Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 671–680 ENTRIES
671
JUL 1, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - July 1, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 1, 2024, at 9:45 AM (Chair Myrna Melgar presiding) to consider five agenda items. The committee voted on four items and continued one item to July 8, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comment was heard on agenda item 4 (rezone 135 Kissling Street) only. Melinda Sarjapur of Ruben Genius and Rose spoke in support of the legislation on behalf of Royal Motors, stating that the changes would allow the business to install stackers on an existing vehicle storage lot and seek conditional use authorization for additional storage across the street to support its 70-year-old auto repair operation. Discussion Items - Item 1: Street Name Change – Oakdale Avenue to James Richards Way – Supervisor Walton (District 10) presented a resolution to rename one block of Oakdale Avenue east of Third Street to James Richards Way, honoring James Richards, a community trailblazer and electrician who provided jobs and fought for housing rights. The resolution directs Public Works to initiate street renaming procedures. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report. - Item 2: Awning Amnesty Program – Representatives from the Department of Building Inspection (DBI) and the Office of Small Business presented an ordinance to make permanent the streamlined permitting process for unpermitted awnings and extend fee waivers through July 1, 2025. The program has resulted in 236 permits issued or completed since September 2023, with 151 from voluntary compliance. The Planning Commission approved the item on June 20, 2024. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the ordinance to the full board as a committee report. - Item 3: 1629 Market Street Public Infrastructure Acceptance – Kahl Hense of the Department of Public Works presented an ordinance to accept public infrastructure improvements (streets, sidewalks, sewers, etc.) from the Plumbers Union Development Project at 1629 Market Street, including dedication of right-of-way and establishment of street widths. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the ordinance to the full board. - Item 4: Rezone 135 Kissling Street and Vehicle Storage Lot Permitting – Madison Tam from Supervisor Dorsey’s office and planning staff presented an ordinance to rezone 135 Kissling Street from Residential Enclave (RED) to Residential Enclave-Mixed (REDMX) and to conditionally permit vehicle storage lots in the REDMX and WMUG districts. The Planning Commission recommended adding WMUG to the conditional use allowance. President Peskin expressed concern that allowing permanent vehicle storage by conditional use could discourage future housing development, suggesting a time-limited conditional use (e.g., three years, renewable). The sponsor agreed to work on an amendment over the next week. Public comment was taken from a representative of Royal Motors in support. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to amend the ordinance (adding WMUG) and continue the item to July 8, 2024. - Item 5: Tenderloin Retail Hours Restriction Pilot Program – Supervisor Preston presented a final amendment to the ordinance creating a two-year pilot program restricting retail food and tobacco establishments in a high-crime area of the Tenderloin from being open 12 a.m.–5 a.m. (or 2 a.m.–5 a.m. if subject to ABC regulation). The amendment adds a 60-day notice requirement before a private right of action can be filed, giving the City Attorney a chance to enforce. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt the amendment and send the ordinance as amended to the full board as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved (3-0) – sent to full board as committee report. - Item 2: Approved (3-0) – sent to full board as committee report. - Item 3: Approved (3-0) – sent to full board as committee report. - Item 4: Amended and continued to July 8, 2024 (3-0). - Item 5: Amended and approved (3-0) – sent to full board as committee report. The meeting adjourned after completing the agenda.

PUBLIC WORKS 28% · LAND USE 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · PROCEDURAL 14%
672
JUN 27, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - June 27, 2024

This meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and also included Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman, Supervisor Myrna Melgar, Supervisor Shamann Walton, and Board President Aaron Peskin. The agenda and raw transcript label the meeting as June 26, 2024, but the supplied meeting timestamp is 2024-06-27 18:45:00 UTC. The committee considered four property/lease resolutions and a proposed $390 million general obligation bond. Discussion Items - Item 1 – UCSF/Potrero Power Station Block 2 assignment and assumption: John Lau of OEWD explained that California Barrel Company LLC is assigning a portion of the development agreement for Block 2 of the Potrero Power Station project to UC Regents on behalf of UCSF, which plans an outpatient cancer clinic and proton therapy center. The city is asked to affirm the Planning Director's approval of the assignment and a waiver of certain indemnification obligations, modified because UCSF is a state entity not subject to local land use laws. The committee forwarded the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation by a 3-0 vote (Chan, Mandelman, Melgar). - Item 2 – Main Library lease to Friends and Foundation of the San Francisco Public Library: The lease covers 387 square feet on the ground floor at 100 Larkin Street for the Friends' bookstore, with an initial annual base rent of $15,555.84 ($40.20 per square foot), annual CPI increases, a five-year term and three five-year extension options. Rent abates to $1 per year if the Friends contribute more than $90,000 during the preceding fiscal year to library activities. Chair Chan requested a written memo describing fundraising/use details. The item was forwarded 3-0. - Item 3 – Cafe Melange lease and revocable license at City Hall: The New Community Leadership Foundation (dba Cafe Melange) will operate a cafe on the lower level of City Hall, with approximately 1,400 square feet for the cafe and an adjacent seating area. Real Estate Director Enrico Pinick described the adjacent dining area as approximately 1,300 square feet, while the resolution text refers to approximately 1,400 square feet. The lease is retroactive to March 1, 2024, runs for five years with one five-year renewal option, and requires rent of 10% of gross sales with a $200 monthly minimum. Supervisors praised the return of food service to City Hall and suggested improved signage. The item was forwarded 3-0. - Item 4 – 141 Industrial Street lease to the Human Rights Commission: This is a new lease with Greater Calvary Hill Missionary Baptist Church for approximately 13,000 square feet and 10 parking spaces, at an initial annual base rent of $351,000 ($27 per square foot), running to May 31, 2027. The Human Rights Commission (HRC) described plans for Dreamkeeper Initiative meetings, summer programming, a literacy project, food security work, and potential staffing/housing of HRC staff. BLA analyst Nick Menard said it was unclear exactly how the space would be used and called approval a policy matter. Chair Chan asked for a written memo with more detail on operations, staffing, and partner organizations. Supervisor Walton strongly defended the department and objected to what he saw as extra scrutiny of programs serving young people of color; Supervisor Melgar supported approval. The committee forwarded the item 3-0 with the condition that Director Davis provide the requested memo before the full board hearing. - Items 5 & 6 – $390 million Healthy, Safe, and Vibrant San Francisco general obligation bond: The ordinance calls a special election for November 5, 2024, and the resolution makes the public interest finding. Brian Strong (Office of Resilience and Capital Planning), Jenny Lewey (DPH), and Bruce Robertson (DPW) presented the allocation: $205 million for public health (including the Chinatown Public Health Center, City Clinic relocation, critical repairs at Zuckerberg San Francisco General and Laguna Honda hospitals, and seismic retrofits); $50 million for adult and emergency shelters; roughly $64 million for street safety and Vision Zero projects; and $71 million for Harvey Milk Plaza, downtown improvements, and recreation space modernization. Board President Peskin offered amendments that were incorporated, shifting $5 million from downtown public realm and $5 million from streets/road portions to public health. The committee also discussed the Silver Avenue neighborhood clinic, whose estimated cost rose from roughly $35 million to about $80 million, and a long-planned child care facility at Zuckerberg SF General; Chair Chan requested a letter from the Mayor's Office or Department of Early Childhood committing $10 million to that child care facility. BLA reported that the $390 million bonds are estimated to cost $737 million with interest over 20 years and noted that the capital plan has not been formally amended. The committee voted 3-0 to amend the ordinance and continue both items to the July 10, 2024 Budget and Finance Committee meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1: Rudy Gonzalez of the San Francisco Building Construction Trades Council voiced full support, citing local hire, apprenticeships, and strong project labor partners. - Item 2: One speaker urged that the library bookstore include all books and not continue 'miseducating' people. - Item 3: No public commenters spoke. - Item 4: Reverend Amos Brown (Third Baptist Church / San Francisco NAACP), Pierce E. Bastiani, and Dr. Joseph Bryant Jr. (senior pastor of Calvary Hill) spoke in support, emphasizing year-round programs, community benefit, and the church's track record of hosting community services. - Items 5 & 6: Brian Springfield of Friends of Harvey Milk Plaza spoke in support, noting community consensus and ADA/transit improvements. Another speaker supported the bond for public health, street safety, and union construction jobs. One member of the public criticized the board, saying it was 'increasing the length of the suffering of your children.' Key Outcomes - All four lease/property items (Items 1-4) were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations by unanimous 3-0 votes. - Items 5 and 6 were amended to shift $10 million from street/downtown allocations to public health, then continued to July 10, 2024, by a 3-0 vote. - The committee directed that HRC provide a written memo with operational details for the 141 Industrial Street lease before the full board hearing. - The committee asked for a written commitment of $10 million from the Mayor's Office or Department of Early Childhood for the Zuckerberg SF General child care facility.

PUBLIC HEALTH 22% · PROPERTY LEASE 14% · CAPITAL PLANNING 13% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12%
673
JUN 27, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Special Meeting: Charter Amendments on Inspector General, DPA Director, and Emergency Management (June 27, 2024)

The Rules Committee held a special meeting on June 27, 2024, at 6:15 PM (UTC) to consider three charter amendments for the November 5, 2024 ballot. All three items were introduced, discussed, and unanimously continued to the call of the chair for further negotiations with the Municipal Executives Association (MEA). Public Comments & Testimony - Barbara Athard (second-generation San Franciscan, former OCC director, past president of NACOL) expressed support for the Inspector General proposal, emphasizing the importance of learning from best practices in other cities. However, she opposed the proposal to elect the Director of the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), arguing that making the position elected would politicize it and deter qualified national experts from applying. She suggested instead having the Controller’s office assist in the appointment. Discussion Items - Item 1: Charter Amendment – Inspector General in Controller’s Office (Sponsor: President Aaron Peskin) - President Peskin presented the proposal to establish an Inspector General (IG) within the Controller’s Office to investigate fraud, waste, abuse, and misconduct. Key features: IG nominated by the Controller, subject to approval by the Mayor and Board of Supervisors; expanded subpoena power over contractors, lobbyists, and permit-seekers; authority to execute search warrants; dual reporting to the Board and Mayor; and a duty for city employees to cooperate. The IG would be funded by an existing set-aside, incurring no additional cost. Peskin addressed concerns from the Ethics Commission, arguing that a requested carve-out would weaken existing controller authority and that overlapping jurisdiction with other agencies is standard practice. Supervisor Safai and Chair Ronan voiced strong support, noting the need to restore public trust after recent corruption scandals. Supervisor Walton requested a clarification that the Sheriff’s Office Inspector General be renamed to avoid confusion, which was included. The item was continued for MEA meet-and-confer. - Item 2: Charter Amendment – Electing the Director of the Department of Police Accountability (Sponsor: Vice Chair Shamann Walton) - Supervisor Walton argued that electing the DPA Director would ensure independence from the Mayor’s office and the Board of Supervisors, building trust between law enforcement and the community. He cited past incidents of police misconduct and the need for proactive, impartial oversight. Co-sponsors Safai, Ronan, and Preston supported the measure, emphasizing that an elected director would not be beholden to the appointing authority and could act more objectively. Public comment raised concerns about politicization, but the committee continued the item to allow further talks with MEA. - Item 3: Charter Amendment – Establishing the Department of Emergency Management in the Charter (Sponsor: Supervisor Ahsha Safai) - Supervisor Safai presented the proposal to enshrine the Department of Emergency Management (DEM) in the charter, including qualifications for the director. He noted that prior leadership lacked required qualifications, but current director Mary Ellen Carroll has done well. The item was continued to the call of the chair for further discussion. Key Outcomes - All three charter amendments were continued to the call of the chair by unanimous roll-call votes (Walton, Safai, Ronan all voting aye) pending completion of meet-and-confer sessions with the Municipal Executives Association (MEA). - The meeting adjourned without any other business.

CHARTER AMENDMENTS 48% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 18% · PUBLIC INTEGRITY 14% · PROCEDURAL 12%
674
JUN 26, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Recessed Meeting - June 26, 2024

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, convened on June 26, 2024, at 6:15 PM (after a morning session that recessed at 2:00 PM and resumed at approximately 4:15 PM). The committee finalized the city's two-year budget for FYs 2024-2025 and 2025-2026, addressing a projected $1 billion deficit. Key actions included accepting most Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommendations, approving several leases and grants, and forwarding the budget ordinances to the full Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - Committee voted to accept all outstanding BLA recommendations except for: Department of Early Childhood – facilities grant (Rec 1); Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing – transgender subsidies (Rec 1); Public Defender – clean slate program (Recs 3, 4, and 5). Human Rights Commission (HRC) and Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) items were held for further discussion. - Seven million three hundred ninety-nine thousand ninety-nine dollars and four cents ($7,399,099.04) in general fund savings and ten million eight hundred sixty-nine thousand nine hundred fifty-five dollars ($10,869,955) in non-general fund savings from various departments were accepted. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Potrero Power Station Assignment): Rudy Gonzalez (San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council) expressed full support, noting the project includes skilled union labor and local hire. Two other speakers also supported the development. - Item 4 (141 Industrial Street Lease): Reverend Amos Brown (Third Baptist Church) and Dr. Joseph Bryant Jr. (Calvary Hill Community Church) spoke in strong support, emphasizing the need for community space for youth and families. A representative from Alpha Phi Alpha Fraternity also voiced support. Discussion Items - Department Budget Deliberations: Chair Chan proposed rejecting several BLA recommendations. After discussion, Vice Chair Mandelman raised concerns about HRC's org chart changes; Supervisor Walton echoed the need for caution on structural spending. Committee recessed to negotiate and later accepted the BLA recommendations for most departments but held HRC and OEWD for further discussion. - Item 12 – Park Code Amendment (Tennis/Pickleball Court Fees): The item would authorize Rec and Park to charge fees for court reservations, estimated to generate $475,000 annually. After debate, the committee agreed to table the item pending understanding of its fiscal impact on the overall budget. - Item 13 – Assessment Appeals Fee Revenue ($400,000): The controller confirmed agreement; committee forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 1 – Potrero Power Station Development (UCSF Assignment): OEWD explained a minor modification to indemnity provisions to accommodate UCSF's state entity status. Committee forwarded with positive recommendation. - Item 2 – Library Lease (Friends and Foundation): Lease of 387 sq ft at main library for $15,555 annual rent, abated to $1 upon meeting $90,000 fundraising goal. Committee forwarded after requesting additional details on operations. - Item 3 – City Hall Cafe Lease (Cafe Melange): Retroactive lease for 1,400 sq ft cafe at City Hall, rent at 10% of gross sales ($200/month minimum). Committee approved with positive recommendation. - Item 4 – 141 Industrial Street Lease (HRC Community Facility): Lease of 13,000 sq ft at $351,000/year for three years. BLA noted unclear usage; Director Davis described plans for summer youth programming and year-round community events. Committee forwarded with requirement for a written memo detailing operations before full board. - Items 5 & 6 – $390 Million General Obligation Bond (Healthy, Safe, and Vibrant San Francisco): The bond includes $205M for public health (Chinatown Health Center, City Clinic, ZSFG/Laguna Honda repairs), $50M for shelters, $71M for street safety and public spaces (including Harvey Milk Plaza). President Peskin proposed amendments reallocating $10M from downtown public realm and $5M from road improvements to public health. Chair Chan expressed concerns about Silver Avenue Clinic's exclusion due to cost escalation from $35M to $80M. Committee amended and continued to July 10 meeting. - Final Budget Vote: After technical adjustments (including $9.8M from BLA and restoration of some cuts), Chair Chan moved approval of the budget and salary ordinances (items 3 and 4) to full board. She gave closing remarks noting the budget avoids immediate crisis but does not resolve structural deficits. The motion passed 4-0 (Peskin absent). Key Outcomes - Approved (forwarded to full board): Item 1 (Potrero Station), Item 2 (Library lease), Item 3 (City Hall cafe), Item 4 (141 Industrial lease with memo), Item 13 ($400,000 assessment appeals fee). - Tabled: Item 12 (court reservation fees). - Continued to July 10, 2024: Items 5 and 6 ($390M bond) as amended. - Final Budget Action: The committee voted 4-0 to forward the Annual Appropriation Ordinance (item 3) and Annual Salary Ordinance (item 4) to the full Board of Supervisors for the July 9 meeting. The motion also heard and filed item 2 (budget hearing). - Rejected BLA recommendations: Early childhood facilities grant, homelessness transgender subsidies, public defender clean slate program, and (initially) HRC and OEWD items (later held). - Technical adjustments: The mayor's office will make adjustments including $9.8M appropriation for the spending plan, restoration of funding for community flea market, MTA rebalancing, and legal vending enforcement positions.

PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · ASIAN AMERICAN HISTORY 10% · PROCEDURAL 9% · AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY 8%
675
JUN 25, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – June 25, 2024

The Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on June 25, 2024, starting at 10:15 a.m. The meeting included a consent calendar, unfinished business (interim budget), new business (various ordinances and resolutions), special orders (commendations and a state-required Beilenson hearing on medical service reductions), roll call introductions, general public comment, and adoption of items without committee reference. Consent Calendar - Items 1-7 were approved as routine, except Item 5 (vending requirements) which was severed by Supervisor Safai. He introduced a non-substantive amendment to restore language urging vendors to remove items, which was accepted. The ordinance then passed on first reading as amended. - The remaining consent items (1-4, 6, 7) passed unanimously. Commendations (Special Order 2:30 p.m.) - Supervisor Stephanie honored Ava Bauer Farbersh, retiring chief district engineer of the Golden Gate Bridge Highway and Transportation District, for her leadership on seismic retrofit, movable median barrier, and suicide deterrent net. - Supervisor Peskin honored Todd Reedstrom, Deputy Controller, for 25 years of service, including work on rainy day reserves, Healthy San Francisco, and COVID-19 response. An imperative resolution declared July 1, 2024 as Deputy Controller Todd Reedstrom Day. - Supervisor Dorsey honored Doreen Horsman, branch manager at SF Public Library, for creating the Read to Recovery program, which provides free recovery literature. The program was expanded to all 27 library branches via legislation passed on first reading. - Supervisor Mandelman honored Friends of Harvey Milk Plaza for their advocacy to transform the plaza, noting $25 million in the proposed Healthy, Safe, and Vibrant SF bond for construction. - Supervisor Walton honored Dr. Temetrius Rice Mitchell, retiring educator with 37 years in SFUSD, for her service in Bayview Hunters Point and leadership in educational equity. Beilenson Hearing – Reduction of Medical Services (Special Order 3:00 p.m.) - Presentation: Dr. Grant Colfax (DPH Director) and Jenny Lewey (COO) outlined proposed cuts to meet budget targets: a 5% reduction ($10M) in community-based organization (CBO) contracts in FY2025-26, affecting behavioral health ($7.3M), population health ($1.5M), and ambulatory services ($1.1M). Also, a $2.7M shift of sugary drink tax (SDDT) funds to HSA for food security, eliminating oral health task forces ($450,000) and cutting healthy community grants. Street Violence Intervention Program (SVIP) faced a $2.5M reduction, with $2.1M shifted to DCYF for school-based crisis intervention. - Supervisor Questions & Concerns: - Supervisor Preston asked how cuts were determined; no public process. He noted the SDDT shift cuts policy advocacy, not just food distribution. - Supervisor Safai questioned the timing and lack of community engagement, especially on behavioral health cuts during the overdose crisis. - Supervisor Walton criticized the lack of planning for outreach services and the impact on Southeast neighborhoods. - Supervisor Chan (Budget Chair) emphasized these are year-two cuts and will be revisited in January 2025. - Public Comment: Over 30 speakers opposed the cuts, representing CBOs providing health education, oral health, food access, youth services, Pacific Islander health, violence prevention, and behavioral health. Many urged restoration of SDDT funds and criticized the lack of transparency. Speakers from Glide, SOMCAN, Horizons Unlimited, TNDC, and others testified to the impact on vulnerable communities. Discussion Items - Deforestation of Police Department and Sheriff’s Department (Item 10): Ordinance passed to transfer $6.87M for overtime in police and sheriff departments. - Polk Street Legacy Business Exception (Item 12): Known as “Bob’s Donuts Notice Act,” passed to allow storefront mergers for legacy restaurants. - Landmark Tree Designation (Item 13): Designated a coast redwood at 4 Montclair Terrace as a landmark tree. - Commemorative Street Name – Dr. Howard Thurman Way (Item 14): Adopted. - Liquor Licenses (Items 15-18): Four resolutions approved for Embarc Wines, Great Star Theater, Zevi Cafe and Bistro, and August Hall. - Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District Report (Item 19): Adopted. - Library Read to Recovery Program (Item 20): Passed on first reading. - Repeal of Deemed Approved Off-Sale Alcohol Nuisance Ordinance (Item 21): Passed after Supervisor Stephanie explained it relieves small businesses of duplicative fees. - Airport Surveillance Policy (Item 22): Passed. - Appointments/Reappointments (Items 23-27): Approved for Building Inspection, Port Commission, Planning Commission, Public Works Commission (Lauren Post, Gerald Turner, Fady Zoubi). - Settlement of Unlitigated Claims (Item 29): Approved to receive $441,521 from U.S. HHS. - Budget & Appropriation Items (Items 8-9): Interim budget and salary ordinances for FY2024-26 passed on final reading. - Justice for Renters Act Resolution (Item 32): Continued to July 2, 2024 at Supervisor Preston’s request. - Reparations Proposals Resolution (Item 33): Amended (removing stray 'd') and adopted. - Final Map No. 11099 (Item 34): Approved. - Imperative Resolution – Todd Reedstrom Day: Adopted. - Roll Call Introductions: - Supervisor Mandelman introduced ordinance to landmark Gilbert Baker’s Rainbow Flag at Harvey Milk Plaza. - Supervisor Peskin introduced "Workforce Housing and Affordable Middle-Income Financing Package" (WHAMMY) to issue project revenue bonds for middle-income housing, and a special use district for 100% affordable housing in Chinatown. - Supervisor Preston reported that the Market Match program was fully restored in the state budget through 2027, and introduced a follow-up letter of inquiry on SFPD’s plans to acquire police robot dogs and other military equipment. - Supervisor Safai introduced a plan to reduce transfer tax for rental housing built with union pension funds and requiring 12% on-site affordable units. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Items 1-4, 6-7 passed; Item 5 passed as amended. - Beilenson Hearing: Filed; the board will consider the budget with potential restorations. - Budget Motion: Budget Chair Chan announced a motion to restore several programs with one-time funding, including SDDT programs, community ambassadors, workforce development, emergency rental assistance, DCYF programs, and SRO outreach. The motion will be considered in Budget Committee on June 26. - Votes: All actions above were unanimous unless noted. Item 32 was continued to July 2. Item 33 passed as amended 10-0 (Safai absent). Item 34 passed 10-0. - Adjournment: In memory of Martin Labaugh (Supervisor Melgar), Narcy David (Supervisor Peskin), and Roseanne Harris (Supervisor Safai).

PUBLIC HEALTH 31% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 19% · BEHAVIORAL HEALTH 7% · PUBLIC COMMENT 6%
676
JUN 25, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting Summary — June 25, 2024

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on June 25, 2024, beginning at 9:30 AM. The meeting included recognition of a retiring employee, quarterly budget and capital project updates, a racial equity progress report, approval of multiple leases, contracts, and financing agreements, as well as the appointment of a new Commission Secretary. All votes were unanimous (3–0) with three commissioners present. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the May 14, 2024, May 28, 2024, and June 11, 2024, meetings. - Consent Calendar Items: A total of 11 consent calendar items (A–K) were approved without discussion or public comment. These most likely included routine contract awards, lease approvals, and other routine actions typically bundled as consent items. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: - A community member from the Bayview expressed frustration over stalled funding and underutilization of the Assistance Center, noting that the controller’s office had received presentations from community members. The speaker warned that if no action is taken, the community may take “holistic action.” - Ian Vogen commented on the Ocean Beach Master Plan, stating that it focused only on wave action and ignored sediment transport, and that managed retreat would be expensive and ineffective. He also raised concerns about Stonestown not having on-site dedicated water piping and instead paying for connections, despite nearby hookup possibilities. - Peter Dreckmeyer (policy director for a 12-year-old retract) encouraged the commission to direct staff to produce a memo on capital investment risks highlighted in the long-term vulnerability assessment, citing a quote from that assessment about trade-offs between reliability and price. - A third remote caller raised a fiscal sustainability concern, stating that the SFPUC has a $6.7 billion deficit in reserves, meaning the agency lacks enough money to replenish assets without borrowing, which adds about 75% to asset costs. He urged an audit or review of the agency’s financial condition. - Public Comment on Specific Agenda Items: No public comments were received on any of the regular calendar items (items 5B, 5C, 5D, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19). Discussion Items - Recognition of Retiree: The General Manager honored Ray Jackson, a plumber who retired after 25 years of service. Supervisors and colleagues praised his dedication, humor, and mentorship. Commissioners expressed gratitude and presented a resolution. - Quarterly Budget Status Report (Item 5B): Deputy CFO Laura Bush reported that for Q3 of FY2023-24, the wastewater, power, and CleanPowerSF enterprises are projecting positive operating results, but water faces a shortfall. Key drivers: removal of the drought surcharge (rescinded May 2023) caused revenue shortfalls for water and wastewater, partially offset by state grant funding ($8.1M for water, $11.6M for wastewater for arrearages/discounts). Water also had $9.8M in legal settlements. Power revenues were above budget due to higher wholesale sales and generation. Financial ratios remain on target. - Wastewater Enterprise Quarterly Report (Item 5C): Bessie Taylor presented updates on the wastewater capital program. Major projects: the Biosolids Digester Facilities project is 51.1% complete; the Headworks Facility project is 86.3% complete. The SSIP Phase 1 overall completion is 67.6%. No budget variances were noted from the last quarter. Staff reported that delays from resource constraints are being addressed through procurement of additional consultant resources and changing delivery methods. - Racial Equity Progress Report (Item 5D): Dr. Chris Bijou provided an update on the agency’s racial equity efforts. Agency demographics: 32% Asian, 8.6% Black, 13% Hispanic/Latino, 2.1% multiracial, 44.2.7% white, 0.6% Indigenous. A 2023 racial equity survey found retention and promotion as the top concern, followed by hiring and recruiting. Staff launched a 42-match pilot mentorship program, relaunched professional development for managers (focused on managing diverse teams), and developed a career pathways tool. Monthly professional development sessions are also being expanded agency-wide. Commissioners praised the work and noted the importance of retention. - Lease Approvals (Items 8 & 9): - Item 8: A three-year lease (with two-year option) for 38,013 sq. ft. at 3801 Third St. (Bayview Plaza) for the Wastewater Enterprise’s collection system division. Base rent: $32,220/month with 3% annual increases. Staff noted limited available space in the Bayview. - Item 9: A five-year lease (with two-year option) for 27,000 sq. ft. warehouse, 6,000 sq. ft. office, and 13,000 sq. ft. outdoor yard at 1900 Oakdale Ave. for plumbers, laborers, and engineers. Rent: $58,893.50/month, flat for five years. Staff compared 12 other properties and found this one uniquely suited. - Contract Awards (Items 10, 11, 12): - Item 10: As-Needed Main Sewer Replacement No. 10 awarded to Mitchell Engineering for $16,028,745 (730-day duration). Three bids received, all above estimate; staff attributed to risk of unknown work locations. - Item 11: Geary Boulevard Sewer and Water Improvements Phase 2 awarded to Cratus Inc. for $45,957,003 (1,034-day duration). Six bids received; low bid was below engineer’s estimate. Project coordinates with the Geary BRT project. - Item 12: Amendment No. 2 to the Lower Alemany Area Stormwater Improvement Project engineering contract with McMillen Jacobs Associates, increasing the contract by $8.3M to $17.8M and extending duration by three years (total 9 years). The increase is driven by complex modeling and encroachment permit requirements from Caltrans (crossing under freeways, bridge structure modeling, etc.) and design of a temporary bypass road. Commissioner Stacy expressed concern about the cost increase; staff explained that requirements became apparent during detailed design. - Commercial Equipment Rebate Program (Item 13): Julie Ortiz presented a public hearing to approve a Commercial Equipment Rebate Program effective July 1, 2024, to promote water conservation. The program offers two types of rebates: metered (up to $7 per 748 gallons saved over 10 years, max $750,000/ project) and estimated savings (lower rates). Minimum annual water savings lowered from 150,000 to 75,000 gallons. Total estimated water savings from nine past projects is 243 million gallons. Commissioners endorsed the program. - Interim Financing Programs (Items 14 & 15): Director of Capital Finance Nikolai Sklarov presented the renewal of credit facility agreements for the Wastewater Enterprise ($275M total) and Water Enterprise ($200M total). These short-term facilities (commercial paper and revolving credit) allow the SFPUC to borrow for construction before issuing long-term bonds. The replacements were selected through an RFP process; fees increased slightly. Unanimously approved. - Bond Issuance (Item 16): Authorize up to $1.305 billion in bonds. This includes: - Series A: Up to $480M taxable (short-term) for the Biosolids Digester project to preserve eligibility for IRA tax credits. - Series B: Up to $125M taxable (short-term) for the Southeast Community Center. - Series C & D: Up to $700M tax-exempt to refinance commercial paper and fund new construction (green bonds). Estimated interest cost as of pricing date (July 17-18) is 4.3% overall. Commissioner Stacy noted the importance of taxable bonds for flexibility and green bonds. Unanimously approved. - Utility User Tax Refund (Item 17): CFO Nancy Hom presented a request to authorize the General Manager to seek Board of Supervisors approval to refund $754,141 in overpaid utility user taxes to three customers: Oliver de Silva ($101,825), Sunol Ag Park ($340), and Alameda County ($651,976). The overpayment resulted from charging the wrong tax rate (7.5% instead of 6.5%) and improperly remitting to San Francisco instead of Alameda County. The City Attorney is still negotiating with Alameda County. Unanimously approved. - Delay of Discount Consolidation (Item 18): Rates Manager Matthew Freiburg presented a request to delay the implementation of the discount consolidation for Hetch Hetchy Power customers on rate schedules A1 UP and A10 US from July 1, 2024, to January 20, 2025. This impacts 21 accounts managed by nonprofits serving low-income housing, which would have experienced 26.5% to 50% bill increases (approximately $8,000 to $27,000/year). The six-month delay will soften the impact and cost the agency an estimated $88,000 in lost revenue, which has no significant financial effect. Unanimously approved. - Appointment of Commission Secretary (Item 19): President Paulson announced the selection of Tiffany Lenair as the new Commission Secretary, replacing retiring Secretary Donna Hood (effective June 28, 2024). The motion also authorized the General Manager to assign temporary staff to cover duties during the transition period. Commissioner Rivera thanked interim secretary Cerrillo Espinoza for his service. Unanimously approved. Key Outcomes - Approved Minutes: May 14, May 28, and June 11, 2024 (3-0). - Consent Calendar: Unanimously approved (3-0). - Leases: Items 8 and 9 approved (3-0). - Contracts: Items 10 ($16.0M), 11 ($45.9M), and 12 ($17.8M amendment) approved (3-0). - Commercial Rebate Program (Item 13): Approved (3-0). - Credit Facilities (Items 14 & 15): Approved (3-0). - Bond Issuance (Item 16): Authorized up to $1.305B (3-0). - Utility Tax Refund (Item 17): Approved (3-0). - Delay of Discount Consolidation (Item 18): Approved (3-0). - Appointment of Commission Secretary (Item 19): Approved, appointing Tiffany Lenair (3-0).

FINANCE AND DEBT 20% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · INFRASTRUCTURE 14% · PROCEDURAL 8%
677
JUN 24, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Recessed Meeting - June 24, 2024

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, held a recessed meeting on June 24, 2024, to hear public comment on the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2024-2025 and 2025-2026. After two weeks of departmental presentations, the committee dedicated this session to hearing from residents. The meeting lasted over six hours, with hundreds of speakers addressing a wide range of community needs and budget priorities. The committee took no final action and recessed to June 26, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - Homelessness & Housing: Many speakers urged restoring funding for family flexible subsidies ($3.3 million requested) and transitional-age youth subsidies ($1.8 million). Several advocated for safe parking sites for vehicular homelessness, noting a 37% increase. Speakers from the Tenderloin Urban Rest and Sleep Center requested $350,000 restored after mid-year cuts. Providers highlighted a doubling of family homelessness and called for longer-term rental subsidies. - Youth Programs: Dozens of youth and organizers from groups like Chinese Progressive Association, Hunters Point Family, Coleman Advocates, and Horizons Unlimited opposed cuts to DCYF-funded after-school, leadership, and mental health programs. Speakers noted over 2,500 program slots at risk in District 11 and over 3,600 in District 10. Several youth described how programs prevented homelessness and provided safe spaces. - Workers' Rights & Immigrant Services: Representatives from the Workers' Rights Community Collaborative (WRCC) opposed a 50% funding cut, citing success in recovering nearly $2 million in wages and reaching 23,000 workers. Immigrant legal defense collaborative (SFILDC) requested $2.5 million to increase capacity, noting 900 people on waiting lists. The Immigrant Parent Voting Collaborative requested $500,000 for outreach. - SRO Tenants & Code Enforcement: Residents of single-room occupancy hotels described unsafe conditions (leaks, pests, broken facilities) and credited SRO collaborative organizers for helping enforce repairs. They urged restoration of code enforcement outreach funding ($5.2 million) and SRO collaborative budgets. - Arts, Culture & Community Gardens: Organizations like Chinese Culture Center, Galería de la Raza, Marigold Project, Sisterhood Gardens, and Hummingbird Farm opposed cuts, arguing arts and green spaces are essential for community health and economic revitalization. - Public Defender & Policing: Several speakers called for equitable funding for the Public Defender's Office, noting it receives less than 60% of the DA's budget and under 7% of the police budget. They opposed a $100 million increase for police, advocating instead for community-based safety programs. - Health & Substance Use: Horizons Unlimited highlighted a $1.5 million loss in DPH contracts for youth substance use treatment, affecting 600 adolescents. Others urged continued funding for Soda Tax programs supporting nutrition and chronic disease prevention. - Pacific Islander & Latinx Communities: Speakers from Samoan Community Development Center, All My Usos, and others requested restoration of DPH Healthy Communities grants and DCYF funding, noting high rates of poverty and chronic disease. Latinx organizations asked to restore $9 million in cuts across multiple departments. - City College & Free City: Students and faculty opposed proposed cuts to Free City College funding, warning that reduced access would harm low-income and immigrant students. They noted over 78,000 residents have benefited since 2017. - Other: Comments also addressed senior services, early childhood education, domestic violence services, trans housing subsidies, and the Community Ambassadors program. Many speakers urged the committee to cut ineffective programs and police spending to fund community needs. Key Outcomes - The committee took no votes on the budget items presented (Items 2-4, 12-13, 16-17) and left them undecided. - The meeting was recessed to Wednesday, June 26, 2024, at 10:00 a.m. - A motion to recess passed 4-0 (Supervisor Peskin absent).

PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · PUBLIC EDUCATION 12% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 11% · HOMELESSNESS 9%
678
JUN 21, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - June 21, 2024

The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Friday, June 21, 2024, to continue hearings on the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2024-2025 and 2025-2026. The meeting covered department budgets, trailing legislation, and proposed reserve motions. Committee members included Chair Connie Chan, Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman, Supervisor Mirna Melgar, Supervisor Shamann Walton, and President Aaron Peskin. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was considered today. Items acted on at the June 20 meeting (items 5-11 and 14) were referred out and not reconsidered. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comment on item 15 (Public Works fee modifications): No speakers appeared. Public comment was closed. - General public comment on department budgets was deferred to Monday, June 24, 2024. Discussion Items - Board of Supervisors Budget Adjustments: The committee approved a motion to increase the Board of Supervisors department budget by $74,000 to restore the legislative expense account, include professional community facilitation services, reclassify attrition savings, provide a 4% COLA to the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA), and note LAFCO statutory funding. The motion passed 5-0. - Mayor's Office Budget: The committee debated a BLA recommendation to delete a vacant mayoral staff position (saving $149,388). The Mayor's office argued the position supports public safety coordination, not solely victim services. The committee rejected the BLA recommendation, allowing the position to remain. - Ethics Commission Budget: The committee rejected BLA recommendations 1 and 2 (upward substitutions for auditor positions) to allow reclassification of policy analysts to official auditor classifications, but accepted the remaining recommendations to deny other upward substitutions. Discussion emphasized the need for effective audits without adding to the structural deficit. - Public Works Fee Ordinance (Item 15): The committee heard a presentation on proposed fee increases for permits (averaging 10% CPI adjustments). No public comment. The item was forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation (5-0). - Public Defender Budget: The BLA recommended reductions totaling $37,217 and policy recommendations to reject transferring three grant-funded positions (Clean Slate program) to the general fund ($370,195 ongoing). The Public Defender argued these positions are critical for expungements, language access, and reentry services. The committee deferred a decision, adding it to a "giant bucket" of unresolved items. - Sheriff's Department Budget: The BLA recommended reducing funding for the jail management system ($130,389) and one prisoner transport bus ($350,000). The Sheriff's office emphasized safety and operational needs. The committee accepted the jail management reduction but deferred the bus funding to the unresolved bucket. Chair Chan requested quarterly overtime reports similar to the police department. - Trailing Legislation: Item 12 (court reservation fees) was continued to the call of the chair due to ongoing negotiations. The committee aims to resolve by June 26. - Technical Adjustments: The Mayor's Budget Office announced a second round of technical adjustments, including appropriating $50 million annually of Prop J parcel tax for the school district, adjusting MTA's budget, and removing a work order between the city attorney and Board of Supervisors. Key Outcomes - Board of Supervisors budget increase approved (5-0). - Mayor's office position deletion rejected (5-0). - Ethics Commission upward substitutions partially approved (rejected BLA recs 1&2). - Public Works fee ordinance forwarded to full board (5-0). - Public Defender and Sheriff's bus funding deferred to unresolved items. - Sheriff's jail management system reduction accepted; quarterly overtime reporting required. - Item 12 (court reservation fees) continued to call of chair. - Chair Chan proposed three motions for reserves to be considered on June 26: 1. Appropriate savings from BLA reductions into a reserve fund with a public hearing in July. 2. Place 10% of elected officials and department head salaries on reserve, releasable by budget chair request. 3. Place growth in overtime ($32.9 million) and non-personnel services ($24 million) on reserve, releasable after the five-year financial plan and board vote in January 2025. - Meeting recessed to Monday, June 24, 2024, at 10 a.m.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 46% · PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES 12% · SHERIFF'S OFFICE 11% · ETHICS COMMISSION 9%
679
JUN 20, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - June 20, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, June 20, 2024, at 20:15 UTC. The meeting covered continuances, a consent calendar, commission matters, department updates, general public comment, and four regular calendar items: the Office Development Annual Limit Program update, major modifications for the Potrero Power Station Block 2, a conditional use authorization and variance for 88 Spear Street, and a conditional use authorization to remove an unauthorized dwelling unit at 21 Flood Avenue. All votes were unanimous (6-0). Consent Calendar - Commissioners approved items 5, 6, and 7 on the consent calendar (2001 Van Ness Avenue conditional use authorization, awning amnesty program code amendments, and 1948 Sutter Street conditional use authorization) in a single 6-0 roll call vote without discussion. - Items 1a/b (1153 Guerrero Street), 2 (320-322 Frederick Street), 3 (58 Buena Vista Terrace), and 4a/b (305 Liberty Street) were continued to July 11, 2024, or indefinitely, approved 6-0. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: One speaker raised questions about demolition calculations under Section 317, citing concerns about the Bernal Heights SUD and the need for written interpretations. The speaker urged the commission to assert legislative authority. - Item 13 (Office Development Annual Limit): A remote caller urged the commission to schedule a public hearing on the inventory of conversions/demolitions, even though the commission has no formal role. - Item 14 (Potrero Power Station): Nine letters of support were received from community groups (Dogpatch Neighborhood Association, Potrero Boosters, YMCA) and individuals. Public speakers expressed strong support for the pocket park, UCSF cancer center, and community outreach. No opposition letters or comments were recorded. - Item 15 (88 Spear Street): A representative from the East Cut Community Benefit District spoke in favor, citing the need for ground-floor activation, cafe space, and the rooftop restaurant. One public commenter suggested considering childcare space. - Item 16 (21 Flood Avenue): No public comments were made. Discussion Items - Item 13 – Office Development Annual Limit Program Update: Zoning Administrator Corey Teague presented an informational update on Proposition C (passed March 2024), which allows adding square footage back to the large cap from conversions/demolitions of 10,000+ sq ft of office space since 1986. Staff will publish a draft inventory by mid-July, accept public comment, and finalize by August 30, 2024. Commissioners requested a future informational hearing on the results and asked about the relationship with Proposition E’s affordable housing requirements. Commissioner Imperial and others supported transparency. - Item 14 – Potrero Power Station Block 2 Major Modifications: The project sponsor (Enrique Landa) and UCSF presented plans for a seven-story building housing a proton therapy cancer center, clinic, and lab incubator. Four major modifications to the Design for Development standards were requested: priority retail frontage, upper building setback, street wall, and parking/loading entrance standards. Staff recommended approval with a condition requiring planning department review of the pocket park design. Commissioner Imperial proposed that the final park design be brought back as an informational item. The project received unanimous support from commissioners citing creativity, community benefit, and job creation. Approved 6-0. - Item 15 – 88 Spear Street Conditional Use Authorization and Variance: The project proposes ground-floor office use, interior renovations, a one-story restaurant addition, and a 50-foot marquee (variance from 25-foot code limit). Project sponsor Presidio Bay Ventures explained the need to activate the building and attract tenants. Zoning Administrator Teague noted the marquee is twice code size but found the site conditions unique. Public comment was supportive. Commissioner Williams joked about restaurant affordability. Approved 6-0. - Item 16 – 21 Flood Avenue Conditional Use Authorization: Removal of a vacant unauthorized dwelling unit (UDU) at the first floor. Staff confirmed three UDUs existed; two in the basement had substandard ceiling height and did not require CU. A fire in 2020 led to code enforcement. Commissioner Williams stressed the importance of site visits to verify no occupancy. Staff affirmed this is departmental policy. Commissioner Imperial asked for more enforcement history details. Approved 6-0. Key Outcomes - All motions on items 1-4 (continuances), consent calendar (5-7), minutes (item 9), regular calendar items 14, 15, and 16 passed unanimously (6-0). - Item 13 was informational; no vote was taken. Commissioners requested a future hearing on the final inventory and public input. - Item 14 approval included a condition requiring planning staff review of the pocket park design before construction documents. - Item 15 approval included the marquee variance, granted by the zoning administrator. - Item 16 approval came with confirmation of a site visit prior to action, reinforcing departmental policy. - Commissioner Koppel announced his departure from the commission, thanking colleagues and emphasizing his commitment to labor and working-class residents.

PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · OFFICE ALLOCATION 14% · LAND USE 14% · PUBLIC WORKS 14%
680
JUN 20, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
SF Budget Committee Debates Fiscal Cliff, Child Care, and Downtown Priorities at June 20, 2024 Hearing

June 20, 2024 The Budget and Appropriations Committee (Chair Connie Chan, Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman, Members Myrna Melgar and Shamann Walton, with President Aaron Peskin absent) held a special meeting on June 20, 2024, to continue scrutinizing the Mayor's proposed FY 2024-2025 and 2025-2026 budget. Chair Chan warned of a "fiscal cliff" in January 2025 if spending was not matched to flat revenue growth, emphasizing that every dollar counts for child care, food access, and senior services. The committee debated major departmental budgets, fee proposals, and policy recommendations from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA), voting on several items while leaving key budget ordinances and contentious decisions pending. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (SFPUC Grant): Accepted and forwarded $23,368,920.23 in federal ARPA funds to assist eligible residential and commercial customers with water and wastewater arrears accrued during the COVID-19 pandemic. Forwarded to the July 2, 2024 full Board meeting. - Items 8 & 9 (City Administrator Fees): Forwarded ordinances to increase County Clerk fees for civil marriage ceremonies by $5 and raise annual entertainment license renewal fees by 15% for brick-and-mortar businesses, with future adjustments tied to CPI. - Items 10 & 11 (Rec and Park): Forwarded a resolution accepting a $2,000,000 USDA Forest Service grant for reforestation and workforce development in Southeast San Francisco parks, and an ordinance imposing a $5 fee on recreation program registrations to support the department's scholarship fund. - Item 14 (BLA Services COLA): Approved a 4% cost-of-living adjustment for the Budget and Legislative Analyst contract, resulting in an annual increase of approximately $125,000. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 5 (Baby Prop C): Dozens of childcare providers, parents, and advocates (including Alan Wong, Mary Evelyn Thomas, Catherine McFarlane, and representatives from the Low Income Investment Fund and Parent Voices SF) urged the committee to protect the Baby Prop C fund for its voter-approved purpose of expanding early care and education. Speakers implored the committee to limit any interest diversion to two years and set a minimum fund balance of $300 million, expressing fatigue over repeatedly defending the measure from budget raids. - Item 12 (Court Reservation Fees): A large number of tennis and pickleball players (Peter Mueller, Laura, Barbara, Lisa Shaw, etc.) overwhelmingly opposed the proposed $5/hour court reservation fee. They called it a money grab, argued it unfairly targeted seniors and families, and criticized the department's lack of community engagement. Many suggested the department should instead charge private schools and paid coaches who profit from public courts. Discussion Items - Early Care and Education (Item 5): The BLA recommended shifting general fund facility costs to the Public Education Enrichment Fund (PEF) and denying an upward substitution. The Department of Early Childhood (DEC) opposed both recommendations, arguing the PEF shift would deny care for 53 children and the position was needed to manage an expanding grant system. The committee (Chan, Melgar, Walton) rejected the BLA recommendations. Supervisor Melgar introduced successful amendments to the baseline ordinance, limiting the use of Baby Prop C interest to two fiscal years and setting the fund's minimum cash balance at $300 million. The amended ordinance was forwarded. - Department of Children, Youth and Their Families / Human Rights Commission (Items 6, 7): The BLA recommended over $13 million in combined cuts to community-based organization grants above the children's and transitional age youth baselines. Directors Maria Su (DCYF) and Sheryl Davis (HRC) argued the funds were already allocated to critical programs for youth, families, and equity initiatives. Chair Chan, Supervisor Melgar, and Supervisor Walton rejected the BLA policy recommendations to protect these services, though Chan held firm against upward substitutions citywide. The JCYC grant agreements totaling over $83 million were forwarded. - Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD): The deep divide centered on OEWD's $15 million proposal for the downtown core, including security patrols, free parking, activations, and permit center staff. Director Phillips defended it as vital for the experience economy and hospitality jobs. Chair Chan and Supervisor Walton strongly opposed several elements, contrasting the $1 million for Union Square activations and $2 million for Powell Street with cuts to community ambassadors in neighborhoods like Bayview and workforce programs. Supervisor Melgar was skeptical, noting the free parking was a non-starter. Vice Chair Mandelman supported the investment. The item was left undecided. - Human Services Agency (HSA) Move: A compromise was reached on funding for the move from 170 Otis Street. The BLA recommended $7.6 million in cuts in year one and $6.6 million in year two. Director Rhorer detailed the active moves to 1650 Mission and 1455 Market. The committee agreed to save $3.5 million instead of $5 million in Year 1 for planning, accepted the cut for canceled debt service (Rec 2), and rejected the Year 2 cut entirely to allow for future facility purchases. - Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) OASIS Hotel: A compromise was reached placing $2.3 million (instead of the BLA's recommended $4.6 million) on reserve for the Providence Foundation contract. The committee required a quarterly report on progress toward shoring up the operator or transitioning to a new one, ensuring no disruption to services for families. - Rec and Park Court Fees (Item 12): The BLA recommended denying two upward substitutions (a deputy director and a manager). The committee mostly supported the BLA on staffing. The primary policy fight was over the $5 court reservation fee. Supervisors Chan, Melgar, and Walton expressed openness to a fee but wanted a restructured system allowing free walk-up play and tiered charges for private entities and paid coaches. Deputy City Attorney Pearson clarified the board can only approve or reject the ordinance as written. The item was left undecided, with the department asked to work with the Mayor's office on an alternative model. Key Outcomes | Action | Items | Details | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Forwarded to Full Board | Items 1, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 14 | SFPUC grant, amended Baby Prop C ordinance, HRC and DCYF grant agreements, fee updates, Rec and Park grants/fees, BLA contract COLA. | | Compromises Reached | HSA, HSH | Agreed to $3.5M cut to HSA move funding (accepting planning details), rejected Year 2 cuts. Placed $2.3M on reserve for OASIS Hotel operator oversight. | | BLA Policy Recs Rejected | DCYF, HRC, OEWD (in part)| Committee rejected recommendations to cut CBO grants above baselines, preserving youth, workforce, and equity programs. | | Undecided / Pending | Items 2, 3, 4 (Main Budget), OEWD Downtown, Item 12 (Court Fees), Item 13, Items 15-17 | Final budget ordinances, downtown core investment, park court reservation fee structure, and remaining department budgets were left for the committee's final deliberations on June 24 and June 25. |

BUDGET AND FINANCE 17% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 15% · PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com