Public Meetings - Maui County, Hawaii

The special committee on real property tax reform met on January 20, 2026, at 9:03 AM to discuss Bill 142 (2025), which addresses the home exemption and long-term rental exemption from real property tax. The meeting focused on proposed amendments to reduce the wait time for the home exemption from up to 18 months to as little as 6 months, with significant discussion on implementation language and potential alternative mechanisms. Public Comments & Testimony - Tom Crowley: Expressed gratitude for the committee but stated he is not in full support of the proposed solution. He noted that the current tax classification system can cause property tax bills to vary by up to 10x, and the proposed bill could reduce the error period to 6 months but still may not fully solve the problem. He recommended deferring action and revisiting with the department. - Michael Williams (President of My Tomorrow Foundation): Presented a revenue tax estimator tool and emphasized that the long-term rental exemption category needs more work, as thousands of genuine long-term rentals are classified as non-owner occupied due to lack of one-year written leases. He urged making the definition easier to qualify. - James Langford: Offered software to help implement solutions and noted that Council Member Johnson's proposal would mitigate pushback. He claimed he could write the necessary accounting software in about 10 minutes. Discussion Items - Bill 142 and Proposed CD1 (Council Member Paulton): The original bill adjusts filing deadlines for home and long-term rental exemptions. The proposed CD1, introduced by Council Member Paulton, narrows the scope by removing the next tax payment option for long-term rental exemption, adjusting deed filing requirements, and reducing the residency requirement from 10 to 5 years. Council Member Paulton clarified she is open to amendments. - Finance Department Concerns: Marcy Martin (Finance) stated that the language proposed by the department (based on Big Island's model) is different from the ASF presented. She preferred the department's language, noting that the late-filed exemption already passed is for people who qualify as of January 1, while the half-year exemption is for those purchasing between January 1 and June 30. She expressed concern about commingling programs. - Differences in Language: Peter Hanano (staff) explained that the ASF he drafted avoids potential conflicts with subsection 3.48.410 D, while the department's proposal would put the exemption in subsection A. Corp Counsel noted that a separate bill (PAF 26004) might require further revisions. - Council Member Johnson's Proposal: Suggested a supplementary fund administered by the administration to cover the difference in taxes for those transitioning from short-term to long-term rentals, allowing them to pay the owner-occupied rate immediately. Finance director Marcy Martin responded that this would be more like a subsidy or grant outside real property tax, requiring legislation. - Statistics: Marcy Martin noted the department receives about 1,500 home exemption applications per year, and about 5-10% of approved applicants fail compliance (e.g., not filing income tax returns). - Resource Person Tom Crowley: Advised the committee not to take action on the ASF, stating it is too confusing and not ready for a decision. Key Outcomes - Deferral: The committee voted to defer Bill 142 and the associated ASF to allow further work on the language and potential alternative mechanisms. No objections were raised. - Next Steps: The committee will work with the finance department, council members, and staff to refine the bill, possibly incorporating a supplementary fund idea or other mechanisms. A future meeting will be scheduled to revisit the item. - No Votes Taken: No formal votes were held on the bill or amendments; the item was deferred by consensus.

The Budget Finance Economic Development (BFED) Committee of the Maui County Council met on January 15, 2026, at 9:07 AM, chaired by Yuki Le Sugimura. The meeting covered three agenda items: a discussion on Bill 4 (amending FY26 budget to provide an additional $5 million to the Lahaina Community Land Trust), a discussion on Bill 3 (amending FY26 budget to recognize $2 million in insurance proceeds for the Komohana Hale Apartments rebuild), and a deferred item on carryover savings. Public testimony was heard on both bills. Public Comments & Testimony - Jesse Law (Kulauka Wakoa Hopua) testified on both items, expressing support and quoting Proverbs 24. He stated he was present to listen and learn for the Kanaka Maoli (full-blooded Hawaiian person). - Caroline Waloa (Lahaina Community Land Trust) thanked the committee for its support, emphasizing the importance of keeping Lahaina's people and identity intact. She expressed full support for the work being done. - Langford (testifier) expressed 100% support for the $5 million and offered software support. He praised the collaborative approach. - Royal House of Hawaii and Lahaina (testifier) objected to any decision-making regarding land, claiming that all land is under royal patent and that descendants have not been consulted. They demanded that lands be returned to royal patent descendants, citing international law violations. Discussion Items Bill 4 – Amendment to FY26 Budget: Grant to Lahaina Community Land Trust (LCLT) The committee discussed Bill 4, which proposes to: - Recognize $5 million in estimated revenue from general fund carryover savings. - Increase the Department of Housing grant to LCLT from $6 million to $11 million. - Delete a $5 million grant condition tied to the Open Space, Natural Resources, Cultural Resources, and Scenic Views Preservation Fund. Presentation by Autumn Ness, Executive Director of LCLT: - LCLT has protected 19 parcels zoned for up to 45 units, with 13 titled properties, 2 planned-giving properties, 5 in escrow, and 8 families under construction. The total is 28–29 parcels protected in two years. - The Keep Lahaina Home program (insurance gap funding) has leveraged $2.8 million of the $3.5 million allocated, with construction costs averaging $400 per square foot (below the CDBGDR estimate of $500). - LCLT raised $9.4 million in private donations in calendar year 2025, plus $50,000 from the Kaluheo program (28 local business partners). - A $5 million anonymous matching grant is pending. - The need for speed is critical: some parcels are listed for less than 5–7 days, and disaster capitalists are poised to buy land after the upcoming settlement payouts. LCLT needs a cash reserve to compete. - The managed retreat fund ($5 million) may not be used; LCLT is working with Hūʻao Pāʻa to help families apply for the ʻĀina Kapuna exemption, potentially allowing the funds to lapse. - The transfer of 266 Dickinson Street from the county to LCLT is stalled due to paperwork issues. Questions from Councilmembers: - Councilmember Uʻi Hodgins asked about oversight and reconciliation of purchases. Deputy Director Samalu Mataava explained that reimbursement claims are reviewed against the grant scope; no claims have been rejected. - Councilmember Rollins Fernandez asked about long-term sustainability. Ness replied that the front-loading will slow down as land is secured, and LCLT will shift to a stewardship organization. She noted that lessons learned include using external consultants and software (Public House, Home Keeper, Salesforce) to expedite work. - Councilmember Johnson asked about the 266 Dickinson property and the CDBGDR (Hōʻokūmāho) program rules. Nes clarified that if a homeowner starts any construction (including planning/permitting), they may be disqualified from Hōʻokūmāho. Councilmember Paulton added that the federal government avoids mid-rebuild intervention. - Councilmember Paulton asked about first-time homebuyer eligibility for LCLT homes. Mataava noted the Department of Housing has a separate first-time homebuyer program with a waitlist. A follow-up letter was requested to clarify CDBGDR first-time homebuyer opportunities. - Councilmember Batangan asked about local families helped. Ness stated that more than half of LCLT purchases come from families who reach out before listing. - Councilmember Senensi asked about leveraging county funds for private donations. Ness confirmed that the first county budget allocation helped attract other funders. - Councilmember Senensi also asked about state tax exemptions and legislation. Ness mentioned a potential bill to add housing protection as a fifth component of conservation easements. - Chair Lee asked about prevailing wages for volunteer labor (Habitat for Humanity, Mennonite Disaster Services). Corporation Counsel will provide a written answer. Key Statistics: - LCLT has recorded 20% of all real estate transactions in Lahaina since the fires (13 of 66 recorded transactions). - The first eight families in the Keep Lahaina Home program represent over 1,500 collective years of residence in West Maui. - Total county funding to LCLT in FY2024-25 was $15 million (plus $3.6 million private). In FY2025-26, $6 million is currently being spent down, with $2.8 million remaining. Bill 3 – Amendment to FY26 Budget: Komohana Hale Apartments Rebuild Bill 3 proposes to recognize $2 million in estimated revenues in the Housing Interim Financing and Buyback Revolving Fund and appropriate the funds for pre-development costs (site assessment) for the Komohana Hale Apartments rebuild. The insurance proceeds total $4.9 million, but only $2 million is being appropriated at this time. Presentation by Budget Director Leslie Milner and Deputy Director of Finance Maria Zelinski: - The insurance proceeds were recorded in the enterprise fund where the capital asset was held, consistent with GASB accounting standards. - The fund is a proprietary fund with little activity, which is why it is not normally included in the budget. - Additional research is needed on the historical background of the fund, established in 1979. Questions from Councilmembers: - Councilmember Paulton asked about insurance for other county-owned properties (Lahaina Crossroads, Kahaleakiola). Deputy Director Mataava stated that insurance is carried by the property manager (Hale Mahaolu) and that a follow-up letter to Risk Management will be sent to inquire about policies. - Councilmember Paulton asked about the total insurance payout ($4.9 million) and why only $2 million is recognized. The remaining funds will be requested later as the design-build phase progresses. - Councilmember Johnson asked about the wording “site work” vs. “construction.” The site assessment is a prerequisite for the design-build RFP. - Chair Lee asked about the legal and accounting basis for depositing proceeds in the enterprise fund. Marcy Sato (Accounting System Administrator) explained that insurance proceeds for enterprise funds are recorded as offsets to capital assets per GASB. - Councilmember Paulton noted that the revolving fund name is identical to another fund, causing confusion. The committee agreed to defer action until additional research clarifies the original intent. Key Outcomes - Bill 4 (LCLT Funding): The committee deferred the item to allow for follow-up letters on several questions: (1) status of 266 Dickinson transfer, (2) admin fee cap for the grant, (3) clarification on CDBGDR first-time homebuyer program, (4) overall housing unit production tracking, (5) prevailing wage requirements for volunteer labor. No vote was taken. - Bill 3 (Komohana Hale): The committee deferred the item pending additional research on the legal basis for the fund and the confusion over the fund name. A follow-up letter will be sent to Risk Management regarding insurance policies for county-owned properties. No vote was taken. - Carryover Savings Item (BFED-22): Deferred due to time constraints (Budget Director Leslie Milner had to leave). - The committee will reconvene to consider passage on second and final reading for both bills on January 23, 2026.

This special meeting of the Maui County Council, held on January 12, 2026, convened at 20:30 UTC (locally noted as 9:05 AM on January 5, 2026, in the opening remarks) to welcome newly sworn-in Council Member Colonoy Batanka (also referred to as Conoy/Calonoy Batanga) and proceed with administrative committee reassignments. Two public testifiers, Zandra Amaral Krause and Daniel Ornales, offered welcome remarks and advice for collaboration, while the council unanimously adopted Resolution 26-1 to adjust standing committee assignments following the vacancy left by the late Council Member Tashakama. Public Comments & Testimony - Zandra Amaral Krause: Expressed full support for the council's recent work despite the challenges of the past three years. She advised against adopting a "one of the four" or "four against five" mentality, urging all council members to adopt a unified "nine for the county" approach for the benefit of Maui Nui residents. - Daniel Ornales: Stated his personal support for Council Member Colonoy Batanka, praising the new member's skills and expressing an intention to help coordinate efforts regarding local assets and the First Nations program. Discussion Items - Resolution 26-1 (Committee Reassignments): Vice Chair Sugimura moved to adopt the resolution amending Resolution 25-51 to assign new members to standing committees previously held by the late Council Member Tashakama. Member Rollins Fernandez supported the motion, clarifying the specific shifts: Member Noheilani U Hodgins moving from Chair to Vice Chair of the Great Committee, and Colonoy Batanka assuming the Chair of that committee (with Hodgins later identified as Chair of HLU in Fernandez's notes, though clarified as Vice Chair in Sugimura's motion) and Member Batanga being moved to the Vice Chair position for HLU. - Committee Assignments: - Council Member Gabe Johnson: Announced plans to add Council Member Batanka to the ADEPT committee while replacing Vice Chair Sugimura, citing Batanka's potential fit for public transportation matters and welcoming him with open arms. - Councilmember Shane Senency: Expressed support for joining the "WhatsApp committee" (referring to a subcommittee discussing mental health and the houseless community) and welcomed Batanka to the group, noting the need for recommendations regarding the central district. Key Outcomes - Adoption of Resolution 26-1: Unanimously adopted to amend standing committee voting members, formally placing Colonoy Batanka in leadership and vice-leadership roles formerly held by Tashakama. - Committee Roster Updates: - Council Member Colonoy Batanka appointed as Chair of the Great Committee (or HLU, per conflicting clarification in the text) and moved to the ADEPT committee. - Council Member Noheilani U Hodgins moved to Vice Chair of the Great Committee and Chair of HLU. - Council Member Gabe Johnson added Batanka and removed Sugimura from the ADEPT committee. - Councilmember Shane Senency added Batanka to the mental health and houseless community subcommittee. - Procedural Action: Public testimony was closed with unanimous consent; written testimony accepted.

The Maui County Council convened on January 7, 2026, to conduct official business, beginning with a ceremonial recognition of Kumu Hula Iola Balabar's 50 years of service and a personal resolution from Chair Lee to cultivate patience. The meeting featured extensive deliberation on budget amendments for disaster recovery, housing projects, and water conservation, followed by a contentious debate regarding the creation of new H3 and H4 hotel zoning districts in West Maui. Various bills were passed on first reading, referred to committees, or tabled for public hearings, while Resolution 26-4 was adopted to authorize a ground lease for affordable housing development on Lānaʻi. Consent Calendar - Unanimous adoption of Resolution 25213, honoring Kumuhula Iola Balabar for 50 years of hula excellence. - Unanimous approval of Committee Reports CR26-1 and CR26-2 regarding Department of Public Works fund transfers and the Lahaina Wastewater Reclamation Facility loan. - Unanimous passage of Committee Report CR26-3 (first reading of Bill 161: swimming pool moratorium in West Maui). - Unanimous passage of Committee Report CR26-4 (first reading of Bill 168: affordable rental property tax exemption). - Unanimous passage of Committee Report CR26-5 (first reading of Bill 158: water conservation enforcement) and the related amendment requiring pool covers. - Adoption of Resolutions 26-2 and 26-3 (one-year lease extensions for Hale Kupuna lessees) and Resolution 26-4 (ground lease to A0745 Lanai LP for affordable housing). - Passage of Bills 105, 182, and 194 on second and final reading. - Passage of Bill 168 (tax exemption) on first reading. - Passage of Resolution 25-230 to transmit H3/H4 hotel district zoning proposal to planning commissions. - Passage of Bill 194 (county council vacancies) on second and final reading. - Passing of Bills 6, 7, 8, and 11 on first reading as a group motion. - Passing of Bills 184, 186–191, and 193 on second and final reading as a group motion. Public Comments & Testimony - Support for Kumu Hula Iola Balabar: Marcy Martin, Ivy Caldito, Rochelle Mendoza, and Johanna Amarin expressed deep personal gratitude and pride in Balabar's 50 years of teaching hula and fostering community aloha. Rochelle Mendoza emphasized that Balabar represents the essence of aloha through patience and humility. - Bill 193/192 Staff Support: Lorraine Akita (Executive Director, Ethics Commission) and Michael Lilly (Vice Chair, Ethics Commission) expressed strong support for increasing Commission staffing from three to five, citing an overwhelming workload and the ethical necessity of separate attorneys for contested cases. - Bill 3 (Housing Interim Financing): Brian Whitman (Director of Housing) clarified that $2 million in insurance proceeds from the Komohana Halle apartments rebuild are in a separate enterprise fund, urging floor action to prevent delays in FEMA-related housing needs. - Budget Flexibility (Bill 4): Director David Rotz and Autumn Ness (Lāhainā Community Land Trust) explained that $5 million in carryover savings from the Open Space Fund should be transferred to Housing to provide flexibility, as current restrictions hinder the trust's ability to secure residential parcels before a potential post-settlement flood of sales. - Housing Urgency: Douglas Bigley (HHFTC) emphasized the critical need to finalize land leases for the Lānaʻi project to meet HIFA deadlines, stating that land control is a prerequisite for financing. - Water Conservation and Moratorium: Jonathan Heldon (Grassroots Institute) and other testifiers expressed strong support for the swimming pool moratorium (Bill 161) and water conservation enforcement (Bill 158), citing the need to prioritize water for housing and essential needs over non-essential uses. Heldon also supported amendments to the H3/H4 zoning to include shoreline safeguards. - Concerns on Zoning Process: Tom Crowley urged the council to avoid embedding specific conditions in the initial zoning enabling legislation, suggesting that such restrictions be handled on a case-by-case basis during change of zoning reviews to maintain flexibility. - Opposition to Expanding TVR Uses: Councilmember Paulton (in testimony, later vote) and others expressed concern that proposed zoning amendments might inadvertently expand transient vacation rental (TBR) uses beyond current legal statuses. Discussion Items - Resolution 25230 (H3/H4 Hotel Districts): Intense debate occurred regarding whether to send a "clean" bill to the Planning Commission or transmit specific amendments (ASFs) proposed by Councilmembers Paulton and Rollins Fernandez. Paulton and Rollins Fernandez advocated for including language on shoreline protection, armoring restrictions, and managed retreat to guide the Planning Commission. Councilmember Cook and others argued for sending the bill clean to avoid complicating the review process, preferring to address specific shoreline conditions in a separate, comprehensive bill later. Councilmember Batangan voted against the amendments due to concerns about zone-by-zone application versus county-wide policy. Councilmember U. Hodgins stated she would vote no on the specific amendments but proposed sending meeting minutes to the commission as an alternative. The motion to adopt Paulton's amendments (substitution) failed 4-5. The motion to adopt Rollins Fernandez's specific amendments (sections 6-9 regarding armoring and removal) failed 4-5. The motion to adopt Rollins Fernandez's other amendments (striking specific TBR phasing language) failed 3-6. However, the motion to file the County Communications and transmit the bill was passed 9-0. Ultimately, the resolution to transmit the bill was passed 8-1. - Bill 3 (Komohana Halle Rebuild): Councilmember Paulton moved to pass the bill on first reading to address urgent FEMA deadlines (700 households potentially needing housing by Feb 28). Discussion highlighted confusion over fund nomenclature (revolving vs. enterprise), with Councilmember Sugimura noting the need for a 7B for clarification, but the urgency prevailed, and the motion passed. - Bill 4 (Lahaina Community Land Trust): Debate focused on the flexibility provided by transferring $5 million from the Open Space Fund. Vice Chair Sugimura requested a 7B to better understand the implications of the fund transfer and real estate market timing, which Councilmember Johnson agreed would be helpful before the budget season. - Bill 120 (Water Availability Policy): Referral to the Water and Infrastructure Committee. - Bills 9 & 10 (Water Infrastructure): Referral to the Budget, Finance, and Economic Development Committee. - Bill 183 (West Maui Height Limits): Tabled pending a required public hearing in the district. - Bill 192 (Houseless Solutions): Passed on second and final reading, updating conditional language to develop a resiliency hub and accommodate a West Maui safe parking site using existing facilities rather than new construction. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25213: Adopted unanimously to honor Kumuhula Iola Balabar. - Resolution 26-4: Adopted unanimously (9-0) to authorize a ground lease to A0745 Lanai LP for the Lānaʻi affordable housing project (372 units). - Bill 3: Passed on first reading (9-0) to authorize $2M for the Komohana Halle Apartments rebuild, enabling immediate pre-development work. - Bill 4: Passed on first reading (9-0) to transfer $5M to the Lahaina Community Land Trust. - Bill 5: Passed on first reading (9-0) to insert Namaka Omalilo as the grantee for the Makwa Yahaiku fund. - Bill 6, 7, 8, 11: Passed on first reading (9-0) as a group for Safe Parking, East Maui Water Authority, Lahaina Homecoming event, and Khalani Apartment unit distribution updates respectively. - Bill 105, 182, 194: Passed on second and final reading (unanimously or near-unanimously). - Bill 185: Passed on second and final reading (8-1, with Councilmember Batangan recusing herself). - Bills 184, 186-191, 193: Passed on second and final reading (9-0) as a group for various capital improvements and budget amendments. - Bill 192: Passed on second and final reading (9-0). - Resolution 2523: Filed (9-0) as moot, superseded by Resolution 26-4. - Bill 158 (Water Conservation): First reading passed with an amendment requiring pool covers (9-0). - Bill 161 (Swimming Pool Moratorium): First reading passed (9-0). - Bill 168 (Tax Exemption): First reading passed (9-0). - Resolution 25230: Transmitted to Planning Commissions with County Communications 26-1 and 26-2 filed separately; specific amendments by Paulton and Rollins Fernandez failed on multiple votes (4-5 and 3-6) due to disagreements on the approach to shoreline management and zone-by-zone versus comprehensive legislation. - Recusals: Councilmember Batangan recused herself from voting on Bill 185 due to a pending Board of Ethics advisory opinion regarding a previous appointment.

The Housing Land Use Committee convened on January 5, 2026, to discuss Resolution 25-230, which proposes creating new H3 and H4 zoning districts to facilitate the continued operation of certain Transient Vacation Rental (TVR) units currently in A1 and A2 districts while preventing further expansion of uses. The meeting featured introductions of proposed amendments by Councilmembers Paultin and Rollins Fernandez, extensive public testimony regarding sea level rise, shoreline access, and specific properties like Maui Sands, and a transition to executive session to consult legal counsel on liability and zoning eligibility. Consent Calendar - No routine approvals were listed or taken during this session. Public Comments & Testimony - John Chason (Maui Sands One Owner): Expressed concerns regarding the unique economic and environmental vulnerabilities of Maui Sands, including a 65% underfunded maintenance reserve, a land lease expiring in 2037 (limiting mortgage availability), and severe sea level rise risks where 3.2 feet of rise would cause complete flooding. He pleaded to have Maui Sands included on the county-initiated zoning change list (Exhibit Two). - Ryan Logtenberg (Maui Sands Owner): Argued in full support of preserving Maui Sands as a historic vacation complex, stating its leasehold structure and economic model do not support long-term housing. He opposed displacement of the property's historic function. - Kaina Nishiki (Resource to TIG/Former West Maui Community Plan Chair): Expressed strong concern that without amendments, the proposal risks increasing property values for offshore owners while ignoring climate risks in the Sea Level Rise Exposure Area (SLOREX). She requested the convening of experts to develop fiscal protections and safeguards. - Albert Perez (Planner/Community Member): Stated opposition to specific language referencing A1/A2 districts, arguing it is not good planning practice for the county code. He expressed concern that the current language might give "ammunition" to ongoing lawsuits regarding non-conforming uses. - Jim Langford: Advocated for incorporating atmospheric water systems (dehumidifiers) into the zoning language to shift the burden of water production and maintenance costs onto the hotel operators. - Jesse Law: Expressed support for the new zoning to address due process concerns but echoed concerns about over-complicating the code with references to other ordinances. He stated support for Councilmember Rollins Fernandez's amendment. - Jackie Keefe: Expressed full support for Councilmember Rollins Fernandez's amendment regarding shoreline access and illegal armoring. - Greg Rilski: Stated support for repealing Ordinance 4369 and asked for clarification on whether the new zones preclude applications to H1/H2. He requested the denial of all shoreline hardening permits in these districts due to failing infrastructure. - Anonymous Testifier (7735): Expressed support for Resolution 25-230 as written but expressed full opposition to Councilmember Paultin's amendment, specifically questioning the clarity of "as available" parking requirements and the potential transfer of shoreline maintenance liability to property owners. - Caitlin Miller (Maui Vacation Rental Association): Stated support for the creation of H3/H4 as a "like for like" transfer of A1/A2 standards. Expressed that sea level rise and shoreline impacts should be addressed in broader, county-wide legislation rather than in this specific zoning amendment. - Testifier (Maui Sands Resident): Delivered an emotional testimony regarding personal trauma, loss of property, and land title claims based on indigenous sovereignty, expressing distress over the administration's handling of her lease and safety. - Kai Maile Makekau: Attempted to testify but was cut off for exceeding time limits; previously noted as a resource to the TIG. Discussion Items - Bill Overview (Councilmember Cook): Clarified that Resolution 25-230 creates new zoning categories (H3/H4) that mirror A1/A2 standards specifically to allow continued TVR use without permitting new development. He emphasized the bill does not rezone specific properties yet but establishes the legal framework for future rezoning. He confirmed that other properties could apply for H3/H4 but that the TIG intent was to limit this specific process to those meeting A1/A2 criteria. - Councilmember Paultin's Amendment: Proposed amendments including a requirement for 10% public shoreline parking (where available), public shoreline access, and a clause exempting the county from liability for future costs associated with sea level rise retreat and hazard mitigation. She argued that beach access is currently obstructed in many areas, requiring residents to swim or climb walls to reach the ocean. - Councilmember Rollins Fernandez's Amendment: Proposed to embed accessory use lists directly into the code, prohibit the construction/maintenance/expansion of shoreline armoring, and add a "Coastal Transition and Phased Removal" section. This section would require agreements to remove non-ecosystem human-made objects (foundations, pools, retaining walls) and acknowledge liability exclusions for the county regarding retreat costs. - Department of Planning (Mr. Post): Recommended explicitly stating the specific criteria for properties to qualify for H3/H4 to ensure only those meeting original A1/A2 TVR criteria are included. He expressed concern over the ambiguity of "as available" in Councilmember Paultin's amendment and the lack of defined standards for shoreline access (e.g., paving, ADA compliance). He noted that prohibiting shoreline armoring in a specific district would be unprecedented and recommended deferring detailed liability discussions to executive session. - Land Jurisdiction (Mr. Nunukawa): Clarified that shoreline armoring often falls under the jurisdiction of the Board of Land and Natural Resources (BLNR), not solely the county. - Executive Session: The committee moved to executive session to consult with Corp Counsel regarding the legality of the proposed amendments, specifically concerning liability releases, the definition of eligible properties, and potential legal challenges to the county. Key Outcomes - Continued Deliberation: The committee deferred action on Resolution 25-230 and the proposed amendments to future meetings after entering executive session for legal review. - Agenda Clarification: Established that H3/H4 zoning is a prerequisite for any future rezoning of properties to TVR use and is not itself a rezoning of specific parcels. - Legal Consultation: Proceeded to executive session under HRS 92-5A(4) to discuss council powers, duties, priviledges, and liabilities regarding the proposed amendments. The meeting concluded with a formal deferral of the item.

The Maui County Council convened on December 19, 2025, at 9:03 AM, adopting a solemn and celebratory tone with opening remarks honoring the legacy of the late Lawrence Cabanilla, followed by public testimony, budget amendments, and extensive deliberation on housing and zoning legislation. The meeting concluded by tabling the contentious resolution regarding new H3/H4 hotel districts to allow for further committee discussion before final action. Consent Calendar - Committee Report 25-87 through 25-91 recommending adoption of settlements and a bill on alternate members for boards/commissions was approved unanimously (8-0). - Resolution 25-223 appointing Max Sai to the Police Commission was amended to place his name on Exhibit C for disapproval; the amendment and main motion as amended carried 8-0. - Resolution 25-224 accepting a $250 donation from CNS Wholesale Grocers LLC for the Department of OEV Resources was approved 8-0. - Resolution 25-228 extending the term of the Special Committee on Real Property Tax Reform was approved 8-0. - Resolution 25-231 authorizing special counsel for the Lahaina Wastewater Facility NPDES permit was approved 8-0. - Resolution 25-232 urging state action for PEG media funding was approved 8-0. - Bill 182 (OEV Resources donation appropriation) approved on first reading 8-0. - Bill 183 (West Maui height limits) approved on first reading 8-0. - Bills 184 through 191 and Bill 193 (Budget amendments for Parks, Transportation, Police, Firefighters, Board of Ethics, etc.) approved on first reading 8-0. - Bill 194 (County Council vacancies) approved on first reading 8-0. - Bill 160 CD1 (Wai Maoli Freshwater Initiative) approved on second/final reading 8-0. - Bills 169, 170, and 171 CD1 (Valuations, Tax Credit, Wildfire Tax Relief) approved on second/final reading 8-0. - Bills 175 and 179 (Police/Transportation funding) approved on second/final reading 8-0. - Bill 180 (Lokahi Pacific grant) approved on second/final reading 8-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Reverend Genshohara Hara & Maya Hara: Spoke in honor of Lawrence Cabanilla, describing him as a "hero" and "icon" whose family's dedication makes the Lahaina Jodo Mission Oboan Festival possible. - Mikey Burke: Expressed deep emotional gratitude, recounting how Cabanilla taught the community to be "strong like bamboo" (flexible, not rigid) rather than an oak tree. - Mahina Martin (Director of Public Affairs): Stated Mayor Bisson held Cabanilla in "deep aloha" and recounted how Cabanilla consistently held the community accountable for faith and respect during post-fire meetings. - John Smith (Recovery Administrator): Publicly thanked Cabanilla for his commitment and strength, stating he gained "resolution" from Cabanilla's example. - Travis O'Connell (Grandson): Delivered a speech stating his grandfather "was a staple" in his life, teaching him that "you can do it" and that life is about taking the "honest way" rather than shortcuts. - Laura Nokitaki (Office of Ethics): Testified in favor of increasing the Board of Ethics staff from three to five positions, citing 55 informal advisory opinions issued in four months and an urgent need for a second attorney to ensure independence. - Owen Gray: Urged the Council to vote in favor of Resolution 25-230 and fully adopt the Temporary Investigative Group (TIG) recommendations for H3/H4 zoning. - Jay April: Expressed support for Resolution 25-232, explaining that public access media (Akaku) is under threat as cable providers (Spectrum) claim public rights of way without paying rent, and urging the state to protect PEG funding. - John Smith (Testifier on Bill 183): Expressed full support for Bill 183, stating the alignment of the community plan with zoning will allow the developer to increase affordable housing units from 143 to 240. - Brian Whitman: Offered observations supporting the Council's housing efforts, suggesting pre-approved building plans and design contests as immediate solutions. - Greg Rilski: Stated support for the TIG report but expressed concern that properties are being considered for conversion without unanimous owner consent; stated he did not want his properties (in A1/A2 zones) to be converted to hotel zones if owners do not want it. - Dan McKenna: Expressed encouragement and full support for the TIG report and Resolution 25-230. - Caitlin Miller (Maui Vacation Rental Association): Expressed conditional support for the referral to planning commissions, emphasizing the need to ensure zoning changes do not have unintended consequences on housing. - Jonathan Heiton (Grassroots Institute): Expressed support for Bill 183 but requested an amendment to allow rebuilding of all structures taller than 35 feet, not just public/quasi-public ones, noting the current draft limits this. - Kainashiki (Testifier): Requested that Resolution 25-230 be referred to a Council committee prior to the Planning Commission to allow for full deliberation and a comprehensive proposal, arguing the community was not involved in TIG discussions. - McKinley Eads: Expressed strong support for Bill 171 (tax relief extension) and Bill 183 (height limits), noting zero commercial properties have been rebuilt. - Tom Crowley: Offered condolences to the Cabanilla family; expressed support for Bill 171 and the referral of Resolution 25-230, suggesting clear criteria should be established for rezoning based on historical tax records. Discussion Items - H3/H4 Zoning (Resolution 25-230): Council debated the referral of H3/H4 hotel district zoning to the Planning Commissions. Member Paulton moved to amend the bill to require shoreline access, parking, a 10% profit contribution to a managed retreat fund, and suspended Rule 19 to allow final action. Member Cook argued the bill was not ready and lacked support from residents of the affected complexes. - Committee Referral Debate: Multiple members (Johnson, Rollins Fernandez, Paulton, Senancy) argued they were not part of the private TIG meetings and did not have enough time or information to make informed decisions. They pushed to send the item to a committee (DRIP or HOU) for a full 7B discussion before sending to Planning. Member Uu Hodgins argued against reopening the issue and supported sending it to Planning to meet the 120-day timeline. - Planning Director Testimony: Director Blystone clarified that transmitting the item by January 9th is required to have it heard at the last February meeting of the Planning Commissions; delaying would push the timeline to March. - Procedural Deadlock: Without six votes (including the Rule 19 suspension vote), the resolution could not pass. The Council voted to table the item to a future meeting (scheduled for January 7, with a committee meeting on January 5) rather than vote it down or pass it without amendments. Key Outcomes - Table Motion: Resolution 25-230 (H3/H4 zoning) was tabled until the next scheduled Council meeting on January 7, 2025, with a committee meeting (DRIP) scheduled for January 5, 2025, to allow for further deliberation and amendment. - Appointments: Resolutions 25-223 (Sai to Police Commission) was denied; Resolutions 25-229 (Butello to Water Supply) and 25-234 (Ellison to Water Supply) were adopted/filed. - Taxes & Budget: Bills 170 and 171 (tax credit and fire relief) and various budget amendments (Bills 182-193) passed unanimously on first or second reading. - Legislation: Bill 194 (Council vacancies) passed on first reading to codify the existing vacancy process. - Adjournment with Song: The meeting adjourned with the traditional Hawaiian song."

The Water and Infrastructure Committee convened on December 17, 2025, to hear testimony and deliberate on Bill 158, which proposes repealing Chapter 14.06A and establishing a new Chapter 14.06B to consolidate water conservation policies, water shortage declarations, and enforcement provisions. The Department of Water Supply presented a comprehensive overview aimed at protecting Maui's scarce water resources, addressing rising chloride levels, and offsetting capital costs for new water sources through conservation measures. Consent Calendar - N/A Public Comments & Testimony - His Highness Kawau (Kingdom Hawaii Government): Expressed opposition to the concept of water conservation under the current government, framing water rights as a sovereignty issue tied to historical grievances against the United States; stated that water is a resource belonging to the Kingdom, not the current county. - JC Law: Expressed strong support for the bill and acknowledged the cultural importance of water conservation in Hawaiian history; noted the upcoming Year of the Fire Horse and potential for social justice changes. - Kynashiki (Nishiki): Expressed full support for prioritizing water conservation for affordable housing; argued that county control of West Maui water resources is necessary to build 4,000 new units; advocated for a defined hierarchy of water uses with Hawaiian homelands having priority; supported amending plumbing codes to allow recycled water for toilet flushing in multifamily facilities. - Casey Lamb (LED Corps Maui): Expressed full support for the bill; highlighted the necessity of integrating water conservation into design standards like LEED and SITES programs; emphasized the use of native drought-tolerant landscaping and smart irrigation to reduce consumption by 20-40%. - David Good (LED Corps Maui/Upcountry Resident): Expressed support for the bill but recommended amendments including mandatory in-unit water monitoring for multifamily/commercial properties, extending water-efficient landscape requirements to single-family lots over half an acre and small agricultural lots, and clarifying definitions to include "canoe plants." - Brendan Kennedy: Expressed support for the bill; advocated for expanding recycled (R1) water use to single-family homes via HOA-managed systems. - Jim Langford: Expressed support for exploring technical solutions like atmospheric water generation and 3D printed basins as supplements to conservation, though not directly on the bill's text. Discussion Items Water Conservation Policies & Statistics - Director Stoffelbean presented that the current water usage is 40 million gallons per day; conservation measures could save 10 million gallons daily, equating to $200 million in avoided capital costs. - Outdoor Watering Restrictions: Proposed prohibition of sprinkler use between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., with exceptions for drip irrigation, newly installed landscapes, and recycled water use. - Leak Management: Committee members and staff discussed requiring repairs of private leaks within 30 days and the installation of smart meters, noting a potential 15% reduction in water use. - Pool Covers: Director Stoffelbean expressed support for requiring pool covers but noted the logistical difficulty for existing pools; suggested a 30-day unused threshold for existing pools and immediate requirements for new construction. - Commercial & Hotel Engagement: The Department confirmed ongoing engagement with hotels and resorts; members discussed the effectiveness of tiered water pricing in encouraging conservation. Legislative Amendments & Clarifications - Title Change: Members agreed to remove "and control of water use during water shortage" from the chapter title to reflect that permanent conservation measures apply at all times, not just during shortages. - Definition of Water Efficient: An amendment was proposed and passed to define xeriscaping as utilizing "water efficient native, canoe, or non-invasive plants." - Submetering: Member Paulton moved to encourage, "where appropriate," the installation of in-unit submetering for new commercial and multifamily properties; the motion passed as a non-mandatory encouragement. - Shortage Percentages: An amendment was adopted to clarify that water shortage reduction goals (10%, 20%, 30%) are based on "current use" rather than an undefined baseline. - Notification Methods: An amendment was made to replace "newspaper of general circulation" with "media of general circulation" and change "published" to "posted" to allow for flexibility in public notices (e.g., websites, social media). - Wind Speed Enforcement: Member Paulton proposed a specific wind speed limit (30 mph) for avoiding spray irrigation; the Committee adjusted the language from "must" to "should" and set the wind threshold at 30 miles per hour to aid enforceability. - Property Types: An amendment was adopted to extend water-efficient irrigation and landscape requirements to single-family lots over half an acre and agricultural lots under five acres (non-farm portions), pending administrative rule clarification. - Pool Covers (Amendment by Member Johnson): An amendment was passed requiring pool covers for private swimming pools when not in use during the day. - Phasing: Established a one-year exemption for existing properties, with a specific deadline of March 1, 2027, to allow for compliance. - Scope: Clarified that the requirement applies to all properties within the DWS jurisdiction, noting that pool covers for new pools are mandatory, while existing pools are subject to complaint-based enforcement unless a building permit is sought. - Exceptions: Public safety and repair activities remain exceptions; hotels are noted as likely exempt due to daily usage, though they are not explicitly excluded from the text. - Effective Date: An amendment was passed to set the ordinance's effective date to March 1, 2026, to allow the Department of Water Supply time to develop necessary administrative rules. Key Outcomes - Motion to Substitute: The Committee voted to substitute Bill 158 with the proposed CD1 version, incorporating all discussed amendments. - Motion to Amend Title: Passed, changing the chapter title to simply "Water Conservation" to remove the limitation to water shortage periods. - Motion to Amend Definitions: Passed, clarifying "water efficient" to explicitly include "non-invasive plants." - Motion to Amend Incentives: Passed, encouraging in-unit submetering for new commercial and multifamily developments. - Motion to Amend Shortage Baselines: Passed, defining reduction percentages based on "current use." - Motion to Amend Notification: Passed, changing notification requirements from "newspaper" to "media" and "published" to "posted." - Motion to Amend Wind Restrictions: Passed, setting spray irrigation restrictions to "should be avoided or delayed" when average wind speeds exceed 30 mph. - Motion to Amend Property Coverage: Passed, expanding irrigation requirements to include single-family lots 0.5 acres and ag lots <5 acres (non-farm portion). - Motion to Amend Pool Covers: Passed, making pool covers mandatory for use during the day when vacant or unused for 30 days, with a compliance deadline of March 1, 2027. - Motion to Set Effective Date: Passed, delaying the effective date of the ordinance to March 1, 2026. - Final Recommendation: The Committee unanimously voted to recommend passage of Bill 158 (2025) on first reading, as amended, for further consideration by the full Council.

The Disaster Recovery, International Affairs, and Planning Committee convened to discuss two primary agenda items: interim restrictions on private swimming pools in West Maui and the South Maui Community Plan update process. The meeting opened with a sovereignty statement recognizing the historical context of the Hawaiian Kingdom. Committee members, including Councilmember Shane Sinanti, introduced a moratorium on new pools in West Maui due to water shortages, supported by testimony from the public and resource personnel regarding water conservation and reliable capacity. The committee unanimously voted to pass Bill 161-2025 with amendments. The second item addressed delays in the South Maui Community Plan update, leading to a recommendation for deferral until June 2026 to resolve discrepancies and coordinate with the Department of Oceans, Environmental, and Water Resources. Consent Calendar - No items listed on the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - Greg Rilski (Kilohana Resident): Expressed full support for the swimming pool moratorium, emphasizing that the inconvenience to new pools is minor compared to the necessity of securing water for rebuilding other structures and developments previously halted due to water issues. - Paele Kia Kona (Lahaina Resident, Testifying via Teams): Expressed full support for the measure, noting it is an opportunity to alleviate future stress and prevent "shooting ourselves in the foot" regarding water usage. Proposed a potential dual-dollar system where new pool owners pay a fee to fund water infrastructure, such as dual-meter systems for recycling water. - Jim Lankford: Expressed support for prioritizing life and liberty over luxury water needs. Suggested that technology like atmospheric water generation could mitigate water strain, allowing for future residential pools if used strategically in hotel zones. - Kai Nishiki (Kahului/Kula Resident): Expressed full support for the legislation, stating that wasting water for luxury pools is unjustifiable during an extreme drought. Argued that while pool covers are a mitigation measure, they are unlikely to be taken seriously by homeowners and therefore a direct moratorium is a more practical way to free up water for affordable housing. - JC Long (Kula, Kulaooku): Offered general support, noting that sharing pools in apartment complexes mitigates some private pool demand. Questioned if any pools in Kula were destroyed by the fire. - His Highness Kawa (Representing a Sovereign Group): Spoke from a position of spiritual urgency, referencing scripture and the historical context of 1893. Expressed a call for the committee and government to act righteously and address the suffering of orphans and widows caused by political "murder" and mismanagement. - Mike Moran (Kihei, CPAC Member): Expressed support for the delay in the South Maui Community Plan, noting that it is better to get the plan right than to rush it, despite the disappointment of the delay. - JC Long (Second Appearance): Reiterated his desire for the Royal Patent Plan to be aligned with current community plans and noted the cultural significance of the number 13 in relation to Kula fire trucks. Discussion Items DRIP 20: Bill 161-2025 (Interim Restrictions on New Private Swimming Pools in West Maui) - Councilmember Shane Sinanti (Introducer): Explained the bill imposes a moratorium on new private swimming pools in the West Maui Community Plan area until December 31, 2030, or until three specific water resource conditions are met. Clarified that the measure is a first step; community members had initially requested an outright ban. Noted that reconstruction of pools destroyed by wildfires is allowed if they were lawfully permitted prior to the ordinance. - Greg Post (Planning Department): Presented the bill, noting the Department of Public Works and Water Resources supported the conservation intent but recommended placing the ordinance in Title 14 (Water Conservation) or Title 16 (Building Code) rather than Title 19 (Land Use) to stop the process at the building permit stage. The Planning Commission recommended extending the expiration date to December 31, 2030, and removing the penalty section. - Deputy Director Kira Kahahani (Commission on Water Resource Management): Expressed strong support for conservation efforts and the bill's intent to ensure responsible use of water resources during the ongoing drought in West Maui. - James Jensen (Department of Water Supply): Confirmed support for conservation. Addressed questions regarding water usage, stating that pre-fire daily usage was approximately 5.5 million gallons against a reliable capacity of 4.5 million gallons (approximately 141% demand). Noted that evaporation is the primary water loss factor for pools, which can be mitigated by covers. - Jordan Molina (Director, Dept. of Public Works): Argued against moving the ordinance to Title 16, stating that land use regulation is the appropriate context for Title 19, whereas Title 16 covers health and safety building codes. - Councilmember U. Hodgins: Clarified that the moratorium applies to West Maui only and allows reconstruction of lawfully permitted destroyed pools. Proposed and carried a motion to amend the ordinance text to explicitly insert "repairs, reconstruction, and maintenance" into the exemptions. - Councilmember Cook: Expressed support for the West Maui-specific measure but not an island-wide ban. Questioned the accuracy of water usage estimates for pools, specifically regarding evaporation rates and the scale of rebuilds (e.g., bigger homes, French Street Apartments). - Councilmember Johnson: Expressed concern regarding the precise boundaries of the West Maui Community Plan to ensure no properties are partially exempt and partially subject to the moratorium. Staff (Mr. Post) indicated no known properties fall on a bisecting line but committed to verifying. - Councilmember Senanti: Confirmed the bill is signed by the Corporation Council and addresses no legal entitlement to own a pool. - Councilmember Lee: Asked why the Department of Water Supply could not confirm reliable yield pre-fire; staff deferred to the Department of Water Supply. - Councilmember Rollins Fernandez: Deferred to staff regarding the prioritization of municipal uses in the Water Use Permitting Assessment (WUPA) process, which the Commission noted was not yet finalized. DRIP 9 Peren 3: South Maui Community Plan Update Process - Chair/Committee Staff: Explained that the update process is being deferred until June 2026 to resolve discrepancies with the Department of Oceans, Environmental, and Water Resources (OEV Resources) and to ensure coordination with other departments. Noted that the South Maui plan began in 2020 before OEV Resources was staffed, leading to gaps in collaboration compared to the West Maui plan. - Jackie Takakura (Planning Program Administrator): Discussed the deficiencies found, specifically the lack of clarity in 2.80B.070E and the need for better collaboration with OEV Resources. Confirmed the team has fully staffed the long-range planning division. - Director Blystone (Planning Department): Addressed a request by Council member Cook for specific budget assignments for infrastructure projects (e.g., North Saw Collector Road). Confirmed that Cost Impact Projection (CIP) numbers are included in Appendix H but emphasized that these figures are estimates and should be viewed with caution as project costs fluctuate. Key Outcomes - Bill 161-2025: Passed out of committee and recommended for first reading with the following actions: - Motion: To substitute Bill 161-2025 with the proposed CD1 version (dated December 11, 2025). - Amendment: Passed to amend Section 19.98.050 to explicitly include "repairs, reconstruction, and maintenance of a private swimming pool" in the exemption list. - Vote Tally: 7 Ayes, 0 Noes (1 Excused - Member Sukimora). - Intent: Imposes an interim moratorium on new private swimming pools in the West Maui Community Plan area until Dec 31, 2030, or until water resource conditions are met. - DRIP 9 Peren 3: Deferred until June 2026 to allow the Planning Department to resolve discrepancies with the Department of OEV Resources and finalize the plan before Council action. - Scheduling: A special Council meeting is tentatively scheduled for January 5, 2026. The 2026 Council calendar will be finalized after the organization of standing committees. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned at 3:24 PM.

The Budget Finance Economic Development Committee convened on December 16, 2025, at 9:03 AM to address two primary agenda items: a budget transfer within the Department of Public Works for fiscal year 26 and amendments to the fiscal year 26 budget regarding the Lahaina Wastewater Reclamation Facility upgrades. The meeting proceeded with brief public testimony from two citizens and concluded with the unanimous passage of all proposed resolutions and bills. Consent Calendar - None. (Agenda items were processed under Discussion Items). Public Comments & Testimony - Kashiwa Sugimura: Expressed full support for the importance of the Lahaina treatment plant sludge operations. Specifically thanked the tank truck drivers and the Department of Public Works. Asked for clarification regarding a reported $3 million grant from the US EPA for purchasing land for recycle centers in Lahaina. (No response to the specific land purchase question was recorded in the transcript, but the speaker's intent was noted). - James Langford: Stated concurrence with the agenda items. Noted that he had provided data on a Facebook page regarding the mathematics of the agenda but offered no further verbal testimony or position beyond this acknowledgment. Discussion Items BFED 13 Resolution 25-221: Public Works Budget Transfer - Proposal: A transfer of $220,000 in unencumbered balances within the Department of Public Works to cover unforeseen costs. The funds are sourced from $145,000 in savings from the Road, Bridge, and Drainage Maintenance Program (9 vacant positions) and $75,000 from the Traffic Management Program. - Positions & Clarifications: - Deputy Director Paul Barney stated the funds cover repairs for vehicles damaged in accidents and replacements for end-of-life signal equipment. He confirmed that the work will not be delayed despite the transfer from salary budgets because sufficient remaining A-funds exist to pay for the positions if they are filled. - Councilmember Elizabeth Cook: Expressed support and noted understanding of the utilization of funds to cover immediate needs. Asked if the funds could be used for speed bumps at the Lumlung boat ramp; Deputy Director confirmed speed humps are in engineering works but this specific operational fund would not directly apply. - Councilmember Rollins Fernandez: Expressed curiosity regarding why the item was referred to committee rather than being passed on first reading at full council, though no opposition was expressed to the item itself. Asked about the impact of transferring salary funds on operations; Deputy Director clarified that the positions have been vacant and recruitment is active. - Councilmember Palton: Expressed interest in using funds for speed bumps on the Hana Highway due to blind hills and tourist traffic. Clarified that the wall on Highway 30 is a State issue, not a County issue. Asked if funds could be used for Honoapiilani Highway improvements; Deputy Director clarified that these funds are operational and cannot be cross-overed to Capital Improvement Projects (CIP). - Councilmember Jose Sonancy: Asked about insurance proceeds for accidents; Director Maria Zelinski explained that proceeds come through county-wide self-insurance and do not benefit the Department of Public Works directly. BFED 12 Bills 2025-177 and 178: Lahaina Wastewater Facility Upgrades - Proposal: Approving an Intergovernmental Agreement for a $22,409,000 loan from the State Water Pollution Control Revolving Fund (SRF) to upgrade the return activated sludge and dewatering systems at the Lahaina facility. Bill 178 amends the FY26 budget to appropriate the loan. The loan is eligible for 100% principal forgiveness. - Positions & Clarifications: - Director Agawa: Described the project as replacing aging concrete and centrifuges to remove solids and improve efficiency. Stated that the timeline involves sending notice to proceed in January 2026, with an estimated duration of 18 months to two years. Expressed assurance that no external permits are required as the work is within the facility. - Councilmember Elizabeth Cook: Expressed support for the project details. Asked about new technologies; Director Agawa confirmed the project involves upgraded centrifuges for better efficiency and reduced electricity usage. Asked about the timeline; Director Agawa provided the Jan 2026 start and 18-24 month duration. - Councilmember Jose Sonancy: Asked if the loan would be repaid with departmental funding; Director Agawa clarified that the loan is 100% principal forgiveness and standard repayment via rates and fees applies only to the non-forgiven portion (if any) or as per standard SRF protocols. - General Sentiment: Councilmembers Cook, Fernandez, Palton, Lee, and Sonancy expressed support for the straightforward nature of the budget amendment. Councilmember Johnson was absent but excused. Key Outcomes - Adoption of Resolution 25-221: Passed by a vote of 7 in favor, 0 against (1 Member Johnson excused). The amendment transfers $220,000 for Public Works vehicle repairs and signal equipment replacement. - Passage of Bills 177 and 178-2025: Passed by a vote of 7 in favor, 0 against (1 Member U. Hodgins excused). The bills authorize a $22.4 million SRF loan for the Lahaina Wastewater facility upgrades with 100% principal forgiveness. - Meeting Adjournment: The meeting adjourned at 9:34 AM.