing street sweeping regulations. Assistance Police Chief Jeff Clark explained enforcement would focus on street sweeping violations but could address other parking issues. Councilmember Matucci initially wanted to table due to lack of information but after discussion made a motion to approve, emphasizing that enforcement should not occur after the sweeper passes. Councilmember Sheikh requested more detail but then supported the motion. The motion passed 7-0. - Item 9A (Mobile Home Space Rent Stabilization Ordinance): Following the public hearing, council members debated the proposal. Councilmember Sheikh expressed strong support, calling it a “rent stabilization ordinance” (not rent control) and a matter of local control. Councilmember Kalani disclosed meetings with residents and ownership, asking detailed questions about the subsidy program; ownership representative Mike Masera stated that if the SRSO passed, the subsidy program would terminate. Councilmember Lewis asked about lease terms and the impact on future increases. Councilmember Gerson argued that mobile home parks are the safest real estate investments and that the city should not be in the business of negotiating contracts; he said his conscience drove him to support the ordinance. Councilmember Matucci opposed, arguing it strips property rights and noting that Proposition 33 (statewide rent control) failed. The council voted 5-2 to approve the SRSO (first reading, ordinance to return for second reading in January), with Councilmembers Gerson and Sheikh voting no. The motion to close the public hearing passed 7-0. - Item 9B (Fashion Square at Del Amo Project): Staff presented the 260-unit townhome development on 16 acres at Carson and Madrona. The project includes 37 buildings (3-5 stories), 699 parking spaces (2.7 per unit), and a gated community. The Planning Commission had approved it 7-0. Councilmembers asked about cost, sales price (estimated $850,000 to $1.1 million), and community outreach. The applicant reported one outreach meeting with 11 attendees, mostly supportive. The council voted unanimously to approve the mitigated negative declaration, conditional use permit, development permit, subdivision, modification of variance, and modification of development permit (6 resolutions). - Item 9C (Benevolence Industries Revenue Obligations): After a brief public hearing, the council unanimously adopted Resolution 2024-98 approving the issuance of up to $37 million in tax-exempt bonds for health facility acquisitions, including a Torrance location. The city has no financial liability. - Item 10A (Artesia Blvd Recycled Water Discontinuation): Staff presented that due to cross-connection health concerns, the city would permanently stop using recycled water for irrigation on Artesia Blvd parkways between Hawthorne and Western, and return maintenance to property owners. Council unanimously approved. - Item 10B (Homeless Update & 3290 Extension): Staff provided a comprehensive update: since July 2022, 38 clients from the 3290 temporary housing site have been permanently housed, 53 connected to healthcare, and the street outreach team has responded to 710 outreach requests and permanently housed 34 individuals. The total cost to operate 3290 is $1.867 million annually, funded by federal/state grants and Measure SST as a backup. Councilmembers discussed the need for faster throughput, better outreach response times, enforcement of the anti-camping ordinance, and reliance on county/state funding. Councilmember Matucci expressed frustration that local SST funds might be used in place of county funds. Councilmember Gerson moved to accept the report and extend 3290 through June 30, 2028; the motion passed unanimously. - Items 10F, 10G, 10H (Finance Committee Items): These items were taken up late in the meeting (after 12:30 a.m.). - 10F: First quarter budget review showed a projected general fund increase of $5.5 million and a net increase of $4.2 million across funds. Program modifications were approved. - 10G: Approved Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for city departments and priorities for the FY 2025-27 budget. Councilmember Gerson questioned a KPI regarding increased felony filings; staff explained it was a target to measure prosecution outcomes, not a quota. The motion passed with Gerson voting no. - 10H: Accepted the first quarter investment portfolio report, showing a portfolio yield of 4.489% and $3.448 million in earnings. Key Outcomes - Adopted Mobile Home Space Rent Stabilization Ordinance (SRSO) on first reading (5-2), limiting annual rent increases to 5% plus CPI (max 10%). Second reading and final adoption scheduled for January 2025. - Approved Fashion Square at Del Amo project (260-unit townhome development) with all six resolutions (7-0). - Authorized supplemental parking enforcement contract with ACE Parking Management, Inc. for $565,594 (7-0). - Extended 3290 Temporary Housing Program operations through June 30, 2028 (7-0). Staff to issue an RFP for a new operator contract and continue seeking funding. - Discontinued recycled water irrigation on Artesia Blvd parkways and returned maintenance to property owners (7-0). - Approved FY 2024-25 first quarter budget modifications and FY 2025-27 budget priorities and KPIs (6-1, Gerson dissenting on KPIs). - Approved issuance of $37 million in revenue obligations for Benevolence Health Centers (7-0). - Deferred item 10C (commission compensation changes) to a future meeting. - Council concurred to bring back items on memorial services for former officials and an update on e-bike enforcement from police. - Recognized Torrance High Girls Flag Football team for undefeated Pioneer League champion season. - Certified results of the November 5, 2024 special municipal election (Measure TTC passed with 44,061 yes votes, 17,855 no).

This document is a compilation of various video segments produced by the City of Torrance, including cooking shows, nature documentaries, and community features, rather than a formal city council meeting. However, several segments include remarks from city officials and highlight city services and events. Mayor's Remarks - Mayor George Chen (speaking on behalf of the Torrance City Council) thanked veterans and active military members, noting the city's 62nd Armed Forces Day parade and celebration. He mentioned the Torrance Veterans Memorial Wall, listing 151 names (with five new additions), and encouraged contacting the Torrance Historical Society at 310-328-5392 for further research. Social Services Commission Report - Debbie Bickford, Chair of the Social Services Commission, explained that the commission was created in 2016 to focus on veterans, homeless populations, adults with developmental disabilities, and children with special needs. She highlighted the annual Veteran Appreciation Luncheon and Resource Fair, and the Veterans Memorial Wall at Torrance Boulevard and Maple Avenue. Community Cooking Program - A cooking show segment demonstrated Haitian-inspired blackened ribeye, fried plantains, and sautéed kale. Host Maria Preckies and guests provided recipes and cooking tips. Viewers were invited to request a recipe by sending a self-addressed stamped envelope to the Office of Cable and Community Relations at 3350 Civic Center Drive, Suite 200, Torrance, CA 90503, noting the show number. The Torrance Farmers Market at Wilson Park (2200 Crenshaw Boulevard) was promoted as a source for fresh ingredients. Senior Scene Program - Host Hope Witkowski presented two segments: one on foot health (interview with podiatrist Dr. Tellis) and another on senior housing challenges. The latter featured Sharon, a senior at risk of losing her home, who was assisted by Affordable Living for the Aging (ALA), a home-share program. ALA Program Manager Cynthia explained the program's screening process and rental models. Common Sense Program: Business Features - A segment profiled Smog City Brewing, a Torrance craft brewery owned by Porter and Lori. The company's startup journey, brewing process, and community role were discussed. Another segment featured Navitas Semiconductor, a Torrance-based company specializing in gallium nitride and silicon carbide power chips for clean energy. CEO Gene Sheridan discussed the company's growth, workforce development program, and partnership with the South Bay Workforce Investment Board. Other Content - The compilation also included a nature documentary about frazzle ice in Yosemite National Park, a PSA about underage drinking, an advertisement for GED programs, a segment on the Americorps VISTA program, and a chair exercise routine led by LA Parks Recreation Coordinator Monica. Key Outcomes - No formal city council votes or decisions were recorded in this compilation. The material appears to be a collection of public information programming produced by the city of Torrance.

The Torrance City Council convened on December 3, 2024, starting with a Closed Session at 5:00 PM and the Regular Business meeting at 6:30 PM in the Council Chamber at 3031 Torrance Blvd. The agenda included consent calendar items, two public hearings, administrative matters, and community recognitions. No minutes or substantive transcript were provided, so this summary is based solely on the published agenda. Consent Calendar - 8A. TCEA MOU Ratification: Adoption of a resolution for a Memorandum of Understanding for Torrance City Employees Association for 2024–2028. Expenditure: $1,454,464 (General Fund and Non-General Fund approx. $363,616 annually). - 8B. Zenith Energy Pipeline Franchise: Second and final reading of Ordinance No. 3940 granting a pipeline franchise to Zenith Energy West Coast Terminals LLC. - 8C. Mural Policy Ordinance: Second and final reading of Ordinance No. 3941 amending the Municipal Code regarding original art display and adding a mural policy. - 8D. Beach Cities Green Streets Project: Approval of a cost-sharing MOU with Hermosa Beach, Manhattan Beach, and Redondo Beach for the Beach Cities Green Streets Project (S-194), with appropriation of $550,607 from Measure W interest earnings. - 8E. Recycled Water Discontinuation: Approval to discontinue recycled water irrigation and relinquish parkway maintenance on Artesia Blvd between Hawthorne Blvd and Western Ave due to cross‑connection concerns. - 8F. Transit Safety Plan: Authorization to submit Torrance Transit’s Agency Safety Plan for FY 2024‑2025 to the Federal Transit Administration. - 8G. Vehicle Replacement Purchase Order: Authorization of a purchase order with Rush Truck Centers of Whittier for 34 replacement vehicles at a not‑to‑exceed amount of $2,796,887 (cooperative purchase with Sourcewell). - 8H. Easement Quitclaim to TUSD: Approval of an easement quitclaim deed to Torrance Unified School District for the Hamilton Adult Education Center site. Public Hearings - 9A. Mobile Home Space Rent Stabilization Ordinance: The Council conducted a public hearing to consider a Mobile Home Space Rent Stabilization Ordinance, which would add Chapter 17 to Division 4 of the Municipal Code. Staff recommended a CEQA exemption and adoption of the ordinance. - 9B. Fashion Square at Del Amo Townhome Project: A public hearing was held for a 260‑unit townhome development at 3405 Carson Street and adjacent addresses. The project required a Mitigated Negative Declaration, Conditional Use Permit, Development Permit, Division of Lot, and modifications to a variance and development permit for the Del Amo Fashion Center boundary. Applicant: Lennar Homes (Madrona F & F, LLC). Administrative Matters - 10A. Commission Compensation: Discussion and consideration of amending Torrance Municipal Code sections to adjust commission compensation, with direction to bring back an ordinance if desired. - 10B. Homelessness Update and Temporary Housing Extension: The Council accepted a report on homelessness progress and approved extending the 3290 Temporary Housing Program operations through June 30, 2028 (three additional years). - 10C. External Lighting Policy: Review and direction on a policy for external lighting at city facilities. Community Matters - 6A. Recognition of Torrance High Girls Flag Football Team: The team was recognized for their achievements. Key Outcomes No voting results or final decisions are documented in the provided materials. The items listed above reflect the agenda and recommended actions; actual council decisions cannot be confirmed.

The Torrance City Council convened on November 19, 2024, for a regular meeting that included a closed session at 5:00 PM and open business beginning at 6:30 PM. Due to the unavailability of meeting minutes and a non‑relevant transcript (the provided transcript pertains to an unrelated occupational therapy discussion), this summary is derived solely from the published agenda. All items are presumed to have been considered as listed unless otherwise noted. Consent Calendar - 8A – Adopted a resolution approving Program Supplement No. F019 for the design of Citywide Traffic Signal Improvements (T‑171) and appropriated $88,530 in Carbon Reduction Program grant funds, increasing the project budget to $1,881,530. - 8B – Approved a first amendment to the Goldsworthy Desalter ground lease with the Water Replenishment District (WRD) for an additional 16,591 square feet and adopted a resolution of public interest. - 8C – Adopted a resolution implementing a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Torrance Police Commanders Association (TPCA) for hours, wages, and working conditions for the period January 1, 2024 – December 31, 2025, with an expenditure of $971,568 (approx. $485,784 annually from the General Fund). - 8D – Approved the second and final reading of Ordinance No. 3939 amending sign regulations, electronic/digital billboards, and enforcement. - 8E – Authorized emergency slope repairs between Vista Montana and Vista Largo, adopting CEQA categorical exemptions and direct payments totaling $424,928.66 to Ford Foundation Drilling, Inc. ($378,543.66) and Clarke Contracting Corporation ($46,385.00). - 8F – Approved a fourth amendment to the lease with KinderCare Education LLC for continued daycare operations at 1520 Greenwood Avenue within Greenwood Park. - 8G – Authorized a purchase order for six 2026 Autocar/Heil ACX64 CNG refuse trucks at $3,363,305.37 via cooperative purchase. - 8H – Appropriated $640,976.41 and authorized a purchase order for two 2024 Ford F‑450 Medix Metro 153 Type I ambulances via cooperative purchase. - 8I – Approved setting a closed hearing date of January 14, 2025, to consider an employee termination appeal (Police Officer). - 8J – Accepted and filed the FY2023‑24 Traffic Commission Annual Report. - 8K – Approved an examination to fill the Finance Director position on an open basis. - 8L – Accepted and filed the September 2024 Investment Report. - 8M – Approved reclassification of 1.0 FTE Fire Battalion Chief to Deputy Fire Chief. - 8N – Approved three on‑call roofing service contracts (Rainy Day Roofing, Bazan Roofing, Rite‑Way Roofing) each for up to $1,500,000 through June 30, 2027, plus CEQA exemption. - 8O – Approved two on‑call general contractor service contracts (Harry H. Joh Construction, MDJ Management) each for up to $2,250,000 through June 30, 2027, plus CEQA exemption. - 8P – Approved City Council minutes from October 8, 22, and 29, 2024. Community Matters - 6A – Proclamation declaring November 30 – December 7, 2024, as Torrance Small Business Week. - 6B – Accepted and appropriated a donation for the Community Emergency Response Team (CERT) with no General Fund expenditure. Hearings - 9A – Public hearing on municipal water rate increases: Proposed annual increases over five years (January 1, 2025 – December 31, 2029), with a maintained discount for low‑income senior and disabled customers. - 9B – Public hearing on replacing an expired pipeline franchise with Zenith Energy West Coast Terminals LLC for a ten‑year term (with one ten‑year extension option); CEQA categorical exemption adopted. - 9C – Public hearing on the Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI) covering July 1, 2024 – June 30, 2028; final AI approved. - 9D – Public hearing on the FY2023‑24 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) and appropriation of HOME and CDBG awards. Administrative Matters - 10A – Accepted and filed the forensic review of the City’s financial processes report. - 10B – Discussed and considered amending Torrance Municipal Code sections related to commission compensation; directed the City Clerk to bring back an ordinance. - 10C – Discussed and considered adopting an ordinance amending the Municipal Code regarding public art murals and adopting a mural policy resolution; CEQA exemption adopted. Closed Session - 13A – The Council met in closed session for a performance evaluation (City Manager), conference with legal counsel on existing litigation, labor negotiations, real property negotiations, and anticipated litigation. Adjournment - The meeting adjourned to December 3, 2024, at 5:00 PM for closed session, with regular business at 6:30 PM. (November 26, 2024, was a dark night.) Note on Source Material No meeting minutes were provided, and the transcript supplied is unrelated to the City Council meeting (it discusses occupational therapy for seniors). Therefore, this summary reflects the agenda as published; actual discussion, public comments, and vote tallies beyond adoption of the consent calendar and resolutions are not available.

The Torrance City Council held a regular meeting on November 19, 2024, beginning at 5:08 p.m. The meeting covered the consent calendar, public hearings on water rates, a pipeline franchise, fair housing analysis, and CAPER, as well as administrative matters including a forensic review of financial processes and a mural policy ordinance. The meeting also included public comments on various issues and council member announcements. Consent Calendar - Approved Resolution 2024-84 for a program supplement for citywide traffic signal improvements (CRP grant of $88,530 added). - Approved Resolution 2024-85 for a first amendment to the Goldsworthy Desalter ground lease with WRD. - Approved Resolution 2024-86 for a memorandum of understanding with the Torrance Police Commanders Association (TPCA), with a $971,568 expenditure. - Adopted Ordinance No. 3939 amending sign regulations to allow electronic/digital billboards. - Authorized emergency slope repairs between Vista Montana and Vista Largo ($424,928.66). - Approved a fourth amendment to lease with KinderCare Education LLC at 1520 Greenwood Avenue. - Authorized purchase of six 2026 Autocar/Heil ACX64 CNG refuse trucks ($3,363,305.37). - Authorized purchase of two 2024 Ford F-450 ambulances ($640,976.41). - Set a closed hearing date for January 14, 2025, to consider a police officer termination appeal. - Accepted and filed the FY 2023-24 Traffic Commission annual report. - Approved an open examination to fill the Finance Director position. - Accepted and filed the September 2024 investment report. - Approved reclassification of 1.0 FTE Fire Battalion Chief to Deputy Fire Chief. - Approved on-call roofing services agreements with three contractors ($4,500,000 total). - Approved on-call general contractor services agreements with two contractors ($4,500,000 total). - Approved minutes from October 8, 22, and 29, 2024. All consent calendar items were approved unanimously with Councilmember Sheikh absent. Public Comments & Testimony - Several residents spoke during the water rate public hearing, expressing opposition to the proposed 35% increase over five years. They argued that the increase was unreasonable, penalized conservation, and that rates should be justified more frequently (e.g., 1–2 years). One resident noted that the reduction in water sales due to conservation was cited as a reason for rate increases, calling it unfair. Another resident questioned whether cost-cutting alternatives were considered and urged that the water enterprise fund not be used for non-water purposes. - During the forensic review item, one speaker asked for three specific improvements since 2020. Another speaker, Andy Porchop, questioned why a forensic review was conducted instead of a full audit and alleged that former officials were responsible for the fiscal crisis. - During oral communications (both sessions), residents raised concerns about the new online agenda system's accessibility for seniors, trash and drug paraphernalia left on a street, and the need to maintain public access to baseball fields in upcoming lease agreements. Discussion Items - Water Rate Hearing (Item 9A): The Council conducted a public hearing on a proposed five-year series of annual water rate increases for Torrance Municipal Water customers (effective January 1, 2025 through December 31, 2029). Staff presented that imported water costs from MWD are rising dramatically (11% in 2025, 9.5% in 2026, projected up to 120% over 10 years), and that the proposed increases (6.5% in 2025 & 2026, 6% in 2027–2029) would still keep Torrance rates below neighboring agencies. The plan includes maintaining a low-income senior/disabled discount. A Prop 218 mail ballot was sent to 26,800 customers; 730 written protests were received (far short of the 12,700 needed to block). Council members acknowledged public concerns but noted the need for revenue stability to fund local water independence projects (North Torrance Well Field, Van S well field, Goldsworthy Desalter expansion) and that the city's water fund is used solely for water purposes. The public hearing was closed, and Resolution 2024-87 was adopted unanimously. - Forensic Review of Financial Processes (Item 10A): BDO USA presented the results of an independent review covering FY 2014–15 to FY 2022–23. Five root causes of the 2020 fiscal crisis were identified: unsustainable budget practices, insufficient transparency and accountability, limited time for council budget analysis, insufficient control over the use of unassigned reserves, and insufficient risk assessment/contingency planning. The report noted that the city reacted quickly with cost-cutting and revenue-generating measures (including zero-based budgeting, improved reporting, and reserve controls). Current control maturity was rated 3.1/5 (up from 1.6 pre-2020). Council members thanked staff and BDO. Councilmember Kaji made a lengthy statement accusing former city manager Leroy Jackson, former finance director Eric Sow, and former mayor Patrick Furey of concealing structural deficits and misleading the public. He moved to accept and file the report. Councilmember Kalani clarified her vote, stating she did not want to be part of accusations without substantial evidence. The motion carried. - Mural Policy (Item 10C): The Council considered an ordinance amending the Torrance Municipal Code to regulate public art murals on public and private properties, along with a resolution adopting a mural policy. Staff revised the policy based on prior direction. A resident expressed support for murals but also frustration with the new online agenda system. Council discussed content concerns (e.g., trademarked logos) and confirmed that murals would require approval from the Cultural Arts Commission and the Council. The ordinance (No. 3941) and resolution (No. 2024-88) were adopted unanimously. - Pipeline Franchise (Item 9B): A public hearing was held on replacing an expired pipeline franchise with Zenith Energy West Coast Terminals LLC for a 10-year term with a 10-year renewal option. Staff reported the franchise generates $23,613.20 annually with CPI adjustments. The pipeline was installed in 1969 and carries petroleum products. One resident spoke in favor. The franchise ordinance (No. 3940) was adopted unanimously. - Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing (Item 9C): A public hearing was held on the final AI covering July 2024–June 2028. A resident asked for details on planned zoning amendments. The Council approved the AI. - CAPER (Item 9D): A public hearing was held on the FY 2023-24 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report for HUD. The Council approved the report and appropriated FY 2023-24 and FY 2024-25 HOME and CDBG awards. Key Outcomes - Water Rates: Resolution 2024-87 adopted, approving a five-year series of annual water rate increases (6.5% in 2025, 6.5% in 2026, 6% in 2027, 6% in 2028, 6% in 2029) for Torrance Municipal Water customers, effective January 1, 2025. The low-income senior/disabled discount is maintained. (Vote: unanimous with Councilmember Sheikh absent) - Forensic Review: Accepted and filed the BDO forensic review of financial processes. (Vote: 6-0, with Councilmember Sheikh absent) - Public Art Murals: Ordinance No. 3941 and Resolution No. 2024-88 adopted, establishing a mural policy and amending the municipal code. (Vote: unanimous with Councilmember Sheikh absent) - Pipeline Franchise: Ordinance No. 3940 adopted, granting a 10-year franchise to Zenith Energy West Coast Terminals LLC. (Vote: unanimous with Councilmember Sheikh absent) - Fair Housing Analysis: Approved the final Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI) for July 2024–June 2028. (Vote: unanimous with Councilmember Sheikh absent) - CAPER: Approved the FY 2023-24 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report and appropriated FY 2023-24 and FY 2024-25 HOME and CDBG expenditure budgets. (Vote: unanimous with Councilmember Sheikh absent) - Deferral: Items 10B (commission compensation) and 10C (mural policy originally) were deferred to a future meeting (date TBD). However, 10C was actually heard and approved (the agenda noted deferral of the original item but the council discussed a revised version).

On October 29, 2024, the Torrance City Council held a regular meeting beginning at 5:00 p.m. with a closed session and reconvening at 6:30 p.m. The council took action on a consent calendar, conducted a public hearing on digital billboard regulations, and approved funding for new pickleball courts. All votes were unanimous. Proclamations and Legislative Update - Military Veterans Appreciation Week Proclamation (6A): The council proclaimed November 4–11, 2024 as Military Veterans Appreciation Week. Social Service Commission members and Vietnam Veterans of America Chapter 53 accepted the proclamation and announced a Veterans Appreciation Luncheon and Resource Fair on November 8, 2024 at the Torrance Cultural Arts Center. - Legislative Update (6B): Senator Steven Bradford (35th State Senate District) provided a final legislative update, highlighting bills signed into law on consumer protections, cannabis taxes, energy affordability, and reparations. He noted Torrance will no longer be in his district after the November 5 election and thanked the council for their partnership. Consent Calendar - 8A: Approved City Council minutes of October 15, 2024. - 8B: Adopted Resolution 2024-80 setting hours, wages, and working conditions for executive and management employees, repealing Resolution 2024-66. - 8C: Adopted Resolution 2024-81 pursuant to MOU with Engineers and Torrance Fiscal Employees Association (TFEA) for July 1, 2024 – June 30, 2028; expenditure of $2,151,876 (approximately $537,969 annually). - 8D: Determined CEQA exemption, adopted Resolution 2024-82 declaring intent to consider a fuel oil pipeline franchise from Zenith Energy West Coast Terminals LLC, and set a public hearing for November 19, 2024 at 6:30 p.m. - 8E: Adopted Resolution 2024-83 amending Resolution 2024-69 to memorialize the Torrance Police Enhanced Recruitment and Retention Incentive Pilot Program. - 8F: Approved first amendment to consulting services agreement with Blais & Associates for grant writing services; $170,223 (new not-to-exceed $323,013 through Nov 7, 2025). - 8G: Approved side letter agreement between Torrance Professional and Supervisory Association (TPSA) and Management modifying pay ranges and PARS plan. - 8H: Approved two side letter agreements: one with Torrance Fire Fighters Association modifying longevity pay and vacation accrual for rehired firefighters, and one with Torrance Municipal Employees-AFSCME Local 1117 implementing an Enhanced Recruitment and Retention Pilot Program. The consent calendar was approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Oral Communications 1: - Janet Payne (Torrance Historical Society) announced museum open days and a "Visit with a Veteran" event. - Charlie Salinas promoted the Historical Society’s veteran event. - A speaker urged a "no" vote on proposed Charter Amendment TC, arguing it removes accountability for fund sources and disbursement. - Andy Portia criticized Civil Service Commissioner Pat Fury’s behavior and questioned council’s appointment. - A speaker asked if the city paid a consultant to fine-tune the TC language for council pay raises; City Manager confirmed a consultant was used for ballot language. - Luke Mosco (RC Club president) requested communication on a prior agreement but no funding yet. - Public Hearing on Digital Billboards (9A): - Jack, a property owner on Prairie and Artesia, expressed support for digital billboards and requested a half-mile spacing instead of one mile. - Andy Portia supported billboards but asked to shield Pat Fury from them. - Pickleball Facilities (10A): - Debbie Martin and Jeff Martin voiced strong support for new pickleball courts, citing community health and bonding. - Multiple residents urged more courts, noting Torrance lacks adequate facilities and many travel elsewhere to play. - Sean, a player at Serla Brea, supported the Wilson Park courts. Discussion Items - Digital Billboard Ordinance (9A): - Staff presented proposed amendments to allow electronic/digital billboards along freeways, defining on-premise vs. off-premise signs. Up to 12 potential sites, with 10 meeting criteria, including two city-owned parcels. Revenue estimated at $100,000–$120,000 annually per sign. - Council debate focused on controlling proliferation: Councilmember Kalani moved to separate on-premise and off-premise allowances. After discussion: - First motion: Strike subsection L from Section 911.6.100 to allow on-premise digital signs. Unanimously approved. - Second motion: Restrict off-premise digital billboards to city-owned property only, eliminate the one-acre minimum lot size, reduce required spacing from one mile to half a mile, and remove the conditional use permit requirement (Section 911.10.010.C). Unanimously approved. - The ordinance (as amended) was adopted unanimously; staff will bring back development agreements for specific sites. - Pickleball Facilities (10A): - Staff recommended allocating $1,250,000 from the Wilson Park Building Aid Capital Improvement Project to construct eight new pickleball courts at Wilson Park. The existing condemned building will be demolished this fiscal year; future phases will design replacement facilities. - Council supported the investment, with Councilmember Kalani noting private-sector interest in indoor/outdoor commercial pickleball venues. - A motion to approve item 10A passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: All items 8A–8H approved unanimously. - Digital Billboard Ordinance: On-premise signs allowed immediately; off-premise signs restricted to city property with new standards (no acre requirement, 0.5-mile spacing). Ordinance 3939 adopted unanimously. - Pickleball Courts: $1,250,000 allocated from Building Aid fund for eight new courts at Wilson Park; staff to return with contract and operational policy. - Deferred Item: Item 10B (Commission compensation) was withdrawn and rescheduled for November 19, 2024. - Meeting Adjourned: To November 19, 2024 at 5:00 p.m. (closed session) and 6:30 p.m. (regular business).

The Torrance City Council met on October 22, 2024, at 5:00 p.m. for a closed session and reconvened for regular business at 6:30 p.m. The meeting covered consent items, a public hearing (deferred), administrative matters including the Inglewood Transit Connector proposal, budget modifications, military equipment policy renewal, and positions on November 2024 ballot measures. Consent Calendar - Item 8A: Approved City Council minutes from September 17 and September 24, 2024. - Item 8B: Accepted and filed the Investment Report for August 2024. - Item 8C: Approved reclassification of 1.0 FTE Administrative Assistant to Senior Administrative Assistant ($14,600/year). Councilmember Sheikh noted the position is eliminated, not newly created, resulting in no net General Fund increase. Approved unanimously after being pulled from consent. - Remaining consent items approved unanimously with 8C removed. Public Comments & Testimony - Oral Communications 1: - Charlie Salinas spoke about mental health resources. - Dick Emmaya thanked Public Works for reopening a lane in North Florence after a contractor delay. - Mary Ann protested police brutality and called for civilian oversight. - Sebastian Bogner (Behavioral Health Services) announced a medication take-back event on October 26 at Sam's Club (10 a.m.–2 p.m.). - Andy Porchop commented on various topics. - A speaker opposed Charter Amendment Measure TC, arguing it reduces accountability for airport fund transfers. - Item 10D Public Comment: - Representative from Inglewood thanked the city and estimated 326,000 South Bay residents would be served by the Inglewood Transit Connector (ITC). - Andy Porchop opposed, citing empty transit centers and cost. - Item 10A Public Comment: Andy Porchop supported the budget modifications. - Item 10B Public Comment: Andy Porchop sarcastically supported military equipment expansion. - Item 10C Public Comment: Andy Porchop criticized the council's position-setting as “brainwashing.” Discussion Items - Item 9A – Variance Denial Hearing (417 Via Anita): Deferred to a future date per staff request; no discussion. - Item 10D – City of Inglewood Transit Connector Proposal: - Staff presented: ITC is a 1.6-mile people mover (estimated $2.2 billion), connecting Metro K Line to downtown Inglewood and the entertainment district. Inglewood has secured $1.8 billion, needs an additional $493 million backstop, requesting early access to Measure M decennial funds via South Bay Cities Council of Governments (SBCCOG). Torrance is a voting member. Potential impacts to Torrance projects (PCH/Crenshaw $40-50M, fiber network $20-30M) are indeterminate. - Council asked about timeline, financial risk, and commitments from Inglewood. Mayor Butts of Inglewood and consultant Letha Tripoletti answered questions, offering future support for Torrance projects. - Councilmember Kaji suggested Torrance be more ambitious with its Regional Transportation Center. - Motion to direct COG representative to support with assurances failed for lack of a second. Substitute motion to oppose (no support) passed 4-1 (Councilmember Lewis voting no). - Item 10A – Fiscal Year 2024-25 Program Modifications: - Approved restructuring of Community Development (split building division, conversions saving $13,712/year) and adding an IT Manager for Police ($203,409/year from Measure SST Fund). Unanimous. - Item 10B – Military Equipment Use Policy Renewal: - Staff reported no complaints or deficiencies; community engagement meeting held Oct 15, 2024. Council affirmed compliance and renewed Ordinance 3902. Unanimous. - Item 10C – November 5, 2024 General Election Ballot Measures: - Staff presented positions from the State Legislative Advocacy Committee: Support Prop 4 (climate bond), Neutral on Prop 5 (bond threshold) and Prop 32 (minimum wage), Oppose Prop 33 (rent control) and Measure A (homeless services tax), Support Prop 36 (felony thresholds), Neutral on Measure G (LA County charter amendment). - Councilmember Gerson proposed supporting Measure G; council voted to adopt committee recommendations as presented. Motion carried 5-2 (Gerson and Sheikh voting no). Key Outcomes - Item 10D: Council voted 4-1 to oppose supporting the Inglewood Transit Connector funding request (i.e., direct COG representative to vote “no”). - Item 10A: Approved budget modifications for Community Development and Police departments. - Item 10B: Renewed Ordinance 3902 for military equipment use policy. - Item 10C: Adopted ballot measure positions as recommended by the State Legislative Advocacy Committee. - Consent Calendar: Approved with item 8C separately considered. - Meeting adjourned to October 29, 2024, at 5:00 p.m. for closed session, 6:30 p.m. for regular business.

The Torrance City Council convened on October 15, 2024, at 5:00 PM for a closed session meeting in Council Chambers. The meeting included roll call (six councilmembers present, one absent), flag salute, invocation, and oral communications (no speakers). The council then entered closed session to discuss legal matters, a performance evaluation, real property negotiations, and labor negotiations. The meeting reconvened at 6:27 PM with no action reported from closed session, and was adjourned to October 22, 2024. Consent Calendar - No items. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke during oral communications. Discussion Items - Closed session items covered: existing litigation (City of Torrance v. Hi-Shear Corporation, California Regional Water Quality Control Board orders); public employee performance evaluation (City Manager); real property negotiations (2700 Skypark Drive); and labor negotiations with multiple employee organizations. Key Outcomes - No action reported from closed session. - Council voted to adjourn the meeting at 6:27 PM to Tuesday, October 22, 2024, at 5:00 PM for closed session, with regular business at 6:30 PM.