Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 581–590 ENTRIES
581
NOV 7, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting - November 7, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on November 7, 2024, at 6:15 PM. Chair Dean Preston presided, joined by Board President Aaron Peskin. Vice Chair Stephanie and Supervisor Chan were excused. The sole agenda item was a hearing on the Controller's report regarding invoices under a grant agreement between the San Francisco Police Department and SF SAFE, which was continued to a future date. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were offered on the item. Discussion Items - Hearing on Assessment of Invoices for SF SAFE (Item 1): President Peskin reported that the City Attorney's Office had worked with counsel for individuals previously issued subpoenas. He anticipated the hearing would be held on December 5, 2024. Chair Preston moved to continue the item to the call of the chair, which was seconded and passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - The committee voted to continue the hearing on the Controller's report regarding SF SAFE invoices to the call of the chair, with the expectation it will be heard on December 5, 2024. Motion passed 2-0 (Peskin and Preston in favor; Vice Chair Stephanie and Supervisor Chan excused).

PROCEDURAL 100%
582
NOV 6, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - November 6, 2024

The San Francisco Police Commission met on November 6, 2024, at 1:45 PM. Vice President Carter Oberstone presided with Commissioners Clay, Benedicto, Yanyez, and Yi present (Commissioners Walker and Elias excused). Chief William Scott provided a crime trends update, the Department of Police Accountability (DPA) reported on case activity, and commissioners discussed several policy matters, including the removal of Department General Order (DGO) 10.11 from the agenda and a dispute with the Police Officers Association (POA) over social media posts. Consent Calendar - The commission approved, by a 5‑0 vote, a consent item to receive and file complimentary registration fees for the 2024 Benchmark Analytics User Summit valued at $22,750. Commissioner Yi asked about ethical obligations for employees accepting the fees; Deputy City Attorney Alice Gabora confirmed the arrangement complies with local rules. Public Comments & Testimony - A speaker urged the commission to emphasize self‑control for police officers, stating that technology such as drones lacks self‑control. - A mother of a murder victim spoke about unsolved homicides in San Francisco and pleaded with the incoming mayor to retain Chief Scott. She called for more tipster incentives and asked anyone with information about her son’s case to call the anonymous tip line at 415‑575‑4444. Officer Recognition - Officer Megan Sinclair (Star 863) of Park Station was presented with the Weekly Officer Recognition Certificate for her calm, proactive work, including identifying a road‑rage suspect via ALPR and arresting a serial burglar. She was also announced as Park Station’s 2024 Co‑Officer of the Year. Chief’s Report - Chief Scott reported overall Part I crimes are down 32% year‑to‑date (13,653 fewer incidents). Violent crimes fell 14%, property crimes 33%. Homicides decreased from 47 to 30 (a 36% decline), with an 86% clearance rate. Vehicle break‑ins dropped 56%. Gun seizures rose to 933 (from 920), but ghost gun seizures declined to 92 (from 172). Three recent homicides were detailed; suspects were arrested in two cases, and one investigation is ongoing. Two non‑fatal shootings occurred. Retail theft operations led to 30 arrests, including at a Lululemon burglary. An attempted burglary at Louis Vuitton was thwarted. - Commissioner Clay asked about the impact of Proposition 36 on booking practices for retail theft. Chief Scott said the department is consulting with the District Attorney’s office and will focus on prolific offenders with prior convictions. - Commissioner Yi asked whether the department would seek receipts from SF Safe (related to a prior $5.3 million contract) or waive attorney‑client privilege on drone purchases. Chief Scott replied there are no plans to sue for receipts while a criminal case is ongoing and declined to waive privilege. DPA Director’s Report - Acting DPA Director Diana Rosenstein reported that since the last meeting, the office opened 50 new cases and closed 46. Year‑to‑date, 625 cases have been opened (vs. 703 at the same time last year); 216 cases are under investigation, and 725 have been closed (vs. 642). There are 120 sustained cases pending with the Chief and 8 with the Commission. The most complaints this week came from Southern Station. Commission Reports - DGO 7.01 Update (Commissioner Yanyez): Chief Scott reported that legal review of community feedback is nearly complete, but disagreements remain on some legal interpretations; further consultation with the City Attorney is needed. - Statement on POA Social Media Post (Commissioner Yanyez): Commissioner Yanyez accused the POA of posting a video showing his home address and falsely claiming he and his wife obstructed a police investigation. Chief Scott confirmed there is no investigation of Commissioner Yanyez for obstruction, though a separate, open investigation exists (not targeting Yanyez). Yanyez called the post defamatory and doxxing. - POA Litigation (Commissioner Benedicto): The POA filed litigation regarding DGO 9.07 (traffic stops). Benedicto requested a privileged briefing for commissioners once the city is served. - Station District Boundaries (Commissioner Benedicto): Update on the steering committee’s map recommendations, which have gone to the Chief and will be presented to the Commission later this year or early next. - Election and Commitment (Commissioner Benedicto): Acknowledged the day after a consequential election, reaffirming the commission’s dedication to evidence‑based, accountable policing regardless of political changes. - Medal of Valor Ceremony (Commissioner Yi): Yi noted that several commissioners attended the ceremony and thanked the Chief. - DGO 10.11 (Commissioner Yi): Yi explained that the item was removed from the agenda because the working group spreadsheet was not publicly posted per 3.01. He expressed concern that some unanimous recommendations from the working group, including those from law enforcement subject matter experts, were not incorporated. He commended Chief Scott for requiring all members, including command staff, to wear body‑worn cameras. - Caution on Investigations (Commissioner Clay): Clay warned that commissioners should be careful when discussing investigations, as federal inquiries may exist beyond the department’s knowledge. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar approved 5‑0. - Minutes for October 2, 9, and 16 approved 5‑0. - DGO 10.11 was removed from the agenda due to a procedural posting issue; it will be brought back at a future meeting. - Closed Session was held (Item 11) after a vote to proceed. The commission then voted not to disclose any discussion from closed session. - Chief Scott confirmed Commissioner Yanyez is not under investigation for obstruction; the POA’s social media claim was false. - The commission directed staff to continue work on DGO 7.01 and to schedule a privileged briefing on the POA litigation.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 39% · PROCEDURAL 36% · PUBLIC SAFETY 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9%
583
NOV 5, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – November 5, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, November 5, 2024, starting at 10:15 AM. The meeting began with roll call, the Pledge of Allegiance, and a land acknowledgment. All 11 supervisors were present except Supervisor Safai. The board unanimously approved the consent calendar, several unfinished and new business items, and heard general public comment. No items were removed from consent or debated individually. Consent Calendar - Items 1–13 (routine approvals): The consent agenda was adopted without objection. Key items included: - Real property acquisition at 2280 Market Street (not to exceed $11,620,000) with certain administrative code waivers. - Settlements of lawsuits: San Francisco Apartment Association et al. ($93,000); Park Hotels & Resorts Inc. (three settlements with stipulated assessed values of $140,700,000, $93,237,202, and $222,145,336 and refunds totaling $3,366,020 plus interest); Yulanda Williams ($625,000); Jane Doe ($200,000); Barnard Jones and Patricia Farrell ($475,000). - Police Code amendment regarding notice of supermarket closure. - Administrative Code amendment establishing a "Cash Not Drugs" Sobriety and Recovery Pilot Program. - Planning Code and Zoning Map amendment creating the New Asia Senior Housing Special Use District at 758 and 772 Pacific Avenue. - Public right-of-way acceptance for De Long Street. - Administrative Code amendment creating an E-Bike Incentive Fund. Unfinished Business - Items 14–15 (Redevelopment Plan Amendments – Hunters Point Shipyard and Bayview Hunters Point): Two ordinances were passed unanimously. They authorize the transfer of up to approximately two million square feet of research and development and office space from the project areas and extend the redevelopment plan time limits. - Item 16 (Planning Code – Below Market Rate Owned Units): An ordinance passed unanimously to allow certain BMR owned units to be resold at a price affordable to households at an increased area median income (AMI) level, require BMR units originally purchased with parking and amenities to be resold with them, and require periodic reporting to the inclusionary housing technical advisory committee and the Board of Supervisors. New Business - Items 17–18 (3333/3700 California Street Project – Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District and Development Agreement Amendment): A resolution of intention to establish San Francisco Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District No. 3 and an ordinance approving a development agreement amendment with Laurel Heights Partners, LLC were adopted unanimously. The amendment extends the term by eight years (to September 11, 2043), modifies affordable housing requirements to allow qualification for the temporary fee reduction program, and includes a finance plan using incremental property tax revenue to fund public capital facilities and affordable housing. - Item 19 (Increase of Interim Funding Programs for Wastewater, Water, and Power Enterprises): An ordinance passed on first reading to increase the aggregate principal amount of the Wastewater Enterprise Interim Funding Program from $750 million to $1.25 billion, the Water Enterprise Interim Funding Program from $500 million to $750 million, and the Power Enterprise Interim Funding Program from $250 million to approximately $450 million. - Item 20 (Professional Services Agreement – Consor PMCM, Inc.): A resolution adopted to authorize a contract not to exceed $10,720,500 for construction management staff augmentation services for the new City Distribution Division Campus at 2000 Marin Street, with a term from February 2025 through April 2029. - Item 21 (Real Property Acquisition – Easement from Sunol Glen Unified School District): A resolution adopted to acquire a 4,080-square-foot easement and a temporary construction easement for an underground water pipeline for a total of $50,000. - Items 22–23 (Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program Grants): Two resolutions adopted authorizing the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development to accept and expend grants from the California Department of Housing and Community Development: $29,745,053 for Sunnydale Block 7 and $41,162,574 for 160 Freelon Street, both for transportation, streetscape, and pedestrian improvements. - Items 24–25 (Golden Gate Avenue Phase I Loan Agreements and Multifamily Housing Revenue Note): Resolutions adopted authorizing loan agreements totaling not to exceed $23 million (including $12.5 million for a 55-unit low-income housing development, $10.2 million for a 20-unit moderate-income rental housing development, and $1.25 million for a parking garage) and a multifamily housing revenue note of up to $32,132,689 for the 55-unit LIHTC project. Supervisor Preston requested to be added as a co-sponsor. - Item 26 (Radio Usage Agreement – University of California San Francisco): A resolution adopted to enter into a trunked radio system usage agreement with anticipated revenue of $2,406,460. - Item 27 (Grant – State Physical Activity and Nutrition Program): A resolution adopted retroactively authorizing the Department of Public Health to accept and expend a $440,000 grant from the CDC through the California Department of Public Health through September 30, 2028. - Item 28 (Administrative Code – Catastrophic Illness Programs): An ordinance passed on first reading to authorize the Department of Human Resources to administer the TJ Anthony Employee Catastrophic Illness Program and the Catastrophic Illness Program for Family Members of City Employees. - Item 29 (Surveillance Technology Policy – Juvenile Probation Department): An ordinance passed on first reading approving the use of web filtering software. - Item 30 (Reappointments – In-Home Supportive Services Public Authority): A motion approved to reappoint Jesse Nichols, Sascha Bittner, Daisy McArthur, and Robin Wilson-Beattle to terms ending March 1, 2027 or 2026. Public Comments & Testimony - Mark (member of the public): Read Romans 13, advocating for a return to one-day paper ballot elections, and commented on the powers that be being ordained by God. - Leah McGeever (District 6 resident): Expressed anger at the government for what she described as harassment and threats against her, referencing her father’s military service and stating that the government is not worthy of such sacrifices. - Arcelio Joseph Ray Wyomes Noble (Sun Devil 12066): Discussed topics including student debt cancellation, interest rates, hurricanes, public housing, cannabis equity, and the 2024 elections, and asserted rights, privileges, and honors from Arizona State University. - Jim McBee: Criticized San Francisco for being proud of fraud, mentioned the 49ers, and encouraged others to participate in fraud. - Unnamed speaker (last speaker): Complained that there is no form available to report cyberstalking, alleging that people are paying for access to a system used for cyberstalking and that suicides and deaths are linked to this. Key Outcomes - All consent calendar items (1–13) were adopted unanimously. - All unfinished business items (14–16) were passed unanimously. - All new business items (17–30) were adopted unanimously, with the ordinances on items 19, 28, and 29 passed on first reading; all other ordinances finally passed or resolutions adopted. - Supervisor Preston added as co-sponsor on item 24. - The meeting will continue with further agenda items (not covered in the provided transcript).

PUBLIC COMMENT 28% · PROCEDURAL 23% · LAND USE 9% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 9%
584
NOV 4, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Regular Meeting – November 4, 2024

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on November 4, 2024, at City Hall, chaired by Supervisor Shamann Walton. The committee considered three agenda items: a resolution for street naming in the Hunters View Hope SF Phase III project, an ordinance on rapid rehousing policy, and a reappointment to the California State Association of Counties. Public comment was called on each item, but no members of the public spoke. The meeting was adjourned after approving two items and continuing one. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was listed on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided testimony on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1: Official Naming of Streets – Hunters View Phase III (File 241044) – The committee heard a presentation from MOCD (Mayor's Office of Community Development) staff and the developer, John Stewart Company. The project is part of the Hope SF initiative to revitalize public housing sites. Phase III includes 118 affordable housing units (53 public housing replacement with project-based vouchers and 64 units without operating subsidy), a new one-acre park, and infrastructure improvements. The proposed street name "Memory Lane" was chosen by residents through a community process (online survey, door-to-door knocking, and interviews) to honor the legacy of Hunters View residents, including those who advocated for improvements. The existing Fairfax Avenue name will be extended. Supervisor Walton noted the importance of community input. The item was approved unanimously and forwarded to the full board. - Item 2: Administrative Code – Rapid Rehousing Policy (File 241038) – Supervisor Myrna Melgar (substituting for Supervisor Ronan? Actually the transcript says "Supervisor Ronan" but likely a mis-spelling; Supervisor Ronen?) requested a continuance because the city attorney had not yet approved amendments to the legislation. The ordinance would declare city policy to provide up to five years of rapid rehousing assistance to eligible households when shorter subsidies would risk return to homelessness, and require annual hearings and reports by the Homelessness Oversight Commission. The committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the November 18, 2024 meeting. - Item 3: Reappointment to California State Association of Counties (File 241035) – The committee voted unanimously to recommend the reappointment of Supervisor Rafael Mandelman to the California State Association of Counties, term ending December 1, 2025. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Street Naming): Approved 3-0 (Vice Chair Ahsha Safai, Member Myrna Melgar, Chair Shamann Walton) and forwarded to the Board of Supervisors for the November 19, 2024 meeting. - Item 2 (Rapid Rehousing Policy): Continued to the November 18, 2024 meeting of the Rules Committee by a 3-0 vote. - Item 3 (Reappointment): Approved 3-0 and forwarded to the full board. - Other: Supervisor President Aaron Peskin was excused from the meeting by a 2-0 vote (Vice Chair Safai absent at the time of the motion).

LAND USE 53% · PROCEDURAL 24% · HOMELESSNESS 10% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 8%
585
OCT 30, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Meeting, October 30, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar, met on October 30, 2024, to consider eleven agenda items. The committee approved all items, forwarding them to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Notable discussions centered on the proposed Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD) for the 3333 and 3700 California Street projects, which aim to deliver over 1,300 housing units in the Laurel Heights neighborhood. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (240897): Resolution retroactively authorizing the Department of Public Health to accept a $440,000 grant from the CDC and California Department of Public Health for the State Physical Activity and Nutrition Program and CalFresh Healthy Living Grant (August 1, 2024 – September 30, 2028). Approved unanimously. - Item 2 (240991): Resolution authorizing a trunked radio system usage agreement with UCSF, with minimum revenue commitment of $2,406,460 through June 30, 2035. Approved unanimously. - Item 5 (240956): Resolution approving easement acquisition from Sunol Glen Unified School District for a water pipeline, not to exceed $50,000. Approved unanimously. - Item 6 (240985): Ordinance increasing interim funding programs for SFPUC enterprises: Wastewater to $1.25 billion, Water to $750 million, Power to $450 million. Approved unanimously. - Item 7 (240954): Resolution approving a $10,720,500 construction management contract with Consor PMCM, Inc. for the 2000 Marin Street campus. Approved unanimously. - Item 8 (240989): Resolution accepting a $29,745,053 grant from HCD for Sunnydale Block 7 affordable housing and transportation improvements. Approved unanimously. - Item 9 (240990): Resolution accepting a $41,162,574 grant from HCD for 160 Freelon Street affordable housing and transportation improvements. Approved unanimously. - Item 10 (240991): Resolution approving loans totaling $22,747,350 for Golden Gate Avenue Phase I (75 affordable units, including educator preference). Approved as amended with not-to-exceed amounts. - Item 11 (240992): Resolution authorizing a multifamily housing revenue note not to exceed $32,132,689 for the same project. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 3 & 4 (EIFD and Development Agreement): Several speakers expressed strong support. Representatives from Building Trades, Chamber of Commerce, Mercy Housing, Jewish Community Center, and neighborhood groups highlighted the need for housing, affordable senior units, and community benefits. No opposition was voiced. Discussion Items - Items 3 & 4 (3333/3700 California Street): The Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) presented a resolution of intention to form an EIFD and an ordinance amending the development agreement for 3333 California Street. The EIFD would capture 50% of incremental property tax revenue to fund $280 million in public infrastructure (open space, child care, streetscape). The development agreement amendment reduces the on-site affordable senior housing from 185 to 125 units (17% inclusionary, above current city requirements) and extends the term by 8 years. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) noted that including 3700 California Street in the EIFD does not strictly comply with board-approved financial policies (no development agreement or area plan), and the due diligence on financial need was incomplete. OEWD argued the projects meet the spirit of the policy and are critical for housing production. The committee added co-sponsors and adopted a non-substantive amendment to the resolution. Key Outcomes - All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Items 3 and 4 were amended as read by OEWD (adding a cross-reference to the development agreement). Item 10 was amended to adjust not-to-exceed loan amounts for the Golden Gate Avenue project. All votes were unanimous (3-0). The committee also noted that the November 6, 2024 meeting is canceled.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 26% · PROCEDURAL 20% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · FINANCE AND DEBT 11%
586
OCT 29, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - October 29, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on October 29, 2024, at 10:15 AM. The meeting addressed a wide range of items including routine approvals, legislation on affordable housing, e-bike incentives, supermarket closure notices, and two special hearings on San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD) programs. The meeting included roll call, approval of minutes, consent agenda, discussion of regular agenda items, special orders for commendations, and committee of the whole hearings on SFUSD's math pilot and resource alignment initiative. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 10 were approved unanimously. These included settlements (e.g., $93,000 to San Francisco Apartment Association, $625,000 to Yulanda Williams, $475,000 to Barnard Jones and Patricia Farrell), stipulated property tax refunds for Park Hotels & Resorts Inc., fee waiver for the Vicha Ratanapakdee Mosaic Stairway, and amendments to the Administrative Code regarding Street Teams reporting. Public Comments & Testimony - General public comment included speakers on homelessness, cybersecurity threats, unsecured property tax issues, and housing affordability. One speaker urged the board to consider restoring natural habitat at Ocean Beach for the Snowy Plover. - During the 4:00 PM hearing on SFUSD's math pilot, students from Flynn Elementary testified that the program increased their confidence in math. Parents praised the program for collaborative learning and joy in math. Teachers and administrators highlighted data showing significant gains in math proficiency and reduced chronic absenteeism. - During the 5:00 PM hearing on SFUSD's resource alignment, over a dozen speakers including parents, students, union representatives (UESF, SEIU 1021), and community members criticized the school closure process for lack of transparency, inadequate community engagement, and disproportionate impact on schools serving students of color and low-income families. Speakers called for an independent forensic audit of SFUSD's budget, restoration of trust, and a halt to privatization efforts. Discussion Items - Item 15 (Eliminating Public Art Requirement for 100% Affordable Housing): Approved 10-1 (Supervisor Peskin voted no). The ordinance removes the public art requirement for 100% affordable housing projects and allows relocation or removal of existing artwork under certain conditions. - Item 16 (Real Property Acquisition - 2280 Market Street): Approved 11-0. Authorized the acquisition of property from Market & Noe Center LP for up to $11.62 million, with waivers of certain administrative code requirements. - Items 17-25 (Various Contracts and Grants): All approved unanimously. Notable items included a retroactive contract with CENIC for fiber optic network ($6.97 million revenue), agreement with Gillig LLC for electric transit buses ($68.77 million), grant acceptance for port freight infrastructure ($9.16 million), and grant application for HUD Continuum of Care Program ($61.12 million). - Item 26 (Supermarket Closure Notice - Police Code Amendment): Supervisor Preston presented the ordinance requiring large supermarkets to provide six months' notice before closing. After discussion, the item was duplicated and referred to the Government Audit and Oversight Committee for further clarification. Supervisor Preston, Walton, Chan, Safai, and Ronan were listed as co-sponsors. - Item 27 (Cash Not Drugs Sobriety Pilot Program): Approved unanimously. Authorizes a voluntary three-year pilot providing weekly payments up to $100 to eligible CAAP beneficiaries who test negative for illicit drugs. - Item 28 (Settlement with Maplebear Inc.): Approved unanimously. Resolution to settle unlitigated claims for $8.25 million involving tax refunds for 2019-2022. - Item 29 (De Long Street Acceptance): Approved unanimously. Authorized acceptance of a street segment from BART for maintenance and liability, after decades of neglect. - Item 30 (E-Bike Incentive Fund): Approved unanimously. Establishes an electric bicycle incentive program administered by the Department of the Environment to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. - Item 31 (Commemorative Street Name - Joe Rosenthal Way): Approved unanimously. Designates the 600 block of Sutter Street in honor of photojournalist Joe Rosenthal. - Item 34 (New Asia Senior Housing Special Use District): Approved unanimously. Creates a special use district at 758 and 772 Pacific Avenue for 175 units of extremely low-income senior housing and restoration of the New Asia Banquet Hall. - Item 35 (BMR Ownership Units - Amendments): Passed on first reading with amendments. The ordinance allows certain below-market-rate owned units to be resold at higher income limits and requires amenities to be resold with the unit. Supervisor Peskin proposed a sunset date of three years, which was adopted without objection. The file was duplicated for potential further amendments. - Special Orders - Commendations: The board recognized Renee Berger for the Burnside Steps renovation and San Francisco Stairway Month; Father Simpad Sabangian for his leadership at St. Gregory Armenian Church; and Dr. Martina Ayala for her work as executive director of the Mission Cultural Center for Latino Arts. - 4:00 PM Hearing - Committee of the Whole: SFUSD Math Pilot: The board heard from SFUSD administrators, principals, and teachers about the Whole School Lesson Study Math Pilot. Key results: math proficiency increased from 21% to 34% over two years; Flynn Elementary saw 13% growth in math proficiency (vs. 0.1% district-wide); chronic absenteeism decreased 16% and 89% of students reported enjoying math. The program is funded by the city's Student Success Fund. DCYF Director Sheri Dorsey Smith and SFUSD Superintendent Dr. Maria Sue committed to continuing and expanding the program with long-term planning and stable funding, including adding Daniel Webster Elementary next year. Supervisor Ronan emphasized the program must not be diluted. - 5:00 PM Hearing - Committee of the Whole: SFUSD Resource Alignment Initiative: The board heard from UESF President Cassandra Couriel and SEIU 1021 representative Anthony Robertson about the impact of the proposed school closures and mergers on educators, paraeducators, and staff. UESF presented data showing that 745 members (12% of workforce) would be affected by closures, and the process lacked transparency and community input. SEIU highlighted concerns about staffing, food quality, and central office bloat. Superintendent Dr. Maria Sue acknowledged the harm and committed to transparent processes. School board Commissioner Alita Fisher apologized for the harm caused. The board expressed support for collaboration and urged the district to engage stakeholders before making future decisions. Key Outcomes - Items 1-10 (Consent Agenda): Approved unanimously. - Item 15: Passed 10-1 (Supervisor Peskin dissenting). - Item 16: Passed 11-0. - Items 17-25: All passed unanimously. - Item 26: Duplicated and referred to Government Audit and Oversight Committee. - Item 27: Passed unanimously. - Item 28: Passed unanimously. - Item 29: Passed unanimously. - Item 30: Passed unanimously. - Item 31: Passed unanimously. - Item 34: Passed unanimously. - Item 35: Passed on first reading with amendments (sunset date added). Duplicated file retained. - Items 38-39 (Adoption Without Committee Reference): Adopted unanimously (resolutions on Sensible Density Working Group and Legion of Honor Centennial Celebration). - SFUSD Math Pilot Hearing: DCYF and SFUSD committed to continuing and expanding the program with stable funding from the Student Success Fund. A steering committee will explore district-wide implementation of lesson study. - SFUSD Resource Alignment Hearing: The board acknowledged the flawed process and received commitments from SFUSD to ensure transparency and community engagement in future decisions. Superintendent Dr. Maria Sue and Commissioner Fisher expressed commitment to repair harm and rebuild trust.

PUBLIC EDUCATION 43% · PROCEDURAL 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 17% · PUBLIC HEALTH 4%
587
OCT 28, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - October 28, 2024

The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on October 28, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Shimon Waltz, joined by President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered three items: appointments to the In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS) Public Authority Governing Board, a surveillance technology policy for the Juvenile Probation Department's use of web filtering software, and amendments to the TJ Anthony Catastrophic Illness Program. All items were approved unanimously and recommended to the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony No members of the public provided oral comments on any of the agenda items. Discussion Items - IHSS Public Authority Appointments (Item 1): The committee considered reappointing four members to the IHSS Public Authority Governing Board. Jesse Nichols (Seat 5) was absent. Sasha Brittner (Seat 11) testified through her father, sharing her lived experience as a high-needs IHSS consumer and disability rights activist. She expressed full support for the program and her commitment to serving on the board. Daisy McArthur (Seat 12) also testified, praising the IHSS program and her work supporting seniors and people with disabilities. Robin Wilson Beattie (Seat 13) was not present but had submitted an application. Supervisors Walton and Safai expressed appreciation for IHSS providers and consumers. The motion to forward all four names to the full board with a positive recommendation passed unanimously. - Juvenile Probation Web Filtering Software Policy (Item 2): A representative from the Juvenile Probation Department presented a proposed surveillance technology policy for web filtering software used to protect youth in detention from harmful content and security threats. The software blocks distractions, malware, and restricts live chat on allowed sites like YouTube. It retains visited website data for at least one year but can be purged earlier. The initial cost was approximately $2,000–$3,000, with ongoing per-user license fees. The policy was previously reviewed and recommended by PSAB and COIT committees. The committee moved the ordinance forward with a positive recommendation, passing unanimously. - Catastrophic Illness Program Amendments (Item 3): Carol Isen, Director of the Department of Human Resources (DHR), presented amendments to the TJ Anthony Catastrophic Illness Program. Key changes include transferring full administration from the Department of Public Health to DHR, creating a general sick leave donation pool (instead of earmarking for specific employees), and reducing the waiting period for new employees from one year to three months. Dr. Fiona Wilson, chief physician for city employees, noted that approximately 50 applications are received annually, with about 85% approved. Denials typically involve chronic conditions like diabetes or arthritis rather than truly catastrophic illnesses. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the ordinance to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (IHSS Appointments): Motion to send the names of Jesse Nichols, Sasha Brittner, Robin Wilson Beattie, and Daisy McArthur to the full Board with a positive recommendation passed 3-0. - Item 2 (Web Filtering Policy): Motion to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation passed 3-0. - Item 3 (Catastrophic Illness Program): Motion to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation passed 3-0.

PROCEDURAL 41% · DISABILITY RIGHTS 28% · TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION 19% · HUMAN RESOURCES 8%
588
OCT 28, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
October 28, 2024 Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Land Use and Transportation Committee met on October 28, 2024 at 9:45 AM. Chair Mirna Melgar presided, joined by President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. Two items were heard: an ordinance to allow increased AMI eligibility for certain below-market-rate (BMR) owned units, and a special use district (SUD) for a new senior affordable housing project in Chinatown. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (BMR ordinance): John Abolos (Council of Community Housing Organizations) expressed support, noting the focus on real households and urging no delay. - Item 2 (Asia Senior Housing SUD): Multiple speakers voiced strong support, including Alan Lowe (Perkins CUI, representing Chinatown Community Development Center), Sharon Lai (former city planner and Chinatown member), Saol Ling Chiang (Pingyun Resident Improvement Association), and a representative of CCHO. They highlighted the 40-year need for affordable senior housing, the preservation of the New Asia Banquet Hall, and the project's community and cultural benefits. Discussion Items - Item 1: BMR Ordinance – Chair Melgar introduced an ordinance to fix a discrepancy between maximum resale price and affordable price for a small number of BMR homeownership units, triggered by a family (the Jansucks) facing loss of equity. Amendments were proposed: annual reporting to the Inclusionary Housing Technical Advisory Committee, Planning Commission, and Board after 10 adjustments and every 12 months. Concerns were raised about a potential “slippery slope” (President Peskin) and the unknown universe of affected units (estimated from a handful to as many as 100). A 36-month sunset was discussed but deferred to a duplicated file to allow further review. The Mayor's Office of Housing (MOHCD) clarified that only one unit currently qualifies, and the affordable price is calculated at resale based on current costs (HOA, interest, insurance). The committee approved the amendment and moved the original file forward with recommendation, while duplicating the file for continued consideration on November 18, 2024. - Item 2: Asia Senior Housing SUD – President Peskin presented the ordinance to create a SUD at 758 and 772 Pacific Avenue, enabling a 15-story, 175-unit affordable senior housing project (targeting extremely low-income at 30-40% AMI) and preserving the New Asia Banquet Hall. MOHCD confirmed $7.1 million in commitments and plans to use LOSP and SOS subsidies. The Planning Commission recommended approval unanimously. The project would be the first new affordable senior housing in Chinatown in 20 years. The committee added Supervisor Preston and Chair Melgar as co-sponsors and voted to forward with recommendation as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to amend the ordinance (adding reporting requirements) and motion to duplicate the file (to allow potential sunset clause) passed 3-0. Motion to recommend the amended ordinance to the full Board as a committee report passed 3-0. The duplicate file will be continued to the November 18, 2024 meeting. - Item 2: Motion to recommend the Asia Senior Housing SUD ordinance to the full Board as a committee report passed 3-0. The item is expected to appear on the Board's agenda on November 5, 2024.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 62% · PUBLIC COMMENT 28% · PROCEDURAL 9% · LAND USE 1%
589
OCT 24, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting – October 24, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, October 24, 2024, to consider a range of items including continuances, consent calendar approvals, commission matters, and several regular calendar items. Key actions included recommendations on amendments to the Inclusionary Housing Ordinance to enable alternative financing for affordable units, a fee waiver for a residential project at 524 Howard Street, and two conditional use authorizations: one for the Greg Angelo Museum (a landmark general entertainment use) and one for a project at 229–233 Whitney Street to legalize an illegal demolition and construct a modified replacement building. Consent Calendar - Items 5, 6, 7: The Commission unanimously approved three conditional use authorizations: 2298 Lombard Street (wellness studio), 1888 Mission Street, Suite B (commercial expansion), and 1337 Mission Street (cannabis delivery business). (Vote: 6-0) Public Comments & Testimony - Inclusionary Housing Ordinance (Item 13): John Avalos of the Council of Community Housing Organizations (CCHO) opposed the legislation, arguing it would allow market-rate developers to compete for scarce state/federal affordable housing subsidies normally reserved for 100% affordable projects, potentially harming production of deeply affordable units. William Wilcox of the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development responded that the new pathway would require a modest 10% increase in inclusionary units and that 100% affordable projects would still be prioritized in the competitive bond and tax credit allocation due to their deeper affordability levels. - Greg Angelo Museum (Item 16): 22 members of the public spoke in support, including neighbors, artists, and community members, highlighting the museum’s 35-year history, its role as a healing space and incubator for local artists, and its lack of neighborhood disruption. Two speakers, including a representative of the Balboa Terrace Homeowners Association, opposed, citing concerns about parking, noise, and future intensification. - Whitney Street Project (Item 17): Multiple neighbors from 225 and 237 Whitney Street and their representatives spoke in strong opposition. They alleged bad faith by the developer, referenced an earlier agreed-upon design (May 2023 plans), and objected to the increased massing, inadequate light wells, and the developer’s lawsuit against the city to remove rent control restrictions. They requested the Commission reject the current proposal and require a return to the earlier, smaller design. Discussion Items - Item 13 – Inclusionary Housing Ordinance Amendments: Staff presented a proposal (sponsored by Mayor Breed) to add a third compliance option for inclusionary housing: developers could exceed baseline requirements by 10% (with those additional units affordable to households at 80% AMI or below) in exchange for eligibility to use CDLAC tax-exempt bond financing and TCAC 4% tax credits. Staff recommended approval with a technical clarification. Commissioners debated competition with 100% affordable projects; Mr. Wilcox assured that the city’s deep-affordability projects would outcompete inclusionary projects in the state allocation process. The Commission voted 5-1 to recommend approval with staff modifications (Commissioner Williams dissenting). - Item 14 – 524 and 530 Howard Street Open Space Fee Waiver: The Commission considered a proposed ordinance to waive the Transit Center District Open Space Impact Fee for the project at 524 Howard Street (672 dwelling units, including 68 affordable). As a condition, the developer would construct a publicly accessible pedestrian bridge to the Transbay Rooftop Park and pay an estimated $2.3 million to the Transbay Joint Powers Authority. The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to recommend approval. - Item 16 – 225 San Leandro Way (Greg Angelo Museum): The Commission reviewed a request for Conditional Use Authorization to allow a general entertainment use (the Greg Angelo Museum) in a landmark building within an RH-1 zoning district. The museum had operated for approximately 35 years. The proposed conditions included limited hours, maximum guest sizes, and indoor-only evening events. After extensive public testimony (overwhelmingly supportive), the Commission unanimously (6-0) approved the authorization with the conditions outlined in the staff presentation and redlined hours of operation. - Item 17 – 229–233 Whitney Street (Illegal Demolition Remedy): The Commission returned to this matter after issuing an intent to disapprove the previous week. The project sponsor presented revised plans that removed the roof deck, added light wells (two 5x5-foot wells), reduced glazing, and added a fourth dwelling unit. Neighbors strongly opposed, arguing the changes did not address their concerns and were insufficient compared to earlier agreed plans. After lengthy discussion and staff input, the Commission voted 5-1 (Commissioner Campbell dissenting) to approve a modified version of Motion 1 (approval with conditions). The approved conditions included: elimination of the fourth floor, a combined 5-foot-deep light well on the north side, and frosted windows on the second-floor light well. The project thus proceeds with a three-story front building and the other previously proposed modifications. Key Outcomes - Item 13: Recommended approval of Planning Code amendments to expand inclusionary housing financing options (5-1). - Item 14: Recommended approval of the open space impact fee waiver for 524 Howard Street (6-0). - Item 16: Approved Conditional Use Authorization for the Greg Angelo Museum as a general entertainment use in a landmark building (6-0). - Item 17: Approved Conditional Use Authorization for the Whitney Street project, subject to modifications: removal of the fourth floor, a contiguous 5-foot-deep north light well, and frosted windows on the second floor light well (5-1). - Continuances: Items 1, 2, 3, 15A, and 15B were continued to later dates (6-0). - Consent Calendar: Items 5, 6, and 7 were approved (6-0). - Minutes: The October 10, 2024 draft minutes were adopted (6-0).

LAND USE 22% · PUBLIC COMMENT 18% · PUBLIC ART 13% · PROCEDURAL 12%
590
OCT 23, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - October 23, 2024

On Wednesday, October 23, 2024, the Budget and Finance Committee met at City Hall. Chair Connie Chan and Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman were present, joined later by Supervisor Myrna Melgar. The committee reviewed ten agenda items covering contracts, grants, and property acquisition, and voted to recommend all items to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 6 (2280 Market Street Acquisition): Many speakers from the GLBT Historical Society, community organizations, and the public urged approval. Speakers included Executive Director Roberto Ordenana, Archivist Isaac Fellman, Board Members Ani Rivera, Peggy Sue, Yves Avirous, Andrea Aiello (Castro Community Benefit District), Laura Thomas, Sally Morrow (Community Vision), Carolyn Choi (CAST), and Board Chair Ben Gilliam. One speaker opposed, criticizing the project as a product of family breakdown. - Items 8, 9, 10 (Technology-related): A single speaker commented on each, arguing that technology is used for control and should be resisted. No other public comments were made on other items. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Electric Transit Buses (Gillig LLC): The Office of Contract Administration and SFO presented a $68.8 million, four-year contract to purchase up to 50 electric buses for SFO. The budget legislative analyst (BLA) noted the cost is 7.8% below SFO’s estimate. Chair Chan asked about grant funding and justification for Gillig over other vendors; SFO explained that New Flyer did not bid. The committee approved. - Item 2 – Community Health Engagement (SF Public Health Foundation): DPH presented a $21.3 million contract amendment to support health equity programs, including fall prevention, vision zero, violence prevention, and hepatitis C navigation. BLA recommended approval. Chair Chan asked about cultural competency; DPH confirmed subcontractors hire staff with lived experience. Approved. - Item 3 – Port Freight Infrastructure Grant: The Port accepted a $9.16 million state grant for fendering, roadway repairs, and a zero-emission truck study. BLA noted a 20% matching fund from the Port. Chair Chan inquired about the zero-emission study scope; the Port explained it will evaluate battery and hydrogen options. Approved. - Item 4 – HUD Continuum of Care Grant: HSH applied for up to $61.1 million to fund 1,500+ permanent supportive housing units and rapid rehousing. The grant includes $5.3 million in bonus funding for 195 new units. Vice Chair Mandelman asked about new units; HSH noted the Granada Hotel is one. Approved. - Item 5 – SFO Project Management Support (PGH Wong): A $17 million contract amendment for Westfield Garage 675 project management. BLA confirmed the increase was originally envisioned. Approved. - Item 6 – 2280 Market Street Acquisition: Supervisor Mandelman introduced the ordinance to purchase the property for $11.6 million as a permanent home for the GLBT Historical Society museum and archives. The Director of Real Estate explained the transaction, including existing tenants (Barry’s Boot Camp, Dignity Health) and plans for a nonprofit lease. The committee approved after extensive public comment. - Item 7 – Auction Services (Bar None Auction): OCA presented a five-year, $3.9 million revenue contract for city vehicle auctions. BLA recommended approval. Chair Chan asked about vehicle retirement criteria; OCA deferred to fleet management. Approved. - Item 8 – Last Mile Broadband Grant: DT accepted a $10.4 million CPUC grant to connect 432 affordable housing units in Bayview, Chinatown, and Tenderloin. BLA noted a 20% match. Chair Chan co-sponsored. Approved. - Item 9 – Fiber Optic Network (CENIC/UCSF): A retroactive 10-year contract from 2021 to 2031 generating $6.97 million for DT to provide fiber to UCSF locations. Chair Chan asked about campus sites. Approved. - Item 10 – Radio System Agreement (SF State): A retroactive 11-year contract for $1.69 million allowing SF State police to use the city’s public safety radio system. Chair Chan inquired about similar agreements with City College and school district; DT noted potential future opportunities. Approved. Key Outcomes All ten items were moved to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Each passed unanimously (Vice Chair Mandelman, Chair Chan, and later Supervisor Melgar) without objection, except where Supervisor Melgar was excused. The committee expedited Item 6 due to a November 30 closing deadline.

PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION 11% · REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 11% · PROCUREMENT 10% · PUBLIC ART 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com