The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, March 26, 2024, at 10:15 AM in City Hall. The meeting included a veto override, adoption of numerous ordinances and resolutions, special commendations, and public comment. Key actions included overriding the mayor's veto on density controls in three historic districts, passing a resolution prioritizing municipal affairs, and honoring community members. Consent Calendar - Item 2 (Potrero Power Station development agreement amendment) – finally passed 11-0. - Item 3 (900 Kearny Street Special Use District) – finally passed unanimously. - Item 4 (Planning code amendments for various districts and uses) – finally passed unanimously. - Item 5 (Homeward Bound Program for homeless individuals) – finally passed unanimously. - Items 6-7 (Appropriations and small business fee waivers) – passed on first reading. - Item 8 (Assessor-Recorder fees) – passed on first reading. - Items 9-14 (Grants, lease, loan, and Pier 70 infrastructure items) – adopted or passed on first reading unanimously. - Item 15 (Commemorative street name “Sean Monterrosa Boulevard”) – adopted unanimously. - Item 16 (Mayoral appointment to Entertainment Commission) – approved. - Items 17-18 (Committee reports on homeless services and tobacco paraphernalia) – adopted/passed. - Items 23, 25-29 (Resolutions on Wu death investigation, grocery store in Tenderloin, Nowruz, etc.) – adopted 11-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Several speakers urged the board to pass Item 23 (resolution on the death of Yanfang Wu), calling for transparency and accountability from SFPD and the District Attorney’s office. Speakers included a retired judge (Judge Singh), community advocates from Chinese for Affirmative Action, and others. They expressed concern over the handling of the case and the lack of culturally competent victim services. - A speaker supported Item 24 (full-service grocery store in the Tenderloin), noting the need for affordable fresh food in the area. - Floyd Rollins, president of San Francisco Firefighters Local 798, thanked Supervisors Peskin, Safai, and Chan for introducing legislation to replace PFAS-laden turnout gear, citing over 300 firefighter cancer deaths since 2006. - A member of the public raised concerns about the “Sherlock” system used by the Human Services Agency, alleging it interferes with personal decision-making. - One speaker used profane language to criticize public comment procedures and expressed support for trans rights. - Henry Durr and others spoke in support of investigating Mrs. Wu’s death, referencing past consent decrees for bilingual police officers. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Veto Override – Density Controls in Historic Districts): President Peskin explained that the legislation reinstated density limits in the Northeast Waterfront, Jackson Square, and Jackson Square Extension historic districts, which had inadvertently allowed 270-foot towers under state law. The Planning Commission unanimously recommended the ordinance. Supervisor Safai criticized the mayor’s veto as inconsistent and political. Supervisor Dorsey opposed the override, arguing it sets a dangerous precedent against housing. Supervisor Mandelman supported the override, noting the unanimous Planning Commission support and the small geographic area affected. The board voted 8-3 to override the veto (Supervisors Engardio, Melgar, and Dorsey dissenting). - Item 21 (Resolution Prioritizing Municipal Affairs): Supervisor Engardio introduced the resolution to encourage the board to focus on local issues over matters outside city jurisdiction. After amendments were adopted, Supervisor Ronan spoke against it, fearing it would be misused to criticize political speech. Supervisor Preston argued the resolution was unnecessary and would be used as “clickbait” to relitigate the ceasefire resolution. The resolution passed 10-1, with Supervisor Ronan voting no. - Special Orders – Commendations: - Pierce’s Pledge: Supervisors Stephanie honored Leslie Hugh and Cody Doherty for their work on gun storage advocacy after the murder of Hugh’s 9-year-old son. They described founding Pierce’s Pledge and creating a national firearm storage map. - Dorothy May Asbury: Supervisor Walton recognized the 102-year-old for her life and contributions. - Dr. John Brown: Supervisor Mandelman commended the retiring EMS medical director for 28 years of service. - San Francisco Women’s 100×1 Mile Relay Team: Supervisor Melgar presented a commendation for setting a Guinness World Record (9 hours, 18 minutes, 32 seconds) and raising over $5,000 for Girls on the Run. Key Outcomes - Veto Override (Item 1): The ordinance was approved over the mayor’s veto by a vote of 8-3, with Supervisors Engardio, Melgar, and Dorsey voting no. - Resolution Prioritizing Municipal Affairs (Item 21): Adopted 10-1 after amendments, with Supervisor Ronan dissenting. - Other Legislation: All consent calendar items and adoption without reference items (21-29) were passed, many unanimously. - New Introductions: Supervisors announced upcoming legislation, including a resolution to initiate landmarking of the Gilbert Baker rainbow flag at Harvey Milk Plaza (Supervisor Mandelman), a resolution and budget analyst request on traffic safety (Supervisor Melgar), a PFAS ban in firefighter turnouts (Supervisor Peskin), and a resolution urging the Housing Authority to use the Faircloth-to-RAD program for 3,668 new affordable units (Supervisor Preston). - Public Comment on Item 23: The board received extensive testimony urging approval of the resolution on Yanfang Wu’s death; the resolution was later adopted 11-0 as part of the consent calendar.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on Tuesday, March 26, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of previous minutes, general public comment, reports from the General Manager, consent calendar approvals, regular calendar items, and commissioner initiatives.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 25, 2024, at 6:00 PM. The committee considered two items: the annual surveillance technology report and a proposal to waive certain contracting requirements to expedite the implementation of an automated speed enforcement system. Both items were approved unanimously and forwarded to the full Board. Annual Surveillance Report (Item No. 1) - Julia Crucial, Privacy Analyst for the Committee on Information Technology (COIT), presented the 2023 Annual Surveillance Reports submitted by 23 departments covering 44 reports for technologies including Automated License Plate Readers (ALPR), security cameras, drones, and others. - Two violations were noted: one data retention violation by SFMTA for ALPR (a vendor miscommunication regarding hit counting, corrected promptly) and an internal audit adjustment by the Department of Public Health for security cameras. Several departments proposed changes (e.g., job title updates, technology modifications). - Supervisors asked clarifying questions about the ALPR violation; the SFMTA IPMO director explained that it involved a miscommunication with the vendor regarding hit data retention and that no tickets were issued from the error. Discussion: Automated Speed Enforcement System Contracting Waiver (Item No. 2) - Shannon Haik, Speed Safety Camera Program Manager at SFMTA, presented a request for an ordinance waiving normal contracting requirements (Chapters 6 and 21 of the Administrative Code) to allow a single design-build-operate-maintain (DBOM) procurement for a speed camera pilot program authorized by California Assembly Bill 645 (effective January 1, 2024). - The pilot allows six California cities (including San Francisco) to operate speed cameras for five years, targeting vehicles traveling 11 mph or more over the speed limit. The first 60 days of each camera would issue only warnings, and the first ticket for low-end violations would be forgiven. - SFMTA identified 33 candidate locations across all supervisor districts, based on the High Injury Network (12% of streets accounting for 68% of serious injuries/fatalities), speed-related collisions, proximity to schools, parks, and senior centers, and vehicle speed data collected via pneumatic tubes. - Total program cost is estimated at less than $10 million over five years, funded from SFMTA operating funds (not coming to the Board budget committee; SFMTA Board approval is planned). Revenue from fines, if any, would by law go to traffic calming improvements. - Supervisor Safai requested a citywide map of planned locations and emphasized the need for community outreach and public education. Supervisor Walton raised concerns about owner liability (e.g., if someone else drives your car) but expressed support for the goal of slowing traffic. Chair Ronin expressed strong support, calling the legislation life-saving. Public Comments - No members of the public spoke on either item, and both public comment periods were closed. Key Outcomes - Item No. 1 (Surveillance Report): Motion by Chair Ronin to forward to the full Board with positive recommendation passed unanimously (Vice Chair Walton: aye, Supervisor Safai: aye, Chair Ronin: aye). - Item No. 2 (Speed Camera Contract Waiver): Motion by Chair Ronin to forward to the full Board with positive recommendation passed unanimously (Vice Chair Walton: aye, Supervisor Safai: aye, Chair Ronin: aye). Supervisor Walton was added as a co-sponsor. The committee directed SFMTA to return in June 2024 with the system use policy and impact report (including locations) under Administrative Code 19B.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 25, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar and joined by Board President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston, considered five agenda items related to planning code amendments, a waterfront flood study, and disability access deadline extensions. All items were approved or forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4 (Waterfront Draft Plan): Beck Trebesh with San Francisco Parks Forward spoke in support of nature-based solutions and equity for the southern waterfront, advocating for restoration of Islais Creek Channel and reinvestment in wetlands to protect surrounding communities. Discussion Items - Item 1: Citywide Expansion of Allowable Commercial, Restaurant, and Retail Uses – President Peskin introduced amended language regarding use size limitations in residential districts (1200 sq ft in RH/RM1/RM2, 2500 sq ft in RM3/RM4). The amendment also clarified language on outdoor activities (changing "not at front" to "elsewhere"). No public comment. The committee voted to amend and forward to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 2: Tobacco Paraphernalia Establishments in North of Market SUD and Lower Polk NCD – Continued from the previous week. Vice Chair Preston noted prior discussion and moved to send to the full board as a committee report. No public comment. Unanimous vote. - Item 3: Rezone 68 Nantucket Avenue from Public to RH1 – Planning staff presented a request to rezone two irregular parcels (approx. 1900 sq ft combined) from Public to RH1 (one-family residential). Chair Melgar questioned why the parcels were not aggregated with the adjacent owner’s property for multifamily housing. Staff noted the owner’s home is next door and the parcels are small. No public comment. Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 4: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers SF Waterfront Coastal Flood Study Draft Plan – Assistant Port Director Michael Martin and Brad Benson (Port Waterfront Resilience Director) presented the draft plan, which proposes $13.5 billion in coastal flood defenses along 7.5 miles of waterfront. The plan includes raising shorelines, floodproofing buildings, and nature-based features. Key issues: costs (65% federal share possible), coordination with other city agencies, concerns about gate closures on bridges affecting Muni, and environmental contamination in Bayview. Rachel Tanner (Planning) discussed urban design opportunities. Chair Melgar raised questions about citywide coordination and induced flooding. The committee filed the item with a motion to continue discussion in the future. - Item 5: Building Code – Extending Deadlines for Disability Access Improvements – Supervisor Mandelman, the sponsor, presented the ordinance to extend the compliance deadline for the Accessible Business Entrance (ABE) program from June 2024 to December 31, 2024. He noted challenges faced by small businesses and expressed intent to introduce future legislation to remove DBI enforcement. The committee duplicated the file, amended the duplicate to extend the deadline to December 31, 2024, and sent it to the Building Inspection Commission. The original file was forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to amend and recommend to full board passed (3-0). - Item 2: Motion to recommend as committee report passed (3-0). - Item 3: Motion to recommend to full board passed (3-0). - Item 4: Motion to file the item passed (3-0). - Item 5: Original file recommended to full board (3-0). Duplicate file amended (deadline extended to Dec 31, 2024) and continued to the call of the chair (3-0).
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, March 21, 2024, to consider continuances, a consent calendar, commission matters, department reports, general public comment, and one regular calendar item. All votes were unanimous. A notable discussion arose regarding public outreach for the Housing Element rezoning. Consent Calendar - Items 1 and 2 (at 638 Rhode Island Street and 1234 Francisco Street) were continued to April 4 and April 11, 2024, respectively. (Vote: 7–0) - Items 3a, 3b, 4, and 5 were approved: modifications to approvals at 530 Sansome Street (extending performance periods), conditional use for 1155 Pine Street (Intermediate Length Occupancy unit), and conditional use for 1567 Sloat Boulevard (Crumbl Cookies formula retail). (Vote: 6–0; the Zoning Administrator separately closed the hearing for variance Item 3c and intended to grant with matching performance period.) Public Comments & Testimony - George Shudish spoke on two occasions. During the discussion of the Board of Supervisors resolution on state funding, he displayed a chart showing income inequality and urged the commission to forward it to Sacramento. During general public comment, he criticized Section 317 demolition calculations, stating they are not stringent enough, and argued that speculation has driven up housing prices in Noe Valley by a cumulative $150 million, with an average increase of over $4 million per property. He called on the commission to adjust the demolition calculations to preserve existing housing. - Tom Radilovich (Livable City) urged the commission to take action on the ecological crisis. He highlighted two upcoming state requirements: the Priority Conservation Areas update (due 2025) and the Open Space Element update (due 2026 per SB 1425), noting that these have not yet been included in the department’s work plan. - Tom Ray expressed concern about inadequate public notification for the rezoning near Geary and Masonic. He requested mailed notices to affected households, noting that many neighbors are elderly or working and unable to attend meetings. He felt the scale of the project was out of proportion to the neighborhood. Discussion Items - Land Acknowledgement (Item 6): Commission read the traditional land acknowledgement. - Adoption of Minutes (Item 7): The draft minutes for March 7, 2024, were approved without discussion. (Vote: 6–0) - Endorsement of Board of Supervisors Resolution on State Funding (Item 9): Vice President Moore moved to endorse the resolution supporting state funding for affordable housing. After public comment (George Shudish), the motion carried 6–0. - Department Report (Item 11): Aaron Starr, Manager of Legislative Affairs, reported on recent Board of Supervisors land use committee actions, including tobacco paraphernalia controls in NOMA, the 900 Kearney SUD, and the mayor’s ordinance on lotable commercial uses. He also summarized full board actions on state ADU controls, a landmark designation, conditional use requirements, and exceptions/extensions. - Outreach Discussion (from General Public Comment): Following Tom Ray’s comment, Commissioners Williams and Moore expressed concern that many residents are unaware of the Housing Element rezoning. Director Hillis acknowledged the issue and committed to providing a memo on existing outreach efforts and to adding a discussion on community engagement to the next Housing Element Implementation hearing. - Regular Calendar – 557 23rd Avenue (Item 12): Staff presented a request for conditional use authorization to demolish a vacant single-family dwelling and replace it with a new 499 sq ft ADU. The project includes a rent-control covenant to comply with SB 330. No public comment was offered. The commission approved the item with conditions. (Vote: 6–0) Key Outcomes - Items 1 and 2 continued to April 4 and April 11, 2024. - Consent calendar approved (Items 3a, 3b, 4, 5). Variance Item 3c was separately handled by the Zoning Administrator. - Minutes of March 7, 2024, adopted. - Resolution endorsing state funding for affordable housing approved. - Conditional use authorization for 557 23rd Avenue approved with conditions. - The commission directed staff to report on public outreach efforts for the Housing Element and scheduled a future discussion on engagement. - All votes were unanimous. (Note: The vote on the continuance motion was recorded as 7–0, while all other votes were 6–0, despite only six commissioners being present at roll call.)
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on March 21, 2024, at 6:15 PM. The committee considered several items including a memorandum of understanding with the Deputy Sheriffs' Association, reports from the Sheriff's Department Oversight Board, a behested payment waiver extension for homeless services, and a performance audit of the city's street teams. The committee also convened in closed session to discuss settlement of lawsuits and claims. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were listed. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 2-4 (Sheriff's Oversight Board): Julie Su, President of the Sheriff's Oversight Board, commended Inspector General Terry Wiley and highlighted the need for adequate staffing, noting that the board has only had 20 hours of training instead of the expected 80 hours. She also mentioned that the inmate population has grown by 50%, suggesting future staffing should consider incarceration numbers. - No public comment was made on items 1, 5, 6, or the closed session items. Discussion Items 1. Item 1: Memorandum of Understanding with San Francisco Deputy Sheriffs' Association - Director of Employee Relations, Artist Graham, presented the ordinance retroactively adopting an arbitration award regarding the MOU effective July 1, 2022 through June 30, 2024. The arbitration addressed muster pay and side letters. The panel ruled in the city's favor on muster pay and partially on the side letters. The committee forwarded the item to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). 2. Items 2-4: Sheriff's Department Oversight Board Reports - Supervisor Shamann Walton introduced resolutions accepting quarterly and annual reports for calendar year 2023. Inspector General Terry Wiley provided an update on the Office of Inspector General (OIG) progress: launched a case management system at a cost of $60,000, created a website, established social media presence, and is developing a disciplinary schedule. The OIG budget request is $2.5 million, but a fully functional office would require $5-6 million. The OIG currently has no investigators and relies on DPA loans. A complaint portal for inmates is planned within a month. The committee forwarded the items to the full board (3-0). 3. Item 5: Behested Payment Waiver for Temporary Shelter and Homeless Services - Emily Cohn, Deputy Director of HSH, requested a six-month extension of the waiver to solicit private donations for homeless services. The city faces over 7,700 unhoused individuals, 56% unsheltered. Fundraising goals include $3 million for capital improvements, workforce housing subsidies, and family shelter expansion. Supervisor Chan questioned the long-term reliance on private funding and asked for more specific fundraising goals. The committee forwarded the item to the full board as a committee report (3-0). 4. Item 6: Hearing on BLA Performance Audit of San Francisco Street Teams - The BLA presented findings from an audit covering 11 street teams across DEM, DPH, Fire, and HSH. Key findings included: lack of coordination, inconsistent performance metrics, inadequate data sharing (8 separate systems), contract monitoring failures (DPH had 18-month contract gap), and resource referral gaps (13% of requested resources unavailable, mostly due to shelter capacity). The audit made 20 recommendations. - DEM Director Mary Ellen Carroll and Lauren Bell presented progress: structural coordination through MDT law, data integration efforts via the Mayor's Office of Innovation, and a developing North Star goal. Bell noted that SORT responded to 28,889 calls since inception, and over 1,000 calls in January 2024. The committee discussed staffing, conservatorship, and reporting frequency. The committee filed the hearing (3-0). 5. Items 7-22: Closed Session – Litigation Settlements - The committee approved 16 settlements ranging from $32,000 to $3.9 million, including a $2.8 million settlement for Danielle Dillard and Kim Lee, and a $3.9 million settlement with Deloitte entities. The committee voted to not disclose closed session discussions (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 2-4: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Forwarded to full board as a committee report with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 6: Hearing filed (3-0). - Items 7-22: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0); motion to not disclose closed session discussions passed (3-0). - The committee agreed to continued collaboration on reporting frequency for street teams, with an aim for a public dashboard by Q3 2024 and annual formal reporting.
The Budget and Finance Committee met on March 20, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman (arriving later) and Member Amir Melgar. The committee considered five regular agenda items, all of which were approved with amendments on items 1 and 4. No public comments were made on any item. Discussion Items Item 1: Emergency Radio Communications Site Sharing Agreement – The Real Estate Division presented a resolution to approve a five-year sharing agreement with the Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center for emergency radio telecommunications equipment at 4150 Clement Street. The initial base rent is $117,648 per year with 3% annual increases, with three five-year renewal options. The presenter noted that the VA template is non-negotiable and that the rent is supported by appraisals. The committee approved an amendment to correct the end date from March to May on both lines. The amended resolution was forwarded to the full Board with a 2-0 vote (Vice Chair Mandelman excused). Item 2: Assessor-Recorder Fees – The Assessor-Recorder’s Office presented an ordinance to revise fees for copies of recorded documents and notary services, which had not been updated in over 25 years. The new fee structure includes a flat $1.76 fee for online copies (regardless of page count) and per-page fees for in-person, mail, and kiosk copies. Approximately 67% of transactions are online, and the average 5-page document will see an 82% cost savings for online users. Supervisor Melgar raised concerns about system usability and potential modernization. The ordinance was forwarded to the full Board with a positive recommendation on a 2-0 vote (Vice Chair Mandelman excused). Item 3: Pier 70 Disposition and Development Agreement Amendment – The Port presented a second amendment to the DDA with FC Pier 70 LLC (Brookfield Properties). The 28-acre site is part of a larger special use district approved in 2017. Phase one infrastructure (except parks) is complete, but due to delayed vertical development, special taxes are not yet available for maintenance. The amendment allows maintenance costs incurred by the Port or developer to be treated as reimbursable project costs until special taxes are sufficient. The committee forwarded the resolution to the full Board with a 2-0 vote (Vice Chair Mandelman excused). Item 4: Loan Agreement for 936 Geary Avenue – Small Sites Program – MOHCD presented a resolution approving up to $11.8 million in permanent financing for the acquisition and rehabilitation of a 31-unit residential building with two ground-floor commercial spaces. The project is a joint venture between San Francisco Housing Development Corporation and Noven Development. 42% of households were formerly homeless, and all units will be affordable for 99 years. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended reducing the loan amount by $200,000 to $11.6 million and correcting the address. The committee approved these amendments and forwarded the amended resolution to the full Board with a 3-0 vote (Vice Chair Mandelman present). Item 5: Accept and Expend Grant – Public Defender’s CARE Court Fund – The Public Defender’s Office presented a resolution to retroactively accept a $524,765 grant from the state CARE Court Fund (SB 101/104) for legal representation in CARE Act proceedings. The grant covers one attorney and one paralegal, plus vouchers for clients (shelter, meals, transportation). To date, 21 petitions have been filed in San Francisco, and the office has been appointed on one case. Supervisor Melgar joined as co-sponsor. The resolution was forwarded to the full Board with a positive recommendation on a 3-0 vote. Public Comments & Testimony No members of the public spoke on any agenda item. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Resolution amended (date correction) and forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (2-0). - Item 2: Ordinance forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (2-0). - Item 3: Resolution forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (2-0). - Item 4: Resolution amended (loan reduction and address correction) and forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Resolution forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0).
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, March 20, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included officer recognition, public comments, consent calendar approval, reports from the Chief and DPA, a detailed presentation on language access services, and a closed session on pending litigation. Consent Calendar - Consent Calendar items (motion to receive and file): - Amended Department General Order 1102 (secondary employment). - Secondary Employment Annual Report 2023. - Photo booth donation for SFPD's annual "Bring Your Child to Work Day" event (estimated value $500). - SFPD and DPA SB 1421 reports. - The motion was approved unanimously (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (non-agenda items): - Speaker raised concerns about inter-departmental system credentialing, urging formation of a task force to prevent illegal interventions and surveillance overutilization. - A speaker advocated for an elected police chief, citing Michael Hennessy's idea of increased public accountability. - Speaker referenced Proposition E election results as evidence of public support for police, and called for Commissioner Elias and Commissioner Yanniz to resign over alleged conflicts of interest (family ties to district attorney's office and public defender's office). - A speaker criticized the Commission's micromanagement and called for ethics investigations. - Public Comment on Chief's Report: - Speaker expressed skepticism about crime data accuracy, noting anecdotal underreporting; asked about cross-verification and reporting trends. - Mother of unsolved homicide victim (2006) pressed for agenda item on solving unsolved homicides; provided suspect names. - Public Comment on Language Access: - Speaker proposed creating a "public safety foreign legion" for mutual aid, and noted that AI could assist with language translation. - Public Comment on DPA Director's Report: - Speaker urged a study of lateral transfers, alleging thug hires; asked DPA to track complaints against lateral officers. - Public Comment on Commission Reports: - Speaker called for drug testing of police officers involved in violent incidents, citing Proposition F mandate. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Crime Trends & Incidents): - Part 1 crime down 30% year-to-date (approx. 300-400 fewer crimes). Property crime down 32%; violent crime down 16%. Homicides: 6 this year vs. 10 last year (40% reduction). Shooting victims down 31% (11 fewer). Firearm recoveries: 190 (slightly above last year). - Reported a fatal collision on March 16 in the 900 block of Ulloa Street: driver (78-year-old) arrested for felony vehicular manslaughter after hitting a bus stop; 4 victims died. - Three recent Bayview shootings (March 11, 15, 17) – one non-life-threatening, one critical, one with suspect known; all investigations ongoing without arrest. - Pro-Palestine protest at SFO on March 13 (approx. 300 attendees) – no violence. - Reopening of the Yen Feng Wu homicide case due to new evidence; statement released but evidence not disclosed pending investigation. - In response to questions about SFPD's highest vehicle pursuit collision rate in the state (lowest apprehension rate), Chief cited lack of air support and dense city conditions; noted drones may help once authorized; acknowledged new pursuit policy may increase pursuits but emphasized risk management. - Chief attributed crime reduction to plainclothes unit arrests (51 in February), violent crime strategies (community safety meetings), retail blitz arrests, and new Flock camera technology (rolled out same day). - Confirmed body-worn camera investigation from Palestinian demonstration still ongoing; 61 vandalism incidents identified. - West Portal incident toxicology report not yet available. - Language Access Services (Item 7 – Presentation of Annual Report under DGO 5.20): - OSIA (Office of Civic Engagement & Immigrant Affairs) presented citywide language access compliance overview. Ordinance requires services in Chinese, Spanish, Filipino (threshold languages). Reported FY2022-23 trends: increases in LEP client interactions, translated materials, in-person interpretations; decreases in telephonic interpretations, bilingual staffing, and language service budgets. - SFPD presentation: 374 certified bilingual members (427 total bilingual including 5 core languages). In 2023, 71 members certified. Language Line offers interpretation in 240+ languages. In 2023, SFPD provided 13,955 interpretation services to LEP individuals; 5 DPA complaints received. 5-year comparison shows steady increase. - Community Liaison Unit: 241 outreaches in 2023 (95% increase from 2022). - Department acknowledged delay in submitting 2022 report to Commission (completed February 2023, but not forwarded to Commission until December 2023). Apologized for oversight. - Commissioner Yanniz raised concerns about data discrepancies: SFPD reported 6,635 LEP interactions in FY2022-23 vs. 30,738 in FY2019-20; expenditures dropped from $751,706 in FY2018-19 to $113,851 in FY2022-23. Department could not explain immediately but committed to review. - Commissioner Yanniz noted SFPD's LEP interaction rate was 1.2% of total calls (2023) vs. 2.1% (2022). Other departments with similar budgets report 180,000+ translations. - Discussion on certification process, training, and use of language identification cards. Department stated it does not have sufficient bilingual staff and is working to increase certifications. - OSIA responded that ordinance does not specify threshold for sufficiency; department self-reports adequacy. SFPD reported "no" to sufficiency question due to limited testing scope. - DPA Director's Report: - Acting Director Hawkins reported 314 pending cases (vs. 252 last year). 13 cases pending with Commission, 93 with Chief. 24 new cases in two weeks. Staffing concerns continue. - DPA received second round of stop data audit information; outreach efforts ongoing. - Commissioner Byrne thanked Ms. Hawkins for her service; her last meeting before leaving to TikTok. - Commission Reports: - Commissioner Benedicto: Attended St. Patrick's Day parade; upcoming ride-along with Commissioner Walker in Tenderloin; update on DGO 7.01 (juveniles) – draft public comment period closed, working on revisions. - Commissioner Byrne: Thanked Deputy City Attorney for memo on Prop E implementation; raised question about pending DGOs grandfathered. Chair deferred discussion to next agenda. Key Outcomes - Votes: - Consent Calendar received and filed (6-0). - Motion to hold Item 10 (Closed Session) passed (6-0). - Motion to not disclose Closed Session discussion passed (6-0). - Directives/Next Steps: - SFPD to investigate discrepancies in language access data (client counts and expenditures) and provide follow-up to Commission. - Department to continue working on revising DGO 5.20 and increasing bilingual certifications. - DGO 7.01 revisions to be brought back for action. - Commission will schedule discussion on Prop E implementation at a future meeting.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, March 20, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Supervisors Myrna Melgar and Shamann Walton present, and later joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered three agenda items, including appropriations for sea level rise study at Hunters Point Shipyard, overtime funding for public safety and other departments, and an extension of fee waivers for small businesses. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke on any of the agenda items. Discussion Items Item 1: Appropriation - General Reserve - San Francisco Public Utilities Commission - $500,000 for Sea Level Rise and Groundwater Study at Hunters Point Shipyard - Supervisor Walton, the sponsor, presented the ordinance to appropriate $500,000 from the General Fund Reserve to the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) for an independent third-party study on sea level rise and groundwater impacts at the Hunters Point Shipyard. He noted that the funding would be used to conduct a study recommended by a civil grand jury report. He proposed amendments to correct the fiscal year from 2022-2023 to 2023-2024. - The Budget Legislative Analyst (BLA) stated the appropriation is a policy matter and noted that any funds removed from the General Reserve must be repaid in the next budget year. - Supervisors discussed the appropriate funding source. President Peskin suggested the SFPUC should fund the study due to its interest in subsurface utilities, rather than using the General Fund Reserve. The Mayor's Budget Office noted the SFPUC initially saw no nexus with ratepayers but further analysis could be done. Supervisor Walton expressed willingness to consider any funding source as long as the study goes forward. - Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson advised that the proposed amendments (fiscal year change) were substantive and would require a one-week continuance. Changing the funding source in the future would also require a continuance. - The committee voted 5-0 to adopt the amendments (fiscal year change) and 5-0 to continue the amended ordinance to the next meeting on March 27, 2024, to allow time to explore alternative funding sources. Item 2: Appropriation - Ambulance Service Revenue - Fire Department - $4,770,707 and De-Appropriation and Appropriation - Various Departments $84,988,592 - FY2023-2024 - This ordinance de-appropriates approximately $85 million from permanent salaries and benefits and appropriates approximately $90 million to overtime budgets for the Department of Emergency Management (DEM), Fire Department, Police Department, Sheriff's Department, and SFPUC. The Fire Department also receives new ambulance revenue. - Department representatives presented on overtime drivers: Police cited staffing shortages (currently 1,474 sworn out of a recommended 2,074, down 600), Fire cited minimum staffing requirements and COVID-related leave, Sheriff cited a 15.6% staffing drop since FY2019 and increased cost-of-living adjustments, DEM cited dispatcher recruitment and retention issues, and SFPUC cited wet weather response. - Budget Legislative Analyst recommended approval, noting the overtime is largely due to minimum staffing and vacancies, except for SFPUC which is weather-driven. - Supervisor Walton asked about overtime deployment in District 10 (southeast sector). Assistant Chief David Lazar acknowledged the concern and stated resources are used there for violence reduction. - Committee Chair Chan proposed an amendment from the Mayor's Budget Office to correct funding source calculations on page 5, lines 12-19. - The committee voted 5-0 to adopt the amendment and 5-0 to forward the amended ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Item 3: Business and Tax Regulations Code - Extending Waiver of Permit, License, and Business Registration Fees for Certain Small Businesses - Amanda Freed (Treasurer & Tax Collector) and Katie Tang (Office of Small Business) presented an ordinance to extend the "First Year Free" program through June 30, 2025. The program waives initial registration, license, and permit fees for qualifying new small businesses (gross receipts ≤$5 million, commercial location, not home-based). Since November 2021, over 6,500 businesses have enrolled and nearly $3 million in fees have been waived. Examples included savings of $11,000 to $17,000 for individual businesses. - The program requires no additional appropriation; existing funds are sufficient for another year. - Budget Legislative Analyst noted that without extension, approximately $2.2 million could become available for the next budget. - Supervisor Chan confirmed that extending one year at a time was the agreed approach. The Mayor's Office indicated the program is popular and may be continued in the future. - The committee voted 5-0 to forward the ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Amended (fiscal year change) and continued to the March 27, 2024 meeting to allow exploration of alternative funding sources (5-0 on each vote). - Item 2: Amended (funding source correction) and forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (5-0 on each vote). - Item 3: Forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (5-0). - The next meeting of the Budget and Appropriations Committee is scheduled for March 26, 2024 at 4:00 PM.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on Tuesday, March 19, 2024, at 10:15 AM for a regular meeting. The board considered a substantial consent calendar, heard public testimony, debated several legislative items, recognized community groups and individuals, and voted on a variety of ordinances and resolutions. Notable actions included codifying the Homeward Bound program, approving a major dispatch system contract, and passing resolutions on electric vehicle charging and a grocery store for the Tenderloin. The meeting was adjourned in memory of three community members. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The February 13, 2024 meeting minutes were approved on a 10-0 roll call vote. - Unfinished Business Items (Items 1-5): The following were adopted unanimously without discussion: - Appropriation of $644,675,000 from refunding general obligation bonds (Item 1). - Amendments to various codes to clarify ministerial approval for accessory dwelling units (Item 2). - Landmark designation for the Sacred Heart Parish complex (Item 3). - Waiving conditional use authorization for removal of unauthorized units in single-family homes (Item 4). - Creation of the Legacy Business Assistance Program (Item 5). - Items 6-7 (Potrero Power Station): Ordinance to amend the development agreement and resolution approving the infrastructure financing plan for Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District No. 1 were passed on first reading and adopted, respectively. Supervisor Safai added as co-sponsor. - Items 8-9 (Computer-Aided Dispatch Contracts): Resolutions approving amendments to contracts with Motorola Solutions (up to $44,845,036, extended through 2038) and CentralSquare Technologies (up to $8,364,557, extended through 2027) were adopted. - Item 10: Grant amendment for Self-Help for the Elderly home-delivered meal program, not to exceed $11,515,405, was adopted. - Items 11-14: Annual reports for four Community Benefit Districts (Yerba Buena, Japantown, North of Market/Tenderloin, The East Cut) for FY2021-2022 were received and approved. - Item 15: Agreement for the Excelsior Community Benefit District management was approved. - Item 16: Planning code amendments regarding heights, signage, cannabis dispensaries, and inclusionary housing were passed on first reading. - Item 17: Creation of the 900 Kearny Street Special Use District was passed on first reading. Public Comments & Testimony - Speaker 1: Warned about addictive effects of cell phones and called for a new education system and local farmers to teach food growing. - Speaker 2: Submitted an FBI report alleging credential misuse by city agencies (Human Services Agency, SFMTA) and identified a compromised bus stop at McAllister and Van Ness, claiming it enables signal bouncing leading to traffic collisions and overdoses. - Speaker 3 (Jordan Pryor): Expressed anger over the West Portal traffic death of a family; criticized Supervisor Engardio’s resolution on municipal affairs as “dumb” and called for a ceasefire resolution; supported Supervisor Preston’s grocery store resolution and suggested municipally owned supermarkets; opposed Proposition 10-to-1; wished happy Women’s History Month. - Speaker 4 (Leslie De Thayandier): Supported Supervisor Peskin’s resolution urging the CPUC to deny AT&T’s request to relinquish landline obligations, citing reliability of copper landlines over VoIP in emergencies. - Speaker 5 (John Nakhi): Alleged crimes by public employees at Laguna Honda Hospital and UCSF Medical Center, requesting investigation. - Speaker 6 (Cammy Blackstone, AT&T): Opposed the resolution, stating AT&T would continue traditional service for existing customers, that no residential customers in San Francisco lack alternatives, and that AT&T would remain in the Lifeline program. - Speaker 7: Sang a hymn and spoke about religious prophecy. - Speaker 8 (Salah Hakuya Chandler): Called for wisdom and understanding, offered condolences for the West Portal family, and congratulated awardees. - Speaker 9 (Peter Warfield, Library Users Association): Criticized the Library Commission’s new strategic plan and mission statement for omitting mentions of books, reading, and free/equal access, and noted branch closures at 8 PM instead of 9 PM. - Speaker 10 (Sabanor): Requested an audit of Coritas Management Corporation at 1066 Mission Street. - Speaker 11 (Captain Maggie Hallahan): Raised concerns about the National Park Service closing the Sea Scout base ramp at the San Francisco Maritime National Historical Park, noting the base has 100 youth, and questioned property transfers. Discussion Items - Homeward Bound Program (Item 18): Supervisor Safai presented the ordinance to codify the Homeward Bound program, which reunifies homeless individuals with family in their hometowns. The program served 11,000 people from 2005 to 2019 but declined to just over 300 last year. The ordinance expands eligibility to those in shelters and permanent supportive housing, requires annual reporting, and sets a two-year time limit for participation. The ordinance passed on first reading. - Electric Vehicle Curbside Charging (Introduced by Supervisor Mandelman): Supervisor Mandelman introduced a resolution supporting the development of San Francisco’s first publicly accessible EV curbside charging program. The initiative includes a citywide assessment, stakeholder engagement, and a pilot program expected to begin next year. Currently there are about 1,000 public chargers; the goal is 5,000. - Grocery Store for Tenderloin (Introduced by Supervisor Preston): Supervisor Preston introduced a resolution calling for a full-service grocery store in the Tenderloin, which has not had one in decades. The resolution cites multiple community surveys and reports from 2007 to 2023, and directs city departments to report back within 60 days on past efforts, potential sites, and an attraction plan. - COPA Expansion (Introduced by Supervisor Peskin): Supervisor Peskin introduced legislation expanding the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act (COPA) to include deeds in lieu of foreclosure, allowing qualified nonprofit housing providers to make first offers on multifamily properties at risk of foreclosure, using state funding for affordable housing acquisition. - Resolution on Police Video Release (Introduced by Supervisor Peskin): Supervisor Peskin, with Supervisors Walton and Chan, introduced a resolution urging the SFPD and District Attorney to release video and investigation details in the death of Yan Fang Wu, a monolingual Chinese senior, to build community trust and transparency. - Special Order 2:30 PM – Commendations: The board recognized several groups and individuals: - San Francisco City Guides: Volunteer-led walking tours, 300 guides, 70 tours, 35,000 participants in 2023. Recognized by President Peskin. - Lincoln High School Championship Teams: Boys’ varsity basketball, girls’ varsity basketball, and wrestling teams won San Francisco Section Championships. Recognized by Supervisor Engardio. - Friends of Lakeside Village: Transformed an underutilized parking lot into a community space (Lakeside Landing) with tables, garden, stage, and events. Recognized by Supervisor Melgar. - Dr. Nineveh Caligari: Co-founder of 826 Valencia and Teacher Salary Project, former CEO of Enterprise for Youth. Recognized by Supervisor Mandelman for her work in literacy, teacher pay, and youth internships. - Zainab Amiri: Organizer of Persian New Year (Noruz) events for families, highlighting cultural heritage and public schools. Recognized by Supervisor Safai in celebration of Noruz and Women’s History Month. Key Outcomes - Votes and Adoption: Nearly all items on the agenda were passed unanimously, either on first reading or as final passage. No roll call votes were recorded except for the minutes and the continuance of item 21. - Item 18 (Homeward Bound): Ordinance passed on first reading (no roll call needed). - Item 21 (Board Policy Prioritizing Municipal Affairs): Supervisor Engardio’s resolution was continued to the next meeting (March 26, 2024) by a 10-0 vote. - Item 23 (AT&T Carrier of Last Resort): Supervisor Engardio recused himself. The resolution was amended to require conditions (transition plan and alternate carrier) and then adopted as amended. - Directives: The resolution on the Tenderloin grocery store (introduced) will be referred to committee; the EV charging resolution was introduced and will be placed on the calendar. The COPA expansion and the police video resolution were introduced and will be referred. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned at approximately 4:30 PM in memory of Diego Oliveira, Matilda Oliveira, Joaquin Oliveira (victims of the West Portal traffic accident), Mark Lawrence Wilder, and Richard James Isom (Baldhead Rick).