Public Meetings - Detroit, Michigan

On September 23, 2025, the Detroit City Council held an evening community meeting for District 2 at Fellowship Chapel. Council President Pro Tem James Tate presided with members Angela Whitfield Callaway, Letitia Johnson, Gabriela Santiago Romero, Mary Waters, and others present. The meeting featured presentations, awards, and public testimony on transit, policing, housing, and city services. Presentations & Awards - Detroit Women's Commission: Councilmember Callaway introduced the commission, established in 2024, with chair Angela Bullock and vice chair Jessica Parker. They highlighted their mission to advocate for women's issues and hold monthly public meetings. - Spirit of Detroit Awards: Presented to Patrice Davis, founder of Granny's Pound Cake, for employing individuals with disabilities and opening a brick-and-mortar location in District 2; and to Joseph Carter Harris Jr. (Tommy Poppy) of All Notes TV for youth empowerment through music and environmental cleanups. Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Cunningham highlighted DDOT bus service unreliability and invited councilmembers for ride-alongs. - Hazel Flood (Garden Homes neighborhood) reported persistent illegal dumping behind the post office at 20501 Livernois and requested a sidewalk and USPS responsibility; DPW staff agreed to meet after the meeting. - Russ Ballant urged the council to stop foreclosures related to the drainage fee (rain tax), citing the Michigan Supreme Court's decision to not hear the case, which could lead to foreclosures of churches and businesses. - Patricia Matthews sought a grant for garage repairs; council staff took her information. - Marcel Y. and Jacob Smith (Detroit Alliance Against Racist and Political Repression) criticized the proposed body-worn camera footage release ordinance as weakened, advocating for the original 30-day timeline and broader scope. - Minister Eric Blunt also opposed the current ordinance, calling for immediate release of footage in police use-of-force cases. - Gloria Fennison described poor conditions at Sinai-Grace Hospital (unemptied bedside toilet); Councilmember Callaway committed to sharing her photos with hospital leadership. - Jean Seven Reed (Hubble Puritan Neighborhood Association) addressed cannabis stigmatization versus alcohol prevalence and called for better transportation and business opportunities. - Sylvia Green urged changes to rental property policies to assist homeowners over investors and opposed legalizing mushrooms. - Gregory Palawski invited councilmembers to an upcoming Drug Policy Alliance conference on harm reduction. - Victoria Camille urged the council to pause the body camera ordinance and engage directly with the Coalition for Police Transparency and Accountability (CPTA). - Candidate for council (name not given) criticized proliferation of liquor stores and abandoned schools in District 3. - Detroiters for Tax Justice speaker (name not given) echoed concerns about rain tax foreclosures. - Roy McAllister Jr. gave a campaign speech emphasizing crime, taxes, insurance, affordable housing, and mental health. - Betty A. Varner (via Zoom, SoEla/Broad Block Association) noted her organization will move from District 7 to District 2 in 2026 and promoted the Choice Waiver program for seniors. - Frank Hammer thanked Councilmember Callaway for supporting the preservation of the State Fairgrounds Bandshell, which held its first concert on August 23, 2025. - William M. Davis (virtual) called for retroactive reduction of interest on retiree pension clawbacks and criticized the rain tax management. - Evan Markarian (virtual) raised concerns about illegal parking blocking bus stops and sidewalks in the Avenue of Fashion, and about DDOT bus frequency. Key Outcomes - No formal votes or resolutions were taken. - Councilmember Callaway committed to contacting Sinai-Grace Hospital president regarding Gloria Fennison's complaint. - DPW staff agreed to meet with Hazel Flood to address illegal dumping and sidewalk issues. - Council staff collected information from Patricia Matthews for home repair grant resources. - Multiple speakers urged council to take action on the body camera ordinance and rain tax foreclosures; no immediate commitments were made.

The Public Health and Safety Standing Committee met on September 22, 2025, at 9:30 AM (estimated from agenda flow) to consider a range of items including emergency demolition contracts, HIV grant amendments, bus repair emergency procurement, ordinances on smoking in sports arenas and police footage, and numerous public comments. Chair Gabriela Santiago-Romero presided with Councilmember Scott Benson absent excused. The meeting lasted approximately 2 hours and included votes on over 20 agenda items. Public Comments & Testimony - Melissa Love – Alleged election fraud, stated she never voted in 2020 or 2024, demanded removal from voter rolls and restitution. - John Golick – Appealed a dangerous building demolition order for 13803 Pinewood; explained he obtained a building permit but faced technical barriers. Chair suggested his team would assist. - Mr. Foster – Spoke on free society and rule of law, criticizing that laws are not applied equally to those in power. - Stephen Horing (online) – Defended his reputation against previous comments by Miko Williams; expressed strong support for Israel and criticized a recent Palestine conference. - Not That Karen (online) – Urged making city retirees whole, emphasized need for homeless housing before winter, criticized $600M overtaxation and pension clawbacks. - Cecily McClellan (online, We the People of Detroit) – Called for water affordability through House Bill 4555, noted Detroit Lifeline Program exhaustion, supported retiree pension restoration using city surpluses. - Miko A. Williams (online) – Accused the chair of xenophobia for referring to “black immigrants”; denounced Stephen Horing as a “white supremacist” and criticized right-wing rhetoric. Chair clarified she was referring to black immigrants from various countries. - Cunningham (online) – Complained about bus system reliability, sharing community frustrations. - owner Papa (online) – Questioned HIV grant 6.6's metropolitan area focus, argued funds should stay in Detroit; also raised concerns about speed humps increasing particulate matter. - William M. Davis (online) – Criticized city for retiree health care cuts after bankruptcy, alleged mayor Mike Duggan underfunds city services, predicted Duggan would not be elected governor. - Tahira Ahmed (online) – Thanked Councilmember Waters for addressing land bank issues; alleged $700M in demo dollars given to Gaiaga, concerns over asbestos contamination from demolition debris. - Ruben Crowley (online) – Claimed City Council President Mary Sheffield disrespected veterans; alleged election fraud by various council members; announced plans to open veterans housing. Discussion Items - Unfinished Business (5.1–5.2): Deferrals for properties at 5301 and 5311 East Outer Drive – brought back one week, approved. - 5.3: Helmholtz encroachment for advertising sign – Councilmember Waters requested meeting with residents; brought back TBD. - 5.4: Emergency demo contract for 4815 Tireman ($39,282) – initially deferred for group exec; later confirmed demolition completed September 16; approved. - 5.5–5.6: Emergency demo contracts for 23241 Finkel and 1974 Ste. Helene – brought back one week. - 5.7–5.10: Memos – 5.7 (flooded basement act) received & filed; 5.8 (child abduction broadcast) brought back one week; 5.9 (support Senate Bill 492) moved to formal with approval; 5.10 (Vita Specialty Services) brought back two weeks. - 6.1–6.2: Contract extensions for Ice Arena improvements and environmental due diligence – both approved. - 6.3–6.4: Emergency demo contracts (14136 Myers, 13580 Orleans) – approved. - 6.5–6.6: HIV grant amendments for program administrators – Councilmember Waters questioned service area and contractor location (Sylvan Lake). Deputy Director Floyd replied grants serve Detroit and metro area but prioritize Detroit. Brought back one week for further information. - 6.7–6.9: Emergency bus repair contracts (Cummins, Williams, coach body) – 30 buses down due to varied issues; procurement explanation given; approved. - 6.10: List of delegated approvals (animal carcass removal) – approved after brief discussion. - 6.11–6.12: Ordinances on smoking in sports arenas and police footage – introduced and brought back one week. - 6.13: Dangerous building findings and orders (July 2025) – received and filed. - 6.14–6.15: Property recommendations (3760 W. Chicago recession, 1004 E. 7 Mile deferral) – concurred. - 6.16: Grant application for Michigan Solar for All Pilots – approved. - 6.17–6.18: Parade banners for Turkey Trot and Thanksgiving parade – approved. - 6.19: Memo to board up abandoned St. Riga Catholic School – received and filed. - 6.20–6.21: Memos on DPD training practices and liquor store at 1440 Kurchival – brought back two weeks. - 6.22: Resolution calling for investigation of abuse at Huron Valley Correctional Facility – approved. - 6.23–6.24: Memos on Domestic Violence Awareness Month proclamation and support for House Bill 4362 – brought back two weeks. Key Outcomes - Approved contracts: 6.1 (Ice Arena extension), 6.2 (environmental due diligence), 6.3–6.4 (emergency demos), 6.7–6.9 (bus repairs), 6.10 (delegated approvals), 6.16 (solar grant), 6.17–6.18 (parade banners), 6.22 (Huron Valley resolution). All sent to formal session with recommendation to approve, except 6.16 and 6.22 sent to new business. - Brought back: 5.1–5.2 (one week), 5.3 (TBD), 5.4 (approved after clarification), 5.5–5.6 (one week), 5.8 (one week), 5.10 (two weeks), 6.5–6.6 (one week), 6.11–6.12 (one week), 6.15 (concurred), 6.20–6.21 (two weeks), 6.23–6.24 (two weeks). - Received and filed: 5.7, 6.13, 6.19. - Concurred with recommendations: 6.14–6.15. - Minutes approved from prior session. - Public comment period closed after 10:05 AM; all speakers heard. - Councilmember Benson absent excused.

The Detroit City Council convened on September 18, 2025, as a Committee of the Whole to interview candidates for the position of city ombudsman. The meeting included public comment, interviews with ten candidates, and discussion on the selection process. The council will vote on September 30, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - Several residents and community leaders spoke in support of Deputy Ombudsman Gail Bernard, citing her dedication, consistency, and community engagement. Supporters included representatives from the Field House Block Club and Latin Americans for Social and Economic Development. - Kimberly Marble and Paul Chenault spoke in support of Dennis Perkins and Kim Tandy, respectively, highlighting their responsiveness and work in the community. - Pamela Brown, Helen Moore, and other speakers also endorsed Gail Bernard, emphasizing her long-term service and effectiveness. Discussion Items Interviews with Candidates (in order): - Gail Bernard (current Deputy Ombudsman): Emphasized her 20 years of experience, proposed assigning assistant ombudsmen to each council district, and highlighted her work on office software upgrades. She expressed passion for the role and commitment to transparency. - Reggie Davis: Stressed his experience in both legislative and administrative branches, proposed replacing the current case management system (Wing Swept) with a 311 CRM that integrates GIS. He emphasized innovation and technology improvements. - Jessica Gates: Background in social work and community organizing. Acknowledged limited knowledge of city government but highlighted impartiality and strong listening skills. Currently serves on a charter school board. - Sherry Gay-Dagnogo (current Detroit Public Schools Community District board member): Proposed a 90-day plan focusing on listening and collaboration. Discussed using her experience as a former state legislator and city council staffer to build relationships and improve services. Addressed potential conflicts of interest if serving both roles. - Darius Huff: Background in oversight and compliance, currently managing IT contracts for the Department of Labor. Emphasized data-driven decision-making and equitable access to economic opportunities. Expressed a desire to leverage technology and community engagement. - Dennis Perkins (former deputy district manager and retired police officer): Highlighted 30 years of city service, impartiality, and investigative skills. Emphasized empathy and follow-through on constituent complaints. - Anthony Reddit: Attorney with 15 years of experience, including litigation and work with Social Security Administration. Discussed using subpoena power as a last resort and emphasized listening and accessibility. - Kim Hunter Varner Tandy (district manager for District 2): Architect by training, stressed community engagement and trust-building. Proposed a podcast ("Umbudscast") and satellite office hours to increase accessibility. Referred to her work on street revitalization projects. - Tiffany Tilley (State Board of Education member): Presented a detailed packet with strategic plans, including an Ombudsperson tour, technology upgrades, and monthly council reports. Background includes work as a CED director and community liaison. Addressed potential conflict of interest if staying on school board. - Anthony Zander (Director of Civil Rights, Inclusion, and Opportunity, CREO): Background in process improvement and investigations. Emphasized using data and Lean Six Sigma to improve office efficiency. Noted that CREO and the Ombudsman’s office have similar investigative functions. Key Outcomes - The council directed the law department to investigate whether candidates Sherry Gay-Dagnogo and Tiffany Tilley can simultaneously serve on the school board and as ombudsman. - Council directed staff to conduct background checks on all ten candidates before the vote. - The selection process will use a ranked-choice ballot where each council member votes for three candidates in the first round; the resolution was amended to reflect this intent (originally stated two). - The final vote will be held on September 30, 2025, rather than the originally planned September 23. The current ombudsman’s term ends October 4, 2025, allowing time for transition.

The committee convened on Thursday, September 18, 2025, at approximately 10:00 AM under Chair James Tate. The meeting included general public comment, three public hearings on tax abatement requests, and consideration of numerous unfinished and new business items. Key decisions included advancing two Neighborhood Enterprise Zone (NEZ) district requests for 60-day gestation, approving a Commercial Rehabilitation Exemption Certificate, and denying a rezoning request while directing the applicant to pursue permitted uses under existing zoning. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comments (15 speakers, 1.5 minutes each): - Tina Castleberry (owner, The Garden Block) expressed concern about losing a gardening center and thanked the committee for discussion. - A speaker (name not given) supported a zoning change from R3 to B2 at Davison and Potaski, calling for community education on zoning and criticizing the Land Bank for not informing buyers of restrictions. - A speaker criticized Ms. Castleberry for failing to complete required paperwork for Motor City Match funding, and urged the city to enforce the law. - Scottie (public commenter) accused officials of fraud and misconduct, referencing a death and alleged trap houses. - Eb (caller) described her situation: 11 years in a rental, landlord died, property in foreclosure, auction bid at $27,000; she asked for tenant rights to prevent displacement. - Betty A. Barner (President, D.E.S.O.D.A. Elsewhere Black Association) promoted donations and senior assistance programs. - Miko Williams criticized Chair Tate for not holding a district tour on the Land Bank MOU, alleging conflict of interest and lack of resident input. - Stephen Haring defended himself against Miko Williams' comments, calling him mentally ill and citing his own business success. - William M. Davis criticized Mayor Mike Duggan for using surplus funds to cover tax revenue declines due to abatements, and predicted he would not be elected governor if he does not help city retirees. - Not That Karen agreed with Mr. Davis, calling for an end to retiree clawbacks and repurposing the Renaissance Center for housing. - Owner Papa criticized the city for giving tax breaks to developers while ignoring retirees and residents facing foreclosure, and called for a moratorium on planning department approvals. - Belicia distinguished between speaking about white people and white policies, and asked about police union endorsements. - Mike Shane spoke on behalf of Ebony Boyd (foreclosure case), urging council to call Eric Sabree to pull the house from auction. - Tracy Peters (District 4 resident) commented on the Land Bank MOU, citing Section 756 on preservation of property value, and asked for transparency. - Christine Holmes (Woodbridge Neighborhood Development) spoke in support of agenda item 6 (NEZ request in Woodbridge). - Marguerite Scarlet Mattox thanked members for a walk-through and urged keeping families together and addressing homelessness. - Joanne Warwick criticized the city for not holding demo contractors accountable, and noted that the council could have prevented foreclosures by taking occupied properties out of tax auction, as was done in 2017. - Public Comments on Line Item 5 (NEZ for 663 Prentice): - A speaker raised concerns about management at the Dr. Maya Angelou building and lack of recycling. - Not That Karen criticized the selection of older buildings that exclude accessible housing, and opposed using historic buildings as an excuse to avoid ADA compliance. - Betty A. Barner asked about parking in midtown, noting meters and wondering if residents pay. - William M. Davis asked about handicap/senior accessibility and parking problems. - Marguerite Maddox spoke briefly (unclear). - Owner Papa asked what projects the developer has previously worked on, noted that NEZs hurt the general fund, and called for a moratorium until a look-back is done. - Cindy Dara spoke about rising rents and the need to evaluate past NEZ projects. - Public Comments on Line Item 6 (NEZ for 12th and Forest): - Cindy Dara questioned the policy of tax breaks for improvements and suggested state law changes. - Owner Papa asked about 80% AMI dollar amounts, who gets the abatement, the meaning of "naturally occurring affordability," and argued that all projects should be held until a fiscal impact review is done. - William M. Davis asked about parking and whether nearby residents were given priority for Land Bank lots. - Not That Karen argued that NEZs are selectively issued, and that developers can make buildings accessible with stair lifts, so they should not use accessibility as an excuse. - Garrett Burton (President, Woodbridge Citizens Council) spoke in support of the development and Mr. Lockwood's application. - Marguerite Maddox spoke briefly about accessibility and design. - Public Comments on Line Item 7 (Commercial rehab for Epic Health): - Owner Papa questioned why the city subsidizes every business, and asked if Epic Health (the EMR company) is the same entity and if they receive subsidies elsewhere. - Marguerite Maddox spoke briefly about mobility and accessibility. Discussion Items - Line Item 5 – NEZ District Request for 663 Prentice Street (Midtown Detroit PropCo LLC): - Presented by David Howell (DEGC) and developer Michael O'Connor. The project is a $4.1M renovation of a 29-unit building (15 studios, 14 one-bedrooms, currently 90% occupied). Improvements include new roof, windows, masonry, HVAC. Existing rents $750-$1,150; current residents capped at 2% annual increase. At turnover, 10% of units at 60% AMI and 10% at 80% AMI. Projected 15-year net benefit to city: $374,614. Developer noted challenges with ADA in pre-war building (no elevator). Chair Tate asked about recycling; member Johnson requested developer consider recycling. Public comments raised concerns about accessibility, parking, and the precedent of NEZs. Committee voted to bring back as a line item on November 20, 2025 (60-day gestation). - Line Item 6 – NEZ District Request for 12th and Forest (XYZ Development): - Presented by David Howell and developer Phil Lockwood. Multi-phase project: 4 for-sale condos, 46 rental units, plus event space. Total investment $18.7M. 20% of rental units at 80% AMI, plus additional naturally occurring affordable units. Parking: 62 spaces behind buildings. Public comments questioned AMI levels, abatement benefits, parking, and accessibility. Committee voted to bring back as a line item on November 20, 2025. - Line Item 7 – Commercial Rehabilitation Exemption Certificate for 4306-4340 E. Davison (Epic Health): - Presented by Nicole Scott (DEGC) and Brooke Booth. $3.4M project to build a 7,000 sq ft primary care clinic. 10-year abatement, net benefit to city $225,239. Developer noted 25 permanent jobs, ADA compliance, and community engagement. Public comments questioned subsidies. Committee voted to send to formal session with recommendation to approve. - Line Item 8.5 – Rezoning Request (4213 & 4225 W. Davison, Tina Castleberry): - Ms. Castleberry's request to rezone from R3 to B2 for a garden center. After discussions with Planning Director Alexa Bush, she agreed to pursue uses permitted under R3 (nonprofit, childcare, domestic violence shelter). CPC recommended denial of rezoning. Committee voted to approve CPC's denial and send to formal session, with members noting systemic issues and thanking the ombudsman. - Other Business Items: - Items 8.1, 9.11 (NEZ boundary extension) referred to Budget, Finance and Audit Committee. - Item 8.2 (resolution supporting diverse athletic offerings at Pistons multiplex) sent to formal with recommendation to approve (one objection from member Johnson). - Item 8.4 (tax preparation services contract) sent to formal. - Item 8.6 (request for list of tax abatements in District 1) brought back in two weeks. - Items 8.7, 9.9 (ADA/bird safety for bridge) received and filed. - Item 8.8 (properties owned by real token LLC) brought back in two weeks. - Items 9.1-9.5, 9.6-9.8 (various contract extensions and amendments) sent to formal with recommendations to approve. - Item 9.10 (secondary street sign applications) brought back October 23. - Item 9.12 (temporary construction easement) sent to formal. - Item 9.13 (BZA questions) referred to LPD and brought back in two weeks. Key Outcomes - Line Item 5 (NEZ for 663 Prentice): Motion to bring back as a line item on November 20, 2025, approved without objection. - Line Item 6 (NEZ for 12th and Forest): Motion to bring back as a line item on November 20, 2025, approved without objection. - Line Item 7 (Commercial rehab for Epic Health): Motion to send to formal session with recommendation to approve, approved without objection. - Line Item 8.5 (Rezoning denial): Motion to approve CPC's recommendation of denial and send to formal session, approved without objection. - Line Item 8.2 (Pistons multiplex resolution): Motion to send to formal with recommendation to approve, approved with one objection (member Johnson). - All other items (8.1, 8.3, 8.4, 8.6, 8.7, 8.8, 9.1-9.5, 9.6-9.8, 9.10, 9.12, 9.13): Approved as moved (receive and file, bring back, refer, or send to formal) without objection, unless noted. - Minutes: Approved. - Adjournment: Motion carried.

The Budget, Finance and Audit Standing Committee met on September 17, 2025, to discuss several fiscal items including the lockboxing of elected officials' budgets for the election year, a detailed financial report for fiscal year 2025, the status of council's closing resolutions, and a proposed ordinance to ensure financial stability during election years. Public comment included concerns about elections, city services, tax fees, and retiree matters. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The committee approved the minutes from the previous meeting without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - Mr. Rue: Alleged that the 2025 Detroit election was "cheated" by Gina Avery Walker and Detroit City Clerk Janice Winfrey, and claimed that the mayor, city council, school board, and police commissioners were also cheated in. He urged that they not run the 2025 election. - Betty A. Barner (President of De Soda Elsewhere Block Association): Advocated for her community and shared information about a seniors program (60+) offering free services such as branch removal, fuse replacement, door locks, window screens, and security doors. Provided contact: 313-579-1000 ext. 301. - Cunningham: Expressed concerns about D-DOT bus services taking longer on routes (Jefferson, etc.) and urged attendees to share information about an upcoming D-DOT meeting. He also gave out bus tickets and asked for kindness towards those waiting long periods. - Carolyn Hughes: Questioned the start of public comment before a quorum was present (the chair clarified it is allowed). Raised concerns about foreclosure programs, homeless services worsening, and unexplained special fees on tax bills. Also noted that garbage pickup fees appear to be increasing despite earlier assurances. - Ms. Warwick: Expressed concern about being dropped from the public comment queue. Criticized the budget for not funding people affected by "unconstitutional solar takings" while budgeting over $5 million for Farmington Hills attorneys. Also commended Coleman Young II for speaking out about Charlie Kirk, and contrasted legal immigration with illegal immigration. - William M. Davis: Criticized Mayor Duggan's proposal to use surplus funds for declining tax revenues, arguing that tax abatements for millionaires and billionaires reduce revenue. Predicted a campaign against Duggan if retirees are not helped, and noted that Detroit's population rank dropped from 18th to 26th largest city under Duggan. Called for clawbacks on developers who fail to deliver, not on retirees. - Not That Karen Winston: City of Detroit retiree, opposed clawbacks of retiree money and urged clawbacks on developers who do not fulfill their obligations. Also argued that the pension board mishandled funds, not retirees. Opposed illegal immigration but welcomed legal immigrants. Called for city council to change committees every two years as per the charter. Discussion Items - 5.1 – Status of Office of CFO: Allocation of Elected Officials Budget for FY26: Donnie Johnson (Acting Deputy CFO and Budget Director) presented a resolution to lockbox 50% of each elected official's office budget (including council president's support budget) until after the election and start of the new council term. This ensures newly elected officials have six months of budget available. Councilmember Young confirmed that current council members are on track to stay under 50% spending. The committee voted to send to formal with a recommendation to approve. - 5.2 – Financial Report for 12 Months Ended June 30, 2025: Donnie Johnson explained drivers of surplus in professional contractual services (unspent flood response reserves), operating supplies (lower-than-expected software licensing costs and as-needed contracts), and other expenses (workforce investment fund not needed due to vacancies, and interfund transfers). No city services were impacted. The report was received and filed. - 5.3 – Legislative Policy Division Report on Status of 2024-2026 Priorities: Renee Short presented a detailed report on the status of council's 119 closing resolutions. Highlights: 77% of items have been acted on (open or closed); 46 items were funded in the FY25 budget. Accomplishments included funding for residential cyber repair, tree trimming, Office of Disability, Office of Immigrant Affairs, paid parental leave, reparations task force, nurse navigation, etc. Council also secured $9.5 million in ARPA funds for council-directed use and $14.5 million in OCFO reallocated funds, with $5 million for homeless initiatives. Items under consideration include behavioral health training, child care, Motown Museum, retiree rainy day fund, police mini stations, and more. Councilmember Young asked about the 30-minute neighborhoods progress and DPD mini stations; Ms. Short suggested further discussion with DPD. The report was received and filed. - 5.4 – Councilmember Benson’s Memorandum re Detroit Public Library Foundation Information: Due to potential litigation regarding the Detroit Public Library Foundation, the committee voted to bring this item back to a date to be determined, at the request of Chief Officer Antonio Brown. - 6.1 – Proposed Ordinance to Amend Chapter 17 (Budget Allocation to Elected Offices): This ordinance provides for financial stability of elected offices during election years. It was already discussed in item 5.1. The committee voted to send the ordinance to formal for introduction and setting of a public hearing. Key Outcomes - Item 5.1: Approved to send to formal session with recommendation to approve (motion passed without objection). - Item 5.2: Received and filed (motion passed without objection). - Item 5.3: Received and filed (motion passed without objection). - Item 5.4: Tabled to a date to be determined (motion passed without objection). - Item 6.1: Sent to formal for introduction and public hearing (motion passed without objection). - Meeting Adjourned: At the call of the chair without objection.

The Internal Operations Standing Committee met on Wednesday, September 17, 2025, with Councilmembers Letitia Johnson (Chair), Mary Waters, and Angela Whitfield Callaway present. The committee heard public comment, conducted interviews for two city board appointments, and voted on several contracts and settlements. Public Comments & Testimony - Mr. Rue alleged absentee ballot fraud by the Detroit City Clerk and Election Commission, urging the committee to investigate. He stated that “Detroit has been took over by absentee ballot fraud.” - iPhone promoted the neighborhood beautification grant and shared free senior services offered by Franklin Wright Settlement Organization, including home repairs and seasonal maintenance. - Not That Karen expressed disappointment that many seniors do not qualify for the fast-track city council resolution. She called for restoring pensions and healthcare for Detroit retirees, stopping clawbacks, and addressing homelessness. She also advocated for term limits and rotating committees per the city charter. - William M. Davis argued that the city should do more for retirees and predicted Mayor Mike Duggan would “lose badly” if he did not address retiree issues. He criticized rising property taxes and tax abatements for the rich, noting Detroit fell from 18th to 26th largest city. - Miko A. Williams condemned comments made by a previous speaker as anti-Semitic and warned about political violence. She called for civility and accountability, referencing threats made by others. - Cunningham discussed bus service issues, handing out bus tickets and supplies, and asked for support for outreach efforts. - Ronald Foster praised the council for listening but urged transparency on police settlements (citing line item 8.4, $250,000) and said the public has a right to know payouts. He also warned about unmarked law enforcement. - Carolyn Hughes (Owner Papa) asked why the committee does not call police to explain lawsuits, and criticized the police union and indemnification of officers. She also questioned the legality of a contract amendment and Mr. Hornsby’s forgiveness of millions to the Land Bank. - Caller ending 124 asked for notice of Brownfield CAC meetings, questioned the right-to-counsel program’s absence for solar-taking victims, demanded the city clerk explain Melissa Love’s voter record, and alleged lies by the law department. - Tohear Ahmed thanked Councilmember Callaway and complained about home repair corruption, accusing other council members of blocking help. He promoted the Michigan Home Energy Rebate Program and argued against illegal immigrants taking resources. - Galaxy S22 Ultra (Mr. Holloway) urged unity, prayed for the council, and called for restoring retiree money. He criticized funding billionaires over retirees. Discussion Items Appointments - Kristen Lessen (Elected Officials Compensation Commission) was interviewed. She is an attorney and former Board of Ethics member. Councilmember Callaway supported her, citing her fairness. Lessen confirmed no conflict of interest. The committee combined line items 5 and 8.1 and voted to send to formal session with a recommendation to approve. - John Barth (Detroit Brownfield CAC) was interviewed. He holds a master’s in urban planning and works in community development. He discussed his experience with community engagement and data analysis. The committee combined line items 6 and 7.1–7.4 and voted to send to formal session with a request to the Law Department to draft a ballot motion. New Business (Line Items) - 8.2 – Amendment to Right to Counsel contract with Lakeshore Legal Aid. Attorney Diamond Conley explained that the amendment transfers ownership of the intake and income verification system to Lakeshore to protect attorney-client privilege. Approved unanimously. - 8.3 – Monthly report of administratively approved contracts ($25k–$50k) for July–August. Chair Johnson requested more information; the item was brought back in two weeks. - 8.4 – Workers’ comp settlement ($250,000) for Philip Leonard vs. Detroit Police Department. Approved. - 8.5 – Settlement ($4,000) for All Ways on Time Transportation vs. city (DDOT). Approved. - 8.6 – Settlement ($14,500) for Atia Hunt vs. city (Fire Department). Approved. - 8.7 – Settlement ($310,000) for Cornell Jackson vs. city and Darrell Russell (DDOT). Approved. - 8.8 – Settlement ($75,000) for Jill Babcock et al. vs. State, County, City, and Detroit Wayne Joint Building Authority. Approved. - 8.9 – Inspector General debarment report for Lucas Enterprises. Received and filed. - 8.10 – Councilmember Callaway’s request for a report and resolution on a domestic violence task force. Brought back in two weeks. Key Outcomes - Appointments: The committee approved sending Kristen Lessen’s nomination for the Elected Officials Compensation Commission and the four nominees (including John Barth) for the Brownfield CAC to full council for formal approval. A ballot motion will be drafted for the Brownfield appointments. - Right to Counsel Amendment (8.2): Approved with a motion to send to formal session. - Settlements (8.4–8.8): All approved unanimously. - Administrative Contracts (8.3): Held for two weeks pending further research. - Domestic Violence Task Force (8.10): Held for two weeks due to committee cancellation. Member Reports - Councilmember Waters reminded of the Skilled Trade Task Force meeting at 4–6 p.m. at the Copper to Mirror Rights Training Center. - Councilmember Callaway reported on protesting non-union workers at a project at Pershing High School, announced an expungement clinic on September 20, and celebrated new banners on Livernois (Avenue of Fashion). - Councilmember Johnson reminded that the Neighborhood Beautification Grant closes October 24, 2025, with special funding for areas within the Stellantis footprint.

The Detroit City Council convened on September 16, 2025, at approximately 10:00 a.m. for a regular formal session. The meeting opened with a prayer led by Councilmember Coleman A. Young II and included a special presentation honoring Transportation Riders United (TRUE) for its 25th anniversary of transit advocacy. The council then heard public comments from residents on a range of topics, including property tax overpayments, police accountability, vendor displacement, voting rights, and community development. Following public comment, the council considered numerous contracts, resolutions, and discussion items, including a resolution requesting a forensic audit of the Detroit Land Bank Authority (eventually approved), a contract to rent Detroit Public Schools buildings for elections (approved after debate), and a postponement of the TraP Tailgate event. The meeting concluded with member reports and adjournment. Consent Calendar - Routine approvals of meeting minutes. - Adoption of multiple consent agenda items without separate discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - In-Person Speakers: - Branetta Moore: Expressed concern about theft at a shelter and lack of access to replacement clothing. - Betty Lyons: Raised allegations about $600 million in overpaid property taxes and accused city officials of withholding funds. - Brenda Allen: Praised Councilmember Coleman A. Young II for assisting with her roof repair. - Sharon Williams: Criticized the Detroit Police Department for allegedly employing individuals with criminal records and failing to protect citizens. - Melissa Love: Demanded removal from voter rolls and accused the council of misusing taxpayer funds and neglecting Detroit residents. - Ramon Jackson: Presented USB drives with voter data, alleging fraudulent voting by jailed individuals using the county jail address. - Jocelyn Jackson: Raised issues about vendor displacement at Campus Martius Park by Glowworks, claiming lack of city support. - Joshua Lamere: Requested funding for a bird sanctuary pocket park at 2000 Woodward Avenue and praised Councilmember Angela Callaway. - Mr. Cunningham (public transit advocate): Thanked council for supporting public transportation, noted rider concerns about route reliability, and promoted the TRUE gala. - Pastor Lamonzo Sewell: Raised concerns about voting procedures for incarcerated individuals and requested assistance with property drainage fees for his church. - Grace Howard: Questioned how Glowworks obtained control of Campus Martius Park, displacing long-time vendors. - Barbara Logan: Criticized council for sometimes contradicting public comment, stating it silences residents. - Rhino Foster: Emphasized free speech and warned against political violence and oppression. - Online Callers: - William M. Davis: Opposed Mayor Duggan's use of surplus funds to cover tax revenue declines, urged focus on retirees and poor residents. - Hira Ahmed: Accused Mayor Duggan and Council President Sheffield of mismanaging funds and neglecting homeless and retirees. - Stephen Haring: Criticized a recent Palestine conference in Detroit, alleging terrorist rhetoric, and expressed support for Israel's right to exist. - Multiple callers echoed themes of property tax overpayment, voter suppression, and the need for term limits. - Tyson Gersh: Discussed BZA transcript fees, arguing city council never approved a pass-through to a private vendor and suggested using video recordings instead of costly transcripts. - Crystal Rice: Highlighted lack of response to community issues, praised Mary Waters for addressing voter questions, and criticized council for not prioritizing black-owned businesses. - Miko A. Williams: Advised Council President Sheffield not to accept endorsements from Mayor Duggan or Santi Ojinga, and decried police harassment. - Cina Brown Anderson: Criticized the public comment process as demeaning, demanded audits of the land bank, and called for reforms to election procedures and alcohol licensing. Discussion Items - Presentation for Transportation Riders United (TRUE): Councilmember Gabriela Santiago-Romero presented a testimonial resolution celebrating TRUE's 25th anniversary. TRUE's director spoke about advocacy achievements and invited council to a gala on September 25, 2025. The resolution was approved unanimously. - Contract for Detroit Public Schools Polling Places (Item 16.1): A $297,653 contract to rent DPS buildings for August and November 2025 elections drew debate. Council members questioned why the city now pays for school use (since 2022) and expressed concerns about scope creep and budget impact. The administration cited post-pandemic inflation and difficulty finding accessible locations. The contract was approved, with a waiver attached. - Forensic Audit of Detroit Land Bank Authority (Item 17.10): Councilmember Mary Waters introduced a resolution requesting the Michigan Office of the Auditor General conduct a forensic audit. Councilmember Scott Benson advocated for using the city's own auditor general, citing cost and control. After discussion, including input from Auditor General Flora Goodsby who confirmed the office has resources and plans to conduct a follow-up forensic audit, the council approved the resolution (objections none). A waiver was also granted. - Zoning and Public Hearing Items (Items 17.5-17.8): Multiple zoning ordinance introductions and public hearing settings were approved, including a rezoning for retail sales at a farm/insider operation and a public hearing set for October 16, 2025. Item 17.8 (rezoning coordination) was postponed for community engagement updates but later moved forward after consultation with the city planning commission. - Contract for Municipal Parking System (Item 19.8): A $10.9 million contract with Madaxo Traffic Management was postponed for one week due to pending tax clearance, as noted by the Office of Contracting and Procurement. - TraP Tailgate Event (Walk-On): The event originally scheduled for October 12, 2025 at Rose Bell Park was withdrawn at the petitioner's request; postponement to 2026 was confirmed by the special events department. - Secondary Street Sign Ordinance (Walk-On): A resolution setting a public hearing for October 23, 2025 was approved. Key Outcomes - Approved: Resolution honoring Transportation Riders United (TRUE). - Approved: Multi-year contract for DPS polling places ($297,653) after debate; waiver granted. - Approved: Resolution requesting a forensic audit of the Detroit Land Bank Authority by the Michigan Auditor General (with waiver). - Approved: Numerous contracts and resolutions for housing, public safety, construction, and grants across multiple departments (items 17.1–19.11). - Postponed: Contract for municipal parking system (Item 19.8) for one week. - Withdrawn: TraP Tailgate event petition; postponed to 2026. - Scheduled: Public hearings for zoning changes and secondary street sign ordinance on October 16 and October 23, 2025, respectively. - Waivers Granted: For multiple items to bypass waiting periods. - Adjourned: Meeting concluded with a moment of silence for community leaders Jeffrey Thomas and Eric Ford.

The committee convened on September 15, 2025, to conduct administrative appeals hearings for properties on the dangerous buildings list. Chair Councilmember Gabriela Santiago-Romero presided, with Councilmembers Scott Benson and Mary Waters present. Over 50 properties were considered. The hearing included testimony from property owners, inspection reports from the Buildings, Safety Engineering and Environmental Department (BSEED), and votes on demolitions, withdrawals, and deferrals. Public Comments & Testimony - George Mujanis (2952 Cast): Expressed desire to keep the property, stating he had a plan to repair the roof but faced a bank loan freeze due to a city notice. The committee returned the property to BSEED for continued conversation. - Ms. Patterson (4713 Crane): Sought to keep the property; reported a tarp on the roof and raised concern that the fire department used the home for training, causing additional damage. The property was withdrawn from the demolition list. - Shafon (3836 Fisher): Stated the property went into foreclosure but she remained owner. She wanted demolition. The committee ordered demolition and recommended legal counsel. - Camilla El Shabazz (4900 South Martindale): Wanted to keep the property, had a dismissal letter from a prior hearing. BSEED noted openings; she addressed them and was selling. Returned to BSEED until October 20. - Hill Harper (3975 Cass): Expressed strong support for preserving the historic building, describing a major redevelopment plan with a renowned architect. BSEED reported openings and debris. Returned to BSEED. - Tiffany (6043 Beagle): Working to keep her late mother’s home; had torn down a porch, was tarping the roof, and sought help with a tree from a neighboring school. Returned to BSEED. - Danielle Winesley (5937 Cooper): Wanted to keep her grandmother’s home; had overgrowth and debris issues. Received advice on bulk pickup. Returned to BSEED. - Cedric Felix (8913 North Clarendon): First hearing, wanted to demolish. Advised to obtain contractor permits. Ordered demolished. - John (15795 Cloverlawn): Registered vacant property, sent pictures, demolished garage. BSEED noted openings. Returned to BSEED. - Cassandra Webster (14247 Marlowe): Planning to keep and renovate; overgrowth cut, boarding in progress. Returned to BSEED. - Eddie Mora (3707 Grisel): Property withdrawn; recommended to register as vacant. Numerous other property owners participated with properties that were withdrawn or ordered demolished; many had addressed BSEED requirements. Discussion Items - The administration and BSEED (Dili Portel) explained the hearing process: these are legally required administrative appeals from prior informal hearings. - Committee members discussed the importance of securing property openings, removing debris, and registering vacant properties. - Several callers experienced technical difficulties; Councilmember Waters provided her office contact for follow-up. - The committee advised owners to self-demolish to avoid city liens and directed property owners to send updated photos to BSEED. Key Outcomes - Properties Ordered Demolished: 3836 Fisher, 8913 North Clarendon, 15795 Cloverlawn, 1709 Kendall, 8617 Harper, 6022 Hazlitt, 3784 Hogarth, 9915 Kirchaville, 12293 Kilborn, 9353 Laura, 1709 Kendall, and others as per block votes. - Properties Withdrawn from List: 4713 Crane, 3027 Cadillac, 3753 Web, 14959 Karam, 15032 Evanston, 17836 Gable, 2655 Atwater, 18921 John R, 6672 Clifton, 4947 Maplewood, 13556 Metatal, 3707 Grisel, 10410 CadYou, 8261 Colfax, 17350 Cooley, 744 Cotrel, 14198 Evergreen, 15210 Foyer (withdrawn during hearing), 6684 Pellose, 14928 Sorrento, 3095 St. Clair, 18050 St. Louis, 9978 Stahalin, 8812 Stopel, 13445 Tacoma, 1546 Trinity, and others. - Properties Returned to BSEED: 2952 Cast, 4900 South Martindale, 3975 Cass, 6043 Beagle, 5937 Cooper, 15795 Cloverlawn, 14247 Marlowe, 7230 Rosemont, 2739 Pasadena, 3704 West Warren (reconsidered and returned), and several others with deadlines for further progress. - Final Block Votes: The committee voted to concur with department findings for Block 8 (modified: 6043 Beagle returned), Block 9 (modified: 3975 Cass returned), Block 10 (modified: 5937 Cooper and 15795 Cloverlawn returned), Block 11 (concurred), Block 12 (modified: 14247 Marlowe returned), Block 13 (modified: 4900 South Martindale and 2739 Pasadena returned), Block 14 (modified: 7230 Rosemont returned), Block 15 (modified: 3704 West Warren returned after reconsideration), Block 16 (concurred). - Next Steps: Property owners were instructed to secure openings, maintain yards, register vacant properties, and send updated photos to BSEED at bseedemo@detroitmi.gov. The next hearing is scheduled for October 20, 2025.

The Detroit City Council Public Health and Safety Committee met on September 15, 2025, at approximately 10:00 AM under Chairperson Santiago Romero. The meeting covered public comments, unfinished business, new business, and several committee reports. Key discussions included the status of the Broadhead Armory, DPD video release ordinance, a recalcitrant landlord (Munoz Real Estate), and various contracts and petitions. The committee also noted a dangerous buildings hearing scheduled for 1:30 PM. Public Comments & Testimony - Mr. Cunningham (in-person) expressed concerns about Detroit Department of Transportation (DDOT) service delays on Jefferson and Woodward routes, describing 30–40 minute waits. He thanked the council for support and urged improvements. - Tony Camillary (in-person) voiced strong support for the Marine Corps Reserve Center (Broadhead Armory), calling it a “gem” and urging the city to allow the parade company to purchase or extend the lease. He shared personal history of maintaining the facility and noted its deterioration after the Marines left. - Not that Karen (online) criticized the committee for allowing extra time to the first speaker, demanded restoration of Detroit retiree pensions, and called for return of property tax overpayments ($600 million). She also highlighted homelessness and child welfare. - Betty A. Varner (online, president of Soda Ellsworth Black Association) promoted a senior/disabled assistance program through DAA (Detroit Area Agency on Aging), providing Medicaid eligibility and in-home support. She also gave donation information for her organization. - Owner Papa (online) accused the chair of lying about receiving a voter fraud report, alleged cheating by certain officials, and referenced the murder of Kenisha Coleman. He also criticized the city’s handling of municipal bonds and voter fraud. - Miko A. Williams (online) expressed concern about residents getting sick and inquired about the Broadhead Armory status. She also criticized the parade company and called for action on the $600 million taxation issue and senior homelessness. - Caller ending 124 (online) opposed the parade company’s efforts on the Broadhead Armory, called for contacting Senator Rand Paul, and criticized the solar vote and eminent domain. She also commended Councilmember Coleman Young for calling out political violence. - William and Davis (online) agreed with “Not that Karen” on retiree pensions, noted over 400 Detroit general fund retirees died this year, asked about reimbursement for emergency demolitions, criticized DPD video release delays, and supported the “Fix Our Flooded Basement Act.” - Tahira Ahmed (online) objected to sanctuary cities, claimed illegal immigrants are replacing black residents, and accused Councilmember Romero of supporting immigration policies harmful to Black Detroiters. She also asked about reparations. - Ronald Foster (online) defined political violence, urged a memorandum to the U.S. Attorney’s Office against political violence, and called for fair elections free from harassment. - Later caller (owner Papa again) demanded action on retiree pensions, criticized Munoz Real Estate for unsafe housing, and asked about speed humps and particulate matter. She noted the committee had received and filed a report on speed humps. Discussion Items - Unfinished Business 5.1 and 5.2 – Emergency Demolitions (23241 Finkel and 1974 Stalin): Brought back after one week; motion to approve carried. - 5.3 – Renovation of Linden Street Facility (Police) – Contract No. 6007191, $500,000. A correction letter was needed to indicate funding from 911 surcharge rather than general funds. Robert Millender (director of public safety IT) confirmed the funding source and promised a correction letter by next formal session. Motion to approve and send to new business carried. - 5.4 – DPD Video Release Ordinance – Law Department presented a draft ordinance (30-day hold on video release). The ordinance had been coordinated with Prosecutor Kim Worthy and Police Chief Todd Bettison. Motion to receive and file carried. - 5.5 – Rescission for 7285 Prairie – Concurred with BSEED recommendation; approved. - 5.6–5.8 – Memos on Flooded Basement Act, Child Abduction Broadcast Act, and Senate Bill 492 – LPD requested these be brought back in one week; motion carried. - 5.9 – Munoz Real Estate Compliance – BSEED officials reported that Munoz has registered 95% of properties but only 37% are in compliance. He owes approximately $200,000 in tickets. An update was provided on bi-weekly meetings and a target of 18 inspections per week. Chair Romero expressed concern about tenant safety, lack of water accounts, and slow progress. The committee discussed legal options, escrow accounts, and potential litigation. Motion to bring back TBD (to be determined) carried. Councilmember Waters noted the need for HRD to launch an online rental escrow process. - New Business 6.1–6.5 – Contracts approved: 6.1 (environmental remediation for Preserve on Ash III, $1M, contractor from Columbus, OH), 6.2 (HIV/STI navigation services, $85K, Detroit), 6.3 (ShotSpotter evaluation extension, ARPA-funded), 6.4 (Rides to Care renewal, $400K increase), 6.5 (conduit lines, $1,500 per pole/year). All sent to formal with recommendation to approve. - 6.6 – Dangerous Buildings Findings (Aug 29, 2025) – Received and filed. - 6.7–6.8 – Deferrals for 5301 and 5311 East Outer Drive – Vice Chair Benson requested a week’s delay to investigate the proposed use of a defunct SOB (sexually oriented business). Motion to bring back in one week carried. - 6.9 – Deferral for 9765 Sanalic – Concurred with department recommendation. - 6.10–6.11 – Grants – 6.10: $1,245,790 grant for battery electric buses and charging infrastructure (four buses: two 60-ft articulated, two 40-ft). Expected in service by end of 2025. 6.11: Firearm safety grant application authorization. Both approved. - 6.12–6.16 – Encroachments and Vacations – 6.12 (Arab American/Chaldean Council sign), 6.13 (MDOT decertification of streets for Roosevelt Park), 6.15 (vacation of Columbia Street for Olympia Entertainment), 6.16 (alley vacation) approved. 6.14 (Himelhoch building sign for Museum of Illusions) – brought back one week due to resident concerns about illumination and tenant impact. - 6.17 – Vape Products Ordinance Questions – Brought back in two weeks. Key Outcomes - Minutes from last session approved. - Public comment cut off at 10:05 AM; each speaker given 2 minutes. - 5.1 and 5.2 – Emergency demolitions brought back in one week. - 5.3 – Approved pending correction letter; sent to new business. - 5.4 – DPD video release ordinance received and filed; draft to be presented next week. - 5.5 – BSEED rescission concurred. - 5.6–5.8 – Memos brought back in one week. - 5.9 – Munoz compliance update; motion to bring back TBD; LPD asked to explore punitive options; committee to meet with HRD and BSEED. - 6.1–6.5 – Approved and sent to formal. - 6.6 – Received and filed. - 6.7–6.8 – Brought back one week for further information. - 6.9 – Concurred. - 6.10–6.11 – Approved. - 6.12–6.16 – 6.12, 6.13, 6.15, 6.16 approved; 6.14 brought back one week. - 6.17 – Brought back two weeks. - Committee recessed at approximately 11:00 AM, with a dangerous buildings hearing scheduled at 1:30 PM.