Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 401–410 ENTRIES
401
JUN 20, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Recessed Meeting - June 20, 2025

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on June 20, 2025, to continue its second round of hearings on the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2025-2026 and 2026-2027. The committee addressed trailing legislation and disputed recommendations from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA), hearing from multiple departments. The meeting recessed until Monday, June 23, 2025, at 10:00 a.m. for further public comment and deliberation. Public Comments & Testimony - Rec and Park Fee Legislation (Items 13-16): Numerous speakers addressed the proposed fee increases, including paid parking in Golden Gate Park, court reservation fees, golf surcharges, and recreation program fees. Supporters, including union representatives, workers, and park advocates, argued the fees are necessary to avoid service cuts, pool closures, and layoffs. Many opposed privatization of golf courses. Opponents, particularly from tennis and pickleball communities, argued fees would disproportionately harm low-income residents, youth, and seniors, and called for alternative funding or audits. Some speakers also urged preserving the Partnerships Division, which generates millions in private funding. - Our City, Our Home Fund (Items 17-18): Several speakers, including service providers and advocates, thanked the committee for revising the spending plan to maintain funding for youth and family housing and prevention. Some expressed concern about moving funds from housing to shelter, emphasizing the importance of permanent housing solutions. Discussion Items - Police Department (Item 11): The committee heard a proposal to increase vehicle registration fees from $1 to $2 per vehicle and $2 to $4 per commercial vehicle to fund fingerprint identification programs. The department agreed with all BLA recommendations, but Chair Chan noted ongoing discussions about a civilian management position reduction. The item will be adjudicated later. - Asian Art Museum: The new director, Dr. Soyoung Lee, presented her vision. The museum disagreed with BLA recommendation AAM-2 to delete a vacant manager position (head of production and preparation). The museum argued the position is critical for exhibitions and operations. Chair Chan expressed disappointment over the cancellation of a planned Forbidden City exhibit but appreciated the commitment to future cultural diplomacy. - Public Library: The library director requested support to retain two vacant manager positions (main library manager and logistics supervisor) that the BLA recommended eliminating. The BLA noted the positions have been vacant for months and that the library has a low management-to-staff ratio (1:35). Supervisor Engardio and others advocated for the positions, noting they have no general fund savings. - Department of Early Childhood: The director opposed BLA recommendations to delete three vacant positions and reappropriate funds from the Public Education Enrichment Fund (PEF). The BLA argued the positions have never been filled and that moving facility costs to PEF would not affect the baseline. The chair noted the policy debate around spending special funds. - Department of Emergency Management (DEM): DEM agreed with all BLA recommendations. The committee discussed the new neighborhood street teams and ambassador program consolidation. Chair Chan proposed putting $9.9 million (year two) on reserve, requiring DEM to report back in November. DEM agreed. - Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD): OEWD reached agreement with the BLA. The committee discussed City Build program changes and the legacy business program. Chair Chan requested dedicated staff for legacy business, and OEWD committed to further discussion. - Human Services Agency (HSA): HSA agreed with 12 of 26 BLA recommendations, totaling $2.5 million in savings. Disagreements involved 14 vacant positions, upward substitutions, and a $1 million sugary drink tax fund transfer. The director argued the positions are mission-critical, especially for foster care, workforce development, and food security. Chair Chan signaled opposition to the debt service cut for a Bayview building but maintained a policy against upward substitutions. - Recreation and Park Department (RPD): RPD disagreed with BLA recommendations to delete $900,000 in vacant positions (aquatic supervisors, recreation coordinators), an SUV, and two upward substitutions for manager positions. The department also opposed a cut to the Partnerships Division (6 filled positions). RPD presented fee legislation (Items 13-16) to generate $11.8 million over two years, including paid parking in Golden Gate Park ($4.9 million net), court reservation fees ($1 million), utility surcharges, and recreation program fee changes. The department announced it would not pursue outsourcing golf maintenance, instead proposing revised golf fees to reduce the general fund subsidy by 60%. Chair Chan requested amendments to the scholarship policy to use San Francisco area median income and to clarify cost recovery for golf. The committee will continue discussions. - Adult Probation Department: The chief requested approval of a new manager three position and retention of a manager two position, citing increased workload from Prop 36 and re-entry services. The chair noted the policy against new management positions but agreed to further discussion. - Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) - Items 17-18: HSH presented an updated Our City, Our Home (OCO) spending plan, agreed to with the BLA. The plan reallocates $34.7 million in unprogrammed funds and $19.5 million in interest earnings to expand housing for families, youth, and adults, including rapid rehousing, restore beds, and problem-solving resources. The trailing legislation suspends caps on short-term rental subsidies and authorizes future revenue spending. Supervisor Fielder expressed concern about a clause allowing future funds to be allocated without board approval, stating she would seek its removal. The committee will review amendments by Monday. Key Outcomes - Agreements: Many departments reached agreement with the BLA, including Police, DEM, OEWD, HSH, and parts of HSA and RPD. The committee will adjudicate unresolved items later. - Votes: The committee voted unanimously to excuse Supervisor Walton and to recess the meeting until Monday, June 23, 2025, at 10:00 a.m. All items not yet disposed will be considered at that time. - Next Steps: The committee directed the city attorney to draft amendments for the OCO legislation and requested further discussions on RPD fee proposals, including scholarship policy and golf cost recovery. Departments with unresolved disagreements will continue negotiations.

PARKS AND RECREATION 16% · PROCEDURAL 15% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 10%
402
JUN 18, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Meets June 18, 2025, to Review Department Reductions and Fee Changes

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on June 18, 2025, to continue its review of the Mayor's Proposed Budget for FYs 2025-2026 and 2026-2027. Departments appeared to address proposed reductions recommended by the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) office and to present trailing legislation. The meeting also included discussion of several fee ordinances and a lease amendment for a shelter expansion. The committee forwarded two administrative code items to the full board with positive recommendation and forwarded a resolution regarding a shelter lease to the full board without recommendation. Consent Calendar - The committee unanimously voted (5-0) to forward Items 5 and 6 (administrative code amendments regarding SOGI data transfer and Treasure Island Development Authority status) to the July 8 full board with a positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - No public speakers appeared for any of the agenda items, including the shelter lease amendment (Item 10). Public comment was opened and closed for each item without participation. Discussion Items City Attorney – Programmatic Project Funding (Federal Litigation Support) - The City Attorney's Office accepted all fiscal recommendations. The BLA flagged a policy item: a $1,060,000 per-year programmatic project to fund three new attorney positions (classification 817) for litigation against the Trump administration. City Attorney David Chu requested support, noting the office is "completely overwhelmed" and that the positions would help defend billions in potential liabilities and pursue revenue-generating affirmative cases. Chair Chan expressed support, calling it a legal fee investment, and Vice Chair Dorsey noted the office's value in protecting the city. The item remains under discussion. Treasurer & Tax Collector – First Year Free Fee Waiver (Item 4) - The department accepted all BLA recommendations. The ordinance would extend the waiver of first-year permit, license, and business registration fees for small businesses through June 30, 2026. The committee deferred action to a later meeting (June 20) for consolidated fee discussion. Assessor-Recorder – Upward Substitution Recommendation - The department agreed with fiscal recommendations but disagreed with a policy recommendation to deny an upward substitution (1824 Principal Administrative Analyst to 0922 Manager 1) in the public service division. Assessor Joaquín Torres argued the change supports efficiency and staff morale. Chair Chan opposed the substitution, citing a citywide 20% management growth and preferring a $1.6 million investment in six new FTE for appeals to generate revenue. President Mandelman suggested continued conversation. No vote taken. Department of Human Resources – Deputy Director Position - The department agreed with fiscal recommendations but opposed eliminating a vacant 0953 Deputy Director 3 position. Director Carol Eisen argued the role is critical for policy work (return-to-work, leave, civil service reform) and that the incumbent is on administrative leave as acting director of the Human Rights Commission. The BLA noted the position supervises only three employees, while other deputy directors supervise 19–60. Chair Chan signaled opposition to retaining the position, consistent with her stance on management vacancies. Department of Technology – Management Positions and Work Order (Items TIS 11, 12, 13, 14) - DT agreed with fiscal recommendations but opposed eliminating two vacant deputy director positions (Enterprise Applications and Network Services). Director argued the department's staff-to-management ratio is 17:1, above city average, and the roles are critical for high-risk systems (police operations, affordable housing internet). The BLA also recommended eliminating a redundant work order with the City Administrator for digital services, shifting billing to Admin Services in FY 2026-27. The City Administrator's office accepted that recommendation. Chair Chan suggested placing work order funds on reserve for flexibility. Items deferred. Office of the City Administrator – Multiple Positions and Trailing Legislation - The department agreed with 9 of 10 fiscal recommendations and accepted policy recommendation ADM 13 (work order shift for digital services). Disagreement remained on 7 policy recommendations involving positions in the Real Estate Division, Office of Contract Administration, Office of Cannabis, and TIDA. Deputy City Administrator Katie Patruccioni warned that eliminating two campus managers and a contracts deputy would be "completely untenable" and "catastrophic." Chair Chan noted many positions were not general fund supported, reducing direct savings. No vote taken. Department of Public Works – Vehicles, Manager Positions, and Fee Ordinance (Items 8, DPW 7-14) - DPW agreed with fiscal recommendations but opposed policy recommendations to eliminate four vehicle replacements and four vacant manager positions. Director Carla Short emphasized the vehicles' age (20+ years), lack of airbags, and 97% utilization rate. She argued the corridors program manager (vacant 5 years) is critical for a growing workforce development program, and other manager roles are needed for procurement oversight ($1 billion in contracts) and landscaping management. The BLA offered an alternative of downgrading the corridors manager from 0933 to 0932. The committee also considered Item 8, a fee ordinance updating DPW fees (subdivision, excavation, general fund) with modest CPI-based increases and waivers for small business permits. Action deferred. Mayor's Office – Protocol Fund and Management Positions - The department agreed with some fiscal recommendations but opposed a $100,000 cut to the Special Protocol Fund and elimination of two vacant management positions in the Finance and Policy Division. Budget Director Sophia Kittler said the fund had no spending as of May 30, and the positions may be filled (requiring layoffs). The BLA noted they appeared vacant in the budget system. Continued discussion. Department of Public Health – Fee Ordinance (Item 9) - DPH accepted all BLA recommendations, except a policy recommendation to eliminate a 0923 Manager 2 position serving as liaison between the Mayor's Office and health/homelessness agencies. Director Maureen Sia said the role is critical for coordination. The ordinance removes DPH permits for veterinary hospitals and laundry facilities, updates fees for solid waste, food safety, and tobacco penalties, and lowers certified farmers market permit fees by half. Action deferred. Shelter Lease Amendment – 2177 Jerrold Avenue (Item 10) - The resolution would authorize up to $3,055,982 for improvements to add approximately 82 shelter beds at an existing temporary shelter on Jerrold Avenue, with the lease running through January 1, 2039. Supervisor Walton (District 10) strongly opposed, arguing the community was not consulted and already hosts multiple shelters. He accused the mayor of ignoring district voice. The BLA flagged the item as a policy matter. The committee voted 5-0 to forward the resolution to the June 24 full board without recommendation. Key Outcomes - Items 5 & 6: Forwarded to the July 8 full board with a positive recommendation (5-0). - Item 10: Forwarded to the June 24 full board without recommendation (5-0). - Items 4, 7, 8, 9, and 11-18: Held over to the June 20 committee meeting for further discussion and consolidated fee action. - No votes were taken on individual department budget reductions or fee increases during this meeting. The committee will continue deliberations on Friday, June 20, and Monday, June 23 (public comment). - Chair Chan reiterated that she will consistently reject upward substitutions and vacant management positions recommended by the BLA, citing a citywide 20% growth in management positions over the last four years. - The meeting recessed at 12:20 PM and will resume on Friday, June 20, 2025, at 10:00 AM.

PROCEDURAL 26% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 25% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 10% · TECHNOLOGY AND INFRASTRUCTURE 6%
403
JUN 18, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - June 18, 2025: Recognitions, Crime Report, DPA Budget, and Chief Search

The San Francisco Police Commission met on June 18, 2025, at 1:45 PM UTC (in person). The meeting included officer and citizen recognition awards, presentations on community programs, the Chief's crime report, the Department of Police Accountability (DPA) budget crisis, and an update on the search for a permanent Chief of Police. The commission also voted on two Department General Orders and held a closed session. Consent Calendar - Weekly Officer Recognition Certificate: Sergeant Gordon Lee and Sergeant Maria Peregrina (absent) were recognized for resolving a difficult sexual assault case. The commission commended their dedication and professionalism. - Citizen Recognition Award: Registered nurse Odette Horstaus was honored for rendering life-saving aid at a vehicle collision scene on May 8, 2025, stabilizing a victim with a severe head injury and performing CPR until fire department arrived. - Presentation on the San Francisco Brown Bombers: Dr. Raymond Ross, president of the community-based youth organization, presented its 26-year history of serving over 5,000 youth, providing sports, mentorship, and academic support. He highlighted that the organization contributes over $998,000 in volunteer man-hours annually and requested deeper partnership and funding from the San Francisco Police Department (SFPD). Commissioners expressed strong support for the program. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: - A speaker raised concerns about out-of-state vehicles near public safety facilities, suggesting potential security risks and urged military involvement. The speaker also flagged an upcoming anti-AI protest on July 11, 2025. - Multiple DPA investigators (Ellen Dolis, Terry Torgeson, Candace Carpenter, Steve Ball) spoke against proposed layoffs of DPA investigators, stating that the investigations unit has been decimated from 17 to 11 line investigators, and that a senior investigator received a layoff notice. They urged the commission to use its influence to prevent cuts, citing low morale and threats to statutory deadlines. - A mother of a murder victim (Arby Abercasa, killed August 14, 2006) pleaded for her son's unsolved case to be investigated, expressing concern that budget cuts would further delay justice. - Public Comment on Chief's Report: - Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez (Society of Professional Journalists) and Ginny LaRoe (First Amendment Coalition) praised Chief Yep for proactively reaching out to discuss press access during protests, but raised concerns about journalists being detained and phones being smacked during June 8-9 protests. They requested a meeting to ensure compliance with state law protecting press access. - Public Comment on Commission Reports: A speaker urged community turnout for an upcoming Board of Supervisors vote on legislation related to tipsters and unsolved cases. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 5): Acting Chief Paul Yep reported: - Crime trends: Violent crimes down 23% week-over-week; property crimes down 43%; overall crime down 27% year-to-date. - A 400% increase in rapes (from 1 to 5 incidents) was due to a single case with multiple suspects and victims; arrests were made. - Hate crime incident: On June 14, a victim was attacked with inflammatory slurs near Fillmore and Moulton; one suspect arrested for aggravated assault with hate crime enhancement. - Stunt driving prevention: On June 14-15, a stunt show was preempted; approximately 200 vehicles were turned back to the East Bay; no event occurred in San Francisco. - The “No King” protest on June 14 attracted an estimated 75,000 people; minimal vandalism; no arrests or use of force reported. - Command promotions: 12 command staff announced effective July 5, including Deputy Chiefs and Commanders. Commissioner Elias noted only two women were among the 12; Chief Yep committed to promoting women and diversity. - Pursuit policy: Commissioner Benedicto asked about a vehicle pursuit on June 16 that ended in a crash. Chief Yep did not have full details but agreed to include the incident in a future review of the 2024 pursuit policy changes. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 6): Executive Director Henderson reported: - Complaints are up significantly this year due to protests. - Budget hearings occurred; the Board of Supervisors and Mayor’s office are reevaluating proposed cuts to DPA. - Layoff notices have been issued for filled positions, but no final decisions have been made. Henderson confirmed that all unfilled positions have been eliminated, leaving only 39-40 filled positions. - The charter ties DPA investigator positions to the number of SFPD officers (1 per 150 officers), but Henderson argued that number is insufficient given case complexity and statutory deadlines. - Commissioners expressed support for DPA investigators and requested detailed impact data on caseloads and public access if cuts proceed. - Search for Chief of Police (Item 8): DHR Director Anna Biaspis and Manager Jen Lowe presented the process: - Requests for proposals for executive recruitment firms are due June 20, 2025. - The selected firm will conduct up to five community meetings and an online survey, recruit candidates, and assist with screening and interviews. - The target is to bring the selected firm before the commission in July 2025. - Commissioners asked about safeguards against firm bias and requested transparency, including posting the RFP criteria on the commission website. - Department General Orders: - Item 9: Adoption of revised DGO 6.10 (Missing Persons). The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to adopt. - Item 10: Approval of DGO 9.06 (Vehicle Tows) for meet-and-confer with bargaining units. The commission voted unanimously (5-0) to approve. Key Outcomes - Votes: - Adopted revised DGO 6.10 (Missing Persons) – unanimous 5-0. - Approved DGO 9.06 (Vehicle Tows) for meet-and-confer – unanimous 5-0. - Closed Session: The commission voted to enter closed session (Item 12) and later voted not to disclose any discussions beyond the President’s report (Item 14). - Next Steps: - A follow-up report on the DPA budget impact and caseloads is expected at the next meeting. - The search for a police chief will proceed with firm selection by July; community input meetings will be scheduled. - A future meeting will review protest response and press access, including discussions with journalists. - The commission will continue to monitor the DPA layoff situation and use its influence to advocate for investigator positions.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 29% · PROCEDURAL 21% · PUBLIC SAFETY 14% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 11%
404
JUN 17, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - June 17, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on June 17, 2025, starting at 10:15 AM. The meeting included a consent agenda, special orders for commendations and three related appeals concerning the proposed Heritage on the Marina project at 3400 Laguna Street, unfinished business, new business, and general public comment. The board voted on the appeals and passed several routine items. Consent Calendar - Items 1–5: Routine approvals including settlements of lawsuits (Golden Bear Insurance, State Farm General, Marie Thornton, Larry Jacobs, Chime Financial) totaling $6,242,167.64. Adopted unanimously (11-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Support for appellants (Save the Marina's Heritage): Multiple speakers argued that the Heritage on the Marina project violates planning code by converting rent-controlled units into institutional use, unlawfully removing affordable housing. They contended that the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) only approved the certificate of appropriateness with Condition 1 (requiring Architectural Review Committee review of massing and details), and that removing this condition would undermine the HPC’s authority. They also raised concerns about traffic safety at Bay and Laguna streets, inadequate analysis of the Notice of Special Restrictions (NSR), and the project’s scale (60,000 sq ft for only 23 new units). Speakers included Tanya Albuquerque, Steve Williams, and several neighborhood residents. - Support for project sponsor (Heritage on the Marina): Speakers, including residents and a preservation architect, emphasized the need for updated senior housing, the financial crisis faced by Heritage (annual deficit of $3–8 million), and the inadequacy of current units (average 250 sq ft). They argued the project would improve the historic building and add 23 larger care suites (average 700 sq ft). They urged approval without Condition 1, stating it was unnecessary and legally problematic. Alan Murphy (attorney for sponsor) and CEO Mary Lindy spoke. - General public comment: Several speakers addressed other topics, including opposition to a proposed RV towing policy, support for the Homicide Reward Fund, and criticisms of city governance. Discussion Items Special Orders: 3400 Laguna Street Project Appeals (3:00 PM) The board held three joint appeals regarding the project at 3400 Laguna Street, a historic landmark (Julia Morgan building) operated as a residential care facility for seniors. The project proposes demolishing two non-historic buildings, constructing two new 40-foot buildings, adding a below-grade parking garage, and increasing care suites from 86 to 109 (23 net new units). - Appeal of Final EIR Certification (Items 25–28): Appellant Save the Marina’s Heritage argued the EIR was inadequate (noticing, traffic analysis, project description). Planning Department staff responded that all issues were addressed and the EIR met CEQA standards. The board voted 11-0 to affirm the certification (Item 26) and table Items 27–28. - Appeal of Conditional Use Authorization (Items 29–32): Two appellants: Save the Marina’s Heritage (arguing violations of existing CU, inadequate notice, detrimental impacts) and the project sponsor (seeking modification of Finding 6L to remove reference to ARC review). Planning recommended denying the neighbor’s appeal and modifying Finding 6L per sponsor’s request. Supervisor Sherrill moved to amend Item 31 (disapprove Planning Commission’s decision) to approve the CU with a modified Finding 6L stating that final review would be completed by Planning Department preservation staff, without ARC involvement. The amendment passed 10-1 (Supervisor Chan dissenting). Then the board approved the amended Item 31, directed preparation of findings (Item 32), and tabled Item 30, also 10-1. - Appeal of Certificate of Appropriateness (Items 33–36): Project sponsor appealed HPC’s condition requiring ARC review of massing/details (Condition 1). Planning and City Attorney advised that Condition 1 as written was an improper delegation and could violate the Permit Streamlining Act. Supervisor Sherrill moved to amend Item 35 (disapprove HPC decision) to approve the COA with a revised Condition 1: final architectural details (fenestration, materials, finishes) to be reviewed by Planning Department preservation staff, provided no reduction in square footage. The amendment passed 10-1 (Supervisor Chan dissenting). The board then approved the amended Item 35, directed findings (Item 36), and tabled Item 34, also 10-1. Commendations (2:30 PM) - Supervisor Chen honored firefighter Stan Lee for 30 years of service, including over 400 working fires, Maui wildfire relief, and community leadership. - Supervisor Dorsey offered in memoriam for Muni operator Rodney Bowden and retired Deputy Sheriff Rhonda Gaines. Unfinished Business (Items 6–9) Passed unanimously. Key item: Item 9 – Planning Code amendment to eliminate retail size limits on health service uses in the MUO district east of 7th Street. New Business (Items 10–24) Passed unanimously via "same house, same call" votes. Included interim budget ordinances, settlements, permit approvals, and sign district changes. Committee Report (Item 37) Ordinance to allow tourist hotels/motels to be used for interim housing without losing hotel use classification. Passed on first reading unanimously. Key Outcomes - 3400 Laguna Street EIR: Appeal denied. Certification affirmed (11-0). The board found the EIR adequate under CEQA. - Conditional Use Authorization: Approved with modified Finding 6L (10-1). Final design review shifted to Planning Department staff; no ARC oversight required. - Certificate of Appropriateness: Approved with modified Condition 1 (10-1). ARC condition removed; planning staff to review final architectural details without allowing square footage reduction. - Consent Calendar and all other agenda items passed unanimously. - In Memoriams: Meeting adjourned in memory of Rodney Bowden and Rhonda Gaines (Supervisor Dorsey).

PROCEDURAL 43% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 8%
405
JUN 16, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - June 16, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on June 16, 2025, at 6:15 PM to consider four items: an ordinance approving the Municipal Transportation Agency's (MTA) surveillance technology policy for red light and no-turn enforcement cameras, two appointments (Entertainment Commission and Police Commission), and an appointment to the Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District. The meeting featured extensive public testimony on the Police Commission appointment, with seven candidates and over 60 public speakers. Item 1: Surveillance Technology Policy – Red Light and No-Turn Enforcement Cameras - The MTA presented its automated red light and no-turn enforcement camera program, operating since 1996 as part of Vision Zero. The system uses 3D radar and cameras at 19 cameras across 13 intersections. It captures three images and a 12-second video of each potential violation. Two human reviews (contractor then SFPD) occur before a citation is issued. Data is stored up to 30 days; if no citation, destroyed after 15 business days; if cited, up to 5 years. Only SFPD, Superior Court, and vendor have access without a warrant. The program issues approximately 1,000 citations per month (10,000–11,000 per year). - Supervisor Mandelman asked about citation rates and aging out of violations. The MTA manager stated some events expire due to limited SFPD review capacity (one officer). A report on events vs. citations will be provided. - No public comment. - Motion: Forward to full board with positive recommendation. Passed unanimously (Walton, Sherrill, Mandelman all aye). Item 2: Appointment, Entertainment Commission - Laura Thomas, current public health seat holder (appointed 2016), reapplied. She holds a Master's in Public Health and has HIV/AIDS experience. - No public comment. - Motion: Forward to full board with positive recommendation. Passed unanimously. Item 3: Appointment, Police Commission – Seat Three (Term Ending April 30, 2029) Seven applicants were considered: Albert Mayer, Franco Sorrelli, Haseeb Imran, Marjan Philhour, Meredith Osborne, Pratiba Techie, and Patrick Hallanan (not present). Each applicant gave opening statements and answered questions from the committee on police policy, pretextual stops, accountability, engagement with the Board, and selection of a new police chief. Public Testimony: Over 60 speakers, with strong support for Pratiba Techie (from Tenderloin community, tenant advocates, labor unions) and Marjan Philhour (from small business owners, Asian American community, police rank-and-file supporters). Several speakers also supported Haseeb Imran (from Muslim community, former police deputy chief). Discussion: Supervisor Mandelman emphasized the seat's history as a community seat (previously held by Petra de Jesus and Jesus Yanez) and the need for a candidate committed to both public safety and reform. He expressed support for Pratiba Techie, noting her deep roots in the Tenderloin and daily work on open-air drug markets. Supervisor Sherrill thanked all applicants but noted a slight difference of opinion. Supervisor Walton commended all candidates. Motion: Supervisor Mandelman moved to forward Pratiba Techie's appointment to the full board with positive recommendation. - Vote: Mandelman aye, Walton aye, Sherrill no. Motion passed 2-1. Item 4: Presidential Appointment, Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District Public Financing Authority No. 1 – Supervisor Stephen Sherrill - Motion to approve Supervisor Sherrill as an alternate to seats one, two, and three. Supervisor Sherrill was excused from the vote. - No public comment. - Motion: Amend to strike "rejecting" and replace with "approving", then forward to full board. Passed unanimously (Mandelman and Walton aye, Sherrill excused). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Red Light Cameras): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (unanimous). - Item 2 (Entertainment Commission): Forwarded Laura Thomas's reappointment (unanimous). - Item 3 (Police Commission): Forwarded Pratiba Techie's appointment (2-1, Sherrill dissenting). - Item 4 (EIFD Authority): Approved Supervisor Sherrill's alternate appointment (unanimous, Sherrill excused).

POLICE OVERSIGHT 63% · PUBLIC SAFETY 15% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 6% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
406
JUN 16, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use Committee Hears Housing Rezoning, Passes Interim Hotel Housing Ordinance on June 16, 2025

This regular meeting of the Land Use and Transportation Committee, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar and joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmoud, addressed two agenda items. The first was a routine ordinance to allow certain tourist hotels and motels to be used for interim housing without losing hotel use classification. The second was an informational hearing on the 2025 Housing Element Rezoning, a complex plan to rezone large portions of the city to meet state-mandated housing production targets. The hearing featured extensive presentations, supervisor questions, and over 70 public comments, reflecting deep community division. The committee voted to advance the hotel ordinance to the full board and filed the rezoning hearing. Public Comments & Testimony Item 2 – Housing Element Rezoning: Over 70 speakers provided public comment. Positions were deeply divided: - Opposition (39 speakers): Residents and neighborhood groups argued the plan would displace existing tenants and small businesses, demolish rent-controlled housing, harm historic resources, and primarily produce market-rate luxury units rather than affordable housing. Many cited outdated population projections and the state mandate as flawed. Speakers from Neighborhoods United SF, Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods, Planning Association for the Richmond, and others urged rejection or major revisions. - Support (19 speakers): YIMBY groups, housing advocates, and some residents highlighted the need to increase housing supply to lower costs, retain families and workers, support public transit, and avoid state-imposed building remedies. They praised the plan’s focus on transit corridors and inclusionary housing options. - Conditional/Amendment (17 speakers): Organizations such as the Race and Equity in All Planning Coalition, Chinatown Community Development Center, and the Labor Council called for stronger tenant protections, a right of return for displaced tenants, affordable housing funding, small business support, and 3D modeling to visualize impacts. They expressed cautious support if equity measures are strengthened. Discussion Items Item 1 – Ordinance on Interim Housing in Hotels and Motels (File 250257): This ordinance amends the Planning and Building codes to allow certain hotels and motels used for temporary COVID-19 shelter to be used for interim housing without losing their hotel use designation. The committee had previously amended the legislation. Public comment was called but no speakers came forward. A motion to send the item to the full board as a committee report passed unanimously (3-0). Item 2 – 2025 Housing Element Rezoning (File 250552): This informational hearing occupied the majority of the meeting. Planning Department directors Rachel Tanner and Lisa Chen, alongside Josh Switsky, presented the “Family Zoning Plan.” Key details: - The city must accommodate an additional 36,200 housing units above current zoning by 2031 to meet state law. - Of these, 20,300 must be affordable to low-income households, 8,400 to moderate-income, and 7,500 to above-moderate income. A 15% buffer brings the total target to approximately 94,300 units. - The plan proposes height increases along major corridors (e.g., 40–85 feet on transit streets, up to 140 feet in select areas) and density decontrol in residential areas, allowing up to 6 units at base zoning under a new local program. - The local program offers flexibility on inclusionary housing, height, and open space to incentivize projects to opt for local rather than state bonus programs. - Related policies include tenant protections (codifying SB 330), an affordable housing sites strategy, and small business support measures. Supervisor questions touched on: - Density decontrol and family housing: Vice Chair Chen expressed concern that removing unit caps could reduce family-sized units. Planning responded that a 25% requirement for units with 2+ bedrooms would be maintained. - Affordable housing strategy: Planning noted a forthcoming sites analysis tools to help identify parcels for 100% affordable projects, but acknowledged funding is the primary constraint. - Historic preservation: President Mandelman stressed the need for a clear plan to landmark buildings before upzoning triggers demolitions. Planning agreed to develop a strategy. - Incentives for local program: Supervisor Mahmoud requested comparisons with state density bonus. Planning highlighted flexibility in affordable housing compliance and design standards as key incentives. - Local refinements: Supervisor Ingario requested height reductions near the Sunset coast and Merced Manor; planning agreed to review. Key Outcomes Item 1: The committee initially voted 3-0 to recommend the ordinance as a committee report. After discovering a typographical error (lot number listed as “101” instead of “010”), the committee rescinded the first vote, adopted the correction as a minor amendment, and then voted again 3-0 to forward the amended ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors for consideration on June 17, 2025. Item 2: The committee voted 3-0 to file the informational hearing, meaning no further action was taken. The rezoning legislation is expected to be introduced in the coming weeks, with additional hearings scheduled at the Planning Commission (June 26) and later at this committee. The final adoption deadline is January 2026.

LAND USE 44% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 32% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 6% · PROCEDURAL 3%
407
JUN 13, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting – June 13, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a special meeting on Friday, June 13, 2025, starting at approximately 9:15 AM. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and members Joan Engardio, Shamann Walton, and President Rafael Mandelman (who joined later), considered the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2025-2026 and 2026-2027, along with several related ordinances. The meeting began with items related to the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC), then proceeded to department budget hearings for the Police Department, City Attorney, Superior Court, Environment, Law Library, Public Library, Retirement System, Rent Board, Department of Emergency Management (DEM), Juvenile Probation, Adult Probation, Public Defender, Fire Department, Sheriff's Department, Department of Police Accountability (DPA), Office of the Inspector General (OIG), and District Attorney. Public comment was taken on specific items and on the overall budget. The committee voted to forward several ordinances to the full board and continued the main budget hearing to June 18, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - SFPUC Items (6‑8): Matt Harry, water quality technician and union delegate, expressed concerns about staffing shortages, temporary exempt positions, and excessive vacancies, urging the city to staff up. - Library Trailing Legislation (Item 4): Emily Garvey (Executive Director, Friends of the SF Public Library) and Kate Lazarus (board member) spoke in support of the grant, highlighting programs like One City One Book and Summer Stride. - Public Defender Trailing Legislation (Item 5): No public speakers; comment closed. - General Budget (Items 1‑3): Several speakers addressed the committee: - Peter Warfield (Library Users Association) criticized library service inequities. - Brent Bayan (DPA investigator, TWU Local 200) opposed DPA layoffs, noting the loss of a senior investigator. - A second speaker from DPA urged retention of investigative positions to meet legal timelines. - A speaker questioned reallocation of resources away from investigators. - Michelle Wright (SEIU 1021) requested restoration of a museum conservator position at the Asian Art Museum. - A speaker from the Department of Environment urged no layoffs in FY2026-2027. - Anya Warley Zigman (People's Budget Coalition) noted that increases in public safety department budgets could cover all proposed cuts elsewhere. Discussion Items SFPUC Budget Adjustments (Items 6‑8) Deputy General Manager Ron Flynn and Budget Director Anna Dooning presented. The SFPUC is in the second year of a fixed two-year budget (operating $2.1 billion, capital $1.6 billion). They requested: - Item 6: De‑appropriation of $86,916 from the capital budget (no project changes). - Item 7: Authorization to issue up to $1.054 billion in water revenue bonds, with a $14.1 million increase in debt capacity. - Item 8: De‑appropriation of $12,990,064 from the operating budget. The Budget Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended a technical amendment to clarify the bond increase. The committee voted unanimously (4‑0) to adopt the amendment and then unanimously to forward all three items to the July 8 full board meeting. Department Budget Hearings Police Department (SFPD): Acting Chief Paul Yip presented. Violent crime down 16.6% year‑to‑date; property crime down 28.6%. Sworn staffing remains well below baseline; overtime budget increased to $71 million, but projected spending around $97 million. The department plans a reserve officer program and special event officers to reduce overtime. Six civilian layoffs and 25 FTE deletions (mostly vacant) were proposed. Questions focused on overtime accountability, civilianization, recruitment (4,500 applicants projected; 30,000 needed long‑term), and the Office of Victims' Services. No formal vote was taken on the police budget as part of the overall hearing. City Attorney: David Chu presented. The office has devoted nearly 8,000 hours this year to federal litigation, filing six lawsuits. The federal administration poses threats to funding; $1 million in the mayor's reserve would fund three new positions. The proposed budget is $125 million. No questions were raised by supervisors. Superior Court: Executive Officer Brandon Riley discussed the civil grand jury ($250,000 budget) and indigent defense administration ($10.048 million, a $248,000 increase). Due to public defender unavailability, 25% of new criminal cases go to the conflict panel. Court may need a supplemental if unavailability continues. COVID backlog eliminated. Environment Department: Director Tyrone Ju reported a 60% general fund cut over two years. Year one absorbed through program restructuring, but year two would force layoffs and cessation of climate action plan, building electrification, and EV work. The department has won $84 million in grants since 2022, but $39 million are at risk due to federal changes. The Climate Equity Hub, funded by the board, would be zeroed out. President Mandelman expressed alarm and commitment to sustain the work. Law Library: Director Diane Rodriguez presented a budget $45,000 less than FY24‑25. The library has 9 staff, down from 12 pre‑pandemic. No questions. Public Library: Director Michael Lambert presented. The budget maintains 1,400 weekly hours across 28 branches and continues the Ocean View Branch project. No personnel reductions. The library is on track for a third consecutive circulation record. The committee later voted to forward the Friends grant ($1,072,600) as recommended. Retirement System (SFERS): CEO Alison Romano reported 97% funded status, $36.6 billion in assets. Proposed budget $55.7 million, no FTE changes. Prepayment of contributions saves the general fund $23 million annually. No questions. Rent Board: Executive Director Christina Varner presented. Fee‑supported department with 50 FTEs, five vacancies. Budget increases due to salary and fringe. No layoffs. Inventory of housing units improving. Department of Emergency Management (DEM): Director Mary Ellen Carroll presented. Proposed budget $161 million. 18 position changes (10 filled positions eliminated, 8 vacant). New positions for neighborhood street team leads. Overtime and 911 dispatch improvements; three dispatcher academies per year. Questions about street team hiring versus core mission concerns. No vote. Juvenile Probation: Chief David Miller reported no layoffs; 65 positions eliminated over five years via attrition. Proposed budget uses state funds for DJJ realignment. Caseloads increasing; facility redesign estimated $200 million. Discussion about capital planning. Adult Probation: Chief presented a $62 million budget. 14 vacant FTE deletions; no layoffs of filled positions. One new position requested for Prop 36 preparedness. Caseloads vary by risk (26 to 121). Mobile probation van launching late August. Public Defender: Mano Rajou reported high caseloads, with 40% increase in active cases over five years. Office declared unavailability on a percentage of cases; estimated cost to city of conflict panel is $5 million per year if continued. Trailing legislation (Item 5) accepts a $3.4 million grant from Crankstart Foundation for four immigration defense positions. Committee unanimously forwarded the ordinance to full board. Fire Department: Chief Dean Crispin presented a $554 million budget. No cuts to frontline staff. Six civilian positions eliminated (fire protection engineers, IT, facilities intake). Four firefighter academies planned over two years. Overtime improving. Fleet aging; 70% of apparatus over 20 years old. Committee praised department's lean management. Sheriff's Department: Sheriff Paul Miyamoto reported 76% sworn staffing, no layoffs. Recruiting improved; 91 new deputies hired this year. Overtime budget increased to $31 million. Body cameras and jail management system upgrades funded. Discussion on jail programming re‑start after COVID. Department of Police Accountability (DPA): Director Paul Henderson reported a 40% workforce reduction over six years (22.32 positions). Proposed cuts of four positions, including three investigators. DPA argued these cuts are disproportionate and may violate charter mandates. Public comment echoed concerns. Committee members expressed need for adequate oversight. Office of the Inspector General (OIG): Marshall Kine presented. Budget reduction of $209,000; only one position (board secretary) at risk. Without it, the Sheriff's Department Oversight Board cannot function. The office has no inspector general currently. Committee discussed charter compliance and possible solutions. District Attorney: Brooke Jenkins presented a $96.7 million budget, a 3.3% increase driven by salary and fringe. Caseloads rising: felony filings up to 4,200 in 2024; misdemeanor lawyers average 186 cases. No new positions. Requests for race‑blind charging software, Racial Justice Act staff, Be the Jury program, and operational cost increases were not funded. Committee thanked DA for maintaining flat staffing. Key Outcomes - SFPUC Items 6‑8: Amended and forwarded to full board (July 8) with positive recommendation (4‑0). - Library Trailing Legislation (Item 4): Forwarded to full board (July 8) with recommendation (4‑0). - Public Defender Trailing Legislation (Item 5): Forwarded to full board (July 8) with recommendation (4‑0). - Main Budget Hearing (Items 1‑3): Continued to the committee's June 18 meeting (4‑0). - No other formal votes were taken; department budgets remain under review. Note: The meeting recessed for approximately 30 minutes at 1:00 PM and resumed. The meeting adjourned after public comment on the overall budget.

PUBLIC SAFETY 19% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 12% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 11% · PROCEDURAL 6%
408
JUN 12, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting – June 12, 2025

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, June 12, 2025, at approximately 12:15 PM. The meeting covered a range of items including continuances, consent calendar approvals, informational presentations on the Railyards development and a housing project at 668 Guerrero Street, adoption of the Racial and Social Equity Action Plan Phase 2, and a conditional use authorization to merge two dwelling units at 301 Main Street. The Commission voted to adopt the equity plan, deny the unit merger, and continued several items. Consent Calendar - Item 3 (1635 Divisadero Street): Unanimously approved (6-0) a Conditional Use Authorization for a real estate office (Tusker Corporation) on the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - Continuances: A member of the public questioned why the Community Investments Toolkit item keeps being continued, noting its importance to the Housing Element implementation. Joseph Smook (Race and Equity and All Planning Coalition) supported further continuance to allow more engagement. Another speaker urged the city to lobby Sacramento to exempt Priority Equity Geography neighborhoods from SB 423. - General Public Comment: Several speakers addressed SB 79 (state density bill), with Catherine Petrin (Neighborhoods United SF) and Bridget Maley urging the Commission to request a full analysis of costs and impacts. A housing navigator shared personal stories about housing insecurity and the need for transparency. - Racial and Social Equity Action Plan (RSEAP): Numerous community members and organizational representatives spoke in strong support of adopting Phase 2, including Dale Seymour (Equity Council), Leah Johnson (Friendship House), Atheus Cervantes, Krista Larcon Luna (MEDA), Annie Chung (Self-Help for the Elderly), Eric Argoyo (Cultura y Arte Nativo de las Americas), Naima Hall, Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition), Isan Looper (Tenderloin CBD), Patty Rodriguez (small business owner), and Alma Casalanos (Klecha). All stressed the importance of institutionalizing equity, building community trust, and maintaining funding. - Railyards Development (Prologis): A speaker expressed disappointment that affordable housing was not mentioned in the presentation. Another speaker (self-identified as new to the process) supported the project’s ambition and called for continued momentum. A speaker via reasonable accommodation requested that presentations be posted online and noted the lack of live broadcast on SFGovTV. - 668 Guerrero Street: Georgia Shudish questioned why the project is classified as an alteration, asked about demolition calculations, and which units would be affordable. Bridget Maley echoed concerns about height and unit mix. - 301 Main Street (Unit Merger): Georgia Shudish referenced a past merger on California Street where kitchens were kept separate, and urged a strong policy against merging flats. Bridget Maley raised concerns about future impacts on housing stock. A neighbor spoke in favor of property owners’ rights to adapt units for aging in place. Discussion Items - Item 8 – Racial and Social Equity Action Plan Phase 2 Adoption: Staff presented the plan, highlighting community feedback, revisions for feasibility and accountability, and division-level strategies (historic context statements, code equity audit, impact analysis toolkit). The Commission unanimously supported adoption, with members praising the collaborative process, the inclusion of output/outcome metrics, and the institutional commitment. Director Hillis noted the plan is adaptive and builds on existing external work. - Item 9 – Railyards Site Development (Prologis) Informational Presentation: Prologis presented a vision for a 20-acre transit-oriented development with up to 7 million square feet of mixed use, thousands of homes, a new Caltrain station, and parks. The project envisions heights up to 850 feet as a regional transit hub. Commissioner questions focused on community engagement (led by Prologis with city oversight), affordable housing commitments (still under discussion), parking ratios, bike parking, and the need for more detailed urban design diagrams. The item was informational only; no vote taken. - Item 10 – 668 Guerrero Street Informational Presentation: The architect presented a 12-unit state density bonus project (SB 423) with a mix of unit sizes, including two- and three-bedroom units. Commissioners noted the improved presentation compared to previous SB 423 projects, supported the unit mix, and asked about affordable unit placement (determined later during permitting) and notification procedures. The item was informational; no vote. - Item 11 – 301 Main Street 26A & 26B – Conditional Use Authorization to Merge Two Dwelling Units: Staff recommended denial, citing loss of a housing unit in a time of shortage. The project sponsor argued for multi-generational living and aging in place, noting the merger would allow a live-in caregiver for the owner with a vision condition. Commissioners debated the policy trade-offs: some were sympathetic but ultimately voted to deny by 5-1 (Commissioner Campbell dissenting). A condition requiring the units to be restored upon sale was discussed but not applied due to the denial. Key Outcomes - Continuances Approved: Item 1 (935 Geary Street) continued to July 24, 2025; Item 2 (Community Investments Toolkit) continued indefinitely. Vote: 6-0. - Consent Calendar Approved: Item 3 approved 6-0. - Racial and Social Equity Action Plan Phase 2 Adopted: Unanimous 6-0 vote. The plan sets two- and five-year checkpoints and prioritizes existing projects. Next steps include publishing the full plan and an equity dashboard. - 301 Main Street Conditional Use Denied: Motion to deny the unit merger passed 5-1 (Commissioner Campbell against). The project would have removed a housing unit in a transit-rich area.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · LAND USE 14% · RACIAL AND SOCIAL EQUITY 12%
409
JUN 12, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting - June 12, 2025

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, held a special meeting on June 12, 2025, to hear presentations from multiple city departments on the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2025-2026 and 2026-2027. The meeting included presentations from the Asian Art Museum, Fine Arts Museums, California Academy of Sciences, Arts Commission, War Memorial, Child Support Services, Department of Early Childhood, Recreation and Park, Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH), Department of Public Health (DPH), Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD), Human Rights Commission (HRC), Department of Children, Youth and Their Families (DCYF), and Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD). The committee also considered numerous trailing legislation items. Public comment was taken on many items, with speakers expressing concerns over cuts to early childhood education, homelessness services, workforce development, and community programs. The committee took several votes, including amendments and continuances. Consent Calendar - Item 5 (Resolution to accept bequest from estate of William Benjamin Bobo for park furnishings, $3.6 million) was unanimously forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Items 10-14 (DPH trailing legislation: patient rates, acceptance of grants, etc.) were unanimously forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Early Childhood (Item 4): Over 30 speakers, including parents, educators, and advocates from Parent Voices and other organizations, urged the committee to protect Baby Prop C funds. Many requested restoring the cash balance threshold from $200 million to $300 million before interest could be used for other purposes. Speakers emphasized the importance of universal child care, support for children with special needs, and wage equity for educators. - Recreation and Park (Items 5-6): Several speakers opposed the proposed outsourcing of golf course operations and maintenance, arguing it would harm union jobs and public access. Others expressed concerns about the lack of community engagement regarding the Gerald Avenue shelter project. A few speakers supported paid parking in Golden Gate Park as a revenue measure. - Homelessness and Supportive Housing (Items 7-9): Many speakers opposed the reallocation of Our City, Our Home (Prop C) funds, arguing it would cut housing for families and transitional age youth in favor of shelter beds. Speakers from Project Homeless Connect, Larkin Street Youth Services, and the Coalition on Homelessness urged the committee to maintain funding for permanent housing and support services. Community members from Bayview expressed anger over the lack of community input for the Gerald Avenue shelter expansion. - Public Health (Items 10-14): Speakers opposed cuts to the Soda Tax-funded programs, including healthy eating grants and community health worker programs, which they said would harm Pacific Islander, Latino, and other communities facing health disparities. - MOHCD, HRC, DCYF, OEWD: Numerous speakers urged restoration of funding for civil legal services, workforce development (CityBuild), immigrant legal defense, and programs for women and LGBTQ+ communities. Several city employees facing layoffs spoke about the importance of their roles in compliance and economic development. Discussion Items - Asian Art Museum ($34M total budget): Presented by Deputy Director Emiko Usui. The museum currently operates five days a week due to staffing reductions. Mayor's proposed budget maintains current staffing, avoiding a 15% cut that would eliminate 11-13 positions and potentially force closure. - Fine Arts Museums ($85.8M total budget): Director Tom Campbell highlighted the museums' economic and educational contributions. The mayor's budget avoids a full 15% reduction, but headcount is reduced by 5.75 FTE. Free Saturdays continue to attract over 720,000 visitors since 2019. - California Academy of Sciences ($80M total budget): CFO Matthew Lau reported that the city's $8.1M supports the Steinheart Aquarium and essential engineering staff. Ratified first union contract with goal of $25/hr minimum wage. Budget restores engineering capacity in FY27. - Arts Commission: Director Ralph Remington presented the merger of Arts Commission, Grants for the Arts, and Film Commission into a new agency. The mayor's budget eliminates $500K in DKI grant-making (redirected to HRC). The committee discussed the transition and workforce impacts. - War Memorial ($32M total budget): Managing Director Kate Sofis highlighted efforts to increase earned revenue and implement patron screening. Budget includes $737K decrease in general fund reliance through efficiencies. - Child Support Services: Director Karen Roy reported a lean budget with no new positions. Caseload declined 22% over five years. Collections exceed state and national averages. No layoffs proposed. - Department of Early Childhood ($600M+ over two years): Director Ingrid Mesquita presented kindergarten readiness improvements (66% to 78% from 2022-2024). The trailing legislation (Item 4) allows use of interest from Baby Prop C fund to reduce baseline spending by up to $16.9M annually. Supervisor Melgar proposed amending the cash balance threshold from $200M to $300M before interest can be used. The committee approved the amendment after the mayor's budget office signaled support. - Recreation and Park ($263.9M in FY26): Director Phil Ginsburg and CFO Antonio Guerra presented a $17.5M deficit requiring $11.8M in new revenue (paid parking, fees). The budget eliminates $7.5M general fund subsidy for golf in FY27 and proposes exploring lease agreements. Without revenue measures, service reductions including pool closures, rec center hour cuts, and 34 full-time layoffs would occur in October 2025. Paid parking in Golden Gate Park (Item 6) was continued to align with other fee proposals. - HSH ($742.7M in FY26): Executive Director Shireen McSpadden outlined the "Breaking the Cycle" initiative, including $122M for 630 new interim housing beds and a strategy to address vehicular homelessness. Trailing legislation reallocates $88.5M from Prop C fund balance and interest to shelter and hygiene programs, suspends the 12% cap on short-term rental subsidies, and authorizes flexible spending for three years. The committee expressed confusion over the plan and concerns about cuts to family and TAY housing. Supervisor Walton criticized the lack of community input for the Gerald Avenue shelter expansion (Item 7). All three items (7,8,9) were continued to allow further discussion. - DPH ($3.37B gross budget): Director Daniel Sai presented a budget with no layoffs but $31.6M in CBO reductions. The department commits to $530M in new revenue over two years. 24 FTE were reassigned, and 182 vacant positions deleted. Supervisor Walton questioned cuts to Hope SF wellness centers and Soda Tax-funded programs. - MOHCD ($172M in FY26): Director Dan Adams reported a $25M decrease from current year, driven by paused residential vacancy tax collection and cuts to general legal services, community building, and financial capability programs. 13 vacant positions deleted. DKI funding continues via non-general fund sources. - HRC and DOSW ($27.9M combined): Acting Director Mawuli Tugbenyo presented the merger of the two agencies. 9 positions eliminated (2 filled). $5.7M in grant reductions. The committee questioned the future policy priorities for women's issues. - DCYF ($350M annual): Interim Director Sharice Dorsey Smith noted an $11.8M cut, primarily from rescinding a community grants RFP. The department is in the second year of a five-year funding cycle. 18 positions vacant, one deletion. - OEWD ($86M to $29M reduction): Director Sarah Dennis Phillips explained that $26M of the reduction is the transfer of ambassador programs to DEM, and $19M is one-time expiring funds. The remaining $12.5M in true reductions includes 18 position eliminations (12 filled) across workforce compliance and small business programs. The committee expressed frustration with cuts to CityBuild compliance officers and the legacy business manager. Key Outcomes - Item 4 (Early Care and Education baseline): Amended to raise the cash balance threshold from $200M to $300M before interest can be used. Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (5-0). - Items 5 (Bequest): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (5-0). - Item 6 (Paid parking in Golden Gate Park): Continued to the call of the chair to be heard alongside Recreation and Park fee proposals next week (5-0). - Items 7,8,9 (Gerald lease, OCO reallocation, HSH expenditure plan): Continued to the call of the chair for further discussion, with the intention to agendize next week (5-0). - Items 10-14 (DPH trailing legislation): Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (5-0). - Items 1-3 (Budget and salary ordinances): Continued to the next meeting (June 13, 2025) (5-0).

BUDGET AND FINANCE 27% · PROCEDURAL 16% · HOMELESSNESS 12% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 9%
410
JUN 12, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Regular Meeting – June 12, 2025

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on June 12, 2025, chaired by Vice Chair Bilal Mahmoud, with Supervisors Danny Sauter and Cheyenne Chen (sitting in for Chair Dorsey) present. The committee considered three items: two liquor license applications and a resolution endorsing the Tenderloin Community Action Plan (TCAP) Investment Blueprint. All items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Consent Calendar - No items were on the consent calendar; all agenda items were discussed individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (TCAP): Dozens of community members and organizational representatives spoke in strong support of the resolution and urged continued city investment. Speakers included residents, youth, seniors, and leaders from Glide, Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation (TNDC), Tenderloin Community Benefit District (TLCBD), Chinatown Community Development Center (CCDC), St. Anthony's Foundation, Bshop, Wu Yi Children's Services, and others. They highlighted tangible outcomes from the initial $4 million participatory budgeting process: over 3,400 residents served, 235,000 fresh meals delivered to SRO residents, 2,000 square feet of murals installed, the launch of the Tenderloin's first Arab Youth and Teen Drop-in center, and improved safety and cleanliness. Many speakers emphasized that the neighborhood is at a tipping point and that cutting funding would reverse hard-won progress. A recurring request was for the city to allocate an additional $4 million for the next phase of the TCAP. Discussion Items Item 1: Liquor License Transfer – Bottles and Bites (1799 Union Street) - Officer Natalie Villotaro Crane from the SFPD ABC Licensing Unit presented the Police Department report. The applicant sought a Type 21 off-sale general liquor license. Two letters of protest were received but resolved by the applicant agreeing to a 10 p.m. cutoff time. The location is in census tract 130.01, a high-crime and high-concentration area. Northern Station had no opposition. The applicant's representative, David Villavo, spoke in support, noting the store's revival. Supervisor Mahmoud confirmed that Supervisor Sheryl (district supervisor) supports the transfer. The committee unanimously voted to direct the clerk to prepare a resolution finding that the license would serve public convenience or necessity and to forward it to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Liquor License Issuance – Club Deluxe (1511 Haight Street) - Supervisor Mahmoud voiced strong personal support for the return of Club Deluxe, a historic music venue and cultural institution in the Haight. Officer Crane presented the PCN report for a Type 90 on-sale general music venue license. There were zero letters of protest or support. Conditions included noise limits, compliance with the San Francisco Entertainment Commission, litter control, loitering prevention, and two uniformed security guards during live entertainment. The applicant's representative expressed gratitude and noted that the Type 90 license is the only vehicle for the venue's return. The committee unanimously voted to prepare a resolution of public convenience or necessity and forward it to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 3: Resolution Endorsing the Tenderloin Community Action Plan (TCAP) Investment Blueprint - Supervisor Mahmoud introduced a non-substantive amendment to add the Chinatown Community Development Center (CCDC) to the list of community-based organizations on page 2, lines 1–4. The amendment was adopted unanimously. A joint presentation followed by Asil Farah (San Francisco Planning), Curtis Bradford (TNDC), and Isan Looper (TLCBD). They described the three-year, community-led process that produced the blueprint, built on the earlier Tenderloin HIP and People's Congress plans. The $4 million participatory budgeting pilot funded 21 community-prioritized projects, leveraging $6.6 million in additional resources. The blueprint outlines seven strategies: street stewardship, eliminating open-air drug trade, public space improvement, youth investments, wellness services, small business support, and housing. Presenters and public commenters stressed that the plan is a holistic, community-authored roadmap. Supervisor Mahmoud noted that the current mayor's budget does not include additional funding and asked about the consequences of disinvestment. Presenters responded that stopping now would derail momentum and undermine trust. The committee voted to approve the amendment and then to forward the resolution as amended to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Bottles and Bites): Committee voted 3-0 to forward a resolution of public convenience/necessity to the full board. - Item 2 (Club Deluxe): Committee voted 3-0 to forward a resolution of public convenience/necessity to the full board. - Item 3 (TCAP): Committee voted 3-0 to approve an amendment adding CCDC and then 3-0 to forward the resolution as amended to the full board with a positive recommendation. - All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of June 24, 2025.

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 34% · PROCEDURAL 13% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 11% · PUBLIC SAFETY 10%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com