The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 15, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Vice Chair Dean Preston chaired the meeting, joined by Chair Mirna Melgar and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered four agenda items, all of which were voted unanimously to be sent to the full Board of Supervisors. No public comment was offered on any item. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were considered. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided testimony on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Street Encroachment Permit (240386): Resolution granting revocable permission to RP Pennsylvania LLC to maintain a public stair and scenic overlook on 22nd Street between Missouri and Texas streets, connecting the Dogpatch and Potrero neighborhoods. The project is privately funded, constructed, and managed. Lindsay Lopez Weaver (Supervisor Walton’s office) and Eric Lamb (DPW) presented the proposal. All necessary city agency referrals were approved. The committee unanimously recommended the item to the full board. - Item 2 – Interim Zoning Controls (240683): Resolution imposing interim zoning controls for 18 months in the Upper Market Street NCT and Castro Street NCD districts, requiring conditional use authorization for changes from health services or social services uses. President Aaron Peskin, the sponsor, explained the controls were prompted by the potential eviction of Queer Life Space, an LGBTQ mental health facility that has operated in the Castro for over a decade. The controls aim to protect LGBTQ healthcare services. The committee unanimously recommended the item as a committee report for the July 16, 2024 board meeting. - Items 3 & 4 – Stonestown Development Project (240409 and 240575): Two ordinances to establish the Stonestown Mixed Use District, Special Use District, Height and Bulk District, Special Sign District, and amend the General Plan accordingly. The project is bounded by Eucalyptus Drive, 19th Avenue, and Buckingham Way. These items were continued from the previous week. The committee unanimously recommended both items as committee reports for the July 16, 2024 board meeting. Key Outcomes - All four agenda items were passed by a 3-0 vote (Preston, Peskin, Melgar) with positive recommendations to the full Board of Supervisors. - Items 2, 3, and 4 were forwarded as committee reports for consideration at the Board of Supervisors meeting on July 16, 2024.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Vice Chair Joel Engardio and joined by Supervisor Dorsey (with Chair Stefani excused), met on July 11, 2024, to consider one ordinance regarding buprenorphine availability and three liquor license applications. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Discussion Items Item 1: Health Code Amendment – Requiring Retail Pharmacies to Stock Buprenorphine - Sponsored by Supervisor Dorsey and co-sponsored by Supervisors Mandelman, Ronan, Preston, and Peskin. Presented by Dr. Jeffrey Hom of the Department of Public Health. - Key context: In 2023, 810 San Franciscans died from unintentional overdoses, 80% involving fentanyl. Buprenorphine, a gold-standard medication for opioid use disorder, reduces mortality risk by up to 50%. - A 2023 study found only 47% of California pharmacies stocked buprenorphine; a 2024 DPH survey found just 44% of San Francisco retail pharmacies had it in stock on the day called. The proposed ordinance would require all retail pharmacies that dispense controlled substances to stock sufficient buprenorphine to fill existing prescriptions and at least two new prescriptions (24 mg/day for 7 days). A three-day grace period is allowed for restocking. Noncompliance would result in administrative penalties. - Discussion included barriers to prescribing, such as stigma among healthcare providers. No public comment was offered. - Motion to forward to the full board as a committee report with a positive recommendation passed 2–0 (Engardio and Dorsey aye; Stefani excused). The item is scheduled for the July 16 Board of Supervisors meeting. Item 2: Liquor License Issuance – 475 Haight Street (The Faight) - Application for a Type 90 on-sale general music venue license by Faight Collective, SFLC. SFPD reported one letter of protest (denied by ABC) and zero letters of support. The location is in a high crime and high concentration area; Northern Station had no opposition. - Conditions recommended: noise monitoring, active loitering prevention, litter maintenance, and two uniformed security guards during live entertainment. - No public comment was received. The committee voted 2–0 to forward the resolution with a positive finding of public convenience and necessity to the full board (scheduled for July 23 per standard timeline). Item 3: Liquor License Transfer – 3250 Mission Street (Evergreen Market) - Application for a Type 21 off-sale general license by Ayabs Community Market Corp. SFPD reported 55 letters of protest (described by the applicant as form letters from a competitor) and 19 letters of support, including from the Cali 824 Latino Culture District. The area is low crime but high concentration; Ingleside Station had no opposition. - The applicant stated the business will be a full-service market with imported alcohol, meat counter, and produce, not competing with nearby liquor stores. - No public comment was offered. The committee voted 2–0 to forward the resolution with a positive recommendation. Item 4: Liquor License Transfer – 340 Balboa Street (Tomorrow's Wine) - Application for a Type 20 off-sale beer and wine license (with instructional tasting) by Tofino Wines Inc. SFPD reported zero letters of protest or support. The location is low crime and low concentration; Richmond Station had no opposition. - The applicant, a longtime natural wine retailer, is relocating from Geary Masonic to Balboa Street. Conditions include litter control, loitering prevention, and signage during tastings. - No public comment was received. The committee voted 2–0 to forward the resolution with a positive finding. Key Outcomes - All four agenda items were approved by the committee (2–0) and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. - Item 1 will appear on the board’s July 16 agenda; items 2–4 are expected to appear on the July 23 agenda unless otherwise noted. - No public testimony was given on any item.
The Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronan, met in a special session on July 11, 2024, to consider two charter amendments aimed at improving accountability and transparency for children and youth funding, and a hearing on a proposed initiative ordinance to safeguard reproductive freedom. Supervisors Myrna Melgar and Ahsha Safai were present; Vice Chair Shamann Walton was excused. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1 & 2 (Charter Amendments): Leslie Who (Secretary, United Educators of San Francisco) expressed staunch support for clarifying that the Student Success Fund and Children’s Fund are separate, noting voters would not have wanted the latter shortchanged. Ephraim (Latino Task Force Education and Family Services Committee Chair) supported the language but wanted to ensure the Our Children, Our Families Council remains advisory without funding authority. Patricia Barraza (Latino Task Force volunteer, Beacon director) supported specific language to prevent misinterpretation and emphasized keeping families central. John Tresvenia (District 11 homeowner, public school product) supported the amendments, highlighted a controller’s office estimate of up to $500,000 per year in new costs, and noted the need to streamline reporting to avoid duplication. - Item 3 (Reproductive Rights Ordinance): Ruth Nunes (Senior Center Director, Planned Parenthood Northern California) expressed support, noting the San Francisco Health Center sees an average of 10,000 patients annually and that the Reproductive Freedom Act would further protect access in the face of ongoing attacks. Discussion Items - Charter Amendments – Accountability for Children & Youth Services and Student Success Fund: Supervisor Melgar introduced her charter amendment (File 240545) to require a citywide outcomes framework, a community needs assessment, and enhanced budget oversight for departments and the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD). Key additions from amendments: removal of references to the Our Children, Our Families Council; new five-year spending proposals from SFUSD for the Public Education Enrichment Fund (PEEF); annual reporting (including a “look back” on prior-year expenditures); and a data sharing agreement between the city and SFUSD. Supervisor Ronan introduced her charter amendment (File 240676) to clarify that the Student Success Fund (passed by 70% of voters in 2022) cannot be counted against the Children’s Fund baseline—a practice that occurred in the last two budgets. She proposed three minor edits to broaden language on school-site innovations and grant timelines. Both supervisors expressed frustration that such clarifications were necessary and noted the measures would be merged. Supervisor Safai voiced support and co-sponsored. - Reproductive Freedom Ordinance (File 240705): Mayor Breed’s office presented the proposed initiative, which would declare city policy to safeguard reproductive freedom, establish a dedicated fund, require city signage about where abortion and emergency contraception are available (including at limited-services pregnancy centers), prohibit city cooperation with out-of-state prosecutions for lawful care, and clarify that reproductive health clinics are a permitted use in non-residential zones. Supervisor Melgar emphasized reproductive freedom as both a human right and an economic right, noting the Dobbs decision has led to 14 states banning abortion and 7 more restricting it. Supervisor Safai underscored San Francisco’s leadership. Chair Ronan noted the symbolic importance of allowing voters to affirm these values in November. Key Outcomes - Motion to excuse Vice Chair Walton: Passed unanimously (2-0, Safai absent). - Motion to merge Student Success Fund language into File 240545: Passed unanimously (3-0). - Motion to amend Student Success Fund section with three changes (community/school-site language, grant timing, and model/strategies wording): Passed unanimously (3-0). - Motion to adopt Supervisor Melgar’s amendments (as read into the record): Passed unanimously (3-0). - Motion to continue File 240545 as amended to the July 15, 2024 Rules Committee meeting: Passed unanimously (3-0). - Motion to table File 240676 (Student Success Fund standalone item): Passed unanimously (3-0). - Motion to file the hearing on Item 3: Passed unanimously (3-0).
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on July 10, 2024 to consider a wide range of fiscal items, including financing mechanisms for workforce housing, a $390 million general obligation bond, real estate acquisitions, shelter hotel extensions, and a major development at Stonestown. The meeting lasted over four hours and included extensive public testimony and committee debate. Consent Calendar (Items 2, 5-7, 9-11) - Item 2 (Annual Retail Food Special Event Permit): Approved unanimously after brief discussion, as it was continued from a prior meeting. - Item 5 (Purchase of 624 Laguna Street - $13.8 million): Approved unanimously. The city will acquire a 56-bed assisted living facility at 624 Laguna Street from Pacifica SFO LLC, funded by homeless gross receipts tax. The BLA noted the purchase relocates existing beds rather than expanding capacity. - Item 6 (CDC Grant Acceptance - $107,707): Approved unanimously. Retroactive acceptance of a grant for HIV/TB technical assistance. - Item 7 (Hoedown Yard Option Extension - $8.28 million): Approved unanimously. Extended the city's option to purchase the PG&E-owned Hoedown Yard at 22nd and Illinois Streets for five years. - Items 9 & 10 (Headworks Facility Contract Amendments - $57.5 million and $31.68 million): Approved unanimously. Amendments to contracts for engineering and construction management at the Southeast Treatment Plant's new headworks facility, necessitated by unforeseen conditions. - Item 11 (Green Infrastructure Grant Program Extension): Approved unanimously. Extended the SFPUC's delegation of authority to enter into 20-year grant agreements for green infrastructure projects through July 2026. Workforce Housing and Affordable Middle-Income Revenue Bonds (Item 1) Board President Aaron Peskin introduced an ordinance to amend the Administrative Code to permit the city to issue tax-exempt revenue bonds for workforce and middle-income housing (up to 120% AMI). The presentation emphasized the need to finance housing for essential workers, with tax-exempt bonds offering lower interest rates than taxable bonds. Public comment was strongly supportive, with speakers noting the missing middle-income housing gap. The committee adopted three minor amendments and voted unanimously to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Healthy, Safe, and Vibrant San Francisco General Obligation Bond (Items 3 & 4) The committee considered a $390 million general obligation bond for the November 2024 ballot, funding healthcare, mental health, shelter, and infrastructure improvements. The Mayor's Budget Office proposed last-minute amendments to strengthen accountability and transparency for ACA 10 compliance (lowering the voter threshold). The committee adopted those amendments but, because they were substantive, continued the items to a special meeting on July 16, 2024 at 11:00 a.m. 1000 Sutter Street Loan – Granada Hotel (Item 8) The committee approved an amended and restated loan of up to $71.1 million to Episcopal Community Services for the rehabilitation and permanent financing of a 214-unit SRO at 1000 Sutter Street, serving as permanent supportive housing for formerly homeless individuals. The BLA report highlighted that the rehabilitation cost ballooned from $28 million to $66 million, resulting in a $39 million opportunity cost. Supervisors Melgar and Chan voiced frustration over the lack of consistent inspection processes and cost controls. The item was approved unanimously. Hotel Booking Agreement Extensions (Items 12-14) The Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing requested seven-month extensions (through March 2025) for three non-congregate shelter hotels: the Cova (95 units), Adante (93 units), and Monarch (100 units). HSH is negotiating long-term leases to reduce costs, but needed time. Public comment strongly supported keeping the shelters open, with residents testifying to the positive impact. The committee adopted amendments to reduce the dollar amounts as recommended by the BLA. - Item 12 (Cova Hotel): Passed 2-1, with Vice Chair Mandelman dissenting due to concerns about street conditions and the high cost per bed ($200-$250/night). Supervisor Mandelman argued the city should find an alternative location. - Items 13 & 14 (Adante and Monarch Hotels): Approved unanimously. All three items will go to the full board. Stonestown Development Agreement and Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (Items 15-17) Supervisor Melgar presented the Stonestown Development Project, which will transform surface parking around the Stonestown Galleria into 3,500 housing units (20% affordable), six acres of open space, a child care center, a senior center, and new streets. The project includes a development agreement and a resolution of intention to create an Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD) to capture tax increment for infrastructure. Public comment was overwhelmingly supportive, with speakers highlighting the need for housing on the west side. The committee adopted an amendment to codify the 50% cap on tax increment diversion as recommended by the BLA, then voted unanimously to forward all three items to the full board with positive recommendations. Key Outcomes - Items 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17: Approved unanimously and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. - Item 12 (Cova Hotel): Approved 2-1 (Chan and Melgar aye, Mandelman no) and forwarded with recommendation. - Items 3 & 4 (Bond): Continued to a special Budget and Finance Committee meeting on July 16, 2024 at 11 a.m. after substantive amendments.
The San Francisco Police Commission held a regular meeting on July 10, 2024, beginning at 1:45 PM. The meeting included officer recognition, public comment, reports from the Chief and DPA Director, a presentation on a proposed movable community service facility (Peacelets), and several votes on revised Department General Orders (DGOs) to implement Proposition E, which was passed by voters earlier in the year. The Commission also considered resolutions to accept a grant and an in-kind gift. Most actions were approved unanimously, with one item continued to the next meeting. Consent Calendar - Received and filed the Police Commission report of disciplinary actions for the second quarter of 2024. - Approved acceptance of a grant from the San Francisco Police Foundation for Blue and Blue debriefing training valued at $1,180. - Approved acceptance of a grant from the San Francisco Police Foundation for the Mothers, Fathers, and Families Impacted by Homicide March valued at $5,480. - Approved acceptance of a grant from the San Francisco Police Foundation for SFPD’s National Night Out event valued at $20,000 ($2,000 per district station). - Approved acceptance of a grant from the San Francisco Police Foundation for neighborhood safety team uniforms valued at $494.44. - Approved acceptance of a donation from the San Francisco Police Credit Union for the Law Enforcement Torch Run for Special Olympics valued at $350. - Received and filed the SB 1421 and SB 16 monthly reports for June 30, 2024, and July 3, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - A member of the public advocated for foot patrols and police kiosks (cobans) and called for electing a police chief with those platforms. - A speaker urged the public to deposit banana peels on Waymo vehicles as a protest, stating the police would do nothing (position: opposition to Waymo vehicles). - A deaf individual described a 911 call experience where the officer ignored her because of her deafness, stated that officers in three precincts did not know how to use communication devices, and felt the police department was scamming federal grant money. They asked to speak with DPA privately. - A speaker demanded the arrest of London Breed and Melissa Bryant, alleging surveillance, fraud, and murder, and urged the Commission to contact the District Attorney (position: urging action against city officials). - A speaker thanked Officer Watson for his service and congratulated Commissioner Walker on reappointment. - A mother of a homicide victim (son murdered in 2022) requested media coverage for unsolved cases and a street naming in his honor. - Comment on the Chief’s report: A speaker praised the community meeting for the Hill Bomb and criticized Raphael Mandelman for pulling permits that caused friction. - Another speaker clarified the number of Waymo tire slashings (20) and asked for it to be noted. Presentation by 3rd Street Youth Center & Clinic (SF Next) on “Peacelets” - Richard Corriea (retired SFPD commander) and Sorcia Riley McLaughlin presented the Peacelets concept: staffed, movable parklet-like structures staffed by police officers and service providers, managed by neighborhood collaboratives (Peace Partners Collaborative). The goal is to activate neighborhoods, reduce disorder, and connect residents with services. The proposal is novel and not modeled after existing U.S. programs. Commissioners expressed strong interest, noting the concept aligns with community policing and could be tailored to each neighborhood. Commissioner Yee was especially supportive for Chinatown. The Commission asked the Chief to assign a liaison and invited the presenters back in six months to report progress. Chief’s Report - Chief Scott reported crime trends: Part one crime down 32% overall; property crimes down 34% (approximately 9,000 fewer incidents); violent crimes down 11% (over 300 fewer). Homicides down 39% compared to 2023 (18 year-to-date vs. 28 last year). Shootings down nearly 40%; 71 firearm incidents resulting in 80 victims year-to-date. Firearm seizures up slightly (622 vs. 536), but ghost gun seizures down (74 vs. 117). Car break-ins down 54%. Several specific shooting incidents were described, with arrests in some cases. The Hill Bomb event on July 6 was successful with no violence, no arrests, and only two skateboarder injuries. Pride events and July 4th were peaceful. Updated on Automatic License Plate Readers (ALPRs): 120 deployed so far, with 400 expected by end of year; arrests have been made. Staffing for Hill Bomb: approximately 60 officers (six squads plus tactical unit), mostly overtime. - Commissioners asked about the decrease in property crime (attributed to arrests of prolific crews and retail theft operations), staffing for Hill Bomb, and Fourth of July operations. Concerns were raised about ALPR data retention and Fourth Amendment issues; Chief stated data used only for criminal investigations without a warrant and within retention period. DPA Director’s Report - Director Henderson reported that the DPA investigation unit opened 73 new cases and closed 85 since last meeting; cases past 270 days reduced to just one (the lowest ever). Audit team working on stop data audit; field work testing expected to complete by July. Peer review by Association of Local Government Auditors scheduled for end of July. DPA participated in several outreach events. Reviewed draft DGO 6.10 on missing persons. No closed session matters. Commission Reports - Commissioner Benedicto: Pleased with Hill Bomb outcome; attended DPA summer speaker series; mentioned quarterly audit liaison meeting; reserved comments on DGOs for later. - Commissioner Walker: Thanked department for community meeting ahead of Hill Bomb; working on pilot program for private camera infrastructure; praised Pride event. - Commissioner Yee: Reported a Chinatown town hall with Chief, DA, and Mayor; testing instant Chinese translation; residents feel safer. Discussion and Votes on Department General Orders (DGOs) for Proposition E Implementation - Item 12 – DGO 5.01 (Use of Force Policy): Approved unanimously (6-0) with an amendment to add type three uses of force (complaints of pain without injury) to the exception requiring documentation on body-worn camera or CAD. The DGO will now go to meet and confer with bargaining units. Commissioners emphasized that the revisions strictly implement Prop E while preserving transparency. - Item 14 – DGO 5.04 (Arrests by Private Persons): Approved unanimously (6-0). DPA Director requested requiring signature of the arresting private person instead of allowing a verbal affirmative on BWC, but the Chief argued BWC documentation is sufficient and more efficient. The motion passed without the change. - Item 15 – DGO 5.05 (Emergency Response and Pursuit Driving): Continued to the next meeting (July 17, 2024) after Commissioner Carter-Oberstone proposed an amendment to require reporting of the number of apprehensions resulting from pursuits in the annual report. The Chief and some commissioners argued for sticking to Prop E language, but others supported the amendment as best practice. The City Attorney will provide an opinion on the amendment, and the item will be reconsidered with public notice. - Item 16 – DGO 5.06 (Citation Release): Approved unanimously (6-0). Closed Session - The Commission voted unanimously to hold a closed session (Item 20) for discussion of personnel or legal matters. After returning to open session, they voted not to disclose any discussion held in closed session. Key Outcomes - Approved retroactive acceptance of an in-kind gift of 1,800 units of naloxone valued at $81,300 (unanimous). - Approved retroactive acceptance of a $72,275 grant from Cal OES for the forensic lab (unanimous). - Approved DGOs 5.01 (with amendment), 5.04, and 5.06 to go to meet and confer (all unanimous, with labor relations resolution invoked for 5.01). - Continued DGO 5.05 to July 17 meeting for further discussion of the apprehensions reporting amendment. - The presentation on Peacelets was well received; the Commission agreed to revisit the proposal in six months. - Closed session held; no disclosure of discussion.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on July 9, 2024, at 2:00 PM in City Hall. The meeting included a special appearance by Mayor London Breed for a formal policy discussion, adoption of the consent calendar, continuation of the FY2024-2026 budget, recognition of commendations, and a heated debate on a resolution supporting the Justice for Renters Act (repeal of Costa Hawkins). Consent Calendar - Items 2–6 (Settlements): Approved unanimously. Settlements included: Jean Agustin ($75,000), Rahul Seth, M.D. (city to receive $170,000), Vincent Keith Bell ($500,000), Denise Wear ($45,000), Wendy Offen and Stephen Offen ($140,000). - Item 7 (Transient Occupancy Tax Exemption Increase): Ordinance raising daily exemption from $52 to $60 and weekly from $130 to $149, with a controller review by September 2027–2029. Passed unanimously. - Item 9 (Tenderloin Retail Hours Restriction Pilot): Two-year pilot prohibiting retail food and tobacco sales from 12 a.m. to 5 a.m. (2 a.m. to 5 a.m. if alcohol-licensed). Passed unanimously. Special Order – Mayor's Appearance (2:00 PM) Mayor Breed discussed the U.S. Supreme Court’s Grants Pass decision, which lifts restrictions on street encampment enforcement. She stated that San Francisco will continue outreach and shelter offers (60% increase in shelter capacity since 2018), noting that about 30% accept, 60% refuse, and 10% are already housed. She emphasized a compassionate but firm approach, including progressive penalties. Supervisor Preston asked about repealing Costa Hawkins; Mayor Breed expressed support for rent control but nuanced views on vacancy control and the ballot measure. She declined to take a definitive position without further review. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers addressed general matters. One speaker urged the board to support the Justice for Renters Act, linking it to tenant protections. Another speaker accused Supervisor Safai of groping at a 2018 political event. A speaker criticized the mayor’s homeless shelter strategy, arguing shelters keep people on the street. Other comments touched on local politics, climate change, and federal policy. Discussion Items - Budget Items (10–33): Supervisor Chan introduced clerical corrections to item 10, which were approved. Supervisor Ronan added amendments to item 21 (reallocating $13.676 million from the Our City, Our Home Fund) to require explicit notification to subsidy recipients about eligibility for extensions up to five years. The entire budget package was continued to the next meeting (July 16, 2024). - Commendations (2:30 PM): The board recognized Linda Ronstadt Day (July 15, 2024) – Joel Selvin accepted on her behalf. Supervisor Ronan honored Marcia Contreras, Deputy Director of Mission Housing, for her leadership in affordable housing and community development. - Item 36 – Resolution Supporting Justice for Renters Act: Supervisor Preston championed the resolution to support repealing Costa Hawkins, which allows local rent control. He argued it would restore local authority and protect tenants from skyrocketing rents. Supervisor Dorsey opposed, calling the ballot measure overly broad and warning it could empower anti-development jurisdictions to block housing. After debate, the resolution passed 8–2 (Supervisor Dorsey and Supervisor Engardio voting no). Key Outcomes - Approved resolutions: Linda Ronstadt Day (July 15, 2024) and Black Women’s Equal Pay Day (July 9, 2024) adopted without committee referral. - Vote on item 36: 8 ayes (Chan, Mandelman, Melgar, Peskin, Preston, Ronan, Safai, Walton) and 2 noes (Dorsey, Engardio). - Budget continuation: Items 10–33 (with amendments to 10 and 21) continued to July 16, 2024. - Other ordinances passed on first reading: Item 34 (1629 Market Street infrastructure acceptance) and Item 35 (rezoning 135 Kissling Street). - Meeting adjourned in memory of Jane F. McAlevey, Con Ringo Hallanan, and Chekyuk Lu Chan.
The Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronen and joined by Vice Chair Shaman Walton and Supervisor Asha Safai, met on July 8, 2024, to consider eight charter amendments for the November 5, 2024 ballot and a resolution supporting the repeal of Costa Hawkins. All items were either continued to a future meeting or sent to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public comment was heard on each item. Item 1: Charter Amendment - Electing Director of Police Accountability - Action: Continued to the call of the chair. - Public Comment: Two speakers supported the measure, with one suggesting also electing the police chief. Supervisor Walton indicated ongoing negotiations with the Municipal Executives Association. Item 2: Charter Amendment - Inspector General in Controller’s Office - Action: Amended and continued to July 15, 2024. - Amendments: Removed the word "misconduct" from certain sections and added consultation with the Department of Human Resources. Supervisor Peskin stated the meet-and-confer obligation was satisfied. - Public Comment: Two speakers supported the measure, emphasizing the need for oversight of contracted services. Item 3: Charter Amendment - Affordable Housing Opportunity Fund for Seniors and Families - Action: Amended and continued to July 15, 2024. - Amendments: Added persons with disabilities; established annual appropriation of at least $8.25 million starting fiscal year 2026-27, with a first-year minimum of $4 million; added reporting requirements. - Public Comment: Over 30 speakers, including representatives from Senior and Disability Action, SRO Families United, SomCAN, and faith-based organizations, urged support. Speakers shared personal stories of living in SROs, being unable to afford rent, and facing eviction. Many noted that affordable housing is unaffordable for extremely low-income households. Supervisor Ronen and Supervisor Safai expressed support, noting the need to protect the most vulnerable. Item 4: Charter Amendment - Commission Reform - Action: Sent to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Public Comment: One speaker opposed, calling it a competing measure to TogetherSF's; another speaker supported it, noting the need for reform but criticizing the TogetherSF approach. Item 5: Resolution Supporting the Justice for Renters Act (Repeal Costa Hawkins) - Action: Sent to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation as a committee report. - Public Comment: Over 20 speakers supported the resolution, arguing that Costa Hawkins enables displacement and rent increases, particularly for seniors, people with disabilities, and communities of color. Several speakers criticized opponents as being pro-real estate industry. Supervisor Ronen expressed frustration with colleagues who oppose the repeal. Item 6: Charter Amendment - Per Diem Nurse Retirement Credit and Public Safety Communications Personnel - Action: Amended and continued to July 15, 2024. - Amendments: Clarified effective date of January 4, 2025, and specified that nurses must work at least one year full-time to buy back up to three years of per diem service. The change reclassifies 911 dispatchers from miscellaneous to public safety safety retirement. - Cost Estimate: Controller Greg Wagner estimated annual costs of $3.8 million to $6.7 million in the first year, rising over time. - Public Comment: Dispatchers and a union representative supported the measure, citing severe understaffing (20% vacancy) and mandated overtime. One speaker also noted the need for staffing in other sectors. Item 7: Charter Amendment - Fire Department Service Retirement Pension - Action: Amended and continued to July 15, 2024. - Amendments: Changed final compensation calculation from "average compensation earnable" to "average compensation earned," saving approximately $1 million per year. The retirement board will consider a 20-year amortization period to save an additional $600,000 annually. - Cost Estimate: Controller Wagner estimated costs of $10.2 million in the first year, rising to $21.2 million by 2040-41, then decreasing. With amendments, savings reduce the net cost. - Public Comment: Firefighters and union representatives supported the measure, citing cancer as the leading cause of death (205 active and retired firefighters diagnosed since 2018) and the need to allow retirement at age 55 instead of 58. One speaker from IFPTE Local 21 raised questions about cumulative fiscal impacts of all pension enhancements. Item 8: Charter Amendment - Minimum Police Staffing Levels and Voluntary Deferred Retirement Option Program (DROP) - Action: Amended and continued to July 15, 2024. - Amendments: Removed minimum staffing numbers from the charter; changed the Prop E workload assessment to a three-year cycle; added definitions; required annual reporting on recruitment, retention, civilianization, and 30×30 pledge; limited DROP eligibility to ranks below command staff and required assignments to patrol or investigative work. - Cost Estimate: Controller estimated DROP costs between $600,000 and $3 million in the first year, with potential savings or costs up to $3 million in subsequent years. The removal of minimum staffing language eliminated the need to estimate costs for mandatory staffing levels. - Public Comment: Mixed. Some speakers opposed, calling the DROP a waste of money and arguing that it rewards officers who may have misconduct records. Others supported the measure as a retention tool to stem retirements. Supervisor Ronen expressed concerns about the lack of data on whether officers actually leave to work for other agencies, and noted the city has already spent heavily on police without seeing improved response times. Key Outcomes - All votes were unanimous. - Items 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, and 8 were amended and continued to the July 15, 2024 Rules Committee meeting. - Items 4 and 5 were sent to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations for the July 16, 2024 agenda. - The committee did not set a specific timeline for continued items, but they are expected to return the following week for final votes.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 8, 2024, to consider several items, including a rezoning for vehicle storage, acceptance of two Mission Bay parks, and the Stonestown Development Project. The committee voted to advance the first two items to the full board, and continued the Stonestown items for further amendments. Public comment was overwhelmingly supportive of the Stonestown project. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was listed. The first item (135 Kissling Street rezoning) was processed as a regular agenda item. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (135 Kissling Street): John Kevlin, representing Royal Motors, spoke in support of the rezoning, which is necessary to complete the renovation of their auto repair operation at 12th and Howard Streets and to continue operating a PDR business that has existed for four years. He noted that a nearby parking garage lease expires in August, making the project particularly urgent. - Items 3 & 4 (Stonestown): Numerous speakers expressed support, including: - Joe Sanders (Painters and Drywall Finishers Local 913), Anthony Wanis (Carpenters Local 12, SF Building Trades trustee), Eddie Reyes (Iron Workers Local 377 president), and other union representatives who emphasized job creation and training opportunities. - Corey Smith (Housing Action Coalition) cited over 300 petition signers and noted the project is privately financed mixed-income housing. - Jane Natoli (SB Action) called the project transformative for the West Side. - Local residents, including Meg Ann Pryor, Kath Sakalakis, and Tracy Friedman, praised the outreach and the need for housing. One resident, Rome Hemp Street, raised a concern about the lack of a pedestrian overpass across 19th Avenue. - A veterans' affairs commissioner expressed support for affordable housing and hoped veterans would benefit. Discussion Items - Item 1 (135 Kissling Street Rezoning): Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey's office) reported that amendments were being finalized in response to President Peskin's concerns, and the committee voted to duplicate the file and continue the duplicate to the call of the chair, while forwarding the original file with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 (Mission Bay South Parks P22 and P19): Kyle Hennessy (Public Works) presented the park acceptance, noting P22 is nearly complete (95%) and P19 is about half an acre. The committee adopted clerical amendments and advanced the ordinance. - Items 3 & 4 (Stonestown Development Project): Patrick Race (Planning Department) and Jonathan Cherry (OEWD) presented the project, which includes 3,500 homes (20% affordable), a child care center, a senior center, parks, and street improvements. Christy Donnelly (Brookfield Properties) highlighted the community engagement and unanimous support from the Planning Commission. Discussion included fire department decisions on auxiliary water supply (hose tenders instead of piping) and affordable housing fulfillment options (on-site inclusionary units, land dedication, or in-lieu fees). Supervisor Preston praised the project's lack of opposition and community benefits. The committee approved amendments to item 3 and continued both items to July 15, 2024. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to duplicate the file and continue the duplicate to the call of the chair passed 3-0. Motion to send the original file with a positive recommendation to the Board of Supervisors passed 3-0. - Item 2: Motion to amend and recommend the ordinance passed 3-0. - Items 3 & 4: Motion to amend item 3 passed 3-0. Motion to continue both items (240409 and 240575) to the July 15, 2024 meeting passed 3-0.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on July 2, 2024, at 10:15 AM. The meeting included roll call, adoption of the consent agenda, public comment, special commendations, and action on several items. Supervisor Stephanie was excused from the meeting. The meeting adjourned in memory of Kim Marie Thompson Cromb and Robert Higgs Ortega. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 15 were adopted unanimously, including routine approvals such as settlement of lawsuits (e.g., Jean Agustin - $75,000, Vincent Keith Bell - $500,000, Denise Wear - $45,000, Wendy Offen and Stephen Offen - $140,000), a tolling agreement with Maplebear Inc. ($2,204,716), and various land use and administrative code amendments. - Items 16 through 27 were also passed unanimously, including amendments to the Public Works Code for vending requirements, lease approvals (e.g., Friends and Foundation of the San Francisco Public Library - initial annual base rent of $15,555.84; New Community Leadership Foundation - sales-based rent; Greater Calvary Hill Missionary Baptist Church - initial base rent of $351,000), grant agreements with Japanese Community Youth Council (totaling $40,386,800 and $43,214,178), acceptance of $23,368,920.23 from the American Rescue Plan Act for water and wastewater arrears, and an increase in the transient occupancy tax exemption. Public Comments & Testimony - A speaker (Chris Ward Klein) alleged misuse of military-grade equipment and weaponization of public health and safety, referencing Martin Luther King Jr.'s speech and deaths at 250 Kearney Street. - A speaker (PJ Bastiani III) proposed a plan to reduce homelessness by 90% by November 1, 2024, using outreach teams and container communities. - A speaker (Jordan She/They) criticized the security perimeter at Pride, cuts to guaranteed income programs for trans people, the Grants Pass decision, and Supervisor Mandelman's policies, using strong language. - Paulette Brown spoke about her son's unsolved 2006 murder, advocating for unsolved homicide rewards and a permanent street sign. - A tenant in D5 spoke in support of the Justice for Renters Act, urging repeal of Costa Hawkins and criticizing Supervisor Stephanie's stance. - Olga Miranda (president of SEIU Local 87) thanked the board for pandemic decisions but raised concerns about janitors' working conditions, including lack of clean air after 6 PM and excessive square footage requirements. - A speaker (not named) criticized SFPD and Supervisor Mandelman's plans for upcoming events, noting lack of MTA, parks, and youth commission involvement, and urged harm reduction and cross-departmental coordination. Special Commendations - Kim Marie Thompson Cromb (Posthumous): Recognized for 38 years of service at the Department of Technology and union leadership. June 29, 2024, was proclaimed Kim Marie Thompson Cromb Day. Her husband David Cromb and IFPTE Local 21 president Bianca Polavina spoke. - David Nakanishi: Honored for nearly 30 years of public service, particularly as director of the Healthy Streets Operations Center (HSOC), where he led 890 operations placing over 2,900 people into housing and services. Supervisor Dorsey presented the commendation. - Leadership San Francisco: Recognized for nearly 40 years of training community leaders, with over 2,000 alumni. Executive Director Michael Zweifelhofer and former director Diane Easton spoke. - Jean Robertson: Honored for 30 years at SFUSD, most recently as assistant superintendent for special education. Supervisor Ronan and others praised her work. Robertson challenged the board to support public schools. Discussion Items - Item 30 (Justice for Renters Act): A resolution to support the California state proposition. Supervisor Preston requested referral to the Rules Committee due to insufficient votes for immediate adoption. The item was referred without objection. - Item 32 (Urging SFUSD to include equity criteria in Resource Alignment Initiative): Supervisor Peskin introduced amendments to add neighborhoods (Mission, Western Addition, Bayview Hunters Point, Vis Valley) to the resolution. Supervisor Walton, Ronan, and Preston expressed support. The resolution was adopted as amended. - Item 33 (Appropriation of Cost Savings): A motion to intend to appropriate approximately $48 million (amended to $58 million) of cost savings to restore programs for children, youth, seniors, and vulnerable populations. Unanimously adopted as amended. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: All items (1-27) passed unanimously. - Item 30: Referred to the Rules Committee. - Item 31: Adopted unanimously (proclamation for Kim Marie Thompson Cromb Day). - Item 32: Adopted as amended (with added neighborhoods). - Item 33: Adopted as amended (increase to $58 million). - Supervisor Safai's Drafting Request: Introduced a request to investigate air quality standards for service sector employees working after 6 PM and square footage limits. - Adjournment: Meeting adjourned in memory of Kim Marie Thompson Cromb and Robert Higgs Ortega.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 1, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Hilary Ronan, with Vice Chair Shimon Walton, and joined by Supervisors Asha Safai and Myrna Melgar. The committee considered three charter amendments proposed for the November 5, 2024 ballot, all of which were continued to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Children & Youth Services): One speaker opposed the charter amendment, calling it "more red tape" and stating that every department already has outcome measures. - Item 3 (Commission Reform): Multiple speakers opposed Supervisor Peskin's proposal and supported the Together SF alternative. Speakers argued that Peskin's measure does not cap commissions, could increase them, and gives unelected bodies lawmaking power. Supporters of Together SF claimed their measure has 50,000 signatures and would reduce commissions to 65. Other speakers, including the co-authors of the Civil Grand Jury report "Commission Impossible," expressed general support for Peskin's approach as a first step, but recommended a permanent oversight body. One speaker criticized the signature-gathering process for Together SF as paid and uninformed. Discussion Items - Item 1 (240545): Charter Amendment – Accountability for Funding Children and Youth Services – Supervisor Melgar presented the measure, which would strengthen coordination between city departments and SFUSD, require annual budget hearings and resolutions, and mandate data-sharing agreements. She requested a continuance to allow further amendments, including removal of language regarding the Our Children, Our Families Council due to ongoing commission reform discussions. - Item 2 (240550): Charter Amendment – Affordable Housing Opportunity Fund for Seniors and Families – President Peskin presented the measure, which would require the Board of Supervisors to set aside funds for project-based rental subsidies for extremely low-income households. He requested a continuance due to ongoing negotiations. - Item 3 (240547): Charter Amendment – Commission Reform – President Peskin presented a measure to establish a Commission Streamlining Task Force to recommend ways to modify, eliminate, or combine city commissions. He proposed amendments to add findings referencing the Civil Grand Jury report and the Rhodes Institute study, and to clarify the task force's expiration date (24 months after first meeting, with charter section removed by December 31, 2026). The task force would include the City Administrator, Controller, City Attorney, and appointees from the Mayor and Board President. Supervisor Safai questioned the provision allowing the task force to introduce ordinances, which City Attorney Ann Pearson clarified only allows introduction to the Board, not direct ballot access. Supervisor Ronan praised the measure and requested to be added as a co-sponsor, noting the need for a systematic review rather than an arbitrary cap. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to continue to the call of the chair passed unanimously (Walton, Safai, Ronan aye). - Item 2: Motion to continue to the call of the chair passed unanimously (Walton, Safai, Ronan aye). - Item 3: Motion to adopt President Peskin's amendments and continue the item as amended to the call of the chair passed unanimously (Walton, Safai, Ronan aye). All three charter amendments will be considered at a future Rules Committee meeting before potentially appearing on the November 5, 2024 ballot.