On January 29, 2024, the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission held a special meeting to review the Water Enterprise and Hetch Hetchy Water operating and capital budgets for fiscal years 2024-25 and 2025-26, along with the 10-year capital plan. The meeting began with a land acknowledgment and roll call establishing a quorum. No new budget hearing questions were presented. The bulk of the meeting was a presentation by Assistant General Manager Steve Ritchie, followed by commissioner questions and public comment. The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to continue the budget discussion to a special meeting on February 2, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony - Nicole Sandkulla (Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency – BAWSCA): Expressed support for the proposed budgets and 10-year CIP. Highlighted concerns about project delivery delays due to staffing, requested closer involvement in the PUC's capital planning improvements initiative, suggested including delivery metrics for commission tracking, and recommended that the PUC proactively document its history of funding the first two years of the CIP with past appropriations to avoid public perception of inability to deliver. Also noted that BAWSCA's demand projections differ from the PUC's financial planning assumptions, urging clarity on the purpose of each. Discussion Items - Water Enterprise Operating Budget Overview (FY 2024-26): The total water budget is projected to grow from $674.5 million in FY 2023-24 to $765.5 million by FY 2025-26, driven primarily by capital improvements. Key operating requests include: - Conversion of 12 temporary positions to permanent for staff stability. - Three new positions for lead-in-school monitoring (new state regulations requiring sampling at over 200 San Francisco schools). - Two positions for enforcing new hydrant meter regulations to address abuse. - Staffing for the Alameda Creek Watershed Center and native plant nursery. - Moving alternative water supply program staff from temporary to permanent. - $1.5 million increase for treatment chemicals (sodium hypochlorite) due to nationwide supply chain volatility. - Funding for equipment and fleet modernization (including electric vehicle conversion). - Programmatic requests shifted from capital to operating budget, netting a slight decrease. - Hetch Hetchy Water Operating Budget: Growth similarly driven by capital projects, increasing from $95 million in FY 2023-24 to $116 million in FY 2025-26. Highlights include: - Temporary-to-permanent conversions (4 positions) and one new position for a Native American Cultural Resources Management Program to improve tribal relations in the Sierra region. - $2+ million for environmental review of O'Shaughnessy Dam in-stream flow management plan (in collaboration with National Park Service). - Increases for MOAs with National Park Service, Turlock, and Modesto Irrigation Districts for Don Pedro relicensing and habitat improvement. - WECC/NERC compliance upgrades for power infrastructure. - Water Enterprise Capital Programs (10-Year Plan): Three separate programs totaling $3 billion (local water $1.3B, regional water $1.6B, Hetch Hetchy water $1.5B). Key projects: - Local: $604 million for main replacement (including 2000 Marin headquarters construction starting August 2024, $400M project); lead service line replacement program. - Regional: Millbrae Yard campus improvements ($411M) including new lab and office, shops relocation; Snow Valley Water Treatment Plant ozone project ($175M); five major transmission main projects ($196M) to replace aging prestressed concrete cylinder pipe; Los Vaqueros Reservoir Expansion (institutionally complex, with decision pending); four purified water projects (including partnerships with San Mateo, Alameda County, San Jose/Santa Clara, and a San Francisco project coordinated with Wastewater Enterprise). - Hetch Hetchy: Moccasin Penstocks replacement project ($322M, 100-year-old pipelines, leading option is deep shaft and tunnel); Mountain Tunnel improvements; Moccasin Powerhouse generator replacements; San Joaquin Pipeline valve and safety projects; transmission line clearance mitigation. - Commissioner Questions and Feedback: - Commissioner Ajami: Inquired about systematic approach to future contaminant monitoring; chemical cost volatility and implications for alternative water supplies; drought response staffing (half FTE for outreach, now ended); and Native American cultural resources position hiring strategy. Also asked about alignment of recycled water staffing between Water and Wastewater enterprises. - Commissioner Maxwell: Stressed hiring a Native American person for the cultural resources position. Questioned the correlation between 23% vacancy rate and contracting out; requested further information on contract vs. in-house workforce. Sought details on affordability as a service goal (noted under sustainability). Asked about youth programs ($1.3M contribution) and wanted to ensure racial equity is explicitly addressed. Inquired about innovative features of the 2000 Marin project (community layout, solar, hydrogen readiness). - Commissioner Rivera: Supported youth employment and requested a presentation on PUC youth programs. Suggested including a hydrogen fueling station in new facilities, noting successful city-run stations. - Commissioner Stacy: Emphasized collaboration and overlap among divisions, particularly asset management. Asked about classification of operating vs. project positions; clarification on programmatic requests (shift from capital to operating budget); Treasure Island position reduction (system transfer); and landscape conservation program (grant reduction). Noted that WECC/NERC compliance items appear in Hetch Hetchy water budget but are power-funded. - President Paulson: Thanked staff for the comprehensive presentation. Highlighted the importance of investing in aging infrastructure (e.g., penstocks, tunnels). Requested a tour of Alameda Creek Watershed Center and Pillar Citos facilities. Wanted to understand how contract vs. in-house decisions are made. Asked about institutionalized coordination with MTA/Public Works for joint transit projects (response described monthly meetings and successful examples like Taraval and Geary). Key Outcomes - The commission took no vote on the budgets at this meeting; discussion will continue. - A motion to continue the meeting to a special session on Friday, February 2, 2024, at 9:00 AM in Room 416 was moved, seconded, and approved unanimously (5-0).
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on January 29, 2024, at 9:45 AM, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, joined by President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee considered seven items, including infrastructure acceptance for Treasure Island, planning code corrections, fire code amendments for lithium-ion batteries, density calculation changes, and the Gas House Cove Marina project. Several items were voted forward to the full Board, with some amended and continued. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 1-3 (Treasure Island): No public speakers; public comment was closed. - Item 4 (Code Corrections): No public speakers. - Item 5 (Lithium-Ion Batteries): Multiple speakers expressed support for the ordinance, including representatives from the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition, Gateway Tenants Association, San Francisco Firefighters Local 798, and residents. Some speakers raised concerns about definitions, enforcement, and the need for an educational campaign. A speaker from the disabled community noted that mobility devices for disabilities were not covered. The public comment was overwhelmingly supportive of passing the ordinance. - Item 6 (Density Calculation): Several speakers from the Housing Action Coalition and other groups supported the ordinance, arguing it would increase housing supply and vibrant neighborhoods. Opponents, including members of the San Francisco Landers Coalition, argued the measure benefits developers without guaranteeing affordable housing. Some speakers urged caution and transparency. - Item 7 (Marina Yacht Harbor): Dozens of speakers overwhelmingly opposed the project expansion, citing loss of open space, public access, water views, and impacts on swimming, rowing, sailing, and community gatherings. Speakers represented diverse neighborhoods and organizations including the South End Rowing Club, Sierra Club, and the Dolphin Club. Many called for better remediation of pollution and questioned the financial assumptions of the project. Only a few speakers supported aspects of the plan, such as retaining a fuel dock. Discussion Items Items 1-3: Treasure Island Infrastructure Acceptance Anne-Marie Rogers (TIDA) presented three ordinances: accepting street and public infrastructure, acknowledging ferry terminal and other improvements, and delegating park acceptance authority to TIDA. Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey's office) supported the items, noting their importance for the island's transformation. President Peskin raised concerns about the delegation of park authority, requesting clarification that it be limited to parks under the development agreement and include a sunset clause. After discussion, items 1 and 2 were approved as committee reports for the February 6 Board meeting. Item 3 was initially continued to February 5, but later amended and approved to be sent to the Board with amendments clarifying delegation scope and adding a five-year sunset. Item 4: Planning and Administrative Code Corrections Audrey Merlone (Planning Department) presented an ordinance correcting typographical errors and outdated cross-references. President Peskin raised an issue about signage language on pages 24-25, suggesting temporary removal of certain words pending future legislation. The city attorney requested time to review. After public comment, the committee adopted the amendment and sent the ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 5: Fire Code – Lithium-Ion Batteries in Powered Mobility Devices Fire Marshal Ken Coughlin presented amendments to the ordinance, which had been refined through stakeholder meetings. The ordinance sets standards for charging/storage, prohibits damaged or reconditioned batteries, and mandates an informational campaign. President Peskin, who introduced the legislation, noted that fires grew from 12 in 2020 to over 60 last year, with one fatality. The committee heard extensive public support. President Peskin moved amendments that included defining “safety certified powered mobility device” and incorporating a trade-in program intent. The amended ordinance was passed unanimously (3-0) and sent to the full Board. Item 6: Planning Code – Density Calculation in Certain Districts Audrey Merlone presented a proposal to replace numeric density limits with form-based controls in commercial and transit-oriented districts outside priority equity geographies, as part of the Housing Element implementation. Supervisor Safai co-sponsored, citing examples where density decontrol led to more affordable units. President Peskin requested time to prepare amendments addressing potential unintended height increases from state density bonuses in historic districts. Supervisor Preston questioned the lack of neighborhood outreach and whether a feasibility study under Planning Code 415.6 was required. After public comment, the committee voted to continue the item to February 12, 2024, to allow for amendment preparation. Item 7: Implementation of Gas House Cove Project – Marina Yacht Harbor Sarah Madlin (Rec and Park) and budget analyst Alex Thibodeau presented on the proposed marina expansion and its financial impacts. The proposed project would expand the West Harbor by over 150 feet, add 235 slips, and include a breakwater and fuel dock. Under the proposed ordinance restricting expansion, the number of East Harbor slips would drop from 359 to 165, and the total marina slips from 736 to 542, reducing revenue and requiring fee increases of 15-32%. Supervisor Safai and President Peskin argued that the department had not engaged the community adequately and had ignored strong public opposition. They highlighted alternative funding sources and the need to preserve public access and recreational uses. The committee voted 3-0 to amend the ordinance with a technical clarification (not beyond the western edge of the Wave Organ) and send it to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2 (Treasure Island Infrastructure): Approved as committee reports for February 6 Board meeting (3-0). - Item 3 (Treasure Island Park Delegation): Amended with clarifications and five-year sunset; approved as a committee report (3-0). - Item 4 (Code Corrections): Amended to remove signage language; approved as amended (3-0). - Item 5 (Lithium-Ion Batteries): Amended with technical and policy changes; approved as amended (3-0). - Item 6 (Density Calculation): Continued to February 12, 2024 (3-0). - Item 7 (Marina Yacht Harbor): Amended with technical clarification; approved as amended (3-0). All items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors’ agenda on February 6, 2024, unless otherwise stated.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission held a special budget hearing on January 26, 2024, to discuss the proposed Wastewater Enterprise (WWE) operating and capital budgets for fiscal years 2024-25 and 2025-26, and the 10-year capital plan. Commissioners reviewed detailed proposals, heard public testimony, and voted to continue the meeting to January 29, 2024. No final budget approvals were made. Public Comments & Testimony - Jennifer Vataru (Marina resident): Expressed strong opposition to the closure of the Pierce Street Outfall, stating that its decommissioning caused sewage backups in October 2021 and December 2022, displacing her family and endangering the community. She called on the commission to add repair of the outfall to the current budget for health and safety. Staff clarified that the outfall closure was studied and was not found to be the cause of the flooding, but agreed to provide additional information to the commission. Discussion Items 3. Summary of Budget Hearing Questions - Commissioners acknowledged a thorough response to prior questions; no further discussion. Commissioner Stacey thanked staff for addressing concerns about the loss of a school program. 4. Proposed Bureau Operating Budgets for FY2024-25 and FY2025-26 (Wastewater Enterprise) - Joel Prater (Acting WWE AGM) presented the $428 million budget growing 23% to $525 million over two years. Key drivers: debt service and capital projects. Proposed 10 new positions and 4 temp-to-perm transitions, with 28 substitutions to minimize costs. - Operating budget requests included: - 25% insurance cost increase (risk management). - $1 million for UC Berkeley Center for Smart Infrastructure ($500K from WWE). - Expansion of residential green infrastructure grant program (300 interested residents). - New positions for green infrastructure maintenance, gardeners, operations (chemicals and sludge removal), collection system (asset management, laterals, pre-treatment), and lab (business analysts and chemists). - Overtime budget increase to avoid mid-cycle supplements (requesting $600K for current year). - Southeast Community Center: converting temp positions to permanent recreation facility assistants and adding admin support; continuing digital inclusion program funded by adbacks. - Commissioner Ajami urged using climate change as a primary lens across all budget lines, not merely a bullet point. She stressed the need to aggregate climate-related costs and risks. - Commissioner Maxwell questioned the green infrastructure pilot uptake and overtime policy. - Commissioner Stacey praised materials and endorsed the smart infrastructure investment, racial equity in hiring (e.g., eliminating unnecessary education requirements for community center roles), and requested updates on sedimentation studies. - Commissioner Rivera supported the green infrastructure program and asked about potential resident engagement growth. 4. Capital Budget Presentation - WWE presented a 10-year capital plan driven by operational reliability, seismic resilience, safety, and stormwater management (1.3 inches / 5-year storm). - Major projects: - Biosolids Digester (BDFP): $2.6B total, 45% complete, cost increases from single bidders and material costs. - Folsom Stormwater: $430M total, to upgrade combined sewer in Mission District (flood mitigation). - Lower Alemany: $300M pipe project (mandated by regional board after green infrastructure alternative rejected due to timeline). - Nutrient Removal: $1.47B placeholder; planning to begin now, with pilot side-stream treatment underway. - Southeast Outfall Replacement: $2.9B (mostly beyond 10-year plan), $80M in 10-year plan for planning/env review. Staff noted complexity due to multiple jurisdictions and potential alignment with waterfront adaptation. - Green Infrastructure: $100M capital plan shift to performance-based approach, targeting 65 acres of drainage management in 10 years. - Commissioners raised concerns about integration of nutrient removal and outfall projects, regional collaboration (e.g., with water agencies on recycled water), and long-term affordability. Finance staff mentioned seeking federal grants to offset ratepayer burden. - Commissioner Ajami expressed disappointment that the regional board forced a pipe over green infrastructure for Alemany, but praised interagency collaboration (MTA, SFUSD, Rec Park). - Commissioner Maxwell asked if nutrient removal could include recycled water production; staff noted this will be evaluated during planning. - Commissioner Stacey highlighted the complexity of the Southeast Outfall and the importance of recycling for bay health. Key Outcomes - No votes on budget items were taken; the hearing was purely informational and for public input. - Motion to continue the meeting to Monday, January 29, 2024, was approved unanimously (5 ayes). - Staff agreed to provide the commission with additional information on the Pierce Street Outfall closure rationale and potential budget implications.
The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, January 25, 2024. President Diamond was absent; Commissioner Tanner had resigned to become Director of Citywide Planning. The Commission considered continuances, consent items, commission matters, an informational budget presentation, an informational presentation on the SF Gateway Project, and a Conditional Use Authorization for 2351 Mission Street. All votes taken during the meeting passed unanimously, 5-0. Consent Calendar - Items 6, 7, and 8 were approved unanimously: 1075 Market Street Unit 605 and 16 Jessie Street Unit 410 (Intermediate Length Occupancy units) and 3820 24th Street (Curo Pet Care animal hospital expansion). - Item 5 (520 John Muir Drive) was removed from the consent calendar at the request of Eileen Boken and heard separately. Public Comments & Testimony - In general public comment, Eileen Boken discussed SB 951 and coastal zone issues, questioning how the legislation was drafted and its relationship to coastal permitting decisions. She stated she supports soil remediation but raised transparency concerns. - Tomorovich (Livable City) urged the Planning Department to revive comprehensive neighborhood planning for the Western Edition and Bayview, arguing these communities deserve long-term planning conversations, especially regarding equitable development and redevelopment-related harms. Commission Matters - The Commission acknowledged the Ramaytush Ohlone as the original stewards of the land. - Minutes from January 11, 2024 were adopted unanimously. - Vice President Moore led a recognition of former President Tanner, who said she was leaving the Commission to become the Planning Department's Director of Citywide Planning. Commissioners offered thanks and praised her leadership. - Commissioner Moore raised concerns about state density bonus and upzoning, noting that objective standards such as tower separation and seismic safety are rooted in life-safety science. She requested that the department involve fire safety and seismic experts when evaluating standards. - Commissioner Imperial suggested forming subcommittees to delve into such issues. - Director Hillis announced that the department would hold two informational hearings in February on rezoning proposals. - Aaron Starr, Manager of Legislative Affairs, reported that the Board of Supervisors Land Use Committee continued the code corrections ordinance, the state ADU ordinance, and the constraints reduction ordinance; Westwood Park entrance gateways and pillars passed first read 10-1; and an appeal for 2395 Sacramento Street was continued to February 6. Discussion Items Item 5: 520 John Muir Drive – Coastal Zone Permit - The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission requested approval to demolish seven one-story recreational structures and remediate contaminated soil around four former skeet-shooting fields on an approximately 11-acre site at Lake Merced West. Approximately 4,800 cubic yards of soil would be removed and four eucalyptus trees would be taken down; work would last about three months, with completion anticipated by late summer 2024. The project is Phase 1 of a larger project whose EIR was certified in January 2023. - Eileen Boken spoke in support of the remediation but identified what she called inaccuracies in the project description and inconsistencies between the coastal zone permit and the Local Coastal Program. - Commissioner Imperial said the project is aligned with the previously certified EIR and moved to approve. The Commission approved the permit with conditions unanimously (5-0). Item 15: FY2024-2026 Proposed Department Budget and Work Program (Informational) - Budget analyst Katie Lay presented. The Mayor's Office projects citywide general fund deficits of $245 million in FY24-25 and $554 million in FY25-26, a total of $799 million over two years. Departments were asked to cut general fund spending by 10%. - The Planning Department proposes a $920,000 reduction in general fund support and a $3 million reduction in fee revenue, mainly through keeping positions vacant and reducing contracts. Personnel costs are expected to be 63% of the budget in the budget year and 70% in the out-year. Staff noted the FTE count would decline from 225.6 to 207.55. - The budget equity tool found that 23% of work programs would center equity in FY24-25. - Commissioners expressed support for maintaining racial and social equity programs and asked about internship programs and equity training. Director Hillis said the department is prioritizing housing element implementation, transportation element, and community planning, but acknowledged limited capacity. - No vote was taken; the item was informational. Item 16: San Francisco Gateway Project (749 Toland Street / 2000 McKinnon Avenue) – Informational - Planning staff and Prologis presented a proposal to replace four older PDR buildings (448,000 sq ft) with two multi-story buildings containing over one million sq ft of active PDR space, plus support space, totaling about two million sq ft. The project would create approximately 2,100 construction jobs and support over 2,000 permanent on-site jobs. It would also build out eight city blocks with sidewalks, crosswalks, and lighting. - Public comment was overwhelmingly supportive. Speakers included community members, local contractors, the Market Zone Working Group, and representatives from multiple trade unions (Teamsters, Sheet Metal Workers, Plumbers, Elevator Constructors, Bricklayers, Glaziers, Painters, Sprinkler Fitters, etc.). They emphasized local hire, union jobs, and community benefits. - Commissioners praised the project and the engagement process. Commissioner Koppel highlighted the importance of blue-collar jobs and local apprentices. No vote was taken; the item was informational. Item 17: 2351 Mission Street (Casements) – Conditional Use Authorization - The restaurant Casements requested permission to convert 1,800 square feet of a public parking lot (10 of 81 spaces) into an outdoor activity area, including outdoor dining and amplified entertainment, and to expand its existing liquor service. The Planning Department recommended approval with conditions limiting outdoor hours to 9 a.m.–10 p.m. - Public comment was split. Supporters called the patio a vital safe space for queer and immigrant communities and noted the economic difficulty of closing early. Opponents, including neighbors from Cap Street and surrounding blocks, reported excessive noise, particularly from live music, that affected their homes and quality of life; they urged a strict 10 p.m. curfew. - Vice President Moore expressed support for the staff recommendation and added a condition requiring an on-site community liaison with a published contact number and a requirement that unresolved issues be reported to the Zoning Administrator. The Commission approved the CUA with conditions unanimously (5-0). Key Outcomes - All motions passed unanimously (5-0): 1. Continuances for Items 1A/B, 2, 3, and 18A/B approved; Item 4 withdrawn. 2. Consent Calendar Items 6, 7, 8 approved. 3. Minutes of January 11, 2024 adopted. 4. Coastal Zone Permit for 520 John Muir Drive approved with conditions. 5. Conditional Use Authorization for 2351 Mission Street approved with conditions, including a 10 p.m. outdoor activity curfew and a community liaison condition.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on January 25, 2024, with Chair Supervisor Catherine Stephanie presiding. Vice Chair Ingario was present, and Member Supervisor Matt Dorsey was excused. The meeting focused on a single hearing regarding a liquor license transfer for Pink House by the Bay at 800 Bay Street. Discussion Items - Liquor License Transfer (Item 231289): The committee considered a person-to-person, premise-to-premise transfer of a Type 20 off-sale beer and wine license to Pink House by the Bay LLC, doing business as Pink House by the Bay, located at 800 Bay Street. Officer Salmuson from the SFPD ABC Liaison unit presented the application, noting zero letters of protest or support. The location is in police district 106 (high crime) and census tract 10202 (high saturation). The police department had no opposition. The Planning Department (LU) recommended approval with a condition: the petitioner shall actively monitor the area under their control to prevent loitering on any property adjacent to the licensed premise. Chair Stephanie confirmed the item is in her district and indicated she was fine with it. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke or submitted written comments during the meeting. Key Outcomes - Motion and Vote: Chair Stephanie moved to have the clerk prepare a resolution finding that the issuance of the liquor license transfer would serve the public convenience or necessity. The motion passed unanimously with two ayes (Chair Stephanie and Vice Chair Ingario), Member Dorsey being excused. The resolution was forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation for the February 6, 2024 meeting. - Condition: The approval is subject to the condition that the licensee actively monitor adjacent areas to prevent loitering, as per ABC Form 253.
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on January 24, 2024, to consider 15 agenda items, including grants, contracts, budget reserves, and reimbursements for the APEC summit. The committee approved most items, often with recommendations, and heard extensive public comment on mid-year budget cuts and APEC spending. Regular Agenda Items - Item 1 (Grant for Overdose Prevention Initiative): Ordinance to accept $1,086,740.83 from CDPH and amend salary ordinance. Continued from last week and amended; passed unanimously (2-0-1, Melgar absent). - Item 2 (CleanPowerSF Bank Credit Facility): Ordinance to authorize amendments to credit facility for up to $150M over 10 years. Passed 3-0. - Item 3 (Contract Modification – Alameda Electrical Distributors): Resolution to increase contract by $600,000 to $10.5M. Continued to January 31, 2024, at department request. Passed 3-0. - Items 4 & 5 (DPH Grants): Retroactive grant agreements – $6,774,965 for crisis stabilization unit at 822 Geary St and $3,973,298 for Tobacco Prevention Program. Passed 3-0. - Item 6 (Declaration of Restrictions – 1450 Owens St): Resolution to establish no-build easement on city property for fire access, with annual payments of $72,000. Passed 3-0. - Item 7 (Pretrial Diversion Contract Amendment): Resolution to increase contract by $499,000 to $19.8M. BLA report noted lack of audited financials and program performance concerns. Committee forwarded to full board without recommendation, accepting BLA recommendations including a cost-benefit analysis. Passed 3-0. - Item 8 (Port Grant – Amador Street Infrastructure): Resolution to accept $9.6M federal grant for road and utility improvements. Passed 3-0. - Item 9 (Loan Amendment – 1000 Market St Affordable Housing): Resolution to increase MOHCD loan by $1.9M to $12.8M for rehabilitation of 58-unit SRO. Passed 3-0. - Items 10-12 (State Housing Grants – 850 Turk St & 750 Golden Gate Ave): Resolutions to accept $8.1M Infill Infrastructure Grant, $32M Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities award, and support for $10M Local Government Matching Grant application. Total of 167 affordable units planned. Passed 3-0. - Item 13 (Appropriation Reserve – Mid-Year Budget Cuts): Ordinance to place $48.4M of mayor's mid-year cuts on committee reserve, allowing further review. Passed 3-0. - Items 14 & 15 (APEC Funding): Resolution to accept $6.5M grant from Special Events Committee for police overtime, and hearing to release $6.5M from reserve to cover APEC costs. Net city cost after philanthropy estimated at $20M. Item 14 passed with recommendation; Item 15 passed without recommendation (hearing filed). Passed 3-0. Public Comments - Item 13: Multiple speakers, including representatives from Larkin Street Youth Services, Latino Parity and Equity Coalition, ECS, Compass Family Services, Housing Rights Committee, and former Supervisor John Avalos, urged the committee to restore cuts to community programs, food security, workforce development, and legal aid, citing disproportionate impacts on communities of color. - Items 14 & 15: Extensive public comment opposed to releasing APEC funds, with speakers citing police brutality, displacement of unhoused people, losses to small businesses (estimated $3.5M+ loss in Yerba Buena area), and calling for funds to be redirected to housing, worker rights, child care, and community gardens. Supporters of APEC highlighted its positive global visibility and economic impact ($62M estimated). Key Outcomes - All 15 agenda items were approved or continued as noted. No items were rejected. - The committee accepted BLA recommendations for Item 7, including a cost-benefit analysis of contracting vs. in-house pretrial services. - For Item 15, the committee released $6.5M from reserve without recommendation, acknowledging the ongoing budget deficit and community concerns. - Chair Chan and Supervisor Dorsey announced a supplemental proposal to create an APEC Small Business Resilience Fund to compensate affected businesses in the exclusion zone. - The committee placed $48.4M in mid-year budget cuts on reserve to facilitate further negotiations.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Tuesday, January 23, 2024, at 10:15 AM. The meeting covered consent items, several ordinances and resolutions, committee appointments, a special commendation, and public testimony on the proposed closure of the Fillmore Safeway store. The board approved the mayor's appointment of Greg Wagner as Controller and debated the appointment of Janet Tarlov to the Municipal Transportation Agency Board of Directors. Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved minutes from December 5 and 12, 2023. - Passed ordinances and resolutions on consent, including: - Authorization of American Registry for Internet Numbers agreements (Item 4) - Grants for the District Attorney (Items 6-7): $2,050,000 for organized retail theft prosecution and $1,200,000 for the Safety and Justice Challenge - Waiver of competitive bidding for organized retail theft grant procurement (Item 8) - Grants for Building Inspection (Item 9, $100,000), Children, Youth & Families (Item 10, $1,000,000), Public Library (Item 12, $375,000), and others - Adoption of a fixed two-year budget cycle (Item 13) - Amendment to Treasure Island Master Lease with the U.S. Navy (Item 14) - Grant for Juvenile Probation (Item 15, $360,570) and for domestic violence program (Item 16, $305,850.45) Discussion Items - Item 17: Emergency Declaration – Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital – Resolution to approve emergency repairs to chiller, boiler, and cooling tower with costs exceeding $250,000 (estimated $47 million). Supervisor Chan flagged the lack of a not-to-exceed amount and announced future amendments to Administrative Code Section 6.6. Passed same house, same call. - Item 18: Existing Building Code – Supplemental Inspections for Tall Buildings – Ordinance requiring buildings 15+ stories to conduct inspections of windows and exterior glass every five years, prompted by window failures during a 2023 windstorm. Passed first reading. - Item 19: Conditional Property Exchange Agreement – Kensington Way LLC – Resolution authorizing exchange of vacant land on Edgehill Mountain for city property near Moraga and Noriega avenues. Passed unanimously. - Item 20: Planning Code – Landmark Designation – Westwood Park Entrance Gateways and Pillars – Ordinance sponsored by Supervisor Melgar to landmark historic entrance structures. Debate included discussion of racist restrictive covenants removed by the homeowners association. Roll call: 10 ayes, 1 no (Supervisor Preston). Passed first reading. - Item 21: Health Code – Regulating Medical Specimen Test Collection Sites – Ordinance making violations a misdemeanor and public health nuisance. Unanimously passed first reading. - Item 22: Support for SOMA Pilipinas Gateway Cultural Marker – Resolution continued one week due to administrative error. - Items 23-24: Liquor License Transfers – Two resolutions approving license transfer to 690 Sacramento Street and issuance to 177 Eddy Street. Adopted unanimously. - Item 25: Campaign and Governmental Conduct Code – Form 700 Filers – Ordinance clarifying conflict-of-interest filing requirements. Passed first reading. - Item 30: Settlement of Claims – SFPUC Water Pipeline Break – Ordinance authorizing settlements up to $7 million aggregate for the September 10, 2023 pipeline break at Fillmore and Green streets. Passed first reading. - Item 31: Mayoral Appointment – Municipal Transportation Agency Board – Janet Tarlov – Supervisor Preston opposed, citing lack of transit expertise; others supported her small business perspective. Roll call: 10 ayes, 1 no (Supervisor Preston). Appointment approved. - Item 32: Mayoral Appointment – Controller – Greg Wagner – Unanimously approved (11-0) to a 10-year term. Wagner pledged honesty, integrity, and data-driven decision-making. Public Comments & Testimony - ADA Accommodation Speaker (public comment before minutes) praised the board's ceasefire resolution on Gaza and thanked Supervisor Preston. - General Public Comment (after introductions) included over 20 speakers. Several speakers urged the board to keep the Fillmore Safeway open: residents, community leaders, and representatives from Japan Town and the Fillmore United Alliance spoke about the critical need for the grocery store, especially for seniors, disabled, and low-income families. Many thanked Supervisor Preston for his resolution and urged passage. Reverend Amos Brown stressed historical discrimination and the need for community involvement. Other speakers: library advocates requested restored evening hours; an individual raised concerns about the Public Utilities Commission and alleged surveillance; a speaker criticized the city's handling of Laguna Honda Hospital; a speaker identified as an unhoused journalist expressed frustration with blight. - Public Hearing on 2395 Sacramento Street (Items 26-29) – No speakers; item continued to February 6, 2024, at the parties' request. Special Order - 2:30 PM – Commendation for Dr. Hallie Hammer – Recognized for 30 years of service to the Department of Public Health, including leadership in ambulatory care, behavioral health, and COVID-19 response. Dr. Hammer and Director Colfax spoke. Key Outcomes - Approved appointment of Greg Wagner as Controller (11-0). - Approved appointment of Janet Tarlov to MTA Board (10-1). - Passed ordinance requiring supplemental inspections for tall buildings (Item 18). - Passed landmark designation for Westwood Park gateways (Item 20, 10-1). - Passed medical specimen test collection site regulations (Item 21). - Continued SOMA Pilipinas cultural marker to January 30, 2024. - Continued hearing on 2395 Sacramento Street to February 6, 2024. - Adopted Resolution Urging Safeway to Reverse Closure of Fillmore Store (Item 35, as amended) – Unanimously adopted; amendment noted Safeway's announcement to extend closure from March 2024 to January 2025. - Supervisor Preston announced intention to introduce the Neighborhood Grocery Protection Act requiring six months' notice and community engagement for grocery store closures. - Supervisor Stephanie announced plans for legislation banning algorithmic rent-fixing software, a hearing on SB 43 implementation, and a review of contractor labor practices. - Supervisor Mandelman sent a letter of inquiry to City College trustees regarding governance concerns and the chancellor's departure. - Meeting adjourned in memory of several individuals, including Dexter Scott King, Joan Holden, Jim Hurley, Ruben Winkler, Richard Darnell May, Eddie Lee Cottrell, Dejan Milojević, Richard Perina, and Joshua Coffey.
The Port Commission convened on January 23, 2024 at 10:15 AM, with Vice President Willie Adams presiding. Commissioners present: Gail Gillman, Stephen Lee; Ed Harrington absent. The meeting included election of officers, the Executive Director's 2024 lookahead, consent calendar approval, an economic recovery update, and endorsement of a term sheet for the Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330 project. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Amend and restate Lease No. L-16997 with YMCA for Building 49 in Crane Cove Park (Resolution 2401). - Item 10B: Accept and expend $7,800,000 grant from California Coastal Conservancy for Southern Embarcadero Resilience and Enhancement Project (Resolution 2402). - Item 10C: Accept improvements, approve amendment to DDA for Pier 70 Phase 1 (Resolutions 2403 & 2404). - Item 10D: Conditional no-cost transfer of abandoned historical artworks to a cultural institution (Resolution 2405). - Item 10E: Accept and expend $200,000 grant from MTC for multi-space parking pay stations (Resolution 2406). - Item 10F: Award $2,117,010 construction contract for South Beach Marina Repairs to Yerba Buena Engineering & Construction (Resolution 2407). - Item 10G: Award $1,558,275 construction contract for Hyde Street Harbor Repairs to Yerba Buena Engineering & Construction (Resolution 2408). All consent items were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Election of Officers (Item 9A): One caller initially misunderstood the item but did not comment. No other public comment. - Executive Director's Report (Item 9B): No public comment. - Consent Calendar (Item 10): No public comment. - Economic Recovery (Item 11A): No public comment. - Piers 30-32 & Seawall Lot 330 (Item 12A): Multiple speakers expressed support: - Dan Torres (Sprinkler Fitters Local 483, Building Trades trustee) spoke in favor, citing union jobs and the pool. - Alan Dundas raised concerns about state density bonus law compliance and Prop C requirements. - Mike Gowerty (San Francisco Bay Ferry/WETA) thanked the Port for partnership and emphasized the facility's importance for emergency response. - Zach Montesis (water polo coach, real estate professional) strongly supported the aquatic center and housing. - Greg Hardiman (Elevator Constructors Local 8) supported, noting job creation, sea level rise, and public fishing. - Rudy Gonzalez (San Francisco Building Trades Council) urged adoption, praising the developer's community engagement. - Alice Rogers (South Beach community) appreciated extended community outreach. - Joe Riley (emergency manager) supported for maritime emergency response capabilities. - Julie Rome (SF Travel) supported for tourism, cruise ship berth, and economic benefits. - Eddie Reyes (Iron Workers Local 377) supported for union construction jobs and infrastructure. - Tyson Bell (Tsunami Swim Team) supported for aquatic sports access. Discussion Items - Election of Port Commission President and Vice President (Item 9A): Commissioner Adams nominated Kimberly Brandon for President; seconded and approved unanimously. Commissioner Brandon nominated Gail Gilman for Vice President; approved unanimously. Both gave acceptance remarks. - Executive Director's Report (Item 9B): Director Elaine Forbes presented the 2024 lookahead, highlighting priorities: clean, safe, vibrant waterfront; economic recovery; Fisherman's Wharf revitalization; waterfront leasing; development projects (Piers 30-32, 38-40, 45); resilience (flood study, Prop A bond); equity (REAP 2.0, psychological safety, data, hiring/promotions). Staffing increases and new technology tools were noted. Commissioners praised the report and discussed labor, housing, and safety. - Economic Recovery & Expenditure Plan (Item 11A): Megan [last name not given] presented an overview of $64.4 million in combined funding sources (including $10 million harbor funds, $10.4 million tenant attraction/retention, $36 million in port infrastructure grants, $8 million Southern Waterfront beautification). The plan focuses on Fisherman's Wharf (activation, beautification, ice machine, gangway/float) and Southern Waterfront (maritime improvements, parks, Blue Greenway). Commissioners discussed the need for clearer reporting on Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund spending and safety concerns. The commission approved the expenditure plan for the $10 million economic recovery project (Resolution 2409) to be submitted to the Board of Supervisors for release of funds. - Piers 30-32 & Seawall Lot 330 Term Sheet (Item 12A): Wyatt [last name not given] presented the project: up to 713 residential units (25% affordable including on-site inclusionary and a dedicated 100% affordable building), 375,000 sq ft office, 70,000 sq ft retail/market hall, aquatic center (50-meter pool), deep water berth, and reconstruction of piers and seawall (estimated $460 million horizontal improvements). Financing includes CFD/IFD, and a $125 million gap may be filled by market improvement or public sources. Ground leases: 66 years for piers ($900,000/yr), 75 years for seawall lot ($600,000/yr with CPI adjustments, increasing to $1.8 million if milestones missed). Port participates in upside (20% of net proceeds above 18% IRR). DEI plan includes swim access, BIPOC artisan retail, affordable housing partner selection, LBE/WBE goals, and project labor agreement. Two ENA amendments: 18-month extension and allowance for strata to transfer investors without commission approval (provided Strata retains control). Public comment was overwhelmingly supportive. Commissioners endorsed the term sheet and approved the ENA amendments (Resolution 2410) unanimously. Key Outcomes - Elected Kimberly Brandon as Port Commission President and Gail Gilman as Vice President (unanimous). - Approved consent calendar items 10A-10G (Resolutions 2401-2408) unanimously. - Approved Resolution 2409: Endorsed the economic recovery expenditure plan for the $10 million fund and authorized staff to seek release from the Board of Supervisors. - Approved Resolution 2410: Endorsed the non-binding term sheet for the Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330 project, and approved amendments to the Exclusive Negotiating Agreement with Strata-TCC Partners (18-month extension and investor transfer provision). - Directed staff to provide a report on security of abandoned Southern Waterfront buildings and to present a proposal for future allocation of Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund with project-level details.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held its regular meeting on January 23, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The meeting was called to order with a quorum (President Paulson, Vice President Rivera, Commissioners Maxwell, Jamy, and Stacy). The commission acknowledged the unceded lands of the Muwekma Ohlone tribe. Item 6 (BAWSCA update) was pulled from the agenda, and item 15 (closed session litigation) was rescheduled. The meeting covered the approval of minutes, general public comment, a human resources update, consent calendar items, and three regular calendar items: a watershed management agreement with Yosemite National Park, an increase in power sales contract revenue authority, and an amendment to the General Manager’s employment contract. The commission also entered closed session for two litigation items. Consent Calendar - Minutes of January 9, 2024: Approved unanimously with no corrections. - Consent Calendar Items 7a–7i: Approved unanimously. These included amendments to contracts for engineering services, time and cost contingencies, and acceptance of completed work. Notable discussion occurred on item 7a (Lower Alemany Area Stormwater Improvement Project): an additional $2 million was needed due to a tunnel realignment prompted by Caltrans feedback that an off-ramp closure would be too disruptive. The project is at 65% design. Commissioner Jamy expressed concern about communication with Caltrans, noting a similar issue on the Folsom project. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 4): Spreck Rosecrans (Restore Hetch Hetchy) thanked the commission for projects around Hetch Hetchy Reservoir (safer Wapama Falls Bridge, boat ramp repair, potable water at campsites). Other speakers raised concerns about the Bayview Hunters Point waste treatment facility: a 5% community benefit commitment (approximately $15 million based on a $300 million project) and the status of a stationary engineer training program. Lassonia Mansfield and Demetrius Williams (San Francisco Hyperlocal Building Trades Contractors Collective) requested reinstatement of the stationary engineer program and resources for community training. - Public Comment on Item 5 (HR Update): A speaker criticized the lack of progress on the contracting center model for community workforce development. - Public Comment on Item 8 (Yosemite MOA): Spreck Rosecrans opposed the agreement, arguing it poorly describes the Raker Act and discriminates against park visitors; he urged the commission not to approve it. Discussion Items - Item 5: Report of the General Manager – Human Resources Update - Wendy Macy, Chief People Officer, and Melissa White presented. The raw vacancy rate for permanent funded positions is trending downward despite adding over 100 positions. The SFPUC now has over 2,000 filled positions. The average time to fill a position has decreased from 275 to 175 days. The HR division is reorganizing from siloed units into cross-functional client-centered pods (e.g., a dedicated pod for Power Enterprise). Two new recruiters are on board, focusing on outreach and branding. Commissioners discussed retention, job title flexibility, the need to re-evaluate education/experience requirements, and the importance of tracking candidates and outcomes. Commissioner Stacy asked about pre-COVID vacancy rates; Macy indicated data reliability has improved recently. Commissioner Maxwell asked whether the process is sufficient to meet staffing needs; Macy responded that strategies are sound and the agency is trending in the right direction. - Item 8: Yosemite National Park Watershed Management Memorandum of Agreement - Margaret Hanniford (manager of Hetch Hetchy Water Division) presented the agreement with the National Park Service for comprehensive management of watersheds within Yosemite. The $40,958,727, 4-year agreement supports source water protection, environmental stewardship, and security of SFPUC facilities. The agreement is required to maintain filtration avoidance designation under the Safe Drinking Water Act. The commission approved it 5-0. - Item 9: Increase in Power Sales Contract Revenue Authority - Julia O'Geen (director of origination and power supply) requested approval to increase the annual revenue cap for power sales contracts exceeding $1 million from $10 million to $20 million per year through July 1, 2025. The increase is needed due to higher wholesale electricity prices driven by global shortages and supply chain disruptions. The commission approved the increase and authorized the General Manager to seek Board of Supervisors approval. Commissioners discussed the cap, market volatility, and waivers for city policies (e.g., LBE, prevailing wage) that do not apply to short-term commodity transactions. Barbara Hale (AGM for Power) clarified that waivers are reported quarterly. - Item 10: Amendment to General Manager’s Employment Contract - President Paulson explained that the contract with General Manager Dennis Herrera had a two-year reopener. After a performance review, the commission approved an amendment to set the salary at the midpoint of Range C of the Department Head 5 salary schedule. The motion passed 5-0. Key Outcomes - Approved Minutes of January 9, 2024 (5-0). - Consent Calendar passed (5-0). - Item 8 (Yosemite MOA) approved (5-0). - Item 9 (Power Sales Authority) approved (5-0). - Item 10 (GM Contract Amendment) approved (5-0). - Closed Session: The commission asserted attorney-client privilege and held closed session on two litigation items (Nicholas Navarro claim settlement and another unlitigated claim). After closed session, the commission voted not to disclose discussions. - Next Meeting: A budget hearing is scheduled for Friday, January 26, 2024, at 9:00 AM in Room 416. - Commissioner Jamy requested a survey of other commissions regarding remote public comment options; staff will follow up within a day.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronin with Vice Chair Supervisor Shamann Walton and Supervisor Ahsha Safai, met on January 22, 2024, at approximately 10:15 a.m. (listed as 18:15 UTC) to consider four mayoral appointments: the Controller, two seats on the Food Security Task Force, one seat on the Elections Commission, and one seat on the Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) Board of Directors. All items were advanced to the full Board with positive recommendations after unanimous votes. Public Comments & Testimony - Food Security Task Force: One speaker, a person experiencing homelessness, thanked the committee for prioritizing food security and stressed the need for stricter food safety standards at pantries serving the homeless population. - Elections Commission: Multiple speakers supported Kelly Wong’s candidacy: - Finn Palomero (Dolores Street Community Services) praised Wong’s commitment to democratic processes and uplifting immigrant communities. - Vincent Pan (Chinese for Affirmative Action) highlighted Wong’s work in immigrant rights and noted that CAA would implement firewalls to ensure she does not engage in campaign election activities, in compliance with commission rules. - Wendy Aaudubon (Urban Habitat) emphasized the importance of language justice and representation for non-citizens, referencing the 2016 Prop N allowing non-citizens to vote in school board elections (upheld by appellate court in August). - Kevin Williams, a resident, supported Wong as a bright, moral, and ethical person. - Another speaker (Brent Turner) urged the incoming commissioner to be well-versed in open-source election software, citing potential cost savings and national security benefits. - SFMTA Board: Several speakers endorsed Janet Tarlov: - Paul Terry (small business advisor) praised Tarlov’s broad business perspective from running Canyon Market. - Flo Kelly (Stop Poverty Tows coalition) appreciated Tarlov’s empathy toward low-income residents facing fines and towing. - Seth Brenzel (resident) noted Tarlov’s collaborative work with merchants and citywide perspective through the Council of District Merchants Associations. - A Small Business Commission member highlighted Tarlov’s thoughtful, diplomatic approach. - Another long-time acquaintance emphasized Tarlov’s integrity and care for all stakeholders. Discussion Items 1. Mayoral Appointment of Greg Wagner as Controller (File 240033) - Chair Ronin introduced the item, expressing strong support for Wagner, noting his 17 years in city financial management (as Mayor’s Budget Director and CFO/COO of the Department of Public Health). She stated he maintains the trust of everyone and called his nomination a “perfect choice.” - Wagner thanked the committee and emphasized his commitment to independence, data-driven decision-making, and collaboration. He acknowledged a challenging financial period with an $800 million projected deficit over two years, driven by 40 million square feet of vacant downtown office space, slow recovery of hotel/sales taxes, and property tax devaluation. He outlined priorities: using the controller’s office to analyze the structural deficit, improve contract administration with nonprofits (including consistent COLAs and streamlined monitoring), and continue robust auditing. - Supervisor Walton asked how Wagner would handle decisions contrary to the appointing authority. Wagner replied that independence is guided by the City Charter, which requires both independent judgment and collaboration with the Mayor’s Office and Board. - Supervisor Safai discussed the need for expanded auditing of departments like Public Health and Homeless Supportive Housing (referring to a recent ballot measure he led). Safai also emphasized the controller’s role as an arbiter providing data and recommendations. Wagner agreed to meet regularly with board members and use the city performance unit to analyze service consolidation and vacant positions. - Outgoing Controller Ben Rosenfield praised Wagner as an honest broker with a belief in government’s ability to do good, citing his problem-solving approach. - Public comment: None. - Amendment and vote: Chair Ronin offered an amendment to clarify the term start date (“the latter of the effective date of this motion or the resignation of Controller Ben Rosenfield”) and to delete the word “rejects” throughout. The amendment passed unanimously. The committee then voted unanimously to send the amended appointment to the full Board as a committee report with positive recommendation. 2. Appointments to the Food Security Task Force (File 231186) - Two applicants for two seats (Seats 18 and 19): - Hannah Grant (Associate Director of Nutrition Services, Meals on Wheels of San Francisco) stated she is a registered dietitian and emphasized food security as essential for health equity. She said the task force’s biennial report should use data and personal stories to demonstrate the importance of food security services. - Laura Jones (Program Manager, Leah’s Pantry) described her work with CalFresh Healthy Living and the Department of Disability and Aging to conduct needs assessments and engage older adults and adults with disabilities. She highlighted the negative impact of the end of COVID-era food supports, noting longer lines at food banks. - Public comment: One speaker thanked the committee and urged stricter processes for food handling. - Vote: A motion to recommend Hannah Grant for Seat 18 and Laura Jones for Seat 19 was passed unanimously. 3. Appointment to the Elections Commission (File 240013) – Term ending January 1, 2029 - Two applicants for one seat: - Ruth Cowitz (product manager in tech) said she would bring data analytics and stakeholder management skills. She had hosted a polling station in her garage in 2022. She emphasized accessibility but deferred to commissioners for specific outreach ideas. - Kelly Wong (immigrant rights community advocate at Chinese for Affirmative Action, CAA) is a non-citizen from Hong Kong. She has hosted in-language workshops and a Cantonese podcast to explain voting rights. She stated her commitment to increasing voter participation among immigrant communities, promoting culturally competent language access, and collaborating with trusted organizations. She noted she had spoken with the Elections Commission President, Director, and several commissioners, and would serve on the community input subcommittee. - Public comment: Five speakers (details above) supported Kelly Wong. One speaker also urged the commission to consider open-source voting systems. - Vote: Supervisor Safai moved to appoint Kelly Wong, noting the critical need for representation of immigrant communities with language barriers. Chair Ronin thanked Ruth Cowitz and promised to find another way for her to serve. The motion passed unanimously. 4. Mayoral Appointment of Janet Tarlov to SFMTA Board (File 231254) – Term ending March 1, 2024 - Janet Tarlov (co-founder of Canyon Market in Glen Park, former president of Glen Park Merchants Association, and vice president of Council of District Merchants Associations) described her 16 years running a grocery store employing 100 staff, serving 1,700 customers daily, and dealing with parking, loading, and construction issues. She said she supports safe, reliable, clean, and affordable transit and wants to improve community outreach, particularly to merchants. - Questions: - Supervisor Walton asked about vehicularly housed residents (people living in cars/RVs). Tarlov expressed empathy and said agencies must collaborate to provide secure parking with sanitation and power. - On fare increases, Tarlov said revenue is critical but affordability must be preserved for low-income, disabled, senior, and student riders; she would work to avoid fare hikes without service cuts. - On poverty tows, Tarlov admitted she was unfamiliar with the term but after explanation agreed that towing is a drastic step and fines can be burdensome. She promised to study existing policies to ease burdens. - Supervisor Safai asked about her use of public transit. Tarlov said she primarily bikes but recently has been riding Muni more (took the M line to the hearing). She noted she was pleasantly surprised by cleanliness and operator professionalism. - Safai raised the issue of SFMTA’s poor outreach to merchants. Tarlov acknowledged that as a business owner she experienced inadequate outreach and would prioritize improving communication, including a direct liaison per supervisorial district. She confirmed that outreach is her top priority. - Chair Ronin asked about Vision Zero. Tarlov said safety is paramount; she supports infrastructure changes like speed humps, bulb-outs, and daylighting, even if unpopular. She called pedestrian and cyclist deaths heartbreaking. - Public comment: Four speakers (Paul Terry, Flo Kelly, Seth Brenzel, a Small Business Commissioner, and another) all endorsed Tarlov for her integrity, empathy, and business perspective. - Vote: The committee approved an amendment to delete “rejects” and passed the appointment unanimously as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Greg Wagner appointment as Controller – Approved unanimously (amended to clarify effective date and remove “rejects”). Term: 10 years from effective date. Recommended to full Board as committee report. - Food Security Task Force – Hannah Grant (Seat 18) and Laura Jones (Seat 19) appointed unanimously. - Elections Commission – Kelly Wong appointed unanimously for a term ending January 1, 2029. - SFMTA Board – Janet Tarlov appointed unanimously (amended to remove “rejects”). Term ending March 1, 2024. Recommended to full Board as committee report. - All items are scheduled to appear on the Board of Supervisors’ agenda on January 30, 2024.