Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on May 24, 2023, to hear two major items: the nine-month budget status report for FY2022-2023 and a hearing on city investments in the Lakeview, Oceanview, Merced Heights, and Ingleside (OMI) communities from 2013 to 2023. The committee also received public testimony and took votes on both items. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Budget Status Report): Francisco DeCosta criticized the committee as "one of the worst" he had watched. David Pilpel praised the report's detail but requested greater consistency in fund naming across documents. - Item 2 (OMI Investments): Multiple speakers expressed support for increased investment in the OMI community. Renard Monroe (Youth First) emphasized the need for continued resources and correct neighborhood naming. Zelia Fitzpatrick (Good Rule) requested clarity on how resources are tracked and allocated. EJ Jones (neighbors and community stakeholders) noted that homegrown programs are at capacity and need more support. Monique Gidry (African American Early Childhood Educators) asked about funding distribution, timelines, and oversight for early childhood grants. Mary Evelyn Thomas (provider) questioned where mental health services are located. Gwendolyn Brown (OMI Job Center) stated that departmental investments are low compared to documented need. Naeema Charles (Children's Council) highlighted high poverty rates and urged investment in families rather than tax breaks for businesses. Discussion Items Item 1: Nine-Month Budget Status Report (FY2022-2023) Carol Lu, Citywide Revenue Manager from the Controller’s Office, presented the report. Key highlights: - The projected ending fund balance is $209.3 million, a $36.3 million improvement from the March forecast. - The two-year budget deficit is reduced from $780 million to $744 million. - Revenue is $30 million below budget overall but $26 million better than prior projections. - Transfer tax is very weak: forecast at $174 million vs. budget $390 million, down from $520 million last year, due to rising interest rates and work-from-home trends. - Property tax is $86.5 million above budget, driven by supplementals and higher assessed values. - FEMA reimbursements are delayed; only $23.4 million expected this year vs. budget $243 million, but future payments are still anticipated. - The overpaid executives tax (new) is expected to bring in $190 million this year, including 1.5 years of collections, with a base of $100 million per year going forward. - Departmental savings are largely from vacancies, especially in Human Services Agency ($13 million in expenditure savings) and the Mayor’s office ($2.3 million). - The Department of Public Health shortfall ($6.9 million) from Laguna Honda Hospital revenue is covered by a reserve. Supervisors Chan, Safai, and Ronan asked questions about property tax trends, transfer tax volatility, FEMA timing, vacancy-driven savings, and the overpaid executive tax. The committee then heard public testimony and voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. Item 2: City Investments in OMI Communities (2013-2023) Supervisor Safai, the hearing sponsor, introduced the item as a follow-up to a 2021 hearing. Seven city departments presented: - Human Services Agency (HSA): Susie Smith reported that HSA serves about 42,000 clients in OMI zip codes (17% of caseload) with $34 million annually, plus $91 million in leveraged state/federal funds. Programs include CalFresh, Medi-Cal, IHSS, and community food programs. Food programs serve 4,000 residents with $4.5 million. A new mobile office will launch. - Department of Early Childhood (DEC): Ingrid Musquita noted that enrollment data in OMI is limited due to administrative changes. Funding for a Family Resource Center in OMI is about $1.3 million. Efforts target building child care capacity, especially for Black providers. - Department of Children, Youth and Their Families (DCYF): Maria Su estimated investments in OMI at $3.5 million in FY2022-2023, up from $1.3 million in 2013-2014, using a prorated methodology. Programs include summer learning, youth workforce, and mental health. - Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD): Kate Sofis reported over $1 million in community economic development investments (e.g., Good Rule hub, COVID relief grants), $141,000 in small business grants, and over $2 million for workforce programs including the OMI Job Center (opened 2019) and a satellite center. - Department of Public Health (DPH): Halley Hammer presented data showing that residents of OMI zip codes represent 15% of primary care patients, 6% of behavioral health clients, and 21% of WIC participants. Services include the OMI Family Center (mental health clinic) and various outreach programs. - Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD): Brian Chu highlighted service investments of about $600,000 annually, with capital projects such as the public gateway project and affordable housing at Randolph/Hearst. Future RFP for services planned in 2024. - San Francisco Public Library: Michael Lambert reported $6.8 million annually to operate three branch libraries in OMI (Ocean View, Merced, Ingleside). A new Ocean View Branch Library is a top priority, with $15 million budgeted in FY24 and $4.8 million in FY25, but the site selection (Brotherhood Way) remains under discussion. Supervisors Safai, Walton, and Chan asked questions about food security, child care capacity, summer programs, capacity building for local nonprofits, and the library site. A heated exchange occurred between Supervisor Safai and Library Director Lambert over the Brotherhood Way site, with Safai accusing the library of delaying the project despite community consensus. Lambert maintained that the site is still under consideration and that the library is proceeding with budget building and community engagement. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to continue the hearing to the call of the chair passed unanimously (5-0). - Item 2: Motion to file the hearing passed 4-0 (Vice Chair Mandelman absent). The meeting was adjourned after the two items.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on May 23, 2023, beginning at 9:45 AM. The commission unanimously approved a new three-year schedule of retail water and sewer rates (FY2024–2026), adopted a stormwater credit program, and set new power rates for Tuolumne County customers. The meeting included a report on the retirement of Deputy CFO Charles Pearl, an update on the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA), and public testimony on rate impacts, flooding, and support for urban agriculture water rates. Public Comments & Testimony - Water and Sewer Rates (Items 6 & 7): Numerous members of the public spoke in opposition to the proposed rate increases, citing affordability concerns for residents, small businesses (e.g., laundromats), and fixed-income seniors. Speakers also raised issues with the accuracy of outreach, the impact of the drought surcharge (since rescinded), and the new stormwater charge. Several callers argued that the rate increases would disproportionately affect low-income communities and that the Proposition 218 process did not constitute an adequate administrative hearing. - Stormwater Credit Program (Item 8): A resident of the Marina district testified about repeated sewage floods and urged the commission to conduct a postmortem on the Pierce Street outfall closure before approving rate increases. Other speakers expressed concerns that the stormwater charge would be duplicative of property taxes (clarified by staff as not the case). - General Public Comment (Item 11): Representatives from the Florence Fang Community Farm, City of Dreams mentoring program, and other urban agriculture advocates requested the creation of a separate water rate category for urban farms and gardens, noting that current rates are a barrier to providing fresh food in food deserts. They highlighted conservation measures already in place and asked for policy support. - Item Initiated by Commissioners (Item 12): A caller expressed support for developing progressive SFPUC water policies for urban agriculture, including grants and water budgeting assistance. Discussion Items - Retirement of Charles Pearl (Item 4): General Manager Dennis Herrera recognized Deputy CFO Charles Pearl, who retired after 15 years at SFPUC. Commissioners thanked him for his leadership in fiscal policy, green bonds, and mentoring staff. - BAWSCA Update (Item 5): BAWSCA CEO provided an update on the Tuolumne River Voluntary Agreement (VA) process. She noted that BAWSCA submitted oral comments supporting the State Water Board's environmental review and expressed optimism that the VA could provide more flows for fish while ensuring water supply reliability. Public comment from the Tuolumne River Trust criticized the VA as insufficient and urged the commission to consider alternative water supply scenarios. - Water and Sewer Rate Proposals (Items 6 & 7): Staff presented the proposed rate increases: 5% annually for water and 9% annually for sewer over FY2024–2026, driven primarily by capital costs (80% of increase). The sewer rate restructure includes a new stormwater charge (23% of wastewater revenues) phased in over seven years, based on impermeable surface area for most customers. An enhanced customer assistance program (up to 40% discount for lowest-income customers) was highlighted. The Rate Fairness Board chair endorsed the proposals, noting the balance between rate stability and capital needs. The commission received 351 written protests (plus 4 hand-delivered) against a universe of 177,564 property owners/customers—not a majority per Proposition 218. - Stormwater Credit Program (Item 8): Staff detailed the new stormwater credit program, effective July 1, 2023, which allows customers to reduce their stormwater charge by installing green infrastructure (rain gardens, permeable pavement, cisterns). Credits are proportional to drainage area managed; residential customers have simplified flat-rate credit options. Existing projects under the Stormwater Management Ordinance will be automatically enrolled. - Hetch Hetchy Power Rates for Tuolumne County (Item 9): Staff proposed a 50% increase in power rates for three customer groups (U.S. Forest Service, CA Dept. of Fish and Wildlife, and SFPUC employee housing) to move toward cost-of-service rates. The new rates are 7.5¢/kWh for USFS and 5.25¢/kWh for the other two groups. These customers represent less than 0.1% of Hetch Hetchy Power volume. Key Outcomes - Item 3 (Approval of Minutes): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 6 (Water Rates): Motion to adopt three-year water rate schedule passed 3-0. - Item 7 (Sewer Rates): Motion to adopt three-year sewer rate schedule passed 3-0. - Item 8 (Stormwater Credit Program): Motion to adopt rules and regulations passed 3-0. - Item 9 (Power Rates for Tuolumne County): Motion to adopt new power rates passed 3-0. - Proposition 218 Determination: The commission noted that the required written protests did not reach a majority; therefore, the proposed rates could be adopted. - Directive: Staff will follow up with the Florence Fang Community Farm to explore available assistance programs. Commissioners expressed interest in exploring water rate relief for urban agriculture and businesses serving low-income communities.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, May 22, 2023, at 6:15 PM UTC to consider mayoral reappointments and appointments to the City Hall Preservation Advisory Commission and to hold a hearing and vote on appointments to the Cannabis Oversight Committee. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey with Vice Chair Shamon Walton and member Asha Safai, voted unanimously on both items. Public Comments & Testimony - City Hall Preservation Commission: Two remote callers spoke in support of Clarence Blanchard (resident of District 10) and Ellen Schumer (described as a historian and docent). No in-person public comment. - Cannabis Oversight Committee: Nineteen applicants presented brief statements. Several members of the public spoke in person and remotely, endorsing specific candidates including Jakari Donaldson, Alex Asefaw, William Dolan, Bram Goodwin, Perry Jones, David Talley, and others. Commenters emphasized the need for equity representation, community reinvestment, and applicant experience. City Hall Preservation Advisory Commission Appointments (Items 1–3) - The committee considered three nominations: reappointment of Ellen Schumer (term ending January 13, 2026), reappointment of Mae Woo (term ending January 13, 2026), and appointment of Clarence Blanchard (term ending January 13, 2024). - Supervisor Dorsey noted the commission’s role in preserving City Hall’s historical character. Supervisor Safai highlighted City Hall’s resilience after the 1906 earthquake and 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake. - Ellen Schumer spoke about the building’s Beaux-Arts architecture and 107-year history. Clarence Blanchard described his career as an electrician including work on City Hall and his Navy service; he is also a community member involved in Heron Head Park. Mae Woo was unable to connect remotely. - Key Outcome: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to strike the word "reject" from all three motions and recommend the nominations to the full Board of Supervisors for approval. Cannabis Oversight Committee Appointments (Item 4) - The committee held a hearing to consider nine seats (terms ending December 3, 2024) on the Cannabis Oversight Committee. Eighteen applicants applied for seats covering equity, labor, retail, cultivation, regulatory expertise, economic development, and medical cannabis patient/consumer categories. - Supervisor Dorsey noted that some seats had no eligible applicants (e.g., organized labor seats 10 and 11) and that the prescriptive requirements limited flexibility. He encouraged unsuccessful applicants to remain involved. - Supervisor Safai stressed the importance of equity (minimum 40% ownership for equity applicants), market parity before opening more applications, and support for a pause on new storefront permits to allow existing equity operators to catch up. He also noted public safety coordination with SFPD and planning code changes for security gates. - Vice Chair Walton thanked all candidates and reminded them that non-selection was not personal. - Public comment included calls for better communication between the committee and supervisors, adding seats for event licensees and the Human Rights Commission, and support for specific candidates. - Key Outcomes: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend the following appointments with two residency waivers: - Seat 8 (Equity): Ali Jamalian - Seat 9 (Cultivation/distributor <20 employees): Adam Hayes - Seat 11 (Organized labor – delivery): Apollo Wallace (residency waiver approved) - Seat 12 (Storefront retailer): Jakari Donaldson - Seat 13 (Equity applicant): David Talley (residency waiver approved) - Seat 14 (Expert on state regulations): Shay Gilmore - Seat 16 (Medical cannabis patient/consumer): Antoinette Mobley - The committee noted that seats 10 and 11 remained unfilled and would continue working with organized labor. Appointments will be forwarded to the full board for final approval.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 22, 2023, at 1:45 PM UTC, with Acting Chair Dean Preston presiding, joined by Supervisors Aaron Peskin and Matt Dorsey. The committee considered two agenda items: a planning code amendment to allow continued use of shared spaces in parking lots in the Mission Street NCT District, and an administrative code amendment to expand the displaced tenant preference in city affordable housing to cover tenants displaced by flooding. Public Comments & Testimony - Jillian Fitzgerald, co-owner of Caseman's Bar, expressed support for Item 1, thanking the committee for their time. Discussion Items - Item 1 (File 230164): Planning Code – Non-Conforming Public Parking Lots in the Mission Street NCT District – Presented by Anna Herrera, legislative aide for Supervisor Ronen, and Aaron Starr from the Planning Department. The amendment clarifies that using a portion of a public parking lot as a shared spaces patio does not constitute abandonment of the underlying parking use, allowing Caseman's Bar to continue operating their shared spaces patio. The Planning Commission recommended approval on April 20, 2023. The committee voted unanimously to send the item to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (File 230560): Administrative Code – Displaced Tenant Preference in City Affordable Housing – Presented by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, the legislation seeks to extend the displaced tenant preference to tenants whose unlawful units were removed by a Planning Commission approval or who were displaced by flooding. Supervisor Dorsey noted that details need further refinement after stakeholder input and moved to continue the item to the call of the chair. The committee voted unanimously to continue the item. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to send to the full Board with recommendation passed 3-0 (Preston, Peskin, Dorsey voting aye). - Item 2: Motion to continue to the call of the chair passed 3-0 (Dorsey, Peskin, Preston voting aye).
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 18, 2023, at 6:30 PM to consider five agenda items. The committee voted on a motion to audit the Police Department's overtime management, heard a performance audit of affordable housing funds, received testimony on PG&E's response to a major power outage, continued a hearing on TODCO contracts, and approved a resolution for the Excelsior Community Benefit District assessment ballot. Item 1: Motion to Audit SFPD Overtime - Chair Dean Preston presented a motion directing the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) to conduct an audit of the San Francisco Police Department's management and use of overtime. Preston noted that overtime spending had risen from $14.2 million in 2018 to a projected $81 million in the current fiscal year, and the department had failed to comply with city law regarding pre-approval. Nick Menard of the BLA said the audit would evaluate internal controls, policies, and effectiveness of new overtime-funded initiatives. The motion passed unanimously (3-0) and was sent to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Hearing on BLA Performance Audit of Affordable Housing Funds - Fred Brusseau of the BLA presented the audit of MOHCD's affordable housing financing. Key findings included: over the five-year period from FY 2018-2022, revenues averaged $215.2 million versus expenditures of $177 million; a fund balance of $536 million at the end of FY 2022, of which only 16% was committed via executed loan agreements; MOHCD's quarterly milestone reports did not fully comply with code requirements; and the office lacked formal written procedures for funding decisions. MOHCD Deputy Director Benjamin McCloskey responded, acknowledging the audit's recommendations and committing to improve reporting, including fund balance details and per-unit costs. Public comment included support for transparency and concerns about the discretion exercised by the mayor and MOHCD director. The hearing was filed. Item 3: Hearing on PG&E Electric Fire Response and CPUC Regulatory Role - President Aaron Peskin led the hearing on the April 26-30, 2023 power outage that initially affected 9,454 service connections. The outage began with a vault fire at Sansome and Halleck Streets. Chief Postel of SFFD reported that fire crews arrived in four minutes, but PG&E needed 20 minutes to arrive. Mary Ellen Carroll of DEM described challenges getting timely, accurate information from PG&E, especially regarding critical facilities like Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital, which experienced its own outage on March 26-27. Terry Saltz of DPH confirmed that communication from PG&E was delayed and that after-action meetings on recent outages were held only just before the hearing. Aaron Johnson, PG&E Regional Vice President, stated that the outage was due to a transformer failure, that 94% of customers were restored within 24 hours, and that the remaining customers (including Golden Gateway Apartments' 1,258 units) were restored by May 1. Angela Johnson and other Golden Gateway residents testified that PG&E provided inaccurate restoration estimates, no direct communication, and that building management had to procure generators at a cost of over $400,000, while PG&E claimed it was technically infeasible. Public comment echoed the lack of communication and the hardship to elderly residents. The hearing was filed. Item 4: Hearing on TODCO Contracts (Continued) - Due to the absence of sponsor Supervisor Stephanie, the committee voted to continue this item to the call of the chair. Item 5: Excelsior Community Benefit District Assessment Ballot - Chris Corgus of OEWD presented a resolution authorizing the mayor to cast assessment ballots in favor of forming the Excelsior CBD. The city owns three parcels with a total annual assessment of $6,887.86, representing 2.02% of the weighted vote. Public comment was received. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion passed (3-0) and sent to full Board. - Item 2: Hearing filed. - Item 3: Hearing filed. - Item 4: Continued to call of the chair. - Item 5: Resolution passed (3-0) and sent to full Board.
The San Francisco Police Commission convened on Wednesday, May 17, 2023 at 1:45 PM to discuss a wide range of items including the Chief's report on crime trends and fentanyl enforcement, a Violence Reduction Initiative update, a contentious debate on rescinding two department bureau orders (plain clothes and social media), and approval of updated traffic enforcement policies. The meeting included public comment, a consent calendar, reports from the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), and closed session items. The vote on rescinding the bureau orders failed 3-3, while both revised Department General Orders (DGOs) were adopted unanimously. Consent Calendar - The consent calendar (Item 3) was approved unanimously (6-0), receiving and filing multiple reports: Family Code 628 incident report, SFPD firearm discharge review board report, DPA's SAPD first quarter document protocol report, SFPD's SB 1421 report, and DPA's SB 1421 report. Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Petrellis (multiple appearances): Called for equal time for unsolved crimes, criticized “copaganda” at officer recognition, demanded remote public comment be reinstated, and urged the commission to agenda the murder of Banco Brown. He also objected to the use of a third-party processor for public records requests. - A mother of a homicide victim (Aubrey Abracassa): Pleaded for her son's case to be solved, provided names of alleged perpetrators, and requested that phone lines be opened for parents who cannot attend in person due to mental health disabilities. - Speaker referring to Banco Brown: Expressed outrage that the security guard’s claim of self-defense was uncorroborated by video, called the district attorney’s decision “irresponsible,” and questioned why a Walgreens security guard carried a gun. - Julie Tron (Bar Association): Supported collaborative policy-making and offered the Bar’s criminal justice task force to assist with the social media policy. - Paul Allen: Criticized the inflammatory language in the resolution to rescind bureau orders, urging teamwork and less harsh rhetoric. Discussion Items - Item 4 – Chief’s Report: Chief William Scott reported a 7% decrease in overall serious crimes year-to-date, but noted a 25% increase in homicides (20 vs. 16) and a 40% increase in firearm-related homicides. Property crime was down 8%, violent crime up 5%. He highlighted a 180% increase in fentanyl seizures (over 51,000 gross grams in 19 weeks) and 314 arrests for possession/sales. Enforcement continues in the Tenderloin with CHP and National Guard support. Commissioners questioned the increase in overdose deaths (268, up 37%) and discussed balancing enforcement with treatment and diversion. Chief Scott responded that enforcement does not necessarily cause more deaths and emphasized the need for alternatives to jail. Commissioner Carter-Oberstone raised concerns about the handling of the Banco Brown shooting, questioning the district attorney’s decision not to charge the security guard. Commissioners also discussed the Violence Reduction Initiative (see Item 7) and live monitoring surveillance requests. - Item 5 – DPA Director's Report: Acting Director Diana Rosenstein reported 26 cases past the 270-day deadline (down from 32 last year), 7 cases pending with the commission, 84 with the chief. Top complaint allegations: officer inappropriate behavior, bias policing, unjustified towing, failure to act, and threatening behavior. The DPA is working on a five-year analysis and a final audit of SFPD's misconduct handling. Commissioner Yanyez requested trend data on multiple allegations per officer. - Item 6 – Commission Reports: Commissioner Benedicto reported attending a rally for the Compassionate Alternative Response Team (CART) and noted a forthcoming updated resolution of support. Commissioner Walker discussed meetings on patrol specials and private security coordination. Commissioner Yanyez updated on juvenile diversion best practices and requested a presentation on the draft DGO for pre-booking diversion. - Item 7 – Violence Reduction Initiative (VRI) Update: Lily Gamrell (VRI manager) presented the 2022 year-in-review. Goals: reduce gun violence in Supervisorial District 10, reduce recidivism, and build police legitimacy. From 2021 to 2022, direct outreach attempts increased from 17 to 149; 60% of individuals contacted accepted service referrals. 25 individuals are currently enrolled with the Street Violence Intervention Program (SVIP), receiving life coaching and stabilization services. The team is now tracking recidivism and victimization outcomes. Commissioner Yanyez asked about expansion beyond District 10 and integration with existing services. The program received $6 million in additional grant funding in 2022. - Item 8 – Resolution to Rescind Plain Clothes and Social Media Bureau Orders: A contentious debate centered on whether the department circumvented the commission’s policymaking authority by issuing bureau orders (BOs) on plain clothes and investigative social media while DGOs were pending. Commissioner Carter-Oberstone argued the BOs were improper and violated the spirit of the 2016 DOJ report. Chief Scott defended the BOs as legal operational directives, citing DGO 3.01, and stressed the need for a policy in place. Commissioner Benedicto proposed an amendment to delay rescission of the social media BO until a new DGO is enacted in 35 days. The amendment was accepted, but the underlying resolution still failed 3-3 (Carter-Oberstone, Benedicto, Yanyez in favor; Walker, Byrne, Yee opposed). Commissioner Byrne and Walker objected to the resolution’s language accusing the department of “illegal” and “usurpation.” The city attorney clarified that departments have legal authority to issue BOs and the resolution’s claim of exclusive commission authority was incorrect. The commission also discussed revising DGO 3.01 to clarify boundaries. - Item 9 – DGO 9.01 Traffic Enforcement: Deputy Chief Daniel Peret and Officer Crispin Jones presented the updated DGO. Commissioner Benedicto praised the work. Officer Jones offered a series of minor non-substantive amendments, including replacing “should” with “is responsible for” and striking references to “California Vehicle Code” to encompass all applicable codes. Commissioner Byrne initially suggested tabling for a clean copy but ultimately voted yes. The motion passed unanimously (6-0) with the amendments and labor negotiation resolution 23-30. - Item 10 – Revised DGO 9.02 Vehicle Crashes: Approved unanimously (6-0) with labor negotiation resolution. - Items 11-14 – Closed Session: Public comment was taken; no speakers. The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to hold Item 13 in closed session and assert attorney-client privilege for sub-items b-f. After closed session, the commission voted unanimously not to disclose any discussion. Key Outcomes - Failed motion: Resolution to direct the Chief to rescind Plain Clothes and Social Media Bureau Orders failed 3-3 (not passing). Commissioner Benedicto’s amendment to defer rescission of the social media BO until a new DGO is enacted (within 35 days) was included in the motion but did not secure a fourth vote. - Approved DGO 9.01 (Traffic Enforcement): Unanimously approved (6-0) with non-substantive amendments and labor negotiation resolution 23-30. - Approved Revised DGO 9.02 (Vehicle Crashes): Unanimously approved (6-0) with labor negotiation resolution. - Closed Session: Unanimously voted to enter closed session and later not to disclose discussions. - Next steps: The commission will pursue a revised DGO for investigative social media accounts within 35 days (per the amendment that was part of the failed resolution, though not binding). DGO 3.01 revision is expected to be agendized. The commission will continue to receive updates on the VRI, crime trends, and DPA reports.
The San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on May 17, 2023, to discuss several items including an update on the Healthy Airport Ordinance, bond authorizations for San Francisco International Airport, and multiple affordable housing financing resolutions. The meeting featured extensive public testimony from airport workers and community members, as well as discussions on worker retention, health care benefits, and the selection process for affordable housing developers. Key votes included continuing the Healthy Airport Ordinance hearing to the call of the chair and approving financing for a 160-unit affordable housing project at 730 Stanyan Street with an amendment urging inclusion of transitional-age youth services. Public Comments & Testimony - Numerous airport workers and union representatives testified in strong support of the Healthy Airport Ordinance (HAO), emphasizing that the health care benefits provided by the ordinance are essential for them to afford living in the Bay Area and to cover medical expenses. Speakers described personal experiences of medical debt, the importance of health care for their families, and the challenges of low wages and high turnover at the airport. - Several community members and service providers testified in support of the 730 Stanyan Street affordable housing project, urging the committee to maintain the commitment to a transitional-age youth (TAY) drop-in center on the ground floor, as previously promised in community meetings and loan applications. - A few speakers expressed concerns about the selection process for the developer of 730 Stanyan, questioning the transparency of the scoring and the lack of audit oversight. One speaker criticized the small sites loan program as potentially misusing taxpayer funds. - Many residents and service providers spoke in strong support of the Homekey grant application for 1174-1178 Folsom Street, noting the urgent need for supportive housing for young adults leaving homelessness and emphasizing the positive impact such housing has on health and stability. Discussion Items - Healthy Airport Ordinance Update (Item 1): President Aaron Peskin, co-sponsor of the hearing, opened by noting that the ordinance is under litigation by Airlines for America (A4A) and that a federal judge upheld the city’s authority. Airport representative Kathy Widener provided data on covered employers (70 airlines, 91 service providers) and wage comparisons (QSP rate $19.65/hour, annualized $41,000). Widener confirmed that contracts and leases include HAO compliance language. Discussion centered on worker retention: SEIU USWW representative Jane Martin stated that nearly one-third of passenger service workers have been on the job less than a year, and over 60% less than three years, indicating a crisis in retention. Martin reported that contract negotiations with G2, ABM, PrimeFlight, and Compass have stalled over wages. The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. - Airport Bond Authorizations (Item 2): The resolution to authorize up to $6.06 billion in bonds and other related financings was continued to the call of the chair without discussion. - 730 Stanyan Street Affordable Housing (Items 3 & 4): The Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) presented a plan for 160 units of 100% affordable housing with 20 units for transitional-age youth, 12 for families experiencing homelessness, and a childcare center and community spaces on the ground floor. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) raised concerns about the developer selection process, noting an unusual supplemental questionnaire and scoring irregularities. Supervisor Dean Preston proposed a non-binding amendment urging MOHCD to include TAY drop-in center services as a ground floor use, referencing prior representations. The amendment passed 2-1 (with Vice Chair Mandelman dissenting). The committee then voted unanimously to forward items 3 and 4 to the full board with a positive recommendation, item 4 as amended. - Small Sites Loan (Item 5): MOHCD requested $18.8 million (amended to $18.7 million per BLA recommendation) to refinance four existing small sites properties owned by the San Francisco Community Land Trust, funding capital improvements and an ADU. The committee approved the amendment and forwarded the item to the full board. - Homekey Grant Application (Item 6): The Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) requested authorization to apply for up to $14.7 million in state Homekey funds to acquire 1174-1178 Folsom Street for permanent supportive housing for 42 young adults leaving homelessness. The committee forwarded the resolution to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Healthy Airport Ordinance hearing): Continued to the call of the chair (motion passed 3-0). - Item 2 (Airport bond authorizations): Continued to the call of the chair (motion passed 3-0). - Item 3 (Multifamily housing revenue notes for 730 Stanyan): Approved with amendment and forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 4 (Ground lease and loan agreement for 730 Stanyan): Approved as amended (including the urging for TAY services) and forwarded to full board (3-0); the amendment passed 2-1. - Item 5 (Small sites loan – SFCLT): Amended to reduce not-to-exceed amount from $18.8 million to $18.7 million, then forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 6 (Homekey grant application): Forwarded to full board (3-0). - The committee noted that the budget and appropriations committee would meet later that day at 1:45 PM.
Date: May 17, 2023 Committee: Budget and Appropriations Committee, San Francisco Board of Supervisors Members Present: Chair Connie Chan, Supervisor Hilary Ronan (excused for items 2-3), Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman, Supervisor Shamann Walton, Supervisor Ahsha Safaí Clerk: Brent Taliba Introductory Paragraph The Budget and Appropriations Committee convened on May 17, 2023, to discuss two main agenda items: (1) a hearing on the status of programming and funding for transitional housing programs serving criminally involved individuals, including Cameo House and Norma Hotel, and (2) a hearing and resolution to accept the Sheriff's Department Oversight Board (SDOB) 2022 Annual Report. The meeting highlighted the success of transitional housing programs and the progress of establishing an independent oversight body for the Sheriff's Department. Consent Calendar - No formal consent calendar was used; all items were acted upon individually. Public Comments & Testimony Item 1 (Transitional Housing): - Victoria Westbrook (Adult Probation) expressed gratitude for continued funding for Norma Hotel, emphasizing its success in teaching life skills to justice-involved transitional age youth (TAY) and its impact beyond reducing homeless nights. - A formerly homeless individual expressed concern about the city's repeated budget cuts to these programs and called for an audit of the last 10 years of budget activities. - Dan Macallair (Executive Director, Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice) thanked the Committee and Sheriff's Department for their support of Cameo House, noting it was the first residential alternative sentencing program for women with children. - Francisco DeCastro (public comment) emphasized the need for wraparound services (e.g., psychiatrists, psychologists, therapy, nutritionists) and a public website detailing services, and alleged that the city has wasted over $400 million on programs without standards. Items 2 & 3 (Sheriff's Oversight): - A former Sheriff's Department employee questioned the transparency and effectiveness of the Oversight Board. - Alexander Nancy Thompson raised concerns about communication and whether currently incarcerated individuals are hired to communicate with affected populations. - Francisco DeCastro (public comment) criticized the Oversight Board's operations, noting low public attendance, a disconnect between board members, lack of funding and orientation, and questioned why a new body would not be fully funded. Discussion Items Item 1: Hearing on Status of Funding for Transitional Housing Programs - Supervisor Ronan announced that after conversations with the Mayor's Office and various departments, funding for Cameo House and Norma Hotel would be included in the Mayor's budget, averting cuts. - Rebecca Jackson (Director, Cameo House, CJCJ) described Cameo House's services: alternative sentencing for justice-involved homeless women with children, serving 11 families (up to 22 children), with an average stay of 18 months. She noted that over 90% of women have substance use history, over 100% have experienced violence, and the program emphasizes dignity and individualized life plans. - Shania Brander (Program Manager, Recovery Survival Network) detailed Norma Hotel's services for justice-involved individuals aged 18-35, providing housing, life skills, and savings opportunities. She highlighted a success story of a client who reunified with family, obtained permanent housing, and reduced charges. - Supervisors Chan, Ronan, Walton, and Safaí expressed strong support for the programs, emphasized the importance of public safety beyond law enforcement, and praised collaborative efforts to secure funding. Items 2 & 3: Sheriff's Department Oversight Board 2022 Annual Report - Supervisor Walton provided background on the creation of the SDOB via Prop D (November 2020), its charter duties, and the need for independent oversight. - Jason Wector (SDOB President), Socheal Carrion (Vice President), and Dan Leo (SDOB Secretary) presented the annual report. Key points included: - Recruitment for the Inspector General (IG) is ongoing, with a timeline to hire by October 2023. - The Office of Inspector General (OIG) does not yet exist; current staffing is minimal (only the Secretary). - The budget for the new department was originally set below $3 million but was cut by about half a million dollars in the previous budget year. The board identified a need for 7 additional positions (total 20) to become operational, including a receptionist, legal assistant, IT administrator, data analyst, additional attorney, and public relations officer. - Community meetings have been held to solicit input, but attendance has been low (four members of the public at the first three meetings). - DPA has been providing infrastructure support, including complaint investigations, and has an online complaint portal, but the OIG will have broader authority to investigate all complaints. - Supervisor Ronan raised concerns about DPA making decisions (e.g., location, database) that should be deferred to the future IG to ensure autonomy. She emphasized the importance of accessibility for impacted populations. - Supervisor Chan noted a scheduled community meeting was cancelled due to quorum issues. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The hearing was heard and filed unanimously (5-0), with funding for Cameo House and Norma Hotel confirmed in the Mayor's budget. - Items 2 & 3: A motion to excuse Supervisor Ronan for the remainder of the meeting passed (4-0). The hearing (Item 2) was heard and filed, and the resolution accepting the SDOB Annual Report (Item 3) was forwarded to the full Board with a positive recommendation, both by a vote of 4-0. Next Steps: The Inspector General recruitment is expected to be completed by October 2023; the SDOB will continue community outreach, including a scheduled meeting at Glide Memorial Church in early June 2023.
This meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, convened on Monday, May 15, 2023, at 10:00 AM. The committee considered three appointments: Dennis Herrera to the Regional Water System Financing Authority, Robert Vergara to the Historic Preservation Commission, and the reappointment of Ovava Afuamango to the Sheriff's Department Oversight Board. All three appointments were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Vergara): One in-person speaker expressed strong support for Robert Vergara's appointment, praising his knowledge of San Francisco history. - Item 3 (Afuamango): One remote caller endorsed the candidate, also praising the Sheriff's Department's history and the success of a school program in the jail. Discussion Items - Item 1: Appointment of Dennis Herrera to the Regional Water System Financing Authority – Chair Dorsey provided background on the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) serving 2.6 million customers and the authority created by Senate Bill 1870 in 2002. The resolution reappoints SFPUC General Manager Dennis Herrera for a four-year term ending June 30, 2027. No questions or public comment were received. The committee voted to recommend approval. - Item 2: Appointment of Robert Vergara to the Historic Preservation Commission – Mr. Vergara, a 41-year history teacher at St. Ignatius College Preparatory and a lifelong San Franciscan, introduced himself. No committee questions. One public comment supported him. The committee voted to amend the motion to strike language rejecting the nomination and to recommend approval. - Item 3: Hearing on Appointment to the Sheriff's Department Oversight Board – The committee heard from Ovava Afuamango, who is seeking reappointment to Seat 1 (term ending March 1, 2027). She noted the board is in the middle of hiring an inspector general. Vice Chair Walton highlighted the board's creation via Proposition D in 2020 and noted an upcoming report at the Budget and Appropriations Committee. The committee voted to forward her name with a positive recommendation. No action was taken on Seat 3. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation passed 2-0 (Supervisor Safai absent). - Item 2: Motion to approve (as amended) passed 2-0 (Supervisor Safai absent). - Item 3: Motion to forward Ovava Afuamango's appointment to the full board passed unanimously (3-0). - All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on May 23, 2023.